Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Duty of Candor to the Court: Epic Games and “One Bite” at the Apple with Dr. Wendy Patrick & David Carr
Transcript
- 0:03and welcome to duty of candor to the court, epic
- 0:06games and one bite at the apple. I'm Samantha
- 0:09Seves and I'm one of the membership committee
- 0:11chairs of the barrister section of the Beverly
- 0:13Hills Bar Association. And I am delighted to
- 0:16introduce today's speakers today, Dr. Wendy Patrick
- 0:20and David Sikar. Dr. Patrick is a career prosecutor
- 0:23who has completed over 170 trials and was named
- 0:27California Public Lawyer of the Year by Chief
- 0:30Justice of the California Supreme Court. She
- 0:32has also been recognized among the state's top
- 0:35professional responsibility and criminal attorneys
- 0:37and was honored as Instructor of the Year by
- 0:40the California District Attorneys Association.
- 0:44In addition to her legal work, Dr. Patrick owns
- 0:46Black Swamp verdicts, where she teaches and consults
- 0:49globally on legal, ethical, and psychological
- 0:52topics. Mr. Carr is an attorney based in Tucson,
- 0:55Arizona, specializing in legal ethics, discipline,
- 0:59defense, and attorney licensing. He previously
- 1:02served as a disciplined prosecutor and manager
- 1:04at the State Bar of California before returning
- 1:06to private practice in 2001. Mr. Carr is active
- 1:10in several professional organizations and is
- 1:12licensed to practice in California, Texas, and
- 1:15New Mexico. Now, let's get started. All right.
- 1:19Thank you so much for that great introduction.
- 1:22I'm going to share my screen and we're going
- 1:23to hopefully have some fun here because I happen
- 1:27to think legal ethics is one of the most exciting
- 1:29topics. that we teach, and I think we're going
- 1:31to try to prove it to you during the course of
- 1:34this next hour. All right. So as soon as I can
- 1:39figure out how to start the program here, let's
- 1:43see. Let's see if this works. Yeah, I should
- 1:49do it. There we go. All right. So, you know.
- 1:53One of the things that David and I share is a
- 1:57love of talking about legal ethics, all of the
- 2:00different dilemmas and different kinds of questions
- 2:04that come up. I mean, it's one of the most fascinating
- 2:06topics that you can teach on. And it permeates
- 2:09everything we do as lawyers. And I would say
- 2:11everything we do in our personal lives as well,
- 2:13which is another one of my programs. But what
- 2:15we're going to talk about today. is a very relevant
- 2:19line of, let's say line of cases because there
- 2:23are lots of different cases that get creative
- 2:26when it comes to sanctioning. for violations
- 2:30of duty of candor to the court. And that has
- 2:32to do with the kind of case file that was present
- 2:37in Epic Games versus Apple. And when I say case
- 2:40file, I mean the record of what happened, the
- 2:43record of non -compliance with a court order
- 2:46and how that intersects with the duty of candor
- 2:48rules that we know and love here in California.
- 2:52It's a wonderful thing to be familiar with the
- 2:55duty of candor to begin with. And one of the
- 2:58trajectories that we've seen as a legal ethics
- 3:00community, I would say over the last 15 years
- 3:03that David and I have been really doing a lot
- 3:05of these programs, he probably a lot longer,
- 3:08is just that, is that it's been a trajectory.
- 3:11There are more creative ways that lawyers are
- 3:14being called out for violating the duty of candor.
- 3:18It's not just affirmative misrepresentations.
- 3:21It's the more subtle, the more malicious, the
- 3:24more devious, those are court's words, not mine,
- 3:27that characterize some of what we see in some
- 3:31of the rulings at issue. And that's going to
- 3:33include a little bit about what we're gonna be
- 3:35talking about the ruling in the Apple case today.
- 3:39And to give a foundation for what we're gonna
- 3:42be talking about, I like to think of it as candor
- 3:45inside... and outside of the courtroom. Because
- 3:48we in California, and this is common in some
- 3:51other states as well, we have a variety of ways
- 3:54that lawyers manage to violate the duty of candor.
- 3:58It's not just candor when speaking in court.
- 4:00It can be a violation of truthfulness in negotiations.
- 4:04It can be misrepresentations in pleadings. It
- 4:08can be a affirmative. I'll call it miscalculations
- 4:12or creative ways to say that you're following
- 4:16a court order when actually you're sidestepping
- 4:19the rationale behind the court ordering whatever
- 4:22it was you were supposed to do in the first place.
- 4:24And we're going to see that with respect to the
- 4:26Apple case in just a minute. But Kander is becoming
- 4:29an ever -expanding duty of a lawyer. I also have
- 4:32to say, you heard that David is a former State
- 4:34Bar prosecutor. What a great platform for him
- 4:38to be able to sort of work in some of the trends
- 4:41that perhaps he's seen over the years in the
- 4:43variety of ways that a lawyer's candor can either
- 4:46be an aggravant or a mitigant in state bar proceedings.
- 4:51So for a variety of reasons, the duty of candor
- 4:54is one of the most important duties that lawyers
- 4:57have. Cutting corners doesn't cut it. when it
- 5:00comes to state bar prosecutions and discipline.
- 5:04And that is ever so true today, perhaps even
- 5:08more so in years past. And I say that knowing
- 5:10that no doubt plenty of my Los Angeles based
- 5:13colleagues may actually be on the call, who could
- 5:16probably turn places with me in a second and
- 5:19just pick it up and give the rest of the program,
- 5:21David could as well. So I'm sure I'll get emails
- 5:24after the fact if we do or say anything that
- 5:27they can relate to because it's really a great
- 5:28topic. Okay, I'm gonna turn it over to David
- 5:31for this. You know, I'm a career prosecutor.
- 5:34I also have a PhD in theology. That's why I'm
- 5:37often called Dr. Patrick, but you know, the process
- 5:41of getting the PhD in theology really made me
- 5:43appreciate all the work and trouble we go through
- 5:46in learning how to not only be lawyers, but how
- 5:49to be ethical lawyers, giving that continually
- 5:52changing legal landscape. And with that wind
- 5:56up, David, take it away and let us know a little
- 5:58bit about Epic Games. versus Apple. Well, thanks,
- 6:02Wendy. I appreciate the kind introduction. Let
- 6:05me just, as a sort of the preliminary matter,
- 6:08talk about the duty of candor and contrast it
- 6:13with the duty to be honest. There are actually
- 6:17two concepts at play that are related, which
- 6:20is honesty and honesty in California. I think
- 6:24we have a slide on this down the road. is typically,
- 6:27at least in the State Park context, prosecuted
- 6:30through Business and Professionals Code, Section
- 6:336106, which says that an act of corruption, dishonesty,
- 6:37or moral turpitude is a cause for disbarment
- 6:41or suspension. So we have an actual statutory
- 6:44duty of honesty, which to some degree is replicated
- 6:48in our, I call them new rules of professional
- 6:51conduct. They're new, I guess, from 2018. Still
- 6:54fairly new. But we also have a different duty,
- 6:59which is found in the Business and Professions
- 7:01Code, Section 606A -D, which basically is a duty
- 7:08of candor. And the distinction is important because
- 7:12candor is actually, the way candor is often defined,
- 7:18and I think specifically defined by the Office
- 7:21of Admissions for the State Bar of California.
- 7:25in the admissions context. The duty of candor
- 7:28is the quality of being so forthcoming, of being
- 7:33open, of revealing information that you may not
- 7:37even have a duty to disclose. Candor is a quality
- 7:45in many ways. It is much more than being honest.
- 7:49Honesty is important, but to be prosecuted for
- 7:52a dishonest act, you have to have an intent to
- 7:55deceive. Candor is actually a more expansive
- 7:58duty than the duty of honesty. So that's an important
- 8:02distinction. And I know it's an important distinction
- 8:04because when courts are, and you see this, this
- 8:08is something you see in the Epic versus Apple
- 8:12decision. It's more than being honest. The court
- 8:15wants you to be forthcoming. The court wants
- 8:18you to give the court information. and not play
- 8:22silly games, concealing information, or standing
- 8:28on legalisms to say, well, this is the fact,
- 8:31this is not a fact, this is privilege, this is
- 8:33not privilege. The court, and I think you see
- 8:36this in Epic Games, maybe you see this even more
- 8:40in federal court than state court, though every
- 8:43judge wants you to be candid. Every judge wants
- 8:47you to be more than honest. Every judge wants
- 8:50you to tell the judge what's really going on
- 8:53here and not high buying, you know, silly games.
- 8:57And it's funny, this decision is called Epic
- 9:00Games. And when you read Epic Games, you get
- 9:03the feeling that Apple was playing its own Epic
- 9:05game of trying to deceive the court by fighting
- 9:10clever, clever, too clever by half. Ways around
- 9:15this junction so at the games versus Apple is
- 9:19a pretty interesting decision It's kind of a
- 9:22disheartening decision And the thing that struck
- 9:28me about epic games was that the judge the magistrate
- 9:33judge in her decision the April I think April
- 9:3730 decision where she referred the batter to
- 9:41for possible criminal contempt prosecution, the
- 9:45judge really took Apple to task for this incredibly
- 9:49elaborate pattern of conduct, a pattern that
- 9:53was quite apparent in the evidence of working,
- 9:56trying to work around the court's previous injunction.
- 9:59And the thing I guess that strikes me as a lawyer
- 10:01who represents other lawyers is the extent to
- 10:05which the lawyers emerged somewhat unscathed
- 10:11in the decision. Apple was put on the carpet
- 10:15for a lot of behavior, but the lawyers essentially
- 10:20were not referred for discipline. The lawyers
- 10:22weren't even mentioned in the decision, which
- 10:25I found very interesting. There's a line where
- 10:30they reference the fact that although lies were
- 10:33told, the lawyers took no remedial measures to
- 10:36correct the lies. So the thing about Epic Games
- 10:39is interesting to me. is that the lawyers essentially
- 10:44emerge relatively unscathed in the decision,
- 10:47which I found interesting. And you see on the
- 10:52screen about sort of a little bit about the highlights
- 10:54of the decision. And I've got one more that David
- 10:57kind of talked about this. I'm going to pick
- 11:00up on what a really great point that David made.
- 11:03So we may not be the ones, the lawyers may not
- 11:05be the ones engaging in dishonesty, game playing,
- 11:08whatever it is. Misrepresentation is what we
- 11:11often say because it's possible to be technically
- 11:13correct and completely misleading in context.
- 11:17I often teach on ethical advertising. We talk
- 11:20a lot about that. Well, the duty of candor in
- 11:23court 3 .3 includes a duty to clean it up. If
- 11:26you know something got out there and you know
- 11:28it's not true, take remedial measures. And I
- 11:31have to say our new California rules that we
- 11:33adopted in 2018 and take a very expansive approach
- 11:36as to what that means. And I always say, you
- 11:39know, you look at the rule 3 .3 duty of candor.
- 11:41Most people have it memorized. Don't cheat yourself
- 11:43by not looking at the comments because we have
- 11:45more comment sections today in the new rules.
- 11:50I say new since. than ever before. And I will
- 11:54also remind everybody that not all of those rules
- 11:57are dated back to 2018. Several of them had been
- 12:00revised as recently as last year. You know, it
- 12:05used to be like the phone book. You know, you
- 12:07had an entry in there or an ad or whatever it
- 12:09was. And if it was incorrect, you had to wait
- 12:11till the next year. That is not true anymore,
- 12:14anywhere. And it's also the case with ethical
- 12:16rules. Ethical rules. are revised frequently.
- 12:20One stunning example of that is artificial intelligence,
- 12:23competence 1 .1. But that's just one of many
- 12:27example as to why you can't just print out the
- 12:30ethics rules, put them in a binder and put them
- 12:32on your shelf. They have to be a living document
- 12:35and you have to look and make sure that they
- 12:37haven't been updated. Oftentimes when they are,
- 12:40They come with accompanying case law that justifies
- 12:43the update. So that's one of the ways in which
- 12:45you can comply with one point one competence.
- 12:48I just have to I just have to comment, Wendy,
- 12:50that that is such an important point that you
- 12:53have to work to keep up with the ethics rules.
- 12:56Even the ethics experts have to work to keep
- 12:59up with the ethics rules. You can't rely on what
- 13:03you learned in law school. The thing you learned
- 13:05in law school, I mean, what I learned in law
- 13:08school goes back so far, I don't even want to
- 13:10talk about it, but it goes way back, actually
- 13:14all the way back to the old model code of professional
- 13:16responsibility with the ECs and the DRs, which
- 13:20sounds like it's the Stone Age now. You can't
- 13:23rely on what you learned in law school. Hopefully
- 13:25you had a good PR course in law school, but your
- 13:30ethics knowledge has to be a living. breathing,
- 13:34ongoing process. There's one of my favorite California
- 13:40cases says a lawyer has a constant and perpetual
- 13:44rendezvous with ethics. And that's what Wendy
- 13:47was talking about when she says ethics pervades
- 13:49everything we do as lawyers and even lawyers
- 13:52in our personal lives. That is literally true.
- 13:57And I always try to work to instill that attitude
- 14:01in lawyers that the state part of California
- 14:04says, well, you get to spend four hours every
- 14:07three years learning about legal ethics. Of course,
- 14:10if I had my way, it'd be a lot more. And it's
- 14:14really disheartening to see good lawyers get
- 14:17into trouble out of sheer ignorance. So don't
- 14:21be that lawyer. Yeah, no, that's a really good
- 14:24point. I mean, you know what that that's a great
- 14:26segue into a discussion of the California rules
- 14:29Illustrated with a photo I took not from the
- 14:32internet out in Palm Desert But you know part
- 14:35of why I just I love photography in California
- 14:39is we are so unique in so many different ways
- 14:41and beauty and geography or some of them but
- 14:43the ethics rules are another and we are tough
- 14:46in California when it comes to looking at violations
- 14:50when it comes to taking the duty of candor type
- 14:53violations more seriously than perhaps it would
- 14:56be taken elsewhere. And this ruling we're talking
- 14:58about today really illustrates that fact. You
- 15:01know, I'm a career prosecutor and one of the
- 15:03trends that we begin to see as as as long as
- 15:07maybe 20 years ago in the readiness departments.
- 15:09was and if we were doing this live, I would see
- 15:12if anybody in the audience would guess this.
- 15:14The one question courts complained more about
- 15:17than anything else is, are you blank? And the
- 15:22answer is ready, because the same is true in
- 15:26civil courts. The worst thing lawyers were doing.
- 15:29is answering up ready when they technically didn't
- 15:32know whether or not everybody was served. Everybody,
- 15:34you know, discovery was complete. The negotiation
- 15:38process. And what they were doing is tying up
- 15:40courts precious time with cases that really weren't
- 15:42ready. So that became a candor issue. And David
- 15:47would say, you know, this goes to, is it honest
- 15:49not to have full disclosure as to the facts one
- 15:53way or another? And so it would probably be preferable
- 15:56asked questions like that if lawyers explained.
- 15:58You know, this part is ready. This part isn't.
- 16:01You know, do you want me to check on this? In
- 16:02other words, this full portrait of whether or
- 16:05not you actually are ready to get sent to a department.
- 16:08So too with complying. with court orders, which
- 16:11of course was one of the bases of the recommended
- 16:15sanctions in the Apple case, is court orders
- 16:18are meant to be obeyed. You know, like that mug
- 16:22that says she is meant to be obeyed or your parents
- 16:24are meant to be obeyed. I've seen it a lot of
- 16:26different ways. Court orders are meant to be
- 16:28obeyed. There was a great line in the Apple decision
- 16:31about a court order is an order, not opening
- 16:34negotiation. So that is one of the things that
- 16:38we'll probably see again. But I wanna say one
- 16:41of my favorite parts, I know, right? Wendy, get
- 16:44a life. One of my favorite parts of the, our
- 16:48rules here in California is this. It is rule
- 16:511 .0, comment four. Why? Because it illustrates
- 16:55very nicely how our rules really advise us and
- 17:01suggest and invite us to look elsewhere for guides
- 17:04if we can't find the answer we need in California.
- 17:06Which, by the way, for many of my ethicists on
- 17:09the line, you know that happens more often than
- 17:12not. The California rules just don't cover everything
- 17:15that rules in other states do. And if they do,
- 17:18they cover it a little bit differently. By the
- 17:20way, that really applies to our latest acquisition,
- 17:248 .3, the snitch rule. We really did. Our snitch
- 17:28rule really looks very different than the ABA
- 17:30or other states, so a little caveat. But look
- 17:32at what it says here in comment four. In addition,
- 17:35to the authorities identified in this rule. We
- 17:39are looking also at opinions of ethics committees.
- 17:42So for example, David and I sat for years, I
- 17:45think you still are on the San Diego County Bar
- 17:47Ethics Committee. We both chaired it. I'm a former
- 17:50chair of CoPRAC. I think David spent his time
- 17:52on CoPRAC also. But we spent all this time writing
- 17:56ethics opinions to try to give factual support
- 17:59in hypothetical form for practitioners so that
- 18:02they never do get that letter from the state
- 18:04bar. Look what else comment four says ethics
- 18:07opinions rules and standards by other jurisdictions
- 18:11and bar associations emphasis mine may also be
- 18:15considered. Some of you may be old enough to
- 18:17remember Google ethics. We used to have these
- 18:19like special Google browsers that we could use
- 18:22to find different topics. Now it's just a regular
- 18:25search or I don't know. I'm sure a lot of you
- 18:26are doing it on. chat GPT or Westlaw and then
- 18:29of course backing it up with with reading the
- 18:32cases. But it's it's a great disclaimer we have
- 18:35in our own rules that you're invited to look
- 18:37elsewhere. Now David also testifies as an expert
- 18:40witness in ethics and what he would probably
- 18:42say is this is part of a standard of care nowadays
- 18:46is that lawyers are expected to know that they
- 18:49don't just stop their search in the state where
- 18:51they're licensed because the state bars looking
- 18:53at other jurisdictions. If we don't have what
- 18:55we need here. So should we. And if you look at
- 18:58the comment sections at many of our own state
- 19:02bar and our own professional rules here in California,
- 19:06you will see other jurisdictions and guidelines
- 19:09cited right in our own annotations. Right in
- 19:12the comments, you'll see references to the ABA
- 19:15standards. You'll see references to other standards.
- 19:17And that's important to understand how expansive
- 19:20our rules are. David, anything before I move
- 19:23on? Well, there's an important point here for
- 19:26practitioners in federal court is that the rules,
- 19:30the rules of professional conduct of the state
- 19:32bar of California are binding in California courts.
- 19:37Now, when it comes to the federal courts, though,
- 19:40there's a little more latitude that federal judges
- 19:42have. And take a look in most federal local rules,
- 19:49usually around a local rule 83 .3 or DAS 3, you'll
- 19:54see a discussion of what standards are binding
- 19:57in this federal district court. And you'll see
- 20:00that generally speaking, well, you see language
- 20:04much like this. They'll say generally speaking,
- 20:06the rules of professional conduct and the standards
- 20:10of the State Bar of California are the standards
- 20:12of conduct in this court. But they're not the
- 20:16exclusive standards in federal court. Federal
- 20:21judges being separate sovereigns have more discretion
- 20:25to pick and choose between the rules they like.
- 20:29And honestly, many of them like the ABA model
- 20:32rule formulation of rule 3 .3. I did a panel
- 20:37about 15 years ago with the magistrate judge.
- 20:41We were talking about a model rule 3 .3 versus
- 20:44California's Actually, California had not adopted
- 20:473 .3 at this point. The ABA model rules are much
- 20:51different than California because they contain
- 20:54much more robust exceptions to confidentiality.
- 20:58The ABA version of the model rule actually gives
- 21:02a lawyer permission as part of remedial measures
- 21:07to correct past perjury or dishonesty. gives
- 21:10the court gives the lawyer permission to disclose
- 21:13information to the court. It's not present in
- 21:16California. So in federal court, you in state
- 21:21court, we have California's very strict confidentiality
- 21:24rules, which make our rules of professional conduct
- 21:28different. In federal court, it's a little bit
- 21:31more open. And I'll tell you the federal and
- 21:33keeping with that candor concept. The federal
- 21:36judge, magistrate judge really likes the rule
- 21:39that says you got to talk. You got to talk about
- 21:42stuff that might, you might not be able to disclose
- 21:45in California. And that's often an ethical issue
- 21:49is the federal judge wants me to disclose confidential
- 21:54information. Can I do that? And it's a tricky
- 21:57question because the rules are a little bit different
- 22:01in federal court. That is one of the most fascinating
- 22:04questions we've discussed over the years, is
- 22:06what do you do when you're not technically following
- 22:09at all times our California version, which of
- 22:12course, highlights the duty of confidentiality
- 22:15above candor to the court. We've actually written
- 22:17an ethics opinion on that in San Diego. It's
- 22:20a fascinating question. I know some of you on
- 22:22the call probably have discussed it with us at
- 22:25some of these ethics symposiums and maybe someday
- 22:28we'll get a ruling and an answer as to how we
- 22:30do that. But let's go through the main rule that
- 22:34we're always talking about and see exactly how
- 22:36it's phrased here in California. So it talks
- 22:39about knowingly make a false statement of fact
- 22:42or law. Now, we have all unknowingly misstated
- 22:47facts. It just happens. Maybe you didn't jeopardize
- 22:49a case or you misspoke. I mean, there's so many
- 22:52different things that happen in court. Maybe
- 22:55a witness is expected to make certain statements,
- 22:58so you make an offer of proof, and then there's
- 23:00the big oops moment. That is not a knowing violation
- 23:04of 3 .3 now. It might be a violation of 1 .1
- 23:07competence, so you don't want to default into
- 23:10either statute if you can help it. But this is
- 23:14for knowingly making false statements a fact
- 23:16or a law to a court. And here's what we were
- 23:18talking about earlier. Or failing. to correct
- 23:22them. Now what's interesting about showing you
- 23:24this rule in a conversation about the Epic Games
- 23:28case versus Apple is that the court affirmatively
- 23:32stated that somebody had lied. Now that's very
- 23:35different than saying, you know, well, First,
- 23:37you said this, then you said this. To call something
- 23:39an affirmative lie insinuates you are basing
- 23:42it on evidence that's in the record sufficiently
- 23:44credible that you're going to make that statement.
- 23:47It reminds me of, again, the way 8 .3 is phrased,
- 23:50this niche rule. You have to have that level
- 23:52of corroboration where you have confidence in
- 23:54what you're saying. And this judge's order led
- 23:57us to believe she had that kind of confidence.
- 24:00So that is the way it is phrased in the first
- 24:04statement. And then here is where I think many
- 24:09lawyers probably find themselves in trouble sometimes,
- 24:12unknowingly. There's a lot of, and there's probably
- 24:16less so nowadays now that really the courts and
- 24:19state bars are really cracking down. I mean,
- 24:21motions have to be really good. Shepardai is
- 24:23updated up till the minute that you present that
- 24:27in court. If a law clerk does that, you have
- 24:28to read every case. I mean, we really have to
- 24:30be careful that we don't accidentally fail to
- 24:33disclose controlling legal authority. And we
- 24:35also have to make sure we don't offer false evidence,
- 24:38but it has to be known to be false. Now, one
- 24:41thing about this prong that will take a second
- 24:44to discuss. The case law on this issue is a higher
- 24:48standard than some people believe. Some lawyers
- 24:51worry that, well, I really believe that it's
- 24:54reasonable. My client said it. I feel like it's
- 24:56corroborated. That's very different. than making
- 25:00a statement that really doesn't make much sense
- 25:03to anybody. And there's an argument out there
- 25:05that, well, anybody would know that that should
- 25:07have been corroborated before it was affirmatively
- 25:09stated to the court. Same thing with negotiations.
- 25:12You know, 4 .1 talks about truthless negotiations,
- 25:15and then we'll get to 6106 as well. But courts
- 25:18seem to have less patience for statements recklessly
- 25:21made that... maybe arguably don't even seem like
- 25:24anybody would would find them believable without
- 25:27doing due diligence and actually having sufficient
- 25:29proof on which to base those statements. But
- 25:33having said all of that, it is hard to find maybe
- 25:37some somebody on the call has found it. So please
- 25:39email David I afterwards case law that is that
- 25:44is really clear as to what the quantum of proof
- 25:47is to be guilty of offering evidence. known to
- 25:51be false. Now the easy example is your client
- 25:53tells you it's false and you offer it anyway.
- 25:55You don't ever have that, okay? Lawyers don't
- 25:57go out and knowingly commit perjury for the most
- 26:00part. It's that gray area we worry about where
- 26:04maybe we feel uneasy representing it because
- 26:07there's something gnawing at us that makes us
- 26:09think, you know, we should do something to corroborate
- 26:12this evidence before we just enter into the evidence
- 26:14and vouch for it if we really don't know. And
- 26:19it's also interesting, and I'm gonna toss it
- 26:21to David for his commentary after I do this slide,
- 26:25that candor in the courtroom doesn't just mean
- 26:29a regular courtroom you're sent to with a bailiff
- 26:32and a pitcher of water and those little paper
- 26:35cups. No, it also governs proceedings, including
- 26:39ancillary proceedings. And they give the example
- 26:42of a deposition. I can't tell you over the years
- 26:44how many lawyers just said, well, that didn't
- 26:45happen in court. That happened in the deposition.
- 26:47Well, guess what? Right there in comment number
- 26:50one, deposition conducted pursuant to a court's
- 26:54authority. And then, of course, tribunal is one
- 26:56of those fancy words that's defined. But this
- 26:58whole process, I'd love to hear David Idnei even
- 27:02call to mind some other illustrative examples
- 27:05of how expansive duty of candor to the court
- 27:08now really is. Well, I think of the recent cases
- 27:11that have come out about lawyers and this is
- 27:14something Yeah, you know again dating myself
- 27:18we used to go into a room with a court reporter
- 27:21and everybody was in a room and hopefully the
- 27:24room had a lot of hot coffee ready for consumption
- 27:27and We take a deposition in a room now We take
- 27:30off and take depositions via zoom or video platform
- 27:34and there's been a number of cases lately And
- 27:39I actually had a discipline case not too long
- 27:42ago. I guess I can talk about it because it's
- 27:44over now. Where a lawyer was essentially taking
- 27:49advantage of the video format to coach the witness.
- 27:53We've had a number of stories in the paper about
- 27:56lawyers coaching the witness, including one story
- 28:00where the lawyer was texting the witness during
- 28:05the deposition. while the remote deposition was
- 28:08going on and basically telling the witness what
- 28:11to say which i think is a violation of 3 .3 candor
- 28:16to the court includes candor in a deposition
- 28:19and coaching the witness uh my case the the the
- 28:23lawyer was actually doing it verbally during
- 28:25the deposition but we've had situations where
- 28:28lawyers again uh unscrupulous dishonest lawyers,
- 28:33in my view, and the view of the court and probably
- 28:36the state bar, only thinks like texting witnesses
- 28:39during depositions and telling them what to say.
- 28:42That's a violation of 3 .3. That is a lack of
- 28:45candor and probably a dishonest conduct as well.
- 28:51Those are some really good examples. I like the
- 28:53way you said texting because it's easier to text,
- 28:57but somebody's going to see it and it's going
- 28:59to be easier to prove as well. Well, that's why
- 29:02you know on the on the zoom call they kept noticing
- 29:05that the lawyer would be looking down And the
- 29:09same time the witness would be looking down at
- 29:12the off -camera phone Which is how everyone which
- 29:14is how opposing counsel said wait a second How
- 29:18come they're both like looking down like they're
- 29:21looking at something else and that's kind of
- 29:23how the how it came to light Although the lawyer
- 29:25denied it. It was pretty clear that that was
- 29:28going on Called circumstantial evidence. So that's
- 29:31a great example very good So here's an interesting
- 29:35part of a 3 .3 a3 regarding remedial measures
- 29:39So we talked about knowingly offering evidence
- 29:42to known to be false but one thing that is sometimes
- 29:45overlooked is lawyers will say well that wasn't
- 29:48my client that was just a witness and So I I
- 29:52don't know what the witness said and I don't
- 29:54have a duty there, but you do Reading all the
- 29:57way through 3 .3 sometimes fascinates lawyers
- 30:00that are used to the old codes and just kind
- 30:03of common sense approaches. They would describe
- 30:06it as to where the duty of candor ends. But look
- 30:10at this oral witness called by the lawyer. Now
- 30:13the material evidence may come out in cross -examination,
- 30:16but that doesn't matter according to the rule.
- 30:18It doesn't say that. It talks about coming to
- 30:20know about the falsity. and take the duty to
- 30:22take remedial measures, including, if necessary,
- 30:25disclosure to the court. Unless, and here's where
- 30:28we get our business and profession code section
- 30:306068 coming back into play, the confidentiality
- 30:34provision under E, that takes precedence over
- 30:36Canada, the court in California. It's hard to
- 30:38even get that sentence out because it doesn't
- 30:41make sense to anybody that practices in another
- 30:43state or under the ABA because it's different
- 30:46in California. And courts, I'm sure, are not
- 30:50pleased about the fact that it's under 6068 subdivision
- 30:56E that elevates that duty as paramount. So we
- 30:59had that before we adopted the new set of rules
- 31:01in 2018, and many predicted we were gonna do
- 31:04away with it and become more consistent with
- 31:06the ABA in the other states, but we didn't. That's
- 31:09the only in California side of us is that we
- 31:13retained that chronology of loyalty under California
- 31:17rules. Well, the I just have to say that statutory
- 31:23law was written in 1847 and And by a guy named
- 31:27David Dudley feel and by strange coincidence
- 31:30his brother Stephen feel Was one of the first
- 31:34judges on the California Supreme Court? So maybe
- 31:37that's why we've had even stuck with 6106 since
- 31:421851 what was originally enacted and the legislature
- 31:47shows no sign of getting rid of the BNP code.
- 31:50So we're going to have to live with that for
- 31:52a long, well, the rest of my life, certainly.
- 31:56And David, you weren't even around in 1861, if
- 31:58I'm not mistaken. I was very young in 1861. Yes,
- 32:02I was just a kid. You know, institutional knowledge
- 32:05often provides rationale and knowing the rationale
- 32:09behind some of these rules might have prevented
- 32:11the misbehavior in Epic Games versus Apple. because
- 32:15one of the things the court also said that David's
- 32:17comments remind me of is that the behavior violated
- 32:20the spirit of the order. It's not enough to say,
- 32:24oh, technical compliance, I really did comply.
- 32:26No, you knew the spirit of the order and you
- 32:28were in violation of that. And that doesn't,
- 32:32judges don't appreciate that. And it often serves
- 32:34as an agreement because then it appears to be
- 32:36devious or malicious or an intentional attempt
- 32:39to circumvent what was clearly the intent of
- 32:42the judge issuing the order. So, you know, thank
- 32:45you for reminding me about that. That's really
- 32:46important. And I'll tell you another rule that's
- 32:49really important here in California is good old
- 32:516068B. And for those of you that don't know that
- 32:55off top of your head, that is the duty of respect
- 32:59to the court. And let me show you a little bit
- 33:02about the way that is phrased. Duty of an attorney
- 33:05to maintain the respect due to the courts. So
- 33:09if you ever find yourself traveling on vacation
- 33:11and you have forgotten literature to read, you
- 33:13don't have a magazine, pull up the annotations
- 33:16to 6068B. They read like a novel. You can't make
- 33:20these stuff up when you look at the kinds of
- 33:22case law that's been made by lawyers failing
- 33:24to show respect to court orders. It is absolutely
- 33:28unbelievable. But that's part of the analysis
- 33:30in a case like this is you've got to follow an
- 33:33order. There are ways to judge. There are ways
- 33:36to challenge a judge's order. You have to take
- 33:38one of those attempts at remedying the injustice
- 33:42if you believe the court was wrong instead of
- 33:44disobeying the order. Kind of like in my line
- 33:46of work, you know, If you get arrested, you don't
- 33:48think you deserve it. You've got to go ahead
- 33:50and go through the process and then you challenge
- 33:52it. So too, when it comes to failing to respond
- 33:55and obey a judge's order. And it's more than
- 34:00that. There are lots of cases that are just fascinating
- 34:04examples of Kahliliquis caught on the record.
- 34:07uh as to the kinds of things that lawyers do
- 34:10and say thinking that they're well i've made
- 34:12a record that i was about to disobey a judge's
- 34:15order because i found it to be unlawful and then
- 34:17going ahead and disobeying the order and you
- 34:19know the court disappears to the state bar and
- 34:20it's easy to prove That would be the kind of
- 34:23case David would have loved to have had when
- 34:24he was a state bar prosecutor. It was a transcript
- 34:26of what transpired that was dishonest. But 6068
- 34:31talks about that and the case law and the annotations
- 34:33give some really good, clear examples that won't
- 34:37surprise a lot of people, but may surprise some
- 34:40that have a lingering belief that, well, it's
- 34:44the right thing to do for your client. If you
- 34:46know the court's wrong, the right thing to do
- 34:47for your client is not to get yourself in trouble
- 34:49now on top. of the fact that your client's already
- 34:53litigating a matter in court. So this is one
- 34:54of the citations you'll have in your material.
- 34:58Now, this is interesting. Now, those of us that
- 35:01have been around for 30 years or more, nobody
- 35:04do the math, but some of us remember the old
- 35:07business and profession code section 6068C. And
- 35:12I would, again, I wish I was live with you guys
- 35:14because I can imagine some of you are nodding
- 35:16your head right about now. Do you remember the
- 35:19offensive personality? prescription. I mean,
- 35:22what in the world did that mean? Who who has
- 35:24an offensive personality? Many lawyers would
- 35:27say, yeah, that's why I went all my cases is
- 35:29I'm really good in the court. I'm a bulldog in
- 35:31a court. Yeah. Some lawyers would say, well,
- 35:33I'm a good lawyer, but my personality is offensive.
- 35:36But. And, and it's, it's, you know, this is nostalgic
- 35:41for me because as a prosecutor, I prosecuted
- 35:44a lawyer for, uh, under this role. Uh, this was
- 35:47a lawyer who, but his behavior was really extreme.
- 35:51He would lose his temper and throw chairs during
- 35:54one of those old fashioned in, in the room depositions.
- 35:57He'd get mad and pick up a chair, kind of like
- 35:59Bobby Knight. He was like the Bobby Knight. personal
- 36:03injury lawyers. He'd pick up a chair and throw
- 36:06it across the room in the deposition when he
- 36:08got mad. And so I prosecuted him early in my
- 36:12career under this rule. And a few years later,
- 36:15the Ninth Circuit said unconstitutionally vague.
- 36:18Offensive personality. What was the result of
- 36:21your case? Did you win? Well, yeah, the public
- 36:25retrieval. It was minor discipline, but still
- 36:28it was something and it was under the old version
- 36:31six and six eight f i think we could agree that
- 36:33throwing a chair across the room is offensive
- 36:36personality uh but that's that's we had that
- 36:40tool back then and uh uh but the truth is if
- 36:44the state bar wants to prosecute a lawyer they
- 36:46will find a a way to do it but that was a convenient
- 36:50way to do it then And you know, what's interesting
- 36:53about that comment, David, is a convenient way
- 36:55to do it is also by looking at recent case law,
- 36:57judge's orders, and decisional law. You sort
- 37:00of get a feel for, well, what are the courts
- 37:02consider to be dishonest behavior nowadays? And
- 37:05there was a time when not every lawyer believed
- 37:07that failing to follow completely and to the
- 37:10T, a court's order would get them into trouble
- 37:13and get them disciplined. Now we even have these
- 37:16nuances as to, well, maybe technically, You followed
- 37:19my order or most of my order, but you did it
- 37:22in a fashion that you knew would give yourself
- 37:25another option of finding another way of doing
- 37:27what I said you couldn't do, which is also part
- 37:30of the Epic Games versus Apple ruling. So it's
- 37:33interesting, and this is the case that we normally
- 37:37cite for approving that rule, but it's almost
- 37:40like if any of you have raised teenagers, there
- 37:42come to be those years where they're smart enough
- 37:44to know how to technically be in compliance with
- 37:47what you told them they had to do or they couldn't
- 37:49do, but still manage to misbehave. And what do
- 37:52you say in response unless you're a lawyer? Well,
- 37:54the spirit of the rule wasn't followed. You may
- 37:56have followed my word. I mean, that's what the
- 37:57lawyers were doing in this case, arguably. You
- 38:00know, there's two sides to every argument, but
- 38:02that was the argument here. And that's what the
- 38:04argument is in plenty of other cases like Epic
- 38:09Games versus Apple, where the court makes a ruling
- 38:11and the lawyers find creative ways to continue
- 38:14making profit, continue doing whatever it was
- 38:16they were doing. Speaking to the media, by the
- 38:18way, is another place in which we've seen very
- 38:21high profile. failing to follow court orders,
- 38:25whether it's a gag order, whether it's a limited
- 38:27gag order. But there are always creative ways
- 38:30to circumvent a judge's ruling, even when a lawyer
- 38:34does understand exactly why that ruling was in
- 38:37place. All right. Yeah, just a quick comment
- 38:41on the offensive personality. We have a lot of
- 38:45there's there's case law being made all the time.
- 38:47And of course, there's a lot of discussion. the
- 38:50judges are very upset about the decline of civility.
- 38:53There are certain civility measures that are
- 38:56still pending in the Supreme Court. Actually,
- 38:59they've been pending for two years now, so it's
- 39:02interesting that the Supreme Court has not acted
- 39:03upon them. But the last point is, and we may
- 39:08have a slide on this down the road, one of the
- 39:13things that exist in tension with that duty of
- 39:16respect to the court is the fact that a lawyer
- 39:18still has first amendment rights even in the
- 39:22courtroom to an extent a lawyer still has first
- 39:25amendment rights to to free speech and uh in
- 39:29the recent case law from the state park court
- 39:32where lawyers have engaged in various kinds of
- 39:35uh questionable speech the court has done a very
- 39:40adroit job of maneuvering between the duty of
- 39:45respect to the court and the lawyer's First Amendment
- 39:48right to criticize a judge, because you do have
- 39:51a First Amendment right to criticize a judge.
- 39:54Now, but there are nuances. That right doesn't
- 39:58extend to making threats against the judge's
- 40:00family. We had a recent case in the state park
- 40:03court where the lawyer was making threats. Threats
- 40:06are not covered, but legitimate criticism can
- 40:09be protected by the First Amendment. And that
- 40:12is sometimes in the heat of battle, lawyers forget
- 40:16where the line is. And that's a good point. You
- 40:19know, 8 .2, the rule that talks about what lawyers
- 40:22can say about judges really talks about dishonesty.
- 40:26And it's an interesting point you bring up. It's
- 40:28kind of the reverse here is that. We can't say
- 40:30anything that's dishonest made in bad faith.
- 40:33And by the way, stay tuned. Several of these
- 40:35rules were out for public comment recently regarding
- 40:38potential updates. And that goes back to what
- 40:41we said at the beginning is these rules are living
- 40:44beings. They are being updated. as issues arise
- 40:47and as ethical issues get litigated in court.
- 40:50And then you have rulings like this. Now, when
- 40:52I say like this, I mean ordering a criminal referral.
- 40:55And I show you by example, violating 60, 60 A
- 41:00.D. in court, messing with opposing counsel's
- 41:03papers during a court recess, hiding things.
- 41:07I mean, that sounds pretty bad, doesn't it? 60
- 41:09days suspension. you would think that it would
- 41:13have been more serious. And I feel like we've
- 41:15seen cases since then that have been more serious.
- 41:19And Epic Games versus Apple is one of them, when
- 41:21now you're actually also talking about potential
- 41:23referrals for criminal contempt. Now, I mentioned
- 41:278 .2 because I knew this slide was coming up
- 41:31next. That has been another way in which a lawyer's
- 41:34statements have been analyzed when it comes to
- 41:37honesty, which is the topic of today. This is
- 41:40a case from Arizona and where David just explained
- 41:43to me they're in monsoon season last week, I
- 41:46guess, despite it normally being really dry and
- 41:49hot. This is a case where a lawyer brought a
- 41:53motion for an honest and honorable courts and
- 41:55made statements about the judge such as dishonorable,
- 41:59brainless coward. But look at this. Now, this
- 42:01is not a try this at home moment. But it is interesting
- 42:06that the court said, well, that's not really
- 42:08A point to A because who really knows what a
- 42:11brainless coward means. Dishonorable is a little
- 42:14closer, but some of the litigation that's been
- 42:17successful in prosecuting lawyers have included
- 42:19the word dishonest. And part of that has to do
- 42:22with the insinuation that a term like that used
- 42:25it to describe a judge. basically it means you're
- 42:29basing it on undisclosed facts and there's something
- 42:31in there on a record that he or she did. However,
- 42:35the rulings go on and this is just an example
- 42:37of the kinds of rulings that hold this kind of
- 42:40result. There may be terms that are ambiguous,
- 42:42like offensive personality was maybe unconstitutionally
- 42:45vague, but there are other ethics codes that
- 42:49are going to get you making statements like this.
- 42:51They give the example of 8 .4D, which of course
- 42:53is misconduct. 3 .5, we'll go through some of
- 42:57those in there in your materials also. And even
- 42:594 .4A, which has to do with the way you treat
- 43:02another party, there's no substantial purpose
- 43:05in making comments like that under 4 .4A other
- 43:08than to embarrass and burden judges. This comes
- 43:12up in so many different ways from calling a judge
- 43:14by his or her first name. to making statements
- 43:16loudly in the hallway and in the earshot of other
- 43:19litigants about to go into the courtroom. There's
- 43:21a lot of that that goes on in the heat of the
- 43:23moment when lawyers lose their tempers. But what
- 43:26really gets them into the most trouble is when
- 43:28it is also insinuating that a judge is dishonest.
- 43:32The same thing that judges expect from lawyers.
- 43:37I think the result in California would have been
- 43:39different under California case law than the
- 43:42Arizona case. I suspect that that lawyer would
- 43:46have been disciplined in California for making
- 43:49those statements. More than he was. In pleading,
- 43:52apparently he didn't, Arizona was forgiving for
- 43:57whatever reason, but that would not fly in California
- 44:00in my view. And look at this explanation that
- 44:03was given, that given but not accepted. the medical
- 44:06defense was not accepted. And, you know, even
- 44:08if a court thinks, well, you know, maybe actions
- 44:11are not 100 % intentional, they were knowing
- 44:14more culpable than negligence. And that's another
- 44:17thing that we have done in California when we
- 44:19amended our rules. We talk about the negligence
- 44:23standard differently in the way the rules are
- 44:26phrased. That's true both in competence 1 .1
- 44:29and in diligence 1 .3. So keep an eye on those.
- 44:33They talk about gross negligence not. plain negligence.
- 44:36And I always say, you know, my legal advice,
- 44:38don't be the test case because you never know
- 44:41how a different state bar judge, maybe you won't
- 44:43get a prosecutor like David. Maybe you'll have
- 44:45somebody else that's arguing the subtlety of
- 44:48why we have the rule and why we have those distinctions.
- 44:51And if there's conduct engaged in that circumvents
- 44:53a court order like we had in Epic Games, that
- 44:56might be something that is going to be found
- 44:59to be knowing. So that's kind of an example of
- 45:02how that might come out in California. All right.
- 45:07So one of the things we'll move into just briefly,
- 45:10and you'll be able to see these in your materials,
- 45:13but I wanted to point out comment four, since
- 45:16we've been on the topic of both what you say
- 45:18and how you say it. The decorum of the courtroom
- 45:20rule. Now, why am I showing the ABA rule? Because
- 45:23we don't have... a perfect counterpart here in
- 45:26California, which is one of the reasons for Rule
- 45:281 .0 Comment 4, is we're invited to look elsewhere
- 45:32for guidance since we don't have anything explicit
- 45:35here. But many judges will tell you, and David
- 45:38and I frequently co -present with judges, anytime
- 45:40we start talking about contempt, the judge will
- 45:43get ready to interject because what are they
- 45:45going to say? They're going to say, for the record,
- 45:48contempt is a last resort. We, as judges, do
- 45:52not run around holding litigants in contempt,
- 45:55it is a last resort. We might threaten it, we
- 45:58might discuss it, but we're not going to do it
- 46:01unless we have enough to back it up. Another
- 46:04reason this case was so significant. But look
- 46:07at Comment 4 under ABA Rule 3 .5. Doesn't it
- 46:11sound a lot like the old offensive personality
- 46:14standard? It also calls up these civility standards
- 46:18that we all know and love that have been promulgated
- 46:21in our jurisdictions. refraining from abusive
- 46:24or obstreperous conduct. Don't you love that
- 46:27word? It just rolls off your tongue. Obstreperous
- 46:30conduct is a corollary of our right to speak
- 46:32on behalf of our clients. So it's sometimes interesting
- 46:35and certainly informative to read about what
- 46:37is expected in the courtroom if we don't already
- 46:41know instinctively. It goes back to some lawyers
- 46:44thinking, you know, I'm paid to be a zealous
- 46:47advocate and that's exactly what I'm going to
- 46:49do. And without my edge, I might not win every
- 46:52argument. Well, without your edge, you probably
- 46:55stand a lot more likelihood of never being a
- 46:58foul of any of these ethics rules because more
- 47:01and more, they're sure beginning to look like
- 47:02they're incorporating the mandate of civility
- 47:05in addition to ethics. Well, that's the tension
- 47:10in the law between the duty and the Z word is
- 47:15sometimes mentioned among ethics lawyers. The
- 47:18Z word is zealous. And the idea that zealous,
- 47:22you can be zealous, but you can't be a zealot.
- 47:25In other words, you have to, you can advocate
- 47:30vigorously for your client within the bounds
- 47:33of the law. That's Justice Holmes' famous formulation.
- 47:37And that ought to be always, the picture I always
- 47:40had of that is, well, you can go 100 miles an
- 47:42hour. But then you got to be prepared to stop
- 47:45on a dime and some lawyers can't stop by the
- 47:48time and they crossed the line from from being
- 47:51a cellist advocate to being an obstreperous zealot,
- 47:55you know, because they as a matter of human nature,
- 48:01it's it's knowing the line is difficult. And
- 48:05that's our job as lawyers is always to know where
- 48:08the line is, always know where the line is. And
- 48:12we don't always fulfill that role for you. And
- 48:15by the way, if you in a heat of passion drive
- 48:19right over that line, you can make it better
- 48:21for yourself by engaging what case law declares
- 48:24is the post outburst purge. In other words, you
- 48:28apologize immediately. You don't wait for a court
- 48:30to make a ruling and hold you in contempt. You
- 48:32get up right ahead of it and you do everything
- 48:34you can to mitigate it. You know, it was said
- 48:37in the heat of passion, you lost your temper.
- 48:39It's not going to happen again. Lawyers have
- 48:40really saved themselves much more pain and heartache
- 48:44down the line by acknowledging guilt early. And
- 48:48that's encapsulated in this comment as well.
- 48:51Look at what it says. It says you're protecting
- 48:53the record for subsequent review and you're preserving
- 48:57professional integrity. Here we get a lot more
- 49:00colorful too. They talk about that's a better
- 49:02tactic than engaging in belligerence or theatrics.
- 49:06Don't you love it? I mean, they really thought
- 49:08this through in describing no doubt some of what
- 49:11then seen in the courtroom in trying to give
- 49:14us some good guidance that that's not what they're
- 49:16going to expect to see from you. Now, this is
- 49:20an interesting part of comment for, isn't it?
- 49:22Here we go turning the tables again. If you have
- 49:26a judge. that is engaging, so you believe, in
- 49:30behavior that perhaps violates their canons of
- 49:32judicial ethics. Your remedy is not joining them
- 49:36in their misbehavior. Look at what it says. Stand
- 49:39firm against abuse. You avoid reciprocation of
- 49:44the judge's default. Let it be no justification.
- 49:47Listen to this. for similar dereliction by an
- 49:51advocate. So there's no excuse here under the
- 49:56law if, well, he started it, nope, you would
- 50:00be in violation of 3 .5, even if that in fact
- 50:03was the case and you had a record to prove it.
- 50:08All right, and there again, we talked about throwing
- 50:10chairs at depositions. Here you go again. That
- 50:13duty to refrain, and David, this would go to
- 50:16the chair throwing example. Absolutely. They
- 50:20talk about more than dishonesty, disruptive conduct.
- 50:23So you can imagine that's a very broad swath.
- 50:26You probably can imagine witnessing lots of things
- 50:28that happen in the courtroom as being disruptive.
- 50:30But there again, that is just not in a regular
- 50:34traditional courtroom that also includes a deposition.
- 50:40Just a comment on the ABA model rules. The ABA
- 50:45model rules, I mean, I spent a lot of time pondering
- 50:48the differences, and every state's enacted a
- 50:50different version of the model rules. But California's
- 50:53is very, very different than the ABA model rules.
- 50:57But in terms of concepts, the ABA model rules
- 51:01and the comments are much more extensive. You
- 51:04have a very long preamble to the ABA model rules,
- 51:08which is worth reading. Now, they're not the
- 51:12law in California. But they can be extremely
- 51:15valuable. And I've certainly used them in my
- 51:19work as a defense lawyer and discipline cases.
- 51:22I certainly use the concepts of the ABA model
- 51:25rules for persuasion, as opposed to them being
- 51:29black letter rules of law. So if you study the
- 51:32ABA model rules in law school or power to you,
- 51:37you didn't waste your time. Now that doesn't
- 51:40mean you can't know the California rules too.
- 51:43I would say to California lawyers, you may have
- 51:45studied the model rules of law school, but you've
- 51:47got to read the California rules because they're
- 51:49much, much, much different. Yeah. Um, we talk
- 51:54about the code of civil procedure and the court's
- 51:56power and you'll have those in your materials,
- 51:58but I want to follow up on, um, something that
- 52:01David said about, you know, kind of the difference
- 52:04in California and the ABA. We have measures and
- 52:08statements and comments such as in our rules
- 52:10that implicate the division of responsibility,
- 52:14the allocation of authority between you and your
- 52:16client. Obviously, when it comes to the goals
- 52:19of litigation, the goals of filing a case, you
- 52:21know, the client has a lot of sway there, but
- 52:24not when it comes to defining how it's going
- 52:26to be accomplished ethically. And that is where
- 52:29you have what I'm going to turn it over to David
- 52:31to talk about another one of my favorite rules.
- 52:33is the issue of client communication and the
- 52:37way in which you are an advisor of sorts. And
- 52:41that goes not only with meritorious claims and
- 52:44contentions, which is something that you're going
- 52:47to have to decide, but it's also going to talk
- 52:50about a couple more rules and then we're going
- 52:52to turn it over for questions. So this is one
- 52:54section, but I really want David to talk about
- 52:56this rule. I think it's so important. I broke
- 52:59it up into two slides for him because this is
- 53:01a really important rule that many lawyers have
- 53:05never actually read and considered in its entirety.
- 53:08I frequently hear lawyers saying, well, that
- 53:10consideration isn't really appropriate for me
- 53:12to discuss with my client. I'm really only paid
- 53:14to do legal analysis. Well, maybe. No, you're
- 53:17not. Maybe your role is broader than that. David,
- 53:20what do you think? Well, this is what they call
- 53:23you. I've heard things like this referred to
- 53:25as Easter eggs. This role is an Easter egg. It's
- 53:29a it's hidden in plain sight. It's not no one's
- 53:33to my knowledge has ever been prosecuted in at
- 53:36least in California for violating this rule But
- 53:39this rule goes to the essence the absolute essence
- 53:42of what it is to be a lawyer a lawyer I'm sorry
- 53:47epic games. I'm sorry Apple But you're not a
- 53:52hired gun You know, you're you're not a you're
- 53:55not a mindless robot that that takes direction
- 53:58from the client and and win at all costs You
- 54:02are a officer of the court. It's not in this
- 54:06role, but you see it elsewhere. It's clear the
- 54:10judges think you're an officer of the court,
- 54:11but you have a duty to exercise independent professional
- 54:16judgment and render candid advice. Shockingly,
- 54:20this means that sometimes you have to say, no,
- 54:22client. No, you can't do that. Or no, client,
- 54:27I won't do that. In the case law and in the rules,
- 54:34you'll see funny examples. Rule 1 .2 is a good
- 54:39one here as well, talking about the roles of
- 54:41attorney and client. You're not a robot. You're
- 54:44not a hired gun. You are a officer of the court.
- 54:49You're a quasi governmental official, which sounds
- 54:51crazy in a world where lawyering has gone business
- 54:55mad. You know, what motivated the lawyers for
- 54:59Apple? Well, money. I mean, let's be honest.
- 55:02That's what it's all about in high stakes litigation,
- 55:04right? Money. But you're still someone obligated
- 55:10to exercise independent judgment. And, um, a
- 55:14lawyer may initiate advice to a client when doing
- 55:17so appears to be in the client's interest. In
- 55:19other words, you can even go outside the scope
- 55:22of the thing that you've been hired to do to
- 55:26say, don't do it. that this reflects a vision
- 55:31of lawyering that dates from the time when lawyers
- 55:35were not service providers. We didn't provide
- 55:39a commodity, but we had a relationship with our
- 55:43clients. So you might say, well, this is a little
- 55:45bit anachronistic. Maybe it is. But in my view,
- 55:49this is what the essence of professional lawyering
- 55:52is all about, the exercise of independent judgment.
- 55:55And I think it's important to keep this light
- 55:57burning. Eat this Easter egg, bring out this
- 56:00Easter egg from under wraps. That's great. And
- 56:05what's interesting also about 2 .1 is this last
- 56:09section here. Many times I've heard lawyers say,
- 56:12well, I can't talk about politics and religion.
- 56:13I mean, but look at what it says in comment two.
- 56:17It doesn't prevent a lawyer who renders advice
- 56:20from considering things like moral, economic,
- 56:24social. political factors, if it's relevant to
- 56:27the client situation. I mean, it's a fascinating
- 56:30rule, like David said, that's been hiding there
- 56:32in plain sight. It's always been there. I've
- 56:34always thought it was fascinating. You just don't
- 56:36hear about it. But some lawyers have found it
- 56:38to be enormously valuable to sort of read the
- 56:42room, read the jurisdiction, know what arguments
- 56:44will and won't be persuasive in a certain area.
- 56:47on certain facts of your case. Is it a rural
- 56:50jurisdiction, a red state, a blue state? I mean,
- 56:52there are so many factors that may allow you
- 56:56and be who your client to be able to talk about
- 56:58some of those factors that are just non -legal.
- 57:01And by the way, in terms of the advice that you're
- 57:03giving and the case that you're representing,
- 57:05David mentioned 1 .2, which is allocation of
- 57:08authority. 1 .2 even says that you may not. buy
- 57:13in to all the arguments you're making to be able
- 57:15to make them. In other words, you may be representing
- 57:18a client in a matter that personally wouldn't
- 57:20be the way you would resolve the matter. And
- 57:23so 1 .2, 2 .1, some of these sleeper rules, as
- 57:26we say, are really valuable in today's legal
- 57:30climate. Now, we are reaching the end of the
- 57:33hour. So what I'm going to do is take a little
- 57:37peek in the... I don't see the Q &A. I see the
- 57:41chat. That's just... I see the Q &A. Okay, maybe
- 57:47I want to read the question. Only if it's one
- 57:51that one of us can answer. Well, we only have
- 57:55a few questions, so I think we can at least take
- 57:58a stab at them. The first question says, what
- 58:00happens when the judge's directives omitted orders
- 58:03and orders are unclear? What do you do then?
- 58:08Yeah, you know that happens all the time David
- 58:10I can both give our answers on this that happens
- 58:12a lot of time in my practice because I'm a court
- 58:14every day and you know, we seek clarification
- 58:17all the time Oftentimes we have the luxury of
- 58:21a court reporter So they you know, they need
- 58:22get a read back of what they said and figure
- 58:24out themselves how they maybe can rephrase it
- 58:27But it's never really been an excuse to especially
- 58:29if it's an unreasonable interpretation of an
- 58:31order to claim Well, that's that's you know,
- 58:33that's what you said And I would imagine that
- 58:37would go back to, again, what we saw in Epic
- 58:39Games versus Apple is that everybody knew that
- 58:42the remedy and the rationale behind the remedy,
- 58:45the injunction, the order, and that finding another
- 58:47way to make money off platform was the last thing
- 58:51they should have done given the boundaries of
- 58:53the order. But I'll give David a chance to answer
- 58:55this. It's a great question. Well, again, you
- 59:00have to play, in some sense, the cards you're
- 59:02dealt. You have opportunities to ask the court
- 59:05for a clarification, perhaps in the courtroom
- 59:09while the order is being made. You have the opportunity
- 59:12to seek reconsideration. You have the ability
- 59:15to appeal. All of those may be imperfect remedies.
- 59:20It may be very difficult to understand the court's
- 59:24orders. They may be ambiguous, but you have to
- 59:29do your best to try to get clarification. So
- 59:32that so that everybody knows what the judges
- 59:35is ordering the litigants to do and There's no
- 59:39perfect answer to that because judges are human
- 59:42like everybody else and and sometimes What they
- 59:46do is not clear Preface it with two and by the
- 59:51way, everybody take a screenshot. That's our
- 59:53contact information You can preface it and I've
- 59:55done this a lot is preface it with I if I may
- 59:58ask for some clarification because I want to
- 59:59make absolutely sure I understand the boundaries,
- 1:00:03the scope, the breadth of the court's order so
- 1:00:04I don't violate it. You know, you make a record
- 1:00:06like that, what's the state bar going to do?
- 1:00:08Come after a lawyer like that. You've done everything
- 1:00:10you can to understand the clarification. You're
- 1:00:13seeking clarification because you want to make
- 1:00:15sure you understand. And that's always going
- 1:00:19to save you. And guess what? Judges love to hear
- 1:00:22that kind of a question because they're going
- 1:00:25to be even more sure. uh that if you do do something
- 1:00:29accidentally that it wasn't intentional because
- 1:00:31you took the time to seek that kind of clarification
- 1:00:34and making the records the kind of courteous
- 1:00:38patient uh zelle advocacy that the role talks
- 1:00:42about and when i do it i always say thank you
- 1:00:45judge thank you judge for allowing me to make
- 1:00:47a record in my most polite diplomatic way to
- 1:00:51to sort of make it clear to the judge that thank
- 1:00:55you for Thank you for being part of a constructive
- 1:00:59part of the process. Making record is really
- 1:01:03something a judge can't. I've actually, there
- 1:01:07have been instances where the judge said, no,
- 1:01:09I'm not going to let you make a record. I will
- 1:01:12tell you what court and what county that was
- 1:01:14in, but it's one you may know well in California.
- 1:01:19It does happen, but you do your best. The second
- 1:01:21question, and it's a good one, is the judge obligated
- 1:01:24to report CCP 128 .5 sanctions based on lying
- 1:01:29and intentional suppression of information. I
- 1:01:32think that the question is, is the judge obligated
- 1:01:34to report that to the state bar? And as I read
- 1:01:37the statutes, I think the question is yes. The
- 1:01:41Office of Chief Trial Counsel actively solicits
- 1:01:45the judge's cooperation. They send letters to
- 1:01:48the judges on a regular basis. and say, tell
- 1:01:51us what's going on in your courtroom. Sometimes
- 1:01:54judges don't want to report a lawyer to the state
- 1:01:56bar. They don't want to be a snitch. But the
- 1:01:59Office of Chief Child Counsel, in their selfless
- 1:02:02way, encourages judges to keep the state bar
- 1:02:06informed about misconduct. So I think you have
- 1:02:08to assume the answer is yes. And we're going
- 1:02:11to have to defer the rest in case you want to
- 1:02:13email both of us offline. I'd like to thank David
- 1:02:17for joining me on this program. I mean, just
- 1:02:19terrific. So you've gotten two perspectives,
- 1:02:23a number of fresh, timely issues that no doubt
- 1:02:27are just the beginning of courts really taking
- 1:02:29a hard line as to the ways in which they expect
- 1:02:32compliance with the orders that they make. So
- 1:02:34with that, I'm going to turn it back over to
- 1:02:36our presenters. And I want to thank everybody
- 1:02:38for being on the call today. Thank you, everyone.
- 1:02:40It's been fun. Thank you.