Latest / Politics with Paul / When is it Appropriate to "Talk About Politics"? | Politics with Paul #110
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today, we're going to be discussing when is it appropriate to talk about politics.
- 0:15When we're being socialized growing up, and even when we become adults, we're often told
- 0:21not to talk about two things, politics and religion.
- 0:25That it's impolite to talk about those things, that they're just too divisive of topics, and
- 0:30they'll cause issues if we do discuss them.
- 0:33And it's easy to accept that idea when you see how toxic just about any conversation about
- 0:39politics or religion can be.
- 0:42Now, of course, this podcast is not about religion, so we won't get into that.
- 0:46But is it true that we should generally avoid talking about politics with other people?
- 0:53I've had a couple of previous guests on this podcast propose that maybe this attitude of
- 0:59avoiding political discussions has been a contributor to the toxicity that we see today,
- 1:05that not knowing how to talk about politics has led to people not being able to have a real
- 1:11discussion, not being able to see how and why other people think the way they do.
- 1:17And I hadn't quite thought about this issue of toxicity and polarization from that angle
- 1:22before.
- 1:23And I think there is something to that notion of just how we haven't really taught people how
- 1:28to talk about politics versus this idea that we should just not talk about politics at all.
- 1:34But at the same time, there is a time and place for everything.
- 1:38Just like how we shouldn't always avoid political talk and policy talk, there is that
- 1:44other extreme of people bringing up politics sometimes unprompted so that they can
- 1:50congratulate themselves for supposedly figuring everything out for having the, quote, unquote,
- 1:54correct ideas.
- 1:56So the better question is not whether we should or shouldn't avoid talking politics, but asking
- 2:04when and where we should talk about politics.
- 2:08It's a much more normative and philosophical discussion than we usually have here, but you
- 2:15need both philosophy and practicality.
- 2:17So let's further explore this question of when and where is it appropriate to talk about
- 2:23politics.
- 2:25But first, we have to acknowledge that some people will just refuse to talk about politics
- 2:30in every or nearly every circumstance.
- 2:34It's not everybody wants to open up about it, and it's for various reasons, and we need to
- 2:39understand the reasons why people do that.
- 2:42Most people should and need to be able to discuss politics because of how important it
- 2:47is, but we should also be careful not to force people to do it either.
- 2:52That's part of those First Amendment rights of you know, when it comes to freedom of speech
- 2:58and to petition your government and so on and so forth.
- 3:03You also don't have to do those things if you don't want to.
- 3:08Doesn't mean that you shouldn't or that you should stay silent, but you can if you want.
- 3:15You can stay on the sidelines if you want.
- 3:17Although, a lot of times, that's not the better option, but we'll get into that shortly.
- 3:23But you have to think about the reasons that people don't wanna talk about politics
- 3:26regardless of whether you think it's valid or not.
- 3:29And one of those big things is apathy.
- 3:31A lot of people just do not care about it.
- 3:34They don't see its relevance to their life, or they have some other reason that they don't
- 3:38care.
- 3:39And I've had several guests on this podcast talk about it previously.
- 3:43I've talked about it on my own previously, but such guests such as Shaka Mitchell talking
- 3:48about political apathy, Travis Taylor, who I had a couple of episodes ago.
- 3:52Shaka Mitchell was, I think, I wanna say episode 51.
- 3:56So he was a he's a while ago, but not just them.
- 3:59Other guests have brought it up too.
- 4:01This this problem of political apathy that pervades American politics.
- 4:06We do have a lot of people that just don't really want to invest themselves for one reason
- 4:11or another.
- 4:12And one of those reasons that they don't want to invest in it and why they don't wanna talk
- 4:17about politics is because they're just swamped with other things going on in their life.
- 4:22It's not like us who were involved in this kind of thing for a living or we really just
- 4:28thoroughly enjoy politics or we're just very interested in it.
- 4:33Some people may want to do that, but they've just got all these other things going on in
- 4:37life, and they're they have jobs that are completely outside of at least the normal
- 4:43consider what you would normally consider to be a political job because as we'll talk about
- 4:48surely, politics isn't just about everything.
- 4:51But some people have a significant other.
- 4:55They have a spouse.
- 4:55They have kids that they have to take care of.
- 4:59They have family members that might be sick at a given point in time or just they they're just
- 5:06struggling economically in general, and they're and, of course, politics has a lot to do with
- 5:11that, but the their economic situation may just take up so much of their time that they don't
- 5:18really have the means or the emotional capacity to deal with politics, at least to talk about
- 5:28politics more.
- 5:29Another reason that people won't talk about politics is that they fear pushback or even
- 5:35violence.
- 5:36Some people really do want to learn more, and they have the capacity to learn more, but
- 5:42they're just afraid of any sort of retribution for what they think, which is quite
- 5:49understandable because it seems like you can't voice any sort of opinion that might be even
- 5:54slightly different than somebody else without somebody getting mad at you.
- 5:57Sometimes a real person, sometimes a bot on the Internet, but that's it's it's something that
- 6:03is a reasonable thing to be concerned about.
- 6:08And then lastly, there's that low political efficacy.
- 6:12And I can't remember the exact episode I had on it, but there was one episode I had about
- 6:17political efficacy, internal versus external.
- 6:21The internal being how much people know about politics and how much they think they know
- 6:26about politics, and the external, which is how much people can impact politics and how much
- 6:32they think they can impact politics.
- 6:35And both of those tend to be very low.
- 6:37Now, of course, if you talk to people who are a lot more polarized, who participate in politics
- 6:41and and or participate in politics a lot more, they tend to have much higher rates of
- 6:47efficacy.
- 6:47Now whether they actually know what they're talking about, they certainly think they know a
- 6:52lot more about what they're talking about, and they certainly have an outsized impact on the
- 6:56process.
- 6:56So there is still a high level of efficacy amongst those kinds of people.
- 7:01But for a lot of regular people, they do not feel that way.
- 7:05So part of this problem of not discussing politics involves addressing these problems.
- 7:11Why some people don't want to talk about politics?
- 7:14It's not like a lot of these people just have never encountered political topics before, and
- 7:20they're all of a sudden like, oh, politics.
- 7:21What is this thing?
- 7:22No.
- 7:23They have all these reasons why they don't wanna talk about politics, and we need to
- 7:29figure out how to address that.
- 7:30And you're not gonna get everybody to start thinking about policy issues and elections
- 7:37more.
- 7:37You're you're gonna get you can some people, it is possible to get them to start thinking about
- 7:42that more, but you're not gonna get everybody to start doing that, which is okay.
- 7:46You don't need everybody to start doing it.
- 7:48And to an extent, there it might actually be a good thing that some people don't get involved
- 7:55in it because of x, y, and z reasons.
- 7:58But problem is we have too many people that are sitting on the sidelines.
- 8:02We really need to make sure or do what we can to make fewer of those people sit on the
- 8:07sidelines.
- 8:08But in any case, there are definitely inappropriate places to talk about politics.
- 8:14There's no question about that.
- 8:16Any any time or place can be the wrong place or time to talk about politics if we don't know
- 8:23how to converse reasonably about it without getting enraged or even violent.
- 8:30Some instances, though, regardless are just they're just not right for the discussion of
- 8:36politics.
- 8:37I can tell you a couple of personal instances that I've had.
- 8:39I remember one time I was in the locker room after a workout, this older guy I don't even
- 8:45remember how, but he just started talking to me.
- 8:48It was just, okay.
- 8:49Whatever.
- 8:50But step kept going on and on, and then he brought up politics completely unprompted.
- 8:55And also his health issues is like, really didn't need to know about any of these things.
- 9:00And he was definitely a very one-sided person.
- 9:04Put it that way.
- 9:04I also remember another time where I was watching a spring football game for my
- 9:08undergraduate alma mater, University of South Florida Goebbels as a spring football game.
- 9:14I I can't remember if I was a student still at that point.
- 9:16I wanna say I was.
- 9:17And then this guy, it was should I say we scored a touchdown?
- 9:22Of course, we scored a touchdown.
- 9:23It's a spring football game.
- 9:24It's it's it's your team playing against itself, but there was a guy who talked to us or
- 9:30or just I don't even remember what exactly it was he said, but he started talking to us, and
- 9:36then he started shoehorning in something about young people and politics, and it was, like,
- 9:41clearly derisive.
- 9:42And I don't I don't even know how he even found a way to to shoehorn it in.
- 9:46So there's obviously a much more tactful way to go about it and also, you know, not just bring
- 9:54it up when nobody asked you to in a setting that is completely otherwise devoid of
- 10:01politics.
- 10:03And, of course, at work, it's often inappropriate too.
- 10:06Like, I I I do things outside of politics for work.
- 10:10I actually am a youth sports coach, and I I don't bring up any of my politics stuff unless
- 10:15somebody if somebody asks me what else I do outside of it, I might give a cursory like, I
- 10:21do a nonpartisan political podcast, and I do research and all sorts of things in a
- 10:26nonpartisan setting.
- 10:27Might say that, but otherwise, I don't really I don't bring it up.
- 10:30I don't go on about it.
- 10:32Now, obviously, that's not the same thing for a lot of other people, but in in work settings,
- 10:38typically, it's not wise to bring up politics because it's usually just going to lead to to
- 10:43problems.
- 10:44But part of that is people not really knowing how to discuss politics, which we'll get to in
- 10:53just a minute.
- 10:54But wanna talk a little bit more about some of the factors that influence when it's
- 10:58appropriate to talk about politics.
- 11:00Because, yes, there are some places where, like, it's it's definitely inappropriate to say
- 11:07anything about elections and policies and and so on.
- 11:10But there's also lots of subjectivity to when and where politics and policy are most proper
- 11:17to discuss.
- 11:18And so I wanna explore some of those circumstances that influence this.
- 11:21And, this is a lot of subjective opinion here too.
- 11:25I some of my takes on here might be completely different from your takes.
- 11:31That's okay.
- 11:31Maybe we can come up to a better understanding and and solution for these things this way.
- 11:38But what I I often think of I think the main factors to look at is the locations and the
- 11:45settings that you're gonna be talking about politics in, the time of the year that you're
- 11:49doing it, the specific election or policy topic that is at hand, and why you are talking about
- 11:57that election or policy topic.
- 12:00And depending on those factors and how you evaluate each one of them, it may make politics
- 12:07more appropriate or inappropriate to talk about.
- 12:11But in the case of locations and settings, politics may or may not naturally come up
- 12:16depending on what you're doing.
- 12:17Maybe it's you really are just having a long conversation with somebody.
- 12:20Somebody a a really deep conversation, and it does just happen to go to politics.
- 12:25And you may have a perfectly reasonable discussion.
- 12:29But does that change based on whether we're talking about work or whether we're talking
- 12:35about school, family events, working out at the gym, going on walks with your friends, going to
- 12:40the store?
- 12:41It's just looking at those settings alone.
- 12:44It's not necessarily easy to figure out when it is or is isn't appropriate to talk about
- 12:50politics.
- 12:50I know I just talked about work earlier and how a lot of times it's not it's not usually wise
- 12:55to talk about it there, but part of it is because we just don't know how to discuss it.
- 13:00But it might also be affected by the time of the year.
- 13:04Is it more appropriate to talk about politics when it's closer to election time or when it's
- 13:10not closer to election time?
- 13:11Because more people are paying attention at election time.
- 13:15Those of us who are junkies about this stuff, we're paying attention to it all the time.
- 13:19But most people, most voters are really only looking at it in the weeks leading up to a
- 13:25general election.
- 13:27A lot of them are not even participating in the primaries, and a lot of them are not
- 13:31participating in elections that are not the presidential.
- 13:34So we've got the midterms coming up right now.
- 13:36A lot of the people who are participating in 2024 are not gonna be participating in in 2026.
- 13:43So you have more people paying attention at election time.
- 13:46Okay.
- 13:46Well, then maybe it's more appropriate to talk about then because now more people are paying
- 13:50attention to it.
- 13:51Or election time is more heated, and it's gonna be harder to have a reasonable conversation.
- 13:57So will it then be more appropriate to have a political discussion months away from an
- 14:02election or months after an election has happened.
- 14:05And depending on where you live, you might have politics at other times of the year, like in a
- 14:11lot of local elections that happen in odd numbered years and earlier on in the year, like
- 14:17in April or May or June.
- 14:19So you might so then how does that affect the calculus of when it's appropriate to talk about
- 14:25politics?
- 14:27And politics is happening all the time, including when major legislation is being
- 14:31debated and voted on.
- 14:32It's not just about elections.
- 14:34So do these same considerations for talking about politics at election time then apply
- 14:38where you have a major bill like the protect college sports act that's going along going on
- 14:45right now in the in congress.
- 14:49Does it become more appropriate to talk about now because it's it's much more salient, or do
- 14:56we want to avoid it more until things calm down a bit?
- 15:02And when there's legislation that is not getting as much media attention is talk being
- 15:07talked about, do we start talking about politics more than because it'll be less likely
- 15:11to get heated?
- 15:13But sometimes, just because something is being is getting very emotionally charged doesn't
- 15:18mean we always shy away from it.
- 15:21We need to turn the temperature down, but we don't necessarily just outright escape it,
- 15:26which I think is a good segue into this next topic or this next factor to talk about when it
- 15:31comes to influencing the appropriateness of talking about politics.
- 15:35And that's the election or policy topic that is at hand.
- 15:38Obviously, right now, we don't we don't have a presidential election this year, but the last
- 15:44however many presidential elections you want to to use as examples have been very emotionally
- 15:52charged.
- 15:52Well, I mean, of course, every presidential election is emotionally charged.
- 15:55It's for the highest office in the land.
- 15:57But in the at least in the last three, four, five elections, it's been much more it's been
- 16:05arguably more emotionally charged than usual as time has just marched on with Donald Trump.
- 16:12Do you support him, or do you not support him?
- 16:15So maybe the presidential election, we should just not touch.
- 16:18But what about these other elections, like, for governor or for state certain state
- 16:24legislatures or more local offices like a mayor or maybe another statewide office like attorney
- 16:30general?
- 16:31Like, when it when is it appropriate to discuss those situations, and when is it not?
- 16:37The or if we talk about a specific policy public policies, like abortion or guns or LGBTQ
- 16:48policy or immigration, the economy.
- 16:54When do we talk about those things?
- 16:56Those can be very hard to figure out when to talk about those things because of how divisive
- 17:02those policies can be, or at the very least, how emotionally charged those policy areas can
- 17:11be.
- 17:13Whereas if you're talking more about something like, even though it's a hot topic right now,
- 17:18it's not does not have the same partisan or ideological divide that some of those other
- 17:24examples I just said were.
- 17:26But the college sports act and congress getting involved in that, or maybe some environmental
- 17:34situations like like drilling in the ocean, or should AI data centers be built?
- 17:42Right right now, AI data centers are actually very unpopular with both Republicans and
- 17:50Democrats, and then and then independents too.
- 17:53So it's a bit more unusual how unifying the issue of AI data centers are, except it's
- 18:04against AI data centers.
- 18:06But because those are less divisive topics, is it then easier and then more appropriate to
- 18:12talk about those specific areas of politics?
- 18:16That's that's not necessarily a straightforward answer.
- 18:20And then lastly, why are you talking about an election or a policy topic?
- 18:26Because a lot of times when people bring up politics, it's not for a useful purpose.
- 18:32A lot of times, it's just to argue and to grandstand and to self congratulate, pat
- 18:37themselves on the back for being so smart and superior compared to people who have different
- 18:44opinions.
- 18:45So are you bringing up elections and policies just to argue, or are you trying to
- 18:50legitimately debate?
- 18:53And legitimate debates aren't necessarily it's not necessarily a time or place for that
- 18:58either.
- 18:59And there are some things that are just so clearly right or wrong that you have to stand
- 19:04against them, like when out and out bigotry is going on.
- 19:08Now, of course, there is some divides on that where, you know, when we talk about is this
- 19:13policy actually a racist or sexist policy or is it not?
- 19:18I'm not talking about those things.
- 19:19I'm talking about things that are clearly out and out, like when somebody says something
- 19:24that's clearly racist or sexist or homophobic or some other form of bigoted where we really
- 19:32should be able to call it out.
- 19:34Although those aren't it's not necessarily technically a policy issue, but you're talking
- 19:38about a candidate's behavior.
- 19:41But that can be considered to be a talking politics.
- 19:46So we're and we're all gonna argue at some point, but doing it for its own sake is not
- 19:53going to fix anything either.
- 19:56Are you also just focused on winning and getting people on your side?
- 20:01Wanting to win is not inherently a problem, by the way.
- 20:04Wanna make that clear.
- 20:06When we get involved in politics, of course, we're trying to win because we firmly believe
- 20:11in a candidate being the right person for the job or voting yes or no on a certain bill or
- 20:20implementing a certain policy.
- 20:22Of course, we're supposed to be it's expected you wanna win, and a lot of us are competitive.
- 20:30There's not necessarily anything wrong with that.
- 20:32You should be you should fight for what you believe in.
- 20:35But the problem is when you become obsessed with it, when it completely drives you and you
- 20:40think that winning at all costs justifies what you're doing.
- 20:44The ends justifies the means.
- 20:46As long as you win, any way you get there is fine.
- 20:50That's where we start to have a problem.
- 20:53But instead of those things, are you earnestly just trying to inform?
- 20:56Are you are you more of a civics education type where you're just trying to tell people, hey.
- 21:00Look.
- 21:00These issues are going on right now.
- 21:02These are what sides a and b.
- 21:05And if there's a side c or a d, these are what these sides tend to believe about this issue or
- 21:11about this election or about this candidate.
- 21:14You have to have those people who are willing to just be informative and try to facilitate
- 21:20that discussion.
- 21:21That can be a lot more appropriate in situations versus simply saying like, you know,
- 21:26I think candidate a is the is the best for this state or this country, and candidate b is going
- 21:32to result in the deaths of everybody.
- 21:35It's probably a little bit more appropriate to go with route a than it is with route b, but
- 21:41you have to think about also or or another way to think about why you're talking about an
- 21:48election or policy topic is, are you discussing it from a nonpartisan, non ideological angle,
- 21:53or are you doing it in favor of a party ideology or issue stance?
- 21:58So the latter is not once again, it's not inherently problematic.
- 22:02Some there's nothing inherently wrong with being identifying with a party or well, depends
- 22:11on what the ideology is.
- 22:12If it's something that's so out and out out there and basically calls for oppressing people
- 22:19or murdering people.
- 22:20That's obviously a much different thing.
- 22:22But generally speaking, fighting for a certain ideology in of itself is not necessarily a
- 22:28problem.
- 22:28It's how much you adhere to that party or ideology or issue stance and how much you won't
- 22:35budge and how much it's a part of your identity.
- 22:39But in any case, those are not always warranted either.
- 22:43Sometimes it's more warranted to just talk about it from that nonpartisan, non ideological
- 22:48angle.
- 22:49And I'm not just saying that just because that is what I do with this podcast.
- 22:53It is natural to generally lean towards one side or another, but to be out and out one way
- 23:00or another isn't necessarily warranted in a given situation.
- 23:05But in any case, let's let's go back to the ultimate crux of this discuss discussion.
- 23:12Why is discussing politics so critical?
- 23:15And that that that might seem very obvious and self explanatory, and especially to those of us
- 23:20who are more involved in politics.
- 23:23Like, well, yeah, of course, it's it's it's important.
- 23:25Why why wouldn't people understand that?
- 23:28If it really was so obvious why politics discussing politics was so critical, more
- 23:34people would be able to converse about politics and policy and elections and be able to do that
- 23:41in a reasonable manner, in a worthwhile and useful manner.
- 23:46But we don't learn about things without talking about those things and having an honest
- 23:53conversation about it.
- 23:54It's just like when we learned about things in school.
- 23:58We needed somebody to tell us about it.
- 24:00We needed to be able to discuss those things, and that's why typically speaking, classes and
- 24:07this makes more much more sense or tends to make more sense for older students and for
- 24:13college students.
- 24:15Classes based on discussing a topic versus simply having the professor or the teacher spit
- 24:22out facts at you.
- 24:24Because when you're discussing things, you're engaging a lot more with the the material, and
- 24:30so you're thinking about things a lot more.
- 24:32And it's gonna be much more likely you internalize those things.
- 24:35It's the same thing with discussing politics.
- 24:38To not just have somebody bark their opinions at you, you should actually try to think things
- 24:44over and come to your own conclusions.
- 24:46And we need to discuss things to come up with solutions to our problems or at least better
- 24:51solutions because we do not have everything figured out.
- 24:54And theoretically, everybody understands that, but based on the attitudes that a lot of people
- 24:59have, there are certainly many people, many polarized people especially that think they
- 25:05have everything figured out and that their worldview explains everything.
- 25:08And that's something I've often criticized and complained about on this podcast.
- 25:14But when you discuss things, you may find an angle that you've never considered before, or
- 25:18you'll correct a misunderstanding you had about other people, and you suddenly are now more
- 25:25knowledgeable about a topic.
- 25:27But, also, politics is so critical to discuss because it affects everybody, and it's not just
- 25:32about the people you tend to agree with.
- 25:34So it's not gonna affect just Republicans.
- 25:37It's not gonna affect just Democrats, just independents, just conservatives, liberals,
- 25:42moderates, capitalists, socialists, communists, fascists.
- 25:46It's affecting everybody, and you need to recognize that some people think they either
- 25:54aren't gonna benefit or they think they're not gonna benefit.
- 25:57And you should be able to try to come up with ways that you can include everybody in the as
- 26:06many of the benefits as possible.
- 26:09But there's also a fact that politics is at some point just inescapable.
- 26:14Unfortunately, politics permeates basically everything and is everywhere.
- 26:19Even when politicians and policy aren't even relevant, Places of work have political
- 26:27machinations where people are trying to climb over each other up the corporate ladder, or
- 26:34there's clicks in the workplace where people are creating their own teams, sort of like how
- 26:42you see in politics with political parties or ideological groups.
- 26:46And then even in your interpersonal relationships outside of the workplace, you you
- 26:53see politics get involved.
- 26:57And it unfortunately can look a lot like the typical politics you see in Washington or your
- 27:03state's capital or even your your local government's city hall.
- 27:10And even when and there's also, of course, other cases where politicians and policies
- 27:16aren't directly involved, but they do have an indirect impact.
- 27:21What are your kids learning in school?
- 27:23What resources do your schools have?
- 27:25Do you have poorly maintained roads where you live?
- 27:28The businesses and jobs that are brought to your area.
- 27:31The environmental aspects of your community.
- 27:36Your does does your community have any sort of nonprofits or other community events going on
- 27:46or or community initiatives going on?
- 27:49Politics are directly or indirectly involved in those and how available those things are.
- 27:55So it's not realistic to completely eschew politics because it's going to impact your life
- 28:01at some point.
- 28:01Now, of course, that does also does not mean that you have to voraciously consume politics,
- 28:06and it's healthy to not be about politics twenty four seven.
- 28:11And like I said before, it can actually be okay that some people don't really participate in
- 28:16politics at all as long as there's not too many of those people that do that.
- 28:21But even when you do try to completely remove yourself from politics or remove yourself from
- 28:28politics as much as you can, you also have to understand, and maybe not necessarily for you
- 28:33listening or watching this, but for the people in your life that try to avoid politics at all
- 28:40costs to even avoid talking about it.
- 28:43Not making a choice is still making a choice.
- 28:47You can choose to sit out of elections by not voting, but you have still made a choice.
- 28:53And you're still going to be impacted by the results of that election no matter what you
- 28:58think is going to happen.
- 28:59Not engaging with political discussions at all.
- 29:02A lot of these discussions are going to impact what you do and and and your place that you
- 29:09live.
- 29:11Not researching the nuances of a policy discussion.
- 29:14Maybe not every single policy is going to impact you, but a lot of them will, and some of
- 29:18them may indirectly impact you, or they're going to impact somebody that you know,
- 29:22somebody that you love and care about.
- 29:25So not getting involved is still going to impact those things, and it can often impact
- 29:32those things negatively because you're not including your own input.
- 29:36And maybe it's not something you have a lot of experience with, but you can still learn about
- 29:40it and still see why people care about it.
- 29:42And then you might actually figure out, actually, you know what?
- 29:45This thing matters to me too.
- 29:47Maybe you don't have kids, but you still were a kid once and you still went to schools.
- 29:56Now you maybe you were homeschooled, but a lot of people were were in public or private
- 30:01schools.
- 30:03But maybe you have friends that have kids that are in school, and you care about them.
- 30:10So you might find, you know what?
- 30:13I should get more involved in in education policy in my local area.
- 30:17And then you might eventually decide that you do wanna have kids.
- 30:20More and more people are having kids later on in life.
- 30:24But you wanna make sure that you give them a place where they can go to good schools and
- 30:28have a quality education.
- 30:32So even if something doesn't impact you now or you think it doesn't impact you now, it's going
- 30:36to down the line, or it's gonna impact somebody you care about down the line, or it may still
- 30:41directly impact you.
- 30:42Because maybe you don't care about that education policy in your local area, but you
- 30:50are trying to run a business, and now you need to hire people, and you may need to hire people
- 30:56that have a quality education.
- 30:59But now you can't go to your local area to do that because the educational system has not
- 31:07been working the way it should in that area.
- 31:09Now you have to go outside of the county.
- 31:12So now there, it has impacted you and what you are doing.
- 31:16Even if you thought it didn't impact you now or it didn't it wasn't directly impacting you
- 31:21before, now it is all of a sudden come to be an issue for you.
- 31:27And you might not necessarily put two and two together, but there are a lot of things that do
- 31:31that for people where they what you thought wasn't gonna impact you at some point
- 31:37eventually comes to impact you.
- 31:40But I think the big thing to think about I mean, obviously, of course, when and where to
- 31:44discuss politics.
- 31:46But even if we come up with a better way to determine when it is appropriate to discuss
- 31:53politics, We need to get better at how we discuss politics.
- 31:57That's arguably more important than knowing when and where to discuss it.
- 32:02Politics should never be your identity.
- 32:05It should never be the thing you lead in.
- 32:07Are you gonna go up to people and talk to them?
- 32:11And I'm not talking about, like, if you're at a rally or something.
- 32:13You're just going about your business, and you interact with somebody, and you just go, hey.
- 32:18I'm so and so, and I'm a Republican, or I'm a Democrat, or I'm an Independent, or I'm
- 32:22anything.
- 32:23That's a pretty weird way to introduce yourself.
- 32:26But in a way, it's kind of how we go about things.
- 32:30Or for a lot of people, that's how they go about things because they we just get so
- 32:35wrapped up in these politics being our identity.
- 32:39And when it is, we can't talk about it reasonably or without feeling personally
- 32:44attacked on it.
- 32:46And I'm not gonna pretend like this has never happened to me.
- 32:48There are plenty of things that I care very deeply about, and sometimes it's hard for me to
- 32:52not feel like it's a personal slight when people have a different viewpoint than me, but
- 32:57you have to be cognizant about that.
- 33:00Views and beliefs are inevitably going to be some part of your identity, but it should not
- 33:05drive everything about what you think and do.
- 33:09And I would go back to in the past couple of years, governors Spencer Cox of Utah and
- 33:17Michelle Lujan Grisham of New Mexico, they had this discussion.
- 33:21I believe it's National Governors Association.
- 33:23This discussion about polarization.
- 33:25And one of the points they talked about was how when they were younger, they politics your your
- 33:34political affiliations were, like, point 10 to 15 when it came to what was most important
- 33:41about you.
- 33:42And now it's one, two, or three where politics is most important about you.
- 33:48It's it's it's so far so much higher up the list now of what's the most important thing for
- 33:54people to know about us.
- 33:55I'm not saying that you should completely mask every your your political views.
- 34:00Of course not.
- 34:01But when you have it be such an intrinsic part of who you are, you really it really makes it
- 34:08more difficult for you to actually try to get to a solution that works for a wider swath of
- 34:15people.
- 34:16And you become blind to learning about new things about a topic because it might conflict
- 34:25with your prior assumptions, and now you feel like you're being personally slighted, that
- 34:30you're being personally attacked, that there's an existential threat.
- 34:33And right now, politics has become largely unapproachable, not just for people who don't
- 34:38regularly get engaged, but people who want to get engaged and who do regularly get engaged.
- 34:43It's becoming more and more unapproachable because people are getting too mad about it.
- 34:47People are getting too afraid to touch it.
- 34:49People don't know where to begin because it can be so inaccessible, whether it's to research it
- 34:56or to know how they can get involved in a political topic of of of any kind.
- 35:03It's become so overtaken by the most polarized voices, the people who have the most undue
- 35:09influence on politics and keep pulling things further and further to the left and further
- 35:15further to the right.
- 35:16And there's becoming less and less room for other people who might have a different idea
- 35:23about how to do things.
- 35:26We need to be more welcoming to people, and that includes people who might be much more to
- 35:32the left and or much more to the right.
- 35:35You can't take the approach of the most polarized where they try to suppress opinions
- 35:40and completely try to suppress them.
- 35:43I think of back during the times of the nineteen fifties during the Red Scare and
- 35:51during Joseph McCarthy's reign of terror, for lack of a better term, where basically just
- 35:58accused anybody who even had a slight disagreement of being a communist.
- 36:05And you see that a lot today where people accuse others of being communist or accuse
- 36:11others of being fascist, and it's really to just completely try to delegitimize any sort of
- 36:18differing opinion.
- 36:19Not not because those people may or may not actually be communist or fascist, but to
- 36:24basically delegitimize and disregard any sort of differing opinions and just and say and be
- 36:32it's an intellectually lazy way to just disengage with other opinions, kinda like when
- 36:38you just talk about people being extreme.
- 36:41A lot of times, it's not really a matter of whether people are or aren't being extreme.
- 36:47It's just a way to try to silence people who don't think the same way.
- 36:53But the funny thing is when we were doing that during the nineteen fifties, it was exactly the
- 36:59kind of tactic that a communist country would use, was to suppress differing opinions.
- 37:05We can't go about doing that.
- 37:07Now when there's truly abhorrent things being said, those need to be forcefully rebuked.
- 37:14That's you you can rebuke things without actually trying to silence people through the
- 37:22law or with the government.
- 37:24You can actually land based people and say, this is not how we should do things without
- 37:31actually trying to trample over other people's first amendment rights or any other rights that
- 37:37they have.
- 37:38So we need to be more welcoming to people, especially when they're trying when they're
- 37:43trying to get more understanding of when to appropriately discuss politics.
- 37:49And we should not be forcing this with us or against us mentality.
- 37:53It's very rare that that is actually the case where it's really that binary.
- 37:58You find a lot of things in politics are really not so binary the way that some people would
- 38:02have us believe.
- 38:03And if you try to enforce that attitude on people, you might have been able to bring them
- 38:09to your side, but now because you gave them an ultimatum where they had to be with you or
- 38:14against you, now they're just going to sit on the sidelines because they just don't wanna
- 38:17deal with it.
- 38:18They might be too afraid to speak up.
- 38:21They might tend to side with your opinion, but because you try to enforce uniformity, now
- 38:27they're just going to be silent about it.
- 38:30But they might have some critiques about your side of the aisle.
- 38:36And, also, people who legitimately want to be part of a solution don't need to be expected to
- 38:42have an answer for everything because that's not really realistic.
- 38:46And those of us who are more involved in politics, oftentimes, we don't have a real
- 38:52answer either even though we oftentimes think we do when we don't.
- 38:56And perhaps more than anything, we need to take a long look in the mirror, and this is for
- 39:04everybody, including myself.
- 39:06We need to take a look in the mirror to see whether we are finding the right times to end
- 39:12places to discuss politics and also knowing how to best discuss politics.
- 39:18Make sure that we really do go about things the right way when it comes to that.
- 39:24How are we discussing politics?
- 39:26Really earnestly assess how we're discussing politics and whether politics govern too much
- 39:33of our identity.
- 39:35If we're discussing politics for the right reasons, are we doing it because we actually
- 39:39want to inform people or we want to actually come up with a solution or are we just trying
- 39:42to self congratulate and argue?
- 39:45Are we truly understanding why we believe what we believe and why others believe the way they
- 39:50do?
- 39:52And sometimes we think we understand why we think the way we do and we don't.
- 39:57But more than that, we don't oftentimes really know why other people think the way they do.
- 40:03And oftentimes, we ascribe more nefarious motives to them than they actually have.
- 40:09Are we getting too emotional in our discussions?
- 40:12Listen.
- 40:13It's normal to get emotional about politics at some point.
- 40:16I do it.
- 40:17As much as I try not to be, it happens to me.
- 40:20It happens to all of us.
- 40:21It's just some people, it's a lot more frequent to get emotional about politics than for some
- 40:29other people.
- 40:30Hence, we need to try to be less emotional and try to take ourselves out of things and try to
- 40:37understand why other people think the way they do.
- 40:40And are we letting politics unduly erode our relationships?
- 40:46Listen.
- 40:46There are some times where, yes, somebody really says something truly vile and
- 40:52discussing, and they should be reprimanded, and they might not ever change.
- 40:57And I can understand at some point, you may need to cut off contact.
- 41:01But a lot of times, we are way too quick to try to sever our relationships with friends, with
- 41:09significant others, with our family, where we think that we're fighting the good fight
- 41:18because we're telling these bad people how bad they are.
- 41:23But is it is it a, are you really actually solving anything?
- 41:27And b, are they really as bad as you think, or is it just they just have a different way of
- 41:33looking at things?
- 41:34That's really not as easy of a dividing line as we make it out to be.
- 41:39And too and too many people are too quick to cut off others because of a difference in
- 41:45political opinion.
- 41:48And it's something that I hope we're a lot more careful about going forward because we already
- 41:53have enough issues with echo chambers as it is.
- 41:56We don't need to create them further for ourselves.
- 42:01So it's not just about when and where is the most appropriate place to discuss politics, but
- 42:09how we discuss politics may be the more important question.
- 42:14So some food for thought, and that's where we're gonna end for today's episode of politics
- 42:18with Paul.
- 42:19As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 42:21Please like, comment, subscribe, and my links are in the show notes.
- 42:27My other works like my five day educational email course about how we can all more
- 42:30effectively mitigate toxicity and polarization in politics, including some of the most common
- 42:35mistakes we make that can actually make polarization worse.
- 42:39My book on political independence on Amazon.
- 42:43It's on other retailers, but Amazon the Amazon link is the one in the show notes.
- 42:48And then my writings on medium.com, and then my other profiles, my LinkedIn profile, my
- 42:54facebook.com page, my website, paulraider.org, and my email, Paul Raider writes at Gmail dot
- 43:03com.
- 43:05So once again, thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.