Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 321. The Respect Effect: What Stereotype Threat Teaches Us About Communication
Transcript
- 0:02Matt Abrahams: One of the benefits of communication is it allows us to
- 0:05demonstrate that we truly see other people My name is Matt Abrahams, and
- 0:10I teach Strategic Communication at Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:14Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:18Today, I look forward to speaking with Claude Steele.
- 0:20Claude is the Lucie Stern Professor and Social Scientist
- 0:23Emeritus at Stanford University.
- 0:25He's held several academic leadership roles, including Dean of Stanford's
- 0:28Graduate School of Education and Provost at both UC Berkeley and Columbia.
- 0:33He is widely recognized for his groundbreaking research on stereotype
- 0:37threat, and he is the author of Whistling Vivaldi and his latest
- 0:41book, Churn: The Tension that Divides Us and How to Overcome It.
- 0:45Well, welcome, Claude.
- 0:46I have been a long admirer of your work, and I'm so excited to
- 0:49have this conversation with you.
- 0:50Claude Steele: Uh, I couldn't be happier to be here.
- 0:52It's been something I've been really looking forward to.
- 0:54Matt Abrahams: Thank you.
- 0:55Are you ready to get started?
- 0:56Claude Steele: I'm ready to go.
- 0:57Matt Abrahams: All right.
- 0:57Well, I'd like to start with how I came to first know of you and your work.
- 1:00As an undergraduate here at Stanford studying psychology, I learned about
- 1:04stereotype threat and found it not only interesting, but really important.
- 1:08And I'd love for you to take a moment just to share with everybody what that
- 1:12is and the impact it can have on people.
- 1:14Claude Steele: Yeah.
- 1:15It's a kind of social predicament that one can find oneself in.
- 1:18You're in a situation where there are negative stereotypes about one
- 1:22or another of your identity, your age, your race, your religion, and
- 1:27the stereotypes apply to what you're doing in that situation, you know then
- 1:31that you could be judged or treated in terms of that negative stereotype.
- 1:36And if the situation is important to you, that prospect is threatening,
- 1:41and that's what stereotype threat is.
- 1:43It's just finding yourself in a circumstance where, "Boy, I'm the
- 1:47oldest guy here. Are they going to think all my ideas are dated and I have
- 1:51no technological competence at all?"
- 1:53And those are stereotypes I know out there about age, and when I'm in a
- 1:57situation where they're applicable, and if it's an important situation, I
- 2:02can worry about that, and that worry can affect my behavior right there in
- 2:06the immediate situation, if I'm trying to perform something, a standardized
- 2:11test where a lot of the research has been done, or an athletic activity
- 2:14or, uh, any kind of intellectual activity where the stereotype applies,
- 2:18it can have a pretty serious effect.
- 2:21It could motivate you to avoid that situation.
- 2:23So it can have real, pretty profound effects on our choices as well
- 2:28as our behaviors, who our friends are, where we want to live, what
- 2:31schools we want our children to go to, where we feel comfortable,
- 2:34where we don't feel comfortable.
- 2:36A lot of that would take the form of stereotype threat.
- 2:39Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 2:40It can impact us in the moment, but also long term.
- 2:43I'm curious, how does social media impact and influence this kind of
- 2:47stereotype and stereotype threat?
- 2:49Claude Steele: Well, I think its effectiveness, its dramatic effectiveness
- 2:52at purveying stereotypes and images of groups and images of different identities,
- 2:58I think it can amplify the number of situations that people feel this kind of
- 3:03threat in because its currency is in big part summary, quick images of identities,
- 3:10and people have no tolerance for any elaboration or exception, so it can be
- 3:14very generative of this kind of threat.
- 3:17I do think, though, it can sometimes purvey things that
- 3:20would reduce the threat, images that would reduce the threat.
- 3:23So it can cut both ways, but so much of the tenor of social media seems to be
- 3:29more of a negative sort, and that makes us all the more, in a diverse society
- 3:34like the one in which we live, it makes us all the more conscious of our identities
- 3:39and what people might think of us.
- 3:41So the whole phenomenon can be amplified by social media.
- 3:44Matt Abrahams: So it can absolutely amplify, and I think it necessitates
- 3:48that as we consume social media, that we at least think about what are
- 3:52the stereotypes being communicated and how does that have impact on us.
- 3:56And by bringing that to consciousness might impact how we feel about it.
- 4:00Which leads me to the next question.
- 4:02I'm very curious to know what are some of the most effective and
- 4:05lasting interventions that can help mitigate stereotype threat
- 4:09and the negative impact from it?
- 4:11Claude Steele: There's been an important evolution over the last couple of
- 4:13decades of research on that, probably for the most part in academic settings,
- 4:18but increasingly in business settings.
- 4:21In academic settings, you know, you have minority kids, let's say African
- 4:24American kid, he's in a, an integrated classroom, which we think of as a very
- 4:28desirable thing, but he does know at some level, and his parents know, that there
- 4:33are these negative stereotypes about African Americans' abilities and the like.
- 4:38It can nag at a person, and they can be particularly vigilant as to how they're
- 4:43being perceived, and that can, as we just mentioned, interfere with performance
- 4:48right there in the immediate situation.
- 4:50Or it can, even if they feel that pressure is persistent, they can
- 4:54disidentify with the whole enterprise.
- 4:57You know, every time I raise my hand and I have this extra worry that if I get it
- 5:01wrong, I'm gonna be seen in terms of those stereotypes and confirm, that pressure
- 5:05every day in an important situation like schooling can be very daunting.
- 5:10You could see in a analogous situation, a white guy who's really
- 5:15good at basketball trying to make a career at that, he's gonna be
- 5:18seen in terms of, or could be seen.
- 5:21He doesn't know for sure if that decision by the coach had anything to
- 5:24do with stereotypes about his group's abilities in basketball or not.
- 5:28So a lot of the work has looked at its impact in schooling, and there is
- 5:32where I think progress has been made.
- 5:34One thing that helps is even knowing about stereotypes.
- 5:38It's just that this is a pressure coming from the social context that
- 5:41we're in, and let's understand it as such, and that can lower its impact.
- 5:45So that knowledge has been subject to considerable research
- 5:49and pretty well established.
- 5:50I think affirmations, I'll give you an example where students are asked
- 5:55in some of the early research, these were seventh graders in integrated
- 5:59classroom, and the teacher asked them to just take 15 minutes and write to me a
- 6:04little essay about the things that are most important to you and the people
- 6:07that are most important in your life.
- 6:09So students do that, and for the white students in the classroom,
- 6:13you know, it doesn't hurt, doesn't particularly help them.
- 6:16But for the African American students in the classroom, it has a dramatic
- 6:20effect 'cause it gives that student a chance to tell the teacher that
- 6:25they're more than that stereotype.
- 6:27It sounds like a funny, easy thing to do, but it has a very
- 6:31transformative effects on their grades.
- 6:33The student who gets to write this essay, their grades go up a bit.
- 6:38And then because their grades go up a bit, they feel a little less
- 6:41vulnerable to that stereotype.
- 6:43And feeling a little less vulnerable to that stereotype,
- 6:46their grades go up even more.
- 6:48So there's a, a kind of recursive chain of events, relief of this pressure.
- 6:52They come to understand themselves in relation to the setting they're in in
- 6:56a different way, and it sets them on a different trajectory, which gives
- 7:01us both a sense of, you know, how powerful this thing can be and when
- 7:05it's unattended to how powerful it is.
- 7:07Matt Abrahams: What's amazing about that intervention is that it is quite simple.
- 7:11Claude Steele: It's simple.
- 7:12Matt Abrahams: And that it has such a profound in the
- 7:15moment, but long tail impact.
- 7:17Claude Steele: Yeah.
- 7:18Matt Abrahams: I wonder if the advice is, if you are somebody who feels different
- 7:23in some way, either based on who you are, your gender, your race, maybe you
- 7:29have an accent, maybe you're newer to the team, you're an older person, it
- 7:34might make sense to share in ways that you feel comfortable about yourself
- 7:38with those around you to help them see you outside of those stereotypes
- 7:43Claude Steele: Yeah, no, I think it is.
- 7:44I think another strategy is building relationships and focusing on building
- 7:48personal connections with each other, because once you get a bond like that,
- 7:52the beginnings of a friendship bond, it's less likely that person is going
- 7:56to see you in terms of stereotypes.
- 7:58It can not completely wipe out that concern altogether, but it's going to
- 8:01substantially reduce it and enable the person in a situation like schooling to
- 8:07allocate their attention a lot more to the work at hand than to these anxieties,
- 8:11so it can start to have an effect.
- 8:13Matt Abrahams: I appreciate you sharing that.
- 8:15So let's talk about your new book, Churn.
- 8:17Can you define for us what you mean by churn, and how can it help us
- 8:22better understand relationships and intergroup relationships?
- 8:26Claude Steele: Yeah, churn is really that.
- 8:27It's sort of that concern in a diverse setting where there are
- 8:31different kinds of people from different kinds of backgrounds,
- 8:33different identities, and the like.
- 8:35The concern in that setting that somehow or another I could be devalued based on my
- 8:40identity, devalued, treated differently, seen with different expectations.
- 8:45I could worry about those things, whereas if I were in a situation that
- 8:49was more homogeneous identity-wise, if, if it's just us old guys at Pete's early
- 8:54in the morning talking about things, I feel, you know, pretty comfortable.
- 8:59The diversity itself, when the situation is important, if you're just riding
- 9:04a bus or in a basketball game crowd or something, no, it's not an issue.
- 9:08But when you're in a situation where it's important to you and it's
- 9:11important to your life outcomes, then diversity can have this, by raising this
- 9:16possibility that you could be seen in terms of sort of out-group stereotypes
- 9:20about your group, it can be tense.
- 9:22And so churn is just the term I came up with to capture that sort of psychological
- 9:27state of anxiety and vigilance to, you know, like, I have to stay alert.
- 9:32It's a tension between remembering and forgetting.
- 9:35Should I remember how my group can be seen and use that to interpret what's
- 9:39happening to me in this situation?
- 9:41Or can I just forget that and relax and trust this situation?
- 9:46Matt Abrahams: I really like that definition of the tension
- 9:48between anxiety and forgetting.
- 9:51And the churn is really what's going on in your head, the anxiety, it's, it's
- 9:56vigilance, and it's rumination, too.
- 9:58It's all of that together.
- 10:00I want to dive deeper onto ways to reduce the stress that churn has,
- 10:05and you've alluded to the fact that trust-building plays a factor in that.
- 10:10Can you give us an example, a real-world example that some of our listeners in
- 10:14their workplaces might encounter that could help reduce some of the churn
- 10:18for some of the people in those groups?
- 10:20Claude Steele: Yeah, I can illustrate it best with an experimental finding
- 10:23led by Geoff Cohen, and Lee Ross and I did this together, and we were just
- 10:27interested in a basic question, how does a professor give critical feedback
- 10:32to, say, an African American student and have that feedback be trusted?
- 10:36How do you do that?
- 10:37And so we had them write an essay about their favorite teacher.
- 10:41We brought Stanford students, Black and White, into the laboratory
- 10:45and asked them to write this essay about their favorite teacher.
- 10:48And if it was good, we'd publish it in a new magazine we were starting on teaching.
- 10:52That was the ruse.
- 10:53And we told them if they come back in two days, we're going to give
- 10:56them the feedback on that essay.
- 10:58And they do come back in two days, and we give them the feedback,
- 11:01and our big question is how much do they trust this feedback?
- 11:04And what we vary is how we give the feedback.
- 11:07And what we found was expected, but nonetheless unsettling in the first
- 11:11two conditions of this experiment.
- 11:13When we gave the feedback straightforwardly, "Here's the
- 11:16feedback on your essay," or we gave it with a real positive bromide
- 11:20kind of compliment up front, "Gee, you bring a lot of great energy to
- 11:23my class, and here's the feedback," White students trusted it and Black
- 11:27students were very mistrusting of that.
- 11:29And you'd wonder, well, look, they're Stanford students, they're privileged.
- 11:33Why wouldn't they trust this feedback in this institution that's, seems so
- 11:37committed to their welfare and so on?
- 11:39But from their standpoint, this ambiguity comes up again.
- 11:43If you put yourself in their shoes, you don't know whether the feedback
- 11:46for sure is based on your essay or from the feedback giver's opinions, views,
- 11:52stereotypes about your group's abilities.
- 11:54You don't know for sure.
- 11:56And you have to, have to remain a bit in churn.
- 11:59So the third condition gets to the question you asked,
- 12:03which is a demonstration of how you can get rid of it.
- 12:06In that condition, uh, very heartening, the feedback giver says, "Look,
- 12:11we use high standards here because we only publish these essays, and
- 12:15I've looked at your essay, and I think you can meet those standards."
- 12:19When it was put that way, Black students' motivations just went off the chart.
- 12:24Three times more of them in that condition took the essay home to
- 12:27improve it, used the feedback to improve the essay as participants in
- 12:31any other condition of the experiment.
- 12:33So they trusted it wildly.
- 12:36And you know, when you think about it, that kind of feedback from an authority
- 12:40who says, uh, you know, "We use high standards, and I think you can meet
- 12:44them," that kind of feedback can be very powerful, transformative to most of us.
- 12:49It can launch us on a career path if we get that at the right time.
- 12:52But I think that illustrates one of the critical dimensions of cutting
- 12:56through this churn and this sense of threat that diversity can pose to us.
- 13:01It says basically, there may be a stereotype out there about
- 13:05your group's abilities, okay?
- 13:06It doesn't say this explicitly, but the implication is, that may be
- 13:10true, but I respect your abilities.
- 13:12I respect you, and I respect your abilities, and it's conveyed to
- 13:15you by me having high expectations for you and having looked at your
- 13:20work and having, you know, see some promise, some potential in it.
- 13:23That is a central strategy.
- 13:25When we deal with people from different backgrounds and the like,
- 13:29it's critical to signal respect.
- 13:32One phrase I use in the book is to be able to see full humanity and full potential
- 13:38in difference, if we can adjust our perception, if we can just give a little
- 13:44signal, then it's very powerful, and it can be transformative in the sense
- 13:49of enabling a relationship and reducing the pressure that person might feel.
- 13:54Matt Abrahams: The ability to establish that there are criteria on which you
- 13:59are making, in this case, decisions, giving feedback, I think is good
- 14:04hygiene for any communication, let alone the situation you're describing.
- 14:10Well, this has been a great conversation, Claude.
- 14:12Thank you so much.
- 14:13And before we end, as you well know, I ask three questions.
- 14:16One I'm gonna make up just for you, and two I've been
- 14:18asking people for a long time.
- 14:19Are you up for that?
- 14:20Claude Steele: I'm up for it.
- 14:21Matt Abrahams: You have held several leadership positions
- 14:24in very large organizations.
- 14:26What are one or two skills that you have found have been most helpful for you in
- 14:31those leadership roles to be successful?
- 14:33Claude Steele: I do think to the extent that I've been able to do it, it is
- 14:37understanding that everybody you interact with needs that signal of respect.
- 14:42If we make a mistake in society, it's that we think we don't have to deal with
- 14:47that, that we can just assume that trust.
- 14:50And I think the realities of our society and life suggest the contrary,
- 14:56that no, you have to respect that, and you have to build that trust
- 15:00and understand that that's kind of what people need at some level.
- 15:04And so in ministering, I think maybe guided in bit by, or more than
- 15:09just a little bit by this research, and just watching really effective
- 15:12leaders, they had a knack at that.
- 15:15And the beloved leader is a leader that people trust, even though that, you know,
- 15:20they're gonna disagree with that person, or they're gonna not like what they
- 15:23have to do as directed by that person.
- 15:25But if they have a sense that that person respects their humanity and
- 15:30their potential, they roll with things, and you get a very different climate.
- 15:36Matt Abrahams: A lot of what you have shared with us is about
- 15:39demonstrating that we see other people and that we're there for them.
- 15:43Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 15:48Claude Steele: I have to say Barack Obama, because for a guy named Barack
- 15:53Hussein Obama to be elected President of the United States, he's got to have
- 15:57that ability to give people a sense that he respects them, that he's not
- 16:03gonna be polarized against them in some way or reflexively against them or
- 16:07with resentment toward them and all the things that they could be churning about.
- 16:12His style and language is a remedy to.
- 16:15So as a figure, I wish we would take his style much more seriously and understand
- 16:21that the significance of it, that it has the capacity to get to people and
- 16:26make them feel seen and connected to each other in terms of their humanity
- 16:31first and their identity second.
- 16:34And that's a really nice knack that he has.
- 16:37Matt Abrahams: I like that, humanity first, identity second.
- 16:40Our final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into
- 16:44a successful communication recipe?
- 16:47Claude Steele: The first thing is recognizing that
- 16:50all people have this need.
- 16:52In the book, I talk about, uh, power differences, is that the teacher
- 16:55is more powerful than the student.
- 16:57So who should go first in terms of being wise?
- 16:59Well, probably the teacher.
- 17:01It's gonna be harder for the student to expose themselves like that with
- 17:05trusting them without some evidence that it, it's safe to do that.
- 17:09So I do think that tone is to me in communication, both as a, within academic
- 17:15life, but as an administrator, that tone is important in a diverse society in a
- 17:19way a lot of people need some evidence that you're gonna be sensitive to, that
- 17:23you're gonna see them and see their needs.
- 17:26That's why they need some, as a first ingredient, some indication
- 17:30that you're aware of what's at stake here and, and you care about that.
- 17:35And I'm a big fanatic about clarity.
- 17:37I pay a lot of attention to the way sentences are written and so on, and
- 17:41how things are conveyed, 'cause when they're not or they're frustrating, it
- 17:44can really defeat a valuable message.
- 17:46So clarity, just simple clarity.
- 17:48Try to be really direct and clear about things.
- 17:52And then third, I personally appreciate some warmth and evidence of beneficence.
- 17:58I think people need to know that you're a human being in order to trust you.
- 18:03And so I think of that as a really important thing to convey, too, that
- 18:07you can disappoint people with decisions that you have to make, and you have to
- 18:11do that if you're in an administrative position, obviously, all the time.
- 18:15But they would like to have some evidence that you're a good person and that you, in
- 18:19general, would wanna be as helpful as you possibly can under these circumstances.
- 18:24So evidence of beneficence and real beneficence, really being
- 18:27concerned about people, I think, is a, a third thing I'd point to.
- 18:31Matt Abrahams: Those listening know I like alliteration a lot, so I'm gonna
- 18:33take a little liberty with what you said, but it's about connection, that
- 18:37tone, recognizing there's a connection.
- 18:39It's about clarity, and then it's about caring and demonstrating concern.
- 18:44And when you do those things, you can really see somebody, and you
- 18:49can demonstrate trust and respect.
- 18:51Claude, this was a wonderful conversation.
- 18:53Thank you.
- 18:53You shed light on some things that I think are really important for us to talk
- 18:57about and had some direct, very specific ways that we can address some of these
- 19:02issues around churn and stereotype threat.
- 19:05Thank you for your time.
- 19:06Claude Steele: Uh, well, thanks for the opportunity.
- 19:07I much enjoyed it.
- 19:10Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think
- 19:12Fast, Talk Smart, The Podcast.
- 19:15It was great learning from Claude.
- 19:16Really understanding the stereotype threat implications and about churn
- 19:22can help all of us to trust and respect others, and this can really help us if
- 19:28we take the time to think about how we give feedback and how we orient people
- 19:32to our organizations and to our teams.
- 19:35To learn more about how to set expectations and how they shape our world,
- 19:39check out episode 40 with Alia Crum.
- 19:42This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Alex McCarthy,
- 19:45Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 19:48Our music is from Floyd Wonder, with special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 19:52Please check out our monthly newsletter to gain additional useful knowledge.
- 19:56You can subscribe at fastersmarter.io under Resources, or you
- 20:00can subscribe on LinkedIn.