Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / The Two Sides of the Coin with Julián Ruiz
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, illuminating the human
- 0:06side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences and we discuss their meanings
- 0:16from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:22Disclaimer, this is a translated version using
- 0:25AI voice for the guests. Welcome to Science Behind
- 0:28the Glass, where we explore the intersection
- 0:30between economics and the environment. Today,
- 0:33we are thrilled to host an economist who is breaking
- 0:35new ground in environmental analysis. Julian
- 0:39Ruiz is an economist currently pursuing his master's
- 0:42in environmental and development at the Institute
- 0:44of Environmental Studies at the National University
- 0:47of Colombia. His research focuses on critical
- 0:50and contemporary topics, analyzing the factors
- 0:53that either limit or enhance ecological agriculture
- 0:56in a province of Boyacá, Colombia. This is not
- 1:00just an environmental issue. It is also economic
- 1:02and social, aiming to find sustainable agricultural
- 1:05paths that benefit rural communities. Julián's
- 1:09commitment to the environment goes beyond academic
- 1:11research. He works as a consultant for the Association
- 1:15Ambiente y Sociedad, where he develops and implements
- 1:19innovative community -focused methodologies.
- 1:22His mission is to assist two municipalities in
- 1:25southwestern Colombia by conducting economic
- 1:27valuations of environmental losses and damages.
- 1:30He's also a member of the editorial team of the
- 1:33magazine La Voz Agraria, a project aimed at giving
- 1:36visibility to actors in the national agrarian
- 1:39context. With an inclusive focus, this magazine
- 1:43has become a platform to amplify the voices of
- 1:45those working for Colombia's rural areas. Julian,
- 1:49thank you so much for accepting our invitation.
- 1:52Thank you for inviting me. I'm really happy to
- 1:54be here with you. Julian, let's start. Tell us.
- 1:58Being an economist, what led you to focus on
- 2:00the environment and development instead of pursuing
- 2:03a more traditional path like banking, finance,
- 2:07or earning more money? Well, I've always been
- 2:10inclined toward natural sciences and rural topics.
- 2:12When I was a child, I frequently visited a municipality
- 2:15in Boyaca called Nuevo Colón because my maternal
- 2:19family is from there. So, I had constant contact
- 2:22with nature. As time passed, I became very interested
- 2:26in social sciences and exact sciences. I found
- 2:29in economics a field that combined mathematics
- 2:31and social sciences, something that humanities
- 2:34subjects like sociology, history, and anthropology
- 2:37didn't quite offer. That's why I was drawn to
- 2:40economics. But throughout my studies, I always
- 2:43had environmental issues on my mind. Back then,
- 2:46I didn't think of it as environmental per se,
- 2:49but rather as rural or agricultural. I tried
- 2:52to incorporate subjects related to rural themes
- 2:55into my undergraduate program. For instance,
- 2:58I took a course called Structure of Agrarian
- 3:00Problems. All of this led me to consider pursuing
- 3:03a graduate degree focused on environmental issues
- 3:06instead of following the path that many of my
- 3:09peers took toward economic sciences or finance.
- 3:12My interests leaned more towards social and rural
- 3:14issues. In my faculty, the Faculty of Economic
- 3:18Sciences at the National University, I discovered
- 3:21a graduate program called Masters in Environment
- 3:23and Development. That's how I began to connect
- 3:26with these topics. Excellent. Let's continue.
- 3:29Could you explain to us a bit about what economic
- 3:31valuation means? We often hear about the economy
- 3:35in terms of growth or GDP. These are the indicators
- 3:40we usually hear about in the news, right? But
- 3:43what exactly is economic valuation? How is valuation
- 3:46applied in extreme situations, for example? Yes,
- 3:52well, that's quite a complex question. I related
- 3:55a lot to my experience entering the master's
- 3:57program. When I joined as an economist, I carried
- 4:00with me the foundation of orthodox or neoclassical
- 4:04economics, which governs how states operate globally.
- 4:07This perspective is heavily focused on economic
- 4:10growth, often tied to the idea of economic development.
- 4:14The prevailing notion is that for a country to
- 4:16become wealthier, it must produce more goods
- 4:19and services. That's the core of economic growth
- 4:23and the discourse surrounding developing and
- 4:25developed countries. This narrative largely stems
- 4:28from the global North, Europe, and the United
- 4:30States. These countries developed by accumulating
- 4:33capital and this neoclassical economic framework
- 4:36is what I was taught and what most economic schools
- 4:39teach. However, during my studies, I also encountered
- 4:43alternative perspectives, which are sometimes
- 4:45referred to as heterodox economics. The master's
- 4:48program is very multidisciplinary. It includes
- 4:51not only economists, but also lawyers, geologists,
- 4:54engineers, biologists, and professionals from
- 4:57many other disciplines. The program seeks to
- 5:00level the knowledge of those without an economics
- 5:02background, while also helping economists like
- 5:05me strengthen our understanding of natural sciences.
- 5:08Now, environmental economic valuation is grounded
- 5:11in the logic of orthodox economics, focused on
- 5:14capital accumulation. It aims to measure changes
- 5:17in social well -being. For instance, when a piece
- 5:20of infrastructure is built, a construction project
- 5:23is initiated, or a region undergoes some sort
- 5:26of transformation. These changes inevitably impact
- 5:29social welfare, and economic valuation attempts
- 5:32to quantify these impacts. Using statistical
- 5:35techniques derived from orthodox economics, this
- 5:38approach assigns a monetary value to changes
- 5:41in social welfare. So, what are the main applications
- 5:45of this valuation? It's widely used for environmental
- 5:48licensing. In Colombia, for example, licensing
- 5:52is required for projects, works, or activities
- 5:55with significant societal impact. Environmental
- 5:58economic valuation becomes a crucial tool for
- 6:01decision -making in public policies. Its main
- 6:04purpose is to assign a monetary value to assess
- 6:07and compare the costs and benefits of a project,
- 6:10considering its societal impact. In my consulting
- 6:13work with the Association Ambiente y Sociedad,
- 6:16I was hired to design a methodology that isn't
- 6:19overly technical, but is instead more community
- 6:22-oriented and participatory, specifically in
- 6:24the context of environmental losses and damages
- 6:26caused by disasters. In Putamayo, for instance,
- 6:30I am implementing this methodology in two municipalities,
- 6:33Mocoa, the department's capital, and Puerto Oasis,
- 6:37located further south. Could you share some specifics
- 6:41about what you have encountered in Mocoa? Sure.
- 6:45As many of you may know, in 2017, a landslide
- 6:49in Mocoa destroyed much of the city, leaving
- 6:52numerous victims. At that time, the government
- 6:55provided monetary aid, built some houses, and
- 6:59offered economic assistance. In my work, I've
- 7:02engaged with about 15 people who were directly
- 7:04affected. One key realization is how the state
- 7:07viewed these losses and damages. They focused
- 7:10solely on the immediate aftermath. How many homes
- 7:14were lost, how many lives were taken, and how
- 7:17many people became ill. They aimed to resolve
- 7:19those figures. But losses and damages are far
- 7:22more complex. Seven years later, we're still
- 7:25seeing consequences that were not accounted for
- 7:28back then. The methodologies used didn't include
- 7:31aspects like mental health. For example, many
- 7:34affected individuals from rural areas were relocated
- 7:37to small urban houses. These people underwent
- 7:40significant cultural and behavioral changes.
- 7:42They could no longer farm or cultivate their
- 7:45land. Instead, they found themselves confined
- 7:48to four walls, which led to numerous conflicts.
- 7:51All those changes brought a host of challenges.
- 7:54As you can see, these are complex issues that
- 7:57are difficult to analyze and traditional valuation
- 8:00methods don't capture the full picture. Recognizing
- 8:03this complexity, a new approach has emerged within
- 8:06environmental economic valuation called integral
- 8:09valuation. Integral valuation argues that we
- 8:12can't limit ourselves to assigning a monetary
- 8:15value alone. Instead, we must incorporate additional
- 8:18concepts to make the valuation more comprehensive
- 8:21and reflective of the real situation. This means
- 8:24including monetary, ecological, and social dimensions.
- 8:28For the ecological aspects, This isn't my area
- 8:31of expertise, but there are methodologies like
- 8:34environmental impact assessments and other ways
- 8:37to measure natural losses and damages. For the
- 8:39social side, ethnography plays a significant
- 8:42role. That's what I've been doing in my work,
- 8:44listening to the community and documenting their
- 8:47experiences of losses and damages through in
- 8:50-depth, semi -structured interviews. Using these
- 8:53methods, I collect detailed information and analyze
- 8:56it to understand the broader impacts. It's not
- 8:59about generating statistics or graphs, but rather
- 9:02using ethnographic techniques to grasp the human
- 9:05aspect of the issue. From these interviews, we
- 9:08derive qualitative insights into the value of
- 9:11these losses. While it's not a numerical value,
- 9:13it provides a richer understanding of the affected
- 9:16community's perspective. That's fascinating.
- 9:19But what challenges have you encountered with
- 9:21this approach? One challenge is that economic
- 9:24valuation often struggles with ambiguity and
- 9:28subjectivity. For example, let's say we're valuing
- 9:31a tree. Each of us might perceive its value differently.
- 9:35Linda might see sentimental value in it. Daniel
- 9:38might think it's unimportant, and I might value
- 9:41it for its shade. Another issue is that some
- 9:43things are simply incalculable. In Putamayo,
- 9:47for instance, there's a significant Inga indigenous
- 9:49community in Mokoa. They spoke about sacred sites
- 9:53that were damaged after the landslide or affected
- 9:55by tourism. These sites hold immense spiritual
- 9:59value for them, and that's not something you
- 10:01can quantify. Remember taking a course on environmental
- 10:05economics where we discussed methods for assessing
- 10:08economic value through resources. For instance,
- 10:11calculating the value of a forest by measuring
- 10:14how much CO2 it captures and comparing the cost
- 10:17of maintaining it versus exploiting it. Yes,
- 10:21I remember that after Mokwa disaster, I heard
- 10:24about someone who had planted many trees along
- 10:27the stream. Their properties suffered far less
- 10:31damage compared to the areas that were deforest.
- 10:34Those trees serve as a natural protection, which
- 10:37demonstrates the need to think about long -term
- 10:41strategies rather than short -term gains. Exactly.
- 10:45Those types of calculations are common. But often...
- 10:48they fail to consider long -term impacts, both
- 10:51environmental and economic. That's a great point,
- 10:54but it seems like many environmental impact assessments
- 10:56remain overly qualitative, especially in industries
- 11:01like mining. What more effective alternatives
- 11:04exist to measure environmental and social impacts,
- 11:07and how has this evolved in recent years? Well,
- 11:11there's been progress in response to critiques
- 11:13of traditional assessment methods. For instance,
- 11:16There's a method called contingent valuation
- 11:18that involves directly asking communities about
- 11:21their willingness to pay to resolve an environmental
- 11:24issue or their minimum willingness to accept
- 11:27compensation for environmental damages. But this
- 11:29method isn't always effective. When I tried applying
- 11:32it in my work, asking people about their willingness
- 11:35to pay, they responded, why should we pay? The
- 11:38state should compensate us. And they had a point.
- 11:41This is where integral valuation comes into play.
- 11:44It incorporates ethnographic and social science
- 11:47methods to assign value in ways that traditional
- 11:50economic models cannot. There are also other
- 11:53methodologies and matrices commonly used, such
- 11:56as those employed by Columbia's Ministry of Environment.
- 11:58These tools attempt to integrate social aspects
- 12:01because, in the end, they are crucial for providing
- 12:04a more comprehensive valuation. However, it's
- 12:08important to understand that these phenomena
- 12:09are inherently complex, much like the environment
- 12:13itself. In the master's program, we often reference
- 12:16the concept developed by Augusto Angel Maya,
- 12:20one of the founders of the program and a prominent
- 12:22Colombian environmental thinker. He described
- 12:24the environment as a relationship between ecosystems
- 12:27and culture. From that relationship emerges everything
- 12:32we consider environmental. He emphasized that
- 12:35environmental issues are not limited to socioeconomic
- 12:38or sociopolitical concerns. They're fundamentally
- 12:41about the interaction between ecosystems and
- 12:44culture. People often think of the environment
- 12:47in purely ecological terms, mountains, trees,
- 12:50forests, but it also encompasses social and economic
- 12:53elements. It's about understanding that we, as
- 12:57human beings, are part of nature, not separate
- 13:00from it. That's a beautiful way to put it. How
- 13:04do you see this idea influencing policy or initiatives
- 13:07in Colombia today? In our current context and
- 13:11with the current government, there's a bit of
- 13:12an opening for organizations like the one I work
- 13:15with, which embraces a critical perspective on
- 13:17environmental issues. This is why they hired
- 13:20me, because they recognized the limitations of
- 13:22traditional economic valuation methods used by
- 13:25entities like ANLA, National Authority for Environmental
- 13:29Licenses. They understood that something more
- 13:31was needed. That's excellent. Speaking of growth
- 13:34and development, just recently the Nobel Prize
- 13:36in Economics was awarded to researchers studying
- 13:39why some countries grow more than others and
- 13:43the origins of inequality. Why do you think there
- 13:46is such resistance to changing the way we measure
- 13:50development, growth, and well -being, especially
- 13:53when it's traditionally tied to GDP? This ties
- 13:56back to what we discussed earlier about economic
- 13:59models. Economics, like any science, has schools
- 14:02of thought. The dominant one is the neoclassical
- 14:05school, which places significant emphasis on
- 14:08economic growth. The key indicator for many public
- 14:11policies is GDP, which measures the total goods
- 14:15and services produced in a country within a year.
- 14:18However, there's been growing criticism of GDP
- 14:21as a measure of well -being. New indicators are
- 14:24being developed to incorporate social variables,
- 14:27like unpaid domestic work, often carried out
- 14:30by women. Certainly. This approach includes a
- 14:41feminist perspective highlighting activities
- 14:43like domestic work and caregiving, which have
- 14:46historically been unrecognized and unpaid, even
- 14:49though they contribute significantly to the economy.
- 14:52People who directly contribute to GDP, like entrepreneurs,
- 14:56depend on this unpaid labor. Recognizing these
- 14:59overlooked variables is crucial for creating
- 15:02more inclusive economic models. That's such an
- 15:05important point. You have also mentioned how
- 15:07the Global South is trying to reshape these narratives.
- 15:12Could you share your perspective on how Latin
- 15:14America is redefining concepts of growth and
- 15:17development? Absolutely. In the Global South,
- 15:21particularly in Latin America, there's an effort
- 15:23to rethink these ideas. Institutions like CIPOL,
- 15:27Economic Commission for Latin America and the
- 15:30Caribbean are leading the way in questioning
- 15:32traditional development narratives. For example,
- 15:35the term developing countries is widely used,
- 15:38but its implications haven't been deeply explored.
- 15:41In industrialized nations, development has historically
- 15:44revolved around the production of goods and services.
- 15:47Meanwhile, in Latin America, our history of colonization
- 15:52disrupted ancestral practices that didn't prioritize
- 15:55accumulation. This raises critical questions.
- 15:58What do we mean by development? Is it tied to
- 16:02industrialization and accumulation, or can it
- 16:05be rooted in the unique knowledge and values
- 16:07of each community? It's time to challenge the
- 16:10global economic framework that dismisses anything
- 16:13outside of industrialized models as underdeveloped.
- 16:16There are aspects of these discussions that I
- 16:19find particularly interesting. Take Argentina,
- 16:22for example, where President Javier Maileai a
- 16:25very radical figure, has sparked intense debates,
- 16:28especially on social and gender issues. He's
- 16:31implementing policies that I find unique, even
- 16:34experimental. What's distinctive about economics
- 16:37is that its laboratory is society itself. Unlike
- 16:41natural sciences, where experiments are conducted
- 16:44in controlled environments, economics implements
- 16:47policies and observes their outcomes in real
- 16:49life. Fascinating way to put it. Can you tell
- 16:53us more about Millet's approach and its implications?
- 16:56He's trying to drastically reduce the size of
- 16:59the state, aiming for the economy and market
- 17:01to regulate themselves. From the beginning, he
- 17:04announced plans to eliminate several ministries,
- 17:07arguing that sectors like sports and education
- 17:10should operate independently under market forces,
- 17:13driven by supply and demand. He identifies as
- 17:16an anarcho -capitalist, anarcho because he advocates
- 17:19for a minimal state, and capitalist because he
- 17:22believes in the market's ability to regulate
- 17:24everything. While this is an interesting experiment,
- 17:27it raises significant concerns. For example,
- 17:30while he may have managed to reduce inflation,
- 17:33it's essential to ask, at what cost? That's a
- 17:37critical question. What have been the consequences
- 17:39of these policies? From what I have observed,
- 17:42poverty has increased significantly, by nearly
- 17:4550%. Additionally, he's cut funding for basic
- 17:48scientific research. arguing that research should
- 17:51have immediate practical applications. Institutions
- 17:54like CONICET, a major research hub in Latin America,
- 17:58have been particularly affected. Scientists and
- 18:01academics even wrote an open letter opposing
- 18:03these cuts, emphasizing the long -term importance
- 18:06of research for economic and social growth. Millet
- 18:09has also removed subsidies for essential utilities
- 18:13like electricity and water. Essentially, he's
- 18:16letting the economy run on its own to see what
- 18:19happens. But again, the question is, at what
- 18:21expense? And that highlights a common challenge.
- 18:26When the market is left entirely unregulated,
- 18:29inequalities tend to grow. Those who have more
- 18:33gain more, while those with less fall farther
- 18:36behind. Exactly. That's why contrasting approaches,
- 18:40like those of Colombia's current president, Gustavo
- 18:42Petro, are interesting. Petro advocates for the
- 18:46state to take a more active role, reaching historically
- 18:49neglected areas to provide education, health
- 18:52care, and other essential services. It's a stark
- 18:55contrast to Miley I's approach. It's fascinating
- 18:58that both leaders are economists, yet they take
- 19:01such different approaches. Yes, it shows how
- 19:04economics is deeply embedded in society and can
- 19:08be interpreted in various ways. What's crucial
- 19:11is having decision -makers who understand environmental
- 19:13issues. For instance, President Petro has an
- 19:17environmental perspective, having pursued studies
- 19:19in the field, though he didn't graduate because
- 19:22he resisted incorporating statistical methods
- 19:24like econometrics into his thesis. Economics,
- 19:28after all, is historically a social science.
- 19:31The integration of statistics has formalized
- 19:33it, but Petro's stance highlights the importance
- 19:36of diverse approaches to understanding economic
- 19:38phenomena. That's a valuable insight. It also
- 19:41underscores the need for collaboration across
- 19:43disciplines, something Petro has been criticized
- 19:46for and not always achieving. Building on what
- 19:50you have mentioned about the economic growth
- 19:53and environment responsibility, we often hear
- 19:56critics of GDP as an incomplete measure. For
- 20:00example, it often ignores inequality and environmental
- 20:03damage. Meanwhile, wealthier countries tend to
- 20:07externalize environmental costs to developing
- 20:10countries. What changes could make economic growth
- 20:14fairer and more equitable in a globalized world?
- 20:17This is a crucial issue. I recently attended
- 20:19the COP Biodiversity and Climate Change Conference
- 20:22in Cali, where this topic was discussed. The
- 20:25debate focused on the disproportionate responsibility
- 20:28that certain countries have for emissions. Countries
- 20:31like the United States, Australia, And many in
- 20:34Europe contribute far more to global pollution
- 20:36than nations like Colombia or others in Latin
- 20:39America, Africa, or Asia. So the question is,
- 20:43how do we address this imbalance? Their responsibility
- 20:46cannot be the same as ours. But what about the
- 20:50role of multinational corporations? They often
- 20:54operate in developing countries with minimal
- 20:56oversight. That's another layer of complexity.
- 20:59Many multinational corporations exploit resources
- 21:02in our territories under the guise of development.
- 21:05For example, in Colombia, Canadian mining companies
- 21:09extract our minerals, creating significant environmental
- 21:12and social conflicts. Take Mocoa, for instance.
- 21:16There's a Canadian company, LiberoCobra, that's
- 21:19been eyeing the region for years because the
- 21:21area is rich in minerals like copper and nickel,
- 21:24what they call green transition minerals. With
- 21:27the push for energy transitions, their interest
- 21:29has only intensified. It's created deep divisions.
- 21:33Many people oppose these activities, but local
- 21:36power structures, such as mayors, are often co
- 21:39-opted by these companies, exacerbating social
- 21:41tensions. This continues the historical pattern
- 21:45of treating our territories as resources to be
- 21:47exploited. While it's essential for communities
- 21:50to adopt more sustainable practices, the greater
- 21:53responsibility lies with these companies in their
- 21:56home countries. which must rethink their consumption
- 21:59and production models. But changing habits isn't
- 22:02easy. How can individuals start addressing these
- 22:05challenges? Our habits are deeply cultural and
- 22:08challenging to change. However, every small action
- 22:12counts. Even something as simple as recycling
- 22:15contributes to the broader goal of sustainability.
- 22:18In Bogota, for example, there's been a surge
- 22:20in urban farming initiatives. People are composting
- 22:24organic kitchen waste. and using it in community
- 22:26gardens. These small changes help shift mindsets
- 22:29and encourage more sustainable practices. But
- 22:33the most difficult shift is moving away from
- 22:35a culture of accumulation. Even those with strong
- 22:38environmental awareness feel the temptation to
- 22:40acquire more. A car, gadget, something new. It's
- 22:44normal, but finding balance is key. Living with
- 22:47less and adopting sustainable alternatives, like
- 22:50cycling instead of driving, can make a real difference.
- 22:54That's such a crucial point. Speaking of the
- 22:56energy transition, what about the exploitation
- 22:58of resources for the so -called green energy?
- 23:02Isn't there a risk of repeating the same mistakes
- 23:05of over -extraction? The energy transition has
- 23:08a significant downside. Resources for renewable
- 23:11technologies like solar panels and batteries
- 23:14still rely on extractive practices. And in many
- 23:17cases, the recycling of these materials hasn't
- 23:20been prioritized. For example, in Australia,
- 23:23there's been an accumulation of unused solar
- 23:25panels because recycling systems are insufficient.
- 23:28Instead of addressing this, the focus shifts
- 23:31to mining new resources, even exploring deep
- 23:33-sea mining. This approach risks creating one
- 23:37environmental issue for another. Yeah, so it's
- 23:40essentially the same capitalistic logic applied
- 23:42to renewable energy. Exactly. Many companies
- 23:46involved in the green transition still operate
- 23:49under the same frameworks of capital accumulation
- 23:51and exploitation. Without systemic changes, we
- 23:56risk falling into the same patterns, albeit under
- 23:59a different name. That's a way to transit to
- 24:02a growing discourse around economic models like
- 24:05the growth. Economists like Kohei Sato from Japan
- 24:09and Mariana Mazzucato from Italy are gaining
- 24:11traction with ideas that challenge the prevailing
- 24:14economic framework. Do you think concepts like
- 24:17degrowth could generally benefit both society
- 24:20and the environment? Absolutely. Degrowth is
- 24:24a critical concept to explore, especially in
- 24:26the context of transitions, whether energy or
- 24:29agri -food transitions. The idea of transition
- 24:33itself is positive because it implies a shift
- 24:36away from existing unsustainable models. For
- 24:39instance, renewable energy projects in low -income
- 24:42communities can be transformative. providing
- 24:44opportunities for self -sufficiency. But we must
- 24:48be cautious about how these transitions are managed.
- 24:51Take energy transitions, for example. While renewable
- 24:54energy can empower communities, the capitalist
- 24:57market tends to co -opt these initiatives. Terms
- 25:00like green or sustainable are often used to commercialize
- 25:04solutions that may not address deeper structural
- 25:06issues. Similarly, in the agri -food sector,
- 25:10there's increasing interest in ecological farming
- 25:13practices. While agroecology promotes sustainability,
- 25:17large corporations that previously sold agrochemicals
- 25:20are now marketing green products under certifications
- 25:23that small and medium farmers can't afford. But
- 25:26there are alternatives that can empower smaller
- 25:28producers. For example, participatory guarantee
- 25:31systems, SPGs, are a promising alternative. These
- 25:36allow communities to self -certify their ecological
- 25:39practices, bypassing the expensive and often
- 25:43exclusionary formal certification processes.
- 25:45These alternatives are beginning to gain official
- 25:48recognition from governments and institutions.
- 25:51This ties into the broader conversation about
- 25:53degrowth. By challenging the idea that growth
- 25:56is always necessary, we can reimagine economies
- 26:00that prioritize well -being over accumulation.
- 26:03That's powerful, but degrowth can be a controversial
- 26:07concept. What challenges do you see in promoting
- 26:10it? The biggest challenge is cultural. Our societies
- 26:13are deeply conditioned to equate development
- 26:16with growth and accumulation. The person with
- 26:19three apartments and four cars is seen as successful.
- 26:22But is that really development? Degrowth invites
- 26:25us to rethink this narrative. Take Colombia as
- 26:28an example. Irene Velez, the Minister of Mines,
- 26:32mentioned degrowth about six months into her
- 26:34term, and the backlash was immediate. Critics
- 26:37claimed she didn't understand economics. and
- 26:40some even called for her resignation. It shows
- 26:42how deeply ingrained the growth mindset is. It's
- 26:46almost existential, isn't it? These are philosophical
- 26:49questions at their core. They force us to ask,
- 26:52what is the purpose of life? Some philosophical
- 26:55traditions argue that happiness is the ultimate
- 26:58goal. But what makes us happy? The prevailing
- 27:01narrative suggests that happiness comes from
- 27:03having more things. But what if that's not true?
- 27:06Degrowth challenges us to consider these questions.
- 27:10It's not just about economic or environmental
- 27:12changes. It's about rethinking how we live and
- 27:15what we value. It's exciting to see these conversations
- 27:18gaining traction. 20 years ago, this kind of
- 27:22discussion wasn't as common, right? Back then,
- 27:25there were few platforms for these ideas. Today,
- 27:28more people are questioning traditional models,
- 27:30and spaces like this podcast are essential for
- 27:33fostering those conversations. Another critical
- 27:36issue tied to this is climate change. Its impacts
- 27:40are far -reaching, affecting sectors like agriculture
- 27:43and infrastructure. Recent studies like one from
- 27:47the University of Chicago highlight how traditional
- 27:49models underestimate the long -term cost of climate
- 27:52change. From your perspective, how can valuation
- 27:55methodologies better reflect this impact? This
- 27:58connects strongly to my work. Climate change
- 28:01has profound... long -term effects that aren't
- 28:04always visible immediately. Losses and damages
- 28:07extend over decades, which is why we need methodologies
- 28:12that capture this complexity. For instance, after
- 28:15the 2017 Mokoa disaster, the government provided
- 28:18immediate aid, but it didn't account for long
- 28:21-term consequences like mental health issues
- 28:23or cultural shifts. Relocated rural residents
- 28:26had to adapt to urban lifestyles, losing their
- 28:29connection to the land. These changes created
- 28:32conflicts and deeply affected well -being. So,
- 28:35traditional valuation methods fall short in addressing
- 28:38these broader impacts. That's why integral valuation
- 28:42is so important. It combines economic, ecological,
- 28:46and social dimensions, offering a more holistic
- 28:49understanding. For example, mental health is
- 28:52often overlooked in traditional valuations, yet
- 28:55it's a significant consequence of climate change.
- 28:58After disasters like the Mokoa landslide, the
- 29:01stress of relocation and adapting to new environments
- 29:04led to increased anxiety and depression among
- 29:07affected communities. This is why incorporating
- 29:10social sciences into environmental evaluations
- 29:13is crucial. Through methods like ethnographic
- 29:16studies and community engagement, we can better
- 29:19understand the full scope of these impacts. That's
- 29:22a compelling perspective. Could you share more
- 29:25about the practical challenges you have faced
- 29:28in implementing these methodologies? One of the
- 29:30challenges is addressing ecosystem -specific
- 29:33issues. For instance, in Puerto Assis, a town
- 29:37south of Mocoa, the problem isn't a past disaster,
- 29:40but the current exploitation of wetlands and
- 29:43rivers. People build on wetlands, causing flooding
- 29:46and other environmental problems. To address
- 29:49this, it's essential to consider the ecological
- 29:51dimension in planning. This includes understanding
- 29:54the role of biological corridors and using tools
- 29:58like territorial planning frameworks to determine
- 30:00safe distances for construction near rivers.
- 30:03Unfortunately, these frameworks are not widely
- 30:06applied in practice, not always. While plans
- 30:09like Colombia's Plains de Ornaminoterritorial,
- 30:12territorial development plans, exist, they're
- 30:15often ignored, especially in vulnerable ecosystems.
- 30:19This leads to high risk situations and unnecessary
- 30:22environmental degradation. Not prioritizing prevention
- 30:25over reaction is a recurring issue. Governments
- 30:29often focus on recovery after disasters instead
- 30:32of investing in mitigation or adaptation. For
- 30:35instance, it's easy to declare certain areas
- 30:38as off limits for construction, but without offering
- 30:41viable alternatives, the problem persists. Investing
- 30:45in adaptation and mitigation measures It can
- 30:50reduce the need for subsidies or rebuilding after
- 30:53disasters. That ties back to the importance of
- 30:56education. Environmental education is a cornerstone
- 30:59of these efforts. By teaching communities about
- 31:02ecosystem cycles and the consequences of their
- 31:05actions, we can empower them to make more sustainable
- 31:09choices. This education should start early in
- 31:12schools and local communities. ensuring that
- 31:15people understand what can and cannot be done
- 31:17in certain ecosystems. Ultimately, this not only
- 31:21benefits the environment, but also saves governments
- 31:24significant costs in recovery and restoration
- 31:26efforts. William, thank you very much for joining
- 31:29us today. This conversation has been incredible
- 31:32and enlightening, especially for those of us
- 31:35coming from the natural sciences. Your insights
- 31:38have been very valuable. As we wrap up, what
- 31:41message would you like to leave? To our listeners,
- 31:45I encourage you to reflect on your daily habits.
- 31:47Ask yourself, what am I investing my time and
- 31:50money in? How does my work or lifestyle impact
- 31:53the environment and ecosystem around me? It's
- 31:57crucial to understand the ecosystems we live
- 31:59in, their risks, and how we can contribute to
- 32:02positive change. Each small action, whether recycling
- 32:05or adopting more sustainable habits, plays a
- 32:08part in mitigating climate change. Thank you
- 32:11again, Julian, for sharing your expertise. Thank
- 32:14you for having me. This has been a truly enriching
- 32:17conversation. Today's episode explored the delicate
- 32:19balance between economic progress and environment
- 32:22preservation. We hope it inspired you to think
- 32:25about how individual actions and systemic changes
- 32:27can align to create a more sustainable future.
- 32:31Don't forget to follow us on social media and
- 32:33share this podcast with friends. If you have
- 32:36been inspired by our mission, consider supporting
- 32:38us through PayPal via our website. Every contribution
- 32:42helps us to keep this project alive and growing.
- 32:45Stay curious, stay inspired, and always seek
- 32:48the human side behind every discovery. Thanks
- 32:51for being part of our journey. Until the next
- 32:54time.