Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / Nothing More Certain #2
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensemble podcast is intended for professional financial advisors.
- 0:03This content is created in partnership with Asponsor, Generation Life Limited,
- 0:07ABN 6809284302, AFSL 225408, and is limited to publicly available information.
- 0:14Before acting on any general advice, you should consider whether appropriate
- 0:18had obtained financial advice from a qualified financial advisor.
- 0:21Ensemble does not hold an AFS license and does not provide any financial
- 0:25advice or services or endorse any general advice.
- 0:28If a PDS or IM exists, you should obtain a copy and review it thoroughly before making a decision.
- 0:42Generation Life is an award-winning market leader in tax-effective investment solutions.
- 0:48As the pioneer of Australia's first truly flexible investment bond,
- 0:51and now with over 5.2 billion in funds under management,
- 0:55they have been at the forefront of providing innovative tax-effective investment
- 0:59and retirement income solutions since 2004.
- 1:02As part of an ASX-listed company, Generation Life is passionate about designing
- 1:07innovative products that use the power of financial markets with the goal of generating
- 1:12greater wealth and better lifestyles for all Australians.
- 1:16Hello and welcome to the Ensemble podcast.
- 1:20My name is Vin Scully, Founder at Life Shripper, Australia's leading online financial advisor,
- 1:25and this episode is brought to you by our very good friends at Generation Life,
- 1:30who've developed a thought-provoking paper entitled Structure, Strategy and Trust,
- 1:37Accelerating Confidence in the Next Era of High Net Worth Advice.
- 1:42This is episode two of our two-part series called Nothing is More Certain,
- 1:47in which we explore this paper and its implication for advisors.
- 1:51Today, we look at how advisors can leverage a regulatory change to deliver a better client
- 1:56experience, showcase their expertise, and build trust.
- 2:01And in this episode, I'm joined by Felipe Rojo, Chief Executive Officer at Generation Life,
- 2:08and by Michael Bolver from Sydney, Founder and Managing Director at Family Wealth Advisor.
- 2:15If you haven't already done so, pause and grab a copy of the paper using the link in the show notes.
- 2:22So let's crack on with the show. Today, I'm joined by Felipe Rojo, CEO at Generation Life,
- 2:30and Michael Bolver Advisor and Principal of Family Wealth Advisory,
- 2:36and Trust of Courses become a, in both senses, the word, both in the sense of
- 2:42community trust and in the sense of the legal structure trust has become a very important topic.
- 2:47It's always been important in financial advice. In many ways, it's the only thing we have to sell
- 2:53that what our clients are looking for is confidence, confidence that they're making the right
- 2:58decision today and confident that they'll be okay, and trust is an incredible part of that.
- 3:04Part of that is trust in the individual, and increasingly, and possibly more importantly,
- 3:09for scalability and durability, is trust in the process. So the reason we're together today
- 3:17is that Generation Life has just published a very important thought piece on the whole trust issue
- 3:25in the light of what's happening in the marketplace. So it's great to have Felipe here to help
- 3:30explore that in a little bit more. So Felipe, I'm sure you need no introduction.
- 3:38Perhaps you've just given us 30 seconds on Generation Life so that we all have the context.
- 3:43Sure, absolutely. Let me just add, you know, Vince Markle, great to be having this chair today.
- 3:48It's obviously key to obviously not our profession in financial advice. So we're really looking forward
- 3:54to extrapolating some of the findings and hopefully assist advisors around the country on ways
- 4:00to engage with their clients. But let's start with, you know, who's Generation Life? So just to
- 4:05remind listeners, Generation Life has been in the market since 2017 as a new brand of an organization
- 4:12that being in market since 2004. What do we do? We're a live company specializing in structures.
- 4:19There's two primary structures that we specialize. The number one for us is the world of investment
- 4:25bonds, right? And I'm sure Vince, we're going to talk about it today. It is. There's always so much to
- 4:30talk about investment bonds. And Vince, you and I have done podcasting with the past them.
- 4:34And I'm so passionate about this. And, you know, there was so much to talk about it.
- 4:39The second one is the lifetime annually, right? It is one that we have been in market now for
- 4:44almost four years. It's really exciting because there's a demographic shift that will demand that
- 4:50will require more longevity solutions in the future, which is an exciting opportunity for us to,
- 4:56again, just flex almost all and truly innovate the opportunities that advisors have to engage
- 5:03the clients and address their needs. Wonderful, Felipe. Thanks for that intro. Now we know a little
- 5:08bit more about Generation Life. Let's turn to the topic of the day, which of course is your
- 5:14thought piece on trust and the current advice environment. And one of the things that struck me in
- 5:23this fairly striking piece of research is the statistic that, and I'll read this, 71% of
- 5:31high net worth clients feel less financially confident than in 2022. And 69% were less confident
- 5:39about retiring comfortably. Now that's, yeah, a few quarters of the population. And you would
- 5:46think that in a period where we've seen probably some of the strongest stock market returns in
- 5:53history when you look at relatively low inflation, might not feel that way when you go to buy a
- 5:58coffee, but we do have relatively low inflation compared to the 70s and 80s. And we've had remarkably
- 6:05strong real returns in the markets. So what was your reaction when you saw this number? I was
- 6:10gobsmacked when I read it. So as I arrived, but then quickly what occurred to me is the opportunity,
- 6:16right, ahead of us all. And I think that the reality of the difference now between performance
- 6:22and confidence, right, and the importance of confidence at first take, Vincent is that clearly
- 6:29the Australian retirement system is incredibly strong, right? But what's key here? What's the
- 6:36biggest difference that we've noticed through this research and the reason why I've decided to
- 6:41issue this thought leadership is that the confidence in the certainty of its rules have softened.
- 6:47Right? There's a greater awareness of the constant narrative of changes and the implications
- 6:55that it may have to invest this. And underpinning all of this is now the notion that confidence,
- 7:02not performance, is the real measure it now of financial trust of financial advice values.
- 7:08Yeah, I mean, we deal mostly with younger clients here at large, and they're certainly experiencing
- 7:15the impact of inflation. And because few of them are investing before 2008,
- 7:22few have seen it downturn. So they don't, they're not boy by that historical difference.
- 7:27Turning into Michael Bover from financial wealth advisory. Are you seeing what are you seeing in
- 7:32your client base, which is more of a high net worth client base than ours? Yeah, I mean, a similar
- 7:37a similar response. You know, I do deal with some very ultra high net worth families and the fear
- 7:44of running out of money is not something that's just for for those that probably aren't in that space.
- 7:51So I think it probably starts more from an emotional perspective. Doesn't matter whether you've
- 7:56got a million, 10 million, 50 million. There is probably in some ways a slightly irrational fear that
- 8:03that money is not going to last. And so really coming back to confidence, it's giving the family's
- 8:10confidence that the money will last. That's where our financial modeling tends to come in very
- 8:16strongly and let them sort of dispel I guess a lot of the emotion that sort of wraps around that
- 8:21fear of money. Yeah, that's that's true. I mean, in many ways, looking at it from a practitioner's
- 8:27viewpoint, we're actually seeing less change now that we have done. But the media coverage is much
- 8:33stronger than it ever was. I mean, I don't know if you're both old enough to remember RBLs in the
- 8:39move to transitional RBLs. I mean, these were big, big changes and the, you know, the introduction
- 8:45of the CIS act. These were huge changes that changed the way people think about money. And so
- 8:51division 296, which we'll come on to in a moment is the topic du jour in that media. And
- 8:59you know, whilst it's important for clients with lots of money, it affects very few people in
- 9:04the population today. And yet, it's got this huge coverage in the press. I mean, I suspect part of
- 9:11it was the initial attempt to buy by accident more than the designer think the attempt to tax
- 9:19unrealised capital gains. But sort of coming back to to that point, I'm sure I don't have
- 9:27telling you if I listen to what division 296 is about, it's an additional tax on higher
- 9:31superannuation balances. And the second go at it is I think it's been tabled in parliament,
- 9:38isn't it? The first first reading. It hasn't passed yet. But we've certainly seen that the
- 9:45tax that we know of a two tiered system and that cuts in our three million and an extra step that
- 9:53cuts in a ten million. And in many ways, I suspect this will be a temporary tax because anyone who
- 10:01hasn't hit the total superannuation balance cap by now will never get there. So I suspect that
- 10:07we'll be here in 20 or 30 years. Well, perhaps I won't, but the industry that's profession will be
- 10:14here in 20 or 30 years celebrating the demise of division 296. That's a personal view, not a view
- 10:20of live sugar or other participants. So this is my personal view that we'll just run out of people
- 10:26with 10 million dollar balances. But I think if I'm a giant being here, I think this is one of the
- 10:32the realities that we have identified through this research, is that yes, right? If you focus
- 10:37on division 296 in isolation, yes, it does impact a few lucky individuals who have made the most
- 10:44of the opportunities they're available for them, right? I think it's very easy to look back and
- 10:48hindsight and believe that the reality of the system was too good, not conducive of a sustainable
- 10:55structure, but it was a reality of the time and it was available for anyone in Antarctica, Stella,
- 11:01very vocal about the median dollars into superannuation, a zero percent tax environment.
- 11:05But you're right. Just right. Just right forward the 2000 ad crash. That's it. That's it. Great
- 11:10timing. But you're right, right? It's a reality that will self-correct itself within the next
- 11:17generations because it becomes significantly harder to accumulate those large balances in superannuation.
- 11:25But this is where I believe the opportunity lies ahead, right? The work that Michael do, the work
- 11:29that you do, the work that advises to around the country, to educate clients that's no longer
- 11:34a superannuation, the only driving force of our industry, right? There are other structures which
- 11:39are available. There are the means to invest your capital. Each addressing the individual need,
- 11:44each haven't individual outcome, but financial advisors truly are the only professional capable
- 11:52of navigating that maze and ensure that clients can achieve their goals.
- 11:59One of the things I've lived my career by is that all change is good change because all change
- 12:05creates opportunity. And so that sort of leads to... And I completely agree, right? I think that
- 12:12regulatory uncertainty certainly is a trust opportunity. We're talking about confidence here.
- 12:17The reality is clients may not appreciate if the impact of division 296, division 293,
- 12:23right? Which has been in play for a very long time. And I think what they seeking now more than
- 12:29ever, this is what the research has shown us is that they want that contact with their financial
- 12:34advice, right? They're seeking financial advice. And this is where, you know, my opening, I said,
- 12:38look, after that initial shock, after being Gobsmack, you know, I quickly realized the
- 12:43opportunity ahead of us, our financial advisors, to educate the broader population that things may
- 12:50not be as deemed as they may look like at a face value via the introduction of a new text
- 12:55regime in super because there are alternatives. Yeah. And certainly if you're looking at a 40%
- 13:01marginal tax rate in super, the bond environment starts to look very attractive. Look, it does. And
- 13:09tax is a very important component, right? And in a generational life, we stand for tax
- 13:14certainty, right? We are the first to disclose exactly what is the after tax returns of clients
- 13:20because to us, it's very important for clients to understand the difference between a headland
- 13:25return and a consumable greater return, right? And the reasons behind it, but know what is great
- 13:32about the structure of investment bonds is that not only does it address the wealth accumulation
- 13:37needs by ensuring that the assets accumulate in a tax effective environment, but commonly as well,
- 13:42particularly for the individuals that have got large balances, it addresses the emotive need,
- 13:47which Michael mentioned earlier around the intergenerational world transfer, right? Most often
- 13:52a night and talking to advisors, the conversation with their clients, now that they've accumulated
- 13:58the assets to a point is how that transfer will occur, who is going to receive it, how will they
- 14:04receive it, how will the next generation become the custodians of the family's wealth? You know,
- 14:09for future generations, not just the consumers of an inheritance. And Michael, what sort of,
- 14:15a beyond the obvious compliance matter is what sort of discussions are you having with your
- 14:20high net worth clients around around Div 296? Yeah, I mean, look, I think the one constant is that
- 14:25change will always be there. And so a key role of the advisor is to, I guess, be across the
- 14:31changes and help direct the traffic of where the wealth ends up. So superannuation has obviously
- 14:36been a great environment to build wealth for a time in a very, very tax effective environment,
- 14:41obviously managing preservation issues and super diff taxes. As the rules change on that,
- 14:46it does chip away a little bit around confidence of clients ability to put more and more money into
- 14:51super because they're saying, well, are they going to keep changing the rules, keep changing the
- 14:54rules? But my general feedback there is they're always going to have the rules,
- 14:58in superannuation more concessional than anywhere else. Otherwise, you won't have that encouragement
- 15:03factor to get more money into super. And I think that's in everyone's best interest. But they'll
- 15:07always chip away at it. And really, the role of the advisor then is to know, well, what role is
- 15:12superannuation? And this, I'll be getting into that kind of slightly high net worth family,
- 15:15where there's more capital to deploy. Once the superannuation environment is full, what are our
- 15:21next options? And now some of that is obviously driven by tax. Some of it's driven by control and some
- 15:26of it's driven a little bit through a state planning as well. So really, the key role of the
- 15:31advisor is to know the client really, really well, to understand where the wealth should be accumulating.
- 15:37So super, super, super, very concessional. They're changing rules, particularly for the high net
- 15:43worth balances, 10 mil. That's starting to look, you know, at 40%. There's probably better tax
- 15:48environments for that wealth to sit in. Obviously, that's a policy decision and it's a policy decision
- 15:52to try and get that money out of super. We hear that and no doubt people will start acting on that
- 15:58once the legislation comes through. So then the role of the advisor is to then work with the client
- 16:03and say, well, where is potentially if that wealth does come out of super? Where does it go? And
- 16:08that's where a lot of the modeling comes in. And it's important to know that also that the new rules
- 16:14are a proportional tax. So it's not every dollar one above three mil and it's not every dollar one
- 16:19above 10 mil that you'll get taxed. So that is a proportion of the funds. So it is really important
- 16:25to take each case and duty analysis on that. So, but that's a key role that we play with our clients
- 16:31is knowing where where the money should sit. So that intergenerational wealth can build
- 16:37in a very tax effective environment. Excellent. And I guess that sort of brings
- 16:42one to the top of that. You know, we you touched on one of your flagship products,
- 16:46Philip, the traditional investment bond. They've been around for a very long time. And I noticed
- 16:52in that your thought pace report positions them almost as a trust mechanism. Now I assume that
- 17:00trust in both senses of the word, the trust being a legal structure and trust being the part of
- 17:06the relationship with an advisor rather than just a tax structure. That's something that strikes
- 17:12me around a few spend as much time on personal finance channels on personal social media as I do.
- 17:18But you know, investment bonds come in for a lot of uneducated flak focusing on the tax implications
- 17:26for particularly for lower tax rate investors. But this to me is far more than a tax issue. The
- 17:33tax issue is sort of a nice feature that comes along with this. But it's actually all those other
- 17:39parts of them. They're rolling at structuring that strikes me as the the important points. So how
- 17:44do you, you know, help advisors and consumers generally maybe get away from thinking about them
- 17:53purely as a as a tax structure? Yeah, it's a great question. At face value, right, I hear a
- 17:59lot, Philippe, it's complicated. It's not a simple structure. And I always say, right,
- 18:04respectively, superannuation is actually complex, right? Investment bonds by comparison are
- 18:10relatively straightforward. The issue with investment bonds is that they are not mainstream,
- 18:15right? Because if you institute to your point, they actually precede superannuation,
- 18:19yet in 92, right, with a significant change of superannuation and a focus on the fine
- 18:25contributions and superguarantee just took the focus completely away from what were them called
- 18:31insurance bonds and made superannuation the driving force, right? And for the obvious reasons,
- 18:37it's a phenomenal structure. It is a little one that will hide, you know, it's the envy of the
- 18:42world. We're on track to becoming and having the world's second largest pension system, right?
- 18:47But investment bonds have been around for a very long time. That talks to to the stability of
- 18:52of the structure, right? But you cannot look past the fact that once upon a time they weren't as
- 18:58effective as they are now, once upon a time they did not have the investment money that they
- 19:02have now, once upon a time they did not have the features that they have now. And that has been
- 19:07my focus. That has been the job of generation life and our continued focus on ensuring that
- 19:13the investment bond structure, and I'm mindful and careful of referring to us as a structure,
- 19:18because that's how we see ourselves and how we outsource the defense to very well-known fund
- 19:23managers and we share a bit of IP with them on how to best trade within the structure. But we
- 19:29hear as a structure provider, right? That structure is not only tax effective, but it's also very
- 19:36effective upon the transfer of wealth because of the governance of the life act within it. So there's
- 19:42two governing components to the structure. One is the tax act that pegs us against the corporate
- 19:48rate, and he shows that we can be very tax effective by minimizing the tax accessible income
- 19:55on a quarterly basis, right? Unlike other structures, whenever there is a capital loss,
- 20:01we've got an opportunity to look at any income that has been received within the options,
- 20:07we can deduct one against the other and we can reduce the accessible income.
- 20:13That's very powerful. So Philip, this presumably works because it's on revenue account
- 20:17inside the bond. Is that right? That's exactly right. And that is something that,
- 20:22you know, a face value sometimes, I ever see feedback, and if you're telling me more, it's hard
- 20:25to understand, but it's as simple as making a comparison if you hold the assets at a personal level,
- 20:32and you unfortunately may experience a capital loss equity market, for example, and you have to
- 20:37wait until you've got a capital gain to trade one against the other, right? But operating out of
- 20:42the revenue account, for instance, you've mentioned, and we do it, banks do it, no insurance
- 20:47companies do it. If we have a capital loss, we've got an opportunity to then look at any income,
- 20:53any distribution that has been received, deduct one from the other and we reduce the
- 20:58accessible income. We can't control the tax that we pay. We're always going to pay that 30 cents
- 21:04on the dollar, or we can control is just that accessible income. By reducing that accessible
- 21:10income, we have what it's then at a lower effective tax rate, right? And that's powerful because
- 21:17it helps then individuals make the most of their wealth accumulation journey by not having
- 21:23any tax liqueatures. Taxes are really good, and obviously ammunition never be looked in isolation
- 21:28because there will be years where of huge returns where you're paying more tax, and that's a good
- 21:32thing. What you don't want is unnecessary tax liqueatures, and what you don't want, you don't want
- 21:37to provide that it's enough flexing internal muscles to extract the best out of every single investment
- 21:43option. We've been focusing very much so on ensuring that we've got the most tax effective
- 21:49that we're leading the way around an ocean of as an industry, as a profession, we have focused
- 21:56heavily on fees. But hang on a second, tax is also a very large component consumer of that
- 22:04headline return. Is there anything that can be done? Super does it incredibly well? What else?
- 22:09And this is the world that that we're playing in, and going a desi head to head against truss,
- 22:15right? And commonly known as as family truss. So the terminology and the use of truss as we describe
- 22:21that the structure is very much on purpose, because it talks to the stability of the life
- 22:27act, the legislation that governs the world of investment bonds. It also talks to the very
- 22:34easy comparisons that you can make between an investment bond and a family truss. But in our world
- 22:39there is a very simple but huge point of difference. And it's the fact that we don't have to
- 22:46distribute any gains during the year to the end beneficiaries, right? In the world of a family
- 22:52truss, as those gains are realized throughout the year beneficiaries must receive those distributions.
- 22:58In the world of an investment bonds, they don't have to. Those gains are reinvested internally,
- 23:03right? And over a long period over the long term, that reflects seem to a higher after-text
- 23:10result, right? But these we we're being focused on educating financial advice, right? We are
- 23:17unashamedly an organization that is completely pro financial advice. We have not had an
- 23:23opportunity yet to educate the broader population that podcasts like this and every now and then
- 23:29we've got an opportunity at a media and those opportunities that presented themselves particularly
- 23:33with the impetus of division 206. We're highlighting more and trying to educate the broader
- 23:39population on the benefits of investment bonds. But I dare say, no, we haven't done enough. There's
- 23:45still so much more that we can do. There's still so much more that we can educate the broader
- 23:50population on the benefits of investment bonds. I mean, I certainly wasn't encouraging you to
- 23:55go and read it and spread the word. I spend my life just I spend my life trying to talk my
- 24:01listeners and our customers at Lausher Perto stay off the personal advice channels on subreddits
- 24:09on Reddit. It is just such a cesspit. But back to I mean, educating consumers is an extraordinary
- 24:17difficult and expensive job. I still the vast bulk of consumers still think there's commissions
- 24:24on investment and super products. We haven't had them for a decade. I think I think it's a decade
- 24:28or more now. But anyway, back to the practitioners world. How have you been using these Michael?
- 24:36What's the sort of strategies? I guess it's probably a better word to
- 24:40that you've been using with your with your clients, particularly in Div 9296.
- 24:45Obviously, we don't want to anticipate doing stuff before we know what the law is, but what's
- 24:50that sort of story that you're working with your clients on? So investment bonds for us is a tool
- 24:58and they generally play two roles for our accumulator clients who are in that position where they go
- 25:05good cash flow generally on top marginal tax rate and are looking to save and build wealth.
- 25:11We use the investment bonds amongst other vehicles as a way to kind of build wealth and a
- 25:17really tax effective environment because your taxes kept at 30%. They're paying sort of 47. So
- 25:22it's a nice tax differential. So that's a good starting point for the accumulators, but really the
- 25:27heart and soul of the accumulator model is to kind of drive those savings. And the thing we love
- 25:34about the investment bond structure is you can increase your savings automatically by 125% each
- 25:39year without resetting the 10-year tax rule. So we love that because it's almost like a
- 25:44force savings for that accumulator base to keep driving their savings up 25% every year. And over
- 25:50next year and in the year after that, it's amazing how quickly that otherwise lifestyle will absorb
- 25:57that. And our objective is to get the families to that financial independence position much quicker.
- 26:02So this is a very effective tool that's not only tax effective, but it's also behavioral
- 26:07effective in that it drives a motivation to just keep savings going into the right investment. So
- 26:12for our accumulator base, absolutely love it plays a very key role there for our high net worth
- 26:18families. And Felipe touched on it, family trusts, which can accumulate large amounts of capital
- 26:25need to distribute that capital somewhere. So it's either going to individual beneficiaries,
- 26:29but when you got a large amount in there, it doesn't take long before they've sort of used up the
- 26:33and they're on top marginal. There were options typically where it could go to children.
- 26:39But the tax office seems to be taking a much stricter view. I think through sex and 100
- 26:44a on that. So if you use going to children, it has to go to them. They can't sort of be gifting
- 26:48it back through love and affection. And so that's just making that a little bit of school fees are
- 26:52still very expensive. You can absorb a lot of that by paying school fees. Yeah, so definitely reach
- 26:58out to your account and get good tax advice on that one. But then they start to use things like
- 27:03market companies. So the fallback strategy is if there's no individual beneficiaries to go to,
- 27:08then typically what we see is that it ends up in the bucket company. And what we're saying more
- 27:13and more is that the bucket company's then become a third investment vehicle for these families
- 27:18for intergenerational wealth, where they've accepted that this company. And once again,
- 27:22speak to your own account about tax advice. But some of the families that we've been saying is
- 27:26they're accepting that the corporate entity is going to become an investment vehicle despite the
- 27:30fact it's not going to get a CGT discount. And for money that's going to sit there long term,
- 27:37and you're not going to rip it all out and go on by a super yacht, it can work because you can
- 27:40drip the money out through dividends and sort of manage your kind of marginal tax and retirement.
- 27:45So we're saying definitely saying a lot more about that. But the investment bonds then play a sort
- 27:49of a third arm because you can put capital, like if a family trust has capital, you can put the capital,
- 27:54the family trust can own the investment bond. And to fill up those points, the investments would
- 27:59then sit within the investment bond. And the income doesn't need to go up and be distributed
- 28:04through to the beneficiary. So it is a great way to build wealth that you just want to keep
- 28:09within that family trust environment in a very tax-effective way. And we do love the 10-year
- 28:15tax rule on it. So unlike the bucket company strategy where you're always going to have top-up
- 28:20tax, the great thing about the investment bonds is if you do get to the year 10 and the money comes
- 28:26out, you avoid that sort of top-up tax pain. I mean, the corporate, the bucket company versus
- 28:32investment bonds are pretty straightforward argument in that sense that both both are non-CGT
- 28:39discount burners, but you get that uplift at your 10 with the bond. Yeah, you would only really
- 28:46use the bucket company for I want to call it pre-tax dollars. And it's not always pre-tax dollars,
- 28:52but not fully tax dollars. So for example, a lot of our family business clients generate excess
- 28:58profits from their business in a PTI-limited company. If they pull all of the profits out in any
- 29:03given year, generally, there's top-up tax. Whereas if there's excess surplus capital that they want
- 29:09to keep reinvesting, most accounts will tell you don't invest in your trading vehicle is too much
- 29:13asset protection risk. So it normally goes up and across and into a bucket company where you can
- 29:20get distributed into the bucket company is no top-up tax because it's the same corporate rate.
- 29:24But there might be a 5% difference. If it's a big company, so like a family yesterday,
- 29:30their company's paying 30% tax because they're above a certain threshold in terms of their turnover,
- 29:35but generally the profits from the business can then go into the bucket company. There's no
- 29:39sort of top-up tax in a way you go and you keep investing tax deferred. But if you've got
- 29:43after-tax dollars, obviously into an investment bond makes a lot of sense, or it can go into the
- 29:49family trust and then potentially into the investment bond. But where is the bucket company's
- 29:54kind of more tax deferred dollars? Excellent. Now, that probably brings me to the other topic that's
- 30:02a bit of a hot button among advisors. Both of you, I'm sure, are familiar with the work of Michael
- 30:08Kitzes, who's probably one of the big names in or influence us as opposed to the technical
- 30:14him these days in the financial advice space in the US. But he's been writing a lot of stuff
- 30:21around the intergenerational wealth there. There's a quote in the report about the number of
- 30:28clients who sack their advisors once they are usually their husband's advisor when the surviving
- 30:36spouse inherits. We're actually finding the opposites and our younger members are referring
- 30:40their parents as their parents reach retirement, not quite inheritance living yet, but our 30-40
- 30:46something have parents who are in that pre-retire early retiree stage and they're referring their
- 30:52parents. But this is the other side of that equation where you've got older clients who either
- 30:59lose capacity or pass way and that money then transfers the so-called giant intergenerational
- 31:07transfer of wealth. I'm not rushing to contribute my share to that much to my boys' dismay, but
- 31:17how are you seeing that play out in your business before I come back to Philippe and say how bonds
- 31:22help with that? I mean, look, it's critical so much of what we teach as governance around how to
- 31:28be a custodian of wealth as opposed to a I guess a spender of it. It starts obviously with
- 31:33the parents, but we try as much as possible to engage the next generation as early as possible.
- 31:39It's a bit of a cost to the business because typically those type of clients can't really afford
- 31:45advice the children of the parents, but we see it as an absolutely critical part one so that if the
- 31:51next generation aren't educated, they're just going to blow up the capital, it doesn't matter
- 31:53what structure you put in place. So we just see it as such an important part of that governance
- 31:58and custodial role. And so we spend a lot of time trying to get that next generation in and we
- 32:05almost sort of treating them as their own client and getting them one a little bit of the savings
- 32:09plan, just teaching them about how to manage money. So if and when something happens to Mum and Dad,
- 32:14the transition through to them to begin that educational journey and then and for the bigger families
- 32:19will normally have an annual family meeting where the kids are sitting in that they understand all
- 32:23the structures, they understand all the strategy so that it's not coming in cold if something
- 32:28hurts to Mum and Dad. Now we've seen the transition of wealth across Mum and Dad's passing and that
- 32:35work that we do typically tends to result in those next generations being a little stickier.
- 32:40I mean it's not that's not why we do it, but it's an important part of us helping families build
- 32:46wealth is the education such a critical part. But if you're not doing that, if you're not engaging
- 32:51that next generation, then I can absolutely see why once they take control, they're just going to
- 32:57say, well, I just want to surround myself with with my advisors and you've won the relationship
- 33:02and offer us. Yeah, I mean from in our business again, you know, completely different business,
- 33:06but the members that we pick up who've had a previous advice relation, the vast bulk of our
- 33:12customers have never had an advice relationship before. And the ones that did have it was their
- 33:18parents advisor. So Mum and Dad had introduced themselves to the advisor when they were, yeah,
- 33:23early 20s may be saving for the home, getting their first super fun, perhaps, and you know,
- 33:27get to the early 30s and they're going, well, we've had enough of Mum's advisor or dance
- 33:32advisor and they move to us. So we're not picking up business from other advisors generally,
- 33:38we're picking up new to profession clients generally, but they opposite to us that they're
- 33:44referring their parents, which is say a different kettle of fish. So I'm interesting to see,
- 33:49you know, how that plays out in 10 or 20 years when the big wave of inheritance starts to flow through.
- 33:56I think we hit peak 65 year olds next year, is that right, Philip?
- 34:00That we'll do. Yeah, I've just missed that by a year, so but I'm close to the peak. And so,
- 34:09what does that, how do you think your business can help with that helping advisors deal with
- 34:15that transition, Philip? Yeah, look, it's great hearing from Michael, right? I think
- 34:19practitioners, you know, the best guide into how to between approach, how to engage clients
- 34:26around that transfer of wealth from our perspective, the structure facilitates the conversation,
- 34:32but the conversation must be held and it's through those open lines of conversation,
- 34:37is through those annual family meetings that you can avoid a significant amount of erosion of
- 34:44the estate upon passing because the family will be squabbling over who gets what, right? From our
- 34:51perspective, our generation life, we represent a non estate asset, right? That's very powerful,
- 34:57because you can ensure that the right assets go to the right beneficiaries. And if warranted,
- 35:02you can put a restriction in place, right? Without wanting to offend anyone here, you know,
- 35:07it's a great way to rule from the grave, right? Because you can dictate how much and when that
- 35:12distribution will occur using the investment bonds. And it's very easy because we've made it as part
- 35:18of the application form. So instead of having to rely on wording on the deed, it's as per the
- 35:24application form. So I think the free form text you could write in, you know, this money cannot be
- 35:29spent on at the TAB, for example, but it is not quite so, yeah, so it's not quite free flow text,
- 35:37just because we want to make sure that the systems with stands generate sure, yeah, if you know what I
- 35:42mean. So yes, we've built systems around it to ensure that we can stand by our wording on their
- 35:47guarantee that you're not going to have it. So how it works is you choose a pointing time, right?
- 35:53To date, and then you can dictate a upon passing, I want, let me pick on little Johnny here,
- 35:59I want little Johnny to receive my 500,000, but I don't want him to access more than 10% of the value
- 36:07of that bond for the first 10 years, right? Where we seen that, we seen that in live cases from
- 36:13advisors on grandparents bypassing generation and going straight to the grandkids, right? And
- 36:21they're not necessarily worried about the kids, you know, perhaps any serious misuse, but they
- 36:29just worried about their mismanagement of a large lump sum of money and end to Michael's point
- 36:33earlier paraphrasing him easy come easy go, right? And they may waste that lump sum of money straight
- 36:39away. So for grandparents, it's important for a period of time to have restrictions in place for
- 36:45the grandkids to get used to having a large lump sum of money into their, let's call it bank
- 36:51account. At times for parents, what we've seen that feature being very useful is when kids may
- 36:59have a dependency which limits their capacity to manage their own affairs, right? So again,
- 37:06it's protecting kids from themselves. It's to ensure that the assets allow them to fulfill their
- 37:13life, but they're down the custodians of the assets, they're not going to completely deplete that
- 37:18value of the estate. But I think, you know, I humbly what I believe, you know, the structure of
- 37:23investment bonds and got even an added note on funeral bonds if I may as well. Oh, wow.
- 37:28What did it mean to you to do? I know, right? But it enables you to have that conversation,
- 37:33right? I think the reality of financial advisory on the country is that you don't, when it comes
- 37:40to estate planning, you don't even need to sell an investment bond. You just truly identified,
- 37:45what are your clients' needs? And one of the vehicles to achieve those needs, those objectives
- 37:50is the structure of investment bonds. But on the funeral bond, if I may,
- 37:55it's the right thing to do. So to answer your question around a very
- 37:58succinct point, what is generation life doing to encourage that? We're sharing education,
- 38:04right? It is our job as providers of investment bonds, funeral bonds, lifetime and use to share
- 38:10information. You know, it's great to hear you. It's great to hear Michael in a level of knowledge
- 38:15across structures on financial services is one that gives clients that confidence, right? And we
- 38:22just want to make sure that we're peaking those best practices and sharing around the country.
- 38:26I recall when I was doing a lot of professional development presentations, when I used to talk about
- 38:31funeral bond, which again, right? Funeral bond is purely a structure. There's an investment
- 38:35menu there, but it's purely a structure can be very tax effective because it's the only
- 38:40structure in Australia that is 100% asset and income test exempt, right? Not the demographic
- 38:46to which we're addressing this podcast, but the way that I used to encourage advisors to talk to
- 38:51it is you can nominate at a funeral director or the estate when it comes to a funeral bond, right?
- 38:57No, what I hope no, everyone gets out of this question as podcasts means is the conversation
- 39:03is important, right? You must be having those discussions. It's important to ensure that
- 39:07no, you address all of your clients needs, financial advisors, no more of a client's affairs than
- 39:13any other professional, be it in a accountant, be it a Wilson estate lawyer. Absolutely right. I mean,
- 39:20one of the listening to their flip, one of the things that struck me partly from my personal
- 39:26experience, but also from what I'm saying in the marketing, you'll talk to more advisors than
- 39:32most people have hopped in is, but in my case, my father is 93. Still plays golf three times
- 39:39a week. Still lives in the family home, still cruises twice a year. So they're not in their
- 39:44slow go years yet. I'm 63 and my boy's 25. So by the time my father passes, I'm more likely
- 39:53than not to be retired, assuming he's got five to 10 years or so of solid life ahead, maybe more,
- 40:01and my boy will be 30s. He's already a homeowner. So the dynamics around the traditional late 60s
- 40:10passing of the first generation, handing the money to the kids just as they're in their
- 40:16young kids, big mortgage stage of life has sort of moved on and demographics have overtaken that.
- 40:23So now we're seeing people being much older and they inherit. And so the generation skipping
- 40:31concept I think is is catching on. I don't know if you will see that, Michael. Yeah, I am. What I am
- 40:37also seeing though is the Sydney based in Sydney, well, Australian property prices are quite high.
- 40:43And what the challenge is and we've touched on this through the whole podcast is you have to be
- 40:51so careful. And this is the whole governance of stay planning, however you want to sort of
- 40:54custodial relationship education piece. How do you give enough to your kids to help them, but not
- 41:00too much that you actually it becomes a detriment because you rob them of the need to be productive
- 41:05in the world. And that's a delicate thing. And what I am finding the biggest struggles is,
- 41:10particularly the families that have I guess a little bit more wealth and they want their family
- 41:14to live around them in a suburb, which is probably unaffordable for the kids, is that balance
- 41:19between how much do I give the children to give them a leg up into the home, but not too much
- 41:25that I've given too much wealth to them so that they're kind of unproductive. So we're definitely
- 41:29seeing that a little bit. So it used to be small amounts like helping with a little deposit to
- 41:35get them into a house, but I'm seeing those small amounts getting bigger and bigger. So I am
- 41:38starting to see a bit of a wash through of existing wealth going early to the next generation.
- 41:45And then you just got to be very clever about how it goes. Is it going as a line? Is it going as a gift,
- 41:50advantages and disadvantages of both? But I guess to your point, what am I seeing? I'm definitely
- 41:55seeing more of that because they want their family to live near them, but they can't afford to,
- 41:59and then they need to bring some inheritance forward a little bit to get them into that position.
- 42:05Yeah, it's interesting you should say that about helping them to the harm. I mean, that is a big
- 42:09part of our business, I would say, that two-thirds of our young home buyers will be getting some
- 42:16or even substantial help from, momentarily, particularly in metropolitan areas. And one of our
- 42:23biggest, most most-read e-books is a book called How to Get Your Parents to Help You Into Your
- 42:29First Home Without Losing Your Dignity or Destroying Their Retirement. And that concept of,
- 42:35if you're about to take your quarter of a million dollars from Mum and Dad to get into your first
- 42:41home, however willingly, it sort of gives Mum and Dad a bit of a legitimate cause to
- 42:48be able to question your spending. And so when you rock up for Christmas dinner, you are probably
- 42:55opening yourself up to giving Mum and Dad a perfect excuse. So I take your point about that,
- 43:01taking away the incentive to work. But there's all sorts of family dynamics there. And
- 43:09I've even had some people saying, well, I'd rather give 47% to the tax office than 100% to my kids,
- 43:16but different strokes for different folks, I suppose. Which I guess is probably time to
- 43:24try and pull these threads together. So I'm going to ask you both the same question. But I
- 43:31like to start with you, Philippe, that if you could leave the advisors listening to this, the one
- 43:37thing that could go back and do something differently in their practice this week, based on the
- 43:43competence of your report, what would that be? Yeah, and look, and it may not be necessarily
- 43:48something different, right? But I think, you know, hopefully everyone has heard loud and clear
- 43:53today that that confidence in certainty in the system has softened, right? I don't think anyone
- 43:59needs to be worried about it, but I think what is clear is that clients want reassurance from
- 44:04their financial advisors. So make sure that you're having the right conversations with your clients,
- 44:09make sure that you across all the structures, which may be applicable to your clients,
- 44:15understand the demographic shifts, understand the different desires that their clients may have,
- 44:21and understand that unfortunately, there's no such thing as a silver bullet. And as further
- 44:26changes occur to the primary force of our industry's superannuation, there will be a strong
- 44:32desire for alternative structures. And it's important they will abress so that you can educate
- 44:37your clients and build that trust throughout. And before I come to you, Michael, just on that,
- 44:44what are the resources apart from this report that you got to support advisors in that journey?
- 44:50Well, we've got some, we've got the thought leadership piece, we've got some peer-to-peer guides,
- 44:55we've got the team at Generation Life here to assist. It is our job just to convene that education,
- 45:02it's our job to share around the country. We'd love to do it yet, we're very passionate about it,
- 45:08definitely reach out to us, if you say we'll all be able to help advisors.
- 45:11Okay, and Michael, having read the report and been a participant in its creation, what's your
- 45:20common to other advisors? Obviously, we shouldn't be, we should be sharing as professionals,
- 45:25rather than going, well, this is what I do there for you, you should do it. But as a professional,
- 45:29we obviously have a duty to share some of this stuff. What would your thoughts be?
- 45:33I mean, I have a natural level of learning. And as I said at the beginning, change is the one
- 45:40constant, it's always going to be coming through the pipeline. So as advisors, I think the best
- 45:45thing we can do is to be across the current reality, the current opportunities that are presented
- 45:52from that current reality, and then put ourselves in the best position to then advise families,
- 45:57moving forward, what's the best direction for them? So that's probably my key takeaway,
- 46:03we touched on trust. Trust is obviously our clients only going to follow your direction if they trust
- 46:09you. And I find the best way to engender trust is to learn as much as I can and care as much as I
- 46:16can about a family and learn as much as I can about the, I guess, the environment that we live in
- 46:23in terms of strategy and opportunity for those families and then just bringing both of those
- 46:28together. Yeah, one of the things that's always challenged or interested me in my 40 odd years in
- 46:36this industry or this sector is that giving advice is one thing, ensuring that the client
- 46:44A fully understands that it embraces it and then follows through. I've a few of my good friends
- 46:53are physiotherapists and they tear their hair out, giving the same patients the same exercises
- 46:58every few years when they come back with the same complaint. And well, if you did these exercise
- 47:03three years ago, when I gave them to you, you wouldn't be here today. But as advisors, there's
- 47:07sort of a, you know, there's always a portion of advisors of clients who go, well, thanks for that,
- 47:13but on good things. And there's also, there's a, there's a subtlety to that fence and you've
- 47:20really touched on it. There's a subtlety to a part of the role of the advisors is to, I guess,
- 47:25know that if the clients do follow this path, they're going to be better off, but to that initial
- 47:32inertia to get them going very difficult. So that's why things like when I touched on it, like
- 47:37the investment bond structure where it almost forces you out of that inertia because it's forcing
- 47:42you to save that extra 25% the following year. And it builds habits. It's all about building habits,
- 47:48following them through that first two to three years. And then it's kind of got its own momentum
- 47:51and off it goes. So, you know, a key part of what we do is to just really hold a client's hands
- 47:57through the used one, two, and three. And you'd see it as well. Once they get, once they start to
- 48:02see the momentum of the well strategy kind of having its own compounding effect, then we can
- 48:08step back a little bit and then just kind of it's more governance. But through those first one,
- 48:12two, three years, it's the footpath, the footprints in the sand. And this is what Benjamin Graham,
- 48:20you know, the original value investor said in his, I think it was 1934, but don't crop me precisely
- 48:27on that when he introduced dollar cost averaging that he says, you know, this is not a mathematical
- 48:32answer. This is about behavior and discipline to keep putting the same amount of money into the
- 48:36market every period, not more when the market feels good and less when it feels bad. But by putting
- 48:43the same number of dollars in over time, you end up with a lower average cost. And it's actually
- 48:49the discipline rather than the maths that makes that work. And I encourage all of our young
- 48:57advisors to read widely in the space. And one book I would encourage every advisor to read is a book
- 49:06called Advice that sticks by Dr. Moira Summers, I think it's her surname. She's our medical practitioner.
- 49:15But this book is, it's a fairly thin, easy to read book, but it goes right to the very heart of,
- 49:20yeah, delivering advice is one thing, but you've got to deliver it in a way to the client. Well,
- 49:25A, do it and B, stick to it, which is your point. And so I would thoroughly recommend any advisor,
- 49:31read that, read that book. And you know, for me, it comes back to the, you know, the five P's,
- 49:36you go, purpose, why am I doing this plan? This is what we're going to do to achieve that purpose.
- 49:42Portfolio, which is what's the investment I need to do that package, which is around the
- 49:47tax structure you're going to put around it and platform, which is how you're actually going to
- 49:53put it together and then product being the underlying investment product. So you have to put all
- 49:58those P's together. And if you take the client on that journey and building the disciplines that
- 50:03you're talking about, Michael, I think that's the answer. And of course, package and platform is,
- 50:08yeah, we're fully staying. Come in. So before I wrap up, was there anything either if you wanted to,
- 50:13to add to that story? No, I think that's a, you, you've subbed it out really well,
- 50:18the events. Really, we deal in helping families manage their relationship with money.
- 50:23There's an element to trust to that. There's an element to strategy to that. But that sort of lies
- 50:27at the heart and soul of what we do, understand each family's individual relationship with money and
- 50:32then help them guide them forward and then use the right tools to achieve the best outcome for them.
- 50:38I mean, if it was just about the maths, everyone in Reddit would be a millionaire and in quite
- 50:41clearly it's not. And so despite what AR might be doing to some of the tasks we do, I think the
- 50:50need for advisors will be around for a very long time to come. Isn't that exciting, right? Just that
- 50:56thought that confidence is more important than performance, right? Of course, performance has to
- 51:01be there, right? But that confidence now is a center to all conversations with clients.
- 51:07Well, thank you, Michael. Thank you, Philippe for joining us. And certainly thank you to
- 51:10Generation Life for this interesting thought pace that's food for thought for, I think all of us.
- 51:18And I'd encourage everyone listening to read and digested. And thank you to Generation Life
- 51:26for sponsoring this podcast. I'm Vin Scully and I've been joined today by Michael Bova of
- 51:32Family Wealth Advisory in Philippe Arojo CEO at Generation Life. So till next time, bye for now.