Latest / The So What? / Getting a Grip on the Informal Sector
Transcript
- 0:05Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in
- 0:08which political economic analyst J .P. c
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of
- 0:13South Africans. You can find a written version
- 0:16of this content on J .P.'s website, jplandman
- 0:19.co .za. I am Ruda Landman, and I am your host.
- 0:26This podcast accompanies J .P.'s newsletter dated
- 0:30the 21st of July, 2025. under the title Getting
- 0:35a Grip on the Informal Sector. The outgoing Capitec
- 0:39CEO, Harry Fourie, generated quite a debate recently
- 0:43on South Africa's informal sector and the unemployment
- 0:48rate. And this is in response to that, right
- 0:51JP? Yes. Where did you go to find information?
- 0:54Well, I paid a visit. I went to see Joe de Beer,
- 0:57who's the Deputy Director General at Stats SA,
- 1:00responsible for economic statistics. And he was
- 1:04very helpful, very generous with his time and
- 1:07experience. And he's clearly a guy who's got
- 1:09his feet very, very firmly on the ground. He
- 1:11knows what's going on. I also relied on reports
- 1:14by the Bureau for Economic Research at Stellenbosch
- 1:17and also on work that was done by Professor Johan
- 1:21Verrie from the Stellenbosch Economics Faculty.
- 1:23So those three sources helped me to try and come
- 1:26to grips with this rather complex topic. Okay,
- 1:30so let's start with the basics. How is GDP determined?
- 1:35That is indeed the starting point. We follow
- 1:39in South Africa the international standard of
- 1:43SNA, and SNA is simply a system of national accounts.
- 1:47It is run by the United Nations. It was started
- 1:50in 1947. The first one was issued in 1953, and
- 1:55there are regular updates, and the latest update
- 1:58was in 2025. So what we can see is that there
- 2:02are many, many people in many countries in the
- 2:04world over many decades who are seized with this
- 2:08matter. And South Africa obviously is one of
- 2:11them. If you say it was published, what was published?
- 2:16Is it a kind of template? It's a template. It's
- 2:19a template with rules and standard formulations
- 2:23that must be used. So it's really a globally
- 2:26synchronized and globally standardized system.
- 2:29And South Africa applies that. Now, what happens
- 2:33is that the S &A, the System of National Accounts,
- 2:37measures the transactions that take place in
- 2:40the economy through three accounts, a production
- 2:43account, an expenditure account, and an income
- 2:46account. And basically what happens is you trace
- 2:49the flow of money as money moves through the
- 2:52economy, and you capture it in the different
- 2:54accounts. And that gives you a bird's eye view
- 2:57of what's going on in the economy. That bird's
- 3:00eye view is what we call GDP or gross domestic
- 3:02product, which all our listeners will be familiar
- 3:06with. Now, it is very important to note that
- 3:09gross domestic product is the value added by
- 3:13all economic actors. So whether you're a household,
- 3:16individual, a podcast studio, a bank, a mine.
- 3:21They're all economic actors. And the issue is
- 3:23how much value do they add onto the economy?
- 3:27Why is this important? It is only about the value
- 3:31added. You have to deduct from what an economic
- 3:35player produces, a bank or a podcast studio.
- 3:38Whatever they produce, you have to deduct the
- 3:41input cost. What does it cost them to produce
- 3:44that good or service? If you don't do that, you
- 3:47do double counting. And you don't want to do
- 3:50that. It'll give you a completely wrong reading.
- 3:53And many of the Qazi economics people, if I can
- 3:57call it that, make this basic mistake of not
- 4:00deducting the input costs. And then you sit with
- 4:05unreliable data. Unpack it in terms of, say,
- 4:09someone who sells tomatoes on the street. OK,
- 4:13let's take a street vending lady selling on the
- 4:17street tomatoes and sweets. Let's say that she
- 4:20makes 2000 rand a day. That is what she takes.
- 4:24That's her total income. And now, of course,
- 4:27she's registered nowhere. So she doesn't appear
- 4:29in any system. And it's all cash. And it's all
- 4:31cash. And now people say, well, we missed that
- 4:342000 rand in our economic statistics. That is
- 4:38not quite true. First of all. Our street vending
- 4:42lady is buying her product somewhere. She may
- 4:45buy it from the fresh produce market. She may
- 4:47buy it from a fruit wholesaler. She may buy it
- 4:50from a next door neighbor who happens to grow
- 4:52tomatoes. That's quite possible. The next door
- 4:55neighbor is not giving it to her for free. So
- 4:58let's assume of the 2 ,000 rand sales that she
- 5:01had, that she had 1 ,000 rand in cost to procure
- 5:04the goods that she's selling. Then she has got
- 5:07some other costs. Let's assume that she's spending
- 5:1050 Rand on getting to the place, the spot where
- 5:13she's selling it. And let's assume that she's
- 5:16paying another 50 Rand to a youngster who helps
- 5:18her to carry the goods and look after the store
- 5:21for the day. So she earns 2 ,000 Rand. The basic
- 5:25input cost is 1 ,000. There's 50 Rand transport
- 5:29cost. There's 50 Rand to an assistant. That's
- 5:31100 Rand. She nets 900 Rand. And what you capture
- 5:37in the production accounts is the R1100. How
- 5:41do you mean what you capture in the production
- 5:43accounts? Well, the sales that are made by the
- 5:47fresh produce market or the sales that are made
- 5:51by the shop that sells the tomatoes. Her purchase
- 5:56is their sale. And so it will be recorded there.
- 5:58So it's counted on their books? It's counted
- 6:00on their books. Now, what we haven't explained
- 6:03yet is the 900 Rand out of the 2 ,000. What happens
- 6:06there? Well, that 900 Rand gets spent. Even if
- 6:10she puts it under the mattress for a week or
- 6:12two, at some point it gets spent, spent on her
- 6:15personal... food and clothing and transport the
- 6:19things that people spend money on that is after
- 6:21all why she's doing the street vending is to
- 6:23generate money for her own existence and the
- 6:26900 rand goes into the economy and it's picked
- 6:29up by the various people who sell her the services
- 6:32so if you if you look at it from these two sides
- 6:35you can see that most of the 2000 rand gets captured
- 6:39wherever it is getting captured but of course
- 6:42it's realistic to say that not every rand in
- 6:46the economy gets recorded. It is only realistic
- 6:50to say that some money will flow around that
- 6:53we do not capture. Now, how much? How much? That's
- 6:56the big question. I found it interesting that
- 6:58StatCSA themselves acknowledges in the way they
- 7:03present these figures that there will be some
- 7:06money which is not counted anywhere. Absolutely.
- 7:08And what's their thumbsuck? So their thumbsuck
- 7:11is 8 % of the economy is informal. And there
- 7:15are various ways, again, international benchmarks,
- 7:18what other countries are doing. Now, Joe De Beere
- 7:20made it quite clear to me that he thinks that
- 7:24may be a little bit too low. That could go up
- 7:27to 9 % or even 10 % of GDP. Now, when the next
- 7:31rebalancing of the economy is done, which is
- 7:33done every five years, they will probably up
- 7:37that 8%. But let's just work with that 8 % that
- 7:40we've got. Now, the interesting thing is if you
- 7:42look at 2023 numbers in the economy, that 8 %
- 7:46would amount to 562 billion rand. That is more
- 7:52than the entire mining sector in 2023, which
- 7:55only came to 444 billion. So just think about
- 7:58that. The imputed informal sector, 562 billion.
- 8:02The entire mining sector, that's platinum, gold,
- 8:06diamonds, coal, even stone quarries, all of that.
- 8:10only came to 444 billion. So the informal sector
- 8:14measured by this standard is bigger than the
- 8:17mining sector. And I think that should give comfort
- 8:20to people that we actually capture most of the
- 8:24data somewhere in the economy. You can fit a
- 8:27hell of a lot of informal transactions into 562
- 8:31billion rand. whether it's the tennis coach taking
- 8:35cash only, whether it's your doctor or dentist
- 8:37taking cash only, whether it's our street vending
- 8:41lady, whether it's a spa or shop, whether it's
- 8:43a brothel. The money goes out and somewhere it
- 8:46gets captured. So I think we can rest assured
- 8:49that by and large, we know we have a grip on
- 8:53how big the sector is. What does this mean in
- 8:56terms of unemployment? That's where things become
- 8:59very interesting. The unemployment numbers that
- 9:03got the Capitec boss animated is the fact that
- 9:06StatsSA said in the first quarter of this year,
- 9:09our unemployment rate is 33%, 32 .9%, make it
- 9:1433%, or 8 .2 million people. And against that,
- 9:19there were 16 .7 million people, more or less
- 9:22double the number, who were actually working
- 9:24and were employed. And he felt that these numbers
- 9:28are not right. Now, on what basis did he say
- 9:31that? He said that because Capitec has got 24
- 9:35million individual clients. They have 8 .8 million
- 9:40fully banked clients. I'm not sure precisely
- 9:42what that means. And they've got 13 million active
- 9:45users of the Capitec app. And he says those numbers
- 9:49tell him that the unemployment rate must be much
- 9:52lower. The problem with that approach is those
- 9:56numbers from Capitec do not tell us who is employed,
- 10:00who is unemployed, who is on a social grant,
- 10:03who is receiving a COVID grant, who is a pensioner
- 10:06that receives a pension but has got a Capitec
- 10:09account. You cannot draw just from that data
- 10:12conclusions about unemployment. I think that
- 10:15would be very wrong. So how does Stats SA do
- 10:18the unemployment measurement? They have 33 ,000
- 10:22households. which they survey every quarter,
- 10:26four times a year. And there you ask people questions
- 10:30around, have they earned money in the past week
- 10:33from working? Are they working somewhere? Is
- 10:36it a fixed full -time job or a part -time job?
- 10:39That sort of thing. And from these household
- 10:42survey, they then calculate the unemployment
- 10:45number. Now, the criticism is, first of all,
- 10:49that the sample of 33 ,000 houses It's based
- 10:53on the 2011 census, which is old, it's long ago.
- 10:57That's not quite correct. That number gets updated
- 11:00with regular other stats essay surveys. So it's
- 11:05not a number just from 2011. But is 33 ,000 enough?
- 11:10Yes, it is. You know, again, these things are
- 11:13done in terms of international comparisons and
- 11:15international benchmarks. And we're a country
- 11:18of about 60 million people. We do 33 ,000 households.
- 11:22It's comparable to a country like the UK with
- 11:25also about, what, 60, 65 million people using
- 11:29even fewer households. So, yes, it is enough.
- 11:32And what about the question, Mark, about the
- 11:35honesty of the respondents that people don't
- 11:38want to say? that they have earned money. Well,
- 11:42that's a good point. And that goes to the quality
- 11:44of the interview between the respondent and the
- 11:47stats essay official walking around asking the
- 11:50questions. But I think, you know, you must give,
- 11:53it's difficult to determine that, but I think
- 11:55you must give some credit to people who's got
- 11:58experience of this working around that problem.
- 12:01But it is quite possible that there's room for
- 12:03error. I think that is possible. So what do we
- 12:06learn from this? I think what we learn is that
- 12:08Capitec obviously sits on very valuable information
- 12:11and so do all banks. It's not just Capitec. And
- 12:15if one can combine the information that they
- 12:17have with StatsSA data, we may get a much better
- 12:21reading of the unemployment problem. StatsSA
- 12:24uses a survey method. Maybe one can supplement
- 12:28the survey method with data from the banks. Now,
- 12:32of course, you'll have to get the banks to cooperate.
- 12:34They'll have to make their data available on
- 12:36an anonymous basis and so on. It's not an easy
- 12:39thing to do, but there are people who feel that
- 12:42you can do that. And if the Gadifuri debate,
- 12:46if I can call it that, if it results in that
- 12:49kind of cooperation between the banks and Stats
- 12:52SA, I think it would have been worth all the
- 12:54carbon dioxide that was ejected. So in summary,
- 12:59so what? I think in summary, the first thing
- 13:01to remember is that you will never have 100 %
- 13:04accurate numbers. Forget that. The question is,
- 13:07can you be 90 % or 85 % correct? That is, I think,
- 13:11the benchmark to apply. The second thing is certainly
- 13:14that anecdotal evidence is not good enough. When
- 13:17you talk about something as complex as an economy
- 13:19involving 62, 63 million people to say, but I
- 13:24had this or that experience is not quite good
- 13:27enough. You're one of 63 million. And I think
- 13:31one should sort of display a bit of modesty,
- 13:34shall I put it that way. Thirdly, the system
- 13:38of national accounts which we run in South Africa
- 13:40is a robust system. It is applied internationally.
- 13:44It's applied in almost 200 countries. with similarities,
- 13:50but also differences with South Africa. So I'd
- 13:53be very careful to just chuck the baby out with
- 13:55the barf water. I think we can rely on what comes
- 13:58out. The current inclusion of the informal sector
- 14:02in our national accounts is 8%, and that is much
- 14:07bigger than the mining industry. And it's something
- 14:09just to think about. South Africa is a mining
- 14:11country, and there are a hell of a lot of mining
- 14:14activity. If the informal sector is bigger than
- 14:17that, then it tells you that we're probably not
- 14:19missing too much. We will miss some, obviously,
- 14:23but not too much. And lastly, I think there is
- 14:26room for cooperation between the banks who have
- 14:30the data of their clients available and stats
- 14:35essay and putting it all in a pot and trying
- 14:37to come to a better understanding. For example,
- 14:40if you take the banking data and you clean it
- 14:42up from people who receive grants, which you
- 14:45can do from ID numbers, it'll give you already
- 14:48a different picture. If you can clean it up further
- 14:51from regular payments, which reflect something
- 14:53like a pension, gives you a further cleanup,
- 14:56then I think one can come at useful figures.
- 14:59Thank you very much. That certainly taught me
- 15:03some things. I'm glad. That's good. Thank you.
- 15:07Thank you for listening to the So What Podcast.
- 15:10If you enjoy this content, please don't forget
- 15:13to leave a review and a rating, and please consider
- 15:16subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 15:19Also, tell your friends. Remember, you can find
- 15:22a written version of all JP's content at jplandman
- 15:26.co .za.