Latest / Chatter that Matters / Calum MacKay - To Build the Impossible Dream
Transcript
- 0:06One of my proudest moments in life is when
- 0:09I bought my first home. It was on Strathmore Boulevard in Toronto.
- 0:13Cost me a $110,000. I
- 0:17had to do everything in my power to cobble together enough of a down
- 0:21payment, but I can tell you that every day I walked in that home, every
- 0:25day I put my key in my lock, even with the drafty windows,
- 0:29a furnace held together with duct tape, it didn't matter
- 0:33because it was my house. And I grew up at a
- 0:37time when owning a home was part of the Canadian
- 0:40dream. A promise made and a promise kept. Get a good education,
- 0:44work hard, and home ownership was something that was both desirable and
- 0:47feasible. But today, when I talk to people in
- 0:51their twenties thirties, they say, why bother even trying to
- 0:54save? I might as well just live now and live for the day.
- 0:58Owning a home is no longer something I can afford to do.
- 1:03And I think that's not only sad, it's something we need
- 1:07to change. Now Maslow's
- 1:10hierarchy of needs, theory of motivation talks about the most
- 1:14important thing we chase as humans is safety and security, a roof
- 1:18over our head, and if we're one of the fortunate ones, a roof that we
- 1:21own. Home ownership may be growing increasingly out of
- 1:25reach for many Canadians. It's pretty expensive around here. Definitely not
- 1:29thinking of buying because we won't be able to afford that. They've already
- 1:32abandoned the dream of owning a single family home amid rising real
- 1:36estate prices. Just with cost of living and other
- 1:40expenses. It's just it's really hard to get a mortgage. It feels like I
- 1:43can't run on the hamster wheel fast enough.
- 1:47Today, I wanna bring 3 guests to open our minds to ways in
- 1:51which we can again unlock the Canadian dream. Callum MacKay is
- 1:55a young man in Vancouver, living in a 1 bedroom apartment with
- 1:59his wife $2,700 a month, and they were about to start a
- 2:02family, so had to find somewhere else to live. Callum
- 2:06shares the gauntlet he had to run through, the wet cement, and how he approached
- 2:10bureaucracy and even the banks, not with a sledgehammer, but with a
- 2:13heart. It was amazing what, how empathetic people were when you were able to get
- 2:17them on the phone. Next Brad Bradford is a Councillor I admire in Toronto,
- 2:21came out of the city planning office, and he says we have to
- 2:24change the bureaucracy. We need some leadership change. We need a
- 2:28different type of politics, and we need to create a culture
- 2:32of yes. And finally, Leah Robinson from RBC and how
- 2:35her team has put together some innovative solutions for people that own
- 2:39a home to do more with it. So that families and communities
- 2:43can live, live a bit differently. I hope that by listening to
- 2:46Calum, Brad, and Leah, that we, in fact, open our
- 2:50minds to the possibility that the Canadian dream of
- 2:53affordable housing within a city like Vancouver or Montreal
- 2:57or Toronto is still something that has great possibility.
- 3:02Hi. It's Tony Chapman. Thank you for listening to Chatter That Matters presented by
- 3:06RBC. If you can, please subscribe to the podcast. And
- 3:10ratings and reviews, well, they're always welcome, and they're always appreciated.
- 3:17Joining me now is Calum MacKay. He's someone that pursued the
- 3:20Canadian dream of owning a home, but to do
- 3:24so, he had to apply some great creative thinking,
- 3:28had the help of his family, and even then probably had to move a few
- 3:31mountains. Calum, welcome to Chatter That Matters. Thanks for having me, Tony. I look
- 3:35forward to, to exploring this with you. Give me a sense of how old you
- 3:39are, your family situation, and then we'll move into the,
- 3:43to pursuing the Canadian dream of home ownership. Turned 31 on,
- 3:47Thursday of last week. 5 month old at home right now and married my
- 3:50wife about 2 years ago now. I was lucky enough that,
- 3:54she had a home in the family. It was a family home. As we started
- 3:58doing our family planning, as one does in their in their late twenties and early
- 4:02thirties, We started exploring what our options were. Married for a couple
- 4:05years. Were you renting at the time? Yep. Renting at the
- 4:09time. At the time, I was working downtown in the city when we first,
- 4:12got together and then obviously COVID happened. I went to a fully remote
- 4:16job. So, we decided to, you know, move into a
- 4:20place that had a, a den, which at the time in 2020 seemed, you
- 4:24know, we were paying a little bit extra. I think my rent was $2,700
- 4:27a month, which was not cheap. And it was the best, one of the best
- 4:30decisions I've ever made because I spent, countless hours in that, in
- 4:34that little 5 foot 5, 7 foot class box. As your
- 4:38family situation changes and you've got a beautiful 5 months at home
- 4:42to, prove it, obviously, your how we're gonna live and where we're
- 4:45gonna live starts factoring into your decision. We,
- 4:49certainly knew at the location that we were in a great location. I live in
- 4:52Vancouver, very central to everything that was going on, and we
- 4:56knew that we weren't going to be able to afford to live in that area.
- 4:59So, we started expanding our search. And, for those
- 5:02who, been in the real estate market area in Vancouver, it's a
- 5:06it's a big challenge. So slowly, we realized we were looking further and further
- 5:10out of the city. So you got $27100 you're paying in
- 5:13rent. So, you know, that is some substance when you're starting to look at purchasing
- 5:17a house. But even with that kinda income, what I
- 5:20understand is you realize that you'd have to be a little bit more creative than
- 5:23just trying to put up a down payment in that rent if you're gonna get
- 5:27a a home that you wanted in a place that you wanted. Absolutely. It
- 5:30wasn't necessarily the cash flow that was the problem. It was the down
- 5:34payment. You know, my wife and I, we were lucky enough that I, had
- 5:37had graduated with with no debt out of university. You know, I had my
- 5:41parents had done a great job of setting me up for success. I had a
- 5:45good career and, even still just kind of living in Vancouver,
- 5:49getting sort of putting aside money every month to slowly afford
- 5:52a, a down payment felt like a climbing a mountain. To me, I
- 5:56remember walking into my first house and feeling
- 6:00like I'm an adult. I'm on my way. Instead of paying rent,
- 6:04paying myself in terms of that mortgage will eventually turn into a house
- 6:07I own. Has that impacted, do you think, your generation that
- 6:11in terms of that expectation? Has it changed the way you sort
- 6:15of think and feel and behave when it comes to homeownership?
- 6:19My generation is extending its twenties. Homeownership seems
- 6:23so far out of reach that you may as well
- 6:26enjoy your life while you're while you're young, and there
- 6:30was no point in really saving, because it felt
- 6:34like the amount that you needed for a down payment was so
- 6:38insurmountable, that I think a lot of people in
- 6:42my generation, especially if they aren't already starting a family, if you're
- 6:45just single and you're living, your, like, owning isn't even on
- 6:49your radar. You're just, for a lot of people, putting a little bit of money
- 6:52aside, living paycheck to paycheck, and there's a lot of fun things to do in
- 6:56Vancouver. It's pretty easy to spend money. And so as your family
- 6:59situation changed and you started expanding your universe and you
- 7:03started looking at different markets, you found a very
- 7:07creative way to get into the homeownership, and that's the story I'd love you to
- 7:10share because to me, what used to be a
- 7:14perfectly paved speedway in terms of, you know, my twenties and
- 7:18my early thirties of buying a home requires a lot of resourcefulness,
- 7:21requires some creativity. In your case, as you said, time in and time out when
- 7:25you're doing the pre interview, a lot of luck. It absolutely starts with luck. I
- 7:29had a solid family foundation. My parents were able to, you
- 7:32know, give me a great upbringing and, you know, really teach me the
- 7:36value of, you know, saving. And I would also say
- 7:40discipline, you know, knowing that it might not be possible today. It might not be
- 7:44possible tomorrow, but just because you can't do something now doesn't mean that you shouldn't
- 7:47be shouldn't be trying for something bigger in the future. As I sort of
- 7:51migrated into that sort of later twenties of my life, as we started doing a
- 7:54lot of this research, my pay my parents, I was lucky enough, were able to,
- 7:57you know, help me out with, you know, we were planning on buying a condo
- 8:00at Port Moody. We're, we're planning on putting a down payment down on a
- 8:04condo. As we started doing more research, we
- 8:08kept coming back to this house that my wife's family had. It was great. It
- 8:11was a great place for her family to be able to live. We had
- 8:15an aunt and an uncle, and at times, different members of the family in their
- 8:18twenties, whether they were in between jobs or at school, they would go rent out
- 8:21a room in the house. It was honest. It was like a little catchall. My
- 8:24wife and my brother-in-law were on the title of this house. My brother-in-law is is
- 8:27also 30 years old my age. My wife is 2 years older than me, and
- 8:30we were all sitting here thinking, you know, what are we going to do here?
- 8:33None of us owned anything, in terms of property. So we started doing
- 8:36more research into what we could do with this place. Was it sell it? Was
- 8:39it move in? It was an older home, built in the, I believe, the
- 8:43sixties. It was not a big home. I think it was around 1200 square
- 8:47feet. The more research we did, and actually by chance, we
- 8:51saw that there was a builder on our street who had actually just built 2
- 8:54duplexes, similar homes, similar lot sizes. And these,
- 8:57these homes look great. And so we kind of got in our heads, what if
- 9:01we did a duplex? What if we, you know, we came in together, you know,
- 9:05use the money that my family was gonna give us for the down payment to
- 9:08sort of finance the, the construction, of this
- 9:12home. Another just key part of this that we were quite lucky with was there
- 9:15was only around 380,000 left on the mortgage of this home in
- 9:19Vancouver, which from a loan to value perspective, when you start looking at borrowing
- 9:23against the house, it did us a lot of favors in being able to get
- 9:26financing to be able to afford the construction, or so we thought. So, what's the
- 9:30or so we thought point of this story? So, we had
- 9:34a home, we had the help from the family, and we thought we were going
- 9:38to be able to borrow against the outstanding value in the home,
- 9:42to be able to finance the rest of this, this project. All in, the build
- 9:45was gonna take roughly $1,000,000 Let's let's use that as a as a
- 9:49placeholder. It was a little bit less than that. We were lucky enough that this
- 9:52builder that we did find on the street, we interviewed a couple, he was by
- 9:55far the best fit, came in at a low rate. We had got a chance
- 9:58to meet the guy. We had had a chance to the builder, and we had
- 10:01had a chance to talk to a few of his other clients who had built
- 10:04homes in the area. And everything came up very positive. So it was a
- 10:08big gamble. We went in with this guy. We we signed a contract. And thinking
- 10:11that we were going to be able to easily finance this, what we realized as
- 10:15we very late on in the process was that we were going to
- 10:19have to sign a document with the city and the bank acknowledging
- 10:22that if anything, if any codes were to be broken, essentially, if there was anything
- 10:26wrong in the building process or we weren't, you know, doing our due diligence as,
- 10:30as a homeowner of the property, that the city could fine us
- 10:34and the money essentially would go to the city first instead of
- 10:38the bank. For those of you who are familiar with mortgages, essentially, the city gets
- 10:41put in front of the bank. Bank doesn't like that. Turns out that's not how
- 10:44the bank sees it. The bank came back to us and said, you have 2
- 10:48options. You either finance this
- 10:52entire project on a construction mortgage through the bank
- 10:56at prime plus 2%, which at the time was like
- 10:599 a half percent interest, which was going to be a
- 11:03nightmare. And for those of you who are familiar with, you know, building,
- 11:06construction loans, there is a lot of administration that goes into this.
- 11:10It extends the length of the project and it involves,
- 11:14essentially inspectors, from the, from the
- 11:18bank coming and inspecting the various stages of the, of the build as we
- 11:21go through the construction phases. So the other option outside of the construction
- 11:25mortgage was, hanging out the mortgage
- 11:30and financing this completely on our own, which is
- 11:34the only option that we were really able to take. Fortunately, I had an aunt
- 11:38who was able to loan me the money to be able to pay out the
- 11:40mortgage. Even the city, it was so new, this this covenant that I
- 11:44had to sign to to get the city to acknowledge that we were building was
- 11:48only less than a year old. So even my mortgage broker didn't
- 11:51really understand the implications of this. So it was a lot
- 11:55of uncertainty. There wasn't a lot of information online to be able to look up
- 11:58about this. There was a lot of just phoning city hall, try and figure
- 12:02out, is there any way to get around this? And it turns out, there wasn't.
- 12:06So Why do you think the city, given that they're so
- 12:10the rhetoric is least about let's build more homes, why do you think they would
- 12:13impose this? Like, what what was their motivation? Because, I mean, adding months to
- 12:17a construction project or even worse people just saying it's just not worth the
- 12:21hassle is not in the best interest of the city or the people.
- 12:25It's certainly in the best interest of the banks. Why is it in the best
- 12:28interest of the banks? I mean, to me, they don't wanna be put they don't
- 12:31want the city ahead of them. It's in the best interest of the
- 12:34banks because previously the banks didn't necessarily have to
- 12:38be notified that someone was building. Theoretically, right? If we weren't lucky enough to be
- 12:42able to have families to pay out the mortgage and completely finance the project, we
- 12:45would have gone back to the bank and given them an $30,000 in interest over
- 12:49a year. The momentum now you've bought the property out, is it now
- 12:52perfectly paved? The cities, everybody's falling in line, or did you continue to
- 12:56just deal with bureaucracy and sort of cement? Once we had the clean
- 13:00title, it was a weight off of our shoulders. We were fortunate that,
- 13:03the builder had a nice gap within his building schedule. Construction
- 13:07began, within 2 weeks of us getting that that, notice
- 13:11of title. We were all ready to go. The family had moved out of the
- 13:13house. I'd say the next hiccup we had was selecting our appliances. I
- 13:17learned at the point of, of the essentially building, we're only
- 13:21able to get 200 amps service into the house. And with the
- 13:25recent rule changes by the city, we had to put in 2
- 13:28electric car charging ports in our garage. This was going to greatly impact
- 13:32the amount of draw that potentially our house was under at
- 13:36full load. So let's say you're running your fridge, your oven, your AC,
- 13:40everything at the same time, including the 2 car charging ports, we only had
- 13:44a limited amount of power that we could use. And the only alternative to this
- 13:47was to put in a massive transformer in one of our backyards, and it
- 13:51was gonna cost anywhere between 20 to $40,000 for BC
- 13:54Hydro to come in and do this. And it was gonna potentially extend the timeline
- 13:58of the build by 9 months. And this was, like, very last minute that we
- 14:01found this out. And that to me was shocking because
- 14:05the city wants you to do more with, you know,
- 14:08essentially build more units on the same amount property. That's what everybody's trying to do
- 14:12is, you know, how do we, you know, take the land base
- 14:16that we have now and build, you know, as many homes as we can,
- 14:20to, to, to kind of support growing families. And this to me
- 14:24was been the exact opposite of that. How do you stay normal with
- 14:27all of this? To me, that's just like we want more people
- 14:31living on the same lot, but at the same time, we're gonna limit the amount
- 14:35of electricity you get and force you to carve out a big chunk
- 14:38of it for car charging. Like, it's just a is it just different departments
- 14:42not talking to each other? Or It's a clash between the
- 14:46environment and sustainable, you know, sustainable growth and housing.
- 14:50Those two things, at times, it seems like, aren't running in parallel. Those
- 14:53oppose each other. I would think that the city would be interested
- 14:57in, you know, incentivizing people to do more with their
- 15:00properties. How much of your success has been
- 15:04this ability, first of all, with your family
- 15:08members to do the initial research and you just being tenacious
- 15:12and persistent versus just saying this isn't worth it. Yeah. There were
- 15:15absolutely times that we wanted to quit, but having a child is a
- 15:19great motivator. I will tell you that. All of a sudden, it wasn't
- 15:23about, you know, just me. It wasn't about my level of stress or my level
- 15:26of happiness. I was now I had something else to think about. You know, it
- 15:30was really just sort of putting your head down. There were definitely some stressful times,
- 15:34but I really could see the end. I could see,
- 15:38and I could visualize being in a home with my
- 15:41wife and my son, my brother-in-law having a home. I was
- 15:45very lucky I had my parents and my dad to, to go to for a
- 15:49lot of advice. I'm a salesperson, in my
- 15:52career. I'm a pretty resourceful person. I'm not afraid to call
- 15:56people and demand answers. That would be my advice to everybody is
- 16:00make yourself human. Don't email, call whenever you
- 16:04can. You know, when you can get another person on
- 16:07the other line of the phone that realizes that you're just
- 16:11another guy with a family who's trying to do the best for himself, it was
- 16:15amazing what how empathetic people were when you were able to get them on the
- 16:18phone. Where are you today? Because when we talked, I mean, the one thing that
- 16:22said, it's almost like it was all worth it because now you've got
- 16:25your home. I'm still pinching myself every day. You know, my wife and I are
- 16:29homeowners in Vancouver in a brand new home. We are not millionaires. You know,
- 16:33I do not make a ton of money. Now I'm at the point where we
- 16:36get to host family. You know, I've got my father-in-law staying with me. He's here
- 16:40with his wife from Hong Kong. We had my parents come and stay
- 16:44with us when my son was born. To make matters even
- 16:47more interesting, we moved a month after my son was born. So the my
- 16:51son was born April 10th, and we moved into this home on April 17th. And
- 16:55all of the, you know, going and visiting the house and essentially getting the
- 16:58final sign off with the builder that, you know, we were able to move in
- 17:01all happened when my son was either just being born or a couple weeks old.
- 17:05So maybe this will hopefully encourage others to to, you
- 17:09know, think outside of the box and to really do some research into
- 17:13trying to figure out how to build, you know, a multifamily house.
- 17:16These things are possible. You took a a lot that had a bungalow
- 17:20on it, I guess, in a in a basement suite. Where are you today? We
- 17:24have a front front back duplex. I'm in the front unit
- 17:27with my with my wife and my son, 3 bedrooms. My
- 17:31brother-in-law has the back unit. He's in a 3 bedroom unit as
- 17:34well. He is, actually renting his
- 17:38his unit out right now. He plans to move in there, you know, when he
- 17:41gets closer to to having a family and such. And we have,
- 17:45my niece living in our our rental suite below our house. So it's really
- 17:49interesting that not only have you creatively solved this and financially
- 17:53solved this, you actually have an opportunity to create, a life with
- 17:56family all around you. We're very blessed to be able to,
- 18:00get to this point, and we're very lucky to be able to, you know,
- 18:04get to share in our good fortunes with, with both sides of our
- 18:08family. Must feel something special when you put that key in the lock, and it
- 18:11and it opens, and you open that door, and you go, this is mine. It's
- 18:14nice to just be able to walk out of the front door and be outside.
- 18:17I'd lived in a building for a very long time. Even just sitting out, having
- 18:21my coffee on my steps in the morning is joy that I don't know if
- 18:25it'll ever get old. So, Calum, I always end with my 3 takeaways. And the
- 18:28first one was just, you know, you talk about how fortunate you are
- 18:32with the family that you have and the family that you inherited. And I think
- 18:36one of the most important lessons they gave you is a sense of financial literacy.
- 18:39And even if you can't do something today, you can save to do it
- 18:43tomorrow. And I think that's just a great lesson in life for all
- 18:47of us to think about. I think your insight in terms of extending your
- 18:5020s when we lose sight of that long term dream, and I'm seeing that with
- 18:54people that go, I'll never be able to afford retirement, so why not live
- 18:58for today? I think it's important that we remind ourselves that,
- 19:02you know, there is a tomorrow and it will come. And then the final one,
- 19:04which I think is one of the most beautiful lessons I've heard is make yourself
- 19:08human. You know, in a guy your age that's got Reddit and the world with
- 19:11an arms reach of desire, you understand the importance of picking up a phone
- 19:15and connecting with somebody that might have his own family or her own
- 19:19family and then decides they wanna be part of solving your
- 19:22problem versus you becoming their problem. I think it's just a it
- 19:26is an extraordinary lesson for all of us to, to take away as well. I
- 19:29guess the the last point I'd make is, you know, as you said, there's lots
- 19:32of bumps along the road. Try not to get lost in those smaller things.
- 19:36Those challenges will happen. Remember, if you know, your little wall, I'd call it
- 19:40the walled garden, right? It was this end state that I had in mind and
- 19:43I wasn't gonna let anything sort of pull me away from that. And there are
- 19:46times that are hard. Luckily, I have a supportive family and a very supportive wife
- 19:50to, to get through all of it. I'm so happy that you joined and shared
- 19:53your story with such honesty. And one day when I'm in Vancouver, you could host
- 19:57me for, for a cold one. Absolutely. I got, 2 chairs sitting
- 20:00out on the patio right now. We're happy to have you.
- 20:04I consider affordable housing to be the biggest problem
- 20:08facing Canada in the next decade. Everybody deserves a
- 20:11roof over their head. And there's so much complexity to this, so don't go
- 20:15away. Because when we come back, I have Brad Bradford, who I consider
- 20:19one of the most progressive city councilors that I've come across, talk
- 20:23about what cities must do to make this reality happen. And
- 20:26then Leah Robinson from RBC talking about what her bank is doing to
- 20:30ensure that affordable housing is a matter of choice, not chance.
- 20:35Hi. It's Tony Chapman from Chatter That Matters. RBC is offering
- 20:39more financing options to support Canadian homeowners
- 20:43looking to maximize their property's potential. Whether you want to provide
- 20:46supportive housing for a family member or supplement your income with a
- 20:50rental, RBC's Construction Mortgage Multi Units Program
- 20:53has you covered. You can finance additions like laneway homes,
- 20:57garden suites, modular units, or even redevelop your home
- 21:01into duplexes or triplexes. Speak to an RBC mortgage specialist
- 21:04today to see how this program can work for you. Maximizing the potential of
- 21:08your home, well, that matters to you, to me, and to RBC.
- 21:14Why it is a challenging time in the housing market right now. We were waiting
- 21:18for prices to come down or interest rates to come down, and we've made
- 21:22the decision it's it's time to buy even if it's at an inflated cost. More
- 21:25young Canadians are choosing to partner with their parents to be able to jump those
- 21:29hurdles. It's not ideal, but this is what people are doing these
- 21:32days, or else people are just gonna be stuck, and it's sad.
- 21:38It's Tony Chapman. A big shout out to RBC for supporting chatter
- 21:42that matters. We hope to counter the negativity and growing sense of
- 21:45impossibility with stories of people who overcome circumstances
- 21:50to chase their dreams and change their world and ours for the better.
- 21:54Joining me now is Brad Bradford. He's a city council in Toronto.
- 21:58I view him as a positive force to change. He's He's pragmatic.
- 22:02He's focused. He has purpose. He has values. And he's on a mission
- 22:05to change the status quo, to reduce the friction between those who, for
- 22:09example, want to renovate their homes and add a density, and the
- 22:12bureaucracy who often finds a way to stand in their way. Brad, welcome to chat
- 22:16of the matters. Thanks very much, Tony. Huge fan of the pod, and it's an
- 22:19honor to be here. Listen. I love the fact that your roots are in city
- 22:23planning. That in your knapsack, you were in the the
- 22:26plumbing of the city trying to figure out how to organize a chessboard for
- 22:30the next 5, 10, 25 years. Taking that time
- 22:34in into into account, what is the most pressing issues a
- 22:37city like Toronto or Vancouver, any major city is gonna have to deal
- 22:41with in the next quarter century to century if we're gonna continue to
- 22:45be viable as a city where people feel excited about living? Well, I
- 22:49think you hit the nail on the head there with the question viability of
- 22:52our cities, municipalities across the country and the continent right
- 22:56now. And if you look at the city of Toronto, we're seeing
- 23:00an alarming number of folks leaving this city
- 23:03on an annual basis. Board of Trade pointed out last year,
- 23:0750,000 folks, many families actually picked
- 23:10up and left Toronto in a flight for affordability.
- 23:14And that's because if this is a city where we cannot secure the
- 23:18most, fundamental need, which is a roof over your head, a place
- 23:22that you can call home and afford, you're going to go elsewhere.
- 23:25And that's a big challenge for for our cities, which are the
- 23:29economic engine of our country, because it's the people who
- 23:33are actually doing the work, contributing to our economy, growing
- 23:36our GDP. They're the ones who are leaving. All of this sort of
- 23:40goes back to the issue of supply, supply of
- 23:44housing that peep people can afford and the different types of housing
- 23:47that for a long time in cities like Toronto has really
- 23:51been off limits for people to build. We need some leadership
- 23:54change, we need a different type of politics, and we need to create
- 23:58a culture of yes within the bureaucracy rather than
- 24:02the the roadblocks that most folks encounter when they they try and
- 24:06do something new or purpose driven in a city like Toronto. You know, Maslow's
- 24:09hierarchy of needs talks about safety and security. Essentially, a
- 24:13roof over your head is one of the most important things that we can give
- 24:17a society, especially a country as rich as Canada. Why do we get so
- 24:21many roadblocks when it comes to what to me should
- 24:24be the the primary focus of city council right now is to
- 24:28say, we gotta create affordability, and that begins with a roof over
- 24:32someone's head. Well, you think about all the dynamics that have changed in our world
- 24:36over the past 5 years, 10 years, and it's been a
- 24:39lot, the increasing trend of globalization, mass
- 24:43migration, immigration, global pandemic,
- 24:46inflation, all of these things mean that the world we're living in today
- 24:50is very different than the one we were even a few years ago. And
- 24:55unfortunately, big bureaucratic organizations are
- 24:59not very good at responding to change, they're not very good at creative
- 25:03thinking or innovation. In fact, they're set up to do the opposite. They're
- 25:06set up to do the same thing over and over again and
- 25:10repeat that. And of course, there's a role for that in government, but
- 25:14our ability as governments collectively to respond
- 25:17to the challenges and the pace of which change has taken place
- 25:21has really under delivered for people who are trying to call cities like
- 25:25Toronto home. And as a result, we have a massive
- 25:29lag on supply. We don't have the type of urgency
- 25:33within our bureaucratic institutions to wrap their arms around
- 25:36these wicked problems and solve them. And, I I think
- 25:40there's also just a big culture of fear within these organizations.
- 25:44Nobody wants to make a decision. The easiest answer is always
- 25:48no, and the bureaucracy is on a pathway of least
- 25:51resistance. So there is no reward for innovation or thinking outside the
- 25:55box or trying to problem solve. The safe position and the
- 25:59status quo is the one that prevails, And too often,
- 26:02that's the approach that we end up taking when it comes to housing. You know,
- 26:05we're so in tune. I wrote a post on LinkedIn last week talking about the
- 26:09invisible bars of status quo. And my hope is that AI,
- 26:12which doesn't have empathy, doesn't have heart, it doesn't fear change,
- 26:16and drives for efficiency is gonna expose a lot of these inefficiencies.
- 26:20But I got a question for you, Brad. If we gave you the game ball,
- 26:23and I know there's a lot of people in Toronto who would love to see
- 26:26you running this city, what would you do? The biggest thing we can
- 26:29do is empower people within the government to make those decisions to
- 26:33drive projects forward. It's it's understanding what are our
- 26:37priorities going to be, and I think there are a lot of challenges in government,
- 26:40and certainly we're seeing that here in the city of Toronto where our priorities
- 26:44are scattered. We're very reactive rather than proactive. I
- 26:48think it's about getting back to the the core business of local
- 26:51government, you know, when it comes to housing, setting up an environment where there
- 26:55are opportunities for growth, opportunity for market and
- 26:59not for not for profit sector to to thrive,
- 27:02and then making sure that the bureaucratic stage gates, the different
- 27:06divisions and all the commenting partners that are circulated on an application,
- 27:10that we're all rowing in the same direction, and that direction is getting
- 27:13to yes and getting there as quickly as possible. It's actually a mentality
- 27:17shift here at the city of Toronto. How do we remove those roadblocks?
- 27:22How do we empower people to get through the approval cycle
- 27:25faster? And just fundamentally, how do we set the table
- 27:29so that we can accommodate the growth and the supply that is
- 27:32desperately needed? The other thing that you're an advocate for is
- 27:36to open up our creative minds that there's other ways to do things. One of
- 27:40the things you've been talking a lot about is prefabricated homes. How do
- 27:43you sell the public on saying this makes a lot of sense and
- 27:47it's a win for everyone? When you take a step back and look at the
- 27:50global landscape, there are a lot of countries and
- 27:54sectors that are leading on prefab,
- 27:57on modular type of construction. And here
- 28:01in Ontario, we've been doing it the same way for decades
- 28:05decades. And I think that's being challenged now because we
- 28:09have had a shortage of of skilled labor.
- 28:12We are seeing challenges with respect to interest rates that go
- 28:16are going up. So the time that a project takes for completion
- 28:20is now more expensive because you're paying more money on the the cost of
- 28:24capital for construction financing and the inflation related
- 28:27to materials. So when we can do
- 28:31that faster, when we can utilize technology, modular,
- 28:34prefab, building materials, ultimately, that
- 28:38helps us deliver housing quicker, which means that housing can be more affordable.
- 28:42And, you know, Tony, a lot of people have preconceived notions about
- 28:46modular as, like, the portables that many of us went to school
- 28:49in growing up here in Ontario. I've had
- 28:53the opportunity and privilege to tour a number of factories
- 28:56that are going up here across the province. And I can tell you the stuff
- 29:00that's coming out of them is everything from affordable housing to
- 29:03luxury hotel rooms. You're building everything in a
- 29:07controlled environment and climate. You can build 365.
- 29:10You're never getting rained out. And the types of tolerances that
- 29:14they can hit in that precision controlled environment, it's it's really like
- 29:18transformation that's going on right now, akin to the the startup of the
- 29:21Model T and automotive assembly. So, Brad, my last question,
- 29:25because we're really talking about a changing mindset, a changing
- 29:29mindset within the public sector, within the all the people
- 29:32that sort of support the creation of housing, How
- 29:36do we create a sense of positivity and possibility with
- 29:40that young generation who once thought that owning a home was
- 29:44part of the rite of passage? It was part of the Canadian dream. And
- 29:47yet when I talk to people like Callan, they're saying most of my friends just
- 29:51are extending their twenties because they don't think they'll ever home own a home.
- 29:55So why even bother saving for 1? My message to folks, you know, and I'm
- 29:58a 1986 model. I'm 38 years old. So it's it's folks in
- 30:02my my cohort that are very much feeling this challenge in a
- 30:06really acute and real way, you know, trying to raise a family in a
- 30:10big city is it's never been more difficult, but the
- 30:14solutions are also there. And when we talk about modular
- 30:17technology, when we talk about unlocking supply, ending exclusionary
- 30:21zoning in vast swaths of neighborhoods that have been off limits
- 30:25for new types of gentle density, you know, we're breaking the mold
- 30:29on all of that stuff. And the way that Toronto was governed from a zoning
- 30:33and planning perspective for the past 20 years since amalgamation,
- 30:37that is not working anymore, and there's a growing chorus of voices
- 30:40that recognize that and are pushing and advocating for some of those
- 30:44changes that are already underway. And I
- 30:48think the idea of home ownership is still a big part of the Canadian
- 30:52dream. And there's a lot of us out there swinging with both arms,
- 30:56who are not ready to give up on that. It's about creating more
- 30:59opportunities for supply, more housing that people can afford,
- 31:03and that is that's right next to the supply problem.
- 31:07We need to create an environment where we can unleash an avalanche of
- 31:10housing across this country. And a big part of that is changing
- 31:14the regulations that have been there to to do the precise
- 31:18opposite of that, which is of course restrict and stop housing. That needs
- 31:21to change if we wanna be a country that continues to grow, if prosperity
- 31:25is available to the people who are doing the jobs and growing the economy, that
- 31:29value proposition needs to change. So there's reason for hope because we've
- 31:33gotten to such a breaking point. It is now a conversation that I can't walk
- 31:36down the street or spend any time in the supermarket or go over to a
- 31:39buddy's for a beer, and not end up talking about housing. We
- 31:43just need committed leadership of folks who are are ready to, to
- 31:47bring in the change that we need to see. You are, as I introduced you,
- 31:50a force of positive change. And you know that I'd be championing for you to
- 31:54one day run this country, but maybe just running the city will be enough
- 31:58to be your legacy and, and something that will give me great peace of mind.
- 32:01So thank you for joining me on Chatter That Matters. Thanks for the, the support,
- 32:02Tony. Love you chatting with you. So
- 32:12the third part of this story today on this concept of the
- 32:16missing middle or gentle density, getting getting more from a lot, putting
- 32:20more people on the same square footage is Leah Robinson. She's a
- 32:23vice president of home equity financing at RBC. Leah,
- 32:27welcome. Tony, thanks for having me. I'm happy happy to join you today
- 32:31on this important topic. I think this show is fascinating. I mean, we first start
- 32:34with Callum MacKay. He's a young kid living with his wife in
- 32:38Vancouver, 1 bedroom, and they find out she's
- 32:41expecting, and they need to make a move. And they start looking around
- 32:45further and further out of the city to find space that they they
- 32:49feel confident they can raise a family in. And he talks about getting
- 32:52lucky, you know, in within his family, there was a house that they could
- 32:56build upon, create, you know, 2 bungalows and a and a
- 32:59rental suite. So everything we're talking about is saying, you know, that when property
- 33:03exists, can we do more with it? And the real question I have for you
- 33:07is that he ran into so much challenge in terms of
- 33:11getting banks to open their minds to the fact that this is a new
- 33:15way of looking at housing. It requires more innovation,
- 33:19more creativity from the bank's point of view. And I understand that's what you're doing
- 33:22at RBC, so I thought you could weigh in and talk more about,
- 33:26which isn't necessarily a a skip in the park or an easy thing to
- 33:30sort of approve, but still requires the kind of thinking and
- 33:33creativity that that, you're willing to put into it. You know, the example you gave
- 33:37is is such a great one of of where families and and
- 33:40people are thinking about, you know, how how can they live differently. Right?
- 33:44And so, you know, when we look at programs as a bank, we wanna be
- 33:47able to support support customers, who are interested
- 33:51in making some of those changes. And construction right off of the bat is not
- 33:55for the faint of heart, and I'll say that, you know, I'll say that over
- 33:57and over, because there certainly is challenges in terms of working through
- 34:01the process. But it's it's different ways of living. You know, when
- 34:05you look at some of the the the supply challenges, we really have
- 34:09to look at this in many different ways. New buildings, yes, are
- 34:13great, but how do we reuse and recycle some of
- 34:16the existing infrastructure and modify it so that families
- 34:20and communities can live, live a bit differently? And and that's
- 34:24where, you know, we're looking at our programs saying, how do we support people,
- 34:28who wanna do this, who wanna live in multigenerational homes or
- 34:32have the ability to to generate, additional income
- 34:35to be able to support support a mortgage. And so if I was
- 34:39in that situation saying, listen. I've got this house. I you know, maybe I want
- 34:43my mother-in-law to move in, or I wanna find some rental income.
- 34:47Is a process for approaching someone like RBC different? Because
- 34:51it isn't your, you know, here's my down payment, and here's how much I
- 34:55can afford in a house. This is something I own and wanna do more with
- 34:57it. Yeah. I mean, we certainly have programs both at if it's an
- 35:01existing property that you own or that you wanna purchase. And it
- 35:05just depends as well in terms of how deep are you planning on on going
- 35:09with that home. We do have those options for both kinds of
- 35:12clients depending on what you wanna do, whether it's multiple suites, whether it's
- 35:16putting in a single suite, adapting a space,
- 35:20you know, for family members, whether they're seniors and they need special equipment,
- 35:24whatever it is. And we will recognize in the cases that that clients want
- 35:28to, the income that that that they will generate if if that's
- 35:32the intended use of the property. Leah, part of this is not just the
- 35:36sort of doing the math, but it's the the insecurity and
- 35:39uncertainty, the path that I haven't followed in the past. What is your
- 35:43advice? Yeah. I mean, I think the first place to start is to really understand
- 35:47where you're living and what are what are the requirements there. But when you're
- 35:50ready to kinda go through that process and you said, this is a
- 35:54decision that makes sense for me, our mortgage specialists are
- 35:57are best equipped to kind of have those have those discussions.
- 36:02Finding a qualified builder, I think, is also a really
- 36:05important piece of of that process, and making sure you're
- 36:09working with somebody who's reputable, who knows what they're doing, and can also
- 36:13help guide you through that process in terms of working with the
- 36:17municipality. What are the requirements in terms of permits? How do you go
- 36:20through that application process? And then the financing that
- 36:24you need, you need to get through that. What role can an organization
- 36:28like RBC play working with the
- 36:31city, 2 very different entities, to try to
- 36:35encourage this kind of sentiment so that
- 36:38people that do have the ability to dream and wanna do
- 36:42find less friction and less bureaucracy and
- 36:46more people there saying, yes. Let's do it together. We can make this happen. I
- 36:49think one of the things that we're thinking of is is how do we build
- 36:52those those bigger partnerships and processes. Right? Because what
- 36:56you you wanna be able to do, and I think, Tony, some of the stories
- 37:00that you've delved into is it really is it it's really difficult
- 37:04right now. And so how can between a builder, a
- 37:07municipality, and a bank sort of come together and say, we kinda
- 37:11need to create a repeatable process? Because when people hear
- 37:15about how difficult, it can be, it sort of pushes them
- 37:18away from that. Right? And it creates creates that fear of taking
- 37:22something like a a big project like that on. So, you know, creating
- 37:26those opportunities is really about, looking at what are the right
- 37:29partnerships and what are the experts, that the average person
- 37:33needs around them in order to be able to accomplish
- 37:37something like doing a major major renovation on their home, major
- 37:41re reconstruction of their home in order to be able to accomplish their goals.
- 37:44So, Leah, you've launched this. What's the uptake like? We still
- 37:48haven't seen a lot of uptake. The simplicity of putting in
- 37:52a laneway or, you know, a basement suite, that's a lot
- 37:55easier. One of the things that you you wanna see as you look at sort
- 37:59of that dense density is is getting up into those 4plexes, those
- 38:036plexes. We're just not seeing it happen. There's still a lot of
- 38:06hesitation given the given the complexity of what people face
- 38:10to kind of move through these projects, but also the cost. You know, you need
- 38:13to be working with reputable people. These are not, this isn't a bathroom
- 38:17renovation that could go wrong, you know, like, this is a big deal.
- 38:21People hear horror stories about some of that, and so so it's
- 38:25scary. Leah, for all the things that you work on and manage, I have to
- 38:29believe that what you're doing here in terms of really
- 38:33helping people dream and do, find a way to get more from
- 38:36their property, whether that's more family living with them or more income, it's gotta
- 38:40be some of the most rewarding work you're doing. Absolutely. I mean, I've got I've
- 38:44got personal stories in in my own family, you know, the difficulty,
- 38:49in in affordability. Right? And and so giving people
- 38:53the options to be able to adapt their their spaces.
- 38:56I love the story of this client that you've met and being able to do
- 39:00that. And not only does he get to stay with his family, but, and, and
- 39:03he's generating some income, which helps him, but he's also created another
- 39:07space for another family. Right. And that allows
- 39:10them to, you know, live in a different style of housing
- 39:14in a different neighborhood and things like that. So You know, Leah Robinson, I love
- 39:17the fact that you talk. I have many stories, and I think telling these stories
- 39:21and sharing these stories is gonna have people realize that, you
- 39:25know, it isn't insurmountable. Not easy as you said, requires a lot
- 39:29of resilience like Calum showed and a lot of, you know, approach
- 39:33to finding a way through it. But when you get there, as he said, is
- 39:36there's nothing more exciting than coming home and knowing I live in a bungalow.
- 39:40My brother-in-law lives in the bungalow behind me, and then we have a
- 39:43rental suite helping both of us covering the cost of the mortgage that it was,
- 39:47it was time well spent. So I appreciate your time today and, just
- 39:51looking forward to seeing what RBC's doing in this space and, give you a
- 39:55standing ovation because fulfilling mortgages is repeatable
- 39:58doing something like this. Each one of them's a bit of a one off and,
- 40:02I'm I just congratulate you for taking that on. Thanks for having me, Tony.
- 40:06Appreciate it. Once again, a special thanks to RBC for
- 40:09supporting Chata that matters. It's Tony Chapman. Thanks for
- 40:13listening, and let's chat soon.