Latest / The Last Known: True Crime, Missing Women & Unsolved Mysteries / The Silent House on the Hill: The Villisca Axe Murders | The Last Known
Transcript
- Eight people were alive at nine-thirty that Sunday night, laughing in a church hall. By morning, the only sound left was the wind rattling against windows covered in blankets. Let’s start with the light. Not the darkness that would soon fall, but the warmth of a perfect Iowa evening in June. It is the night of June 9th, 1912. The town of Villisca is quiet, settling into the kind of stillness that feels safe. Josiah Moore and his wife Sarah are getting ready for bed. They are parents to four children: Herman, ten; Mary Katherine, eight; Arthur, six; and little Paul, just five. They are an affluent family, well-liked, respected. Their home stands as a testament to their standing in the community. But safety is fragile. That evening, two young girls, Ina May Stillinger and her sister Lena Gertrude, came over to stay the night. They had attended the Children’s Day Program at the Presbyterian church, coordinated by Sarah herself. At nine-thirty, the service ended. The Moores and the Stillinger sisters walked home together, arriving between nine-forty-five and ten. The front door closed. The lights went out. Inside, eight hearts beat in the dark. They did not know that the silence here was about to become loud. We don’t know exactly when it happened. We only know it was after they slept, and before the sun rose. But the house tells us something chilling about patience. In the attic, investigators would later find two spent cigarettes. Someone had been up there. Waiting. Watching. Patiently waiting until the Moore family and the Stillinger guests were asleep. This wasn’t a crime of passion in the heat of the moment. This was calculated. The killer or killers descended from that dark space above the bedrooms. They began in the master bedroom, where Josiah and Sarah slept. Josiah received more blows than any other victim. The violence was so severe that his face was cut to such an extent that his eyes were completely destroyed. There is even a gouge mark on the ceiling, left when the murderer lifted the axe to strike him. Think about that image. The geometry of that violence. The height required. The force. Then, the killer moved to the children’s room. Herman, Mary Katherine, Arthur, and Paul. All bludgeoned in the head. Same manner. Same weapon. The murderer returned to the master bedroom one last time, inflicting more blows on the elder Mooers, before moving downstairs to the guest room. Where Ina and Lena lay. Every mirror in the house was covered with blankets or clothing. Garments removed from dressers to hide the glass. Why cover the mirrors? Was it superstition? Or was it a desire to erase reflection? To leave no trace of self? Most of them never woke up. Investigators believed all victims except Lena Stillinger were asleep when murdered. But Lena fought back. She was found lying crosswise on the bed, a defensive wound on her arm. Her nightgown had been pushed up, leaving her exposed. Her leg positioned in a way that revealed her genitalia. Law enforcement at the time speculated that the killer had sexually molested her or attempted to. Later investigations showed no evidence of this physical act, but the violation remains part of the scene’s horror. A 4 lb slab of bacon was taken from the icebox and laid next to the axe. Bloodied water sat on the kitchen table. Untouched food remained. The killer had time. Time to eat? Time to wait? Time to stage? The murder weapon, an axe belonging to Josiah Moore himself, was found in the guest room where the girls died. An axe used to destroy the very family that owned it. The intimacy of that betrayal is hard to comprehend. You use the tool of your own household to end its lineage. It is a desecration of domestic life itself. At seven in the morning, neighbor Mary Peckham noticed something wrong. The Moores had not come out to do their morning chores. Concerned, she knocked. No answer. She tried the door. Locked. Peckham let the chickens out—a small act of care in a growing dread—and called Ross Moore, Josiah’s brother. Ross arrived, knocked, shouted. No response. He unlocked the front door with his key. While Peckham stood on the porch, holding her breath, Ross went into the parlor. He opened the guest bedroom door. He saw Ina and Lena Stillinger’s bodies on the bed. He immediately told Peckham to call Henry Horton, Villisca’s primary peace officer. Horton arrived. His search of the house revealed the full scope of the nightmare. The entire Moore family and the two Stillinger girls had been bludgeoned to death. Eight lives extinguished. When the news broke, the town reacted with a chaos that would haunt the investigation forever. Around eight-forty, the central telephone office issued an 'all call' alert. Within minutes, townspeople began crowding into the house. They wanted to see. They wanted to know. But in their curiosity, they contaminated the scene. Some even stole pieces of Josiah’s skull as souvenirs. The murder weapon was handled by hundreds. The sheriff could not gain control for hours. Evidence vanished into pockets and palms. The crime scene was lost before science could even begin to speak. The investigation yielded several suspects, but none stuck. Early focus fell on local men. George Judd was arrested, but released due to lack of evidence and alibi witnesses. Leslie Williams was also arrested in 1912, but again, insufficient evidence linked him directly to the crime scene. The case grew cold, yet it never truly froze. In 1915, insurance investigator William G. King identified Joseph Mann as a prime suspect. Mann had recently collected life insurance policies for the Moores. A motive of greed? Perhaps. Mann and his wife Sarah were arrested in 1916. They stood trial. But the trial collapsed. Key physical evidence had been mishandled. Witness credibility was compromised by the initial contamination of the scene. Both were acquitted. The system failed to deliver justice. Decades later, theories emerged implicating local figures like Dr. Henry Burdett, or even a traveling salesman. But none have been proven in court. No definitive confession. No conclusive physical evidence. The case remains officially unsolved. The Villisca Axe Murder House stands today as a historic site, listed on the National Register of Historic Places. But for those who listen closely, it is not a museum piece. It is a grave. And the silence inside is deafening. Justice isn’t just an outcome; it’s a presence. And in Villisca, that presence has been absent for over a century. We often think of true crime as a puzzle to be solved, a box to be checked. But here, we must remember that these were real people. Josiah and Sarah. Herman, Mary Katherine, Arthur, and Paul. Ina and Lena. They loved each other. They attended church together. They shared meals. They lived ordinary, beautiful lives until a night of extraordinary evil interrupted them. The failure of the investigation—the looting of the scene, the loss of evidence—adds a second layer of violence to the tragedy. It robbed the families of closure. It robbed history of truth. When we look back at 1912, we see a community traumatized, yes, but also a legal system ill-equipped for the complexities of forensic science. Today, we have DNA. We have better protocols. We have a deeper understanding of trauma. Yet, the names remain unresolved. Josiah B. Moore, aged forty-three. Sarah, aged thirty-nine. The children, ranging from five to eleven. Two visitors, eight and eleven. Let’s remember their names. Let’s honor their memory not by sensationalizing the gore, but by acknowledging the void left behind. The silence here is loud because no one has ever answered it fully. Thank you for listening. Thank you for bearing witness to the Moores and the Stillingers. I’m Teresa Howarth. This story is drawn from public records and widely reported accounts. Our thoughts are with everyone affected.