Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 7 Episode 11: Why Coercive Control Laws Alone Won't Protect Women and Children with Dr. Marsha Scott
Transcript
- 0:16David Mandel: And we're back.
- 0:17David Mandel: Hello.
- 0:18R: How's it going?
- 0:19David Mandel: I'm doing okay this morning.
- 0:21R: And who are you?
- 0:22David Mandel: I'm David Mandel, and this is partner with Survivor.
- 0:24David Mandel: Who are you?
- 0:25R: I'm Ruth Ramundo.
- 0:26R: Yes.
- 0:27David Mandel: And I'm glad that we avoided the Benadryl crisis this time.
- 0:30R: Oh, I almost took Benadryl this morning, guys.
- 0:32R: It would have been a really fun episode.
- 0:34R: But before we start and before we introduce our guest, I just want to do a little land acknowledgement.
- 0:39R: We are on Tunksis Masako land in the Farmington Valley.
- 0:43R: And it is firmly springtime in a matter of 24 hours.
- 0:49R: And the trees have decided they are just going to push out all of their little leaf leafages in a short brief period of time.
- 0:56R: Nothing leafages.
- 0:57R: Leafages.
- 0:58R: It's a new word.
- 0:58R: I can make up words.
- 1:00R: So it's a beautiful land.
- 1:02R: And we just want to send our regards to any Indigenous elders, past, present, and emerging.
- 1:09R: All right.
- 1:10David Mandel: So we have a long standing relationship with the country of Scotland.
- 1:17David Mandel: And then people, but you don't have a real, you know, I don't know, you have a relationship with the land, but also with people.
- 1:22David Mandel: And just as uh because we're celebrating our 20th anniversary, Scotland was the first place that we did our core training outside of the United States.
- 1:30SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:31David Mandel: And shout out to Anna Mitchell, you know, who kind of helped create that.
- 1:35David Mandel: But within that, we've had a long-standing relationship with Scottish Women's Aid.
- 1:39SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:40David Mandel: And much of that time has been with our guest.
- 1:45David Mandel: That relationship has been our guest.
- 1:47David Mandel: I'm going to say Dr.
- 1:48David Mandel: Marcia Scott.
- 1:49David Mandel: I'm going to give you your full kudos, Marsha.
- 1:53David Mandel: And who's the CEO of Scottish Women's Aid.
- 1:56David Mandel: And not only is she a national leader in the domestic abuse prevention and intervention field, but also an international leader on coercive control, uh, children's humans' rights, uh, and a number of different things.
- 2:09David Mandel: And so this is, I think, the second time we've had Marsha.
- 2:12David Mandel: Yeah.
- 2:12David Mandel: So I just want to, Marcia, welcome you to the show.
- 2:16SPEAKER_03: Well, thank you.
- 2:17SPEAKER_03: Hi guys.
- 2:18SPEAKER_03: It's so lovely to see you.
- 2:19SPEAKER_03: It's lovely.
- 2:20David Mandel: Yeah, and you're actually joining us from the United States, not actually from Scotland.
- 2:25SPEAKER_03: No, I know.
- 2:26SPEAKER_03: Well, the time frame, the time difference is a little easier from Nashville than it is from it is from Edinburgh.
- 2:34SPEAKER_03: Although, you know, we always make it work, as you know, although Australia is a challenge.
- 2:39R: But we we very much everywhere that we go, just to let you know.
- 2:44R: And and and and I'm a person who's I'm very I give out compliments very sparingly because I can't say what I don't mean.
- 2:52R: So every time I say that Scotland is at the forefront of a lot of change and best practices around domestic violence in children, I absolutely mean that.
- 3:06R: And every once in a while I go back and I do a search and I look at all the different reform efforts, and I'm like, yeah, okay, you know, Scotland and Australia are still at the top, in my in my estimation.
- 3:17R: So for whatever it's worth, Scotland has my heart for its reform efforts and for its constant towards changing the the impact of systems on women and children.
- 3:33David Mandel: So, you know, I maybe for us to start, we we often give guests questions and then we kind of blow them up right away, which is I think what we're doing today.
- 3:41David Mandel: But, you know, I off of that comment, I just want to say that one of the greatest joys, I think, in my professional career at this point is building connect great people and also to take learnings from one place to another.
- 3:54David Mandel: So off of your point, Ruth, you know, I will often talk about the course control law in Scotland as a gold standard, not only for how what it is, but how it was written and how it's you know, implementations for.
- 4:09David Mandel: And so Marcia's presented at our Australian conference remotely on that.
- 4:13David Mandel: And then most recently, we've helped connect up Marsha's Scottish Women's Aid and efforts in Scotland around child contact with the wonderful folks we're working with in Australia.
- 4:25David Mandel: So I, you know, that's you know, that's sort of a wide open space, Marcia, for you to comment on the relationship or just sort of the Scotland or, you know, let's turn it over to you.
- 4:33SPEAKER_03: Well, first of all, it's it's very germane, really.
- 4:38SPEAKER_03: When you talk about our having done all this innovative work, and you can tell I don't live in the US anymore because I don't say innate in and how do we set how do you say it in the US?
- 4:48SPEAKER_03: Innovative.
- 4:49SPEAKER_03: That was innovative.
- 4:50SPEAKER_03: I'm acculturated now that I've been there for 25 years.
- 4:53SPEAKER_03: But we're 50.
- 4:56SPEAKER_03: Scottish Women's Aid is 50 years old this year, and I'm so minded that any of the work that we're doing in 2026 depended on the work that was done in 2016 and in 2006.
- 5:12SPEAKER_03: And you know, the and the reality is, and I say this often, but I mean it every single time, which is we're standing on the shoulders of women who didn't have a safe and together institute to help, you know, to give them tools that actually worked with social workers that didn't, you know, do the work with social workers to help change hearts and minds and courts and and everybody else.
- 5:39SPEAKER_03: And you know, it's those women who were visionaries.
- 5:43SPEAKER_03: And and and beyond that, I suppose just wouldn't quit.
- 5:50SPEAKER_03: Do you know what I mean?
- 5:51SPEAKER_03: And those women are everywhere.
- 5:53SPEAKER_03: I which Scotland doesn't have the you know, the only supply of fabulous women like that.
- 5:59SPEAKER_03: I you know, we the fact that we've been able to do some some things that I'm very proud of, I mean, that I think are terrific, but that are only the beginning, making changes for women and children has come comes from a set of circumstances that nurtured, you know, the passions of people who were committed to children's rights and women's rights.
- 6:23SPEAKER_03: And and as we know in current political times, that can disappear very quickly.
- 6:29SPEAKER_03: But the foundation is always there, I think.
- 6:32SPEAKER_03: And eventually, eventually we come back to understanding what's valuable in our lives.
- 6:39R: I love I love that community.
- 6:41R: Yeah, I love that acknowledging of all of the efforts before, you know, and building on each of those skills and building that advocacy.
- 6:53R: And that brings me into, I'm kind of skipping over our first question and going into our second about policy wins in Scotland, including the course of control legislation, and how those have translated into real change where they have and where they've not quite.
- 7:14R: So I don't know if you want to go over your bird's eye view of that.
- 7:19SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think I think we didn't probably recognize at the time just how radical that legislation was in terms of if you're sincerely implementing it, that it requires significant attitudinal and system change.
- 7:39SPEAKER_03: So I would say that it would be overly optimistic to say that it had you know changed a huge amount of people's lives at this point in terms of women and children experiencing domestic abuse.
- 7:56SPEAKER_03: It's changed some.
- 7:57SPEAKER_03: There's there isn't any question.
- 7:58SPEAKER_03: I mean, I think two months after the the bill went live, we had a woman call our helpline and say, I I used to go to the police all the time and tell them what he was doing to me.
- 8:09SPEAKER_03: And they would say, That's awful, that's terrible, but it's not illegal.
- 8:13SPEAKER_03: There's nothing I can do to help you.
- 8:14SPEAKER_03: And then after the new law was passed, she went, she brought the guy pled guilty because the evidence was overwhelming, and she got a 24-month non-harassment order, which changed a lot.
- 8:27SPEAKER_03: So I I don't want to I don't want to undersell what's happened, and those things happen still every day.
- 8:33SPEAKER_03: However, my my assessment of what happens in courts and what happens in sentencing and what happens out with courts and sentencing with women who are don't trust the system rightfully, don't trust the system to to to seek help from the system, is that we still have a really long way to go.
- 8:54SPEAKER_03: And we always were gonna have a long way to go.
- 8:57SPEAKER_03: It's not, you know, this is not change that you can, you know, wake up on Sunday and suddenly have a society that values women and children's human rights and that and then sees the changes it needs to make to do that.
- 9:11R: I want to I want to kind of dive into the the nut of your point, and that is is that oftentimes change efforts are focused on legal changes, specific policy changes, with the belief and with the the necessary building, the scaffolding of change to create expectations, but with the belief that it is going to change practice, to change outcomes.
- 9:42R: Can you talk to me just a little bit about the about the dividing line between the belief that changing a law and changing policy is going to necessarily lead to better outcomes and where that breaks down?
- 9:56R: Because I think that's very important for people who are change makers, who are trying to make change in spaces, particularly around collaboration with other people.
- 10:07R: Because one may be a legal expert and change a law, but changing the law does not necessarily mean that the law is applied in the spirit of the law by the persons who are in charge of litigating.
- 10:20David Mandel: Or before Marshall, or survivors' faith in change makers and systems, and whether they think it's a genuine effort to change or window dressing.
- 10:27David Mandel: Right.
- 10:28David Mandel: Because, well, this you guys did this, you you're promoting it, you're in the news, you know, but nothing's changed for me.
- 10:34David Mandel: So therefore, I can't trust you or the system versus having maybe a more nuanced view.
- 10:40David Mandel: So yeah, if you could break that down, Marsh, that'd be great.
- 10:42SPEAKER_03: There's so much in all of that.
- 10:43SPEAKER_03: It's really hard to know where to start.
- 10:45SPEAKER_03: I would say that uh the core of my answer, Ruth, I think with your question about does it make a difference having a new law and how much of a difference does it make?
- 10:56SPEAKER_03: And how do you make it make a difference?
- 10:59SPEAKER_03: Is it's something that David's heard me carry on about quite a bit over the years, which is implementation.
- 11:07SPEAKER_03: And everybody in Scotland loves this new phrase that we have an implementation gap.
- 11:12SPEAKER_03: Well, I'm sorry, everybody has an implementation gap.
- 11:15SPEAKER_03: And from my perspective, we've been letting everybody off the hook for changes for years by saying, okay, we have the law, we have the code of practice or the protocol or the this or the that, we've done the training with the people.
- 11:31SPEAKER_03: So everything must be better.
- 11:33SPEAKER_03: But you're absolutely right.
- 11:34SPEAKER_03: If it's if it's not, you know, if we can't demonstrate that women and children are safer, safer, and in in our context in Scotland, safer, less poor, have more power at the tables that are distributing resources, whether it's in their family, in their workplace, in their community, in their country, you know, then then we you know, then all of the you know, pretty words make no difference.
- 11:59SPEAKER_03: So my my feeling is that so we can uh we can unpick our our system at the moment, and I this is where I live, right?
- 12:08SPEAKER_03: You know, is so what what would make this law make a difference for women and children?
- 12:14SPEAKER_03: Well, you know, obviously the the prosecution, the the pol the policing, then I'll come to police probably because that's the most important at this point in my life, but uh the judiciary, which are a wicked issue for us, how how the how the hell you support them to change, and the the legal the legal infrastructure so that women have good legal advice and and services.
- 12:41SPEAKER_03: So all of those things are areas that we have to be working in.
- 12:45SPEAKER_03: But for me, I guess the reality is that it's a lot of moving parts, you know, yeah.
- 12:53SPEAKER_03: And and and the critical piece for me is always ask what's your what's your infrastructure?
- 13:00SPEAKER_03: If you're making a change and you're trying to put it in place and there's no infrastructure to to to feed it to survive and to thrive and to continue to innovate, then then you just flush that money down the toilet.
- 13:14SPEAKER_03: Because and that's what I say I'm saying all the time about training in Scotland.
- 13:18SPEAKER_03: But these everybody wants to just train people and then walk away.
- 13:21SPEAKER_03: I'm like, well, why don't you just take that money and flush it down the toilet?
- 13:24SPEAKER_03: Because it's not gonna make any change in the courts.
- 13:26SPEAKER_03: And we saw that we were part of the training, the court ordered training for all sheriffs and judges after the law was passed.
- 13:33SPEAKER_03: It was a great training, changed nothing.
- 13:36David Mandel: So it's I I w I wonder if the yeah, I've had an experience recently.
- 13:42SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah, we know how to do it.
- 13:44SPEAKER_03: We do know how to do it.
- 13:45SPEAKER_03: So that's my thing is it's not a black box anymore, right?
- 13:49SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 13:50SPEAKER_03: So we do know you do need training, but then you need you need supervision and account accountability, right?
- 13:57SPEAKER_03: And yeah, and if you don't don't have those last two, the first is what useless.
- 14:03R: So for me, just you know, I know I haven't been doing this as long as you, and you have very in-depth knowledge of your perspective.
- 14:11R: And I probably have what a nice way to say boring.
- 14:14R: Yeah, okay.
- 14:16R: And I probably have more surface level multi-regional bird's eye view.
- 14:21R: But for me, what I see as severely lacking is actually the accountability piece.
- 14:26R: Ultimately, at the end of the day, the accountability piece rubbing up against things like judicial immunity, judicial, you know independence and and other issues within the court systems.
- 14:40SPEAKER_03: But, you know, I love that you are so grounded in not only changing the scaffolding of the law and the policy, but also about making sure that Scottish Women's Aid is always in there about the implementation about the Well, that's one of the things I was gonna say is that we don't get people saying, Oh, you shouldn't talk about this law because it hasn't made any difference.
- 15:08SPEAKER_03: In part because it has changed the national discourse around domestic abuse.
- 15:13SPEAKER_03: It's very significantly.
- 15:15SPEAKER_03: Now, there's still a lot a lot to do about that, but nobody asks me what about the man anymore.
- 15:23SPEAKER_03: Right?
- 15:24SPEAKER_03: Nobody nobody says, Oh, well, that's not domestic abuse if you're describing um stalking and you know, horrific control of everyday life.
- 15:34SPEAKER_03: Now, that hasn't transferred into what I would call appropriate practice in the courts, but it's part of the picture.
- 15:44SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 15:44SPEAKER_03: But the the other thing for me is we do have accountability in the sense that we have police data, we have crown data, we have you know health data.
- 15:56SPEAKER_03: So it's really clear to us that the outcomes have not shifted significantly yet.
- 16:01SPEAKER_03: But I I do have faith that that and let me go circle back just a bit.
- 16:08SPEAKER_03: So, but the other thing is part of the the joy of my job is that I get to I get to whine a lot.
- 16:18SPEAKER_03: So I you know, I I don't know if I'm allowed to say this on the podcast, but I get to be I get to say bitchy things about um the failure for people to do what it says on the tent.
- 16:33SPEAKER_01: Right?
- 16:34SPEAKER_03: And and that's part of the you know, that's part of the mechanisms of change in Scotland, is that because we're small, because we have a political, very carefully, intentionally, explicitly crafted political process that allows significant engagement with our with our responsible politicians, right?
- 17:00SPEAKER_03: And officials.
- 17:01SPEAKER_03: And don't, you know, don't get me started on all the things that would change about it, but it's a much it's much more amenable, I think, to innovation.
- 17:10SPEAKER_03: And also they they quite like being better than England.
- 17:14SPEAKER_03: So um so I, you know, we have we have levers for change, but what we're changing here are, you know, centuries-old attitudes about women being property and children being property, yeah, and I can do with you whatever I want, you know, as long as nobody sees it and makes a big deal about it.
- 17:35SPEAKER_03: You know, I think that you know, it is it's a massive task, and we shouldn't undersell how how far we've come.
- 17:42SPEAKER_03: And that's the other lesson from being 50 this year, is when I look back, you know, 50 years ago in Scotland, you could still rep your wood.
- 17:52SPEAKER_03: There were hardly any refugees, there was no national 24-7 helpline, you know, and we we lose sight of those things and we burn ourselves out when we do.
- 18:03SPEAKER_03: So I think that's so important.
- 18:06SPEAKER_03: Is it enough?
- 18:07SPEAKER_03: No, God no, it isn't.
- 18:09SPEAKER_03: But it how do we how do we keep going is sometimes it's by stopping and looking back.
- 18:16R: I love that.
- 18:17R: I love that it's so easy to get caught in an advocacy trap, like the advocacy dungeon is what I'm gonna call it, where you just you're down in the basement, you're fighting with the pipes that are all rusty and not working, and you just think I'm never gonna make my way out of here, and you haven't seen the daylight in a long time.
- 18:38R: So, all of you advocates out there all around the globe, please hear Marsha's wise, wise advice to be able to see the full breadth of what it is that's been done.
- 18:51R: But also, you know, Marsha, I just want to give you a lot of kudos because I love the way that you express your advocacy in Scotland.
- 19:02R: I've always been very touched by it because it's so easy to get burned out, to become jaded, to become just just frozen with with with the negative, that keeping the view that we have to look at the long view of what we are trying to achieve and what we have achieved, but also to really just say, well, this is my job.
- 19:32R: These systems are this way.
- 19:35R: They're this way, they've been this way, they've been this way for a long time.
- 19:38R: And my job is just to keep pointing out to these systems where they're not actually doing the job they say they're doing, and they're not giving the the tin promise that they say serve and protect, not serving and protecting women and children.
- 19:56R: I'm giving fair judicial judgments for people in divorce, not giving fair judicial judgments.
- 20:03R: That's kind of our it's kind of the job that that has to be done, and I love the way that you do it.
- 20:08R: So that's just a little bit of encouragement for advocates out there around the world.
- 20:12SPEAKER_03: Just put a footnote the that that big picture that I talk about is exactly what I've said.
- 20:17SPEAKER_03: However, I do hear on almost a daily basis about how change has made some women and children's lives better.
- 20:24SPEAKER_03: Yeah, and and there's an awful lot of people working hard to make that be true, you know.
- 20:29SPEAKER_03: So we have champions in the in the police, champions in the crown.
- 20:35SPEAKER_03: It's starting to get some champions in the judiciary.
- 20:38SPEAKER_03: So, you know, it's it's all those people working together, God knows.
- 20:43SPEAKER_03: So that's great.
- 20:44SPEAKER_03: Well, it's really important.
- 20:45SPEAKER_03: That's great.
- 20:46David Mandel: It's it's actually this one isn't what I was gonna say, but it's making me think about that quote.
- 20:50David Mandel: I I I officiated a wedding this weekend and about having the the one hand the world in your the whole world in one pocket and answers and dust in the other.
- 20:59David Mandel: You have to hold you have to hold both.
- 21:01David Mandel: You have to hold this reality of magical, huge change of things that have been embedded for centuries or or or thousands of years, and then sort of the the unacceptable nature of the slowness of that change and the reality of the real harm that's continuing.
- 21:16David Mandel: It's it's both things are true.
- 21:17David Mandel: And it's hard to hold those, especially if you're sitting in a position where you're the person being harmed, or you're the person who's really dedicated yourself to making meaningful change.
- 21:26SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 21:27David Mandel: I have a uh Marsh, I have a question for you that was raised, it's sort of along the lines of this conversation around coercive control.
- 21:34David Mandel: Uh I was talking recently about sort of how we use with the Safety Institute coercive control is this analytical engine, this assessment engine, you know, looking for behaviors, looking for patterns, as and as as you and I have spoken about, where you said very elegantly, you know, not privileging physical violence anymore, not ignoring it, but really saying, wait a second, we're really gonna think about right, we're gonna think about entrapment, we're gonna think about deprivation of human rights.
- 22:00David Mandel: You can't look just through a narrow is there physical violence here or not lens.
- 22:05David Mandel: And really, I agree with that a thousand percent.
- 22:07David Mandel: And so we train practitioners in sort of thinking through this lens of patterns of behavior, starting with course control as the big picture.
- 22:15David Mandel: And then sort of maybe it's not there, maybe it's not there in the same way.
- 22:18David Mandel: We all know that there can be entrapment in one area, maybe not in another one the same way.
- 22:22David Mandel: And that, but this person responded on social media and was like in this binary.
- 22:28David Mandel: It's like it's present or it's not.
- 22:30David Mandel: And I realized they were looking through a criminal justice lens.
- 22:32David Mandel: And so, so I just wonder if you could speak to that tension, which is sort of because the criminal justice system is is there enough evidence to charge somebody with this crime?
- 22:43David Mandel: Boom.
- 22:44David Mandel: And then can we convict them on this crime?
- 22:46David Mandel: Boom.
- 22:47David Mandel: It's very binary, it's there or it's not.
- 22:50SPEAKER_03: Yeah, that's why course of conduct laws are so important, I think.
- 22:55SPEAKER_03: And that, you know, ours is not the only one, but that was one of the very significant changes when we moved from the existing criminal justice framework to use to prosecuting it as a course of conduct.
- 23:10SPEAKER_03: Because I think that the the answer to that question of is it there or isn't it there, from my perspective comes down to did what the the accused or the perpetrator do constrain the choice, the life choices of a woman or children?
- 23:31SPEAKER_03: And so it's a it's about the possible effects rather than than the actual effects often.
- 23:43SPEAKER_03: And getting getting some folks in the criminal justice system to move away from this binary thinking is one of the big challenges of you know improving implementation of this law.
- 23:53SPEAKER_03: And you know, they've got a million different pressures on them.
- 23:57SPEAKER_03: I wouldn't, I'm not pretending that they're sitting down going, I wonder how we can police coercive control better.
- 24:03SPEAKER_03: But I do think that the the I we try to we talk about the space for action thing all the time, because that's really the where the rubber hits the road.
- 24:14SPEAKER_03: And it, as you say so eloquently in your work, it it's the perpetrator pattern, it's different in every case.
- 24:21SPEAKER_03: And and an action in in one family or with one woman might might diminish her space for action immeasurably, and with the next not at all.
- 24:32SPEAKER_03: And that's how you have to look at it, I guess.
- 24:35SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 24:35R: Can you just explain for our listeners, because they don't know what those course of conduct laws mean?
- 24:41R: So can you just give a little outline of what that means?
- 24:44SPEAKER_03: So so our law is a course of conduct law, which means that, or the section of the domestic abuse act that that refers to coercive and controlling behaviors.
- 24:55SPEAKER_03: And that means that there has to have been, and it's still a little bit incident-based, but it turns out if I'd known I did worry about that at the time a little bit, and it turns out not a problem at all, and I should have thought of this, because so it it kind of it turns around.
- 25:12SPEAKER_03: Are there two at least two incidents in which the accused has behaved in a way that either was intended to harm or be with and be is the much more important one because you can't prove intent easily at all, is what what a reasonable person think that this was, you know, that that this person was reckless in the face of possibly harming somebody.
- 25:39SPEAKER_03: And what what that course of conduct then means is that you don't have to say him, you know, refusing to give you the car keys and take your child to the to the school in itself was you know, was a crime because there might have been other you know circumstances going on.
- 25:58SPEAKER_03: But when we look at that, plus the fact that he threatened to take the children away if you leave, or he locked the food cabinets, or you know, all the stories we hear.
- 26:09SPEAKER_03: Um that there's somebody trying to can control and constrain somebody else.
- 26:18R: Right, remove somebody's uh liberties and self-determination.
- 26:22R: You know, it's it's it's really interesting to me because we're ranging between conversations about different systems pretty easily in this room because we all work between different systems.
- 26:36R: But most people work within their little silos, right?
- 26:41R: They work within the court system, or they work within child protection, or they work within domestic violence services, or they work within child and family services.
- 26:50R: So sometimes I think what's difficult is adopting an attitude between all of those services that perhaps the court systems can only do this much.
- 27:02R: And they can only do this much right now.
- 27:05R: And perhaps the problem is thinking that everything is a single stroke intervention, that we're just gonna get a conviction for coercive control instead of saying, you know what, this particular case may not be so black and white, but there is a pattern of behaviors that shows liberty reduction.
- 27:24R: And therefore, some professional needs to work with this family and have eyes on through this process of separation to assure that the liberties of the of the person who is being impinged upon are not are not removed or not impacted by their behaviors.
- 27:45R: We haven't started thinking like that yet.
- 27:48R: Everything is still thought through the lens of accountability, is a single-stroke action, which is court-based and conviction-based.
- 27:55R: And at least, you know, here in the United States, particularly for marginalized, racialized populations, I am part Latina, that does not work for us.
- 28:06R: We need multiple points of intervention of people who are very well skilled at working with coercive control and post-separation abuse, that respect the fact that there is a lot of people who do not want to engage the court system for that intervention for a lot of very good reasons, including the low rate of success, not only at convictions, but at feeling as if your life has improved with contact with the courts.
- 28:36R: And all of us as professionals need to look at this from the vantage point of how do I be an interventive backstop for somebody who's experiencing domestic abuse and course of control in my context and to share that responsibility.
- 28:54R: So that's where I see that we haven't quite we we still are thinking in silos in a lot of instances.
- 29:02R: I don't know if you have thoughts on that, Marsha.
- 29:05SPEAKER_03: I do.
- 29:06SPEAKER_03: I think it's complicated and don't have any big answers.
- 29:09SPEAKER_03: I will say I think we need to be really careful in thinking that one small piece of the system changing is going to change the rest of the system.
- 29:20SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 29:21SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 29:22SPEAKER_03: And I actually just had this conversation with somebody in when I was in New York about the whole you know movement to defund the police and you know move away from criminal justice.
- 29:37SPEAKER_03: And I guess, as you know, Ruth, it's been a debate in feminist circles for decades.
- 29:43SPEAKER_03: And I I again it's not a binary for me.
- 29:48SPEAKER_03: Do you know what I mean?
- 29:49SPEAKER_03: I think that we all know that most women and children never come into contact with the police, and they never contact the police, and that and that those women and children find resources in their lives, in their communities, in their families, wherever to become safer, right?
- 30:10SPEAKER_03: There's no accountability for the perpetrator in any of that, generally, but their women and children are probably that was uh, you know, I'm the last person to second guess those choices.
- 30:23SPEAKER_03: So what that tells me is you know, social work, schools, health, nobody's off the hook here.
- 30:30SPEAKER_03: You know, do not be counting on the courts to take care of your business.
- 30:34SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 30:35SPEAKER_03: So all of that has to be done.
- 30:38SPEAKER_03: But the the flip side of no binary for me is as a survivor of domestic abuse and as somebody who did, you know, our helpline is filled with 23,000, 25,000 probably this year calls from people, many of whom are just desperately trying to figure out what's going to get them safer.
- 30:58SPEAKER_03: You know, the the the first the last line and the first line of defense.
- 31:04SPEAKER_03: How do I say this?
- 31:05SPEAKER_03: It's the last resort for women to call the police.
- 31:08SPEAKER_03: Absolutely the last resort.
- 31:11SPEAKER_03: But it's the only thing that they have at that moment in their lives.
- 31:16SPEAKER_03: And so, you know, the we we need to be able to improve what happens to them when they do that.
- 31:24SPEAKER_03: Absolutely.
- 31:30SPEAKER_03: But we also need, I think, to talk to them and find out what is happening in their communities that would give them, you know, that that we could change, that would make things better.
- 31:42SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 31:42SPEAKER_03: Because it's there's no simple answer to any of this.
- 31:46SPEAKER_03: And and we have certain mechanisms in our society that are that that should be supportive.
- 31:52SPEAKER_03: Do you know what I mean?
- 31:53R: Well, just from a governmental standpoint, to look at police services and say, wow, 80% of your callouts are about domestic abuse, but your practice in domestic abuse is horrible.
- 32:08R: If that was any other professional uh body where we could track those poor responses and the overt resistance to responding to one's bread and butter call-out, there would be a big problem.
- 32:23SPEAKER_03: And government is funny that you use the bread and butter phrase because I actually use that all the time.
- 32:28SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 32:29SPEAKER_03: You know, I'll be saying, I'll be saying to the to the crown, you know, I don't think you need a specialist approach to domestic abuse.
- 32:37SPEAKER_03: It should be your bread and butter.
- 32:39SPEAKER_03: But that should be the first thing everybody gets trained on because it's 25 to 35 percent of your business, and there is nothing else that you do that comes in at you know at a higher percentage.
- 32:50SPEAKER_03: So I'm totally with you on that, that this is their bread and butter.
- 32:53SPEAKER_03: And until their practice reflects this as their priority need, right?
- 32:58SPEAKER_03: I I do think that the you know, we're we're we've just passed legislation in Scotland to do domestic homicide.
- 33:08SPEAKER_03: I can't believe I couldn't get them to change that to femicide, but anyway, and suicide reviews, right?
- 33:15SPEAKER_03: And that's that's gonna be another good lever, I think, for us for accountability.
- 33:20David Mandel: That's great.
- 33:21David Mandel: I'm thinking about two things that as I listened to this really wonderful conversation.
- 33:25David Mandel: One is this siloing, and at our recent conference, and and Judge Beckhouse, who you you you met recently, was one of the panelists.
- 33:32David Mandel: We had a judicial panel.
- 33:34David Mandel: But the reason I one of the reasons I wanted to do a judicial panel was to have judges, it was a judge and a justice, say to a mostly NGO audience, you know, women's advocates, child welfare, child protection, all sorts of folks say, your evidence, you the way you write your notes is really important to us, really makes a difference.
- 33:54David Mandel: Because a lot of times it's sort of like, well, the judges are up here with all this power.
- 33:58David Mandel: And I know, and you know, that it's it's actually much more complex than that.
- 34:01David Mandel: And judges, even well-intentioned, well-educated judges can only rule on what's in front of them.
- 34:06David Mandel: And so it's often this poor solicitors, poor legal representation, poor evidence, poor, you know, and and I and so they said that literally, and Ruth highlighted the time that Justice Altebelli is on the panel and said, a perpetrator pattern-based approach, focusing on behaviors is gold for me as a judge.
- 34:24David Mandel: And and that's only going to come from their judges, they are not investigators, judges are not, you know, people who gather information, they're not assessors, they don't write reports, they they may do findings, they make decisions.
- 34:36David Mandel: But so so that's one thing I'm thinking about.
- 34:38David Mandel: But the other thing I'm I'm really thinking about this sort of how do you you make coercive control embedded in the way people do business?
- 34:48David Mandel: That understanding of what it is, what it looks like, you know, how do you operationalize it for people in their role, and then how do you help them carry that every day?
- 35:00David Mandel: And I know that I'm constantly encouraging people, this is one part of it, to say, well, ask somebody when they're not going to work or they're not going to a job or they're not they're expressing unhappiness about how they're raising their kids and wanting to do it differently.
- 35:17David Mandel: Ask them how would your partner respond if you right now picked up and went over to see your mom?
- 35:22David Mandel: Like, let's just make it really practical.
- 35:24David Mandel: Like, what's stopping you not physically being chained here?
- 35:27David Mandel: Describe to me what you would face as a reaction if you went out looking for a job today, or you you spent money the way you want, or you parented the way you want to.
- 35:38David Mandel: And that often captures that course of conduct because somebody will say, he'll do this, he'll do this, he'll do that.
- 35:45David Mandel: Well, why do you tell me, give me a little more information about what makes you believe that?
- 35:49David Mandel: And it's not questioning, but it's gathering information.
- 35:51David Mandel: And they'll tell you, he's done this before, he's done this before, he's threatened this, he said this.
- 35:54David Mandel: And so I believe him because he's either done it before, he's credibly threatened it.
- 35:59David Mandel: And I I really been trying, I really try in all these different settings that we get to have contact with to help people really think through this lens of I love your comment about intent, it's hard to prove because they've been struggling with this in Australia and the course of control law, I'm sure you know in New South Wales as an intent component.
- 36:16David Mandel: So I was talking to somebody about this intersection of men and suicide.
- 36:23David Mandel: You were talking about suicide in a slightly different context a second ago, but they were asking me, they wanted to do a study on the intersection of men's suicidality and domestic abuse perpetration, which was great.
- 36:36David Mandel: And they were look, they were asking questions about intent.
- 36:39David Mandel: I said, you can't, don't think you you want to look at intent.
- 36:43David Mandel: Because intent is this sort of deep well of sort of like depression, what's going on?
- 36:48David Mandel: Is this person really about trying to kill themselves, or are they really about trying to control somebody?
- 36:52David Mandel: It's like that sort of feels like a like a no-win conversation.
- 36:56David Mandel: I said, what you want to do is look at an impact.
- 37:00David Mandel: You want and you want to look at patterns.
- 37:02David Mandel: Is the suicidality embedded one in a larger course of conduct around course of control?
- 37:07David Mandel: So that's one way, but also forgetting like good, bad intention controlling timing is is the suicidality timed to, well, I'm leaving you, I'm ending the relationship.
- 37:19David Mandel: And does it have the effect of because if I care about you, the fact that you might kill yourself, I leave is gonna be one of the biggest controlling things you can imagine.
- 37:32SPEAKER_03: So don't if you have children.
- 37:35David Mandel: And if you have children, what's gonna happen to the kids?
- 37:37David Mandel: I mean, it's right, you know, we know from survivors that they're thinking about a father who killed himself.
- 37:41David Mandel: That's right.
- 37:41David Mandel: All these so, so, but for me, what I want to just you know throw to you is sort of this how do we, because what guides me in those moments, what I want I want this researcher to be thinking about, which is think about coercive control, think about this this question of research through this really powerful lens of is this embedded in a pattern of behavior that's wider than just the suicidality versus your narrow lens of mental health or suicidality?
- 38:08David Mandel: And then think about impact, because I don't care at that moment, like we can't parse, like it's like weighing out like on a scale, like how much of this is true desire to harm oneself versus desire to control somebody else.
- 38:25David Mandel: It seems like an impossible question.
- 38:29David Mandel: How do we keep people on track with this?
- 38:32SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think it comes around to what I was saying about the the way the law is crafted in Scotland, which is it's you do not have to prove any harm to the victim, right, in Scotland.
- 38:44SPEAKER_03: You only have to prove the possibility that somebody was reckless and in the face of that harm and the potential of that harm.
- 38:52SPEAKER_03: And I would say that that that in a way that sits actually nicely with what you were describing about what's the impact, because it's about the potential impact, right?
- 39:03SPEAKER_03: And you know, I've like you both, I'm sure, I've you know spent years being involved in asking the question trainings and you know how do you how do you identify course of and I and I hear so often it makes me so uncomfortable when people say, Oh, well, she didn't understand that she was experiencing abuse.
- 39:22SPEAKER_03: And I'm like, maybe she didn't use your words for it, but you know she didn't like it.
- 39:27SPEAKER_03: Yeah, you know, I'm like so.
- 39:30SPEAKER_03: What's the impact here?
- 39:32SPEAKER_03: Is it is the harm is it is the suicide, for instance, in the suicide thing, the suicidality, is it, you know, is it what's the impact on other people?
- 39:44SPEAKER_03: What would you what would a reasonable person think the impact of telling somebody I'm gonna kill myself if you leave me is going to have?
- 39:52SPEAKER_03: And that's what you have to assume was gonna happen.
- 39:54David Mandel: Right.
- 39:55David Mandel: And it and it's and it is it's this I I think a lot about the Invisible Woman data book.
- 40:03David Mandel: And I'm I I um wish I could remember her.
- 40:05SPEAKER_03: Carolyn uh Creato.
- 40:08SPEAKER_03: Oh, I can never remember both.
- 40:09David Mandel: Yeah, me too.
- 40:10David Mandel: I I feel really bad because I've cited her a number of times.
- 40:13David Mandel: But for you know, I really it really made an impact on me, which is she says out of our research, what gets left out of it over and over again is women's unpaid caregiving, you know, women's and women's women's experience of violence by men against them and women's health in their body.
- 40:30David Mandel: Those are the three areas I remember.
- 40:31David Mandel: There might have been one more, but I I really, I really like as I'm looking at this research being done on men, which I generally support in this conversation about men's health and well-being.
- 40:40David Mandel: I generally support, I'm always looking to say, how are we connecting the dots?
- 40:45David Mandel: Because we know the connections.
- 40:47David Mandel: We can't just say, oh, there's a connection between mental health and domestic abuse, or connection between substance abuse and and domestic abuse.
- 40:54David Mandel: We have to operational, I'm with you, we have to operationalize it and make it tangible in our practice.
- 41:03David Mandel: You can't just say, I'm I get I can get on the soapbox, but I'm really tired of people who are talking about men say, Oh, we don't want to talk about men and boys at the expense of women and girls.
- 41:12David Mandel: And then do nothing to operationalize it.
- 41:17SPEAKER_03: I mean, because you know, Jesus, if if men and women didn't interact, we wouldn't have domestic abuse, for God's sake.
- 41:24SPEAKER_03: So, you know, let's let's get with the program.
- 41:27SPEAKER_03: I mean, I think that it, you know, I'm I was just thinking, you were reminding me of Marianne Hester's research about who does what to whom, and then the more recent research about men who identify as victims of course of control or domestic abuse and what their experiences are and what their needs are, and what their you know, and some of that'll be mental health and some of it, but the overriding need they had was for somebody to counsel them about their relationships, right?
- 41:59SPEAKER_03: And and you know, I mean, I suppose it comes back to the he's afraid she'll laugh at him and she's afraid he'll kill he'll kill her.
- 42:08SPEAKER_03: But you know, the the reality for me is if we don't understand how that understand identifying yourself as a victim because she wouldn't let me go to the football game, although I went to the football game two weeks ago.
- 42:22SPEAKER_03: Do you know what I mean?
- 42:24SPEAKER_03: But also identifying what impact that has on him is gonna be crucial to the people who are trying to provide mental health services.
- 42:32SPEAKER_03: And it shouldn't be, and it should be, but it's I had a friend who was a psychiatric nurse for 17 years, and she said, you know, the fact that you're excuse my language, but this is what she said to me.
- 42:44SPEAKER_03: The fact that you're nuts doesn't mean you can then be able to harm people recklessly one way or the other and get off the hook, because that's not how it works.
- 42:54SPEAKER_03: And it's what you're saying, David, about operationalization.
- 42:57SPEAKER_03: Just because you have a mental health issue doesn't mean that you suddenly can't tell the difference between, you know, harming somebody and not harming somebody.
- 43:06David Mandel: Yeah.
- 43:07David Mandel: And even, you know, it goes deeper for me, which is that if you're uh going down this this line for a second, if you're an advocate for men's health or well-being, to be willing to and and need to move toward actively, this is my position, to say the perpetration of domestic abuse actually not only harms the other person, the victim, the kids, family, you know, the community, it is gonna likely increase your sense of isolation, your sense of shame, your sense of depression, your lack of resources.
- 43:38David Mandel: You know, if if I'm depressed and abusive, or I'm subducing and abusive, then I don't have somebody in my circle on my side the way they should be, if I wasn't hurting them.
- 43:48David Mandel: And so there's just there's just sort of, and this is where I'm gonna be getting into the next period of time, you know.
- 43:54David Mandel: So the drive research that, you know, the out of out of out of uh England, you know, that said that.
- 44:00David Mandel: High-risk domestic abuse perpetrators are suicidal at rates that are far beyond prison populations, probation populations, you know, these high-risk populations for suicide already.
- 44:14David Mandel: And that if we don't, we're not willing to explore those connections, but do in a responsible and ethical way that sort of says this isn't just a mental health issue.
- 44:21David Mandel: You have to think about how dangerous this person is to somebody else.
- 44:26David Mandel: We're missing opportunities for intervention.
- 44:28David Mandel: We're missing opportunities for understanding coercive control more deeply.
- 44:33David Mandel: You know, so I I just really appreciate the richness of your thinking about coercive control.
- 44:40David Mandel: You're thinking about sort of how to desilo things.
- 44:44David Mandel: Because I think it's what we need.
- 44:46David Mandel: I'm I'm really supportive of that tremendously.
- 44:48R: I'm very much enjoying the back and forth between you two.
- 44:51R: And I'm gonna, I'm gonna, I'm gonna refocus us in a different direction if that's okay.
- 44:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 44:57R: Because there's a this this topic particularly Yeah, this is fine, but get on topic.
- 45:03R: This topic about intent, yeah, is a it really could we could go on forever and ever, you know, and I was debating whether or not to bring in, because we're speaking fairly binary about male-female interactions, and as the representative bisexual in the room, you know, we could we could bring in other elements about abuse and gender and family and you know, intergenerational trauma, because this is we learn those behaviors through seeing them modeled by somebody, right?
- 45:37R: But what I really want to focus on now is is I really want to pick your brain, Marsha, about how survivors are currently being treated by child protection and family court systems there in Scotland.
- 45:54R: And you kind of touched upon the reality that though the laws have changed, there's still a lot of space for for improvements in those judgments and in the practice itself.
- 46:07R: So I don't know if you can reflect on that bigger picture.
- 46:13SPEAKER_03: So we for a long time have you know, like every domestic abuse charity everywhere, I think, have you know really struggled with a with a theory of change that worked for how to improve what happens to women and children in civil proceedings around custody, residence, depending on where you are, they use different words, but and visitation.
- 46:40SPEAKER_03: And the we'd hope that the domestic abuse 2018 law would help with that.
- 46:47SPEAKER_03: It really hasn't very much, although there's some interesting work being done inside that least by Emma Forbes, who's working on improving the use of uh aggravate child aggravations.
- 47:00SPEAKER_03: So, but I'm gonna put that to the side because it's probably not the core question here.
- 47:05SPEAKER_03: So the the core question from our perspective is what are the things that need to change in order for better decisions to get made, A and B, for the experience of being involved in a civil proceeding of some kind.
- 47:20SPEAKER_03: And in Scotland, it's we have a unique setup where children are very often or families with domestic abuse and where there's children, the the child will get referred to a children's hearing panel rather than going to a court, okay?
- 47:36SPEAKER_03: And the here and the panel or the child the reporter will make a decision about contact.
- 47:43SPEAKER_03: And then this the sheriff, or the in you know, in Scotland they're called sheriffs at the lower level.
- 47:48SPEAKER_03: The sheriff will is the final arbiter.
- 47:52SPEAKER_03: So if somebody appeals, it goes to the sheriff, but generally the it stays with the hearing and and it doesn't go anywhere near a sheriff.
- 48:00SPEAKER_03: So there's we have two strands in our system, is essentially what I'm trying to say, both of which need work.
- 48:07SPEAKER_03: Okay, is the nicest way I can say it, I guess.
- 48:11SPEAKER_03: So the you know, the change, the attitude and print and you know, sort of social change that we're trying to work through around eradicating domestic abuse, it's it's so funny because it works, it seems to work, it goes forward uh for women sometimes, but in this case, not for children.
- 48:34SPEAKER_03: And so children are still there's still this whole you know flawed, evidenceless assumption that we should that children should have joint, you know, that there should be joint custody when parents are separating, and that and that that that would be the best in the best interest of the child.
- 48:55SPEAKER_03: And it has proved ridiculously difficult to dislodge that.
- 49:01SPEAKER_03: And so we did some analysis about trying to figure out what it is, both in the hearing system and in the courts, would shift that.
- 49:09SPEAKER_03: And our analysis is there's a few things you need to do, but the single biggest influence is, and David, it's exactly what you described about judges in Australia.
- 49:20SPEAKER_03: They can only act with what's in front of them.
- 49:23SPEAKER_03: So we need to improve the quantity and the quality of the information that's coming to them, no matter where it's coming from.
- 49:31SPEAKER_03: So the police need to do a much better job of evidencing what's happening with children when they do a police, when they do a police investigation, right?
- 49:41SPEAKER_03: The crown needs to ask for, if there, if there's a prosecution, needs to ask for an aggravation and demonstrate why that was so it's all on record and going into the court, right?
- 49:56SPEAKER_03: In Scotland and in a lot of places, that can all happen beautifully, and it can never wind up in the civil proceeding because they're separate, right?
- 50:05SPEAKER_03: So we need to.
- 50:16SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 50:17SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 50:18SPEAKER_03: But I think it's the social work reports that come in, yeah.
- 50:22R: I think it's the welfare reports, the police reports, yeah, all of those are fixable.
- 50:27R: Yeah, and that's that's I was gonna I was gonna zero in on all the reports that are attached to that, you know, going right down the slush all the way down to to therapist reports for the child, where for us, unless you have that perpetrator pattern behavior in the documentation, linking it to impact to the child, yeah, and showing how much the survivor had to work to protect, to mitigate that impact, to put to to try to keep it critical.
- 51:05SPEAKER_03: And you know, Ruth, I assume you know that when people ask me the next question, which is okay, so how do we fix the system?
- 51:12SPEAKER_03: What do I say?
- 51:14SPEAKER_03: You and you do embed safe and together together.
- 51:18David Mandel: We we we this is why we have a wonderful partnership, amongst other things.
- 51:23R: Even more generally, we just need to demand better sense of of ownership over the information that we're sharing, even before we do that.
- 51:35R: Everybody needs to have a better sense of ownership over the information.
- 51:39David Mandel: I'm gonna make this problem bigger and more wicked, okay.
- 51:42David Mandel: Going back to used to learn, but I do really I think it's important to name this.
- 51:46David Mandel: And I I I really hope people appreciate this versus see it as a making making waves and being negative.
- 51:52David Mandel: I think because you did name mental health people and sort of the system of they're they're so critical, really, because mental health, the mental health frameworks and the social work frameworks, they really are that basis of those assessments, those reports, those, those, those, those those really big, besides the besides the the criminal justice system, they're the and probably they're bigger, like you said, that more people are in contact with these systems than maybe they are with the the police.
- 52:18David Mandel: That my experience is that the mental health system to date is not fit for purpose for what we're talking about.
- 52:26David Mandel: That they're about diagnosing usually adults or children with a condition, yeah, with uh with a pathology, right?
- 52:34David Mandel: Developing a treatment plan and executing that treatment plan for those things.
- 52:40David Mandel: And and within that, they're not domestic violence informed.
- 52:43David Mandel: So they're not developing.
- 52:44David Mandel: I'll like I can't tell you how many adult therapists say, I won't comment on her parenting.
- 52:49David Mandel: Yeah, because that's not my job.
- 52:51David Mandel: You know, and so they Well, and they're not qualified, kind of because you haven't been trained to do it or but but they have the pathology deficit.
- 52:58David Mandel: I think we really have to really kind of wrestle with that the medical model of mental health, which really drives so much of these systems, is a pathology-focused system.
- 53:09David Mandel: Forget even the the sexism that's embedded.
- 53:12David Mandel: Let's just kind of talk about the pathology part of it.
- 53:15David Mandel: And that when we're looking for evidence, and I've seen this in sort of multi-agency team work, right?
- 53:21David Mandel: More information is not better information.
- 53:25David Mandel: And so if everybody touches the survivor and through a deficit lens, you've got six agencies that say, well, she dropped out of housing, we offered her housing, and she had an addiction and she relapsed because that's what I know and that's what I see.
- 53:39David Mandel: And then we say, Oh, let's share information.
- 53:41David Mandel: Now we've got a hub that's got all that sort of negative information about the victim.
- 53:46David Mandel: And then they have no information about the perpetrator, except maybe he was arrested once or twice here or there.
- 53:50David Mandel: And but he never sought services.
- 53:53David Mandel: And so we don't have documentation.
- 53:55David Mandel: So he's practically invisible in this.
- 53:59David Mandel: And what we have is negative about her, deficit-oriented.
- 54:02David Mandel: And yes, we can overcome those with a good framework and approach, but we're already starting two or three or five or six or ten moves back.
- 54:10David Mandel: So I really think we just need to name that we're up against fundamentally imbalance, the maybe is the nicest word I can say, systems that aren't fit for purpose to provide that evidence up the chain that you're talking about.
- 54:26SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 54:27SPEAKER_03: Well, I mean, that's you know, it's what we say is we want more and better information.
- 54:32SPEAKER_03: And part the part of the more is because you can have a you can have a civil proceeding where there's no evidence from the criminal system because the the mother is being advised by her solicitor not to mention the domestic abuse.
- 54:45SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 54:46SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 54:47SPEAKER_03: Or lots of lots of scenarios.
- 54:50SPEAKER_03: And I don't think the mental health system is it is well, I think the mental health system probably is set up to do what it's set up to do.
- 55:00SPEAKER_03: Do you know what I mean?
- 55:01SPEAKER_03: And that is not to comment on domestic abuse.
- 55:03R: Right.
- 55:04R: Right.
- 55:04SPEAKER_03: You know, because they don't understand it.
- 55:06R: Right.
- 55:07SPEAKER_03: So I think, you know, and and if we had we thought about setting up a specialist witness service for for courts for a while in order to get around this problem of them bringing in child psychologists, for instance, who didn't have a scooby about course of control, and and would were make judgments based on you know irrelevant evidence about what whose parenting skills were, you know, up to par and and where custody or visitation or residents should should go.
- 55:40SPEAKER_03: So but we couldn't because the courts, the assessment that we did was that the courts were so opposed to the expertise of people on the ground that they wanted an academy of some kind, you know, I mean, and preferably not run by women.
- 56:00David Mandel: So no, no, no, this is exactly because what we I found the same thing, which is you get accurate, you get accurate descriptions of behavior, that's what this in child protection, and people would say, Well, you're biased, and you're on her side.
- 56:11David Mandel: Like, no, we're actually child-centered in our descriptions, and we're actually just you have a document in front of you that describes his behaviors and how they're harming the kids.
- 56:19David Mandel: And we'd have people, so I'm totally with you, that we'd have this like, no, you're advocating, you're advocating for the money.
- 56:25David Mandel: I'm like, no, we're describing harm to children, we're doing the job that you're actually asking us to do.
- 56:29R: Misogyny, you would show up in such strong ways in so many places.
- 56:34R: You know, I think that's that's that's I think that's literally the definition of hysterical.
- 56:41R: And and the and you know, Marcia, I'm I'm really, I'm really focused in on because I I love having you on the show, and I want to make sure we mine every bit of your awareness for our listeners to help them with their journey.
- 56:56R: But I'm I'm I'm really curious about what you think needs to happen then to pivot people from the responses and reactions of victims to coercive control and domestic abuse, which show up in mental health reports and assessments in ways that harm victims and children and their liberties and their rights and their safety.
- 57:22R: How do we help to pivot these institutional practices towards the perpetrator as a parent rather than assessing the responses and reactions of victims to their perpetration?
- 57:38SPEAKER_03: I mean, and we'll go back to say this is one of the reasons why I think our law is pretty special, which is it's all crafted around the behaviors of the accused, right?
- 57:48SPEAKER_03: And nothing about the impact or the character or the whatever of the complainter, as they say.
- 57:59SPEAKER_03: But the system hasn't caught up with the language in that law, right?
- 58:04SPEAKER_03: So the the reality to me is we we need to think about what do people need to change?
- 58:11SPEAKER_03: And you guys are way better at this than I am, okay.
- 58:15SPEAKER_03: But uh, I mean, essentially, if we want that pivot, what we have to do, as you know, is to make it really uncomfortable not to change.
- 58:24SPEAKER_03: Yeah, really uncomfortable not to change, and then say, okay, so, and this is all about training and implementation.
- 58:31SPEAKER_03: Okay, so we're not happy with the way we as an institution respond to this thing.
- 58:37SPEAKER_03: So we're gonna put in training and then we're gonna train your supervisor and they're gonna coach you into how to do this better.
- 58:44SPEAKER_03: But you know what?
- 58:45SPEAKER_03: At the end of the day, they're also gonna do your your uh you know, job assessment.
- 58:50SPEAKER_03: And are you doing your job and have you changed your behavior?
- 58:53SPEAKER_03: Because if you haven't changed your behavior, you're out of here.
- 58:56SPEAKER_03: So, you know, that's and it's so boring to talk like that, but that really is the nuts and both of us.
- 59:04David Mandel: Oh, it's not it's not boring, it's not boring to us at all.
- 59:07David Mandel: Yeah, it's probably it's not boring to us at all, and it's and you know, we're really focused on that right now in so many different ways, which is how do you how do you embed this?
- 59:15David Mandel: How do you embed the safety of the model, really specifically for us?
- 59:18SPEAKER_03: And for me, you're such an important resource, yeah, because you know, we they can say, Well, how do we do this?
- 59:24SPEAKER_03: And I'm like, Well, you you train people in the safe and together approach, and then you support them to continue to deliver it.
- 59:30SPEAKER_03: Do you know what I mean?
- 59:32SPEAKER_03: And that's so nice to have that in a box because if somebody says to me, What do we do about you know sentencing?
- 59:38SPEAKER_03: Oh god, that's a you know, a seven-hour conversation.
- 59:41David Mandel: So no, it is yeah, if if you could, you know, you just did this child contact conference, right?
- 59:47David Mandel: And you didn't, you know, you told us it was really well received.
- 59:51David Mandel: What does that point to for you in terms of Scotland in terms of next steps around moving forward around the family court arena, the the child contact arena?
- 1:00:04SPEAKER_03: I'm I have to say I think there's a a a light at the end of the tunnel in terms of the courts.
- 1:00:11SPEAKER_03: We we've been acting, you know, as I described, the system's complicated because of the children's hearing system and the court process and the lack of access to good legal services for women.
- 1:00:24SPEAKER_03: And in that's really critical in civil proceedings, right?
- 1:00:28SPEAKER_03: So what do we do?
- 1:00:30SPEAKER_03: The next steps from our perspective are find work with the the social work, Marcia, trying to use your words, the the Scottish social work organizations to improve their training of social workers.
- 1:00:48SPEAKER_03: They are also part of our you know advocacy with the with the government to improve the child welfare reporter role and make it we so it's now gonna be a standard registered role, and we might actually get some people doing it who aren't lawyers.
- 1:01:05SPEAKER_03: And but also the the issue for us is we we really need some champions inside, and I hate the word champion because I don't think it's a great model most of the time, but um, because then it's like the champion's gone and the work's gone.
- 1:01:22SPEAKER_03: But the like I said, judges only listen to judges.
- 1:01:27SPEAKER_03: So we we need and I I'm circling back, I'm gonna answer your question, David.
- 1:01:32SPEAKER_03: One of the things one of the things that really, really pleased me and slightly surprised me about our conference was the we did a a round table, invitation only round table at the afterwards with with justice leaders, and it was very small.
- 1:01:49SPEAKER_03: We had like eight people there and you know, a couple academic and there was no pointing of fingers, which has been the the my my experience in the past of you know, oh well, it's not the police's fault, it's the crown's fault, or it's not the judge's fault, it's the crown's fault because they didn't give us the evidence we needed, or it's this or it's that.
- 1:02:12SPEAKER_03: There really was a refreshing sense of how do we change this together.
- 1:02:17SPEAKER_03: And I don't think I have no rose-colored glasses that you broke a long time ago.
- 1:02:23SPEAKER_03: So I think that you know, getting one or two is you know, just the beginning, but it it gives you platforms that you didn't have before.
- 1:02:33SPEAKER_03: So I think there is that, but also we started the conference out with a young woman, her pseudonym is Florence, and she spoke about her experiences of being taken away from her mother and then and eventually taking her father to court, getting that decision overturned when she was a teenager and getting to go back to her mother.
- 1:02:58SPEAKER_03: And and she talked about child protection and and what kind and she's and she said to people, what kind of a system says this protecting child that tears a screaming child off of their mother and hands them to a father that she doesn't want to go with?
- 1:03:14SPEAKER_03: And you know, I think those are the messages we've really struggled with making sure that the messages about the harm that our current system does to children is the it's always told through the eyes of their mother because you it's very difficult to get children.
- 1:03:30SPEAKER_03: Do you know what I mean?
- 1:03:31SPEAKER_03: We we've had lots of incredibly wise children advising us in our in our advisory groups and stuff, but they're still minors and they still have engagement with their fathers.
- 1:03:43SPEAKER_03: So, or some of them don't but don't want it either.
- 1:03:46SPEAKER_03: Do you know what I mean?
- 1:03:48SPEAKER_03: So it's quite a it's it's a landscape that's not been influenced enough, I think.
- 1:03:52SPEAKER_03: But what happens to children, right?
- 1:03:55SPEAKER_03: What really happens to children, and and I'm putting my hand up and that you know the easy way is always to talk to their mothers.
- 1:04:02SPEAKER_03: It's not easy, but it's more accessible.
- 1:04:05SPEAKER_03: So I think part of the for us, part of the what we're gonna do is continue to uh to get children's stories and share those, make sure that we are continuing to gather the evidence, and it is from our perspective overwhelming that things have not changed significantly in the and there's been research funded by the government that said, guess what?
- 1:04:26SPEAKER_03: This is your law hasn't made a damn bit of difference for children in in these situations, and and our our helpline is filled with these stories.
- 1:04:36SPEAKER_03: The Scottish Women's Rights Center is filled with these stories.
- 1:04:39SPEAKER_03: So the evidence is incon incontrovertible.
- 1:04:42SPEAKER_03: And what I said to them at the beginning of the conference was our assumptions here are that you know this is a problem.
- 1:04:48SPEAKER_03: We last year we talked, we proved that to you.
- 1:04:51SPEAKER_03: We're not gonna argue that now.
- 1:04:53SPEAKER_03: Now we're gonna talk about how do we solve this problem, right?
- 1:04:56SPEAKER_03: And so the next steps for us are continue to work, and then I was really, really pleased that the children's reporter and the children's hearing system were very receptive to our critique of what was going on, and this, but you know, changing systems like that or institutions like that is a long process.
- 1:05:19SPEAKER_03: It is, yeah, but it damn well better get started because right it will never have outcomes for children and women and their mothers until it does.
- 1:05:29R: I'm gonna I'm just gonna say one little bit about the the the children's and children's rights and the attitudes towards children is that we have a long way to go around believing children, around responding and respecting their their fear, their har the harm that they're experiencing and their rights.
- 1:05:51R: And here in the United States, we have an even longer way to go.
- 1:05:55R: So there's a lot of work that we need to do around engaging children.
- 1:06:00R: Around believing them.
- 1:06:02R: And we know that, for example, though everybody talks about child sexual abuse, child sexual abuse from an adult to a child is prosecuted at less than 10% because we don't believe children.
- 1:06:18R: We don't believe children when they tell us that they're being sexually abused.
- 1:06:21SPEAKER_03: You know, I went to a conference in Ireland one time, say Fireland did it a couple years ago.
- 1:06:26SPEAKER_03: More than that, probably now.
- 1:06:27SPEAKER_03: And they said there was this researcher there who pointed out exactly that.
- 1:06:30SPEAKER_03: It was a tiny percentage of the, but you know, these are the number of cases from everything we know that we can project.
- 1:06:36SPEAKER_03: These are the number of the cases that get reported, these are the number of the cases that get prosecuted.
- 1:06:41SPEAKER_03: And she said, essentially, child sexual abuse is legal in that's correct.
- 1:06:46SPEAKER_03: That is essentially child sexual abuse is legal everywhere.
- 1:06:51R: This was a you know, a real it's horrible.
- 1:06:55R: It's horrible.
- 1:06:55R: We have a long way to go.
- 1:06:57R: So so sorry to bring in that piece.
- 1:06:59R: And I love that you hold both things.
- 1:07:01R: I love you hold the the advancements that have happened, and yet what needs to be addressed and a long way to go, that is such a critical piece to really be able to be open as an advocate and say we've made we've made this much progress, and this much progress still has to happen is such a critical piece.
- 1:07:24R: But you know, moving away from all the questions because we're we're we're moving to wrapping up, just asking you from that vantage point what you would say to workers and advocates working for change in these spaces, and then what you would say to survivors.
- 1:07:46SPEAKER_03: Well, first of all, that's not a binary.
- 1:07:48SPEAKER_03: I don't know a lot of us are survivors.
- 1:07:51David Mandel: That's right.
- 1:07:51David Mandel: That's right.
- 1:07:52SPEAKER_03: And when and when people say that to me, oh, we need the voices of lived experience.
- 1:07:56SPEAKER_03: This will be an official from the government, right?
- 1:07:59SPEAKER_03: In a room of women, because they only invited women, but because it's women doing this work for the market, right, right, right.
- 1:08:08SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 1:08:09SPEAKER_03: Bless you, David.
- 1:08:10SPEAKER_03: And so so, you know, I I'm I'm I'm constantly irritated by that as if it's a it's if it's a different set.
- 1:08:20David Mandel: And it said non-ironically, right?
- 1:08:22David Mandel: It said non-ironically.
- 1:08:23David Mandel: It said, it said with all seriousness, right?
- 1:08:25David Mandel: We need to we need to list the voice of the survivors.
- 1:08:28David Mandel: And it's like you're going, we you are, here we are.
- 1:08:30David Mandel: We're in front of you in front of you.
- 1:08:32David Mandel: In fact, it may include you, but you don't identify that way.
- 1:08:35SPEAKER_03: Anyway, so uh anyway, so that's what that's just a a personal irritation, I suppose.
- 1:08:41SPEAKER_03: But it is important though to to change people's views to understand that all women experience misogyny.
- 1:08:48SPEAKER_03: So we're all victims of violence against women and girls.
- 1:08:51SPEAKER_03: And and a really, really large percentage of us are victims of domestic and sexual abuse.
- 1:08:59SPEAKER_03: And when you look at a room and it has women in it, it has survivors in it.
- 1:09:04SPEAKER_03: And that's that's needs to reframe people's.
- 1:09:06SPEAKER_03: It's not this little pocket of poor, vulnerable, oh, we just didn't understand what was happening to her, you know, groups of women.
- 1:09:15SPEAKER_03: This is women in our society.
- 1:09:18SPEAKER_03: So that's the first thing I'm gonna say.
- 1:09:20SPEAKER_03: So I guess the first thing I'm gonna say is guess what?
- 1:09:23SPEAKER_03: You have an incredible amount of women around you who have experienced the same kinds of things, not not from the same guy, not in the same situation, but very similar.
- 1:09:34SPEAKER_03: Uh and they have survived.
- 1:09:37SPEAKER_03: And some of them have gone on to change the world.
- 1:09:40SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:09:41SPEAKER_03: And we are you are, you know, you are surrounded by people who are working really hard to try and find you, help you, support you, and change what happened to you.
- 1:09:51R: Yeah, that's great.
- 1:09:53David Mandel: That that's that's so wonderful.
- 1:09:54David Mandel: And we talk so much about that non-binary of survivor professional, and we're really committed to working with you to breaking that down.
- 1:10:03David Mandel: Because I don't think it's a small thing.
- 1:10:04David Mandel: I don't think it's a pet peeve.
- 1:10:06David Mandel: I think it's actually fundamental to the way we practice and structure our things.
- 1:10:10David Mandel: And and you know, I talk to somebody, I now give an I say to people, you should operate your organization as if 60 to 80 percent of your staff, and I think the numbers 100% depending on how we define it, right?
- 1:10:24David Mandel: You know, but are are victims of domestic and family violence.
- 1:10:29David Mandel: Let's say even keep it that way, like but even even men, if we talk about men and women, because I mean boys grew up with it.
- 1:10:35R: I think that frightens people because the reality is that in all professional spaces, right, we have a certain percentage of people who have experienced violence in coercive control, and then we have a certain percentage of people who have perpetrated it, and that is real, and that is impactful to our practice and to the ways that judgments are laid out.
- 1:10:52SPEAKER_03: I talk all the time about the fact that our set of perpetrators is almost as big as our set of victims.
- 1:10:58SPEAKER_03: And and we have, and there's you know, there was some statistical evidence around that by somebody from Analytical Services a few years ago in Scotland, and uh, and it's not this little pocket of crazy guys who are just drunk on Saturday nights and going out and being and boy are they busy if there's only this little pocket, because look at how many victims right, right.
- 1:11:17David Mandel: No, it's it it's just to add one anecdote to this, and we need to truly wrap up is I was just talking to a psychiatrist who's doing global work around child and and uh adolescent psychiatry and presented on course of control, and she had a tremendous rate of self-disclosure from the people participating.
- 1:11:36David Mandel: These were psychiatrists saying, you know, the number I think she gave me was 69% of the people who answered her survey.
- 1:11:43David Mandel: And then a bunch of people didn't answer the specific question.
- 1:11:45David Mandel: I don't know the details of the survey and the context, and so don't, and the statisticians out there don't go crazy.
- 1:11:50David Mandel: But it was, it was, it was really, and she said she did a presentation, people were crying because this was so poor.
- 1:11:57David Mandel: Like, I I think we have so much when we're talking about how much further we have to go, is the breaking down this barrier you're talking about, Marcia, which is sort of let's stop thinking about us and them, poor women, and and what does it mean to really build systems where we recognize, respect, and listen to what Ruth talks about as credible experts around this, which is people who have professional experience and lived experience, who can really speak with authority about systems and how they need to do better.
- 1:12:26David Mandel: Uh, and you really kind of exemplify that if I can say it that way.
- 1:12:29David Mandel: So we do need to address because we could all chat together.
- 1:12:35R: Talk for another minute.
- 1:12:36David Mandel: We need a pint, we need a pint and a tapping the next round.
- 1:12:40R: We do.
- 1:12:41R: Thank you.
- 1:12:42R: Thank you, Dr.
- 1:12:42R: Scott, so much.
- 1:12:44David Mandel: Yeah, and thank you for being on with us.
- 1:12:46David Mandel: And you've been listening to Partner with Savarin.
- 1:12:49David Mandel: I'm still David Mandel.
- 1:12:50R: Still Ruth Ramundo.
- 1:12:52David Mandel: And if you like this podcast, please share it, like it, write a review on your favorite platform.
- 1:12:57David Mandel: We're really inviting people to do that.
- 1:12:59David Mandel: You know, we'll put stuff around Scottish Women's Aid in our show notes.
- 1:13:03David Mandel: And for if you're interested in the safety of the institute, of course, go to safety of the institute dot com, check out our virtual learning platform, academy.safety of the institute dot com, and look for us in all your favorite social media platforms.
- 1:13:16R: And with that, we are out of it.