Latest / Raising Men / Why Boys Need Controlled Fear with Dr. Randolph B. Schiffer
Transcript
- 0:00what is the right way to to deal with that
- 0:03well I'll remind us all that fear is built in to
- 0:07to children uh
- 0:09all infants and young toddlers uh
- 0:12are fearful sometimes they just come that way
- 0:14however courage the
- 0:17the capacity to speak
- 0:20think and act in spite of our fears
- 0:22that is not built in we have no courageous infants
- 0:25or young toddlers that I ever saw
- 0:28that has to be Learned
- 0:37welcome back to raising men
- 0:39in a parenting culture that often defaults
- 0:43to protecting children from discomfort
- 0:47we might be missing an opportunity
- 0:49to help them build real resilience
- 0:52Doctor Randolph Schiffer he's a neurologist
- 0:55former Marine and the founding director of
- 0:58the Cleveland Clinic's Center for Brain Health
- 1:01offers a different perspective
- 1:04that strength isn't built by avoiding fear
- 1:08but by helping children understand and move through it
- 1:12in this conversation
- 1:13we're gonna explore how storytelling
- 1:15language and a parent's presence
- 1:17can shape how boys experience fear
- 1:20and how those early experiences influence
- 1:23the kind of men that they'll become
- 1:26Doctor Schiffer welcome to raising men
- 1:29thank you for having me Shawn
- 1:31so most parents I think
- 1:34and I'm definitely one of them
- 1:36instinctively want to protect their boys from fear
- 1:41right and we say don't be afraid or when
- 1:44when a child is scared but as a neurologist what
- 1:47you know what is actually happening in a boy's brain
- 1:51when they experience fear
- 1:53and when we tell them to suppress it
- 1:55rather than process it
- 1:58um what happens
- 2:00I think that you're correct
- 2:01we have kind of a parent mythology now
- 2:05that we need to protect all our children
- 2:08boys and girls from upsetting experiences
- 2:12fearful situations difficult topics
- 2:15uh like death
- 2:17whatever uh drugs
- 2:19sex uh
- 2:21and as a there are consequences for this
- 2:23and I think they're for boys and girls
- 2:25all their boys and girls are different
- 2:27but the consequences in my view
- 2:29are that we have now a fearful society in itself
- 2:34these are tangible results
- 2:36there are um
- 2:39I mean I can give
- 2:40what are we afraid of
- 2:41I think we're afraid of so many things now
- 2:44we're afraid of failure
- 2:48responsibility development of responsibility
- 2:51the capacity to say
- 2:53there has been a terrible mistake here
- 2:58and I am responsible this
- 3:00I can just I can tell we're afraid of death
- 3:04the wellness movement now is uh
- 3:06widespread and to for
- 3:09to that
- 3:10all Americans
- 3:11are assumed to want to prolong their lives uh
- 3:14without regard for whether it's a good life or not
- 3:17I think we're afraid of life itself
- 3:20suicide rates have risen 40% over the last 20 years
- 3:24at all ages I'll just give one example
- 3:27um
- 3:29I'm coming back I'm not forgetting the brains
- 3:31but I'm coming back to I'm just
- 3:33the context here of what what the results are
- 3:36in the area I know best in medicine
- 3:40the consequences of this uh
- 3:43new kind of parenting
- 3:45protecting the children from upsetting
- 3:47fearful dramas uh
- 3:50experiences we now have young doctors
- 3:55a major medical center one of the top in the country
- 3:58not mentioning the name
- 4:00where in the internal medicine department
- 4:02the residents
- 4:03the first year doctors are afraid to be on call
- 4:07and so they're not on call
- 4:09they never get the call in that first year
- 4:12from the emergency room doctor you
- 4:16wow you have to come
- 4:17you better come down here because we have this problem
- 4:20or that they're protected from that
- 4:23and um
- 4:24as a result
- 4:27well the long term outcomes
- 4:28I think are
- 4:31I have consequences
- 4:34yeah that you're
- 4:36it's not that that's a framing that I
- 4:38haven't thought of before
- 4:39which is that some of what ails our culture
- 4:43and I talk a lot about
- 4:46what I consider to be a masculinity crisis and
- 4:50and
- 4:51a significant portion of that is explained
- 4:53by what you're talking about
- 4:55which is we are
- 4:58at the same time kind of stoking fear in our culture
- 5:02like through social media and
- 5:05and you know the whole engagement
- 5:10economy
- 5:11but
- 5:13but are also trying to avoid it right and
- 5:17and uh
- 5:17trying to avoid it for ourselves
- 5:18trying to avoid it for our children
- 5:20and that's that
- 5:22that's not the way the world is
- 5:26it's not the way we've evolved
- 5:27that's not necessarily healthy and
- 5:29and I think that the demands for
- 5:33some of these value development
- 5:35things are greater now on boys than girls
- 5:38because we have very powerful
- 5:41cultural ideas about what it means to be a boy
- 5:45or a girl a man or a woman
- 5:47those are changing and I think that right now
- 5:50my view of the cultural mythos
- 5:52certainly for young men
- 5:54has become almost impossibly difficult
- 5:59because the more traditional masculine type behaviors
- 6:03leadership strength
- 6:05courage um
- 6:07implicit violence those things are still there
- 6:13although some people wish they weren't
- 6:14but now in addition
- 6:16the more traditional feminine values compassion
- 6:20conflict avoidance
- 6:22nurture nurtureance etcetera
- 6:25the young men are now expected to write poetry as well
- 6:29uh as take command of a Marine Corps platoon in combat
- 6:33hmm it's almost impossible now the
- 6:36the women have kind of
- 6:37of through the looking glass alteration 2 because now
- 6:43but I think it's less dramatic for them
- 6:45but now they are not expected
- 6:49but they have permission to develop more
- 6:52some of these traditional masculine qualities as well
- 6:55on top of the more traditional feminine roles
- 6:58but I think for the young boys
- 6:59it's more difficult
- 7:01I think so too and I think
- 7:03we do ourselves a little bit of a disservice by
- 7:06these things being associated with gender
- 7:09as strongly as they are um
- 7:12because then you have to
- 7:14then you have to go through this kind of mental
- 7:17gymnastics to
- 7:18you know explain that
- 7:21that it's not necessarily like
- 7:23like men can exhibit traditionally female qualities
- 7:27and women can exhibit traditionally
- 7:30masculine qualities and
- 7:31and it's it's just a shame that we don't have
- 7:35gender neutral ways of expressing those things
- 7:38um
- 7:40but but
- 7:41but yeah I mean there's
- 7:43there is a a challenge
- 7:45and an opportunity for us to experience the world
- 7:51in an in a
- 7:52in a new way by embracing what
- 7:56you know the traditional values and
- 7:58and just you could decide
- 8:00instead of society imposing those values on you
- 8:02because of your gender you could pick what you want
- 8:04but then
- 8:05that imposes upon you the responsibility to pick well
- 8:09and I think that we're doing that first thing
- 8:12our culture is thrusting us into the position of oh
- 8:16okay well
- 8:16you know the
- 8:17the the traditional
- 8:19um the
- 8:20the traditional roles are no longer valid
- 8:23so pick what you want and that's freedom
- 8:26that's great and then
- 8:27but we're not
- 8:30embracing the responsibility of doing that well
- 8:32and I I
- 8:33I think that's kind of the
- 8:35that's the illness that is happening there and
- 8:40yeah so going back to the notion of fear
- 8:44what is a better way you know
- 8:48when my daughter is comes to me
- 8:52and she's claiming to be afraid of
- 8:57just being in her room alone right
- 9:00what
- 9:01how how
- 9:02what what is the right way to
- 9:04to deal with that well
- 9:07I'll remind us all that fear is built in to
- 9:10to children uh
- 9:12all infants and young toddlers uh
- 9:14are fearful sometimes they just come that way
- 9:17however courage
- 9:19the uh capacity to
- 9:22speak think and act in spite of our fears
- 9:25that is not built in we have no courageous infants
- 9:28or young toddlers that I ever saw
- 9:31that has to be Learned
- 9:33and I think that's Learned uh
- 9:36from the parents or grown UPS around them
- 9:39through several mechanisms
- 9:41one is modeling we demonstrate
- 9:44they know who we are
- 9:46we show them how we respond to fears
- 9:49um and a key thing there is
- 9:51I think many of us as parents have
- 9:54now
- 9:54you're mentioning your daughter talking about her fears
- 9:58uh I won't personalize this
- 9:59but how many of us parents
- 10:02have talked with our children about our fears
- 10:05so that they can see that we too
- 10:08are afraid of things and see how we process them
- 10:11so that's kind of an identification process
- 10:13it goes on for about 50 years
- 10:16they learn from us how to deal with um
- 10:20man that's such a powerful statement
- 10:22and I one of the
- 10:25just constant refrains in this whole project has been
- 10:28that 80% of it is modeling
- 10:32whatever it is you're trying to impart to your
- 10:34to your to your kids 80% of it is modeling yes
- 10:38and but I'm I'm in spite of that
- 10:40and in spite of being very aware of that
- 10:43it's never occurred to me
- 10:45that I need to be
- 10:47talking to my kids explicitly about my own fears
- 10:50or that was a way to handle
- 10:51so I have this interesting
- 10:53reoccurring situation going on with my daughter
- 10:56which is why I brought it up
- 10:57and she's going she's 4 years old
- 11:00and she's going through a phase where
- 11:03it feels to me like she is trying
- 11:07to manipulate me using fear
- 11:11she knows that
- 11:13claiming to be afraid of things is a way to get me to
- 11:19respond
- 11:21and and so you know
- 11:23I she recognizes that if I tell her to go into her room
- 11:29by herself that she can say
- 11:33I'm scared and I now have to do something
- 11:38she she recognizes this
- 11:41but it feels to me like pure manipulation
- 11:45I don't I don't know if she's
- 11:46I don't think she's actually scared
- 11:48but she might be but I also think she to the extent
- 11:52she is actually scared she's manufacturing the fear
- 11:54and I'm really at a loss to do what I to
- 11:56to figure out what to do about that
- 11:58and I know there is a productive way to handle it
- 12:01but I don't know what that is
- 12:04and go ahead
- 12:06so you think she is um
- 12:09creating special father time with herself
- 12:12by these behaviors then you come into the room with her
- 12:15in this case it's usually when
- 12:18when she's been acting out
- 12:20and she's going to her room to take a break
- 12:23and she's trying to avoid punishment
- 12:25parenting is the most difficult task in our lives
- 12:28it's more difficult than marriage
- 12:29it's more difficult than work
- 12:31and we all make mistakes we do
- 12:32but I would what I
- 12:34what I have been working on
- 12:36and thinking about is stories
- 12:38and storytelling because
- 12:40in addition to identification processes
- 12:43with the adults and the parents
- 12:45children learn from the stories
- 12:46about who our heroes are how they process fear
- 12:51how their courage comes into play
- 12:54their conflicts their failures
- 12:56and so I think so called bedtime stories
- 12:59and I've written this book
- 13:01bedtime stories I love to get into this
- 13:03this is great so uh
- 13:05the figures the heroic figures in the stories
- 13:09stay with us to the very end
- 13:12and the nice thing
- 13:12the good thing is you can craft the stories to fit your
- 13:17your children and yourself so that they fit
- 13:20but if the stories are told
- 13:23children love stories well
- 13:24so do grown UPS um
- 13:26if the lead figures
- 13:28the heroes in the story are shown to overcome fear
- 13:32frustration whatever
- 13:33and develop positive skills courage responsibility
- 13:39respect for others uh
- 13:41those figures from the story stay with them forever
- 13:45all two our
- 13:46our two boys now age 40 and 38
- 13:48they still talk about some of the figures from the book
- 13:52I love that yeah
- 13:53so your bed
- 13:54your book is called Bedtime Stories
- 13:57that will Terrify Children right
- 14:00and so why why is that such a powerful way
- 14:06a powerful training ground for
- 14:09for the nervous system there
- 14:11well um
- 14:12remember the um
- 14:13memory systems and the fearful systems in the brain
- 14:17are colocated deep in the brain
- 14:21medial temporal lobes above the brain stem hypothalamic
- 14:25uh
- 14:26I mean if you have any doubt about memory
- 14:29and emotional arousal being connected
- 14:32uh we don't want to personalize this too much
- 14:34but if we think now at our age
- 14:36it's very difficult to meet people
- 14:38and remember their names but not
- 14:41if the person you meet is particularly obnoxious
- 14:44or particularly attractive
- 14:46those names are with us in a second
- 14:48because the emotional arousal
- 14:50it's probably neurological
- 14:51inside the medial temporal lobes
- 14:53just locks those all together
- 14:55so with the bedtime stories
- 14:57if they're told right
- 14:58and the stories and the figures are captivating
- 15:01they'll stay with these children forever
- 15:03they are legacy uh
- 15:05to the children and the
- 15:07the book that I wrote is told in the voice of a father
- 15:12who has but one year to live
- 15:14hmm
- 15:16so the stories are his legacy to the two boys
- 15:22uh about his values and what he thinks are um
- 15:27the important things in life
- 15:29and the children are in the stories too
- 15:31and the father's in the story
- 15:33so that's another you
- 15:34that's one way to make sure that there's engagement
- 15:38if you put the child and yourself into the stories
- 15:40in ways they really like that
- 15:43yeah are you uh is
- 15:46is the book geared towards a particular age range
- 15:49of kids um
- 15:53uh you know I the
- 15:54the truth is I don't know
- 15:56I think it's more a book for parents than for children
- 15:58now it can be read as uh
- 16:02suspenseful dramatic stories
- 16:04bedtime stories for children
- 16:06it can be read that way but I think fundamentally
- 16:08it's about if our time is limited with our children
- 16:13which it is for all of us
- 16:15but what if it were just one year
- 16:18what stories would we tell them
- 16:21yeah I've
- 16:22I love that sentiment
- 16:23I used to tell stories um to my kids
- 16:30at bedtime and I
- 16:32I still do but um
- 16:34but it's it's less common now for some reason and um
- 16:39I would make up the stories
- 16:40yeah and they would all start the same way
- 16:44so I started this with my son and and
- 16:46and he was he was in the story
- 16:48so it was uh
- 16:50once upon a time there was a little boy named Lake
- 16:54and he had two dogs named Penguin and chicken
- 16:57and then one day something happened and he would
- 17:02lake would just
- 17:04he loved these stories and he would beg me for stories
- 17:07and there were so many times at the end of a long day
- 17:12where I was mentally exhausted
- 17:15and just I
- 17:17I really had a difficult time coming up with a novel
- 17:20story
- 17:22and um
- 17:25sometimes I gave into that and man
- 17:28I just too tired to come up with story today
- 17:30but most of the time I I
- 17:31I tried to push through it
- 17:32and I would normally be successful
- 17:34you know to some degree
- 17:35some of the stories were really good
- 17:36some of them weren't
- 17:38and
- 17:40finally I
- 17:41once I I intimated to a friend
- 17:43who had a son about the same age as mine
- 17:47and I said man
- 17:47you know how do you deal with this
- 17:50and uh
- 17:51and he goes you know
- 17:52you don't he doesn't know any stories
- 17:55you don't have to make them all up
- 17:58and he goes he goes
- 18:00like I'll just tell Cinderella as if I made it up
- 18:04and it never even occurred to me
- 18:06that I could plagiarize other people's stories
- 18:09and pretend that they were my own
- 18:12when telling my kids stories
- 18:14and I eventually decided not to do that
- 18:18because we kind of
- 18:20have this principle that we don't lie to our kids
- 18:23about anything
- 18:24it's I
- 18:25don't know it's very similar to
- 18:26to what you're saying
- 18:27like we need to be able to confront hard truths
- 18:29and as parents it's our duty to figure out how to
- 18:32do that in an age appropriate way
- 18:34um but uh
- 18:37but I just thought that was an interesting
- 18:38interesting little point that my buddy made
- 18:41like you don't have to make up every story
- 18:43you can tell stories that have already been made up
- 18:46well here's what I say about lying
- 18:48um cause I used to lie to my patients sometimes too
- 18:52interesting a lie is a deliberate
- 18:55alteration or adjustment of truth or facts
- 19:00that is self serving
- 19:02if the time should come
- 19:04that some adjustment of what we tell our children
- 19:08or our patients uh
- 19:09which is not true is done genuinely for their benefit
- 19:14that's not a lie
- 19:16interesting I yeah
- 19:18I think that that's a yeah
- 19:21that's a good way to think about it
- 19:25yeah I also I
- 19:27you know the
- 19:27it's also
- 19:29I I
- 19:29I encountered this interesting definition
- 19:32of suffering recently
- 19:35and um
- 19:37the definition is that suffering is when
- 19:42you find out that
- 19:44the map of reality that you have in your head
- 19:47is different than the actual reality on the ground
- 19:49and it's that
- 19:51disjoint that disconnect
- 19:54that is suffering
- 19:58and and so when you think about it in that lens
- 20:04the reason lying is such a problem is because it
- 20:07results in suffering right
- 20:08you you are
- 20:10you are creating that disconnect
- 20:12or you are allowing it to
- 20:14you're fostering that disconnect
- 20:17but what you're what you're
- 20:19what you're kind of saying there is
- 20:20there is a there is a place for
- 20:27for reducing suffering
- 20:29in allowing some of that disconnect to persevere
- 20:36you know maybe easing somebody into the transition
- 20:38into making that realization
- 20:40is that am I making sense there
- 20:42I I feel like I'm now just rambling yeah
- 20:44no I'm
- 20:45it's the idea I'm still on the stories of yeah
- 20:48telling the stories and the characters in the stories
- 20:51in a way that is good for the children at their stage
- 20:56and that's very individualized
- 20:58but the there can be uh
- 21:01children are quite comfortable with magic
- 21:04good evil spirits
- 21:06uh
- 21:07transformations of the household dog into a rabid wolf
- 21:11beast if the moon rises red in the October sky
- 21:15they're quite
- 21:15they are quite comfortable with all these things
- 21:18but I think the stories were
- 21:19the hope is to transmit heroic figures to them
- 21:24in ways that are uh
- 21:26good for them and
- 21:28and they'll give you clues about that too
- 21:30sometimes you can ask them
- 21:32you know well
- 21:33you why don't you tell the story tonight
- 21:35and then it comes from their imaginations
- 21:37which are which are very creative or a variety
- 21:41but the transmission of these figures
- 21:45and there are figures which are not simplistic
- 21:50um timid
- 21:51fearful figures which so many children's books are now
- 21:55I think complex figures growing up
- 21:58learning to take responsibility to be courageous
- 22:02to be self reflective and figures like that
- 22:04they'll stay with these children just forever
- 22:08and um
- 22:10I can give one story about that
- 22:12um yeah
- 22:12let's hear it if I can uh
- 22:14I I'm I
- 22:15I have to be careful I
- 22:17toward the end in medicine
- 22:18I developed pathological weeping
- 22:20so I cry now so um
- 22:24so that gets in my way sometimes but um
- 22:27um that's really why I had to quit medicine
- 22:31is that right I
- 22:32I I feel like I'm in the process of developing that
- 22:36I I'm like I
- 22:38I mean the first 10% of that I
- 22:40I really find myself
- 22:44a lot more likely to cry these days than I was
- 22:47five or 10 years ago you'll see it on this podcast
- 22:50but anyway as to these figures um
- 22:52this Frank Marywell
- 22:54mythical heroic figure at Yale from the 19 or so
- 22:59always fair always kind uh
- 23:04always successful well
- 23:07one time in Vietnam I just walked around the bend
- 23:10and there were four
- 23:12North Vietnamese soldiers just standing there and um
- 23:15the rest of my patrol had gone further down
- 23:18and I thought well
- 23:20I'm gonna kill these guys
- 23:21oh my gosh so um I
- 23:25step towards them um
- 23:28to picked up the rifle to do it
- 23:30they weren't very far away and they didn't do anything
- 23:33they just stood there looking at me
- 23:34and then right in the middle of all that
- 23:37the image of Frank Marywell
- 23:39intruded into my mind and I asked myself
- 23:45would Frank Marywell
- 23:47shoot these four poor Asian guys down
- 23:51and I decided well
- 23:53in a second no
- 23:55Frank Murray wouldn't do it
- 23:56and I'm not gonna do it either
- 23:58so uh
- 23:59I went on my way they went on their way
- 24:01so that's the power of those uh
- 24:03those kind of internalized heroic figures
- 24:07wow of course it was a terrible mistake
- 24:10life punishes you for every good deed
- 24:13those guys were on a mission that was evil for us
- 24:17and which they then carried out later
- 24:20but I that part I choose to forget
- 24:23that is such a powerful story
- 24:25I
- 24:28I can't imagine being faced with that and
- 24:32wow
- 24:35you know what
- 24:38what made you decide to write this book
- 24:41the way that you did
- 24:46when our boys
- 24:49were three and one this is now 37 years ago
- 24:54the three year old developed leukemia
- 24:56a L L acute lymphocytic leukemia
- 25:02at that time
- 25:04I I
- 25:05I I took care of these children
- 25:06I was always in pediatrics
- 25:08uh uh
- 25:09uh
- 25:10for for some disease treatments
- 25:14and I knew a lot about the leukemia children
- 25:16I'd taken care of some of them that time
- 25:18that disease was 50% fatal
- 25:20um
- 25:22but of the 50% who died I knew that it
- 25:27they didn't all die from the biology of the disease
- 25:30a number of them died because they
- 25:33or their families were unable to tolerate
- 25:36the prolonged and painful treatments
- 25:39so I designed the bedtime stories
- 25:41to toughen up the older boy
- 25:45wow
- 25:48so so basically what
- 25:51what you're saying here is that
- 25:54is that like
- 25:56the storytelling was
- 25:58almost a necessary part of the treatment
- 26:00it was it was
- 26:02I mean you're sitting here faced with
- 26:04with having to to accelerate this 3 year old's ability
- 26:08to really withstand fear and pain and discomfort
- 26:15and so how did it work you know what
- 26:19what was that process like
- 26:20well he survived
- 26:22um I can't prove what role the stories had but uh
- 26:28I think they were a comfort for him
- 26:30and positive for him cause I
- 26:32of course I knew what lay ahead for him some
- 26:35so the some of the elements in the story
- 26:37they're not about well
- 26:38actually one or two of them are about sick children
- 26:41but they're about children facing difficult
- 26:45traumatic conflicts between good and evil
- 26:49doing the right thing failing even death itself
- 26:53some children
- 26:54uh in the squirrel story
- 26:56the squirrel is an evil animal
- 26:58who presides over the ragged hole in space and time
- 27:03between this world and another
- 27:05and he drags children through it
- 27:08um
- 27:10that's just what he does so um
- 27:13by the way the squirrel was the favorite character uh
- 27:16of of our boys
- 27:18so is that right
- 27:19so anyway the stories
- 27:21I figured you know
- 27:22our boy has leukemia but every child is facing
- 27:26the drama and the struggle of growing up
- 27:29and it lasts for 30 or 40 years
- 27:31so maybe all the stories are designed
- 27:34each one
- 27:35it's about a different kind of a dramatic challenge
- 27:39the squirrel it's good and evil
- 27:41life and death but there are
- 27:44there are strange there are evil goddesses that come uh
- 27:50who seek power and
- 27:53uh anyway
- 27:54so each story is different
- 27:56but I thought well maybe um
- 27:58and I tried to have them
- 27:59pick up elements of the challenge
- 28:02which lay ahead for our child with leukemia pain
- 28:06courage endurance um
- 28:09maintaining your your own self
- 28:12maintaining your your school work
- 28:14your keeping your room
- 28:15you know variety of things
- 28:17uh and I hope that those are in the stories
- 28:19and I hope that maybe you know now um
- 28:22other children
- 28:23might be interested in hearing these stories
- 28:26what was your
- 28:27what's your son's recollection of that time period
- 28:30they talk about him both of them will talk about him
- 28:33I don't ask
- 28:35you know but it comes up now and then
- 28:37they mention the squirrel
- 28:38they mention the bear
- 28:41um that's the final story
- 28:45as I say I don't unpack it with them
- 28:47but I know they're still in their minds
- 28:51yeah interesting
- 28:52yeah I mean I love this concept of
- 28:57the thought that occurred to me when
- 28:58when you were talking about the way that stories
- 29:02can be used to to convey these stories
- 29:04is that is that storytelling
- 29:07one of the reasons it's so powerful
- 29:08is because it's another form of modeling
- 29:11yes it is
- 29:13and and so
- 29:14you know I don't have to necessarily
- 29:18uh model courage directly
- 29:20I don't necessarily have to face down the lion
- 29:23in front of my kids
- 29:24in order to model that kind of courage
- 29:26I can tell stories about it instead
- 29:28or stories about other characters
- 29:29or even stories about them in situations
- 29:32and then we can talk through how to
- 29:34how to how to handle certain things and um
- 29:40I think that's really where the power is there
- 29:44yes
- 29:46I wanna touch a little bit more
- 29:47on your experience in Vietnam
- 29:50and you mentioned the the story about the the
- 29:54the 4 um
- 29:55enemies that you encountered
- 29:58um
- 29:59did that
- 30:02did did that influence your experiences in Vietnam
- 30:05how did they influence your
- 30:07the way that you think about this stuff
- 30:10well the war in Vietnam in the 1960s
- 30:14was the central fact
- 30:16in the lives of young men in this country
- 30:18in the United States yeah
- 30:20you couldn't avoid it uh
- 30:22it was so big and so long lasting
- 30:26you had to make a decision about it
- 30:28you could go with it you could go away from it
- 30:32you could go to Canada whatever
- 30:34but whatever choice you made in later years
- 30:38you'd have regrets so we were all damaged
- 30:42those of us who went those of us who avoided it
- 30:46we were all damaged by it
- 30:49we all have regrets now and one of the problems I have
- 30:52is this pathological weeping which um
- 30:56I think probably is from that
- 30:58so I didn't have it for a long time
- 31:00but then about age 60 or so
- 31:03I'd get up in medicine and in front of groups to talk
- 31:07and I just
- 31:08or people would come to see me at the Cleveland Clinic
- 31:11from far away yeah
- 31:12they'd tell their stories and I'd just start to cry
- 31:16so I had to stop but
- 31:18so I decided to go I went
- 31:22I went in the Marine Corps
- 31:23I was an infantry officer but um
- 31:26I'm scarred by it too
- 31:29yeah I can imagine
- 31:31um
- 31:32I can imagine
- 31:35Dr Shiver I always like to end these conversations um
- 31:39by asking people for a principle
- 31:42so you've got 35 years or more than that
- 31:4450 years of medicine of war
- 31:47of fatherhood
- 31:49if you could distil those experiences
- 31:51into an operating principle one
- 31:54and you know
- 31:55obviously there are many
- 31:56so you just have to give us one
- 31:58one operating principle for raising men
- 32:00of character and of courage
- 32:03what would that be
- 32:05um self curiosity
- 32:07uh that comes more easily to girls and women in my
- 32:12than to men but self curiosity about our
- 32:15about who we are and who we wish to be
- 32:19if that can be begun and nurtured and modeled
- 32:23that's the most valuable skill of all
- 32:26that's perfect
- 32:28Doctor Schiffer
- 32:29thank you so much for joining us today on
- 32:32on Raising Men thank you for your time
- 32:34thank you for sharing this uh
- 32:36this wonderful book um
- 32:38I really
- 32:39really look forward to
- 32:40to reading it and for sharing those stories
- 32:44or using them to inspire stories
- 32:46that I tell to my kids it's such a tremendous way um
- 32:51you know to model the
- 32:52the those right kind of values not
- 32:53not just courage and and not just
- 32:56you know teaching them to
- 32:57to deal with fear but also
- 32:58teaching them to deal with other kinds of difficult um
- 33:02situations I really appreciate the lesson here
- 33:05thank you for having me Sean
- 33:07and if you're listening if this episode challenged
- 33:10how you view your son's big feelings
- 33:12I encourage you to try what Doctor Shiver calls
- 33:16a safe scare this week
- 33:19put down the device
- 33:20turn down the lights and share a story that
- 33:23that matters and check out the book
- 33:26the book is called
- 33:28Bedtime Stories That Will Terrify Children
- 33:31and the link is in the show notes
- 33:34as always thank you for listening to Raising Men
- 33:37and you are a great parent
- 33:47raising men is produced by Phil Hernandez
- 33:51this episode was edited by Ralph Tolentino