Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Light Triad vs Dark Triad (2020 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hageserven listeners. It's just me today. I thought I would answer some Patroon
- 0:04emails. This first emails from anonymous Patrin saying, have you heard about the
- 0:09light triad personality traits in contrast to the dark triad? So apparently there's something
- 0:15called a light triad as opposed to the dark triad? What do you think
- 0:19about it? Can someone, for instance, exhibit these traits? Blah blah
- 0:24blah? Is there sort of Is this sort of thing going to be an
- 0:27area of interest in the mental health community? End of email? So no,
- 0:32I had never heard of the light triad. I'd heard of the dark
- 0:34trad So the dark triad is often associated with a character. It's a consolation
- 0:44of character traits that are associated with bad things. Narcissism, machiavelianism, and
- 0:51psychopathy. Narcissism meaning that you're self centered and you have a grandiose sense of
- 0:57your own entitlement and your own specialness that is not rational, Machiavalenism meaning that
- 1:03you scheme to screw people over for your own gain, and psychopathy in a
- 1:11nutshell meaning that you don't have a lot of empathy or care for other human
- 1:14beings or respect for other human beings. And apparently there's something called the light
- 1:19triad, which is Kantianism, which is essentially being nice to people just to
- 1:26be nice, not for personal gain. So this is like the opposite of
- 1:30Machiavellenism, right. Machiavelianism is like, you're only nice to people if it's
- 1:34if you're going to get something out of it. But Kantianism is, you
- 1:40know, just being nice to people just to be nice because you know,
- 1:42you just feel like that's the right thing to do, do you unto others.
- 1:47That kind of thing humanism valuing the dignity and the worth of each individual,
- 1:53and faith in humanity, believing in the fundamental goodness of humans. So
- 1:59being nice to people just to be nice, valuing other people and you know,
- 2:02considering everyone is worth something, and believing that other people are good.
- 2:07So that is the light triad. You know, you can tell that it's
- 2:12not actually the opposite of the dark triad. It's not like the absence of
- 2:15the dark trad because you know, if we really look at it, so
- 2:19the dark tred the dark tridea have narcissism, you know, being seeing yourself
- 2:23as the most important person in the world. So having that having narcissism doesn't
- 2:30mean that you also can't be nice to people just to be nice. Plenty
- 2:35of narcissistic people can be nice to people just to be nice. Also,
- 2:38you can be narcissistic and value the dignity of other people. You can also
- 2:45be narcissistic and believe in the fundamental goodness of other humans. So right there,
- 2:50we realize that the dark triad is not the opposite of the light triad.
- 2:55Other things here are. So if we look at psychopathy, you know,
- 3:00you don't really care about other people's feelings. But being a psychopath doesn't
- 3:05mean that you take pleasure in other people's harm. It just means that you
- 3:09just don't have as much empathy as other people do. You don't when you
- 3:14see people suffer. It doesn't get to you the way that it gets to
- 3:16other people. And being a psychopath doesn't mean also that you're not nice to
- 3:22people. Psychopaths can be perfectly nice to people, even if it's not for
- 3:27personal gain, so not as it's not as likely. Also, you can
- 3:32be a psychopath and believe in the fundamental goodness of other humans, So it's
- 3:38not you know, it's not exactly the opposite, and Scott Coffin was wanted
- 3:44to be clear about that the correlation is only moderate. Actually between the two
- 3:47it's about a point five correlation, meaning that as you gain more dark triad
- 3:53traits you will see a correlation line of about point five instead of one to
- 3:59one, if that makes it. If you understand statistics, you understand what
- 4:01this means. So what did they find. Well, what they found was
- 4:03in this study is they actually looked at a lot of different people and tried
- 4:09to measure how much of a how much dark triad they had and how much
- 4:13light triad they had, and then also tried to get a lot of demographic
- 4:15information and other personality and sort of lifestyle information. And so here's what they
- 4:19found, and it's kind of interesting. So what they found was that the
- 4:24average person was that was somewhat light. So most people, the bell curve
- 4:32of people is not super light, but somewhat light, if you know what
- 4:38I'm saying. So if you have a spectrum from dark to light, which
- 4:41actually isn't really a spectrum, there's more of a squishy scatter plot. So
- 4:47if you know a scatter plot, Gosh, how do I want to talk
- 4:50about this. I think you understand. What I'm saying is that the average
- 4:54person is is like slightly to moderately light. The high end you have some
- 5:01people are actually very light, but you have very few people who are very
- 5:06dark. Does that make sense? Okay? The dark triad was positively correlated
- 5:13with the following things, the dark triad being younger. So why would being
- 5:19younger be more associated with dark triad? So as we by implication, as
- 5:26we age, we become more light triad. So as we age, we
- 5:30become we're more likely to be nice to people just to be nice. We're
- 5:35more likely to value the dignity of other people. We're more likely to believe
- 5:40in the fundamental goodness of humans. Now why is that? Well speculation?
- 5:46When we're younger, we're more selfish. Generally speaking, as three year olds,
- 5:53for example, we can be really quite selfish, and we don't really
- 5:57have the capacity to understand whether people's feel the way we do, say when
- 6:00we're twenty five or forty five. So one could appear more dark triad because
- 6:08of that. And that's the other thing to think about is like, just
- 6:10because you have a little bit of dark triad doesn't mean you are a terrible
- 6:15person. So there's that. So that's one speculation. I guess another is
- 6:24that younger people have less power in their life and maybe don't have the time
- 6:30and space to really care about other people. You know, I found for
- 6:33myself anyway. As I age, I get more power in life. You
- 6:38know, I become a boss, I get more money. You know,
- 6:41my life is more stable or something, and I have more I have less
- 6:46stress, and so I'm better able to care about other people. So I
- 6:49think that might be another factor. Also, dark triad is positively correlated with
- 6:55being male. Now they didn't which bothers me give the effect size, So
- 7:00it's hard to know what this means, but stands to reason. Right men
- 7:06are at the very least socialized to be more dark triad. Right, men
- 7:12are socialized to be less compassionate, less relationship oriented, more focused on entitlement
- 7:19and assertiveness and taking what you want to need and achievement oriented. Women are
- 7:27more socialized to be concerned about other people's feelings, to be more cooperative.
- 7:33So men are more likely to be dark triad towards dark than light by how
- 7:39much. Again, they didn't show, so I suspect it's not a large
- 7:45effect size. Also, one might speculate, particularly if a Verda was here,
- 7:50that men are born with a tendency towards dark than light. That's really
- 7:56hard to know because we live in a culture and it's just impossible for us
- 8:01to know the answer. That we would have to raise people in you know,
- 8:07containment isolation chambers and see how they were raised, you know, in
- 8:11different environments, and that would even be hard to do. But anyway,
- 8:13so anyway, being males associated with dark tride. Being motivated dark tride is
- 8:20also associated with being motivated by power, which makes sense. Also being motivated
- 8:24by instrumental sex, meaning that the sex is not for relationship building, it's
- 8:31just for either the pleasure itself or what you sort of get out of it
- 8:39Selfishly. Dark tride is also associated with being motivated by achievement. It's also
- 8:46associated with having self enhancement values, so you're trying to enhance the self.
- 8:52You're also more likely to have immature defense styles, meaning like when you're having
- 8:58an emotional problem, yell at people, or you drink or that kind of
- 9:03thing. Selfishness is also associated with dark triad, which makes sense. And
- 9:07here's what's the here's the interesting part because a lot of people who write to
- 9:11me about dark triad, they're like, well, if I want to get
- 9:16the most out of life, and I want to be happiest, then I
- 9:18shouldn't I be selfish? You know? Shouldn't I take what I want?
- 9:22Should I be assertive? Well, let's look at the data here. The
- 9:26findings is the dark triad is associated with lower life satisfaction. So the more
- 9:33dark someone is, the less satisfied they are with their life. This is
- 9:39not hard to know the reason why we are naturally social creatures. And when
- 9:45we are integrated well into our society, into our relationships, then we are
- 9:52quote unquote in a more natural state and we're going to be more happy about
- 9:56our situation. You throw humans into the ocean and forbid them from coming ashore,
- 10:03they are going to be unhappy quite quickly because we are not naturally in
- 10:09the ocean. We are naturally on the land. We are naturally social creatures.
- 10:15That a lot of positive neurotransmitters and you know, brain processes are in
- 10:22all likelihood involved when we are living our more you know natural life, if
- 10:28you will, which seems to involve a lot of socializing, a lot of
- 10:35togetherness, so dark triad less life satisfaction. Also, when we talk about
- 10:43you know, the Big Five, lower conscientiousness, so dark triad people are
- 10:46less organized. Essentially, they're less likely to be sort of careful about things.
- 10:54They're less agreeable, which makes sense. They have self transcendent values,
- 11:00meaning that they value or no sorry, they value less self transcendence, meaning
- 11:09that dark triad people are more into being that. So in other words,
- 11:15light triad people tend to be more into trying to transcend the self, like
- 11:20to give to charity or to make the world a better place. You know,
- 11:24this is transcending the self. You're trying to get out of you and
- 11:28into the world, if that makes sense sense. Dark trid people are less
- 11:33compassionate, have less empathy. Then they have a less belief that humans are
- 11:39good, and they have a lower belief that their own self is good.
- 11:43So that's interesting, right, So having dark triad means that you have lower
- 11:48self esteem and your life sucks more. This is probably again related to being
- 11:56in an unnatural state where you're not in and what your body and emotional needs
- 12:03actually need, which is to be connected to other people. But also a
- 12:07lot of our self esteem comes from just the day in and day out attachments
- 12:13with other people, you know, just being with other humans and existing with
- 12:20them. You know, you can have friendships, but if you only see
- 12:24them once a week and you don't really have anyone else for the six other
- 12:28days, then that's going to be hard for us. We you know,
- 12:31for most of us, we need to be connected to people. Okay,
- 12:35so what did they find the light triad associated with. Well, it's associated,
- 12:39like I said earlier, with being older, with being female, and
- 12:43also with less childhood unpredictability. So for dark tried people, their childhoods were
- 12:48more unpredictable, so there's more chaos, probably more abuse. Light triad people
- 12:56had higher levels of religiosity and spirituality, which is interesting. Right, So
- 13:03light triad people, you know, I don't know the effects size, but
- 13:07you know, probably a little bit more likely to be religious and spiritual,
- 13:11which is like chicken in the egg, right is, if you are dispositionally
- 13:20just more positive about humans, does that mean that you're more likely to join
- 13:24a religion, or by joining a religion, does that make you more positive
- 13:28about other human beings or maybe both? Hard to know. People with light
- 13:35triad are more satisfied with their lives. They also accept other people more often.
- 13:41They believe that other people are good. They believe that themselves are good.
- 13:45They have higher self esteem, they have more compassion, more empathy,
- 13:48more openness to experience, more conscientiousness, more organization, more responsibility, positive
- 13:54enthusiasm. So they're more enthusiastic about life. They have more satisfaction with their
- 14:01relationships. They have more competence and more autonomy. So this is interesting because
- 14:05it's not intuitive. Is that dark triad people people who are more narcissistic,
- 14:11psychopathic and machiavelian they have, you know, they feel less competence and they
- 14:22feel less independent. Isn't that interesting right? They also have higher levels of
- 14:26secure attachment style light triad people. I liked it. They actually looked into
- 14:33this because that's something that is often ignored on these kinds of studies. So
- 14:37they found a correlation between light triad and secure attachment. In other words,
- 14:43in all likelihood, if we are raised well and our parents are attuned to
- 14:48our feelings sufficiently, we are more likely to believe in other people to be
- 14:56nice, just to be nice, and to value other people. Let's see
- 15:07see light light light triad people are primarily motivated by intimacy and by self transcendent
- 15:13values as I was talking about earlier. They have more curiosity about the world,
- 15:18they have more zest for life, they have more love, they have
- 15:22more kindness, more teamwork, more forgiveness which is interesting, and more gratitude.
- 15:28So a lot of good things about the light triad, right, and
- 15:31a lot of bad things about the dark trib The light triad does not appear
- 15:35to be associated with any obvious downsides according to the researchers, except the light
- 15:43trad was negatively correlated with motivations for achievement and self enhancement. So dark triad
- 15:52people tend to be more motivated by achievement and more motivated by self enhancement.
- 15:58So this could be looked at in two different ways. I mean, you
- 16:02know, certainly being motivated by achievement isn't a bad thing, right, but
- 16:07it could be. It's like, why are you motivated for achievement? Are
- 16:10you motivated for achievement because you want to crush your enemies because you want to
- 16:15show off? Or are you motivated by achievement for achievement's sake? It really
- 16:21just depends, right, Like for me in my life, I guess throughout
- 16:26my life, I've vacillated between this, between the two stances of because I
- 16:33am very motivated for achievement and I always have been, But for what reason?
- 16:38Right is it because I'm trying to show off or because it's in line
- 16:44with a value that I have, like trying to make the world a better
- 16:45place? So you know that one's complicated. Also in the article, it
- 16:51said even though the light triad was positively related to productivity and competence, So
- 16:56anyway, also, unlike the dark triad, the light tread was uncorrelated with
- 17:00bravery, bravery, or assertiveness. So the dark triad is correlated with bravery
- 17:08and assertiveness. Where it's a light tread, it's not so if you're dark
- 17:12triad. If you're more towards that end of the spectrum, you're more likely
- 17:17to be brave and you're more likely to be assertive. Now, brave sounds
- 17:22good, right, and assertive sounds good. But again, when we look
- 17:26at this, if you are narcissistic and psychopathic, particularly if you're psychopathic,
- 17:30you pend it. You tend to not have as much fear psychopathic people of
- 17:37because of unknown reasons. Really, we could speculate why they don't have as
- 17:44much anxiety about things. They're more likely to do dangerous things, and they're
- 17:49more likely to be you know, like certain jobs, high stress jobs that
- 17:56would stress out the average person. For a psychopath, it's less likely to
- 18:00stress them out. Now, I've talked about this before, but I guess
- 18:03that barriers are peeding in this context. Is that one of the theories about
- 18:07psychopathy development is that it merely has to do with the person being born with
- 18:14a lower capacity for fear. Because if you are born with a lower fear
- 18:22reactivity, you will see two kinds of things. One is obvious, meaning
- 18:27that you'll see the child jumping off of things more readily, they get hurt
- 18:33more often, you know. You know, they don't seem to be afraid
- 18:38of the slide or of you know, playing baseball. They just sort of
- 18:44jump in and they don't really care because they don't seem to have that natural
- 18:48fear reactivity that other kids have on average. So that's pretty obvious. But
- 18:52another effect that could be a result of not having been born with a reactivity
- 18:57to fear is that you have less empathy. You know. One of the
- 19:03ways theoretically that we develop empathy for other people and an understanding of other people's
- 19:08feelings. Is when we are a child and say, you know, we're
- 19:17very young, we're two years old, our parents are picking us up,
- 19:19taking us away from the playground, and we slap our parents across the face.
- 19:25Now, a two year old slap across the face is very quaint,
- 19:27it's not very it doesn't hurt very much, but it's annoying and it's concerning
- 19:30to a parent. And the parent will make a face usually right, and
- 19:33they might even yell and be like hey, you know, and all of
- 19:37this very sudden reactivity that a parent has when they're smacked in the face by
- 19:42a two year old, to the average kid, the child will have a
- 19:48fear response. Now, the reactivity from the parent is not, you know,
- 19:52designed to necessarily cause fear in a child, like deep terror, but
- 19:57it is you know, you want to get across to the child like,
- 20:00hey, you know, what you just did was wrong? Uh, and
- 20:04we're not going to just talk about this. I'm going to react strongly right
- 20:07away. In fact, I have an involuntary response to that of just like,
- 20:11whoa, you just hit me in the face. Well, when you
- 20:14do when a when a child sees a parent react with those signals, it's
- 20:21you know, logical to think that children will have a fear response because oh,
- 20:27whoa, I just what did I just do? Like I just freaked
- 20:30my parents out? Or you know, is my parents My parents just had
- 20:34you know, sort of a reaction and I'm afraid that I hurt their feelings
- 20:38or I'm afraid that I did something wrong, like, you know, there's
- 20:41a there's a visceral reaction that a two year old will have. Well,
- 20:45if you have less capacity for fear, then you'll have a less reaction.
- 20:48You have a lower reaction to that. So just like a normal two year
- 20:52old, you smack your parents across the face, your parents have this reaction
- 20:56and it doesn't get under your skin the way it would a normal kid,
- 21:00because your neurons are such that you just don't have a very strong fear reaction.
- 21:07And then you compound that over and over and over again, and a
- 21:11different developmental course is set in which the child never really develops an understanding of
- 21:18other people's emotions because you kind of have to develop that empathy early in life,
- 21:23and once you pass that window, then it's hard to develop that later.
- 21:26In life. So anyways, just and then that leads to a confusion
- 21:32for the person about how other people operate. They feel like they don't really
- 21:37understand emotions, and they also will use other people for their own gain because
- 21:48they don't notice necessarily when other people are suffering, and or they don't care
- 21:55because it doesn't get under their skin the way that it does to non psychopathic
- 21:59people. So yeah, so the dark triad is again more associated with the
- 22:07bravery than the light triad, So that bravery characteristic could be because of that,
- 22:14you know, fearlessness that they have. The other thing that the dark
- 22:17triad is associated with is assertiveness. Well, in order to be assertive,
- 22:22one thing that helps you is to not have compassion for other people, right,
- 22:26because you're more you don't care about confrontation as much, and so therefore
- 22:33you're a little bit more likely to be assertive. So I think that's another
- 22:37thing, but that's speculation. So that's the light triad. I think it's
- 22:41a wonderful thing, you know, to bring up, because it's like,
- 22:45why do we always have to talk about the dark triad? You know,
- 22:48why we always talk about sadism and murder? Why can't we talk about the
- 22:52good things in life. Why can't we measure positive aspects of psychology? Why
- 22:56does psychology and clinical work have to be focused on disorder and dysfunction and pathology.
- 23:02Why can't it be focused on what most of us have, which is,
- 23:06you know, the light side, the positive side, the strengths,
- 23:08the perseverance, the resilience. Positive psychology and other postmodern you know areas are
- 23:15focused on that, but they're in the minority. So I'm glad to whomever
- 23:19sent me this question. All right, let's take a break, and when
- 23:22we get back, I'm going to take the test and we will determine how
- 23:27much light triad I am and how much dark triad I am, and then
- 23:32you can sort of follow along yourself, and you know, informally take the
- 23:37test yourself along with me. All Right, we're back from the break.
- 23:44It is definitely a light triad thing to become a patron of the podcast because
- 23:49you are giving you have compassion for me and my struggles to prepare for this
- 23:56podcast a big part of what gives me the space and time. Like today,
- 24:02I'm you know, I'm answering emails and blah blah blah, and I'm
- 24:06not earning any money at my regular jobs, and so you know, when
- 24:08you become a patron, it makes it so I can actually pay my bills
- 24:11and spend a lot more time in the podcast. So, uh so there's
- 24:15that. How's that for manipulating people? So yeah, all right, let's
- 24:19let's go into the test here. If you want to take the test,
- 24:23you can go to Scott Barry Koufman dot com, Light Triads Scale, Scottberry
- 24:29Kaufman dot com slash light Triads Scale. So, and I think there's only
- 24:34like twelve questions or something, so it won't be taken too long. So
- 24:37the first question is, and it's from strongly disagree to strongly agree. I
- 24:41tend to see pee. I tend to see the best in people. I
- 24:45tend to see the best in people. I strongly agree with that. I
- 24:49really do. I tend to admire others. I'm gonna give that one an
- 24:55agree. It's you know, it's not as strong because I do admire other
- 25:00people, but I notice some people admire other people more than I do.
- 25:03That makes sense. I tend to manipulate others to get my way. No,
- 25:11I don't think I've ever been that way. In fact, I could
- 25:14probably do with a little bit of Machiavelianism in my life. Sometimes sometimes I
- 25:18just walk naively into situations. So I'll strongly agree with that. I prefer
- 25:22honesty over charm. Yeah, but you know I don't mind charm, so
- 25:27I'll give that one and agree. I tend to lack remorse. Oh God,
- 25:32no, strongly, Oh no, I tend to lack remorse. Yeah,
- 25:36strongly disagree. I tend to want others to admire me. I tend
- 25:41to want others to admire me. Yeah, I do want others to admire
- 25:44me, but I'm not desperate for it, So I'm gonna give that one
- 25:49a neutral right down the middle. I tend to trust that other people will
- 25:53deal fairly with me. I tend to trust that other people will deal fairly
- 25:59with me. Yeah. This has always been a problem of mine that I
- 26:06frequently will tell myself, Kirk, why do you trust people so much?
- 26:11Like? Why did you think that was going to go well? So I
- 26:15would say, you know, my trust for people is actually maybe too high.
- 26:19Strongly agree. I tend to applaud the successes of other people. Absolutely,
- 26:23I I you know, I get a little bit of schadenfreud when other
- 26:29people suffer, but I really enjoy it when other people are doing well.
- 26:33So I'm going to say strongly agree on that I have used a seat or
- 26:37lied to get my way. I have used a seat or lied to get
- 26:41no Again, that machiavelinism stuff is just not Yeah. The example I sometimes
- 26:48think about is when I was a kid, my mom would make the same
- 26:55my so you know that we had their six people in my family, and
- 26:59we also sat around this round white table in the dining room, which is
- 27:04just kind of like it wasn't really a dining room. It was just sort
- 27:07of like the extension off the kitchen, if that makes any sense. We
- 27:10didn't have a fancy house. So and my mom was not a great cook
- 27:15when I was a kid. She got married at the age of she got
- 27:21pregnant and married at the age of like nineteen. Both my parents were just
- 27:26one or two years out of college, and my mom didn't know much about
- 27:30home economics as they used to call it, and so she had to learn
- 27:33cooking rather quickly. She also had to cook humongous meals for six people,
- 27:41and she often would cook enough to make leftovers for the next day. Also,
- 27:45like when you don't have a lot of money, you can't really afford
- 27:48nice food things. Also, you know, the sort of food culture in
- 27:56America in the seventies was not great. So all this to say, now,
- 28:03my mom, since I moved out of the house at eighteen, I
- 28:08think she's actually a really good cook once she I guess had the time and
- 28:11space. But anyway, so there were some meals growing up for me that
- 28:17I wasn't enthusiastic about. Let's spit it that way, and my family you
- 28:21ate everything on your plate. There was just you know, there was I'm
- 28:23not I am one of the most unpicky eaters you will ever find because my
- 28:29parents beat that pickiness out of all of us. All everyone in my family.
- 28:36We will will eat anything put in front of us, and we like
- 28:38a lot of different kinds of foods anyway, and being Japanese American you kind
- 28:42of have to be that way because there's a lot of weird shit that comes
- 28:45out of Asia, believe me. So oh yeah, So there were a
- 28:52lot of things that I did not want to eat and I was or I
- 28:56couldn't eat because they would make me literally gag. And we had a dog
- 29:02and we had a cat and I was sometimes left at the table to finish
- 29:06my meal. I was like, well, you know, if you can't
- 29:08leave the table until you finish the meal, so I would be sitting there
- 29:11by myself. It didn't happen very often, you know, maybe once a
- 29:15year or something, and in those moments, I would just sit there and
- 29:19go, Okay, well, I guess I got to power through this.
- 29:22You know, if it takes me five hours, it takes me five hours.
- 29:25I don't know what to do. It never occurred to me to take
- 29:30the food and give it to the dog. The dog would have ate it,
- 29:33no one would have noticed. I was practically in the dark in another
- 29:37room. It never occurred to me to just throw the food out the window,
- 29:42or to you know, throw it in the garbage or it put it
- 29:47in a napkin. It just never occurred to me. You know. I
- 29:48hear about other kids doing stuff where they they would take some nasty food and
- 29:52they would like splatter it underneath the table, you know, sort of stick
- 29:56it, or they'd you know, put it in their napkin and then go
- 30:00to the bathroom and dump it in the toilet or something. You know,
- 30:03all these things that people do. It just never occurred to me as a
- 30:06kid, so like I do, I don't. And again I think that
- 30:11a little bit of a seat could be helpful sometimes, But I just I
- 30:18don't know, you know, I don't know why my siblings weren't that way
- 30:21either, My no one in you know, none of us Honda kids were
- 30:26that way. Maybe it was just model to me and I was. We
- 30:30also grew up very religious, so there's a lot of values that were being
- 30:36taught to us as kids that you know, said don't do that kind of
- 30:40stuff, I guess anyway, So the question of I have used the sit
- 30:45or lied to get my way is like, strongly disagree, because it's it's
- 30:48it just doesn't occur to me. Even I don't feel comfortable overtly manipulating people
- 30:56to do something I want. I don't feel comfortable overtly manipulating people to do
- 31:02something I want. Yeah, I do not feel comfortable overtly. I'd rather
- 31:06just do it myself, so strongly agree. I tend to not be too
- 31:10concerned with morality or the morality of my actions. I tend to not be
- 31:15too concerned with morality. I tend to not be too concerned. Now I'm
- 31:21pretty concerned with morality. I'm pretty concerned. I'm very concerned with morality.
- 31:26Actually, in fact, I'm one of the only therapists that even brings up
- 31:32morality in my circle. I'm often because when when we're talking, like someone
- 31:41was consulting with me about a client and what did the client do? The
- 31:49client was abusive? Oh, that's right. So the so my you know,
- 31:56a trainee or a consultee was telling me about a case and one of
- 32:00their clients had been abusive to another person and in some way, and they
- 32:08were the therapist who was consulting with me had kind of a dilemma around like
- 32:13how to see it in this sort of thing, and I was like and
- 32:16they and the therapist seemed to be on the side of trying to defend their
- 32:23client and saying like, you know, giving all the reasons why they did
- 32:28the abuse. And I said something like, Okay, you know fine,
- 32:32I'm glad that you can have compassion for this person, but you have to
- 32:36understand this person is a perpetrator of abuse, and you probably only know like
- 32:42two percent of the abuse that this person has committed and you know done to
- 32:47these other people because your client isn't likely to divulge the full extent of what
- 32:53they've done. It's possible they did. But either way this you know your
- 32:59client is a perpetrator, your client is immoral, your client has done You
- 33:05know your client isn't immoral, but your client has done immoral things. Your
- 33:08client has done terrible, terrible things. That doesn't mean you stop treating them.
- 33:13It doesn't mean you don't have compassion for them, It doesn't mean you
- 33:15don't have a conceptualization of why they did those things. But you just have
- 33:22to acknowledge that that. You know, if you were talking to one of
- 33:27their victims, you wouldn't look at the perpetrator and not see the fact that
- 33:32that perpetrator did something immoral. Right, And I find that that kind of
- 33:38very explicit talk about morality needs to be in there because we're all thinking it
- 33:44right, and without the ability to voice that, I think it causes all
- 33:47these weird clinical lingo that gets thrown around around, you know, having boundaries
- 33:53with people or I don't know. It's like, there is a moral code
- 33:58to humans that I believe in, that that the vast majority of humans believe
- 34:02in, which is, do not harm other people on purpose uh bottom line,
- 34:08you know, like you can suffer, uh, you know, and
- 34:13that's sad, but you can't purposely make other people suffer just because you're suffering,
- 34:20or just because you want to, you know, or just because you
- 34:23know you're you're poor and you're living paycheck to paycheck and you don't know what
- 34:29you're going to do. So you you know, you get a knife and
- 34:32you hold up a grandma at a store and you take her purse. Okay,
- 34:37you know, I get the motivation because you're struggling, but you fucking
- 34:40did and a moral thing. That's wrong. You know, it's against the
- 34:45moral code. So and I'm you know, and I'm often railing about this
- 34:51sort of thing like uh sometimes like people like politicians or authors, like there
- 35:02was this one author I think he was even from Seattle. I can't remember
- 35:06his name, but he actually wrote about the iPhone. Some people will remember
- 35:13this, this guy, but he became he came he became famous fairly briefly
- 35:20about ten years ago because he had claimed to have gone to China and talked
- 35:27to the factory workers at Apple iPhone factories. You know, this is at
- 35:34the height of iPhone you know, fame and uh, you know, for
- 35:38an article to come out and talk about the underbelly of the iPhone, it
- 35:44was this big sensational thing. And he claimed to had talked to actual factory
- 35:49workers, and there was this interpreter that there was just you know, there
- 35:52is and it was a he gave like public talks. You know, he
- 35:55was the talk of the hour for you know, a few months. Well,
- 36:00then it came out that he fibbed on a lot of his what he
- 36:04was saying, you know, that he actually didn't talk to so and so,
- 36:07that he you know, in fact, he heard a story through through
- 36:10someone else, and he exaggerated things and he claims that, well everyone knows
- 36:19that that's the kind of performer. He's a performer, he's not a journalist.
- 36:24And I found that to just be the stupidest fucking thing I've ever heard.
- 36:30He clearly was deceiving other people for his own gain. Now I don't
- 36:35disagree with his message. If he was trying to help people in China,
- 36:37then great, But you can't overtly lie to people and then in your head
- 36:43go like, well, I'm doing a performance art thing and I'm sort of
- 36:45bastardizing his excuse. But I get very angry when people are lying, you
- 36:52know, and and I and I get very angry when I find myself way
- 37:00more angry than other people when people when people experience other liars. Like I
- 37:08can't come up with an example, but like, you know, like a
- 37:13police officer is trying to protect himself or something because he doesn't want to be
- 37:19prosecuted for brutality or something, and so he lies, and then afterwards the
- 37:23storyline is, well, of course he lied, you know, I mean,
- 37:25what's he gonna do. He's got to defend himself. And to me,
- 37:28I'm like, no, Okay, I see the motivation align, But
- 37:32why are we just treating it like it's a given that a police officer is
- 37:37gonna lie? I mean, I believe in you know, all things,
- 37:40you know, Superman values, telling the truth and having pride and morality and
- 37:45doing the right thing and standing up for the right thing, and you know,
- 37:51I don't know if it's a childish sort of thing. So so at
- 37:57the very least, I don't want to as one member of the seven and
- 38:02a half billion people society on this planet, I don't want to. I
- 38:06don't want to give people a pass on lying, you know, I want
- 38:09to uphold this expectation that people tell the truth even when it harms them.
- 38:15You know, the world will be such a better place. Imagine if all
- 38:19politicians told the truth. But they can't because the other guy's gonna lie and
- 38:24win. So they all have to lie. That's why they lie. They
- 38:30probably want to tell the truth sometimes, but they're not going to be reelected
- 38:34or they're not going to get elected if they tell the truth. They know
- 38:36that, and so you know, that's a simplistic way of looking at it.
- 38:39But anyway, so getting back to this light triadscal I tend to not
- 38:44be too concerned with morality. No, I'm extremely concerned with morality, so
- 38:47I'm going to tend to not be too concerned. So I'm strongly disagreed.
- 38:53I tend to want others to pay attention to me. You know, that's
- 38:58a funny one because as a podcasts like I obviously want people to pay attention
- 39:01to me, But in my social circles, I'm not actually concerned at all.
- 39:07In a lot of ways, I don't mind being invisible. So I'm
- 39:15gonna say disagree with that one. I tend to want others to pay attention
- 39:19to me, disagree, but not strongly, but just disagree. I think
- 39:22people are mostly good. Absolutely strongly agree. I tend to treat others as
- 39:28valuable. Yeah, I do strongly agree. I have used flattery to get
- 39:34my way. No, I don't even know how to do that. I
- 39:38would like to be authentic, even if it may damage my reputation. I
- 39:43would like to be authentic, even if it may damage my reputation. Yeah,
- 39:46you know, I consider this to be kind of a fault of mine,
- 39:51what pops into my head or two things. One is the podcast,
- 39:53Like, there are ways I could probably make a lot more money on the
- 39:57podcast, be a lot more famous on the podcast if I I was less
- 40:00authentic. You know, I've studied enough manipulative people to know how to manipulate
- 40:06people. I don't manipulate people, but I know how people manipulate people.
- 40:09Elizabeth Holmes, Charlie Manson, you know the fire Festival guy, I've I've
- 40:19you know, the people on the podcast asked me to study these people,
- 40:22and I do, and I walk away going like, oh, okay,
- 40:23there's a formula to this. It's not hard if you got the formula and
- 40:30you trial and error enough, like you'll you know, it'll work eventually,
- 40:34especially if you're smart about it. Even if you leave a trail of obvious
- 40:40con artistry, it won't matter. You know. L Ron Hubbard left a
- 40:49long trail of being a con artist, but then he finally discovered scientology and
- 40:53boom, you know he is what he is. So so anyway, not
- 41:00that it pops in my head. So that's why I want. I think
- 41:02one like, I'm probably authentic to somewhat of a fault on the podcast,
- 41:09but I know that for some people it appeals to them in that way,
- 41:13and I guess that's just a synergy of just like the way I am fits
- 41:19with what people want. I guess. The other thing I think about is
- 41:24when I'm at Antioch as a as a professor, it would benefit me,
- 41:30and it's particularly my reputation if I would just shut up in meetings or at
- 41:34to very least be a way more diplomatic. But I will say super cranky
- 41:39shit in meetings. You know, We'll be in the meeting with upper administration
- 41:44and other professors and staff people and shit will just blurt out of my mouth.
- 41:51I mean, part of it is that I'm one of the more most
- 41:53senior employees at the university. At this point, I've been there for twenty
- 41:58plus years. Because when I first started working in ANTIOC twenty years ago,
- 42:02there was this cohort of baby boomers essentially, who were all the top positions
- 42:08and everything. Well, they all a whole wave of them over the past
- 42:12ten years have have retired, particularly the last five years, and so now
- 42:16it's now I'm suddenly you know, for a long time, I was like
- 42:21the baby, and they would talk about me, Oh, Kirk, you're
- 42:22so young, You're the baby. Then boom, overnight, seemingly to me,
- 42:27I'm now the oldie. I'm the old crotchety, cranky guy sitting on
- 42:32a porch in a rocking chair and you know, whittling and yelling at everyone.
- 42:38And so in meetings I walk away from meetings going like, Kirk,
- 42:43like just shut up, Like don't get involved. Why do you have to
- 42:45voice what's in your head? Like just it doesn't it doesn't help you,
- 42:51and probably people probably think you're a dumbass or or a rage aholic or something.
- 42:59So yeah, I would like to be like I like to be authentic,
- 43:05even when it damages my reputation. I don't know how to answer that
- 43:07one. I would like to be authentic, even if it may damage my
- 43:12reputation. I mean, I'm gonna say agree with that because I don't know
- 43:15if I enjoy it. I am that way a lot of times. There's
- 43:19certainly a lot of times where I hold my tongue, but more than not,
- 43:22I'm telling myself to shut up. I tend to be callous or insensitive.
- 43:27No, strongly disagree. I tend to seek prestige or status. I
- 43:32tend to seek prestige or status. I mean again, with the podcast,
- 43:36it's like there's this constant push to you know, market and blah blah blah.
- 43:43And I guess even just starting a podcast is some effort at prestige and
- 43:45status. So I'm gonna give that one a neutral because I don't. I
- 43:53don't feel like I care that much about status. Like there have been jobs
- 44:00that I have either quit and or turned down that had way more prestige in
- 44:06my field. I mean it sounds like a humble brag, of course,
- 44:09but and I that was the dilemma I ran into. Like I was being
- 44:17asked by upper administration my university to consider taking this highly prestigious position at the
- 44:25university, and I was flattered. I was like, whoa, Like,
- 44:31like, that's a big position, that's an important job. I would be,
- 44:37you know, mister boss man, in charge of all sorts of things,
- 44:39and I'd have my own office and blah blah blah. And you know,
- 44:45it was tempting. I was like, oh, you know, the
- 44:47prestige of that job, like, wow, that's a big deal. And
- 44:52then I thought, but I don't care enough about prestige to suffer what that
- 45:00job entails, you know, like being a professor has suffering, but the
- 45:05suffering is worth it because I care a lot about teaching. I mean,
- 45:08I guess you could say that's sort of prestigious, you know, being a
- 45:12teacher, you know, wanting to be in front of a crowd. Anyway,
- 45:17I'm quick to forgive people who have hurt me. I'm quick to forgive
- 45:21people who have hurt me. I'm quick, Yeah, I am. Actually
- 45:23as soon as they say there, I've known that for years. If you've
- 45:29wronged me and all, and you just apologize, even if it's mildly,
- 45:34you know, a mild apology like I am good. Like that's all I
- 45:37ask for people, is it's like, hey, you know people make mistakes,
- 45:42just say you're sorry, and boom it's over for me. So strongly
- 45:45agree. I enjoy listening to people from all walks of life. Yeah.
- 45:52Absolutely. As a therapist, I'm I remember early in my career thinking like,
- 45:57Wow, this is a great job because you get to hear the inner
- 46:00lives of such a wide variety of people that you would never come into contact
- 46:04in your social life. I tend to exploit others toward my own end.
- 46:07No, strongly disagree. When I talk to people, I am rarely thinking
- 46:12about what I want from them. When I talk to people, I'm rarely
- 46:15thinking about what I want from them. Yeah, I'm again, whatever the
- 46:20opposite of machiavellian I am, And again I could probably use with a little
- 46:24bit of it. I really just don't. I never never think about that
- 46:30kind of stuff. I tend to be cynical. It depends on what we
- 46:35mean by cynical, So I tend to be pretty optimistic. So I'm just
- 46:38going to say disagree, because I certainly can be cynical about some things.
- 46:44I tend to expect special favors from others. No, but there's nothing wrong
- 46:50with getting favors. I tend to expect special favors from others, not think
- 46:54I know what they're getting at. I'm gonna say strongly disagree. Congratulations,
- 46:58you have completed the tests. This is the first time we take the test
- 47:07answering these final questions or asking me how old I am? For their statistics
- 47:13and blah blah blah, gender, How spiritual are you? How religious are
- 47:19you? Where do you live, what state do you live in, and
- 47:27what ethnicity are you? How much money do you make? You don't have
- 47:30to answer these questions. What's your education level? How satisfied are you with
- 47:36your current job? I'm very satisfied. I love my jobs. How satisfied
- 47:40are you with your life in general? I'm very satisfied with my life in
- 47:44general. Which of the following best describes your own history of mental illness?
- 47:50Yeah, you know I've suffered from panic disorder. So I will say,
- 47:54We'll say low, let's see continue, all right, What did I get?
- 48:01Okay, So light triad and dark triad. So remember the light triad
- 48:08is these three different things. So faith in humanity? So how how much
- 48:13faith in humanity do I have? Well? I am the max on that
- 48:16one. I scored one hundred On that one, I have a shit ton
- 48:20of faith in humanity, and I really do. You know, if you've
- 48:25listened to the podcast long enough, you know that this is no surprise.
- 48:28I believe in the goodness in people who are murderers, you know, I
- 48:35strongly believe that there's there's good in them. Humanism and it is basically a
- 48:40belief system. I mean, people will argue with me. I was like,
- 48:44oh boy, I don't believe in the goodness of people, and you
- 48:45know, I can't argue with them. It's just a it's just a belief,
- 48:49you know, you just because there's no evidence. There's a hard evidence
- 48:53that people are good. But according to my experience, people are good.
- 48:59Humanism, you know, valuing the worth of other people. I'm a little
- 49:05bit less on that one. I'm a ninety five ish it looks like,
- 49:08but you know, still pretty high. Kantianism, treating people as an ends
- 49:15themselves, meaning you know, just being nice to people, just to be
- 49:19nice. Even a little lower. It looks like about a ninety but still
- 49:23pretty high. So. And then the dark triad narcissism. I'm at I'm
- 49:30zero on narcissism, which seems inaccurate psychopathy, meaning you know, being callous
- 49:37and lack of empathy. I looks like I'm about a five out of one
- 49:42hundred, and Machiavelianism I'm a thirty out of one hundred. How did that
- 49:46happen? Strategic exploitation and deceit? You know, I feel like that one
- 49:52would have been I feel like I should have been higher on narcisism and lower
- 49:54on Machiavelianism. That's strange anyway, interesting little test. Oh, based on
- 50:01your replies, you are tilted eighty one percent to the light side. Eighty
- 50:09one percent to the light side. Huh interesting eighty So I'm eighty one and
- 50:15they have a picture of Yoda, so apparently I'm you know, I'm I'm
- 50:22I'm like Yoda in terms of the light side or something. Who would they
- 50:27show on the dark side? Well, I guess they're probably so Vader.
- 50:30Okay, So that's that, And that was me tying. So you know,
- 50:34you can again go to scottbarrycoffin dot com light triad scale for yourself post
- 50:42on Facebook. What'd you get? Okay? So all this leads to why,
- 50:45you know, why do I have these sorts of things? And why
- 50:50do other people have other sorts of things. So let's get into that.
- 50:52I ask people on Facebook and if you want to be a part of these
- 50:55these kinds of conversations, like us on Facebook, participate in the conversations.
- 51:00I asked people on Facebook to take the test for themselves and tell me why
- 51:04they think they are the way that they are. Top Fan Veronica said that
- 51:09she is fifty six percent to the light side and forty four percent on the
- 51:15dark side. She says she scored high on humanism and high on Kantianism.
- 51:22She says it definitely would come from being raised on good morals and wanting to
- 51:27help others. So this is an excellent speculation that I think is true for
- 51:34me as well, that my high light side is due to the way I
- 51:38was raised, my parents, the church I grew up in, my friends,
- 51:44my extended family, and my siblings. There was a lot of lessons
- 51:49to be learned. Like actually, one lesson that I remember learning when I
- 51:53was in high school. Well, I was young. I was I don't
- 51:58know, ninth grade, eight or something and fourteen thirteen years old, and
- 52:02I was a child and was talking crap about a friend of the family essentially,
- 52:12and I was denigrating his job. I was like, oh, you
- 52:15know, his job, blah blah blah. And I don't know where that
- 52:17came from. I think I definitely wasn't old enough to really understand occupations and
- 52:23class issues very well, but I was, so it was definitely parroting something
- 52:29that i'd heard, but I said it and it was not good, and
- 52:32it got back around to my parents, and my parents sat me down and
- 52:36had a pretty stern talk with me about, you know, that people of
- 52:43all jobs work hard and that I should appreciate that and that I shouldn't feel
- 52:49like I'm above other people in any way, or something like that. And
- 52:52I remember immediately just being like, oh my god, you know what.
- 52:57I can't believe I said it. You know. I immediately was shocked back
- 53:02into my high light side, you know, by my parents, and they
- 53:07did it in a way that was firm and very to the point. I
- 53:10mean, I remember being humiliated, but appropriately so, you know. And
- 53:17I was given the opportunity to learn from that lesson and I did, and
- 53:22ever since then, I've tried really hard to make sure that I don't give
- 53:27into the propaganda around class and elitism which is just so funny because you know,
- 53:35my family was very lower middle class or you know, somewhat middle class.
- 53:39My family, I was not rich by any means, with four kids,
- 53:45blah blah blah. And you know, it's like, where did I
- 53:47get those notions from? You know, insecure fourteen year old makes sense,
- 53:52right, But anyway, so being raised well and being given these notions of
- 54:00you know, what are the different things here? Again? To be nice
- 54:02to people? You know, contuentism just be nice, to be nice,
- 54:06you don't have don't be nice to get anything back from other people. Good
- 54:10people are nice to others. Humanism valuing the dignity of others and the worth
- 54:16of others. That was definitely taught to me. Faith in humanity, you
- 54:21know, believing in the fundamental goodness of humans. I think faith in humanity
- 54:24probably has to come from experience, right, you know, being nice,
- 54:30you know, continism, being nice just to be nice, I think has
- 54:34to be also done from experience, but also has to be done from learning
- 54:37lessons, like you have to learn that when you're nice to people, you
- 54:43know, it comes back around. When you're nice to people, it just
- 54:47creates goodwill and they're just much more likely down the road to be nice to
- 54:51you. It could be years from now that they're nice to you in a
- 54:53significant way, but it all comes back around. And also another thing that
- 54:59you have to learn through experience is that when you're nice to people, you're
- 55:01not setting yourself up for vulnerability, meaning that you aren't humiliated or you know,
- 55:07criticized or bullied or something, and so having a pretty sheltered life growing
- 55:14up. For me, continism was free to be learned from experience and also
- 55:20overtly as well, people just saying you know, you need to be a
- 55:24good person, you need to be nice to other people, and you need
- 55:27to not think about what's in it for you. Humanism valuing the dignity and
- 55:32the worth of other people, again has to become from experience, meaning that
- 55:38if people respect you, you tend to respect others. If you feel that
- 55:44you are of you're valued, and that you're given dignity, then you tend
- 55:47to allow other people dignity and vice versa. Also it has to be taught.
- 55:52You have to have people who raise you in a way that you know
- 55:55tells you look other people have value. Just you know that experience I had
- 56:00of my parents sitting me down and being like, to denigrate someone's job is
- 56:05immoral and wrong and you need to think about what you did and make sure
- 56:08you don't do it again. That valuing of this person's dignity was very important
- 56:15and drilled into me very very overtly. So it's both experience and through being
- 56:22taught and my parents modeling that my parents, through my memory never made fun
- 56:29of other people's jobs or never talks crap about other people, or when they
- 56:34did, it was rare, you know, that kind of thing, And
- 56:37so that was, you know, a modeling issue. And I guess contunism
- 56:40as well is you know, seeing my parents being nice to people without any
- 56:46expectation of you know, reciprocation, giving gifts, giving a smile, giving
- 56:53a compliment without any complication, and not walking away saying like, hey they
- 56:59didn't. You know that modeling is also important. So I guess experience that
- 57:06teaches you that you can be this way without being burned being taught these overt
- 57:12morals meaning that your family or society sits you down and says, hey,
- 57:19to be good is to do this, and to be bad is to do
- 57:21this. And also through modeling, you know what are the people doing around
- 57:24you, because if if no one around you is being nice just for the
- 57:28sake of being nice, then you're going to learn to be nice. Just
- 57:30to be nice is ridiculous, right, You're being a silly person. And
- 57:36then the third light triad element faith in humanity. I think this has to
- 57:42come from experience. I think mainly to me at speculation, you have to
- 57:49experience other humans as being good to believe in other people being good. You
- 57:55know, I guess your parents could model faith in humanity by believing in other
- 58:00people. So there's that. And I suppose one could teach this to kids,
- 58:05like, hey, you got to believe it. You have to believe
- 58:07in the fundamental goodness of others. But in my experience, and it's hard
- 58:10to say, I think this faith in humanity has to come from actual good
- 58:16experiences, And this rings this speculation rings true anecdotally in my personal life when
- 58:22I talk with people and they don't have faith in humanity, Invariably they come
- 58:27from backgrounds where they have very good reasons to not believe in the fundamental goodness
- 58:31of others, because they were treated very badly repeatedly over time, particularly by
- 58:36their parents, and they learned, No, I don't believe in the fundamental
- 58:40goodness of others. Why would you believe such a stupid notion, like there
- 58:44are good people and there are bad people, and the bad people are bad
- 58:47to the core. There's you know, there's and lots of people don't care.
- 58:52So going on with top fan Veronica's message here and not message but comment,
- 58:59and I said, going to read this on the air. So so
- 59:01she says, you know, I'm fifty six percent light side because I was
- 59:07raised on good morals and I wanted to help others when I was young.
- 59:12She goes on to say, I would also say suffering from bullying and mental
- 59:15abuse beginning at a young age from peers. It comes from wanting others to
- 59:21feel appreciated and cared for, probably something I wanted to get from other peers
- 59:24but never really got. So through this experience, through her being treated badly
- 59:30by others, you know, she walked away with this decision of like,
- 59:34well, I can believe that bullying is the way to go, or I
- 59:37can walk away with realizing, look, when you know, I know what
- 59:40it's like to be treated badly, and so I'm going to try to treat
- 59:45others well, because I don't want other people to feel the way I felt.
- 59:51And then she goes on to say, in regard to the forty four
- 59:52percent of dark side, I definitely balanced myself between contientism and on the cynicism
- 59:59side of psychopathy. In my adolescent years, I finally had to grow my
- 1:00:04backbone and stop allowing others to walk over me, a flaw from my ability
- 1:00:08to find the good in all humans. It also stemmed from how much I
- 1:00:13gave to others and how people gave little or nothing back to me. I
- 1:00:17was getting tired of it. It led me to realize while I can care
- 1:00:21for others and raise them up, I had to learn I also needed to
- 1:00:23care for myself and let those who would use me alone. So end of
- 1:00:30comment here. So basically, she's saying, my dark side comes from experience
- 1:00:32of being walked on and having to not believe in the fundamental goodness of others
- 1:00:39and realize that other people aren't necessarily good. And I think that this is
- 1:00:43a different concept to me anyway. The notion that other people are fundamentally good,
- 1:00:50I think, is different than the notion that other people can't hurt you.
- 1:00:53Because I absolutely know that other people can hurt me, and yet I
- 1:00:57believe in the fundamental goodness of other people. I believe in the fundamental goodness.
- 1:01:04But that doesn't mean I'm naive, and it doesn't mean I don't have
- 1:01:07boundaries, and it doesn't mean that I don't detect dangerous people and walk away
- 1:01:10from them. Absolutely, And I think that that's an important distinction that I
- 1:01:14feel like people don't understand me when I'm saying so maybe I need to be
- 1:01:17clear about that. Is that we can have empathy, and we can have
- 1:01:22conceptualizations that are understanding of people's conditions, narcissism, this sort of thing,
- 1:01:29while at the same time recognizing that I don't want to mess with that stuff.
- 1:01:32I don't want to mess with someone who's abusive. I don't want to
- 1:01:35mess with someone who's going to hurt me. I don't want to mess with
- 1:01:37someone who's going to exploit me. I have a conceptualization of them that is
- 1:01:42fair to them and kind of lets them off hook a little bit because I
- 1:01:46realized that the reason why they are that way is because of massive defense mechanism
- 1:01:52that they had to develop early in life due to difficulties. But it doesn't
- 1:01:57mean that I allow myself to get walked down. I am extremely protective of
- 1:02:00myself. I am extremely boundaried when it comes to people who are, you
- 1:02:06know, not healthy for me. It's taken me a long time to realize
- 1:02:09how to do that, and yet I still have fundamental belief in humans.
- 1:02:15So I don't know. That's kind of an interesting one. All right,
- 1:02:19Let's go on to Alexis good Ol. Alexis says that she is also fifty
- 1:02:23six percent on the light side. Interesting, so Veronica and Alexis both fifty
- 1:02:29six percent light side. She has highest and faith in humanity and contunism.
- 1:02:34So that's faith in humanity and the idea of just being nice, just to
- 1:02:37be nice. And I asked her why, and I would read it on
- 1:02:39the podcast and she said, oh gosh, never thought about it. Forgiveness
- 1:02:44has always been hugely important to me. So just there, she's just saying,
- 1:02:49you know, when I was young, I just I remember really making
- 1:02:52sure I wanted to be nice for the sake of being nice and forgive other
- 1:02:57people. It's just important for people to forget give each other. You know
- 1:03:00where that came from? Hard to know. I think it's a product of
- 1:03:04witnessing so many lost connections that could have been resolved by better communication, willingness
- 1:03:09to see other perspectives, and less subbornness and more forgiveness. My parents can
- 1:03:15hold a grudge like no other, and arguments often made me uncomfortable. So
- 1:03:22for her, she has, you know, faith in humanity and contientism because
- 1:03:28she watched her parents do the opposite and so she learned from their mistakes contuinism.
- 1:03:34I feel like I just learned those values from my parents and movies I
- 1:03:37watched growing up. Well, that's interesting. Yeah, movies involve a lot
- 1:03:42of light side modeling and light side you know, lessons to be learned,
- 1:03:51especially movies gearage towards young people. Those have extremely overt messages. You know,
- 1:04:00while we're on the topic of light side dark side, of course Star
- 1:04:01Wars, you know, the messages around believing in Luke, seeing the good
- 1:04:08in Anakin, Ray seeing the good in Kylo. These are belief in the
- 1:04:15fundamental goodness of humans right and giving to others even when they don't give to
- 1:04:21you. For Ray to save Kylo's life just for the sake of being nice.
- 1:04:28For Luke to not kill Anakin, not to kill his father, just
- 1:04:33for the sake of being nice is a principled approach to life that is very
- 1:04:41lauded in the Star Wars plot points most of the time. So now you
- 1:04:46could argue all sorts of philosophical things about the whole thing, but a lot
- 1:04:51of movies will do that, you know. So that's interesting that you would
- 1:04:55also learn it from movies, And I would say I did too. I
- 1:04:58watched a lot of movies and TVs shows growing up, and that must have
- 1:05:00been pumped into my head all the time, even like little things like Scooby
- 1:05:04Doo and stuff continent. Is that, Yeah, I feel like I just
- 1:05:08learned those values from my parents and movies I watched growing up. Relationships were
- 1:05:12always emphasized as significantly more important than ambition and getting ahead. My parents were
- 1:05:18older and so fortunate enough to not need to work until I was ten years
- 1:05:23old, a lot of time together, and not as much emphasis on competition.
- 1:05:28So so through her experience with her parents, who were great, she
- 1:05:33became mostly light side. Mary Ellen says, I am seventeen percent dark side,
- 1:05:41So that means pretty high side, pretty you know, pretty light side.
- 1:05:45I think that's what it means, or I don't. Maybe I don't
- 1:05:48know what these percentages exactly mean, but anyway, I as may mary all
- 1:05:54and you know why, she says, well, I have low faith in
- 1:05:58humanity, paired with the idea that we're all just using each other as a
- 1:06:02means to an end. No one really cares about anyone else unless it serves
- 1:06:06them somehow. So Mary Ellen has this cynical view of humans, and so
- 1:06:12she's just kind of elaborating on that. But she didn't she didn't list why.
- 1:06:15Tap Top fan Marie says, I'm only about ten percent light side,
- 1:06:23and then she says, now I feel bad about myself, and she does
- 1:06:26crying face, and she said and I asked her why, she says,
- 1:06:29well, she just said a short answer, she had trust issues. So
- 1:06:32you know, when you're taking these tests, you have to know that they're
- 1:06:35just online tests and it's just a reflection of how you see the world.
- 1:06:41And my belief is that people who are higher on the dark side are that
- 1:06:46way because they needed to be, because of the defenses that were necessary to
- 1:06:51them growing up and in their current adult life. You know, I think
- 1:06:55faith in humanity is something that we develop ongoing over time, and so it
- 1:07:00doesn't necessarily have to do with something that happened when you were young. It
- 1:07:04could be bad things that happen when you're older. Watching a lot of politics.
- 1:07:09You know, if you spend a lot of time paying attention to politics,
- 1:07:13your trust in other humans will be eroded. Not because of it's a
- 1:07:16quote unquote accurate understanding of humans, but because of the propaganda nature of the
- 1:07:24news cycle. They are highly, highly incentivized to only report on things that
- 1:07:30will make you upset, will make you afraid, will make you angry,
- 1:07:36will make you hate some group. And for that reason, they're very,
- 1:07:44very, very fucking good at their jobs. The marketers of these people,
- 1:07:47of these sorts of news outlets, whether it's Facebook or CNN or something,
- 1:07:54and you will become biased just because of the stuff you're looking at. In
- 1:07:59fact, I bought a book recently and I'm going to start. I haven't
- 1:08:03received it in the mail yet, but i was told that this book is
- 1:08:09a book of all the good things that are happening in the world right now,
- 1:08:14and I'm planning on reading from that book every every episode. I almost
- 1:08:19called these sessions, and of course they're not sessions, but because one I
- 1:08:24just want to read the book for my own sort of well being. But
- 1:08:28I feel like the world needs to understand that there are a lot of good
- 1:08:30things happening in the world, a lot of really good things. You know.
- 1:08:33Just one thing. While I'm on this topic, people, I was
- 1:08:36listening to a podcast recently and a comedian was making a joke about how,
- 1:08:42you know, so after World War Two, there was a lot of belief
- 1:08:47that there would be no more world, there'd be no wars because of the
- 1:08:51realization of just how horrible World War Two was, and everyone was like,
- 1:08:55well, maybe maybe we shouldn't go to war anymore because it's just too costly
- 1:08:59to everyone involved. But the aggressors like Germany and so people will make jokes
- 1:09:05and they'll be like, oh, yeah, well we thought wars are never
- 1:09:08going to end, but you know, how stupid were we. Well,
- 1:09:11the fact is is, wars have essentially ended. There are wars currently and
- 1:09:15have been since World War Two, for sure, things that we would call
- 1:09:20a war, and legitimately so. But the percentage and even just the raw
- 1:09:27number of people who are affected by war are vastly lower than they were in
- 1:09:31the early twentieth century, I mean early twentieth century had World War One and
- 1:09:35World War Two, amongst other conflicts that involved millions upon millions upon millions of
- 1:09:43people. Now, you know, again someone out there is like, well,
- 1:09:46you know, the atrocities and the refugees in Africa and the refugees and
- 1:09:50all these parts of the world. Yeah, you know, I'm not saying
- 1:09:53it doesn't happen anymore. What I'm saying is that the narrative needs to reflect
- 1:09:59reality. Have to do is look at the percentages and that again the sheer
- 1:10:02numbers of casualties for more to realize like we have. Essentially, it's compared
- 1:10:08to the early twentieth century, which a lot of people thought was a trend
- 1:10:12of things come. I mean when I was growing up in the eighties and
- 1:10:15the seventies, people were convinced world War three was going to happen. It
- 1:10:17was like, well, we had World War One, you had World War
- 1:10:19Two. Well, world War three is just around the corner. You know,
- 1:10:23it's just a matter of time before you know, the Cold War becomes
- 1:10:27hot. It was. It was not something that people, you know,
- 1:10:30thought lightly of. We were convinced. I was convinced. I certainly figured
- 1:10:35yeah, you know, like a movie like Red Dawn, where essentially Russia
- 1:10:42uses a proxy invasion force from I believe Mexico to invade the United States seemed
- 1:10:48totally plausible. I mean, not because we were stupid, but because the
- 1:10:53tensions were real and the threat was real. So and you know, there's
- 1:10:58nothing to say about nuclear holocausts as well. But that's a wonderful, wonderful
- 1:11:04thing that as a race, we have accomplished the fact that we could annihilate
- 1:11:11each other with nukes and we don't. So many countries have the capability to
- 1:11:15wipe out entire other civilizations and choose not to. There are there's like a
- 1:11:23dozen countries around the world who have a button, you know, Donald Trump
- 1:11:29and many other leaders have a button that they can press and nuke entire you
- 1:11:32know, parts of the map, if not the entire map, and they
- 1:11:34choose not to every day. That is a wonderful thing. Now, if
- 1:11:40you frame it a certain way, it's like it's terrifying, right, and
- 1:11:42it is. It's it's a concern, it's I think we should get rid
- 1:11:44of all of them. But it is a testament to humans, a testament
- 1:11:49to our ability to compromise, a testament to our ability to cooperate. Our
- 1:11:54testament, a testament to learn from our mistakes, because if because if these
- 1:11:58countries had these capabilities in nineteen forty two, there would have been nukes.
- 1:12:01You know, Hitler would have nuked London, Winston Churchill would have nuked Berlin
- 1:12:08in the same way that the United States nuked Japan. You know, it
- 1:12:14would have happened. I mean the amount they were already essentially nuking entire cities
- 1:12:18already with fire bombing and whatnot, which was killing millions of civilians just with
- 1:12:25bombing, let alone actually raping and pillaging in Poland and whatnot. But so
- 1:12:31we were it was looking grim man, and we as a globe learned from
- 1:12:38our mistakes clearly. So how do I get on to that? Anyway?
- 1:12:44So this is me trying to model faith in humanity for all of you,
- 1:12:49not to say that you have to have my point of view, but I
- 1:12:55think that someone and people need to start giving the other side a story so
- 1:13:02that people are given the opportunity of faith in other humans. Anyway, last
- 1:13:05person here, top fan Patrick says, oh wow, thank you guys for
- 1:13:10going with my topic suggestion. Oh you're welcome, Patrick, looking forward to
- 1:13:14the episode, he says he's thirty one percent light side, highest on contunism,
- 1:13:18so being nice to other people just to be nice. So top fan
- 1:13:23Patrick is nice just to be nice. So that's great. I asked him
- 1:13:26why and I would read it on the podcast. He says, not sure
- 1:13:29why. I'm thirty one percent light side. Oh you know what I think
- 1:13:31it is. Gosh darn it, you know I've been reading this wrong.
- 1:13:36I think fifty six percent. When I'm saying top fan Veronica is fifty six
- 1:13:41percent light side, I think that means she's at like the seventy fifth percent
- 1:13:45tile into the light side, if that makes any sense. And Mary Ellen
- 1:13:48being seventeen percent dark side means she's she's just on the she's in the middle,
- 1:13:56but she's just a little bit more dark than light. And top fan
- 1:14:00Marie being only ten percent light side, meaning that she's in the light side,
- 1:14:05but just barely into the light side. I don't know. Top fan
- 1:14:10Patrick says thirty one percent light side, so I think that's like a third
- 1:14:13of the way into the light if that makes any sense. If in the
- 1:14:15middle is perfectly light and dark, I don't know. But anyway, top
- 1:14:23Fan Patrick says I'm not sure why I'm thirty one percent light side. I
- 1:14:26imagine it probably had something to do with growing up in a decent neighborhood and
- 1:14:30being raised to have morals and empathy. So that's what we've been talking about.
- 1:14:33I am and always have been quite idealistic, though I have come to
- 1:14:38embrace different ideals than the ones I had when I was young. That's interesting.
- 1:14:43Yeah, I've been I'm pretty idealistic as well. I remember being pretty
- 1:14:46idealistic at a young age, and I think it's from my parents, and
- 1:14:51I think also from church. You know, I had a very positive experience
- 1:14:56growing up in church, Christian non and what we called denominational. Later on,
- 1:15:02the church that I went to kind of switched to Evangelus, Evangelic evangelicism
- 1:15:09or whatever, meaning that they hate gay people, which was abhorrent when I
- 1:15:14looked at their website and I was just like, oh, boy, definitely
- 1:15:16wasn't the case when I was growing up in the seventies. It was.
- 1:15:20You know, it's a lot of young families, you know, young parents
- 1:15:25with kids who just didn't really want to judge other people and wanted to have
- 1:15:31community, and you know, I'm sure they had some interesting politics that it
- 1:15:34was the seventies after all, But you know, my biracial parents and us
- 1:15:44were treated well, you know, it wasn't anyway. I'm quite positive if
- 1:15:48there were any out gay people, they would have been ostracized for sure.
- 1:15:51But it wasn't talked about very much, I think mainly because in the seventies
- 1:15:56and eighties gay people were so closeted by four that the question just never had
- 1:16:02to be raised, you know. But anyway, aside from that little diet
- 1:16:06tribe, the Church I remember talking very explicitly about what it was to be
- 1:16:13a good human and their interpretation of the New Testament, which was to have
- 1:16:16faith in humanity, to be nice, just to be nice, to give
- 1:16:21to others, to forgive. To forgive was to be godly, you know.
- 1:16:27To give to others without expectation of anything back was to be like Jesus.
- 1:16:31And I remember that just being like really drilled into us of just like,
- 1:16:34you give because it's the right thing to do. You care and have
- 1:16:41empathy and notice other people's pain, not because of personal gain, but because
- 1:16:46it's the right thing to do. And you know, we were all rewarded
- 1:16:51for doing such things, and we would see that amongst you know, the
- 1:16:57older people. And I'm not talking at the age of like four. This
- 1:17:01was drilled into my head. You know, this was something that was quite
- 1:17:04prevalent so so. But the idealism, I think was also a part of
- 1:17:10it. I remember, I don't know if it's just my personality or something,
- 1:17:13but I remember being at a very young age really being very idealistic about
- 1:17:17uh, you know, I had at the age of like ten or fifteen,
- 1:17:21I was already ranting and soapboxing in a young, immature way. But
- 1:17:28but I just a belief that the world, you know, has the opportunity
- 1:17:31to be good and should be good, and that people need to try to
- 1:17:35be good. You know, that we can accomplish things if we try.
- 1:17:41I don't know where I got that from, but it is. It is.
- 1:17:45It was an early trait, that idealism. And I think I think
- 1:17:47when you have when you're given the opportunity, I suppose privileged enough to actually
- 1:17:53given the opportunity to be idealistic, I think you're probably more light side.
- 1:17:56Maybe I don't know, as long as the world has let you down.
- 1:18:00Top Fan Patrick also says, also I tend to obsess about meaning and purpose,
- 1:18:04and I don't think that's very compatible with dark traits. Interesting meaning and
- 1:18:10purpose for sure. Yeah, of darks of the dark traits. I am
- 1:18:15more Machiavelian than anything, and probably have a bit of mentality, consistently seeking
- 1:18:21out something better, perhaps sometimes even at the expense of good things I already
- 1:18:28have for myself, but also, as I see it, for society too
- 1:18:31interesting. All right, well, that probably does it for that episode of
- 1:18:35psychology and Seattle, thanks for joining me out there. What do you think
- 1:18:39about the light traad? You know, take the tests, what'd you get?
- 1:18:45You know, what's it if you're a more dark side? What is
- 1:18:47that like? Let me know. Go to our website and you can contact
- 1:18:53me by using the contact space, or you can comment below and share with
- 1:18:57everyone else where you are. And please take care of yourself because you deserve
- 1:19:00it, and take care of other people because it's goddamn moral