Latest / Geoffrey Challen: Teaching and Technology / Time to Try Teaching
Transcript
- 0:00Geoffrey Challen: Hey everyone, my name is Geoff Challen, and I teach computing at the University of Illinois.
- 0:04Geoffrey Challen: I write about teaching and technology at geoffreychallen.com,
- 0:08Geoffrey Challen: where you can find a written version of the essay you're about to hear.
- 0:11Geoffrey Challen: What follows is the essay being read aloud, but not by me, by a clone of my voice.
- 0:16Geoffrey Challen: I hope you enjoy it.
- 0:17Geoffrey Challen: If you have any feedback, please don't hesitate to reach out to me directly.
- 0:21Geoffrey Challen: I'd love to hear from you.
- 0:22Geoffrey Challen: Time to Try Teaching, an essay by Geoffrey Challen, read aloud by Geoffrey Challen's voice clone.
- 0:29Geoffrey Challen: AI is an existential threat to current educational practices.
- 0:34Geoffrey Challen: Universities, long distracted by research, are unprepared to mount an educational response.
- 0:40Geoffrey Challen: I have seen the university from both sides of its mission.
- 0:44Geoffrey Challen: My first academic job was as a research-focused faculty member at the University at Buffalo.
- 0:49Geoffrey Challen: I was excited to begin teaching,
- 0:51Geoffrey Challen: which is why I remember so vividly being told to teach poorly for a few
- 0:55Geoffrey Challen: years and then show artificial improvement before applying for tenure.
- 0:59Geoffrey Challen: I failed at research, but succeeded as an educator,
- 1:02Geoffrey Challen: and continued in a teaching-focused role at the University of Illinois.
- 1:06Geoffrey Challen: There I have watched research count for more than teaching even when we hire and promote teaching faculty.
- 1:13Geoffrey Challen: Research has come before teaching at every university I have known.
- 1:17Geoffrey Challen: The focus on research begins as students arrive on campus.
- 1:21Geoffrey Challen: Undergraduates who have barely begun their studies are still encouraged to seek out research opportunities.
- 1:27Geoffrey Challen: Once they reach graduate school, budding academics learn to disdain teaching.
- 1:32Geoffrey Challen: Stronger students are funded to do research, and the rest are required to teach.
- 1:36Geoffrey Challen: Teaching must never get in the way of research, and the less time spent on it, the better.
- 1:41Geoffrey Challen: And they aren’t wrong to do this, because when they apply for academic jobs, their teaching is barely evaluated.
- 1:47Geoffrey Challen: Nor will it be meaningfully considered when they apply for tenure,
- 1:50Geoffrey Challen: or for promotion, or for positions in university leadership.
- 1:54Geoffrey Challen: The result is a university consumed by research.
- 1:58Geoffrey Challen: Once you start to look, the evidence is everywhere.
- 2:01Geoffrey Challen: Teaching-focused faculty are usually ineligible for tenure, poorly paid, and absent from meaningful leadership roles.
- 2:08Geoffrey Challen: Revenues generated by teaching are used to pay the salaries of faculty spending most of their time on research.
- 2:14Geoffrey Challen: Academic hallways and newsletters brim with reports about research
- 2:17Geoffrey Challen: accomplishments while rarely mentioning educational innovation.
- 2:21Geoffrey Challen: The list goes on.
- 2:23Geoffrey Challen: Universities claim that, by assembling the best researchers, they are also assembling the best educators.
- 2:30Geoffrey Challen: But study after study has shown that there is no relationship between research and teaching ability.
- 2:35Geoffrey Challen: There are only so many hours in the week.
- 2:38Geoffrey Challen: The more time faculty spend on their research, the less they spend on their teaching.
- 2:43Geoffrey Challen: The retreat from teaching is part of a larger retreat from the university’s intellectual community.
- 2:49Geoffrey Challen: Research-focused faculty frequently show little interest in undergraduates, or in colleagues outside their own field.
- 2:56Geoffrey Challen: Students have noticed.
- 2:57Geoffrey Challen: At Harvard, a faculty committee found that students skip class and still collect high grades,
- 3:03Geoffrey Challen: because they find their clubs and projects more meaningful than their courses.
- 3:07Geoffrey Challen: If faculty contribute so little humanity to our students’ education, maybe we deserve to be replaced by AI.
- 3:15Geoffrey Challen: The arrival of AI has made plain how little attention universities have been paying to instruction.
- 3:21Geoffrey Challen: I am watching AI agents take on remarkable roles in supporting student learning in my classrooms.
- 3:27Geoffrey Challen: It’s clear to me that, used properly, AI has a positive role to play in higher education.
- 3:32Geoffrey Challen: It’s equally clear to me that, at present, it undercuts our already poorly supported educational mission.
- 3:40Geoffrey Challen: Successfully incorporating AI will require a coordinated institutional effort.
- 3:45Geoffrey Challen: To meet this challenge we need new and revised assignments, courses, degrees, and departments.
- 3:51Geoffrey Challen: This is work that universities should be prepared for.
- 3:54Geoffrey Challen: But it is educational work, the kind that research-focused institutions have been avoiding and diminishing for decades.
- 4:01Geoffrey Challen: AI’s threat to higher education is real today, and so is its promise.
- 4:06Geoffrey Challen: So there’s no excuse for delay.
- 4:09Geoffrey Challen: And yet, most of what you see universities doing now is stalling.
- 4:13Geoffrey Challen: Pleas for students to promise not to use AI in their courses.
- 4:17Geoffrey Challen: Committees assembled to study the issue and generate reports.
- 4:21Geoffrey Challen: Light modifications to existing programs marketed as AI preparation.
- 4:26Geoffrey Challen: At a moment when we need all university faculty working together to update our educational practices,
- 4:32Geoffrey Challen: most are too focused on their research to participate.
- 4:35Geoffrey Challen: While reports like the recently released one from MIT are full of
- 4:39Geoffrey Challen: good starting points for universities attempting to incorporate AI,
- 4:43Geoffrey Challen: they never ask whether anyone on campus has the time, the skill,
- 4:47Geoffrey Challen: or the incentive to do the work, in the classroom or out of it.
- 4:52Geoffrey Challen: Universities have rewarded today’s faculty for minimizing teaching for their entire careers.
- 4:58Geoffrey Challen: Perhaps they will suddenly have a change of heart, particularly given this year’s federal research cuts.
- 5:03Geoffrey Challen: Research-focused faculty are belatedly discovering that it is teaching that keeps the paychecks coming.
- 5:09Geoffrey Challen: But I worry that many universities are simply full of the wrong people for this job.
- 5:15Geoffrey Challen: In the short term, universities can do everything possible to reward the educational work required to respond to AI.
- 5:22Geoffrey Challen: Research-focused faculty have long been able to receive
- 5:25Geoffrey Challen: research funding over the summer when classes are not in session.
- 5:29Geoffrey Challen: Funding educational innovation during those same months would help keep pace with this fast-moving technology.
- 5:35Geoffrey Challen: Recognition for this work is cheaper still, and nearly as effective.
- 5:39Geoffrey Challen: In the long term, universities need to align their internal incentives with their public mission:
- 5:45Geoffrey Challen: a balanced commitment to research and education.
- 5:48Geoffrey Challen: That could take many forms.
- 5:50Geoffrey Challen: Hiring teaching-focused faculty with equivalent pay and job
- 5:53Geoffrey Challen: security to their research-focused colleagues is a good start.
- 5:56Geoffrey Challen: The University of California system and several Canadian and Australian universities already have such roles,
- 6:02Geoffrey Challen: although not enough of them to counterbalance their research-focused faculty.
- 6:06Geoffrey Challen: Finding good teaching-focused academics is difficult, given how early academics learn to look down on it.
- 6:12Geoffrey Challen: Putting teaching and research on a more equal footing would require changes to
- 6:16Geoffrey Challen: undergraduate and graduate education as well as faculty hiring and promotion.
- 6:21Geoffrey Challen: A new focus on education is unlikely to emerge from institutions fixated on research.
- 6:26Geoffrey Challen: Change is more likely to come from the people paying for it.
- 6:30Geoffrey Challen: Today, if you’re looking for a university education,
- 6:33Geoffrey Challen: you’ll need to ask some uncomfortable questions during the information session.
- 6:37Geoffrey Challen: How many teaching faculty are there, and how are they treated?
- 6:40Geoffrey Challen: How much contact will my child have with faculty outside the classroom?
- 6:45Geoffrey Challen: Does the university evaluate whether students are learning, not just whether they liked the class?
- 6:50Geoffrey Challen: How is teaching quality evaluated when faculty are hired and promoted?
- 6:54Geoffrey Challen: Has anyone been denied tenure due to poor teaching?
- 6:57Geoffrey Challen: Are there teaching faculty who hold meaningful leadership roles at the campus level?
- 7:01Geoffrey Challen: No university I know of has the balance right, but the answers will identify the ones that are trying.
- 7:08Geoffrey Challen: Families pay enormous sums to send their children to university in the hope that they will be educated.
- 7:14Geoffrey Challen: But few seem informed about the realities on campus.
- 7:17Geoffrey Challen: As Ian Bogost pointed out recently in the Atlantic,
- 7:20Geoffrey Challen: most still approach university faculty with the question: “What do you teach?”
- 7:25Geoffrey Challen: Perhaps the parents would stop writing the large checks if they realized that,
- 7:29Geoffrey Challen: for many faculty, the answer is: “I’d prefer not to.”
- 7:33Geoffrey Challen: This is real Geoff again.
- 7:34Geoffrey Challen: Thanks for listening.
- 7:36Geoffrey Challen: You'll find more essays at geoffreychallen.com, and you can subscribe to the podcast wherever you're listening now.
- 7:42Geoffrey Challen: Until next time.
- 7:42Geoffrey Challen: Keep teaching with technology.