Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Step Inside the Artwork: A Practitioner's Guide to Immersive and Digital Art Law
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:08Step Inside the Artwork, A Practitioner's Guide
- 0:10to Immersive and Digital Art Law. I'm Alla Policastro,
- 0:14Director of Education and Professional Development
- 0:16at Beverly Hills Bar Association, and I'm delighted
- 0:19to introduce our speakers today, Lorena Guzman
- 0:22-Diaz and Adam Weisman. Adam is the founder of
- 0:26Weisman Law, where he practices media, arts,
- 0:29and entertainment law. He represents photographers,
- 0:32filmmakers, visual artists, designers, commercial
- 0:34production companies, creative and advertising
- 0:37agencies, and influencers across a wide range
- 0:40of matters, including intellectual property,
- 0:43contract development, and complex deal negotiations.
- 0:46He has been named a super lawyer rising star
- 0:48in entertainment law seven years running. Lorena
- 0:52is an associate at Weisman Law, where she focuses
- 0:54on media, art, and entertainment law. Before
- 0:57joining the firm, she clerked for the honorable
- 0:59C. Darnell Jones, the second of the U .S. District
- 1:02Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
- 1:05She serves on the advisory board of the Center
- 1:07for Art Law, co -chairs the New York County Lawyers
- 1:10Association's Art Law Committee, and sits on
- 1:13the New York City Bar Association's Entertainment
- 1:15Law Committee. We're so excited to hear what
- 1:17they have to share with us today, so I'm going
- 1:19to turn it over to them. All right. Thank you.
- 1:25Good afternoon. Thank you, everyone. Thanks for
- 1:26having us. Beverly Hills Bar Association. We're
- 1:28really excited to be here. As Aala said, my name
- 1:31is Adam. I am the founder of Weisman Law. And
- 1:34what we do at the firm is a pretty broad range
- 1:38of things. Like Aala mentioned, we represent
- 1:40a ton of different types of artists, production
- 1:42companies, creative agencies, and everyone in
- 1:44between. But talking about immersive and digital
- 1:46art, it's something I'm going to probably refer
- 1:48to a lot today, something that we see more and
- 1:50more in the practice, something called activations.
- 1:52It feels like a culmination of our practice in
- 1:55many ways. It encompasses IP considerations,
- 2:00live production issues, live event issues, lots
- 2:03of different things that pop up in small bits
- 2:06with all of our other clients. But when it comes
- 2:08down to live events and live art events and activations,
- 2:15we're seeing all of these elements come out at
- 2:17once. A lot of the protocols and practices that
- 2:20we're going to discuss today are actually coming
- 2:22out of what we see in our day to day. So we're
- 2:25going to be applying a lot of our real life experience.
- 2:30Hi, everyone. As we stated, I'm an associate
- 2:34at Weisman Law, where I focus on intellectual
- 2:37property and commercial transactions. I am co
- 2:40-chair of the New York County Lawyers Association's
- 2:42Art Law Committee. I sit on the advisory board
- 2:45of the Center for Art Law, and I serve as co
- 2:48-executive editor of the Women's Lawyers Journal.
- 2:50This talk today is built on an article I published
- 2:53earlier this year that grew out of a panel that
- 2:56my Art Law Committee presented at the Naikla
- 2:58Art Law Institute. The article is actually part
- 3:01of your materials. So before we get started,
- 3:05I know, Adam, you have some quick disclaimers.
- 3:09Yes. I have to say everything we talk about today
- 3:12is for informational purposes only, is not to
- 3:14be construed as legal advice. We're both two
- 3:17New York -based attorneys. We're not here to
- 3:19provide legal advice on anything that's happening
- 3:21in California. We are going to talk a little
- 3:23bit about California because some of our practices
- 3:26have led our New York clients to dealing with
- 3:28California from time to time, but we certainly
- 3:29are not licensed out there and are not advising
- 3:32on the law there. All that being said, if anything
- 3:34pops up today that you have a question about,
- 3:37I highly recommend speaking to local counsel
- 3:38out by you. Thank you, Adam. So our five learning
- 3:43objectives for today. Number one, to identify
- 3:46the risk management and insurance considerations
- 3:49that distinguish immersive installations from
- 3:51traditional exhibitions and live events. Two,
- 3:55recognize privacy, brighter publicity, and biometric
- 3:58data issues in immersive environments and the
- 4:00jurisdictional patchwork that governs them. Number
- 4:03three, structure, licensing, compensation, and
- 4:07copyright registration strategies for immersive
- 4:09and digital works. Four, draft customized collaboration
- 4:14agreements and studio protocols addressing joint
- 4:17ownership, moral rights, and cross -border enforcement.
- 4:21And five, apply the ethical obligations of competence,
- 4:25communication, and collaboration when representing
- 4:27clients at the technological frontier. By the
- 4:31end of the hour, you should walk away with five
- 4:33concrete things. Those are the learning objectives
- 4:36I just read and which are on the slide. So let's
- 4:39get to it. So our agenda for today, we just welcome
- 4:44everyone and frame the conversation. Up next
- 4:48we have what is immersive art in 2026. Then we
- 4:50will be covering business and legal realities
- 4:53of immersive art. Second to that, we will be
- 4:56covering protective IP and immersive and digital
- 4:59art. Following that, we have protocols and frameworks
- 5:02unique to immersive art. Then we have enforcement,
- 5:05monitoring, and the global digital landscape.
- 5:07And finally, practical considerations for council.
- 5:11Following that, we will have two quick hypotheticals
- 5:14where we would issue spot and then top 10 practice
- 5:17tips for lawyers representing artists in this
- 5:21space. And then we will open up the floor for
- 5:24audience Q &A. into anything specific, highly
- 5:31recommend. If you have questions, feel free to
- 5:33raise them as we go. Lorena and I will do our
- 5:35best to answer them as we go along, because I
- 5:37think we'll have much more to say if we're answering
- 5:39in situ as opposed to after the fact. Oh, thank
- 5:43you, Adam. Well, perfect. So let's set the scene.
- 5:46What is immersive art in 2026? Before we get
- 5:49into doctrine, let's define our terms. Our working
- 5:52definition of immersive art is creative work
- 5:55that transcends the traditional frame. engaging
- 5:58audiences through sight, sound, touch, sometimes
- 6:02taste and smell, and very often direct physical
- 6:05or digital interaction. The umbrella covers Walkthrough
- 6:09installations like Team Labs exhibitions or Meow
- 6:13Wolf's House of Eternal Return, large scale festivals
- 6:16and pop -ups such as Van Gogh Alive, where the
- 6:19various immersive whatever experiences rotating
- 6:22through convention centers, pure VR and AR environments,
- 6:26whether distributed through headsets or mobile
- 6:28apps, and multisensory performance work that
- 6:32blends live performers, generated audio, and
- 6:36interactive lighting. What makes these projects
- 6:39legally distinctive is that they almost always
- 6:42implicate four legal domains at once. Premises
- 6:46liability, intellectual property, privacy, and
- 6:49contract. Adam and I are going to walk through
- 6:52each of those domains, then close with a practice
- 6:56tips checklist. Adam, take us in. Going to talk
- 7:01a little bit about things like personal injury
- 7:03risk management and types of issues that might
- 7:06pop up when you are running these types of events.
- 7:09Now, what makes immersive art and activations
- 7:12and similar types of events so exciting is really
- 7:16the exact same thing that makes it so much riskier
- 7:18than, let's say, live theater or going to an
- 7:21art gallery. You have audiences touching, walking
- 7:27through your event. sometimes physically interacting
- 7:30with performers, physically interacting with
- 7:32the builds, sometimes even going so far as to
- 7:35eat the things that are part of the installation
- 7:38or the performance. And while that makes things
- 7:40very exciting, it also turns it into a high risk
- 7:44situation that just does not exist in other areas
- 7:46of entertainment or art. So there are six pressure
- 7:50points that we really start off with that we
- 7:52should be thinking about before getting started
- 7:55on sort of running production. on these things
- 7:57when you're working and onboarding a client.
- 7:59The first thing that you need to consider, and
- 8:02this might seem really basic, but I think a lot
- 8:04of us can occasionally take it for granted, is
- 8:06just having that first conversation with your
- 8:09new client going, who are you in this deal? Because
- 8:13there are so many moving parts in these types
- 8:15of events that the specific client that you have
- 8:18and what they're doing really matters. Are they
- 8:20an individual artist that's just providing a
- 8:22specific piece of artwork or multiple pieces?
- 8:24Are they the producer that's overseeing everything
- 8:27and is handling all the artists and independent
- 8:30contractors and employees that might be coming
- 8:31in? Are they the venue that has wildly different
- 8:35exposure than the producer and also has much
- 8:37longer term things to think about when looking
- 8:39at the location? Commercial galleries, for -profit
- 8:43event spaces. They're going to get pulled into
- 8:46standard premises liability frameworks. By contrast,
- 8:49if you're dealing with a non -profit museum or
- 8:51educational institution, there might be some
- 8:53charitable immunity carve -outs. If you are working
- 8:55with a municipality, a city, they already might
- 8:58have wildly different practices and requirements
- 9:00than a normal venue would. When you are asking
- 9:04all these questions, make sure that you are allocating
- 9:07the risk out appropriately in your contracts,
- 9:10indemnification, contribution, figuring out who's
- 9:13responsible for what insurance, what additional
- 9:16endorsements need to be made. These all need
- 9:17to be stated explicitly. None of them can be
- 9:19taken for granted. And they really do change
- 9:21with every single event that you're doing. Do
- 9:25you have something that someone's writing? Do
- 9:28you have something somebody's touching? Do you
- 9:30have? fireworks going off. All these things are
- 9:32things you need to be thinking about from the
- 9:34get -go and then drafting accordingly. Format
- 9:36and scope. Kind of the same idea. There's not
- 9:40a one -size -fits -all to this. A three -day
- 9:42festival with 10 ,000 nightly attendees is going
- 9:44to call for crowd control plans, emergency response
- 9:47protocols, seven -figure insurance limits. By
- 9:50contrast, a three -week pop -up in a converted
- 9:52warehouse might be a lot safer and have fewer
- 9:56moving parts, but you're going to need potentially
- 9:59temporary certificates of occupancy and other
- 10:01considerations to take into with the premises
- 10:03owners. ADA evaluation comes into play, maybe
- 10:07special events permits. And finally, if you're
- 10:09dealing with a permanent installation, like the
- 10:11Museum of Ice Cream, which I know we have here
- 10:13in New York, I believe there's one in LA, it's
- 10:16ongoing maintenance protocols, periodic safety
- 10:18audits, things that you are looking into all
- 10:21of the time. Jack writes in, how does it all
- 10:26work at Burning Man annually? Well, we're not
- 10:29personally involved with Burning Man, but my
- 10:31guess is every year you're essentially starting
- 10:33from scratch. I don't believe there's any, in
- 10:37these types of events that happen once every
- 10:40year, you're not usually doing recurring contracts.
- 10:43You have contract, I'll say customs and things
- 10:47you can honor from prior years, but they're going
- 10:49to change every year. And we know with Burning
- 10:50Man, it does change every year. On top of that,
- 10:53something we're probably not going to talk about
- 10:54is the fact that Burning Man has a lot more contributions
- 10:57from the attendees than just the producers itself.
- 11:00So there's probably a whole bunch of other elements
- 11:02that I'm not even thinking about at this moment.
- 11:05Releases and consents. You go to a concert, you're
- 11:11going to look at the back of your ticket, and
- 11:13there's going to be a few sentences in there.
- 11:15with some standard release language, you're probably
- 11:18not going to question it or think about it too
- 11:20hard, but it's mostly the same each and every
- 11:22time. In this context, a simple handful of sentences
- 11:27is probably not going to be sufficient. You need
- 11:29specific disclosure language and an informed
- 11:32consent checkbox that really identifies what's
- 11:35happening in the specific installation that you're
- 11:38working on. If there's edible components, if
- 11:41there's sensory deprivation, If there's induced
- 11:44disorientation, strobe lights, which we do see
- 11:48a lot of those in regular waivers, fog, water,
- 11:50altered states, elements, all these things need
- 11:52to be identified and you need to have your attendees
- 11:54signing off on them specifically and explicitly.
- 11:58Going to California, as I'm sure practitioners
- 12:01that we're speaking to today know. There is a
- 12:04whole line of cases that make pre -injury releases
- 12:07unenforceable where public interest is implicated
- 12:10and that waivers of gross negligence are void
- 12:12on public policy grounds. So make sure that all
- 12:14of your waivers, particularly if you're operating
- 12:16in California, reflect that. Anytime that we
- 12:19encounter that and we have to bring in local
- 12:21California council, we're adding those pieces
- 12:23to our waivers. Practical implications of this
- 12:27are that you need to cover ordinary negligent
- 12:29risks. You need to avoid Blanket perspective
- 12:32waivers of gross negligence and willful misconduct
- 12:34and building informed consent record into it.
- 12:37Make sure that people understand what they're
- 12:39reading. The very basic information needs to
- 12:41be there and it needs to be not widely technical
- 12:45legalese. People need to be able to look at it
- 12:47and digest it and go, okay, I understand what
- 12:49I'm signing off on because the last thing you
- 12:51want somebody claiming that was too technical
- 12:53for them to appreciate. ADA and sensory. Accessibility
- 12:58compliance. Now, immersive installations are
- 13:00magnets for ADA Title III claims because they
- 13:03combine physical navigation when going through
- 13:05ramps or up steps or around ladders, heavy visual
- 13:08and auditory content such as strobing or reduced
- 13:13lights, and dense digital interfaces. There are
- 13:17private rights of actions along California for
- 13:20not including minimum statutory damages for violation.
- 13:22Now, that's not to say that you need to advise
- 13:25your clients on building something out that is
- 13:28completely accessible as is. But if your clients
- 13:31are not doing that, if they are doing something
- 13:32that is going to have inaccessible components,
- 13:35you should consider providing sensory accessible
- 13:39accommodations with quiet hours, advanced warnings,
- 13:42maybe altered versions of it at different times
- 13:46that you can give to different audiences. But
- 13:49you need to make sure that the option is there
- 13:51because if you're essentially just saying people
- 13:53with certain accessibility issues simply cannot
- 13:56access this period, you are opening yourself
- 13:58up to penalties. Multi -jurisdictional issues.
- 14:03If an installation tours, obviously you need
- 14:06to start thinking about where that installation
- 14:08is going to go and the jurisdictions that it's
- 14:10in. Practically speaking, what we have seen and
- 14:14what we will often recommend is if you're doing
- 14:17multiple installations and they're going to be
- 14:19in specific periods for extended periods of time.
- 14:21You create a special purpose entity in each state,
- 14:24usually an LLC, usually give the tour so that
- 14:27claims can't go back to the parent company or
- 14:30can't affect different installations in different
- 14:32states. Obviously, if you're going to do this
- 14:34and you're going to go into different states,
- 14:36if you are advising your clients from California,
- 14:38if you're advising clients from New York, when
- 14:40you're going to those other states, Make sure
- 14:42to coordinate with local council, look into things
- 14:44like permits, fire codes, ADA and related issues.
- 14:48Even make sure that your clients are coordinating
- 14:51with accountants that understand the different
- 14:53tax implications of going into those different
- 14:55states. Just know that while you may be completely
- 14:58buttoned up in your own jurisdiction, there may
- 15:00be things you're not thinking about in those
- 15:02other jurisdictions, hence why it's always good
- 15:03to have lawyers license in those spots that you
- 15:06can call on. And finally, Not finally. It's finally
- 15:11on my page. But next is insurance. And this is
- 15:14a big one. If somebody gets sued, yeah, our contracts
- 15:20and our releases and our compliance that we're
- 15:22advising on is going to help prevent damages
- 15:25from happening. But a lawsuit still might have
- 15:27to happen. And your clients are probably not
- 15:30going to want to pay out of pocket for that.
- 15:33And insurance is the best way to ensure that
- 15:34they're covered. Insurance providers are not
- 15:39one size fits all. It kind of goes back to contracts.
- 15:42We need to understand when you're working with
- 15:43a broker and you're working with an insurance
- 15:46provider those brokers are looking for. They
- 15:48actually understand the work that you're doing.
- 15:50We work with a handful of brokers that understand
- 15:55these issues specifically. You're going to want
- 15:57to work with brokers that cover live events and
- 15:59cover media issues. Insurance companies off the
- 16:02top of my hand is Anthony asking, can't think
- 16:04of them. I'd have to look at who my brokers are
- 16:07setting up my clients up with. But the key for
- 16:10me when I help my clients with those conversations
- 16:12with the brokers is understanding that the broker
- 16:15on the other side truly gets the business. It's
- 16:18really the same sort of conversations we're having
- 16:20with them. Our aim is to set up the contracts
- 16:22and all their policies. Their aim is to make
- 16:25sure that the coverage that they're getting is
- 16:27appropriate. And it covers all of these different
- 16:30things. It covers things like sharing wearables,
- 16:35covers things like consumables, it covers interactive
- 16:37devices, maybe biometric capture. Make sure that
- 16:40all the language is in there. And then you as
- 16:41their attorney should be saying, before you sign
- 16:43this policy, send it to me so we can sort of
- 16:45go through the checklist and I can make sure
- 16:48that what is in there actually covers all of
- 16:50your activity. That's the last thing that you
- 16:52want to happen is your client getting a $10 million
- 16:54umbrella policy that just does not explicitly
- 16:57cover their activity. And finally, practical
- 17:00protocols. And this one, it's in the name, practically
- 17:05speaking, is probably the most important of everything
- 17:07you're going to do, which is lawyers can talk
- 17:11themselves blue in the face about what should
- 17:13happen, but making sure that your clients actually
- 17:15figure out how to implement them is most important.
- 17:18This goes to talking to clients about training
- 17:20their staff and volunteers. Things like who's
- 17:23checking and enforcing for the waivers at the
- 17:25door? Who is on radio if incidents pop up in
- 17:28the middle of a large installation? What are
- 17:32the claims notifications workflow if something
- 17:34does go wrong and an attendee reaches out after
- 17:36the fact? You should have written procedures
- 17:39for all of this. You should be telling your clients
- 17:41to train all of their staff that's working for
- 17:44them and making sure that if something goes wrong,
- 17:46the plans being implemented matches what you've
- 17:48actually talked to them. Also to note, insurance
- 17:51providers are probably going to ask for some
- 17:53proof of this, or at least you checking off a
- 17:56box saying you do have these things. This is
- 17:59what has saved our clients from getting sued.
- 18:03It's us. being able to say just follow the plan
- 18:07and they do it and it works out decently well.
- 18:10And that really goes back to the starting piece.
- 18:14Who's your client? What are their risks? What's
- 18:17the format and scope of this? Understanding all
- 18:19that and not just putting it in a, you know,
- 18:21contract that's only for behind the scenes people
- 18:24to see, but putting it in protocols for the staff
- 18:27to see, to understand and to deal with the attendees
- 18:29when things go wrong. Great. Thank you, Adam.
- 18:34So now we're moving on to privacy, publicity,
- 18:37and biometric data. The second reality that hits
- 18:41immediately is privacy. Immersive installations
- 18:44very often record, monitor, or biometrically
- 18:47scan attendees, sometimes as part of the art,
- 18:50sometimes to drive interactivity, and sometimes
- 18:53simply for security or documentation. There are
- 18:56four issues. There are four main issues here.
- 18:59Number one is expectation of privacy. Attendees
- 19:02in a public or semi -public exhibit have a diminished
- 19:05expectation of privacy, but the expectation can
- 19:09re -inflate in generally intimate or experimental
- 19:12spaces. Our practical fix for this is visible
- 19:15signage at every entry point, written disclosure
- 19:18and ticketing materials, and a consent click
- 19:21-through in digital ticketing. Our point number
- 19:25two is biometric data. the fastest moving area
- 19:28of the practice. Illinois BIPA, Texas CUBI, and
- 19:34Washington's Biometric Privacy Act regulate facial
- 19:37recognition, iris scans, fingerprints, and in
- 19:41some readings, voice prints, and gait motion
- 19:44capture data. Illinois, in particular, authorizes
- 19:48per -violation sedatory damages and is a major
- 19:51class action magnet. If the installation will
- 19:54travel to Illinois, Texas, or Washington, implement
- 19:58written opt -in consent, retention limits, and
- 20:02destruction schedules before opening. Our third
- 20:05point is data protection, the CCPAs slash CPRA
- 20:10and GDPR in depth. Any personal data captured
- 20:15sits behind a cybersecurity posture proportionate
- 20:18to a sensitivity, encryption at rest and in transit,
- 20:24access codes, and regular audits. For California
- 20:27exhibit, it works specifically. California Civil
- 20:30Code section 1798 .100 applies to businesses
- 20:35that clear the revenue, data volume, or data
- 20:39sale thresholds. CPRA additionally carves out
- 20:43sensitive personal information, including biometric
- 20:47and geolocation data for purpose limitation and
- 20:52right to limit treatment, which captures much
- 20:55of what immersive installations collect. So build
- 20:58in consumer notice at collection, the right to
- 21:01know slash delete slash correct workflow, a do
- 21:05not sale slash share link. for cross -contact
- 21:08behavioral advertising, and if the installation
- 21:11is at a permanent venue, a privacy policy annual
- 21:16update cadence. For works touring to Europe,
- 21:19GDPR applies extraterritorially under Article
- 21:233 .2 when data subjects in the EU are targeted.
- 21:28Plan local basis documentation, GPIA for biometric
- 21:33processing under Article 35, and EU -UK representative
- 21:37designation under Article 27. Our fourth point
- 21:41is right of publicity. So, California diverges
- 21:46subtly from New York years, a practice point.
- 21:49California Civil Code section 334 .4 .1 recognizes
- 21:55a postmodern right of publicity lasting 70 years
- 21:58after death. New York Civil Rights Law, Section
- 22:0250 and 51 does not extend post -mortem in the
- 22:06same way. Consent forms for an installation that
- 22:09mature both states must account for the broader
- 22:14California scope and be especially careful when
- 22:17attendee imagery will be reused in advertising,
- 22:21merchandise, or promotional materials after the
- 22:24installation closes. Yeah, one one thing that
- 22:27I see quite a bit of still which is just not
- 22:29sufficient is the one line consent clause literally
- 22:32just saying by entering you consent to be photographed
- 22:34and it's just not adequate given the what we're
- 22:38doing or what our clients are doing with people's
- 22:41images and data and biometrics. But that wouldn't
- 22:46be like. adequate for a modern immersive experience.
- 22:51The experience collects biometric data or uses
- 22:54footage commercially. You need layered consent,
- 22:57such as ticket purchase at the door and potentially
- 22:59as specific thresholds inside the installation
- 23:02itself. Yep. Before we jump on to licensing stuff,
- 23:08Angela asked in the chat, what about the risk
- 23:10of an assault verbal or physical from another
- 23:12visitor? This is obviously going back a step.
- 23:15Insurable under SOPs, So this would, as opposed
- 23:20to your main, I'll say general commercial insurance
- 23:23and umbrella liability, probably be covered by
- 23:26workers comp to some degree. But on top of that,
- 23:28you as the producer are going to have an obligation
- 23:32to set up the experience to not put or to minimize
- 23:40the risk to your staff. If there is a component
- 23:45where visitors and attendees are physically touching
- 23:49the staff, you need to set up parameters around
- 23:51that. And I think beyond insurance, it just goes
- 23:53back to the practical considerations that we
- 23:55were talking about before in implementing policies
- 23:57there. Does using images of actor in immersive
- 24:00productions for advertising the production violate
- 24:03the rights of publicity? In short, yes, the rights
- 24:09of publicity are different in every state. They
- 24:11are definitely the strongest in California with
- 24:12New York falling a little bit behind there. The
- 24:16line that we take with all of our clients is
- 24:19that if you are using somebody's name, image,
- 24:21or likeness for commercial purposes, you need
- 24:23to get rid of consent. That's really been our
- 24:25through line. There's maybe some exceptions to
- 24:27it that we can come up with if we really want
- 24:29to get creative, but it's not. made my opinion
- 24:33worth exploring further. But anyways, let's jump
- 24:36into licensing, compensation, and contractual
- 24:39clarity and start with what I consider one of
- 24:43the most common sources of disputes in this space
- 24:45and really any space that's involving production
- 24:49of IP and entertainment and art assets. It's
- 24:53informal licensing. You know, deals start with
- 24:56a handshake. A lot of these events that we're
- 24:58talking about started between friends just trying
- 25:00to do something cool. And of course, when you
- 25:02are in that position, you're not always thinking
- 25:04about IP ownership and contracts. Everybody's
- 25:08given a handshake, everybody's working on the
- 25:10same vibe. Five months later, the installation
- 25:12is up, it's touring in multiple cities, but nobody's
- 25:15really committed to Paper who owns the work who
- 25:19controls the work who gets money who gets how
- 25:22people get paid So there are four things you
- 25:23really need your clients to set out from the
- 25:26outset contractual relationship For those of
- 25:30you don't know copyright which covers ownership
- 25:34of works of art and really all works Has it as
- 25:40the the default and copyright laws essentially
- 25:42that? the creator or creators of that work of
- 25:46art is the owner, barring a contract stating
- 25:50otherwise. In commission and collaborative projects,
- 25:54which is what most of this immersive work is,
- 25:56because it's usually not something that one individual
- 25:58does on their own, that default rarely reflects
- 26:01the actual intent. You're going to see language
- 26:04superseding that default copyright language.
- 26:07Agreement must state explicitly, is this a work
- 26:10for hire? Is copyright simply being assigned
- 26:13or is it simply being licensed? Is there exclusivity
- 26:15to the license? What's the scope and duration
- 26:17of the license? If it is a license or even if
- 26:20it is assignment, are modifications allowed,
- 26:23reproduction, sub -licensing, derivative works,
- 26:25and on what terms? This needs to be figured out
- 26:29because if it's not, it's a giant open -ended
- 26:31question and the default is not going to be very
- 26:33useful for your clients. The thing I tell people
- 26:36who are new to the IP space is that it's not
- 26:39rocket science. Getting it out there in plain
- 26:42English is going to accomplish what you need
- 26:44most of the time. You just need to be making
- 26:45sure you're thinking of all the angles. A short
- 26:47deal memo, a two -page, or even an email with
- 26:50enough language is going to be better than nothing.
- 26:53Compensation structures. So another one. Working
- 26:56with, let's say, four models. They are not interchangeable.
- 27:00Flat fee for discrete. deliverables. You have
- 27:04milestone -based payments tied to different production
- 27:06stages. This is particularly important when you're
- 27:09bringing in people who have high, high expenses
- 27:11that need to be covered. Commissions based on
- 27:14sales or attendance. and revenue sharing related
- 27:18to tickets, downloads, or in -app purchases.
- 27:22For VR or AR, where you are licensing or being
- 27:25assigned a VR AR product to bring into your production,
- 27:30that could keep generating revenue long after
- 27:32the production's over. So revenue share would
- 27:34often make sense, but then you need to include
- 27:36things like audit rights and detailed accounting,
- 27:38things that are going to tie you to the artist
- 27:41or the inventor or the creator and the producer
- 27:44for many, many years to come. Due diligence.
- 27:48This is something that we tell all of our clients
- 27:51to do before you sign up with somebody. Look
- 27:54into whether that person on the other side is
- 27:57trustworthy. Are they financially stable? Do
- 28:00they have a track record of timely payments?
- 28:02Who else in the industry has worked with them?
- 28:03And if you know, call up those people and ask
- 28:06how it's going to go. And I tell all of my clients,
- 28:10contract is not useful if the other side is not
- 28:12going to honor it. So you really want to understand
- 28:16how the other side is going to treat you when
- 28:18you're owed money or when you are owed feedback
- 28:20on the things that you're creating with them.
- 28:24Especially if you are producing for other people
- 28:27or your clients are producing for other people,
- 28:29the thing you need to think about is getting
- 28:30paid upfront, whether it's a deposit, whether
- 28:32it's just payment for expenses. The biggest issue
- 28:36I see from newer producers is trusting clients,
- 28:40taking on all the production costs themselves,
- 28:42and then being out of pocket. And that happens
- 28:44quite a bit. Where it's been happening in a more
- 28:46commercial space that I see, which is kind of
- 28:48tough, is you'll have people who are, let's say,
- 28:53native to the art world who are now working with
- 28:54brands, and brands want to do these live activations.
- 28:56And brands are not necessarily comfortable with
- 28:58the idea of paying upfront. They want a live
- 29:00activation to promote what they're doing, to
- 29:04promote their products. And the client, the producer
- 29:08client needs to explain to them, hey, love to
- 29:10do this with you, but I need 75 upfront because
- 29:13usually 80 plus percent of the budget is just
- 29:17for expenses. It's not going into my pocket.
- 29:19So those are tough conversations you need to
- 29:20have upfront. But if you can have those conversations,
- 29:23get through it and get the other side to agree,
- 29:25it's going to save a massive, massive headache
- 29:27later on. And then another thing to think about
- 29:29is copyright registration. Register with the
- 29:32U .S. copyright. before delivery, depending on
- 29:35who's supposed to own what. Two reasons to do
- 29:38this. A, simple enough. Public record of authorship
- 29:41is there for you. It prevents arguments down
- 29:44the road or at least gets ahead of arguments.
- 29:46And it's, copyright registration is a prerequisite
- 29:48for statutory damages and attorney's fees. Really
- 29:52important to think about. It's an easy process.
- 29:55A lot of our clients are handling copyright registration
- 29:57on their own. And the other thing too, especially
- 29:59with works that are evolving over time, if you're
- 30:00making updates and significant upgrades, register
- 30:04those upgrades and derivative works later on
- 30:06too. Is there any cost waterfall we should know
- 30:09about when calculating revenue profit share?
- 30:14It is really a function of contract. And we always
- 30:19advise people, you know, don't break the mold
- 30:21too much. In film, it's very simple. You know,
- 30:24there's obviously going to be variations on a
- 30:26film. uh, revenue waterfall to some degree, but
- 30:29most of what we're creating or what we're receiving
- 30:31looks pretty similar in this space, which has
- 30:35not been around for too long, especially when
- 30:37with the rev share model, you're going to have
- 30:40to figure it out. You're going to have to talk
- 30:41to your colleagues. You're going to have to talk
- 30:44to other producers in the space. And work it
- 30:46out with the people on the other side. And really,
- 30:48I think the big thing is understanding what other
- 30:50individuals' contributions are and how meaningful
- 30:52it is to equate to the percentage that you're
- 30:54going to give them, which can be pretty tough.
- 30:56Of course, if we're representing the party that's
- 30:58producing everything, we're going to want a really
- 31:01nice, broad definition of net that makes sure
- 31:03that our clients are recovering before they have
- 31:05to share funds and then kind of going from there.
- 31:07Of course, if you're bringing in investors, then
- 31:11that's something you need to think about as well.
- 31:13Jack Russo says, are you aware of any paymaster
- 31:17who automates all these payments as a bank does
- 31:19in a construction contract or paychecks for employees?
- 31:23You have cameras in film. I don't know if there's
- 31:26equivalent in this space. You can always hire
- 31:29third parties to do that. I'm not sure of services
- 31:31off the top of my head that would be able to
- 31:34provide that though. Let's move on to slide 11.
- 31:42Yes, so next we're going to talk about IP challenges,
- 31:46trade dress, and international protection. This
- 31:49is where the interesting doctrinal questions
- 31:51live. Immersive work tests the outer limits of
- 31:54copyright and pushes practitioners into trademark,
- 31:57trade dress, and increasingly designed patent
- 32:00territory. First, we have copyright ability.
- 32:03So the Copyright Act, 17 USD, section 102, protects
- 32:07original works of authorship fixed in a tangible
- 32:10medium. Fixed sculptural components, video projections,
- 32:15program sequences, those fit comfortably. Ephemeral
- 32:19and variable dimensions, such as participant
- 32:22-driven movement, real -time algorithmic response,
- 32:26and sense press the fixation requirement. The
- 32:29ninth circuit in Tangle versus Eritzia, Eritzia,
- 32:34Inc. held that kinetic and manipulable sculptural
- 32:38works are sufficiently fixed even when their
- 32:41pose changes, analogizing to dance, film, and
- 32:45music. The central district of California in
- 32:49Team Lab versus Museum of Dream Space held that
- 32:53interactive immersive installations with fixed
- 32:55elements are copyrightable despite variable user
- 32:59experiences. These cases open doctrinal space,
- 33:03but ephemeral edges remain uncertain and practitioners
- 33:06should think about patent protection for novel
- 33:09interactive mechanisms and trademark slash trade
- 33:12dress protection for distinctive sensory signatures.
- 33:16Some international considerations. Fixation of
- 33:19moral rights, design rights. Fixation is a U
- 33:23.S. rule. Japan, so GCL, I can't remember what
- 33:29GCL stands for right now, I'm so sorry. Articles
- 33:3221 through 27 does not impose a fixation requirement,
- 33:36opening broader protection for performance -based
- 33:39and ephemeral warfare. Burn sets a floor for
- 33:43not a ceiling. on moral rights. France, Germany,
- 33:47and much of the EU recognize robust and in some
- 33:50cases perpetual moral rights that can restrict
- 33:56post -sale modifications and support attribution
- 33:59claims in the US. 17 USC section 106A, which
- 34:08is BARA, does not reach. on design rights. The
- 34:13EU's registered community design and the new
- 34:16EU design regulation give a useful alternative
- 34:19protection layer for the distinctive visual configuration
- 34:23of an installation, a category US design patents
- 34:27also address, but with meaningfully different
- 34:29scope and cost. A practical strategy here. Portfolio
- 34:34across copyright, trademarked last trade dress,
- 34:37design rights, and selective patents market by
- 34:40market. A single jurisdiction IP strategy leaves
- 34:43holes everywhere else. Next, we're going to talk
- 34:47about trade dress and branding. Where copyright
- 34:50is uncertain, trade dress can pick up the slack
- 34:53for the distinctive look and feel of an installation,
- 34:57provided it is non -functional and has acquired
- 34:59secondary meaning. So the headline case here
- 35:03is Meow Wolf versus Wake the Tiger. A U .S. immersive
- 35:07art company alleging that a UK immersive installation
- 35:10copied its distinctive configuration and aesthetic.
- 35:14Law .com and Texas Lawyer have both reported
- 35:18a coming wave of trade dress litigation in immersive
- 35:21art. a case in the Western District of Texas
- 35:29involving the neutral beige and cream aesthetic
- 35:33dispute. This case settled, but it left open
- 35:36novel questions about copyright and trade dress
- 35:38protection for social media sensory aesthetics.
- 35:44The trade dress piece is really interesting.
- 35:46We're definitely gonna be seeing a lot more cases
- 35:48coming out in the next five to 10 years. It's
- 35:50really... filling a gap that copyright and trademark
- 35:56on the other side of things is sort of lacking,
- 35:59but there will need to be a ton of case law decided
- 36:04to actually see how it plays out. It's a big,
- 36:08vague, ambiguous beige area right now. So it'll
- 36:12be, I think that's something if you're interested
- 36:14in this space to really keep an eye on over the
- 36:16next little while. Yeah, it's becoming a key
- 36:19defensive tool. So next we have, right, protocols
- 36:25must be unique. Here we go. So I want to spend
- 36:29a few minutes on something that's easy to underestimate,
- 36:32the protocol layer. Traditional art law protocols,
- 36:36standard gallery contracts, film production agreements,
- 36:39do not translate clearly to immersive work because
- 36:42immersive work has four distinctive features.
- 36:46Number one is multiple layers of IP, code, sound,
- 36:50visual art, choreography, life performance, each
- 36:53may be created by a different person or a team,
- 36:57each subject to its own rights regime. A VR installation
- 37:01can combine proprietary code from a tech partner,
- 37:04licensed music, freelance created visual assets,
- 37:08and a live performance layer. Without a protocol
- 37:11that delinates ownership of each component, disputes
- 37:15over credit, compensation, and control are almost
- 37:18guaranteed. The second feature is real -time
- 37:23collaboration. So works are often built and operated
- 37:27in real time with artists, engineers, curators,
- 37:30and AI systems all contributing. Authorship blurs,
- 37:34and sometimes the audience becomes a co -creator.
- 37:38Protocols must address both initial authorship
- 37:40and ongoing modifications to the work. The third
- 37:45point is participant data and privacy. So the
- 37:49work uses participant data such as biometrical,
- 37:52behavioral, emotional data to drive the experience.
- 37:56You cannot treat privacy and IP as separate silos.
- 38:00You need one integrated policy framework. And
- 38:04then our last point is international distribution.
- 38:08As we all know and have seen, immersive work
- 38:10travels. The protocol has to be portable across
- 38:14privacy regimes, IP regimes, safety standards,
- 38:18and accessibility requirements. The four protocol
- 38:21types we use at Wiseman Law are one, custom interdisciplinary
- 38:26collaboration agreements with ownership and revenue
- 38:30sharing defined at each layer. Two, jurisdiction
- 38:33specific IP strategies, recognizing that what
- 38:37is copyright protected in the US may need to
- 38:39be registered as a design right in Europe or
- 38:42a trademark elsewhere. Three, integrated privacy
- 38:46and IP policies, and four, which is ongoing legal
- 38:50review, because technology and law change faster
- 38:53than any static contract can anticipate. So with
- 38:59all that in mind, we go into authorship and collaboration,
- 39:02which is very difficult with a lot of these things,
- 39:05especially now that we have artificial intelligence
- 39:09being thrown in the mix, which is just an element
- 39:11that comes up in our practice on an almost daily
- 39:14basis now, as I imagine it does for many of you
- 39:16in the audience. So defining authorship. We talked
- 39:21about how the copyright recognizes authorship
- 39:24by default as people who are creating things.
- 39:27And when two or more human creators intend to
- 39:31create something together, there's joint authorship
- 39:34there. Keyword there, however, is human. Copyright
- 39:38office. And recent federal decisions have been
- 39:40pretty clear that works generated solely by AI
- 39:43are not copyrightable. They cannot be registered
- 39:45as copyright. It cannot necessarily be protected.
- 39:47So when AI is used as a tool, an artist directing,
- 39:53prompting, selecting, modifying, the question
- 39:55becomes whether the human input rises to creative
- 39:58authorship or not. You have to document those
- 40:01inputs, save the prompts, the iterations, the
- 40:03selection decisions. And you also need to make
- 40:05sure that your contracts Identify this, it allocates
- 40:08ownership and it identifies when and where AI
- 40:11is coming into play. You don't want just blanket
- 40:13language saying that AI is just okay. or AI is
- 40:18not okay, you need to figure out exactly how
- 40:20that's going to work. Studio practices. A person's
- 40:23studios often look like film crews. You have
- 40:26assistants, fabricators, coders, sound designers,
- 40:28VFX artists above the line, below the line. Without
- 40:31written agreements, for example, a programmer
- 40:33who wrote custom code for your interactive installation
- 40:35can assert joint authorship at any point. Every
- 40:39contributor down to the interns who are just
- 40:42coming in for a few hours a week needs to get
- 40:44an agreement that identifies what their work
- 40:49is, how it's being contributed to the production
- 40:51or not, protocols and agreements. Our standard
- 40:55onboarding packet for our clients in the space
- 40:58usually includes some sort of work for hire or
- 41:02assignment writer, of course, language, depending
- 41:04on the jurisdiction that you're in, your short
- 41:09-form or long -form, engaging letter that's going
- 41:11to be... attached to that rights waiver where
- 41:14applicable via rights waiver confidentiality
- 41:17which is not something a lot of people tend to
- 41:19think about until you know their staff starts
- 41:22leaking their secrets online and crucially a
- 41:25crediting provision that says who gets what credit
- 41:28and what format you don't want that to be argued
- 41:31against one thing that's always kind of funny
- 41:33is we see that A lot of our clients ask us about
- 41:38credits and what the default is. And our answer
- 41:40usually is, well, there's industry standards.
- 41:42But from a legal perspective, credits are kind
- 41:44of artificial. So make sure it's in the contract
- 41:47specifically. Otherwise, figuring out it's going
- 41:48to be very, very difficult. AI training data
- 41:52provenance. One more pressure point you should
- 41:54not skip. If your client's installation incorporates
- 41:56AI systems trained on third party material, you
- 41:59should look into whether the training data was
- 42:00licensed. There's a pending wave of generative
- 42:03AI training data litigation like the New York
- 42:06Times versus OpenAI, Getty Images versus StabilityAI,
- 42:09Anderson, and StabilityAI, which are probably
- 42:12going to reshape the risk posture over the next
- 42:14year of using AI or not. For now, you want to
- 42:18make sure clients are getting the warranties
- 42:19and indemnities needed from their vendors. And
- 42:22you want to make sure your clients understand
- 42:25all of these things. Going back to ownership,
- 42:27make sure your clients recognize when they can
- 42:29and can't claim ownership over something. Adam,
- 42:33one thing I'll underscore, the moral rights waivers
- 42:36matters more than people think because immersive
- 42:39works are constantly modified post -launch. New
- 42:42lighting, new audio, new interactive elements.
- 42:45Without the waiver, a contributor can later object
- 42:48to those modifications as mutilations of the
- 42:51work under barra. Ralph in the thread writes,
- 42:58I apologize for questioning this further, but
- 42:59I understood that writer publicity protects an
- 43:01individual from use of their voice or image for
- 43:03use in commercial products, such as cereal boxes
- 43:05or toys. That's correct. If one makes a movie
- 43:08about Marilyn Monroe, the First Amendment protects
- 43:10the work, including advertising for it. Creating
- 43:12dolls of Marilyn for sale in the lobby would
- 43:14be prohibited. That's mostly correct. I will
- 43:17caveat it with there are exceptions. I've certainly
- 43:20seen art pieces of deceased famous people that
- 43:25are really just action figures at the end of
- 43:27the day. But yes, if you're making a biopic,
- 43:30you do have a lot of First Amendment exemptions.
- 43:33But the second you start commercializing that,
- 43:35you know, I don't think you're gonna be able
- 43:36to make a popcorn bucket out of Marilyn Monroe's
- 43:39head so easily. But again, there are a lot of
- 43:42caveats to that. And I think the big thing to
- 43:44know is it's also different state by state. Thank
- 43:48you, Adam. So up next, we're going to talk about
- 43:52enforcement, international, and monitoring. Greg
- 43:56points out Marilyn Monroe has no porous modem
- 43:58ROP, and that's going to depend on where she
- 44:01passed away, whatever state she was in. So thank
- 44:03you for that, Greg. I'm not sure off the top
- 44:05of my head. Greg, if you want to follow up with
- 44:07where, that would be helpful. I don't know either
- 44:10where she died. So back to enforcement, international
- 44:15and monitoring. Even with the strongest protocols
- 44:18in place, the enforcement problem doesn't disappear.
- 44:21It intensifies, actually, because immersive and
- 44:24digital work can be copied, streamed, and exploited
- 44:28across borders almost instantly. I'll take the
- 44:31final and international piece. Adam will handle
- 44:34the tech -assisted tools. First, we have international
- 44:38enforcement. IP protection in the US does not
- 44:41solve the problem abroad. Some jurisdictions
- 44:44have weak enforcement, some don't recognize the
- 44:46right at all, and international treaties set
- 44:49floors, but don't create a unified forum. A practical
- 44:53strategy here. Register in key target markets,
- 44:57line up local council in each, and plan for use
- 45:00of the burden convention, TRIPS, and applicable
- 45:03bilateral treaties. Active monitoring. Because
- 45:08the Supreme Court's decision in Warner Chapel
- 45:11Music versus Neely, 2024 keeps the pre -filing
- 45:15damages window alive, you still want to detect
- 45:18infringement early. Delay still kills injunctive
- 45:23relief and leverage. Your client needs an active
- 45:27monitoring regime across social media, NFT marketplaces,
- 45:31and video platforms. Larger clients retain dedicated
- 45:35staff or third -party services. Smaller clients
- 45:38should at a minimum run Google Alerts and reverse
- 45:41image searches on a schedule. Tech tools for
- 45:46enforcement. These are not things that we're
- 45:48necessarily doing at our firm, although some
- 45:50of our litigation colleagues at other firms certainly
- 45:52are. But these are things that we've talked to
- 45:54some clients about and we've seen them implement
- 45:55in the past. AI -powered monitoring, I think
- 45:58maybe one of the upsides of AI, is that automated
- 46:02infringement detection services can scroll through
- 46:05the internet, looking at vast swaths of websites
- 46:08and platforms for matches and generate takedown
- 46:10requests at a scale just not possible by individual
- 46:14humans. Use them carefully, though. Make sure
- 46:17you're using ones that are vetted. Make sure
- 46:19that you're not using one that's going to get
- 46:20you a lot of false positives. I think that's
- 46:22going to be a really interesting area in general
- 46:25when it comes to IP enforcement that we're going
- 46:27to see develop over the next couple of years.
- 46:30Watermarking, visible and invisible watermarking
- 46:32makes ownership easier to prove. Of course, unfortunately,
- 46:35AI is also in there to get rid of watermarks.
- 46:38One thing that we tell a lot of our artist clients
- 46:40as they're work in progress is give low resolution
- 46:44files to your clients before they pay you and
- 46:46after they pay you, give them the full ones,
- 46:48just little things to protect you long term.
- 46:52Content poisoning tools, nightshade, glaze, these
- 46:55are tools that can alter your work to corrupt
- 46:58their value for unauthorized AI training. It's
- 47:00a defensive tool, but they carry their own risks.
- 47:03Of course, there's downstream risk. If you're
- 47:05going to use that, make sure once again, using
- 47:07a tool that is trustworthy. So in some cases,
- 47:11it might be don't use that tool yet. Blockchain
- 47:13provenance recording provenance licensing terms
- 47:16and transfers on a distributed ledger gives your
- 47:18client a transparent temper resistant record,
- 47:20especially useful in NFT and digital collectible
- 47:23context. Not seeing this as much as we were maybe
- 47:25five years ago, as you can imagine, but there
- 47:27is still some application in the art space that
- 47:30is, I think, a very good holdover from the NFT
- 47:34grace from half a decade ago. Yes, so the overarching
- 47:41point on enforcement. You can design the best
- 47:44IP regime in the world, but if your client has
- 47:46no monitoring posture and no budget for enforcement,
- 47:49the protection is theoretical. Council has to
- 47:52build the enforcement posture into the initial
- 47:56engagement. Yes, Angela noted for UK IP consolidation,
- 48:02might the installation have some physical objects
- 48:04that could be within scope for registering as
- 48:05well as your designs in UK? faster and quicker
- 48:07than trademarks in the UK. Not sure specifically
- 48:10about the UK, but actually in the United States,
- 48:12that is the case too. You can absolutely register
- 48:16copyright over sculptures, over useful objects
- 48:19if there's sufficient design incorporated into
- 48:20it. So if there is a, let's say, centerpiece
- 48:24in your installation that you register copyright
- 48:27and is knocked off one for one, that's going
- 48:30to be a much easier case than somebody just kind
- 48:32of copying, let's say, your overall feel and
- 48:35color scheme. Thank you, Adam, for answering
- 48:39the audience questions. I really appreciate that.
- 48:42So next, we're going to talk about the practical
- 48:44considerations for counsel at the technological
- 48:47frontier. We want to close with four practice
- 48:50management pointers for attorneys representing
- 48:53clients in this space. These aren't doctrinal.
- 48:56They're about how to actually run the representation
- 48:58well. Adam, you have the first one. Yeah, industry
- 49:03fluency. This is something that anytime I'm talking
- 49:06to lawyers getting into a space is the first
- 49:09thing I discuss. I don't care. how much you understand
- 49:14about the law if you can't talk about the industry
- 49:16that you're getting into. You need to understand
- 49:20platforms, monetization models, tech. More importantly,
- 49:24you need to understand industry standards that
- 49:26making sure that the things you're asking for
- 49:28are not going to be completely out of scope or
- 49:30completely unexpected. Your clients should be
- 49:33able to chat with you and walk away going, OK,
- 49:36this lawyer knows what I'm doing and not feel
- 49:39like they have to follow up. with a million points
- 49:43to try to educate you. You should be educating
- 49:45them wherever possible. The second practice pointer
- 49:50is cross -disciplinary co -counseling. Immersive
- 49:53work sits at the intersection of IP, privacy,
- 49:57tech regulation, foreign law, tax, labor, and
- 50:01in the NFT context, securities. Bring in specialists
- 50:05early and co -counsel with local council and
- 50:08foreign jurisdictions. Building a trusted co
- 50:10-counsel bench is one of the highest leverage
- 50:13investments you can make in this practice. Client
- 50:17education and expectation management. Many of
- 50:22the clients coming to you in this space are coming
- 50:25to meet a lawyer for the first time ever and
- 50:27they often underestimate things like IP enforcement
- 50:31costs, timelines if you are getting involved
- 50:34in lawsuits or threatening lawsuits, and realistic
- 50:37leverage points. What you need to do is set expectations
- 50:40from the get -go. Both Lorraine and myself used
- 50:43to be litigators. We are not anymore. We are
- 50:46now transactional attorneys. Our job today is
- 50:49really more just coaching clients on the cost
- 50:52of contract review and negotiation. But when
- 50:54it comes to litigation, I think The thing that
- 50:58I used to see the most was lawyers promising
- 51:00the moon and not telling their clients how much
- 51:02it's going to cost to get there. Conversation
- 51:05goes better at an intake than before a client
- 51:09has dropped six figures into a project, discovering
- 51:12that their lawsuit is not that tenable in the
- 51:16first place. Jay asked us to show any examples
- 51:20of the kind of artwork you are discussing. Lorraine,
- 51:23are those accessible in the different cases that
- 51:27we included? Some of what specific kind of are,
- 51:33sorry? Everything we're talking about. Jay, I
- 51:36would recommend - Yeah, they're definitely in
- 51:37the cases that are cited throughout, and at the
- 51:41end of the PowerPoint slides, there's the CLE
- 51:44materials that were cited, and I cite all the
- 51:46cases. I would highly recommend Googling Meow
- 51:49Wolf. To me, they are the perfect example. of
- 51:52the type of work that we're talking about and
- 51:53they have some unbelievable installations in
- 51:57different parts of the country. And the Van Gogh
- 52:00live one that ran for so many different states.
- 52:03I feel like I'm not a fan. I'm not a huge fan
- 52:05of that one. You didn't like it. Oh, my God.
- 52:08I loved it. And I feel like the Van Gogh one
- 52:10was kind of like what prompted everything, you
- 52:13know, that I think that was the first like immersive
- 52:15artist that I ever went to. That was a just just
- 52:18for people listening aren't familiar. That was
- 52:20a projection of Van Gogh's paintings over massive
- 52:24warehouse rooms. And I think they were all. moving
- 52:27pieces of art, right? Yeah, they were all moving.
- 52:31It was like a big, really big videos. It was
- 52:33super cool. I loved it. So going back to our
- 52:38practice management pointers, our fourth and
- 52:41final practice management pointer is supporting
- 52:44collaborative, creative ecosystems. Immersive
- 52:47work is built by teams, assistants, fabricators,
- 52:50coders, sound designers, performers, council
- 52:53artists on fair compensation structures, transparent
- 52:57crediting practices and protocols that acknowledge
- 52:59the labor of technical collaborators. Helping
- 53:02clients build equitable practices is both good
- 53:06counseling and in practical terms, dispute prevention.
- 53:09The best way to avoid authorship and credit litigation
- 53:12is to have agreements and crediting practices
- 53:15everyone in the studio understood from the start.
- 53:22So now we're moving on to our two hypotheticals
- 53:25that have to do with immersive art. Adam, you're
- 53:27welcome to take the first one. Sure, so let's
- 53:30go through this. Your client is a Los Angeles
- 53:32-based immersive studio that has developed a
- 53:3445 -minute VR experience using mix of original
- 53:37code, licensed music, and freelance -created
- 53:39visual assets. Experience uses eye tracking to
- 53:42drive adaptive narrative, which means it captures
- 53:44biometric data. The studio wants to tour the
- 53:47work to New York, Chicago, Austin, and London,
- 53:49spot the top three legal issues. So ones that
- 53:52we were thinking about as we're going through
- 53:54this, you're looking at biometric privacy compliance
- 53:56issues. The Illinois BIPA is the big one here,
- 54:00plus the GDPR in London. IP layering in the contract
- 54:04claim, make sure that there's clean rights in
- 54:06the code that's being assigned or licensed to
- 54:08you, all the music that you're going to use,
- 54:10all the visual assets, and whether the rev share
- 54:12model survives multi -jurisdictional tax treatment.
- 54:15That's certainly when you're going to want to
- 54:16bring in an accountant too. And then finally
- 54:18premises liability insurance coverage at each
- 54:20venue, particularly when it speaks to the VR
- 54:24headset sharing and disorientation risks that
- 54:26come from that. In our second hypothetical, oh
- 54:33wait, where'd it go? Sorry, lost my notes. One
- 54:36second. Okay. A collective, three human artists
- 54:40and a proprietary AI image generation system
- 54:43create a large scale project installation for
- 54:46three California museums. One of the three artists
- 54:50leaves the collective mid -project. A fourth
- 54:52artist is hired to finish. Who owns the work?
- 54:56So we first start with whether the three artists
- 54:59collective contributed as joint authors under
- 55:0217 USC section 101. Human intent to merge contributions
- 55:06into a unitary whole. The AI generated portions
- 55:10are not independently copyrightable, but human
- 55:13selection and arrangement can be. The departing
- 55:16artist likely pertains joint ownership of her
- 55:19contributions unless she assigned them. The late
- 55:23-joining artist's contributions need an assignment
- 55:26or work -for -hire agreement. The best practice
- 55:29is a written joint authorship agreement from
- 55:32day one and an assignment or work -for -hire
- 55:34agreement with any later contributor. And finally,
- 55:43we have our top 10 practice tips for trials of,
- 55:48let's say, authors for attorneys. counseling
- 55:52clients in this space. Adam, they're the first
- 55:54five. Yeah, let's blitz through this and then
- 55:57see if we have any questions to end this off
- 55:58on. So start every engagement with who you are
- 56:01in this deal. Talk to your clients, understand
- 56:03where they're coming from, understand the different
- 56:05exposure that their role plays in the production.
- 56:08Match the insurance submission to actual activities,
- 56:11interactive, biometric, consumable, participatory.
- 56:13Disclose everything, and then when that policy
- 56:15is handed to your client, make sure you're reading
- 56:17it through with them to understand that they're
- 56:19actually covered. Use customized risk -specific
- 56:21liability waivers. That one -liner is not going
- 56:23to do. Make sure that the actual activities that
- 56:27are in the installation are reflected in that
- 56:31waiver. Implement written opt -in biometric consent,
- 56:34BIPA, CUBI standards, even if you do not think
- 56:37you will tour those states. Much better to just
- 56:41draft that waiver with the universe of what you
- 56:43need, then having your client come to you last
- 56:46minute going, oh, we actually showed up here.
- 56:48What should we be doing? And then put every collaborator
- 56:51under a written contract. Every human being who's
- 56:54touching this project should be signing something
- 56:57and should be signing something that matches
- 56:59what you think they are entitled to and what
- 57:01you're entitled to back for them. We cannot stress
- 57:04that enough, the importance of contracts. Our
- 57:09next five. Top practice tips are register copyrights
- 57:14before delivery. Register updates and derivatives.
- 57:17For commercial reuse of attending footage, layer
- 57:21consent at purchase, at entry, and at relevant
- 57:24thresholds inside the installation. Build trade
- 57:27dress protection into the branding strategy where
- 57:30copyright may be uncertain. Document human creative
- 57:34input on any AI -assisted work. Screen capture
- 57:37the prompts and save the iterations. And last
- 57:41but not least, budget for enforcement at the
- 57:44engagement stage, not after. Monitoring is truly
- 57:48not optional. Before we take any questions, the
- 57:54thorough line of everything we've said today,
- 57:56immersive art requires lawyers to think across
- 57:58domains, premises liability, IP, privacy. contract,
- 58:03and practical business counseling simultaneously
- 58:06and in real time. The single domain specialist
- 58:09is at a disadvantage. The payoff is that this
- 58:12is generally exciting work on the cutting edge
- 58:15of what creative expression truly looks like.
- 58:18So I know we have about five or four minutes
- 58:21for your questions, anything at all. If you have
- 58:23any questions about the hypos or any of the issues
- 58:27that we touched upon, please go ahead. I see
- 58:31a few questions in here hanging on from a few
- 58:33minutes ago, although I'm not sure we're going
- 58:35to get into any specific detail with these ones.
- 58:37Any trend for licensing content for AI training
- 58:39purposes? Would you recommend such a license?
- 58:41I'm certainly seeing a lot of that with some
- 58:44of our clients where platforms are reaching out
- 58:46to them to train on their work. Whether I think
- 58:49that's a good thing or not is not something I'm
- 58:51going to get into today. Do you represent writers
- 58:54in Broadway theater projects? We have in the
- 58:57past, not a major area of focus in our firm,
- 58:59but certainly feel free to reach out to us after
- 59:01if there's somebody you'd like us to speak to.
- 59:03Maria, how do you advise AI developers and service
- 59:06providers from the EU wanting to enter the US
- 59:08market? I feel like that is a tremendously open
- 59:12-ended question that, Maria. I know we've talked
- 59:15offline. Feel free to reach out to me if you
- 59:17have specific questions. Greg goes, how to deal
- 59:19with unauthorized copying by visitors posting
- 59:21cell phone pics and videos other than prohibiting
- 59:23photography. That's a tough one. You're going
- 59:27to want to include language in your waiver or
- 59:30in your release saying no photography allowed,
- 59:34something like that, that you can't share images.
- 59:36The big part of it is you If this is a closed
- 59:42set type of installation, you don't want people
- 59:44releasing images of the public. You want to be
- 59:46surprised to all your attendees. From a practical
- 59:50perspective, that might entail putting stickers
- 59:53on people's phone cameras or might entail bagging
- 59:55them or other things like that. That goes to
- 59:57the policy and purchaser's things that you could
- 59:58be working out with your client. From a legal
- 1:00:00perspective, sending cease and desist letters
- 1:00:04to individual attendees, probably not a great
- 1:00:07look. Yeah, are they in violation of that waiver
- 1:00:10or that admission thing that they signed with
- 1:00:14you? Sure. Are you going to do anything about
- 1:00:16it? Probably not. If things are posted on social
- 1:00:20media, can you maybe take advantage of the DMCA
- 1:00:23regime and get things taken down? Potentially.
- 1:00:26You don't own the photograph, but you certainly
- 1:00:28might own some of the copyrighted material that
- 1:00:30they're posting. So there's angles there, but
- 1:00:32I would be very hesitant to go the formal legal
- 1:00:35route. of threatening to see those individuals.
- 1:00:40Any other questions? I know we're pretty much
- 1:00:41at time. Lorraine, do you want to take us home?
- 1:00:50I'll close up. Yes. So if we don't have any more
- 1:00:52questions, thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar
- 1:00:55Association for contact, or just for everyone
- 1:00:58who was wondering here, all the cases that I
- 1:01:01cited, which you can find. There's also secondary
- 1:01:04materials as well. Our contract information and
- 1:01:08a references to the Acacia statutes and article
- 1:01:10cited today are at the end of your materials.
- 1:01:12We are happy to continue this conversation offline,
- 1:01:15so feel free to email either of us. And thank
- 1:01:17you so much for being here today. This was great.
- 1:01:19I hope everyone learned a lot. And thank you
- 1:01:22for having us again.