Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #206 - Mayor Ken Sim (ABC Vancouver)
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. This is Van Color Play Folks. My name is Momir and
- 0:23this is Van Color, British Columbia's Bonifide culture and politics TV talk show.
- 0:27Tonight, we're joined by a very special returning guest here to discuss a few
- 0:32major issues in the City of Vancouver, including political leadership, homelessness, and
- 0:38escalating property taxes, issues that are relevant and maybe even top of mind for
- 0:43many municipalities across BC. In last October's municipal election, every single candidate in
- 0:49his party ABC Vancouver won their seat on park board, on school board,
- 0:54and on city Council. He himself won his race in a landslide to become
- 1:00the forty first Mayor of Vancouver, the first Chinese Canadian and first person of
- 1:04color to hold the office. He is Mayor Ken sim Ken. Hello,
- 1:10thank you for returning to the program. Thank you for having me. Absolutely
- 1:12I see you occasion. Thank you. At the end of this well see,
- 1:18I was going to say, you wore your best outfit for one of
- 1:22my nicest shirts that I have in that closet. Yes, I do love
- 1:26the vibe. I will be completely honest with you, but I do have
- 1:29some questions about some of the decisions that you and city council have have made
- 1:33since you've taken office. Sure. The first is the City of Vancouver used
- 1:37to be the largest living wage employer in Canada, which means that the City
- 1:42of Vancouver would ensure a living wage for all of its employees and contractors.
- 1:49ABC, Vancouver. Your party comes into power into city Council and you say,
- 1:52you know what, Vancouver, We're not going to be a living wage
- 1:56employer anymore. So this this might not affect, you know, some of
- 2:00the managers in the office, but this might affect tow truck drivers or janitorial
- 2:05staff. So when you made that decision, what signal do you think it
- 2:07sends to other BC municipalities or other companies and just the country in general.
- 2:14Yeah. So, first thing I do have to disclose that a lot of
- 2:17these conversations were held in camera, so there are a lot of things I
- 2:22can't talk about. What I can tell you is we still have a living
- 2:25wage in the City of Vancouver. The only thing that's different is we moved.
- 2:30We changed the formula. It went from you know, an annual formula
- 2:35to a five year rolling average. But make no mistake about it, we
- 2:38are a support of the living wage. And you know, the vast majority
- 2:42of people that work at the City of Vancouver get paid while above the living
- 2:46wage, and the living wage is not going down. So when people say
- 2:52that Vancouver is no longer a living wage employer, we're saying that we are
- 2:57not still a living wage employer. Absolutely. Yeah. Do you think it's
- 3:00fair to have a five year average when we've seen the cost of living escalate
- 3:04the way it has in the last few years. You know, once again,
- 3:07I'm very limited as to what I can and cannot say, but what
- 3:10I can tell you is it helps smooths smooth out you know big you know,
- 3:17spikes or declines in any given year, and it gives a lot more
- 3:21predictability to employers, and it just you know, at the end of the
- 3:25day, we still support the living wage. We still have the living wage
- 3:30in Vancouver. Let's talk about another controversial, perhaps more high profile decision that
- 3:35you and your council made, and that was around the decampment of Hasting Street
- 3:38in the downtown east Side. Now we know that these tent encampments did pose
- 3:44a fire risk. However, we also learned from a recent Vancouver Sun article
- 3:49that in the decampment process. The City of Vancouver officials were aware that there
- 3:53were not enough shelter beds for folks that were being displaced, and we saw
- 3:57that right like we saw folks that were sleeping in a tent on Hasting Street,
- 4:00then suddenly still on Hasting Street, but now without a tent. Do
- 4:03you have any regrets about that entire process? Yeah, Well, first of
- 4:08all, I want to clarify a couple of things for the record. There
- 4:10always was enough housing or shelter space, and I know that because I was
- 4:15there the day of. We're working very closely with BC Housing and we were
- 4:19working at the whole time, and so leading up to the event. For
- 4:21eight months leading up to the event, we were offering you know, shelter
- 4:28housing options to individuals and people that wanted it got it. For two months
- 4:31leading up to the event, people started to decline them day of only ten
- 4:40people out of the sixty structures put up their hands, all ten got it,
- 4:43and the next day only eight additional people. So then this Vancouver Sun
- 4:46report saying that city officials were well aware that they did not have enough spaces
- 4:51to shelter people. Is that false or is that being spun in a different
- 4:55way. I'm trying to reconcile. Yeah, no, our version events and
- 4:58what I'm reading it. You know, Okay, I know the the article
- 5:01talked about they pulled, you know, emails and what have you. And
- 5:04I wasn't part of those emails. I can tell you I was in the
- 5:06situation room and that's something that we looked at very closely, and we had
- 5:11enough space. Okay now, and the record shows like every single person that
- 5:15put up their hand got space. Okay, so I have I can't really
- 5:21comment more about that, but at the end of the day, everyone he
- 5:26wanted it got it. The decampment process started on April fifth. About a
- 5:30week before that, there was a motion in city Council that was passed about
- 5:33nonprofit organizations having to be respectful to city council and a respectful workplace policy.
- 5:41A lot of people understood this as like, if you're an organization receiving city
- 5:46funding and you criticize the city, your your funding will be pulled. Does
- 5:50that Does those two things have anything to do with each other. The fact
- 5:54that you pass this motion that may have silenced some critics in the downtown Easide
- 5:58and then decamped the next week. No, not at all. Well,
- 6:00So, first of all, I think being critical and being respectful those are
- 6:06two different things. Sometimes they are the same, but a lot comes they
- 6:11aren't. So we actually love diversity thought, and we love you know,
- 6:15when people have different opinions, and so we will celebrate that. We continue
- 6:17to celebrate it. I think there's a distinction between being critical and you know,
- 6:25crossing a line somewhere, And all we ask is, look, we
- 6:29believe in creating safe workplaces, and one part of it is you have to
- 6:31be you know, respectful of language and how you carry yourself. So when
- 6:34this motion was passed, do you think it affected organizations in the Downtown east
- 6:39Side from perhaps being critical of the City of Vancouver for fear that they're funding
- 6:44may be pulled. No, I don't think so at all, because I
- 6:46think there are a lot of people that were vocal on April fifth and thereafter.
- 6:50Okay, so when we talk about this idea of being respectful but critical,
- 6:55you know me, I've been a critic of your government. I've been
- 6:59on CBC rate and on Twitter, and I've said that you know, ABC
- 7:01counselor Mike Classen has been gaslighting the public, and I've used that term.
- 7:06Is that disrespectful or is that critical? Well, I don't know the context
- 7:12of what you're talking about. So it was with regards to the empty homes
- 7:15tax, and which we'll get into the next segment. But even that phrase,
- 7:17you know, is that disrespectful? Um? Without context? I think,
- 7:23you know, I would have to see that term used in the context
- 7:27of the information you're referring to and what you're talking about, but to without
- 7:30that, So it sounds like the policy might be applied in a somewhat subjective
- 7:35way. Yeah, you know, it's really on a case by case basis.
- 7:39If there's something that's totally egregious, that's one thing. You know,
- 7:43people are entitled to their opinions. When it crosses a line, Um,
- 7:46you know, then we'll we'll, you know, we'll highlight it, all
- 7:49right. And so, having not heard what you said, I'm not in
- 7:54a position to comment on it. But you know what, if if it
- 7:56was egregious, I you know what, M I respect your ability to be
- 8:01critical and I will reciprocate. Um. Yeah, you know. I mean
- 8:05it's different for me as a commentator versus someone who's working or a director of
- 8:09a nonprofit organization, right, and I think the fear is that we're silencing
- 8:13them by that motion that was passed a week before the decampments. Do you
- 8:16do you kind of see what I'm saying in terms of the fear of the
- 8:20City of Vancouver or people maybe thinking that these two things are linked. Look,
- 8:24people can form their own opinions, but they're not linked at all.
- 8:26And so you know, it's people are entitled to their own opinions. And
- 8:31you know, we're very clear what we stand for, and we're not you
- 8:35know, there are a lot of people that may think that, you know,
- 8:39the policies that we pursue or the way we pursue them, they disagree
- 8:43with them, and that's okay, that's great. We should celebrate that.
- 8:48It's you know, if you cross the line, and you know, you're
- 8:52you know, when you cross the line, and it's not about I can
- 8:56appreciate that I'm going to disagree with some policies after the break and hoping that
- 9:00I don't cross the line. No, no, hey luck, we love
- 9:03we love diversity of thought. It actually makes us stronger, you know,
- 9:07and that's why you know, at ABC, for example, we'll never run
- 9:11a full sleep because we actually think it's healthy to have differing views in that
- 9:15chamber. I can appreciate that I got many more questions for you after the
- 9:18break. I figures Ken, thank you folks, stick around because after some
- 9:22business, Mayor Ken Sim will explain why the City of Vancouver's property taxes are
- 9:26up but the city's empty homes tax is down. That's up. Next,
- 9:37welcome back to This is Van Color. We're spending the entire episode with the
- 9:41Mayor of Vancouver. He is, of course, Mayor Ken Sim and this
- 9:43conversation is supported by shelter point single malt whiskey, distinctly Vancouver Island, uniquely
- 9:50shelter point. Wow, that was a tongue twister. I made it though.
- 9:54You should get bonus points for being able to say that on your first
- 9:58try. You just like to butt me up, so I take it easier.
- 10:01I'm trying to take time off the clock. I could see that.
- 10:03Okay, real talk. When you were on the campaign trail, you were
- 10:07talking about how you were going to go through the budget line by line and
- 10:11you were going to find efficiencies. You told everyone that you were a black
- 10:15belt in lean and despite the projection of a seven to eight percent property tax
- 10:20increase. You and your counsel increase property taxes by almost eleven percent. Did
- 10:26you break a campaign promise here? Well, what we did promise was we
- 10:30were going to go through the budget line by line and we'd be super thoughtful
- 10:33and we would be incredibly transparent. And you know, at the end of
- 10:35the day, property large property taxes are not sustainable, and we're staying true
- 10:41to that commitment. When we lifted the hood, we discovered, you know,
- 10:46a lot of challenges, like we have a half billion dollars capital deficit,
- 10:50so we may have a problem where we won't be able to flush toilets
- 10:54in twenty years. The reserve fund was basically depleted. We had a fire
- 11:00department that was not fully funded, a police department that wasn't fully funded.
- 11:03We have potholes, like the list goes on and on, and so we
- 11:07were put in a position where we had a choice, do we, you
- 11:11know, bite the bullet and fix what we would call a leaky roof,
- 11:16or do we kick it down the road like previous administrations and let someone deal
- 11:22with an even bigger challenge. And so that's what we did. We actually
- 11:24built the bullet and we you know, we now have a fully funded fire
- 11:30department and fully funded for the first time in like fourteen years the police department.
- 11:33We're building up reserves and you know, we're working on making the city
- 11:37more So you're going to have three more budgets under your belt before the next
- 11:41election. What can Vancouver rights reasonably expect when it comes to property tax increases?
- 11:48Okay, so there's a few things. First of all, like we
- 11:50said during the election as well, we're going to get the smartest people in
- 11:54the room to help us with it. And so that's what we did.
- 11:58We said up the Mayor's Budget Taskforce with a bunch of h CFAs and fcpas
- 12:05and chartered accountants we name it um working on it, but also a great
- 12:09cross sectional represent representation of individuals. So we have Joy make Fail on the
- 12:16community. We have Bridget Anderson from the Border Trade on the community. We
- 12:20have Wade Grant, uh you know, from Musculum so with the view of
- 12:24reconciliation, and they're tasked with you know, not holding back, looking at
- 12:30everything we do and being very you know objective and critical as to where we
- 12:35can you know, make improvements. So there could be potentially double digit property
- 12:39tax increases for the next few years. You're not ruling that out. Look,
- 12:43what we're committed to is making sure that we have the smartest people in
- 12:46the room that are independent of the city looking at our budget and they're going
- 12:52to come up with a bunch of recommendations that we are looking forward to.
- 12:56And I do put out there that well too. Things. First of all,
- 13:00um, while the City of Vancouver collects taxes um for everyone with half
- 13:05of half of the taxes we collect aren't actually City of Vancouver taxes. They're
- 13:09um and they're not in the control of the City of Vancouver, like Metro
- 13:13Translink, the provincial school tax, and so some of the increases that you
- 13:18see actually have nothing to do with the City of Vancouver. But what we
- 13:20do is we can control what we can control, and we're going to be
- 13:24incredibly diligent on that. And you know, I do want to say as
- 13:28well as UM, well, you know, optically sometimes you know, uh,
- 13:33you know, and don't get me wrong, big property tax increases are
- 13:37not sustainable. When you look at the ten point seven percent property tax increase,
- 13:41what that means to the average condo owner is a thirty three cent per
- 13:46day property tax increase. I mean, that's going to be a hard stepper,
- 13:50but nobody can. But even even that, even that increase, no,
- 13:54no, but even that, come on, what do you got any
- 13:56thirty seconds on this um? The cup fee? So if you have someone
- 14:01an average family of two individuals living in a condo, their property taxes from
- 14:07the City Vancouver one up thirty three cents, but their cup fee went down
- 14:11fifty cents. As an example, for work, they were buying cups,
- 14:13but buying cups? Okay, ken, how do you justify two property owners
- 14:18in Vancouver that their property taxes are going to be increased eleven point seven or
- 14:22sorry, ten point seven percent, But at the same time, the empty
- 14:28homes tax, which was slated to go up five percent, you actually brought
- 14:31back down to three percent. So, on one hand, property owners are
- 14:33paying more in property tax, but people who are keeping empty homes actually have
- 14:39more exemptions and their tax is lowered. How do you justify that to Vancouver
- 14:43rights? Okay, So you have to look at these two things individually,
- 14:46and so when you look at what is the goal, what do we need
- 14:48to do? We need to build as much housing as quickly as possible.
- 14:52I think we can all agree on that, okay, okay, And we
- 14:56want to get more housing stock out there. So when you actually look at
- 15:01the empty homes tax, the recommendation was to keep it at three, So
- 15:07we just kept it at three, but it was slated to be increased.
- 15:09And if you look at how do we build more housing faster, it's if
- 15:13you keep it at three, there's two things going on. What the data
- 15:16shows us that if you increase it by five, now people are incentive to
- 15:18play games and they'll actually take housing out of the rental pools. And that's
- 15:24that's the first thing. The second thing is what we want to do is
- 15:28we want to create an environment where builders of all types it's there's an environment
- 15:33where they're incentive to build more faster. And so how much more is going
- 15:37to be built by keeping the empty homes tax at three percent? Because you
- 15:39just said that you looked at the data, do you know the actual numbers?
- 15:43You know, we don't have those numbers for you. But what you
- 15:46have to do is you have to create an environment where builders are incentive to
- 15:50build. Because builders, whether we like it or not, they have a
- 15:54choice. And what's happening now is builders are choosing some not all, but
- 15:58some of them are choosing not to build in the city of anchor Ver anymore.
- 16:03And so if we don't create an environment were builders, it doesn't matter
- 16:07if they're a for profit not for profit, you know, a small big
- 16:11If we create an environment where people flee, we build less. And you
- 16:15have a situation that we have now. And this is a situation. So
- 16:18let's say that's fine. Let's say, okay, the exemptions that you added,
- 16:22keeping it at three percent, that's fine. Why did your city council
- 16:26give back millions of dollars of property tax or empty homes tax? I should
- 16:30say that was already collected earmarked for social housing. It was millions of dollars.
- 16:33You gave it back to profitable real estate developers. And this is why
- 16:37I was accusing my classen of gas lighting the public, because he was kind
- 16:41of doing mental gymnastics and trying to justify this. So how do you justify
- 16:45that while again it's still raising property taxes on people? So hard to justify
- 16:48it in a sound baite, It's going to take me about a minute,
- 16:51But you got about a minute. I got a mate, awesome, So
- 16:55what you have to do is you have to create an environment where people want
- 16:57to build. You may have to make it easy. And so when you
- 17:00charge an empty home tax on in standing inventory. M While it may seem
- 17:07like, oh, you know what, you're forcing people developers, rich developers
- 17:11to sell, what you're really doing is I think of let's say you make
- 17:15you know, frozen pies and you tell people, I get changing the tax,
- 17:22but why give them money retroactive? And that's why I have to like
- 17:26it. Like it takes me a minute to explain it because it's so hard
- 17:27to explain it sound. So let's say you have an environment where you know,
- 17:32you're you're a small business owner, and you make frozen pies and then
- 17:34one day you know and you already have the challenges of the economy of people
- 17:40are coming into your store, pandemics, what have you Now? So the
- 17:44government comes in and says, well, if you don't sell your pies in
- 17:47three days, you're going to be charged to tax on top of that.
- 17:49And you're sitting there going, well, okay, I'll struggle through this,
- 17:53but do I really want to open up another pie store in the city of
- 17:56Vancouver when I can go to Richmond and I don't like it's hard enough to
- 18:00run a business. I'm going to open my next store in Richmond. That's
- 18:04what we're doing to developers now, it's they're the easy target, or homebuilders,
- 18:10they're the easy target. What we have to do is we have to
- 18:12look beyond the politics and we have to say, look, how do we
- 18:15build as much housing as possible? Because I can tell you right now,
- 18:19I just spoke to your friend who has a place. I just can I
- 18:22just don't know if we would give money back to the pie store. We
- 18:25do have to end the segment care though, But I appreciate that answer nevertheless.
- 18:29And I got rapid fire questions when we're right, all right, folks,
- 18:33stick around. We got a few more minutes and we're gonna go rapid
- 18:34fire with the Mayor of Vancouver, Ken sim Up next. Welcome back to
- 18:44this as Van Color. We're here with the Mayor of the City of Vancouver.
- 18:47He is Ken sim Ken. You've been a great sport. Thanks for
- 18:51sticking around. I got some rapid fire questions for you. No thoughtful answers,
- 18:56just whatever's in your head. This is incredibly dangerous. Oh it will
- 18:59be yeah, all right, First one what's your favorite pizza place in the
- 19:03City of Vancouver. Nook Okay, hypothetical you win a trip to Disneyland for
- 19:08you and all your ABC City councilors except for one. You have to choose
- 19:14which one doesn't get to go to Disneyland. Which ABC City councilor do you
- 19:18leave behind? And why is it? Mike Classen? Well, that's Mike
- 19:22Classen because you just gave me a note. So because most said so,
- 19:29thank you for that. How many times a day do you think to yourself,
- 19:32Well, at least we're not surry? Oh all the time? Kidding.
- 19:37We love Surrey. They're one of our partners who has been your biggest
- 19:41source of moral support, aside from the Daily Hive. Moam, fair enough
- 19:52your second. You did give me an interview on the Monday after the election.
- 19:56I'll give you that. In twenty twenty four, which Vancouver based organization
- 20:00will have greater revenue growth? Lulu Lemon or the Vancouver Police Department? Oh,
- 20:07Lulu Lemon. No, you're not gonna fund the police thirty percent next
- 20:11next budget. Well, if inflations running out, thirty perctep. But if
- 20:17that's if inflation is running out, thirty percent. I think all of us
- 20:21are in a lot of time. I think so too. Okay, last
- 20:23rapid fire question, free library services, bike lanes or a living wage in
- 20:30your opinion, which has overstayed its welcome in the City of Vancouver. Oh,
- 20:33they're all important, none of them. You ripped out a bike lane,
- 20:37though, you got rid of the living wage according to some people,
- 20:40and you've suggested that maybe people should pay for some library services. You know,
- 20:45what actually happened was we removed a temporary bike lane and the emphasis on
- 20:48temporary, and we're re envisioning it and it's going to be even better and
- 20:52it's going to be more amazing. Living wage is still there. And not
- 20:57only have we fully funded, in complete supported the libraries, we were also
- 21:02talking about additional revenue opportunities as an idea. Obviously, the SoundBite took a
- 21:07life of its own, but we are completely supportive. Libraries play such an
- 21:11important role, not just in libraries, budding community and helping the city of
- 21:17Vancouver and a resident and our most vulnerable populations and a lot of hosts of
- 21:22issues, and we are the biggest cheerleaders supporters. So all three have are
- 21:26super important, and none of them have over and none of them could.
- 21:30I said, no thoughtful answers. But thank you, Ken Listen, You've
- 21:33been a great sport. You came in here, no holds barred. You
- 21:37let me ask whatever I wanted to. I respect that at the end of
- 21:40the day, and I do wish you and city Council, including my class
- 21:44and the best of black going forward. So thank you so much for your
- 21:45time tonight, Thanks for having me, and I'll give Mike a big hug.
- 21:48Absolutely, folks, listen, he is a popular mayor and I will
- 21:53say that regardless of how some of you may feel about his decisions, and
- 21:57you know that I feel very strongly about some of them. He came in
- 22:00here, no holds barred, and you have to respect him for that.
- 22:03He is the mayor of the City of Vancouver. He is Ken sim And
- 22:07that's it for tonight's show. If you want more, this is Van Color,
- 22:10including full episodes and bonus content, find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 22:15Check Media's YouTube channel, and the Check Plus app. But for now,
- 22:18this is Van Color and I'm o emir telling you that in a province
- 22:22where you can be anything, be colorful. Peace