Latest / 20-Minute Health Talk / Nerve blocks: Fighting opioid addiction with safer pain management
Transcript
- 0:02Dr. Marino: What's so beautiful about the nerve block
- 0:05is that, God forbid, if you fracture your hip, you're going to come in
- 0:08and people are going to perform a procedure that takes seconds and is
- 0:14going to give you significant pain relief without the adverse effects
- 0:17of morphine-like drugs.
- 0:19This will be standard of care across every Northwell facility.
- 0:30Host: Welcome to 20-Minute Health Talk.
- 0:32I'm your host Rob Hoell. The overuse of pain medications and narcotics
- 0:37like opioids in health care over
- 0:39the last two decades has had devastating effects.
- 0:42Our guests today are leading the way in expanding the use of nerve
- 0:45blocks.
- 0:46The use of this long-lasting regional anesthetic has revolutionized
- 0:50the field of anesthesia and is part of an important and necessary
- 0:54shift in the conversation about how we manage pain
- 0:58joining us in the studio is
- 1:00Dr. Joseph Marino.
- 1:01He is Northwell's senior, vice president for anesthesia who is not
- 1:04only championing
- 1:05the use of nerve blocks in the surgical setting.
- 1:07Now expanding its use to other services, including emergency
- 1:11departments; a game changing move that has immediate and potentially
- 1:15life-saving results.
- 1:19Here to share their experience and joining us virtually in implementing
- 1:22this novel approach in an emergency department setting are:
- 1:25Dr. Joshua, Greenstein, assistant medical director, the department of
- 1:29emergency medicine at Staten Island.
- 1:31Dr. Maria Tama, co-director for the division of emergency, ultrasound and
- 1:35Dr. Simone Rudnin, co-director division of emergency ultrasound.
- 1:40So, we'll get started with a question for you.
- 1:42Dr. Marino. Tell us what exactly is a nerve block?
- 1:45Dr. Marino: So a nerve block is nothing more than the placement
- 1:49of Novocaine or local anesthetic around the nerve.
- 1:53visa-vie a needle tip. Under the guidance of an ultrasound probe
- 1:59we're able to visualize the needle tip and also visualize the
- 2:05novocaine or local anesthetic.
- 2:07Bathe the surrounding nerve.
- 2:10Host: So, basically, what it's doing, it's like almost big being at the
- 2:12dentist.
- 2:13It's numbing the area, so you're not feeling pain, but you're not
- 2:16feeling High?
- 2:17Correct
- 2:19Host: That's awesome.
- 2:20So you're saying that nerve blocks have revolutionized the field of
- 2:23anesthesiology in the last two decades.
- 2:25Why?
- 2:26Dr. Marino: So I just want to give the visual to the patients and two people out
- 2:31there.
- 2:32We used to put people to sleep and the only mechanism that we had to
- 2:36treat their post-operative pain was intravenous morphine-like drugs
- 2:42or narcotics.
- 2:43So typically, you would find a patient in the recovery room
- 2:47holding an emesis basin
- 2:49nauseous and potentially vomiting because of the side effects
- 2:54of that opioid and also very drowsy and very sedate.
- 3:00In certain cases, if there was too much morphine or too much opioid given
- 3:06there would be some respiratory rate or breathing decrease issues.
- 3:12So, opioids, and I'm talking not too far ago
- 3:17I'm talking probably 15 years ago, were the mainstay of post-operative
- 3:23pain therapy. Now because of the advent of the nerve block, and the
- 3:28ability for us
- 3:30to anesthetize a certain part of the body that had surgery performed
- 3:36on it
- 3:37virtually eliminates the need for these post-operative opioids.
- 3:42Host: Dr. Greenstein the team at Staten Island University.
- 3:44Hospital began using femoral nerve blocks for patients into the
- 3:48emergency department in 2021.
- 3:49Tell us about how this got started started.
- 3:52Dr. Greenstein: It started becoming described in the literature in the last decade, but it
- 3:55really wasn't standard care.
- 3:57I myself graduatedin 2015.
- 4:00Never did a single one of these procedures who during my residency and so we
- 4:03didn't really have the staff that was really trained to do it.
- 4:06Even though it was something we thought we thought we'd be able to do.
- 4:09We put a lot of needles
- 4:10next targets.
- 4:10We use ultrasound in many different procedure itself.
- 4:13So Dr. Marino, the real visionary along with power chair at the time.
- 4:16Dr. Birol, who's now, the associate medical director came together
- 4:19and we said, how can we make this a reality for our patients?
- 4:22How can we train our staff? Help
- 4:23Provide some education. And furthermore it was a little complicated because
- 4:26a lot of these patients were doing this for patients with hip fractures
- 4:30So they're being admitted to other services.
- 4:32Other surgeons are taking care of the patients.
- 4:34They're gonna have to deal with the procedure that we do, and they're
- 4:36going to manage it.
- 4:37And so it's kind of like we're handing off or procedure and they're
- 4:39going to then be left with the patient and self.
- 4:41And so, we brought all the players involved, we brought
- 4:43orthopaedics, we brought
- 4:44Trauma, anesthesia, kind of explained what we're going to do.
- 4:48We got brought in from all the major players, and we were able to
- 4:50accomplish it.
- 4:51And we're currently, we're aiming to get 100% by September of this
- 4:55year.
- 4:55We're currently at 70% of our emergency medicine, physicians, are all
- 4:58trained
- 4:59how to do this and
- 5:00credentialed.
- 5:00That's really really revolutionized
- 5:02how many are getting it
- 5:03Because instead of being one in a few that know how to do it
- 5:0670% are doing it.
- 5:07So, when you have this patients, it's not like, oh, I don't know how
- 5:09to do it.
- 5:10It's when can we do it?
- 5:13Host: Dr. Greenestein just talked a little bit about training
- 5:15emergency room physicians in the use of femoral nerve blocks.
- 5:18Dr. Rudnin
- 5:19Can you tell us a little bit more about that process?
- 5:22Dr. Rudnin: Sure. So the ultrasound division in the ER is ensuring that all of our Ed
- 5:29providers
- 5:29are receiving training to perform these procedures. Our residents get
- 5:37every several months, a procedure lab where they get to practice it.
- 5:41Our attendings also.
- 5:41We do faculty development for that.
- 5:44So they have simulators where they can actually practice these
- 5:47procedures and they ultimately get credentialed and are very excited
- 5:52to go ahead and continue and providing these procedures to actual
- 5:56patients.
- 5:57Dr. Tama: And we also
- 6:00review a lot of these cases.
- 6:03And so a lot of the residents and attendings are kind of still
- 6:06reaching out to us.
- 6:07Like, oh, we did this nerve block, can you take a look?
- 6:10So we're still kind of, you know, making sure everyone's following the
- 6:13rules and doing it appropriately.
- 6:16Host: It's awesome to hear about that enthusiasm Dr. Tama
- 6:19right now, emergency departments at Northwell
- 6:21are starting with femoral block, but there are many types of
- 6:24nerve blocks. Are there plans expanding training to emergency
- 6:28physicians in uses for others?
- 6:30Dr. Marino: So I love the question and just like the Staten Island team and I were
- 6:35envisioning bringing this powerful tool to treat hip fractures
- 6:42vis-à-vis, the femoral block and that can can essentially eliminate
- 6:47pain leg knee
- 6:52foot, if we have to. We already have visions of expanding the use of
- 6:56ultrasound-guided nerve blocks for
- 7:00Upper arm problems.
- 7:02So somebody comes in with a shoulder dislocation or a
- 7:05laceration to the arm, shoulder or hand
- 7:09God willing
- 7:10If we continue on this path of innovation, we're going to be able to
- 7:16in service our emergency medicine physicians, in partnership and
- 7:20collaboration with the anesthesiologist, to do these upper arm or
- 7:25upper extremity nerve blocks and provide a reduction in pain.
- 7:30A reduction in need for opioids and significant patient satisfaction.
- 7:35Host: So where exactly are the nerves that get the nerve blocks in the human
- 7:39body?
- 7:40Dr. Marino: Yeah.
- 7:40So, you know, I'm going to give you a little bit of an anatomy lesson
- 7:44here.
- 7:44So the brachial plexus or the upper extremity nerve bundle is just
- 7:51above the shoulder and we could place novocaine around that brachial,
- 7:56plexus to essentially numb the shoulder entire arm
- 8:00and hand. The lumbar plexus is where the femoral nerve is located in
- 8:04the groin.
- 8:05And then the abdomen has a variety of different areas that we could
- 8:10inject novocaine in under ultrasound guidance, to significantly
- 8:14reduce some of those more provocative surgical operations of the
- 8:18abdomen, like a hernia operation or a C-section.
- 8:24Host: It's great
- 8:25Dr. Tama what types of patients are using are using nerve blocks for?
- 8:30Dr. Tama: So, the majority of patients are ones with hip fractures.
- 8:35Sometimes, we'll get femur fractures as well.
- 8:37You also can use it for patients that have like really bad laceration or
- 8:43patients that have a significant burn to the thigh
- 8:47We're kind of on the lookout for that. But those are other potential
- 8:50uses for this nerve block.
- 8:53Host: Yeah.
- 8:53I mean, I would imagine it hip fractures and extremely painful and
- 8:58difficult to deal with.
- 8:58So Dr. Marino
- 8:59How does
- 9:00the nerve block compared to the standard approach in this situation and
- 9:04what has been the reaction from the patients who received the nerve
- 9:07block?
- 9:08Dr. Marino: Yeah.
- 9:08So excellent question and the reaction has been, you know, needless to
- 9:16say, high satisfaction scores.
- 9:19So, you know, just think about it.
- 9:21Somebody is going to church.
- 9:23They fall on the concrete and they don't know if they have a fractured
- 9:28hip, but it's really
- 9:30uncomfortable.
- 9:30And by the time they get into the ambulance and bounce around on the
- 9:35gurney, get taken to the hospital. Bounce Around even more.
- 9:39That is a very provocative experience for the patient.
- 9:42And again in the past all we did in all we had were IV morphine like
- 9:47injections for these patients.
- 9:49Now it worked it would take a little bit of the edge of the pain away.
- 9:53But if you moved that patient, the pain would still be there.
- 9:58And what's so beautiful
- 10:00about the nerve block is that you can move these patients.
- 10:05And the movement will not provoke that serious pain that you see with
- 10:11the with the IV narcotic injection.
- 10:13So, not only does it eliminate the need for narcotic, or I should say,
- 10:18significantly reduce - its opioid sparing - but the movement of the
- 10:24patient is appreciated with significant less provocation.
- 10:28Host: And when you talk about collaboration, you can only see this spreading
- 10:31and the Innovation growing, you know, not only in Northwell but
- 10:34in other places.
- 10:35Dr. Marino: Is correct hundred percent?
- 10:37Yeah, it's only a matter of time.
- 10:38I mean now we piloted this at Staten Island in their Brilliance and
- 10:43success demonstrated that it works and it's safe.
- 10:47We're rolling it out at South Shore [University Hospital] and before you know, what Northern
- 10:51Westchester [Hospital], Phelps [Hospital], [LIJ] Forest Hills, they're all going to be a part of it.
- 10:55And then before, you know it this will be standard of care across
- 10:59every Northwell facility.
- 11:01God forbid.
- 11:01If you fracture your hip you're going to come in and people are going
- 11:05perform a procedure that takes seconds and is going to give you significant
- 11:10pain relief without the adverse effects of morphine like drugs
- 11:14Host: Dr. Tama.
- 11:15What do you say to a patient?
- 11:16Obviously, a patient's going to come in and excruciating pain and they
- 11:18might be demanding, you know, some sort of pain medication.
- 11:21What do you say to them?
- 11:21And how do you can convince them that this is the right move?
- 11:26Dr. Tama: So it does take some finesse definitely, because it is something new
- 11:30that a lot of patients or their families are not familiar with.
- 11:34We tell them kind of what to expect.
- 11:37And then we tell them that later on
- 11:39they won't be able to move their legs and kind of the expectations of
- 11:42what they should feel after the block is done and when it's done
- 11:45correctly. And everyone is like signing the consent form, like right
- 11:49then and there like a sure, sign me up.
- 11:51No problem.
- 11:52It definitely kind of
- 11:54starts their treatment from the beginning
- 11:57they walk into the emergency department.
- 12:00and helps them kind of move along through
- 12:02the hospital stay quicker.
- 12:04Host: So, Dr. Rudnin
- 12:05does learning something like this, make you a better
- 12:08physician?
- 12:10Dr. Rudnin: So learning a technique like a nerve block, as long as we were
- 12:14familiar with the anatomy hitting that nerve kind of came as second
- 12:18nature
- 12:18once we were comfortable with the anatomy. When it comes to making you
- 12:23a better physician
- 12:24Absolutely.
- 12:25You're able to do a procedure that spares a patient significant pain
- 12:30without providing them, you know, the potential effects of opioids.
- 12:36Dr. Tama: Yeah, and the definitely the patients feel that also
- 12:40We've had a few cases where we've had patients request, you know, they
- 12:44didn't, they did not get their surgery within 24 hours because of
- 12:48other Hospital complications and they have actually called and
- 12:52requested to have the emergency department come and do another nerve
- 12:56block.
- 12:57And so they definitely feel the benefits of it as well.
- 13:01Host: Dr. Greenstein how satisfying is it to be leading this effort and to be
- 13:05helping to, to get this message out and to be training others?
- 13:08Dr. Greenstein: Yeah.
- 13:09I mean, it's absolutely amazing.
- 13:10That what's really amazing is when the patient's family finds in the
- 13:13hallway, the next day they tell you about how, like their mother,
- 13:16their grandmother got a good night's sleep or how they didn't
- 13:19take his another dose of pain medication till the surgery.
- 13:22That's really get the ultimate satisfaction.
- 13:25So, it's really great thing, and it's gone really
- 13:28Well.
- 13:28We've had no issues.
- 13:31Using the ultrasound has really made it straightforward and simple
- 13:33so it's really awesome.
- 13:42Host: We sort during Covid, such an increase in opioid use in opioid
- 13:46overdoses.
- 13:47While still necessary.
- 13:48In some cases.
- 13:49These dangerous narcotics can lead to addiction. About three to four
- 13:53percent of patients undergoing
- 13:54elective surgery who have never taken an opioid develop a dependency.
- 13:58The addiction rate is higher for some types of procedures, and we
- 14:01know it's also associated with longer hospital stays and a higher
- 14:04rate of readmission. Can nerve blocks help stem that tide.
- 14:09Dr. Marino: Oh, it's always
- 14:12Back to, you know, the concept of treating pain.
- 14:14So procedurists in general, that would perform a surgical procedure,
- 14:19would typically give a patient, you know, a couple of week or a month
- 14:23supply of opioids.
- 14:25We no longer do that.
- 14:26We Now understand that giving a patient the appropriate dose of a pain
- 14:32medication.
- 14:33After a surgical procedure 3 to 5 days-worth; getting a nerve block,
- 14:39which is going to essentially
- 14:41significantly reduce the amount of pain in that very provocative first
- 14:46post-operative day and then allow the pain to the patient to
- 14:50transition to their pain medication for a three to four day
- 14:55period is exactly how the medical community is looking to.
- 15:00address and define success in reducing opioid dependency in surgical
- 15:04population.
- 15:05Host: Have you seen any data yet showing that how this is reducing
- 15:09addiction?
- 15:10Dr. Marino: So that's what the Statin Staten Island team and I are planning on
- 15:15doing this collecting data.
- 15:17So we have years of data of not doing a femoral nerve block and seeing
- 15:22how much morphine like medication patients with a hip fracture
- 15:26typically have received, and now, we're going to compare
- 15:30this new cohort of patients that have received the femoral nerve
- 15:34block and we're going to look at variables like how long it took them
- 15:38to go to surgery?
- 15:39What their Hospital length of stay is.
- 15:42And without question what their pain scores and morphine consumption
- 15:46was. And I think it's going to be easy to show that the morphine
- 15:50consumption and the pain scores are significantly lower leading to
- 15:55higher patient satisfaction scores.
- 15:57Definitely, and Dr. Marino I'd like to add, I think also
- 16:00So the patient outcome is going to be not only are they going to have lower
- 16:02morphine, but their outcome; they'll be ambulatory more quickly
- 16:06after surgery.
- 16:06I think the all those things that you want, you want the person that
- 16:09fell and has a fracture to be the same person before the surgery as
- 16:13they are after the surgery.
- 16:14This is going to help a lot.
- 16:16Host: We've been talking about using one type of nerve block in emergency
- 16:19departments, but
- 16:20Dr. Marino
- 16:20How commonly do nerve blocks
- 16:21get used in the surgical setting and at Northwell
- 16:24what is the ratio of patients getting nerve blocks compared to
- 16:26those other methods of pain management?
- 16:29Dr. Marino: I would say it's the overwhelming majority of patients who were having
- 16:33some sort of a provocative Orthopedic procedure.
- 16:36So total knee replacement, total hip replacement, total shoulder
- 16:40replacement, standard of care is to get what we call a regional nerve
- 16:45block.
- 16:46In addition to some sort of either general anesthetic or sedation.
- 16:51So that when the patient does wake up from the surgical procedure,
- 16:57their body part is totally numb.
- 17:00Host: And what about when when, when it wears off the 18 to 24 hours is up
- 17:04then just the pain come back?
- 17:06Dr. Marino: So we teach the patient that as they're getting that numb and tingling
- 17:10feeling starting to come back because, you know, when the numbness is
- 17:14starting to wear off, they should start their oral pain medication
- 17:19regimen.
- 17:21Host: Ok. And what is that mostly is that mostly like ibuprofen?
- 17:23Dr. Marino: it's a, it's usually, a combination of Ibuprofen and Tylenol and a
- 17:27very, very light narcotic.
- 17:30Host: Are there any side effects?
- 17:32I know like sometimes with opioids, you could you get nauseous, you
- 17:35could vomit, you could have itching.
- 17:37Is there any side effects with with a nerve block
- 17:39Before when we were doing the Poke and hope approach
- 17:42We would put our finger on the femoral artery because the femoral
- 17:46nerve lies right next to it.
- 17:48And we would place the needle tip right next to the nerve.
- 17:52And again, we would poke through the skin and hope that the local
- 17:56anesthetic or novocaine was bathing
- 18:00The periphery of that nerve.
- 18:01Well, sometimes the needle tip would enter into a blood vessel and
- 18:07that's not where that local anesthetic should go.
- 18:10If that was the case, the patient may be afflicted with something called
- 18:16local anesthetic before when we were
- 18:19Where when the body when the blood vessels absorb quickly the local
- 18:24anesthetic that is not a good place to be. Patients can get very
- 18:28dizzy.
- 18:29They could get numbness
- 18:30around their lips; and in severe cases, it could lead to a seizure.
- 18:35So the ultrasound has virtually eliminated that concept that Prospect
- 18:40and that's why we're all as practitioners feel like we have power in
- 18:45our hands.
- 18:46Host: So this is all exciting stuff, you know and here on 20-Minute Health Talk
- 18:49We always like to end on a positive note.
- 18:51So I like to ask each one of you, what gives you hope what gives you
- 18:55optimism going forward and I'll start with you.
- 18:58Dr. Rudnin.
- 19:00Dr. Rudnin: So, what gives us hope at least for me is the fact that patients their
- 19:05overall satisfaction is going to be increased.
- 19:08They're going to be having a significant reduction of their pain
- 19:12without having the detrimental side effects of opioids
- 19:16Host: Dr. Tama, what gives you hope but gives you optimism.
- 19:21Dr. Tama: This collaboration that we have with anesthesia
- 19:26gives us hope.
- 19:28I think that
- 19:29as physicians we want to encourage each other to continue to do better
- 19:33and this kind of multidisciplinary team work
- 19:37really gives me hope that there's so much more that us as emergency
- 19:40department
- 19:40doctors can do for our patients and even started from the beginning
- 19:44because we are the entryway to the hospital.
- 19:47So I definitely think that this opens the door for so much more work.
- 19:51That could be done for them.
- 19:53Host: Has there been any
- 19:55pushback from Physicians?
- 19:58Because sometimes,
- 19:59People don't want to do different things.
- 20:00They're kind of set in their ways.
- 20:04Dr. Greenstein: Yes, I would say that.
- 20:05That was probably one of my biggest concerns was teaching, you know,
- 20:09new trick to some people that have their set ways and how they
- 20:11managed their practice and manage other things.
- 20:13And once somebody learned how to do it and do just that one of them
- 20:17and saw the impact on the patient's, they want to do it, like they
- 20:20wanted to become in their practice.
- 20:22So we've been able to just want to none like people do one of them
- 20:25like, oh, I need to do it for every single one of patients.
- 20:28So it's really been amazing.
- 20:28And that's really the hope for me is that we bought into this, this
- 20:32culture of nerve blocks
- 20:33is that the sky's the limit
- 20:35We're a burn center here.
- 20:36We have so many terrible burns of the extremities, imagine we can provide
- 20:39them with an anesthetic right to that to the nerve, give them 18 hours
- 20:43of pain control instead of pain medicine after pain medicine and pain medicine,
- 20:47and the outcomes could be great.
- 20:49Host: Dr. Greenestein I loved how you answered both of those questions right
- 20:52there.
- 20:52Dr. Marino, what gives you hope?
- 20:54What gives you optimism going forward?
- 20:56Dr. Marino: So, I'm the old guy of the group and you look at these three.
- 21:00brilliant young physicians to my right. You know, sometimes I come off
- 21:06as The Nutty Professor.
- 21:06Hey guys, I got this idea.
- 21:09I think it's going to work.
- 21:10I think it's going to have an impact on patients and you really don't
- 21:13know what the feedback or the buy-in is going to be.
- 21:17But my hope really lies and I'm really echoing what
- 21:21Maria said before, which is it all comes down to Innovation.
- 21:26So if you change your thought process and you have
- 21:30Courage to ask a question and then you have these young spirited,
- 21:34brilliant minds
- 21:36that look at you and have enough trust in you.
- 21:38And to say, okay.
- 21:42Let's try this.
- 21:43Let's make sure if we're going to do it
- 21:45Let's do it right.
- 21:46But let's try this.
- 21:47And just because of our partnership.
- 21:51We're already able to impact people on a real visceral level, and my
- 21:56hope lies in that.
- 21:57As long as we continue to come up with the idea.
- 22:00Continue to have the courage to ask the question.
- 22:03Always try and overcome the hurdle, find the yes.
- 22:06And together you could see that there are differences in generation
- 22:10because of the age gap. But because of these brilliant minds, my hope
- 22:15lies in them.
- 22:18Host: Thank you all so much for joining us here on 20-Minute Health Talk.
- 22:20It was a great conversation.
- 22:22Thank you.
- 22:23Dr. Marino.
- 22:23Dr. Greenstein.
- 22:24Dr. Tama and Dr. Rudnin.
- 22:27And thank you.
- 22:27The Listener for tuning in.
- 22:29I'm Rob Hoell
- 22:29Have a great day and stay safe.