Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Dependent Personality Disorder and Overfunctioning (2021 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. Just me today. I thought I would answer some
- 0:03patron emails. This first email from anonymous patron, She writes, my daughter
- 0:08is seven years old now. My daughter is seven years old now and almost
- 0:13always wants me to make choices for her, with things like which move she
- 0:18should make in a game or which flavor of ice cream? Does she want
- 0:23simple choices like that? Is this normal or is it just a phase?
- 0:27I try to tell her it's her choice and be patient with an answer from
- 0:32her. Maybe way the pros and the cons vocally with her, but she
- 0:35insists that I decide for her. She's only with me in the summer,
- 0:40so I don't really know how she is with her dad. I guess I'm
- 0:43concerned since I've been diagnosed with a personality disorder and I worry about her going
- 0:48through the same thing as I did. End of email. Yeah, so
- 0:53it's hard to tell from your email and even as a parent, if a
- 0:59child is developing dependent personality sort or otherwise. But let's go over your email
- 1:04here. You're saying your daughter's almost seven and always wants you to make choices
- 1:10for her, and you're trying to help her make the choices but she refuses.
- 1:15She's like, no, you must make this choice for me. You're
- 1:19also telling me that she's only with you in the summer and she's with her
- 1:23dad the rest of the year, and you don't really know how she is
- 1:26with her dad, So that kind of tells me that you're not in frequent
- 1:30communication or at least open communication with him. And you also say that you've
- 1:36been diagnosed with a personality SO and you're concerned about that. So again hard
- 1:41for me to tell over email, but could be early dependent personality sort Sometimes
- 1:48people say that you can't diagnose teens or children with personality soorders, and although
- 1:53generally that's something we want to avoid, but that doesn't mean that we can't
- 1:57look at children and teens behavior and wonder if they are developing or have a
- 2:05child or teen version of the personality disorder. You know, we usually make
- 2:09those conceptualizations tentatively because children change over time. But when you see an adult
- 2:17with dependent personality sorder, you will always see proto personality sort of behaviors and
- 2:24schemas early in life. Because, of course, the personality disorder, in
- 2:29my opinion and a lot of experts opinions, develops in the first five years
- 2:34of your life anyway, usually, so you should see behaviors that will,
- 2:40you know, pre date the official adult diagnosis. And you know this would
- 2:46always get taught in this not always, I shouldn't say always. Sometimes this
- 2:50will get taught in this really silly way, Like you know, you can't
- 2:53diagnose children with personality disorders as if it's some I don't know, dogma or
- 2:59religion just rule or something. And although yeah, we can't really know,
- 3:06but it's not like magically at eighteen you suddenly develop personality sorders right anyway,
- 3:12so it couldn't be an early dependent personality sorter. And what we would see
- 3:15in a seven year old are the schemas we would see schemas that some you
- 3:22know, with the pendent personage sort. It's often a schema of incompetence,
- 3:27meaning I am desperately incompetent by default, and I need someone to tell me
- 3:31what to do or else something really horrible is going to happen. So I
- 3:37have tremendous anxiety when I try to make a decision on my own, and
- 3:42I am desperate for someone else to tell me what to do, just desperate.
- 3:46It's people often will say this is what codependency. That's the wrong label.
- 3:52It's not the right usage of that term. And what we're talking about
- 3:58is the pendent person I s or. And it's not something that people do
- 4:01by choice. It's something that becomes ingrained in their personality early in life and
- 4:05they have a hard time letting go of it, and that can manifest at
- 4:10the age of seven of not being able to make any choices. And this
- 4:15can be developed by divorce, by losses in one's life as a child,
- 4:23differences in parenting, maybe schemas of the parents being played out with the child
- 4:30that will manifest independency in the child. And the key is for you as
- 4:38a parent. I don't know what your situation is. You're saying you have
- 4:41a personality disorder. You're also saying that you're worried that it might affect your
- 4:46child. And regardless of this is one of the facts or not, I
- 4:49hope that you're getting the treatment that you need so that you can heal from
- 4:53your relational traumas that resulted in your personality disorder. It's such that you won't
- 4:58engage in projecting identification with your child too much, and you also will be
- 5:04able to not see your child through a distorted lens of your past traumas,
- 5:11if that makes sense. Having said that, it could be something else.
- 5:15When you see a kid seven years old saying, please make decisions for me,
- 5:20it could be a random phase. Children go through random phases. Not
- 5:24all children, but some children do. And some children go through some pretty
- 5:28weird phases. I mean, some children will go through like psychopathic phases.
- 5:30It's not frequent, but you'll hear and I treated kids like this that would
- 5:34go through a couple of years of having total lack of empathy for other human
- 5:41beings and would be almost sadistic, and then emerge a couple years later they're
- 5:46not like that, and they would look back on that with horror, like,
- 5:48I can't believe how mean I was to people back then. So,
- 5:51yeah, phases are a thing in children, whether it's just them exploring things,
- 5:57or their brain is still developing, or they just are confused, or
- 6:01you know, there's just a lot of reasons as to why we would conceptualize
- 6:05something as a face. There's also a possibility that she just wants attention from
- 6:10you, She misses you. In all likelihoods, she hasn't seen you in
- 6:13nine months, because she's just with you in the summer, and by her
- 6:17saying this, you know, but you know, make a decision for me.
- 6:20It could be her regressing, you know, adjusting to seeing you for
- 6:25the summer, regressing to an earlier time when she felt more secure with you.
- 6:30Maybe it's just a barometer sort of indication that she wants a connection with
- 6:35you, and if you increase that secure connection and attunement, maybe this behavior
- 6:42will diminished. But I don't know. I would consult with a child and
- 6:45or family therapist, all right. This next email is from listener are from
- 6:50Norway. They write, I was wondering if you could talk about the d
- 6:56d LG lifestyle, So just chiming in here. The d d LG lifestyle
- 7:00is daddy dom little girl lifestyle, which is a sexual or romantic relationship where
- 7:10there's a dominant male in the daddy figure, you know, the daddy dom
- 7:14he's a you know, the daddy dominant and you have a woman playing the
- 7:17role of a young girl. Some people in the daddy dom little girl lifestyle
- 7:24will only do it in private and when they are with friends there they're not
- 7:29in the lifestyle, whereas others it's all day long. They will do it
- 7:33at work, they'll do it with their friends. It's it's you know,
- 7:36how they identify essentially. So reading this email, I was wondering, if
- 7:43you talk about the d D LG lifestyle. I heard you say something in
- 7:46a plath Fill reaction video that it's not a healthy relationship when one of the
- 7:51people is too dependent and almost childlike. What if you genuinely, genuinely want
- 7:57to live this way, could that still cause problems in the future. I'm
- 8:00very curious and would love to hear more about this. End of email.
- 8:03Yeah, so the daddy dom little girl lifestyle is fine. There's nothing wrong
- 8:09with it if two people are consenting to that, even if it's all day
- 8:13long. It looks weird to the outside culturally it has some trigger points of
- 8:20sexism or misogyny or abuse or something. But there are people who live the
- 8:24daddy dom little girl lifestyle and are fine there, or more generally just dom
- 8:30submissive lifestyles, regardless of gender. There are many people who are very into
- 8:35it and some people who are, you know, just kind of into it
- 8:39if you will, and it's fine. There's nothing wrong with it. And
- 8:46it's not the same thing when I'm talking about people being overfunctioning, under functioning,
- 8:50or you know, dependent to someone who's dominant. That's the reason why
- 8:58it is a problem is by its definition, it is either harmful and or
- 9:03not meeting the needs of the individual. So when you are in your daddy
- 9:07dam little girl lifestyle. Listener are from Norway, you have to evaluate each
- 9:16individual's needs are they being met. For the little girl person who is acting
- 9:22like a child, it's possible that it could be a manifestation of their dependent
- 9:28personality. People with dependent personality they want to depend on other people on the
- 9:33outside, but on the inside they don't really want to depend on other people.
- 9:37They want to be independent. They want to feel competent, they want
- 9:43to feel like they are capable of doing things on their own. They're just
- 9:46so terrified and so convinced that there's something wrong with them that they don't attempt
- 9:50it. So to the dependent personality individual, they will be very childlike and
- 9:56very underfunctioning, but they're not happy on the inside. In fact, they
- 10:00can often be quite upset suicidal at times, and also they can be very
- 10:05angry. So if you are in a daddy dom little girl lifestyle, the
- 10:13little girl person could be a dependent personality disordered individual because it would fit with
- 10:20that, but it could also just be someone who doesn't have a personality disorder
- 10:26like dependency and is just really into what it feels like to be a little
- 10:33girl and to have a dominant daddy, dominant partner, and so you'd really
- 10:39just have to ask them are you getting your needs met? Do you feel
- 10:45like you're fulfilled? Do you feel like you're full? Because if you went
- 10:48to the little girl person and you said are you happy, they might say,
- 10:56well, I'm If they suffered for independent personality, they might say something
- 11:01like, well, I feel like this is right for me, and you
- 11:03might say, well, are you happy? Do you feel balanced? Do
- 11:07you feel like you're living the full the fullest of your life. A lot
- 11:13of people with dependent personality to sort of say no, I just I don't
- 11:18feel that way because I would like to be more independent, but I just
- 11:22don't think I'm capable of it. And the caveat to that is that when
- 11:30you ask dependent people prior to them becoming aware of their dependency, they're often
- 11:35in denial of their dependency. They're often quite embarrassed and ashamed, and so
- 11:41they will avoid they're very good at avoiding the conversation. Not always, but
- 11:46so you could go to someone with dependent personality disorder and say like, do
- 11:48you feel fulfilled? They might kind of detect that this is getting close because
- 11:54if you call them out, even if you are being kind about their dependent
- 11:58personnality traits, it's so threatening to them because what it by implication there's something
- 12:05wrong with them, and by implication there whoever is in dominance over their life
- 12:11shouldn't be doing that and thus will go away. So if you come to
- 12:15someone who you know, they're thirty five years old and they still live with
- 12:18their parents, and they think that they're worthless and they can't do anything on
- 12:22their own, and you come to them and you say do you feel fulfilled?
- 12:28They might detect, oh crap. If we get into a conversation that
- 12:33indicates that there's something wrong with me and my relationship with my parents, then
- 12:37it threatens that and I'll be alone and I can't handle that, you know.
- 12:39So they can either be in denial consciously or unconsciously for that reason.
- 12:46Anyway, So the point is is the daddy dom little girl or you know,
- 12:48dominant submissive relationships could be playing into pathologies from both sides and could not
- 12:56be it just it just you just don't know unless you would as the individuals.
- 13:01It's like saying, is marriage in general, or you know, being
- 13:05in a couple relationship, is it pathological or not? Well, you can't
- 13:09know that unless you actually, you know, assess the individual the other side
- 13:13of it. That the daddy dom or the dom part of that duo can
- 13:20also have problems right that the dom person could you could see a psychopathic or
- 13:26any social person being being attracted that Maybe you could see someone who was an
- 13:33overfunctioner, a narcissistic person being attracted to that role, But you could also
- 13:39see people who are just into it. We tend to pathologize sex things that
- 13:45don't that aren't common or commonly talked about, and you'd just have to look
- 13:50in movies to see examples of this. So I definitely don't want to play
- 13:56into that ignorant trope of pathology doms or submissive. So that's what I'll say
- 14:03about that. I'll write next email anonymous patron. He writes and says,
- 14:11is it possible to have a dependent personality disorder and develop a coping mechanism through
- 14:16narcissistic personality disorder. After listening to your podcast, I suspect my wife has
- 14:22this kind of combination of dependent and narcissistic. She has real difficulties doing anything
- 14:28by herself or making her own choice for even the most basic of things.
- 14:33But was a perfect student in school, first in class, even at the
- 14:35university. Now, after we've got a child for six months, her behavior
- 14:41has changed dramatically. She commands me and insults me. One time she spit
- 14:46in my coffee, left the room, came back after two minutes and demanded
- 14:48I calm her down because she can't sleep because of me making her angry.
- 14:54That was after our first therapy appointment. She has a twin sister who also
- 14:58mostly likely is on the narcissistic spectrum. Could this seemingly opposite disorder somehow develop
- 15:07between dependency and narcissistic and do they have any experience and do you have any
- 15:11experience on how to improve such a condition? End of email? Yeah?
- 15:16Well, first off, it's hard for me to tell from your email,
- 15:18of course, but I will say that generally speaking, yes, you can
- 15:24absolutely have both conditions, and they're not opposite. Dependent personality and narcissistic personality.
- 15:31There are opposing elements of it kind of, but they're not opposite.
- 15:37They might seem opposite to people who aren't experienced with it, but dependent personality
- 15:45and narcissistic personality borderline, for that matter, histrionic, these kinds of personality
- 15:52disorders to me are all kind of in a very similar category. But anyway,
- 15:56now there is some opposing aspects like often conceptualize dependent personality sorter, narcissistic
- 16:03history on or sorry, borderline dependent history onic as working models of bad self
- 16:11and good other. Right, I am bad, other people are good,
- 16:14and when you're dependent. Of course, it makes total sense that that would
- 16:17be the working models that I can't do things on my own, there's something
- 16:21wrong with me, and other people are the only source of strength. I
- 16:26need to seek other people, whereas with narcissistic it's the opposite, right,
- 16:30the good self and bad other. But remember that the good self developed by
- 16:37narcissistic personality disorder is only a facade. The person with narcissistic personality disorder,
- 16:44they have a like a straw man, if you will, that of working
- 16:49model of self that is good. They definitely think other people are bad,
- 16:53but they also think themselves are bad. But they cover that up with this
- 17:00grandiose fantasy of the self that is good, but they actually don't believe they're
- 17:03good. If narcissistic people truly believed that they were good people and that they
- 17:10were okay, they would stop trying to get narcissistic supply. That's the people
- 17:15without narcisistic personality disorder' that's what they're like. They believe that they're basically good,
- 17:22and people with narcisstic personal disorder do not, and that's why they compensate
- 17:27by constantly seeking narcissistic supply, often by stopping on other people and putting them
- 17:33down. So at essence, narcissistic personality sorder has a working model of self
- 17:41that is bad. I haven't always described it as that way. And side
- 17:47note, maybe some of you have noticed this that my conceptualization of various things
- 17:55changes over the years. I've been doing this podcast for thirteen plus years,
- 17:57and sometimes I worry, like, especially when I start playing reruns, that
- 18:02it's gonna be revealed that wait, Kirk is contradicting himself. And I'm sure
- 18:06that happens a lot, But part of it is I keep evolving in terms
- 18:11of my understanding and a lot of it has to do with more examples that
- 18:19I come across in my work and also just in life that further refine these
- 18:26concepts. But anyway, so both dependent and narcissistic at its core core have
- 18:37a self that is bad, so they don't really oppose each other in that
- 18:41way. And by the way, you mentioned so this is your wife,
- 18:47of course, and it's hard to diagnose one's wife, especially when you're in
- 18:52a conflict with them, and to necessarily be able to bank on your perceptions
- 18:59being unbiased. But you're saying that she you know, she's really difficult doing
- 19:07anything by herself, but she was a perfect student in school. So people
- 19:11with dependent I don't know how you got this idea, but the people with
- 19:14dependent personality sorter absolutely can be good in school, and in fact, sometimes
- 19:18they're very good in school because they're being told what to do. Dependent personality
- 19:25sorted individuals not always, but they will sometimes seek and really thrive in venues
- 19:32of authority for obvious reasons. Right, and school is a very strong if
- 19:38you get into it as a student, you can really thrive within the authority.
- 19:44You know, if you just hand over your entire personality to the authority
- 19:47figures and say what do I do? Tell me what to do? And
- 19:51you know, you happen to be a little bit studious, then you can
- 19:52become like one of the best students in the entire world because your entire personality
- 19:59is oriented wards your teachers and your superiors. So there's that. So,
- 20:07but maybe you were confusing, you know, this schema of I'm incompetent,
- 20:11because that's what dependent personality sorted individuals feel. They feel incompetent, that they
- 20:18that they actually are incompetent, and that's actually not true. People a dependent
- 20:22personal disorder can be extremely competent, but they believe they're incompetent, and they're
- 20:27constantly trying to prove to others that they can, you know, do good
- 20:34by others. You know. It's it's this stuck position of every child goes
- 20:41through this a lot. When child's I don't know, maybe four to seven,
- 20:48they're really concerned. Not always, but they're often really concerned about look
- 20:52at me, I can do this, I can run fast, I can
- 20:55jump off this thing, I can do math problems, I can I can
- 20:59play with I can throw the ball through this thing there, And they really
- 21:03want to feel competent, and they really want you to see them as competent,
- 21:07and you could see adults as kind of like stuck in that place.
- 21:11Right When you see a six year old who's like looking at you, just
- 21:17being like, validate my competence, essentially is what they're doing, you just
- 21:22think, well, they're six, what are you going to do? But
- 21:23when they're thirty five and you have someone constantly saying, validate my competence,
- 21:29you're like, will you like just be competent on your own please for a
- 21:33while. You know that that's what it feels like to be on the receiving
- 21:36end of that. But of course it's not their fault. But now,
- 21:41you, anonymous patron, are saying that she has narcissistic personality disorder. But
- 21:45I'm wondering, based on your description, if you're listening to the Internet's version
- 21:49of narcissism, in that the Internet, I think believes that narcissism equals unreasonable
- 21:56anger and abuse. You know, you're saying, she's she's definitely dependent because
- 22:03she has difficulty doing anything by herself or making even the basic even basic choices
- 22:08on our own. So that's you know, it's pretty hallmark. Uh,
- 22:12You know, I personality trait of dependency. But then you go on to
- 22:18explain how she gets really angry at you and she'll spit in your coffee and
- 22:22you know, and she gets really, you know, very demanding, and
- 22:25you're like, oh, she's narcissistic. I don't know, but from your
- 22:29description, it sounds like you're equating angry partner with narcissism. That that's not
- 22:36that's not a fair conceptualization. Narcissm as much, you know, more specific
- 22:41than that, And anger can come from a lot of places, including dependent
- 22:47personality sort. People with dependent personality sort can be extremely angry. In fact,
- 22:53the most angry people I've probably ever met are people with dependent personality sort.
- 23:00This is something that people just don't understand, and it's so and I
- 23:03don't understand why dependent personality disorder isn't discussed very often. Clinicians out there just
- 23:11do. And maybe I'm wrong, but take a mental inventory of how often
- 23:17you've heard people talk about in your field about dependent personality disorder. I almost
- 23:22never hear. In fact, I'm wondering if I've ever heard another clinician or
- 23:27professor ever talk about dependent personality sort, even though it's really common and once
- 23:33you understand it, you start seeing it in your clients, you know.
- 23:37Anyway, So people with dependent personality sort can be so angry, and not
- 23:44always because there's different shades of dependency. But one of the you know,
- 23:48main shades of dependency is that they were angry, as all children are,
- 23:53particularly when they're being mistreated, but they were made to feel like they could
- 23:59not ex expressed that anger, and so they have at the age of thirty
- 24:03five, they have a lifetime of anger that they have not really expressed.
- 24:07And when they explode or when they get vindictive or when they hate you,
- 24:12they hate you because all of that displaced anger is projected at you, you
- 24:19know. So that's not always the case, but and there's different flavors of
- 24:26that anger. Sometimes it can be extremely overt, like spitting in your coffee,
- 24:30or it could be very covert, like cheating on you or breaking into
- 24:36your computer or slashing your tires and claiming it was a mugger or something.
- 24:41There's very passive, aggressive ways in which dependent people can express their anger,
- 24:48and it's not their fault because they were mistreated growing up. But anyway,
- 24:53so if you're conceptualizing as dependency and you're like, well, she's so angry.
- 25:00You know she also has narcissism. There's a chance, and of course
- 25:03you're in therapy, so keep going to therapy. But there's a chance that
- 25:07the conceptualization is entirely within dependent personality. Okay, so you're asking how to
- 25:12improve, Well, she needs to see that she has these schemas essentially,
- 25:17you know, which drive her distortions, which drive her unreasonable behavior, which
- 25:22trigger you and cause you to trigger her and so on. So obviously you're
- 25:26a part of this equation and you're not talking about how you're contributing to it.
- 25:30Maybe you aren't, but you know you're in therapy, So keep going,
- 25:33keep exploring, keep trying to figure out both of your schemas and how
- 25:37they trigger each other. All right, let's take a break. Do we
- 25:40get back more emails? All right, we're back from the break. This
- 25:48next email is from anonymous patron. I'm going to summarize the beginning of this
- 25:52email. She described being in a family with a lot of fighting, particularly
- 25:57between your parents, like a lot of arguing and fighting between her parents,
- 26:03and then when her parents got divorced, she lived with her mom, and
- 26:06her mom made her do things on her own, and her mom was also
- 26:11very pathologically independent and would force her and her siblings to act like adults even
- 26:18though they weren't yet, and there seemingly was some emotional neglect throughout her childhood.
- 26:23But anyway, so getting to her email here. I have a very
- 26:27avoidant personality when it comes to conflict and all relationships. I have a very
- 26:33hard time trying to figure out what I'm feeling. I have had occasional casual
- 26:37sex partners that I don't feel attached to. I once cheated. So just
- 26:41chime in here. Basically, what the emailer is setting up is I feel
- 26:45avoidant, but I also feel dependent, and I think those are opposite.
- 26:49So how do those fit together? Okay, so I'm getting to the email
- 26:55back here. I have a very avoidant personality. I have a very hard
- 27:00time trying to figure out what I'm feeling. I have had occasional casual sex
- 27:03partners. I once cheated on my partner, and I didn't think it would
- 27:07have hurt their feelings. A few years ago, I accidentally hurt someone I've
- 27:11known for a very long time by saying I don't think that we are that
- 27:14close because I legitimately believed it to be true. However, your view of
- 27:19the avoidant schema is I am good and the world is bad. That doesn't
- 27:23really fit with me. I feel very much like I am completely incompetent and
- 27:27inadequate in everything I do. I desperately want to tell I desperately want people
- 27:33to tell me how to live my life, but I have no way of
- 27:34reaching out to anyone. After graduation, I spent a year working a part
- 27:40time, dead end job until someone suggested I get a master's degree, so
- 27:44I did that. Before that, I was trying to get into the Air
- 27:47Force because that seemed like the best way to just follow orders. I don't
- 27:51think I'm disorganized, and I only ever avoid I never try to latch onto
- 27:55anyone. These traits seem like two opposite people inside of me, but they
- 28:00are both always there. Have you seen something like this before? End of
- 28:03email? Yeah, So I'm glad you're bringing this up, because when we
- 28:08apply personality disorders and attachment styles to human beings, I would say half the
- 28:15time they do not fit very neatly. That's why it's important to not categorize
- 28:22people so much as understand the schemas behind the categories, because once you understand
- 28:27the schemas, then you understand how to apply them and it'll become less confusing.
- 28:33So let's go over the elements here. But you know, it's a
- 28:37good good case example of like, well, I don't understand, you know,
- 28:41I clearly have dependent personality disorder traits because I feel completely incompetent and inadequate
- 28:49about everything, all right, So that's a hallmark of dependency. You also
- 28:56give some clear examples, almost like textbook examples of dependent personality disordered individuals.
- 29:03You say someone suggested I get a master's, so I did that. And
- 29:07you also say that you were wanting to go into the military because you just
- 29:12wanted a place that would give you orders. Would you know, you just
- 29:15wanted someone to tell you what to do. It wasn't like you wanted necessarily
- 29:18to be in the military. You just wanted to be in a venue where
- 29:21people would tell you what to do. So these are quintessential dependent personality disorder
- 29:27traits. If I heard this, I would highly suspect that if I worked
- 29:32with you for you know, a number of months, I would have a
- 29:34pretty it would be high likely that we would continue with the conceptualization of dependent
- 29:41personality, So feeling incompetent, feeling inadequate, and you say about everything,
- 29:47you say, I feel very much like I am completely incompetent and inadequate in
- 29:52everything that I do. Again, that's just hallmark dependency and then seeking air
- 29:59force, getting a master's just because someone else told you to do that.
- 30:03So, but then you present this other thing that seems to be in opposition
- 30:08to that. You say, you have all these avoidant attachment traits like hard,
- 30:15it's hard for you identify your feelings. You've had casual sex, you
- 30:19feel distant from others, you seemingly have impaired empathy. You never try to
- 30:25attach to anyone, you know, because you know the dependent personality disort er
- 30:30core is that you latch onto someone and say, you know, tell me
- 30:34what to do, and you're you can be very clingy, and often it's
- 30:38a person of authorities. Sometimes it's a it's a romantic partner, sometimes an
- 30:44abusive, controlling romantic partner. Right, So you're saying, look, I
- 30:48never attached to anyone, so and I avoid relationships and I seem like cut
- 30:55off from my emotions, And that sounds very much like avoidant attack. So
- 31:00I get this a lot of times with borderline as well. People will say,
- 31:04I feel like I have borderline, but I also feel like I have
- 31:07avoidant attachment. And often what I will find is that the avoidance is a
- 31:14component of the dependency or component of the borderline. So let's talk about your
- 31:18case. Of course, you would want to be assessed by a professional in
- 31:22person, and I could never and would never diagnose from AFAR, but this
- 31:27would be a road to go down with a clinician in person. So people
- 31:33with dependent personal disorder definitely can develop avoidance. If you remember, from a
- 31:38deep dive that's available to patrons only, I gave six different types. It's
- 31:45based on the Milan types and I've modified them. There was the separation anxiety
- 31:51dependent, the enmeshed dependent, the childlike dependent, the compliant and eager dependent,
- 31:56the life avoidant dependent, and the passive aggressive dependent. And in the
- 32:00case examples that I gave in the deep dive, I would usually give more
- 32:05than one type to individuals. You know, it's usual that people will exhibit
- 32:10you know, one or two or three different types. But it helps to
- 32:15identify these types because they can really look different from each other. You might
- 32:20even consider them to be different disorders. I don't, but anyway, So
- 32:24the number five is the life avoidant dependent. So this is someone who believes
- 32:30they're incompetent but avoids situations that will cause them to stress. And although it's
- 32:37not common your presentation, it is within that type that you and it makes
- 32:45at sense given your trajectory. Your early life clearly made you dependent because you
- 32:52have these ideas of incompetence and inadequacy, probably developed early early in life,
- 32:58maybe later in life to tell, but you had this dependent streak in your
- 33:05life as a child. But then your parents get divorced, and your mom
- 33:08who's pathologically independent and forces you to be independent even though you're young and you're
- 33:15looking for guidance. So on the inside you're dependent. You're like, mom,
- 33:19please, please please tell me what to do, Please tell me what
- 33:22to do, but she's refusing to tell you what to do and forcing you
- 33:28to do things on your own. So as a dependent personality disordered individual,
- 33:32it's possible. I don't know you would explore us with a clinician, but
- 33:36it's possible for someone in that position to develop a defense against their dependency,
- 33:44that is, to avoid relationships because it's possible for someone to be like,
- 33:47please tell me what to do, please want and nothing is coming your way,
- 33:52and so you just say, screw it. I'm going to avoid relationships
- 33:57as a way of coping with this constant desire for someone to tell me what
- 34:01to do, someone to be there for me, someone to hold me and
- 34:05make me feel safe. But it's not happening, and I'm so frustrated with
- 34:08this that I give up on it. But that doesn't take away the dependency.
- 34:12It doesn't take away the desire for someone to be there. You've just
- 34:15potentially given up on that desire, which adds another layer to the disorder that
- 34:24has to be sifted through. So you have to sift through both the incompetent
- 34:30schemas, inadequacy schemas, and the schemas of avoiding other people because they're going
- 34:39to hurt you. And it's possible that's also why you're avoiding your feelings.
- 34:44Right, So, I don't know, but given what you said, if
- 34:50I were to work with you, I would pursue a primary diagnosis of dependency
- 34:54with an avoidant layer. That's a defense to the pendency that was developed because
- 35:00your mom was forcing you to avoid your own dependency, all right. This
- 35:06next email is from anonymous patron. They write, I was wondering if you
- 35:09could speak about the experience of a parentified and overfunctioning child and how they operate
- 35:15in romantic relationships. I often had to be the emotional mature one in my
- 35:21family when every one was flying off the handle, and it was my job
- 35:23to stay calm and fix everything. I have a deep resentment over this,
- 35:29and sometimes it spills into my romantic relationship. When my partner is trying to
- 35:32express larger emotions, it sometimes triggers me, and I feel upset at her
- 35:37for not having more space for me, for not listening to me more,
- 35:42or for doing what I perceived to be walking over my needs. At the
- 35:46beginning of our relationship, I was okay with listening to her emotions, but
- 35:51now I feel my patience wearing down because I'm so resentful the fact that I'm
- 35:54not being taken care of when she expresses herself. Sometimes I feel like this
- 36:00is justified, and sometimes I feel like I'm just being entitled. I don't
- 36:04like having this resentment. Is there any way to heal from it? I'm
- 36:07currently going to therapy. End of email. Yeah, I'm glad that you're
- 36:10going to therapy. Continue doing that. Just some comments on what you're saying
- 36:16here, is parentification equals resentment. By the way, resentment is a hallmark
- 36:22of being an overfunctioning parentified child for obvious reasons. You're thirteen, and like
- 36:30a common scenario is there's a divorce or some kind of single parent or some
- 36:35kind of strife that the family is going through, and the oldest child or
- 36:38one of the children is required to take care of the younger children and or
- 36:44of the parents. Right, but particularly if you're taking care of the younger
- 36:47children, you know that the younger kids are getting off scott free while you
- 36:53have to do all the work. And children are programmed some extent to pay
- 37:01very close attention to fairness of treatment between them and their siblings. And so
- 37:07when you're being forced to be responsible, and you know there's pros and cons
- 37:13right to the overfunctionary, you get to feel powerful, you get to feel
- 37:15special, you get to feel mature, you get to feel older than you
- 37:20are. But of course you have to give up your childhood. You have
- 37:22to. You have all these responsibilities, You have this added anxiety. You
- 37:25get blamed for things that aren't really your fault, but anyway, so the
- 37:31resentment is a hallmark of prentification for obvious reasons, and you talk about that.
- 37:37So the fact that you're resentful of your partner makes total sense. You've
- 37:42displaced it onto your partner. You're truly resentful and angry at your parents for
- 37:47forcing you to become primified and overfunctioning. I'm guessing that as a child you
- 37:53felt as though people were quote unquote walking over your needs, as you put
- 37:58it, and you just place that onto your partner, of course, and
- 38:00it's a total trigger. Right. I didn't read your whole email, but
- 38:05you were talking about how your partner can become over emotional, and when your
- 38:08partner becomes emotional that totally resembles what your parents and your whole family was like.
- 38:15You know, just to get back to your description here is I often
- 38:20had to be the emotional mature one in my family when everyone was flying off
- 38:23the handle, and it was my job to stay calm and fix everything.
- 38:27So in that moment, you're being traumatized, and then currently in your relationship,
- 38:32as your partner is being emotional and you have to be the emotional mature
- 38:37one, it throws you back into that time where you were being abused essentially,
- 38:43and you were being ignored, And so it feels in any context now
- 38:50when your partner is needing you and depending on you and having an emotional episode,
- 38:55it feels as though you're being ignored because that's what was happening to you
- 38:59when you were younger. So it makes total sense that all of that would
- 39:05be triggered by a partner when they're having emotions, and you're emotionally mature enough
- 39:10to recognize this, you're like, actually, I think there's something wrong with
- 39:14my perception here. I feel like I'm overly reactive. Now you're in therapy.
- 39:22It can take a long time to recover from this. By the way,
- 39:24you know, parentification overfunctioning, this can take a long time to sift
- 39:29through because essentially and the overfunctioners and the printified children who become adults, they
- 39:36often will downplay their own needs because of course that's what their families did.
- 39:39And underneath that overfunctioning veneer can be just a lifetime of dependency that needs to
- 39:49be cared for. And so you know, buckle up for years of therapy
- 39:55where you become childish in a way and regressive you know, you regress to
- 40:04a child emotional place while your therapist takes care of you, while you are
- 40:10resentful of the fact that they are in power over you, potentially while you
- 40:17are displacing neglect onto your therapist. You know this can be rough, so
- 40:24you know, depending on the situation, but I'm glad you're in therapy.
- 40:30The other thing I'll say is, it's possible that your partner has a complementary
- 40:32schema, maybe even dependency. It's possible that when your partner is overly emotional
- 40:37and depending on you, that she might be doing she might be overly depending
- 40:44on you, because maybe that's how the two of you fit well together in
- 40:49terms of your schemas and your issues. Is you were the overfunctioner, she's
- 40:52the underfunctioner, and so she might be taking it far in her direction and
- 41:00not taking care of you very often. You know, it wouldn't be uncommon
- 41:04for a parentified adult to pick someone that doesn't really notice other people's feelings very
- 41:10much. You know, overfunctioners are very good at choosing people who don't tend
- 41:17to see other people's needs, because overfunctioners tend not to express their needs and
- 41:24they're terrified of their needs, and so they often will choose partners that just
- 41:30by default, don't see their needs anyway. Let's get to another email,
- 41:34all right. This next email is from listener Genevieve from Buffalo. She writes,
- 41:39how do you deal with an underfunctioner as a roommate? I know I
- 41:45tend to be a little bit of an overfunctioner, especially when I'm anxious,
- 41:49But my roommate is super lazy. He leaves the kitchen a mess. I
- 41:53recently had to deal with flies laying eggs and hatching at our indoor garbage can,
- 42:00but when I mentioned it, he didn't even acknowledge it and said that
- 42:02it wasn't a problem. I worry that he'll just see my anger as me
- 42:07being overly sensitive. I try to let him make his own mistakes, but
- 42:10then his mistakes only negatively impact me. I want to live in a place
- 42:15where I feel comfortable, but I don't want to clean up his messes.
- 42:19I don't know how to approach the situation in a way that won't just be
- 42:22futile or make me angrier. Is there even a way? Lol? End
- 42:27of email? Yeah. First off, I've been there before. I,
- 42:30in my twenties lived with various roommates and just because of finances and had just
- 42:39so many problems. And I'm sure I was a problem to many people.
- 42:45And it's just I don't know if you're young, Genevieve, but if you
- 42:50are, it's one of those things. Anyway, I feel your pain.
- 43:00I always think of this one moment when I lived with a bunch of my
- 43:05friends and you know, these are close friends, still are, and we
- 43:08had this deal where we would rotate who did the dishes. And this was
- 43:15a bad system for a number of reasons. But one of the reasons was
- 43:20that it was bad was that you didn't have there was no incentive to do
- 43:24the dishes other than the fact that so the begin okay, let's just go
- 43:30aheato this. Okay, So we figured we did this system. We said,
- 43:34okay, we'll rotate who does dishes, and the incentive is if you
- 43:37do it right away, then you only have to do a few dishes,
- 43:40so you don't have to wait until all the dishes are dirty. You could
- 43:45literally do the dishes twenty four hours after they were done before and probably have
- 43:49like five things to clean and then you're done. And then it rotates through
- 43:52six other guys, and it's a long time before it's your turn again.
- 43:55And I think we figured that if we had it this way, that they
- 44:00would just get done right away and every day a different dude would be cleaning
- 44:05the dishes. Well, of course it's not what happened. And what happened
- 44:08was no one ever did the dishes. And because when it was your turn
- 44:15and you put and you procrastinated, and you're being lazy and you're putting it
- 44:17off, eventually every single plate and pot and silverware item was used and dirty
- 44:24and piled in the sink and next to the sink, and you're looking at
- 44:29it, going, I don't want to that's every single utensil and plate and
- 44:32dinner where we have in this entire house. I don't want to do it
- 44:37today. And if I put it off another day, it doesn't matter because
- 44:39there's no more dishes. And so if I do it today or I do
- 44:44it next week, it's the same amount of work. I'd rather do that
- 44:46next week. And if I think we just would end up eating off of
- 44:54like tinfoil and stuff anyway, flies would and mold, you know, all
- 45:01the gross things. And don't even get me started on our bathrooms, and
- 45:05I was, you know, a full participant in that laziness. So anyway,
- 45:07I as a roommate, Genevieve, I probably would have driven you nuts.
- 45:14But anyway, to this day, me and my friends will still you
- 45:17know, we'll see dishes and we'll just make this joke like dishes because when
- 45:24someone would come home from work and it was his turn to do the dishes,
- 45:28all of us would go dishes. Anyway, But you say that you're
- 45:36a bit of an overfunctioner, especially when you're anxious and you're saying your roommate
- 45:42is lazy and you've tried to talk with him about doing things, and you're
- 45:45recognizing that there's filth developing in their house, and you're getting angry and you're
- 45:52trying to talk with him and he's just blowing you off, and he's just
- 45:55like, yeah, whatever doesn't matter. I'd read your whole email, But
- 45:58you gave a lot of the example of how he was just blowing you off
- 46:01and saying like, well, this is what it's like to live with.
- 46:04People live with it. So you're labeling him as an underfunctioner. But I
- 46:08don't know if he's an underfunctioner. He doesn't want to do the chores as
- 46:15often as you do. That was another thing that I learned that we learned
- 46:20together, was that the ideal situation is that you lived with people with what
- 46:25we call the same filth quotient, meaning that there's a threshold upon which you
- 46:32can't take it anymore. You know, like some people have a filth quotient
- 46:37that is very low. Like for me today, I have a very low
- 46:39filth quotient. I'm cleaning all the time. I'm cleaning the bathrooms and the
- 46:44kitchen and my office. You know, I'm cleaning the garage. I'm cleaning
- 46:50all the time, every day pretty much. It's just you know, I
- 46:52see something, I clean it. I was not like that when I was
- 46:54younger. So if I lived with myself, you know me at the age
- 46:59of fifty, if I lived with my twenty five year old self, I
- 47:01would hate living with him. Was I an underfunctioner when I was twenty five,
- 47:06No, I wasn't. If anything, I was an overfunctioner, but
- 47:09I was not an underfunctioner. I just didn't care, and I was immature,
- 47:15and I had never really lived in a house with peers that was very
- 47:21clean, and I was just like, look, I don't mind it being
- 47:25dirty like this, I don't want it to be totally dirty, but I
- 47:30don't want it to be as clean as you want it to be. And
- 47:32so that doesn't mean you win. And so, and that was what we
- 47:37determined was if you lived with incompatible filth quotients, the person with the lowest
- 47:43threshold lost because they always would react sooner than the people with the higher threshold.
- 47:50And so, because it's not like if you have a high threshold,
- 47:54you care if it's clean, but you have if you have a low threshold,
- 47:58you care if it's dirty. Anyway, so your roommate is incompatible with
- 48:04you is maybe the most non judgmental way of putting it. You're just not
- 48:08good roommates. If he lived with other people with a similar filth quotient as
- 48:13him, they'd probably get along fine. And if if you live with people
- 48:16with similar filth quotients as you, then you'd probably get along with them and
- 48:21you wouldn't you know, it wouldn't affect you, but you do. You
- 48:25do get into your dynamic between the two of you, and that could be
- 48:30an overfunction or underfunctional thing. Maybe you're labeling it that way, and it's
- 48:35funny that you're trying to deal with it. You know, I don't know
- 48:37if you're you know, listening to the podcast and trying to adjust your behavior.
- 48:42You know you're like, okay, because you know, the classic thing
- 48:45you're supposed to do as an overfunctioner is stop overfunctioning, and that'll help the
- 48:50underfunctioner to normal function. If you stop micromanaging, if you stop getting angry
- 48:57at them, then they'll feel more free to just do things, you know,
- 49:00because overfunctioning underfunctioning fit together. And I see, you know, I
- 49:07try to make him make his own mistakes so he can learn for them.
- 49:10Well, that assumes that he sees them as mistakes, you know, if
- 49:15he has a high filth quotient, he doesn't see him as mistakes. He
- 49:17just sees them as enacting his filth quotient. So I don't know if you're
- 49:24in an overfunctioning underfunctioning dynamic. And I'm trying to figure out what that would
- 49:30look like in a roommate situation like this, Like if somehow emotionally you were
- 49:39enmeshed enough such that he felt like you were judging him, and he was
- 49:50walking around feeling judged by you and really wanted you to stop judging him.
- 49:55It doesn't sound like that's the element. It sounds like you're upset and he
- 50:00just doesn't care. And so I would say the more relevant road to go
- 50:07down perhaps is okay, we have to like each other, because it sounds
- 50:15like the two of you aren't really getting along, maybe you don't even have
- 50:17a relationship. And some people will do this right. They will live with
- 50:22roommates that they just meet online or they met through friends, and if you
- 50:25don't have a close and I've actually rarely this has happened. Most of the
- 50:30people I lived with in my twenties were really close, if not best friends
- 50:32of mine. But occasionally. There was one time when I moved in with
- 50:37some friends of a friend and we were cordial but not close, and it
- 50:43was hard to There was a woman that was extremely The only person who had
- 50:51a higher filth cootient than I did was this woman I lived with in the
- 50:54nineties. She was disgusting. I mean she if you met her, you
- 51:00think she was clean. She seemed actually very clean, a very fashionable woman,
- 51:04you know, dressed in really fashionable clothes, very clean, but around
- 51:10the house she was just disgusting. And it shattered my stereotype of women to
- 51:16this day on that level anyway. So I don't know what a situation you're
- 51:22in, but the the key, Genevieve is to have a relationship, because
- 51:27if you have a relationship with him that is built on mutual respect and liking
- 51:32each other, then you can tell him how you feel. You just feel
- 51:37like so, I, you know, I, I guess you don't really
- 51:42care about and you know you have to because if you're an if you're an
- 51:45overfunctional in Genevieve, you're going to tend to use judgmental language, so you
- 51:49want to avoid that. But so you go to him to say so it
- 51:52seems like you don't really care. It's a way to put is. It
- 51:54seems like I care more about a certain level of cleaning cleanning than you do.
- 52:00You know, you just want to word it as non judgmentals. But
- 52:02you have a different idea of what clean means that I do, and that's
- 52:07fine. Everyone has a different idea of that. But it is really driving
- 52:13me nuts. I can't live in a house that is this dirty and you're
- 52:16okay with it, which is fine, and maybe we should have worked that
- 52:21out before we moved in together. But we're living together now and you could
- 52:24really really make my day if you could increase your cleaning a little bit.
- 52:32And I know that's a lot to ask, but can we work together on
- 52:37this because it's I don't know if I can live with you anymore. And
- 52:40that's not your fault. This is my issue. It's not your you know,
- 52:45if you have that kind of talk, it's very non overfunctioning talk,
- 52:47right, you know, maybe there's something you can work out. I don't
- 52:52know. Let me know how it goes though, all right. This next
- 52:59email is from anonymous patron. She writes, could my friends divorce and general
- 53:04struggles over the past several years be a result of her in messed relationship with
- 53:09her mom? So, just summarizing the beginning of the email, she has
- 53:15a friend I'm a patron as a friend and grew up with her and her
- 53:20parents were overprotective and enmeshed, particularly with so she was very in mess with
- 53:24her mom that they talk often, and when her friend pushed back against her
- 53:31mom, the mom would get really angry and so on. So a lot
- 53:36of evidence of ameshment over protection of her friend. About eight years ago,
- 53:42my friend met a guy and got married, but she wasn't happy. She
- 53:45felt like he was totally dependent on her to do all the work in the
- 53:49relationship, like financial planning, looking at houses, thinking about kids, et
- 53:52cetera. She often complained about him to her mom and shared essentially all of
- 53:57their relationship problems with her. She ended up cheating on him a few times
- 54:01with a work colleague. She finally decided to get a divorce, but now
- 54:05her enmeshment with her mom seems worse than ever. I have told her for
- 54:08years that she should find a therapist to help her with her relationship with her
- 54:12mom, but I'm beginning to think she will never realize how bad her enmeshment
- 54:15is. Can you speak a little on how mother daughter in meshed relationships might
- 54:21affect other relationships, both romantic and platonic in adult daughter's life. I have
- 54:27read some sources that list effects of being enmeshed, such as attracting dependent romantic
- 54:34partners, expressing covert aggression towards female friends, competition masked as friendship, poor
- 54:40sense of identity, lowered expectations of romantic needs being met, anger distressed resentment
- 54:46towards men. These are all, by the way, spot on with my
- 54:50friend. Are they common traits of enmeshed people? If so, what might
- 54:54be a good way to end this cycle of repeated complaints about her mom that
- 54:59have dominated our f ship for years? Or should I just accept that unless
- 55:01she ever gets help, this is how she will always be. End of
- 55:06email? Right, So, do you have a friend who you have observed
- 55:09has an unmessed relationship with her mom? Her mom has been over protective in
- 55:15her life. And then your friend gets married but seemingly matched up with someone
- 55:22with a complimentary, you know, trait of being dependent and maybe feels incompetent
- 55:30or depressed or something, and then she cheated on him. She was unsatisfied
- 55:37with his laziness essentially, and she cheated on him, and then they divorced,
- 55:42and now your friend is very enmessed with her mom. And I didn't
- 55:46read your whole email but on the air, but you were talking about how
- 55:51your friend confides in her mom a lot, and you think that might have
- 55:55contributed to the breakup anyway. But yeah, let's go through these qualities criteria
- 56:04that you have identified or found online. I'm guessing. So the first one
- 56:08you say is, you know, are enmeshed people attracted to dependent partners.
- 56:15No, not always for sure, I mean and meshed. There's a lot
- 56:19of people who are products of enmeshment and to say that they all are attracted
- 56:23to dependent people is not true. Can they be, absolutely, But there's
- 56:28a lot of different reasons for that. It matches the idea of relationship being
- 56:32very close, you know, when when one of the attractive qualities of a
- 56:38dependent person is that they really need you. And when someone needs you,
- 56:44it feels like love, and it is to some extent, you know,
- 56:47like with my wife, I need her to some extent, she needs me
- 56:50to some extent, but we don't. There's a limit to that, right
- 56:54And in terms of we can depend on ourselves when we need to, but
- 57:00we can also depend on others when we need to do that as well.
- 57:04But one of the intoxicating things, it's kind of a version of love bombing
- 57:10sometimes is you'll start dating a dependent person and they will just latch onto you
- 57:15and you'll just be like, whoa like, this person needs me, you
- 57:20know, but you won't you won't necessarily say this person needs me. What
- 57:22you'll say is this person loves me. You'll say, this person's really into
- 57:24me, this person wants to be with me, and it can feel powerful
- 57:30as well as particularly if you have a need for that, because the dependent
- 57:34person will do whatever you tell them to do, I mean, within reason,
- 57:37but it'll feel kind of that way like the dependent person on the surface.
- 57:42And there are different types, as I've been talking about, but dependent
- 57:45partners, particularly in the beginning, can feel very malleable. It could feel
- 57:49and thus very safe. You can feel like and again you wouldn't say they're
- 57:52malleable. What you would say is they're just very open and easy going.
- 57:57You know, they'll do whatever. You know, they're up for anything kind
- 58:00of a thing. And so when you are a product of an enmessed trauma,
- 58:07you have attachment insecurity, and so when you meet someone that's dependent,
- 58:10it might be very seductive in that way because it feels more secure. But
- 58:16a dependent person can be seductive in that way to anybody, particularly people with
- 58:21attachment in security, not just those with inmeshment. The other quality that you
- 58:24say, you know, you've read some sources that list effects is expressing covert
- 58:30aggression towards female friends. So this smells like something you read online or in
- 58:37a vogue magazine. So I don't understand this way expressing covert aggression towards female
- 58:44friends. I mean that assumes that in meshed people are female. I'm not
- 58:50sure, but yeah, for sure, some in meshed people can have deep
- 58:54anger that they will express passively. You know, as I was talking before
- 58:58about dependent people, you know, and mesh people can sometimes be dependent,
- 59:02not always, of course, but and some in meshed people, regardless of
- 59:07dependency, can have passive aggression. But to phrase it like this that in
- 59:13meshed people will express covert aggression towards female friends, I don't know. That
- 59:17sounds a little fishy to me and definitely doesn't feel like a universal You say,
- 59:28competition masks as friendship as another quality of in meshed people. Again not
- 59:34my experience. It smells like something you would read online in a bad article.
- 59:40Maybe you know, maybe more of that hidden anger or jealousy. But
- 59:44like I said, there are a lot of people who are products of enmeshment.
- 59:47And to just say they all will use competition at instead of you know,
- 59:52they'll act like they're your friend, but in true truth they're in competition
- 59:57with you. I don't think that makes life lot of sense. It might
- 1:00:00feel that way anyway, poor sense of identity is another thing that you identified,
- 1:00:06and that is absolutely true. You know that is a hallmark of any
- 1:00:12attachment security, but particularly enmeshment and parents who are overprotective is you as a
- 1:00:19child aren't allowed time to get to know who you are because you're constantly being
- 1:00:23invaded by someone else, and thus do not have a sense of who you
- 1:00:29are, don't have a sense of your own motivation, don't have a sense
- 1:00:31of your own needs, your own emotions, and so absolutely that's a big
- 1:00:36hallmark. You also say you read online or read somewhere lowered expectations of romantic
- 1:00:40needs being met. Yeah, absolutely, when not all enmeshed people, but
- 1:00:45certainly for some that has. You know that has to do with your lowered
- 1:00:51sense of identity. You know, you don't you're not in touch with your
- 1:00:57needs, and so you don't notice when your partner is harming you, and
- 1:01:02or you don't know it's okay to speak up for yourself and so, and
- 1:01:08or you've been modeled bad relationships and so you just have a low threshold for
- 1:01:15what seems acceptable to you. You also read anger, distressed resentment towards men.
- 1:01:22Again, this one smells like online silliness that all unmeshed people are competitive
- 1:01:28with their female friends and resentment towards men. It's like, I've read articles
- 1:01:34like this, and you know, putting aside the sort of genderized aspects of
- 1:01:37this, I don't understand. Maybe you know, certainly for some And it's
- 1:01:45not like enmeshment can't result result for a heterosexual woman to have resentment towards men.
- 1:01:52But as a blanket statement, that doesn't make any sense to me at
- 1:01:55all. And what does that exactly mean? Just like all men? They
- 1:01:59just like are prejudiced against all men. That's definitely not my experience with people
- 1:02:04that come from in mess relationships. But anyway, you say, what might
- 1:02:08be a good way to end this cycle of repeated complaints about her mom?
- 1:02:13So chaming in here. What I'm hearing from you is that your friend who's
- 1:02:17in mess with her mom will often come to you and complain about her mom.
- 1:02:22And you've been saying you need to go to therapy, and you're saying
- 1:02:28it it dominates your friendship for years, that your friend is constantly complaining about
- 1:02:34her mom, And you're saying, you know, what's a good way I
- 1:02:37could end this cycle? It's interesting the way you're phrasing it, which I
- 1:02:40think is good. You're saying, you know, how do I end the
- 1:02:42cycle of repeated complaints, So you're not trying to end the cycle of the
- 1:02:45enmeshment. You're trying to like protect yourself from the pathology. And then you're
- 1:02:51saying, or should I just accept that unless she ever gets help, this
- 1:02:54is the way it always will be. Yeah, you know, I don't
- 1:02:59know. I don't know. Do it depends and best case scenario, you
- 1:03:04could say something to her like, look, friend of mine, I love
- 1:03:07you. You know, I'll always be your friend. I always have been
- 1:03:09your friend. And I feel really bad about you and your mom. But
- 1:03:15it's frustrating to me to listen to you talk about your mom because and you
- 1:03:21know, because I'll tell you sometimes that you should push back in your mom,
- 1:03:23but it doesn't seem like you actually do it, or your mom is
- 1:03:25so rigid that she doesn't respond well to it, you know, And it
- 1:03:32hurts me to see you suffering this way. And I feel like there's an
- 1:03:38answer to it, which has to do with you actually taking control of your
- 1:03:42side of the relationship, but you never do it, and I'm watching it's
- 1:03:49almost like I'm watching you self harm or something and it's hard to watch.
- 1:03:52It's painful to me, and I don't know what to do because on one
- 1:03:57hand, I care and I want to be there for you, but in
- 1:04:00their hands, like I don't know if I want to hear it anymore because
- 1:04:02it's been I feel powerless, you know, and I would like you to
- 1:04:10do something about it, But if you don't, then I don't know if
- 1:04:12I want to hear about it anymore because you complain, but you don't ever
- 1:04:16do anything, you know. So and I love you and I'll always be
- 1:04:20your friend. You know. Maybe you could say something like that. I
- 1:04:24don't know. I can't imagine it working. It could work, you know,
- 1:04:28it could be a planning a seed for them to go to therapy.
- 1:04:31But you know, other things you can do are just be differentiated. You
- 1:04:36know, you hear me talk about differentiation. And this is a common conundrum
- 1:04:42for therapists that we will hear clients complain about things that are repetitive and it'll
- 1:04:47get frustrating to us. And so you have to recognize your feelings. And
- 1:04:50so your friend is complaining about meshment with her mom and just assessed for yourself,
- 1:04:56Like, Okay, what am I feeling? I'm feeling frustrated, I'm
- 1:04:59feeling powerless, I'm feeling bad for my friend. I'm feeling angry at her
- 1:05:04mom. I'm feeling triangulated. But those are just feelings. These aren't This
- 1:05:12isn't really an emergency. This isn't really my problem. This is my friend's
- 1:05:15problem. What does my friend want me to do? Well? I think
- 1:05:18my friend just wants to complain because I'm maybe the only person she can say
- 1:05:21this too. So I'll listen, but I'll kind of distance myself a little
- 1:05:27bit in my mind because if I get too close to this it'll feel bad.
- 1:05:30So I'll listen, but I'm not going to get that involved, and
- 1:05:32I'm just gonna kind of turn off half of my brain so I can be
- 1:05:36a good friend in this moment, but I'm not going to get wrapped up
- 1:05:40in this. I'm not going to become and meshed into their enmeshment. You
- 1:05:44know, that's one way to cope with it, right, And you know,
- 1:05:46if that works and you can stay friends, then you know, maybe
- 1:05:50that's that's all that you can do. You can also do other things,
- 1:05:54like your friend is complaining about your mom her mom, and you're just be
- 1:05:58like, yeah, you know I had a problem. You just give your
- 1:06:00own example, like I had a problem like that with my sister one time,
- 1:06:04and what I did was blank And sometimes I can plan a seat as
- 1:06:09well, just giving someone who lacks a sense of identity an idea of what
- 1:06:15it is to have an identity. One of the ways you can help people
- 1:06:18who lack a lack of connection with themselves is to show them what it's like
- 1:06:25to have a self, because then they can actually ask themselves, wait,
- 1:06:27how do I feel about this? You know, like your friends saying,
- 1:06:30ah, I was. You know, my mom was calling me all day
- 1:06:33long, and so I told her that, you know, I'm busy with
- 1:06:38work and stuff and you need to like calm down. But you know,
- 1:06:41my mom gave me the silent treatment for two days, and so I had
- 1:06:44to call her back and I had to apologize even though I didn't want to.
- 1:06:47And you're listening to this and you're getting frustrated. You feel powerless,
- 1:06:51you feel triangulated, and feel undifferentiated. So you say something like, yeah,
- 1:06:57if I were in your shoes, I would feel angry, I would
- 1:07:01feel mistreated. I would feel like the person's invading my life. I would
- 1:07:05feel like they're being unfair. I would feel like, you know, back
- 1:07:11off. I would feel like I'm being guilt tripped for something that I didn't
- 1:07:15do anything wrong, and I don't know. I would get angry and I
- 1:07:18would want to push back on that. Okay, so you're just saying how
- 1:07:24you would react, but you're modeling to them. Maybe something that is sort
- 1:07:29of novel, This idea that one can feel anger, which in meshed people
- 1:07:34often will suppress because it is not permitted in enmeshment. You cannot be angry
- 1:07:44at the enmeshment. You can't be angry at the person who's invading you,
- 1:07:46because you know they'll the person who's invading it will make sure that you aren't
- 1:07:51allowed to feel your anger, which is anyway without going down that rabbit hole.
- 1:07:57And I've done this before. I've found I never I don't know if
- 1:08:02I was ever taught this, but I learned through experience, not only with
- 1:08:05clients, but with students who i'd be very close, you know, working
- 1:08:10with, and would learn that, oh, some people don't know what it's
- 1:08:16like to feel injustice, and then to allow themselves to get angry, and
- 1:08:24that's this is an important aspect of humans and being able to meet our needs.
- 1:08:29You know, when we feel like we are being treated unfairly, we
- 1:08:34have to notice that one and two we have to allow ourselves to get angry,
- 1:08:40which three, you know, motivates behavior. And in an inmesh relationship
- 1:08:45where you don't have a sense of self because you've always been enmeshed, you
- 1:08:48might not have any connection with that process. And so one of the ways
- 1:08:53that you can therapize people is to model it for others. And I and
- 1:08:58I'm you know, I'm guessing a lot of you know this, but I'm
- 1:09:01very much in connection with injustice, not only in the world, but to
- 1:09:08me in particular. You know, when as a selfish, narcissistic individual,
- 1:09:13when when someone is treating me wrongly, like I know it because I feel
- 1:09:19it, I'm like no, no, no, no, no, this
- 1:09:20is and then I get angry and then I try and then I figure out
- 1:09:25what I'm You know, anger motivates behavior. Anger is good. Anger instructs
- 1:09:30us like you got to do something about this. Doesn't mean you punch someone
- 1:09:33in the face necessarily, but it motivates you to do something, do something
- 1:09:40to find justice, to find fairness, to assert for yourself, and it's
- 1:09:47an important part of human functioning and harmony and everything, you know, So
- 1:09:55sometimes you have to model it for other people so that they can feel like,
- 1:09:59oh, so I can I can get And sometimes you know what I
- 1:10:04would do is I would get angry for others, and then the others would
- 1:10:09say, I never knew I could get angry until you showed me, until
- 1:10:15you were angry for me, you know, they'd say to me, like
- 1:10:17you were angry for me, and then that unleashed my anger for the first
- 1:10:24time in my life. I didn't know that I could feel angry. And
- 1:10:28then you you know, when I told you what happened, you felt the
- 1:10:30injustice, you felt the unfairness, and you got real pissed. And I
- 1:10:36feel that now, you know, sometimes you need that, And so maybe
- 1:10:41you could do that for your friend. I don't know, but there's a
- 1:10:44good possibility that without a lot of therapy, your friend is just going to
- 1:10:48be where they're going to be. And the best thing you can do is
- 1:10:51just work on your own differentiation. All right, Well, that does it
- 1:10:57for that episode in which I read all the emails currently in the document,
- 1:11:03how have you to do with dependency and overfunctioning? Let me know what you
- 1:11:06think and tune in next time when we talk about some other topic. Everyone
- 1:11:14out there, please take care of yourself because you deserve it. You really,
- 1:11:16really really do.