Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Third Generation of Electric Cars Arrives
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the Deep Dive. You gave us a fantastic stack of
- 0:13sources, a major strategic report, and some really deep
- 0:15engineering analysis. And today, our mission is to
- 0:18synthesize the two biggest revolutions hitting the
- 0:21Automotive World right now. And they are truly massive.
- 0:24On one hand you've got the unstoppable rise of the software
- 0:28defined vehicle, the the car is basically becoming a computing
- 0:32platform, and on the other you have this fundamental technical
- 0:35shift in the hardware to the incredibly demanding 800 Volt
- 0:39platform. And even beyond that.
- 0:41Exactly. We've gone through a huge
- 0:43industry report from Prostep, IVIP and EY on how to navigate
- 0:46this STV transition. And we've also mastered the
- 0:50electrical physics behind the move from the old 400 Volt
- 0:54systems to 800 V and even 900 V. So our goal today is to connect
- 0:57that high level software strategy with the high stakes
- 1:00engineering reality. OK, let's just let's unpack
- 1:03this. And I think we need to start by
- 1:04understanding just how big this change really is.
- 1:07It's almost impossible to overstate.
- 1:09I mean, the data we pulled from that industry analysis is just
- 1:12staggering. By 20-30, it's projected that
- 1:15nine out of every 10 cars sold will be software defined
- 1:19vehicles 9 out. Of 10.
- 1:21Think about that. We went from just one in 10 in
- 1:242023 to basically 90% in just seven years.
- 1:28This is not an evolution, it's a complete reimagining of the car.
- 1:32So it's moving control. From fixed hardware what you buy
- 1:35on day one, to flexible software that can be updated that can
- 1:39evolve over the life of the car. That sets the scene perfectly,
- 1:42so we have these two huge simultaneous projects happening.
- 1:45Right, happening at the same time.
- 1:46The business challenges of the whole STV ecosystem and then the
- 1:50really intense engineering trade-offs you have to make for
- 1:52high voltage hardware. So let's start with the why.
- 1:55What's the commercial driver behind this whole software
- 1:57transformation? Well.
- 1:59At its core, the STV is just a vehicle where its features are
- 2:02mostly added and improved through software updates.
- 2:05Throughout its entire life. Exactly.
- 2:07It's the complete opposite of the traditional model where the
- 2:10car is basically finished the moment it leaves the factory.
- 2:13And the reason every big automaker is betting their
- 2:15future on this is laid out so clearly in what the report calls
- 2:20the STV value pyramid. The financial promise is just
- 2:24huge. It is new revenue streams from
- 2:27features on demand subscription services.
- 2:29And the research estimates these could generate up to what, $500
- 2:33per vehicle every year? That's the number they're
- 2:35projecting. But tell us, what are people
- 2:37actually paying $500 a year for? It sounds a little vague.
- 2:41Well. It's actually highly specific
- 2:44and it's recurring revenue, which is the key.
- 2:46We're talking about things like enhanced driver assist packages
- 2:50you activate after you buy the car, or maybe remote start
- 2:53functionality, even temporary performance boosts.
- 2:57Or say you live somewhere cold, you might subscribe to heated
- 3:00seats for just the three winter months.
- 3:02So it's reliable money. It's reliable, predictable
- 3:04money, and that's what investors find so valuable.
- 3:07But it goes beyond just the cash.
- 3:09There's a huge operational advantage here.
- 3:11By using what the software world calls CICD Continuous Delivery
- 3:16Pipelines, the cars stay competitive long after they're
- 3:19sold. A four year old car can get a
- 3:21major update to its safety or efficiency systems.
- 3:24So you're extending its product half life.
- 3:26You're extending its half life exactly.
- 3:28It stays relevant. That makes sense, but if
- 3:30software is really eating the car, that must just completely
- 3:33upend the old automotive hierarchy, right?
- 3:35Who loses out here? Are the traditional tier one
- 3:39hardware suppliers just irrelevant now?
- 3:41That's where the complexity just explodes.
- 3:43The ecosystem now has cloud giants like Microsoft and IBM in
- 3:47it. And chip manufacturers.
- 3:48Huge chip manufacturers, legions of software engineers all trying
- 3:53to work with the traditional parts makers.
- 3:55So those tier ones are scrambling.
- 3:57If their component can't be updated or integrated through
- 3:59software, their value just plummets.
- 4:02The old boundaries are just dissolving and it's creating a
- 4:04ton of friction. And this is where the experts in
- 4:06that Pro Step by F report really layout the reality of it.
- 4:09They flagged 6 critical categories that are holding back
- 4:12real progress on the STV. Right.
- 4:14It's not just one thing, it's a whole set of systemic hurdles.
- 4:18So let's dive into them. OK, let's start with two that
- 4:20are really about mismatched expectations.
- 4:23First is regulatory missile alignment right?
- 4:26Automakers are global, but the regulations are all fragmented
- 4:30and regional. You're trying to comply with UNR
- 4:32156 in one place. And then AIS 190 somewhere else.
- 4:37Exactly. So your global software rollout
- 4:39gets slowed down or you have to disable features in certain
- 4:42markets. It's a mess.
- 4:44And the second one, you hinted at this, the collaboration gaps.
- 4:47This is the real culture clash. It is.
- 4:49You've got the slow linear safety first V model of
- 4:53traditional auto engineering. Which is all about ISO 26262A
- 4:57spices, very rigid standards. And that is clashing directly
- 5:01with a rapid continuous DevOps model from the software world I.
- 5:05Heard this great anecdote about that.
- 5:06You have one side saying we need 18 months for physical validated
- 5:10proof of failure. And the software team is saying.
- 5:13We push updates every night. Which version are you even
- 5:15testing? They're on totally different
- 5:16clocks. That is the tension exactly.
- 5:19It's a clash of speed and a clash of risk tolerance.
- 5:23And this feeds right into the third challenge, lack of
- 5:27standardization. Oh, absolutely.
- 5:29We're still seeing incompatible data formats, proprietary APIs,
- 5:34inconsistent protocols between different ECU's.
- 5:36So every platform is a custom job.
- 5:39It's all expensive custom workarounds instead of scalable
- 5:41solutions. The 4th 1 is more operational
- 5:44right? The complexity and processes.
- 5:46Yes, comanies are really struggling to integrate their
- 5:50alication life cycle management, how they build the software with
- 5:53their product life cycle management, which is how they
- 5:55manage the physical car. O you can't track which software
- 5:58is on which iece of hardware. And if you can't do that
- 6:00efficiently, compliance just becomes an absolute nightmare.
- 6:03And the fifth one sounds like the most frustrating of all
- 6:05digital homologation. Oh it's a huge bottleneck.
- 6:09This is getting regulatory approval for any safety critical
- 6:12software update. And the report said it can take
- 6:14up to four months. It's up to four months.
- 6:17And it's not just bureaucracy. It's because regulators need a
- 6:20verifiable physical paper trail to assign legal responsibility
- 6:25for safety. The whole manual process just
- 6:27kills innovation speed. We have to move from that paper
- 6:30trail to a digital one, which I guess brings us to the last big
- 6:34hurdle, the talent shortage. Yes, the skills you need, AI,
- 6:38engineering, cybersecurity, advanced computer science.
- 6:41They just aren't common in the traditional automotive
- 6:43workforce. So OEMs are now competing with
- 6:46who? Silicon Valley.
- 6:47They're competing directly with Silicon Valley, the gaming
- 6:50industry, you name it. And that means huge salaries,
- 6:53high turnover and just the massive cost of trying to poach
- 6:57the talent you need to build all this.
- 6:58OK, so that's the STV story. It's a race for new revenue, but
- 7:01it's held back by all this organizational friction.
- 7:03Now let's pivot completely if the software is all about moving
- 7:07fast. The 800 Volt hardware is all
- 7:09about managing the intense speed and heat that comes with.
- 7:11It exactly we're now in what people are calling the Gen.
- 7:14three EV dedicated platforms, OTA updates and critically this
- 7:18800V architecture. And this is all driven by just
- 7:22fundamental physics. You want high charging power,
- 7:25which is P. Power equals voltage times
- 7:28current. Right, P = U times I.
- 7:30So you have to increase one or the other, and automakers are
- 7:33strongly strongly preferring to increase the voltage EU over the
- 7:37current I. Why is that preference so
- 7:40strong? It's all because of the
- 7:42geometrical heat penalty. Resistive heat is proportional
- 7:45to the square of the current I ^2 R.
- 7:47So if you double the current. You quadruple the heat to get,
- 7:50say, 250 kilowatts of charging power.
- 7:53In a normal 400 Volt system, you need a peak current of over 600
- 7:56amps. The heat load, the cooling
- 7:58systems, the thickness of the cables, it all becomes massive.
- 8:01And with an 800 Volt system. Well a car like the Porsche Tie
- 8:04can only needs around 340 amps to get that same 250 kilowatts.
- 8:08Wow. So that reduction means the 400
- 8:10Volt system is generating roughly 3.28 times as much heat
- 8:13for the same power delivery. That thermal reduction is the
- 8:17absolute game changer. It lets you use thinner, lighter
- 8:20copper cables everywhere, which saves a huge amount of weight.
- 8:22That weight saving is a massive advantage, so let's see how this
- 8:25plays out in the actual components, starting with the
- 8:27battery pack. OK, we can compare A400V pack
- 8:30like in the Tesla Model 3 to the 800 V Ticon or even the 900 V
- 8:35Lucid Air. The payoff is pretty obvious.
- 8:38The Ticon gets from 10 to 80% charge in just 19 minutes.
- 8:43Compared to the model threes 27 minutes.
- 8:45That's just pure speed. But what's the cost of that
- 8:48speed? You mentioned complexity.
- 8:49Is that speed benefit really worth doubling the complexity
- 8:52and the cost in the battery pack well.
- 8:54That's the big question. To double your pack voltage from
- 8:57400 V to 800 V, you basically have to double the number of
- 9:00cells you connect in series. So you go from what, 96 to 192
- 9:04cells? Something like that, yeah.
- 9:06And every single one of those cells needs to be monitored.
- 9:08So that makes your battery management system, your BMS way
- 9:11more complex and expensive. You need more voltage sensors,
- 9:14more fuses, be for your contactors.
- 9:16It's a huge trade off, but the market is demanding that faster
- 9:19charging. OK, so let's move to the
- 9:21inverter. This is the core power
- 9:23electronics that converts DC from the battery into AC for the
- 9:27motor. This is where high voltage
- 9:29really starts to stress things. It does.
- 9:32To handle an 800 Volt bus you have to move away from
- 9:35traditional silicon IGBT's and adopt high voltage silicon
- 9:39carbide Mosfets or sick you need devices rated for around 1200
- 9:44Volt. And six is great for efficiency,
- 9:46but it brings its own problems. It does.
- 9:48It's fast switching, creates all sorts of new electrical issues
- 9:51and the solution is something called a multi level inverter or
- 9:54MLI. OK, what is that?
- 9:56The best way to think of it is like splitting a big electrical
- 9:58hill into three smaller manageable steps instead of
- 10:01forcing 1 semiconductor to handle the full 800 volts.
- 10:05And MLI splits that voltage across multiple devices.
- 10:08And why do? That.
- 10:08Two big reasons. One, it reduces the electrical
- 10:11stress on each component so they last longer, and two, crucially,
- 10:14it massively lowers the electromagnetic interference or
- 10:17EMI noise. Which we care about because.
- 10:20Because high EMI noise can cause something called bearing
- 10:23currents. It's basically stray electricity
- 10:25that jumps across and degrades the motors metal bearings,
- 10:29causing the motor to fail prematurely.
- 10:31So MLIS help keep the motor healthy under these extreme
- 10:34conditions. Let's talk about the motor
- 10:36itself then. The higher voltage allows for
- 10:39higher speeds and much better power density.
- 10:42And this metric power density, that's the Holy Grail, right?
- 10:45It absolutely is. And the contrast is just
- 10:47amazing. The Porsche Tican motor is
- 10:50around 7.4 kilowatts per kilogram, but the Lucid Air
- 10:53motor is almost double that at 14.5.
- 10:56Why is that specific number so important for you as a consumer?
- 11:01It all comes down to physics and packaging.
- 11:03Power density is how much horsepower you get for every
- 11:05pound of weight. Getting 14.5 kilowatts per
- 11:08kilogram means you can deliver huge performance, insane torque
- 11:12and speed with a motor that is physically much smaller and
- 11:15lighter. And that saves space and weight.
- 11:17Can go back into. More passenger room or more
- 11:19battery for more range. It's a virtuous cycle.
- 11:21But there's always a catch. With high voltage there's always
- 11:24a catch here. It's the risk of partial
- 11:26discharge or PD. Those super fast seat IC
- 11:29inverters can cause the these sudden voltage spikes at the
- 11:32motor terminals that can reach up to two times the DC link
- 11:36voltage. So on an 800 Volt system, you're
- 11:39seeing 1600 Volt spikes. You're seeing 1600 Volt spikes
- 11:42hitting your motor windings and those spikes can break down the
- 11:45wires insulation. That's the partial discharge and
- 11:48lead to a catastrophic failure. So how do you possibly fight
- 11:52back against a 1600 Volt attack? With a lot of advanced
- 11:55mitigation, you use thicker insulation on the wires.
- 11:58You do this incredibly thorough process called vacuum pressure
- 12:01impregnation on the windings to get rid of any air gaps.
- 12:04And you use those multi level inverters again.
- 12:06And you use the MLIS again to smooth out those voltage steps.
- 12:10It's a constant battle between speed, power and long term
- 12:13durability. OK, let's wrap up the hardware
- 12:16with the onboard charger, the OBC.
- 12:18It also has to be upgraded to 1200 Volt components.
- 12:21But the real innovation here seems to be about integration.
- 12:25Absolutely. Manufacturers are getting really
- 12:26clever. They're repurposing the high
- 12:28power electronics they already have.
- 12:30Like using the main traction inverter.
- 12:32The thing that drives the wheels to temorarily function as a
- 12:36charger. It reduces redundant hardware.
- 12:39A great example is the Wonder box in the Lucid Air.
- 12:41It can act as a step up converter.
- 12:43So it can charge its 900 Volt pack from an older 400 Volt fast
- 12:47charger. Exactly.
- 12:48It bridges that compatibility gap right on the vehicle.
- 12:51OK. So if we connect this all back
- 12:52together, we've got these two immense transitions, STV and 800
- 12:56V, both driving complexity, cost and risk.
- 12:59The industry can't solve this alone in silos.
- 13:02They can't. Yeah, You need these
- 13:03collaborative initiatives to standardize how this super
- 13:07complex hardware integrates with the Super complex software
- 13:10ecosystem. You have to bridge that
- 13:12organizational chasm we talked about earlier.
- 13:14Which brings us full circle to the four big initiatives that
- 13:17organizations like Prostep, IVIP are pushing for designed to
- 13:20systematically knock down those 6 roadblocks.
- 13:23That's right. First a big focus on software
- 13:25component traceability using something called a software bill
- 13:28of materials, or. This is all about
- 13:31accountability. In that huge web of vendors and
- 13:33cloud providers. You have to know exactly which
- 13:36line of code is running where. 2nd is the need to advance
- 13:39digital homologation. We just can't keep waiting four
- 13:42months for a manual safety approval.
- 13:45The goal is to automate that with a verifiable digital twin
- 13:49that regulators can trust as much as a physical test bench.
- 13:52So you can deploy features at software speed.
- 13:54At software speed 3rd, and this might be the most critical for
- 13:58the culture change, is fostering effective collaboration.
- 14:02Getting everyone to speak the same language.
- 14:03Exactly, creating specific forums and guidelines to bridge
- 14:07that gap between the slow moving OEMs and the fast moving
- 14:11software providers. And finally, a long term
- 14:13investment. Develop integrated university
- 14:16programs. You have to build the talent
- 14:18pipeline right now. Direct partnerships with
- 14:20academia to teach students the specific skills they need.
- 14:24A blend of software engineering, AI and deep automotive
- 14:28knowledge. So to recount the core learning
- 14:30for you, this shift to the software defined vehicle and the
- 14:33800 V architecture isn't really optional.
- 14:36It's a non negotiable transformation being driven by
- 14:39what you demand as a consumer and by just fierce market
- 14:41competition. We've seen that high voltage
- 14:44gives you these incredible benefits, Faster charging, more
- 14:46power, less heat. But it places these incredibly
- 14:50stringent demands on everything from insulation and component
- 14:53cost to industry wide standards. And the key take away is that
- 14:57this transition isn't about choosing to be good at software
- 15:00or good at hardware. It's about mastering the brutal
- 15:03complexity of integrating them seamlessly and reliably across
- 15:07every single layer, from the materials in the battery all the
- 15:11way up to the simulation in the digital twin.
- 15:13That is the real challenge. So what does this all mean for
- 15:16you as someone following this industry?
- 15:18While 800 volts is solving today's problem of fast
- 15:21charging, how long is it until the inevitable jump to post 1000
- 15:24Volt systems? A jump that will demand the next
- 15:27generation of materials, completely new inverter designs
- 15:30and radically different regulatory frameworks?
- 15:32The need for this continuous system wide transformation, It's
- 15:36permanent. That's a great way to put it.
- 15:38Thank you so much for joining us for this deep dive into the
- 15:40future of automotive technology. If you found this useful and you
- 15:44want more of this kind of analysis in your feed, be sure
- 15:47to follow us to stay informed and get the full breakdown next
- 15:50time.