Latest / Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer Podcasts / Commercial litigation EP39: General update
Transcript
- 0:09SPEAKER_02: Hello and welcome to the latest episode in our series of commercial litigation update podcasts.
- 0:13SPEAKER_02: I'm Mora Mackintosh and I'm a knowledge counsel in the firm's commercial litigation team in London.
- 0:18SPEAKER_02: Today I'm joined by Dispute's partner Alex Audie.
- 0:21SPEAKER_00: Hello Maura, thanks for having me on the podcast.
- 0:24SPEAKER_02: And I'm also joined by James Robson, who is an of counsel in our commercial litigation team.
- 0:29SPEAKER_01: Hi.
- 0:30SPEAKER_02: In this episode, after a couple of quick updates, I'm going to cover an interesting decision on privilege and company directors, particularly where the directors are wearing more than one hat.
- 0:41SPEAKER_02: Then Alex will tell us about some important client resources on ADR.
- 0:45SPEAKER_02: And finally, James is going to outline a couple of significant contract law decisions.
- 0:49SPEAKER_02: First, on termination and the recovery of loss of bargain damages, and then on force measure.
- 0:56SPEAKER_02: So starting with the quick updates, first I want to note that the third edition of our textbook, Class Actions in England and Wales, is hot off the presses.
- 1:04SPEAKER_02: It's been fully updated to reflect developments since our second edition was published in 2022.
- 1:09SPEAKER_02: And trust me, there have been a lot of relevant court decisions in those four years.
- 1:13SPEAKER_02: Previous editions of the textbook have been cited in various judgments, including two from the Supreme Court.
- 1:19SPEAKER_02: And I hope the third edition will prove to be a useful resource for both clients and practitioners.
- 1:26SPEAKER_02: Secondly, in our last podcast at the beginning of July, I mentioned that there would be a new business and property division of the High Court, which was going to encompass the Chancery Division, Commercial Court, Technology and Construction Court, and Financial List.
- 1:39SPEAKER_02: In other words, all of the courts that sit in the Rolls Building and have for some time been operating under the umbrella of the business and property courts, but have formed part of different divisions.
- 1:49SPEAKER_02: The timing was slightly uncertain at that point, but it's now clear that the new division is going live imminently from the start of the new term on the 1st of October, which may in fact have arrived by the time some of you are listening to this podcast.
- 2:02SPEAKER_02: It will be led by a new president of the business and property division.
- 2:06SPEAKER_02: The current Chancellor, Sir Colin Burse, is going to have that role initially, but only for a month, as he is to become the new Master of the Roles on the retirement of Sir Geoffrey Voss at the end of October.
- 2:17SPEAKER_02: So we'll have to wait and see who's appointed.
- 2:21SPEAKER_02: In a recent speech, Sir Colin explained a bit about what the new division would mean.
- 2:26SPEAKER_02: And it seems that there won't be a lot of dramatic changes for court users initially, but he did say he could see a case for a radical streamlining of the court guides, which I think would be very good news for litigating parties.
- 2:38SPEAKER_02: So then, the case I mentioned on privilege, which I'll just refer to as Curve OS Group, this was an unfair prejudice petition brought against Curve by a venture capital fund that had a shareholding in it.
- 2:51SPEAKER_02: The company brought an application to resolve the question of whether privilege had been waived in certain of its documents that were in the possession of the petitioners, if it were privileged in the first place, which was assumed for these purposes.
- 3:03SPEAKER_02: Under a subscription and shareholders agreement, the petitioners had been entitled to appoint an investor director to the company, and they had appointed a Mr.
- 3:12SPEAKER_02: Aitkenhead, who was also managing director of one of the companies comprising the petitioners.
- 3:18SPEAKER_02: So he wore two hats as director of both the company and the investor, and of course, that's not unusual in that context.
- 3:27SPEAKER_02: The main issue in the case related to documents which had been provided by the company to Mr.
- 3:31SPEAKER_02: Aikenhead while he was a director.
- 3:34SPEAKER_02: And the court confirmed, unsurprisingly, I think, that disclosure of a company's privileged material to a director in that capacity does not affect the privilege.
- 3:42SPEAKER_02: To the extent that Mr.
- 3:44SPEAKER_02: Aikenhead received the company's privileged material as a director, including as investor director, he did so as the company's agent and had a duty to protect the company's privilege unless the company itself had given him clear authority to waive it.
- 3:57SPEAKER_02: It made no difference that some of the documents had been sent to Mr.
- 4:00SPEAKER_02: Aikenhead at an email address on the petitioner's server, so that in theory they were accessible by the petitioners.
- 4:06SPEAKER_02: That didn't amount to a waiver of privilege, the court said.
- 4:11SPEAKER_02: But the petitioners relied on a provision in the shareholders' agreement to the effect that an investor director would be at liberty to make full disclosure to its appointing director of any information relating to the company unless the board determined that disclosure would conflict with the company's interest.
- 4:27SPEAKER_02: Now, on the face of it, that provision looks quite broad.
- 4:30SPEAKER_02: It appears to enable the investor director to disclose any of the company's information to the petitioners, including privileged material.
- 4:39SPEAKER_02: But the court said that would oversimplify what is a rather more complex legal environment.
- 4:44SPEAKER_02: In particular, the shareholders' agreement could not and did not purport to derogate from the duties that the investor directors owed to the company, which included protecting the company's privilege, unless the company had made a decision to waive that privilege.
- 4:59SPEAKER_02: So the upshot was that Mr.
- 5:00SPEAKER_02: Aikenhead was not entitled to disclose the company's privilege material unless that was consistent with his duty to the company, and the company expressly authorised him to do so, and there was no indication of that in this case.
- 5:13SPEAKER_02: I think this is quite an important decision for investor-appointed directors.
- 5:18SPEAKER_02: It suggests that even where a shareholders' agreement contains broad information sharing rights, those rights will not readily be construed as extending to the company's privileged material.
- 5:29SPEAKER_02: And so investor directors should think carefully before disclosing that privileged material to their appointing investor and make sure they have clear authority to do so.
- 5:39SPEAKER_02: It also means that where parties intend information sharing rights to include privileged material, it would probably be wise to spell that out, particularly when it comes to information sharing by directors, given the duties that come into play in that context.
- 5:52SPEAKER_02: But I suggest it would be wise in other contexts as well.
- 5:58SPEAKER_02: So turning to you, Alex, I understand that you and the team have just relaunched the firm's series of ADR practical guides together with a toolkit on improving conflict management through ADR.
- 6:09SPEAKER_02: Before we get into the detail, can you tell us broadly what these resources are and who they're for?
- 6:14SPEAKER_00: Of course.
- 6:15SPEAKER_00: So starting with the guides, these each cover a distinct aspect of alternative dispute resolution.
- 6:21SPEAKER_00: We begin with an overview of the most commonly used ADR processes, move through practical stages of mediation, and then finish with specialist contexts, employment, arbitration, and resolving tax disputes with HMRC.
- 6:33SPEAKER_00: The toolkit sits alongside the guides.
- 6:36SPEAKER_00: It's designed to help organizations embed a systematic approach to ADR across their operations because mediation works best when there is business buy-in, and this isn't always easy to achieve in the cut and thrust of a dispute.
- 6:49SPEAKER_00: The whole package is designed to give in-house counsel and senior executives a complete practical framework for making better use of ADR.
- 6:58SPEAKER_02: Thanks.
- 6:58SPEAKER_02: So I'm aware these guides were first published ten years ago.
- 7:02SPEAKER_02: What prompted the decision to update them now?
- 7:05SPEAKER_00: Well, a lot has changed in ten years.
- 7:07SPEAKER_00: When we first published the guides, ADR and particularly mediation was obviously already a very important part of how commercial disputes should be managed.
- 7:15SPEAKER_00: Since then, the landscape has shifted further towards ADR.
- 7:19SPEAKER_00: English courts are now able not just to encourage, but actually to order parties to mediate.
- 7:24SPEAKER_00: And we're seeing the same kind of enthusiasm for mediation reflected internationally, including with the Singapore Convention dealing with the enforcement of mediated settlements.
- 7:34SPEAKER_00: In many jurisdictions around the world, the driver is because of pressure on the court systems due to high caseloads.
- 7:40SPEAKER_00: But ultimately, businesses are also under pressure to resolve disputes faster, more cost-effectively, and with less disruption.
- 7:47SPEAKER_00: Against this backdrop, the time felt right to bring everything up to date and give people the tools they need.
- 7:54SPEAKER_02: Right, no, I can see that.
- 7:55SPEAKER_02: The guides cover a lot of ground.
- 7:58SPEAKER_02: Can you share some of the top practical takeaways that cut across the series?
- 8:02SPEAKER_00: Absolutely.
- 8:03SPEAKER_00: If I had to distill the guides down to a handful of things that really make a difference, the first would be to keep an open mind, not just to the idea of mediating, but also to the process itself and the different forms a successful mediation might take.
- 8:17SPEAKER_00: After all, it's just a structured negotiation, so it's flexible.
- 8:21SPEAKER_00: And this is a chance for tech for the parties to take control of the process and shape the result.
- 8:26SPEAKER_00: Second, don't rush selecting a mediator.
- 8:28SPEAKER_00: They play a critical role in the process, and the exercise of identifying suitable candidates can take some time.
- 8:34SPEAKER_00: When you're identifying possible candidates, consult a range of sources and think about the mediation style, practical experience, and subject matter knowledge that would be most helpful to the matter in dispute.
- 8:46SPEAKER_00: And finally, preparation.
- 8:47SPEAKER_00: The work that parties do before a mediation is often the most important part of the process, and the quality of preparation is often what makes the difference between mediations that succeed and those that don't.
- 8:59SPEAKER_00: That means not just thinking about what materials to provide and what you're going to say on the day, but also thinking carefully about who attends and what a realistic outcome looks like.
- 9:10SPEAKER_02: So you mentioned the importance of embedding ADR as part of an organization's culture.
- 9:15SPEAKER_02: What's the business case for doing that?
- 9:17SPEAKER_00: Well, the most obvious benefit is cost.
- 9:19SPEAKER_00: Mediations typically resolve disputes at a fraction of the cost of litigation or arbitration.
- 9:24SPEAKER_00: And the savings can be very significant when you look at them across a portfolio of disputes.
- 9:29SPEAKER_00: But of course, there's also the saving and management time, speed of resolution, and the preservation of commercial relationships where that is possible.
- 9:36SPEAKER_00: Being involved in a dispute can also be stressful.
- 9:39SPEAKER_00: Some of these things are hard to put a price on, but they all have a real value.
- 9:43SPEAKER_02: And is that where the toolkit fits in then?
- 9:45SPEAKER_00: Yeah, exactly.
- 9:46SPEAKER_00: The idea behind the toolkit is for in-house counsel to take a step back from individual disputes and focus on the bigger picture.
- 9:53SPEAKER_00: It covers a number of key areas.
- 9:56SPEAKER_00: For example, conducting an ADR audit, by which I mean examining the type and frequency of disputes that a particular organization faces, the costs and the ADR capability of the in-house legal team.
- 10:08SPEAKER_00: Then it looks at designating an ADR lead, effectively a senior in-house counsel to champion the organization's efforts.
- 10:15SPEAKER_00: And there are also sections on early case assessment, training and education, and how to engage stakeholders.
- 10:21SPEAKER_00: Because having a senior management ADR sponsor can be a real game changer.
- 10:25SPEAKER_00: In a world where AI and technology developments are dominating the conversation, it's worth remembering that companies that focus on managing their disputes docket using ADR processes consistently and effectively are likely to make greater savings of costs and time.
- 10:41SPEAKER_02: Great.
- 10:42SPEAKER_02: And where can people find all of these materials?
- 10:45SPEAKER_00: Everything's available on the Herbert Smith Free Hills Kramer ADR Notes blog.
- 10:50SPEAKER_00: I'd encourage everyone to explore the full set of guides and the toolkit.
- 10:53SPEAKER_00: And if you'd like to discuss how we can help your organization make better use of ADR, please get in touch with me, Camilla McPherson, or your usual Herbert Smith Free Hills-Kramer contact.
- 11:03SPEAKER_02: Thanks, Alex.
- 11:05SPEAKER_02: We will put a link to the materials in the show notes too.
- 11:07SPEAKER_02: It's a fantastic set of resources and well worth exploring.
- 11:11SPEAKER_00: Thanks very much, Maura.
- 11:13SPEAKER_02: So then finally, James, let's look at the contract law cases I mentioned earlier.
- 11:17SPEAKER_02: So the first is a Supreme Court decision, Great Asia Maritime and Orion shipping and trading.
- 11:23SPEAKER_02: Can you give us some background on that?
- 11:26SPEAKER_01: Of course.
- 11:27SPEAKER_01: This is an interesting case about a point that comes up quite often in practice, in my experience.
- 11:33SPEAKER_01: And the point is this: that what damages is an innocent party entitled to if it terminates a contract in reliance on a contractual termination right, but there has been no repudiatory breach.
- 11:47SPEAKER_01: And the case itself arose out of an agreement for the sale of a vessel using a standard industry contract called the Norwegian sale form.
- 11:56SPEAKER_01: Clause 14 of that contract gave the buyers a right to cancel or to terminate, essentially, if the sellers failed to give notice of readiness for delivery by a particular date.
- 12:07SPEAKER_01: And the clause also required the sellers, if that happened, to pay due compensation, those are the words used, for their loss and for all expenses, if the seller's failure was due to proven negligence.
- 12:23SPEAKER_01: Okay, so that was the contract.
- 12:25SPEAKER_01: What happened in fact is that the sellers did fail to give notice by the relevant date.
- 12:30SPEAKER_01: So the buyers terminated and claimed their loss under clause 14.
- 12:34SPEAKER_01: Now the interesting point here, and I I think the reason this uh went uh all the way up to the Supreme Court, is that at the point of termination, the market value of the vessel had risen by almost two million dollars.
- 12:47SPEAKER_01: So if the buyers were to go into the market to try to obtain a replacement contract, it would essentially cost them two million dollars more to do so.
- 12:57SPEAKER_01: And the buyers claimed that that difference in damages, that two million dollars, uh which they said represented their loss of bargain.
- 13:06SPEAKER_02: And so how did they get on with that?
- 13:09SPEAKER_01: Well, it started with an arbitration and it ended up in a supreme court.
- 13:12SPEAKER_01: So there's a bit of history here, but I'll start with the tribunal.
- 13:17SPEAKER_01: So the the the arbitration tribunal held that the sellers were not in repudiatory breach, and that was an important finding, but that their failure was due to proven negligence, and the tribunal awarded the buyers uh loss of bargaining damages.
- 13:32SPEAKER_01: The high court then overturned that decision.
- 13:34SPEAKER_01: The the Court of Appeal reversed the High Court and reinstated the original ward.
- 13:40SPEAKER_01: Uh so the buyers at that point, after the Court of Appeal decision, were recovering their$2 million.
- 13:48SPEAKER_01: The sellers then appealed to the Supreme Court, and they argued that the buyers were not entitled to the loss of bargain damages because the arbitrators had found that the sellers were not in repudiatory breach, and there had been no challenge along the way to that finding.
- 14:04SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 14:05SPEAKER_02: So the sellers then were arguing that loss of bargain damages are only available where there's a repudiatory breach and not where there's termination under an express contractual provision, but but no repudiator breach.
- 14:17SPEAKER_02: Is that is that right?
- 14:18SPEAKER_01: Yep, that's absolutely right.
- 14:20SPEAKER_01: And the sellers, in making their arguments, relied on a Court of Appeal decision called financing's uh limited and bulldock, which is from 1963.
- 14:29SPEAKER_01: And in that case, the Court of Appeal held that a party exercising a contractual determination right there under a uh a higher purchase agreement was not entitled to loss of bargain damages where there was no repudiatory breach.
- 14:45SPEAKER_02: Right, but I I understand financing has had a rather bumpy ride over the years, hasn't it?
- 14:50SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it has, and this was pointed out by the Supreme Court.
- 14:54SPEAKER_01: It it has not been followed by the Canadian courts, for example, and has been the subject of judicial and academic criticism here too.
- 15:03SPEAKER_02: So how did the sellers' reliance on financing play out in this case then?
- 15:07SPEAKER_01: Yeah, so the sellers here were arguing for what they called a causation principle that they said could be derived from financing.
- 15:16SPEAKER_01: And that principle was this, that where a party terminates under an express termination clause without a repudiatory breach, it is the party's own decision to terminate rather than the breach itself, it is the effective cause of the loss of bargain.
- 15:33SPEAKER_01: And so damages to compensate for the loss of bargain should not be awarded.
- 15:40SPEAKER_01: Now the Supreme Court in their judgment expressed some skepticism about that.
- 15:46SPEAKER_01: They pointed out that even in the repudiatory breach situation, the contract does not automatically terminate.
- 15:54SPEAKER_01: The innocent party still has to choose whether to accept the repudiation or to affirm the contract.
- 16:00SPEAKER_01: So there, the innocent party's choice is just as much a cause of loss in that scenario, as it is when they decide to invoke a contractual right to terminate.
- 16:15SPEAKER_01: Putting that to one side, even assuming this so-called causation principle that does in fact exist, um and it means you can't ordinarily get loss of bargain damages where you terminate under an express termination clause absolute refutatory breach.
- 16:33SPEAKER_01: The short point was that the principle would not apply in this case.
- 16:38SPEAKER_01: As the Supreme Court pointed out, clause 14 was not only an express termination clause, but was also an express compensation clause.
- 16:47SPEAKER_01: And I uh uh referred to some of the key parts from the clause earlier.
- 16:53SPEAKER_01: The wording of you know the references to due compensation and the references to the seller's loss, the Supreme Court said was broad enough to cover loss of bargain damages.
- 17:06SPEAKER_01: And in fact, the Supreme Court said loss of bargain was the most obvious form of loss that the buyers would suffer if there was a termination.
- 17:14SPEAKER_01: And if they weren't covered, it was hard to see what loss would be.
- 17:19SPEAKER_01: And so the buyers in the end were awarded the two million dollars as damages.
- 17:27SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 17:27SPEAKER_02: So what are the practical lessons for commercial parties that you'd say come out of this case then?
- 17:33SPEAKER_01: This is the point that comes up quite often in practice, I think.
- 17:37SPEAKER_01: Parties which are considering whether to terminate for non-reputatory breach in reliance on a contractual termination, right, will need to think really carefully about the damages that they will be entitled to.
- 17:50SPEAKER_01: And in particular, whether they will be entitled to loss of bargain damages, which are often the most significant damages that are claimed, particularly where there's no express compensation clause which addresses the point.
- 18:05SPEAKER_01: And and I think the lessons for parties negotiating contracts is whether they want to consider including express words, which clarify not only when they will be entitled to exercise a contractual termination, right?
- 18:21SPEAKER_01: But also if they do, when or whether loss of bargain damages will be recoverable.
- 18:29SPEAKER_02: Really helpful.
- 18:30SPEAKER_02: Thank you.
- 18:30SPEAKER_02: So let's move on to the second case, ADM Industries and INECO, which is a high court decision about force majeure and specifically the meaning of the word unforeseeable in a force majeure clause.
- 18:41SPEAKER_02: Now, some of our audience may have listened to the special edition of this podcast on force majeure that we released back in June.
- 18:47SPEAKER_02: And I remember from that that unforeseeability isn't always a requirement for claiming force majeure, though the two tend to go hand in hand since something that's foreseeable is more likely to be in the party's control and therefore, you know, out with a force majeure definition.
- 19:05SPEAKER_02: But in this case, I think there was an express reference to unforeseeability in the force majeure clause.
- 19:11SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that's right.
- 19:12SPEAKER_01: This case concerned a contract for the sale of Ukrainian corn between the defendant seller and the claimant buyer.
- 19:19SPEAKER_01: And it contained uh a force majeure clause which listed uh various possible events, including, and this was the language, unforeseeable and unavoidable impediments to transportation or navigation.
- 19:35SPEAKER_01: Okay, what happened was that after Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, all vessels entering the Black Sea for the purposes of loading grain had to be inspected.
- 19:44SPEAKER_01: And while the vessel that was nominated by the seller to carry this particular consignment of a corn was waiting for that to happen, inspections unexpectedly ceased for all inbound non-Russian vessels.
- 19:59SPEAKER_01: And inspections were halted for 11 days, which meant the seller could not deliver the corn in time.
- 20:05SPEAKER_02: Right, so the seller invoked force major.
- 20:07SPEAKER_01: Yeah, absolutely, which the buyer then challenged, including on the basis that the event, the suspension of inspections, was not unforeseeable.
- 20:17SPEAKER_01: It argued that foreseeable simply means something that can be foreseen, even if it is extremely unlikely ever to occur.
- 20:26SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 20:26SPEAKER_02: So that means the bar for unforeseeability would be very high, making it harder to invoke invoke force measure in that case.
- 20:34SPEAKER_01: Yeah, exactly.
- 20:35SPEAKER_01: But the court disagreed.
- 20:38SPEAKER_01: It noted that words like unforeseeable or foreseeable have a range of different connotations and take colour from their call their context.
- 20:48SPEAKER_01: And the court said looking at the purpose of this particular clause, it was to cater for events that were so unlikely to occur and affect performance that the parties could not be expected to have allocated the risk of that event exclusively to the seller.
- 21:05SPEAKER_01: So that did not mean they had to be events that no one could ever imagine happening at all.
- 21:12SPEAKER_01: And the court in its decision look looked at the other force measure events that were listed in the clause, and they included things like blockade and strikes.
- 21:22SPEAKER_01: And those are rare, they're unpredictable, but they aren't unforeseeable in the very narrow sense that the buyer proposed.
- 21:32SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 21:33SPEAKER_02: And so was the event in question in this case, the suspension of inspections, was that unforeseeable in the in the court's view?
- 21:41SPEAKER_01: Yeah, this particular event was a short stoppage of inspections for a day or two, that might well be foreseeable.
- 21:50SPEAKER_01: But this was uh a suspension for 11 days, and a prolonged suspension like that was of negligible probability and was therefore unforeseeable.
- 22:02SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 22:03SPEAKER_02: So the seller then could rely on force measure in this case.
- 22:06SPEAKER_01: Well, uh maybe is the answer to that.
- 22:10SPEAKER_01: There were notification provisions in the contract, and the high court said that these were a conditioned precedent to claiming FM.
- 22:18SPEAKER_01: And there remains an outstanding issue as to whether those notification provisions were complied with.
- 22:25SPEAKER_01: And whether notice was given in time turns on precisely when the force measure event commenced.
- 22:32SPEAKER_01: Was it when the inspections were suspended?
- 22:35SPEAKER_01: Or was it only when the length of the suspension became unforeseeable?
- 22:41SPEAKER_01: And there was no finding on that.
- 22:44SPEAKER_01: So it was remitted back to the arbitrators because this was another case that was originally dealt with by way of arbitration.
- 22:52SPEAKER_02: Oh, interesting, thanks.
- 22:54SPEAKER_02: Um so what lessons then would you draw from this case?
- 22:58SPEAKER_01: I think there are two main messages that I would take away.
- 23:01SPEAKER_01: First, terms like foreseeable or unforeseeability in a force majeure clause will always be construed by reference to their context and not simply um as abstract expressions.
- 23:19SPEAKER_01: And secondly, if you want to invoke force majeure, you must comply with the notice provisions.
- 23:24SPEAKER_01: That is something that is always said, the advice that we give at this case illustrates the potential risks if you don't do so.
- 23:34SPEAKER_02: Thanks, James.
- 23:35SPEAKER_02: That all sounds like very sound advice.
- 23:38SPEAKER_02: So that brings us to the end of the podcast.
- 23:41SPEAKER_02: So I just want to say thank you to Alex and James, and of course, to all of you for listening.
- 23:45SPEAKER_02: We will be back with another update in a couple of months.