Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How Inflation Is Quietly Eroding the Real Value of US Debt
Transcript
- Lucas: So we talk a lot on this show about the size of the national debt — $39 trillion and change as of January — and usually it's with a sense of alarm. But there's a quieter story running underneath those numbers that rarely gets aired. Inflation is actually shrinking the real value of that debt. Luna: You mean like the 'inflation tax' argument — where borrowers win and lenders lose because the dollars get paid back with less purchasing power. Lucas: Exactly. The US government is the biggest borrower on the planet, so it's also the biggest beneficiary of that dynamic. If inflation runs hotter than expected, the real burden of all those Treasury bonds falls. And we've got the numbers to show it. The latest debt to gdp figure is 122.6 percent — that's up slightly from 122.57 a year ago, but given the deficit we're running, you'd expect it to be climbing faster. The fact that it's basically flat tells you nominal GDP growth is doing a lot of the heavy lifting. Luna: And nominal GDP includes both real growth and inflation. So if we're running, say, 3 percent real growth plus 3 percent inflation, that 6 percent nominal growth automatically reduces the debt ratio if the deficit isn't growing at the same pace. Lucas: Right. And right now, the 10-year yield is 4.54 percent. The 30-year is just over 5 percent. So the average interest cost on new debt is somewhere in that range. But nominal GDP growth has been running north of 5 percent for several quarters. As long as that spread is positive — growth exceeding the average interest rate — the debt to gdp ratio can actually decline even with continued borrowing. Luna: But isn't that a bit of a gamble? You're counting on inflation staying elevated enough to erode the real debt, but not so high that it forces the Fed to hike rates aggressively and spook the bond market. Lucas: It is a gamble, and that's the tricky part. If inflation comes down faster than expected — say, back to 2 percent — then nominal GDP growth slows, and the debt ratio starts climbing again. But if inflation stays sticky, the real value of all those outstanding bonds continues to melt away. Look at the 30-year Treasury at 5.09 percent yield. If you bought that bond five years ago at 2.5 percent, you're getting paid back in dollars that are worth significantly less. The government wins; the bondholder loses. Luna: And that's the 'inflation tax' in action. The government effectively repudiates part of its debt without formally defaulting. Lucas: Precisely. And this isn't just theory — you can see it in the Treasury's own financial statements. The interest expense on the debt is around $1.1 trillion annually now. But the reduction in real debt value from inflation is probably several hundred billion dollars a year. That's not counted as revenue, but economically, it's a transfer from bondholders to the government. Luna: So what does this mean for the average listener? If you're holding long-term bonds in your 401, inflation is eating your returns. But if you're a taxpayer, the real debt burden is lighter than the headline number suggests. Lucas: That's the uncomfortable trade-off. For a country with $39 trillion in debt, moderate inflation is actually helpful fiscally. It reduces the real value of the debt, and it gives the government room to grow out of the problem. The alternative — deflation or very low inflation — would make the debt much harder to manage, because real interest costs would rise. Luna: But politically, no one campaigns on 'we need a little more inflation to shrink the debt.' Lucas: No, they don't. And the Fed's mandate is price stability, not debt management. But it's a factor that policymakers in the Treasury and at the Fed are acutely aware of. There's a reason we haven't seen a serious push for austerity despite the big deficits — inflation is quietly doing some of the adjustment for us. Luna: Let's talk about the bond market reaction. If investors start to feel like the government is relying on an inflation tax, they'll demand higher yields to compensate. That's the paradox — the very thing that helps the debt could also make it more expensive to service. Lucas: That's the risk. And you can see echoes of it in the steepening yield curve. The 10-year yield is 4.54, the 2-year is 4.16 — that's a spread of 38 basis points. A steep curve often signals that investors expect higher inflation or growth in the future. They're demanding a term premium. If that term premium rises sharply, the average cost of debt goes up, and the benefit from inflation gets offset. Luna: So the question becomes: at what point does the market's inflation expectation exceed the actual inflation rate? If TIPS breakevens start to widen beyond core CPI, you know bond investors are getting nervous. Lucas: Right. And we should check what those breakevens are saying. Last I saw, the 10-year TIPS breakeven was around 2.4 percent. That's not far from current inflation. So the market seems to be pricing in a stable erosion, not a runaway spiral. But that can change quickly if there's a supply shock or a fiscal surprise. Luna: We've talked before about how foreign holders of US debt might react. If they think the US is deliberately inflating away the debt, they could reduce their holdings. China's already been trimming. Lucas: That's a real concern. Foreign ownership of Treasuries is still around $8 trillion. If a major holder like Japan or China decided to accelerate selling, yields would spike and the inflation benefit would disappear. But so far, the data shows mostly steady buying from private investors and some central banks. The real shift has been domestic — US banks and pension funds are stepping in to fill the gap. Luna: So the inflation tax is working, but it's a delicate balance. Too much inflation and you break the bond market; too little and the debt burden gets heavier. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the fiscal conversation is so nuanced. The debt to gdp ratio isn't just about deficits — it's about the interaction of growth, inflation, and interest rates. Right now, we're in a sweet spot where nominal growth is above the average cost of debt. But that window could close. Luna: Let's look at the latest data. Federal debt is 39 trillion, up from 38.5 trillion a year ago. The deficit narrowed slightly to $1.77 trillion from $1.81 trillion. So we're still borrowing a lot, but the debt ratio is almost flat. That's the math working in our favor. Lucas: And if you think about it, that $1.77 trillion deficit — about 6.5 percent of GDP — is still very large by historical standards. But because nominal GDP is growing at around 6 percent, the ratio is stable. If the deficit were 4 percent of GDP and growth was 6 percent, the ratio would actually decline. Luna: So the path to a lower debt ratio is either faster growth, higher inflation, or smaller deficits. And politically, smaller deficits are the hardest to achieve. Lucas: Right. And that's where the inflation tax becomes the default option. It's not declared, it's not voted on, but it's happening. Every year that inflation runs above the coupon on outstanding bonds, the real value of the debt shrinks. The Congressional Budget Office's long-term projections assume inflation returns to 2 percent, but if it stays at 3 percent, the debt in 20 years would be significantly lower in real terms. Luna: And that's the kind of thing listeners might not think about. When they hear 'debt to gdp at 122 percent,' they imagine a crisis. But if growth and inflation are strong, the number can be misleading. Lucas: Exactly. And on that note — if walking through the economy with us has made something click, we'd love your support. This show is ad-free and listener-funded. If you find these conversations valuable, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep digging into the numbers without chasing clicks. Luna: Yeah, and it really does make a difference. We don't have a big corporate backer, so every bit of support goes straight into research and production. Lucas: Alright, back to the inflation tax. One more angle I want to touch on: what happens if the Fed actually succeeds in bringing inflation down to 2 percent? Luna: Then the real debt burden starts growing again, because nominal GDP growth slows but the existing debt doesn't shrink. Lucas: Exactly. That's the risk for the fiscal side. The Fed's success would actually make the debt math harder. Some economists have argued that a deliberate policy of 'financial repression' — keeping real interest rates negative — is the only way to manage the debt without austerity. That's what happened after World War Two. The US ran big deficits but inflation and low rates eroded the debt over two decades. Luna: So the question for 2026 and beyond is: will we see a repeat of that post-war dynamic, or will the bond market revolt before we get there? Lucas: That's the trillion-dollar question. Literally. With the 30-year yield at 5.09 percent, real rates are positive. The era of negative real rates from 2020 to 2022 is over. So the inflation tax is weaker than it was. If yields rise further, the debt service costs could overwhelm the growth benefits. Luna: But for now, the data shows a fragile equilibrium. Nominal growth is outpacing interest costs, and debt to gdp is stable. It's not a crisis, but it's not a solution either. Lucas: Right. And that's the key takeaway. The inflation tax is a quiet force that's buying time. But it's not a permanent fix. Eventually, the country will need to make choices about spending and revenue. For now, we're coasting on a tailwind that could shift at any moment.