Latest / MBA Training Marketing / Getting CAC and LTV honest before scaling
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Leaders Insights Podcast.
- 0:07Today's episode, Getting Cac and LTV Honest Before Scaling.
- 0:11Every quarter I watch a startup torch its series B on paid ads, then act shocked when
- 0:16the money evaporates.
- 0:17Why does this keep happening?
- 0:19Because they scaled on numbers that were flattering, not honest.
- 0:23The article puts it bluntly, most growth failures trace back to one mistake.
- 0:29Staying on metrics that look right but are calculated wrong.
- 0:32Your CAC and your LTV are lying to you before you spend a dime.
- 0:36Spell those out for the people who skip the acronyms.
- 0:39Z-TIE CAC is customer acquisition cost.
- 0:43What you actually pay to land one paying customer, LTV is lifetime value.
- 0:48The total profit that customer throws off before they walk.
- 0:51The whole game is spending less to get them than they're worth.
- 0:55Simple.
- 0:56Almost nobody does the arithmetic straight.
- 0:58Where's the first place they cheat, even if they don't mean to?
- 1:02The CAC denominator.
- 1:04Founders divide ad spend by all new customers, including the ones referrals and organic search
- 1:09brought in for free.
- 1:11That drags the number down artificially.
- 1:14Strip out the free ones.
- 1:15Your paid CAC is the only figure that tells you whether the ad channel actually works.
- 1:20I've seen a blended CAC of $40 hide a real paid CAC of $140.
- 1:25And the salaries?
- 1:26The tools?
- 1:27Do those count?
- 1:28They should.
- 1:29Fully loaded CAC includes the marketing team's pay, the software subscriptions, the agency
- 1:35retainer, HubSpot's benchmarking data, and yes, that's a CRM vendor.
- 1:40So they have skin in making CAC look manageable.
- 1:44Still shows fully loaded costs running 30 to 50% above raw ad spend.
- 1:49If you're only counting media, you're pricing a car by the tires.
- 1:52Fine.
- 1:53Now the fun one.
- 1:54LTV is where everybody inflates, right?
- 1:57LTV is where the fiction gets creative.
- 2:00Two crimes.
- 2:01First, people use revenue instead of gross profit.
- 2:04So an LTV of $900 is really $300 once you subtract the cost of actually serving the
- 2:10customer.
- 2:11Second, they assume customers stay forever.
- 2:15They divide by a churn rate.
- 2:17The share of customers who cancel each month that they measured during a honeymoon cohort
- 2:21before the product got crowded.
- 2:23Give me a number that shows how badly that bites.
- 2:26Today, your monthly churn is 5%.
- 2:29That implies an average customer life of 20 months.
- 2:32But if real churn creeps to 8%, which happens the second you scale into worst-fit buyers,
- 2:38your average life drops to 12 and a half months.
- 2:41That's not a rounding error.
- 2:42Your LTV just fell by nearly 40% and you built the whole ad budget on the old figure.
- 2:48So the honest LTV is always lower.
- 2:50Isn't that just pessimism dressed up as rigor?
- 2:53It's pessimism that keeps you solvent.
- 2:55The article's point is you build the trustworthy numbers before you commit budget.
- 3:00Not after the board asks why the runway's gone.
- 3:03And here's the trap.
- 3:04Early paid customers are your cheapest and stickiest.
- 3:07As you scale, CAC rises and LTV falls at the same time.
- 3:12The ratio that looked like 3 to 1 at small scale collapses to 1.2 at large scale.
- 3:18What's the ratio people should actually hold themselves to?
- 3:21LTV to CAC of 3 to 1 is the old rule of thumb.
- 3:25And it's fine.
- 3:27But only if both numbers are honest.
- 3:28I'd rather see a founder with a real 2.5 that they trust than a fantasy 5 they can't
- 3:34reproduce and measure the payback period.
- 3:37How many months until the customer's gross profit repays what you spent to get them.
- 3:42Under 12 months, you can scale.
- 3:44Past 18, you're financing growth with hope.
- 3:47So if someone's about to pour money into acquisition next week, what's the one thing they do
- 3:51first?
- 3:52Rebuild both numbers from scratch right now.
- 3:55Paid CAC only.
- 3:56WOAT.
- 3:57Free customers stripped out, salaries and tools in.
- 3:59LTV on gross profit using your last 90 days of real churn, not the honeymoon cohort.
- 4:07If the ratio survives that scrub and payback lands under a year, open the taps.
- 4:12If it doesn't, you just saved yourself a very expensive lesson.
- 4:16Honest math before honest scaling.
- 4:18Nobody wants to hear it, which is exactly why it works.
- 4:21That's your 5.
- 4:22The full CMO track, structured, no fluff, is at MBA-training.com.