Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Mindfulness for the Discerning Lawyer
Transcript
- 0:03My name is Dean Sirwin. I'm the chair of the
- 0:06BHBA's wellness section, freshly back from Costco
- 0:09and ready to introduce our program today and
- 0:12our speaker. The program today is Training, Attention,
- 0:17and Exercising Professional Agency, Mindfulness
- 0:20for Lawyers, kind of part two from a program
- 0:22we did literally exactly one year ago today with
- 0:26Emily Keene. I'll introduce her in a moment.
- 0:28First, I want to tell you a little bit about
- 0:30the BHBA and about the wellness section. Wellness
- 0:33is a new optional competence element to the competence
- 0:39requirements for MCLE. And we're very excited
- 0:43about it because it's something that we feel
- 0:44is very important as I've been sitting through
- 0:47some of these programs. Comments, questions,
- 0:50feedback from the participants has indicated
- 0:53that this is an area that impacts a lot of lawyers.
- 0:57So welcome. A little bit about the HBA. We do
- 1:00these programs every day. We have one to three
- 1:03a day sometimes, most of the time. And we'll
- 1:07do them. If a new case comes down, something
- 1:10important happens in any field of law, we'll
- 1:13probably have a program on it within a week.
- 1:17We also have a wonderful, for those of you like
- 1:20myself that are in the compliance, to do in 20
- 1:24days now. BHBA on -demand is kind of like YouTube
- 1:30for MCLE, except unlike a lot of those services
- 1:34that you're probably inundated with emails from.
- 1:37These programs are new, fresh, exciting things,
- 1:41well -produced. A lot of those are orically produced.
- 1:46Regardless, you can go into the BHBA on -demand,
- 1:50find things like this. Those are hard to get
- 1:53areas of your MCLE. They're all considered participatory.
- 2:01So you get that credit as well. And the beauty
- 2:03of it is once you watch it, it's in sort of a
- 2:05little digital rocker that you've done it. And
- 2:08then when it comes time to do the compliance
- 2:10with the bar, it's a couple of clicks. It takes
- 2:13about a minute to certify your MCLE. So that's
- 2:17fantastic. Watch for more programs from the wellness
- 2:23committee. And if you're interested, we are going
- 2:27to start having committee meetings the fourth
- 2:30Wednesday of each month. So we'll start with
- 2:33the 25th of this month. So reach out to the bar
- 2:36if you're interested in participating. With that,
- 2:40I will tell you there are materials. Those materials
- 2:42have been sent to you by email. If you missed
- 2:44that email for any reason, they're also in the
- 2:47chat and they'll be periodically posted in the
- 2:50chat. So just scroll back on the chat. You can
- 2:54find it. It'll also be posted in the Q &A, I
- 2:57believe. And you should receive your certificate
- 3:01for this. It might be tomorrow, since it's already
- 3:03end of the day today. And then it'll be in the
- 3:07BHB On Demand shortly thereafter. So if you want
- 3:10to rewatch it, if you want to send your friends,
- 3:13colleagues, acquaintances, partners, associates,
- 3:15et cetera. So with that, I'm delighted to introduce
- 3:18our speaker once again, Emily Keene. Emily Negassi
- 3:22Keene is Assistant Dean for Law Student Affairs,
- 3:26leading the Law Student Affairs and Academic
- 3:27Success and Bar Program offices at the University
- 3:31of San Diego Law School. She provides strategic
- 3:35leadership for programs and services that foster
- 3:38academic and bar success and oversees law student
- 3:41life, academic advising, and student accommodations
- 3:44and well -being. Keane teaches the course, excuse
- 3:48me, Contemplative Practice of Law, which helps
- 3:52students to develop mindfulness and meditation
- 3:55practices, develop ethically, and increase their
- 3:59professional resilience. Very excited to have
- 4:02her back again with us. I will be monitoring
- 4:06the Q &A, but otherwise we'll have a Q &A section
- 4:09at the end. Take it away, Emily. Great. Thank
- 4:13you so much, Dean. Okay. I'm just going to share
- 4:14my slides. Make sure I can do this correctly.
- 4:19Everyone can see the slides, I hope. Yes. Thank
- 4:24you. Okay. Great. Good afternoon to everybody.
- 4:28Thank you so much for joining and thank you so
- 4:30much, especially to Dean and the Beverly Hills
- 4:32Bar Association for inviting me back one year
- 4:35exactly to the day since I last presented and
- 4:38to continue conversation that's really important
- 4:40to me. 15 years ago, I really couldn't imagine
- 4:46leading a session like this. I'm not what you
- 4:49would have considered to be someone who was well
- 4:52or unstressed. I was working as a human rights
- 4:55lawyer in South Africa, spending long hours in
- 4:59the field, working in prisons, policing, and
- 5:02intervening in the wake of abuses in a way that
- 5:05was pretty psychologically brutal. And on the
- 5:09surface, I was really sustained. by what felt
- 5:13like deep care and moral clarity. And absolutely,
- 5:16that was what motivated me. But beneath that,
- 5:19I really was struggling. I was encountering resistance
- 5:22on multiple levels, resistance from the public
- 5:26in terms of indifference to what I witnessed,
- 5:30institutional resistance to accountability, and
- 5:32my own resistance to my own human limits. the
- 5:36limits, the limits of the work, the limits of
- 5:38what an individual can repair or how much I could
- 5:41help. And my mind and body really absorbed the
- 5:45cost, not to mention my personal and family life.
- 5:49I struggled with insomnia, regular migraines,
- 5:54chronic uticaria, ulcers, you name it. And my
- 5:57stress was really showing up in terms of my body.
- 6:00And It took me a while to kind of push past that
- 6:03and actually do something really meaningful about
- 6:06it. I continued on and I treated the kind of
- 6:09intensity of my work as evidence of my value,
- 6:13evidence of my seriousness, evidence of my integrity.
- 6:17And what I didn't understand at the time was
- 6:19how much my own mind was actually amplifying
- 6:22the string. The external conditions I was navigating
- 6:25were difficult enough. But the internal conditions
- 6:28was really what was relentless. You know, I replayed
- 6:31suffering. I couldn't help. When I failed, I
- 6:35mentally relitigated events that were already
- 6:37over. I carried narratives long after the moment
- 6:40had passed, and my mind treated those narratives
- 6:42as obligations I had to see through. And I couldn't
- 6:46stop working because I thought it meant I failed
- 6:48to help. So it took a while, but I eventually
- 6:53kind of encountered and tried meditation. at
- 6:57a time when my body had made it really clear
- 7:00that something had to change. And when therapy,
- 7:03intense exercise, and burning the candle on both
- 7:05ends just really weren't sufficient anymore.
- 7:08So I went on a 10 -day silent meditation retreat
- 7:11to learn how to meditate and to learn what, quite
- 7:14frankly, I didn't know how to do, which was how
- 7:17to relate to my own mind without being fooled
- 7:19by it. And the big insight was pretty straightforward
- 7:23from that retreat, but it had a very profound
- 7:26effect on my life. The factual pain I encountered
- 7:30in the world was plenty enough on its own, but
- 7:33I was generating additional pain through my mind's
- 7:35compulsive tendencies, through rumination, fixation,
- 7:39and the internal insistence, even when nothing
- 7:42further could be done. The events were real,
- 7:44but the mental suffering that I was inflicting
- 7:47on myself was entirely optional. That insight
- 7:53did not completely erase old patterns, but what
- 7:56changed first was my body. The migraine stopped,
- 7:59the high stopped, the ulcers healed, my blood
- 8:02pressure stabilized. In fact, I haven't had a
- 8:05migraine since 2014. At the same time, habits
- 8:09return very easily and they don't dissolve because
- 8:13of one moment of clarity no matter how profound.
- 8:16But what I did learn and what matters for this
- 8:18session is that the mental habits can be trained.
- 8:22Space can be created between stimulus and response.
- 8:25And within that space, something like freedom
- 8:27becomes available. The capacity to choose how
- 8:31one responds rather than being pulled reflexively
- 8:33into reaction. And so that's the subject for
- 8:36today, professional agency. And by agency in
- 8:40this presentation, I mean the capacity to recognize
- 8:43internal mental and emotional activation and
- 8:46to respond deliberately. conscientiously rather
- 8:50than reacting automatically. In adversarial professions,
- 8:54exercising agency here can shape the tone and
- 8:57the tenor of our interactions, strategy, judgment,
- 9:01ethical consistency, and it also shapes how it
- 9:04feels for us as individual human beings living
- 9:07inside of this work. So let me briefly orient
- 9:12us to the session. We'll begin with mindfulness,
- 9:15neuroplasticity, and what's going on in a lawyer's
- 9:18mind, how attention functions under pressure,
- 9:20and how mental habits can be trained using meditation.
- 9:24I'll then introduce a framework from cognitive
- 9:26science, the modular theory of the mind, which
- 9:28helps explain why strong emotions can quickly
- 9:31capture our attention. And we'll look at simple
- 9:34techniques that make those processes more visible
- 9:36and can disarm those strong emotions once they've
- 9:39taken hold. From there, we'll turn to Stoicism
- 9:42as a complement to mindfulness practice. Stoic
- 9:45philosophy offers a helpful account of how perception
- 9:48becomes judgment and how judgment becomes action.
- 9:52And we'll try a couple of Stoic exercises there.
- 9:55And finally, we'll consider community connection
- 9:57and compassion and how widening the frame of
- 10:00our perception can reduce unnecessary hostility
- 10:03in adversarial settings. and contribute to our
- 10:06own sense of calm and increased ability to collaborate.
- 10:11Throughout this session, we'll pause briefly
- 10:13to try a few short practices. Obviously, it's
- 10:16only an hour, we're not mastering anything, but
- 10:18it's just to experience how shifts in our attention
- 10:20and interpretation affect how the mind operates
- 10:24under pressure. Over time, practices like these
- 10:27can strengthen what we might call professional
- 10:29agency, the capacity to recognize internal activation,
- 10:33examine interpretation, and respond deliberately.
- 10:37So in that sense, the training is also a training
- 10:39in freedom of mind, the ability to work within
- 10:42demanding environments without being carried
- 10:45entirely by their pressures. So mindfulness.
- 10:52In contemporary Western language, it's commonly
- 10:55defined as moment -to -moment awareness of our
- 10:57thoughts, emotions, and bodily sensation without
- 10:59judgment. Within legal culture, structured around
- 11:02critique, competition, and constant evaluation,
- 11:06the practice of observing our internal states
- 11:09without immediately condemning them can be a
- 11:12meaningful solve on its own. Many of us are skilled
- 11:16at analyzing external problems, but we're less
- 11:18practiced at noticing what's unfolding internally
- 11:21while we analyze. And some of us might be outright
- 11:25resistant to see what's actually there, and we're
- 11:28trying to avoid it at all costs. Historically,
- 11:32mindfulness developed within a 2 ,500 -year -old
- 11:36tradition concerned with wisdom and ethical and
- 11:38spiritual development. And in terms of what's
- 11:40taught in most mindfulness circles in America
- 11:42and the West, it's really from a Buddhist tradition.
- 11:46Meditation in that context is a method of training
- 11:48the mind, learning how to observe its activity
- 11:51with calm attention and learning how to redirect
- 11:55our attention with wisdom and discernment. So
- 11:58the point of looking inward, it's not self -absorption,
- 12:02it's not navel gazing, it's to understand how
- 12:05our mind works, refine how it behaves, and refine
- 12:09how we behave outwardly, particularly when our
- 12:12mind is under stress and inclined toward distortion.
- 12:17For lawyers, this has very practical implication.
- 12:21The profession places us in evaluative and emotionally
- 12:24charged environments, and our nervous systems
- 12:26respond accordingly, and then we pay with our
- 12:29health. To understand how this agency can be
- 12:34trained, it helps us to look briefly at how the
- 12:37mind operates under pressure. Psychologist Daniel
- 12:40Kahneman describes two broad modes of cognition,
- 12:43fast, automatic processing, and slower deliberative
- 12:47reasoning, or type one and type two thinking.
- 12:50The FAST system operates quickly and efficiently.
- 12:53It draws on emotion, habit, and pattern recognition.
- 12:57The slower system engages when we analyze, weigh
- 12:59options, and consider consequences. It's our
- 13:02rational reasoning side. In contentious exchanges,
- 13:07FAST processing often arrives first. An email
- 13:10reads as accusatory. A judge interrupts us mid
- 13:13-sentence. Opposing counsel is using a dismissive
- 13:16tone. In these moments, before deliberative reasoning
- 13:19has fully engaged, the nervous system registers
- 13:22a threat. And this activation involves structures
- 13:26such as the medulla in our brain, the small little
- 13:29walnut lizard part of our brain, the sympathetic
- 13:32nervous system mobilizes, our heart rate increases,
- 13:35our muscles tighten, our cognitive bandwidth
- 13:38narrows. And then the pathways associated with
- 13:40strong emotion activate faster than the slower
- 13:43processes associated with reflective reasoning.
- 13:48These sympathetic responses evolve to support
- 13:50our survival as a species, but in professional
- 13:53settings, they're frequently disproportionate
- 13:55to the stimulus and we're flooded with stress
- 13:57and the quality of our decisions and interactions
- 14:00end up suffering and then we start to experience
- 14:03distress. Breathing patterns influence this cascade.
- 14:09Slow, deliberate breathing with extended exhalations
- 14:13stimulate the vagus nerve, increasing our parasympathetic
- 14:16activity, our rest and digest, our calming response,
- 14:22and it supports our physiological regulation.
- 14:24So as the body stabilizes, access to our higher
- 14:28-order reasoning improves, and this is measurable
- 14:31in our physiology. So a really important thing
- 14:34we can do any time of day is to slow down our
- 14:38breathing. So let's start with some 478 breathing
- 14:41to settle down our nervous systems. And this
- 14:45is very simple. There have been lab studies about
- 14:50different breathing techniques. This is one of
- 14:53the ones that's supposed to be the most effective.
- 14:55And basically, you inhale through your nose for
- 14:58the count of four. You gently hold for the count
- 15:02of seven. And then you slowly exhale through
- 15:04your mouth like you're blowing through a straw
- 15:07for the count of eight. So let's try this for
- 15:10a couple of cycles. So inhale to the count of
- 15:13four. Hold for the count of seven. Exhale for
- 15:24eight. Inhale for four. Hold for seven. Exhale
- 15:40for eight. One last time. Inhale. Hold. Exhale.
- 16:03This is what I was doing before the presentation.
- 16:09Attention functions as another regulatory mechanism,
- 16:13and our attention is trainable. Neuroscientists
- 16:17use the term the default mode network to describe
- 16:21a set of interconnected brain regions that become
- 16:23active when we're not engaged in a specific external
- 16:27task. When attention is not anchored, the mind
- 16:31defaults to internally generated activity, much
- 16:33of which takes the form of self -referential
- 16:35narrative. This narrative activity supports autobiographical
- 16:40continuity, planning, moral reasoning, and the
- 16:43simulation of outcomes. It also allows us to
- 16:46learn from experience and anticipate consequences.
- 16:49But it also has a predictable shadow side, rumination,
- 16:54looping self -evaluation, and repetitive rehearsal.
- 16:57For lawyers, it's a pretty familiar pattern.
- 17:01A hearing concludes and the argument continues
- 17:03internally for hours. A comment from opposing
- 17:06counsel repeats itself long after the exchange
- 17:09is over, like a marble circling in an empty bathtub.
- 17:13An anticipated cross -examination unfolds in
- 17:15imagination days before it happens. And then
- 17:19we end up experiencing these hypothetical scenarios
- 17:21with the similar urgency of current threat. Default
- 17:27mode activities especially pronounced in self
- 17:29-referential thinking. The mind begins asking
- 17:33questions of status and identity. How did that
- 17:36reflect on me? What does this mean about my competence?
- 17:40What will people think? When the mind wanders,
- 17:44it often wanders in predictable grooves, evaluation,
- 17:48comparison, self -critique, and the attempt to
- 17:50regain control through rehearsal. Persistent
- 17:54activation of these loops correlates with anxiety
- 17:57and decreased well -being. More importantly for
- 18:00our purposes, it also narrows our perception.
- 18:03When the mind has absorbed a narrative, incoming
- 18:06information is processed through the story rather
- 18:09than assessed on its own terms. Meditation doesn't
- 18:13eliminate default mode activity, but what practice
- 18:17can change is the degree to which the mind is
- 18:20carried by it and the speed with which one recognizes
- 18:23that a loop has taken hold. And repeated attentional
- 18:29training reduces the automatic dominance of narrative
- 18:31and it strengthens circuits associated with executive
- 18:34control and present centered awareness. The effect
- 18:38is gradual. What becomes noticeable over time
- 18:42is an increased ability to disengage from narrative
- 18:45when it's not serving the work. And this capacity
- 18:51obviously has professional consequences. If you
- 18:53can recognize that you're mentally replaying
- 18:55a perceived slate, you can decide whether continuing
- 18:58to do so serves you or the role you're playing.
- 19:02And you can return your attention to preparation
- 19:05or productivity rather than perseveration. Focused
- 19:13attention meditation trains the capacity to direct
- 19:16attention deliberately. It's pretty simple. You
- 19:20choose an object of attention. Most commonly,
- 19:24what I encourage people to focus on is the breath
- 19:26because the breath is always with you. You don't
- 19:28need any special equipment. You don't need to
- 19:30be in a special room or doing this special thing.
- 19:33You're always able to access your breath, which
- 19:36means you can do this anywhere. and you just
- 19:40choose an object of your attention, your breath,
- 19:43and you sustain your attention there. Distraction
- 19:47will occur, recognition of that distraction will
- 19:50occur, and then you return your attention back
- 19:52to your anchor, your breath. Despite how simple
- 19:57it is, several cognitive processes are being
- 19:59trained simultaneously. Selective attention is
- 20:03strengthened by repeatedly choosing the object
- 20:05of attention rather than allowing attention to
- 20:07be captured automatically. Meta awareness is
- 20:11trained by recognizing that attention has drifted.
- 20:14Inhibitory control is trained through the act
- 20:17of interrupting the momentum of thought and returning
- 20:19to a chosen object. Each time attention wanders
- 20:24to planning, memory, or evaluation, default mode
- 20:27activity has engaged. Each time that engagement
- 20:30is recognized and attention is returned, executive
- 20:33networks are being recruited. Over time, the
- 20:36latency between distraction and recognition shortens.
- 20:41Instead of being carried for minutes by a narrative,
- 20:43the mind recognizes a drift much earlier. So
- 20:48for lawyers, say for example, during an oral
- 20:51argument, your attention drifts into internal
- 20:53commentary about performance and outcome. This
- 20:57practice supports your ability to return to the
- 20:59actual question being asked or what's going on.
- 21:03During negotiations, your mind starts constructing
- 21:05a narrative about disrespect or status. This
- 21:08practice supports returning to the terms on the
- 21:10table and the objectives of the role that you're
- 21:12playing. After work, when your mind keeps replaying
- 21:16the day, this helps you recognize the onset of
- 21:19rumination and allows you to redirect your attention
- 21:22towards rest and restoration. It's incremental
- 21:25work. No single session is going to transform
- 21:30your mind, but the effect accumulates through
- 21:33repetition and through practice. You're training
- 21:35a new habit of your mind. So with that, let's
- 21:39spend about two, three minutes just working on
- 21:43the meditation. And you can sit comfortably in
- 21:49your chair. Let your hands rest easily in your
- 21:55lap. Have your back straight, but not rigid.
- 22:00Relax, but with just enough tension so that you
- 22:02don't get sleepy. And if you're comfortable,
- 22:08you can close your eyes or simply lower your
- 22:11gaze. And you can begin by bringing your attention
- 22:17to your breath. And treat your breath as a place
- 22:23where your mind can settle down. like a comfortable
- 22:27home base. Notice your breath coming in all the
- 22:33way, and notice the breath going out all the
- 22:37way. There's no special breath you have to do.
- 22:43Just breathe however is natural and comfortable
- 22:45to you right now. And when your breath feels
- 22:53comfortable, and adjust it if you need to, deeper,
- 22:59shallower, faster, slower, see what feels best.
- 23:06Once your breath feels comfortable, it's gonna
- 23:10be easier for your mind to stay there. And so
- 23:17for the next two, three minutes, just follow
- 23:21your attention with your breath. And if your
- 23:26mind wanders, just drop the thought that is picked
- 23:30up and gently without chastisement, without disappointment,
- 23:36come back to your breath again and again. When
- 24:55you're ready, you can open your eyes and come
- 24:58back. With this practice, you very quickly notice
- 25:05how much the mind wanders, and it's completely
- 25:10normal. Your mind's been trained to move quickly
- 25:16from one thing to another for your whole life.
- 25:21So the entirety of the practice is just to notice
- 25:24when your mind's wandered and to bring it back
- 25:27again and again. No need for irritation or commentary
- 25:33about what that means for you. Our minds are
- 25:36going to wander. Every return you bring to your
- 25:44breath after you're distracted strengthens your
- 25:47mind's ability to stay where you intend for your
- 25:50mind to stay. And the point is not to achieve
- 25:57perfect concentration. That might sometimes happen.
- 26:01But other times, even for really experienced
- 26:03meditators, you're going to sit down and you're
- 26:05going to try to meditate. And it's just not going
- 26:08to happen. So then you're just training your
- 26:10mind again to focus on what you wish for your
- 26:13mind to focus on, which is your breath. So it's
- 26:24really helpful to do this, you know, whenever
- 26:27you can, a few minutes at your desk. But the
- 26:30best thing to do is to establish a daily practice,
- 26:33even if it's for five to ten minutes. You want
- 26:36to work on this because you want to build a new
- 26:38practice and you have it in your mind and you
- 26:40want to train your mind to be directed to where
- 26:44you want it to be directed to. And so even with
- 26:51that brief meditation, we observe the busyness
- 26:54of our minds and the internal conflicts that
- 26:56often are taking place in our minds. A useful
- 27:01framework for understanding that kind of busyness
- 27:03and conflict is the modular theory of the mind,
- 27:07described in popular form by writers like Robert
- 27:09Wright. The concept is about how our minds evolved.
- 27:14Our mind was not designed as a single, unified,
- 27:17perfect executive system. It evolved in layers
- 27:20with semi -independent processes solving different
- 27:23adaptive problems. What we experience as a coherent
- 27:27self is more accurately a shifting coalition
- 27:30of processes that rise and fall depending on
- 27:33the context. Different modules activate under
- 27:37different conditions. A fairness detection system
- 27:40becomes alert in negotiations. A status monitoring
- 27:44system intensifies in hierarchical environments.
- 27:47threat detection responds to perceived disrespect,
- 27:52and a self -protected narrative generator mobilizes
- 27:55when our identity starts to feel challenged.
- 27:59When one of these systems is active, it tends
- 28:02to feel very authoritative. It generates reasons,
- 28:06justifications, and narratives that support its
- 28:08immediate aim, which is to take control of the
- 28:10steering wheel of our mind. In a contentious
- 28:14exchange, for example, A fairness system may
- 28:18generate a story about injustice. A status system
- 28:22may supply anxiety about how one is being perceived.
- 28:27And the defense system starts to assemble counter
- 28:29-arguments before the other person has even finished
- 28:32speaking. Each of these systems has adaptive
- 28:37value. But the difficulty arises when one system
- 28:41captures the field of attention and drives conduct
- 28:44without oversight. Usually, one of these modules
- 28:48takes over our attention when there's a strong
- 28:50emotion animating it to the front of our minds.
- 28:54Our minds are really more like a shouting house
- 28:56of representatives rather than a single executive
- 28:59at the helm. Or a shouty boardroom where there's
- 29:02always at least one or two obnoxious types who
- 29:04take up all the oxygen in the room. Mindfulness
- 29:08increases visibility of these shifts and of these
- 29:11voices. It reveals that what feels like a singular
- 29:16stable I is often a rapid succession of impulses,
- 29:20interpretations, and emotions. From that vantage
- 29:24point, agency becomes less about suppressing
- 29:26emotion and more about deciding which internal
- 29:29processes should guide action in a given role.
- 29:34And we have agency to say no to one of the modules,
- 29:38to one of the shouty board members, to let it
- 29:40know you've been heard. Now let's let a different
- 29:43person speak. In legal practice, the part of
- 29:47you that wants to win an exchange is not always
- 29:49the part best aligned with client interest or
- 29:52long -term credibility. And the part of you that
- 29:56wants to defend status is not always aligned
- 29:58with judgment or what's going to be most effective
- 30:02in the moment. One practical technique that works
- 30:08directly with this modular structure is in -the
- 30:11-moment labeling. So labeling is simple in form,
- 30:15but kind of demanding in execution, especially
- 30:16when you're a little wild up. When a thought
- 30:19or emotion arises, you briefly and neutrally
- 30:22name its presence. There is anger. There is defensiveness.
- 30:26There is anxious planning. There is rumination.
- 30:30Notice I didn't say, I'm anger. I'm feeling defensive.
- 30:34I'm anxious. You're noticing its presence and
- 30:39you're not identifying with it. You're not fusing
- 30:42with it. And this is useful because it shifts
- 30:47your attention from content to process. So instead
- 30:52of following the narrative that anger supplies,
- 30:56attention registers the presence of anger and
- 30:58with it, the fact that the mind is interpreting
- 31:00and reacting. Labeling loosens your identification
- 31:04with the thought or emotion. When a state is
- 31:08recognized as simply a state, it's less likely
- 31:11to dominate the entire field of your awareness.
- 31:15Over time, this practice strengthens your metacognitive
- 31:20abilities, the ability to observe mental activity
- 31:23as mental activity. As that capacity grows, internal
- 31:28modules lose some of their automatic authority.
- 31:31They continue to speak, but they're no longer
- 31:34assumed to be in charge. There's also evidence
- 31:38that effective science that naming emotions recruits
- 31:42regulatory circuits in our prefrontal cortex
- 31:45and that can reduce our amygdala reactivity.
- 31:49In practice, the first effect most people notice
- 31:53is modest but meaningful. A fraction of space
- 31:56appears, something like tapping the brakes in
- 31:59your car. And that fraction of space is often
- 32:02enough to change the emotional tenor of the moment
- 32:06for you. The aim is not to eliminate strong reactions.
- 32:14We can't do that. We're human beings. We're always
- 32:16going to have reactions. But the aim is to be
- 32:20able to recognize these states earlier and to
- 32:26be able to preserve judgment as a governing faculty
- 32:30of our conduct. So the practice is simple. When
- 32:35you're meditating or going about your day, and
- 32:38a disruptive thought or emotion takes hold. Pause
- 32:43for a few seconds, label its arrival, and then
- 32:47bring your attention back to your task at hand.
- 32:51If you're meditating, your breath or your object
- 32:53of focus, or just back to your work. So mindfulness
- 33:03makes these mental movements a lot easier for
- 33:05us to see. Stoic philosophy focuses on what we
- 33:10do with those things. And so it's very helpful
- 33:14complementary philosophy and practice for people
- 33:17who are working on mindfulness. Mindfulness and
- 33:22stoicism are sometimes described as parallel
- 33:24traditions that developed independently and arrived
- 33:26at similar conclusions about perception and the
- 33:29nature of suffering. That narrative has become
- 33:32more complex as scholars have documented actual
- 33:35cultural contact between Hellenistic Greek culture
- 33:38and South Asian philosophical traditions. For
- 33:41example, think about Alexander the Great's campaigns
- 33:44into India. You know, trade routes really expanded
- 33:48during that period and intellectual exchange
- 33:50was possible. So there's very likely some degree
- 33:53of cross -fertilization that actually occurred.
- 33:56It's not just kind of cultural syncretism. For
- 34:01our purposes, what matters is that both traditions
- 34:04place disciplined attention and disciplined judgment
- 34:07at the center of human freedom. Both examine
- 34:10how perception becomes suffering and how unexamined
- 34:13judgments amplify our distress. Stoic philosophy
- 34:18offers a particularly clear account of the process.
- 34:22It describes a sequence. An event presents itself
- 34:26in our mind as an impression. The mind either
- 34:29endorses or revises that impression through assent,
- 34:33and then emotion and action follow. And it's
- 34:39also helpful because Stoic philosophers and teachers
- 34:42didn't develop these ideas, you know, from places
- 34:45of great ease, you know, they weren't in ideal,
- 34:48calm settings where they developed this philosophy.
- 34:52They developed it under very demanding circumstances.
- 34:56Marcus Aurelius governed during plague, famine,
- 35:00military conflict, and political instability.
- 35:03He had an extremely stressful job. His meditations
- 35:06read as personal working notes, ongoing attempts
- 35:09to discipline his perception, resist impulsivity,
- 35:13and exercise authority with his strength, and
- 35:16also to live a happy life. Epictetus approached
- 35:21the same problem as a teacher of stoicism. He
- 35:27started as a slave, who was beaten so badly his
- 35:32leg was maimed. So he was someone who had known
- 35:35great suffering. And then he became a teacher
- 35:39who instructed students entering public life.
- 35:43And he focused repeatedly on how the mind moves
- 35:45from perception to action. An impression in his
- 35:51language is the way a situation initially appears.
- 35:55This is insulting, this is dangerous, this is
- 35:57unjust. Impressions can arise automatically and
- 36:01can be immediately persuasive. But concerned
- 36:05Epictetus was ascent. Ascent is the mind's endorsement
- 36:12of an impression as accurate and decisive. Once
- 36:16ascent is given, emotion and conduct follow very
- 36:18quickly. His discipline was to pause long enough
- 36:22to examine the impression before endorsing it.
- 36:27And one of his exercises was to remind oneself
- 36:29internally that an impression is simply an impression
- 36:32and not identical with the thing itself. This
- 36:36reminder slows endorsement and restores wise
- 36:40judgment. In Stoic analysis, emotional disturbance
- 36:46reflects an evaluative commitment, so anger depends
- 36:49on the judgment that one has been wronged in
- 36:51a way that demands retaliation. Fear depends
- 36:55on the judgment that something external constitutes
- 36:57decisive harm. Anxiety depends on the judgment
- 37:00that a future outcome will determine one's safety
- 37:03or standing. The Stoic task is to bring those
- 37:06judgments into view. Epictetus also emphasizes
- 37:11rule. A recurring question in the discourses,
- 37:14which document his teachings, is one who is in
- 37:20a given situation. It's to ask yourself, what
- 37:24situation are you in? Are you a citizen? Are
- 37:26you an advisor? Are you a parent? Are you a friend?
- 37:29Are you an official? And then your conduct and
- 37:33the quality of your conduct is measured against
- 37:35the obligations of that position, that role that
- 37:39you're playing. And rule of fidelity provides
- 37:43orientation when an interpretation begins to
- 37:45pull judgment off course. In legal practice,
- 37:54in a contentious exchange, the impression this
- 37:58is disrespect may arise instantly. The discipline
- 38:03lies in examining that interpretation before
- 38:06it settles into conviction and then starts to
- 38:08drive our conduct. What actually occurred? What
- 38:13does my role require? Does escalation serve the
- 38:16client's interests or the integrity of the record?
- 38:20Is this person just projecting? Placed alongside
- 38:25mindfulness, you can see how it's complementary.
- 38:29Mindfulness increases awareness of impressions
- 38:31as they arise. We can see that movement in our
- 38:33minds through quiet meditation. And the stoic
- 38:37practice directs our attention to the judgment
- 38:39embedded within those impressions and subjects
- 38:42it to scrutiny and examination before action
- 38:45follows. Early Buddhist sources approach the
- 38:49same terrain through sustained awareness of how
- 38:51quickly narrative forms and how readily our identity
- 38:54fuses with that narrative. Reactions are observed
- 38:58early enough to prevent them from governing our
- 39:00speech or conduct. For lawyers, This type of
- 39:05discipline is really consequential because the
- 39:09rules that we play are consequential. Advice
- 39:12can alter the trajectory of a family, a business,
- 39:14a person's liberty. Strategic decisions determine
- 39:17exposure and protection. The written language
- 39:20we choose becomes binding obligation. And so
- 39:24the cumulative effect of small decisions is often
- 39:27larger than it appears to us in the moment. In
- 39:33our work, interpretations matter. The mind moves
- 39:36quickly from what has occurred to what it means
- 39:38and then to what must be done. Fatigue shortens
- 39:41our patience, anxiety distorts risk, assessment,
- 39:46and our ego can quietly enter into professional
- 39:49disagreement. When an interpretation settles
- 39:52in, it begins shaping tone, strategy, and the
- 39:56range of options that appear to us. Stoic discipline
- 40:02addresses this by directing attention to the
- 40:05judgment embedded in our reaction and asking
- 40:07whether the interpretation is consistent with
- 40:11the role we need to play. Buddhist practice approaches
- 40:14the same terrain by training sustained awareness
- 40:17of the mind's tendency to construct narrative
- 40:20around experience. So the pressures obviously
- 40:26are never going to disappear from our profession.
- 40:30But what can change is the speed with which interpretation
- 40:33is recognized and the habit of examining it before
- 40:35it shapes a response. Over time, the examination
- 40:40becomes steadiness, a pattern of conduct that
- 40:43reflects judgment rather than impulsivity. So
- 40:48one micro practice we can do that the Stoics
- 40:51would like is recalling one's role. So we looked
- 40:56at how attention and interpretation function.
- 41:03In his discourses, Epictetus repeatedly asked
- 41:06students to consider who they are in a given
- 41:09situation and what the obligations of that role
- 41:11require. In legal work, several identities compete
- 41:16for control in moments of friction. The part
- 41:19of our mind concerned with status, the part that
- 41:21wants to win the moment, the part that wants
- 41:23to defend competence in the eyes of others. Role
- 41:28we call introduces a stabilizing reference point
- 41:30for us. So the question is very simple. It's
- 41:33what is my role here? And what conduct would
- 41:37be consistent with that role? So when you're
- 41:40feeling yourself getting activated, you can simply
- 41:42ask yourself this question, pause, and this will
- 41:47help refocus your mind. A second stoic exercise
- 41:55concerns how attention and effort are allocated
- 41:58by us in our minds. Epictetus begins the Enchiridion
- 42:04with a simple but demanding observation. Some
- 42:06things are within our control and some things
- 42:08aren't. Within our control are our judgments,
- 42:11intentions, and actions. Outside of our control
- 42:14are our outcomes, reputation, and the behavior
- 42:17of other people. And then there might be things
- 42:19that we influence, but we don't ultimately control.
- 42:25Legal practice constantly obscures this distinction.
- 42:28because the work is organized around results.
- 42:32Lawyers are trained to pursue outcomes, winning
- 42:35a motion, persuading a court, reaching a settlement.
- 42:39Yet outcomes never depend entirely on one's own
- 42:42effort. They're shaped by institutions, opposing
- 42:46parties, judges, clients, and contingency. And
- 42:51when attention becomes fixed on what cannot be
- 42:54fully controlled, Our mind circles around questions
- 42:57that cannot be resolved by us in the present
- 42:59moment. And then anxiety starts to follow, frustration
- 43:03starts to follow. So the stoic exercise is simply
- 43:08to clarify the boundary between what's a good
- 43:11investment of your attention and what your mind
- 43:14can simply release. So it's just, if you want
- 43:19to do it right now, you can bring to mind a matter
- 43:21that's currently occupying your attention and
- 43:23generating some mental strain. And for a moment,
- 43:27simply sort the elements of that situation into
- 43:30two categories. First, what depends on your judgment
- 43:35and your conduct, your preparation, your reasoning,
- 43:40the clarity of your communication, how you engage
- 43:43with the situation. Second, what depends on other
- 43:48actors or external factors. the decisions of
- 43:53others, the eventual outcome, and circumstances
- 43:56beyond your control. And then you simply allow
- 44:01your attention to rest for a few breaths on the
- 44:03first category, what is under your control? What
- 44:07falls within your responsibility? This exercise
- 44:13doesn't remove uncertainty from the work, but
- 44:16it clarifies where your effort is actually effective,
- 44:19and it gives you permission to drop the weights
- 44:22on the things that you cannot govern yourself.
- 44:31Once attention and interpretation has become
- 44:33a little more visible, another question naturally
- 44:36arises. How do these disciplines influence the
- 44:40way we perceive the people we encounter in our
- 44:42professional roles? Legal practice often occurs
- 44:48in adversarial settings. But the profession itself
- 44:51exists within a broader civic structure. Courts,
- 44:55contracts, regulatory systems, dispute resolution
- 44:58mechanisms, they all serve public purpose. We
- 45:03represent particular interests, but the work
- 45:06takes place within institutions designed to resolve
- 45:08conflict and maintain social order. Operating
- 45:13within these institutions requires a psychological
- 45:15capacity that many philosophical traditions recognize
- 45:18as essential. The ability to prevent perception
- 45:22from narrowing into hostility or personal grievance
- 45:24when conflict arises. Sturrock writers approach
- 45:29this problem by emphasizing the social nature
- 45:31of human beings. Marcus Aurelius repeatedly reminded
- 45:36himself that human beings are made for cooperation.
- 45:40His reflections frame individuals not as isolated
- 45:43competitors, but as participants in a shared
- 45:46civic enterprise whose conduct affects the functioning
- 45:49of the whole. Buddhist traditions also developed
- 45:54a parallel emphasis through the cultivation of
- 45:55compassion. In this context, it's a discipline
- 46:01orientation that allows one to perceive others
- 46:03more accurately when resentment or hostility
- 46:07would otherwise narrow the way we view others.
- 46:12Modern research has also begun to examine compassion
- 46:15empirically. Psychology and neuroscience describe
- 46:20compassion as a trainable orientation that influences
- 46:23both perception and our physiology. One mechanism
- 46:28involves the autonomic nervous system, particularly
- 46:30the vagus nerve, the same nerve we try to simulate
- 46:34with that force of innate breathing that invites
- 46:36our parasympathetic nervous system to activate.
- 46:40and higher vagal tone is associated with emotional
- 46:44regulation, social engagement, and greater stability
- 46:48during interpersonal stress. It's also been studied
- 46:52to show that people who have higher vagal tone
- 46:54behave more altruistically, more regularly. Compassion
- 47:00practices appear to influence these systems and
- 47:04improve our vagal tone. Research using heart
- 47:08rate variability suggests that Cultivating concern
- 47:10for others increases that parasympathetic nervous
- 47:13system, like I said, and supports calmer interpersonal
- 47:17responses rather than defensive reactivity. At
- 47:21the cognitive level, compassion also alters interpretation.
- 47:27When intention includes the circumstances affecting
- 47:30other people, the mind is less likely to default
- 47:33to narratives centered on personal threat or
- 47:35injury. For lawyers, This doesn't mean weakening
- 47:40our advocacy or surrendering a position. It means
- 47:44recognizing that the people we encounter, clients,
- 47:48judges, opposing counsel, our colleagues, they're
- 47:52all operating within constraints and pressures
- 47:54of their own. When that recognition is present,
- 47:58disagreement is less likely to become unnecessarily
- 48:01personal. Seen in this way, compassion functions
- 48:05as another exercise of professional agency. It
- 48:09widens the frame of perception before interpretation
- 48:12hardens into reaction and behavior we might otherwise
- 48:16regret. A brief practice that builds on this
- 48:26idea is what we might call expanding the frame.
- 48:31When tension arises in a professional interaction,
- 48:34the mind narrows quickly around personal impact.
- 48:38We start to focus on what the other person's
- 48:40behavior means for us. Our credibility, our competence,
- 48:44our position in the exchange. These interpretations
- 48:48form rapidly and then it starts to shape our
- 48:52tone and our response. This practice can help
- 48:56interrupt that by narrowing, interrupt that narrowing
- 48:59by deliberately widening the context in which
- 49:01the interaction is being interpreted. So, You
- 49:07can bring to mind a professional interaction
- 49:09that involves some tensions. It could be negotiation,
- 49:13a very difficult conversation, whatever it is.
- 49:19And you just notice the immediate interpretation
- 49:21that forms. What story does the mind begin to
- 49:26tell about what is happening? I'm thinking of
- 49:29a situation right now. And all you need to do
- 49:34is then widen the frame slightly. Consider that
- 49:38other person's circumstances. What pressures
- 49:41might they be operating under? What constraints
- 49:44or incentives might be shaping their behavior
- 49:47in that moment? Finally, widen the frame a little
- 49:51more. Recall the institutional purpose of the
- 49:55setting itself. This interaction is occurring
- 49:59within a system designed to resolve disputes,
- 50:03maintain public order, and allow competing interests
- 50:06to be addressed through law rather than escalation.
- 50:12When we widen the frame like this, our perception
- 50:14often becomes less reactive and more proportional.
- 50:18We can see the situation with greater clarity,
- 50:21and then all of a sudden the range of possible
- 50:24responses start to expand and become broader.
- 50:32A traditional compassion practice that illustrates
- 50:34this orientation is loving -kindness meditation,
- 50:37often referred to as Metta in Buddhist circles
- 50:40and meditation circles. Practices such as focus
- 50:45attention reveal something humbling about our
- 50:48own minds. With even a few minutes of quiet observation,
- 50:53it becomes clear how quickly our attention jumps,
- 50:56how rapidly interpretations form, and how often
- 50:59reactions arise before we've even had a chance
- 51:02to abandon them. So much of our mental life actually
- 51:05unfolds automatically, and then we're frequently
- 51:08carried by it without noticing. Seeing this more
- 51:13clearly can change how we view other people,
- 51:15not just ourselves. When we recognize how messy
- 51:18and reactive our own minds can be, It becomes
- 51:21easier to understand that other people are often
- 51:24operating under the same conditions, responding
- 51:26to pressure, habits, and interpretations in ways
- 51:30that they may not actually be able to fully see
- 51:33themselves. In Buddhist traditions, loving -kindness
- 51:37meditation developed as a way of deliberately
- 51:39strengthening this broader orientation toward
- 51:41others. The practice trains the mind toward goodwill
- 51:45and non -hostility. It's not about manufacturing
- 51:50an emotion but cultivating a stance that counterbalances
- 51:53the mind's tendency to interpret others primarily
- 51:56through threat, grievance, or competition. The
- 52:01practice begins by extending goodwill towards
- 52:03oneself and then gradually widening that circle
- 52:06to include others. The premise is simple. All
- 52:13of us are navigating pressures, habits, and our
- 52:16own limitations. When goodwill is present, people
- 52:21tend to act closer to their values and intentions
- 52:23than when they're operating from fear, resentment,
- 52:26and defensiveness. So over time, when goodwill
- 52:32becomes part of the mind's baseline orientation,
- 52:36resentment and hostility have less opportunity
- 52:38to dominate the way we interpret. Empathy becomes
- 52:44easier because the mind is less quick to assume.
- 52:46that others are acting out of malice rather than
- 52:49their own pressures, habits, and blind spots.
- 52:53So we'll finish with this practice. And for this
- 53:01one, it's really important that you sit comfortably.
- 53:03So stretch, move your shoulders, release some
- 53:06tension. Make sure you're feeling very comfortable
- 53:10and relaxed. It can also help to put your hand
- 53:17on your heart. This helps encourage the release
- 53:22of oxytocin. So sit comfortably and begin with
- 53:33yourself. And you bring attention to your own
- 53:37well -being. And we begin here. because goodwill
- 53:42towards others is really difficult to sustain
- 53:45when our own relationship to ourself is primarily
- 53:50harsh or punitive. So it's important to start
- 53:53with goodwill for ourselves. And you just silently
- 53:58offer yourself some natural good wishes, thoughts
- 54:05of goodwill, loving friendship and kindness and
- 54:09compassion. May I be safe. May I be healthy.
- 54:17May I experience well -being. May I be free from
- 54:21suffering and experience peace and allowing that
- 54:30goodwill to settle, small kindling, that you
- 54:37can continue to grow. And next, bring someone
- 54:45to your mind who you love very, very easily,
- 54:50who you love unconditionally, so easily. A friend,
- 54:56a family member, someone who has supported you
- 55:00and who you know also loves you, and offer the
- 55:05same goodwill to them. May you be safe. May you
- 55:11be healthy. May you experience well -being. May
- 55:18you be free from suffering. And experience peace
- 55:23and joy. And from here, expand to a neutral person.
- 55:34May be colleagues you don't know, people you
- 55:36pass on your commute. And offer the same good
- 55:40wishes. May you be safe. May you be healthy and
- 55:45happy. May experience well -being and be free
- 55:49from suffering. And then, if it comes naturally
- 55:58to you, don't force it, but if it comes naturally
- 56:01to you, you can extend your goodwill to someone
- 56:04who's been difficult, someone who may have harmed
- 56:07you. You don't have to force any affection. It's
- 56:16about recognizing the humanity of this other
- 56:18person. That they will also be of benefit to
- 56:24the world if they feel peace and goodwill. So
- 56:30offer the same wishes. May you be safe. May you
- 56:35be healthy. May you experience well -being. May
- 56:41you be peaceful. And then expand out in all directions,
- 56:48infinitely. Your goodwill is not a limited resource.
- 56:54It is not a zero -sum game. There is an infinite
- 56:56resource of goodwill that you can draw upon.
- 57:01And extend it to all beings everywhere. May all
- 57:05beings be safe. May all beings be healthy. May
- 57:12all beings experience well -being. May all beings
- 57:16be peaceful. So we do this practice because it
- 57:32doesn't mean we have to surrender any position
- 57:35or weaken our advocacy we're cultivating an orientation
- 57:40in which we see people clearly as human beings
- 57:44of equal dignity who are also working within
- 57:50shared systems and that they're not obstacles
- 57:54or enemies. So to close, I'll just summarize
- 58:01what we talked about. The thread really is about
- 58:06professional agency, as I said, attention and
- 58:08judgment as disciplines that can be trained.
- 58:11And that training is a form of freedom of mind.
- 58:17Our work is cognitively demanding and socially
- 58:20pressurized. Our profession tends to reward urgency,
- 58:25certainty, acts of performance of control. Under
- 58:33these conditions our mind is going to do what
- 58:35minds tend to do. Interpret quickly, rehearse,
- 58:38defend, go over narratives. The practices we
- 58:43explored today are small ways of interrupting
- 58:45that momentum. 4 -7 -8 breathing provides a simple
- 58:50way to calm down our physiology. Others train
- 58:58attention itself. We do focus attention meditation
- 59:04to notice when our mind has been captured and
- 59:07to return it to the object of our focus. Labeling
- 59:11makes that mental activity very visible and disarms
- 59:17those thoughts and feelings. Stoke practices
- 59:22help us recall our role and reconnect our conduct
- 59:30with the responsibility. that we're supposed
- 59:32to be delivering. The dichotomy of control clarifies
- 59:39where our effort is effective and where attention
- 59:42can be released. And then the final practices
- 59:45widen our perception. Expanding the frame brings
- 59:52into view the pressure shaping the other person's
- 59:55conduct and the institutional purpose of the
- 59:58setting itself. And meta cultivates a stance
- 1:00:02of goodwill that prevents professional disagreements
- 1:00:04from collapsing into hostility or grievance.
- 1:00:09So mindfulness practice makes these movements
- 1:00:11of the mind much more visible. Thought appears
- 1:00:14as a thought, emotions appear as emotion. Stoic
- 1:00:17practices adds deliberate examination of judgment
- 1:00:20at the moment it's forming and reconnects conduct
- 1:00:23with our roles and responsibilities. And the
- 1:00:26compassion widens the frame further by reminding
- 1:00:29us that the people we encounter are also operating
- 1:00:32under constraints and pressures. Agency is about
- 1:00:39the capacity to regain authorship in the middle
- 1:00:41of activation. And when we do these practices
- 1:00:47on a regular basis, our minds become less governed
- 1:00:49by their own momentum and more capable of choosing
- 1:00:53how to proceed. And these practices are also
- 1:00:58where a more stable, enduring form of joy and
- 1:01:01well -being can emerge in our lives. The experience
- 1:01:04of inhabiting this work with greater steadiness,
- 1:01:08in line with our own values, in a way that helps
- 1:01:10us grow as people, rather than being continually
- 1:01:14carried away by its pressure. So that's the end
- 1:01:18of my presentation. Thank you very much. And
- 1:01:22if you want to contact, whoopsie, didn't mean
- 1:01:25to do that. If you would like to contact me,
- 1:01:29please feel free to reach out to me, and I included
- 1:01:31these resources in the handout as well. Thank
- 1:01:35you, Emily. I appreciate that. It's always a
- 1:01:39pleasure to see you and to experience your knowledge.
- 1:01:44I hope that everyone who was here and everyone
- 1:01:47who watches this on the recording benefits from
- 1:01:51this and takes you up on that offer. I can only
- 1:01:54speak from my own experience, but the my mindfulness
- 1:01:59practice, my meditation practice, and the 4 -6
- 1:02:02breathing or 6 -8 breathing, whichever way you
- 1:02:06do it, has been helpful. I would encourage people.
- 1:02:12One of our other speakers said, oh, you can do
- 1:02:15that like four or five times. Four or five minutes,
- 1:02:17I think, is sort of a minimum for that. It is
- 1:02:21kind of one of those things that you're doing
- 1:02:24it. Is this really working? Is this really working?
- 1:02:27Oh, oh, I feel better. Max, thank you for being
- 1:02:33here. And Max, reach out to me. I'd love to talk
- 1:02:38to you about being on our committee. And with
- 1:02:42that, thank you so much, Emily. Have a lovely
- 1:02:44week. Everybody else have a lovely week and be
- 1:02:46well. Thank you.