Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / LuluLemon (LULU) Value Analysis: Valuation, Growth, and Risks
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. We're here to, you know, cut
- 0:01through the usual noise and really get you informed.
- 0:04Today we're diving into a brand that, well, most of us probably
- 0:07know pretty well, Lululemon Athletica.
- 0:09It's basically synonymous with yoga pants, that whole healthy
- 0:12lifestyle vibe. And yeah, let's be honest, a bit
- 0:15of a premium price. But what happens when even a
- 0:17super strong brand like this takes a big hit?
- 0:20Their stock dropped like 17% after the last earnings call.
- 0:24Pretty surprising. So we dug into a really detailed
- 0:27financial research report on Lululemon.
- 0:29And our mission today really is for you, the curious learner.
- 0:32We're going to unpack those latest earnings numbers,
- 0:34breakdown their business model, which is actually quite clever,
- 0:37look at the risks, but also some surprising strengths.
- 0:40And then just for fun, we'll run Lululemon through a kind of
- 0:43Buffett style checklist. The goal to figure out if this
- 0:45giant after that price drop might actually be one of those
- 0:49rare finds, a great company, but now at a fair price.
- 0:52We want to give you the insights, you know, not just
- 0:54what happened, but why it matters for Lululemon going
- 0:56forward. OK, so those recent numbers,
- 0:59let's unpack them. The Q2 report for fiscal 25, it
- 1:02was a bit of a mixed bag, wasn't it?
- 1:04Yeah, it definitely was. So net revenue, it grew about 7%
- 1:07year over year, hitting $2.53 billion, but that was actually
- 1:13just a tiny bit below what analysts expected, like just
- 1:16under the $2.54 billion. Estimate I just missed on sales,
- 1:20but the earnings? That's where it gets
- 1:22interesting. Earnings per share or EPS really
- 1:24popped. It came in at $3.10, beating the
- 1:27forecasts by a solid 8%. So yeah, profits looked good.
- 1:31OK. So profits beat, sales slightly
- 1:33missed, but the stock tanked like 17%.
- 1:37Exactly. And that's that's the really
- 1:40fascinating part here. It makes you ask why such a
- 1:42massive reaction? It tells you a lot about, you
- 1:44know, market psychology. Right now, it seems the market
- 1:46just zeroed in on that tiny sales miss and probably even
- 1:49more on what management said next, their cautious outlook,
- 1:53especially for the US. Yeah, the US market seems to be
- 1:55the sticking point. It really does.
- 1:56Even a small crack in the growth story for a company like
- 1:58Lululemon, which trades on high expectations, can cause a pretty
- 2:02dramatic repricing. And management didn't really try
- 2:04to those US issues, did they? I saw CEO Calvin McDonald talked
- 2:08about needing to do better for their guests, focusing on
- 2:11product and experience. That's right, he said.
- 2:13We know we can do better. That's the focus.
- 2:15So taking ownership, which is good.
- 2:18And the CFO, Megan Frank, also mentioned they're working on
- 2:21ways to handle higher tariffs. Those can definitely squeeze
- 2:25profits. So they're adjusting.
- 2:26How does that play into their forecast for the whole year?
- 2:29Well, if you look at their updated full year guidance for
- 2:32FY20 25, you can see a bit of a a strategic shift.
- 2:37They're now aiming for revenue between 10.85 and $11.0 billion
- 2:42and EPS between 12 dollars, 7-7 cents and 1297 cents.
- 2:46But they're really key detail. That guidance now includes an
- 2:49expectation of a one 2% decline in U.S. sales.
- 2:51The decline. Wow.
- 2:52Yeah, But they're banking on strong growth still coming from
- 2:56China and other international markets to make up for it.
- 2:58So it's not just a temporary thing.
- 2:59It feels like a real recalibration.
- 3:01They're looking overseas for that future engine.
- 3:04OK, so the US is slowing international nationally
- 3:06growing, but what's the core engine itself?
- 3:10How does Lululemon actually make its money day-to-day?
- 3:13It's premium apparel, sure, but it's built on this like Omni
- 3:17channel thing, right? Absolutely.
- 3:19It's not just one thing. Think of it as hitting the
- 3:22market from multiple angles. Their main money comes from two
- 3:25big streams. First, the actual physical
- 3:28stores they operate. That was about 45.8% of revenue
- 3:32last year. Then there's the direct to
- 3:34consumer, basically their website which is huge for them,
- 3:36around 40.6%. OK, so stores and online are the
- 3:39big two. What's the rest?
- 3:40The rest, about 13.6%, falls into other.
- 3:44That includes things like selling wholesale to some
- 3:46partners, their outlet stores, and remember Lululemon studio
- 3:49that's in there, too. And product wise, yeah, women's
- 3:52apparel is still the foundation, but they've made real inroads
- 3:54with their men's line, plus accessories, yoga mats, bags
- 3:57that even have footwear now. It's broader than many people
- 4:00think. And there's that whole lifestyle
- 4:02aspect. People say they sell more than
- 4:03just clothes that how does that actually work in the business?
- 4:06That's that's spot on. It's crucial.
- 4:09Beyond just the nice fabrics, they really lean into community
- 4:12and services. Think about the free yoga
- 4:14classes they often have in stores or running clubs.
- 4:17Those aren't just, you know, nice little extras.
- 4:20They drive engagement. They build loyalty.
- 4:22So create stickiness. Exactly.
- 4:24They call their customers guests, and they've built this
- 4:26incredibly loyal base. Their membership programs
- 4:30apparently hit something like 9 million members by mid 2024.
- 4:34These are generally affluent people focused on fitness who
- 4:37buy into the whole Lululemon idea.
- 4:40Makes them less likely to switch brands.
- 4:42Interesting. You mentioned Lululemon Studio
- 4:44in that other category, that was the Mirror acquisition from
- 4:462020, right? The interactive fitness Mirror.
- 4:49How's that? Going, yes, Mirror, that was a
- 4:51big ambitious bet on home fitness tech, but it really
- 4:55struggled to gain traction, never really scaled up much
- 4:58beyond. I think the figure was 10s of
- 5:00thousands of subscribers back then and ended up costing them
- 5:02quite a bit. They took a $443 million charge
- 5:04related to it back in 2022. Yeah.
- 5:07So it really highlights that while they do try new things for
- 5:10bread and butter, the vast majority of their money still
- 5:13comes from selling merchandise, clothes, accessories.
- 5:17It was kind of a lesson maybe in sticking to your knitting or at
- 5:20least being careful with diversification.
- 5:23OK. So we've got the immediate
- 5:24issues in the US market, but looking longer term, what are
- 5:28the bigger, maybe more fundamental challenges Lululemon
- 5:31might face, the structural stuff?
- 5:33Right, This is super important for thinking with their future.
- 5:36First off, there's the question of market saturation.
- 5:39How many more yoga pants can they sell in North America?
- 5:42Realistically, future growth probably has to come from really
- 5:45pushing into new categories like they're trying with footwear, or
- 5:48more likely making a big success of their international
- 5:51expansion. Which comes with its own risks.
- 5:53Totally. They have this big goal, the
- 5:55power of 382, aiming to double revenue again by 2026.
- 6:00That relies heavily on executing well overseas, especially in
- 6:03China, right? It's already out 12% of their
- 6:05revenue and grew like crazy over 30% in 2024.
- 6:09But relying on any single international market, especially
- 6:12China, brings geopolitical risks, regulatory risks.
- 6:16Things can change fast. And what about competition?
- 6:18The athleisure space is crowded. Oh.
- 6:20Incredibly crowded. It's not just the giants like
- 6:23Nike breezing down their neck. You've got trendy upmarket
- 6:26brands like Alo Yoga or Vori chipping away at that premium
- 6:30image and then you've got value players putting pressure on
- 6:33prices from below. Plus you always have product
- 6:36risks. Remember the sheer pants fiasco
- 6:38back in 2013? I remember that.
- 6:40Or risks related to their manufacturing, which is mostly
- 6:42outsourced to Asia. Any disruption there could be a
- 6:45problem. These are the long term things
- 6:46management constantly juggles. OK, so with all that going on,
- 6:49competition expansion risks US slowdown, how does it impact
- 6:53their actual bottom line? Yeah, let's let's talk costs.
- 6:56Where does Lululemon's money actually go?
- 6:59Good question. If you break down their
- 7:01expenses, there are really 2 main categories, Cost of goods
- 7:04sold or COD, GS and then SG and A which is selling general and
- 7:08administrative costs. Cod GS being what it cost to
- 7:11make this stuff. Exactly.
- 7:12Mostly the variable cost materials that nickel fabrics
- 7:16like luan and Nulu, they're famous for the labor to make the
- 7:20garments. In 2024 that was about 40.8% of
- 7:24their revenue. So you know, think of $100 pair
- 7:26of leggings, maybe around $41.00 of that is the actual cost to
- 7:29produce. It OK about 41%.
- 7:31What about SG and A? SG and A covers everything else
- 7:34needed to run the business. Payroll for store staff.
- 7:37Corporate teams rent for their what, 600 plus stores worldwide?
- 7:41That's a big fixed cost with all those leases and marketing too.
- 7:45In 2024 SG and A was about 35.5% of revenue.
- 7:48But what's really interesting with Lululemon is their
- 7:50marketing spend. How so?
- 7:52Historically they haven't spent a ton on traditional advertising
- 7:55compared to rivals. They built the brand more
- 7:56through grassroots stuff, community events, word of mouth.
- 7:59So marketing isn't actually this massive drain on their profits
- 8:02like it is for some other big retailers.
- 8:04That is pretty impressive cost discipline, building a brand
- 8:07like that without massive ad budgets, but with global
- 8:10expansion, rising costs, tariffs, can they keep that up?
- 8:14Are margins likely to get squeezed?
- 8:16It's definitely something to watch, but historically their
- 8:20discipline has been excellent. The gross margin, the profit
- 8:23just from selling the goods actually bounced back to near
- 8:25record highs, around 5960% by FY20 24.
- 8:29That shows they still have pricing power and manage their
- 8:32sourcing well. And maybe even more importantly,
- 8:34they've shown fantastic operating leverage, meaning as
- 8:37their sales grew massively, like 5 times bigger, their overhead
- 8:40costs, the SG and A stuff didn't grow nearly as fast.
- 8:43Their SG and A ratio actually improved, dropping from around
- 8:4640% down to 35%. That shows they get more
- 8:49efficient and profitable as they scale up.
- 8:51So while, yeah, external things like tariffs or wage inflation
- 8:54are always potential pressures, their track record suggests they
- 8:57manage costs pretty tightly internally.
- 8:59OK. So strong margins, historically
- 9:01careful class control. Let's talk about leadership.
- 9:04Who's actually making the decisions here?
- 9:05Who's steering the ship through these slightly choppy waters?
- 9:10And how different is it from the early days?
- 9:12Right now, the key figures are CEO Calvin McDonald, who joined
- 9:16in 2018, and CFO Megan Frank, who took over in 2020.
- 9:21It's definitely a different era compared to the time of the
- 9:23founder, Dennis Chip Wilson. He had a huge impact, obviously,
- 9:27but also brought some controversy.
- 9:29He stepped down from the board quite a while ago.
- 9:31Now this current team feels much more like, you know,
- 9:34professional management. They have a solid track record
- 9:36of setting targets and actually hitting them.
- 9:38Like that goal. They had to double revenue by
- 9:402023, which they pretty much did by 20, 24 hitting $10.6 billion.
- 9:45And they seem pretty transparent too, like how they openly
- 9:47addressed the mirror situation when it wasn't working.
- 9:49That kind of stuff builds investor confidence.
- 9:52And how aligned are they with the people who actually own the
- 9:54stock, the investors? Well, one really interesting
- 9:57aspect is the insider ownership. It's quite high, around 26%.
- 10:01And Chip Wilson himself, the founder, is still the biggest
- 10:04individual shareholder, holding about 15% so.
- 10:06Insiders have a lot of skin in the game a.
- 10:08Lot, and maybe even more telling, CEO Calvin McDonald
- 10:11actually bought a significant amount of stock himself
- 10:14recently, around $4.8 million worth back in June 2025 when the
- 10:19price dipped. Wow, that's a strong signal.
- 10:21It really is. It suggests he believes the
- 10:24stock is undervalued and has confidence in the future.
- 10:27Beyond insiders, the ownership is heavily institutional.
- 10:30Big firms like Vanguard, Fidelity, BlackRock, Advent
- 10:34International own about 84% of the shares and generally they
- 10:38seem supportive of management. You can see that and how they
- 10:40vote at the annual meetings. Now, Lululemon doesn't pay a
- 10:43dividend, which might surprise some investors looking for that
- 10:46regular income. So if they're making good
- 10:48profits but not paying dividends, how do they give
- 10:50value back to shareholders? Their main strategy for
- 10:53returning capital is through share buybacks.
- 10:56Pretty aggressive ones actually. Just in June 2024, they
- 11:00authorize another $1 billion for repurchases.
- 11:03That's a big commitment signaling confidence and their
- 11:06plan to return excess cash. And they've been doing this
- 11:09consistently over the last 10 years or so.
- 11:11They've actually reduced the total number of shares
- 11:13outstanding by about 15%. Went from roughly 140 million
- 11:18shares in 2015 down to around 121,000,000 by 2025.
- 11:22And fewer shares means each remaining share represents a
- 11:25bigger piece of the pie, boosting EPS.
- 11:27Exactly. It makes each share inherently
- 11:30more valuable. For a company still focused on
- 11:32growth like Lululemon, management clearly sees buybacks
- 11:35as a more flexible and effective way to enhance shareholder value
- 11:38than locking themselves into a fixed dividend payment.
- 11:41OK, this is fascinating. Let's shift gears a bit and put
- 11:43Lululemon through maybe the ultimate investing filter,
- 11:46Warren Buffett checklist. How does this company stack up
- 11:49against the kind of things the Oracle of Omaha looks for?
- 11:52Ha, yeah, the Buffett test, it's always revealing.
- 11:55And honestly, on the quality metrics, Lululemon scores
- 11:58really, really well, almost ticks all the boxes for a great
- 12:01business. You're looking at incredibly
- 12:03high gross margins, right, consistently up in the high 50s
- 12:07percent range that shows pricing power, excellent returns on
- 12:11equity averaging over 30%, hit 42% in FY20 24.
- 12:15That's phenomenal efficiency in using shareholder money.
- 12:19Superb return on invested capital, around 45%.
- 12:22Again shows they invest money really well.
- 12:24Consistent, strong free cash flow, usually way over 10% of
- 12:27revenue. They generate a lot of cash.
- 12:30The balance sheet is very conservative.
- 12:32Very little debt relative to equity.
- 12:34Well under Buffett's typical .5 benchmark.
- 12:37Minimal interest costs. Healthy current ratio too, about
- 12:40two point 3X and depreciation is low compared to profit.
- 12:43These are all signs of a financially solid, high quality
- 12:46operation. OK.
- 12:47So lots of checks on the quality side.
- 12:48Where did it maybe not quite fit the Buffett mold, at least
- 12:51historically? Well, the main sticking point
- 12:53historically has almost always been valuation.
- 12:56The price. Lululemon stock for years was
- 13:00just too expensive for a classic value investor like Buffett.
- 13:03It's price to earnings ratio. The PE often sat between 30 and
- 13:0750, sometimes even higher. Which is way above Buffett's
- 13:10usual comfort zone of like under 15.
- 13:12Exactly. He wants that margin of safety.
- 13:14Paying 50 times earnings doesn't leave much room for error.
- 13:18Same with price to book value. It was often in the teens
- 13:21whereas Buffett prefers something closer to 1.5.
- 13:24Also, while earnings growth was strong overall, there were a
- 13:27couple of years with slight dips in EPS like FY17, FY18, FY22.
- 13:32Not quite the perfect uninterrupted 10 year rise he
- 13:35loves to see. And a couple of other minor
- 13:37things on book value consistency or owners earnings yield.
- 13:41So it sounds like the conclusion for years was fantastic
- 13:44business, amazing quality, but just too expensive based on
- 13:47traditional value metrics like buffets.
- 13:49It's pretty much yeah, a classic growth stock trading at growth
- 13:51multiples. But, and this is the key point
- 13:53connecting back to the start, something significant changed
- 13:56with that recent stock drop, right?
- 13:57Precisely, this is the aha moment maybe that market
- 14:01correction, that 17% tumble and the subsequent weakness has
- 14:05dramatically changed the valuation picture.
- 14:07Suddenly at the current price around say $170 a share,
- 14:11Lululemon does look much more interesting even through that
- 14:14strict Buffett value lens. How so?
- 14:17Well, it's PE ratio now is hovering somewhere around 11 or
- 14:2012. That's actually well under
- 14:21Buffett's 15X benchmark. Suddenly it's not expensive
- 14:24anymore by that measure. And our analysis suggests that
- 14:27at this price level, there's now a plausible, albeit modest
- 14:31margin of safety. It's potentially offering that
- 14:33rare combination high quality at a reasonable, maybe even cheap
- 14:37price. That just wasn't the case for
- 14:39most of the last decade. That really does shift the
- 14:41perspective. So if the valuation looks more
- 14:43attractive now, what is a more detailed valuation method like a
- 14:47this kind of cash flow analysis? Tell us what might the intrinsic
- 14:50value actually be? OK.
- 14:51So ADCF basically tries to estimate the present value of
- 14:55all the future cash a company is likely to generate.
- 14:57We started with their free cash flow from FY20 24, which was
- 15:01strong at $1.58 billion. Then we ran a few scenarios
- 15:05based on different future growth assumptions for that cash flow.
- 15:08In a pretty conservative case, assuming only 5% annual growth
- 15:12in free cash flow going forward, our model suggests an intrinsic
- 15:15value of around $210.00 per share. $210.00 and the stock is
- 15:20around $170 now. Right.
- 15:22So even in that conservative view, the current price is below
- 15:25the estimated value. If you wanted a 25% margin of
- 15:28safety on that $210.00, you'd be looking for a buy price around
- 15:31$158. OK, what about less conservative
- 15:33scenarios? Well, our nominal or base case
- 15:36used a 15% free cash flow growth rate, which is closer to what
- 15:39analysts might expect given their international plans.
- 15:42That puts the intrinsic value at approximately $326 per.
- 15:45Share Wow, significantly higher. Yeah.
- 15:47And then just to push it an optimist, the case with 25%
- 15:50growth maybe if everything goes right internationally in the US
- 15:53rebounds that suggests a value up around $483 per share.
- 15:56So the key take away from the DCF seems pretty clear then.
- 15:59I think so. The really striking thing is
- 16:01that the current market price, around $170, is below even the
- 16:04most conservative DCF estimate we ran.
- 16:08Unless you believe Lululemon's growth is going to fall off a
- 16:10Cliff entirely, this strongly suggests the stock could be
- 16:13fundamentally undervalued right now.
- 16:15It highlights just how strong their underlying cash
- 16:18generation, their economic Moat really is.
- 16:20And maybe the market is overly focused on the short term US
- 16:23headwinds. OK, so let's recap.
- 16:25We've really dug into Lululemon today, a brand facing some
- 16:28undeniable short term challenges in the US market, which led to
- 16:32that big stock drop. Yet beneath that, we see still
- 16:35strong international growth potential, a really well managed
- 16:38cost structure, impressive profitability metrics and a
- 16:40leadership team that seems very aligned with shareholders even
- 16:43buying stock themselves. And the big picture shift is
- 16:46just fascinating. For years, this was the
- 16:49definition of a high growth, high multiple stock, great
- 16:52company, but expensive. Now that correction has
- 16:55potentially flipped the script, it might actually be offering
- 16:57that rare chance to buy quality at a reasonable, maybe even
- 17:01attractive price, A situation that just didn't exist for
- 17:03Lululemon for most of the last 10 years.
- 17:05So it. Leaves us with a really
- 17:06provocative thought. Not for you, the listener to
- 17:08Mull over. Given Lululemon's powerful brand
- 17:11loyalty, those ambitious global plans and now this potentially
- 17:14attractive valuation, the question is, can they
- 17:17successfully navigate these current U.S. market bumps and
- 17:20get that growth story firing on all cylinders again?
- 17:23Will the underlying quality of the business ultimately went out
- 17:26over these temporary headwinds and deliver on its long term
- 17:28promise? And maybe just as interesting,
- 17:30what is the market's dramatic overreaction to a slight miss?
- 17:33Tell us about investor sentiment and the premium placed on
- 17:36flawless growth in today's world.
- 17:37Something to think about. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 17:41on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 17:44or differing interpretations. The content is for educational
- 17:47purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 17:50Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 17:52decisions. If you want to learn more about
- 17:54this topic, subscribe us on Apple Spotify Podcast channel.
- 17:57Deep Value Investing. Don't forget to take the book
- 17:59List of Value Investing from the episode description.