Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Beef (Netflix) - Chapter 1
Transcript
- 0:00So burto you remember doing an episode in which I talked about my Asian Dell
- 0:04testy, which is similar to the Bechdel test, in which journalists I believe
- 0:11by the name of Bechdel proposed a test for movies and TV shows about sexism.
- 0:17Identify a movie in which you have women characters who are talking, who
- 0:22have names, they're not just anonymous characters in the movie, and they're not
- 0:26talking about a man. Yeah, And when she came up with this test,
- 0:30you think, oh my god, really, I bet you hardly any
- 0:34movies past this test, right, you know, a shockingly low percentage.
- 0:38And yeah, I mean it's such a low bar, right, it just
- 0:41sounds ridiculous talk. Yeah, just two women who have character names in the
- 0:46movie and they're talking about something without a man being there, and they're not
- 0:50talking about a man. So I came up with the Asian Dell test.
- 0:53Who came up with your Latino test? And I watched a TV show called
- 0:59Beef on Netflix that not only passes, but surpasses my Asian Dell test.
- 1:04Let's get into it. What do you say? Let's do it. This
- 1:07is the psychology and shout a podcast. I'm your host, Doctor Kirkanda.
- 1:10I'm a therapist and a professor. My name is and I make shoes that
- 1:15you can use to play tennis. So in this episode, we're going to
- 1:17talk about the Asian nous of the TV show Beef, and then we'll talk
- 1:22about the psychology. There's a lot of psychological concepts that I think are explicit
- 1:26and implicit in this show that we'll get into. So I would say that
- 1:32this show, like I said, receives the highest rating possible. I don't
- 1:36think there's a better show that passes the Asian Dell test. And what is
- 1:38the Asian Dell test for me? Well, at the top of the list
- 1:42is that you have one character in the top three characters that is Asian American
- 1:49who doesn't have a foreign accent. The character has an American English accent.
- 1:55The person is noticeably Asian American, meaning that they're not half or horder or
- 2:00something. Their character is characterized as being from East Asian descent, and their
- 2:06parents also have an a accent. Because that's me, Almost every single Asian
- 2:13American that I know has an American accent. They are noticeably Asian American and
- 2:17their parents do not have accents. I'm not saying you can't have a movie
- 2:23that has no Asian Americans. I'm not saying you can't have a movie that
- 2:28has an Asian American with parents accents. I'm just saying, if you're going
- 2:31to have a culture in Hollywood that produces countless TV shows and movies, surely
- 2:38there would be a percentage of these productions that would pass this test, not
- 2:44only because of the American demographic facts, but also half of the movies and
- 2:50TV shows occur in Los Angeles, which is something like fifteen percent Asian American.
- 2:57The setting is Los Angeles, just like in Beef, and the fact
- 3:00that we almost never have a production that passes this Asian Dell test is just
- 3:07upsetting it and bothersome. So when Beef came along, I was I was
- 3:09really quite happy. But first off, burdo, how many burdos would you
- 3:14give this? Oh man, I love this show. Um, I would
- 3:17give it a nine. Okay, I gave it a ten out of ten.
- 3:21Regardless of the ethnicity and the background of the characters, this is a
- 3:27well acted, well written, compelling, interesting, relatable story. You know,
- 3:34excellently director. Yeah, I just thought it was masterful TV making it
- 3:38moves fast Rotten Tomatoes. What do you think the critics give it? Okay,
- 3:42critics, they must have liked it, sot foight, But about audience.
- 3:47Audience must have also liked it. So ninety seven eighty six, Oh
- 3:53yeah, I wonder why that's interesting? Yeah did they? Okay? I
- 3:58have one theory. So although run tomatoes audience? I don't know. But
- 4:01sometimes there are movies or shows where none of the main characters are likable enough,
- 4:08and this is one of those where they're both horrible people. Well almost
- 4:12everyone, almost everyone is, and so some people might be like, well
- 4:15I couldn't relate to anyone, or they're just all horrible. Yeah. Yeah,
- 4:18you know, people consume art for different reasons, and I think there's
- 4:21a group of people that we're not included in who are looking for something to
- 4:29relax, to to watch with your kids or your parents. You just you
- 4:33just want something that's kind of easy. And so let's talk about the Asian
- 4:38noss of beef and Berto as an adopted Asian. Because you grew up in
- 4:44the States with a lot of Asian all, you're all my high school friends,
- 4:46well not all, but some of my best friends were Asian. Well,
- 4:50what they would say, is we have one lazino Um. Okay,
- 4:57So let's talk about not only the fact that there's a lot of Asian Americans
- 5:00in this but there's a diversity among the East Asian Americans depicted. Most of
- 5:04them are Korean Americans. But Amy is her character played by Ali Wang,
- 5:11has a Chinese father and a Vietnamese mother, and I believe that is Ali
- 5:15Wong's ethnicity if I'm not mistaken. Okay, I'm not entirely sure, but
- 5:18I think Ali Wang also has that ethnicity combination. And those are very different
- 5:25cultures. China and Vietnam are very different. There are very different cultures within
- 5:30China itself. Within Vietnam itself, you have in Vietnam the north and the
- 5:34south and the rural and the city. And in China you have just vast,
- 5:38vast different groups across the nation. The history of these different areas.
- 5:44So even just saying this is not really knowing exactly what we're saying. So
- 5:50we have Daniel and his family being Korean American, we have Amy. So
- 5:55that was an interesting one. Right right off the bat, the show starts
- 5:59and in one of the very early scenes, he has a call with his
- 6:01mom and it took me back to I roomed with a Korean friend of mine,
- 6:06and it was like when he would have calls with his mom. It
- 6:11was the same. You know, I never understood most of what they're saying
- 6:14because they spoke in Korean, but the inflections, the melody of the conversation,
- 6:18and it's sort of the nature of the relationship. My take of it
- 6:24was always like, to me, it always sounded like my friend was complaining
- 6:28to his mom, and but it's actually more about the intonation that the quality
- 6:31of the It's the melodic way that they speak. And so when I was
- 6:35hearing in the show, I'm like, oh my gosh, that's my friend
- 6:38speaking to his mom. I'm back in college. Yeah. Yeah, And
- 6:41of course we can't paint all Korean Americans with one brush, but it's a
- 6:46common enough experience that Korean Americans will talk about where they live in two worlds,
- 6:51and they are Americanized, but they have Korean parents, either living in
- 6:57Korea or in the States. Korean adult children and their relationship with their parents
- 7:02is very different than the typical American adult relationship with their parents. Yeah,
- 7:08certainly there can be a lot of overlap, but for me as a very
- 7:11americanized Asian American. My Korean friends, their relationship and my clients for that
- 7:15matter, their relationship with their parents is very foreign to me. It's very
- 7:19boggling, the amount, the intensity of it, the way that you could
- 7:25be forty five years old and still treated like your ten by your parents.
- 7:29So my recollection and I saw the same thing in the show, and again,
- 7:32it could just be the only two people that I know, right,
- 7:34but my recollection was that I always thought, well, he never smiles in
- 7:39any of the calls. There's never never sounded like there was levity in the
- 7:43conversation. When I call my mom, there's a lot of joking involved and
- 7:47it's just my personality or whatever. And if you listen to it, even
- 7:54if it were in Spanish, you would be like, okay, oh,
- 7:57even if we're having a difficult conversation, it'll sprinkle in some so you'd hear.
- 8:00With my friend, it was always like, is everything okay? It's
- 8:03like yeah, yeah, I mean again, we can't paint everything with one
- 8:09brush. But I'll just say there's a very common profile depicted in this movie
- 8:13where Daniel is both really on the surface trying to impress his parents. If
- 8:18you just took verbade him what he says to his mom and dad. He
- 8:22is very loving, he's caring. He has a pleasant relationship with him.
- 8:26But there's a at least in this particular relationship, a very deep distance between
- 8:33him and his parents, and a sense of constantly running from disapproval from his
- 8:39parents. At the very least, I can say that even like I said,
- 8:41even if they're the only two people this character. Not how awful he
- 8:46is, of course, but the way he behaved with his parents reminded me
- 8:50of my friend. Yeah. And it's like if you saw someone in a
- 8:54show that behaved like a friend. That's what I was doing. I was
- 8:56recognizing someone that I know. Yeah, And in contrast to my Americanized culture,
- 9:01which is, you know, a combination of various different things that are
- 9:07passed down through American culture, also the Pacific Northwest. I you know,
- 9:09I have a theme of Japanese American in me as well. But when I
- 9:13went through my eyes, when I see it, I see it as a
- 9:16lot of guilt tripping, a lot of overdependence, a lot of complaining,
- 9:22a lot of control from the parents compared to my parents, a lot of
- 9:26invasiveness, a lot of nosiness. So from my perspective, I would talk
- 9:30to if Daniel were a friend of mine, I'd just say, just draw
- 9:33boundary with your parents. It's not it's not your problem, you know now,
- 9:35of course in the movie or in the TV show, it is his
- 9:39problem because he involved the sketchy cousin and got the whole family out of the
- 9:46hotel everything. Yeah, and so the parents lost everything and had to go
- 9:50back to Korea in order to survive, and so he had an extra reason
- 9:54to be guilt tripped into that. But anyway, so yeah, there's a
- 9:58lot of Asian US. There, a lot of Korean American US there,
- 10:01and again there's a lot of different profiles of relationships between Korean American parents and
- 10:07their kids. We also have George, who was played by a Korean actor.
- 10:11But doesn't that doesn't bother me. There's there's some hubbub. As a
- 10:15Japanese American myself, it doesn't bother me too much for a couple of reasons.
- 10:18One is that Japanese people are the aggressors historically in East Asia. They
- 10:26were literally the Nazis, make no joke about it. They raped, they
- 10:30pillaged, they colonized, they killed, they committed genocide for a good ten
- 10:35fifteen years, just complete dehumanization of Chinese people, of Korean people that they
- 10:41inhabited, they harmed, they dominated. It was horrific. So to feel
- 10:48bad for Japanese people, they're not traditionally the underdog in East Asia. So
- 10:54that's one. Two. Since Japanese Americans have been in the United States for
- 10:58so many generations, there's not a lot of pure Japanese people anymore. A
- 11:03lot of them are half or quarter or eight. So yeah, like I
- 11:07actually couldn't tell, Like if you had said to me what nationality, I
- 11:09would have assumed he was probably Japanese. Yeah, but I'm also not the
- 11:13best a necessarily telling. It's just that I wouldn't have been able to say,
- 11:16oh, he's definitely Korean. Some people say that they can tell that
- 11:20he's Korean, and for me, I couldn't tell. The Japanese people a
- 11:24lot of their genetics come from immigration from Korea thousands of years ago. I
- 11:31could go on about how many Colombians were really Mexicans, for example. Right,
- 11:35it didn't really bother me. I'm just glad to have them and almost
- 11:39everyone else in the show was of the ethnicity that their character was. Also,
- 11:45he just held himself like a Japanese American. He didn't hold himself different.
- 11:50And of course there's a lot of different types of Japanese American, and
- 11:52his mom was played by a Japanese American. But anyway, so George,
- 11:56the character Japanese American. And also the fact that he's tall. I don't
- 12:01know how tall he is, but he seemed tall and right, it was
- 12:03it wasn't all short Asians, right, like like Ali Wang. Ali Wang
- 12:09is very short, and so it was I don't know, as a tall
- 12:13Japanese American myself. I just like to see, you know, that representation,
- 12:18Like in Thirteen Year Reasons Why there's an Asian American guy who plays a
- 12:22football captain or football right, And that was the writer of that. You're
- 12:28thinking he inspired He was inspired from you. Oh no, he told me
- 12:31so. The so the writer, the adapter of it was a novel that
- 12:35was adapted into the screenplay by my friend Brian Jorkie, and we were pretty
- 12:41good friends in high school. And the character in the book wasn't Asian American,
- 12:43but he made an Asian American because he remembered that you know, in
- 12:48our school, we actually had it wasn't just white guys that were the jocks,
- 12:50it was Asian guys too. And it turns out that guy was a
- 12:54horrific rapist human being that I was not, obviously, but anyway, so
- 13:00George Japanese American mom, very Japanese American accent, So that's and they depict
- 13:05that well too. So Japanese Americans have been around like myself for generations and
- 13:11generations. Right, my ancestors came to United States one hundred and twenty something
- 13:16years ago, around the turn of the century, you know, around nineteen
- 13:20hundred and so Japanese Americans typically their parents and maybe their grandparents, like my
- 13:26grandparents grew up in United States and have American accents. So that was nice.
- 13:30And then to contrast this majority Korean American kids that are adults around thirty,
- 13:37because it seemed like they were in their thirties or something. Right,
- 13:41Yeah, typically, but not always will have parents who were born in Korea
- 13:45or China or Vietnam and the parents have accents, so that was well contrasted.
- 13:50Also that the Japanese family was well off, whereas the Chinese, Vietnamese,
- 13:56Korean families were not because the Japanese people again came over and we're very
- 14:00poor. My ancestors were very poor. They were farmers who were barely holding
- 14:05on. And there was this movement in the early twentieth century because they were
- 14:11farmers in central Washington, there was a movement politically to get rid of them.
- 14:15They white people were trying to pass laws and such that Japanese people,
- 14:20even though they were born in the United States, they couldn't own land,
- 14:24this kind of thing. Yeah and so, yeah, and so they went
- 14:28through that phase, and they fought and they fought, and they put their
- 14:31kids through school. And each generation there's more privilege and more wealth is so
- 14:35to speak. So we see we imagine that George's moms, parents or grandparents
- 14:41had to fight those fights, but then eventually the descendants are able to be
- 14:46well off. And you see that, whereas you see someone like Amy who's
- 14:50kind of in a transition zone where her parents had to struggle a lot,
- 14:52but they seemed to be more established a little bit more in the United States,
- 14:56and Amy was given a little bit of privilege, but she had to
- 15:00fight, fight, fight, really hard for herself. And that's you know,
- 15:03there's this conversation between Amy and George, where George's like, you're so
- 15:05obsessed with money, and then Amy's like, it's always funny to me that
- 15:09the people that say that are the people who grew up with money, right,
- 15:13Like I grew up poor, so I can't. I don't have that
- 15:16luxury of just saying money doesn't matter, because money was a matter of life
- 15:20and death when I was young. And then you have a family like Daniel's
- 15:24family, which is even more teetering on the edge because they lost their hotel
- 15:31and basically became homeless, I think, and then they had to go back
- 15:35to Korea, but they're actually they were on their way up in a way,
- 15:39and then they had a huge setback, right, And you could argue
- 15:41that Daniel even turned to counterfeit formula from the Sketchy Cousin because of racism and
- 15:52lack of opportunity, So there you have to resort to working around the laws,
- 15:58so to speak. So they have that kind of that strata within East
- 16:03Asian American people. Not everyone, of course, is like this, but
- 16:07you know, it's an interesting contrast. And we also have the Japanese bomb
- 16:12looking down on the Chinese daughter in law. So it's great that they have
- 16:18China, you know, Chinese Americans, Vietnamese Americans, Korean Americans, Japanese
- 16:22Americans. But who is not represented in this group that should be from Asians?
- 16:27You mean Asian Americans. I suppose Hawaiians, Puerto Ricans or not Puerto
- 16:34Ricans, sorry, Filipinos Filipinos. Yeah, yeah, so yeah, I
- 16:37mean I guess you could argue. But in terms of numbers, So where
- 16:41do you think Philippine in the you know, top five East Asian American populations,
- 16:45where do you think Filipinos are ranked? Oh? Man, maybe third?
- 16:48Second? Second? Interesting? Yeah, who's number one? Do you
- 16:52think? Well, I would guess Japanese? No, Chinese? Yeah,
- 16:56Chinese. So it's so interesting that you think Japanese because I grew up thinking
- 17:00that as well. Obviously, so many people that I know are a Japanese
- 17:03American, but Japanese American culture is so much more represented. There's a lot
- 17:08of Japanese restaurants, there's Japanese art there. You know, we have Japanese
- 17:12wha Jamaya, you know, the Japanese grocery stores. Yeah. Maybe I'm
- 17:17most so biased because I think in this region specially, I feel well,
- 17:21I don't know. Maybe we have a lot of Chinese people on a lot
- 17:25of Filipino people in Seattle, way more. If you had asked me,
- 17:29I mean, if you had asked me when I was younger, when I
- 17:30was a kid, specially, like I certainly would have set Chinese because for
- 17:33example, that's the only food Asian food. I knew it was Chinese food
- 17:37in Colombia, in Colombia and in New York, right, like that's the
- 17:41only if. But nowadays I feel like a lot of my influences and things
- 17:45and have been more Japanese. Yeah, right, So there's a couple of
- 17:49reasons for that. One we've been here longer. Yeah, Two, for
- 17:53various different reasons. American white Americans were much more fascinated with Japan than other
- 18:00cultures. They I think related more to Japan because Japan had the technology and
- 18:07the military power relative to other nations, and so Filipinos. There's definitely a
- 18:15pecking order in East Asia, and Japan is definitely at the top and below
- 18:21Japan. You know, I don't know the exact rankings. Of course,
- 18:23every country I'll have its own bias and its own racist statitudes, and Japanese
- 18:27people are quite racist towards other East Asians. Not all, but you know,
- 18:33they have a problem just like United States as a problem. And I
- 18:36would say that anecdotally. The ranking system is you have you have Japanese people
- 18:41the top, and this translates into the United States for Japanese Americans Chinese below
- 18:47them, you probably have Korean Americans below them, You probably have Chinese Americans.
- 18:51Below them, you probably have Vietnamese Americans. And then below them is
- 18:56Filipino, Cambodia, Thailand, in Asia, Pacific Islanders. I know I'm
- 19:03missing someone in here, Mongolia. So there's you know, there's definitely a
- 19:06ranking and Filippinos, although ranked second in population in the United States, how
- 19:11many Filipino restaurants are there? How many how many Filipino famous people are there?
- 19:17Right? Um, yeah, that's really interesting. I think Bruno mars
- 19:19is actually half Filipino, if I'm not miss mistaken. But how often is
- 19:23that emphasized. So there's there's a lot. You know, there's a whole
- 19:26history of Filipino colonization by Spain, colonization by United States, a lot of
- 19:33racism, a lot of atrocity, a lot of genocide that Japan was not
- 19:37a great presence in the Philippines. So we still live with that. And
- 19:41they didn't have Filipinos in this in this movie or this TV show. Um
- 19:44they were referred to. Oh yeah, he's like, yeah, the is
- 19:48any Isn't the cousin always paranoid about the Filipinos? Is it? What I
- 19:53remember is he he talks about how he cozied up next to the Filipino inmates
- 20:00because they protected him. Yeah, because and then later, who are the
- 20:03ones that they're gonna kill me? They're gonna gastrate me? Maybe it was
- 20:08Yeah, I feel like he's like, they saved me, and then later
- 20:11it's like they're gonna kill me. Yeah, something like that. Now a
- 20:14lot of the Japanese restaurants are terryoki restaurants. They have employees or owners who
- 20:19are Korean or Filipino or Chinese because they know that if you know, if
- 20:26you're a Korean family and you want to you know, make a business,
- 20:30and you start a Korean restaurant, you're not likely to get customers where if
- 20:33you get if you start a Japanese restaurant, you're likely to get interesting.
- 20:37Because white Americans are much more accustomed to terryoki and sushi and all that kind
- 20:41of stuff. They're not used to the Korean palette, so um, so
- 20:45just perpetuates this notion of like, well, there aren't any Filipinos or Koreans
- 20:49in Seattle because I don't see them around because they don't advertise it because they,
- 20:55you know, probably feel like it's hard to do that, you know.
- 20:56So another really great thing about this movie that I think you would appreciate,
- 21:02because this was this was mainly your point when we were talking about diversity
- 21:04in movie and TV shows, is that they weren't constantly referring to the fact
- 21:10that they were East Asian American totally. So basically, yeah, this was
- 21:14I remember making this point in general that I was looking forward today, where
- 21:17like people are just a character in the movie or a show and they're grouping
- 21:22is ancillary, and it really felt that way. It was like, yeah,
- 21:26this was just a great story and the fact that you can recognize that
- 21:30is great because you see the representation. But they didn't make it all about
- 21:33it or something. It wasn't like it was almost there was almost nothing about
- 21:37it. Yeah, Yeah, and that was impressive. It was exactly what
- 21:41one would want. Yeah, if I wanted to like Colombians in a movie,
- 21:47Colombian Americans, Colombian Americans. I want them to just be great characters
- 21:51and movie. But the interim or the you know, Hollywood will throw you
- 21:56a bone a movie, you will get greenlit if they're like, well,
- 21:59you have to be constantly referring to the fact that they're Columbi. First of
- 22:02all, who's the Columbian in the movie, Well, he's the Miami drug
- 22:04connection from the secondary main character. Right, there has to be just the
- 22:10house has to look Colombian American or the way that white people expect it to
- 22:12look. And as I was watching the TV show, I'm like, so,
- 22:15when are they gonna do that thing where they have the exposition, you
- 22:21know, they have some contrast where they run into the white and they did
- 22:23it just really subtly, like Amy's boss the really rich forest. She started
- 22:29talking to her in Japanese or well, well, the assistant was yeah.
- 22:33So she says a Japanese phrase to a Chinese Vietnamese woman, which is akin
- 22:40to someone coming up to an Israeli and saying something in German and saying like
- 22:47right, like you like I'm relating to you. I mean literally, you're
- 22:51you're looking at two white people and from Europe and you're like German phrase because
- 22:56to a Chinese Vietnamese person saying a Japanese phrase to them is you know,
- 23:00that doesn't feel very good. The history was not long ago when Japan was
- 23:06raping and pillaging those areas. So New York Times article by James pony wadzick
- 23:14I was reading it in preparation for this episode, and I marveled that the
- 23:21review of in the discussion of the TV show, didn't even mention the Asian
- 23:26characters. And this is a white guy writing this until about halfway through he
- 23:32mentions something about Asian Americans, and then the rest of the article that doesn't
- 23:37refer to it. It's just a review of a fucking TV show. You
- 23:41know. When Crazy Ritz Asians came out, that was all the articles.
- 23:45Oh my god, it's literally in the title, you know, it's like
- 23:48Asians in a movie. How weird is this? And for Beef, it's
- 23:55just nice to be normalized, you know, and to have Asian Americans who
- 24:00are dicks, who have three dimensional to personalities, who have regular relatable I
- 24:07mean, what's more relatable as to an American than road rage? Right,
- 24:11And what's more counter to the Asian model minority stereotype than just a good old
- 24:18flipping someone off during a road rage. And this was very key because you
- 24:22know, had this been made in certainly in the eighties, but even nineties,
- 24:26two thousands or whatever, it would have been you know, he's a
- 24:29martial arts expert, right, right, and then she's growing up or mill
- 24:36order bride or something, yeah, something, and then the whole thing is
- 24:40more about that, right. This could have been done with anyone, right,
- 24:44And it's just great characters, great actors, great storyline, and they
- 24:48also authentically represent their backgrounds, right like there are Asian they're not just bland
- 24:56characters with without ethnicity. They have death ethnicity, but it's not constantly for
- 25:02you know, you and I don't walk around in our daily life going like
- 25:06I am Asian American. You know, I'm Colombian American. What am I
- 25:08going to do next? Is this is what a Colombian American. This is
- 25:14the way he would walk to his car, This is how he would dress,
- 25:17this is what he would say, this is how he would see the
- 25:19world. You know, you're just a regular human being that come that has
- 25:23a background. You know, and white people have a background, but when
- 25:27so many people have a similar background, it looks like they don't have a
- 25:32background. Everyone to do that. Every time I show up at people's houses,
- 25:34I'll be like, I want to inspect your coffee machine, and let's
- 25:38talk about drugs for a little while. Yeah. So I was thinking about
- 25:45other movies and TV shows in which Asian Americans are just being Americans, because
- 25:51I at first I thought, I don't know if I've ever seen that.
- 25:55I don't know if I've ever seen a movie or TV show where Asian Americans
- 25:59were just being Asian American. I mean, to be fair, he was
- 26:02in The Walking Dead as just an American character, Okay, who happens to
- 26:06be Asian. But that's not a whole show or something. But but yeah,
- 26:08I mean, I'll take it. Yeah, I'll take it. And
- 26:11I came up with the following movies, One another one with Ali Wong Always
- 26:15be My Maybe I think it's another Netflix. We see that it's pretty good.
- 26:18It's romcom. Ali Wang and Randall Park were friends in high school and
- 26:23they kind of diverged in their life and they rekindle their friendship relationship. A
- 26:30better luck Tomorrow came out twenty years ago. Coming of age sort of amateur
- 26:34sounds familiar. I think I did see that. I bet you anything.
- 26:37Your Asian friends dragged you to see that because you would have been in your
- 26:41late twenties. Yeah, probably, and a very young John cho isn't that
- 26:45movie? And the Asian guy from Fast and Furious, like you know,
- 26:48in college, they dragged me to Joy Luck Club. They Harold and Kumar
- 26:52movies. Oh yeah, I mean that's true. Yeah too, great example,
- 26:56one South Asian, one Asian. Yeah, total American dudes. Yeah,
- 27:00and it's great because again there's that little bit of like, Okay,
- 27:04my father wants me to be a doctor. That's like the extent of it.
- 27:08Yeah, and you know, Harold doesn't really have that kind of element
- 27:11to it. Um the movie Searching again with there's a lot of John Show
- 27:15pretty much anything with John Show or Ellie One. But that's it, you
- 27:21know, everything everywhere all at once. You could say it's like half Asian
- 27:25American because the daughter, but the mom and the grandpa kind of just transplants
- 27:30from their country, you know what I mean, They don't they don't seem
- 27:33to be fitting in which is fine, but it's not as it's all like
- 27:37beef or always be my maybe where you just have Asian Americans just living a
- 27:41regular Asian American life, fresh off the boat. The TV show of course,
- 27:45really funny TV show, Randall Park and Candice Wu. You know,
- 27:49good show, but still kind of in that zone where the Asian nous is
- 27:55definitely played up. You know, Kim's convenience very similar. And I haven't
- 28:00seen Minari, which is another Stephen Steve Stephen Yuan movie. Wait was that
- 28:04the guy did parasite? No different? And I feel bad that I haven't
- 28:11seen it. And I just want to point out that again when we talk
- 28:15about Asian Americans, we are talking about literally sixty percent of the population of
- 28:22the planet is Asian. I mean, you forgot to mention Kung Fu with
- 28:26David Carrotting. Yeah, I did forget to mention that because it's a white
- 28:33guy one and it's uh, I mean, you know, it's a story.
- 28:37You could argue that it has nuance to it in a way, but
- 28:41it really foreignizes Asian Americans and associates them with Kung Fu. Yet again,
- 28:47on its own, it's fine as a kid if you can snatch the pebble
- 28:52from it um. You know, so, uh, sixty percent of the
- 28:56population, something like five billion people live within Asia. So any of those
- 29:02people, if they were to come to United States and immigrate, they would
- 29:04be considered Asian American. So that's a ridiculous category, right, Well,
- 29:10they say, well, what East Asian and Southeast Asian. Well, if
- 29:12we take those two groups, we're talking about forty percent. You know,
- 29:17we're not even talking about India, We're just talking about Vietnam, China,
- 29:21Korea, Japan, Philippines. We're talking about forty percent, three billion people.
- 29:27And so to say one is Asian American, East Asian American Southeast Asian
- 29:33American, that is like combining all the people from United States, from Canada,
- 29:40from Mexico, from Central America, all of South America, all of
- 29:45Europe, the complete Europe, all of Africa, every country, every human
- 29:52being in Africa. Saying someone as East Asian or in Southeast Asian is like
- 29:59saying all of that. Yeah, So if you were in Vietnam and someone
- 30:03came from Africa, and someone came from Europe, and another person came from
- 30:07the United States, and another person came from Argentina, another person came from
- 30:11Mexico. It'd be like in Vietnam. There'd be one box that you would
- 30:17check that you're just like not East Asia basically, you know, and you're
- 30:22not Indian and you're not Russian. That's one box. Imagine you people out
- 30:29there being lumped in with Africa, Europe, North America, South America,
- 30:34that and they think of you as you're all the same. French people are
- 30:38like Colombians are like Alaskans are like the people from South Africa, people from
- 30:45Egypt. It's all the same. So when we talk about East Asia,
- 30:49that's what we're talking about, yeas, and arguably East Asia Southeast Asia has
- 30:56more divergent cultures because there's been a lot of centuries to develop different pockets of
- 31:03dialect and history and genetics stuff anyway. So well, that's one of the
- 31:10super interesting things because since all of Latin America was conquered by one of two
- 31:17powers, I mean, give or take, there's a little bit of French
- 31:19sprinkled in there, but it's mostly Spanish and Portuguese, right, And that's
- 31:25that's incredible because that gives this weird uniformity to the whole thing. And then
- 31:30you go to Asia and it's so many different languages and so many different cultures.
- 31:33If you travel throughout the Latin American countries, you will find a lot
- 31:37of similarities. First of all, again, same same language mostly except Brazil,
- 31:42and culturally a lot similar food, similar style, similar things, but
- 31:48different, right, I mean their differences. But I mean in Clodia,
- 31:51right, the coast has spicy food and Bogata dozen, Yes, definitely.
- 31:55Yeah, it's just maybe maybe I'm anti bias. I just feel like I
- 32:00sense a lot more similarities. But it's not surprising because they were all conquered
- 32:06by one common and you know, in terms of history, relatively relatively recent.
- 32:12Yeah, that's right. Yeah, whereas there are pockets in China and
- 32:15Vietnam and Cambodia and Laos that have that go back, yeah, prehistory.
- 32:21You know that the people have been there forever, and so the specific the
- 32:25specificity of that culture and dialect is so specifically. That's the sad point of
- 32:30it is that it's the thing that would have given more diversity was kind of
- 32:35wiped out, right, Yeah, I mean before the Spaniards show up,
- 32:38show showed up. Undoubtedly, you know, the Pueblo people as opposed to
- 32:43the people that lived in Peru as opposed to the people that live in Alaska.
- 32:46I mean, the impact had more in common with the ancestors of a
- 32:51lot of those Asian civilizations. Okay, let's do one more thing about the
- 32:54Asianists of this and then go to break. There's a lot of stereotypes that
- 33:00were not depicted, that were countered and not on this silly way. It
- 33:06wasn't like, oh, I see what they're doing. They're trying to fly
- 33:08in the face of a stereotype. No, they're just depicting a believable human
- 33:14being. You know. So what were the Asian stereotypes that were thrown out
- 33:17the window? So no one was a martial arts expert, Yeah, I
- 33:22didn't see one. There also wasn't a wise sage like the grew on the
- 33:30mountain trapping flies with the chopsticks. Um golly. It really reminding me of
- 33:35some terrible tropes. Yeah yeah, yeah, but if you're the MCU,
- 33:38then you replace that person with a white person. That's true till the Swinton
- 33:44and doctor Strange. Yeah yeah, to give diversity. Yeah what else?
- 33:50I don't know. You tell me, well, model minority, the way
- 33:53the model minority or the model minority. I see, have you heard of
- 33:57that before? Yeah, I guess so, like you have them minority and
- 34:00they're kind of like little perfect token in in the movie or something. Uh
- 34:05huh, So you haven't heard of this stereotype. So this is the most
- 34:09loud stereotype that I've lived with. It's less so now, particularly in places
- 34:15like Seattle, but I still feel it when I leave the West Coast,
- 34:19which is that Asian Americans are considered to be quiet, obedient, hardworking,
- 34:27not non bothersome of the immigrants. They do good in school, they don't
- 34:32protest, they don't commit crimes. They're quiet, they're polite, and they
- 34:37do what they're told. So we're the model minority in that way. I
- 34:42certainly have heard that, right, like like, well, you know,
- 34:44the Asians they're pulling their weight and unlike these other people, right, And
- 34:49it's it's a stereotype. I mean, certainly we can look at statistics and
- 34:53you don't have to go very far. Specifically, when you start applying to
- 34:58college if you're not Asian, and you start realizing how much competition there is
- 35:02to get into good schools and the people you're often competing against as a lot
- 35:07of Asian Americans or people literally emigrating from Asia just to come to college in
- 35:10the United States. So yeah, you know, there are some statistics we
- 35:15can point to. There are rates of income and other kinds of markers in
- 35:21general. But we're talking about bell curves, you know, we're talking.
- 35:23You know, there's you have the Ali Wongs, and you have the sketchy
- 35:27cousins. You know, there's a there's a bell curve. But yeah,
- 35:30so the model minority trope stereotype is thrown out. Submissive Asian women was thrown
- 35:37out. That's true. Yeah, submissive Asian women is a thing. Yeah.
- 35:40I mean, maybe you live so far from the stereotypes that you don't
- 35:44even remember them anymore. But there are a lot of people who still consider
- 35:49Asian women to always be submissive or I mean, that's one possibility. But
- 35:52the other possibility is I grew up originally in an environment that was so stereotype
- 35:58that it was reduced to just two things martial arts, and you know,
- 36:01actually three things martial arts, the wise, old sage, and Chinese takeout
- 36:08right, those are the three things. Another thing that it throughout the window
- 36:13was that we're all the same and that we look alike. There's a lot
- 36:15of different characters in the show, very different sorts of also the stereotype that
- 36:22we're the perpetual foreigner. That yeah, like what you were saying, it
- 36:24was like everyone's got a thick accent. They haven't really nativized that they don't
- 36:29really understand the cultures. Yeah, in a movie or a TV show.
- 36:32And this is a trope that so say, it's a sitcom that is occurring
- 36:37in a business and you're in a business building, and of course they're white
- 36:39people and they have some foreign investors that are coming, and the secretary comes.
- 36:45It says the foreign investors are in the boardroom, you're you're late for
- 36:49your meeting, and the protagonist is like, oh no, and then they
- 36:52pan to the boardroom. It's always Asians, right, because Asian is sit
- 36:58in for foreigner. If you had a group of black people, or white
- 37:00people or brown people, it wouldn't code as foreigner. If you want foreigners,
- 37:07you have ten Japanese guys in suits and they don't even have to say
- 37:12anything. Yeah, I mean you could look to a boardroom of ten Asian
- 37:15guys and they could all be Asian Americans. Yeah, it could be burto
- 37:21at the lunch table in high school. And so, but it just codes
- 37:25that way, or you need to have tourists that code as foreigners. Hire
- 37:30a bunch of Asian American actors in a camera, yeah, put a camera
- 37:32around their neck, and you have instant foreigners, right. Um, the
- 37:37fact that for what but what you're pointing out, I hadn't thought of that,
- 37:42because you're right that if if you have a movie and you're panning through
- 37:45and you see some Latinos, some some black folks, some other folks,
- 37:50you will not necessarily you won't assume like, oh, those are foreigners,
- 37:52and then you pan to a group of Asians, your mind might go there,
- 37:57yeah yeah, or it could just be a fucking Asian Americans who are
- 38:00fourth generation and they just like to take pictures right like we exist. Uh,
- 38:07So the perpetual foreigner was you know, not represented there. Uh,
- 38:12the stereotype that were nerds and that we're not aggressive or cool or or rough.
- 38:19Because you have the sketchy cousin who you know, he's a he's a
- 38:23cool guy. Right in high school, he probably had a lot of charisma
- 38:28or something. Right, Daniel seems like he's you know, pretty cool as
- 38:30well. Paul seems like a cool guy. The brother, um, George,
- 38:35you know, they all so Daniel is not a smart person, right,
- 38:38and yet his brother is definitely smarter, but was underutilized, you know.
- 38:44Well, Paul was complicated because he was both pretty dumb about something,
- 38:50you know, because I thought he was immature. Well there's this moment when
- 38:53Daniel is like, you know, that's a bot, right, and and
- 38:58Paul is like, no, it's not. And then and then Paul texts
- 39:00the person and says, are you a bote? And the person's say,
- 39:04no, I'm not a boy. Yeah, But that to me, like,
- 39:06look, I used to fall for things all the time when I was
- 39:08younger, and I mean like my twenties, you know, And so I
- 39:12looked at that like he's just naive and okay, you know, but different
- 39:16different words. He seemed to be doing good in school, he was gonna
- 39:20be going to college, I mean, all these things. He wasn't a
- 39:22dumb you know person, but he also wasn't like a genius. And then
- 39:25Daniel was certainly no genius. There were so many things that he did and
- 39:31it was wonderfully written and acted. It was such a great choice to make
- 39:36him. There were several moments where you're like, oh, you're a smart
- 39:39guy, you know. There are moments when he's talking to Ali because Ali
- 39:45Wong's character Amy Amy is she's smart. She knows how to kind of run
- 39:49circles verbally around Daniel and Daniel there are times when he just seems like he's
- 39:54he's not a deep he hasn't thought a lot of deep thoughts. Right.
- 39:58It's like the difference between when he tries to find her and it takes them
- 40:01several stabs till he finally like locates her and then after she realizes he's paid
- 40:07in her house and stuff, it takes her like two seconds to locate and
- 40:09call him. I didn't even I didn't even notice that. Yeah. Also
- 40:14the stereotype that we're exotic and mysterious, you know where if you want to
- 40:20and and Star Wars does this and MCU does this, when you want the
- 40:24exotic character like in Gardens of the Galaxy and you have the alien look more
- 40:30Asian. Yeah, if you want an alien and a strange character, then
- 40:35you have an Asian person dressing up as as an as an Asian I mean
- 40:39Drax and the emotion women are both Asian Americans. But you want the relatable
- 40:45protagonists, you a white guy. Yeah, um, And I guess you
- 40:51could argue that with Zoe Seldonni she's black and she plays also an alien.
- 40:57But but yeah, it happens a lot, so exoticness is played also.
- 41:02The Asian tiger mom is another stereotype that wasn't really presented the Ali Wong.
- 41:09Her character Amy as a mom was often trying to advocate for less pressure on
- 41:15well, and they had a chance to make George's mom that way, but
- 41:22she wasn't. She was way more complex than that, right, Yeah,
- 41:25you would at the beginning of the series, it's like, oh, I
- 41:29get it, the mom is like this, I can now categorize her,
- 41:31And then they would have another scene where there'd be nuance to that. Yeah,
- 41:35there was a lot of but it wasn't like played for shock value,
- 41:37like you thought you knew this person. It was just like an unfurling of
- 41:42their full personalities. Anyway, let's take a break and we get back.
- 41:45Let's talk about some of the other elements in this movie. What do you
- 41:50say, Let's do it all right, we're back from the break. Let's
- 41:55do an opp Burdo. What do you say, oh, Bob. So
- 41:59these people became patrons all the way back in twenty twenty and have stayed patrons
- 42:04ever since. We have Madden, we have Zoo Zoo, we have Cecilia,
- 42:07Lauren, Veronica, Akeisha. All these people didn't list where they where
- 42:13they're from. Yeah, I was wondering, Yeah, Akeisha, John Nelly,
- 42:16Emma aze Lydia, Sarah Roughneck V and Julie So. All these folks
- 42:24became patrons all the way back in twenty two and have stayed patrons through thick
- 42:30and thin burdle, which is just the best. Recently, we also started
- 42:35a program on YouTube where you can become a member on YouTube, and we've
- 42:39had a few people sign up, which is very gratifying to me. When
- 42:43I was embarking on the initiation of the program, I was like, oh,
- 42:47well, anyone sign up? I don't know or and so it's just
- 42:51nice to know that when people sign up. I got my first CAMEO request.
- 42:55Oh right, so tell us about that. You're encouraging me to sign
- 43:00up to Cameo and I finally did. Uh. Yeah, I got a
- 43:02request from Iceland to do a PEP talk. I won't reveal the names,
- 43:08but it was pep talk for someone very special, and I put it together,
- 43:14you know, and they really liked it. It was appreciated. They've
- 43:17been saying a little bit. Yeah, I think you're a perfect match for
- 43:21cameo. Yeah, you're good on improv, you can sing, you can
- 43:28you're thoughtful, So that's great. I want to give a shout out to
- 43:30the very first members on YouTube. I think these are the very first members.
- 43:35We have Jalm Scuttle, Stella Annie, we have Diego, Luciana,
- 43:40Maddie Fern, the Mommy Breakdown, which is a YouTube channel, Mercury,
- 43:46Nielli, Jenny Pete, and Maria. I think we're our very first I
- 43:52wrote it down because when we first started taking patrons, I didn't make a
- 43:57note. Oh because because if you can't, I don't know if you're on
- 44:00the list anymore, right, And so I wanted to make sure I documented
- 44:04those very first people nice you know, sort of like your first customer that
- 44:07walks into your restaurant. Yeah, okay, So here are some other things
- 44:12about the psychology of the of the show. But I thought we talked about
- 44:17the Asian American sort of psychology issues. So The first one that's pretty obvious
- 44:22is the emotional suppression or the emotional troubles yea in this in these characters,
- 44:30So what did you see? Well, so I got so many of them.
- 44:35On the one hand, Daniel is so internal, you know, he
- 44:38doesn't communicate even with his brother about what he's thinking, what he's going through,
- 44:44what he's struggling with, and so a lot of that I could tell
- 44:46in that moment where he bursts and the show starts and the beef starts that
- 44:52it was just like all this pent up world inside of his head that he
- 44:57just doesn't have anyone to talk to about. So that wasn't interesting. And
- 45:00um, similarly, the the on the other side, what's the gal amy
- 45:07is she's got her own crazy world. She is unhappy, so unhappy,
- 45:14but she can't really show it to everyone, and everyone thinks she's perfect,
- 45:17and she's got to show it. She's always gotta be you know, smile
- 45:22and pretend her life. Even that that speech she gives when even there she's
- 45:25being honored and it's like you would think you can't have it all, but
- 45:29you can't, you know, like that kind of thing. It's so depressing.
- 45:32Yeah, Um, so Yeah, So there's things like that. And
- 45:35then the brother is also interesting to me because he's Paul. Paul is presented
- 45:40as a simpler character, but at the same time, like, think about
- 45:44it, he thought he was going to go off to college and as far
- 45:45as he knows, he was not good enough. So he's just must has
- 45:51an older brother that's constantly putting him down. All right, He's like,
- 45:52I guess I'm just a failure. And he's got that whole thing. But
- 45:57he's trying to make it. Man, he's got these crazy ideas, but
- 46:00his brother keeps telling him he's stupid for it. Yeah, it's it's intense.
- 46:02Yeah. And then there's George. George is sitting there Like the other
- 46:08thing that's great and complex about it is it's not just one of them that's
- 46:13like being unfaithful or trying to stray, like they're both not happy. They're
- 46:17both looking externally. And he at first comes off so well put together,
- 46:22so you know, he's a good looking guy, very well spoken. He
- 46:25seems like okay, he's okay, he's the one character we can all relate
- 46:29to. He's very well established. No, he's a mess too. He's
- 46:34also a mess and that was interesting. Yeah, and the theme that I
- 46:39started to think about the theme word was self centered or selfish. Everyone except
- 46:46for Paul. I mean, Paul comes across like a victim and someone who
- 46:52at his core is innocent and good, maybe because Daniel actually protected him from
- 46:58what was happening. There's a scene where they flash back to Daniel's childhood and
- 47:01Daniel and Paul are watching TV and the parents are fighting in the other room.
- 47:07I think about finances or something. And it's interesting and that as well,
- 47:09in terms of the Asian americanness of it is the Korean parents are arguing
- 47:14in Korean, and Amy when she remembers her childhood, her parents are arguing
- 47:17in English, because of course you have a Vietnamese woman and a Chinese man,
- 47:22and so they probably learned English so that they could communicate with her,
- 47:27or maybe they're a little bit more Americanized here. Just that little subtle difference
- 47:30was interesting. But for Daniel, he has one eye on his parents because
- 47:35he's concerned about what's going on in the other room as a kid, but
- 47:37he also is trying to protect his younger brother by saying, you know,
- 47:42meanwhile, his younger brother is just seemingly oblivious to what's happening, you know,
- 47:45because it's not his role to pay attention. But yeah, emotional suppression.
- 47:50Amy has a line where she talks about her she's in therapy, and
- 47:52by the way, the therapy depiction I thought was pretty good. It was
- 47:57kind of bland. The therapist dropped the ball all. I wanted the therapist
- 48:00to lean in with some compassion, a little bit more. But it was
- 48:06not a cartoonist it was. It wasn't a Sigmund Freud, you know,
- 48:10I saw dissect your brain or judgmental were because often I'm pretty sure the writers
- 48:17use therapists as a stand in for themselves or the audience to judge the characters.
- 48:23Yeah, the therapist is often saying things that people will yell at the
- 48:29screen as they're watching, and I'm like, that's not what therapy is.
- 48:31It's not yelling at people. Anyway. Amy talks about when she's in therapy
- 48:36about her childhood and she's you know, my dad was not very good about
- 48:38emotion, and my mom thought emotion emotional expression was just complaining about things.
- 48:45So a lot of immigrants, and of course a lot of late generation white
- 48:51Americans might be able to relate to this as well. But the thinking is
- 48:55is that and Amy goes into this. She talks about how her mom one
- 49:00of the first things she noticed when she came to the States, you know,
- 49:01running out a refugee from the war in Vietnam. One of the first
- 49:07things she recognized was the birds singing and the birds birds, snut singing,
- 49:13chirping birds. What do birds do? Tweet tweeting, right, but now
- 49:20we say twitter anyway, I think she could hear the birds, and she
- 49:23was reminded that in Vietnam, the reason why there were no birds in I
- 49:29think Saigon was because of the of the famine. Everyone ate all the birds.
- 49:34All the birds were gone. And so these individuals that the dad from
- 49:38China probably came from a generation or at least was one generation or removed from
- 49:44the atrocities of Japan. In China and the Korean parents definitely come from a
- 49:52history of atrocities and scarcity. Yeah, atrocities in scarcity. Yeah. And
- 49:58when you have that history or you have that experience on a population, you
- 50:02don't have time to complain. And as a child or as an adult,
- 50:07you know the hierarchy of needs and the baseline is survival, right, And
- 50:15if you're taking care of your children, or you're taking care of your siblings
- 50:17or your your town, people can't self actualize. They can't say, you
- 50:22know what, I would like to cry about this. At least that's the
- 50:24perception. And so you just have to keep keep going, don't give up,
- 50:29don't stop, just keep moving forward, keep moving forward. And of
- 50:31course you deny your humanists, your emotion, your vulnerability, and you pass
- 50:37that on to your children, even though your children are not in that environment
- 50:40anymore. And so there's this transgenerational trauma that gets passed down. I know
- 50:46a lot of different groups of people around the world often coinciding with atrocities and
- 50:52war and famine. For example, Polish people often because you know, in
- 50:57World War One, world War two, and before that of World War One,
- 51:00there's a history of the people who live in Russia or the people who
- 51:04live in the German area invading and raping and pillaging and refugees and genocide of
- 51:10the Jewish people in Poland. And you have these different groups of people that
- 51:14have been traditionally harmed, and you have they emigrate to the United States.
- 51:20Through the generations. You hear you see the echoes of that. And so
- 51:24for example, for me, the thing that I can point to is that
- 51:29my ancestors came from famine. So southern Japan went through some tough times famine
- 51:36wise, and so a lot of Japanese people immigrated United States about one hundred
- 51:40and twenty years ago. And so my people came from that group of people.
- 51:45And then on my other side, a good chunk of my white side
- 51:47came from a famine that happened in Sweden, which my Swedish people came from
- 51:53kind of the Central region, which is where Ikia was founded. It's actually
- 51:59in that town, and they emigrated. So a lot of Swedish people emigrated
- 52:02to Pennsylvania and to Minnesota. That's why Minnesota's associated with Sweden. They also
- 52:08came to a Seattle, you know, Ballard, it's very associated with Scandinavia.
- 52:13But my people went to Kansas for some weird reason, there's a little
- 52:16Swedish community in the middle of Kansas in Salina. They became farmers, and
- 52:22they were foreigners trying to eke out any existence among oppression of the white citizens
- 52:29the United States. So I have themes of that difficulty and that strife,
- 52:35but it's not as bad as having generations of genocide and rape and pillage and
- 52:40you know, having to eat your horse or see dead people in the side
- 52:45road. I mean, you know people in China and Vietnam. I mean
- 52:49not everyone, but a lot. So you have but George, for example,
- 52:52since he's fourth fifth generation, he doesn't have that. Yeah, he
- 52:58doesn't have that. He had he was raised and privilege and had Another Asianist
- 53:02part of this is that a lot of Japanese Americans rose to prominence in art
- 53:08and in architecture, in sculpture and design, so back in the day.
- 53:14And I didn't know this until my dad told me about it, that during
- 53:16my dad's time in the sixties, Japanese people which were the main Asian America.
- 53:22Of course they're a fair amount of Chinese as well, but there are
- 53:23a lot of Japanese that guess what jobs you thought you were slated for as
- 53:30a Japanese American in the sixties. In the sixties, Yeah, I mean,
- 53:35that's interesting. Sixties. I would have think dentistry. No, that
- 53:40would come later. There's a lot of Japanese American dentists. That's a very
- 53:45good identification. That's phasing out to more Chinese and Korean people. But but
- 53:53yeah, dentists and general medical professionals from education in the seventies and eighties,
- 54:00a lot and a lot of nurses, a lot of jack you know.
- 54:04It's sort of like these oh sixties. Landscaping, yes, gardening, gardening
- 54:09so and also art and design, drawing. So it's not because Japanese people
- 54:15are particularly good at design or landscaping or gardening. They are, I mean,
- 54:19there's a tradition of that. But it's similar to how you will find
- 54:23a lot of Middle Eastern nurse who will drive taxi cabs or work at a
- 54:30seven eleven or start a convenience store. You know, think about the stereotype
- 54:34of a pooh this kind of thing, right. The reason why is because
- 54:37you emigrate and you hook up with your community and they say, you know
- 54:42what, I can help you develop your own seven eleven, your own convenience
- 54:45store, because here's how I did it, and white people will expect you
- 54:50to be there if you start. You know, if someone from you know,
- 54:54I don't know, Syria were to open up a dentistry office, you'd
- 55:00at some side eye glances and maybe no one would even go to you because
- 55:02they don't expect to see a Syrian dentist, you know, but they do
- 55:07expect to see a Syrian cab driver or a Syrian convenience store owner. Well
- 55:13that's it. So it's not only generated from within the community, but it's
- 55:16also kind of imposed from the outside. And so for Japanese Americans, for
- 55:22whatever reason, it was gardening and design My dad didn't have any interest in
- 55:29becoming a designer and artist, but he did have some innate talent, and
- 55:34he had a mentor, a white guy who actually kind of shepherded him in
- 55:37that, and you know, he enjoyed it. It was a and he
- 55:39worked with a lot of other Japanese Americans, even though there's not a lot
- 55:45of Japanese American you know, in terms of per capita. For me,
- 55:49that when I experienced a steriad, I had no idea about the gardening thing.
- 55:52I'm sixteen years old and I got a job as a landscaper, you
- 55:57know, weeding and mowing lawns, and oh it was such a horrible job.
- 56:00I mean eight to eight o'clock to four o'clock, hard labor in the
- 56:07in the hot sun of you know, it's not super hot Seattle but hot
- 56:10enough, you know, pretty awful job. And back then they didn't have
- 56:15walkman or earbuds or podcasts. You just you're just sitting there with the hum
- 56:21of the of the lawnmar for eight hours. It was. It was really
- 56:23an awful job. My very first job. It was a one day thing
- 56:29that I got paid for other than my mom paying me for washing her car.
- 56:32Was someone from the church needed someone to come and do some work in
- 56:37the yard. So I went on a Saturday and worked for like ten hours,
- 56:43like doing the most brutal labor, lifting super heavy rocks and with tools
- 56:50I had never used in my life, like those little heads trimmers and all
- 56:53this stuff, and just making mistake after mistakes. So the guy was like
- 56:57yelling at me, and I think, for you know, ten hours,
- 57:00I got like twenty bucks. It was like two bucks an hour. I
- 57:05like, how you call an edge trimmer a hedge trimmer. It's an edge
- 57:08trimmer. Yeah, I just thought it was a hedge trimmer. No,
- 57:10no, no, well the hand motion you made was you know, it's
- 57:14a blade or yeah that blade, that's an edge trimmer or an edger.
- 57:16Okay, okay, yeah, yeah, see I don't even know what it's
- 57:19calling. Yeah, I think a jedge trimmer technically would just be a just
- 57:23what do they call it those anyway? Oh yeah, yeah, it's more
- 57:27like a little mini chainsaw. Yeah exactly. Yeah. So George's father was
- 57:31an artist, a prominent artist, and a sculpture or right, a designer,
- 57:37and that slots right into that whole system. Right. In fact,
- 57:40a lot of my dad's heroes, Japanese American guys are these architects and designers,
- 57:47you know, because they a model, someone a role model. Yeah,
- 57:52it's sort of like if you're a black kid, and I found this
- 57:55a lot of the time. I'd be talking with a black teenager and all
- 58:00wanted to be in the NBA, right, which is fine, But if
- 58:04that's all you feel like you can do, right, because they don't have
- 58:07role models as physicians necessarily, there's not that many spots open, right,
- 58:12and they all think they're gonna make it right, you know, they all
- 58:15because on the playground they're pretty good. But now that's a good point because
- 58:19for example, with a lot of the Latin community in these areas, there's
- 58:22there's a lot of gardening actually, and it must be similar where you know,
- 58:28someone gets into it. It's like, well, I'm looking for work.
- 58:30It's like, well, actually i've got this. Either I've got this
- 58:32company, or I work for a company like this, or you can start
- 58:36your own like this. Here's the formula. Yeah. And when you're thirteen
- 58:39and you start thinking about the future, you start to look at well,
- 58:44what are you qualified to do? Right? And a very compelling heuristic is
- 58:47well, what are the people that look like me, my uncle's, my
- 58:52aunties, other people, what are they doing? And when you see that,
- 58:55you think okay, and you don't see yourself represent and in another areas
- 59:00then you just figure subconsciously that you can't do it. So I'm doing the
- 59:04landscaping. And this old one it was a retirement community and an old you
- 59:07know, all the people there were old, um and by the way,
- 59:10I think the cut off age that you had to be was fifty five.
- 59:15Okay, I'm almost fifty five. Oh, So you know those you know,
- 59:20those communities, those retirements like Shag, which is just a very h
- 59:25ironic name because of course in Britain shag is to fuck right. So there's
- 59:31a retirement condo community in Seattle culture called Shag. But even if you're not
- 59:37thinking of that connotation of Britain because because shag is shaggy carpet or shaggy like
- 59:44meaning it's not doing well, you know. Yeah, So anyway, um,
- 59:49that's also fifty five. But anyway, so I'm in the retirement community
- 59:52in Issaqua Providence Point for those that are following along, and the woman comes
- 59:57up to me, singles me out out of the crew of like ten people,
- 1:00:00and I'm the least qualified and says, I want you to be my
- 1:00:04personal gardener. Oh my gosh, and I'm like, really, how much
- 1:00:07you paying? I think it was like twenty five bucks an hour or something.
- 1:00:10It was insane, so just let you know. Minimum wage of time
- 1:00:14was I think like four four four fifty or something. So what minimum wage
- 1:00:19in Seattle is what fifteen bucks? So that'd be like paying someone one hundred
- 1:00:22and hundred bucks an hour or something. I don't know what the ratio is
- 1:00:25there, but I was like, whoa twenty And I'm like sure, And
- 1:00:30I'm thinking, how did she choose me? She chose anyone else here?
- 1:00:34And then I go home and I'm telling my dad about it, and he's
- 1:00:37like, oh, well, you know why she chose me? And I
- 1:00:39said, no, why did she choose me. She's like, he's like,
- 1:00:42because you're the only Asian and your Japanese. And I thought, well,
- 1:00:46what do you mean. He's like, well, when I was a
- 1:00:49kid, which is where she would have grown ups, this older woman,
- 1:00:52that's that's what Japanese people were. They were gardeners to white people. And
- 1:00:55I thought, huh, well, I'll take it twenty five bucks an hour.
- 1:01:00But you know, it didn't feel good to just be pigeonholed like that,
- 1:01:02right, Like, oh, he's he's Japanese, he's like genetically superior,
- 1:01:09even though he has no training and no skill, you know, to
- 1:01:13just be pigeonholed like that, or martial arts, or you're black and you
- 1:01:17must be good at dancing or basketball or something. Or you're Asian and you
- 1:01:22must be good at math this kind of stuff. Or you're Latino and you
- 1:01:24must be terrible at math, or and you must be interested in dregs.
- 1:01:28You know, it's just this anyway, So emotional suppression and unhealthy emotional coping
- 1:01:35is a pretty big theme. Of course, not every East Asian. And
- 1:01:38also that contrast with George, who is more Americanized. It's not like Japanese
- 1:01:44people are known for their vulnerability and emotional expression. But he's way more Americanized.
- 1:01:49Yeah, and he's more expressive than Yeah, he's way more California.
- 1:01:52The most California guy is George because he's fourth fit generation. Um. Some
- 1:01:59of the food food is represent representative of Asian, like the kim chi and
- 1:02:04this kind of stuff. I love when the cousin first comes out of jail,
- 1:02:07they're having food somewhere and he orders two ox bone soups. I've never
- 1:02:13had oxbone soup, yeah, but it sounds interesting. Yeah, I don't
- 1:02:15even know that. I assume that's a Korean thing because as a Japanese person,
- 1:02:22although I do claim kim chi, although you know it's very Korean,
- 1:02:24of course, but all my Japanese American relatives eat a lot of kim chi,
- 1:02:30and for me, kim chi was half of my diet growing up.
- 1:02:35So also the fact that George's name is George is a Japanese American thing,
- 1:02:39right, My grandfather George Honda, George Takai. You know, there are
- 1:02:45certain names that Japanese. I'm sure every ethnicity has that, where they're just
- 1:02:49certain names that when you come to United States because you're trying to name your
- 1:02:52kids names that or you'll adopt names that will be easier for white people to
- 1:02:58pronounce. Yeah, there's just a set of names. And I always wonder
- 1:03:01as to why, you know, why did these names get chosen? Is
- 1:03:06it because they were just kind of popular names? And you're just like,
- 1:03:08well, it's like if I were to go to somewhere in Latin America and
- 1:03:13I just like, I don't know, call me Jose or something, just
- 1:03:16because I know what that name is. Maybe that's what people are doing.
- 1:03:20But I also wonder if there are certain Americanized names that are more pleasing to
- 1:03:25Japanese people or wherever people are coming from, like they themselves have a better
- 1:03:30time saying that. I don't know. I also want to, you know,
- 1:03:32George Washington. Maybe it's like, well, when Colombians came to the
- 1:03:37States, did you see that happening where they would adopt a certain name.
- 1:03:40No, but you certainly need to shorten your names sometimes, or you know,
- 1:03:45like in my case, obviously there were it was convenient to be able
- 1:03:50to tell people just call me Bartough, right, but that wasn't a thing
- 1:03:53just here my name was shortened by my family names are shortened in general.
- 1:03:59Yeah, but I never saw like, oh, I should change my name
- 1:04:01to a green goo name. Uh huh. Well, maybe it's because you
- 1:04:04came later. If you would have come fifty sixty years ago, I think
- 1:04:09there would have been a temptation to just change your name to Bert. Yeah,
- 1:04:13that's true. It could be or something or Bob, because all my
- 1:04:17relatives in the early twentieth century adopted a name like I had. My great
- 1:04:24great grandfather Wahe Okamoto changed his name to Joe or Joseph. There are a
- 1:04:30lot of Joe's, a lot of Joseph's, a lot of George's. But
- 1:04:32then there's also this phenomenon of naming your kids. There's a lot of Japanese
- 1:04:38Americans of my dad's generation of the Chee Sanse, so my dad is third
- 1:04:43generation Sanse and there's a lot of Allan's. There's a lot of Carol's.
- 1:04:48Interesting, there's a lot of I think there's a lot of Tony's. I'm
- 1:04:50just thinking of my aunts and uncles at this point, Ronald and Gary,
- 1:04:56and there's a lot of there's another name that you Gloria. There's a lot
- 1:05:01of Glorious in Japanese. So anyway, there's just another little touch. I
- 1:05:05was like, his name's George, he's Japanese. Um. Also, the
- 1:05:10pressure that was depicted was was very Asian psychology in this show. How would
- 1:05:15you depict the pressure put on the kids? Yeah, I mean I certainly
- 1:05:19get the sense of urgency, like because there's one thing about like you have
- 1:05:26to do good in school, well in school, or you have to you
- 1:05:28know, do well, get a good job. But there was also an
- 1:05:30urgency about it, like it's got to happen yesterday. Um. Like for
- 1:05:34example, Dan Danny didn't have a plan like wow, man, well we
- 1:05:39had a big setback, but it might take me five years or ten years.
- 1:05:43It was like I gotta get this place now, like we got So
- 1:05:45there was that. There was also a desperation about it, like this kind
- 1:05:50of sense of helpless helplesseness mixed with I'll do anything. And I suppose the
- 1:05:57other aspect was the that it was a matter of identity, like I cannot
- 1:06:04be the person that failed. So I don't know, those are some things
- 1:06:09I noticed. Yeah, And for Amy's character having to sacrifice everything yea to
- 1:06:16rise in their ranks and gain the prestige and the materialism and the money and
- 1:06:23the stability. So you and the materialism. I mean, you could argue
- 1:06:27that a central foundation for the main characters Danny and Amy was materialism and greed
- 1:06:35that they were fighting over a road rage incident. But the side stories,
- 1:06:41their individual stories is for him. For Danny, he's doing whatever he possibly
- 1:06:46can, including exploiting a church to get money. Now he would say,
- 1:06:50well, I'm trying to provide for my parents, right. Well, that
- 1:06:54that's the difference that I would note, Like, obviously what he was doing
- 1:06:57was horrible, and by the way, also so that his true calling in
- 1:07:00life was in fact to be a musician, like because that was an uninteresting
- 1:07:06thing. He was actually a terrible contractor, you know. But it is
- 1:07:10interesting that his motivations for getting the money, even though he's going about it
- 1:07:14horribly and does horrible things, don't seem as much about material wealth. It
- 1:07:18seems like, I gotta fix this for my parents, right, right,
- 1:07:23although he did want his parents to love him as a result, right.
- 1:07:27But in her keys there was this additional layer of ostentation, like the need
- 1:07:31for ostentation that she didn't actually seem to actually care about, but she felt
- 1:07:35like she needed right, And the ending the final couple episodes really dives deep
- 1:07:43into this, and they're hallucinating on poisonous berries and talking about their insecurities and
- 1:07:48how they both just wanted to be loved right. They're running from being alone,
- 1:07:56the experience that they felt when they were young. For Danny, his
- 1:08:00parents fighting all the time, and the pressure that Danny probably felt as the
- 1:08:03oldest son trying to take care of his younger brother and feeling responsible and never
- 1:08:09feeling like he's good enough and never feeling like he's loved and maybe that's why
- 1:08:13he turned to this sketchy cousin originally too for the counterfeited formula, because he's
- 1:08:18like, well, maybe then my parents will love me, and he shoots
- 1:08:23himself in the foot and then for out. For Amy, she's constantly trying
- 1:08:28to be loved and she talks very specifically about and also, I guess another
- 1:08:34contrast is Amy's character, being middle upper class, goes to therapy to talk
- 1:08:40about it, and for him, Danny, he's more talking with friends and
- 1:08:45this kind of thing like yeah, complaining to his cousin, right, you
- 1:08:47know. And so for Amy, she also felt like love was conditional that
- 1:08:56and that was just such a powerful scene and Ali Wong just nail the performance.
- 1:09:00You know, when people cry in movies. Since I'm a professional,
- 1:09:04literally, I'm paid to listen to people cry, to watch people cry.
- 1:09:09Over the past twenty five years, I've picked up on the authenticity of different
- 1:09:14kinds or the ways, the different kind of crying looks, and the crying
- 1:09:16that Ali Wong you know, performs while she's in therapy. She kind of
- 1:09:21she puts her her lip. You have to see it. It's she starts
- 1:09:26to cry and it looks very natural, and her mouth kind of does this
- 1:09:30diagonal thing because you can she's trying to clamp down, you know. She's
- 1:09:34like like it's it's about to burst, but she's trying to keep it together.
- 1:09:41It was just beautifully acted and shot and it was just awesome anyway.
- 1:09:46But she's talking about how she you know, she's like, is there such
- 1:09:49a thing as unconditional love? And the therapist is like, oh, okay,
- 1:09:53I think we're getting somewhere. I think you're talking about your parents,
- 1:09:55because she was just but then the therapists like, well tell me more.
- 1:09:59And Amy said as well, because I don't know if I can love my
- 1:10:01husband for what he did, and the therapist is like, oh, almost
- 1:10:06yeah, but I felt like I just wanted the therapist to well. And
- 1:10:13what's what's great about that scene is we as the audience, know that she's
- 1:10:16actually not just talking about her husband because she knows what she did right,
- 1:10:20and so she's actually asking can my husband unconditionally love me because I've done something
- 1:10:27terrible? And then also can I and really under the surface is can I
- 1:10:31be unconditionally loved by my parents? And the therapist only has one of those
- 1:10:35at the starts like, oh, you're talking about your parents, and then
- 1:10:39thinks that it's only the other one, and then of course misses that there's
- 1:10:42this third one, and it's it's great. It's a great scene. Yeah.
- 1:10:45Yeah. And incidentally, as a therapist, this happens all the time.
- 1:10:50People clients will talk tangentially about the core issue, and when I would
- 1:10:58see that, I would just go the tangential issue because subconsciously I figured or
- 1:11:02guessed that they were processing on the more fundamental issue. But we were talking
- 1:11:08about a tangential issue. So if I were that therapist, I would say,
- 1:11:12well, what do you think you know? Is it possible for you
- 1:11:14to love your husband even though he did this, and it depending on how
- 1:11:16things went. I might introduce the notion of like, well, yeah,
- 1:11:19I mean some people absolutely love is unconditional, and it's up to you,
- 1:11:26of course, as to whether or not you want to love him. You
- 1:11:28know, if this destroys your love, you know, it's just a personal
- 1:11:30choice. But for example, parents, you know, typically good parents,
- 1:11:34good enough parents. Parents who don't come from transgenerational trauma at the very least
- 1:11:39are well, I don't even want to say that. I'll just say that
- 1:11:43parents who do this for whatever reason, because you can come from transgenerational trauma
- 1:11:48and still do this where you will exhibit and embody unconditional love. Your kid
- 1:11:55can make massive mistakes, and typically kids don't make terrible mistakes, they make
- 1:12:01kid mistakes, and parents absolutely, from the bottom of their hearts still deeply,
- 1:12:09deeply love their children. So I would throw that out there because I
- 1:12:12would be thinking, I think we're really talking about your parents here. And
- 1:12:15so for Amy, she's constantly trying to rise in the ladder of success,
- 1:12:21and she's always constantly trying to prove herself to other people, like look at
- 1:12:26me, I'm worthy. I bought this house for you. I've given a
- 1:12:30husband the chance that you can be at home with the daughter, like I've
- 1:12:32set everything up. Do you love me now? Am I lovable? Right?
- 1:12:38But in her, you know, racing towards this finish line, she
- 1:12:42is alienating and distancing herself and being cold and thus ultimately not getting any kind
- 1:12:48of love. And there are these wonderful moments where George, because you could
- 1:12:53easily write George into a corner where he's this floppy fem sure or he's cartoonishly
- 1:13:02new age or something, because they did a little bit of that, but
- 1:13:05there were moments where George was he would just seemed and Amy when they would
- 1:13:10talk, they would have these really genuine moments where it seemed like, Okay,
- 1:13:15tell me about build on top of yeah, tell me about what you
- 1:13:17thought. There were so many moments with the characters where Danny and Amy they
- 1:13:21kind of make up, right, they meet in the parking lot and then
- 1:13:26the guy hawks at them and they both yeah, and Amy and all he
- 1:13:30wants her. She is such a comedia comedic acting genius, like I just
- 1:13:35love to watch her facial expressions. But she calls the guy any other car
- 1:13:40car a shriveled ball sack or what if she sat? I mean, oh,
- 1:13:45man, I just want to get into a fight with someone so I
- 1:13:47can use it you shriveled ball sack or shriveled nut or something. I don't
- 1:13:53know if you were going to get at this, but um, there were
- 1:13:55several points throughout the story where you almost you're like, oh, they're turning
- 1:13:59a lead. Oh and you know what the show is like, so you're
- 1:14:02probably thinking it's not, but part of you wants it to work. You're
- 1:14:05like, yes, this is the way out. Just keep going in this
- 1:14:10direction, right, hold hands and walk in that direction. Yeah, and
- 1:14:14then everything would fall apart. Yeah. Yeah. And so the same thing
- 1:14:17with with her and George. There were moments where you're like, okay,
- 1:14:20so there is a foundation this can work, right, um. And actually
- 1:14:25I would say that was true with a lot of them, like the you
- 1:14:28know, a genius of this was that it gave you enough moments like that
- 1:14:31where you wanted the cousin to make it. You know, Okay, he's
- 1:14:34out of jail, but he's a good guy. It's like we can do
- 1:14:36this, you know, and then he slaps Danny across. Yeah. So
- 1:14:43A common immigrant story to the United States from whether it's Europe or China,
- 1:14:47or Poland or Africa Colombia, is that you might be coming from transgend racial
- 1:14:54trauma, you might be coming from poverty. Particularly in the past, a
- 1:14:58lot of people came to the States as they were running from death, like
- 1:15:00the Swedish people that came over. Because I've done all this genealogy, a
- 1:15:05lot of the relatives, the siblings and the cousins of the Swedish people that
- 1:15:10made it to the United States, they all died young. Oh it doesn't
- 1:15:14say why as I say why, because they didn't keep records of that back
- 1:15:16then. But there was a famine going on. Oh my gosh. And
- 1:15:20I have pictures of these people and they, you know, they look like
- 1:15:24everything's fine, but you know half of that whole generation just died in Sweden,
- 1:15:28you know. So you know you're running from some sort of disaster.
- 1:15:32Yeah. So you come to the States and you're thinking and and you're being
- 1:15:36oppressed by the majority. Right, So your path to existing on the planet
- 1:15:44and not dying is financial stability, and so that becomes your soul focused one
- 1:15:49thing. You don't think about anything else. You're just obsessed with making sure
- 1:15:54that you have money, you have investments, you're making good choices, you're
- 1:15:57not buying things that you you don't need. I think that. So I
- 1:16:01can certainly relate to how my mom was like that or you know it is,
- 1:16:05but definitely was like that because she was that first generation. So she
- 1:16:11was like, no, nonsense, we can't spend money frivolously. We're gonna
- 1:16:15succeed here. We gotta pull ourselves up by our bootstraps and like really put
- 1:16:20money away and blah blah blah. Super conservative and not like politically, just
- 1:16:25like super conservative with money and everything. Right. And then I'm second generation,
- 1:16:29and so I'm like, money, money, we should spend it all,
- 1:16:33right, right, Yeah, And I've seen that with a lot of
- 1:16:35my actual you know, with my Asian friends too, where like they're totally
- 1:16:39not as concerned with, you know, being so they're they're looser with their
- 1:16:44money than their parents were, right Yeah, and then they'll have kids that
- 1:16:46will be even more loose, and it'll be like a George. So another
- 1:16:53aspect that was very Asian American, specifically Korean American, about this TV show
- 1:16:58was the depiction of the Christian Yeah, White Americans might not know this,
- 1:17:02but most Korean Americans are devout Christians. I don't know the percentage exactly,
- 1:17:10but it's up there, and there's a lot of Korean Christian churches in the
- 1:17:14United States, and I think it's particularly Christian. I think in Korea the
- 1:17:17percentage of Christians is up there, but not nearly as high as Korean Americans
- 1:17:23going to church. By the way, that another genius point in the show,
- 1:17:27and another one of those where you're like, oh no, when so
- 1:17:30he goes to the church, he goes to the to the and he's crying
- 1:17:33on all these things, and that was genuine, like he definitely really was
- 1:17:38crying, like yeah, because you could feel his insights pouring out. Yeah.
- 1:17:43Right, And so you go through that. But then then that you
- 1:17:45know, it was like, oh, you know, can you play?
- 1:17:48It's like, yeah, I can play, But we have no information up
- 1:17:51to that point that he's musical. Now they go on to the other scenes
- 1:17:55with the show, and then a song starts playing with someone singing while the
- 1:17:59scene is playing out, and then at the end it pans back and it's
- 1:18:01him singing with this beautiful voice, and I'm pretty sure it was live like
- 1:18:06I don't know about you, but it looked live. When I watch these
- 1:18:11kinds of depictions on TV movie shows, TV and movie shows, one of
- 1:18:15the first things I'm evaluating is if it's live or not. Well, it
- 1:18:18was a very nuanced performance, so it'd be very hard to lip sync.
- 1:18:21Well, you know what I mean. The drummer, the bassist, the
- 1:18:26keyboardist were either lip syncing exactly on the Because it's amazing to me. They'll
- 1:18:31have a movie like The Wedding Singer or something, and they have a pretty
- 1:18:35big budget and they have a nameless extra playing the bass, and you can
- 1:18:40tell that person has never held a bass in their life. I'm thinking it
- 1:18:45wouldn't be that hard to hire someone that plays the bass. They would probably
- 1:18:48do it for free if they're in a movie and they just they don't even
- 1:18:53find someone that knows that they've never held an instrument in their life. Whereas
- 1:18:57in this TV show, Yeah, looked like a real performance. I'm guessing
- 1:19:01they had to do it a few times to get right. But but and
- 1:19:04it's a pretty complicated song. And I gotta say, in that moment,
- 1:19:08there's this additional thing of like, oh, dude, yeah, you missed
- 1:19:12your like this is you. Yeah, and it's heartbreaking because he doesn't even
- 1:19:16recognize it because he thinks he's using them, meaning he whether part of him
- 1:19:21is like, oh yeah, I love doing this. There's that other part
- 1:19:25of him it's like, Okay, this is how I'm gonna get the money.
- 1:19:27He's still on the take, yeah, because that's his foundation. Oh,
- 1:19:29it's so sad. Yeah, you know you're not a handy person.
- 1:19:32You're you're terrible at that, right, Yeah, And I didn't even think
- 1:19:36about that that They are these moments where you're like, oh, you could
- 1:19:42be doing something else. Amy's character talks about this too. Yeah. She
- 1:19:45reminisces about being in college. She's talking to Paul, for example, and
- 1:19:48and she's like, yeah, I just kind of miss those times when I
- 1:19:53was young and I didn't care about things and I could just be myself,
- 1:19:57and you're thinking you could be there do that, and he oh. Because
- 1:20:00the thing is it's not just the music. He goes on to actually become
- 1:20:03a leader in the church and actually he's doing good and he's putting his shoddy
- 1:20:09worksmanship at least to good us and all these but he's still on the tank.
- 1:20:13He's still not getting that wait a minute, like he's not hitting pause
- 1:20:16and going wait, actually, yeah, this is nice. Yeah. Another
- 1:20:20nice thing that I liked about that whole scene, especially that when he first
- 1:20:25starts crying, is that it's so rare to see a depiction in popular media
- 1:20:30of religion being a positive thing right now. You wouldn't walk away from this
- 1:20:34TV show saying it was like telling everyone they should be Christian. No,
- 1:20:40it was just a regular, nuanced depiction. You had an asshole who was
- 1:20:44in the and I don't really like that guy as an actor. He's from
- 1:20:48Umbrella Academy. Oh, I've not seen I read the graphic novel, but
- 1:20:53I haven't seen the show. I just don't think that actor has the chops
- 1:20:57to keep up character. Did he plan Umbrella Academy. Well, he plays
- 1:21:00one of the kids, and he's this he turns into this monster thing,
- 1:21:04this this giant like octopusy thing. But in the TV show he's dead,
- 1:21:10So he's only occasionally in this show and those scenes are great, But when
- 1:21:15he's called upon to actually kind of deliver, like later on I think season
- 1:21:18three and Umbrella Academy, which I did not like Season one and two is
- 1:21:23some of the best TV I've ever seen. Season three. It centers on
- 1:21:27him, and it's an alternate universe, and he's a jerk, and he's
- 1:21:30just not a very good act I'm just going to tell you that. I
- 1:21:32will say in this show he was fine, but I he was certainly side
- 1:21:39you know. Yeah, I almost would say that his interaction was was the
- 1:21:45one cartoony thing. That's what I'm saying. I don't I mean, maybe
- 1:21:47I'm not even just saying just his acting. I'm saying that storyline that one
- 1:21:54could have been trimmed back a little bit, yeah, because this too convenient.
- 1:21:57It was like, one thing is that he starts becoming a leader in
- 1:22:00the church, and actually maybe there's someone there that starts fancying him, and
- 1:22:04maybe he has a conversation with his ax that turns out that they could have
- 1:22:08been something. But it was a little too far. That's like, oh,
- 1:22:11now she wants him and the other guy his nemesis is actually a door.
- 1:22:15That was a little too high school drama for me, right, But
- 1:22:18it was such a small part that I didn't Yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 1:22:21it seemed like it was written into the script to have an antagonist to have
- 1:22:30someone that Danny would be kind of playing. Yeah, and also to raise
- 1:22:34questions as to who burned down that apartment that he was building, right,
- 1:22:39but another Asian American. Sorry, but even that one. They didn't set
- 1:22:45that up. There was already enough second guessing. I was like, well
- 1:22:48it was probably her, Like that was enough there to add the additional subterfuge.
- 1:22:54What was weird about it? It was like, well, they didn't
- 1:22:56set that up well enough because yeah, he beat him at basketball, gonna
- 1:23:00burned down his house. But maybe that was the point is they just wanted
- 1:23:03to be like pretty ambiguous. It turns out it's Danny himself. I mean,
- 1:23:06I love because that to me would have been enough. You already thought
- 1:23:10it was her. They had to seem perfectly set up where she's eating the
- 1:23:14burger right afterwards, and you're like, oh gosh, she burned down the
- 1:23:15place, and it makes sense he just ruined her relationship or you know,
- 1:23:19because of his brother and s and then it's his own damn fault, right,
- 1:23:25Like that was enough, but still, you know, yeah, another
- 1:23:30Asian American. You might be related to this a little bit. Burto is
- 1:23:32the basketball tournament? Oh yeah, Asian Americans love to play basketball, and
- 1:23:39it's something that is not talked about enough, right because I don't think a
- 1:23:43lot of people consider Asian Americans to be super into playing basketball. Probably not,
- 1:23:48But I gotta be honest, I played basketball all the time because of
- 1:23:51my Asian friends, and sadly I stopped playing basketball when I stopped seeing a
- 1:23:58lot of them because I didn't have any when els play basketball. Yeah,
- 1:24:01I played basketball throughout my childhood and beyond. My dad loved play basketball and
- 1:24:06he was really good. My grandfather, George Honda, was a star on
- 1:24:11the basketball team on a white basketball team, so he was he was the
- 1:24:15only non white person and he was one of the star players. So yeah,
- 1:24:20it's I would regularly play with all those guys. I don't know what
- 1:24:27it is. I mean, I think part of it is that any you
- 1:24:30know, being good at a sport, it doesn't matter what race you are.
- 1:24:34So if you're being pushed down in other areas, one of the areas
- 1:24:39that it's a level playing field is sports. Yeah, and so I think
- 1:24:43that's one element that will motivate people to put the effort into becoming better.
- 1:24:49But I also just wonder if I don't know, like this is it sounds
- 1:24:53stupid coming out of my face, but Asians, I think, on average
- 1:24:58can be pretty coordinated when I want to be, and basketball requires a lot
- 1:25:02of coordination. And maybe also Asian Americans tend to be smaller and slighter on
- 1:25:10average, of course, and of the sports. Ironically, for basketball,
- 1:25:15especially if you're not playing like college or NBA, you don't being short isn't
- 1:25:19necessarily that much of a hindrance, you know, if you're fast and you
- 1:25:23can pass well and shoot well, right, because if you're playing in a
- 1:25:27tournament or on the playground or even you know, in high school sometimes the
- 1:25:31tallest guy is probably six two or something. So if you're five five or
- 1:25:36five eight east, you know you're in the you're in the mix. But
- 1:25:42once you get to the upper levels, you have to be a lot bigger,
- 1:25:45a lot taller to compete. Well. There's also a convenience factor,
- 1:25:49like I mean, it's so much easier to play basketball than a lot of
- 1:25:53other sports in terms of the going out and doing it. Like we're like,
- 1:25:57hey, let's go play some football. Like that's a big production,
- 1:26:00right. One thing, you're just throwing the ball. But if we're gonna
- 1:26:02go play baseball. This, yeah, this is why soccer is the is
- 1:26:05the world sport because yeah, yeah, you just you and you don't even
- 1:26:10know the ground, right, and two sticks that represent the goal. So
- 1:26:15uh yeah, yeah. I wonder I'd love to hear from the listeners what
- 1:26:19theories you might have as to why Asian Americans take to basketball so much,
- 1:26:25because you know, it's a big deal among Asian Americans. Um, not
- 1:26:29all. Okay, let's take a break and when we get back more beef.
- 1:26:35Okay, we're back from the break. Also, let's see other things
- 1:26:41in the micro aggressions. They were there, but they weren't super cartoony.
- 1:26:45When the worker for Amy says a Japanese phrase, uh, you could absolutely
- 1:26:51see and she was trying to impress Amy. You know, she's trying to
- 1:26:55suck up to her, And it would be very common for a white person
- 1:27:00to think that a Japanese phrase would go over well with a Chinese Vietnam's wife.
- 1:27:05I wonder if she also got confused because she has a relationship with George
- 1:27:09and so maybe she just doesn't know She's like, she must also be Japanese,
- 1:27:14right, Yeah, so that is a you could absolutely see a white
- 1:27:19American in twenty twenty three, making that mistake today because when microaggressions are depicted
- 1:27:27in movies and TVs TV shows, a lot of times they're really cartoonish,
- 1:27:31you know, like even white audience members will say, whoa, that's crossing
- 1:27:35a line, you know, whereas that one, it's a little bit more
- 1:27:38subtle, like there's a possibility that people watching the show didn't even necessarily know
- 1:27:44what was happening in that scene, right because Amy's character is like, oh,
- 1:27:48yeah, oh, that's true, because it's not like you might not
- 1:27:53even recognize it was Japanese, and then you might not recognize she isn't well
- 1:27:56she says, She's like, oh, isn't that such and such a Japanese
- 1:28:00And then Amy's like oh, and Amy's polite, because that's what you do
- 1:28:03when you have a microaggression against you. You just sort of grin and Barrett
- 1:28:08and they just move on with the scene. It's not explicitly where Amy is
- 1:28:12like, well, you realize I'm Chinese and Vietnamese, right, Like,
- 1:28:15they don't spell it out, so it's a very and then Amy's boss the
- 1:28:19you know, the white woman. She also commits a few more egregious microggressions.
- 1:28:25Again, they don't keep doing it the whole show. So one of
- 1:28:29the complaints right now about a lot of the shows that Marvel has been putting
- 1:28:33out, or even movies where it features a lot of women superheroes, is
- 1:28:38that so many of the scenes are bashing men. And so it's like this
- 1:28:43balance of like, yes, we get it, men can be horrible pigs,
- 1:28:45not every man in every scene has to be a horrible pig. Well,
- 1:28:49and also, you know, this is a side tangent, and art
- 1:28:55is art, you know, if you like She Hulk whatever, but it's
- 1:28:58so pervasive the you know, when I was watching She Hulk, for example,
- 1:29:02I was I was like, okay, you know, I can this
- 1:29:06is interesting. It's it's the style is so different because you know, she's
- 1:29:10a lawyer and there's actual court scenes and and it's comedy and there's twerking and
- 1:29:16you know, so you know, I was on board, but I started
- 1:29:19feeling like it just didn't grab me, and then I and then I stopped
- 1:29:24watching about halfway through, just thinking, man, just I think there's other
- 1:29:27things. So then I watched some breakdowns on YouTube, and there's a lot
- 1:29:30of misogyny on YouTube, but the channels that weren't misogynistic. We're saying,
- 1:29:34let's look at different superhero stories. Let's look at success. You know,
- 1:29:40let's look at what makes the Hulk previous movies, or the Iron Man previous
- 1:29:45movies, or the ant Man previous movies. Okay, yeah, sure,
- 1:29:47these are white guys, but watch the same video I watch because let's let's
- 1:29:53actually analyze and what makes these shows emotionally satisfying. These characters start off very
- 1:30:00incompetent. Yea. They have terrible flaws. Yeah, they have a prop
- 1:30:04you know, Iron Man, he's selfish, he's narcissistic, he's self destructive,
- 1:30:10he's he has a panick story, he has trauma, he's screwing things
- 1:30:15up. But yes, in the end he prevails. So many of these
- 1:30:19women characters, they are writing with no flaws, without any They they transcend
- 1:30:28all adversity before the adversity even shows up. You know, she Hulk becomes
- 1:30:31a Hulk because blood gets on her. Fine, whatever, there's a lot
- 1:30:35of silliness, but that's fine. Spheroes weird, and she immediately has all
- 1:30:43that competence in the world and can control the Hulk aspect, whereas Banner it
- 1:30:47took him still, it took him fifteen years. He spent all of Ragnarok
- 1:30:54stuck in the Hulk mode. And and and when he didn't, you know,
- 1:30:59when he became Banner again, he's like what happened? And they're like,
- 1:31:02um, you've been Hulk for two or three years. Yeah, and
- 1:31:05Banner his psychology was all kind of messed up. And that's interesting, right.
- 1:31:11So this, this is the thing I was saying as well when we
- 1:31:14were starting this conversation, is those shows aren't just a good show with good
- 1:31:20character development. It's got a bit of a well, we gotta really make
- 1:31:26a statement here about how women can be awesome, right, And it's like,
- 1:31:30yeah, you can do that, but you don't have to have the
- 1:31:31whole show revolve around that statement and not and Sue like actual good character development.
- 1:31:38Only it's like, come on, this shows has amazing yah Asians acting
- 1:31:45as normal, awesome characters in great storyline. It's fucking condescending to women.
- 1:31:50Have we checked the box because now we got to go make other shows?
- 1:31:53Yeah, and treats women as fragile viewers. They're not fragile. They can
- 1:31:58take nuance they've been putting a push it for a long time. Give him
- 1:32:00a well rounded character, give him a character that has flaws, and sure
- 1:32:04you can absolutely sprinkle in gender and overcoming things, but you don't want to
- 1:32:10slap people across the face with it. One of my favorite shows and a
- 1:32:14few years back, was Homeland. You remember Homeland with Claire Danes. I
- 1:32:17mean I remember hearing about, oh my gosh, the first few season especially,
- 1:32:21such a good show. She was a protagonist. She was a mess
- 1:32:27dude. She had kind of sexual addiction, she had a lot of I
- 1:32:30forget it was if it was by Polish. She had some sort of issues
- 1:32:33that she had to take medicine. She was a mess, and she was
- 1:32:38the heroine, the star, and she was great. And she was also
- 1:32:42really smart but royally flawed and so good. Yeah, and it was a
- 1:32:45show with great character arcs, great plots, things with a great strong female
- 1:32:50lead who was very like interesting. So Amy's character, Ali Wong is a
- 1:32:57great character with adversity and flaws but relatable, has vulnerability. You want her
- 1:33:02to succeed. She has power, she makes mistakes, she gets what's coming
- 1:33:09true and in the end you could argue it's a happy ending, right,
- 1:33:12it's happening a glorious resolution, yes, yeah, because these two specially where
- 1:33:17things could have gone right, you know, these two souls finally found another
- 1:33:23one that understood their deal. Right. So the feminism of this script is
- 1:33:30women are humans too. Yeah, what a novel thought. Women can have
- 1:33:35all the regular, free dimensionality of life that anyone else can have, and
- 1:33:41we will depict that in all of its richness. We will not just make
- 1:33:45the you know anyway. Yeah. So the last couple of things that are
- 1:33:50Asian about the show that I was really happy to see is the aspect of
- 1:33:56having a sketchy cousin so in in my family. And a lot of Korean
- 1:34:02American families, a lot of Chinese American families, Vietnamese American fans, Filipino
- 1:34:06American families, a lot of us can point to the sketchy the sketchy cousin
- 1:34:13who's you know, very similar to the Isaac was the sketchy cousins where you
- 1:34:20know, he's not like a flat out gang member, but he you know,
- 1:34:25he has angles to things, He knows certain kinds of people, he
- 1:34:28can set you up. I certainly knew people through my Korean friends that were
- 1:34:33in the Isaac direction. Yeah. Right now, it should be pointed out
- 1:34:38that David Show, the actor who plays Isaac the Sketchy cousin, nine years
- 1:34:43ago on a podcast. So this is a big controversy. In fact,
- 1:34:45there was a lot of criticism that they even cast him in the in the
- 1:34:49TV show. I didn't know this. Yeah, he was on a podcast
- 1:34:54a number of years ago and he joked about sexually assaulting a massage therapist,
- 1:35:00forcing her to watch a masturbate, forcing her to hold his penis, and
- 1:35:05then we're seeing for forcing her to perform oral sex on him, you know,
- 1:35:10rape, he raped. He told a story on a podcast, joke
- 1:35:15or what. So there's a big backlash. Oh my gosh. The episode
- 1:35:20comes out and he later says it was a fictional story in which he was
- 1:35:26joking the whole time. You know, I don't know the whole story,
- 1:35:30but it was unfortunate that that sort of tainted the TV show a little bit.
- 1:35:35So you know, that should be pointing out. And the last very
- 1:35:39Asian thing was the slurping of the noodles and just slurping in general. I
- 1:35:45grew up Japanese American, you know, the Japanese American aspects of my even
- 1:35:49though I'm half There was a lot of Japanese American aspects of my family for
- 1:35:55various reasons, but one of which is I didn't realize. Isn't it impolite
- 1:36:00not to slurp the noodles? No, but it's definitely okay. Yeah,
- 1:36:03I thought there was something in Tempopo about it, like you gotta noodles?
- 1:36:08Well maybe I'm not, not that I've heard of. It's not like if
- 1:36:11you had someone that was being quiet that somehow you'd be like, how dare
- 1:36:15you or something. But it doesn't even register to me until I started hanging
- 1:36:19out with Stacey a lot, because I slurp everything. Okay, I slurped
- 1:36:24coffee, I slurped supe, you know, and she it would drive her
- 1:36:27crazy, and she realy is ironic because you're so particular about Yeah, lip
- 1:36:31sounds. I don't even like that. Uh. I don't even hear it
- 1:36:35when when it's when it's udon or or as you call it udon, when
- 1:36:41it's ramen or whatever. I don't even register it. And I never even
- 1:36:44noticed it until Stacy started pointing it out, and so I should call it
- 1:36:48udon, there's a there was a fair amount of slurping of noodles, which,
- 1:36:53yeah, when Stacy and I were watching, I'm like, see it's
- 1:36:56normal, Okay, Berto as usual, we're going way over time, So
- 1:37:00let's break this into two episodes. So let's end this part one, and
- 1:37:04when we return in a couple of days, we will talk about the rest
- 1:37:10of because I got a lot more to say, I got a lot of
- 1:37:12making me kind of rageful. I don't know, So tune in next time
- 1:37:15when we continue talking about beef and everyone out there, please take care of
- 1:37:19yourself because you deserve it.