Latest / Resilient Kid: Therapy and tips for raising strong kids and teens / Motivation - What Really Drives Kids/Teens and Adults
Transcript
- 0:20What drives us? What motivates our kids?
- 0:24Welcome to the Resilient Kid podcast.
- 0:26I'm Ashley Costello, psychotherapist and founder
- 0:29here. So this is the first episode in
- 0:32our miniseries on motivation. What fuels it?
- 0:35What blocks it? And also how do we build more of
- 0:39it, particularly for our kids and teens?
- 0:43So when most of us think about motivation, we picture that
- 0:47sheer willpower, don't we? Pushing harder, working longer,
- 0:52forcing ourselves to keep going. But science tells us motivation
- 0:57isn't about being a robot. It's about energy.
- 1:00It's about purpose is how our brain and body work together to
- 1:06drive us forward. And here at The Resilient Kid,
- 1:10we always start with explaining to kids and teens when we're
- 1:14working with them about how our brain works.
- 1:18So I thought today I would tell you a little bit about how
- 1:22motivation works and how our brain is involved in that.
- 1:26So let's start with the basics, intrinsic motivation, that
- 1:30internal stuff, extrinsic motivation.
- 1:34So psychology often divide it into two types.
- 1:40So extrinsic is when we do something for reward like a root
- 1:44sticker chart, money, you know, grades, praise or avoiding
- 1:51punishment. So things like if your child is
- 1:56practising the piano and they get a sticker at the end, that's
- 2:00an external extrinsic motivation.
- 2:03Intrinsic is when you do something because it feels good,
- 2:07because you're interested, because you're meaningful.
- 2:10Now we always say, don't we? We know that if it comes to
- 2:13homework, kids maybe you know, particularly teens, they'll get
- 2:17it done eventually. Give them a computer game or
- 2:22something they're really interested in.
- 2:24You don't need to know it, they are on it.
- 2:26Absolutely. So that same child that we just
- 2:31talked about playing the piano might do it just simply because
- 2:34they love listening to how it sounds when they create music.
- 2:39Both types can work, but research shows us that that
- 2:43internal intrinsic motivation is much stronger in the long run.
- 2:48And if we connect what we do with curiosity, enjoyment or
- 2:53purpose, we will stick to it and will feel better while we're at
- 2:59it. It's not such a slug.
- 3:02So let's get to the science a bit.
- 3:07What's going on inside our brains?
- 3:10Well, dopamine is talked about a huge amount at the moment, so
- 3:17it's kind of having its day in neuroscience.
- 3:21It's one of the key chemicals involved.
- 3:24Many people call it the pleasure chemical, but that's not quite
- 3:28right. Dopamine is about anticipation,
- 3:31really. It spikes when we expect
- 3:34something good, not just when we have something good.
- 3:37When we take steps towards a goal or when we see progress,
- 3:43that's when it's seen. That's why ticking off a task
- 3:49off your list feels so satisfying.
- 3:52Your brain gives you a little hit of dopamine as a reward for
- 3:56moving forward. I don't know about you, but
- 3:58sometimes I will at the end of the day, write a list of the
- 4:02things I've already done and tick them off even though
- 4:05they're done. Why am I writing them down?
- 4:07I think it is for that little dopamine hit, you know?
- 4:11Yes, I feel like even if I've still got loads on the list, I
- 4:16feel like I've achieved something.
- 4:18Another piece of the puzzle where kind of science is
- 4:23involved is self determination theory.
- 4:27It was developed by a psychologist, Edward DC and
- 4:31Richard Ryan. Now they found that motivation
- 4:35thrives when we've got 3 needs met.
- 4:39One, autonomy, having that sense of choice and control,
- 4:45competence, feeling capable when we see ourselves improve, that's
- 4:51something. And then relatedness, so feeling
- 4:54connected to others and supported.
- 4:58And it's, it's really interesting that those 3, you
- 5:05know, we see those three in motivation.
- 5:07It is because for me, when these 3 needs are nurtured,
- 5:15particularly at school, or we might see it in the workplace or
- 5:20at home, then it just flows. It doesn't have to be forced and
- 5:27we don't have to. We don't actually have to nag
- 5:32our kids to do it. When you see these, she's just
- 5:35brilliant isn't it? That's what we want, so let's
- 5:39just go a little bit further into them.
- 5:42So autonomy, having that sense of control.
- 5:44What do we mean by that? So feeling more motivated when
- 5:48we feel like we've chosen what to do rather than being nagged
- 5:52or forced into it doesn't mean complete freedom, but it does
- 5:56mean having a say. So, for instance, the kids that
- 6:00might be letting a child choose whether to do homework at the
- 6:04kitchen table or in their bedroom still lead to the same
- 6:09outcome. The homework gets done, but the
- 6:11sense of choice makes them more willing.
- 6:15It's feeding into that theory we just talked about.
- 6:19For teens, it might be they choose a subject to revise first
- 6:26and usually often stick with revision longer than if somebody
- 6:32else dictates the schedule. Now schools are quite good at
- 6:36this if they show how to revise and they show what topics in a
- 6:46subject area to revise, but then give the kids a blank timetable
- 6:51to choose themselves because, because also as well, sometimes
- 6:55we're, you know, we might be more in a mood to do English,
- 7:00eh, than to do maths. However, we might be worried a
- 7:04little bit about maths. So choose to, to do, you know,
- 7:07the teens might choose to do that first to get it out of the
- 7:10way and feel better for it, less anxious and stuff.
- 7:14What's it like for us as adults? Well, at work, having some
- 7:17autonomy, like picking the order you tackle your tasks in, having
- 7:22input on a project will boost engagement and effort.
- 7:27And that's what we want, competence.
- 7:29And what does that look like? That feeling capable and seeing
- 7:32yourself improve. Well, when we're motivated, when
- 7:36we believe we can do something, then we see that progress over
- 7:39time. Without this, tasks feel
- 7:43overwhelming and often pointless.
- 7:46So for kids, a child learning swim might feel discouraged if
- 7:51thrown in at the deep end. Although can I just say we when
- 7:55I was learning swim, we had this very famous only in our area by
- 8:00the way, swim teacher called Mrs Manley and there was a high
- 8:04diver. Now this high diver was Olympic
- 8:07height. We had like the best swimming
- 8:10pool in the area. And I think it was because we
- 8:13live near a river. So there was a real push from
- 8:18the local authority to get all the kids to learn to swim, and
- 8:22particularly because, like, my mum learned to swim in that
- 8:25river, so they wanted to make sure that the kids weren't
- 8:28learning to swim in a river. But what she used to do, Mrs
- 8:31Manley, is she would take us to the High Diner and she would
- 8:33hold us and then let us go. And, you know, did it do us any
- 8:38harm? Not at all.
- 8:39We were all right. However, would I recommend it
- 8:42now? Probably not.
- 8:44But, yeah, you know, so it is that, you know, some of us would
- 8:49have been put off for life. Absolutely.
- 8:52But starting, you know, starting small things like building up,
- 8:57starting with floats, gradually swimming small, short, you know,
- 9:00widths to build confidence. Those little wins help kids keep
- 9:07going. What does that look like for
- 9:09teens? Well, a teen learning guitar who
- 9:12masters one song feels capable and that sense of progress
- 9:16really encourages them to try a harder piece.
- 9:19Now, it's really funny because I think that often with, and not
- 9:24all music teachers by the way, but often with music teachers,
- 9:27they go through all the cards, you know, they tell you all
- 9:30about the guitar and, and it's lovely, but it's not helping
- 9:35motivation. You know, just doing scales is
- 9:38not not building that that competence and and the the
- 9:44internal motivation that we want for adults.
- 9:48So in the workplace training that breaks down a complex
- 9:52skill, for instance, public speaking into small achievable
- 9:58steps help people feel confident so they're motivated to
- 10:02practise. Now the lovely Catherine
- 10:05Salmond, who's a friend of Brazilian kid, she runs speaking
- 10:10stuff and she's really good. And I've, you know, I, I've been
- 10:14there when she's when she's done this, breaking down into small
- 10:18bits and then putting it together at the end.
- 10:20And by the end of like her workshops, are you you suddenly
- 10:25are able to speak in public and you think, Oh my goodness.
- 10:28Whereas often, you know, one of the largest fears that we have
- 10:31is speaking in public. And so breaking it down into
- 10:35small bite sized chunks and then mastering those little chunks
- 10:39and then putting it together, you suddenly go, oh, I can do
- 10:42this. Like that fear is gone.
- 10:45So that's, you know, she just had really well relatedness and
- 10:50feeling connected to others and, and also feeling supported.
- 10:55So we thrive when we feel like we're doing, you know, what
- 11:01matters to others and that we're not alone.
- 11:04As human beings, we are wired for connection.
- 11:07And you know, I always say it is the absolute most important
- 11:12component for me in resilience. All of them are important, but
- 11:16but feeling connected helps us with everything.
- 11:19So motivation often increases when relationships are part of
- 11:24the picture. So what does that mean?
- 11:27Well, for kids, a child who plays football isn't just
- 11:31motivated by scoring goals, It's also about being part of a team,
- 11:36celebrated when they succeed, supported when they miss, you
- 11:41know, and that's that's a lovely thing about team sports, isn't
- 11:45it? And you know, there is some
- 11:47fantastic coaches out there, but there are also some parents that
- 11:51I've seen on the sidelines that are like, you know, booing when
- 11:54kids miss. I'm like, get a grip, please,
- 11:57Like this is a kids sport. Back off and for I actually this
- 12:04week have seen one of the New Zealand players and I can't
- 12:08think of a name off the topic. She's really famous that famous.
- 12:11I can't remember a name, but really famous.
- 12:13And she's a New Zealand player now.
- 12:14They they didn't win. But what they, what she came out
- 12:18and said is that A, she has never seen that amount of people
- 12:24at a final for a women's sport ever.
- 12:29And B, that she said she walked in, you know, in a different
- 12:37country, she's not in a home turf.
- 12:39And everyone cheered and loads of people knew her name and the
- 12:43girls were just so like lovely and giving her like lip
- 12:47bracelets and things like that. And she said, you know, the
- 12:51support, she literally cried from the coach to getting into
- 12:54the stadium. And she said the support that
- 12:57they had for the women's game was second to none.
- 13:00And actually feeling part of something is so, so important.
- 13:04You know, and I think we often don't see that in the men's
- 13:08game. And I don't know why, you know,
- 13:10maybe it's because it's been around longer, but the, you
- 13:13know, definitely in, in women's football, but particularly in
- 13:18women's rugby only because I have no more about women's rugby
- 13:21because everyone plays that. But, you know, there's the
- 13:24support for each other and, and the camaraderie and that
- 13:27connection is, is huge. It's so, so big.
- 13:32And, you know, if we're talking about motivating our kids into
- 13:37sports to keep them, you know, physically healthy and mentally
- 13:40healthy, then that's what we want to see.
- 13:43You know, that's support for each other, not just for our own
- 13:46team. So for teens, how do we see
- 13:49relatedness in there? Well, it's a teenager's more
- 13:53likely to engage with this school project if they're
- 13:56working in a group, if that they're connected with, though,
- 13:59that is the, that's the key. Often I see teachers go right,
- 14:03you're going to, you're going to work together, you're going to
- 14:05work together, you're going to, and you know, and that's OK.
- 14:09If you are going to do something that is going to help them feel
- 14:13more connected, It's not enough just that they've got to year
- 14:1510. So of course you must know
- 14:17everybody, but actually, you know, build in a exercise where
- 14:23they connect more before the school project, right?
- 14:28If you're a teacher, show genuine interest in their effort
- 14:33and and you're halfway there. Like absolutely for other adults
- 14:38in the workplace, people are motivated to push through
- 14:42challenges when they feel their manager has their back or when
- 14:46they know their work contributes to something bigger than
- 14:49themselves. You know that mission.
- 14:51So for me with the coaches, it's not just about them, you know,
- 14:57help getting more clients or, or making more money.
- 15:01It's about, you know, the difference that they make.
- 15:04And we talk about that all the time.
- 15:06It's about, you know, the bigger picture.
- 15:09We want to reach a million kids, you know, things like that is
- 15:14not just, you know, and we're all in it together.
- 15:17It's a it's a mutual mission. And that's what we mean when
- 15:19it's related. We're connected by that common
- 15:22theme, that mission. So these 3 needs autonomy,
- 15:28competence, and relatedness. Explain why, You know, some
- 15:33environments naturally boost motivations while others drain
- 15:38it. But actually, it's easy to make
- 15:41tweaks. So, for example, a classroom
- 15:43that offers choices, celebrates the small win, celebrates
- 15:46effort, and builds that team spirit will be more engaged
- 15:49learners 100%. And a workplace that does the
- 15:53same, we'll see employees going that extra mile, you know, So
- 15:58that's, I think for me, it seems like a small theory, but self
- 16:06determination theory has a lot to unpack and actually would
- 16:11really help us in the home and in the classroom.
- 16:16So let me give you an example. Let me give you what we call
- 16:18real, real world story. So I worked with a teenager who
- 16:25dreaded revision for exams. Now we were lucky because they
- 16:29had enough time. They were in year 10, not year
- 16:3111. So we had enough time to try and
- 16:33build this in. Parents had tried rewards, they
- 16:37tried bribes. None of it helped.
- 16:40And you know, it might have helped for a little bit, but the
- 16:43motivation never lasted. So what we did was link the
- 16:48revision to her dream of becoming a vet.
- 16:51And everything shifted from that external motivation, that
- 16:57extrinsic that we were talking about before to we shifted to an
- 17:02internal because she saw revision as not as a chore, but
- 17:06a stepping stone towards that bigger picture, that bigger
- 17:09purpose, helping animals, doing the job that she loved.
- 17:13You know, she imagined getting up every day and, and going in
- 17:17to look after animals, to nurture them, to help them feel
- 17:20better, you know, to work as part of a team that do that.
- 17:24And, you know, eventually she wanted to work in a zoo.
- 17:28And so every you know, we said, and and this comes from James, I
- 17:35want to say clear from Atomic Habits.
- 17:38You know, everything she did was either going towards or away
- 17:42from that big goal. And so her revision was those
- 17:45step towards it. But also what else changed for
- 17:49her? Well, two things.
- 17:51She had autonomy over it. She chose her career path.
- 17:55She felt the competence the more that she did it.
- 17:58Her effort was building those skills and she had relatedness.
- 18:03Her family and I cheered her on. And, you know, she, she knew
- 18:08what she was doing it for. And yeah, it was, it was
- 18:12brilliant. The science of motivation is
- 18:15there literally in that story. So I'm going to do a few
- 18:22podcasts on this. So if you this is going to be
- 18:26like the first of a series, if you've got questions on how to
- 18:30motivate your kid, then you know, or your teen or maybe you
- 18:35know, you're a teacher and you want to know how to motivate
- 18:38your class, then drop us a message.
- 18:41Either come over to the village on Facebook, our our free
- 18:44Facebook group and drop us. You know, you can do it
- 18:47anonymously if you want. Drop us a message there.
- 18:50Put a comment underneath the podcast wherever you listen to
- 18:53it or e-mail me, Ashley at the resilient kid.co.uk.
- 18:59So a little reflection for you and take away.
- 19:04Write down three things and you can do this, you know, as the
- 19:10adults listen or you can ask your kids to do this.
- 19:14Write down three things you do even if nobody paid you, praised
- 19:19you or rewarded you. Now these clues are your
- 19:24intrinsic motivators. They sparks that naturally
- 19:27energise you and you're likely to see science playing out
- 19:31autonomy, competence and connection, you know, and those
- 19:35little dopamine hits that I was telling you about when I do my
- 19:39tick list, when you move forward.
- 19:42So, and let me know, I'd love to hear what what are those three
- 19:47things? In the next episode, we talk
- 19:50about why sometimes you don't do the things that matter most,
- 19:55procrastination, resistance, and some small tools that can help
- 19:59you breakthrough that cycle. But for today, notice what truly
- 20:03drives you, the things that light you up from the inside,
- 20:07because that's where the real motivation is.
- 20:10Thanks for listening. I'll see you in the next
- 20:12motivation episode and lots of love from us to you.
- 20:16Bye for now.