Latest / Bloomberg Law / Landmark Young People's Climate Ruling
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: A landmark climate ruling that will reverberate across the legal landscape,
- 0:14Speaker 2: and it's sixteen young environmental activists who want it. A
- 0:18Speaker 2: judge ruled that the young people, who range in age
- 0:20Speaker 2: from five to twenty two, have a constitutional right to
- 0:24Speaker 2: a safe environment, and that Montana's continued development of fossil
- 0:28Speaker 2: fuels infringes on that right. It marks the first time
- 0:32Speaker 2: a court in the US has declared that a government
- 0:34Speaker 2: has a constitutional duty to protect people from climate change.
- 0:39Speaker 2: One of the young environmental activists, Claire Vasis, told CBS
- 0:43Speaker 2: News that the decision gives her hope.
- 0:46Speaker 3: I hope that as a young person, we might actually
- 0:50Speaker 3: have a chance to make a difference. And for my
- 0:55Speaker 3: life and for my kid's life. You know, not all
- 0:58Speaker 3: hope may be lost, do I mean?
- 1:00Speaker 2: The environmental law expert Pat Parento, a professor at the
- 1:03Speaker 2: Vermont Law and Graduate School, how significant is this ruling.
- 1:08Speaker 4: It's a big deal. It's the first court in the
- 1:11Speaker 4: United States to rule that there is a constitutional right,
- 1:16Speaker 4: based on the Montana State Constitution, to a safe climate.
- 1:20Speaker 4: That's shorthand for the way the Court described it in
- 1:23Speaker 4: the Hell versus Montana case. But that's essentially what Judge
- 1:27Speaker 4: seely hilp is that the youth plaintiffs in that case
- 1:31Speaker 4: have a fundamental constitutional right to a safe or stable climate,
- 1:37Speaker 4: and that the state government is violating that constitutional right
- 1:42Speaker 4: because it adopted a law that prohibits state agencies from
- 1:47Speaker 4: considering just considering the climate change impacts in Montana when
- 1:55Speaker 4: they authorize fossil fuel development like full mines, oil and gas,
- 2:00Speaker 4: well and so forth. So the first time any court
- 2:04Speaker 4: in the United States has ever ruled that way.
- 2:07Speaker 2: It's been called a turning point by the plaintiff's attorney.
- 2:11Speaker 1: Would you go that far?
- 2:12Speaker 4: I think I have to say until we see how
- 2:16Speaker 4: the Montana Supreme Court rules in this case on appeal,
- 2:20Speaker 4: because the state, of course has said it will appeal,
- 2:23Speaker 4: I think it's probably too soon to go that far
- 2:27Speaker 4: to say that we're going to see either in Montana
- 2:30Speaker 4: or more broadly, a turning point on changing, you know,
- 2:34Speaker 4: fossil fuel dependent energy policies. What the court has said
- 2:38Speaker 4: is you have to consider both what's happening in Montana
- 2:43Speaker 4: and elsewhere from what we've already seen with climate change
- 2:48Speaker 4: and the worst consequences that are to come. Plus you
- 2:51Speaker 4: have to look at the alternatives that are available to
- 2:55Speaker 4: reduce emissions, to shift our energy policies to cleaner grid sources,
- 3:01Speaker 4: all of which was laid out in very detailed factual
- 3:04Speaker 4: findings over two hundred factual findings by Judge Steely in
- 3:09Speaker 4: this case, based on the expert testimony the plane is introduced.
- 3:13Speaker 4: It was a remarkable, remarkable job of lawyering in this
- 3:17Speaker 4: case to develop this record on appeal. So it's all
- 3:21Speaker 4: there for the Montana Supreme Court to consider, and it's
- 3:25Speaker 4: all there for, of course the Montana legislature and the
- 3:29Speaker 4: Governor of Montana to consider. Whether they will or not
- 3:33Speaker 4: is very questionable because it's a very red even hard
- 3:37Speaker 4: right read governor and legislature right now that has dismissed
- 3:43Speaker 4: this case, ridiculed this case, refused to change policies and
- 3:48Speaker 4: so forth. So is it a turning point. It's certainly
- 3:52Speaker 4: headed in that direction, but we still have a lot
- 3:55Speaker 4: to see develop if it's going to change the way
- 3:58Speaker 4: things are happening on the ground.
- 4:00Speaker 2: As you said, the state is going to appeal, and
- 4:02Speaker 2: a spokesperson for the governor said this legal theory has
- 4:05Speaker 2: been thrown out of federal court and courts in more
- 4:08Speaker 2: than a dozen states.
- 4:09Speaker 1: It should have been here as well, but they.
- 4:11Speaker 2: Found an ideological judge who bent over backwards to allow
- 4:15Speaker 2: the case to move forward and earn herself a spot
- 4:17Speaker 2: in their next documentary.
- 4:20Speaker 4: Well, you know, name calling doesn't change facts. I'm impressed
- 4:24Speaker 4: by the factual records that this judge developed, and she
- 4:27Speaker 4: evaluated each one of those expert witnesses. There were eight
- 4:31Speaker 4: or more that were called by the planeffs, and she
- 4:33Speaker 4: went through in great detail, you know, what they testified to,
- 4:37Speaker 4: what that testimony was based on. So the governor can
- 4:41Speaker 4: say what he wants about the judge personally, but the
- 4:45Speaker 4: record speaks and the facts speak, and the state put
- 4:50Speaker 4: on no case. The only expert witness they offered was
- 4:54Speaker 4: declared not credible by the judge, and she cited specifically
- 4:59Speaker 4: why the testimony offered by this Terry Anderson was not credible.
- 5:03Speaker 4: It was full of mistakes and so forth. So you know,
- 5:07Speaker 4: when you don't have the facts on your side, you know,
- 5:10Speaker 4: of course, you insult the judge. We've seen that in
- 5:13Speaker 4: other instances, right, Or you insult the plaintiffs, the young
- 5:18Speaker 4: people bringing these cases as being naive or whatever. But again,
- 5:22Speaker 4: the facts in the law are laid out in her opinion.
- 5:25Speaker 4: We will see, you know, what happens on appeal. The
- 5:28Speaker 4: Montana Supreme Court is more conservative now than it was
- 5:32Speaker 4: in earlier days, when it recognized in this nineteen ninety
- 5:36Speaker 4: nine case known as Meic versus de Eq recognize the
- 5:41Speaker 4: fundamental right to a healthy environment. And now that healthy
- 5:47Speaker 4: environment right has been extended to a safe climate. So
- 5:51Speaker 4: there is precedent in Montana for what Judge Seeley did,
- 5:55Speaker 4: strong precedent. Her factual findings are undisputed by the state,
- 6:01Speaker 4: so I think the plaintiffs have a very good chance
- 6:04Speaker 4: of prevailing on appeal. We'll just have to wait and see.
- 6:07Speaker 2: Some of the young plaintiffs testified about how climate impacts
- 6:11Speaker 2: were upending their lives.
- 6:13Speaker 5: You know, it's really scary seeing what you care for
- 6:17Speaker 5: disappear right in front.
- 6:18Speaker 4: Of your eyes.
- 6:19Speaker 2: How important was their testimony to sort of put faces
- 6:24Speaker 2: on this problem of climate change?
- 6:27Speaker 4: Oh? Yes, the children's now some of them are no
- 6:30Speaker 4: longer children, of course, but when it started, they're eighteen
- 6:33Speaker 4: of them, I believe. And she goes through each one
- 6:35Speaker 4: of them individually, and shows how they are particularly affected
- 6:38Speaker 4: by climate change. Some of them have asthma problems, Others
- 6:42Speaker 4: have seen their ranching operations impacted. Others have seen some
- 6:47Speaker 4: of the recreational activities they engage in impacted. Some of them.
- 6:50Speaker 4: There was testimony about both physical and mental impacts on
- 6:55Speaker 4: these young people from what's happening with climate change and
- 6:58Speaker 4: the uncertainty about whether it's going to be dealt with.
- 7:01Speaker 4: So she went through in great detail, and it's compelling
- 7:05Speaker 4: evidence of what's happening to our young people. And it's real.
- 7:09Speaker 4: I mean, these were medical doctors testifying under oath, subject
- 7:13Speaker 4: to cross examination and saying these are real, diagnosable conditions
- 7:19Speaker 4: that are happening to these young people and they're going
- 7:22Speaker 4: to get worse unless we do something about this threat.
- 7:25Speaker 4: And do we care about the livelihood and the well
- 7:29Speaker 4: being of these children? Are not. That's really what the
- 7:33Speaker 4: trial was about. And as I say, the lawyers for
- 7:36Speaker 4: Our Children's Trust did a phenomenal job of laying this
- 7:40Speaker 4: all out on the court record, and there's nothing the
- 7:43Speaker 4: state can say now that can change any of that.
- 7:46Speaker 4: It's real.
- 7:47Speaker 2: So the declaratory relief, let's say that the Montana Supreme
- 7:51Speaker 2: Court affirms the judge's decision.
- 7:54Speaker 1: How would this be enforced?
- 7:57Speaker 4: The judge, on that point said it will influence the
- 8:02Speaker 4: state's conduct in making decisions about either authorizing fossil fuel
- 8:09Speaker 4: development or promoting further extraction of fossil fuels. But she
- 8:14Speaker 4: stopped short of actually ordering the state to do anything
- 8:18Speaker 4: specific to either stop issuing permits obviously, or stop promoting
- 8:24Speaker 4: fossil fuel development. She didn't go that far. The plans
- 8:27Speaker 4: were asking for something like that, they didn't quite get that.
- 8:30Speaker 4: But I think what she's basically saying is it's an
- 8:33Speaker 4: optimistic view that once government officials look at what's really happening,
- 8:39Speaker 4: and document and disclose to the public what's really happening,
- 8:43Speaker 4: and also look at the alternatives that are available for
- 8:47Speaker 4: a different pathway forward, she's optimistically hoping that that will
- 8:52Speaker 4: change the direction of Montana's energy policy. That's the best
- 8:56Speaker 4: way to characterize it is it's a hope that when
- 9:00Speaker 4: facts and rational analysis is brought to bear on the problem,
- 9:06Speaker 4: better decisions will be made.
- 9:08Speaker 2: Pat This has been called a landmark case in light
- 9:12Speaker 2: of that. What makes it a landmark case, Well.
- 9:15Speaker 4: It's landmark in the sense it's the first time a
- 9:17Speaker 4: court has declared a constitutional right to a safe climate,
- 9:21Speaker 4: that's for sure, but it's a lower court decision that
- 9:25Speaker 4: has to be upheld on appeal before I think you
- 9:28Speaker 4: can truly call it landmark. It's a real breakthrough, it's
- 9:32Speaker 4: a major victory, it was an extraordinarily well litigated case.
- 9:37Speaker 4: All of those things are true. But right now, until
- 9:40Speaker 4: you've got the highest court in Montana saying yes, there
- 9:45Speaker 4: is not only a constitutional right to a safe climate,
- 9:48Speaker 4: but it's being violated right now by the state. Until
- 9:52Speaker 4: we have that final word, I'm going to hesitate to
- 9:55Speaker 4: say it's a landmark.
- 9:57Speaker 2: Right now, Montana is one of only a few states
- 10:01Speaker 2: that have the affirmative right to a healthful environment in
- 10:05Speaker 2: their constitutions. So will this only be influential in those states?
- 10:12Speaker 4: It will certainly be influential in the states with these
- 10:16Speaker 4: green amendments, these constitutional right to a healthy environment provisions.
- 10:21Speaker 4: That includes Hawaii. The next Our Children's Trust case is
- 10:25Speaker 4: now scheduled for trial in Hawaii in twenty twenty four,
- 10:28Speaker 4: And of course we all know what horror show is
- 10:31Speaker 4: going on in Lahina right now. Other states that have
- 10:35Speaker 4: similar green amendments, Pennsylvania, New York. Those are potential locations
- 10:41Speaker 4: for where we might see more litigation like this. In fact,
- 10:45Speaker 4: I would predict we will see that. So you've got Hawaii,
- 10:48Speaker 4: You've got Pennsylvania, you've got New York. Louisiana actually has
- 10:52Speaker 4: a very strong constitutional right to a healthy environment provision,
- 10:55Speaker 4: believe it or not. Other states, Washington, Alaska, they have
- 10:59Speaker 4: those provisions. Our Children's Trust has not been successful in
- 11:02Speaker 4: bringing cases in those other states. But I think with
- 11:05Speaker 4: the held decision, and particularly again if it's upheld, I
- 11:09Speaker 4: do think you're going to see more attempts to get
- 11:12Speaker 4: courts ruling in cases being brought not only by youth plaintiffs,
- 11:17Speaker 4: but by other kinds of effective interests. And so this
- 11:21Speaker 4: is part of an increasing number of cases being litigated
- 11:26Speaker 4: all over the world. There are now over two thousand
- 11:28Speaker 4: climate cases that have either been brought or are in
- 11:31Speaker 4: the process of being litigated. So we're seeing a growing
- 11:35Speaker 4: number of judicial decisions across the globe requiring stronger action
- 11:44Speaker 4: to deal with climate change, to disclose what is being
- 11:49Speaker 4: done and what is not being done to address it.
- 11:53Speaker 4: These cases are not going to solve the climate crisis, obviously,
- 11:57Speaker 4: but they are certainly building a body of law, including
- 12:02Speaker 4: constitutional law, that is going to continue to put lots
- 12:06Speaker 4: of pressure on the political branches of government, legislatures and
- 12:10Speaker 4: executive branches. And I think that body of law is
- 12:16Speaker 4: gradually moving the other branches of government to take meaningful action.
- 12:22Speaker 4: That's what I think is happening and certainly what I
- 12:24Speaker 4: hope will happen.
- 12:25Speaker 2: As you mentioned, there's this broad wave of litigation. States
- 12:29Speaker 2: and cities are suing companies like Exxon, Chevron, and Shell.
- 12:33Speaker 1: Have any of those reached a point of trial.
- 12:37Speaker 4: No. The one that's out in front right now is Honolulu,
- 12:41Speaker 4: and the Hawaii Supreme Court is reviewing a decision by
- 12:48Speaker 4: a lower Hawaii court denying the oil company's motion to
- 12:54Speaker 4: dismiss the case against them on the grounds that it's
- 12:58Speaker 4: preempted by federal law. So we're waiting to see how
- 13:02Speaker 4: the Hawaii Supreme Court rules on that issue. If the
- 13:06Speaker 4: Hawaii Supreme Court upholds the lower court, then I think
- 13:10Speaker 4: the next step in the Honolulu case is discovery, which
- 13:14Speaker 4: of course the oil companies are terrified about, and that
- 13:18Speaker 4: discovery will probably start to happen in twenty twenty four
- 13:24Speaker 4: and a trial. Then we can expect to follow maybe
- 13:29Speaker 4: starting in twenty twenty four, but more likely twenty twenty five.
- 13:34Speaker 4: So the bottom line is we're still probably years away
- 13:39Speaker 4: from a verdict on whether the oil companies are actually
- 13:43Speaker 4: liable for their campaign of deceit regarding climate change.
- 13:48Speaker 2: Turning to another environmental issue, pat President Joe Biden announced
- 13:53Speaker 2: close to one million acres of public land around Grand
- 13:56Speaker 2: Canyon National Park as a new national manuit through the
- 14:00Speaker 2: Antiquities Act.
- 14:02Speaker 5: Folks, preserving these lands is good, not only if Arizona,
- 14:06Speaker 5: for the planet. It's good for the economy, it's good
- 14:10Speaker 5: for the soul of the nation. And I believe, in
- 14:13Speaker 5: my core and of course the right thing to do.
- 14:17Speaker 2: Biden also restored two sprawling national monuments in Utah that
- 14:23Speaker 2: were downsized by former President Trump.
- 14:27Speaker 5: We want to restore protection for three national monuments gutted
- 14:31Speaker 5: by the last administration, two not so far from here
- 14:34Speaker 5: in Utah, the Grand Staircase and Bear's Ears.
- 14:38Speaker 2: Is declaring a national monument well within the powers of
- 14:42Speaker 2: the presidency.
- 14:43Speaker 4: Well, we think it is, and I would certainly argue
- 14:46Speaker 4: that it is. I will say this Judge Chief Justice Roberts,
- 14:52Speaker 4: in a case that was challenging the designation of a
- 14:55Speaker 4: marine National monument off the co of New England. He said,
- 15:04Speaker 4: the question of the scope of the president's authority under
- 15:09Speaker 4: the Antiquities Act, which is the act that authorizes these monuments,
- 15:14Speaker 4: has never been resolved by the Supreme Court. So he
- 15:20Speaker 4: sort of flagged in his mind anyway a question about
- 15:25Speaker 4: whether the size of some of these monuments that are
- 15:29Speaker 4: being designated is within the president's authority. So I think
- 15:33Speaker 4: what we have to say on that is, certainly we
- 15:36Speaker 4: are going to see litigation over what President Biden is doing,
- 15:40Speaker 4: and that litigation is probably going to end up in
- 15:43Speaker 4: the Supreme Court. And then it's a matter of cross
- 15:46Speaker 4: your fingers.
- 15:46Speaker 2: Yeah, because a judge dismissed the lawsuit from Utah that
- 15:50Speaker 2: challenged his restoration of Bearsiers and Grand Staircase Escalante national monuments.
- 15:58Speaker 4: Yeah, and those will go up on appeal. And now
- 16:01Speaker 4: this latest designation in the Grand Canyon will also be challenged.
- 16:05Speaker 4: So the litigation over the scope of the Antiquities Act authority,
- 16:10Speaker 4: I think we're going to have to wait and see
- 16:12Speaker 4: how that finally sugars off. As we say in Vermont, I.
- 16:16Speaker 2: Like that saying I may use it myself, Thanks so much.
- 16:18Speaker 2: Pat That's professor Pat Parento of the Vermont Law and
- 16:22Speaker 2: Graduate School. A federal appeals court has ruled that a
- 16:27Speaker 2: law banning gun possession by unlawful users of a controlled
- 16:31Speaker 2: substance doesn't apply to someone who's sober at the time
- 16:34Speaker 2: of the arrest. The US Court of Appeals for the
- 16:36Speaker 2: Fifth Circuit overturned a conviction under the statute because there
- 16:40Speaker 2: was no evidence the defendant was intoxicated at the time
- 16:43Speaker 2: of his arrest. The panel said the law was unconstitutional
- 16:47Speaker 2: as applied because it isn't consistent with the historical tradition
- 16:51Speaker 2: of firearm regulation. Joining me his Second Amendment. Law expert
- 16:55Speaker 2: Eric Rubin, a professor at the SMU Deadman's School of Law,
- 16:59Speaker 2: Eric tell us about the Fifth Circuits decision.
- 17:02Speaker 6: This case involved a challenge to a federal law that
- 17:06Speaker 6: does the unlawful users of drugs or those who addicted
- 17:09Speaker 6: to drugs cannot possess firearms, and in this particular case,
- 17:14Speaker 6: the defendant said that he was a regular user of
- 17:17Speaker 6: marijuana and because under federal law that's unlawful, he was
- 17:21Speaker 6: therefore barred from possessing a firearm, but he had to
- 17:24Speaker 6: firearms on him at the time and he challenged that
- 17:27Speaker 6: as a violation of the Second Amendment rights.
- 17:29Speaker 2: And so the Court applied the Supreme Court's recent history
- 17:34Speaker 2: guidelines for analyzing the constitutionality of firearms laws.
- 17:39Speaker 1: Tell us what their reasoning was the majority.
- 17:42Speaker 6: Here, Yes, the Court was applying the twenty twenty two
- 17:45Speaker 6: Supreme Court case Bruant, which says that in order for
- 17:49Speaker 6: a modern firearm law addressing modern issues to be upheld
- 17:54Speaker 6: as constitutional, the federal government has to point to analogous
- 18:01Speaker 6: of regulations from the late seventeen hundreds or perhaps the
- 18:05Speaker 6: eighteen hundreds. In the case of drug users, including marijuana users.
- 18:10Speaker 6: That's a bit difficult because modern drug use is largely
- 18:15Speaker 6: a twentieth century phenomenon with respect to marijuana and some
- 18:18Speaker 6: other drugs. And so the Court said that there weren't
- 18:22Speaker 6: sufficient analogs from the framing generation or from the eighteen hundreds.
- 18:26Speaker 6: They spent a lot of time looking at restrictions on
- 18:29Speaker 6: possession of firearms when somebody was under the influence of alcohol,
- 18:33Speaker 6: and also of restrictions on gun possession by the mentally ill,
- 18:37Speaker 6: and they ultimately found that those simply weren't analogous enough
- 18:41Speaker 6: to a permanent bar on gun possession by unlawful users
- 18:44Speaker 6: of marijuana today.
- 18:45Speaker 2: The majority wrote, it's helpful to compare the traditions surrounding
- 18:49Speaker 2: the insane and the traditions surrounding the intoxicated, side by side.
- 18:55Speaker 6: Right and again. This is something that the Bruined decision
- 18:57Speaker 6: back in twenty twenty two forces courts into this bizarre
- 19:01Speaker 6: world where they have to try to draw analogies to
- 19:04Speaker 6: regulations that were addressing different issues back in eighteen hundreds
- 19:07Speaker 6: or seventeen hundreds in order to shore up the constitutionality
- 19:10Speaker 6: of today's laws. And what the court acknowledged was that
- 19:13Speaker 6: there are plenty of regulations barring gun possession or gun
- 19:17Speaker 6: use when somebody is intoxicated by alcohol. But those laws
- 19:23Speaker 6: the Court construed very narrowly, saying that they only applied
- 19:27Speaker 6: back in eighteen hundreds or seventeen hundreds when somebody actually
- 19:30Speaker 6: was intoxicated, unlike today's law barring gun possession by unlawful
- 19:35Speaker 6: users of drugs, which applies even when somebody is not
- 19:39Speaker 6: under the influence of the drug.
- 19:41Speaker 2: So, in a concurring opinion, Judge Stephen Higginson said, it's
- 19:47Speaker 2: possible that inferior officers such as myself are misinterpreting Bruin
- 19:51Speaker 2: by focusing on the right to keep.
- 19:53Speaker 1: And bear arms.
- 19:55Speaker 2: And it may be the Supreme Court will remind us
- 19:58Speaker 2: of the Second Amendment's middle where the the framers stated
- 20:01Speaker 2: explicitly that they were fashioning aright necessary to.
- 20:04Speaker 1: The security of a free state. What is he talking about.
- 20:07Speaker 6: Here, Well, what he's talking about here is that in
- 20:10Speaker 6: recent years, over the past ten or fifteen years, the
- 20:13Speaker 6: Supreme Court and the lower courts have focused almost exclusively
- 20:17Speaker 6: on the second half of the Second Amendment, the right
- 20:20Speaker 6: to keep in bare arms shall not be infringed, and
- 20:23Speaker 6: have ignored the first part of the Amendment, which discusses
- 20:27Speaker 6: the militia and also the requirements for the security of
- 20:32Speaker 6: a free state. And what the judge is pointing out
- 20:35Speaker 6: is that a lot of modern regulations that might not
- 20:37Speaker 6: have historical analogs actually could help us secure the state.
- 20:42Speaker 6: But that aspect of the Amendment just isn't getting enough attention.
- 20:46Speaker 2: Is that because the Supreme Court deliberately ignored that aspect
- 20:50Speaker 2: of it and focused on the right to bear arms.
- 20:53Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 20:53Speaker 6: Under some views, the Supreme Court back in Heller in
- 20:56Speaker 6: two thousand and eight, essentially ignored the first half the Amendment,
- 21:01Speaker 6: saying that it does not expand or detract from the
- 21:05Speaker 6: scope of the right to keeping bear arms, and that
- 21:08Speaker 6: ruling that understanding of the Second Amendment from Heller has
- 21:12Speaker 6: led to a rapid expansion, especially in recent years, of
- 21:15Speaker 6: the scope of gun rights in this country, And what
- 21:18Speaker 6: the concurring judge is saying is that perhaps it's time
- 21:22Speaker 6: to take another look at that first half the Amendment.
- 21:25Speaker 2: So though the Fifth Circuit's decision is limited to Louisiana, Mississippi,
- 21:29Speaker 2: and Texas, could it potentially impact the federal case against
- 21:33Speaker 2: Hunter Biden because he's charged in Delaware under the same
- 21:36Speaker 2: statute that the Fifth Circuit is finding unconstitutional.
- 21:40Speaker 6: Yeah, the reasoning in the Fifth Circuit's decision, even though
- 21:43Speaker 6: it was a case involving marijuana, would seem to extend
- 21:46Speaker 6: to other drugs as well, and it would seem to
- 21:51Speaker 6: broadly limit the ability of the government to ban gun
- 21:54Speaker 6: possession by unlawful users of drugs. And so that reason,
- 21:58Speaker 6: because it's so expansive, it could be persuasive to other
- 22:02Speaker 6: courts around the country. And if the Hunter Biden plea
- 22:05Speaker 6: deal continues to unravel, I fully expect that there would
- 22:09Speaker 6: be a strong second amendment argument that his attorneys would
- 22:13Speaker 6: raise that his charge under the same provision that was
- 22:17Speaker 6: ruled unconstitutional in the case in the Fifth Circuit would
- 22:21Speaker 6: be unconstitutional to Hunter Biden as well.
- 22:24Speaker 2: So the Fifth Circuit has now declared two federal gun
- 22:27Speaker 2: statutes unconstitutional. Does it seem as if any gun statute
- 22:33Speaker 2: now is going to be subject to being litigated under Bruin.
- 22:40Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 22:40Speaker 6: Well, one of the things that we've seen over the
- 22:42Speaker 6: year after Brewin came up with this novel test that
- 22:45Speaker 6: requires modern gun laws to be a nowog just to
- 22:47Speaker 6: historical one is that courts are applying the same history
- 22:51Speaker 6: differently in striking down or upholding the identical policies. So
- 22:55Speaker 6: we have splits that are opening up all over the country,
- 22:58Speaker 6: including on the issue of AREM possession by unlawful users
- 23:01Speaker 6: of drugs. Most of the courts that have considered that
- 23:03Speaker 6: law found it perfectly constitutional. And these aren't the only issues.
- 23:08Speaker 6: The Fifth Circuit, being one of the most if not
- 23:11Speaker 6: the most conservative appellate courts in the country, has been declaring,
- 23:16Speaker 6: as you mentioned, a couple laws unconstitutional federal laws. But
- 23:20Speaker 6: other courts around the country are reaching the opposite conclusion.
- 23:24Speaker 6: So one of the things that a lot of Second
- 23:26Speaker 6: Amendment scholars and experts are looking for is for more
- 23:29Speaker 6: guidance from the Supreme Court that if this historical analogical
- 23:33Speaker 6: test is going to be what applies in Second Amendment cases,
- 23:37Speaker 6: there needs to be more guidance in terms of how
- 23:39Speaker 6: to view history, how broadly or narrowly should he construed,
- 23:43Speaker 6: Because right now we see a fair amount chaos in
- 23:45Speaker 6: the lower courts across issues not just on the question
- 23:49Speaker 6: of drugs and guns, but also on the questions of
- 23:51Speaker 6: the constitutionality of assault weapons and ghost guns and large
- 23:55Speaker 6: capacity magazines, and restrictions on domestic abusers and guns. And
- 23:59Speaker 6: so this case and the split that had opened up
- 24:02Speaker 6: is reflective of broader trends right now in the lower courts.
- 24:05Speaker 6: In the wake of that twenty twenty two decisions grew there.
- 24:08Speaker 2: Was a gun case before the Supreme Court next term,
- 24:11Speaker 2: isn't there?
- 24:12Speaker 6: Yes, this is the United States vi. Raheemi also out
- 24:14Speaker 6: of the Fifth Circuit. That case involves domestic abusers. In
- 24:18Speaker 6: that case, the Fifth Circuit said that it's unconstitutional to
- 24:21Speaker 6: disarm temporarily those who were subject to domestic violence for
- 24:25Speaker 6: straining orders. The Fifth Circuit in that case found that
- 24:29Speaker 6: also to be an outlier regulation, an outlier modern regulation
- 24:33Speaker 6: that our ancestors would not have accepted in that case.
- 24:37Speaker 6: Is especially indicative of the challenges of applying this historical
- 24:43Speaker 6: analogical test to modern gun regulations, because back at the framing,
- 24:47Speaker 6: domestic violence wasn't viewed in the same way that we
- 24:51Speaker 6: view it today. In fact, husbands had a right to
- 24:53Speaker 6: chastisement where they could discipline their wives and were protected
- 24:56Speaker 6: to do so, and could discipline their children. So domestic
- 25:00Speaker 6: abuse itself is a phenomenon that is a modern one.
- 25:04Speaker 6: Our appreciation of the risks of gendered violence in the home,
- 25:09Speaker 6: and it's no surprise given that that the court was
- 25:13Speaker 6: unable to find close analogs from back in the seventeen hundreds.
- 25:18Speaker 2: In all these cases about the Second Amendment using Bruin's
- 25:22Speaker 2: so called history test, one that really stands out to
- 25:26Speaker 2: me is a case decided last week by the Ninth
- 25:29Speaker 2: Circuit that found that Hawaii's ban on butterfly knives was unconstitutional.
- 25:36Speaker 4: One of the.
- 25:37Speaker 6: Things that this case, and this is the case Peter v.
- 25:39Speaker 6: Lopez out of the Ninth Circuit, one of the things
- 25:42Speaker 6: that it reflects is just the way that courts are
- 25:45Speaker 6: manipulating his history to reach one outcome or another. So
- 25:50Speaker 6: in that case, for example, the court took a very
- 25:54Speaker 6: broad view of the historical understanding of arms, basically saying
- 25:58Speaker 6: that it encompasses all weapons, including these butterfly knives, which
- 26:03Speaker 6: in modern days are associated with a lot of criminality.
- 26:07Speaker 6: And at the same time that the Court took this
- 26:10Speaker 6: broad view of the definition of Second Amendment arms, it
- 26:14Speaker 6: then took a very narrow view of the historical regulations
- 26:19Speaker 6: that could be analogous to a modern van on butterfly knives.
- 26:22Speaker 4: There were lots of laws back.
- 26:23Speaker 6: In eighteen hundreds of restricting certain types of knives, but
- 26:27Speaker 6: the court viewed that those were disnalogous because, for example,
- 26:31Speaker 6: they governed bigger knives than the butterfly knive, which the
- 26:36Speaker 6: court repeatedly referred to as a pocket knife, even though
- 26:39Speaker 6: you know, these butterfly knives that you can flip open
- 26:42Speaker 6: so are not usually what we think of when we
- 26:43Speaker 6: think of pocket knives. Pocket knives came up repeatedly, probably
- 26:47Speaker 6: a dozen times in this opinion, saying that these butterfly
- 26:50Speaker 6: knives are just pocket knives.
- 26:52Speaker 2: But if they appeal that to the full Ninth Circuit.
- 26:56Speaker 2: Do you think that full Ninth Circuit would overrule the
- 27:00Speaker 2: three judge panel.
- 27:01Speaker 6: I think this was a panel that was not reflective
- 27:04Speaker 6: I think of the broader Ninth Circuit. So it's very
- 27:08Speaker 6: possible that if this case gets appealed, that it could
- 27:11Speaker 6: actually end up with a different outcome with an en
- 27:16Speaker 6: BOONMC panel of the Ninth Circuit. That's been a trend
- 27:19Speaker 6: that we've seen in past years, even before Bruin. Sometimes
- 27:22Speaker 6: there would be a broad, broad, robust, bansive understanding of
- 27:26Speaker 6: what the Second Amendment protects that would get appealed and
- 27:28Speaker 6: reversed on bond. So I would not be surprised at
- 27:32Speaker 6: all if we see a petition to rehear this case
- 27:35Speaker 6: by a broader panel of the Ninth Circuit.
- 27:37Speaker 2: I mean, there are so many challenges based on the
- 27:41Speaker 2: Second Amendment that courts around the country are grappling with.
- 27:45Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 27:45Speaker 6: So there have been over two hundred challenges brought in
- 27:49Speaker 6: the year after Bruin came down, challenging all range of
- 27:54Speaker 6: weapons regulations. There are lots and lots, there are thousands
- 27:57Speaker 6: of regulations on weapons into violence. They're all getting challenged.
- 28:02Speaker 6: One of the things that the Supreme Court did in
- 28:04Speaker 6: that Ruined case is by changing the way that cases
- 28:08Speaker 6: get decided. The Supreme Court basically gave plaintiffs a redo
- 28:12Speaker 6: to challenge laws that had been viewed as perfectly constitutional.
- 28:15Speaker 6: Across the country, advocates are now getting a second bite
- 28:18Speaker 6: at the apple. So we're seeing more Second Amendment litigation
- 28:21Speaker 6: than we even did after Heller. There are more splits
- 28:25Speaker 6: that are opening up courts looking at the same history
- 28:28Speaker 6: and coming to opposite conclusions about the constitutionality of identical
- 28:31Speaker 6: policies than there were after Heller. So there's just a
- 28:35Speaker 6: lot of discord. This is an area of law that
- 28:38Speaker 6: is incredibly influx depending on the makeup of courts and
- 28:42Speaker 6: where litigation is happening in the country. And I think
- 28:45Speaker 6: it's going to take a very long time, if this
- 28:48Speaker 6: Bruin test is going to be workable, for everything to
- 28:51Speaker 6: shake out and become more coherent, because right now there's
- 28:54Speaker 6: just no predictability about the constitutionality of most regulations.
- 28:59Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Eric.
- 29:00Speaker 1: That's Professor Eric Rubin of the s m U Deadman
- 29:03Speaker 1: School of Law.
- 29:04Speaker 2: Michael Bloomberg, the founder and majority owner of Bloomberg l P,
- 29:08Speaker 2: the parent company of Bloomberg Radio is the donor to
- 29:11Speaker 2: groups that support gun control, including every Town for Guns Safety.
- 29:16Speaker 2: And that's it for the s edition of the Bloomberg
- 29:18Speaker 2: Lawn Show. Remember you can always get the latest legal
- 29:21Speaker 2: news by listening to our Bloomberg Lawn podcasts. You can
- 29:24Speaker 2: find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot
- 29:28Speaker 2: bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, slash Law. I'm June Grosso
- 29:33Speaker 2: and this is Bloomberg