Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Inside The Membership Model" with Bellingcat's Development Team
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to a stage talk titled Inside
- 0:04the Membership Model. This week, we were joined
- 0:07by my colleagues, Bellingcat's Sarah Bishop -Woods
- 0:09and Mareike Vitt. They came in to discuss Bellingcat's
- 0:12new membership model. We spoke about the funding
- 0:15model itself, how you can get involved with Bellingcat's
- 0:18membership, and what fueled the decision to move
- 0:20to this funding model in the first place. Packed
- 0:23full with not -for -profit business advice, this
- 0:26talk is useful for anyone interested in learning
- 0:28more about how our news is funded. You can find
- 0:31links to all of the resources mentioned in the
- 0:33talk in the podcast description. This talk was
- 0:36hosted by me, Charlotte Maher, on Thursday the
- 0:3930th of July, 2026, in the Bellingcat Discord
- 0:42server. Hello and welcome to another stage talk
- 0:50in the Bellingcat Discord server. Today we're
- 0:53exploring one of the most influential business
- 0:56models in modern journalism, membership. As advertising
- 1:00revenues have declined and audiences increasingly
- 1:02expect digital news for free, many news organisations
- 1:06have turned to their readers, not just as customers
- 1:08but as supporters and participants. But what
- 1:11exactly is a membership model and can it sustainably
- 1:14fund quality journalism? My wonderful colleagues
- 1:17Sarah Bishop -Woods and Mareike Vitt are here
- 1:20to answer those questions. They are both part
- 1:23of Bellingcat's development team and have been
- 1:25overseeing our transition into a membership model
- 1:27funding structure. In this talk, they'll unpack
- 1:30this newly adopted model of funding, explaining
- 1:33what it means and how it affects Bellingcat going
- 1:35forwards. As usual, we will have plenty of time
- 1:38to answer your questions and you can place your
- 1:41questions in the chat accessible on the right
- 1:43-hand corner of your screen. But please remember
- 1:46that this is being audio recorded for the podcast.
- 1:49So if you don't want me to mention your username,
- 1:51please add that as a note in your question. Okay,
- 1:54Mareike and Sarah, over to you. I'm going to mute
- 1:56for a second. Hi, Charlie. Thanks for the nice
- 2:02introduction and welcome everyone. Great to be
- 2:05back. I think, yeah, I've been here a year ago
- 2:08almost to talk about fundraising in general with
- 2:11you. And as Charlie has mentioned, we'd like
- 2:13to dive a bit more with you into one specific
- 2:17area, which is called membership. Many others
- 2:20maybe know it as a normal small donor program.
- 2:24Like almost anyone can do like a couple of bucks
- 2:26to support the cause that you like. So that's
- 2:30a little bit what this means and much more. And
- 2:33we'd like to dive with you into this today. Yes,
- 2:37why is Bellingcat going into that direction?
- 2:39We've been working towards this for quite a while.
- 2:43And as you know, the current fundraising landscape,
- 2:47especially for journalism, is very difficult.
- 2:50But I think many of you also know that with USAID
- 2:54stopping one and a half years ago, the repercussion
- 2:57in the entire NGO landscape was quite extensive.
- 3:02And this, of course, also affected journalism
- 3:05funding. In general, we've also seen trends of
- 3:10institutional funding going down, especially
- 3:12for journalism grants. But because people were
- 3:16moving more and more towards democracy, resilience
- 3:25funding, and journalism funding is one of them.
- 3:28So there's quite a lot of changes in the market
- 3:30of institutional funding, which for quite a while
- 3:33has been a major milestone for Bellingcat. But
- 3:37looking at our wonderful community and the work
- 3:41that Bellingcat does, it has been obvious for
- 3:43many years that we should actually be community
- 3:46funded. So people having a heart for our work,
- 3:51being practitioners themselves, and using the
- 3:55tools and the skills we're teaching. can also
- 3:58support us themselves and also guide our direction
- 4:02with their support. So that's really the reason
- 4:04behind it. So what you can, if you, if people
- 4:09have been knowing Bellegate for a while, you
- 4:11see, you saw that we've transitioned from a grassroots
- 4:15movement, which was around 2018, I would say,
- 4:18where you can get grants for small organizations
- 4:21to be built up over to grants that have been
- 4:26that have been given to us to professionalize
- 4:29because we're now an organization of almost 40
- 4:31people. So of course, this is a size that has
- 4:35been sustained by governance, by processes, by
- 4:38structures, different than a graph would be.
- 4:40So that's a little bit how we've transitioned
- 4:42and it's now has been the time for a long time,
- 4:45but it's now really the time that we want to
- 4:47be community funded by people like you, but many
- 4:50people worldwide who think it's worthwhile to
- 4:52support our cause. And yeah, I think I've announced
- 4:56it last year that we're going into the direction
- 4:58and Sarah has joined us. I do think that Marika
- 5:03is experiencing a small technical difficulty,
- 5:06but it's also a good time to accept the baton
- 5:10that she's passing. So I'm going to jump in and
- 5:13introduce myself. Hello, everyone. My name is
- 5:16Sarah Bishop -Woods and my role at Bellingcat
- 5:18is as Director of Development and Partnerships
- 5:20for the United States. Before joining Bellingcat,
- 5:23I've spent the bulk of my career in media. Most
- 5:26recently as the Chief Strategy Officer for a
- 5:28newsroom consultancy, where I worked with more
- 5:30than 60 organizations to help them build sustainable
- 5:32businesses around mission -driven work and simultaneously
- 5:36oversaw the firm's own business and operations.
- 5:38But what drew me to Bellingcat is likely similar
- 5:41to what brought you here as well. It's an organization
- 5:45unlike any other. And to appreciate what is unique
- 5:49about Bellingcat is also to appreciate what is
- 5:52unique about a membership program. So I'm going
- 5:55to go a little bit into the trajectory of the
- 5:59news and information industry and the business
- 6:04models that we've seen over the last few decades,
- 6:07and then we'll explore more in depth what it
- 6:09means to have a membership program. To understand
- 6:13why we launched a formal membership program,
- 6:15we first have to look at the broader landscape
- 6:17of news and information. Across the entire industry,
- 6:21the core question everyone is trying to answer
- 6:23is, how are we going to sustain public service
- 6:26journalism, given everything that's happening
- 6:28around the world? For decades, ad revenue funded
- 6:31public interest reporting. But that model has
- 6:34fundamentally broken down. The news industry
- 6:36has suffered over $33 billion in ad revenue losses
- 6:40over the last 30 years. Raking in programmatic
- 6:43ad revenue is not really viable in 2026, nor
- 6:47does it align with independent research models.
- 6:50Some institutions like the BBC rely on public
- 6:52funding or government -backed license fees, but
- 6:55state subsidies inherently carry risks for political
- 6:58pressure, policy shifts, or legislative interference.
- 7:01Outlets like Politico support their free journalism
- 7:04by selling high -priced, specialized business
- 7:07-to -business services like Politico Pro to corporate
- 7:10and institutional buyers. While effective for
- 7:14policy reporting, it requires a specific commercial
- 7:16market. And it is an entire business to run alongside
- 7:20a newsroom. The default pivot for most newsrooms
- 7:24has been consumer subscriptions. And yet, subscriptions
- 7:27almost always require paywalls. Put simply, paywalls
- 7:31hide crucial verified facts behind a price tag
- 7:34right when the public needs free access to the
- 7:37truth. That leaves us with membership. Membership
- 7:40isn't a transactional product. It's a relationship.
- 7:44It allows us to keep our work 100 % free, uncompromised,
- 7:49and unpaywalled for everyone while empowering
- 7:52the community that relies on our findings to
- 7:54directly fund and sustain the mission. As we
- 7:57pivot to membership, it's essential to understand
- 8:00that membership is not just a financial transaction,
- 8:02but really I do mean it is a relationship. Membership
- 8:06is a social contract between a news organization
- 8:08and its members. In this relationship, members
- 8:10are giving more than just their money. They are
- 8:14actively contributing their time, energy, expertise,
- 8:17and personal connections to a cause they believe
- 8:19in. That likely resonates with a lot of the people
- 8:22that are listening to this talk. This is core
- 8:24to how Bellingcat has always operated. Both organizations
- 8:28need to build habits to reach out to their community
- 8:30and audience when they build a membership program.
- 8:33At Bellingcat, this relationship is essential
- 8:35to an open source methodology. And our work is
- 8:38already open to a strong dynamic between the
- 8:40wider community and the Bellingcat staff. This
- 8:44relationship creates constant improvement for
- 8:46Bellingcat as a collective. allowing us to learn
- 8:49from each other and build support. Bellingcat
- 8:51is just such a unique organization. This year,
- 8:55in June, we launched our membership program.
- 8:59Bellingcat has never had advertising or paywall.
- 9:01Our work is free and uncompromised and always
- 9:04will be. We began receiving small dollar donations
- 9:08a few years ago and have had the gratifying experience
- 9:10of thousands of individuals giving at least once
- 9:13to the organization. However, there was room
- 9:16for improvement and to build a program that becomes
- 9:18a steady source of operating support while also
- 9:21giving back to those donors. We've seen this
- 9:24work in other nonprofit organizations and they
- 9:26share one common principle. They treat membership
- 9:29as a sustained editorial and operational commitment,
- 9:33not just a donate button. That's the standard
- 9:35that we've built toward. To launch this program,
- 9:38we've undergone many behind -the -scenes developments,
- 9:40which I'll walk you through now. So when I say
- 9:43that Bellingcat is an organization unlike any
- 9:46other, it's not just because I am effusive in
- 9:50my passion for my place of work, but because
- 9:53of the focus I'm providing for a community of
- 9:56more than 40 ,000, a commitment to training the
- 9:59wider news and information sector, tools and
- 10:01methodologies built and freely shared and tested,
- 10:04and partnerships that act as a capacity builder
- 10:07and a force multiplier. We began this membership
- 10:10program by listening. through a community survey
- 10:13because a membership program is, again, a relationship,
- 10:16not a transaction. Perhaps, if you're listening
- 10:18to this now, you took our survey, and if so,
- 10:21thank you. I ran across 10 platforms for two
- 10:24weeks and garnered more than 3 ,000 responses.
- 10:27From there, we took the data and unique insights
- 10:29to our management team, where we further developed
- 10:33a brand story and value proposition based on
- 10:35the feedback from those surveys. Today, I'm going
- 10:38to take you behind the scenes of what we learned
- 10:40and how we built this new line of business. So,
- 10:43before we go any further, I'd like to put the
- 10:45survey respondents into context. I like to call
- 10:49these groups the hand raisers, people with the
- 10:51willingness and time to answer a survey. They
- 10:53tend to be a bit older, maybe a little more financially
- 10:56stable, and are generally more highly educated.
- 11:00So while these figures don't represent all of
- 11:02Bellingcat's audience, it is still meaningful
- 11:04that more than 3 ,000 people took the time to
- 11:07share their insights. 84 % of the respondents
- 11:10have been following Bellingcat for a year or
- 11:13more. Longevity of following is one of the strongest
- 11:17predictors of conversion to paid support because
- 11:19it means that somebody genuinely cares and appreciates
- 11:22the work coming out of an organization. The respondents
- 11:25also shared a high propensity and activity for
- 11:27giving. before we've made any formal solicitations.
- 11:3245 % said they would donate or already do. 22
- 11:36% were existing donors. And 23 % said they would
- 11:40give if they were asked properly, you know, really
- 11:43a please and a thank you. Finally, we calculated
- 11:48a net promoter score, which was 75. For context,
- 11:53the global average of net promoter scores in
- 11:552025 was 32. according to SurveyMonkey, and anything
- 11:59above 70 is considered exceptional. The score
- 12:03represents people's willingness to promote our
- 12:05organization to others in conversation. And Bell
- 12:09and Cat's audience doesn't just consume the work,
- 12:11they advocate for it. Again, a net promoter score
- 12:14of 75, just really phenomenal. We also asked
- 12:19people to self -report where they were taking
- 12:22the survey from. And our top four demographics
- 12:26were the United States, the UK, the Netherlands,
- 12:29and Canada, which maps relationally on to where
- 12:32we see a lot of our traffic come from. But the
- 12:37highlight here was that we did have respondents
- 12:39self -report from more than 90 different countries,
- 12:42truly a global reach and highlighting where we
- 12:45have an opportunity to continue engaging with
- 12:48audiences all over the world. I'm going to return
- 12:51to the stat that I mentioned that 84 % of the
- 12:55respondents have followed Bellingcat for a year
- 12:57or more. It's incredibly easy to move from one
- 13:00source of media to another and never develop
- 13:02a habit of purposely engaging. That's why brand
- 13:06loyalty is an incredible bellwether for membership
- 13:08programs and this level of 84 % is rare in digital
- 13:12media. Most news organizations are fighting churn
- 13:15constantly. Readers find them through a single
- 13:18story and then they leave. Bellingcat's audience
- 13:20stays, but I'm actually less focused on the user
- 13:23habit here because habit alone doesn't explain
- 13:26why this is worth celebrating. Habits form around
- 13:30things that are usually easy and frictionless.
- 13:33Following Bellingcat is not those things. The
- 13:37work is challenging, the topics are serious,
- 13:40and the methodology requires real attention.
- 13:44People are staying because Bellingcat consistently
- 13:47provides something worth creating a long -term
- 13:49relationship for, not just ease of use. And we
- 13:55also asked in our survey if respondents would
- 13:58be disappointed if Bellingcat ceased to exist.
- 14:0298 % said that they would be disappointed if
- 14:07Bellingcat ceased to exist tomorrow, with the
- 14:09majority sharing in their write -in option that
- 14:12Bellingcat is irreplaceable. So we also asked
- 14:16these survey takers why they would be disappointed.
- 14:20We had an incredible write -in rate, which I
- 14:22sorted into general themes of responses. These
- 14:25themes were the depth of work, showing the work,
- 14:29truth, independence from power, covering stories
- 14:33others ignore, and trust. I'm going to read you
- 14:37some of the write -in responses that really stuck
- 14:40with me. This one tickles me. Bellingcat is an
- 14:45unimpeachable source of solid evidence -based
- 14:48investigations into often overlooked crimes.
- 14:51Its disinterested approach annoys me as someone
- 14:54with distinct political views. That's partly
- 14:57what makes it essential and irreplaceable. Another
- 15:01goes, the level of depth in each investigation,
- 15:04which is unique compared to other news outlets
- 15:06because it has a reproducible discovery method
- 15:09and goes into a level of detail very rarely covered
- 15:12in mass media. and which is increasingly tailored
- 15:14for lower expectations and integrity levels.
- 15:18The others were scientific methodology applied
- 15:20to journalism. Another write -in was journalism
- 15:23for the powerless. And finally, veracity. Bellingcat
- 15:28should be industry standard, publicly funded,
- 15:31and globally protected. When we asked the survey
- 15:34respondents what they wanted to ask of our investigators,
- 15:38their responses were, I found, to be incredibly
- 15:40touching. Again, I sorted the data set to find
- 15:44the patterns and overwhelmingly the themes demonstrated
- 15:46compassion and concern and an eagerness to participate.
- 15:50How do we, Bellingcat, protect ourselves when
- 15:53the people we investigate are dangerous? How
- 15:55do we stay motivated when the scale of what we're
- 15:57documenting feels overwhelming? How do we keep
- 16:00going in a world where the facts exist and accountability
- 16:03is such a long road? And then this one, how can
- 16:07we as an audience help with your mission? I often
- 16:10feel helpless about the state of misinformation
- 16:12online. That question demonstrates something
- 16:15that is special about the Bellingcat community.
- 16:18People aren't just reading. They're worried about
- 16:20the world and they're looking for a way to do
- 16:22something about it. The feeling of helplessness
- 16:24in the face of conflict and disinformation is
- 16:27a defining feeling in 2026. And our audience
- 16:30is telling us they see Bellingcat as an outlet
- 16:32for resolving this. They are willing to build
- 16:35a movement of truth with Bellingcat. Once the
- 16:39surveys closed, the management team worked through
- 16:41a structured value proposition, defining who
- 16:44our audience really is, what promise we make
- 16:46to them, what actions back that promise up, and
- 16:49what we would consider an achievement we're celebrating
- 16:51in the future. This kind of process can feel
- 16:54quite intensive, but I'm fortunate that they've
- 16:56been very patient with these methods and with
- 16:58me and what was developed as a testament to their
- 17:00commitment. This also led to the foundation of
- 17:04membership messaging that is resonant both with
- 17:06Bellingcat's loyal audiences and our teams that
- 17:08lead that work. So, drum roll, this is what the
- 17:13process produced. Bellingcat is a global collective
- 17:17uncovering facts to hold power to account. We
- 17:19share everything, including our methods, because
- 17:21the truth belongs to everyone. Both investigative
- 17:26organizations protect their methods as a competitive
- 17:28advantage. but we publish them, we teach them,
- 17:31we build tools around them. It's a philosophical
- 17:34commitment to the idea that the capacity to find
- 17:36the truth shouldn't sit with a small group of
- 17:39specialists. It should be distributed as widely
- 17:41as possible. That's what our community told us.
- 17:44They recognize and value above almost everything
- 17:47else, which is underscored by the strategy and
- 17:49operations of the entire management team. And
- 17:52we also have this line, which was particularly
- 17:54salient. democracy depends on people who won't
- 17:58take the truth at face value. We are in a period
- 18:02of autocratic upheaval where the manipulation
- 18:05of reality has become a primary instrument of
- 18:08power. In that context, Bellingcat builds a community
- 18:11to further engage the democratic revival, which
- 18:14serves as the governance of democratic resilience.
- 18:18Bellingcat has always been built by many hands
- 18:20and this program is no different. If any of what
- 18:24you've heard today resonates with you, and I
- 18:27do hope that it has. Here's how you can be a
- 18:30part of the membership program. Please consider
- 18:33forwarding our emails along or sharing about
- 18:35the program with your networks. Give us your
- 18:38feedback and wisdom. We always appreciate it.
- 18:40Or make an introduction that might benefit our
- 18:43organization. We love to make friends. We do
- 18:46have some additional activities that are listed
- 18:49in a slide that perhaps we can put in the show
- 18:52notes, but that would be We have these peer -to
- 18:55-peer fundraising activities as well. And we
- 18:59encourage anyone to email us at donations at
- 19:02bellincat .com with their advice. We do read
- 19:05through it all. And thank you very much. If we
- 19:11have any questions, we're happy to answer. Amazing.
- 19:14Thank you so much for going through that. I'm
- 19:20always surprised by Bellingcat in terms of how
- 19:24much we are comfortable and happy to share with
- 19:29our audience as well. I think it's quite unique
- 19:31actually to have a newsroom sit down and have
- 19:36a talk like this, where you're actually kind
- 19:38of revealing the feedback from audience surveys
- 19:42and giving kind of an insight into The business
- 19:46model that lies behind our work, I think it's
- 19:49really refreshing and really helpful as well
- 19:52for people who might be listening and thinking
- 19:54about starting up their own newsroom, for example,
- 19:56which I know a few of you who may have attended
- 19:58Marika's last talk were thinking about. Please
- 20:01keep your questions coming in the chat on the
- 20:03right -hand side. I was wondering if maybe some
- 20:05of those links that you showed in the last slide,
- 20:08if one of you wouldn't mind putting them in the
- 20:10chat as well, because that's usually where we
- 20:12add them. Um, while that's being done, I wanted
- 20:16to start off by asking a little bit more about
- 20:19the membership model as a, as a general model,
- 20:22funding model. And then perhaps later on, we
- 20:24can move into what that means for Bellingcat
- 20:27a little bit more. But what, what distinguishes
- 20:30a membership model specifically from a subscription
- 20:33model? Because that's often a confusion point.
- 20:36I know you touched on it within the talk, but
- 20:38perhaps we can dig that into that a little bit
- 20:40more. And does this model suit? every news organisational
- 20:45structure or is it sometimes more suited to more
- 20:48niche publications where you perhaps have a more
- 20:52dedicated but smaller audience? Yeah, so those
- 20:57are great questions by the way. The first digging
- 21:00into what's the difference between membership
- 21:02and subscription. Typically a subscription model
- 21:06means that something is being paywalled. They
- 21:11can appear very similar because you are still
- 21:14seeing requests for payment. But the major difference
- 21:18is in a membership model, you can always access
- 21:21the product, the information, the research, whatever
- 21:26that organization is putting out, regardless
- 21:29of if you give or not. I've heard people refer
- 21:33to a membership program really as a tip jar,
- 21:38but I think that's missing the vital point of
- 21:41membership. When you give to an organization
- 21:44through a subscription, their motivation is just
- 21:49to ensure that you don't drop your subscription.
- 21:52So they need to provide just enough value to
- 21:54you that you will continue. However, if you are
- 21:59in a membership with that relationship with an
- 22:02organization, you are really considered to be
- 22:05someone that is a part of holding up the sustainability
- 22:09of that organization and you are invited in in
- 22:12a much more relational way. So a subscription
- 22:16is transactional and you have to go through a
- 22:19subscription to access something. Whereas a membership,
- 22:23there is a request for support, but you are always
- 22:26allowed to access information regardless of whether
- 22:30or not you're providing support back. And if
- 22:33you do, you are further brought a step deeper
- 22:37into having a relationship with that organization.
- 22:40Your second question, I don't remember it, so
- 22:42please refresh me. I asked whether the membership
- 22:45model was suited to all forms of news organizations
- 22:48or whether it's more suited to smaller, more
- 22:52niche publications, which might have a smaller
- 22:55but more dedicated audience. Do you think this
- 22:58model, for example, would work for large scale
- 23:00broadcasters as well as smaller, perhaps more
- 23:04independent publications? That's a really great
- 23:07question. And it's something that people debate
- 23:09about quite a bit. I would say that where we've
- 23:13seen membership picked up most is with mission
- 23:16-driven organizations where you inherently are
- 23:19not scaling your audience to an infinite amount.
- 23:24There is a finite amount of people that will
- 23:27be willing to engage. satisfying the needs of
- 23:36your audience with your work then they will have
- 23:39a propensity to give. Can membership replace
- 23:43subscriptions? There are some very successful
- 23:47subscription businesses and they include different
- 23:52types of user needs in what they're providing
- 23:56that's not purely mission driven and so I think
- 23:59that actually Membership is great when you are,
- 24:02you don't need to be a nonprofit, but when you're
- 24:05sort of driven by having this core value that
- 24:09you're pursuing. And a subscription is great
- 24:11for other types of audience needs, you know,
- 24:15entertainment especially. Nick in the chat has
- 24:19asked a question that I was about to follow up
- 24:21with, so I'll ask that now. He's asked, very
- 24:23interesting to see the process of how you think
- 24:25about and approach fundraising. I'm interested
- 24:27in your thoughts about platforms like Substack
- 24:29or perhaps Patreon, which we've had for a while,
- 24:33that make the membership model accessible to
- 24:35newsrooms as small as one person. So what are
- 24:38your thoughts on platforms like that? And why,
- 24:40for example, did Velinecap decide to kind of
- 24:43put our membership model on our website instead
- 24:45of... just using a model like Substack or Patreon?
- 24:50Yeah, I think that there are a lot of tools available,
- 24:53especially for this one -person newsroom, or
- 24:56might be referred to as a creator, news creator,
- 25:01that make a lot of sense for that business case.
- 25:04And especially if you're one person, you need
- 25:06something that is very straightforward. You don't
- 25:09need a technical stack of different platforms
- 25:12that you would then have to manage. Personally,
- 25:16I think I've seen a lot of growth through Beehive
- 25:20in the creator space and I think that that's
- 25:22a very encouraging up -and -comer within the
- 25:27platform world. A lot of people also really gravitate
- 25:29towards Ghost or other open source WordPress
- 25:34products and then integrate with a newsletter.
- 25:38I think that those are phenomenal and you can
- 25:41find a lot of off -the -shelf products. At a
- 25:45certain point in an organization's maturation,
- 25:49especially if you're not just one person by yourself,
- 25:51which is such a grind, you do want to have what's
- 25:57called a CRM, a customer relationship management
- 26:00tool. These are tools like Salesforce and many
- 26:04others. And this tool helps you keep one database
- 26:09very clean, and it's really important to keep
- 26:12your database clean so that you are not continuing
- 26:16to solicit people when they have moved on or
- 26:21you need to update their email or you want to
- 26:24measure different analytics from the giving history.
- 26:30There are lots of tools that build in very light
- 26:33CRMs, but ultimately organizations still preface
- 26:38to a more high -powered option in the end. We'll
- 26:46see if that changes. Technology is constantly
- 26:49improving. The last two years have been absolutely
- 26:52insane in the improvements that are off the shelf
- 26:55for creators. But Bellingcat is at that stage
- 27:00in its maturation where we can make decisions
- 27:05that are better informed for our audience by
- 27:08reading the signals that we can receive. We don't
- 27:12track cookies on our website. So we have very
- 27:18limited pools of information to make things more
- 27:25straightforward and streamlined for our audience.
- 27:28It also helps us make better business decisions
- 27:31by being able to measure trends and giving patterns
- 27:35so that we're not also asking people when they
- 27:38don't want to be asked. That said, you know,
- 27:43if you are one person and you want to begin a
- 27:47membership program, the tools that I've seen
- 27:50a lot of people really gravitate to recently
- 27:52are BeHive, which we're also using as an email
- 27:56service provider now. But I've seen it in the
- 28:00wild before my time at Bellingcat and Ghost.
- 28:04And I think the impetus with Patreon and Substack
- 28:12and Kickstarter to help people crowdfund their
- 28:15work was a very clear signal that we had, you
- 28:18know, starting 20 years ago really in the digital
- 28:21space. YouTube has had membership programs on
- 28:25and off as well, and it's just a sign of a sign
- 28:29of the times that to ensure that work is going
- 28:32to be around, people are requesting in some way
- 28:35their audience supports it. I just wanted to
- 28:38flag that Marika has put in the chat those links
- 28:42that we talked about in the speech earlier. Marika,
- 28:48I don't know if you want to address it in voice,
- 28:50but we've had a few people in the chat asking
- 28:53about membership rewards and possible merchandise.
- 28:57I don't know if you want to address that verbally
- 29:00as well. Yeah. Hi, Charlie. Thanks. I hope you
- 29:05can hear me. Yes, I've been busy answering the
- 29:10questions in the chat. So yes, I mean, the perks,
- 29:14since we've only launched a couple of weeks ago,
- 29:18we're of course building up the perks in the
- 29:20future. Merchandise is one of them that we are
- 29:23looking into. To say it's quite a workload to
- 29:28build this up and to build this up in a good
- 29:30way because of design and licensing, et cetera.
- 29:33And we want to, of course, offer you good products
- 29:35that you then can receive. But yes, it's in the
- 29:38pipeline and coming up. Another one is, of course,
- 29:41offering you other ways of engaging with us.
- 29:43For example, other digital events such as the
- 29:46stage talk, but maybe different ways of meeting
- 29:49people from Bellingcat. in the future hearing
- 29:52about our work. So yes, there's more to come,
- 29:56but stay tuned. I'll share in the chat, we do
- 30:00have a list of the perks on our website, in case
- 30:02you have questions as to the giving tiers for
- 30:07those perks. And Marika is exactly right. We
- 30:13want to be very thoughtful as we launch a merchandise
- 30:17line, but I hope that we will within this year
- 30:21have some exciting news because we want to ensure
- 30:24that the community can participate both in submitting
- 30:29ideas, but then also voting on the products that
- 30:32they would want to see. That brings me nicely.
- 30:37Oh, Silted Knife has just asked quickly in the
- 30:40chat, did I miss podcasts or are they not on
- 30:42the list? In terms of right now, the podcast
- 30:48benefits are tied to our Patreon, which we are
- 30:54internally discussing merging with our membership
- 30:56program. In terms of any podcast creation that
- 31:01we make right now, of course everything is otherwise
- 31:05still free to all audiences and it's just on
- 31:09a delay. So we're considering how to bring that
- 31:14archive to the full public and then also measuring
- 31:18what we can sustainably do through the end of
- 31:2226 and into 2027. Stage talks is something, Charlie
- 31:27knows this, it's something that I routinely listen
- 31:29to. So I think that for as long as we can create
- 31:33something that people are genuinely enjoying,
- 31:36which obviously you are if you're hearing this,
- 31:40that we would want to pursue that. Amazing. That
- 31:42brings me on to my next question in terms of
- 31:45audience access. How will Bellingcat membership
- 31:48affect audience access? Will there be exclusive
- 31:51content for those who are members? If I'm not
- 31:53paying, for example, will I miss out on investigations
- 31:57or will there be additional pressure put on researchers,
- 32:02for example, to deliver large scale, impressive
- 32:05looking investigations because of the membership
- 32:08model? Will it have any effect on the way that
- 32:13we do things at Bellingcat? Yeah, I think there
- 32:18were three questions on that, so I will come
- 32:20back to you if I miss one. The first, are there
- 32:24opportunities for unique content in the membership
- 32:27program? Actually, today we delivered our first
- 32:30membership -only newsletter, which contained
- 32:34a Q &A with our researcher and our editor behind
- 32:39the leaked BB investigation. That said, would
- 32:42we ever hide an investigation or ask the researchers
- 32:49to do something on behalf of membership? Absolutely
- 32:53not. The purpose is to ensure that our investigations
- 32:56are always accessible to the public. at Bellingcat,
- 33:01but especially also in news organizations, but
- 33:03within our entire development team, we feel very
- 33:06strongly about having editorial independence
- 33:08for the researchers and the editorial team and
- 33:11really all of the other operations across Bellingcat.
- 33:15So no, there would never be a time in which the
- 33:18membership program would create opportunities
- 33:22for the research team to be beholden to them.
- 33:24Yeah. Maybe Sarah, if I can add to that, because
- 33:27there was also a question in the chat in terms
- 33:29of earmarked donations or earmarked membership
- 33:33so that you can support maybe other topics that
- 33:35you rely, that you relate more to. And this is
- 33:39exactly the same answer. You can support our
- 33:42toolkit work because that's general for all of
- 33:44the open source research we do. And it's a very
- 33:47solid pillar that we offer to the community.
- 33:52But earmarking in terms of a topic or a topic
- 33:55area. exactly bears that danger so to speak that
- 33:59of course there are topics that are more newsworthy
- 34:03or maybe covered also widely within society rather
- 34:07than other areas which are unreported which exactly
- 34:10is also part of our work that we also shed light
- 34:12on underreported conflicts for example or under
- 34:15other unreported topic areas which then if we
- 34:19related to membership which of course then might
- 34:22be underfunded compared to other areas. So this
- 34:24is a danger we want to prevent in opening up
- 34:29the membership to support our work in general
- 34:31and stay tuned on all of the investigations.
- 34:35But yeah, and to also show respect to all the
- 34:38work that all of our resource rights are doing.
- 34:40Absolutely. I think the earmarked question is
- 34:42a really good question because you often do see
- 34:45campaigns for not -for -profits, for example,
- 34:49based on different topic areas. So it's really
- 34:52interesting to know that that's not something
- 34:54that we're kind of leaning into. In regards to
- 34:57questions from the audience, we had one at the
- 34:58very beginning, which I skipped because I wanted
- 35:01to focus in on the membership model, but perhaps
- 35:03we can visit it now quickly. It was on the stat
- 35:07about advertising losses and what a scale that
- 35:11is over 30 years. And they wondered how the advertising
- 35:13losses looked more on a year by year review.
- 35:16Was there a particular point where advertising
- 35:19for newsrooms or for not -for -profits became
- 35:22something that just wasn't the answer anymore?
- 35:25And what was the definition of advertisement
- 35:29in that kind of sake? Does it include sponsorships
- 35:32and merchandising or was it just subsidies? Perhaps
- 35:35you can give just a very quick overview of what
- 35:38the previous advertising model looked like for
- 35:41many newsrooms and why people are moving away
- 35:43from that a little bit. I don't want to move
- 35:47too much into it because this talks about membership
- 35:49models specifically and you can listen back to
- 35:51Marika's last talk if you want to dive into that
- 35:53deeper, but I just wanted to address that question
- 35:55that came in early on. Yeah, I think there are
- 35:59three real moments that we can hone in on across
- 36:03those more than 30 years. And I'm going to apologize
- 36:07in advance that I'm not going to give you the
- 36:09exact dates because if I got it wrong, I would...
- 36:11Feel very bad, but I can give you approximations
- 36:15right now And it is something that I have in
- 36:18many research notes that I should just make available
- 36:21But first there was a if we go back to the 1990s
- 36:26with the the advent of you know, most people
- 36:30now having a Personal computer in their homes
- 36:33and the expansion of the World Wide Web We see
- 36:38the first general shift in advertising At this
- 36:42point, most news organizations are exclusively
- 36:47print, radio, and broadcast. And this shift affected
- 36:54primarily the print organizations, where we start
- 36:58to see money shift from print ads, classifieds,
- 37:05paying to submit obituaries. I know these sound
- 37:09like really small or like some can you believe
- 37:14the classifieds and obituaries and also in the
- 37:18United States especially posting your marriage
- 37:22license or your name change you would have to
- 37:24do in print. And this was a substantial line
- 37:27of business. But then there's also advertising
- 37:30from corporate interests and that At this time
- 37:34was primarily print ads, like just ads as well.
- 37:38And sponsorships is something that you see develop
- 37:41especially into the early aughts as news organizations
- 37:47make more offerings to feel more customized and
- 37:50tailored to their advertisers. So the first shift
- 37:53that we see is as the World Wide Web comes on
- 37:58and news organizations are slow to their digital
- 38:02transformation. Then into the odds, this is around
- 38:09between 2009 and 2013, there's more cookie tracking.
- 38:15And in this window, Google buys the major cookie
- 38:20tracker, which is tracking how people are visiting
- 38:23different websites. And it provides a lot of...
- 38:26analytics to advertisers and this massively changes
- 38:29again how digital advertising operates on the
- 38:34scale of digital publications. So now it is more
- 38:39difficult to, you have to have click -through
- 38:43rates and you have to have a certain number of
- 38:45impressions to reach the ad spends that you're
- 38:48promised. Then we jump through another let's
- 38:54say seven to 10 years into the 2020s. Facebook
- 38:57is really at its boom cycle. I would say its
- 39:01boom cycle was actually closer to 2015. We have
- 39:05a lot of digital platforms have built their businesses
- 39:09off of capturing the online ad market. And you
- 39:13have lots of Facebook ads and Google has a very
- 39:17successful ad business. And that is spend that
- 39:21You know, the advertisers have a finite amount
- 39:24of money that they are willing to spend. And
- 39:27so that spend is going into platforms again instead
- 39:30of the websites and publications that news outlets
- 39:34would then have. So we have these three tiers
- 39:37of technological innovation that directly affect
- 39:43advertiser behavior and that also creates massive
- 39:47shifts for the news and information sector on
- 39:50how they can deliver. Thank you for that overview.
- 39:53You've just gone through the downfall of the
- 39:57advertising space. I know we're here to talk
- 40:02about the membership model as basically a good
- 40:05thing that Bellingcat has launched, but what
- 40:07are the risks to relying on mentorship as a financial
- 40:12model? I'd love to understand a little bit more
- 40:15about where the risks lie here. Yeah, there's
- 40:20risk in everything. inherent risk in, you know,
- 40:23waking up and deciding to engage. So first, the
- 40:28risk that I am very mindful of is I don't want
- 40:31people to hear more from me than they would hear
- 40:34from the Bellingcat editorial and research teams.
- 40:38So Bellingcat naturally only publishes when there's
- 40:41something that is, when an investigation has
- 40:44closed and it is worth publication, it has a
- 40:47standard of impact and there is a unique finding.
- 40:51That means that we are not operating on a cadence
- 40:55of publication that other newsrooms would do.
- 40:59Another newsroom, if they need to fill their
- 41:01quota, they might cover the pumpkin patch at
- 41:04their local community event. They can just sort
- 41:10of fill content space and that's something we
- 41:12would never do. So one risk is hearing too much
- 41:15from me. Another risk really is As a membership
- 41:24program is built on ensuring that we are speaking
- 41:28with an audience and it's increasingly more difficult
- 41:31for audiences to find publications these days.
- 41:35We have what has been affectionately coined the
- 41:39Google zero when people are expecting to receive
- 41:43no more SEO from Google. We also have no more
- 41:49search results driving to their pages because
- 41:52of Google's changes and how they present search
- 41:58results through paid search, but also because
- 42:00of the artificial intelligence summaries. We're
- 42:05also seeing that we can receive traffic from
- 42:09bots, from AI bots, but that doesn't actually
- 42:12mean that somebody is clicking through or learning
- 42:15about the organization. developing a relationship.
- 42:19So really, the other risk is always audience
- 42:23discovery. And Charlie, I am able to go to sleep
- 42:27at night knowing that you work on that. And I'm
- 42:30constantly impressed by your ability to reach
- 42:33new audiences and really engage in a purposeful
- 42:37and thoughtful manner. But just acknowledging
- 42:40that that's the trend that we see in the industry.
- 42:42And that is one of the existential risks of a
- 42:45membership program. Oh, don't make me blush.
- 42:49Yes, the chat bot's AI search is becoming kind
- 42:55of something that newsrooms, I think we spoke
- 42:57about this on a previous talk, something that
- 42:58newsrooms are currently trying to prepare for
- 43:02and optimize for as well with their headlines
- 43:04and the way that they write stories, which is
- 43:06interesting, the shift in the way that our stories
- 43:10are being recommended to audiences. Please keep
- 43:14your questions coming in. We've got about 15
- 43:16minutes left. So if you haven't asked a question
- 43:19yet, pop it in the chat. Yeah, go ahead. Yeah,
- 43:25thanks. I just wanted to add on that question
- 43:28of the risk of membership. I think it's not in
- 43:33terms of membership specifically, but on relying
- 43:35on one source of funding. It's always a risk,
- 43:39right? I mean, if you look at what happened to
- 43:42USAID, some organizations had quite a portion
- 43:45of their income from this and suddenly it stops,
- 43:48which nobody thought would happen. And then you
- 43:53have quite some difficulty. So in any case, people
- 43:56thinking about building their own organization
- 43:59or outlet, they should always keep in mind of
- 44:02having a diverse source of income. Of course,
- 44:04you cannot build all of this in one month. So
- 44:08it has to be built up continuously, but keep
- 44:10this in mind when looking at your portfolio that
- 44:13if there is a major donor coming your way, great,
- 44:17but you shouldn't rely on one person. And of
- 44:20course you also shouldn't rely on only membership
- 44:22model or a corporation who supports you or one
- 44:26institutional funder. So keep in mind that you
- 44:29constantly try to diversify and think about different
- 44:33stakeholders to your work. who might support
- 44:35you rather than only focusing on one. So yeah,
- 44:38that's a general advice to always keep in mind.
- 44:42Really important advice. And last time you were
- 44:44here, we talked about the collapse of USAID as
- 44:46well and how devastating of an impact that had
- 44:49across your event and worldwide with funding
- 44:53because a lot of organizations depended on it.
- 44:56Thankfully, not Bellingcat though, we never took
- 44:59USAID. In regards to the membership model, what
- 45:05metrics tell you a membership program is healthy?
- 45:08What metrics are you looking for for success?
- 45:11That is such a great question. So there are a
- 45:15few different metrics that we measure in terms
- 45:18of, I mean, let's first define what success means.
- 45:24One very straightforward answer, which is, you
- 45:26know, how is this increasing the sustainability
- 45:28of Bellingcat? But the answer that is really
- 45:32beholden to a membership program is, are we providing
- 45:36real value to people that are willing to support
- 45:39us? So one of the most important metrics is churn
- 45:43rate. So churn rate is... When somebody has given
- 45:48and then they decide to no longer give that could
- 45:51be canceling a recurring gift or just doing one
- 45:55One single donation that that lapses beyond a
- 45:59year having a lower turn rate means that people
- 46:03still Connect to the mission of Bellingcat. We're
- 46:07still asking them in an appropriate way And when
- 46:11they become a member, they find that membership
- 46:14to be worthwhile. So that is If you are launching
- 46:19a membership program and there are lots of key
- 46:22performance indicators that you'll naturally
- 46:24measure in terms of the funds that you're actually
- 46:27raising and your average gift size and the number
- 46:30of people that you're receiving funds from, but
- 46:35the one that really says whether or not your
- 46:37program is meaningful is turn rate. I can see
- 46:41a few people typing as well. So as I said, we've
- 46:44only got 10 minutes left. So do pop your questions
- 46:47in. If you could change one thing about how journalism
- 46:52slash nonprofits are funded today, what would
- 46:56it be? If journalism is a public good, for example,
- 46:59should its survival depend on voluntary contributions?
- 47:04What would you change about the funding system
- 47:06as it stands today? It's an interesting question
- 47:11to consider where I live especially because I'm
- 47:14in the United States and I guess we're very well
- 47:20known for our full embrace of capitalism. So
- 47:26the question is also how do public goods sustain
- 47:31themselves in a capital system? Journalism in
- 47:36particular has such a meaningful metric for informing
- 47:42people and helping them improve their lives through
- 47:47what they learn and can take action on and can
- 47:50hold their own representatives accountable, which
- 47:55makes it tricky to consider, for instance, the
- 47:58BBC model, especially in the United States. But
- 48:03just asking from a global context, there are
- 48:07so many things that are really worthwhile as
- 48:09public good. And what would be lovely to see
- 48:15from a journalism perspective is having secured
- 48:20sources that can distribute a percentage to different
- 48:23organizations with metrics included on tracking
- 48:28that spending. that was from a governing body
- 48:31that was not tied to political institutions.
- 48:36How that could be organized is really, I guess,
- 48:40a pipe dream. There are initiatives in the United
- 48:44States to try to get local cities and states
- 48:49to contribute X amount of their funding to advertising
- 48:54programs for local news, for instance. And I
- 48:58know there are some efforts in the United Kingdom
- 49:00for the public interest media fund. But yeah,
- 49:04there needs to be some, I would imagine, some
- 49:08third party that can be the arbiter on behalf
- 49:12of public goods such as journalism. I think,
- 49:15yeah, in an ideal world, honestly, for me, journalism
- 49:18is community funded completely. But by community,
- 49:21I would enclose also anyone like a corporation
- 49:25or an institutional funder. So like I said, a
- 49:28diverse group of people who believe in public
- 49:29interest reporting, but who also take us accountable
- 49:34of actually delivering accountability and public
- 49:38interest reporting. So I think it should be a
- 49:40dialogue based relationship that you build and
- 49:43that you really, yeah, that you really measured
- 49:45on if you deliver. That takes me really nicely
- 49:49into one of the audience questions that's just
- 49:51come through, which says for large institutional
- 49:53funders that are looking to fund democracy resilient
- 49:56civil society organizations, how do you go about
- 49:59approaching those types of large donors? How
- 50:02do you get your foot in there? Exactly. I wanted
- 50:05to raise that question as well. I saw it in the
- 50:07chat. Thank you for that question. It's difficult
- 50:11to give a general answer because it's depending
- 50:13on the funder, but I think in general, media
- 50:17and journalism needs to have an answer on their
- 50:20role of an information ecosystem. So they need
- 50:24to answer what is their actual theory of change
- 50:28in terms of democracy or playing an important
- 50:31part in democracy because we've seen such a decline
- 50:34over the last years in trust in media in general.
- 50:36So you cannot rely on your traditional model,
- 50:38I think, anymore. So I think what funders are
- 50:43asking is like, okay, what is your current and
- 50:45future role in an information ecosystem that
- 50:48has been in jeopardy and that has asked to continuously
- 50:52play an important role in democracy resilience.
- 50:55So I think it's a very broad question that you
- 50:59need to tie to your actual work that you do.
- 51:02But I think having a good answer to your systemic
- 51:06role being part of the system is the key. We
- 51:11have quite a few questions coming through now.
- 51:13We've only got a small amount of time, so I'm
- 51:15going to run through them. And if we can give
- 51:18short succinct answers, that would be really
- 51:21useful. So, you mentioned that you are risk adverse,
- 51:25not posting content for the amount of posts or
- 51:27to fill content. How does Bellingcat keep audiences
- 51:30interested? Good articles take time, research
- 51:33and time to do it. Or in other words, how does
- 51:35Bellingcat keep working on the edge of publishing
- 51:37good content and satisfying the customer? I think
- 51:42that's a question for you to answer. Yeah, I
- 51:45was about to say that. Good editorial stuff and
- 51:51research is my answer. Yeah, in terms of making,
- 51:58I think what's unique about Bellingcat is that
- 52:02researchers generally work on things that interest
- 52:05them and that they are passionate about and that
- 52:08they care about deeply. researchers aren't just
- 52:11kind of thrown onto a beat that they're not experienced
- 52:14in or not passionate about. And I think that's
- 52:17something that really shows through in the work.
- 52:21And we are quite unique in the fact that we do,
- 52:25because we are marketed as a long form investigative
- 52:29collective, we have the ability and we have the
- 52:33expectation that we can take time with our investigations
- 52:36and that we aren't publishing something every
- 52:39single day. That luxury isn't given to you in
- 52:43mainstream news organizations. For example, at
- 52:48the BBC, they have to publish a certain amount
- 52:50of stories a day and you're not given the same
- 52:54amount of time and flexibility as you do at Bellingcat.
- 52:56So I think the luxury that we have there in terms
- 53:00of the way that the organization was initially
- 53:02set up provides us with the ability to do those
- 53:06in -depth dives. And that's what Bellingcat is
- 53:08known for. And that's what people come to us
- 53:10for. And I think that's kind of part of our selling
- 53:12points. A little follow -up to that is, is it
- 53:16an idea for Bellingcat to sponsor small and or
- 53:19local reporters not affiliated with Bellingcat
- 53:21to gain more localized content? This of course
- 53:24risks that no good research has been done or
- 53:26not be able to check slash authenticated. Think
- 53:28of reporters in North Korea or Russia. I don't
- 53:30know if you guys want to answer that specifically.
- 53:32It's more of an editorial question, but I can
- 53:35give a quick brief and then if you want to take
- 53:40it from there, Sarah. In terms of paying for
- 53:44content, there's quite a few ethical risks involved
- 53:47with that in terms of getting sold stories. If
- 53:54you do pitch to Bellingcat, you can let us know
- 53:58the story that you're looking for and we can
- 54:00work with you on that in terms of developing
- 54:03it. We don't approach individuals for content.
- 54:07Individuals approach us usually, so we don't
- 54:10have training programs for specific researchers.
- 54:16Some of the big organizations do like DW Academy,
- 54:18for example. and that sponsor kind of newsrooms
- 54:22in lots of different jurisdictions. Bellingcat
- 54:25hasn't got the resources for that. We are still
- 54:26a small not -for -profits. However, there are
- 54:30other organizations that have done that in the
- 54:32past, but there are a lot of ethical considerations
- 54:35to take into account. For example, if you listen
- 54:38to our last stage talk with Costanza, she explained
- 54:41some of the issues and why her organization never
- 54:44pays for content. So there's some considerations
- 54:47there, but Sarah, I'll pass it over to you on
- 54:48that. Yeah, I just want to quickly add that another
- 54:52way that Bell and Cat works to participate in
- 54:56localized content is through partnerships. Last
- 55:01year, there were more than 30 partnerships that
- 55:03Bell and Cat interacted with with other news
- 55:06organizations, one that sticks out very clearly
- 55:09to me. is with an organization in the United
- 55:13States called CalMatters for the state of California.
- 55:16They are a regional policy -based organization
- 55:19or a policy coverage organization. This was a
- 55:23partnership where a reporter from CalMatters
- 55:27was in Bakersfield when he experienced an ICE
- 55:30raid from the U .S. Border Patrol. And he began
- 55:35working with an additional partner, which is
- 55:38Evident Media, on telling this story. But they
- 55:41hit several blocks on how far they could take
- 55:46the investigation. And Evident already knew Bellingcat,
- 55:49and they called and they said, we need some help.
- 55:52So Bellingcat was able to partner with CalMatters
- 55:56and actually had three investigations over the
- 55:59course of a year. And this partnership was having
- 56:02multiple researchers, I believe it was five researchers
- 56:05and editorial staff, and then also seven volunteers
- 56:08from our volunteer community working with CalMatters
- 56:11on these three different investigations. So that's
- 56:14an instance where Bellingcat... you know, built
- 56:18with communities does not parachute in. And I
- 56:21think that that's a very effective means of working
- 56:23in a local context. I'm really conscious of the
- 56:27fact that we are now at time. So I just want
- 56:29to ask this final, final question about how we
- 56:32might represent if you are a member or not. So
- 56:36somebody's asked in the chat, if X has the blue
- 56:39tick, would Bellingcat offer something similar
- 56:41to show membership level, like an associate mark
- 56:45or? something like that. Is there going to be,
- 56:48you know, like in the Discord server, we have
- 56:50a little cat symbol for people that you can assign
- 56:53to your name if you want to. Is there going to
- 56:57be something like that that kind of indicates
- 56:59that you're a member, a Bill & Cat member and
- 57:02not just a passive audience member? That's a
- 57:06really great question. We're always open to new
- 57:09ideas and especially being able to share that
- 57:12people are proud of being a Bellingcat member
- 57:14in the Discord server is something I think we
- 57:17can take back to the team and work on. And yeah,
- 57:21I actually, I love that because it's also, it's
- 57:24like a bit of advocacy for Bellingcat and Pride
- 57:27and supporting the organization. Always keep
- 57:30those good ideas coming. You can email us at
- 57:32donations at bellincat .com. And thank you for
- 57:36sharing that one. That was great. Love it. Thanks.
- 57:39As has been mentioned in this talk, you can now
- 57:44get involved with the membership program at Bellincat.
- 57:48These do follow the links in the chat. I'll also
- 57:50make sure that they are within the description
- 57:53of this podcast as well if you're listening back.
- 57:56There is a list of member benefits on there and
- 57:59ways that you can get involved. And there'll
- 58:02be a lot more information coming your way from
- 58:04Bellingcat in the next few months on what you
- 58:08can do to build support for Bellingcat going
- 58:12forwards. But thank you so much, Sarah and Marika
- 58:16for coming in today and walking us through what
- 58:19membership models look like, why Bellingcat has
- 58:21adopted it. the difference between these models
- 58:26in not -for -profits and newsrooms. And we'll
- 58:29be back in two weeks' time with a stage talk
- 58:32on that leap to be the investigation that was
- 58:35just mentioned. So we'll be following up on that
- 58:39piece in two weeks' time. For now, thank you,
- 58:42everybody, and thank you for joining. Thank you
- 58:46for listening to the stage talk. If you'd like
- 58:48to catch a stage tour live where you can ask
- 58:51the guest questions, join the Bellingcat Discord
- 58:54server by visiting www .discord .gg slash Bellingcat.
- 59:01The music you've heard is titled Dawn by Newer
- 59:05Self and is courtesy of Artlist.