Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E023: Dennis Porter – Bipartisan Bitcoin Breakthroughs
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity.
- 0:10Where the? Supply is unaffected by the
- 0:13demand. If you want to preserve your
- 0:16wealth, you have to convert that currency into an asset that's
- 0:21scarce, desirable, portable, durable, and maintainable.
- 0:31Hello, this is Andy Edstrom and I'm happy to welcome you to the
- 0:3323rd episode of Scarce Assets, a show that examines scarcity, the
- 0:37most fundamental driver of economics and markets and the
- 0:40scarcest asset of all, which is Bitcoin.
- 0:43I'm happy to be here with my Co host, Jesse Myers and our guest,
- 0:46the indefatigable Dennis Porter. So I think I first met Dennis in
- 0:51person at my first ever Bitcoin conference speaking gig.
- 0:55It was Bitcoin Day in Sacramento, I think in early
- 0:582022. At that time I recall Erica
- 1:02Rhodes was trying to unseat the infamous anti Bitcoin member of
- 1:06Congress known as Brad Sherman and she made an appearance of
- 1:09that conference. But Dennis gave the keynote and
- 1:12absolutely stole the show. Now, in the three years or so
- 1:16since then, Dennis has continued to steal the show with respect
- 1:20to advances in Bitcoin policy all over the US.
- 1:23His primary vehicle for this work is the Satoshi Action Fund
- 1:26and where he works with lawmakers and regulators, as
- 1:29well as the general public to ensure that Bitcoin is adopted
- 1:33so all Americans had the opportunity to benefit from it.
- 1:36And I know he's working on some exciting policies as we speak.
- 1:40So I'm delighted to talk with him today in this momentous time
- 1:44for Bitcoin policy in the US. So, Dennis, how are you today?
- 1:48I'm doing great, Andy. So good to see you and looking
- 1:52forward to the conversation. You're right, we there's a lot
- 1:54of history actually, we've we've done a lot of things in the past
- 1:56where we've been in the same places.
- 1:58And I remember also we were just talking before the show that I
- 2:01had you on my show back in the day when I was doing podcasting
- 2:04and when I was just a media guy. But a lot of things have changed
- 2:07since then. And I remember also you were one
- 2:09of the first people to get in there and support Erica Rhodes.
- 2:12You know, she didn't work out, but guys like you getting in
- 2:14there, supporting early on. You know, that that that speaks
- 2:17a lot. Not a lot of people were not
- 2:19willing to take those types of risks and you did.
- 2:21It didn't work out with her. But ultimately, you know, I'm, I
- 2:25know I and A lot of people appreciated you showing that
- 2:28level of support or that early on when it wasn't so popular all
- 2:31the time to be pro, pro Bitcoin and politics.
- 2:34Well, that's very kind. Thank you, Dennis.
- 2:36Yet her campaign is actually the only political campaign I've
- 2:39ever supported, and it didn't work out.
- 2:42But you know, this recent round, things have gone rather well.
- 2:47So maybe I'll kick it back to you to just start with the big
- 2:51picture on government policy here in the US or globally and
- 2:57how it's changed as a result of the recent US election.
- 3:02Yeah, absolutely. I mean, we've seen some
- 3:04incredible stuff. You know, when I first started
- 3:06doing this, you know how hard it was.
- 3:08We had to go find people. We had to go find lawmakers.
- 3:12We didn't even find lawmakers. In fact, we had to find
- 3:14candidates. That's why we were working with
- 3:15Erica because nobody would even hardly talk to us about Bitcoin
- 3:18in the political space. So we had to find candidates and
- 3:21we had to try to get candidates elected.
- 3:23And it was hard. It was tough.
- 3:24You know, you had, it was slim pickings among who you could
- 3:27support. It's what's tough to win a race.
- 3:28It's not easy to win politics. It's not easy to win a political
- 3:31campaign and it's it's been a wild ride ever since then.
- 3:35We have seen so many ups and downs.
- 3:37When we eventually launched Satoshi Action in June of 20/22,
- 3:41it was still a tough time, very rough.
- 3:43It was hard to have conversations with anyone.
- 3:45You know, FTX had just collapsed.
- 3:48SPF was about to go to jail. The scammer that we hate more
- 3:51than anybody else. I think the people outside think
- 3:53that they don't like SPF. Nobody hates them more than the
- 3:55people within the Bitcoin space. This guy has really causes a lot
- 3:58of problems. And so ultimately because of
- 4:02that environment that we were in early on in June of 2022 after
- 4:05launching, it was just a, it was a tough time.
- 4:07Lawmakers are thinking, wow, you're doing Bitcoin policy.
- 4:11Is Bitcoin even real anymore? Is this thing even going to
- 4:13survive? Fortunately, we were able to
- 4:15find some lawmakers though that would listen as we educated them
- 4:18about Bitcoin and then eventually they were interested
- 4:20in working on our model policy. You know, a lot of people they
- 4:23ask, what is that? What is model policy?
- 4:25It is a model example of what you could introduce.
- 4:28It's sort of like you write an idea down on paper and it kind
- 4:31of looks like a bill, but it's not a bill.
- 4:33And you show it to the lawmakers and you say, well, now that you
- 4:35love Bitcoin as much as we do, now that you're interested in
- 4:38the technology and you want to see it come to your state, here
- 4:41is a model and idea of a bill that you could introduce.
- 4:45Fortunately, in June of 2022, even though it was all a mess
- 4:48for that first year, when we went into 2023, we were able to
- 4:51get seven bill introduction. So we had seven of our right to
- 4:55mind bills introduced across the country.
- 4:58And ultimately we were able to pass two of those bills into
- 5:00law. Now, some people would say those
- 5:02might have been the most difficult bills we'll ever pass.
- 5:05I certainly think so because nobody wanted to do Bitcoin.
- 5:08Nobody cared about Bitcoin in the political space and in fact
- 5:12it was almost like a taboo to even talk about it, to even use
- 5:15the word Bitcoin. Most people started to say
- 5:17digital asset and crypto blockchain because Bitcoin was
- 5:21sort of a dirty word for a little while for a number of
- 5:23different reasons, but the main one really was the market was
- 5:26just totally collapsed. So moving forward, we go to
- 5:29another legislative cycle, things get a little better, but
- 5:31not much. Only really better because we
- 5:34had Satoshi action had secured some wins, we had one for
- 5:37Bitcoin. We passed 2 bills into law.
- 5:39We passed right to mine in Montana and in Arkansas in 2023.
- 5:43And then in 2024 we were able to get, I think we had like 16
- 5:46introductions for just that piece of policy alone.
- 5:49The the, the rights bills, we call them Bitcoin rights.
- 5:52It started off as right to mine, as I said, but it transitioned
- 5:55into Bitcoin rights. It's expanded the policy and it
- 5:58protected everything from the right to mine, to the right to
- 6:00self custody, to the right to run a no, to the right to
- 6:03peer-to-peer transactions. And I don't think I need to
- 6:05explain too long why, because people were worried.
- 6:08Are we even going to be able to use this technology?
- 6:10You know, just as much as I do, when we were sitting in our
- 6:12rooms during the shutdowns, we said, wow, the government can
- 6:16really do bad things pretty quickly.
- 6:19Maybe we should be thinking about what's going to happen to
- 6:21Bitcoin here if the government goes the wrong direction on it.
- 6:24And it certainly seemed like we were absolutely headed the wrong
- 6:27direction during that period on Bitcoin.
- 6:29But going into 2024, we got a lot more bill introductions.
- 6:33We got about 16 just from the Bitcoin rights bill.
- 6:35And even though it was a more expanded and difficult bill to
- 6:38pass because that had more things in it, the more, the more
- 6:40you put in a bill, the harder it can be to pass it at times,
- 6:43depending on what state you're in.
- 6:45And so we had a lot more stuff in it, but we passed it into law
- 6:48in two more states, Oklahoma and Louisiana, bigger states, more
- 6:52populous, more difficult to pass it, but we got it done.
- 6:55But going forward after that, you know, because the question
- 6:58was talk a little bit about where we've come from and where
- 7:00we're at now. Things are way different ever
- 7:03since the election happened. It's completely different for
- 7:06Bitcoin. We are living in an environment
- 7:08where instead of the lawmakers, instead of us reaching out to
- 7:10the lawmakers and saying, hey, listen to about Bitcoin.
- 7:13We got great things to say. Here's all the benefits that
- 7:16Bitcoin can offer. Bitcoin mining can balance the
- 7:18grid. Bitcoin can save your budget.
- 7:21That's not what's happening now after the election.
- 7:23I don't know what it was. I don't think it's just Donald
- 7:25Trump, and I'll explain a little bit here in a moment, but all
- 7:28the sudden we have this wave of lawmakers reaching out to us and
- 7:32saying I want to do Bitcoin policy.
- 7:34That's never happened. Not one time has that happened
- 7:36to us before 2024 and it was after the election specifically
- 7:41in 2024. Now we have lawmakers reaching
- 7:44out and actually we even have Bitcoiners reaching out who won
- 7:47office. The one of the big things that's
- 7:50made it a changed environment, a lot of people own Bitcoin now.
- 7:53And some of those people who are Bitcoiners, they're running for
- 7:56office and they're winning their offices.
- 7:58I had a newly elected state senator.
- 8:00He said I just, he called me up and he said I just won my office
- 8:04for the first time ever. I've never been elected before,
- 8:08but I've been a Bitcoiner since 2017.
- 8:11And I want the first bill that I introduced, the very first piece
- 8:14of legislation that I do. I want it to be a strategic
- 8:17Bitcoin reserve bill. That's incredible.
- 8:20I mean, this is a thing that I've been getting a lot of
- 8:22pushback for for some time. As people say, well, the
- 8:25lawmakers are just doing it because of the clicks and the
- 8:27likes and they can grow their political careers.
- 8:29Maybe that's true. Maybe that's true.
- 8:31But now the difference is that we have actual Bitcoiners
- 8:35running for office, winning and then working on Bitcoin policy
- 8:39because yes, they might grow their political career.
- 8:41Everybody does. When they win, that's that.
- 8:42That's the great part about winning is your career expands.
- 8:45But when they are getting into office, they're doing it
- 8:48initially because they care about Bitcoin, because they they
- 8:51own Bitcoin, they hold Bitcoin. So this is a new paradigm we're
- 8:54in. We are seeing lawmakers reach
- 8:55out in droves. Some of them hold Bitcoin, some
- 8:58of them don't. But everybody wants to do
- 9:00Bitcoin policy now. It's the hot ticket item And as
- 9:02Satoshi Action, the only group in the world who has been able
- 9:06to pass Bitcoin legislation in multiple jurisdictions, we are
- 9:11very well positioned to help these lawmakers.
- 9:13Lawmakers love to work with winners and they want to work
- 9:16with us because we've been able to win in so many different
- 9:18places. And so now we're so well
- 9:20positioned. We're in an incredible place and
- 9:23we can continue to help lawmakers when not only in this
- 9:25coming legislative cycle, it's almost here in January, but
- 9:28we're going to keep winning and we need to keep the momentum
- 9:30moving. People often, you know what they
- 9:32do, things are getting great and they go, you know what, it's
- 9:35good. Now we don't need to do politics
- 9:37anymore. It's quite the opposite.
- 9:39You know, the political landscape can change very
- 9:40rapidly. It's great right now, but that
- 9:42doesn't mean it's always going to be great.
- 9:44We need to make sure and take advantage of the momentum that
- 9:47we have and we need to move quickly and rapidly to secure
- 9:51victories for Bitcoin politically.
- 9:53We need to, you know, we, I often say we were pushing the
- 9:55ball up the hill. It was a really heavy ball.
- 9:58We are pushing it up the hill at Satoshi action, the ball of
- 10:00getting the ball of getting Bitcoin policy passed into law,
- 10:04securing Bitcoin wins. And eventually we got to the top
- 10:07of the hill after the election and then the election happens
- 10:10and now the ball is rolling down the hill.
- 10:11And So what we need to do is we need to chase after that ball as
- 10:15fast as we possibly can to secure as many wins as possible
- 10:18for Bitcoin. We're well positioned to do it.
- 10:20Like I said, we we've done a great job saving in Bitcoin.
- 10:23A lot of people have supported us and we have a lot of we have
- 10:27our own strategic Bitcoin reserve, but we're well
- 10:29positioned and we're we're ready to rock.
- 10:32We have so many bills coming. We'll have at least 10 states.
- 10:35We were saying up to 10. Now we're saying at least 10
- 10:38states will introduce strategic Bitcoin reserve legislation in
- 10:422025. We already had to do it.
- 10:44We had Pennsylvania, We were the first in the world, first in
- 10:46history to introduce strategic Bitcoin reserve legislation at
- 10:49the state level. And then we were #2 again, we
- 10:52went to Texas. We helped the lawmaker there.
- 10:53There was some problems with the bill, but we, we stepped in.
- 10:55We said we're willing to help. That's why the lawmakers like
- 10:58us, because we can see around the corners.
- 10:59We've done this many times before and we were helping a
- 11:02lawmaker and we had that spaces with him and it was an
- 11:04incredible spaces. So many people tuned in and to
- 11:07ask Texas, this is another cool one live on Twitter Spaces live
- 11:12introduced the strategic Bitcoin reserve piece of legislation.
- 11:15I'm pretty sure I've been on a lot of Twitter spaces.
- 11:17I've never seen anybody introduce a bill live.
- 11:20Not not just strategic Bitcoin reserve legislation.
- 11:22It's never happened. We were the first in history to
- 11:24do that as well. So we're going to continue
- 11:26getting wins and securing firsts for Bitcoin because we care
- 11:30about it. You know, I could people often
- 11:31say, are you Dennis, are you paid to do this work?
- 11:34Of course I'm paid to do it, but I could be making a lot more
- 11:36money doing something else. It's a nonprofit.
- 11:39Nonprofits are not a great way to make money.
- 11:41They're not a great way to grow your wealth, but they certainly
- 11:43a great way to secure wins for Bitcoin.
- 11:45We have secured wins for Bitcoin.
- 11:47We're going to continue to secure wins for Bitcoin.
- 11:49And we're very excited about the momentum that we have at our
- 11:52backs as we go into 2025. It's, it's incredible momentum.
- 11:56And I have to ask the follow up question of what do you think is
- 11:59different now? I, I, I saw a clip yesterday, I
- 12:02think of Van Jones sort of in part of the post mortem of like
- 12:05what went wrong for the Democrats talking about how they
- 12:09turned away a lot of single issue crypto voters.
- 12:12And, and I wonder how much of the change in the winds right
- 12:17now for policy is Democrats saying like, actually, we have
- 12:21to catch up. We have to be open to this.
- 12:22We have to play ball versus Republicans saying, you know
- 12:26what Trump has been open to this has made it part of what he
- 12:29wants to do. So I'm, I'm going to follow that
- 12:32if you want to speak to any of the kind of the political
- 12:34landscape that you're seeing and how that shifted.
- 12:37Absolutely. And to just to start, it's a
- 12:39great question Jesse, but it's a it's an important question.
- 12:42It's about, you know, Bitcoin and bipartisanship and Bitcoin
- 12:46being non partisan. A lot of people know I'm very,
- 12:49very, very big on maintaining Bitcoin as a non partisan
- 12:52technology or bipartisan technology.
- 12:54I have spent more time fighting for that than probably anyone in
- 12:57this space. And it's not just me saying that
- 12:59there's a whole book. There's a progressives case for
- 13:02Bitcoin. It's a great book written by a
- 13:04good friend of mine. He has a whole page about all
- 13:07the work that we've done to be able to introduce to Democrats
- 13:11and progressives and liberals to Bitcoin because they're going to
- 13:14love it just as much as the conservatives are.
- 13:16People don't believe me. I think they might like it more.
- 13:18In fact, because Bitcoin can bank the unbanked.
- 13:21It can provide a financially inclusive service to people all
- 13:24over the world. And then you cannot discriminate
- 13:26with Bitcoin. It's not possible.
- 13:27It's impossible to discriminate with Bitcoin.
- 13:30And that is a really important issue to a lot of Democrats, a
- 13:33lot of progressives. It might be one of the most
- 13:34important issues to a big number of the folks on the progressive
- 13:38side of the aisle. So we certainly believe that
- 13:40that's the direction that things are going to go.
- 13:43We're going to continue pushing for that.
- 13:44But yes, the the Democrats miss an opportunity in the election,
- 13:47I think. So I think more Democrats would
- 13:49be elected today if there was more support for Bitcoin, really
- 13:54the digital asset system writ large.
- 13:55We'll talk, we can talk about that at a separate time.
- 13:57But there was not really a lot of support.
- 14:00There was some good ones. We got Ro Khanna, he's a great
- 14:02champion. You know, I've heard Richie
- 14:03Torres talk good things about Bitcoin.
- 14:06There's a number of others that are in the House as well.
- 14:09And we also have some in the Senate who are open who are
- 14:12interested. Senator Wyden, for instance, who
- 14:14is a very powerful Democrat, very interested.
- 14:16But we need to have more support.
- 14:18And we did not have that support from Democrats, unfortunately.
- 14:21And I do believe a number of them lost their offices or
- 14:24Republicans won their offices because of their support for
- 14:27Bitcoin. Everybody knows Republicans are
- 14:29out on the lead on Bitcoin, but it's only a matter of time
- 14:31before the other party, Democrats, they get smart on
- 14:34this thing and they start to compete because this is going to
- 14:37be one of the most important groups that you can get on your
- 14:40side because you have Bitcoiners and you have crypto people who
- 14:44not only are they really invested, they've got some of
- 14:47these. Some people are living 100% on
- 14:49Bitcoin. I mean, some people that's all
- 14:51they own. They just own Bitcoin.
- 14:53A lot of my friends are like that.
- 14:55And so not only do they have all their wealth tied up in Bitcoin
- 14:58because they truly believe in it, they also believe that
- 15:01Bitcoin is going to do great things for society.
- 15:04Bitcoin is going to, as we already said, bank the unbanked.
- 15:06It's going to be a financially inclusive system.
- 15:09It's also going to help keep a lot of this overspending and
- 15:12waste that we have. It's going to keep it in check.
- 15:14You can't debase the money anymore.
- 15:16You got to, you got to ask permission, so to speak.
- 15:18So people can use the dollar if they want, but they can also go
- 15:21to Bitcoin now. So now lawmakers can't just
- 15:23print as much money as they want.
- 15:25Otherwise people can leave. So Bitcoin will act as a check
- 15:27and balance on the money printer.
- 15:30You also have Bitcoin mining, which is this powerful tool for
- 15:33balancing the grid, for enhancing clean energy.
- 15:35So you have going back, you have the Bitcoiners, they're way tied
- 15:39into Bitcoin. They have all their wealth in
- 15:41it. And then Bitcoin also does all
- 15:43these great things. And so Bitcoin voters, Bitcoin
- 15:45supporters are very, very active.
- 15:47They're some of the most aggressive voters, as I call
- 15:50them. They're like the 300.
- 15:51You don't need very many of them.
- 15:52They're going to get really active.
- 15:54They're going to fight hard and they're going to win with just a
- 15:56few people. And this is the environment we
- 15:58live in. And Democrats are going to
- 15:59figure that out. And I think some Democrats are
- 16:01going to come out as Bitcoiners soon.
- 16:03I think we're going to see a lot more of that now that this big
- 16:05loss has happened. Let's take a look at what
- 16:07happened in the election too, Like what were the big races
- 16:10where we saw a significant amount of negative outcomes for
- 16:13Democrats because of the opposition to Bitcoin?
- 16:16We saw a lot of negative repercussions in some of the
- 16:20Senate races we saw, particularly in Ohio.
- 16:22Sherrod Brown was vulnerable. Nobody is denying that he was
- 16:26vulnerable because the state is getting a little bit more red.
- 16:29But the thing that really set it off for him, the thing that
- 16:31really caused him a lot of problems was he became very
- 16:34opposed to Bitcoin and to really to crypto writ large.
- 16:38He was the chair of Senate Banking.
- 16:39He still is today until till we get to next year.
- 16:41But he lost his seat, in my opinion, because he utilized his
- 16:45position, his authority as chair of Senate Banking to hurt the
- 16:50Bitcoin industry, to hurt the crypto industry.
- 16:52He did it by allowing the DE banking to pit to take place and
- 16:56not doing anything to get in the way of it.
- 16:57And we've seen a crazy amount of DE banking taking place.
- 17:00It's a big problem. It's all across the industry.
- 17:03We're seeing little mom and pop shops, people who don't have the
- 17:07ability to navigate this stuff. We're seeing them be the bank.
- 17:10We're seeing them, their businesses get crushed.
- 17:12I mean, imagine being debanked 10 times.
- 17:14We've had people that are being debanked 10 times.
- 17:18It's incredibly horrible what's happening to these people and we
- 17:21need to fix it. But Sherrod Brown, sort of at
- 17:24bare minimum, he let it happen or worse.
- 17:26It's possible. We'll see when we come.
- 17:28Some people do some more of the investigations and they dig deep
- 17:30into this stuff. He may have been a part of it,
- 17:33but we'll see. But he certainly was speaking
- 17:35negatively about Bitcoin and crypto, and that led for an open
- 17:38door for Bernie Moreno. Bernie Moreno comes out of
- 17:41nowhere and he starts running and he becomes very supportive
- 17:44of Bitcoin. I think he was even supportive
- 17:46of it much before he ran. And it's hard to argue, it's
- 17:50very hard to argue that there were any other defining reasons
- 17:52why he lost because what happened was that that race
- 17:56became an inflection point for the Bitcoin and crypto space.
- 17:59Everybody saw this is the most important race.
- 18:01We have to win it. We have to show that we are here
- 18:04to stay and we're going to impact these campaigns.
- 18:07And you need to be able to impact campaigns and the
- 18:09outcomes of races if you expect to be taken seriously as an
- 18:12industry. The NRA does it all the time for
- 18:14the gun guys. You've got the military guys,
- 18:16you've got the unions, you've got the healthcare industry.
- 18:20People respect those industries because they will cause you to
- 18:23win or lose. They can decide a race.
- 18:25Well, Bitcoin can decide races now too.
- 18:28Sherrod Brown lost his race. He was beaten in Ohio, and he's
- 18:31gone. He's going to be gone from the
- 18:33US Senate, in my opinion, really almost explicitly because of his
- 18:36opposition to Bitcoin and crypto.
- 18:39That's the kind of outcome, in my opinion, that results in a
- 18:42lot of a lot of really bad things.
- 18:45And so you have a lot of lawmakers across the country
- 18:48looking at that going, wow, you know, there's this industry now
- 18:52and they'll just drop, they dropped $200 million in the
- 18:54race. The crypto Bitcoin writ large
- 18:56industry placed at $200 million in opposition to Sherrod Brown
- 19:01and put it in support of Bernie Moreno.
- 19:03So lawmakers are, you know, they're smart.
- 19:05You know, a lot of people think lawmakers aren't smart.
- 19:07They're very smart. They're very instinctual.
- 19:09They saw that and they go, wow, I don't want to have $200
- 19:11million placed against me. I'm actually good with crypto.
- 19:15I'm good with Bitcoin. Or sometimes they go, wow,
- 19:17actually I'm going to now I'm going to go learn about Bitcoin
- 19:19and crypto. I'm hearing that a lot.
- 19:21A lot of lawmakers reaching out and saying, tell me, tell me
- 19:23everything I need to know. Clearly this is, you know, this
- 19:26is an industry that I need to be paying more attention to.
- 19:29That's the way the system works. I don't wish, I'm not a big
- 19:31money guy in politics. I don't like all the money in
- 19:33politics. I think it's a big problem, but
- 19:35unfortunately it's a system that we have and you have to have the
- 19:38money on your side, otherwise you can't win your race.
- 19:40You got to get a bare minimum threshold.
- 19:42So I don't like that this money is being spent so much in the
- 19:44space, but it is. People need to pay attention to
- 19:47the crypto industry. Bitcoin industry writ large
- 19:50accounted for roughly half of all super PAC money.
- 19:53Again, I'm not a big super PAC guy, but it's a system we have.
- 19:56But the crypto industry accounted for roughly half of
- 19:59all the money spent. That's insane.
- 20:01If you think about it, look, take a step back, We beat the
- 20:03Koch brothers. If you pay attention to
- 20:05politics, the Koch brothers, they're always the ones that get
- 20:07all the grief for all the money they spend in politics.
- 20:11We beat the Koch brothers. We beat the oil and gas
- 20:13industry. We beat the military.
- 20:15We beat all of them. We beat the healthcare.
- 20:17We were half of everything. Now, if you go back 10 years,
- 20:21we're actually #2 the number two biggest spender.
- 20:23Even though we never used to spend very much money in
- 20:24politics or in campaigns, we're the number two biggest spender
- 20:28in the last 10 years in the United States.
- 20:30And that's just from one political cycle.
- 20:32What's going to happen next political cycle?
- 20:33We're going to see it double down because what happens when
- 20:36you win, people love to put extra money on their winners.
- 20:39They like to double down on their winners.
- 20:41And people are certainly going to be doubling down on the
- 20:43political space. And I'm very excited for it.
- 20:45We're certainly going to see, I think a wave of Democrats start
- 20:48paying a lot more attention. And as a last note here, I'll,
- 20:50I'll say this on the Democrats because I'm, you know me.
- 20:52I'm, I live in Portland, OR so I got a lot of Democrat friends
- 20:55and I understand their positions, but I had a Democrat
- 20:58office who they talked, they like to talk to me.
- 21:01We talked about Bitcoin. They're nice office, but we sat
- 21:04down for, we sat down to for a meeting and normally we say we,
- 21:07we chat for 20 minutes, thirty minutes tops.
- 21:09That's it. We sat down for two hours and we
- 21:12talked about Bitcoin and we talked about a strategic Bitcoin
- 21:14reserve. We've never had those
- 21:16conversations before. I think people are finally
- 21:18waking up to this thing, and they need to, because if
- 21:20Democrats don't pay attention to Bitcoin and crypto, they're
- 21:23going to keep losing their races and they're going to not be in a
- 21:26good position to help set policy on Bitcoin and crypto.
- 21:29They're going to just let the Republicans do it all.
- 21:31And I don't think that's smart of them.
- 21:32I think we need both sides working on policy together.
- 21:35Amen. That's well said, Dennis, very
- 21:38well articulated and congratulations on your
- 21:42successes in the recent years here.
- 21:45In light of the change landscape, you know, let's press
- 21:49this a little more. Which states do you consider now
- 21:54maybe the most progressive or the most interested or likely
- 21:59to, to achieve, whether it's a Bitcoin reserve or some other
- 22:03pro Bitcoin or Bitcoin friendly policy?
- 22:06I mean, you mentioned 4 states where you already achieved
- 22:09legislation. You know what, what are the,
- 22:12what's the short list that you're looking at right now?
- 22:14And where are you pressing pressing the advantage here?
- 22:18Great question. I will.
- 22:20I'll try to without revealing too much because we have to be
- 22:22careful. You know, you were there.
- 22:24You know what happens? You, you, you gave me a nice
- 22:26compliment about my stealing the show in California when we met
- 22:30for Bitcoin Day. But you saw what happens when
- 22:32you get, when you talk too early about things and you and you
- 22:34announce them too early. You got to be really careful.
- 22:36If you talk about it too early. Learn this lesson the hard way
- 22:39myself, very hard. I got made fun of it pretty
- 22:41badly for it, actually. You learn the hard way.
- 22:43You can't talk too much too early.
- 22:45So you got to be careful. But I do want to give people an
- 22:47idea of where we're seeing a lot of success.
- 22:49I'll, I'll talk more about where we've seen success, but maybe
- 22:52not where we will see success because I don't want to give
- 22:54away too much of the information too early.
- 22:56And then we cause problems for these lawmakers.
- 22:58You got to protect the policy process.
- 23:00You got to protect the lawmaker, and you got to protect the
- 23:02state. You know, we've got a lot of
- 23:03journalists watching us now. You got the AP who just wrote an
- 23:06article. We were in it.
- 23:07You, you know, the New York Times has basically done a whole
- 23:09article trying to tear us apart. They couldn't weird.
- 23:12We, they couldn't find anything on us.
- 23:14They had to write this fluff piece about how we are close to
- 23:16Trump people and that's why we're so bad.
- 23:18Well, it's, you know, this is the world we live in.
- 23:20You're going to you're going to interact with people from all
- 23:21sorts of different sides of the political aisle when you're in
- 23:23politics. So that's a normal thing, but we
- 23:26got to be careful about the policy process.
- 23:28But the states where we've seen a lot of winning, we've seen a
- 23:29lot of winning in states like Georgia, we've seen a lot of
- 23:33winning for Bitcoin mining there.
- 23:34Texas has done a lot of winning for Bitcoin mining as well.
- 23:36I would say both those states, though one thing to keep in mind
- 23:40is they've attracted a lot of Bitcoin mining, but it's because
- 23:42of the pre-existing system that it was in place.
- 23:44They haven't, they haven't done a lot.
- 23:46You know, I asked them, I said what, how'd you get all the
- 23:48Bitcoin miners here? And they said, well, all this
- 23:50stuff was here already in the 1st place.
- 23:51So it just, they just came in and they plugged in.
- 23:53We haven't done anything to actually attract them.
- 23:55We haven't passed any new laws to attract them.
- 23:56So, so Texas got lucky. Good for them.
- 24:00We're happy to have them because now we got a lot of the Bitcoin
- 24:03mining, but we need to see more, more winning than that.
- 24:05You know, we helped states win on Bitcoin rights.
- 24:07We helped Montana. They were one of the first, they
- 24:09were the number two in the country to be able to pass right
- 24:12to mine, which protects the right to Bitcoin mining.
- 24:16And then we also see it saw it pass in Arkansas, which passed
- 24:19that legislation into law. It was the very first in the
- 24:21world in history. It's passed that legislation
- 24:23into law. We've also seen in Oklahoma,
- 24:26they passed the expanded version of the Bitcoin rights bill,
- 24:30which had a lot more stuff in it, right to mine, right to self
- 24:32custody. Same thing in Louisiana as well.
- 24:34But I will going back to Oklahoma.
- 24:37I like Oklahoma. I think there's a lot of great
- 24:39Bitcoiners there in the government and like around the
- 24:42government as well who care a lot about Bitcoin and they kind
- 24:45of competitive. You know, Oklahoma and Texas
- 24:47think they really don't like they like each other just
- 24:49enough, but they're they're very competitive with each other,
- 24:51especially Oklahoma. They're like Texas always takes
- 24:53all the light. So Oklahoma I think is coming
- 24:56for Texas. I think Oklahoma is going to
- 24:58show the world that it is more pro Bitcoin than Texas.
- 25:01You know, Texas, they say we're pro Bitcoin.
- 25:04We're the number one Bitcoin place.
- 25:05They say a lot of things, but they need to do a lot of things.
- 25:07I and that's just something I've said for a long time.
- 25:10You cannot just let lawmakers say positive things about you
- 25:13and not do anything because they'll just get away with it
- 25:17and they'll just keep doing that.
- 25:17They'll play. It's called lip service.
- 25:19There's a lot of industries and a lot of movements in the
- 25:22political space where they have let lawmakers just say nice,
- 25:25fancy things about them and tell them how great they are, and
- 25:28they don't do anything. And it goes on and on for
- 25:31decades and decades. Nothing ever happens.
- 25:33Nothing ever. Nothing ever progresses and
- 25:36lawmakers just learn, oh, all I got to do is say nice things
- 25:38about these people and that's all they want.
- 25:40They don't need, they don't want me to pass any laws.
- 25:42We need the lawmakers to pass laws.
- 25:44If you're going to say great things about Bitcoin, you can't
- 25:46just say great things. You got to do great things.
- 25:48You got to pass legislation. You got to make your state a
- 25:51better place to be. So we highly encourage more
- 25:54folks, Texas and everybody else, You got to pass more legislation
- 25:58and there's many states coming. I'm very excited about
- 26:00Pennsylvania. We were able to introduce our
- 26:02strategic Bitcoin reserve bill there.
- 26:03It was the first in history to do that and they want more.
- 26:06They are coming back. 2025 is going to be very busy.
- 26:10It's going to be packed. You know the lawmakers there.
- 26:12The great thing is that we have a few different lawmakers that
- 26:15we talked to, their good relationships with them and they
- 26:17say things like, you know, I'm talking to other lawmakers and
- 26:20they told me that this is the thing there is they're getting
- 26:23more mail, they're getting more emails, they're getting more
- 26:25messages and more constituents reaching out to them about
- 26:28Bitcoin than anything else. And that is very important.
- 26:31That's super important because lawmakers, like I said, they're
- 26:34smart, they're instinctual. When you say you want something,
- 26:37they're going to listen and they can, they can ignore you, but
- 26:40they know that they can only ignore you for so long and then
- 26:42you're going to do something about it.
- 26:43So and we just certainly will do something about it in the
- 26:46Bitcoin space. We've proven that with the
- 26:47election. That's really, that's the,
- 26:49that's how you keep the lawmakers accountable.
- 26:51The elections is how we keep them accountable.
- 26:53That way they know that we can come in and we can say, listen,
- 26:56if you're not going to do what we want, if you're not going to
- 26:58support Bitcoin, we're going to put someone in who will support
- 27:01Bitcoin and who is going to care about the future of this
- 27:03country. And that because Bitcoin is
- 27:05going to do all these incredible things for the United States and
- 27:07for the rest of the world as well.
- 27:09So Pennsylvania is a great one. A lot of great things happening
- 27:12there. Very excited about some other
- 27:15states. I wish I could say who they
- 27:16were. They're coming there.
- 27:18I will have another one this week.
- 27:19We're supposed to have it this week.
- 27:21Another third bill, 1/3 strategic Bitcoin reserve bill
- 27:24will be introduced this week. That's the word on the street.
- 27:27There might be a fourth, actually, because a lot of
- 27:29lawmakers are coming. They want this stuff.
- 27:30They want it. They want to be the first, too.
- 27:32Everybody wants to be first. They want to get the legislation
- 27:35done before the others. So you're going to see game
- 27:37theory take off. We talk about game theory a lot
- 27:39in the Bitcoin space. Game theory is about to take
- 27:42off. January is going to be a race.
- 27:44It'll be a race between the states.
- 27:45It'll be a race between the States and the federal
- 27:47government as well. Because Trump could do an
- 27:49executive order if he wants. People are saying he will.
- 27:51I've talked to a lot of people who say that he's going to do an
- 27:53executive order and they're very confident about it.
- 27:56They think he's going to do it. He's going to use the exchange
- 27:58stabilization fund to do it and he's going to buy Bitcoin, put
- 28:02it in the treasury. He's going to end the US
- 28:03Marshals auction of the Bitcoin and put it into the treasury,
- 28:06put it into the strategic Bitcoin reserve.
- 28:08But he only has a little bit of time.
- 28:10He's got to do it right away. If he doesn't do it right away,
- 28:12the states are going to win. And you know me, I'm a big
- 28:14states guy. I love the states.
- 28:16I want the states to win. That's where we're also being
- 28:19the most effective. So of course, you know, I'm
- 28:20always going to want my side to win, but I think we all win if
- 28:24we do get a strategic Bitcoin reserve at the federal level.
- 28:27At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 28:30asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 28:34right. There are shortcomings with
- 28:36keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 28:39up your own self custody arrangement.
- 28:41Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 28:44Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 28:47minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 28:50remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 28:54inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 28:56well. On ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 28:59for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 29:02for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 29:05set up. For more information, check us
- 29:07out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah, it's it's incredible.
- 29:12It feels like, like the moment in the, in the hockey stick
- 29:15graph right before, if things go vertical in terms of the
- 29:17competition, the game theory and we, you know, in Bitcoin, we
- 29:21always think about the nation state game theory of like, OK,
- 29:24well, whoever uses the printing press to buy Bitcoin first is
- 29:28going to, you know, have a disproportionate advantage in
- 29:30the, in, in the 21st century. But I, I tend not to think about
- 29:34it at the, at the state level. And there really is an
- 29:36opportunity here that that Dennis, I think you're, you're
- 29:39keyed into that. There's there's an opportunity
- 29:43for a state to carve out an identity as like the Bitcoin
- 29:47progressive state, you know, the, the, the champion of
- 29:50Bitcoin rights and, you know, the home of Bitcoin in America.
- 29:55And, and I feel like maybe that's some of the conversations
- 29:58you're having with States and lawmakers in, in states who, who
- 30:02are starting to see that opportunity.
- 30:04But I can definitely see how this would snowball pretty
- 30:06quickly in the in the game theory of states trying to out
- 30:09compete each other to make that, you know, to become to become
- 30:12the California for the Internet. But now for Bitcoin and and be
- 30:18the the home of where all that innovation and and and and and
- 30:22companies want to be in the Bitcoin space.
- 30:25Absolutely, yeah. Yeah, if you want to speak at
- 30:27all to that or like is, is that what you're seeing?
- 30:28Is that where you see this going?
- 30:30Absolutely. We see it going that way.
- 30:32You know, states love to compete.
- 30:34We call it the laboratory of democracy.
- 30:36The states are competing. Senator Lummus, we had a spaces
- 30:39just recently, her and I spoke one-on-one on Twitter.
- 30:41Spaces. A lot of people were pretty
- 30:43surprised by that. But you know, Senator Lummus
- 30:45loves the state work. She loves what's going on at the
- 30:47states. She's a very big advocate for
- 30:50states rights and for states being what she calls the
- 30:53incubator. That's what she said on the
- 30:54Twitter Spaces. She said the states are the
- 30:56incubator for good ideas. And I 100% agree with her.
- 31:00The states are a great place. In fact, Senator Lummus started
- 31:02at the state level. She started as a state lawmaker
- 31:05and then she's also the treasurer.
- 31:07So she really understands the stuff.
- 31:08She understands how the states can be a great place.
- 31:11She actually was a part of the state's leading when she was in
- 31:13Wyoming. She was a big part of that.
- 31:16And so, so much of her staff as well.
- 31:17She's got incredible staff and her staff was, they were also
- 31:21highly involved in Wyoming to get things done.
- 31:23And so they took all that team and they said, let's go to
- 31:25Washington, DC, Let's take these winners.
- 31:28You want winners on your team and let's take them to
- 31:30Washington, DC and get the work done there as well.
- 31:33So they've done that. They've done a great job trying
- 31:35to advocate for Bitcoin at the state level.
- 31:37They graduated to DC where they continue to fight for Bitcoin.
- 31:41But certainly Senator Lummus really sees the potential of the
- 31:44States, and we do want the states to compete.
- 31:46You want competition just like you want the Republicans and the
- 31:49Democrats to compete for your vote, because competition is
- 31:51good. When people are competing, we
- 31:53see the consumer do well. The consumer wins.
- 31:56In this case, the consumer is the voter.
- 31:58The voter benefits from competition and Americans
- 32:02benefit from competition between the states.
- 32:04You know, we've had a lot of different industries where we've
- 32:06we've had the states compete in the past, The auto industry, the
- 32:09tech industry, the oil and gas industry, the renewable
- 32:11industry. There's a lot of industries that
- 32:13are very successful here in America because of that
- 32:16competition. And so we're trying to foster
- 32:18that competition as rapidly as we can.
- 32:21We want way more competition. And the great part about Bitcoin
- 32:24versus a lot of other industries is you can really compete with
- 32:27Bitcoin pretty much anywhere. You know, the tech industry is
- 32:29not a lot of places the tech industry could go.
- 32:31You need a lot of talent. You need tons of people.
- 32:34This industry is different. It's very decentralized.
- 32:37You can, you know, especially with remote work these days, you
- 32:39really can be pretty much anywhere.
- 32:41You know, you can set up a institution or a bank in a state
- 32:44that doesn't even have any people and it can just be a pass
- 32:46through for the crypto industry. That's that's great.
- 32:49You don't need any very much talent at all.
- 32:50You can provide a lot of banking opportunities for people.
- 32:54You can mine Bitcoin, you can become a hub for Bitcoin mining.
- 32:57You can become the Innovation Center for Bitcoin mining.
- 33:01There's a lot of opportunity there and especially in rural
- 33:03parts of the country. These rural parts, they've
- 33:05really been left behind. They don't, they don't, they
- 33:07don't get a lot of love from the tech industry.
- 33:09They're they're typically very anti tech in fact, because
- 33:12they've been so left behind by the tech industry.
- 33:15But Bitcoin mining is different. Bitcoin and Bitcoin mining is
- 33:17willing to go into those rural parts and create tech jobs in
- 33:21the middle of the rural parts of this country.
- 33:23No ones doing that. No, no tech company is creating
- 33:26jobs in rural America. Bitcoin is, Bitcoin mining is,
- 33:30and so that's why there's just, that's just one of many, many
- 33:32reasons why there's opportunity for all the states to
- 33:35participate. Small states, small economies or
- 33:39big States and big economies, they all have an opportunity
- 33:41here to stake their claim and they're going to try it.
- 33:44They're going to work. They are working right now to do
- 33:45that. So we're excited about the
- 33:47lawmakers competing. We want to see a lot more
- 33:49competition take place and we are going to do everything we
- 33:51can to foster that competition. So, ultimately, that the United
- 33:54States is the best place in the world for Bitcoin.
- 33:57Yeah, I love that framing. It is really important for
- 33:59lawmakers to understand that there's opportunity for all 50
- 34:02States and obviously, there's opportunity for all the
- 34:05countries of the world. And some are already taking
- 34:07advantage, although it's very early innings.
- 34:10So, Dennis, how about you pull out your crystal ball?
- 34:14Let's wind the clock forward a year.
- 34:17OK. And if you don't mind, if you'll
- 34:19humor me on a couple scenarios, what does the success case look
- 34:25like for you? I mean, you talked about right
- 34:27to mine, you know, expanded Bitcoin rights, including self
- 34:31custody. Obviously the, you know, the
- 34:33Bitcoin reserve. There's a bunch of different
- 34:36factors at play here. But I'm curious what you think,
- 34:39you know, how you would explain what happened in the last year.
- 34:42This is again with the clock wound forward in the success
- 34:45case versus the opposite case. Yeah, I'm very big and I'm a
- 34:51very big optimist. So we'll start with the the
- 34:53success case here. I don't like to think too much
- 34:55about how bad it could get, but I'll I'll certainly dive into
- 34:58that a little bit there. So the optimistic case is with
- 35:02these states, we've got at least 10, maybe 12 states that want to
- 35:06introduce strategic Bitcoin reserve legislation.
- 35:09You know, we're very optimistic about the outcome.
- 35:10People keep saying, well, what are the odds you're going to
- 35:13pass one of these bills into law?
- 35:14It's very high. Let me tell you, it's very, very
- 35:16high because we not only have all the success, we've already
- 35:20done this before. I think a lot of people forget
- 35:22we know how to pass legislation. We've done it before.
- 35:24We've been doing our team who we've only been around for three
- 35:27years, but our team has been doing it for a long time.
- 35:29Our policy director has been doing it for a decade.
- 35:31My Co founders have been in doing the political game for
- 35:34over a decade. Our research guy, he's been
- 35:37doing it for way longer. He's like 2530 years.
- 35:40So we have the team, we have the skills, we have the experience,
- 35:43not only outside the Bitcoin space, but now inside the
- 35:45Bitcoin space to get these bills across the finish line.
- 35:49And the great part about it is we're in this era with a lot of
- 35:52political momentum where there's so many lawmakers that want to
- 35:55stake their claim, whether they be pro Bitcoin or they're
- 35:58because they own it or they just see the opportunity, they want
- 36:01to stake their claim. And so lawmakers are working
- 36:03aggressively to introduce this legislation and to pass it.
- 36:06In fact, we have a state, one state, maybe 2, but one state
- 36:10for sure. It's almost a near 100% chance
- 36:13that we passed the legislation into law.
- 36:15And I normally don't say that. I normally am very, I'm very
- 36:18cautious with saying those types of things because I would always
- 36:21normally say it's maybe a 20% chance because it's a lot of
- 36:24work. People don't realize how much
- 36:26work goes into passing legislation.
- 36:27Not only do you got to convince a lawmaker, you got to write the
- 36:29law, you got to convince a lawmaker they introduce the
- 36:31legislation. You hope you get a committee
- 36:33hearing. You don't always get one.
- 36:35You got to fight for it, got to fight for a committee hearing.
- 36:37And then when you get it on the calendar, you got to fly to the
- 36:39state, you got to write testimony.
- 36:41You help other people write testimony.
- 36:43You meet with the individual committee members, you talk to
- 36:45them, them, you explain to them why it matters.
- 36:47And then you go to the committee hearing and you give your your
- 36:49testimony, you testify and then they say, OK, what are we going
- 36:53to do? Then they vote on it.
- 36:53Hopefully you get a vote. You pass out of the committee.
- 36:55Then you go to the floor vote, whether it's the House or the
- 36:58Senate depends on where you started.
- 37:00You go to the floor, you vote. You hope you get that passed
- 37:02too. So that's a whole nother wave of
- 37:04voting. And on a different day too, by
- 37:05the way, it's not all in once it's like they may, they stagger
- 37:07it out. And then what happens is you
- 37:10have to, after you pass it on one side, you have to repeat all
- 37:13of that on the other side. So it's double all of that work.
- 37:16And then, of course, you have to work with the governor's office
- 37:18to get his signature. So it's an incredible amount of
- 37:20work that goes into passing legislation.
- 37:22And there's a lot of things that can go wrong along the way.
- 37:25And we've been able to do it. We've been able to do it four
- 37:27times all the way through the process, passed 4 bills in four
- 37:30different states, and now we need to do it again, but we need
- 37:33to do it for the strategic Bitcoin Reserve legislation.
- 37:35But one of the things that's really great at this one state
- 37:37where it's a near 100% guarantee the lawmakers there, what they
- 37:40do to be able to give themselves the extra ability to get
- 37:43legislation across the finish line is they'll meet in the
- 37:45offseason. A lot of these state
- 37:47legislators, they meet, you know, part time.
- 37:50They only are there maybe three months, two months.
- 37:53In some states it's every other year for two months.
- 37:54So it's very limited time. You got to move fast.
- 37:57So what they'll do is they'll meet before the legislative
- 38:00cycle. Some lawmakers will get
- 38:01together. They call it a task force and
- 38:03they say, OK, what legislation do we like and what do we not
- 38:06like? It's like a pregame.
- 38:07They the pre vote to see if they get can get pre support for a
- 38:11piece of legislation. This one task force that we've
- 38:13been working with for over a year, they're great people,
- 38:16really smart, they really understand this stuff.
- 38:18Got a lot of great lawmakers in there and they vote on bills and
- 38:22every bill they've ever had go through that committee, every
- 38:24single one that is passed through and they voted in favor
- 38:27of has passed into law 100% of the time it is passed into law.
- 38:31Well, our bill just passed out of that task force.
- 38:34So that's why we say we have a near 100% chance we're passing
- 38:37the legislation. I can't guarantee you can never
- 38:39guarantee anything in life, but we're close to being able to
- 38:42guarantee it because we would be the only bill.
- 38:44What's the odds that we're the only bill that doesn't pass?
- 38:46It's very low odds. So very high odds that we will
- 38:49pass it. And that's just one state.
- 38:51There are other states where we feel very optimistic about, we
- 38:54feel very good about, and I would say at least three other
- 38:57states where we feel really good about the legislation.
- 38:59That's a, that's a neutral position though.
- 39:02I would say if we're lucky, if we have a bowl case here, things
- 39:05go really well. We could see this legislation
- 39:07pass in six or seven states. That would be truly monumental.
- 39:11I mean, that would be huge. We got to keep our expectations
- 39:14in check though. So we think one to two states,
- 39:16bare minimum, will pass this legislation into law.
- 39:18But that is, once you do it, it's done and it's, it's then
- 39:22it's then it is OK, how many more can we get after that?
- 39:26And we'll keep coming back. That's the thing that people
- 39:27don't realize about Satoshi action and they don't realize
- 39:29about me is we never stop. We're going to keep coming back
- 39:32because we love to win. And once we started winning, we
- 39:34don't want to stop winning. So we're going to be back as
- 39:36much as we have to, to be able to get these things across the
- 39:39finish line and then ultimately also create that political
- 39:41momentum. You know, when we do this at the
- 39:43state level, when we pass these laws, the federal level, they
- 39:46pay attention. The whole political parties pay
- 39:49attention. In fact, once we passed
- 39:50strategic Bitcoin reserve legislation into law, you'll see
- 39:53a lot of folks start to endorse this legislation and try to pass
- 39:56it very rapidly. The same thing happened with our
- 39:59Bitcoin rights legislation right after right after we passed our
- 40:03fourth bill of Bitcoin rights, the right to mine and the right
- 40:06to self custody the whole GOP party.
- 40:09Said look at that. Look at all this great work
- 40:11happening in the red states because we passed all four of
- 40:13these bills in red states. We love the blue states too.
- 40:15Some blue state news is coming. But they said, wow, look at
- 40:20this. It's so popular.
- 40:21The right to mine, the right to self custody.
- 40:23Let's take that exact language. They took literally those exact
- 40:26words and they put them right into the party platform for the
- 40:28GOP. The whole party now endorses the
- 40:32right to mine. The whole party now endorses the
- 40:34right to self custody and it's great.
- 40:37You love to see that. You want to see more parties do
- 40:39that and you want to see the Democrats do it too.
- 40:41And I think they will. I think especially when it comes
- 40:43to the right to self custody, they really want to protect
- 40:45access. They're very, very big on
- 40:47allowing the average American to have access to financial tools.
- 40:52So that's what happens though. You pass legislation and other
- 40:55people want to do it too and they want to make it their whole
- 40:57party platform. So I think that's strategic
- 40:59Bitcoin reserve legislation. Once we pass it, not only are we
- 41:02going to pass it in other states, I think the parties
- 41:04might even say, wow, we should just make this a whole thing.
- 41:06We should make it a part of our party platform.
- 41:09The party platform has a bunch of different planks.
- 41:11They're called planks and they essentially are the different
- 41:14issues. They have a crypto plank in the
- 41:16Republican Party platform and it says if you go read it, it says
- 41:19we will protect the right to mine and the right to self
- 41:22custody. We're very proud to have had
- 41:24them use the language that we passed into law in those four
- 41:28states. We think we're going to see a
- 41:29lot more of that now. You said give both sides
- 41:32pessimistic and I think the pessimistic outcome is we pass
- 41:35it in one state. To be honest, I think it's
- 41:37happening. I think we're going to get in
- 41:38one state no matter what. That's pessimistic to me.
- 41:40And it'll be just the creation of the strategic reserve.
- 41:43We won't see any sort of allocations.
- 41:44We'll just see them create the reserve and you can add tax
- 41:47money to it or you can donate to it or something along those
- 41:49lines. I think that's going to be
- 41:51obvious that we'll get at least one to do that.
- 41:53It's too easy. Or they'll pass one state and
- 41:55they'll say, OK, we only want the criminal Bitcoin, the
- 41:58Bitcoin that was confiscated through the criminal courts,
- 42:01that that criminal Bitcoin is going to go into the strategic
- 42:05reserve and we are going to keep it for ourselves.
- 42:06I mean, it's just a no brainer there.
- 42:08What what should they do? Should they auction the Bitcoin
- 42:10off or should they keep the Bitcoin?
- 42:12I think they should keep the Bitcoin.
- 42:13We got to be careful about confiscation in this country.
- 42:15But I think it's a no brainer if all the things were done right,
- 42:18if all the process was done right and you have a scammer who
- 42:20scammed people out of their Bitcoin and they can't get the
- 42:22Bitcoin back to the people and the government holds the Bitcoin
- 42:24now, the government should not sell the Bitcoin.
- 42:26It's too valuable, it's too important.
- 42:28We need to hold on to it. Senator Lumas even agrees with
- 42:30that. They're doing the same.
- 42:31They want to do the same thing at the federal level.
- 42:33We got to stop the US Marshals auction.
- 42:35They're trying to auction almost 200,000 Bitcoin off.
- 42:38We can't let that happen. If that happens, if we even sell
- 42:42really Trump promised, he said we won't sell any.
- 42:45We will keep 100%. These are his words.
- 42:47We will keep 100% of the Bitcoin that is currently held by the US
- 42:51government and all future Bitcoin.
- 42:53I think we got to keep that promise.
- 42:55We cannot sell a single sat of the Bitcoin that we hold the
- 42:58government's, whether they be the state government or the
- 43:00federal government. Yeah, that's really well said.
- 43:05Couldn't agree with you more in that regard.
- 43:08I think we're all on the same page with respect to Bitcoin
- 43:12being the best hard asset there is and this being a strategic
- 43:18factor for maintaining and securing the security of our
- 43:22country. And so appreciate the efforts,
- 43:25the great efforts on your part to create a little bit of
- 43:29tension, honestly. And it's not, you know, it's not
- 43:32like it's not out of malice or anything.
- 43:35It's, it's out of love, right? It's, this is the thing to own.
- 43:40All Americans will benefit from it.
- 43:42Individuals, you know, local municipalities, states, the
- 43:46federal government. This is a race to secure the
- 43:50world's hardest monetary asset in a world of rampant debasement
- 43:55of of Fiat currencies. Absolutely.
- 43:58You know, we got it. We got it.
- 43:59Like, listen, even the states, they need it, right?
- 44:01They need to. If the states, I was just in
- 44:03Washington state, they have a $12 billion deficit over the
- 44:07next four years, 12 billion. It's not something that they can
- 44:11just print that the federal government, they have the money
- 44:13printer. They can just say magically we
- 44:15can, we want more debt. We have more debt now.
- 44:17It's just a little bit little little SWIP of a pen and they've
- 44:20got more money. The states can't do that.
- 44:22They don't have a money printer, they're not allowed to.
- 44:24It's unconstitutional. So they are much more cautious
- 44:28when it comes to protecting their budgets.
- 44:29But what happened? We saw inflation rage across
- 44:32this country. We saw the amount of costs that
- 44:35go up for everything. The employees, the housing,
- 44:37everything is way up. And that's a big problem for
- 44:40these states. Their budgets are massively
- 44:43constrained. They have huge shortfalls
- 44:45because of the inflation that we saw over the last four years.
- 44:48And now what's going to happen is you have states like
- 44:50Washington where they have two options.
- 44:52They can do one or two, one of two things.
- 44:54They can either cut tax. They can either cut programs or
- 44:57they can raise taxes. Both of those things are not
- 45:00good. People are not going to like
- 45:01those things. Nobody likes when you get rid of
- 45:03the programs. Nobody likes when you raise
- 45:04taxes. They're going to have to do it
- 45:06though, if they're not careful. What could have happened to
- 45:10though? How could we have solved this
- 45:11problem or avoid this problem if states like Washington state
- 45:14where they have a $12 billion budget deficit over the next
- 45:16four years, if they had just said, you know what, let's add a
- 45:19little bit of Bitcoin to the Treasury right before all the
- 45:22inflation, not only would they not have a shortfall, it's very
- 45:25likely they'd have extra money to spend on top of it.
- 45:27So it's super important. You know, we say, oh, it's great
- 45:31to hold Bitcoin, but we need to hold Bitcoin.
- 45:33These governments, they need it. They need to protect themselves
- 45:36there. We're in an era now where
- 45:38inflation is happening every 5-10 years all the time.
- 45:41We need to have protection against that at the state level,
- 45:43but also at the federal level. We need protection from things
- 45:46like bricks. Bricks is becoming a big
- 45:48problem. For those of you that don't know
- 45:50what bricks is, it is a group of countries that got together.
- 45:53They basically say, you know what, let's pick the the country
- 45:57that is the highest economic driver in a certain region of
- 46:00the world and they'll join in together and we'll create a
- 46:03system that competes with the United States.
- 46:04But there's a, there's a small known secret, of course, about
- 46:08bricks, which is it's, it's mostly ran by countries that
- 46:10don't like the United States very much.
- 46:12I wouldn't say we hate each other, but we certainly don't
- 46:14like each other very much right now.
- 46:16And those countries, they want to compete with the United
- 46:19States, but not just compete, they also want to win.
- 46:21They want to beat the United States.
- 46:22They want to, they want to displace us.
- 46:24They want to be the new world order or at least create a
- 46:27multipolar world where there's two world orders.
- 46:30That is a different environment than where we where we are
- 46:32today. the United States pretty much controls all the financial
- 46:35system all across the world. We can pull a trigger and all of
- 46:38a sudden someone we don't like isn't able to use the financial
- 46:40system anymore. We did it to Russia right in the
- 46:42middle of the Ukraine war. They didn't like that.
- 46:44That scared them. So they're searching for options
- 46:47and we need to make sure that as we enter this multi polar world
- 46:50where BRICS, Russia, China, Iran, all these countries that
- 46:54don't like us, we need to make sure we have a neutral money
- 46:57because it's going to get really hot.
- 46:58It could get really hostile. I'm predicting that it could get
- 47:00very hostile. Whenever you see, whenever you
- 47:03see groups of countries get together and say we want to be
- 47:06the captain now bad things can happen.
- 47:09That's where you see mass conflict take place.
- 47:11That's where you see all sorts of things breakdown.
- 47:14It's a very scary place that we're in right now.
- 47:16We need to be very careful and that's why a neutral money, I
- 47:18call it the Switzerland of money, Bitcoin is more important
- 47:22than ever. We need to have a way to
- 47:24interoperably interact with each other and I think Bitcoin could
- 47:27be a solution to that. And also Bitcoin can act as a
- 47:30hedge against any type of scenario where bricks becomes
- 47:34the new world order. I don't think that'll happen,
- 47:36but even if it's a 1% chance, we got to have a little bit of
- 47:38Bitcoin to defend ourselves against it.
- 47:42Amen. So, Dennis, let's talk a little
- 47:44bit about timing. I mean, the race is ongoing
- 47:47right now. You're working furiously,
- 47:50communicating, preparing, you know, pitching various states on
- 47:55how they can get ahead of this freight train that's coming
- 47:58through. Is this all going to play out
- 48:01literally in the next couple of months?
- 48:04We're here on December 16th, 2024.
- 48:07I mean, how rapidly could additional legislation and or
- 48:12policy changes be implemented here?
- 48:16I mean, at the state level, it's going to happen fast.
- 48:18It's going to happen very fast. These states don't meet for very
- 48:21long. They meet for months at a time.
- 48:22So they're going to meet and they're going to say let's do
- 48:25it, let's move forward. And it's going to happen really
- 48:27fast. It's going to happen in the
- 48:28first six months of the of the next year.
- 48:29It's going to happen almost instantly.
- 48:32It'll feel like to people because you'll see the bill get
- 48:34introduced officially, some of them already are.
- 48:36And then you'll see it get its hearing and then it'll vote and
- 48:38we'll pass it out of the hearing.
- 48:39And the people, wow, it already passed out of the hearing.
- 48:41And then it'll go to the floor and they're going to get
- 48:43unanimous votes for some of the stuff in some of these states,
- 48:45in my opinion, which means everybody votes in favor of it.
- 48:47And then it's going to go to the other side.
- 48:49And then it's going to go to the governor's desk.
- 48:50And they're going to sign it into law.
- 48:51And it's going to happen fast, very fast.
- 48:54And then from there, we're going to see the federal government,
- 48:56if it hasn't done the executive order already.
- 48:58You know, Trump has an opportunity here.
- 49:00He could end the auction. He could come through on his
- 49:02promise and say, we're keeping 100% of the Bitcoin.
- 49:06But he has to act. He has to act right away.
- 49:08Otherwise, the US Marshals will auction off the Bitcoin that is
- 49:11currently held, and they need to do that.
- 49:13They need to hold all the Bitcoin That can happen right
- 49:16away with an executive order. Trump doesn't need to ask
- 49:18permission. He can just do it himself.
- 49:19He should come through on his promise.
- 49:20He should do that. But even if he doesn't do that,
- 49:22we're still going to see momentum pick up and move
- 49:24forward with this type of legislation at the federal
- 49:26level. Senator Lummus's team, they're
- 49:28doing incredible stuff. They really, really know how to
- 49:31talk about strategic Bitcoin reserve legislation.
- 49:34They're so good at it. I mean, I was talking to Senator
- 49:36Lummus on the spaces, but I also got a chance, of course,
- 49:38regularly to sit down with her team.
- 49:40They are experts. They're they're almost, they
- 49:42might even be better than me. And I never say that about
- 49:44anyone when it comes to strategic Bitcoin reserve
- 49:46legislation. They talk about it very good,
- 49:48very smart, very eloquent. And we're very excited that they
- 49:51are there fighting for this type of policy in Washington, DC.
- 49:55So we want to see it happen at the federal level.
- 49:57Who knows? It's hard to know for sure.
- 49:59Washington, DC, sometimes it's a place where dreams going to die.
- 50:03But we'll do it at the state level no matter what.
- 50:04And it's going to happen. And then the federal government
- 50:07is going to go, wow, look at all this stuff happening at the
- 50:09state level, we better do it too.
- 50:11We're going to miss out. We're supposed to be the ones
- 50:13leading. So they need to lead.
- 50:15They need to follow the States and they need to pass strategic
- 50:18Bitcoin reserve legislation into law.
- 50:20I would say best case scenario, Trump comes in, he creates it,
- 50:23he starts to kind of create a quasi strategic Bitcoin reserve.
- 50:26And then legislation needs to follow because even if he does
- 50:29an executive order, he needs to make sure we need to make sure
- 50:33that legislation follows up to enshrine it into law.
- 50:36Because if what happens is Trump can't win again, he will only be
- 50:39one. He's already done one term and
- 50:40now he's going to be doing his second term.
- 50:42So he can't run again. So what'll happen is you'll have
- 50:44another race for the president in four years.
- 50:46And if he, if someone wins and they don't like Trump and they
- 50:49don't like, maybe they don't like Bitcoin, but they win and
- 50:52they don't like Trump or they don't like Bitcoin, they could
- 50:53say with a stroke of a pen, well, my executive order is to
- 50:57get rid of the strategic Bitcoin reserve.
- 50:58And we really, we really cannot have that happen.
- 51:00So we need to once, if Trump does the executive order, no
- 51:04matter what, we need to still follow up with legislation.
- 51:07And I do believe that there is a good shot of doing that.
- 51:09But we got to be diligent. We can't.
- 51:11We cannot wait around. We got to continue to run and
- 51:13Sprint after the momentum that we've created.
- 51:18Very well said. Very well said.
- 51:20Well, as we finish up the year here in 2024 and we head toward
- 51:25Inauguration Day and as legislators, you know, get into
- 51:29session here, I do want to point people toward your
- 51:32organization's Satoshi Action Fund, obviously.
- 51:35What other, you know, ideas or recommendations do you have for
- 51:41all the Bitcoiners listening to this show, as well as more
- 51:45broadly? You know, what actions can
- 51:47people take either right now or in the coming months here?
- 51:52People should make sure to take action.
- 51:54You know, one of the best things I always tell people is if you
- 51:57don't want to do politics, you know, a lot of people say that
- 51:59thank you for doing politics because I don't want to do
- 52:01politics. It is.
- 52:03It is certainly not a line of work for everybody, that's for
- 52:07sure. But what you can do if you want
- 52:09to help us and you don't even have to do anything political.
- 52:12You don't even have to write a letter if you just go out and
- 52:14build something, build something in the Bitcoin space, build a
- 52:17Bitcoin business or build your own strategic Bitcoin reserve.
- 52:20Because when we are able to show examples of Bitcoin progress of
- 52:25Bitcoin industry of things being built with Bitcoin, lawmakers
- 52:28love that. They love to see what is
- 52:30happening with the industry. So the more that's being built,
- 52:32the more we can you know, brag about it to the lawmakers and
- 52:35say look at all these great things happening.
- 52:36So every time someone does something great in the Bitcoin
- 52:39space, whether it be software, hardware, whether it be Bitcoin
- 52:43mining, whether it be making it a way for people to use
- 52:47Lightning Network, we need it all.
- 52:49We need all of that so that we can so go to the lawmakers and
- 52:51say we got to protect this industry.
- 52:52We need it in our, we need it in our borders.
- 52:55We want to keep it here in the US.
- 52:56We want it to be made in the US. So that's really important.
- 52:59If you don't want to do anything political at all, that's the
- 53:01best way that you can help #2 if you want to get on the political
- 53:05side, you can write a letter to your lawmaker.
- 53:08We do these letter writing campaigns all the time.
- 53:10We are really good at it. In fact, we were able to get on
- 53:12our last letter writing campaign, 190,000 letters, more
- 53:15than 190,000 letters sent. In total, we've sent over
- 53:18250,000 letters to lawmakers with the tools that we provide
- 53:22to our advocates. So if you care about Bitcoin and
- 53:24you want to see Bitcoin be successful, you can watch out
- 53:27for those letter writing campaigns and you can furiously
- 53:29write your lawmaker politely, of course, but furiously and let
- 53:33them know that you support Bitcoin and that you want a
- 53:36strategic Bitcoin reserve. Additionally, of course, we are
- 53:39nonprofit. We're always trying to raise
- 53:40money. So if you do like our work, if
- 53:42you're listening and you go, wow, that is the stuff that we
- 53:45need to fund. This is the work that we need to
- 53:47get progress on. We need to have more of these
- 53:49bills and we need to make sure that we're winning with Bitcoin
- 53:52in the United States. You can certainly donate to us.
- 53:54We will take your dollars. We'll spend those first.
- 53:57And then if you donate Bitcoin, we'll, we'll save on to that.
- 53:59We have our own strategic Bitcoin reserve as well at
- 54:02Satoshi Action. So we try to save as much of the
- 54:03Bitcoin as we can. But yes, if people want to help,
- 54:05they can certainly donate. They can support our political
- 54:08efforts by writing letters. They can meet their lawmakers
- 54:11and tell them and say, hey, you got to support Bitcoin.
- 54:13All of that goes a long way with lawmakers.
- 54:16But additionally, if you don't want to do anything politically
- 54:18at all, you're like, no, I don't want to touch it, Nothing to do
- 54:20with it. Just build stuff, build good
- 54:23Bitcoin businesses here in America.
- 54:24That is going to speak volumes to lawmakers.
- 54:28Well, Amen to that, Dennis. I haven't been as we mentioned
- 54:33all that active politically, including with respect to
- 54:36Bitcoin. But overall, I have to say I
- 54:39appreciate your aggressive style here and I agree 100%.
- 54:43Now is the time to press the advantage, right?
- 54:46We've we've gotten through this period of literally years, you
- 54:50know, basically playing defense, being attacked on all sides by
- 54:54the prior administration through through means fair and more
- 55:00means foul. And now is the time to get
- 55:03things done and belt and suspenders.
- 55:06That's the way, as you pointed out, you know, it's great to get
- 55:08an executive order done. Also, we need legislation.
- 55:11Your efforts are in some sense just beginning here.
- 55:15And I encourage people to to lend yours, excuse me, to lend
- 55:19their support to your strong efforts.
- 55:22You've had a lot of successes and I expect a lot of successes
- 55:26in the future for you and your organization.
- 55:28So thank you very much for all you do and thank you for coming
- 55:33on Scarce assets. Thank you for having me on, Andy
- 55:36and Jesse, it's great chatting with you and I appreciate the
- 55:39great interview and looking forward to.
- 55:41We got to get your book out. We got to get more of your book
- 55:43in the hands of more lawmakers. We got to get all of the Bitcoin
- 55:45books out there as much as we possibly can.
- 55:48And you wrote a great 1. So thank you for all the work
- 55:50that you've done in the space. You were an early book writer.
- 55:51Not a lot of people did that. It's it's, I thought about it.
- 55:54It's a lot of work. I never got it done.
- 55:55So congratulations to you on getting your book out there and
- 55:59I look forward to the next time that we can talk in person.
- 56:02Likewise, Thank you, Dennis. Appreciate it.
- 56:04Keep up the great work. Thanks for listening to this
- 56:06week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 56:09valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 56:11rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 56:13All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 56:15notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 56:18reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 56:20entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 56:23investment or legal advice, regardless of where you are on
- 56:27your Bitcoin. Journey, we'd love to hear from
- 56:28you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact
- 56:31to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 56:34Advisors.