Latest / Her Life: Women, identity, culture & modern life / The Weight of 'Should': Reclaiming Ambition From Family Traditions | Her Life
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of loneliness that only exists when you are standing in the kitchen, holding a bottle of wine, watching your best friend’s eyes light up with news that breaks your heart into pieces she doesn’t even know she caused. Here’s what I’m noticing. It wasn’t the announcement itself that got me. It was the three weeks leading up to it. The way Sarah kept touching her stomach while we were washing dishes. The way she’d pause mid-sentence, looking down at her own body like she was trying to solve a riddle written in skin and bone. I remember standing there, scrubbing a pot that was already clean, feeling this strange, cold knot tighten in my chest. Not jealousy, exactly. Not anger. Just a hollow ache so profound it felt like I had swallowed a stone. We had just come off a rough patch for me. You might not know this part of my story yet, but about six months prior, I lost a pregnancy. It was early, quiet, and entirely private. I didn’t tell anyone at work. I didn’t post anything on social media. I just went to bed one night and woke up lighter, emptier, and suddenly very alone in a body that had promised me something it couldn’t keep. And now, here was Sarah, glowing, radiant, carrying the very thing I had been screaming for in the dark. Let’s sit with that for a second. Because society tells us that women should be happy for each other’s joy. And we are! We are supposed to clap, to hug, to cry tears of shared happiness. But what they don’t tell you is that joy can feel like a physical blow when you are still bleeding out from your own loss. It’s complicated, isn’t it? To love someone enough to want their happiness, and to hate yourself for the way their happiness highlights your absence. I want to talk about the mask. Because if there is one thing I have learned in my thirties, it is how good we get at performing normalcy. I showed up to Sarah’s baby shower last weekend. I wore that emerald green dress she loves. I brought a gift that was thoughtful, practical, and completely generic. I smiled until my cheeks hurt. I laughed at the jokes. I held her hand and told her how beautiful she looked. But inside, I was counting the seconds until I could leave. I was replaying every moment where I had almost said something real. Almost. There was a moment during the cake cutting when she looked at me, really looked at me, and asked if I was okay. I heard the concern in her voice. It was genuine. And I lied. I said, "I'm just tired," which is the universal code for "I am grieving a version of my future that never happened." It’s exhausting, being the supportive friend who is also the broken one. We carry this dual burden: we must hold space for their celebration while simultaneously hiding our own collapse. And why do we hide it? Because we are afraid of being the buzzkill. We are afraid of turning their miracle into a tragedy. So we swallow the truth. We sip our wine. We nod. We pretend that our silence is strength, when really, it is just isolation wearing a party hat. There is a room in my house that stays closed. It was painted yellow. Pale, sunny yellow, chosen because I thought it would be cheerful for a nursery. Now, it’s just a storage closet for winter coats and old books. But sometimes, late at night, I walk past it. I don’t open the door. I just stand there in the hallway, listening to the hum of the refrigerator downstairs, imagining what it would have felt like to hear a heartbeat. To feel a kick. To know that I was capable of creating life. When Sarah started talking about buying clothes for the baby, I felt that same cold stone in my chest again. She sent me links to onesies. Tiny, adorable onesies with little bears on them. I stared at those links for hours. I wanted to buy them. I wanted to be the aunt who sends cute socks. But every time I clicked add to cart, guilt washed over me. Did I have the right? Was I betraying the child I lost by participating in this new chapter? It’s such a selfish feeling, I know. And I know that Sarah has no idea about the depth of my pain. She thinks I’m just busy. She thinks I’m just focusing on my career. She doesn’t know that every tiny shoe size she mentions feels like a reminder of what I missed. This is the silent grief. It doesn’t make headlines. It doesn’t bring flowers. It just sits in the corners of our lives, waiting for us to notice it. Let’s dig deeper into why this hurts so much. It’s not just about the baby. It’s about identity. For years, I defined myself partly by my potential as a mother. It was a big part of my dreams, my plans, my sense of self-worth. When that door closed, a huge part of my narrative disappeared. I felt less than. I felt incomplete. And now, watching Sarah step into that role so naturally, so effortlessly, it triggers a fear that I will always be the outsider. The friend who couldn’t. The woman who remained empty. It’s irrational, of course. Sarah’s journey is hers. Mine is mine. But emotions don’t care about logic. They care about resonance. And the resonance of her success is echoing the silence of my failure. I’ve started pulling away from her slightly. Not drastically. Just enough to create distance. I cancel plans when I’m overwhelmed. I take longer to reply to texts. I tell myself it’s because I’m busy, but the truth is, I’m protecting myself. I’m afraid that if I stay too close, the contrast will become too sharp. That I’ll look at her and see everything I lack. That I’ll stop seeing my friend and start seeing a mirror of my own unfulfilled desires. But here is where I need to turn the page. Because I cannot let my grief define my friendship. I cannot let my loss erase my capacity for love. Sarah is still my best friend. She knows me better than anyone. She has seen me at my worst and stayed. She deserves my presence, even when it is hard. So, I am trying to find a new way to show up. I am learning to separate my worth from my womb. I am reminding myself that I am more than a vessel. I am a creator in other ways. I write. I listen. I love deeply. I build communities. These things matter. They are valid. They are enough. It’s a daily practice. Some days are harder than others. Last week, I actually cried in my car after dropping off a package at Sarah’s house. I sat there for twenty minutes, sobbing. Not because I was sad about the package, but because I realized I was ready to grieve without shame. I allowed myself to feel the pain without judging it. And then, I dried my face, took a deep breath, and went home. That small act of permission changed everything. It didn’t fix the loss. It didn’t bring back what I lost. But it gave me back my humanity. It reminded me that I am allowed to be messy. I am allowed to be complex. I am allowed to love my friend and mourn my loss at the same time. I want to invite you into this space with me. If you are walking through a season of silence, please know that you are not alone. There are so many of us. Women who are holding spaces for others while their own hearts are cracking open. Women who are smiling through the ache. Women who are wondering if they will ever feel whole again. You don’t have to perform happiness. You don’t have to pretend that everything is fine. It’s okay to say, "I’m struggling." It’s okay to ask for help. It’s okay to take space when you need it. Your feelings are valid, even if they seem inconvenient to the people around you. Let’s normalize the conversation around infertility, miscarriage, and the complex emotions that surround reproduction. Let’s stop treating these topics as taboo. Let’s bring them into the light, where they can be held, shared, and healed. Because when we speak our truths, we break the spell of isolation. We remind each other that we are not broken. We are just becoming. I am still becoming. I am still healing. And I am still here, loving my friends, living my life, and finding beauty in the unpolished moments. Even the painful ones. Especially the painful ones. Thank you for letting me share this with you today. Be gentle with yourselves. You are doing better than you think. Until next time, I’m Ciara Stewart. Take care.