Latest / No Way Out / Deception Detection Doesn't Work: Credibility Assessment & the Real OODA Loop | Kent Clizbe
Transcript
- 0:00Kent Clizbe: So that that was the first question.
- 0:01Kent Clizbe: What's your job?
- 0:01Kent Clizbe: And the guy said, Well, I I'm a quality control engineer in a moped factory.
- 0:07Kent Clizbe: He he would he had been his his his recruitment was based on him being an engineer in a WMD industry.
- 0:16Kent Clizbe: Turns out that his country had closed that industry a year before he was recruited.
- 0:22Kent Clizbe: He had at one time worked in that industry, but they closed it.
- 0:26Kent Clizbe: And he had been working in a moped factory the whole time he was providing high-level top secret reports on the WMD industry.
- 0:37Kent Clizbe: Next question: Have you ever uh worked for a foreign intelligence service?
- 0:42Kent Clizbe: He goes, Yeah, I'm working for the Cubans too.
- 0:46Kent Clizbe: And in fact, my dad worked for the Cubans, and my you know, we we go to Cuba together a couple times a year uh to report to them.
- 0:55Kent Clizbe: And and there's a couple of of other issues, but those two, it's like it's over right there.
- 1:02Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:03Kent Clizbe: And and the the the interviewer asked him, well, why didn't you tell your case officer this?
- 1:10Kent Clizbe: He said, She never has.
- 1:18John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 1:19John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, and there is no way out.
- 1:22John R. Boyd: What we can eliminate the feature just by it.
- 1:25John R. Boyd: Well, we don't have to do it.
- 1:27John R. Boyd: We want to get a max interactive and a situation to do it.
- 1:32John R. Boyd: We have a mismatch against both, right?
- 1:34John R. Boyd: There is no way out.
- 1:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right, we're talking about deception detection today with Kent Clisby.
- 1:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I recently watched a couple of his uh previous episodes with I believe it's uh Elwood on another uh podcast, and there's a reason I did that.
- 1:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not gonna go into exactly why I came across him, but I do want to share something uh at the moment.
- 1:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Years ago, I was in an industry that you can say was uh very deceptive.
- 1:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It was called the agile industry, and and I know I'm gonna get a lot of hate mail on that, but let me be clear about it.
- 2:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's a lot of pseudoscience in there, and we'll talk about that, I'm sure, today.
- 2:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I saw this uh shared around the internet, and everybody was celebrating it's it's Elizabeth Holmes, it's an image here of her sitting in a chair saying, the minute you have a backup plan, you've admitted you're not going to succeed.
- 2:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I saw this, and I'm like, there's something wrong with this person.
- 2:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And this is before we found out uh the awful things that she did.
- 2:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, and I believe she's uh spending time in jail now.
- 2:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, what's fascinating about this, she convinced people like George Schultz, General Mattis, Admiral Ruffhead to be on her board.
- 2:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what's interesting about that is I don't think any of these guys have any backgrounds in biotechnology or anything like that.
- 2:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So they're they're they're great experts in their domain of war fighting and things like that, but they get pulled into this world that we end up uh seeing as a fraud.
- 2:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then uh you fast forward a few years, you get into Sam Bankman-Fried, uh, that over the last several years, Bernie Mate, uh, but Bernie Madoff, and then you get into somebody that I just recently became aware of, and that was Wayne Simmons.
- 3:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, the reason I reached out to Kent, the reason I reached out to Kent is is this is I was vetting a potential guest for New Way Out, and I couldn't find basic information on them, their background, the military background.
- 3:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I imagine Kent knows who I'm talking about.
- 3:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and my Spidey senses went up.
- 3:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I believe the person lives here in Virginia Beach, or at least Norfolk or Virginia, or did at one point.
- 3:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I kept searching and I just couldn't find anything that validated their claims.
- 3:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And this person has been on massive podcasts.
- 3:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So anyway, I came across Kent's work.
- 3:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, I asked him to come on the show.
- 3:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, he is an Air Force guy, he's a Zoomy.
- 3:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that right?
- 3:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, that was a long time ago, but yep, I was.
- 3:49Kent Clizbe: I did five years in the Air Force.
- 3:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and then you did some time in the uh in the CIA.
- 3:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So welcome to the show, Kent.
- 3:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How are you doing today, man?
- 3:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks, Punch.
- 3:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Great, appreciate it.
- 3:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh fascinating connection here.
- 3:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we'll get into uh holistic contextual credibility assessment.
- 4:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I think there's great overlap with things that we're learning from ecological dynamics, understanding the context, understanding that context drives a lot of things, understanding that orientation determines what we sense, how we perceive, how we decide, how we act, how we adapt, how we learn.
- 4:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And of course, the connection to John Boyd's work as well.
- 4:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we may not dive into that so much because we have a great expert with us today to talk about his work.
- 4:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh, Kent, can you give us some background on how you got into deception detection?
- 4:32Kent Clizbe: Sure.
- 4:33Kent Clizbe: Uh well, I I'm a practitioner.
- 4:35Kent Clizbe: I'm not an I'm not an academic.
- 4:36Kent Clizbe: Uh everything I know, I learned either the the the foundation was in training, and then the vast majority is in actually doing jobs where where credibility assessment was a major part of being successful in in that specific job.
- 4:58Kent Clizbe: Those I s I started out well, I give you a l a real quick, real quick uh background in my bio is it's it's really important when we talk about context, is I developed uh contextual expertise, beginning with flunking out a out of college and and being uh kind of scumbag on the streets.
- 5:19Kent Clizbe: Not you know, not not major, but I was just kind of loser working in a factory job, drinking, smoking dope, just you know, partying.
- 5:29Kent Clizbe: I I was I I I went to the number one party school in the United States the the year that I that was a freshman, East Carolina University.
- 5:36Kent Clizbe: So I lasted uh really a semester.
- 5:39Kent Clizbe: After the first semester, I didn't go to classes.
- 5:41Kent Clizbe: Just it was just a great time.
- 5:44Kent Clizbe: But I was I was involved in things and on the street and and dealing with people that was a great foundation for later um, you know, I I I understand sort of the darker side of life.
- 6:00Kent Clizbe: Uh luckily two years into that that life, uh, I realized I can do better than this.
- 6:06Kent Clizbe: I I was uh d just wasting my life.
- 6:09Kent Clizbe: So I went down to the to the Air Force recruiter and got in.
- 6:13Kent Clizbe: They accepted me.
- 6:15Kent Clizbe: Ended up becoming a uh they sent me to to uh Monterey, the um uh Defense Language Institute.
- 6:21Kent Clizbe: I w I went to school and became a Vietnamese linguist.
- 6:25Kent Clizbe: Same that that required a security clearance.
- 6:28Kent Clizbe: I was able to get the security clearance, uh, got into Intel.
- 6:32Kent Clizbe: So I did I I I I wore headphones like this for three years straight, sitting in the Philippines listening to Vietnamese communists.
- 6:42Kent Clizbe: Listening to their Air Force mostly.
- 6:46Kent Clizbe: Uh so that that was an introduction to my my introduction to Intel, to foreign cultures, foreign foreign affairs, uh opened up a huge interest and and a love that I realized, wow, you know, I I I never knew I I had any aptitude for foreign languages, but uh the military is great for for identifying aptitudes.
- 7:11Kent Clizbe: They have aptitude tests and everything and in basic training.
- 7:14Kent Clizbe: I I went in I I I uh enlisted with no guaranteed job.
- 7:18Kent Clizbe: I went to basic not knowing what I was gonna be.
- 7:20Kent Clizbe: Wow.
- 7:21Kent Clizbe: And in basic, uh like the second week or sometime, they sent they just pull pull me out, pull, you know, handful of guys out of whatever training we were in, and we we go to a lab and they said, You okay, you're gonna take this this test.
- 7:35Kent Clizbe: I think it was called D Lab.
- 7:36Kent Clizbe: It's an aptitude test for languages.
- 7:39Kent Clizbe: So I took this test and aced it, and that's how I ended up uh becoming a linguist.
- 7:45Kent Clizbe: So now I realize I've got this aptitude for languages.
- 7:49Kent Clizbe: I I loved being immersed in in Monterey, California at the time was a huge, a huge community of Vietnamese refugees.
- 7:58Kent Clizbe: So I I got involved with them, loved the culture, loved learning a new culture, ended up in the Philippines for three years.
- 8:07Kent Clizbe: I got immersed in that culture, and I realized, wow, this is you know, I'm I'm good at this.
- 8:11Kent Clizbe: I'm I I picked up the language there, and I then I had to stop and say, Well, I also found out I'm I'm a really bad bureaucrat, and I'm not a good uh I I did not become militarized.
- 8:23Kent Clizbe: I was just a dude doing my job, and the Air Force is probably the the perfect the perfect branch to to be like that.
- 8:31Kent Clizbe: Uh so I could do my job, go in, go into the office and and go home.
- 8:35Kent Clizbe: So I started planning what am I gonna do when I when I get out, because I'm gonna get out at the end of this five years.
- 8:42Kent Clizbe: So I I uh ended up getting going back to school, got a degree in linguistics, and became English as a second language.
- 8:51Kent Clizbe: At the time was a in-demand skill.
- 8:55Kent Clizbe: So I became tea I became a teacher of English as a second language, with my goal, my goal was to go back to Southeast Asia.
- 9:02Kent Clizbe: So there's at the time there's a lot of refugee camps throughout Southeast Asia that used these kind of uh the ESL English as a second language teachers.
- 9:12Kent Clizbe: So I ended up going back to the Philippines as uh working as a civilian, uh working uh in Bataan, Bataan Americans call it.
- 9:21Kent Clizbe: There's a huge refugee camp there.
- 9:23Kent Clizbe: So I was I was a supervisor supervising a team of 15 Filipino teachers teaching Indochinese refugees, Lao, Cambodian, Chinese, uh and Vietnamese, teaching English and culture.
- 9:39Kent Clizbe: Uh we had a culture orientation and a work orientation program.
- 9:43Kent Clizbe: I I also while I was at school, I I I married my my wife who's from Malaysia, so I got immersed in that culture.
- 9:52Kent Clizbe: I s I was traveling to Malaysia every six weeks from the Philippines.
- 9:56Kent Clizbe: Got immersed in the the Malaysian Malay, which is Malaysian culture is a mix of Malay, Chinese, and Indian.
- 10:04Kent Clizbe: Got immersed in that, learned the language, and then I I got my my wife and I were living apart.
- 10:11Kent Clizbe: She was in in Kuala Lumpur and I was in Bataan, and that that that didn't work very well.
- 10:17Kent Clizbe: So I got us jobs working in Saudi for the Saudi government, teaching English in a in in a uh the King Saud University in the middle of the desert, uh in the middle of Wahhabi land.
- 10:30Kent Clizbe: Uh I was the only westerner in in the province uh that I I I ran across one other guy, a German guy who was passing through doing doing air conditioning repair or something, but I was the only westerner that I knew of in the year I was there.
- 10:47Kent Clizbe: After that, they they offered us to extend it.
- 10:49Kent Clizbe: I I laughed at them.
- 10:50Kent Clizbe: It was a it was an interesting experience, but I did not want to stay there another year.
- 10:55Kent Clizbe: So I ended up going to working for a British company in the UK, and then they sent me to Italy doing language consulting.
- 11:03Kent Clizbe: Only then, after after my wife got pregnant, and we were traveling the world, uh, you know, having a lot of fun, but the I I had no health, no health insurance, so I had to figure out a way to get health insurance.
- 11:15Kent Clizbe: So came back to the States, did grad school, uh, ended up doing three different grad programs linguistics, uh, MBA, and instructional design, and ended up at the end of that, got a job with the CIA.
- 11:29Kent Clizbe: Nice.
- 11:30Kent Clizbe: With with that with that background that uh it it's it's now once I started working with the CIAA, I realized that you know this is a great background.
- 11:38Kent Clizbe: Yes, it is, but but it's extremely unusual.
- 11:42Kent Clizbe: Uh the and most people in the agency fit that they hire fit a very uh a template of uh a profile.
- 11:51Kent Clizbe: And when when I look at my background and once I ended up doing the job, it's it was excellent preparation and the profile, the standard profile that they hire, that they use to hire is not really a good background.
- 12:06Kent Clizbe: It was, it would have been 50 or 60 or 75 years ago, in maybe in the 40s and the 50s, hiring a a kid from a fraternity who uh went to you know, he he went to one of the prep schools and then he went to Stanford or or Princeton and you know had had connect high-level society connections.
- 12:29Kent Clizbe: And then they back then their job was doing a lot in that kind of environment.
- 12:34Kent Clizbe: And that, you know, go go to France and go to cocktail parties with uh people like you.
- 12:41Kent Clizbe: That ain't that that is not what the agency does now or when I was in.
- 12:47Kent Clizbe: I I went in in the mid-90s.
- 12:49Speaker 4: Okay.
- 12:50Kent Clizbe: And I realized, man, this is this is I I've got a real real advantage here.
- 12:56Kent Clizbe: I've been ripped off, I've I've I've lived on, I've worked on the strength on the streets, I've seen bad stuff happen, I've I've run from the cops, I've been caught by the cops, I've I've done all kinds of things that when you're a case officer, that's what you're doing.
- 13:13Kent Clizbe: You're doing illegal stuff.
- 13:15Kent Clizbe: But with that background, getting back to credibility assessment, what that background also gave me the uh the experience and context, cultural, social, linguistic, subcultural, to be able to I I I could and can talk to anybody from any background and pretty quickly find some commonality as well as I can understand where they're coming from because I've been involved in so many different contexts.
- 13:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm a little curious.
- 13:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I've got a question here about your apt, you know, you brought up D Lab uh and DLI.
- 13:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So just you you know, I went to a party school.
- 13:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We didn't have the E in front, we just had CUs to Colorado uh and then joined the Navy from there.
- 14:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh but and one of the things that happened in my career is at 12 years of service, I got selected to be a foreign area officer.
- 14:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So everything you're talking about, going to DLI, D Lab, and all that resonates with me.
- 14:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: My question to you is what was it in your past, or what do you know from your past or or anybody's past that increases that aptitude for learning languages?
- 14:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What was it?
- 14:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think it's natural.
- 14:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Music?
- 14:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What was it?
- 14:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What'd you do when you were children?
- 14:25Kent Clizbe: I think no, I think it's a skill, it it is a an inherent skill.
- 14:29Kent Clizbe: It's you either have it or you don't.
- 14:31Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 14:32Kent Clizbe: Maybe yeah, I don't know.
- 14:35Kent Clizbe: I I was I I I was not a good student in high school.
- 14:40Kent Clizbe: I flunked out of college.
- 14:42Kent Clizbe: I read a lot.
- 14:43Kent Clizbe: You know, I I'm I'm a I'm a self-taught.
- 14:46Kent Clizbe: I'm self-taught in almost everything that that I've that I've done.
- 14:50Kent Clizbe: So on my own, I read a lot.
- 14:54Kent Clizbe: I was interested in literature, I was interested in in history.
- 15:00Kent Clizbe: But when I was a kid, I I I for five years I lived in Puerto Rico, so I was exposed to Spanish.
- 15:08Kent Clizbe: I learned excuse me, I learned a little bit of Spanish then, took Spanish in high school, you know, three, four years, whatever, which is pretty much useless.
- 15:18Kent Clizbe: So I I did not div I I I I didn't study to have that aptitude.
- 15:25Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 15:25Kent Clizbe: I I took the D Lab totally cold and you know, it made sense to me.
- 15:30Kent Clizbe: All of these they they use like a a nonsense language, and you know, you you see the patterns or figure it out.
- 15:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Like my background was in music when I was a kid, and that's why they think or I think I was able to decode some of that stuff in the uh D Lab.
- 15:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Interesting.
- 15:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um but I'm just wondering, so there's something that I don't know what it is.
- 15:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know if we're gonna identify it here.
- 15:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's something in your past that that allowed you to do that uh nature and nurture.
- 15:54Kent Clizbe: I really think it's inherent.
- 15:55Kent Clizbe: When you say you're into music, you I I think that's inherent in inherent too.
- 16:00Kent Clizbe: It's a talent you have.
- 16:02Kent Clizbe: I have zero ability with music.
- 16:05Kent Clizbe: You know, and I've I've tried, but I have I can't hear, I I I don't get it.
- 16:10Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 16:11Kent Clizbe: It's just, you know, inherent in my in my thinking, in my brain is I do not get music.
- 16:17Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 16:18Kent Clizbe: I mean, I love music, but I have no idea how to make it.
- 16:21Kent Clizbe: Or when you start talking about musical uh concepts, I don't get it.
- 16:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So maybe it's just the exposure to people too.
- 16:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh that that's something else in your your your early experiences there.
- 16:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I I'd have to say there's street smarts involved with that.
- 16:35Kent Clizbe: Because that's the only thing, the only skill that I had developed by that time was Street Smarts.
- 16:39Kent Clizbe: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 16:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 16:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that that to me is is a lot.
- 16:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you know, growing up uh in Colorado, I'm not going to get into that too much, but I was I was exposed to you know, I was my family's on government cheese.
- 16:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, I got I had to figure out how to go to college.
- 16:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I was first generation, all these things.
- 16:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a different uh, I guess, dossier or or or uh profile than somebody who goes to Yale or Stanford and you end up serving with them in the in the military.
- 17:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You could see a difference right away, right?
- 17:03Kent Clizbe: Huge and so so to bring it back to cred credibility assessment is so in in the agency, everything you do is based on your assessment of the credibility, uh, of the credibility of your targets, of the people that you're meeting.
- 17:18Kent Clizbe: So the job of a of a CIA ops officer or case officer is to spot, assess, develop, recruit, and run foreign human sources of foreign intelligence.
- 17:32Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 17:33Kent Clizbe: You're the only the only one meeting that that source or potential source.
- 17:39Kent Clizbe: It's one-on-one that you are you you don't have somebody, you know, you're not meeting in a team.
- 17:46Kent Clizbe: Generally speaking, there there's always exceptions that prove the rule, but generally speaking, you are one-on-one with another human being, yeah, and you've got to determine is is this guy blowing smoke up your butt?
- 18:00Kent Clizbe: Or is he who he says he is, what he says he is?
- 18:04Kent Clizbe: Can he do what he says he can?
- 18:06Kent Clizbe: Does he have access to what what you think he does or what he says he does?
- 18:11Kent Clizbe: And you've got to do a credibility assessment and with without a deeper contextual background, including street smarts, the abil the ha having been ripped off, knowing that people will lie to you, knowing how they lie to you, as well as specific cultural whatever culture you're working in, uh whatever the profession that your target is in, uh, whatever the subculture they're in, if you're not at least aware of all that context, you're you're totally lost.
- 18:51Kent Clizbe: You know, you're you you end up assuming a lot and making guesses and um and and then so so so then if you don't have the the the contextual competence with in in the um the the the the environment that you're working in against the person that you're uh in if you don't have competence that matches your target, you end up and what happens in in American intelligence bureaucracy is they they fall back on and rely on what they they they think are technical uh solutions, yeah.
- 19:35Kent Clizbe: That is body-based measurements of human uh of the human body.
- 19:43Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 19:43Kent Clizbe: And they tried they they claim they can use that to determine if someone is truthful or not.
- 19:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 19:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's breaking down the the system, and uh analyzing it by little pieces.
- 19:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think I know where you're going with this.
- 19:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and I you know, I read a book years ago by Malcolm Gladwell called Blink, and I was like, wow, that's how everything works.
- 20:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What we know from complex adaptive systems thinking or complexity thinking is you can't decompose a complex adaptive system to its constituent parts, right?
- 20:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's that's fantastic about this is uh uh y you go back to 9-11 and and uh what TSA did and Homeland Security did, and maybe you could talk more about that, but they start breaking things down and saying this is how it works, and we're watching TV shows called was it lie to me back in the day?
- 20:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, and I'm like, ah, this is awesome.
- 20:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I I didn't know back then what I know now, and I'm not not I'm I'm a student just like you, I'm not an expert in I don't I don't claim to be an expert in a lot of things anyway.
- 20:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I I can see the connection between um an engineering approach of trying to break human behavior down into little bits and pieces, and a contextualized approach, which is understanding the context, the environment, everything around them, and that's what we're trying to express on this show is it's a it's a agent or performer engaging with an environment that matters, and that culture, that experience, uh the genetics even matter and all this.
- 21:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we have to look at the whole package.
- 21:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Holistic.
- 21:05Kent Clizbe: That's the the other the other uh buzzword here is holistic.
- 21:09Kent Clizbe: And I have to say contextual.
- 21:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and and I have to I have to say this uh just to be clear, and that is uh you know, I had a family member that lost $200,000 in a in a crypto scam uh scam recently, right?
- 21:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just just yesterday, I was on a phone call, I took a phone call in what seemed to be a very articulate human being, and I quickly realized I was talking to an AI, right?
- 21:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, man, this thing doesn't say uz or ease, or you know, it doesn't pause or hesitate, it's just smooth.
- 21:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And had an answer for everything.
- 21:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, man, this is amazing.
- 21:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So detection, deception detection is absolutely critical in what we do.
- 21:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'll be honest with you, uh veterans, and I I don't know how you're gonna feel about this statement, just because somebody served in the military doesn't make them really credible.
- 21:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 21:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you're very articulate and you served in the military, man, you have a very high likely.
- 21:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That uh you can go out and sell uh snake oil to anybody, right?
- 22:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because one, you have the service, and two, you sound smart.
- 22:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But generally, those are the people that you gotta watch out for, and that I gotta watch out for as a as a military veteran.
- 22:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh that's a lot to share with you, but uh can you build on that?
- 22:16Kent Clizbe: Yeah, yeah, sure.
- 22:17Kent Clizbe: Uh so so I I I I think what you're getting at is I I I want to caveat your the thing about veterans is most veterans do not use their experience and and they're pretty much incapable of using their experience uh to to hoodwink other people.
- 22:35Kent Clizbe: Uh uh what what I found with veterans is that they become so much of part of this little subculture that they can only talk to other veterans.
- 22:44Kent Clizbe: And you know, that's it's uh it's a whole attitude, it's a lingo, it's that just and nobody else understands them.
- 22:52Kent Clizbe: However, there's another subset that's realized that that they can take advantage of those people who come up to you and say, Oh, thanks for your service.
- 23:02Kent Clizbe: And you know, they they that becomes an opening for these, and and they're they're con men.
- 23:08Kent Clizbe: They're they're uh con men, and many of them are fake.
- 23:12Kent Clizbe: You know, it's the stolen valor thing.
- 23:14Kent Clizbe: Many of them that realize that that the the veteran status can be used to con other people are are not actual veterans, or they mischaracterize their their actual experience.
- 23:27Kent Clizbe: So yeah, yeah, I'm I'm with you there.
- 23:29Kent Clizbe: Um no, thank you for that.
- 23:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because because I I'll say this, uh you know, on one of your recent episodes or podcast, you brought up uh uh psychedelics and then the psychedelic assistant therapy community, which you know I'm a huge proponent and supporter of.
- 23:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I will tell you right now, there are evildoers that are veterans in that space.
- 23:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They have big egos, they're out there collect trying to make money, starting 501c3s and all that stuff.
- 23:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They sound awesome, but they're full of shit.
- 23:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 23:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I know this because I I I know who they are and they know I know who they are.
- 24:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm I'm throwing it out there.
- 24:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's dangerous.
- 24:02Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 24:03Kent Clizbe: So you you talked around it a minute ago about the guy that you're vetting.
- 24:08Kent Clizbe: It's the guy's name is Chase Hughes, and you mentioned the the uh the work that I've done with Zach Elwood in vetting Chase Hughes.
- 24:17Kent Clizbe: Uh he's a perfect example.
- 24:19Kent Clizbe: He actually served in the military.
- 24:21Kent Clizbe: Uh Zach foyed his his DD two fourteen.
- 24:25Kent Clizbe: He was a quartermaster.
- 24:27Kent Clizbe: Let me uh so I'm I'm not really up on Navy Navy terminology.
- 24:31Kent Clizbe: I may be I may be misremembering, but I want to say I know that his job was the job that he did, and I'm pretty sure the name is quartermaster, is like a navigation uh the navigator's assistant, sort of.
- 24:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 24:45Kent Clizbe: Is that right?
- 24:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 24:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I looked at the DD214, and I'm not gonna I'm not gonna bash anybody because I don't I I mean, I mean, I I will contribute to the conversation, but I don't know.
- 24:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, I looked at Chase Hughes, don't get me wrong, uh the Spidey senses went up.
- 24:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I looked at the DD214 that you that is shared, uh, and I looked at that after I was trying to understand if this guy should be on my show, and how do I get somebody who's who's getting $30,000 to $50,000 for a keynote to get on this little podcast that I call No Way Out, right?
- 25:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and and I'm I'm looking at him, I'm like, man, this he's he's awesome, by the way.
- 25:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He he's very articulate.
- 25:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He's talking about the things that I'm in, you know, in the space of psychedelic assistant therapy, consciousness, and things like that.
- 25:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, this is awesome, but how does this guy know from his career?
- 25:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you look back at that, and I'm like, there's nothing in there that says anything that connects to uh deception, behaviorism, or beh behavioral science.
- 25:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's it's a good military background.
- 25:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Don't get me wrong.
- 25:39Kent Clizbe: Exactly.
- 25:40Kent Clizbe: There's nothing to be there's there's nothing to be ashamed of in his background, but he has lied constantly.
- 25:48Kent Clizbe: And look look, Zach has a has a great website that uh that spells out that goes back and you know when when he when when Hughes first became prominent, or when he first became active, he tried all kinds of things.
- 26:03Kent Clizbe: He his first his first uh scam was uh a pick he was a pickup artist.
- 26:09Kent Clizbe: He wrote a book about about picking up girls.
- 26:12Kent Clizbe: Which is a great skill to have.
- 26:14Kent Clizbe: Sure, sure, absolutely.
- 26:16Kent Clizbe: But what at that time he didn't claim I learned how to pick up girls uh in the military.
- 26:22Kent Clizbe: But that's he tried that first, and then he uh he he did start building on you know using a military reputation as uh he he was a combat a combat skills instructor.
- 26:35Kent Clizbe: He had YouTube videos of you know, here's you do this, you strike under the nose, and it immediately kills them, and this don't do this at home, and you know, he that that he tried he tried that.
- 26:46Kent Clizbe: And somehow he ended soon soon after that, he ended up beginning to tout his expertise in intelligence.
- 26:56Kent Clizbe: Uh he claimed that he trained the CIA, the FBI, SEALs, uh uh Green Beret.
- 27:03Kent Clizbe: He he he he realized when he was in the military that the intelligence training that the military provided its operators needed his skills and and insights because they were totally useless, and he knew how to whatever he whatever his claims are.
- 27:24Kent Clizbe: His claims are I don't even I can't even remember what they are, but but totally based on nothing.
- 27:30Kent Clizbe: He has no actual experience.
- 27:33Kent Clizbe: He was not in Intel.
- 27:35Kent Clizbe: He was he was you know ended up in in in in the Norfolk area and uh he ended up running a harbor, he was uh a boat driver, things like that.
- 27:47Kent Clizbe: But he he he claim his claims are all were all bait.
- 27:52Kent Clizbe: When he he goes on these big uh big uh podcasts, uh Joe Rogan, uh CEO, I don't even remember the name of him.
- 28:01Kent Clizbe: Yeah, Diary of a CEO Diary of a CEO.
- 28:03Kent Clizbe: You know, he'll always very, very uh humbly, well, you know, 20 years in the military, and you know, it's I I wish I could tell you, but I can't I'd have probably have to kill you.
- 28:15Kent Clizbe: You know, which which right to me as being an actual operator who's worked with actual I I worked very uh uh uh extensively with the military, all of the military special forces.
- 28:28Kent Clizbe: I trained DIA, I designed and trained DIA Hugh Mint uh junior case officer training for for several years.
- 28:37Kent Clizbe: I I know I know them, I know how they work, I know what they do, I know what they know, and this guy is he's full of shit.
- 28:44Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 28:45Kent Clizbe: And that, but that is those claims are what propelled him.
- 28:50Kent Clizbe: It it was the foundation of his credibility.
- 28:54Kent Clizbe: And you know, no nobody dares question him.
- 28:57Kent Clizbe: Well, I don't know if they dare, it's just you know, it's just well, yeah, we'll just we'll just take whatever he says as as the truth.
- 29:03Kent Clizbe: Well, it's kind of like it's a great case study of credibility assessment.
- 29:06Kent Clizbe: Yeah, it's kind of it run across me.
- 29:08Kent Clizbe: I so in HCCA, it's holistic contextual credibility assessment.
- 29:13Kent Clizbe: I'm an expert in the context that he's claiming to be an expert in.
- 29:17Kent Clizbe: Yes, yes.
- 29:18Kent Clizbe: I am an Intel, human Intel guy.
- 29:21Kent Clizbe: I have worked military intelligence for many, many years.
- 29:26Kent Clizbe: I've trained the kind of things that he that that he is claiming expertise in.
- 29:31Kent Clizbe: I I've and I'm a practitioner.
- 29:33Kent Clizbe: I'm an expert practitioner of them.
- 29:36Kent Clizbe: Applying my ex my contextual competence, holistically looking at his stories, his claims, it just does not it's not credible.
- 29:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, you know, I started with Elizabeth Holmes and I brought up the names of the uh people that were on our board.
- 29:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're not coming, they weren't coming from her context, right?
- 29:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and she sounded very articulate.
- 30:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what that's what I'm getting at is I I don't have any, this is my view.
- 30:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't have any issues against what Chase Hughes says on on podcast, because I don't have that.
- 30:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's not my background.
- 30:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't understand, you know, I do look at it, I look at consciousness, I try to understand these things.
- 30:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I get it.
- 30:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm reading that stuff too.
- 30:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not an expert in it, right?
- 30:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I I do have a military background.
- 30:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have a context, contextual background in the military where I look at that and go, well, these aren't connected at all.
- 30:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 30:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I am not gonna say I'm not taking anything away from Chase Hughes and what he's saying on on these podcasts because those things may or may not be true.
- 30:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They may be consistent with science and what we're discovering about.
- 30:37Kent Clizbe: I'm sorry to interrupt, but so so that's where he's at now.
- 30:40Kent Clizbe: He has segued out of the the claims of his expertise in uh he he's he's on on a YouTube channel with other other guys that they'll they'll uh analyze body language.
- 30:55Kent Clizbe: That's how he got famous.
- 30:57Kent Clizbe: I can't remember what it's called.
- 30:58Kent Clizbe: It's yeah, I don't know.
- 30:59Kent Clizbe: That's what rocketed him into notoriety.
- 31:06Kent Clizbe: All this stuff about psychedelics and methylene blue and all this other stuff, it that that is he he has segued away, he's stepped away from the claims that that uh that he got famous and and prominent with.
- 31:21Kent Clizbe: And I I don't care about all that psychedelic and the the stuff he's doing now.
- 31:25Kent Clizbe: I I don't I don't have any contextual expertise, yeah, and I'm not talking about that.
- 31:29Kent Clizbe: I'm I'm looking at his the foundation of his claims, which was military intelligence uh expertise, and it's not there.
- 31:39Kent Clizbe: So sorry to interrupt.
- 31:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there are other folks out there that have worn military uniforms and and some have become politicians.
- 31:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In fact, I would say this my experience in the Navy Reserve is that uh you see a lot of folks that joined out of Yale, Stanford, and they're very articulate, very bright, and you can see they have a desired destination to go on and do something.
- 31:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And they use that moment, that credibility moment in the military to go, I deployed a Djibouti for a year and look at me, and I'm like, dude, what you're in combat, man.
- 32:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, I uh when I was on active duty, fuck you and your your reserve time, right?
- 32:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: John Kerry.
- 32:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But but I get I'm not trying to bash on veterans, I'm a veteran, I love the veteran community, but you got to be careful and you got to be careful with them because some of them are gonna do things and they're very they look very credible.
- 32:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'll tell you, I I shy away from folks right now that you know, once your spidey senses go off, you're kind of like, man, I got to get away from you, you know?
- 32:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't want anything to do with you.
- 32:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh and and in that case, I uh you know, I know Navy SEALs that were trying to figure out what they're gonna do when they get left the military, and and a year after they left the military, they're experts in meditation.
- 32:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, how the fuck is that possible?
- 32:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Anyway, I'm not a again, I I am a student.
- 32:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm trying to learn.
- 32:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm I I know stuff about teamwork, leadership strategy.
- 32:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I can help about talk about consciousness and all that.
- 32:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I you know, imagine when you're when you're trying to figure out who Ponce Rivera is, you you look around real fast and go, okay, this guy is has a social media presence.
- 33:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He he sounds like a dipshit from time to time.
- 33:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's have a conversation, right?
- 33:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That that's what I look at is but we all.
- 33:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and Ken, I was I tell you this having a podcast and and finding folks that seem to be credible and you bring them on here and you realize they're hiding behind AI when they write, you're like, man, so there's a little I'm uh I think there's a good warning for just the folks that are listening that hey, be careful out there, all right?
- 33:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I'm I'm not gonna tell you who you should listen to or not listen to, but just be careful.
- 33:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and fortunately, we've got an expert with us today who can help us through that in the HECA.
- 33:37Kent Clizbe: So uh I I guess I guess the uh the the best the best uh advice there is stay skeptical.
- 33:45Kent Clizbe: Trust, trust but verify.
- 33:46Kent Clizbe: Yeah, say, okay, the interesting, send me your stuff, you know, let's chat and uh yeah, figure them out.
- 33:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, let's get into the uh HCCA.
- 33:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And before we do that, I do want to share something uh with you, which uh I came across just the other day, believe it or not.
- 34:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Anyway, I'll read it to you.
- 34:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So John Boyd talked about a pyramid all the time.
- 34:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Like if you look at a pyramid from the bottom, it looks like a square from the side, it looks like a triangle from the top, it looks a little different, right?
- 34:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So he he points out you have to look at things from many different points of view.
- 34:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And only look at the pyramid from one side, you're gonna have one view of it.
- 34:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you just brought that up, right?
- 34:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we want to look at things from multiple perspectives.
- 34:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We want to challenge assumptions.
- 34:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let's go back to where we we brought up Ekman and we brought up some of the ideas of breaking things down.
- 34:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Take us back to what you discovered, what was wrong with all that, and how you came up with HCCA.
- 34:35Kent Clizbe: So as when I I was I was given my my spiel about how I ended up being in the agency, and then what I discovered in the agency was they were doing deception, they were calling it deception detection using measuring body body measurements of your eye movements, your blood pressure, skin, breathing, whatever.
- 34:56Kent Clizbe: And I real quick learned that doesn't work.
- 35:00Kent Clizbe: You know, we've got and then then then when I started going back in history, and and one thing that that uh American intelligence and probably law enforcement too is very bad at is practitioners don't go back and look at historical cases because you're drowning in so much happening in the moment.
- 35:22Kent Clizbe: You've got so much to do, you got no time to go back and and and look at history.
- 35:28Kent Clizbe: I only ended up having time once I I got out and started started when uh uh actually when I was teaching for the Defense Intelligence Agency, when I was designing courses, I was able to have time to go back and look at history.
- 35:43Kent Clizbe: And the CIA uh and American Intelligence is has a horrible track record of failure.
- 35:50Kent Clizbe: Uh best example, there's two great examples was uh East Germans uh assets that we had supposedly recruited in the 50s and 60s.
- 36:00Kent Clizbe: They they all passed our deception detection body, body measurement based uh deception detection.
- 36:09Kent Clizbe: They had all passed.
- 36:10Kent Clizbe: Come to find out, every single one of the who what we were calling agents were were doubles.
- 36:17Kent Clizbe: That is, they were run by East German intelligence against us.
- 36:21Kent Clizbe: Wow.
- 36:22Kent Clizbe: They were controlled by East German intelligence, a hundred percent of them.
- 36:26Kent Clizbe: Exact same thing with Cubans in the 60s.
- 36:29Kent Clizbe: Uh we had a stable of agents, I don't know, dozens.
- 36:33Kent Clizbe: Every single one of them was run by Cuban intelligence.
- 36:37Kent Clizbe: Cuban intelligence knew everything we were doing.
- 36:40Kent Clizbe: Every one of them had been measured by our uh specialists in body measurement deception detection.
- 36:49Kent Clizbe: Every one of them, and every one of them was bad.
- 36:52Kent Clizbe: Wow.
- 36:53Kent Clizbe: I didn't know that when I was when I was working, but I knew this ain't working because uh these guys that I'm dealing with and the feedback I'm getting from these body measurement specialists are totally different.
- 37:07Kent Clizbe: So I realized it's up to me.
- 37:10Kent Clizbe: I'm the only one meeting with this guy in context, seeing the holistic view of what's happening in this guy's life.
- 37:18Kent Clizbe: I have to do my own, and I realize it's not deception detection.
- 37:24Kent Clizbe: I'm not gonna be able to tell if he's telling a lie, but I'm gonna be able to tell, is he credible?
- 37:30Kent Clizbe: Is this story he's sharing credible?
- 37:33Kent Clizbe: And I have to assess his credibility to make a holistic determination about his credibility.
- 37:42Kent Clizbe: When he says, when I ask him a question, he says yes or no, I'm never gonna be able to tell whether that's a lie or the truth.
- 37:50Kent Clizbe: Not never, but yeah, I'm I'm only gonna be able to make uh uh an educated guess.
- 37:56Kent Clizbe: But there's nothing that can I can hook this guy up to that's gonna tell me that when he said yes, the actual answer is no.
- 38:05Kent Clizbe: I have to sit down and talk to him, get to know him, become like a psychoanalyst, best friend, get him to trust me as much as possible, and then I have to understand holistically everything, the culture he's in, his uh the national, religious, professional, organizational, bureaucratic, everything about his life to be able to be begin to be able to come up with an accurate assessment of his credibility.
- 38:38Kent Clizbe: And I developed that myself.
- 38:41Kent Clizbe: You're s I I still had to uh I I developed that approach, and I and I never had a bad a bad recruit.
- 38:48Kent Clizbe: I I never had anyone that uh ended up being discovered as bad.
- 38:56Kent Clizbe: But I discovered many bad recruitments by by doing file reviews, can counterintelligence.
- 39:04Kent Clizbe: I I can nobody nobody wants to do counterintelligence.
- 39:07Kent Clizbe: Nobody wants to to be the the one, I'm gonna say nobody, there are people who do, but case officers uh shy away from counterintelligence because really you're the one poo-pooing or or or proving everybody else's wrong.
- 39:24Kent Clizbe: My my approach is I I don't know, the the only thing as as I'm as I've matured, I used to be really, really hotheaded.
- 39:33Kent Clizbe: I get angry about many things and fight and was an asshole, but I'm okay, I'm still an asshole.
- 39:39Kent Clizbe: But but but now the only thing that makes me mad is somebody trying to take advantage of me.
- 39:45Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 39:45Kent Clizbe: Somebody trying to play me for a fool.
- 39:47Kent Clizbe: And that's that's that's what drove me to get to really dig into counterintelligence and dig into credibility assessment, because these people are pay playing CIA case officers, the entire organization, the U.S.
- 40:03Kent Clizbe: government, they're playing us for fools.
- 40:05Kent Clizbe: People that that uh that that are lying to us and spinning a story that we buy.
- 40:13Kent Clizbe: So I I because of that that part of my nature, not hating to be taken advantage of or played for a fool, I was really motivated to dig into and look at various cases.
- 40:27Kent Clizbe: And the things that I found were just unbelievable.
- 40:30Kent Clizbe: Some of the the cases that turned out to be bad, and then the the bureaucratic response to these cases being exposed as bad was even more unbelievable and more disappointing.
- 40:44Kent Clizbe: And which it's one one of the big reasons that I realized, nah, this I cannot do this, I cannot be part of this organization that is not interested in in determining the truth, but rather in racking up recruitments or whatever the the statistic or the whatever the measurement is.
- 41:06Kent Clizbe: And there was there's no um there's no reward for finding a bad case.
- 41:11Kent Clizbe: And nobody was punished for when bad cases were found.
- 41:16Kent Clizbe: There was no punishment, there's no you know, or not even punishment, no, no consequence.
- 41:21Kent Clizbe: I couldn't stand that.
- 41:23Kent Clizbe: So I while I was in, I developed my this I developed HCCA, although I didn't un I didn't really put I uh it wasn't explicit then.
- 41:33Kent Clizbe: It was how I did my work and how I got good cases.
- 41:37Kent Clizbe: And then when I studied the history of counterintelligence intelligence recruitment, counterintelligence failures, only then was I able to put together the the concept of HCCA.
- 41:50Kent Clizbe: Uh I'm I'm kind of curious.
- 41:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you brought up when you do reveal to the system that there is some deception or fraud out there, and we can go back through some of the historical ones that you're you're you're part of.
- 42:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh y you you get pushback from the uh the organization, right?
- 42:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, something known that uh you know that you you you you invite the white blood cells of an organization to turn on and they turn against you, right?
- 42:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think a lot of that has to do with ego.
- 42:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: People don't want to feel like they've ever been deceived.
- 42:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let's say we brought somebody into our world, we were partners with them three or four three or four years or five years, whatever it may be, and then we find out later on that there were frauds the whole time.
- 42:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: To protect myself, I'll I'll do everything I can to show that that that that never happened.
- 42:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, I'll I'll make sure that information doesn't flow in.
- 42:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and in fact, I'll I'll attack the messenger.
- 42:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's a general bias of humans, I believe, or or uh response by humans is to protect their egos.
- 42:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I know you have experience with this.
- 42:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then I don't know if you want to talk about uh going back uh what fifteen years ago or so?
- 42:51Kent Clizbe: Like like a case study of that happening?
- 42:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Somebody you you actually revealed or helped reveal.
- 42:56Kent Clizbe: So so uh w one case that uh that was just so egregious was that this guy had been recruited as a penetration of weapons of mass destruction.
- 43:08Kent Clizbe: He was supposedly working in his country's WMD industry.
- 43:14Kent Clizbe: He was run for after he was recruited, he was run for several years.
- 43:19Kent Clizbe: The uh the case officer who recruited him and her boss uh both got huge recognition for this for this recruitment.
- 43:28Kent Clizbe: Got promotions and and other good things came their way.
- 43:34Kent Clizbe: Uh when we did a uh I was working at headquarters, uh I I was a new officer working in headquarters, and uh there for some reason there was a civ there's a civ potential civil rights violation somewhere in the world.
- 43:49Kent Clizbe: And uh the the agency decided to shut down, to do a stand down, no ops, everybody stop, go back and do file reviews of all cases.
- 43:59Kent Clizbe: For civil rights violations.
- 44:03Kent Clizbe: So the office I was working in, and I it may have happened agency-wide, but I know the office I was working in said, hey, this is a great chance to do CI scrub as well.
- 44:14Kent Clizbe: We're look we're looking for civil rights violations.
- 44:17Kent Clizbe: Let's look at the case as a whole.
- 44:19Kent Clizbe: You know, is it good?
- 44:20Kent Clizbe: Is this a good case?
- 44:22Kent Clizbe: So I was doing that.
- 44:23Kent Clizbe: I was I was working on a desk and was doing these uh these case CI scrubs.
- 44:28Kent Clizbe: So I I I got this case, uh dug into it, and you know, it's just like something's not right.
- 44:35Kent Clizbe: There's all I mean, it was several several volumes.
- 44:39Kent Clizbe: Back then everything was in paper.
- 44:41Kent Clizbe: It was several thick volumes of papers that had to go through.
- 44:46Kent Clizbe: And you know, that's it's something questions.
- 44:50Kent Clizbe: The more I more questions I had.
- 44:56Kent Clizbe: Make a long story short, we because of the review I did and the questions I had, we were able to to send a guy out who a guy who uh measures deception detection.
- 45:09Kent Clizbe: But I I sat down with the this measurement guy and I said, Look, here's the questions.
- 45:15Kent Clizbe: Here's the questions that we have.
- 45:17Kent Clizbe: Let's just let's just ask these questions.
- 45:19Kent Clizbe: Forget the machine.
- 45:20Kent Clizbe: Forget the machine.
- 45:21Kent Clizbe: You you know, you're you're gonna have a nice little sit-down with him.
- 45:23Kent Clizbe: Just ask him these questions.
- 45:26Kent Clizbe: So the the guy did that.
- 45:28Kent Clizbe: And he he asked him, have you ever have you ever worked for a foreign intelligence service?
- 45:35Kent Clizbe: What is your job now?
- 45:37Kent Clizbe: Uh so that that was the first question.
- 45:40Kent Clizbe: What's your job?
- 45:40Kent Clizbe: And the guy said, Well, I I'm a quality control engineer in a moped factory.
- 45:46Kent Clizbe: He he would he had been his his recruitment was based on him being an engineer in a WMD industry.
- 45:55Kent Clizbe: Turns out that his country had closed that industry a year before he was recruited.
- 46:01Kent Clizbe: He had at one time worked in that industry, but they closed it.
- 46:05Kent Clizbe: And he had been working in a moped factory the whole time he was providing high-level top secret reports on the WMD industry.
- 46:16Kent Clizbe: Next question, have you ever uh worked for a foreign intelligence service?
- 46:21Kent Clizbe: He goes, Yeah, I'm working for the Cubans too.
- 46:25Kent Clizbe: And in fact, my dad worked for the Cubans and my you know, we we go to Cuba together a couple times a year uh to report to them.
- 46:34Kent Clizbe: And and there was a couple of of other issues, but those two, it's like it's over right there.
- 46:42Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 46:43Kent Clizbe: And and the the the interviewer asks him, well, why didn't you tell your case officer this?
- 46:49Kent Clizbe: He said, She never asked.
- 46:51Kent Clizbe: Never asked, yeah.
- 46:53Kent Clizbe: So, I mean that that was to me, that was just egregious.
- 46:58Kent Clizbe: So what happens?
- 46:59Kent Clizbe: Come come back.
- 47:01Kent Clizbe: Uh to actually to set that up, to get that interview set up, I had to go through, it was like uh it was like I I don't know what it what is it when when when Indians have a captive and make them run down a line where they but they beat him with clubs on both sides, they had a name for it, I forget what it is, but I had to go through something like that just to get that to that point.
- 47:27Kent Clizbe: I I called a meeting and brought in the the recruiting case officer, her boss, uh desk officers, analysts who dealt with the WMDs, et cetera, et cetera.
- 47:37Kent Clizbe: And we sat down, I presented what I'd found and the questions I had, and uh the the recruiting case officer literally stood up and screamed at me, you whatever.
- 47:50Kent Clizbe: I had no idea what she was saying, but that was the response.
- 47:53Kent Clizbe: Instead of, wow, thanks a lot.
- 47:55Kent Clizbe: You know, I I was just I was really busy and I didn't have time, but yeah, you know.
- 48:00Kent Clizbe: I I don't I don't know, I mean, you know, you you want to say ego.
- 48:04Kent Clizbe: Okay.
- 48:05Kent Clizbe: Ego is is is part of it, but it's also see, see, I I don't use I I know we well, we mentioned mice.
- 48:15Kent Clizbe: Mice is bullshit.
- 48:18Kent Clizbe: Mice is a horrible way of looking at human uh factors that motivate humans.
- 48:25Kent Clizbe: Uh we don't know how to do that.
- 48:26Kent Clizbe: Number one is because of money.
- 48:27Kent Clizbe: Yes, money money is up front.
- 48:29Kent Clizbe: The way the my approach, I use uh Maslow's hierarchy of needs.
- 48:35Kent Clizbe: Okay.
- 48:36Kent Clizbe: And there's no money.
- 48:38Kent Clizbe: There humans are not motivated by money.
- 48:40Kent Clizbe: They're motivated by Maslow's hierarchy of needs, another pyramid.
- 48:44Kent Clizbe: And ego, or if you want to call it, I mean, if you say ego, it's it's in there, but it's spelled out a little more clearly.
- 48:55Kent Clizbe: And uh I forget what I forget what it's called, but it's uh social recognition or something like that, which is uh one of the higher level motivators is being recognized in society.
- 49:12Kent Clizbe: And and I think that that is sort of a a uh an ego, it could be translated as ego.
- 49:19Kent Clizbe: But anyway, for whatever reason, the bureaucracy in the the American intelligence community does not want to hear that, does not want to hear they've got a bad case.
- 49:32Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 49:32Kent Clizbe: They don't want to hear it.
- 49:34Kent Clizbe: And I but I pushed through that, you know, and and I I lost all kinds of uh bureaucratic capital.
- 49:42Kent Clizbe: You know, if I had gone along with, oh yeah, yeah, this is a good case, then these people by this time, they're they're the the supervisor who had approved this recruitment was now working in the director's office.
- 49:54Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 49:54Kent Clizbe: You know, it's like a special assistant to the director.
- 49:56Kent Clizbe: Uh, if I'd have gone along with it, I'd I'd have had a good name and I'd have been able to get a good assignment and you know, good, good uh good professional assessment reviews.
- 50:09Kent Clizbe: But you know, to me it's like, nah, uh-uh.
- 50:12Kent Clizbe: That none of that means anything to me if they're if I'm being played for a fool.
- 50:17Kent Clizbe: So there's a good a great case study.
- 50:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Have you uh so you just brought up to be or to do.
- 50:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's actually something uh John Boyd brought up that you can take you could be somebody or you could do something.
- 50:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and what you're saying is you're doing something about, hey, let's take a look at the system.
- 50:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Most people want to be part of the system, they want to rise up to the top, they they want to go up uh Maslow's hierarchy to status, right?
- 50:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what they're doing.
- 50:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, exactly.
- 50:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I think the better approach, and this is what we're encouraging folks to do, is do something, right?
- 50:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Go out there.
- 50:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I like that.
- 50:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, so HCCA is is is your uh you're doing.
- 50:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and I do want to bring up a few things here, uh I didn't know anything about and hopefully this this fits into where you want to go next, but I didn't know anything about Wayne Simmons, right?
- 51:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hopefully I'm saying his name right.
- 51:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and again, this is just you know, uh can you take us through HCCA and maybe Wayne Simmons or another approach, and we can use some slides here so people can see this?
- 51:12Kent Clizbe: Sure.
- 51:13Kent Clizbe: Uh so it's another perfect case study of a con man running a running up against someone who has holistic contextual expertise in the area of his con.
- 51:27Kent Clizbe: He had been for 13 years, he had been one of Fox News's main on-screen sources for uh as a CIA uh counter-terrorism expert.
- 51:40Kent Clizbe: He he had he he was all over, you know, constantly on Fox News, Wayne Simmons, CIA counterterrorism expert.
- 51:50Kent Clizbe: I don't have c I I don't have cable now, I didn't have cable then, and I I didn't watch Fox News, so I'd never heard of him, never seen him.
- 51:57Kent Clizbe: But a friend of mine who who was a friend of Simmons said, Hey, you guys are so much alike.
- 52:04Kent Clizbe: He was a he was a military guy, not not agency.
- 52:08Kent Clizbe: He said, You guys are so much alike, you gotta meet him.
- 52:11Kent Clizbe: Um so I said, sure.
- 52:14Kent Clizbe: Um so he set up a lunch meeting.
- 52:16Kent Clizbe: We we got together for lunch at uh BWI airport.
- 52:20Kent Clizbe: He was passing through, and within five minutes, I knew this guy's fake.
- 52:25Kent Clizbe: He he he has he doesn't know anything about the CIA, but he was he was just babbling nonstop about the things.
- 52:34Kent Clizbe: What he was describing was DEA or counter-narcotics law enforcement operations and calling it CIA operations.
- 52:44Kent Clizbe: Yeah, yeah, we took down, you know, 75 kilos, you know, 300,000, 300 million dollars, and yeah, we busted him, blah, blah, blah, this, that, and the other.
- 52:53Kent Clizbe: Yeah, you know how it is, Kent.
- 52:54Kent Clizbe: I'm going, yeah, yeah, sure, sure, right, dude.
- 52:58Kent Clizbe: You know, I I I did not let him know that I was on to him at that time.
- 53:04Kent Clizbe: Uh, but it was obvious within five minutes that this guy didn't know what the CIA did, had not done anything in the CIA, and was blowing smoke up my ass.
- 53:16Kent Clizbe: So again, you know, playing me for a fool, it it really motivated me.
- 53:21Kent Clizbe: So for the next couple years, I vetted him.
- 53:24Kent Clizbe: Let me ask you this, Ken.
- 53:26Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 53:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If okay, let's swap rules.
- 53:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's say you send me into that meeting at BWI.
- 53:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Would I have picked that up?
- 53:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I want to be clear.
- 53:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No.
- 53:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 53:34Kent Clizbe: No, but I don't think so.
- 53:35Kent Clizbe: No, no, no.
- 53:36Kent Clizbe: Unless you have unless you have expertise in American civilian intelligence operations.
- 53:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I have watched Lioness, so that qualifies me.
- 53:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I haven't, so I don't know what that means.
- 53:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, okay.
- 53:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's it's a TV show about uh CIA operating in the U.S.
- 53:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: anyway.
- 53:55Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 53:55Kent Clizbe: I I I cannot watch any shows like that about the CIA because they're they're so uh then I watched Homeland.
- 54:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know if you ever saw that too.
- 54:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But anyway, no, I haven't seen that one either.
- 54:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just want to make sure it's clear that that had had you sent me in there, I probably would not have recognized that.
- 54:12Kent Clizbe: So and that's a perfect example of we need to when if we're involved in assessing someone, the people that we assign the assessment to need to self-evaluate what is their contextual competence.
- 54:31Kent Clizbe: In fact, let me that's a great example.
- 54:35Kent Clizbe: Let's see if we can share here.
- 54:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And this kind of explains why uh and just switching gears for a moment while you're looking that up.
- 54:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In in when I'm working with corporations and you're speaking to HR professionals or somebody who's trying to understand teamwork and leadership, their context is different.
- 54:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't understand the team science that is actually out there.
- 54:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They've been looking at it from a different lens.
- 54:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when I have a conversation with them, they're like, what the hell are you talking about, right?
- 54:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't know because they don't have that context.
- 55:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Anyway, back to you.
- 55:01Kent Clizbe: They don't have the contextual expertise.
- 55:03Kent Clizbe: So if if you and I were working in some kind of organization that said, hey, uh we need to we need to go uh vet and assess Wayne Simmons' uh uh credibility.
- 55:17Kent Clizbe: If we have, say we have a a stable of ten uh of ten assessors, each one I would have each one of them have completed this contextual competence checklist.
- 55:35Kent Clizbe: These are just examples of um cultures or contexts that you have competence in.
- 55:48Kent Clizbe: So for example, national um national context, think of it as uh so for myself, I here I could say um United States, Malaysia, uh Indonesia, Philippines, Saudi Arabia, Italy, UK, so I have competence in those national contexts.
- 56:18Kent Clizbe: Regional, uh Southern US, um uh uh Mindanao, Southern Philippines, uh uh Kuala Lumpur Malaysia, um uh Java in in the in Indonesia, linguistic, um English, Vietnamese, Malay, Indonesian, Arabic, Spanish, Italian, racial, black American, uh to uh to Chinese, Malay, uh ethnic, so so you you you go through, you gotta identify what you have, you have to be honest, what your competencies are, yeah, what context you're competent in.
- 57:15Kent Clizbe: And you have this profile for each of your operators, and when it's time to send somebody out to assess Simmons, you find so that uh under professional, you'd be looking for uh US uh uh civilian foreign intelligence.
- 57:38Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 57:40Kent Clizbe: You'd looking for someone who has competence in that in that uh context.
- 57:46Kent Clizbe: If you don't have competence in that context, you're wasting everybody's time.
- 57:52Kent Clizbe: Does that make sense?
- 57:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 57:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I just want to point out for our listeners there, you identified culture and you identified experience in previous experience.
- 57:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We call it previous experience.
- 58:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Those two things sit at the heart of orientation.
- 58:02Kent Clizbe: That is Wait, what is the second one?
- 58:04Kent Clizbe: What kind of experience?
- 58:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh just we just call it previous experience.
- 58:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It could be it could be what you had for breakfast, where you went to school, where you worked, were you part of the military, what'd you do in the military.
- 58:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you break it down into that.
- 58:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So those two components, along with genetics, uh determine our orientation, how we sense and decide and act.
- 58:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's it.
- 58:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is this is why I think HCCA connects so well, because you have that orientation of the uh in this case, you or me, going in to evaluate somebody else, right?
- 58:32Kent Clizbe: So I I think that what what I've done here, and uh as I mentioned to you, I know OODA loop, but I don't know it deeply.
- 58:40Kent Clizbe: But now that you describe that, I think previous experience, that's what context is.
- 58:47Kent Clizbe: And I'm I'm saying you've got you can't just say previous experience, you've got to break it out into these sp these and more specific categories.
- 58:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, let me build on that.
- 58:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So a lot of locations you described, I've been to, I have previous experience there, but are you competent though?
- 59:05Kent Clizbe: That's the question.
- 59:06Kent Clizbe: Are you competent?
- 59:07Kent Clizbe: No.
- 59:07Kent Clizbe: Having passed through there doesn't make you competent.
- 59:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 59:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There we go.
- 59:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's what I'm saying.
- 59:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is you were immersed in these cultures, I passed through them.
- 59:15Kent Clizbe: Yes.
- 59:15Kent Clizbe: You're not competent.
- 59:16Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 59:16Kent Clizbe: You're better off than somebody who's never passed through there.
- 59:19Kent Clizbe: Yeah, I can find them on a map.
- 59:22Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 59:22Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 59:23Kent Clizbe: So so uh uh for example, uh professional, like you you mentioned military.
- 59:30Kent Clizbe: You've got to break that down, the professional, into subcultures.
- 59:36Kent Clizbe: So I I was in the military, but I was Air Force.
- 59:40Kent Clizbe: Not only, but I don't know anything about the subculture in the Air Force of flying.
- 59:45Kent Clizbe: I don't know anything about the subculture in the Air Force of electronic repair.
- 59:50Kent Clizbe: I don't know anything in the subculture in the Air Force about logistics.
- 59:54Kent Clizbe: So just being military and just being Air Force is not enough.
- 59:59Kent Clizbe: If we have a case that is a logistician uh uh deployed to to uh a forward operating base in Iraq, then we need to identify someone who has uh who has expertise in that context, at least logistician.
- 1:00:21Kent Clizbe: Yes.
- 1:00:22Kent Clizbe: You know, depending on what what it why we're uh what what we're investigating, what we're looking at.
- 1:00:28Kent Clizbe: But what I'm providing here is a um a framework that people need to realize that it's not just previous experience, it is uh you've got to break down that previous experience.
- 1:00:44Kent Clizbe: So you have a framework here to start thinking about it, and this can be expanded.
- 1:00:47Kent Clizbe: There's this is not all inclusive.
- 1:00:50Kent Clizbe: But this is so so my contextual competence checklist when I when when I went to meet Simmons included uh in under professional uh American civilian foreign intelligence operations.
- 1:01:10Kent Clizbe: I have I have I've I have competence in that context.
- 1:01:17Kent Clizbe: And your yours would not have that.
- 1:01:20Kent Clizbe: Right.
- 1:01:21Kent Clizbe: So d does that explain it?
- 1:01:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah, 100%.
- 1:01:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh it it it it really does.
- 1:01:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's a great connection to the real OODA loop, which is orientation determines how we sense, perceive, decide, act, adapt, and learn, right?
- 1:01:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That drives everything.
- 1:01:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So and that's is it's a strong connection there.
- 1:01:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh uh uh that context is and I heard Pete Blair recently on on the uh Zachary Elwood uh podcast, and Pete Blair's gonna be on this podcast with in within the next week or so, talking about using ecological dynamics, understanding the the the context, the the uh the environment they're in, right?
- 1:01:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So all of these things are connected.
- 1:01:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's fascinating that uh you as a as an operator came up, you know, you're you're converging on the same thing that science and everything else, uh natural science is saying we should converge on.
- 1:02:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's how legal systems are.
- 1:02:10Kent Clizbe: So I I want to also mention that, yeah, I would that's where I developed this approach uh of credibility assessment.
- 1:02:17Kent Clizbe: And but I also in civilian intelligence.
- 1:02:20Kent Clizbe: Uh that's that's how and where the the the context that I developed this approach, but I realized, you know, this this could be used in any this approach can be used for anything.
- 1:02:31Kent Clizbe: Scales.
- 1:02:32Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:02:32Kent Clizbe: Where you're dealing with people that you need to assess their credibility.
- 1:02:37Kent Clizbe: And as I was excelling in the agency and not being rewarded for excellence, in fact, being punished for excellence, I started going, yeah, this was fantastic.
- 1:02:49Kent Clizbe: This was a great move.
- 1:02:50Kent Clizbe: I love it.
- 1:02:51Kent Clizbe: Great job.
- 1:02:52Kent Clizbe: But I cannot, I I cannot, I'm I'm a really bad bureaucrat.
- 1:02:57Kent Clizbe: So what can I do with this expertise that I've developed?
- 1:03:02Kent Clizbe: And that that was the end of the 90s.
- 1:03:05Kent Clizbe: It was 98 going into 99.
- 1:03:07Kent Clizbe: There was uh the dot-com boom.
- 1:03:10Kent Clizbe: You may not be old enough to.
- 1:03:12Kent Clizbe: Oh, I'm old enough to know I'm old.
- 1:03:13Kent Clizbe: I'm 54.
- 1:03:14Kent Clizbe: Come on.
- 1:03:15Kent Clizbe: So the the dot-com boom was it it was it's like AI now.
- 1:03:19Kent Clizbe: Everybody's like, oh, AI is gonna change the world, everything's gonna be different.
- 1:03:23Kent Clizbe: Same thing, dot-com.
- 1:03:24Kent Clizbe: There was no e-commerce is is what's gonna uh change the world, everything's gonna be online.
- 1:03:31Kent Clizbe: Back then, nothing was online.
- 1:03:33Kent Clizbe: Uh there's people were using a little bit of email and you know, to to browse the internet, there's virtually very little useful there.
- 1:03:44Kent Clizbe: But the the the the dot-com industry uh based in Silicon Valley had billions and billions and billions of dollars in investments pouring into it.
- 1:03:57Kent Clizbe: And I said, okay, well, I I'm not technical.
- 1:04:01Kent Clizbe: I don't know anything about about the internet, but I have this skill and credibility assessment and recruiting.
- 1:04:09Kent Clizbe: So what can I do?
- 1:04:11Kent Clizbe: So I jumped out of the plane with no parachute.
- 1:04:14Kent Clizbe: I I resigned from the agency and took a job with a headhunting company, uh, executive recruiters, 100% commission.
- 1:04:22Kent Clizbe: I didn't get paid unless I unless I recruited somebody.
- 1:04:27Kent Clizbe: Uh we were paid by a percentage of uh of the the first year's compensation package.
- 1:04:34Kent Clizbe: So I I got in this small firm.
- 1:04:37Kent Clizbe: These guys were uh involved, they had come out of the um telecommunications industry, and they they were each each each of us, each headhunter in this kind of firm, you build your own business, and they had their own contacts in telecommunications, and they were they were getting orders and uh and doing searches and placements in telecommunications.
- 1:05:01Kent Clizbe: So I got in their office and I realized real quick, you know what, I don't have any contextual competence in telecommunications.
- 1:05:10Kent Clizbe: And so what ended up happening is they they gave me uh a desk, a phone, and a computer, and I had to build my own business.
- 1:05:21Kent Clizbe: And I flailed around for a while, looking, you know, do really doing a survey of who was hiring and who needed help hiring.
- 1:05:30Kent Clizbe: And so so my my my background, I ended up doing a BA in linguistics, and my first master's degree was in linguistics also.
- 1:05:39Kent Clizbe: So I I understand uh linguistics.
- 1:05:42Kent Clizbe: I don't understand computer science, but I very quickly found out there was a huge demand for computational linguistics, computational linguists in in Silicon Valley in dot com.
- 1:05:57Kent Clizbe: Turns out that's the computational Computational linguistics is the foundation of what we now we now call AI, the the uh large language models, is all based on computational ling linguists.
- 1:06:10Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:06:11Kent Clizbe: Back then it was just starting.
- 1:06:13Kent Clizbe: Google had just started, Google was not uh was not dominant, it was just a small startup, and they were they hired computational linguists.
- 1:06:23Kent Clizbe: So I realized, okay, I I can I can speak ling lingu linguistics speak.
- 1:06:30Kent Clizbe: I'm a c I have contextual competence in linguistics.
- 1:06:33Kent Clizbe: I don't have contextual competence in computational stuff, but that's okay.
- 1:06:38Kent Clizbe: There's a lot of recruiters who are out of the uh the computer industry and they do have contextual competence, but they have no idea when when a company is looking for a specific flavor of linguist, they have no idea what what they're looking for.
- 1:06:54Kent Clizbe: So I jumped on that opportunity and I started doing cold calls and started uh and ended up getting a couple of clients who were startups in in Silicon Valley who were doing uh computational ling linguistics.
- 1:07:11Kent Clizbe: Ontology was a big thing.
- 1:07:12Kent Clizbe: Ontology is the science of creating meaning in databases.
- 1:07:18Kent Clizbe: It's it's kind of esoteric, but it's it's a linguistic and philosophical based specialty.
- 1:07:25Kent Clizbe: So I started I I got a couple of of clients.
- 1:07:29Kent Clizbe: Client clients, they don't pay you until you until you place somebody with them.
- 1:07:33Kent Clizbe: So I had to convince them that I had expertise in linguistics and I could find these people they're looking for, and did.
- 1:07:40Kent Clizbe: Got a couple of placements and built on it from there, and I became the only headhunter in the world who specialized in computational linguistics and ontology.
- 1:07:51Kent Clizbe: So once I had established that, and and while I was establishing myself, I realized, you know, what what I'm doing here is the same thing that they should be doing in the CIA or in any human intelligence recruitment operation, is vetting and assessing the credibility of these candidates or or in in intelligent human intelligence, you call them developmentals or assets agents.
- 1:08:21Kent Clizbe: I was doing the what I had gotten really good at in the agency, assessing credibility, vetting developmentals and assets.
- 1:08:31Kent Clizbe: Here I am, and and what I found there, nobody cared.
- 1:08:34Kent Clizbe: You know, if you recruited a bad one, like the WMD guy, nobody cared.
- 1:08:39Kent Clizbe: There's whatever.
- 1:08:40Kent Clizbe: Yeah, whoopee, keep going.
- 1:08:42Kent Clizbe: Oh, you always bad.
- 1:08:44Kent Clizbe: Yeah, well, you you why you shouldn't have told us that.
- 1:08:46Kent Clizbe: Well, guess what?
- 1:08:48Kent Clizbe: In the real world, everybody cares and it matters.
- 1:08:53Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:08:53Kent Clizbe: You can't send the guy uh as a WMD expert who's a moped uh quality control dude.
- 1:09:02Kent Clizbe: So I gave a 100% guarantee the candidate that I present to you, Mr.
- 1:09:09Kent Clizbe: Client, company who's hiring, will be ready, willing, and able to do the job that you need him to do.
- 1:09:17Kent Clizbe: So first I have to be able to understand the job that they need him to do.
- 1:09:21Kent Clizbe: Yes.
- 1:09:22Kent Clizbe: And then I have to vet, I have to find the candidates.
- 1:09:26Kent Clizbe: That's a whole nother story, building a network.
- 1:09:28Kent Clizbe: But once I find the candidates, I have to vet them to ensure that they are ready, willing, and able to do the job that that my client wants them to do.
- 1:09:39Kent Clizbe: And I gave a 100% money-back guarantee that the candidate that you hire from me, the candidate that I present to you, will be ready, willing, and able.
- 1:09:51Kent Clizbe: I never had to pay that guarantee.
- 1:09:54unknown: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 1:09:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna argue or I'm gonna point out something here.
- 1:09:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think your strength is actually on the people ideas and then the things, so the things would be the technical side.
- 1:10:02Kent Clizbe: Oh, absolutely.
- 1:10:02Kent Clizbe: So yeah, I I have no technical expertise.
- 1:10:05Kent Clizbe: I'm a people person.
- 1:10:06Kent Clizbe: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 1:10:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But if you're looking at the computational linguistics side, that's your technical expertise.
- 1:10:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It just happened to be what they were looking for.
- 1:10:12Kent Clizbe: Linguistics.
- 1:10:12Kent Clizbe: I was I was the linguistic side.
- 1:10:14Kent Clizbe: Which and really linguistics is all about how people think and communicate.
- 1:10:18Kent Clizbe: It's it's all people.
- 1:10:19Kent Clizbe: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 1:10:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then when you think about how people hire today, generally it's based around technical skills.
- 1:10:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do you know these technical skills?
- 1:10:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk about them?
- 1:10:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And this is it when veterans transition, that's what they're usually you know, that do you understand how to do this thing?
- 1:10:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do you have a PMP or whatever it may be?
- 1:10:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's not important.
- 1:10:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's important is the people side is the ideas, people ideas, and then things.
- 1:10:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think recruiters get that recruiters' companies get that wrong because they're looking for a technical thing.
- 1:10:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna add one other thing.
- 1:10:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In the agile space I was in years ago, uh, you discover pretty fast that everybody, a lot of folks that are working in software development don't actually have the skills they say they do, right?
- 1:10:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and that was just very apparent.
- 1:10:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's uh they created a resume, and then the people doing the interviews don't know what they're looking for.
- 1:11:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't have any context, so they can't hire the right people, right?
- 1:11:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're just going based off the technical skills they put on the resume.
- 1:11:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh I I think your strength is actually on the people side.
- 1:11:11Kent Clizbe: So so well, yes, you're absolutely right.
- 1:11:13Kent Clizbe: That's my strength.
- 1:11:14Kent Clizbe: However, I did also have to assess their credibility in so the the guys I'm I'm hiring, uh my candidates had to have technical skills.
- 1:11:24Kent Clizbe: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:11:25Kent Clizbe: So I had to assess their technical skills without being an expert.
- 1:11:29Kent Clizbe: I I I have an approach to do that.
- 1:11:33Kent Clizbe: There, there's different ways you can do it, but the technical skills are very important.
- 1:11:39Kent Clizbe: For my job, it's all human.
- 1:11:41Kent Clizbe: It's all human uh to to do my job.
- 1:11:44Kent Clizbe: But I've I recognize that the technical skills are the most important thing for for most of these the candidates and and the clients who were looking for candidates.
- 1:11:57Kent Clizbe: So I had to come up with a way of assessing technical skills, and I did.
- 1:12:02Kent Clizbe: And most of it was uh so tell me about your ontology work.
- 1:12:07Kent Clizbe: Was listening, you know, getting them to talk.
- 1:12:10Kent Clizbe: And just like I got Wayne Simmons to talk, he immediately showed he didn't know what the hell he's talking about.
- 1:12:17Kent Clizbe: And even even though I ended up developing contextual competence in ontology and computation, the the computational issues in computational linguistics.
- 1:12:29Kent Clizbe: I didn't have it when I started.
- 1:12:31Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:12:31Kent Clizbe: But but so you can develop competencies, uh technical or or other contextual competencies, uh, that that become useful in assessing credibility.
- 1:12:43Kent Clizbe: And I I could not sit down and have a technical conversation about programming, right, but I could have a conversation and listen to somebody describing to me the uh the the projects they've done in ontology or large language models or anything technical, and I could make a make a judgment.
- 1:13:08Kent Clizbe: Uh in fact, let's let me let me share another.
- 1:13:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I think what you're describing there is exactly what's happening today, and that is there's a lot of people that don't have context uh that are investing billions and trillions of dollars into vaporware, uh future AI, things that don't exist.
- 1:13:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, I've had guests on the show that I I'm not gonna call a fraud, but they didn't really you know, their companies have failed, they didn't have what they claim to have.
- 1:13:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you're you're seeing more and more of that.
- 1:13:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the the uh and most American most people don't understand what a large language model does.
- 1:13:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't understand active inference, they don't understand reinforcement learning, what deep learning is, uh but they're just buying blindly right now.
- 1:13:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're gonna build these massive data centers.
- 1:13:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're gonna need all these things.
- 1:13:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Everybody's running at this uh and and I think this is the dot-com bubble all over again.
- 1:13:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because people don't see exactly what it is.
- 1:13:55Kent Clizbe: So I I guess I think what you're describing is my my uh my uh analysis is what you're describing is is marketing.
- 1:14:05Kent Clizbe: And marketing is all blowing smoke up your ass.
- 1:14:08Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:14:08Kent Clizbe: You know, so but when when you get to recruiting, and I need to and these guys that are uh are promising, and and that's the way during dot com startups, uh there's a lot of vaporware, but they're making promises and hiring people to do jobs that require specific skills.
- 1:14:29Kent Clizbe: Even if the company that's making the promises doesn't have the ability to do what they're claiming at this point, they're hoping they will.
- 1:14:37Kent Clizbe: They're hoping that they're gonna be able.
- 1:14:39Kent Clizbe: So they're gonna need uh and uh they're they're gonna need people with with these uh technical skills.
- 1:14:46Kent Clizbe: And my job is to find those people and vet them to determine if they have those skills.
- 1:14:53Kent Clizbe: Not that they listed on their resume, but do they have them?
- 1:14:57Kent Clizbe: Nice.
- 1:15:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Curious, before you get into the this right here, uh when you met with Wayne at uh BWI, was he aware of who you were?
- 1:15:07Kent Clizbe: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:15:07Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:15:08Kent Clizbe: Our mutual friend told him, oh, Kenza counterterrorism, CIA counterterrorism.
- 1:15:13Kent Clizbe: At the time, I was I was traveling nonstop.
- 1:15:16Kent Clizbe: I was doing a contract, contracting um uh throughout Southeast Asia, Africa, the Middle East, uh doing uh CIA counterterrorism work.
- 1:15:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just kind of thought it weird that uh that he would want to meet with somebody that uh He was arrogant.
- 1:15:32Kent Clizbe: He'd been on He'd been on Fox News for 13 years.
- 1:15:35Kent Clizbe: Okay, so you there you go and nobody had ever called him out.
- 1:15:38Kent Clizbe: He was arrogant and and and that and that's what really pissed me off.
- 1:15:46Kent Clizbe: Is you know, if I'd seen you on Fox News, I would maybe I wouldn't, you know, I it's a pretty small, especially back then, it wasn't a huge community of CIA counterterrorism people.
- 1:16:00Kent Clizbe: I knew most people who were active in it.
- 1:16:03Kent Clizbe: So if I had seen him on Fox, you know, I'd have said, hmm, I wonder I I would call a couple buddies and say, Do you know this guy?
- 1:16:10Kent Clizbe: But I never had.
- 1:16:11Kent Clizbe: So here I'm meeting him face to face, and um immediately I know I know he's not real.
- 1:16:18Kent Clizbe: Um so crazy.
- 1:16:21Kent Clizbe: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:16:22Kent Clizbe: So uh the this HCCA cycle, uh um uh holistic contextual credibility assessment is when I'm it can be used by I I I I um perfected this as a headhunter because I had to, because I couldn't afford I was a one-man shop.
- 1:16:45Kent Clizbe: I was my I was the only one in my company.
- 1:16:47Kent Clizbe: I my kids were working for me, you know, filing papers and stuff, but I was the only one actually providing value to this company.
- 1:16:56Kent Clizbe: So I I had to um be perfect.
- 1:17:02Kent Clizbe: I couldn't afford to pay back a a pla uh a placement fee.
- 1:17:08Kent Clizbe: Right.
- 1:17:08Kent Clizbe: So I realized this is what I'm doing.
- 1:17:11Kent Clizbe: I'm gathering evidence, I'm going out and finding potential candidates.
- 1:17:17Kent Clizbe: I gather evidence, I interview them.
- 1:17:20Kent Clizbe: Step one, interview, interrogate the subject, whatever you want to call it, interview, interrogate.
- 1:17:27Kent Clizbe: I had to use my contextual competence and also don't forget intuition and intuition, your gut is based on it, it's not something you're born with.
- 1:17:40Kent Clizbe: You develop intuition, you develop your gut based on your experiences, and you have to have and your gut is contextual.
- 1:17:53Kent Clizbe: You you can't be a uh somebody who grew up on the streets of Brooklyn, and then you you go out to the uh to the the Rocky Mountains in Colorado and be walking on a trail in the Rocky Mountains and listen to your gut.
- 1:18:12Kent Clizbe: Your gut has no idea that there's a cougar following you down that trail.
- 1:18:19Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:18:19Kent Clizbe: Your gut is looking for the crack dealer on the next corner.
- 1:18:22Kent Clizbe: So that's intuition.
- 1:18:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the big big point here uh for our listeners, finger spits and gefuel is is fingertip fill.
- 1:18:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that pathway that goes from orient to act.
- 1:18:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that intuition.
- 1:18:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're calling it pathfinding, it's skill acquisition developed through previous experience.
- 1:18:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's um you can get into interoceptive capabilities and things like that.
- 1:18:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's exactly what you're talking about.
- 1:18:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's exactly what that pathway is and the implicit guide, the implicit guidance control pathway from orientation to act.
- 1:18:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Finger spits and good fuel, fingertip fill.
- 1:18:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Interesting.
- 1:18:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:18:53Kent Clizbe: So I call that gathering evidence, you know, using using data, intuition, and you you uh you talk to the person and you don't leave any stone unturned.
- 1:19:05Kent Clizbe: You know, you you it's an investigation, it's a uh a data gathering, and then you review all of the the evidence, all of everything that you've gathered about that the person, and your your contextual competence is guiding the thrust of this effort holistically.
- 1:19:25Kent Clizbe: Once you've done that, once you've gathered all the evidence, then you assess and evaluate what you've gathered.
- 1:19:33Kent Clizbe: You consider everything you've gathered holistically and in context, and use deductive logical reasoning to guide the assessment with your intuition, your contextually uh competent intuition providing support as needed.
- 1:19:50Kent Clizbe: Sometimes there's you know, like with the a best example is Simmons.
- 1:19:55Kent Clizbe: When I met him, I didn't have any documentation to tell me he was wrong.
- 1:19:59Kent Clizbe: It was my intuition.
- 1:20:00Kent Clizbe: My intuition, my contextual, competent intuition told me this guy's full of shit.
- 1:20:06Kent Clizbe: You thought you were going to meet a peer.
- 1:20:07Kent Clizbe: That's all you thought.
- 1:20:07Kent Clizbe: Yeah, there's a peer.
- 1:20:08Kent Clizbe: I meet peers all the time.
- 1:20:10Kent Clizbe: There you go.
- 1:20:11Kent Clizbe: And you know, I I know what they it's kind of gross, but I say I say it's like dogs sniffing butts.
- 1:20:18Kent Clizbe: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:20:18Kent Clizbe: You know, that's they that's what they do.
- 1:20:21Kent Clizbe: And that's what when when you meet a peer, it in in which in in an area that I'm contextually competent in, you sniff butts and go, yeah, no, no, you ain't from around here, man.
- 1:20:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We used to say that too.
- 1:20:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we in in aviation, we say sniff butts, you know.
- 1:20:36Kent Clizbe: Um same thing.
- 1:20:37Kent Clizbe: It's you're it's just a different context, but it's a it's a contextual competence that you can identify other Navy aviators.
- 1:20:47Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:20:47Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:20:48Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:20:48Kent Clizbe: So anyway, you assess and evaluate, then you make a judgment, and then you monitor and review, and then you do it again if needed.
- 1:20:55Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 1:20:55Kent Clizbe: Uh that's that's HCCA in a in a nutshell.
- 1:20:58Kent Clizbe: No, that's that's really cool that it's uh you can see the the uh the uh parallels to to UDA.
- 1:21:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, so this would fit within like to me, this is a process that helps you improve your orientation.
- 1:21:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So just like PDCA or Plan Brief F2 Debrief are are cycles that you could put to improve your understanding of the environment, understanding of yourself.
- 1:21:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, I'm gonna share a few things with you just to make some interesting connections that I'm noticing.
- 1:21:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 1:21:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so this popped up.
- 1:21:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh uh, you know, I have some AI capability here that uh so Boyd actually was looking at some um papers from the CIA, and uh I'm not sure if you're familiar with that, but he's just pointing out that uh he wrote in the margins that the authors cannot tell the ambigu tell ambiguity from deception.
- 1:21:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So he's criticizing some things that he saw inside of uh the CIA's papers.
- 1:21:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Good call.
- 1:21:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and so he I I have it here.
- 1:21:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is just uh I can send this to you if you want to take a peek at this.
- 1:21:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um There's something that he he wrote called the strategic game of question mark and question mark.
- 1:22:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The question marks are isolation, interaction, and isolation.
- 1:22:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, so that's a strategic that's a game we're all playing.
- 1:22:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And he goes into a lot of depth on that as far as uh uh you know what is um moral, physical, mental, that aspect of of warfare look like.
- 1:22:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um but one thing he does say is um a deceiver does not paint the false picture.
- 1:22:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's they're they're painting something for you.
- 1:22:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh he arranges a few features and lets the other man's orientation do the painting.
- 1:22:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when you get inside somebody's OODA loop, that's what that means is we're getting inside their orientation.
- 1:22:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um think of it as uh setting the stage, right?
- 1:22:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what we want to do there.
- 1:22:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and then uh something else he comes back up with is uh you got to look at things from several sides, through several channels.
- 1:22:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what you're saying through the holistic approach, is you're not just taking the one um body reading, uh monitoring heart rate or anything like that.
- 1:22:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're looking at it through many channels, and that's the holistic view.
- 1:23:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's what Boyd puts up here.
- 1:23:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And he says a lie has to hold up from every angle at once, right?
- 1:23:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh it's if you're gonna say something, it's gotta be uh it's gotta hold up from different points of view.
- 1:23:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh something else I want to ask you about, and that's telling a story backwards.
- 1:23:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when we talk about complex facilitation techniques, we like to have people tell stories backwards uh because it's harder to lie, it's hard to make up stuff.
- 1:23:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you ever come across anything like that?
- 1:23:31Kent Clizbe: I've heard of that as sort of an an interview interrogation technique.
- 1:23:36Kent Clizbe: Uh I've never used it myself.
- 1:23:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's fascinating because we so when we when we use, we call it the future backwards.
- 1:23:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you start with the desired future states, good, bad, ugly, however you want to call it, and have them work backwards in time to the current uh where they are today.
- 1:23:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And same thing, where you are today, work backwards from there, going all the way back in time.
- 1:23:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right, it's hard to do, but it's it it's it's it's system, you know, it's a system one, system two challenge there.
- 1:24:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We want to slow your thinking down a little bit.
- 1:24:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's so some of the tools that we've learned from, I believe, good research shows us how to use it in facilitation techniques.
- 1:24:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I just wondered if you ever saw facilitation as in facilitating uh learning or like workshops, yeah.
- 1:24:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:24:17Speaker 5: Yeah.
- 1:24:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh I was absolutely shocked when I heard, I don't want to say shocked.
- 1:24:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Pete Blair, he and I recorded last week, and uh we'll push this episode out here soon.
- 1:24:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But it when he talked about interrogation and and uh using ecological approach to understanding interrogation techniques uh on another podcast, I was like, man, I didn't I didn't know that these things were all connected like this.
- 1:24:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's a there's a lot we're all learning from having these conversations that interesting.
- 1:24:44Kent Clizbe: Yeah, it's well, you know, sort of coincidentally, uh one of one of the many sort of professions or specialties that I've had is uh when I I did uh English as a second language was to be an English teacher, uh teach English as a second language, which led to me becoming a teacher, which led to what once the ESL part of my career was pretty much finished, I I decided that I could build on that teaching experience in as an instructional designer.
- 1:25:16Kent Clizbe: So I I did one of my graduate programs was instructional systems design, which led to I I've I've I've done almost as much as in and in instructional design as I have in espionage and intelligence.
- 1:25:31Kent Clizbe: But one of the skill sets I have that are related to that is facilitation.
- 1:25:36Kent Clizbe: And I'm What's the connection?
- 1:25:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's the connection here?
- 1:25:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's the connection here?
- 1:25:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is fascinating.
- 1:25:41Kent Clizbe: What what of what?
- 1:25:42Kent Clizbe: In Intel and ISD?
- 1:25:43Kent Clizbe: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:25:44Kent Clizbe: None.
- 1:25:45Kent Clizbe: None.
- 1:25:46Kent Clizbe: There's no connection at all.
- 1:25:47Kent Clizbe: Are you sure?
- 1:25:48Kent Clizbe: Well, officially, no.
- 1:25:50Kent Clizbe: You know, they the Intel community doesn't look at look at ISD and say, oh wow, what a great skill set.
- 1:25:56Kent Clizbe: We can use that.
- 1:25:57Kent Clizbe: But I do.
- 1:25:59Kent Clizbe: It's it it has been extremely helpful in you know, I I had already done ISD uh graduate work and and worked as an ISD when I joined the CIA.
- 1:26:11Kent Clizbe: So I found it very useful that that approach uh instructional systems development helped me in in looking at people's it it helped me in developing the the way I approach the what became HCCA, you know, you know, in credibility, in listening, in uh facilitating conversations, in you know, it it's all it was all very useful.
- 1:26:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, it's actually I I want to talk about this for a minute because this is fascinating.
- 1:26:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the the traditional way of teaching or the way we understand teaching is a didactic approach, PowerPoints, lectures, and all that.
- 1:26:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That doesn't work.
- 1:26:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's not what we're talking about.
- 1:26:52Kent Clizbe: That's right.
- 1:26:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If I understand what you're saying is in structural design, ISD, and the connection to what we just went over is that it's contextual, right?
- 1:27:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We look at the context, we look at the orientation, the disposition of the people or person we're training or coaching, and we figure out ways to get to the desired outcomes that we're looking for, right?
- 1:27:13Kent Clizbe: You identify those outcomes first, you you you analyze so so there the the the the the mantra, the guiding uh approach to ISD is ADI A D D I E.
- 1:27:27Kent Clizbe: Analyze, design, develop, implement, and evaluate.
- 1:27:32Kent Clizbe: And that's what you do.
- 1:27:34Kent Clizbe: At the end of you you the analysis is looking at the whole context, the people, the subject matter, and the the output of the analysis is uh learning objectives.
- 1:27:48Kent Clizbe: At the end of this you know, now we've done the analysis.
- 1:27:51Kent Clizbe: Uh if if a learning activity is is what is required or is what can meet our needs, then what What is that what is it that we want to come out of the learning activity?
- 1:28:03Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:28:03Kent Clizbe: At the end of this activity, the learner will be able to fill in the blank.
- 1:28:08Kent Clizbe: Now you feed that learning objective into development and you develop activities that guide the learners to achieve that objective.
- 1:28:19Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:28:20Kent Clizbe: That's design.
- 1:28:22Kent Clizbe: Develop is you you take the design into whatever technical solution is used.
- 1:28:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm wondering, uh have you followed anything from ecological psychology, ecological dynamics, and anything known as the constraints-led approach?
- 1:28:37Kent Clizbe: Probably when I was in grad school, but uh it it does I don't I couldn't quote it.
- 1:28:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's it's uh the big thing today is constraints-led approach.
- 1:28:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's an ecological approach, kind of like Addy, I'd say it's uh the next evolution of that.
- 1:28:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So nonlinear pedagogy.
- 1:28:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we want to create the conditions, the context for the learner, the performer, the agent to do the actions that we want.
- 1:28:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So think about sport.
- 1:29:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In sport, when you dribble around a basketball cone or a cone, do you ever see that during a basketball game?
- 1:29:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The answer is no, you don't, right?
- 1:29:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So why do we create why do we create those games that have nothing to do with the game itself?
- 1:29:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you want to create representative design, right?
- 1:29:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What is the thing that we're actually going to experience?
- 1:29:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do we create for that in a small-sided game or an environment?
- 1:29:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's the same thing we do with like like uh we call it Flow Learning Lab.
- 1:29:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We use a simulation that is about making decisions under uncertainty.
- 1:29:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So people have different pieces of information and we observe them and we design things around what they need to do.
- 1:29:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So they they're actually helping co-create the learning environment as we go.
- 1:29:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The hard thing about that is when you sell that to anybody, that's not what they know, right?
- 1:29:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Their context is, well, I'm I want to know what you're gonna teach me in minute one through 10, through 20, or through 40.
- 1:29:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're like, well, that's I don't know.
- 1:29:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's not learning.
- 1:29:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's gotta be a connection here.
- 1:29:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm just trying to probe with you and see.
- 1:30:01Kent Clizbe: I mean, they what you're describing is is instructional design.
- 1:30:04Kent Clizbe: It's uh it's using different words.
- 1:30:07Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:30:07Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:30:08Kent Clizbe: Uh you know, there's I I but but there's really no they they're they're like parallel trains that don't really cross.
- 1:30:17Kent Clizbe: Yeah, they don't really meet.
- 1:30:19Kent Clizbe: They're you know, instructional design and human intelligence are dealing with very similar sort of raw material, yeah.
- 1:30:27Kent Clizbe: But but they they don't really although they do kind of cross every now and then.
- 1:30:33Kent Clizbe: No, it's fascinating.
- 1:30:34Kent Clizbe: I I can tell you that my my background in instructional design was just as useful to me in recruiting human sources of foreign intelligence as a foreign language and and uh foreign cultural context was.
- 1:30:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:30:50Kent Clizbe: Yeah.
- 1:30:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, and that's that's why we want to look at uh, you know, we want to be generalists and look across all the domains out there and bring them together.
- 1:30:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Whereas the uh specialists, they're they're looking down one domain and they they can't see the other things that that we're all seeing.
- 1:31:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Absolutely.
- 1:31:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think I think that's what makes a good uh in in your case a good agent is is the cross-cutting approach to understanding how systems work.
- 1:31:13Kent Clizbe: Aaron Ross Powell What wide contextual competence is the way I would describe that.
- 1:31:18Kent Clizbe: Wide competence in many unrelated contexts that then become useful in the job.
- 1:31:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Aaron Ross Powell Yep.
- 1:31:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yep.
- 1:31:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's that's what Boyd did he went and looked at all these disparate ideas and brought them all together and said, this is how things kind of work.
- 1:31:36Kent Clizbe: Interesting.
- 1:31:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So yeah, by the way, just so you know, the the military taught us all the wrong ODA loop in in the night in 1996 and a little bit before then.
- 1:31:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh and that's the kind of thing we're trying to correct is hey, if you understand this a little bit better, we'll have greater access to things like our conversation we just had today.
- 1:31:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll get into cognitive warfare, which we had a lot of conversations on.
- 1:31:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've had some human folks on here that that brought up, just like you, hey, I'm I'm not a researcher academic, I'm an operator, and what they're saying in a in academia is not true, right?
- 1:32:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh just wondering, anything else you want to wrap up with today before we uh sign off?
- 1:32:10Kent Clizbe: Uh I don't know.
- 1:32:11Kent Clizbe: Pro uh interesting.
- 1:32:14Kent Clizbe: I I mean I I don't know if you've seen uh my my other area that I I have since I've gotten out and been able to spend time researching and looking back at history.
- 1:32:24Kent Clizbe: I did mention the CI cases uh of failures of of deception detection credibility assessment.
- 1:32:33Kent Clizbe: Is I also now now I call myself pretty much a historian of of intelligence.
- 1:32:39Kent Clizbe: I'm right now I'm in I'm in the middle of a biography, doing the research for a biography, but it's based on the last uh another book that I did called Willing Accomplices, which I went back as a as a human intelligence covert influence operator, went back and looked at how the the the Bolsheviks, the Soviet Union, uh targeted the common turn, Communist International specifically, targeted the rest of the world, including the I I just focused on the United States for covert influence.
- 1:33:16Kent Clizbe: You know, now you call it cognitive warfare, but it's covert influence, active they call it active measures, we call it what we call it, but covert influence uh and and operations.
- 1:33:28Kent Clizbe: So I I identified the operations that are running against us, I identified the operators, how they did it, and I give uh case studies of specific assets that they recruited and inserted in our in our I call them the transmission belts of our culture, Hollywood, the media and academia and education.
- 1:33:51Kent Clizbe: They focused on those specifically.
- 1:33:54Kent Clizbe: But after in the course of doing that research, I identified one guy nobody had ever really identified as as an operator, as a uh a covert influence agent before.
- 1:34:07Kent Clizbe: So I'm I'm in the middle of I've I've gathered all the the uh I've done the the the get evidence gathering.
- 1:34:16Kent Clizbe: I'm assessing and evaluating now uh for writing this book on the guy's name is uh Alexander Gumberg.
- 1:34:24Kent Clizbe: Um so covert influence, uh cognitive warfare is another one of my specialties.
- 1:34:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, this is great.
- 1:34:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we've uh we've had four or five episodes recently, and one of the connections that we learned from Oriane Cohen, Oriane, Orianne Cohen, who's French, is uh the connection between cognitive warfare where it first came from the the the I guess work at Coint was a U.S.
- 1:34:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Air Force major writing about cybernetics and reflexive control.
- 1:34:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm hopefully I get I'm saying that right.
- 1:34:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I might be wrong on that.
- 1:34:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But reflexive control of cybernetics, the connection, the Soviets had a different approach than we did with cybernetics.
- 1:34:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Reflexive control sounds like, and I'm I'm not certain about this, but covert influences and things like that.
- 1:35:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So have you come across any cybernetics, reflexive control theory?
- 1:35:09Kent Clizbe: That's that's so that sounds like probably sixties and seventies kind of I think so, yeah.
- 1:35:13Kent Clizbe: So you're a little bit before then, or I'm I'm I start 1917 and and go up to 33.
- 1:35:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, okay.
- 1:35:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is not new.
- 1:35:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, this has been going on for Oh yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:35:24Kent Clizbe: There there were others doing it before the the Soviets did it, but the Soviets and What am I getting at?
- 1:35:31John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple then.
- 1:35:33John R. Boyd: There is no layout.
- 1:35:34John R. Boyd: Unless we can eliminate the feature just cited.
- 1:35:42John R. Boyd: Well, we don't know how to do this.
- 1:35:44John R. Boyd: There is no layout.
- 1:35:54Kent Clizbe: In fact, the the British, the English were masters of the covert influence against us for both World War I and World War II.
- 1:36:03Kent Clizbe: They had massive operations, cognitive warfare, I call it covert influence, but dragging us into their wars.
- 1:36:11Kent Clizbe: And and the Soviets learned from them and made it e much, even much better.
- 1:36:16Kent Clizbe: The the English were kind of like beaten with a very heavy hammer.
- 1:36:20Kent Clizbe: They were effective, but they weren't too uh they they weren't very nuanced about it.
- 1:36:26Kent Clizbe: The Soviets were very nuanced and uh very effective as well.
- 1:36:31unknown: Yeah.
- 1:36:32Kent Clizbe: So yeah, it's been going on for a long time.
- 1:36:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've been pushing back on the uh you know the cognitive warfare moniker.
- 1:36:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just you know, we're I I'm in Norfolk, Virginia, not too far from that where NATO is, ACT.
- 1:36:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you know, they push a lot of cognitive warfare stuff out there and they get the OODA loop wrong all the time.
- 1:36:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it just frustrates me.
- 1:36:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, you you guys know that if you if you're gonna talk about this, it might be useful if you use a you use the correct one.
- 1:36:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Interesting.
- 1:36:55Kent Clizbe: But sorry, I I didn't want to bring up anything too off topic, but just relatively related.
- 1:37:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, it is it's very related.
- 1:37:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh this is awesome.
- 1:37:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Love to have you back, man.
- 1:37:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's so much more we can dive into for sure.
- 1:37:08unknown: Yeah.
- 1:37:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What do you got?
- 1:37:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What do you got coming up next, other than the book?
- 1:37:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Anything exciting?
- 1:37:12Kent Clizbe: No, no.
- 1:37:12Kent Clizbe: I I am totally immersed in this book.
- 1:37:15Kent Clizbe: So I'm doing research and I I've I've been out to the all the archives.
- 1:37:19Kent Clizbe: I probably have to go to the Library of Congress one more time, gather some stuff, but now I'm sitting at my desk uh processing processing archives.
- 1:37:30Kent Clizbe: So I I'm available anytime you want to chat again.
- 1:37:32Kent Clizbe: Let me know.
- 1:37:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And how can our listeners find you?
- 1:37:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's the best way to get in contact with you?
- 1:37:37Kent Clizbe: KentClisby.com.
- 1:37:39Kent Clizbe: That's easy.
- 1:37:40Kent Clizbe: Yeah, pretty much there there's links there uh to my books, to stuff I've done.
- 1:37:47Kent Clizbe: My my email is Kent at KentClisby.com.
- 1:37:51Kent Clizbe: You're welcome to drop me a note if anybody has questions, comments, criticisms.
- 1:37:56Kent Clizbe: Awesome.
- 1:37:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right, I tell you what, I'm gonna keep you on here for a moment, but we'll wrap it up there.
- 1:38:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks for uh tuning in, everybody.
- 1:38:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: See you next time.
- 1:38:03Kent Clizbe: Thanks, Punch.
- 1:38:04Kent Clizbe: Thank you.
- 1:38:04Kent Clizbe: Thanks, everyone.
- 1:38:06John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 1:38:07John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, then.
- 1:38:09John R. Boyd: There is no layout.
- 1:38:10John R. Boyd: Well, problem though, we don't know how to do this.