Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 1 - Introducing WonkyFolk
Transcript
- 0:03Jed: Hey Andy.
- 0:04Andy: Hey Jed.
- 0:05How are you?
- 0:06Jed: I'm doing great.
- 0:08Well, thanks for sharing this idea of creating WonkyFolk.
- 0:11Andy: Absolutely.
- 0:12Jed: It's something you and I have been batting around here for, I
- 0:15don't know, several months here.
- 0:17And just this idea that if there's anything that I crave
- 0:23in the education space right now is just some sense of coherence.
- 0:27There's just so many things that are happening, at such a pace.
- 0:31And there's just so much variety at a national level.
- 0:35And certainly one thing I've just valued in you, Andy, and your work at Bellweather
- 0:40is just being able to bring coherence also with a perspective that's just nationwide.
- 0:45And so, hey, maybe we end up talking amongst ourselves and
- 0:48we think that there's some value that we're adding for folks.
- 0:51But you know, I just appreciate you willing to take a try with it.
- 0:54Andy: Yeah, I'm excited.
- 0:55Look, I think we both, I mean everybody can agree like the world
- 0:57needs more middle-aged guys with podcasts, a huge market gap there.
- 1:03And so I think we're going to try to fill it.
- 1:07You're one of those people I get on a call with you about something like you
- 1:10end up having these conversations about what's going on in the sector, what's
- 1:13going on in general, before you get to whatever the point of the call is.
- 1:16And you're always like, that conversation like that might
- 1:19make an interesting podcast.
- 1:20So it's good to actually potentially try that out although I unfortunately, I
- 1:24bet it'll be more stilted when we do it now then when you're just like getting
- 1:27on a zoom to kick something around.
- 1:30Jed: Well, we'll hope that we keep it fresh and who knows, we may
- 1:34also invite some people down the road to broaden out the discussion.
- 1:38Andy: Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:38I'm looking forward to that.
- 1:40Jed: Cool.
- 1:41Well, and I also just feel like this nexus of, look I overweight
- 1:46on charters in all sorts of ways.
- 1:48Right?
- 1:48And I think that's a good place for us to be generally.
- 1:51But your knowledge on the wonk side, on the policy side, K-12, that's where I
- 1:58think if we really can focus our energy here, I think there actually is value for
- 2:03two middle-aged white guys to offer here.
- 2:05Andy: Yeah, definitely.
- 2:06I thought you were going to say, coming out of winter, I'm always
- 2:09a little overweight, just period.
- 2:10I thought you were going to go there right out the gate.
- 2:14Yeah, I think that's right and charters are a big part and I think they're
- 2:18illustrative of a lot of what's going on, there are bigger things in the
- 2:22sector and obviously this week, like a big one that's on everybody's mind, is
- 2:27just this horrific shooting last week in Nashville at the Covenant school.
- 2:34Jed: Yeah.
- 2:34I think these shootings have become so frequent that when you start
- 2:40a podcast like this, it's almost off the news cycle already, and
- 2:45we're just grown so immune to it.
- 2:47But there are things that come up about this particular shooting that I just find
- 2:55illustrative of the problems that we face.
- 2:58And here it's a private school, right?
- 3:01The community that was involved or that was affected, all different and
- 3:09new, the political responses that we're seeing from policymakers, new,
- 3:13but all sadly, not very to the point.
- 3:18But I just think that these instances, these incidents of tragedy like this,
- 3:26I just think they contribute to a lack of trust that so many parents have
- 3:32in the public education system, or in public private education -- wherever
- 3:37you want to focus at this point.
- 3:41Well, I think your last blog entry talks about the relative safety of kids in
- 3:47schools versus all these other settings, but the broader narrative is: kids may
- 3:53not be safe at school and if there's anything that parents gravitate to, it's
- 3:58that desire to keep their kids safe.
- 4:01And so I see this potentially contributing to kid parents even pulling their kids
- 4:05back even more and trying to find other settings within to educate their kids
- 4:10where they feel like they're safe.
- 4:11Andy: Yeah, but as we've seen over the last couple of years, these
- 4:15can happen at any kind of a school.
- 4:17They happen at traditional public schools, they happen at charter schools,
- 4:20and they can happen at private schools.
- 4:22Actually they're really rare.
- 4:24I think we are sort of soaked.
- 4:26You have to hold sort of a couple of things in your head at the same time.
- 4:31One, just every one of these is awful and just unique in its awfulness.
- 4:37And that they're also pretty rare.
- 4:38I think most people are surprised when you ask how many people have
- 4:41been killed in mass shootings at school since, say, Columbine.
- 4:45You get some really astronomical numbers and it's actually fewer than
- 4:48200, which is 200 too many obviously.
- 4:52And again, everyone is uniquely horrible, but they're not as
- 4:55ubiquitous as you would know if you spend a lot of time, if you would
- 4:58think you spend a lot of time online.
- 5:00Meanwhile, youth violence, particularly in out of school and communities
- 5:04is an enormous problem, has been for a while and to your point,
- 5:09things that don't get headlines.
- 5:11It doesn't necessarily get a whole lot of headlines and it's just sort of a
- 5:14grinding and sort of staggering toll.
- 5:17And so I think we struggle to talk about these things and then when
- 5:21something like Nashville happens with some of the circumstance around it,
- 5:24everything kind of grinds to a halt.
- 5:26What's I think really troubling about that is, you know, these
- 5:30shootings in general, not everyone, but in general, they're preventable.
- 5:34Four out of five school shooters say what they're going to do ahead of time.
- 5:37We don't have all the details on Nashville, but this person, their parents
- 5:41were apparently concerned enough about them to want to intervene around their
- 5:45access to firearms and so forth, and so I think what's getting lost in a lot
- 5:51of the rhetoric and the concern and the talk about hardening the target and all
- 5:53this is if four out of five young people who do something like this tell you that
- 5:58they're going to do it ahead of time.
- 6:00Why aren't we heading that off more upstream?
- 6:03To your point on trust also what's going on with trust in the school
- 6:06with students where they can't engage adults around these things.
- 6:09There's so much leaking ahead of time, and yet we're still not heading them off.
- 6:15I think we need to have a hard conversation about school
- 6:18culture and why that is.
- 6:21Jed: Well, yeah, I think there are a lot of forces at play right now that are
- 6:24keeping candor and agency out of schools.
- 6:29And so we have a lot of adults and a lot of kids that can't talk about the thing,
- 6:34and when you can't talk about the thing, well, of course you're not gonna be able
- 6:38to talk about these kinds of things.
- 6:40My wife's a clinical psychologist, she was just forwarding me some stories from
- 6:46just social media about parents who are sewing school districts right now over
- 6:52bullying and then suicides that have been happening associated with those.
- 6:56And I think these shootings, they tend to crowd out, the attention
- 7:04on many of these other things.
- 7:06And so of course, the problem of gun violence in schools has to be taken on for
- 7:12sure but also these other issues can't be crowded out from our attention such that
- 7:18we can stay focused on what's really going on with our adolescent kids right now.
- 7:22Because the psychological crisis that we have in this generation is
- 7:26unlike anything we've seen previously.
- 7:28Andy: And they're related though, right?
- 7:30A few years ago, the secret service made an analysis on school shootings.
- 7:34And one of the things they talked about was this leakage and this upstream,
- 7:38kids basically saying, in many cases explicitly, what they were going to do or
- 7:42having a lot of, in the case of Parkland, the shooter said explicitly what they
- 7:45were going to do when they got the chance.
- 7:47Or lots of like signs and indications that common sense would
- 7:50tell you something's going on.
- 7:52But a common factor the Secret Service found was bullying and that kid, the
- 7:57people involved in these shootings, they were the victims of different kinds
- 8:01of bullying and they actually called pretty explicitly for really vigorous
- 8:05anti-bullying programs -- what you would call SEL programs, stuff like that.
- 8:09And I thought it was interesting because SEL is getting sort of sucked into
- 8:13this ongoing culture war vortex we have, and here you've got the secret
- 8:17service, which I don't know that anybody's gonna describe the Secret
- 8:20Service, like a hotbed of leftism.
- 8:22And they're calling for you have to do this, you have to create that culture.
- 8:26Because if kids don't have a trusting environment in school, they don't have
- 8:29adults they're going to trust, they're not going to go to them and say, "hey, here
- 8:32are these things we're seeing that are, that are worrisome" and you're just not
- 8:37gonna have that kind of information flow.
- 8:39It comes back to one of the reasons I know you got active in the charter
- 8:44world, one of the things that attracted me to charters is just where a place
- 8:47we can create a kind of intentional community where kids and adults just
- 8:51interact in different ways than is sometimes the normal in schools.
- 8:55Jed: I think kids are really tuned into whether or not there is authenticity
- 9:00and agency in their environment, and if they sense for whatever reason,
- 9:05that the adults in that space can't say what they want to say, or it's all
- 9:09canned, or it's just completely and utterly predictable, they just disengage
- 9:14and the only place the conversations will be happening is in the hallway
- 9:18or outside of school, and or in social media where of course, a lot of these
- 9:24bullying problems get to be only worse.
- 9:28For me, I just feel like the problem of lack of agency in our public schools is
- 9:32just much more profound than we recognize.
- 9:36Andy: Yeah.
- 9:37I think that's right.
- 9:39So one of the things I knew we wanted to talk about today, speaking of challenging
- 9:43public schools is what's happening in a couple of the cities and you're just down
- 9:47the road from Los Angeles, which was in the news quite a bit with that strike.
- 9:53Jed: Yeah.
- 9:54I think this strike situation in Los Angeles and the problems we see in so many
- 9:59urban schools doesn't get enough attention and perhaps in my writing at CharterFolk
- 10:05just beats on it till people are just ready to cry mercy but, I actually think,
- 10:12no matter how much I can focus on it, there's still way more problems that are
- 10:16there than we're paying attention to.
- 10:20And we're seeing an aspect of the urban education world, only
- 10:27double down a path that we know is going to result in further demise.
- 10:32And that's certainly what I see coming out of the Los Angeles situation.
- 10:37I think things hang into balance right now in Chicago.
- 10:40We are recording this on a Monday, the election results will be on Tuesday
- 10:44and we'll release this on Wednesday.
- 10:46But Chicago and Los Angeles have probably been the two hotbeds of teacher unions
- 10:52taking on new levels of aggressiveness and new levels of political engagement
- 10:57that's translated into them having virtual complete control of the Los
- 11:01Angeles Unified School District right now.
- 11:03And we'll see what happens in Chicago.
- 11:06But should it go in the direction of the Chicago teacher union having
- 11:10more control in Chicago, I don't see that doing anything other than
- 11:15speeding the demise of the district.
- 11:17Do you, do you see it differently here?
- 11:19What nuance can you offer as it relates to the challenges we have
- 11:22in urban education right now?
- 11:24Andy: Oh man.
- 11:24It's hard to know where to start and those two cities are...
- 11:27there's some commonality and some distinct issues.
- 11:29One of the commonalities is obviously just unsustainable fiscal structures.
- 11:34I'm sort of struck we keep having these conversations and these entities,
- 11:38we've got to figure out what we do to get them on a sound financial footing.
- 11:41Whether it's, you know, and itcame up in the Chicago race some of the issues
- 11:46around pension, retirement financing.
- 11:48In LA, you look at the school district's own numbers on the percent of money
- 11:52from the retirement that they're paying into retirement for people who
- 11:55aren't even working in the system.
- 11:56The percentage of classroom dollars that are now going to that it's staggering
- 12:01and we're not sort of having any kind of an honest conversation about that.
- 12:05Whatever the latest thing is ,the strike dujour, and the sort of
- 12:08constant negotiation that the teachers unions have with the districts just
- 12:12plays out in these different ways.
- 12:14I was sort of struck that in the wake of the pandemic, all the avowed concerns
- 12:18about learning loss and everybody saying they're gonna get serious, that in LA you
- 12:22had this strike and there was just very little attention to, like, kids need to
- 12:26be in school right now more than anything else and we're just gonna have a, another
- 12:30school holiday essentially for politics.
- 12:32And there was just like very little outrage, it just almost seemed like
- 12:37it's business as usual, which was striking to me, given the context
- 12:41and given the stakes right now.
- 12:43Jed: Yeah.
- 12:43What was shocking to me was that, Jackie Goldberg was, and the superintendent was
- 12:50there saying there's no need for a strike.
- 12:52We're willing to give you guys absolutely everything, essentially,
- 12:56and yet they wanted to strike anyway.
- 12:58And then at the end of the strike, when they talk about what the deal was
- 13:02it was essentially the same as what they had been talking about for weeks.
- 13:06So what really was the motivation here?
- 13:09And do you really have to have another three days of student learning
- 13:13loss in order to make that point?
- 13:15Andy: That's a tactic and I think that's not always appreciated.
- 13:18Like the teachers unions that having the strike, getting people out there, getting
- 13:22people riled up, it's a membership tactic.
- 13:24It reminds the members why they're there, all this stuff.
- 13:26And they will strike even when it's not, even when we could actually
- 13:30get to a deal without a strike.
- 13:32We saw that in LA.
- 13:33That was really the sort of thing that really I think changed with teacher
- 13:36strikes in general, I think you have to go back to Karen Lewis in which she did
- 13:40in Chicago in back in 2012, I think it was, where that point, the unions were,
- 13:47you know, Randy Weingarten was talking much more about reform than she talks
- 13:51about now and, was saying tenure shouldn't be a job for life and we need to like
- 13:55reform teacher evaluation, much of stuff that now would be considered heretical.
- 13:59But she was like going to the press club once a year to
- 14:01talk about all these things.
- 14:03And in Chicago, Karen Lewis was like, you know, no the hell with that?
- 14:06We're going to fight on this, we're not going to get on this train,
- 14:10we think there's another strategy we can fight and essentially
- 14:14exactly what you're talking about.
- 14:15The ultimate deal was pretty much the contours of the deal that was on the
- 14:18table, but they were pretty explicit, they needed to be able to have a strike.
- 14:21It was politically important and they did.
- 14:25And they and, I mean, the senior people in the union were relatively
- 14:29open about that was what was going on.
- 14:34And here we are, this keeps playing out.
- 14:38And the interesting thing about Chicago is it's such a stark choice.
- 14:42You've got Paul Val, and you can tell the director, we can talk about him and what
- 14:47he's done, and then Brandon Johnson and it's two very different choices facing
- 14:53Chicago voters and it can be no illusion about which way things will go, depending
- 14:57how that race turns out tomorrow.
- 14:59Jed: Yeah.
- 14:59The thing that I just think that we, in the charter world in particular,
- 15:05need to spend more time thinking about what is our agenda, what is our North
- 15:11Star as it relates to the evolution of these large urban school districts.
- 15:15I think for a long time we just basically stayed under the radar screen.
- 15:19Hey, that's not our job.
- 15:21We don't have to worry about what this thing evolves into.
- 15:23Let's just keep growing our schools and it'll work itself out on the other end.
- 15:27Now we're at that other end and charter schools disproportionately have charged
- 15:33into large urban school districts to try and serve as many kids better
- 15:37than they've been served in the past.
- 15:39And now we've got just massive numbers of people leaving major urban areas.
- 15:45And so our schools are there.
- 15:47They're fighting for enrollment in Los Angeles.
- 15:50It's interesting, basically, charter school enrollment has stayed flat for the
- 15:53last five years, around 110-115,000 kids.
- 15:58But in terms of percentage of Los Angeles that is served by the charter
- 16:02school sector, it's grown from 16% to 21%, just because we've stayed flat.
- 16:08Okay.
- 16:08Well, what is the future?
- 16:09What's really going to happen here?
- 16:11I don't think the charter school world can stay in a keep our head low mode anymore.
- 16:16No.
- 16:16We have to say, we actually think this is the future that all of public education
- 16:20needs to move into, and this is the role that we think charter schools can play
- 16:25in helping us get to that better place.
- 16:27Andy: Yeah.
- 16:28And I think the charter community has a decision to make about sort of
- 16:33how it wants to play its politics.
- 16:35Because one of the interesting things about Chicago is there's definitely
- 16:41a race element to the political race -- there is a racial element to it.
- 16:45And you're seeing that and civil rights leaders are talking about that.
- 16:49But you've got some young progressives in the city, some reformers who
- 16:53are African American coming down for Paul Vallas in part over the
- 16:56school issues and the reform issues.
- 16:58And again, I have no idea what's going to happen tomorrow at the ballot box.
- 17:03That's not a prediction.
- 17:05It's just you're seeing, but you're seeing some of that.
- 17:07And I think that does, there is this idea of how do you create sort
- 17:11of a multiracial reform politics that would include charter schools,
- 17:16and used to include charter schools.
- 17:18And then you've got this countervailing pressure, which is the broader pressure
- 17:21in the country with the culture wars and everything where the party just
- 17:24cleaving apart and charters feel like, well, we're going to go, their
- 17:28heart is with the Democrats even though their political support is
- 17:32increasingly more with the Republicans and you're seeing that tension.
- 17:35And that could play out in some really dangerous ways for charters, particularly
- 17:40if you decide these other issues that are sort of adjacent and tangential around
- 17:44educating kids become the thing that you're going to put front and center.
- 17:49So I think it's actually a pretty fraught time for charters.
- 17:53Jed: I agree with you.
- 17:55And I think that the rationale behind the creation of CharterFolk was the
- 18:00idea that our charter people, you know, believing that they're a part
- 18:04of something bigger than themselves and willing to do more than they, than
- 18:08is typically expected, as has been our history will continue to happen.
- 18:14Well, in our urban settings when our charter folk are hearing all of these
- 18:19things about how we're on the wrong side of history and we're associated
- 18:22with all these what, whatever, right wing interests or whatever it is,
- 18:26our own base can become wobbly.
- 18:29Our own base can feel like we're on the wrong side of history.
- 18:31The only way, in my opinion that we can like communicate to them and to other
- 18:37supporters and others that actually our values align with theirs, is to come
- 18:44out and be more vocal about the way our school systems are set up, our redlining
- 18:49attendance boundaries, our selective admissions that we know screen out
- 18:52kids by race, our funding systems that suck money away from high needs kids
- 18:58to subsidize more affluent families' educations, allowing schools to be
- 19:03completely and utterly unaccountable, so that the kids that you know are most
- 19:07vulnerable suffer most -- these are things that are counter to our values and the
- 19:12way that charter schools are set up.
- 19:15We are set up to operate schools in a completely different way, and we're
- 19:18going to advocate not only for our students to be served in that way, but
- 19:22all students to be served in that way.
- 19:24In that moment, I think the progressives who you know have thus far heard silence
- 19:30from the charter school world will need step back and say, wait a second,
- 19:34what do I think about these things?
- 19:36Andy: Yeah, I think so.
- 19:39Look, you're an optimist.
- 19:41I think what's happening now that's very striking to me is two sort of
- 19:46related but somewhat discordant trends.
- 19:47One is, among parents, you're seeing in the data, parents are more willing
- 19:52than ever to move across party lines, at coming out of the pandemic.
- 19:57They're frustrated, the old alignments don't make sense to them, and
- 20:01they want results for the kids.
- 20:03And so, the parental vote is up for grab.
- 20:06It's much more, it's much more fluid right now.
- 20:08And then at the same time, among elites you're seeing people are sort of chucking
- 20:13all their prior education commitments out the window in the interest of partisanship
- 20:17because things are becoming so hardened.
- 20:19And so you've got Democrats who used to support charters who are now like,
- 20:22yeah, you know, like that's two partisan of an issue they've gone quiet and
- 20:26like those two trends, watching them play out, I think there's both an
- 20:31opportunity there for charters, but also just enormous, enormous political risk.
- 20:38Jed: Yeah.
- 20:39And the disconnect between the public positioning and
- 20:42what the polling data shows...
- 20:44I mean, striking in 2019, when UTLA had their last strike, every left-leaning
- 20:52person in Los Angeles, every democratic policymaker wanted to virtue project:
- 20:57we are with the teachers, we're with UTLA, we support this strike, right?
- 21:00And then UTLA thinks, okay, let's capitalize upon that by getting
- 21:03this parcel tax approved that will fund teachers pay at higher levels.
- 21:09Didn't even come close to passing.
- 21:11Not even close.
- 21:13Right.
- 21:13Andy: Well, yeah, it gives a lie to this whole idea of like standpoint,
- 21:16the epistemology and that we're going to listen to people and do what
- 21:19they want, because the support for charters, I mean, you know, strong
- 21:22majority support in the African American community, strong majority
- 21:26support in the Hispanic community.
- 21:28There's the idea that like charters are some sort of like unpopular
- 21:31thing or political jump ball.
- 21:33The only people who really aren't there on charters politically
- 21:35are white progressivesm, right?
- 21:37But white progressives and the teachers unions, that's a pretty powerful
- 21:41coalition inside the Democratic Party and it's not an insignificant
- 21:44political coalition in general.
- 21:46And so here we are, but I do think charters are one of those, you know,
- 21:51they pull back the veneer on some of this stuff and you can sort of see
- 21:56where the more raw political power around some of these issues lies.
- 22:00Jed: Let me ask you something out of white progressives, Andy, because
- 22:02my sense is that their opposition to charters may be fragile because, It
- 22:10can be shown that most of these white liberals have got themselves into very
- 22:14favorable public education situations that they now structurally deny others.
- 22:19But they're not being, it's not being shown to them, or they're not being held
- 22:23accountable for the fact that they are reserving this special benefit for them.
- 22:27And if they were forced, you know, to confront their own hypocrisy on this
- 22:36issue, I don't see how they stay in their current mindset unless they're
- 22:41willing to go to, okay, I actually oppose charters not for these great progressive
- 22:46values, but for naked self-interest.
- 22:49I'm not sure that the white progressives can actually pivot to naked
- 22:54self-interest as their justification for charters opposition going foward.
- 22:58Andy: I don't know.
- 22:59I mean, look, the history of ed reform in this country, going back decades,
- 23:05one way to look at it's a history of people with means evading whatever
- 23:10sort of reform strategies put in place, whether it's busing or choice or anything
- 23:15else more recently, to figure out how to make the system work for them.
- 23:20I mean, I guess I do think there's something to charters made a strategic
- 23:25error by focusing overwhelmingly -- obviously the highest need is in urban
- 23:31communities and then rural communities -- but focusing overwhelming on urban
- 23:34communities without having something there politically for the suburbs in a
- 23:38country where the politics are pretty suburban driven and so you, but not
- 23:42building that coalition so forth, I think they left an exposed flank that
- 23:46is, is causing a lot of trouble now.
- 23:49And so we should think about what does sort of a middle class
- 23:51chartering strategy look like?
- 23:52And I think that's, look, people want customization.
- 23:55They want different kinds of schools.
- 23:56They want Montessori and, and I think there's a lot of political
- 23:59opportunities to make sort of public school choice in the public system
- 24:04much more robust and attractive.
- 24:06But the second part of it is that is also, I think, in some ways self-inflicted,
- 24:11for your strategies, I understand what you just laid out, to work people have
- 24:14to be kind of willing to take some hits, be a little bit contentious, point
- 24:19out this hypocrisy and all the rest.
- 24:22And I think one of the things that really happened over the last decade, and you
- 24:25really have to give her credit for it, is Randy Weingarten kind of convinced
- 24:29a lot of reformers that they were the problem, that they were too acrimonious,
- 24:33they were too divisive, they weren't consensus oriented enough and so forth.
- 24:37And that you heard lots of the rhetoric we have to collaborate and all this,
- 24:42and why do you have to be in...
- 24:43you know, a lot of reformers started to be like, oh yeah, why are we so contentious?
- 24:48To the point where Michelle Ree would run a commercial pointing out that like, A
- 24:52lot of our schools like, you know, huge achievement gaps, they don't stack up
- 24:55well internationally, and everybody's like, oh my God, that's so mean.
- 24:58Take down the ad and, and funders got nervous about it.
- 25:01Your strategy, if we do want to point out that, yeah, of course,
- 25:04everyone's kind of implicated.
- 25:06We redline education opportunity in this country by where you lived.
- 25:10Our colleague, Darrel Bradford, is I think probably one of the
- 25:12most articulate people about this.
- 25:14But there's other folks, Tim DeRoche has a new organization.
- 25:17We do work on this at Bellwether.
- 25:18Yeah, it's interesting, um, that like, you know, if you, you have to actually be
- 25:22willing to take some hits and point that out and be like a little bit contentious.
- 25:26Not just for the sheer hell of this isn't culture war stuff where it's just
- 25:30like for the sheer hell of spinning people up, but just you have to be
- 25:33willing to say some controversial things and make people uncomfortable.
- 25:36And I just don't know if the appetite is there right now.
- 25:41Jed: Or if the courage is there.
- 25:42Yeah.
- 25:43I mean, this is where my MFA playwriting comes back in.
- 25:46Aristotle knew all the way back even then, right, what's the making of drama?
- 25:50Conflict.
- 25:52You choose your conflict and from that you can drive a narrative.
- 25:56Andy: But that's why we get along Jed...
- 25:58When people come into the sector, they're like, they wanna work in education.
- 26:00They're like, what should they read?
- 26:01And they're like, should I read like Dewey or E.
- 26:03D.
- 26:04Hirsch, or whatever?
- 26:04I'm like, start with Aristotle.
- 26:07Understand the nature of power and politics and like a lot of what goes on in
- 26:12this sector will make more sense to you.
- 26:13Jed: But see, I ultimately think our movement will be
- 26:16defined by what we advocate for.
- 26:18And I think that when we advocate for dumb things, that it's easy for somebody
- 26:22like Weingarten to say, you've been too extreme, you haven't been thoughtful,
- 26:25you don't have this all the way thought through, or you're just simply, cheaply,
- 26:29bashing people, you know, without a real theory, we leave ourselves exposed.
- 26:34So I don't by any means say, oh, let's go out and just willy-nilly
- 26:38start taking a meat axe to red lines.
- 26:41But I do believe that there are ways for us to thoughtfully start to erase
- 26:45them such that the question is asked.
- 26:48We're not talking about huge numbers, we're just saying, every school district
- 26:51in America should have to reserve 5% of its seats for people that come
- 26:54from outside the school district so that we can start to have more choice.
- 26:57And, and see what people, how they start to respond at that point.
- 27:01Andy: Yeah.
- 27:02Little things on zoning.
- 27:03There's a lot of stuff you could do.
- 27:04I think choice is a piece of the solution set, but it's not the whole solution set.
- 27:07There's the, your, yeah, your idea, there's something you can do on the
- 27:10zonings, a whole bunch of stuff.
- 27:11I actually think that's how you, it's as if, like, if you think about it, like if
- 27:15you walk from -- you're in Los Angeles, I'm in Virginia, or you know if you walk,
- 27:20you're in California, sorry you're not Los Angeles, we're just talking about LA but
- 27:23you're in California, Northern California, and I'm in Virginia -- and if like we walk
- 27:29to each other and our compass is off a little bit, we're not gonna notice, you're
- 27:33not going to notice that when you're in Nevada and I'm not going to notice
- 27:36that when I'm in West Virginia and Ohio.
- 27:38But when we're trying to get where we're going, we'll suddenly
- 27:40realize I won't get to your house.
- 27:42I'll end up in Portland or down in LA, right?
- 27:45And that's the way we think about.
- 27:47How do you start to change the system?
- 27:49You know, some of this is like the cast some ideas about nudge and so forth.
- 27:53How do you change the system, so in 25 years, people are like, oh,
- 27:56wow, that's totally different.
- 27:57But they didn't see it.
- 27:59You're right, I do think we have people who, and this is I think on both
- 28:04sides, who just wanna be contentious.
- 28:06There's people who just want to sue school districts and all this, and
- 28:11lawsuits that aren't going to actually get anywhere given how the law works here.
- 28:15And there's, you know, people just wanna come in and try to blow
- 28:17things up and it's conflict for conflict's sake is not productive.
- 28:21But there will be some friction if there's going to be progress.
- 28:25That's a pretty well established principle as well.
- 28:29Jed: For sure.
- 28:30Yeah.
- 28:30Well, we talked about keeping this to a around a half
- 28:32hour, so we're getting close.
- 28:34I wanted to just a ask you one last question.
- 28:36What are you making about, and this could be another hour long
- 28:39conversation, but just let's spend a couple minutes ruminating on this.
- 28:43What are you making of ChatGPT and its implications for education?
- 28:49Is it being overhyped?
- 28:51Is it being underhyped?
- 28:53Are we in a moment where we just don't know?
- 28:57I'd just love to hear your thoughts about this because my daughter just, used
- 29:01ChatGPT to help her on her first essay.
- 29:05That's interesting, she's writing about ALS and ALS is at the origins
- 29:09of Charter Folk too, my dear friend Brian Bennett, who passed away.
- 29:13And ALS really matters in our family's life.
- 29:16And now Tess is writing me from college.
- 29:18ChatGPT has helped me understand ALS at whole other levels of understanding.
- 29:25But that's just one example.
- 29:27How are you thinking about it as it relates to K-12 stuff?
- 29:30Andy: Yeah, I mean, look, Jed, I'm far from an expert on this.
- 29:32I'm still learning.
- 29:33I listen to people like John Bailey who are doing a lot of work on this.
- 29:36There's others.
- 29:36So my sense is it over-hyped or under hyped?
- 29:41Yes, both.
- 29:42Great.
- 29:43I can see, every time there's a new technology around
- 29:47learning, people freak out.
- 29:49Paper was controversial at one point.
- 29:51They tried to license printing presses.
- 29:53So when something like this comes along, everyone's like, oh my God, we've have
- 29:56to ban it and restrict it and so forth.
- 29:58That's like an old human reaction to new knowledge technologies.
- 30:04I mean, we even saw that a little bit with like, in the early days of like email
- 30:07and the internet, there was some of that.
- 30:08And so like that sort of reaction is both understandable, time-honored
- 30:14and probably overstated.
- 30:16On the other hand, look, this will change teachers jobs and so forth.
- 30:20I worry it gives, you're starting to hear already again,
- 30:23why are we teaching content?
- 30:25Mere facts when kids are gonna have ChatGPT, which I think is a huge
- 30:30misreading of how we learn and what you need to know to be able to understand
- 30:34the world and make sense of it.
- 30:35So like the excesses on all sides are sort of apparent.
- 30:40I think some of it's very exciting.
- 30:43And one thing I'm intrigued by, you look at some of the stuff it can do and I screw
- 30:47around with it like everybody else does, everybody thought like automation and
- 30:51all this, they were like, oh man, sucks if you're a cashier or a truck driver.
- 30:55Turns out, like probably if you write like entry level ad copy, you work for
- 30:59one of these websites that's basically a click farm and building listicles
- 31:04and this kind of stuff, or maybe, and this is like hits close to home, maybe
- 31:07you're a blogger like me, this thing can do some of the things that you do.
- 31:15And I think that's interesting and maybe we'll occasion a slightly
- 31:20different and less sort of class-based conversation about automation
- 31:24and new technology and so forth.
- 31:26And my last thought is just the speed of it.
- 31:28I remember a few years ago, I was looking at some of this and messing around
- 31:31with, and it was really bad, right?
- 31:33It just was not ready for prime time and now, in a relatively
- 31:37short period of time...
- 31:37So I don't know.
- 31:39And then of course, look, I've seen all the same movies you have like, so I worry
- 31:42like are the robot's going to kill us all?
- 31:50I have lots of thoughts, but no real answers.
- 31:53It's really, it's really interesting.
- 31:55What's your take?
- 31:56I mean, so obviously your daughter's now cheating in college...
- 31:58I appreciate you.
- 32:02Jed: So, I patterned CharterFolk after Stratechery by Ben Thompson.
- 32:09And I've just been so impressed by him over the last five
- 32:13years of reading his stuff.
- 32:15And he is just always so smart and he is always so measured.
- 32:19And then he had a chance to see Chat GPT, and he just went over
- 32:28the moon about what this meant.
- 32:30He had never had an experience interacting with technology in that way.
- 32:35And he wrote that, and that then led the New York Times and to BBC and all sorts of
- 32:40others, quoting him and interviewing him.
- 32:42What is so new about this?
- 32:44I tend to think that since COVID and and racial reckoning with George Floyd
- 32:51this is probably the most important thing that has happened in the world
- 32:55and when we look back on something that happened during this decade.
- 33:01And I also think it's happening at the same moment that trust in education
- 33:06is evaporating and people want to be able to do different things, but they
- 33:12don't feel equipped to do it themselves or in small groups or whatever.
- 33:18And I just think this ChatGPT thing is going to give people the
- 33:23confidence that they don't have to have any more trust in any other
- 33:28schools that is absolutely necessary.
- 33:31And so if there's anything I think this is going to do, it's going to accelerate
- 33:36the forming of new educational models and ones that ultimately are going to
- 33:43challenge our public education system much more so than it will empower.
- 33:49Andy: All right.
- 33:50Well, that's a bold prediction.
- 33:52I'll be interested and we can revisit this.
- 33:55I'm not going to be in the prediction business, but by the time this does
- 33:58come out and this will be our first one, we'll see what people think,
- 34:01we will know at least the answers to whether or not the Chicago cops
- 34:06can all put their "Let's go Brandon" stickers back on their cars or not.
- 34:10So we will pick it up with that and some other stuff very soon.
- 34:15Jed: See you in a couple weeks.
- 34:17Andy: See you.
- 34:17Jed: Okay.
- 34:18See you.