Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA's Supervisory Priority Letter with Farrar & Miller Part 1
Transcript
- 0:35Mark Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another episode of
- 0:37With Flying Colors, and this is our third annual NCUA Letter to Credit
- 0:43Unions on Exam Supervision, Supervisory Priorities, or Exam Priorities, the
- 0:49letter, as I like to call it, which comes out every January, and I'm excited to
- 0:53have two of my team members here that I've worked with at NCUA for a long time
- 0:58and have helped me here on the podcast and have helped Help me with the clients
- 1:03that we have throughout credit unions.
- 1:05And I want to introduce them.
- 1:07If you haven't, they haven't been on the podcast unless it was a rerun
- 1:10that I reran because it was so good.
- 1:11They haven't been on the podcast last couple of months.
- 1:13And 1st up we're joined by Steve far.
- 1:16Steve, could you give yourself a little bit of an intro on what you did at N.
- 1:20C.
- 1:20U.
- 1:20A.
- 1:20for those new listeners who may not have heard some of the older podcasts.
- 1:22Steve Farrar: Oh, great.
- 1:23Yeah, glad to be back for the year three.
- 1:25Interesting year last year and we'll see what happens next
- 1:28that has this coming year.
- 1:29But I spent 32 years in NCOA and half of it was working in region,
- 1:35the western region, and most of that was as a problem case officer.
- 1:40Which was really good to get well rounded and strengthen operations.
- 1:44Then I spent the last half of my career in the central office working on problem
- 1:49resolution on a more national basis.
- 1:51And then towards the end of my career, I was the vice president of
- 1:54the Central Liquidity Facility and worked a long time on the risk based
- 2:00Todd Miller: capital role.
- 2:02Mark Treichel: Long time on the risk based capital rule, got it ready for prime time.
- 2:05And then politics took a little while longer after you retired for basically
- 2:10that rule to get approved as you had drafted it before, before you left.
- 2:15So Steve and I worked together at many of those stops he mentioned there.
- 2:20And anyway, so with that, I'm gonna Pivot to Todd Miller.
- 2:24Todd, could you give a little intro of your background at NCUA?
- 2:29Todd Miller: Didn't realize it until just now, but I beat Steve by two years.
- 2:32I was with NCUA for 34 years roughly the same time as Steve.
- 2:37Steve, I retired in 2021.
- 2:40During my career, the first 10 years, you can say I was an
- 2:43examiner and a problem case officer.
- 2:45The middle 10 years.
- 2:46I was a capital market specialist from 2000 to 2010.
- 2:50And then the last 11 years of my career, I spent it as a director of
- 2:54special actions, supervising problem case officers and capital markets.
- 2:59Around 2010.
- 3:00That was a great recession.
- 3:02So I had a couple of very busy years there as a director of special actions.
- 3:07Unfortunately, there's a few credits in the western region didn't survive that
- 3:12we can serve to quite a few of them.
- 3:131 of them return to the members.
- 3:15So that was quite a good experience to be able to fix accrediting
- 3:19and return it to his members.
- 3:21But I had 34 good years with enjoy every bit
- 3:24Mark Treichel: of it.
- 3:26You and me both.
- 3:27And you beat me by four months.
- 3:28I was 33 years and eight months.
- 3:31So you are the longevity winner at NCOA, at least for us
- 3:35three, at least for us three.
- 3:37All right, guys.
- 3:37There are seven priorities.
- 3:40Well, I've plus two other mentions that we're going to walk through here today
- 3:44compared to the last couple of years.
- 3:46And for the most part, we'll walk through them in order of what they're
- 3:50listed at in the NCUA letter, although we may pull interest rate risk up for
- 3:55a discussion along with liquidity.
- 3:58But first out of the gate in NCUA's letter, is credit risk.
- 4:02And as a reminder of where that was previously last year, credit risk was list
- 4:08third and in 2022 it was rated first in order and in order doesn't necessarily
- 4:17but it does mean something because you want to put first what's most important.
- 4:21Number one, 2024 NCUA's priorities for the examination is credit risk.
- 4:26What are your thoughts relative to that topic and how it relates
- 4:31to credit unions for 2024?
- 4:33Yeah,
- 4:36Steve Farrar: I'll take a look.
- 4:36I looked at some of the numbers and, the trends, definitely show.
- 4:41And a weakening of credit quality, which was expected as inflation
- 4:45started to impact people's income and decisions that they had to make
- 4:50the another important item is you start looking at credit risk is.
- 4:54In the opening of the letter, they talk about their concern about the
- 4:58increase in assets in Camel 3 and above.
- 5:02And that is, you can generally can be reflective of it.
- 5:05Anytime you have increases in delinquency, it's going to affect Camel codes.
- 5:09And then there were, there was a kind of a shh.
- 5:11Fairly sharp increase in the provision for loss expense, which would have
- 5:15been, of course, affecting earnings.
- 5:18So that part is also part of what's caused this concern with the credit
- 5:24unions with the camel codes of 3 and above, especially some of the larger
- 5:28ones, but you just can't ignore that.
- 5:31So many of the loan types show trends in increasing delinquency, credit
- 5:36cards being one and junior liens, the kind of the unsecured products are
- 5:42showing the most weakness that I could
- 5:43Mark Treichel: see.
- 5:45Interesting.
- 5:45Todd Miller: There's a couple more pieces to that.
- 5:47Prior to the thought podcast, I went on Fred's and I pulled down some numbers
- 5:52just on income growth, median income growth and where inflation is and
- 5:57really for the last pretty much since June of 2021, consumers are getting
- 6:03behind while unemployment is low.
- 6:05If you look at income growth, it's actually lagging behind inflation.
- 6:10Realistically, for two and a half years, consumers are in a worse position on a
- 6:14median, and I think it probably affects the lower income people, maybe higher
- 6:18than folks in those higher income tiers, and there's always a lag effect to this.
- 6:24If you look at quarterly numbers last year, March actually
- 6:27looked better than year end.
- 6:29So all that deterioration Steve talked about has really
- 6:32happened from March to December.
- 6:35If you look at the references that NCUA made, There are the
- 6:40attachments to the letters.
- 6:42They're all a referral back to credit risk fundamentals.
- 6:46There's stuff that was published.
- 6:48At or before that last recession.
- 6:50So they're really directing people, Hey, let's go back to credit
- 6:54risk management fundamentals.
- 6:56They have a right to be concerned.
- 6:58When we go for two years and consumers are falling farther behind inflation,
- 7:03and then you combine that with rising interest rates, it's going to be harder
- 7:07on borrowers and unemployment the press tells you it's all time lows.
- 7:13That's kind of true.
- 7:14It's actually been inching up during 2023, and there's really a
- 7:18wide disparity around the country.
- 7:19You've got places that are at 1.
- 7:239%.
- 7:24And then you've got other states that are hitting five and a half.
- 7:27And our large population states, California, New York, Texas,
- 7:31those guys are in the four.
- 7:33Behind that one gross number, you've There's little bubblings of problems
- 7:37here and there around the country.
- 7:38And, NCUA has a right to be scared of credit risk.
- 7:42We've all read articles of what's going on with commercial real estate and potential
- 7:46vacancies there and a crumbling there.
- 7:50That's what causes the agency.
- 7:52Large chunks of money is deteriorating credit risk, a little fraud here and
- 7:56there, but credit risk is the big one.
- 7:58And there's lots of signs that the consumers are.
- 8:03Struggling.
- 8:05Mark Treichel: And I think Todd in a call with a client recently, you
- 8:10might have talked about how it was the sand states in 0809, right?
- 8:14And recessions don't happen uniformly.
- 8:17And so some of the numbers you just cited would link to that,
- 8:20that we're going to start seeing pressure points in different areas.
- 8:24And then another thing that was touched on I was listening to an economist
- 8:28walking today and they were saying that actually unemployment rate went
- 8:31up when you adjust for those that are dropping out of the workforce.
- 8:34Right?
- 8:35And so you've got all of those different, different things interacting and
- 8:40then piggybacking off of some things Steve said tied to, the delinquency
- 8:44going up in different things.
- 8:46I think about how the delay.
- 8:49Yeah.
- 8:49For implementing Cecil was something that politically was things Cecil
- 8:53was talked about for several years, and it was delayed, delayed, delayed.
- 8:56And then by the time it all came forward to having to book that
- 9:01you also had other real issues.
- 9:03So it was kind of like a double whammy and how much of this is Cecil
- 9:06and how much of it is delinquency and in all that I don't know.
- 9:09And I don't I'm not expecting you to know those numbers there, but you've
- 9:13kind of got all these different things mixing together and the condition of the.
- 9:18Borrowers and the lower income folks that are impacted by inflation, et cetera.
- 9:23It's going to be.
- 9:24An interesting 2024, but I don't expect to see the numbers getting
- 9:28better anytime soon in that regard.
- 9:31Todd Miller: CECL is an interesting comment because, there's a ratio
- 9:35on the FPR of your allowance to delinquency, right after CECL in March.
- 9:40That number shot up to like 216 percent.
- 9:43It was at 126 in December, but then over the course of this year, it's
- 9:47fallen back down to 166 and provision for loan loss expenses have doubled.
- 9:53And so did we overfund CECL or did we fund CECL right?
- 9:57And as the years progressed, credit unions are sitting
- 10:00there underfunded in September.
- 10:02I don't know the answer to that question.
- 10:04It could have been a conservative overfunding of CECL in that first quarter.
- 10:08And if It wasn't over funding the first quarter.
- 10:12Then we have balance sheets that are underfunded now in September.
- 10:17I don't know which was a true case, but one of those two is true.
- 10:20Mark Treichel: Well, in that ratio cover the coverage ratio.
- 10:23If you I think that is the is or similar to the coverage ratio, which reminds me
- 10:28of when Steve and I worked for Dan Murphy.
- 10:30When I was a director of special actions and, we would brief him on different
- 10:34cases about, the delinquencies X percent here, but the allowance is overfunded.
- 10:39And it's in this type alone.
- 10:41And the next one would come in and it would be a different type alone.
- 10:44And the, and everybody was saying but the allowance is adequate.
- 10:47And it was all over the map as far as delinquency and the allowance.
- 10:50And so Dan just said, you guys come in here and tell me, I
- 10:53just look at the allowance.
- 10:55And I look at delinquency and I compare the two, and I think I think
- 10:59we coined it the Murphy ratio at the time, so that made, it made Page
- 11:03happy if there was enough in the allowances, there wasn't delinquency
- 11:06because it was a simple benchmark.
- 11:11All right, anything else on credit risk, guys?
- 11:15Todd Miller: No.
- 11:15Returning to fundamentals, if we look at clients, one of the things
- 11:18we've seen routinely amongst clients last year is NCUA wanted people to
- 11:25justify their concentration limits.
- 11:28We've seen that over and over.
- 11:29It's concentration risks that cause the agency money or cost the
- 11:33agency money and insurance losses.
- 11:36And that's one thing we've seen across many of our clients last
- 11:40year is they wanted justification for those concentration limits.
- 11:46I'll tell
- 11:46Mark Treichel: you so much so that the last I did a solo podcast saying, Hey, the
- 11:50letter would normally come out this week.
- 11:52Here's what I think is going to be on it.
- 11:54And my prediction was concentration risk was going to pop back on
- 11:57because of how much we've seen credit unions being asked about that.
- 12:01I'm a bit surprised it's not.
- 12:05All right.
- 12:06So topic NCUA's list is liquidity risk.
- 12:10We've.
- 12:11We've talked a lot about it with clients.
- 12:14We've talked a lot about it on the podcast.
- 12:17And CUA has it number two here.
- 12:20They came out with a regulatory alert the week before, which was interesting
- 12:25that they had an alert and then a week later they had it in their priorities.
- 12:29And here it is at number two.
- 12:30As a reminder, it was number two last year.
- 12:33And ironically there were 10 priorities in 2022 and it was not any of the 10 interest
- 12:40rate risk where they may have dabbled into it was 10th on the list in 2022.
- 12:44So it shot up to number two, stayed at number two with a bullet here for 2024.
- 12:49Thoughts on liquidity risk?
- 12:53Todd Miller: This is interesting.
- 12:54I keep a whole bunch of statistics going back to 2000 on party and share structure
- 13:01on savings rates, different things.
- 13:05Earlier I mentioned, with loans, their whole references, they
- 13:11want to return to fundamentals.
- 13:13I think with balance sheet structures in general.
- 13:16What we're seeing today is a reversion to mean, if you go back to 2005, 2007, 2008.
- 13:24Hot money, which I would call borrowings, non member deposits,
- 13:28certificates, money markets.
- 13:30Back then it was roughly 54, 55 percent of a credit union's balance sheet.
- 13:36And then we got into this period of low rates out of the end of the last recession
- 13:41that lasted all the way through 2022.
- 13:43And things got somewhat muddled.
- 13:45That hot money fell to as low as 35 percent of the balance sheet, and then
- 13:51as the Fed started reducing or increasing rates in April of last year I read a thing
- 13:56a long time ago that people don't really care about rates, so they're insensitive
- 13:59to rates until rates get around 4%.
- 14:02And we're seeing that.
- 14:03So what we've seen in the last year and a half since the Fed started raising rates
- 14:07is this migration from core deposits to certificates, credit unions using
- 14:13borrowed money and non member deposits to control that marginal cost of funds.
- 14:18It's easier to do that rather than raise rates on the whole thing.
- 14:22As we get to the end, September of 2023, that hot money, borrowed money.
- 14:27And CDs and non member deposits, it's still only 46 percent of shares, so it's
- 14:33still way less than it was back when we had a normal interest rate environment.
- 14:39I think what we're going to see, and NCUA has a right to be nervous
- 14:43about liquidity, is we're going to continue to see that migration from
- 14:47core deposits into higher cost shares.
- 14:51We're going to continue to see credit unions using borrowed money
- 14:54and non member deposits to control that marginal cost of funds.
- 14:58I'm actually somewhat surprised as how well credit unions have been able to
- 15:02keep their interest margins where they were given how fast these rates will.
- 15:07Have risen.
- 15:07They've actually done a fairly good job with that.
- 15:11The other thing that we see that's a little out of the norm.
- 15:14If you look historically from 2000 up until the last 23 years, credence
- 15:20deposit growth was a little faster than the national savings rate.
- 15:24That hasn't been true.
- 15:25The last 2.
- 15:265 years and part of this.
- 15:28We already talked about it.
- 15:30Inflation is rising faster than income rates or growth, but just even at
- 15:35the national savings rate, credit and share growth have been behind that,
- 15:38and that's the first time that's happened in a couple of decades.
- 15:42And I think maybe that's a reluctance for them to raise rates, or it's
- 15:46just a matter of trying to control that marginal cost of funds.
- 15:50It's one of those unusual types of things.
- 15:53The borrowing and the increase in the borrowings, it certainly
- 15:56made the regulators nervous.
- 15:58We've seen a lot of exam reports that have findings and they're critical of
- 16:05credit unions, liquidity management.
- 16:08We see a lot of exam reports.
- 16:12inferring that there's a whole issue with this rising cost of funds.
- 16:16Even in credit unions that have kept their interest margins stable, they're
- 16:20still being criticized for that potential increasing cost of funds.
- 16:25So I find that somewhat interesting.
- 16:27It tells you that examiners are nervous and NCUA is nervous that this
- 16:32cost of funds will continue to rise.
- 16:34And I think it will because we haven't reverted back to that mean yet.
- 16:38That hot money is not where it's at yet on the balance sheet.
- 16:42So I think we're going to see some continued deterioration
- 16:46in those core deposits probably through the next year yet.
- 16:49We'll see what the Fed does with rates.
- 16:52It's certainly the increase in borrowings and reliance on non member
- 16:56funds is making the agency nervous.
- 16:58And we see it in clients exam reports.
- 17:00They're getting criticized for that rising cost of funds.
- 17:04They're getting criticized for using borrowed money.
- 17:09In some cases, it's deserved.
- 17:11In other cases, it's not.
- 17:14Examiners aren't just going through that whole total analysis process and
- 17:19seeing what's going on with everything.
- 17:21The liquidity is really, really tied very closely with interest rate risks.
- 17:26It's changes in interest rate risk that started creating all the
- 17:30pressures on everyone's liquidity.
- 17:32Yeah, we've went through an unprecedented time over the last 20 months.
- 17:36I think our fed funds have risen.
- 17:38I got it written down here somewhere on one of my sheets.
- 17:41I don't want to wrinkle my paper and get that involved in the thing, but
- 17:44it's a little over 500 basis points that Fed funds have went up since April
- 17:49of 2022 that created an inverted yield curve because long term rates have
- 17:54only went up a couple hundred basis points or a little bit less than that.
- 17:58That's caused a devaluation in credit unions assets.
- 18:01You see it very clearly in those gap net gap.
- 18:06net worth ratios, that has fallen.
- 18:08You see it in the losses on the HTM and AFS portfolios.
- 18:13They're down around 13, 14 percent.
- 18:16I don't have the number exactly in front of me, but that creates a whole
- 18:20bunch of pressure on institutions and they can't really go sell
- 18:23assets to fund this liquidity.
- 18:25So even the folks that have significant investment portfolios, They're
- 18:30unwilling to use them to fund that loan portfolio because they have to recognize
- 18:35those losses and so with liquidity, they reference that in the letter.
- 18:41They want you to go back and look at that interagency guidance from 2010.
- 18:46They want people shoring up their contingency funding plans.
- 18:50For some credit unions, they've dug into parts of their contingency
- 18:53funding plan, just to help restructure their balance sheet this year.
- 18:57So I think the liquidity pressures will continue unless rates fall, those asset
- 19:02valuations are not going to go back up.
- 19:05So there's still going to be a reluctance to sell things overall,
- 19:09though I think you give the industry some kudos, the increased in borrowings.
- 19:15It's just an indication of their managing their cost of funds.
- 19:19in marginal cost of funds to the best of their ability.
- 19:22And like I said, overall, I think the industry itself has done fairly
- 19:27well at managing their liquidity and responding to the interest rate risk.
- 19:32NCUA had to do away with their extreme risk rating on asset liability
- 19:38management in part because so many credit unions were hitting it, which
- 19:42means they probably shouldn't have had it in there before to begin with.
- 19:45I guess 1 thing that we see with our clients and we see a lot of clients
- 19:49being asked to reduce interest rate risk or change their limits.
- 19:53Something maybe that bothers me a little bit is N.
- 19:57C.
- 19:57U.
- 19:57A.
- 19:57is really focused on any V.
- 20:00but what you don't see in their exam reports is any discussions of the credit
- 20:04is income simulations or liquidity.
- 20:07And a lot of these institutions, they're doing just fine at holding up with keeping
- 20:12their earnings level where they're at.
- 20:14Capital ratios have come down a little bit because of growth, but a lot of
- 20:17credit unions are doing just fine in terms of managing that net interest
- 20:22income, keeping that net income positive, keeping those assets or
- 20:27capital numbers where they need to be.
- 20:30And so I think NCOA is maybe being a little bit harsh and emphasizing
- 20:34this NEB number, which has definitely went down when rates go up 500.
- 20:41And they're not looking at that income simulation piece, which
- 20:44is also very, very important.
- 20:46And I guess.
- 20:48What makes me nervous is some of the NCOA's guidance, and we see in clients,
- 20:53they want them to reduce interest rate risk without making any changes
- 20:57in interest rate risk assumptions.
- 20:59This yield curve is changing every single quarter.
- 21:02It's really challenging for management, and things they do to make NED look
- 21:07better today in this inverted yield curve could actually cost them a lot of money
- 21:13when that curve comes back to normal.
- 21:15And so I think credit unions You need to really be doing some simulations
- 21:21at different interest rate risks.
- 21:23You need to be able to push back on examiners.
- 21:26I think a little bit on this emphasis on any B.
- 21:29What is your income simulations looks like?
- 21:31Let's not do something today that's going to cost us a lot of money in
- 21:35the future when rates change again.
- 21:38Certainly some credit unions are interest rate has gotten excessive,
- 21:41but I think a lot of credit unions have also been told their interest rate risk
- 21:46is excessive and it's probably just fine and they can weather the storm.
- 21:51If they keep their liquidity appropriate and keep their earnings there, the
- 21:55liquidity always becomes a problem when you have poor asset quality and
- 21:59net worth starts falling, but, credit unions keep their capital level and
- 22:02they keep earnings positive, they can generate liquidity if they need it.
- 22:08where they get into trouble when asset quality deteriorates and
- 22:12capital starts deteriorating.
- 22:14Then that wholesale funding gets taken off the table and you have some more issues.
- 22:19So the credit risk is definitely at the heart of that.
- 22:22That's what causes those things to deteriorate the fastest.
- 22:26But interest rate risk and liquidity, it's just so challenging because of how
- 22:29fast interest rates rose and how the shape of the yield curve changed on them.
- 22:34Certainly there's individual creditors having trouble.
- 22:37They, in, Refer to that in the increased number of Camel 3s.
- 22:42But as an industry, the craniums are actually doing pretty well managing
- 22:46through this challenging environment.
- 22:49Mark Treichel: Well said, said.
- 22:50And Steve any thoughts you want to add to
- 22:53Steve Farrar: it?
- 22:54I want to emphasize one thing and then ask Todd about three other
- 22:58issues that shouldn't take long.
- 22:59I liked how he talked about, when when the credits are taking action
- 23:04to improve liquidity or interest rate or reduce interest rate risk.
- 23:07Some of the responses, they need to be properly analyzed as Todd talked
- 23:13about, kind of, when you're going to take those actions and then make
- 23:17sure that you outline the income affect the expenses related to that.
- 23:22And also include that foregone revenue that be from those things, because,
- 23:27sometimes these short term actions to get the examiner off your back, but they're
- 23:30not a real good long term decision.
- 23:32If you document that, at least you're able to respond on that.
- 23:36The other 2 issues I wanted to bring up with that for discussion is.
- 23:40The increased competition for deposits, which I noted the other regulators had
- 23:45made comments on, and I wanted to get Todd's thoughts real quickly on how
- 23:49he sees that affecting liquidity risk
- 23:52Todd Miller: and interest rate risk.
- 23:54Well, you need, we've had loan growth and loan growth has continued.
- 23:59It's slowed, but it continues.
- 24:01So the matter of is do you really need those deposits?
- 24:04I would go back first.
- 24:06Let's make sure you're pricing your loans and that loan growth is
- 24:09genuine and you're going to get some positive returns on that loan growth.
- 24:14I think the competition for funds is going to continue.
- 24:18Like I said, the savings rate is really low.
- 24:21We've already talked about it.
- 24:23Inflation is still higher than income growth.
- 24:25So you're not seeing a huge growth in, disposable income debt
- 24:30for people to add to savings.
- 24:32There's lots and lots of strategies out there for generating new deposits.
- 24:37A lot of this is new products.
- 24:39Can you create products?
- 24:41If you go back and look when hot money was 55 percent of the deposit
- 24:45base You know you had people that were somewhat rate sensitive, but
- 24:49they didn't lock their money up That was sitting in money market accounts.
- 24:52My wife is one of those she wants a fair return But she doesn't
- 24:56really want to lock her money up.
- 24:57She wants to go down to the bank and get it tomorrow Then you've
- 25:00got these investor type savers.
- 25:01They want very Competitive CD rates.
- 25:05They have no problems going from Bank A to Bank B to credit C to credit D.
- 25:10They're very rate sensitive money.
- 25:12Those people are probably the people we've seen moving already.
- 25:16But I don't think we've Really sorted out that middle tier.
- 25:19It's all in flux.
- 25:21So a lot of this is product development and talking to your members You
- 25:26know going out and getting borrowed money or non member deposits easy.
- 25:30It's a phone call to break a broker What's a little bit harder is that
- 25:34organic growth you need to spend some time building up relationships with your
- 25:37members and Asking them for deposits.
- 25:41I guarantee you every credit union members have more money that they don't have it.
- 25:46The tricky part is, is I think in this environment, right?
- 25:49You just have to recognize they're going to have to pay
- 25:51competitive rates to get that.
- 25:53And core deposit growth is not going to be easy.
- 25:56It's a demographic thing.
- 25:58We have more old people going away than we have young people coming up.
- 26:01Usually it's new families and new households.
- 26:03We're creating all that deposit core deposit growth.
- 26:07And.
- 26:08We're just not generating those new households anymore at the rate we used to.
- 26:13So, it's challenging for credit unions.
- 26:16They're going to have to work at this deposit growth
- 26:19and, the core deposit growth.
- 26:20You're going to have to steal it from the competition by having
- 26:23better relationships, better product designs, better websites.
- 26:26All the things young people want.
- 26:28And at the higher end for the people that are rate sensitive, you're going to
- 26:31be have to be willing to pay for that.
- 26:34And that really requires your local communities to really balance
- 26:39your loan rates with your deposit rates and understand the margin.
- 26:44Is this loan product profitable, given what we have to pay for deposits,
- 26:49our wholesale funding to fund it.
- 26:50And I think credit unions have done a good job of paying
- 26:53attention to that marginal stuff.
- 26:55They were maybe a little bit slow to raise loan rates, but you see, most of them are
- 26:59getting those loan rates up there now.
- 27:02I don't really, I don't envy the challenges that cruddy in space right
- 27:07now in this competition for deposits.
- 27:09And part of it is the savings rate is low.
- 27:11The pie is not getting big as fast as they need it to get.
- 27:15And like I said, one of the things I commented on is we're
- 27:18at a point where this is.
- 27:19First time in a long time where credit is deposit growth is
- 27:22lower than that savings rate.
- 27:24I don't know what the numbers look like in banks.
- 27:262023 was really good returns for people in the stock market.
- 27:31I don't know how much money that sucked out of, the banking
- 27:33and the credit industry.
- 27:35I'm certain it was some it's going to be a challenging 2024.
- 27:40And I think if credit is continue to do what they did in 2023, though,
- 27:45they'll do all right in 2024.
- 27:48But examiners are going to be looking, cashflow forecasts better be good.
- 27:52They're going to look for lots of scenario analysis.
- 27:54They're going to look for you modeling that business plan.
- 27:57We do see just amongst some of our clients an increased level of criticism
- 28:03if you don't hit your targets in your business plan and really that just means.
- 28:08A longer discussion at your ALCO in minutes where you're talking about why
- 28:12I don't think in an environment like this, you can hold credence to hitting
- 28:15every metric in their business plan, but credence need to sit down and have
- 28:19some discussions at the ALCO level.
- 28:22So their actions and their decisions are transparent to the examiners.
- 28:27I think that's one thing we see.
- 28:29is examiners don't see that transparency.
- 28:32It invites criticism of management.
- 28:35It's still with COVID, the offsite exams, the agency has said they're still going
- 28:39to continue to do offsite what they can.
- 28:42There just seems to be less dialogue between credit unions and management.
- 28:46And so if things aren't transparent in your committee minutes, board
- 28:49amendments, you invite a little bit of criticism from your examiners because
- 28:54they don't seem to be sitting day.
- 28:56Take the time to sit down and talk with management about what they did and why.
- 29:01It just doesn't seem to be occurring the way it has in the
- 29:05past, in certain cases anyway.
- 29:08Yeah, I think
- 29:09Steve Farrar: you covered 1 of my other questions that there is that
- 29:11with all of the change in the interest rates, a lot of credit unions found
- 29:15themselves outside of policy numbers in terms of liquidity measures and a L.
- 29:20M.
- 29:20measures.
- 29:21And I think you kind of just covered that before I even asked it and that
- 29:24it's that you properly document that.
- 29:27And we've seen some of our clients we deal with that.
- 29:29They're looking at now in their next run, they'll be making changes to their
- 29:33assumptions, which will change their results to suddenly bring them into
- 29:38compliance of policy and examiners are certainly going to be going what
- 29:42you just change your assumptions.
- 29:43So you could get him policy that I think that's going to be an issue this
- 29:46Todd Miller: year.
- 29:47Actually, I want to take just a minute to talk about it.
- 29:50It might run things a little bit long, and it's not related to the
- 29:52letter, but I think it's valid.
- 29:55So if you go historically, they wanted those non maturity deposit assumptions to
- 29:59be built over multiple business cycles.
- 30:02And so credit unions did that.
- 30:05Now what we're seeing is share growth is negative in those checking
- 30:08accounts, money markets, it's flowing into CD funds and now examiners are
- 30:13telling credit unions, hey, we want you to update your assumptions just
- 30:16based on these short term trends.
- 30:19If you look at what's going on with rate sensitivity factors.
- 30:24Most of the cruddy's they haven't raised their core deposit rates.
- 30:27They haven't raised rates on those regular shares.
- 30:30They haven't really done anything to checking accounts that did pay
- 30:34interest rates, money markets.
- 30:36They moved them a little, but a lot of cruddy's haven't moved them at all.
- 30:39So when cruddy's update their assumptions, they end up lowering
- 30:42their rate sensitivity factors because that's in truth what it was.
- 30:46They had conservative assumptions, examiners that update your assumptions.
- 30:50Now it makes the shares a little bit longer because rate sensitivity
- 30:53factors are lower and it reflects the criteria's behavior and decay rates.
- 31:00What you're finding, and we've seen this with our clients, a lot of them
- 31:03were excessively high and they do the studies based on what they have.
- 31:07And yes, some of them have lost shares this year.
- 31:09They end up lowering their decay rates, too, and making those shares longer.
- 31:13So, you know, the examiners, we start out with, we want assumptions
- 31:17based over multiple cycles, because we don't like what's happening.
- 31:22Now they say, Update your assumptions based on short term assumptions.
- 31:26Well, those assumptions are actually better for the carding, so the
- 31:29examiners don't like that either.
- 31:31So they don't
- 31:31Mark Treichel: get the reality.
- 31:32We don't like, yeah, we don't like the reality.
- 31:34Those numbers didn't impact it the way we thought it might.
- 31:37So that, careful what you ask for, you just might get it.
- 31:40Todd Miller: Yeah I think it's interesting, and it was interesting
- 31:44just to see examiners ask for that, because It was pretty self evident that
- 31:49that's the way the math is going to come out, that those rate sensitivity
- 31:52factors are going to get lower because gradients haven't changed rates.
- 31:55And the examiners want it both ways.
- 31:57That's why I think gradients, they need to be willing to push back
- 32:01on the examiners a little bit.
- 32:03And the whole point of the NCUA's supervisory NEV test was not to have
- 32:09this discussion about core deposits.
- 32:11And then they delve into it anyway, and it doesn't go the way they want, which.
- 32:16I find somewhat interesting.
- 32:18Mark Treichel: Yeah, so they've lost sight of the reason we did any B and
- 32:22as you both were talking, I took a bunch of notes and it reminded me of
- 32:25some other conversations we've had.
- 32:27But, we went through 3, 3 black swan events, essentially the pandemic.
- 32:33500, 600 increase to Fed funds, 500 base point increase.
- 32:41And then Silicon Valley Bank, which rocked the world on how money moves.
- 32:45All of those individually could be considered to be black swan events.
- 32:50And Todd, as you're talking about NEB and what it's used for, and
- 32:53what it can be misused for, and what else you need to consider.
- 32:56It reminds me and I might not get this quite right, but you can correct me on it.
- 32:59It reminds me of something you said once where it shows a 300 basis point shock
- 33:07because it triggers all of the things that are built into those bonds and It
- 33:10makes the covenants kind of explode.
- 33:13So you see what you've got.
- 33:15And now we've already had 500 basis points and then to then rely on any
- 33:20V and say, okay, well, is it going to go up another 300 basis points
- 33:23when we've already had five and we've already triggered everything, any,
- 33:26anything there you want to touch on?
- 33:29Todd Miller: Well, I've always believed that NAV is a good indicator of risk,
- 33:33but not the sole way to manage your balance sheet because you're making
- 33:37assumptions and doing cash flows.
- 33:39If you're a real estate lender, they're over a 30 year period.
- 33:43So I think they're a good indicator of direction of risk.
- 33:47And certainly when you get down to negative NAV numbers you're probably,
- 33:51it's an indication of trouble.
- 33:53But I've always been a believer too that, this income simulation
- 33:57and this other piece is important.
- 34:00And yeah, credit union cash flows, the, the 300 basis points
- 34:04was to trigger all the options.
- 34:06And I'm pretty sure we've triggered all the options on a
- 34:08credit union's balance sheet.
- 34:10The real estate loans they're extending out is as far as they're going to.
- 34:14What you don't capture in the models and which you're also seeing
- 34:18in the optionality is this whole inflation rate and the fact that
- 34:23disposable incomes are not growing.
- 34:25That's triggering and altering some of the people's behaviors, not in favor.
- 34:30Of our credit unions in any way, shape or form so I just think it's interesting
- 34:36that any B is important, but those income simulations and how you're managing that
- 34:40interest for net interest margin and how you're holding up with liquidity
- 34:45and capital is every bit as important as that any B number, and I think N.
- 34:50C.
- 34:50U.
- 34:50A.
- 34:50Is losing sight of that sometimes because we see it in exam reports.
- 34:54We read there's this criticism or any B is going and there's not even a mention.
- 35:00of their income simulations or liquidity numbers.
- 35:03I mean, they're just totally silent.
- 35:05And so it's an important number.
- 35:07It's a good indicator, but relying solely on that without looking at
- 35:12other factors is not the way to analyze your interest rate risk.
- 35:19Mark Treichel: I'm part of the challenge to that.
- 35:22And not that this is an excuse.
- 35:23But, I think back to when we all started and we took
- 35:25examiner level 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5.
- 35:28And I remember any time a discussion went into.
- 35:32It was like, oh, we're we're, we're going to handle that in the last class.
- 35:35We're going to handle that in the last class and.
- 35:37Built up all that anticipation of that last class being real good
- 35:40where they explained it to me.
- 35:41And I remember walking out of there scratching my head saying they
- 35:44said they'd answer it in the last class and they didn't, which led
- 35:47to there being some good, we hired better people, experts in that area.
- 35:52But then you layer on top of that, since the 0809 economic the Great
- 35:57Recession, half of NCOA staff.
- 36:00Is new since then, maybe even more, but at least half of the staff.
- 36:04So they've not really gone through any of these issues and
- 36:07any of the income simulations.
- 36:09All those things are nuanced and they're stretched thin and.
- 36:15I think that's leading to some of these over reliant, it's like when
- 36:20they had CMOs and it was thumbs up or it's thumbs down, right?
- 36:22NEV, it's the be all end all, and we're seeing a little bit of that
- 36:26in what, what's happening out there.
- 36:29And credit unions just need to push back and try and make sure they're
- 36:32being treated fairly on these, on this
- 36:34Todd Miller: issue.
- 36:36That's probably true.
- 36:37I hadn't really thought about the new examiners.
- 36:39Because the other thing you see with new examiners, and I'm sure I was this
- 36:43way too, Is they tend to be risk averse, and they're scared of making a mistake.
- 36:49And I think with experience and, Steve and I, and yourself, we were all problem case
- 36:55officers and you have to take a little bit of risk to fix the troubled credit union.
- 37:00And so we're probably a little bit more accepting of different risk levels
- 37:06than a lot of the newer examiners are.
- 37:10And that, that just comes with experience and it comes with that
- 37:14whole total analysis process.
- 37:15And that's what we see maybe lacking sometimes is, our examiners and
- 37:21our clients, they're picking on one single fact and they'll pull
- 37:24that out and what they write in their reports is factually true.
- 37:28Yeah.
- 37:29But they're missing the whole picture, and everything is used out of context,
- 37:33and that's when credit unions need to push back a little bit with their examiners
- 37:38is, wait, look at the whole picture here.
- 37:40Yes, what you said is true, but, we don't run any financial
- 37:44institution by one number.
- 37:46There's a focus on member service here and, managing risk takes
- 37:50a lot of different numbers and
- 37:54Mark Treichel: especially, yeah, especially in this environment,
- 37:56especially in this environment.
- 37:57That was a great conversation on that possibly, and this is I think
- 38:01in the past I've cut this podcast into, and I think I might do that.
- 38:05And this might be a natural spot.
- 38:07where we do it.
- 38:08And so we discussed credit risk number one, liquidity risk number two.
- 38:12We jumped down to number five, which was interest rate risk because that but the
- 38:16reality is that's because liquidity risk and interest rate risk are so intertwined.
- 38:20Microphone Array (Intelr Smart Sound Technology for Digital Microphones): And this is where I did
- 38:22cut the podcast in two.
- 38:23, I want to thank you for listening, , to part one of NCUA's priority letters,
- 38:28and you can stay tuned for part two, which will discuss consumer financial
- 38:33protection and a few others of NCUA's priorities from their priority letters.
- 38:37Thanks again for listening.
- 38:38This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.