Latest / Two Talking Fools Podcast / What We Carry: Grief, Loss & Learning to Live Again with Edy Nathan
Transcript
- 0:00The only duo brave enough to talk nonsense with conviction.
- 0:06Ladies and gentlemen, Shabba, Kate, Two Talking Fools.
- 0:17All right. Good morning, everybody. Welcome back to the Two Talking Fools.
- 0:21It is Kate, your co-host.
- 0:24I am doing another solo podcast today. Shabba will be back soon.
- 0:29We have a special guest on the show today you know one of the things that we
- 0:33listen to a lot is our listeners our viewers and we have a nice bond together
- 0:40we connect on life events and things that are happening,
- 0:45and one of the things that happens and we talk about a lot is is grief,
- 0:50and this may actually be an episode that some people are nervous to listen to
- 0:54and i'm using myself as an example.
- 0:57Grief is something that makes us vulnerable. It hurts. We don't know how to react to it.
- 1:03So that's why we're having this conversation today.
- 1:07The fears we have, the fears of
- 1:09losing people, the fears of the future not looking like we thought it was,
- 1:14the dreams, our health, who we used to be, these are all things that lead to,
- 1:21loss, that lead to grief.
- 1:24Some of us carry grief and some of us are being carried by our grief.
- 1:30And the reality is at the end of the day that none of us are getting through
- 1:34life without experiencing it in some form or fashion.
- 1:37So that's why I wanted Edie Nathan here today. Edie is on our show.
- 1:43I don't want to go into too much. I'm going to let Edie do this,
- 1:47and I don't want to just sit here.
- 1:49But Edie is a licensed therapist, a grief expert, author, and speaker who has
- 1:55spent decades working with grief, trauma, and loss.
- 1:59And I am so happy to introduce Edie. Edie, welcome to the Two Talking Fools podcast.
- 2:06Kate, it's wonderful to be here. Thank you so much for having me.
- 2:10It means the world to me. We had an awesome conversation before we got started
- 2:15here, just how close we are, the degrees of separation, my goodness.
- 2:21I'm just very happy to have you here and really get into this.
- 2:25You did a couple podcasts that instantly you were talking about grief and the
- 2:30way that you talked about it with just the empathy and just such sincereness. I loved it.
- 2:37But before we get into that, Edie, tell us a little bit about yourself and how you kind of got here.
- 2:43There are paths that we find ourselves on, and we might have thought on some
- 2:50level that we chose those paths, right?
- 2:53But I think they ultimately choose us.
- 2:56And I have been thinking about death and thinking about truly like spirituality
- 3:04as well since I'm yea high.
- 3:08I was looking at the world in ways that I could see just beyond laughter or beyond pain.
- 3:21It just seemed like there was grief around, and I could feel it,
- 3:27and it was palpable. And...
- 3:30As we grow up, we have what I call the little Gs, the little losses.
- 3:36And those little losses, when they're not dealt with, they accumulate.
- 3:40And those little losses can come from a bad haircut, right?
- 3:47Because that bad haircut, if it was done.
- 3:53At a precious age and you missed your hair, or it was done as a punishment,
- 4:01which actually happened with me.
- 4:04Getting my hair cut, I feel grief at times if it's not done well.
- 4:11And so those are the little Gs.
- 4:15And we don't even take them on as grief, as a grief experience or a grief response.
- 4:22And then there are the big Gs. And those big G's, which is what we're primarily
- 4:29going to be talking about today, come in the form of the losses of loved ones.
- 4:36And the umbrella under which loved ones fall is huge. It's magnificently huge.
- 4:45And those loved ones can be certainly a parent, a grandparent, a child.
- 4:54Underneath all of those losses, which is the loss of an external soul that we
- 5:02loved, there's also the accumulation of the loss of self.
- 5:08And we don't tend to talk about the loss of self when we think about the grief
- 5:13that we carry when we're experiencing the loss of someone dear.
- 5:21And the way that I define grief is it's a yearning for, a hunger for that person
- 5:31we can't replace or that experience we can't have back.
- 5:37And so, I lost my partner when I was 27 years old, but I had had a lot of prior
- 5:43losses. But that loss opened up a world of,
- 5:49And realizations that, wow, grief doesn't just wound, it totally occupies you.
- 5:57And I was held by its grip, but I was also held by the fact that I had no resources.
- 6:03And the lack of those resources just left me going to groups with men and women who had lost spouses.
- 6:15And I was looking for help. But what I was getting was, you're young,
- 6:19and you're going to get better, and you're going to move on.
- 6:23And it was like, but I'm in this pain now.
- 6:27And the last thing that I can think about is how I'm going to move on.
- 6:30And the last thing I can think about is, oh, let's just go out and,
- 6:35you know, meet somebody else.
- 6:40That wasn't the cure. And somehow there was this, like, what they thought to
- 6:48be a legitimate argument of, you're going to get better, it's all going to be
- 6:52in the past, and that's it.
- 6:55But you know what, Kate? It's never in the past.
- 6:59And I realized, okay, so there needs to be a whole new languaging around this.
- 7:05And I was in the theater, I was an actor, I was just trying to kind of go through
- 7:14my paces with that world,
- 7:16and stopped everything and realized I now need to focus on this.
- 7:23And the loss of Paul refocused my entire life in writing about, talking about,
- 7:30and doing deep dives into the very thing that we don't want to talk about—grief.
- 7:37And, frankly, trauma and our own senses of self.
- 7:43What did that look like when you lost Paul?
- 7:47What was that time frame? When did you feel like, okay, I can survive this.
- 7:56I can get, I feel okay. I can wake
- 7:58up every morning and maybe not feel overwhelming like this isn't a dream.
- 8:07Or does it ever? You know, Kate, it's such a great question because sometimes
- 8:12it still feels like a dream.
- 8:15And that doesn't mean that my life has not moved forward and I'm with a terrific,
- 8:23guy in this moment in my life and I adore him.
- 8:31And, but subsequent to Paul dying, I,
- 8:39within the year, met someone, got married to that person,
- 8:46raised that person's children who were almost teenagers then. And.
- 8:58It was a reaction to a loss.
- 9:03That in hindsight, I needed to step back and not move so quickly,
- 9:09and not move so arbitrarily. But I was young.
- 9:12I mean, 27 doesn't seem so young, but when,
- 9:18you know, everyone's history is different, and we are young in different ways
- 9:23in our lives throughout our lives, and we are all of the ages we were up to the age we are now.
- 9:31And so I will sometimes be that little girl, and I will sometimes go into my
- 9:36wounds, and I will sometimes go into my very mature self, and it's always fluctuating.
- 9:42And I think that it does, and it does in terms of grief.
- 9:47Grief isn't linear, and we want it to be linear. Oh, Kate, we want to think, right? Don't we?
- 9:55We want to believe we're going to start here, we're going to end here,
- 9:59and there's going to be an end. There's going to be an end in sight.
- 10:02But I don't know that there's an end. I think there's an evolution.
- 10:06It's such a great way of putting it.
- 10:09You can't get rid of it. I don't want to, to be honest with you,
- 10:14because let's play with that for a little bit.
- 10:17Let's play with that, Kate, for just a moment. And anybody who's listening,
- 10:22let's say we got rid of the grief.
- 10:26Okay? It's a pretend world. Okay?
- 10:29And it's not that grief doesn't change or fluctuate over time,
- 10:34and you learn to dance with it and live with it.
- 10:36But let's say, as what is promised, you get through it, and there's this thing
- 10:43called, which I don't ascribe to now, closure.
- 10:48It's done. Done.
- 10:50What else gets taken away in that world? It's done.
- 10:56It's like closing a chapter of your life. Maybe you don't necessarily want to.
- 11:01Yes, there is that. And there's no necessarily right answer here.
- 11:06But what if it also is like, okay, so you've put that away. So it's not part of who you are anymore.
- 11:17It's not your identity. It's not part of the pie or the puzzle or the mosaic of the self, right?
- 11:26And it's like, okay, so there's the mosaic, but that part of the mosaic is kind of dark.
- 11:33I don't want that part of the mosaic to be dark. I want that part of the mosaic
- 11:38to have color and to be alive in me.
- 11:41And to bring that part of the mosaic into my life and into my life force and
- 11:49into my creativity and into how people get to know Edie,
- 11:56and how I actually get to know other people because of that part of my mosaic. Right.
- 12:05So I don't want there to be closure and it's open and shut. Right.
- 12:12I, and this is how I work with people, right? I want us,
- 12:17to have that glimmer of light and that love that we had for those we've lost,
- 12:25and pay it forward and bring it forward within our lives, within our souls,
- 12:31within our spirituality, within our sense of community.
- 12:37Within our psyches, our souls.
- 12:40Yeah. Because it's part of me.
- 12:44You know, if you had a crappy childhood...
- 12:49And there's not going to be a closure to it, but maybe there's a way to partner
- 12:53with that crappy, cruddy, hurtful time.
- 12:57And it's not about forgetting, but how do you remember more peacefully?
- 13:02And how does it become a dance and a partnership of integration?
- 13:06Because when we try to push things away, you know, we think about anxiety and
- 13:12we just push it away, push it away, just push it away. You know what happens?
- 13:16It gets bigger and bigger and bigger and bigger.
- 13:20Yeah. And so it's not about it getting bigger. The way to mitigate its power
- 13:25and its strength is to say, okay, I'm going to be curious about you. I want to know about you.
- 13:31I want to know about where you live in my body and how that changes.
- 13:35I want to know about the body memoirs my grief carries.
- 13:40And does it live sometimes in my gut? Probably. In my jaw? Maybe.
- 13:46In what I hear, what I see, what I feel. You know,
- 13:51when I see a dead animal, and we see dead animals on the roads,
- 13:55we see roadkill, it's like, oh, yeah, okay, that brings me back too.
- 14:02And if I just have, like, it's done, it's over, I might not be open to that.
- 14:09But it comes into our consciousness, so why not honor it?
- 14:14Grief, trauma, it all plays a very big role emotionally and physically.
- 14:22And I feel like there are people among us and around us where you can look at them.
- 14:28I don't even think you need to be an empath to do this. You can look at them
- 14:32and you can say, my goodness, their backpack is heavy. What they're carrying is heavy.
- 14:39And I feel like, Edie, I feel like I see it everywhere I go.
- 14:43I don't care if I'm running into the supermarket. I see people that are hurt.
- 14:49They carry everything right with them.
- 14:53And it's sad, especially when I feel like you can see it and you can almost feel it from them.
- 15:01Yeah. Can you tell us a little bit about emotionally and physically the grip
- 15:06that this can take on people, the toll.
- 15:10Grief is like your fingerprint. It's as individual as you are.
- 15:15And though there may be phases of grief, I call them the phases,
- 15:22and in my book I have 11 phases of grief.
- 15:28The phases look at what happens physically, what happens spiritually,
- 15:34what happens emotionally.
- 15:37And that first phase I call the emotional armor phase.
- 15:41And it is an armoring, but it is also a place that we can go back to time and
- 15:49time again. I see that emotional armor phase as the safe harbor.
- 15:54And so what happens to one person physically in their grief response is going
- 16:00to be different than how somebody else experiences a physical response to their grief.
- 16:07And they may not even be aware of that physical response.
- 16:11What I can say is that there are commonalities in how one experiences it or what the experience is.
- 16:21For example, lack of sleep or too much sleep, overeating or no eating at all.
- 16:28Self-care is either magnified or completely breaks down. And that can look like,
- 16:36I don't remember the last time I took a shower or ate or slept.
- 16:41So that can be one person's grief response, right?
- 16:45On the other hand, it could be, I'm not eating.
- 16:49All I want to do is sleep, and my self-care is, you know, on an as-needed basis,
- 16:58but will do it on an as-needed basis.
- 17:03So, as you can hear, there's a different paradigm, but dealing with the same,
- 17:12experience of sleep, or food, or self-care,
- 17:17or frankly, sex.
- 17:20Some people use sex as an outlet.
- 17:23It's not emotional, but it is a relief.
- 17:28For some people, that outlet is a way to feel something for some other people
- 17:36it's just an outlet to be to just be,
- 17:42wow yeah,
- 17:45I don't know that I answered your question. You did. Okay. No, you did. Okay.
- 17:51I want to talk about living with grief.
- 17:55I said something and I want to touch on it if we can. Let me get it in front of me.
- 18:02Between the notes on my phone, the notes on my laptop, and the notes on my... Okay. Okay.
- 18:09Some of us carry grief and some of us are being carried by our grief.
- 18:17I want to start by asking you, based on that, what are the signs or what people
- 18:25that are going through extreme grief,
- 18:28what are the signs that they should look for when it's almost like,
- 18:33okay, maybe the grief is now taking over and is the pilot in your life versus
- 18:38you handling it? if that makes sense.
- 18:42I have a story that I love to tell, and it's actually the opening to a new book
- 18:48that I'm working on right now.
- 18:51And it's about these monks from like the year 1400 AD.
- 18:58And these monks knew that they were going to be attacked, and they had this
- 19:03Buddha that they wanted to survive even if they didn't.
- 19:06So they slathered this Buddha in clay and concrete and glass to make it appear really, really ugly.
- 19:18And they did not survive. They knew they wouldn't.
- 19:22But the Buddha, this ugly Buddha, did survive.
- 19:28Fast forward to the 1950s, and the Buddha was being moved, and in the moving
- 19:35of the Buddha, the Buddha fell.
- 19:37And a chip of the encasement came off, and what was revealed was gold.
- 19:45And it was the most gorgeous golden Buddha, and bit by bit,
- 19:52the new monks chiseled away at the clay and the concrete and the glass to reveal this golden Buddha.
- 20:01That was just gorgeous and stunning and had been hidden in plain sight for all those many years.
- 20:10And grief has a way of plastering us and creating a protection.
- 20:21And initially it might be a protection, but if that slathered protection, the emotional armor.
- 20:32Stays on, then you become one with the protection.
- 20:38And one becomes one with their grief.
- 20:41And this becomes really a conversation about identity.
- 20:47And remember, I referred to the pie, and we've got this great pie of all these
- 20:53different aspects of the self.
- 20:55And the pie is also what I refer to as a mosaic. So you'll, you know,
- 21:00for all of you who are listening, understand that I'm using these analogies
- 21:05and these metaphors interchangeably, okay? I'm a metaphor girl.
- 21:10I love my metaphors because I think sometimes it's a lot easier to talk in story
- 21:15or to talk in a metaphor than it is to actually talk about,
- 21:21the depths of the pain. And our psyches want to protect us. So let's make this
- 21:28an easier conversation even though we're still talking about those depths, okay?
- 21:33And so the idea of the emotional armor and the numbness that is in there,
- 21:41and the despair that is in there and the hypervigilance that is in under that
- 21:48umbrella of emotional armor.
- 21:50That that emotional armor becomes what you walk with and it becomes part of an identity.
- 21:58And if you find that all you're thinking about is how the grief that you didn't invite in,
- 22:10it is, you know, you open the door and if grief is standing there,
- 22:15all you want to do is run and it will catch you because you can't escape it
- 22:20and you can't hide from it.
- 22:22And you can't get the person who you lost to come back except...
- 22:28In the way you tell stories around them, except in perhaps a piece of clothing that you held on to.
- 22:35I carry Paul's watch, and every
- 22:38once in a while when I want to hear him or remember him, I'll wind it.
- 22:43It was an old Timex watch, and I'll wind it and I'll hear tick,
- 22:46tick, tick, tick, tick, and it's like, okay, I've got my Paul.
- 22:51And it doesn't mean that I haven't been on a journey of moving with my grief.
- 22:59I have, and I can still find a balance, a calibrated place of my memories of
- 23:09Him, the life that I have now, which is delicious.
- 23:13And the life that I will have going forward.
- 23:16And so it's the encasement of the emotional armor came off.
- 23:23Does it mean that it stays off always? No. Sometimes we need to go back into
- 23:28the emotional armor phase. And I think that as we go through all of the different
- 23:31phases that are nonlinear, they don't come in an order.
- 23:35And sometimes the anxiety phase and the anger and rage phase, they intertwine.
- 23:48And it's layered. It doesn't just like, they don't come in a single file mode, you know?
- 23:56And sometimes it's just so overwhelming. And then you go back into the emotional armor phase.
- 24:02So what I would say is, if the identity is, I am the grief, I don't know,
- 24:10the way you asked the question,
- 24:13I don't know that people who are so solely associated to their grief and their
- 24:20identities have become the grief,
- 24:23if they're even aware that that's happening.
- 24:28So the way that I heard your question, and please correct me,
- 24:32the way that I heard it is that you know it's happening.
- 24:37I don't think you know it's happening. I don't think one knows I am the grief.
- 24:44I think it may be observable to people who love them and care about them,
- 24:48and it's a very tricky situation.
- 24:51It's incredibly tricky. And we want to,
- 24:55we can't break through the trickery of it because it might feel for the person
- 25:00who is the container of that, that you want to take something away from them,
- 25:05that they need, they want.
- 25:10They don't know how to get out of its grip They don't know how to get out of
- 25:14its occupation Because there's a sense at times And this is not for all people It is for some people.
- 25:25In that moment, they can feel that they are dishonoring the love they felt and
- 25:32the love they had from the person they lost.
- 25:37So it is about helping someone realize they can honor, like I hold on,
- 25:42I have my tick, tick, tick of the watch, and that my honoring of Paul was to be able to love another.
- 25:52That's that's all yeah you honor him but you still live your life you still,
- 26:00you still have a life to live while you're here in the earth world but that
- 26:03was a learning process that is a learning process it doesn't just it doesn't
- 26:08happen with a magic wand it doesn't happen because we have grief relief
- 26:14it happens because there's desire,
- 26:18because you can see that There's a window.
- 26:22And a path that you can take that allows you to have a relationship with the
- 26:30loss and with who you've lost,
- 26:33have a relationship to a new empowered self that can navigate,
- 26:42I loved this person.
- 26:44I lost this person.
- 26:46My identity does not need to be just in the loss, but can be in taking that loss and realizing,
- 26:59I can love myself first.
- 27:04And that loss doesn't have to be all of me.
- 27:08It can be a part of me, and anybody who says, now it's time to move on,
- 27:15a person who is solely identified with the loss, and their identity is the loss, is the grief—.
- 27:27Is like saying to them, go kill yourself.
- 27:31Yeah. That's what you hear. That's what's being heard. And frankly,
- 27:35no one, people say things that might, that feel, that sound inappropriate because
- 27:42they don't, they're at a loss.
- 27:44And they want to say something that soothes them and hopefully soothes you, you know. Right, right.
- 27:53Yeah. And I wonder what would happen with the people with, and I've certainly
- 28:00worked with a lot of people who identified with their loss and needed,
- 28:06and their identities were the loss.
- 28:08And they would go about life, but they weren't daring to live.
- 28:14They weren't really thriving.
- 28:16They were minimally surviving.
- 28:22And they were just walking on their own planks, if you will, of life.
- 28:28Yeah. And almost waiting for relief. And relief.
- 28:37Is a choice. And it can't be manufactured, and you can't be told just,
- 28:45you know, okay, so now I want you to just dance with your grief. No.
- 28:51There's a liberation that needs to occur that allows you to understand you can have both.
- 28:59You can have your life and you can have your memories and you can have bits
- 29:05and pieces of that life they will always live with you you will always have
- 29:10this and there's a yes and,
- 29:14As someone who's lost somebody close to me, thinking of the listeners now and
- 29:21myself, it's like, but I hear that, but death is so permanent.
- 29:30It's so permanent, Edie. Sometimes I look around with my father's passing,
- 29:36and it's been years now, so it's easier to talk about, and you learn to do that dance.
- 29:42But then sometimes you look around and you say, wow, I say, God,
- 29:46you're only 42. I have my whole life.
- 29:49I have my whole earth life to live without this person who I love so much.
- 29:54That's right. That's so, it's so difficult.
- 29:57It is. Oh, gosh. Gosh.
- 30:01And you have your whole earth life to keep them close in the way that works for you.
- 30:12So you're only 42 and yeah you have so many more years and and is there,
- 30:22is there a hole is there a missing piece yes yeah there is integrating that missing piece into you,
- 30:34and keeping him alive through your stories,
- 30:40through your dedications of him?
- 30:45Do we have the capacity to bring him back or to bring back the people we've lost? No.
- 30:51And yet, do we have the capacity to keep their memories alive and therefore,
- 30:59by keeping their memories alive in the ways that we do that.
- 31:04We don't forget. And I think there's this fear of forgetting.
- 31:09Because, yes, as time goes by, as time passes, my mom's been gone for 20-something
- 31:16years. And I make it my business on her birthday, on the anniversary of her death.
- 31:23My mother loved to shop. So what do I do? I shop.
- 31:29Okay? And I have a whole conversation with her. Love it. Okay,
- 31:34Mom. What are we going to buy today?
- 31:37What do you think of this? And I have these whole conversations,
- 31:41you know, she loved to decorate.
- 31:44She loved color, like they had a lot of artwork.
- 31:49So maybe I'll buy a small piece of art at a craft show or I'll buy a beautiful top.
- 31:58Or, and, you know, she just was known as just this, she was a runway model,
- 32:04and she was gorgeous, and, you know, so,
- 32:08I embody, like, an aspect of her, and on Mother's Day, I buy a Mother's Day card.
- 32:18I write her a Mother's Day card, and I write her a poem, because she stays alive. in me.
- 32:30I can't bring her back, but I can make a choice of mourning her,
- 32:38but also being excited by.
- 32:44Bringing her memory alive and the way that I've filtered her beauty into me.
- 32:53I love that. Now, I just want to say to all of you, I just painted a picture
- 32:59of my relationship with my mother as if it was like this really delicious,
- 33:04wonderful relationship. And let me tell you something. It wasn't.
- 33:08Okay? It was hard. It was—we argued all of the time.
- 33:15We were very different people.
- 33:19And I was pretty obese as a kid and my mother was a runway model.
- 33:26Do I need to say more? Okay.
- 33:30And it wasn't until she was dying and this is, you know, I was a therapist at that point and I knew,
- 33:41and I'd worked with a lot of people who were dying and.
- 33:47Though I wasn't a death doula, I would consider myself a grief doula in helping
- 33:54people move with their grief,
- 33:57deliver their grief in a more peaceful way to themselves.
- 34:03In those moments with my mom, I was a death doula.
- 34:09And we had six months, and my repair with her was nothing less than miraculous.
- 34:18And we, and I just want to say this, that repair, it's never too late if you
- 34:26want it. Now, me, I wanted it.
- 34:29I did. I wanted it. I hungered for it.
- 34:32I yearned for it because it was a grief that was there while she was alive.
- 34:40Because there can be a grief for the people who are alive who made us invisible.
- 34:47And that invisibility doesn't go away.
- 34:53And it's traumatic, and we're not going to get into that part of the story, but it's a grief.
- 35:01When one feels invisible, and there's a traumatic underpinning around it, there is.
- 35:10So when she was dying, like, I was there. They lived in Chicago. It's where I'm from.
- 35:18I flew back and forth from New York.
- 35:21And I was there. And, you know, just she allowed me into her world, and she apologized.
- 35:33Now, I got an apology.
- 35:35I never thought that I would get an apology. I never thought that she would
- 35:40think an apology was necessary or needed.
- 35:45And then the question becomes, can you, as the person who was so hurt and invisible, can you take it in?
- 35:57Can you allow for it to happen?
- 36:00Because forgiveness is one of the phases.
- 36:04And that forgiveness is huge. And it's not just forgiveness of perhaps the person that hurt you,
- 36:13but it's forgiveness of the self and allowing yourself to forgive yourself for,
- 36:22not how you might have responded,
- 36:25but just for being kinder to yourself even though you might have been hurt.
- 36:34So, because sometimes the way that we are hurt by the people who didn't know how to love us,
- 36:45is the way that we treat ourselves. And hence, I was overweight.
- 36:53And that was my best way to get back at her. I don't think I was conscious of
- 36:57it then, but that was me. That was me then.
- 37:01What I can say, though, is that when she apologized, that opened up a whole world for us.
- 37:07And we then could communicate on levels that we had never communicated before,
- 37:13even though she was in her morphine state at times.
- 37:18We wrote I wrote a eulogy that I read to her and she said but what about this and what about that.
- 37:27And and I asked her what kind of music she wanted,
- 37:32and my mom true to form she said well I don't want the normal music and I'm
- 37:38like okay well what music do you want and she said well I want the first song
- 37:42I want is she works hard for her money and.
- 37:46And I'm like, what? And so there we are.
- 37:50It's the funeral. And I put this on. And the people at the funeral home say,
- 37:56do you know what's playing? And I said, yeah, it's what she wanted.
- 38:00And that was her. And so I bring this up because it actually brought a repair
- 38:09to the fracture that was everlasting.
- 38:13Now, does that mean that my mourning and grief period was easier because of it?
- 38:21Guess again. And I say this because we think, oh, I got what I needed, and it was delicious.
- 38:29I got what I needed, and God damn it.
- 38:33How come it took so long?
- 38:36Why couldn't I have seen her earlier and gotten that earlier?
- 38:43But it couldn't. It wasn't.
- 38:45But that's what I ended up mourning.
- 38:47And that's why I was embedded in my grief with her for three, four years.
- 38:53But in that time, a year after she died, I met my now husband.
- 39:01And if you're a woo-woo in any way, I think there were energies that It was
- 39:07like her dying opened up,
- 39:11opened me up to allow my next greatest love.
- 39:18So do you see then my identity shifted and changed?
- 39:24I wasn't the grief. There were certainly many days that I was,
- 39:29but it opened up pathways.
- 39:32Edie, if you didn't get that apology from your mom, that single apology,
- 39:40do you think the trajectory would have been the same?
- 39:43It's a great question.
- 39:48You know, we never know, right? But there's a great old movie,
- 39:54I think it's called Sliding Doors, and what's interesting is it's the same person
- 40:01but two different paths taken,
- 40:03and in a way they end up in the same place.
- 40:07And so perhaps it would have taken me a little bit longer, or the goal would have been different, or,
- 40:18maybe I would have been yearning for the apology rather than wondering how come it took so long.
- 40:26Or maybe I would have made excuses. Yeah. Yeah. Because I think that that's what happens for us.
- 40:34When there's that kind of wounding that's developmental in nature, I think that.
- 40:42We write our stories and we make excuses. And those excuses are divine, you know, in many ways.
- 40:50And they help us to be the survivalists that we are.
- 40:55And grief is not for the faint of heart, and we don't choose it.
- 41:01Don't choose it. And the reason that I wrote about the 11 phases is because
- 41:09they move in and out of one another.
- 41:11And that last phase is not in any way about closure or you've now gone through it.
- 41:22It's about how do you find your grace?
- 41:25How do you dance with it in a graceful way so that you can know who you are
- 41:32with it and apart from it.
- 41:35And that you meet grace, and then you lose it. And you meet it,
- 41:38and it becomes smaller. And.
- 41:45It's like a butterfly. You know, you see it, and then it's beautiful,
- 41:48and then it disappears, and then it flutters back to you, and then it disappears,
- 41:53and then sometimes it's in a cocoon, and you see it, and you watch it evolve, and you watch,
- 42:00its wings develop, and then it's gone,
- 42:02and I think that that's the relationship with grief. Yeah.
- 42:07But to understand that, and to think, oh my God, I'm having a really hard day
- 42:11now, I'm thinking about my mom or my dad, which was a whole other complicated mess,
- 42:19and I bring up my personal stuff, because I don't come to this work just from
- 42:24a clinical, you know, place.
- 42:29I want to use language that's for all people. That's for everyone.
- 42:36You know, because we don't escape it.
- 42:41Different cultures deal with death in very different ways.
- 42:47And children in the We have sanitized the whole deathing process properly.
- 42:57And there are some cultures now that are going back to, you know,
- 43:02kind of the old ways of how one caretakes a body.
- 43:07But children who in the 1700s and 1800s,
- 43:14when they were given dolls, were, you know, instead of being given a crib,
- 43:19they were often given coffins, like little tiny coffins. And,
- 43:24the children would place their dolls in the coffin, and that was like what they
- 43:29played with, because children died often.
- 43:35And it was kind of a way of having the truth in the room with the child. Wow.
- 43:48So I say this because,
- 43:53in sanitizing loss, grief, death, we then sanitize, we want to sanitize the emotions.
- 44:03And you can do it so far until it starts to affect your gut, your teeth.
- 44:11People who've had, you know, really some horrific things happen to them,
- 44:17we know that health-wise they can, you know, get rheumatoid arthritis.
- 44:22They can have immunity issues. They can, you know, we know this.
- 44:26There's studies now that we didn't have even 20 years ago.
- 44:30So it's just, it's being able to say there's another way.
- 44:37I'm not going to go through these five stages and be done.
- 44:40When Elizabeth Kubler-Ross wrote those five stages, Kate, she wrote them for
- 44:45people who were dying not for the living, and I need to repeat this over and over and over again.
- 44:53It's not sacrosanct, it's not sterile, and you don't move from this to this to this done.
- 45:01There is no done. We want to believe, we wish for done, but done then wipes
- 45:09out the beautiful memories.
- 45:15The allowances for the stories, maybe a place setting,
- 45:21maybe a story time night maybe a visitation at the cemetery or wherever,
- 45:30or if it was ashes then taking that boat ride again every year and you know
- 45:37playing music and living fully in light of the loss,
- 45:45so that the occupation is not so much of an occupation,
- 45:50it's a little O rather than a big O right.
- 45:57Edie, does spirituality and religion and all that, does that play a role as
- 46:07far as people who grieve?
- 46:10And I'll just give you, for instance, different people that I've listened to over the years.
- 46:15I come from a Christian background, but I love Carolyn Mace and just different
- 46:21things on a spiritual level.
- 46:23And in a way if you know i guess you i presume you know if you believe that
- 46:29you go on you know you believe there's another side sure,
- 46:34you know that you reunite and and and whatnot if you have that i suppose technically
- 46:40that should make grief easier no.
- 46:44I laugh because i'm making light of it but that's how i that's sometimes how
- 46:50even i handle my own grief i'll say well kate,
- 46:53If you believe in the afterlife, if you believe that we are spiritual beings,
- 46:58not bound by a physical body, that we go on after this,
- 47:02then you do realize that time here, time over there is fast, instantaneous.
- 47:09Time in the earth world is long. And, you know, I do play with the concept of
- 47:15maybe we're here to learn specific lessons.
- 47:18You know, maybe we signed a spiritual contract before coming here.
- 47:22You know, I've kind of kept an open purview of all that Sure Shouldn't that
- 47:27make it easier? Shouldn't that make grief, life Shouldn't it make it all easier?
- 47:35Can. Not necessarily though, right?
- 47:39No. Because here you've just laid out, you know, a daring conversation around,
- 47:49you know, spirituality,
- 47:52which may scare some people, okay?
- 47:55But it doesn't matter what you believe in. If you believe in something and it
- 47:59works and it helps give you some peace. Great.
- 48:05And there's so much we don't know about what's next.
- 48:11That's the other piece. There are people who say, I see signs.
- 48:15There are signs. I'm one of those people.
- 48:19Do I believe in signs? Yes. And could they be reasoned out? Sure.
- 48:25But do they calm something in my nervous system? because we are dealing with
- 48:29a really active nervous system when we're dealing with grief, right?
- 48:34And if whatever your beliefs are help you.
- 48:42To calm that nervous system down, feel closer to the one you lost or the people you've lost,
- 48:50or help you just mitigate some of the anxiety or the anger or the fear that you're feeling,
- 49:01or help you feel that you are part of a community that's bigger than you.
- 49:06And we know that community is essential in the work of grief and in actually
- 49:14in all aspects of our mental and physical health. We know this.
- 49:20So I did not have community as part of one of my,
- 49:25spheres of you know what are the the the it was like four spheres or five spheres
- 49:32and I added community as part of that that the importance of socialization and community,
- 49:39when dealing with grief and whether you're an introvert or an extrovert or an ambivert,
- 49:46you will find your own communities to be witnesses to what you are going through.
- 49:52And we all need those witnesses.
- 49:55In terms of spirituality and believing in your belief system that there's more and that, you know,
- 50:06that in spiritual terms, you know, it's a blip.
- 50:12And then there's life, which can also feel like a blip. Yes. Right? And that.
- 50:22If it calms you, if it helps, if there are other people you can share this with
- 50:28who aren't judging you but actually hold you and caretake you,
- 50:35and are like.
- 50:39Our communicators heart center to heart center, then fine, great, super, great.
- 50:47So, there's no right or wrong here. There are people who drop out of their spiritual
- 50:54relationships with their churches, with their synagogues, with their mosques,
- 50:58with all of their beliefs.
- 51:00And then there are other people who step in and become even more religious, more faithful.
- 51:06And, you know, we talked earlier about the loss of identity,
- 51:11and some people go all in to the point where they're unrecognizable because they become all faith.
- 51:21And that along the way, they may lose certain people because those folks don't
- 51:27know how to deal with the identity of all faith.
- 51:32And there are people within the paradigm of you know before and after and i
- 51:36have this in the book the before the loss and after the loss who was in your
- 51:40circle if you're in the middle who was there
- 51:43and after the loss and after the loss three months six months a year three years,
- 51:50who who's there who's gotten closer who's gotten further away what is your status
- 51:56how have you changed so not only how people are close to you,
- 52:01but how are you close or not to people?
- 52:04Maybe because of something someone said.
- 52:07Maybe because someone doesn't like your spiritual perspective.
- 52:12Maybe because it was all couples, and now that couple group, you're single.
- 52:20They don't know how to be with you, And you, mm, don't know how to be with them. And that's tough.
- 52:30And so I have a whole section in the book within the 11 phases of role confusion. Who am I?
- 52:38I don't know who I am. And that is a common question. I'm a caretaker.
- 52:42Yes, but if I'm not a caretaker, who am I?
- 52:46Am I still a daughter? We talked about that a little bit before.
- 52:49Or, you know, am I the mother to my child, even though that child passed?
- 52:54Of course you. Of course you.
- 53:01And the loss of a child doesn't follow the natural way of the path of our aging
- 53:09and how things are supposed to be.
- 53:12And so, sadly, marriages will break up from the stress.
- 53:16Some marriages are able to really hang in there, and it's harder when there's blame.
- 53:25It's harder when the perspective is, yeah, but if only you would have done fill-in-the-blanks.
- 53:35And trying to work the blame game out is tenuous and difficult.
- 53:42Can it be done in a loving way? Sure.
- 53:45But how much of the blame is that sense of helplessness that you couldn't save your child?
- 53:53Reminds me of a story that's it's kind of made headline news lately with emily and brady kaiser they,
- 54:01brady was watching their was watching their young children and while he was
- 54:08watching them and the mother emily his wife emily was off with some friends,
- 54:13just going out to dinner their their their older son, Trig, who was,
- 54:18I think, three, fell into the pool and he drowned while Brady was in the house
- 54:25with the other child. She gets a call.
- 54:29But the reason I bring up the story is something you just said,
- 54:32and it's what she said, too.
- 54:35When she was on a podcast, she was asked, like, how do you get through this with Brady?
- 54:40How do you keep this marriage together and not blame him for Trigg's death and with tears in her eyes.
- 54:49And it makes me, I don't know why it makes me emotional, but she says,
- 54:54I don't blame him because it could have easily have been me in that same situation.
- 55:00That kind of grace, you know, people can say what they want about people in
- 55:05the spotlight, but that kind of grace, giving that to another human.
- 55:10I feel that's so next level. I thought that was so beautiful.
- 55:14Very similar to what you said to me. Thank you for that story.
- 55:16It's a beautiful story and remarkable.
- 55:21And everybody deals with grief differently, right?
- 55:24And everybody holds it differently. And for her to be able to say,
- 55:30it could have been me, it shows that, you know, she,
- 55:37the occupation may not be as,
- 55:41as stressful or as overwhelming because she's chosen to partner with her partner.
- 55:49She's chosen to partner with the grief and,
- 55:54it doesn't mean that it's the only way she feels. Right.
- 56:00It means that it's an aspect, one place that she can go to.
- 56:07And it doesn't mean that there aren't other places, other dots,
- 56:12other manifestations of her grief that are consistent and constant.
- 56:20And what he lives with would be an interesting part of the conversation as well.
- 56:29You know, and.
- 56:35We cannot necessarily understand why people react the way they react to the losses they have.
- 56:43And no one does it the same way. It can look the same, but their internal process is theirs.
- 56:50And is based on what I call, when I start to see people, whether it's an individual
- 56:56or it's a family, you think it's just you in the room? This is a very crowded room.
- 57:03So, Kate, as I speak with you, and yes, right now you're the interviewer,
- 57:09you're the podcaster, and I'm your guest.
- 57:13Each of us have very crowded rooms behind us, with us. We carry those rooms with us.
- 57:20And it's our parents and our friends and doctors and people who've been great
- 57:26to us and people who've been cruel to us.
- 57:29The rooms are crowded.
- 57:31And grief is a sacrifice. It's like there's a sacrifice of the soul. Yeah.
- 57:43So true. And so we live with that sacrifice.
- 57:47And how we live with that sacrifice, if we think about, we go back to the Buddha story, you know,
- 57:55the monks sacrificed their lives, probably to take the time to slather this,
- 58:00knowing they were not going to live. They knew it.
- 58:04And it was a sacrifice. But their sacrifice allowed something to live beyond them.
- 58:10And it was their legacy.
- 58:12And so how can the legacies of those we've lost and loved get carried with us
- 58:21and within us, and how do we partner with,
- 58:28that sacrifice, that legacy?
- 58:32And if I stay in my constant state of grief and don't let anyone else in,
- 58:41and I don't let myself out,
- 58:44then am I really honoring who I lost, or am I just dying with them,
- 58:54thinking that that's the best way to honor them?
- 58:57And it's a question to be asked.
- 59:02It's a time to be curious. It's a time to be, to explore, because that curiosity,
- 59:10and that curiosity is one of the hardest things to do with the self.
- 59:16Because when we're in pain, we don't want to meet the pain.
- 59:20Curiosity, when it meets the pain, is going to be asking questions.
- 59:27And we need to be asking those hard questions.
- 59:31You are, you are, you know, I could talk to you, you are, I could talk to you all day.
- 59:39You are just, just the easiest person to communicate with. It's,
- 59:44it's, you understand, you meet people, just our conversation,
- 59:49you can meet anyone at their level because you, you just, you so sincerely understand it.
- 59:54And it's so delicate. Everything, this is delicate, and it makes you vulnerable.
- 1:00:02But I love what you said about you have to learn how to part.
- 1:00:05You almost have to partner with it. You have to learn to dance with it.
- 1:00:07You have to learn to walk with it.
- 1:00:10And it's a choice. Yes. Please understand, these are choices.
- 1:00:16And when you begin this journey, you are saying to yourself,
- 1:00:22I'm making a choice here, and I'm not dishonoring the one I lost.
- 1:00:30I'm honoring the love I had with them.
- 1:00:36I mean, I love being able to honor Paul and wind his watch. And I play it.
- 1:00:43I often have it with me when I'm speaking at conferences, and I wind it and
- 1:00:49I say, this is Paul's watch.
- 1:00:52It's tick, tick, tick, tick, tick. And when I feel nervous, when I'm scared,
- 1:00:58when I'm about to talk about grief, which I started this journey really because of his loss,
- 1:01:06that watch and that tick,
- 1:01:10it fills the room.
- 1:01:12And his heart and what he taught me about love fills the room.
- 1:01:23To paul you know cheers to paul and cheers but and cheers to your father and cheers,
- 1:01:33this is what we want we want to see how we can take our lessons from the people
- 1:01:42we've loved and pass them along as their gift,
- 1:01:47yeah because that legacy keeps
- 1:01:50them alive in others yes so keep telling stories about this father and,
- 1:02:00you know whoever else you've loved and lost or you know even had difficult time
- 1:02:05I mean I can talk about my difficult time with my mother and yet,
- 1:02:11I hope that in the story there was hope great,
- 1:02:16absolutely Edie we.
- 1:02:20Touched on your book several times. Where can our listeners and viewers,
- 1:02:25where can they get your book?
- 1:02:27Sure. So Amazon is a really good place. I'm on Amazon internationally.
- 1:02:33So it's always surprising, you know, when certain like countries pop up and
- 1:02:38it's like, what? How did that happen?
- 1:02:40But it's not translated into any languages, but there's definitely,
- 1:02:44it's grief, Grief, The Dance of Self-Discovery Through Trauma and Loss.
- 1:02:50In, hopefully, the show notes, there'll be a free chapter that's for you to
- 1:02:54download, so you can absolutely have that.
- 1:02:57There's also, along with the book, is a journal. It's a three-month journal,
- 1:03:05and it's called It's Grief, Notes to Self.
- 1:03:08And there's three very specific prompts, so that's on Amazon as well.
- 1:03:13And you can also get in touch with me through my website ednathan.com and I
- 1:03:20am in the New York Tri-State area.
- 1:03:23I will be leading a four-day seminar at Kripalu in Lenox, Massachusetts in February.
- 1:03:32So all you have to do, it's live, it's up on their site and if you want to do
- 1:03:36like a four-day intensive, it's going to be much of what we've talked about
- 1:03:40here but even more because we get to see each other live and it's a limited group.
- 1:03:46It's only like 40 people. So please come and meet me and let's continue this conversation.
- 1:03:54Edie, thank you so much. I will be emailing you after the show just to follow up on our conversation.
- 1:04:01Thank you so much for your time. Thank you for giving me over an hour of your time.
- 1:04:06It means the world. Thank you so much. Thank you. This was my pleasure.
- 1:04:11And you made it so easy to talk about something that people don't want to talk about. So thank you.
- 1:04:19Thank you, Edie. My gosh, I got a new friend in you. Yes. We'll be in touch.