Latest / Lise and Sarah / America’s Next Top Model Was Unhinged. Why Did We Love It So Much?
Transcript
- 0:00Lies and Sarah!
- 0:03Welcome to Lies and Sarah!
- 0:14Hello, I'm Lies.
- 0:15Hello, I'm Sarah.
- 0:17And welcome to your low-states listen for your very high-stress lives.
- 0:24We know what you're going through.
- 0:25We're living it too, and sometimes you just need a break from the outside world.
- 0:28So we're just saying, come on in, come on over, come on over, baby.
- 0:34And just sit with us and hang with us for half an hour while we talk about the things
- 0:37that we're interested in, we're pretty sure you'll be interested in.
- 0:41That's it in a nutshell.
- 0:42I'm excited because today's episode is, I mean, we've just been chomping at the bit to
- 0:47do this.
- 0:48We are going to be dissecting the Tyra Banks America's next top model documentary that has been
- 0:55ripping through the charts on Netflix, okay?
- 0:57I was waiting for you, we were all waiting for you, I'm tearing you up, never in my life,
- 1:02you're the girl like this.
- 1:04But before we do that, Sarah, a little sort of recap with your Louis Vuitton bag.
- 1:09Last week you received a phone call from a very terrifying British woman from the Louis
- 1:16Vuitton headquarters who was investigating or potentially investigating you, right?
- 1:21So for the purchase of a fake handbag in Malaysia, which I was very open and honest about,
- 1:25I'm sick of hearing about it, it's a cross that I have to bear.
- 1:29I'm ashamed of it, I wish I'd never done it.
- 1:32I wish I was just like every other silly bitch out there with a fake handbag who's pretending
- 1:36it's real.
- 1:37Okay, I'm just going to confess and I think you have a sense for this, but I set you
- 1:42up.
- 1:43He was a fake call.
- 1:44I'm not even going to say me, it was also our producer.
- 1:46Okay, I'm not taking the fall for this.
- 1:50It actually was all her idea, but she did say, do you think Sarah's going to be really
- 1:54pissed off?
- 1:55Is there any part of you that kind of was like, oh crap, maybe this is real or did we actually
- 2:03get you?
- 2:04No, no.
- 2:05I did think it was a G up, but also I've heard the feedback loud and clear from people
- 2:11that buying a fake handbag is not okay.
- 2:16Oh, for God's sakes, what happens when you go into seed and buy a jupe of a clovey
- 2:22item?
- 2:23I don't have the time to go into the morals of fake handbags, but just know that it's
- 2:28now a prop behind us in the show.
- 2:30That's right.
- 2:31It was a $200 prop.
- 2:32That's Sarah.
- 2:33Yeah.
- 2:34My pleasure.
- 2:35But, Lise, can we get to the crux, the nitty-gritty of what we want to dive into?
- 2:41Oh, top.
- 2:42And I know that it's been out for a few weeks.
- 2:44It's been in the top 10 for a few weeks now, reality check, America's next top model,
- 2:48a three-episode docky inventory.
- 2:51And you may have heard other takes on it, but you haven't heard Lise and my take on it.
- 2:56And I suppose we wanted to give everyone a little bit of time.
- 3:00We know that if you're anything like us, you might take a while to come to things.
- 3:05Or also, it's just a busy life.
- 3:07You kind of know the moment it hits Netflix, but it might take you that couple of weeks
- 3:12to get around to actually sitting down and binging it or what have you.
- 3:16So, I have so many thoughts on this.
- 3:19I couldn't wait to get stuck in.
- 3:22This is a show that sort of took over.
- 3:25When did it come out?
- 3:262004?
- 3:27I think it premiered.
- 3:28So, we were 24 years old when it came out.
- 3:31Which, interestingly, I'm actually kind of embarrassed that I was watching at a 24.
- 3:35To be fair, to me and my head, I was more like 17.
- 3:38Lise, you watch buffs now.
- 3:40I like, yeah, I know.
- 3:42But like they're adults and it's about adults getting married.
- 3:46Or maybe it was because, and this is a really big point, reality TV was so new.
- 3:52The format was so new that we were all just intrigued to get a peek behind the curtain
- 3:59of an industry that is, let's be honest, back in the early 2000s, the modeling or fashion
- 4:06industry was sort of held up on a pedestal.
- 4:08It was revered.
- 4:09It was this sort of mystical world, right?
- 4:12And it's all very secret squirrel.
- 4:15And only the elite can make it behind those walls, right, behind that curtain.
- 4:20Yeah.
- 4:21But I think what you just said before that you can't believe you were watching it at 24.
- 4:25I can.
- 4:26I was watching it.
- 4:27There was our entire generation.
- 4:28I would say 99% of the women listening who are millennials or elder millennials.
- 4:34We were so invested in any popular TV show, not just one, because we've got to cast
- 4:41our mind back that there were only like four channels in circulation.
- 4:45And so when something became popular, it was a shared connection, it was a shared experience.
- 4:50It was something that people were talking about metaphorically and figuratively, literally
- 4:55around water coolers in workplaces.
- 4:58I think the other thing to say is we were absolute lambs to the slaughter as viewers.
- 5:07Obviously, the contestants were absolute sacrificial lambs, but we'll get to that a little
- 5:12bit later on.
- 5:13But I'm talking in terms of understanding the format that is reality TV.
- 5:19None of us understood that it was as manipulated as it was.
- 5:24No.
- 5:25You watch reality TV and you get a real sense for, okay, the producers are in their ears.
- 5:32Each contestant has a producer.
- 5:34They're very closely pushed into scenarios, encouraged to talk.
- 5:38They're tired.
- 5:39There's alcohol.
- 5:40We actually know all the tricks of the trade now as consumers of reality TV.
- 5:45Back then, we were just like, this is real life.
- 5:48And there were no safeguards for these contestants.
- 5:52So I think we were all just passengers in this absolute train wreck.
- 5:57And none of us were savvy enough to understand how this was being played and that they were
- 6:03puppeteers at the top, whether that puppeteer was Tyra Banks herself or Ken Mock, who was
- 6:08also one of the executive producers.
- 6:12No one knew that these people were so closely involved in how this played out, right?
- 6:17We were just watching it as pure fascination and entertainment.
- 6:21While it's shocking to look back on retrospectively, at the time, we were so groomed to expect
- 6:29this kind of exploitation on our screens that it didn't feel that shocking.
- 6:34It just felt like really great TV.
- 6:36Well, I'm going to say you've used the word exploitation.
- 6:40We didn't even see it as that.
- 6:41No.
- 6:42That's the danger here is at the time we were so conditioned to watching young women be
- 6:50publicly humiliated because I suppose the culture at the time was so much about if you want
- 6:59this badly enough, you will do anything.
- 7:02It's almost like resilience was rebranded.
- 7:07You know, it was like, how bad do you want it?
- 7:09How bad do you want to be a model?
- 7:10This is what the fashion industry is like, you've got to have tough skin, you've got to
- 7:14be prepared to do whatever it takes.
- 7:17These industries, they hold so much appeal.
- 7:21This is the only way you can break into that industry.
- 7:24In this day and age, modeling agencies don't even hold the power that they once did because
- 7:29you can become a model through Instagram.
- 7:31Yeah.
- 7:32But back then, you had to be scouted by somebody in the industry to be tapped on the shoulder.
- 7:38You had to be discovered.
- 7:40Yeah.
- 7:41Here's a show that gives you an opportunity to be discovered.
- 7:45Now, these girls didn't know that nothing would come out of it for them.
- 7:49And I'll talk about that a little bit later because none of those girls or very, very
- 7:54few of those girls actually went on to become working models.
- 7:57Yeah.
- 7:58But I think, too, when we're talking about looking at it at the time when we did and watching
- 8:01it and why it didn't seem that shocking, it's because the broader conversations around
- 8:05women from every facet of our lives in the grocery stores looking at magazine covers
- 8:09to any public discourse about women was always about how they looked and what they needed
- 8:15to change about themselves and that a size 8 to 10 was considered plus size in the modeling
- 8:20industry, in the celebrity industry.
- 8:22So there was nothing that was shocking when a teenage girl at 18, 19 was told to lose
- 8:28weight or was told to change something about her appearance because that narrative had
- 8:32been forced on us all through the 90s.
- 8:35And that TV show played into everything that was happening at the time, which is why it's
- 8:40interesting when we try and look at Tyra's role in all of this as the host, as the woman
- 8:45who was supposedly championing these girls.
- 8:49Is she really the villain?
- 8:51And look, she's not great.
- 8:52I'm not going to pussy foot around that and say that was heaven.
- 8:55But she was playing into a very wider piece of what society wanted.
- 9:00Like I was as sucked in as anybody with it.
- 9:03Like that's what I mean.
- 9:04You're saying I can't believe I watched it at 24.
- 9:06Well, because we did.
- 9:07I know.
- 9:08I thought, my God, like she's not going to be pretty enough.
- 9:10No, she is going to have to change the gap in her teeth.
- 9:12Oh, yeah, she looks better as a redhead, like it was just so superficial and damaging.
- 9:18And the whole thing makes me terribly sad.
- 9:21Thankfully we are so much smarter now in understanding that you just can't talk about people that
- 9:31objectively anymore.
- 9:32And the goal posts have shifted, like once upon a time, there was that very clear definition
- 9:39of what commercial fashion beauty needed to look like.
- 9:43But these days, we know that that's not the truth.
- 9:46So could there ever be a show like that ever again?
- 9:49It just wouldn't work.
- 9:50I think it's just, I think they're different times.
- 9:52It just infiltrates in different ways nowadays.
- 9:54I think we can say you and I can sit here and pick holes in the whole thing and be like,
- 9:58we can't believe it.
- 9:59It's terrible.
- 10:00But it's still happening out there in the world.
- 10:04It absolutely is.
- 10:05But at the time, this dream of young girls to be plucked from the plain Jane lives,
- 10:10the milkmaids and dairy queens, I think they use that term in the series.
- 10:13And to have somebody look at them and say, I see something in you.
- 10:17I see cover girl in you.
- 10:18I mean, there were 10,000 girls who would line up for castings.
- 10:23And I can't imagine anything like that happening nowadays.
- 10:27I mean, it was wild.
- 10:29When you look back now, you just go these poor kids.
- 10:33The audiences became complicit because the darker that shit got,
- 10:38the more we watched it.
- 10:40It was like a blood sport.
- 10:41It was like the Coliseum.
- 10:42We were watching young women get humiliated.
- 10:46And guess what?
- 10:47That's because that's pretty normal.
- 10:49Like back in the 90s and early 2000s,
- 10:52young women being torn to shreds about their physical appearance.
- 10:56Yeah, it was happening in our everyday lives as just regular civilians.
- 11:00And so seeing it reflected on a TV screen was no different.
- 11:03Normal.
- 11:04OK, according to those judges, and in front of millions of people,
- 11:06she doesn't look great in a bikini.
- 11:08Oh, like we've been told that.
- 11:10Yeah.
- 11:10We've been told that something's wrong about our figures that we need to change.
- 11:13So there was no, there was no like us and us and them kind of thing.
- 11:17It just felt like we're all on par here.
- 11:20Like even those really pretty girls are being creed and torn to shreds.
- 11:25And the body shaming just across the board was such a terrible time.
- 11:29But then you can, I don't want to say I understand it.
- 11:31I don't know if that's the right thing.
- 11:32But when Tyra is saying, you wanted this, you made me do it.
- 11:36She's not actually wrong there.
- 11:38She's not wrong.
- 11:38And if we know anything about networks,
- 11:41it's that when something's making money,
- 11:43they're not going to stop it for moral reasons.
- 11:46Yeah, morals were optional in the early 2000s.
- 11:50I mean, let's talk about some of those storylines.
- 11:53Oh, my God.
- 11:53OK, let's start with Sandy.
- 11:55She was the tall, very lanky blonde kid
- 11:59from somewhere out in like Midwest USA.
- 12:03She was working in a wall, greens,
- 12:05but she wants out of her hometown.
- 12:07And she is as green as they come.
- 12:10I left home the summer after high school.
- 12:14I saw my dad on the way out.
- 12:16He's like, where are you going?
- 12:17I was like, I'm moving.
- 12:20I'm leaving.
- 12:20And he's like, all right, how nice life.
- 12:22I was like, bye.
- 12:23And the storyline with Sandy is that, really,
- 12:27she ends up drinking too much as young women can
- 12:30when they're in a model house or anywhere, really.
- 12:33It's not unusual for a native girl to have a few drinks.
- 12:37And she weighed all of like 43 kilos.
- 12:40And she ends up getting blind, pass out drunk.
- 12:46I was just excited just like, have a night.
- 12:49We were just like talking, drinking.
- 12:51And she has sex with one of the male models
- 12:56that they were on a film set with that previous day.
- 12:59And she gets filmed by the film crew.
- 13:02Having sex in a shower, she has no recollection of it.
- 13:06I remember getting the hot tub.
- 13:08I remember April Mercedes getting the hot tub.
- 13:11Everything kind of after that is just a blur.
- 13:17Then she's vomiting, they're filming that too.
- 13:20When she eventually comes to, she realises
- 13:23very publicly in front of millions of people
- 13:25that not only has this happened in front of the cameras,
- 13:29but she's also cheated on her long-term boyfriend.
- 13:33So you see this young woman unravel.
- 13:36And then the heartbreak that ensues of her realising
- 13:41she has to make the phone call to her boyfriend.
- 13:43And the humiliation of that.
- 13:46It just flooded over me.
- 13:49And I just sat there and cried.
- 13:52There's no sense of, this is a really sensitive, difficult time.
- 13:57It was all up for grabs.
- 14:00And I think she's a changed woman because of that.
- 14:03You can see that something broke in her, that day.
- 14:06Well, and then she certainly didn't consent to being filmed.
- 14:09But then that would say, through it back on her and say,
- 14:11we treated it like a documentary.
- 14:13You signed it all away.
- 14:14You signed it all away.
- 14:16And Tyra, they bring it up.
- 14:18And Tyra's just looking up to the left, the right,
- 14:22trying to recall it and then does the deflection.
- 14:28I do remember her story.
- 14:29It's a little difficult for me to talk about production
- 14:32because that's not my territory.
- 14:35It absolutely was.
- 14:37Because she can recount other stories
- 14:39where she can remember how a girl breathed basically.
- 14:42There's production, like when that was filmed by the camera crew
- 14:46who ever gave the green light to film it at 2am.
- 14:50There's that.
- 14:51That's step one.
- 14:51But then that footage goes to the cutting room, to the editing room.
- 14:56Then there's another set of decision makers in that room.
- 14:59That footage comes across their desks and their monitors.
- 15:01There's a whole other group of adults there going to sign off.
- 15:05Oh, guys, we didn't know you filmed this.
- 15:07That's not going to air.
- 15:09But it does go to air.
- 15:11So who was responsible back then to go,
- 15:15this is going to be awesome.
- 15:16Because that was the environment back then.
- 15:20It was unscrupulous.
- 15:22Can you ever imagine seeing something like that
- 15:24as an executive producer and going, put it on?
- 15:27Yeah.
- 15:28It's literally like we were saying,
- 15:30we were talking about the Colosseum thing.
- 15:32It's like thumbs up, thumbs up, thumbs down to a child.
- 15:37I should say tame.
- 15:38And here's the other thing.
- 15:39These girls agreed to do this show.
- 15:43Does responsibility come into it at some point
- 15:47if you decide to sign your life away?
- 15:49Are you also complicit?
- 15:52We treated top models at documentary.
- 15:54And we told the girls that on day one, when they were sharp,
- 15:57we would go over the rules with them.
- 15:59No matter what happens while you're on camera,
- 16:02we're going to document all of them.
- 16:04I think if you cast your mind back to how we were all like at 18
- 16:07and naive and trusting, there's not a doubt in my mind
- 16:10that the majority of those girls,
- 16:12particularly in those early seasons,
- 16:15had no idea of what was actually involved
- 16:17in the making of that show.
- 16:19Season one and two and three.
- 16:20The rudest shock.
- 16:21And on the reality check documentary now being interviewed,
- 16:25they're still emotional.
- 16:26They still cry.
- 16:27They're still anger there.
- 16:29Because that's betrayal.
- 16:31You even think about Danny, one of the other contestants in it
- 16:34who had a great smile, had a gap in her teeth.
- 16:37And she was told she was yelled at
- 16:39that she had to change this gap.
- 16:41Get them teeth on.
- 16:43All the way.
- 16:44I think all the way.
- 16:47Congratulations.
- 16:48Still on the running towards becoming America's next top model.
- 16:51And then two or three seasons later,
- 16:54another contestant had a gap and they wanted to widen her gap.
- 16:59Tyra was like, we're going to widen that gap.
- 17:02We'd love to exaggerate that and take you
- 17:04a little bit more to Lauren.
- 17:06Making as big as you want it.
- 17:08And what they did to those girls,
- 17:10like it was actual body modification,
- 17:13like we're not talking just a box of hair dye
- 17:16and a few hair extensions,
- 17:17although they did that to many of them.
- 17:19Whole new teeth, veneers.
- 17:22You know what needs to happen in order to get veneers.
- 17:25Yeah.
- 17:26You've got a chisel actual healthy teeth.
- 17:28Yeah.
- 17:29Down to pegs.
- 17:30Yes, and you never get those healthy teeth back.
- 17:33And never get those healthy teeth back.
- 17:34And nobody tells you if you get veneers
- 17:37that they have to be replaced.
- 17:38Right.
- 17:39Don't they last for something like, I don't know, 15, 20 years
- 17:42and you have to get them.
- 17:43And the cost of each time.
- 17:44And the cost of each time.
- 17:45So the girls who were getting this free dental work
- 17:48stuck with the ramifications of that for life.
- 17:51And there was one of the women who had a snaggle tooth,
- 17:55which was the tooth, you know, the grows up higher in your gum.
- 17:57And she said she still has bite problems to this day
- 18:00because they're just throwing them through dentist
- 18:01to get things done super quickly.
- 18:03And again, Lee's that wasn't shocking
- 18:05because we also had TV shows on air
- 18:07at the time like 10 years younger in 10 days.
- 18:09Or the swan.
- 18:10Or that came out.
- 18:11They literally gave people 10 days
- 18:13to get plastic surgery, duh, duh, duh, duh,
- 18:16and then do a big reveal to their family and friends.
- 18:18Like this quick fix economy was well and truly alive.
- 18:23And you know what's disgusting?
- 18:25I remember watching those episodes and going,
- 18:27she's so lucky.
- 18:29Yeah.
- 18:30No, it's true.
- 18:31I'm actually interrogating.
- 18:32My reaction to that was, wow, that's how conditioned we were
- 18:36to wanting to change ourselves.
- 18:40Getting that done for a reality competition TV show
- 18:43is just insane.
- 18:44That would absolutely never happen these days.
- 18:46There were so many things that wouldn't have happened.
- 18:48There were race-swapping photos.
- 18:50Oh, shoots.
- 18:50I mean, blackface was very much alive and well
- 18:54in America's next top model back then.
- 18:56Again, appalling.
- 18:57But that just wasn't on people's minds.
- 18:59No.
- 19:00There was the young woman who was accused of being gluttonous.
- 19:03And every time she was keen, I loved her.
- 19:06And every time she was on screen, she would eat a bagel.
- 19:09But then they would make out like she was eating four bagels
- 19:11in the one sitting.
- 19:12It was a little bit damaging to see them editing me eating,
- 19:16showing me eating it as if I've eaten three different bagels,
- 19:19but it really was the same one.
- 19:22They would hone in on her tummy.
- 19:24She had just a normal tummy, but it wasn't a concave tummy.
- 19:28Keenin needs to lose weight. Keenin needs to lose weight.
- 19:31They tried to make her an elephant.
- 19:32Yes, shoots.
- 19:33There was a photo shoot where they'd
- 19:35taken all the girls to Africa, because the final five
- 19:39or whatever it is, get taken to somewhere incredible.
- 19:42And of course, they tried to do a stupid shoot
- 19:44where you had to portray one of the African animals.
- 19:48So of course, the tallest and skinniest girl
- 19:50was surprise, surprise, a giraffe, which
- 19:52is quite elegant and beautiful to do.
- 19:54And Keenia gets lugged with the elephant
- 19:57after she's repeatedly been humiliated in front of her peers.
- 20:01She's been weighed, so there was the elephant thing,
- 20:04and then there was the other photo shoot
- 20:06about the seven sins.
- 20:07We did the seven deadly sins, and they gave me gluttony.
- 20:11This is like, gluttony, like, oh, I'm greedy.
- 20:14I'm hungry, like, rawr.
- 20:16She's given gluttony.
- 20:17All these undertones, it's not even an undertone.
- 20:20It's blatant mockery of the young woman.
- 20:24gluttony looks like dumpy.
- 20:25It's like piggy chic.
- 20:28It definitely was a little bit damaging
- 20:29to watch with all of America to see that narrative play out.
- 20:34And I think it was proposed as being character building
- 20:37and that Tara, by putting them through all these really
- 20:41hard, uncomfortable challenges or storylines,
- 20:44was that she was preparing them for what the industry was
- 20:47actually like, because she was living in the industry
- 20:50and working in the industry and had been for many years herself.
- 20:53I don't think there's ever been
- 20:54in the history of fashion a photo shoot
- 20:56where a human is turned into an elephant.
- 20:58You know, like, this is the thing.
- 21:01And one of the things that came out of it
- 21:02in the final episode, this isn't really a spoiler by any means,
- 21:06but they do interview a few girls about life after.
- 21:08And I think it was Danielle, who actually ended up
- 21:12doing some actual modeling work.
- 21:14And, you know, you have a portfolio as a model,
- 21:17which is essentially a scrapbook.
- 21:19Sorry, I'm interrupting.
- 21:20If you're new here, you may need to know
- 21:21that Lee's was a model, don't roll your eyes at me.
- 21:24I'm rolling my eyes.
- 21:25Lee's was a working full-time model in New York.
- 21:29I think it's important so that when you're talking about this,
- 21:32people know that it's coming from a place of knowledge.
- 21:33Yeah, continue as you were.
- 21:35So each photograph in your portfolio or book, as it's called,
- 21:40is meant to showcase to any client how you can transform.
- 21:43So often the photographs in an actual model's portfolio,
- 21:47which is now, by the way, all digitalized.
- 21:50Nobody actually carries around a large book
- 21:53like we used to back in the day.
- 21:55But which was such a flex?
- 21:58Such a flex.
- 21:59Such a flex to see the girls walking down the street
- 22:03with their massive portfolio.
- 22:05Oh, yes.
- 22:05With the agents name branded on the book.
- 22:08So you talk about, you're in the presence of someone special
- 22:13because they'd been scouted.
- 22:15They'd been chosen to be.
- 22:17Chozen branded claimed.
- 22:20Yeah, a real models book.
- 22:22The photographs will usually be actually very paired down.
- 22:25Like, there's not a lot of makeup.
- 22:27They usually, like, almost look like they've just rolled out of bed.
- 22:30You just want to see features or you want to see expression
- 22:35on the face or weird ass poses or ability to move.
- 22:40In fact, a modeling portfolio with a lot of makeup
- 22:43often spoke to shittier agencies.
- 22:45There was a real hierarchy of if your book had lots of photos
- 22:51with lots of hair and makeup stuff.
- 22:53I'm not talking about, like, if you got editorials in Vogue
- 22:56and they transformed you and did something super high-end.
- 22:59I'm talking about glamour shots or overdone makeup.
- 23:03You looked down upon and you were never booked.
- 23:06So these girls would rock up to New York
- 23:09with these books or the stupid stuff they were forced to do.
- 23:12And people were laughing at them and saying,
- 23:14no, thank you, I can't even see your face through all that makeup.
- 23:17So, Tyra pretending or proclaiming, rather,
- 23:20that she was preparing them for the actual industry?
- 23:23Your thoughts?
- 23:24My thoughts on how tough it was and the criticism you copped
- 23:29absolutely correct, people would talk about you as if you weren't there.
- 23:34So you do have to have a tough skin
- 23:36and you do have to look at yourself as a product.
- 23:39That is all correct.
- 23:40But all the photo shoot stuff is incorrect.
- 23:44That's not the way it works.
- 23:45Overall, the show when I watched it just made me sad.
- 23:49I was watching by myself in my lounge room
- 23:51and I just gave this great big exhale,
- 23:54probably 10 minutes in because, for me,
- 23:58it just felt so visceral of I can remember living in that time.
- 24:03I can remember being so critical of how I felt I looked.
- 24:10Yeah, because you also modeled.
- 24:11At the time.
- 24:13Yes, but not to the degree that you did.
- 24:14But I was very much like on the cusp of plus size
- 24:18because I'm a size 10 and I remember being in parades
- 24:22wearing the Maggi Tabara plus size clothes.
- 24:25And I was just a very...
- 24:26I was a tall slim girl, but in that time,
- 24:30that early 2000s, everything was just like,
- 24:33it's a size six and that's what the aim is for modeling
- 24:36and anything outside of that is too big.
- 24:39So I just felt sad for all of us
- 24:41because I feel like so many of us felt like that.
- 24:44Absolutely.
- 24:45Yeah, there's a lot of uncomfortable stuff there.
- 24:48But coming up next, I want to talk about the humiliation theory.
- 24:52I've gone...
- 24:53I've done a weird, deep dive.
- 24:55OK.
- 24:56..on socials and I need to tell you about it.
- 24:59Lee's and Sarah.
- 25:00I'm a color girl. I'm a color girl.
- 25:03I'm a color girl.
- 25:08I'm damn you!
- 25:09I have never in my life the order to grow like this.
- 25:11I was rooting for you. We were all rooting for you.
- 25:13I'm damn you!
- 25:15So we're back talking about the Tyra Banks,
- 25:19America's next top model documentary that's dominating Netflix.
- 25:22Have we spoken about Tyra herself enough?
- 25:24Well, we've mentioned her here and there,
- 25:26but I mean, of course, there's a lot of what's going around
- 25:30on social media at the moment is absolutely blaming
- 25:35the entire thing on Tyra because the premise of the show
- 25:39was her brainchild.
- 25:41She says that she wanted to bring different kind of beauty
- 25:45into the spotlight because she had gone through as a woman of color
- 25:51as a curvy model.
- 25:53She'd been put through the ringer herself
- 25:55and she really wanted to show America first
- 25:59and then the world globally that beauty could come in all shapes
- 26:03and sizes and then it turned into the juggernaut
- 26:05that it turned into and we've seen the progression and the spiral
- 26:09of how far they pushed this show, right?
- 26:12But what do you think about her part in all of this?
- 26:16Do you think she's as guilty as they say?
- 26:19I have some thoughts because when I watch them all take their seat
- 26:23in front of the documentary cameras,
- 26:26there are other players there and somehow Tyra's
- 26:29the one who's being called the main villain in this.
- 26:33Well, I mean, she was the front facing person.
- 26:36She was the face of the show.
- 26:37Do I think she's entirely bad?
- 26:40No, I think it's probably more of a two things can be true.
- 26:45I think she needs to take accountability
- 26:46that a hell of a lot of harm was caused from that show.
- 26:50But I can also acknowledge that she did champion
- 26:53different kinds of beauty at a time that that wasn't happening.
- 26:56She was really trying to get behind black models.
- 26:59She was pushing plus size models.
- 27:01I also think that maybe she capitalized on the industry
- 27:05that she already knew was so messed up because she'd been in it.
- 27:09Why do you think she doesn't take any accountability?
- 27:12It's a little difficult for me to talk about production
- 27:15because that's not my territory.
- 27:17Well, I also think she's just playing it like a man.
- 27:20And what we don't like is a woman who's like,
- 27:22I'm not saying sorry for this.
- 27:24When men do that, we don't bat an eyelid.
- 27:26But because we've got a woman here who's like,
- 27:28oh, that wasn't really my thing.
- 27:30Because somehow not saying sorry.
- 27:32Somehow Ken Mo, the other executive producer.
- 27:34The other executive producer.
- 27:36He was integral to the show and how the story lines were crafted
- 27:40and what was greenlit.
- 27:42And somehow he's just not a huge focus really in the documentary.
- 27:48He comes out strong.
- 27:49You hear from him very quickly.
- 27:51And then towards the back end of episode three,
- 27:54he sort of disappears.
- 27:55He sort of like smoke bombs.
- 27:57Yeah.
- 27:57Nobody's now talking about Ken Moch on social media commentary,
- 28:01the way they're talking about Tyra.
- 28:03There's so many things on the show where you go,
- 28:05oh, she's a, that's just, she's, it's a bit dodgy.
- 28:09Her friends get fired.
- 28:10And look, I can probably understand that.
- 28:12Like those TV networks, they are machines.
- 28:15You can't blame one person and say loyalty,
- 28:18loyalty, loyalty, that's not how Hollywood works.
- 28:21Right.
- 28:22So that part of it is Iki,
- 28:24but you could almost see there's more involved there.
- 28:27There's no question that she's problematic.
- 28:30She's like that's in my, that's definitely in my head.
- 28:33But is the entire problem Tyra or is it
- 28:38how we consumed young women's insecurity as entertainment
- 28:43that it was a time in women's history and she was guilty?
- 28:46But are we vilifying Tyra now instead
- 28:50of being able to like suck ourselves out
- 28:53and have a bird's eye view of what was going on
- 28:55across the board, which I think only people
- 28:59who lived through that era can talk to
- 29:01and be like, we were all messed up.
- 29:04It was all coming at us.
- 29:06Yeah.
- 29:07I mean, women have been burned at the stake for centuries
- 29:10for millennia.
- 29:11Are we seeing a very modern take on that
- 29:14where Ken Moch ain't being dragged?
- 29:17Nope.
- 29:19Okay.
- 29:20Yeah.
- 29:21I teased it before the break.
- 29:23This humiliation theory.
- 29:24I have gone down a rabbit hole,
- 29:26but I'm only touching the sides because it has
- 29:28blown my mind so much.
- 29:29There's a video that's been circulated
- 29:31on social media of Tyra Banks in Sydney.
- 29:34There's multiple videos, in fact,
- 29:36if you search it up.
- 29:37And there's footage of Tyra at a drag show.
- 29:41Now, we know that drag shows are really fun
- 29:44over the top theatrical dramatic.
- 29:46Like, they would love the shit out of Tyra.
- 29:48You know, back in the 90s, 2000s,
- 29:50she would have been a queen, a gay icon, if you will.
- 29:53But this footage of Tyra is so unhinged.
- 29:56So she's onstage.
- 29:57I don't know under what context.
- 29:59She's wearing like a bright yellow,
- 30:02almost like a smurfette wig,
- 30:04also a matching yellow beard.
- 30:07And she's on an absolute dire tribe.
- 30:11Like, you can't even make sense of the story she's telling.
- 30:14She's calling herself gay Santa.
- 30:16She's saying that she's actually an old gay man
- 30:19trapped in this body.
- 30:21You know, when Santa Claus tells you
- 30:24that he's gonna come down your chimney
- 30:27and he wants you to leave some cookies
- 30:29and cream on that thing for him to eat.
- 30:32Do you know what he's doing?
- 30:33Shall he invite an actor?
- 30:35And the camera, whoever's filming,
- 30:38is panning around the crowd.
- 30:40There's women, there's men,
- 30:42there's drag queens, the gays are there.
- 30:45And everyone is so uncomfortable.
- 30:48So this is not like she's putting on a show for them.
- 30:52It comes across like she's taken over the stage
- 30:55and people are very confused.
- 30:56It sounds like a bit of a worry.
- 30:58Awkwardly laughing and looking at one another.
- 31:00It is insane footage.
- 31:01Now, I went into the comments section straight away.
- 31:04Some comments are very funny.
- 31:06Some comments are sad,
- 31:08because people are raising the question,
- 31:10is she unwell?
- 31:12Certainly nobody knows.
- 31:13We know that Tyra loves a bit of theatre
- 31:16and drama.
- 31:17Maybe she was just letting loose
- 31:18and having fun in a gay bar.
- 31:20Like, we don't actually know.
- 31:22But then there was this one comment, several in fact.
- 31:25So the top line is that there's a large contingent
- 31:29of people around the world who believe
- 31:31that some of the biggest stars,
- 31:34celebrities in the current zeitgeist,
- 31:37have struck a deal with the devil.
- 31:40Stay with me.
- 31:41There's this whole underbelly of people
- 31:45who think that stars who have shot to fame
- 31:49have essentially sold their soul to the demon.
- 31:52And in exchange for their soul,
- 31:55they get superstar celebrity.
- 31:58But then at some point the payback comes
- 32:01and the devil wants humiliation in return.
- 32:04This is in reference to the deal with the devil.
- 32:06I feel like the deal is that for a certain amount of time,
- 32:10they, as in the celebrity,
- 32:11have this abundant fame and fortune and popularity.
- 32:15All the cool things.
- 32:16But after a while, they got to look either crazy or insane.
- 32:20Way too many celebrities have been falling into this same cycle.
- 32:25All of a sudden you see a celeb that has been chill for a while
- 32:28and you're like, what's going on?
- 32:31And I feel like it's indicating their time being up
- 32:34and they have to pay back the price for their fame,
- 32:37which is now like an anti-fame or infamous status.
- 32:41It's a wild theory, but of course bottom line is demons are real.
- 32:45And if you, demons are real,
- 32:48your eternal life is definitely at risk.
- 32:51Then other people are saying they have to go through
- 32:54humiliation rituals to keep their fame level up.
- 32:58Oh my god.
- 32:59I obviously don't believe in that stuff.
- 33:01What I find interesting is that it's the woman
- 33:04who's painted as insane.
- 33:06Yeah.
- 33:07This is a pattern we see repeating in history.
- 33:09People are citing Britney Spears.
- 33:11But what does that do?
- 33:12It points to women.
- 33:14It's always the women, the women.
- 33:15Yes.
- 33:16The women's fault.
- 33:17They've done something and look,
- 33:19I'm not for one standing here and saying Tyra is the same.
- 33:22I don't.
- 33:23I think she's a bit whack.
- 33:24Yeah.
- 33:25And I don't agree with so much of what she did.
- 33:27Surely we know that there's more players here.
- 33:29Yeah.
- 33:30And why are we so disgusted
- 33:33when a woman does something bad?
- 33:35It's not treated the same way.
- 33:37I do think what she did was disgusting.
- 33:39I don't condone it.
- 33:40I think she had the responsibility of young women in her hands.
- 33:43She had the responsibility of viewers in her hands.
- 33:46But she wasn't the only one.
- 33:48But so did everyone else behind it.
- 33:50That's what I mean.
- 33:51Everyone else.
- 33:52She's not the only guilty person.
- 33:53She's not. She is guilty.
- 33:54Yes.
- 33:55But she's not the only guilty one.
- 33:56And now people are saying she's done a deal with the devil.
- 33:59Like how quickly do we go back to medieval times?
- 34:02Yeah.
- 34:03It doesn't take much to tie her up to wooden stake.
- 34:06I think we just didn't get the resolution
- 34:09that we wanted from the series.
- 34:10What we wanted was for Tyra to say,
- 34:13I would never do those things again.
- 34:15And why didn't she?
- 34:16Is that because she's saving face?
- 34:18Because she knows that there were a million other people behind her
- 34:21who should be saying sorry as well.
- 34:23But why didn't she say?
- 34:25I don't know.
- 34:26It opens the documentary with it was a different time.
- 34:29That is a valid statement.
- 34:30That's true.
- 34:31That is factual.
- 34:32Why can't it be?
- 34:33I have no idea what we were thinking.
- 34:35There were a lot of us that sat there and I was one of them.
- 34:38And I was guilty as everyone else of believing that this was good TV.
- 34:44Is it a litany?
- 34:45And I wish I hadn't thrown those young women under the bus
- 34:48because it went on for years in other talk shows
- 34:51when they would bring contestants back and try and still get those
- 34:54traumatic moments relived out of them.
- 34:58But we just didn't get that and I think that's why people are so angry
- 35:01because I just find it absolutely perplexing
- 35:05that this position she's taken is not denial
- 35:09but complacent.
- 35:10And I do think that the show came from a good place initially.
- 35:14But then it all went to pot once that popularity, once the money,
- 35:19once everything else comes in.
- 35:21And that is the story of the entire world
- 35:24because we are insatiable for watching people be vulnerable
- 35:29and be embarrassed.
- 35:31And the Colosseum is still alive and well.
- 35:34Absolutely.
- 35:35It's just in a different way, shape form.
- 35:37I actually just want to watch it all over again
- 35:40and really pick it apart.
- 35:42I don't want to watch it again.
- 35:44The whole thing just made me so sad for that whole era
- 35:48of formative years in women's lives.
- 35:52I hate it.
- 35:53And I hate that I loved it at the time.
- 35:55I know.
- 35:56You know, Lee's and Sarah.
- 35:59But anyway, there are some other things going on with women
- 36:02and culture that I want to turn my lens to this week.
- 36:04We're going to do it in Friday, in gold.
- 36:07And it's all about, I don't know if you've heard about this.
- 36:09The Perry Metapausal Posse?
- 36:11No, yeah.
- 36:12It's, I've seen it on my feed and I just scroll past
- 36:16but I do actually want your take on it.
- 36:18Okay, great.
- 36:19So I've got to take, it's going to be this Friday in gold
- 36:22behind the paywall because it's that good.
- 36:24Now, if you do want to become a Goldie, it's super easy.
- 36:27You just click on subscribe in Apple podcasts
- 36:30and find us there where it's a group of listeners
- 36:33that get bonus episodes every single Friday of the year.
- 36:37There's no rest for us, Lee's.
- 36:39And we just say the things that we wouldn't say on this show.
- 36:43Which makes it sound like it's...
- 36:45No, but you know, like you did that episode on the WhatsApp group
- 36:48and stuff and you got 50%.
- 36:50Think you're a hero, 50%.
- 36:52I would actually say 90% think I'm here.
- 36:54I actually think you've turned the time.
- 36:56I think so.
- 36:57I think the 10% of the problem, the 10% who don't think I'm here,
- 37:00you're the problem in WhatsApp groups.
- 37:02But I think you've helped people through the WhatsApp group jungle.
- 37:06Well, and I intend to do that with the Perry Metapausal Posse this Friday.
- 37:11And if you want to become a Goldie,
- 37:13subscribe in Apple podcasts.
- 37:15Super easy.
- 37:16But look, we got to go, we got to roll
- 37:18because we have got a disco club in Brisbane on Saturday night.
- 37:22Our first one for the 2026 tour.
- 37:245,000 women on the banks of the Brisbane River.
- 37:27And we're dancing together.
- 37:29I need a paper bag and I need to breathe into it.
- 37:32I'm so excited.
- 37:33I'm so excited too.
- 37:34But you know how I feel about these things.
- 37:36And when you all say hello to us when we're there, please, please.
- 37:39Please.
- 37:40All right, have a great life.
- 37:41We love you guys.
- 37:42We love you.
- 37:43We love it.
- 37:44All the time, yeah.
- 37:45Bye, bye.
- 37:46Thanks to Cleeshot Digital in Brisbane,
- 37:48where we record this podcast.
- 37:49This podcast was recorded on the lands of the Tourable and Yaguro people
- 37:53and we pay our respects to their elders past and present.