Latest / Beyond the Ballot AZ / Let’s Talk Third Parties
Transcript
- 0:02Parties were never part of our founding documents in this country,
- 0:07right?
- 0:08They kind of inserted themselves in the election process over the years.
- 0:12And it has kind of worked as a check and balance system.
- 0:15Republicans checked the Democrats and Democrats checked the Republicans.
- 0:22You're listening to Beyond the Ballot AZ.
- 0:24I'm Tom Collins,
- 0:25Executive Director of the Arizona Clean Elections Commission.
- 0:28And I'm Gina Roberts,
- 0:29voter education director.
- 0:31For decades,
- 0:31candidates for public office have tried to run independent of political parties,
- 0:35and Americans have grappled with how to change the two-party system.
- 0:39There's been quite a bit of rumbling around this lately with Elon Musk declaring he was going to start a new party.
- 0:46Surveys show Americans continue to be interested in what Musk is getting at.
- 0:50We're here to give some context about the two-party system and what it takes to run on a third-party ticket,
- 0:56and where does the independent voter fit in?
- 1:02So we're here with
- 1:04Dr. Tom Riley,
- 1:05professor at ASU and co-director of the Center for an Independent and Sustainable Democracy,
- 1:11and the author of The Independent Voter.
- 1:14Dr.
- 1:14Riley,
- 1:15thanks for joining Beyond the Ballot AZ.
- 1:17Thanks for having me.
- 1:19Elon Musk recently attempted to start a conversation about a new national third party.
- 1:29Here in Arizona,
- 1:31how have third parties impacted our elections?
- 1:35Well,
- 1:36like the rest of the nation,
- 1:37they haven't been very successful.
- 1:38It's exceedingly hard,
- 1:40as you well know,
- 1:41to get on the ballot.
- 1:42So the third parties that have appeared,
- 1:45like
- 1:46Libertarians and Green Party,
- 1:48and most recently No Labels,
- 1:50have had their own challenges as far as getting on the ballot,
- 1:54but their numbers are fairly small at this point.
- 1:58So,
- 1:58you know,
- 1:59one of the things that,
- 2:00you know,
- 2:00some people have seen happen at the legislature,
- 2:03for example,
- 2:04is they've made it,
- 2:05I think,
- 2:06more difficult for folks to get on the ballot from those third parties than it might have been years ago.
- 2:11Those kinds of things,
- 2:12because the two parties see,
- 2:14at least in a general election,
- 2:16the third parties as kind of spoilers almost.
- 2:19Yeah,
- 2:20and that's been kind of the dominant view throughout the United States,
- 2:25that the two parties don't agree.
- 2:28upon a lot,
- 2:28but they definitely agree upon keeping third parties out.
- 2:33And,
- 2:33you know,
- 2:33we see this all the way at the top from the Federal Election Commission,
- 2:37where the Federal Election Commission is the only commission that is designed to deadlock with three
- 2:43Republicans and three Democrats.
- 2:45That has evolved over time.
- 2:47As you know,
- 2:48parties were never part of our founding documents in this country,
- 2:53right?
- 2:54They've kind of inserted themselves in the election process.
- 2:56So
- 2:57over the years.
- 2:58It has kind of worked as a check and balance system.
- 3:00The Republicans check the Democrats and the Democrats check the Republicans.
- 3:04So we see this not only at the federal level,
- 3:06but we see it all the way down to voting centers and where the canvassing takes place.
- 3:12And that worked well in majority people,
- 3:14Republican and Democrats.
- 3:16But now that we have the majority of individuals nationally and a sizable number in Arizona identifying themselves as independents,
- 3:24that check and balance system.
- 3:26doesn't work as well.
- 3:28So Dr.
- 3:28Riley,
- 3:28to that point,
- 3:29you know,
- 3:29here in Arizona,
- 3:31and just to clarify for our listeners,
- 3:33you're considered an independent voter,
- 3:35an unaffiliated voter,
- 3:36if you're not registered with one of the recognized parties here.
- 3:39And as you were stating,
- 3:40we've got a sizable amount of independent voters.
- 3:42They're,
- 3:43I think,
- 3:43the second highest when it comes to voter registration.
- 3:46So is there any appetite,
- 3:48or do you think Arizona could possibly move away from the two-party system?
- 3:52And what would that look like.
- 3:54That's a good question.
- 3:54And to your point,
- 3:55yeah,
- 3:56the people who are not part of the Republican
- 3:58Democratic Party is actually out edge,
- 4:01right?
- 4:01If you count the Libertarians,
- 4:02no labels,
- 4:03and Green Party,
- 4:04they actually edge out the Republican vote.
- 4:07And for a long period of time,
- 4:08independents have been this very strong voting bloc.
- 4:11But the question of whether they can get leverage as a third party,
- 4:16one is that it's just exceedingly difficult to corral people who identify
- 4:22other,
- 4:23right,
- 4:23or nonpartisan or independent into one ideology,
- 4:28right,
- 4:28because they kind of represent,
- 4:29you know,
- 4:30the whole entire spectrum.
- 4:31And although many people view it more as a bell curve,
- 4:34right,
- 4:34where,
- 4:35you know,
- 4:36more fall within the moderate,
- 4:38it also includes individuals who feel their parties are either not liberal or conservative enough.
- 4:44So trying to find that ideology of a third party is real challenging.
- 4:48I mean,
- 4:49most recently,
- 4:50Elon Musk is coming about the American first party.
- 4:53And the question is,
- 4:55what is their idea?
- 4:56What is the ideology?
- 4:57You know,
- 4:58how do you bring?
- 4:59a group of voters together that are so diverse,
- 5:03right?
- 5:03And so not only is the system set up to thwart third-party membership and to have them participate either as individual candidates,
- 5:14the threshold to get on the ballot is exceedingly high.
- 5:18The overall issue is really kind of hard as to what would a third party look like,
- 5:22right?
- 5:23What is that ideology that would draw large enough numbers together?
- 5:28So.
- 5:29Dr.
- 5:29Riley,
- 5:30just hearing all of this,
- 5:31and so the work that we do at Clean Elections,
- 5:33right,
- 5:33we're trying to connect with every voter,
- 5:35and we want to see participation,
- 5:37right,
- 5:37from every voter,
- 5:38regardless of their affiliation.
- 5:40This is a conundrum to me.
- 5:42So what I hear is we've got a very large amount of independent voters in the state,
- 5:49but we're not seeing high turnout from independent voters in the primary.
- 5:54And maybe you can shed some light on,
- 5:56are they turning out in general elections?
- 5:59What do we do here with the current system?
- 6:02Are independent voters voting?
- 6:04How do we get them to vote?
- 6:05Are candidates targeting independent voters,
- 6:08paying attention to them?
- 6:09Because it kind of seems like you need to.
- 6:11You would need that power of the independent vote,
- 6:12especially if you're running in a district that's not competitive.
- 6:15You hit upon the key issue.
- 6:17Our own research has shown,
- 6:19and I think this reflects in other states,
- 6:22is that independents underperform in the primary level,
- 6:26but in some cases overperform in the general election.
- 6:29I mean,
- 6:29if you looked at the last,
- 6:30you know,
- 6:31the Edison data that we looked at,
- 6:32which is about 23,000 exit polling in the United States,
- 6:36we did an analysis of that.
- 6:38And independents were about 33 percent of the vote of people who self-identified as independent,
- 6:44which is actually outpaced Democrats.
- 6:46So they were actually a large portion of the voting.
- 6:49If we look at just recently,
- 6:50Gallup just came out with their polling on the views of the president.
- 6:55And if you look at that polling,
- 6:56it's pretty telling is that.
- 6:59Almost all Republicans support
- 7:02Donald Trump.
- 7:02Now,
- 7:02he,
- 7:02you know,
- 7:03in the Gallup polling went from 95 to 89,
- 7:06and all Democrats oppose him,
- 7:07except for like two to 4%.
- 7:09The shifting in polling for Trump has been solely independence.
- 7:16You know,
- 7:16that is the group of individuals.
- 7:18Now,
- 7:19it's hard to identify independence because of the differing and varying laws for each state,
- 7:25right?
- 7:25Because,
- 7:26I mean,
- 7:27some states,
- 7:27you have to be part of the party.
- 7:29a major party to vote,
- 7:31right?
- 7:31So even if you would self-identify as independent,
- 7:33you have to register in order to participate.
- 7:37But even in states like Arizona,
- 7:38we've made some progress in the sense of we have semi-open that you can,
- 7:42as an independent,
- 7:43participate,
- 7:44except for the presidential,
- 7:46right,
- 7:47primaries,
- 7:48which is terribly confusing.
- 7:49I mean,
- 7:49I deal with young people a lot,
- 7:51you know,
- 7:51and part of the issue is how do we get young people to vote?
- 7:54And we know that voting is habit-forming,
- 7:56right?
- 7:56So if we could just get them to start voting.
- 7:59And then socialize with others,
- 8:00we see an increase.
- 8:01And as you age,
- 8:02you vote more.
- 8:03But when you talk to young people,
- 8:05the voting system isn't as easy as people say it is,
- 8:09right?
- 8:09And it is confusing.
- 8:11You throw in there that you're a nonpartisan independent,
- 8:13which by the way,
- 8:15over 50%
- 8:16of young Gen Z voters are not party affiliated and have no interest in joining the party.
- 8:21So we have the majority of young people are not party affiliated.
- 8:25They're not getting cues from the parties.
- 8:26But when they attempt to vote.
- 8:28it's confusing,
- 8:29particularly if they're a university student,
- 8:31they come from a different state,
- 8:32then you have to say,
- 8:33well,
- 8:33you actually have to go through another step.
- 8:35So we're going to put another barrier in to make it confusing that if you show up on election day,
- 8:41you can just request a ballot,
- 8:43but majority of people vote by mail.
- 8:45So that takes you to actually calling them,
- 8:47who do I call?
- 8:47When do I call to get a separate ballot?
- 8:51So because of that,
- 8:52we've seen less and less individuals participating in the primary level.
- 9:01We have more information for independent voters linked in the show notes.
- 9:05You can go to azcleanelections.gov,
- 9:07click on the Independent tab,
- 9:09which is listed under Election Security,
- 9:11to learn more about voting as an independent in Arizona.
- 9:14That's also linked in the show notes,
- 9:16along with links to some of the studies that Dr.
- 9:19Riley discussed.
- 9:21Well,
- 9:21that's it for today's Beyond the Ballot AZ.
- 9:23I'm Gina Roberts.
- 9:24And I'm Tom Collins.
- 9:25We'll see you next time.