Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Settlement Checkpoints: When and How You Can Get Your Case Resolved
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Settlement Checkpoints. When and how
- 0:07you can get your case resolved. I'm Philip Vondra,
- 0:11Chair of Beverly Hill Bar Association's Personal
- 0:13Injury Law Section. I am delighted to introduce
- 0:16our speakers today, Brigida Simerant and John
- 0:21Davidi. Brigida Syramant is an attorney with
- 0:24Panache Raviputi LLP who focuses her practice
- 0:28on catastrophic personal injury and wrongful
- 0:31death matters across California. She brings to
- 0:34her work a deep commitment to consumer advocacy
- 0:38shaped by her leadership at Southwestern Law
- 0:42School and her early experience clerking at the
- 0:46firm. Jonathan Davidi is a trial attorney at
- 0:49Panache Raviputi LLP. who represents clients
- 0:53in complex personal injury, wrongful death, and
- 0:56product defect cases, securing more than 100
- 0:59million in verdicts and settlements. A skilled
- 1:01trial lawyer recognized as a super lawyer rising
- 1:05star and best lawyers, ones to watch honoree.
- 1:09He maintains an active practice across California,
- 1:13Nevada, and Texas. And now let's get started.
- 1:18Thank you, Philip. Welcome, everybody. We have
- 1:21a slide deck that we'll be putting up for you
- 1:23just here in a minute. Okay, and as Phillip said,
- 1:32my name is John Davidi. My colleague Brigida
- 1:35Simorant is on here as well. Today, we're going
- 1:38to be talking about settling cases. And a lot
- 1:43of people, I think, like to talk about trying
- 1:45cases. And there's a lot of CLEs and webinars
- 1:48and conferences about trying cases and being
- 1:51a trial lawyer and sharpening your trial skills.
- 1:54When in reality, obviously, that's important.
- 1:57And it helps get cases settled. But whatever
- 2:01the statistic is, 90, 95, 98, 99 % of cases settle.
- 2:07And I'm sure if you ask a lot of judges or settlement
- 2:10judges, they say 100 % of cases should settle.
- 2:13So when the reality that we live in is that 95
- 2:16plus percent of cases do settle, we have to.
- 2:21sharpen those skills too and look at when and
- 2:24why and how we can maximize the results for our
- 2:28clients. Brigida and I are both plaintiff's lawyers,
- 2:31so a lot of this will be kind of tailored to
- 2:34the plaintiff's bar, but a lot of it will apply
- 2:36even if you don't do personal injury and to the
- 2:40defense as well. So here are the six key moments
- 2:47that will be focusing on to apply pressure and
- 2:51get a case resolved. They're kind of like checkpoints.
- 2:54That's the name of the title. We'll go through
- 2:57each of them a little more in depth, obviously.
- 3:00But before we do, what I want to say is these
- 3:03are obviously not the only moments that a case
- 3:06can settle. And within each of these, there are
- 3:10many moments where a case might be ripe for settlement.
- 3:12There might be some that we miss. Every litigation
- 3:15is different. Every case is different. Whenever
- 3:18we sign a client up, they ask how long it's going
- 3:21to take. And I say, we're going to get a trial
- 3:24date probably within a year and a half or two
- 3:26years because the courts are backed up. And then
- 3:28I say, but a case can settle at any time. You
- 3:31never know when the mediation is going to come.
- 3:33You never know when the defense is going to be
- 3:35ready. Our job as the plaintiff's lawyers is
- 3:38to apply pressure to try to accelerate that process
- 3:42as much as possible. And so we're going to start,
- 3:45even though we're litigators, most of what we
- 3:47do is litigation. Let's start with before filing
- 3:50a lawsuit and the pre -litigation phase and what
- 3:53you can do to get your case ready to resolve
- 3:56pre -litigation. Brigida? Hi, everyone. Like
- 4:01John said, the first time in your case where
- 4:03you should be thinking about settlement and settlement
- 4:06should be on your mind is prior to filing the
- 4:09lawsuit. As you all know, lawsuits are expensive,
- 4:13they take a long time, and this is a good time
- 4:17for you to package a persuasive demand and lay
- 4:21out your case clearly. So just so you know where
- 4:26to send it, you should be sending it to the email
- 4:28address or physical address um designated by
- 4:33the liability insurer um if you know your insurance
- 4:37rep send it directly to them but the best practice
- 4:40is send it to everyone send it to the defense
- 4:42attorney the adjuster the insurance company and
- 4:45if the defendant is not personally represented
- 4:47you can send it to the defendant as well uh at
- 4:51that time they can either accept your demand
- 4:54They can ask you for clarification. They can
- 4:57ask you for additional time information. They
- 5:01can also ask you for more details regarding your
- 5:05client. And if they don't want to accept the
- 5:09demand, they need to tell you in writing prior
- 5:13to the expiration date in your demand. The rejection
- 5:19alone does not automatically mean it's going
- 5:23to be a bad case or an open policy, but it's
- 5:26just another thing for the court to consider
- 5:29if you do try to pursue a bad faith case later
- 5:32on. And this slide just shows language you can
- 5:36use. You should use the exact language of the
- 5:40code, which is, you know, plaintiff is offering
- 5:42to settle his claim prior to filing a lawsuit
- 5:45in the disclosed policy limits and. you have
- 5:50you know 30 days to 30 day deadline to respond.
- 5:58So CCP 999 is the time limited demand prior to
- 6:04filing a lawsuit. This is the code you can use
- 6:06in your demand and there are seven requirements
- 6:10for these demands. So first you want to state
- 6:14that it's time limited. It should be not less
- 6:18than 30 days if it's by mail fax or certified
- 6:22mail and 33 days otherwise. Number two, you want
- 6:27to have a clear offer to settle all claims within
- 6:31the policy limits including satisfaction on all
- 6:34liens. Number three, it should be an offer for
- 6:39a complete release from the claimant for the
- 6:42liability insurers. uh from all present and future
- 6:46liability for this occurrence number four you
- 6:49want to clearly state the date and location of
- 6:53the loss this is important and we usually put
- 6:56this in so we'll have like a introduction and
- 6:59then we'll have facts about the case and i will
- 7:02write like the accident happened on this date
- 7:04at this time these were the parties this is where
- 7:07it happened Number five, you want to have the
- 7:11claim number if you know it, and that would be
- 7:12in the very beginning. You want to put the claim
- 7:14number, the parties, and the date of liability.
- 7:18And then number six, you want to have a description
- 7:21of all the injuries. So this would go in a damages
- 7:26section, and we lay it out very clearly. This
- 7:30is the injuries our client suffered, and this
- 7:33is all the treatment they've gotten. This is
- 7:35what they're still continuing to suffer from.
- 7:38And then number seven, you want reasonable proof.
- 7:41This might include medical records, bills, anything
- 7:45sufficient to support your claim. And then on
- 7:48this slide, again, is just a way to state it
- 7:51in the demand, and you can use the code in your
- 7:54demand letter. This settlement is made pursuant
- 7:57to Code of Civil Procedure Section 999. And in
- 8:01fact, you should use the code, and you should
- 8:03use that language. And if there are any of you
- 8:05who haven't read 999 and 999 .1 at SEC, it's
- 8:10important that you do because, look, the reality
- 8:13is in practice, if you don't follow the code
- 8:16to the letter of the law and there's a $250 ,000
- 8:19policy and your case is worth more than $250
- 8:22,000, they're probably still going to pay you.
- 8:24They're going to accept your demand. But this
- 8:26matters because what if you have the potential
- 8:30for an open policy and bad faith. You don't want
- 8:33their argument to be, well, you didn't meet this
- 8:36one little criteria of 999, and then your bad
- 8:39faith case is dead on arrival. So it's just good
- 8:41practice. All these things should be included
- 8:45in your demand anyway, but it's good practice
- 8:47to also lay it out. Pre -live demand, it is a
- 8:54firm deadline, and so it's a way to set up your
- 8:57case strategically with the defense. It automatically
- 9:02builds pressure prior to filing your lawsuit
- 9:04because you're clearly outlining the facts, liability,
- 9:08and damages. So it's a way to force the carrier
- 9:12to do a realistic evaluation early on. it's beneficial
- 9:16for defense and for your client because like
- 9:19we said earlier, you know, litigation is long
- 9:22and it's expensive. So it's good to set up your
- 9:25case from the start well using a pre -lit demand.
- 9:30And another thing I like about this is like Brigida
- 9:33said, it triggers a response. Every demand pretty
- 9:38much that you make, pre -lit or lit, will trigger
- 9:41a response because insurance companies want to
- 9:42respond. They don't want to be seen like they're
- 9:44acting in bad faith or ignoring you. In addition
- 9:47to forcing the carrier to realistically evaluate
- 9:50the claim, making a pre -litigation demand might
- 9:53give you more information before filing the lawsuit
- 9:56that could be helpful. For example, if you have
- 9:59a case where liability might be tricky or you
- 10:01don't know whether liability is tricky or not,
- 10:03and you have some big damages, The carrier might
- 10:06give a very detailed response to your demand
- 10:09saying, here's why we think you're going to lose.
- 10:12Here's why we think the damages aren't legitimate,
- 10:15whatever it is. And now you can take a moment
- 10:17to evaluate your case. Now, a lot of times, carriers
- 10:22ask for extensions, ask for more information,
- 10:24et cetera. That's usually a judgment call. That's
- 10:27not something that we could teach you here. You
- 10:30want to give them as much information as possible.
- 10:32pre -litigation. We had a case recently where
- 10:36it's a huge injury and there was a good policy
- 10:40and we think that the policy really should have
- 10:43been paid. We gave them 30 days. It was around
- 10:46the holidays. They asked for an extension. We
- 10:48granted an extension. They asked for some more
- 10:50records. We gave them more records. They asked
- 10:53to speak with the mother of the plaintiff pre
- 10:57-lit and we even granted that, which usually
- 11:00we wouldn't do, but this was a case where We
- 11:02wanted to give them a real opportunity, pre -litigation,
- 11:06to pay the policy limits in good faith. And they
- 11:10didn't. And they denied the policy limits demand,
- 11:12which was a little bit of a surprise. But now
- 11:14we're going to litigation feeling a lot better
- 11:16about a potential open policy or bad faith case
- 11:19because we gave them so much that they asked
- 11:22for. And at the end of the day, they said it
- 11:24wasn't enough. We were really being reasonable.
- 11:26We were really trying to act in good faith. And
- 11:28it really seemed like they just didn't want to
- 11:30pay. So I feel more confident going into an open
- 11:33policy or bad faith case because I gave them
- 11:36so much as opposed to if it was just a 30 day
- 11:39demand and I didn't give them any extensions
- 11:41and they ended up denying it there. So all things
- 11:44to consider. Ultimately, we're all lawyers. We
- 11:47need to use our judgment. That's part of what
- 11:48we do. OK, the next checkpoint that I like. is
- 11:56right after filing the lawsuit. I think there
- 11:58are a lot of people who will file the lawsuit
- 12:01and want to do some discovery and do a deposition,
- 12:03et cetera. That's totally fine, too. That's actually
- 12:06our third checkpoint. But sometimes right after
- 12:09filing a lawsuit, especially if the policy limits
- 12:12kind of align with the extent of the injuries,
- 12:15is a way to get it done quickly. And a lot of
- 12:18times we'll send a 998 offer right after filing
- 12:22the lawsuit on the earliest possible date. What
- 12:25changes when you go from pre litigation to litigation
- 12:27is that one usually there's now a defense lawyer
- 12:30a lot of times there isn't one in pre lit and
- 12:36To usually there's a new adjuster. You'll now
- 12:38have a litigation adjuster usually on the case
- 12:42Litigation adjusters typically are a little bit
- 12:44more sophisticated. They understand risk a little
- 12:47bit better. You're getting a new set of eyes
- 12:49on the case there's a new calculation that's
- 12:52going on behind the scenes for the insurance
- 12:54where you can make your demand and maybe it'll
- 12:58spark conversation, maybe it won't, but it's
- 13:00worth a shot. I would keep it at the same demand
- 13:03that you had pre -litigation, for example, if
- 13:05it's a policy limits demand, but give it a shot
- 13:07to get it done right after. And here, I think
- 13:10this next slide is where we'll talk about 998.
- 13:13And like I mentioned before, I like to do it
- 13:15in the form of a 998. A couple of reasons, one
- 13:19it's I think you come from a position of strength
- 13:23when you do a 998 really early obviously for
- 13:27those of you who may not be as familiar under
- 13:29998 it's a statutory offer to compromise. And
- 13:33if you're plaintiff and you make this offer to
- 13:35compromise the defense has 30 days to respond
- 13:37if they reject it and you go to trial and get
- 13:40more than your offer you're entitled to interest
- 13:4310 % per year and expert costs. So serving the
- 13:47early 998 does give you interest accruing a lot
- 13:51earlier, which is great. And we have a case right
- 13:53now where we served a really early 998. The trial
- 13:56is coming up in a few months. And we've accrued
- 14:00two years of interest on the 998 already, obviously,
- 14:03if we beat the number. The reasonableness of
- 14:08the 998 this early on depends. It depends how
- 14:12much you gave them pre -lit, depends how much
- 14:14information that they have. They might object
- 14:16and say, we don't have the deposition, we don't
- 14:18have the IME, we need XYZ. A lot of times what
- 14:21we will do when we serve this early 998 is serve
- 14:25it with a cover letter that is essentially a
- 14:27demand letter. And in that, we'll say, if you
- 14:30want to depose the plaintiff, if you want to
- 14:32take the plaintiff's IME, we will waive the statutory
- 14:35notice requirements and make them available within
- 14:37the 30 days. They have maybe one time in my history
- 14:42of doing this has a defense lawyer taken us up
- 14:44on that. Usually they just ignore it and object
- 14:47anyway, but at least now we're coming off as
- 14:50good faith actors who are trying to be reasonable
- 14:52and the 998 can seem more reasonable. So the
- 14:59next part in your case where you should be paying
- 15:02attention to a possible settlement is after key
- 15:05depositions. John and I actually litigated a
- 15:10case last year. It's confidential, so we can't
- 15:13say the names of the parties or the amount that
- 15:15it settled for, but it was against a hotel. The
- 15:18plaintiffs were family members of two guests
- 15:22that were staying in the hotel. One of the guests
- 15:25husband, I think they were separated at the time.
- 15:28He showed up at the hotel. He's not a registered
- 15:32guest. His name was not on the reservation. And
- 15:35despite that, the hotel employee gives him a
- 15:39room key. He goes up to the room and shoots and
- 15:43kills both guests that were staying there. So
- 15:46during discovery of this case, the hotel produces
- 15:50their written policies and their policies are
- 15:53super clear. They spell out that staff is not
- 15:57allowed to issue any room keys to anyone whose
- 16:00name is not on the reservation. And beyond that,
- 16:03it also specifies that these policies are in
- 16:06place to emphasize guest safety and protect the
- 16:12people staying there. So then we go into depositions.
- 16:17We depose the employee who was there that day
- 16:20who gives this guy a room key. He admits under
- 16:24oath that he broke company policy. He admits
- 16:29to giving the key to someone who was not a registered
- 16:31guest, which, by the way, we also had video footage
- 16:34of, and he admits that he knows it violated their
- 16:39policies and that he was trained on the proper
- 16:42procedures that he was supposed to do. So at
- 16:45that point, even without admitting, we had liability.
- 16:50And so we chose to write a demand letter at that
- 16:53stage. and we attached screenshots of their safety
- 16:57policies. Immediately after that we attached
- 17:00screenshots of the deposition testimony where
- 17:04the employee admits to violating those policies
- 17:07and we lay it out side by side so those violations
- 17:10are just undeniable at this point. We also had
- 17:13a section in the demand letter that discredited
- 17:17the defense's position that the hotel didn't
- 17:21have any liability because obviously we had a
- 17:23lot of evidence that they are liable. We also
- 17:28addressed any suggestion of comparative fault
- 17:30and we made it really clear that even if the
- 17:33shooter bears any fault, the hotel can't escape
- 17:37liability when it directly failed to follow their
- 17:40own safety procedures that were in place designed
- 17:43to protect their guests. We ended up settling
- 17:48the case for the full policy limits. So just
- 17:52depositions are not just to gather facts. They
- 17:56create settlement leverage. So you should be
- 17:58using the production on discovery that you obtain
- 18:02with your depositions. Ask questions from stuff
- 18:07you obtained to gather a case where you're building
- 18:11liability. I don't know if you have anything
- 18:13to say on that, John. Yeah. You know, the first
- 18:17two checkpoints we talked about were nice and
- 18:20it would be great if cases settle pre litigation
- 18:23or right after filing a lawsuit and both sides
- 18:25save a bunch of money and it's everyone saves
- 18:27a bunch of time. But for the most part, if you
- 18:31have something a little bit complex, if you have
- 18:33something that's high value, if there are issues
- 18:36to the case, the carrier is going to want more
- 18:39information. They're going to want to investigate.
- 18:41They're going to want to take the plaintiff's
- 18:42deposition. They're going to want to do an IMB,
- 18:44maybe. They're going to want to see what the
- 18:46defendant's depositions look like. And a lot
- 18:49is being evaluated in these depositions, including
- 18:53who the attorney is, right? And that's something
- 18:55to think about when you're taking the depositions
- 18:58as being totally prepared so that they go back
- 19:01to the carrier and say, this is a good lawyer
- 19:03who knows what he's doing. Getting the demand
- 19:08After I think the key depositions, that's probably
- 19:11the best time because at this point Usually there's
- 19:15enough information written discovery has been
- 19:18completed. You can put You could pull deposition
- 19:21testimony from the plaintiff about damages from
- 19:25the defendants about liability and put them in
- 19:27the demand letter You need to show the carriers
- 19:32and the defense lawyers why you are going to
- 19:35win You can't just say we're going to win You
- 19:38have to actually pull it out of them. You have
- 19:41to pull the settlement out of them is the way
- 19:43I like to think about it. And the way to do that
- 19:45is by showing them the actual evidence and that
- 19:48it's not going to get better for them if things
- 19:50go to trial. What I will say is, if it's a case
- 19:54where liability is not really in dispute, you
- 19:57may consider doing this type of demand after
- 19:59the plaintiff's deposition, because really that's
- 20:01the key deposition here. Or if some treating
- 20:05doctors get deposed, that would be a good time
- 20:08to do it. If the defense hasn't noticed any and
- 20:10you think a treating doctor might be helpful,
- 20:12find a treating doctor to take their depositions,
- 20:16get some good deposition clips from them, and
- 20:18plug those into the demand letter so that, again,
- 20:22the insurance carrier knows what the exposure
- 20:24and the risk is in a case like this. And we also
- 20:27usually include a little paragraph. It's on the
- 20:29slide here. of exactly what they're already in
- 20:32possession of. So you have plaintiffs written
- 20:35discovery. You have their deposition. You already
- 20:37did this, did that. So it's very clear all the
- 20:41information they already have. So they can't
- 20:43come back to you and be like, oh, we need this.
- 20:45We know exactly what you have already. And it's
- 20:48pretty clearly laid out. Another thing I'll go
- 20:50ahead. Another thing I want to say is, you know,
- 20:53what John was saying, being prepared, going into
- 20:56depositions. The more prepared you are as a plaintiff's
- 20:59attorney from the start in every proceeding,
- 21:02every interaction, every email, the more pressure
- 21:05builds on the defense that we are ready and we
- 21:08have all the information and we're going to show
- 21:10up ready every stage of the case, including trial.
- 21:13So it just shows that carrier and the defense
- 21:16attorneys the value of the case based on that.
- 21:20And one thing I will say on Brigida's second
- 21:23to last point, which was state in these demand
- 21:26letters, everything that they have, everything
- 21:28that they've done, 100%. And if they have been
- 21:32slow to do anything or delaying, mention that
- 21:36too. We've offered the plaintiff up for deposition
- 21:39three times in the last three months and you
- 21:41failed to give notice. We've offered to make
- 21:43them available for an IME and you haven't taken
- 21:45the IME to show that they're not really the good
- 21:48actor. here and they have their own reason sometimes
- 21:51people are busy or just lazy or delay or whatever
- 21:54but you want it all in writing again because
- 21:57if this does one day go to bad faith um you want
- 22:01to have this well documented but either way you
- 22:03want to show them that you're on top of things
- 22:05hey i remember three months ago you said you
- 22:08wanted to take the plaintiff's deposition and
- 22:09i gave you some dates and you never responded
- 22:11things like that show that you're in control
- 22:14of the litigation and you know what you're doing
- 22:15exactly and i would also add The more so let's
- 22:20say you have really good key depositions and
- 22:22your your your liability is pretty clear. I would
- 22:26steer away from more law trying to prove liability
- 22:30and just talk about the facts talk about exactly
- 22:33what happened in the case and lay it out clearly
- 22:36because that to me that's stronger than doing
- 22:40a really long legal argument in your demand.
- 22:42You're just talking about the actual case and
- 22:44what happened and you're showing that we pretty
- 22:46much have liability. And the beauty of this type
- 22:51of demand letter, and especially at this point,
- 22:53is that you'll put the effort into it, you'll
- 22:56make it good as it should be, and then you can
- 22:59pretty much use it for your mediation brief.
- 23:01And a lot of times what we see is after this
- 23:05phase, there start to be conversations about
- 23:09a mediation. If it's a case that needs to be
- 23:11mediated and isn't a clear policy limits case,
- 23:14there start to be discussions. And sometimes
- 23:16even after the, if you make the demand right
- 23:20after filing a lawsuit, sometimes the defense
- 23:22lawyer will say, look, it's a case we want to
- 23:24get settled. Let me take a couple of depositions
- 23:27and let's get a mediation on calendar for a few
- 23:29months out. Great. But here is where they'll
- 23:31have a lot more information. And it's kind of
- 23:35ripe for a mediation around this point, too.
- 23:37But the reality is that if you don't make the
- 23:40demand, they're probably not going to pay attention
- 23:43to anything. They're probably not going to propose
- 23:45mediation. There needs to be these little reminders
- 23:49and triggers. And you have to be a little bit
- 23:51of a pest, not too much, so that this case stays
- 23:55top of mind for the defense lawyer and for the
- 23:57adjuster. And you let them know, we're not going
- 23:59to back down. You know we're going to try to
- 24:01get this case resolved. We're going to exhaust
- 24:02all efforts to do so before trial and we're still
- 24:05going to prepare prepare for trial. But whenever
- 24:08you're ready to come to the table, we're ready.
- 24:11Yeah, and the way I think about it too is don't
- 24:14don't let them leave any stone unturned like
- 24:17give them everything you have to lay out your
- 24:19case as good as you can. OK, so the next stage
- 24:24that you should be thinking about settling is
- 24:27after the IME. Sometimes an IME will confirm
- 24:32what you already know. Your plaintiff has real
- 24:35injuries that were directly caused by the incident.
- 24:39When the defense doctor can meaningfully, they
- 24:42can't meaningfully dispute the mechanism of injury
- 24:45or causation, this tells you that your trial
- 24:49argument is going to be good and theirs is limited.
- 24:52That's valuable information to you. Conversely,
- 24:56even if the IME isn't great for your client,
- 24:59it's still clarity for you and it shows you how
- 25:02far the defense expert is willing to go. It shows
- 25:05you what they actually have and sometimes what
- 25:08they don't have. So if causation is clearly tied
- 25:12to the incident and the defense doctor can't
- 25:15credibly break that chain, This is a really strong
- 25:19time for you to push for resolution before you
- 25:23incurred all the costs and time of trial prep
- 25:26experts, you know, motions and lemonade, exhibit
- 25:30works, trial subpoenas. It just keeps adding
- 25:32up until trial happens. So this is a really good
- 25:35time for you to sit back and be like, okay, you
- 25:38know, even their defense expert is agreeing with
- 25:41us. And we... we like to send it a renewed demand
- 25:45at this stage and you can attach the IME report
- 25:49and you can point out, you know, even if the
- 25:51defense's own doctor confirms causation and plaintiffs
- 25:55continuing to suffer, you know, this shows the
- 25:59carrier defense that this is a good time to settle
- 26:02because our trial posture is much better than
- 26:04theirs and it strengthens your case value. And
- 26:07then again, on the flip side, you know, if the
- 26:09IME exposes some weaknesses, this is your moment
- 26:12to reassess the case's value and it might be
- 26:15a practical time for you to settle knowing how
- 26:19much you know how many more costs you have coming
- 26:22up to trial you have you know experts and all
- 26:24these things and it's like if you see at this
- 26:27point that maybe maybe we should settle here
- 26:29and not incur all those costs you you have a
- 26:32time to reassess the value of your case and it's
- 26:37I think this is especially helpful in a case
- 26:40where If the injuries are really big and the
- 26:44liability is really tough, this is especially
- 26:47helpful there because you'll have, you know,
- 26:50if you have real good objective bad injuries,
- 26:54then what's the defense doctor can't say anything,
- 26:56right? They're going to say, yes, they suffered
- 26:58this broken leg, you know, this they needed this
- 27:01surgery, whatever. And you have that. And now
- 27:04you have your damages kind of confirmed. uh by
- 27:08the other side and all that's left to argue is
- 27:12liability and you say you know hey our damages
- 27:13are so big this doctor that you hire that you
- 27:17pay thousands of dollars to agrees and so even
- 27:20if we get 50 percent liability or 70 percent
- 27:23liability the damages are so big that you know
- 27:26this is a case that should settle for x or whatever
- 27:29right and again same as depositions good time
- 27:32after here um to try to get into a mediation
- 27:37I, you know, as the plaintiff's lawyer, I never
- 27:39really like to propose mediation myself. I always
- 27:43want to wait for the defense to do so. They usually
- 27:46do because they want to, you know, try to get
- 27:49it done. It's part of the course of action. They
- 27:50want to see if they could get any sort of discount
- 27:52off the policy. But making the demand is kind
- 27:55of a good way to start triggering in their minds
- 27:58that maybe we should mediate this case. And by
- 28:02the way, if you're the defense, if anyone Juan
- 28:05here is a defense lawyer. I don't know if all
- 28:10my years of practice I've ever had a case where
- 28:14a defendant made an offer just kind of on their
- 28:18own. It would be great if they did sometimes.
- 28:21We could get the ball rolling. Usually it's in
- 28:23response to a demand. But after these checkpoints,
- 28:27the deposition and the IME and you've gotten
- 28:29your written discovery down and you've got your
- 28:31subpoenas and your medical records, if you're
- 28:33a defense lawyer, And the players lawyers are
- 28:35making demands or, you know, they're the ones
- 28:37kind of dropping the ball and aren't being aggressive
- 28:39about it. You should propose a mediation, you
- 28:42know, be the aggressor, get a mediation on calendar,
- 28:44because you want your case to get settled for
- 28:46your client to before they spend a bunch more
- 28:49money. Because after this, it's really just experts.
- 28:52And that's when a case gets really expensive.
- 28:54So I think both sides know that, you know, after
- 28:56this checkpoint for depositions done, I mean,
- 28:59done subpoenas received. All that's left is experts.
- 29:02Maybe they're six months away. Let's get a mediation
- 29:05on calendar in the next three months or so and
- 29:08see if we can't get this resolved before we both
- 29:10spend a ton of money getting ready for trial.
- 29:17OK, and speaking of expert discovery, another
- 29:20great time. This is usually on the cases that
- 29:23are. More complex, a little trickier. Maybe you
- 29:27have an aggressive lawyer on the other side,
- 29:29an adjuster who doesn't like to pay. We've all
- 29:32been there. It happens. They want to see some
- 29:34expert depots. You know, you got to get your
- 29:37experts ready, spend the money. But again, this
- 29:40goes to earlier when we were talking about the
- 29:42depositions, you need to be prepared so that
- 29:44you're taking a much better deposition than they
- 29:47are of your experts. And having these expert
- 29:50opinions, which don't really exist before expert
- 29:54disclosures, they might in that you might have
- 29:56a life care plan or you might want to show something
- 29:58at a mediation or as part of a demand for confidential
- 30:02settlement purposes. But once you have this in
- 30:06sworn testimony and reports are produced and
- 30:09the picture of trial becomes a lot clearer, that's
- 30:13another good time to revisit it. Most of our
- 30:17cases I will say settle around expert discovery
- 30:20in the middle of expert discovery or after expert
- 30:23discovery and closer to trial because the picture
- 30:26is painted We know what the evidence is going
- 30:29to be a trial and we've worked the case up We've
- 30:32gotten the right experts. They know that we have
- 30:34a good case going forward Sometimes we don't,
- 30:39and it's a good time for us to evaluate our case,
- 30:41and if the expert depositions don't go well,
- 30:43that's a conversation that we have with the client
- 30:45and discuss, you know, hey, maybe this is one
- 30:48that we need to settle, not one that we want
- 30:49to settle, right? Which hopefully doesn't happen
- 30:53very often, but sometimes does happen, and we
- 30:55have to be realistic. So once you have these
- 30:59expert reports and depositions, You can make
- 31:03another demand. You could take the old one and
- 31:05supplement it. You could say, you know, you already
- 31:08know everything about liability based on the
- 31:10prior letters. You already know about the damages
- 31:12based on the prior letters. But here is what
- 31:14all the experts and doctors confirmed, including
- 31:17your doctor who said. The injuries are all related.
- 31:20He needs future care. This was all the accident's
- 31:23fault, et cetera, et cetera. Our life care plan
- 31:26is $3 million. Your life care plan is a million
- 31:29and a half. Either way, it's a seven figure life
- 31:32care plan. Whatever the facts of your case may
- 31:34be, not everyone's dealing with cases with life
- 31:37care plans like that, which I understand. But
- 31:39whatever the facts of your case may be, sniff
- 31:41them out and find them. And you should be taking
- 31:43the expert depots. really in a way that you're
- 31:47going to have good clips to play at trial. And
- 31:49those clips are usually pretty good to put into
- 31:52a demand as well. So here, you know, it's late
- 31:56in the game, but it's usually, you know, if you
- 31:59get this far and you have a good case, you're
- 32:02probably getting maximum value at this point.
- 32:11And then the next phase. Know if you want to
- 32:14talk about this right before trial. So this is
- 32:16right after you finish up all your experts. You're
- 32:21about to incur all the expenses of trial and
- 32:23at this stage you and the defense should know
- 32:27exactly what the case value is. There should
- 32:29be no surprises going into trial. Yeah, and you
- 32:35know when when people say that their case settles
- 32:38on the. Courthouse steps when I first became
- 32:42a lawyer. I thought that was like literal Where
- 32:45you're on the courthouse steps and you talk and
- 32:48make a deal and I'm sure it happens sometimes
- 32:50it's never happened to me, but I think the metaphorical
- 32:55courtroom steps is very very real in that everything
- 32:59is done trial documents are done all that's left
- 33:03is that the case needs to be tried and Sometimes
- 33:05it's showing up to the final status conference
- 33:08that helps move the needle Sometimes it's maybe
- 33:11you getting more reasonable in your demands and,
- 33:14you know, starting to close the gap. And when
- 33:16you're only fighting over this big of a gap versus
- 33:19this big of a gap, the case becomes a lot easier
- 33:22to settle. And a lot of times, you know, a client
- 33:25might not want their case to go to trial. They
- 33:27might not want to deal with the stress and anxiety.
- 33:30And we could push it as far as we can to ultimately
- 33:32their decision. Our job as plaintiff's lawyers
- 33:34is to maximize the result and what we can get.
- 33:38Before that, you know, we we had one case where.
- 33:44It's you know, it's kind of funny and like we
- 33:46joke about it at the office a little bit, you
- 33:49know, we wanted X number of dollars and they
- 33:53were offering. $100 ,000 under X right and. It
- 34:01would have been hard to pass up the number that
- 34:03they were offering. We said, you know what? Let's
- 34:06keep applying the pressure. Let's show up. Let's
- 34:09just go and see if they cave and pay the extra
- 34:13money. And we showed up. We had our exhibit binders
- 34:16printed. We had our trial binders printed at
- 34:20a courthouse with five boxes, whatever. And they're
- 34:22like, come on. You guys are really going to go.
- 34:23We're offering you this. But they're like, hey,
- 34:25this is our number. Whenever you guys want to
- 34:29pay it, let us know, you know, let us know by
- 34:31Friday because we're picking a jury Monday, right?
- 34:34And that's what it took. It took, you know, so
- 34:38much of our world is virtual now, but it took
- 34:39going to downtown. It took going to downtown,
- 34:42getting into the courthouse, seeing them there.
- 34:45They came up from Orange County. They probably
- 34:47didn't want to make that drive either, but we
- 34:49forced their hand. and it forced them to have
- 34:52another conversation and pull the extra money
- 34:54that we wanted. And it makes a huge difference
- 34:56for our client because, you know, to us or to
- 34:59them, it might be $50 ,000, $100 ,000, whatever,
- 35:01but to our clients, that's real money. You know,
- 35:04that could be a year of rent. That could be,
- 35:06you know, this new car that they've been needing
- 35:07for 25 years that that's going to help them live
- 35:10a much more comfortable life. So it makes a difference
- 35:13if you're willing to push it to the limit. Right.
- 35:16It costs a little bit more. We had to spend a
- 35:18couple thousand bucks on exhibit binders, but
- 35:20obviously it was worth it in the end. What John
- 35:23is saying and what you referenced before too
- 35:25like when you're taking these expert depositions
- 35:27you should be thinking about how is this going
- 35:31to play at trial? You want to create a clip for
- 35:34trial so that mindset should be in your head
- 35:37from before you file the lawsuit and at each
- 35:40stage of litigation you should be thinking about
- 35:43how is this going to play out at trial? All of
- 35:47that is equivalent to value in your case. And
- 35:50so again, the more you show up ready, the more
- 35:54you have every deposition has clips ready to
- 35:57play at trial, the higher value your case will
- 36:00be. I also wanted to talk about the demand on
- 36:04the on the screen here. We we had a case come
- 36:08in that was. It was going to trial like in a
- 36:12few weeks and we started prepping it for trial.
- 36:15And we realized discovery was already closed
- 36:18at this point. We realized defense had not even
- 36:21to pose the plaintiff. They had done very, very
- 36:25little to build their case. And we decided at
- 36:30that point that we were going to send a demand
- 36:32and we showed up to the FSC ready to go. The
- 36:36defense attorney didn't even show up in person
- 36:38and we sent a demand and we said, you know, we
- 36:42just. Joined in on this case and You haven't
- 36:46even Deposed the plaintiff, you know the bare
- 36:50minimum here and this exposed defense to a real
- 36:55excess verdict risk and They ended up paying
- 36:59the full three million dollar policy limits the
- 37:02date right before it expired the day of So when
- 37:05defense waits that long trial risk is leverage
- 37:09for you And it's all about preparedness. The
- 37:13reality was we were prepared, we were ready,
- 37:16even though our firm came in two, three weeks
- 37:19before trial, we were up to speed and we were
- 37:22ready to go. And preparedness is your friend,
- 37:25whether it's a week before trial, a year before
- 37:28trial, pre -lib, whatever it is, the more prepared
- 37:31you are, it shows, it shows. And so make sure
- 37:35that you, your staff, if you have other attorneys
- 37:37at your office, that they're prepared and they
- 37:40know their stuff with everything that they're
- 37:41doing. And I think nowadays it's a lot easier
- 37:44to be prepared with technology and everything
- 37:48is on Zoom. And so we've saved so much time not
- 37:50having to drive from place to place for a deposition.
- 37:53And we could just share screens with our documents
- 37:56instead of having to print everything. But it's
- 37:59still one of the most important parts of our
- 38:02practice. And another part of our practice that
- 38:06we tend to always do is we usually don't ask
- 38:09for extensions. We try to be ready. Anytime discoveries
- 38:14do, we're prepping it. We're not waiting till
- 38:16the last day it's due and submitting it late.
- 38:19You want to show up ready always because that
- 38:22is positioning you and your case and your client
- 38:25and the value of your case. And we just got a
- 38:30question. And I think we can open Q &A now as
- 38:32well if anyone has questions. We just got one
- 38:35question that asks, can you talk about the downside
- 38:38to using 998 offers? Hard to think of one. For
- 38:43a plaintiff, there's very little downside. You
- 38:47can make multiple in a litigation. I would say.
- 38:52never make one higher than one you've already
- 38:55made before. So for example, if you made one
- 38:57early on for a million dollars, it does not make
- 38:59sense for you to make one for $2 million later.
- 39:01It makes sense for you to make one for lower
- 39:03if you want to, and if it's something that your
- 39:05client will take. And sometimes we'll make another
- 39:09one later on when the case is a little more clear
- 39:12and we have a better idea of the value and also
- 39:15it might be seen as a more reasonable one given
- 39:18that depositions and everything have been done.
- 39:20So sometimes we'll make more than one. The downside
- 39:23that I could maybe think of if I had to think
- 39:26of one is that if you serve one, it's more likely
- 39:29that the defense will serve one. And if the defense
- 39:32serves a 998 offer and you don't beat their number,
- 39:36then you owe them the expert costs, their expert
- 39:40costs. There's no interest. So 998 is a little
- 39:43bit more favorable to plaintiffs than it is to
- 39:45defendants. That's why I think every case should
- 39:47have one. But it does happen where the defense
- 39:54now makes a 998. You're like, ah, you know, that's
- 39:56a tough number to beat. You know, we'll see what
- 39:58happens. What I will say last thing about 998
- 40:01is, you know, I think there's two schools of
- 40:04thought on the 998. One is this is, you know,
- 40:07going to be my bare bones number that I can beat
- 40:10at trial. And that's why I'm going to make the
- 40:11998. The other is I'm kind of treating it as
- 40:16a demand. i like to treat it more as a demand
- 40:19i think whatever your 998 number is assume that
- 40:21they're going to try to work you off of it right
- 40:24unless you're at the very very end very close
- 40:26to trial last ditch 998 and even then they'll
- 40:29try to work you off of it a little bit too so
- 40:32be mindful of that when you're making your 998
- 40:35and i think the argument of oh well our low 998
- 40:39that was just the number we can beat our actual
- 40:41demand is x is really hard to make. It's really
- 40:44hard for insurance carriers to pay something
- 40:46more than a demand that you've already made.
- 40:49So just really keep that in mind. One more thing
- 40:52I would add to. John and I do email demands quite
- 40:57often and they work. You know, it's not a formal
- 41:00demand letter that you're mailing out to the
- 41:02defense, but it's just an email laying out. You
- 41:04know, this is the facts. This is what's going
- 41:06on. We are willing to settle at this number.
- 41:10And that has worked pre -lit and during litigation
- 41:14as well. The next question we have is, what do
- 41:17you do when the defense attorney refuses mediation?
- 41:22It's rare. Usually, when that happens, you're
- 41:25not in a good position, I think. It's because
- 41:27they think that they have a really strong case.
- 41:30And it's something that you've got to be aware
- 41:32of. In that case, I would kind of stick to the
- 41:36game plan, which is make the proper 998s, keep
- 41:39making the demands because they have to report
- 41:41them. If you really want, if you want to mediate
- 41:44the case, I would say, you know, in the demand,
- 41:47something like this, you know, write a demand
- 41:49letter. Our demand is for this much. Our client
- 41:52is open to, you know, a mediation and you can
- 41:55even give names of mediators if you want to and
- 41:57say, you know, let us know if you're interested
- 42:00in mediating in the next, you know, two to three
- 42:02months or whatever it is. But if they refuse,
- 42:06I mean, you can't force them to do it. Some courts
- 42:09do have mandatory ADR, whether it's a mandatory
- 42:13settlement conference or LA's MVP program or
- 42:16resolve law, whatever it is. And a lot of times
- 42:19those can be helpful, especially for, you know,
- 42:21if you're a solo shop or, you know, the expense
- 42:24of a mediation is going to be a lot for the type
- 42:26of case that you're at using free court mediation
- 42:30programs is awesome. Frank Chika, great question.
- 42:35Have you attempted to apply pressure early on
- 42:37for settlement by filing a motion for trial preference?
- 42:40What are the risks in doing so? Pros and cons.
- 42:43Thanks again. And hello, this is just a compliment.
- 42:44Thanks for the compliment, Frank. Your question
- 42:49was so awesome that I can't believe that we forgot
- 42:51to even mention this in the webinar. In 100 %
- 42:55of our cases where we can file a motion for trial
- 42:57preference, we will file a motion for trial preference.
- 43:00And that is, it should have been number one.
- 43:02That is the number one way to get a case settled.
- 43:05for those of you who aren't familiar CCP 36 is
- 43:10and 37 actually 36 is for a motion for trial
- 43:13preference which says essentially if if the plaintiff
- 43:17is over 70 years old and has some health conditions
- 43:19that could affect their ability to testify at
- 43:21trial or if they are under 14 years old period
- 43:25or if the interest of justice would allow it
- 43:28or if they have some medical condition that that
- 43:31may make it hard for them to testify at trial
- 43:32even if they're not 70 or CCP 37 says, if the
- 43:38defendant was convicted of a felony in the causing
- 43:45of the tort, then you could get trial preference.
- 43:48And that means that the trial has to be set within
- 43:50120 days of the motion. This is a game changer.
- 43:54It changes it from an 18 -month wait to get a
- 43:57case settled to now an expedited real four to
- 44:00six month window. The defense is paying attention.
- 44:03Everything's a little bit expedited, which is
- 44:05great because when we have older clients, it's
- 44:07not fair to them to wait this long to litigate.
- 44:10And when you have younger clients, you don't
- 44:11want a 12 year old kid going through a two year
- 44:14litigation. You want to try to reach early resolution.
- 44:17There's always, I think there are much more pros
- 44:19than cons to answer that part of the question.
- 44:22The cons are you need to know your case. And
- 44:25you need to know how complex your case is. And
- 44:27if you are going to be able to get everything
- 44:29done in the four months, because at the end of
- 44:33the day, we're the plaintiff. We have the burden
- 44:35of proving our case. And you need to be realistic
- 44:37about all the depositions you need to take, any
- 44:41motions that might come up, whatever it is, you
- 44:43got to be realistic and do it. You can make it.
- 44:47With preference motions, they usually will get
- 44:50granted because the the code is so clear if they're
- 44:54over a certain age or they're a minor or they
- 44:56have a condition that they can't you know wait
- 44:59long the judges usually will grant trial preference
- 45:02but they have I remember some that got granted
- 45:05the judge will say like you know you better be
- 45:07ready we're not gonna we're not gonna wait so
- 45:10what John's saying is true you need to really
- 45:12know your case and you need to be ready to try
- 45:15it that fast. And look, sometimes we'll also
- 45:19mean confer with the defense on a preference
- 45:21motion and say, hey, we're going to file preference.
- 45:23Do you want to just agree to six months instead
- 45:25of opposing the motion? Or eight months, whatever.
- 45:27And that gives us both a little bit more time.
- 45:30You can make a preference motion at any time
- 45:32in a litigation. So if your client turns 70 or
- 45:35if their condition gets a lot worse. you might
- 45:38consider making a motion or making another one
- 45:40if you made one before that was denied. Or if
- 45:44it's a case where a lot of work needs to be done,
- 45:46you can wait until you feel like you're at a
- 45:48good spot and then make the preference motion.
- 45:50And if there's already a trial date on calendar,
- 45:53you might even ask the court to just take that
- 45:56trial date and please give it preferential treatment,
- 45:59which means it cannot be continued because defense
- 46:02lawyers love continuing trials. having a trial
- 46:05that cannot be continued is great leverage too.
- 46:08But yeah, generally we do always, for the most
- 46:12part, file preference motions for the cases where
- 46:15the plaintiff fits that criteria and it does
- 46:18absolutely help to settle your case and to get
- 46:22the highest value. Yeah. And another question
- 46:25we have is, what about the danger of a 998 policy
- 46:27limit demand where the policy limits are nowhere
- 46:29near enough compared to the value of the damages?
- 46:32So the carrier has incentive to accept and settle
- 46:34at a deep discount. Good question. Totally depends
- 46:38on your case and what your client wants. I mean,
- 46:40the reality is it's hard to get personal assets
- 46:43from people. So if it's a case where you're gonna
- 46:45take the policy at some point anyway, then that's
- 46:48a good time to do it. If it's a case where you're
- 46:49not gonna take the policy, then don't make the
- 46:52998 for the policy. Whenever you do make a 998
- 46:56at any point, make sure it's a number that you're
- 46:59okay with taking because they might sign, right?
- 47:02They might accept it. You got to make sure you
- 47:05get written authority from the client to do it.
- 47:07Explain it very well. Because if they sign and
- 47:11you're thinking, oh, shit, I actually wanted
- 47:13more than that, it's too late. So you got to
- 47:16make sure you know. And repost the webinar materials.
- 47:24I think the webinar materials are being shared
- 47:26by BHBA. And they're typing an answer to you
- 47:29right now, Gene. Any other questions about getting
- 47:34your case settled? I had one question for you
- 47:40guys. Early in the presentation, you mentioned
- 47:43the disclosed policy limits when you're doing
- 47:46a pre -lit demand. How do you get that information
- 47:50or if you ask the adjuster for it to get it from
- 47:53their client and it's refused, how do you handle
- 47:56that? Awesome question. Happens all the time.
- 48:00More often than not, I think nowadays we're not
- 48:03getting what the limits are. There are a couple
- 48:06of ways that we handle it, depending on the case.
- 48:08If it's a case, first of all, if it's a trucking
- 48:12company, there's at least a million bucks, right?
- 48:14So that informs you. If it's a guy driving a
- 48:171992 Toyota Corolla, you're probably not dealing
- 48:21with an umbrella. So that should inform you a
- 48:23little bit too. There are a couple of ways that
- 48:26we handle it in terms of the wording of our demand.
- 48:29If we want whatever the policy limits are, if
- 48:32we think that we would accept them, understanding
- 48:35that they might be 30 or less or whatever, then
- 48:39we will just say, we demand the full policy limits,
- 48:43including any excess or umbrella limits. And
- 48:46we need a declaration of no other insurance and
- 48:48yada, yada, yada. are worried that there's not
- 48:54enough insurance and we're not sure if we would
- 48:56even take the insurance because, A, there's this
- 48:58guy who we think might have some personal assets
- 49:01and we think might be underinsured and they're
- 49:03not disclosing and it's a little iffy. We have
- 49:07a case like that right now, actually, where they're
- 49:08not disclosing and it's a big injury and we don't
- 49:12know what the policy is. We're just going to
- 49:15make a demand for what we think the case is worth.
- 49:18And so we're making a multimillion dollar demand.
- 49:21And we're going to let the insurance company
- 49:23say, hey, we got your multimillion dollar demand.
- 49:26We're going to offer our $250 ,000 limits, which
- 49:29we didn't know was $250 ,000 before. But now
- 49:31they've offered it and they know. Technically,
- 49:34we don't have offer and acceptance because we
- 49:36didn't offer to settle the case for the policy
- 49:39limits. We offer to settle the case for millions,
- 49:41right? And they've now offered to settle the
- 49:44case for $250 ,000. And we can decide if we want
- 49:46to accept it or not. And now we have clarity,
- 49:49we have an idea, and we have a firm offer for
- 49:52the client to decide. So those are the couple
- 49:53of ways to do it. Mediator from Northern California,
- 49:59welcome. The time frame filing a complaint to
- 50:02go to trial in LA. How long does it usually take?
- 50:05My information is that it can take close to the
- 50:07five -year dismissal deadline. Depends. That
- 50:10does happen. I think that typically happened
- 50:13more for some cases that were kind of dealing
- 50:15with COVID stuff back in the day. But also that
- 50:18usually happens when plaintiff's lawyers agree
- 50:21to continuances and plaintiff's lawyers aren't
- 50:23on top of things. And, you know, because if we're
- 50:26on top of things and we're pushing it forward
- 50:27and the defense isn't, we just keep pushing.
- 50:31We keep our foot on the accelerator and don't
- 50:33agree to any continuances. And eventually the
- 50:36court is going to deny it. Might give them the
- 50:37first one, might give them the second one, but
- 50:39eventually that continuance is going to be denied.
- 50:41And you've got to have a trial date to get a
- 50:44case settled. That's it. Like at the end of the
- 50:47day, that's what matters. You got to have a trial
- 50:49date. We, at our office, the policy is to never
- 50:53continue the trial. Be prepared. Never continue
- 50:56the trial. There are some exceptions that we
- 50:57make here and there. But for the most part, we
- 51:00will never agree to continue a trial date because
- 51:02it's the only way that a case is going to get
- 51:05resolved. And we'll tell the defense lawyer that.
- 51:07It's like, look, I hear you. I know you want
- 51:09the trial date to be continued. But we both know
- 51:11it's only going to settle if the trial date sticks.
- 51:18I'm curious if we have ever demanded mediation,
- 51:21but only with our preferred mediator. I mean,
- 51:25we don't have just one mediator that we mediate
- 51:28with. It's we usually won't agree to a mediation
- 51:33with someone that we don't like or someone that
- 51:36we don't trust For the most part though in my
- 51:38experience you want the defense to be comfortable
- 51:41through the mediators you want the carrier to
- 51:44be listening to this mediator because We're presenting
- 51:47a good case and we're gonna have a good mediation
- 51:49brief and we want them to be able to get money
- 51:51from the other side But we still want it to be
- 51:53someone that that we can trust So usually we
- 51:56pass around some names and it ends up not being
- 51:58an issue How to approach a miscarriage lost from
- 52:05a T -bone car accident. That is a case -specific
- 52:07question. Hit us up offline. I have some thoughts
- 52:10on what you can do to get that one resolved.
- 52:17Okay, let's see any other questions that we missed.
- 52:28We got a few more minutes. Oh, what kinds of
- 52:32injuries treatment reach the bar for $1 million
- 52:35pre -lit settlement? Good question. Do you want
- 52:38to take this one Brigida? Sure, so. I think about
- 52:43that like you know a couple broken ribs or like
- 52:48a couple scratches is not going to meet the bar
- 52:51on a $1 million pre -lit settlement. It needs
- 52:55to rise to the injuries are significant, meaning
- 53:00like broken bones that led to surgeries or pain
- 53:06that's still existing today. And it's real injuries
- 53:10that the medical records are telling you as well.
- 53:15I don't know if you have anything else to say
- 53:16on that, John. I think the short answer to it,
- 53:19one, it's hard to answer that. But the short
- 53:21answer to it is you probably need a surgery.
- 53:26at some point and depending on the surgery, it
- 53:29might be borderline, but you probably need at
- 53:33least a surgery to get to the $1 million threshold.
- 53:37I have a good example of this. I had a case where
- 53:41a woman was hit in the crosswalk. She was walking
- 53:45and she broke her pelvis and she broke another
- 53:52bone. and she was she went to the er and did
- 53:56not have a surgery and we got the million dollar
- 53:59policy the liability was really clear i mean
- 54:03she was walking in the crosswalk with a walk
- 54:06signal and a guy was making a left hand turn
- 54:09and truly just did not look um so the liability
- 54:13was great and you know that her damages she didn't
- 54:17have surgery but she was hit pretty hard. She
- 54:21hit the ground and it was traumatic to go through
- 54:23that. She had some broken bones and we were able
- 54:26to get the policy on that. So I guess it varies
- 54:28but if you have amazing liability and pretty
- 54:32significant damages you can get the million or
- 54:34you should be able to. It's always worth a shot.
- 54:37It also depends on insurance. Is there only a
- 54:40million in insurance? Is there an umbrella? If
- 54:42there's an umbrella, then they're not really
- 54:43as afraid of risk. But the joke I like to make
- 54:47is the easiest way to get a $1 million settlement
- 54:49is to have a $2 million case with a $1 million
- 54:53policy. Let's see. Non -economic damages are
- 55:00serious, 100%. It's harder to quantify the example
- 55:05that this this person who asked the question
- 55:07is if an actor can't audition for a part because
- 55:10of the injuries I think that would go to lost
- 55:12earnings and It might be a little bit speculative
- 55:15But it's something that that's gonna be hard
- 55:17to prove pre -lead and they might want to depose
- 55:19the plaintiff and get some more information about
- 55:21something like that Knee meniscus surgery shoulder
- 55:26rotator cuff surgery. Are they worth a million
- 55:29bucks? Maybe Depends. Could be. If it's both
- 55:34in the same case, then much more likely. But
- 55:37it depends. Look, I don't think there's a cookie
- 55:40cutter answer, I wish that there was, to this
- 55:43is worth this. Usually there's ranges for cases.
- 55:46A lot of it depends on the plaintiff. A lot of
- 55:48it depends on liability, who the insurance carrier
- 55:51is, who the defense lawyer is that you draw.
- 55:53There's so many different factors. How far are
- 55:56you willing to take it? If you have a knee tear
- 55:59and a shoulder tear and they're both surgeries,
- 56:01Maybe you'll get offered, you know, 350 or 500
- 56:04pre -lit, but if you take it all the way to experts,
- 56:06you got a much better shot at getting, you know,
- 56:08a million or close to a million. There's a great
- 56:11question. Do you include jury verdict research
- 56:14with a demand letter? So something we always
- 56:17include in our demands is our firm's verdicts
- 56:21on cases that are similar to the case that we're
- 56:24litigating. So we have, you know, I literally
- 56:28have a list of all of our for example, traumatic
- 56:31brain injury results that we've gotten. And I'll
- 56:34include that list and say, you know, our firms
- 56:36gotten all these results for similar cases. And
- 56:39it does show the value. It also you also can
- 56:42do it with verdicts in your where the case has
- 56:46jurisdiction, other plaintiff verdicts for the
- 56:50same injuries. So you can show like, you know,
- 56:52this venue does get good verdicts for these injuries.
- 56:55Yeah, I agree. 100%. Something good to do something
- 56:58that we included demands. Does it make a difference
- 57:02if a public entity is the defendant as far as
- 57:04pre -lit settlement? I would say yes, in that
- 57:07public entities almost never settle pre -lit.
- 57:09It's very rare. You'll make your government claim.
- 57:12They'll deny it. They'll wait for you to follow
- 57:13the lawsuit. They don't want to pay until and
- 57:17unless they have to. So I don't even really bother
- 57:23sending public entity pre -lit demands at this
- 57:26point. Yeah. I mean, I guess it's good. In litigation
- 57:30for maybe a bad faith case, but generally I agree
- 57:34with John. It's not you wouldn't need to or want
- 57:36to do it pre lit with a public entity. Yeah,
- 57:39here's our contact information. Both of our emails
- 57:46were. in West LA, the Panish firm, if you guys
- 57:49ever want to stop by. If you have any cases that
- 57:51you want to discuss, whether it's one that you
- 57:53want to consider co -counseling on or just one
- 57:56that you want us to take a look and give feedback
- 57:58on value or strategy or whatever, happy to do
- 58:00so. We both really love our jobs and really like
- 58:03looking at cases. I think it's fun and interesting.
- 58:07with as much that happens there. So just feel
- 58:10free to shoot us an email anytime where everyone
- 58:12at the firm is super helpful. We've handled pretty
- 58:14much every type of case that you can imagine,
- 58:16I think. So happy to share, you know, specific
- 58:19templates or whatever you guys need as well.
- 58:22And then there was a question about email for
- 58:25referrals. You can or you just send your email.
- 58:28You can also email either of our emails and we'll
- 58:30respond regarding any referrals or cases. As
- 58:34John said, always happy to discuss anything you
- 58:37have questions on, happy to help in any way that
- 58:40we can be a resource. Like he said, we both really
- 58:43do love our job and I love talking about our
- 58:46cases and helping people as much as I can. Awesome.
- 58:56Alrighty, this concludes today's presentation.
- 58:58Thank you so much, John and Brigida for an excellent
- 59:01presentation and thank you so much to our audience.
- 59:04Have a great day, everybody. Thank you.