Latest / Serves You Right / #90 Alice Feiring: What's Actually In Your Wine Glass?
Transcript
- 0:00One day I, you know, looked around and I realized the wines
- 0:02that I used to love were disappearing from the earth.
- 0:05And so I went on a journey to find out how this could be and
- 0:10who is responsible. And we were in the era of one
- 0:13very, very, very important wine critic who popularized.
- 0:16He didn't create the 100 point score, but popularized it.
- 0:20And people sold out their wines. Thank you for listening to
- 0:25Serbs. You're right.
- 0:25My name is Andrew and if this is your first time tuning in, this
- 0:29is a show for all the bartenders and servers out there.
- 0:32I've been in the bar and restaurant world for the last 20
- 0:35years. I've done everything, made every
- 0:37mistake you can think of, and I love it.
- 0:40And I'm trying to share that love and passion with the world.
- 0:43I try to find people who are either inspirational in the
- 0:46restaurant bar scene or have done something interesting in
- 0:48wine or food. And today's guest is one of the
- 0:51big ones, Alice firing. So if you don't know Alice, he
- 0:56may have lived under a rock. If you're into wine now, Alice
- 0:59is tied in everyone's mind to the natural wine movement.
- 1:03She's the author of many books, The Battle for Wine and Love to
- 1:07fall in love. Drink this for the love of wine,
- 1:09natural wine for the people. She writes online.
- 1:13She's written for so many publications, and she's a
- 1:16champion of all things natural wine.
- 1:18And today we get to talk to her about her work, her books, her
- 1:21life. It's fascinating.
- 1:24We do everything from Georgia all the way to serial killers.
- 1:27No joke. So yeah, this is served.
- 1:30You're right. Thanks for listening.
- 1:31Let's do it. You started off.
- 1:34It's the journey of a girl who starts off finding out she likes
- 1:38wine. She discovers she likes to drink
- 1:40good wine, and she tells other people too.
- 1:42And then chaos ensues. And like, why is it that loving
- 1:47natural wine, loving unadultered wine, has been so controversial?
- 1:52And it doesn't stop, does it? It is, it is very peculiar
- 1:59because, you know, it really is nothing new.
- 2:03It really is just going back to the way wine used to be made.
- 2:06But throughout the centuries, it seems like there always had been
- 2:11another natural wine movement. But this is the first time that
- 2:15it actually exploded because of social media.
- 2:19So why? Because if something's natural,
- 2:22something else is not natural. And of course, we live in the
- 2:25era of widely circulated very commercial ones because of
- 2:33technology. This was not possible pre 1970s.
- 2:38And of course it'd be it was fine-tuned in the 90s just as
- 2:43natural one was coming in. So yeah, this is the first time
- 2:47we actually have it as a, you know, kind of an issue.
- 2:51Back in the old days, like let's say Middle Ages, people were
- 2:57pilloried for making wines that weren't natural.
- 3:00Yeah, You have stories of people, like, forced to drink
- 3:03their wine and then it's poured over their heads and like.
- 3:06It used to be really a thing, you know, you could not
- 3:09adulterate wine and you were punished for it.
- 3:12And now you seem to be punished if you say, you know what, I'm
- 3:15going back to making wine naturally.
- 3:17So, you know, it's economics. It always comes economics.
- 3:21Also, one could make an argument that from the 90s to the aughts,
- 3:27we had, you know, the era of the wine critic who told you bigger
- 3:36is better. And so we had a lot of people
- 3:38investing in wines that they believed were good.
- 3:41And then somebody else is coming around and telling me, wait a
- 3:43minute. Some of those people who had
- 3:45minds of, you know, who could think on their own decided, hey,
- 3:48you know what? I didn't like those wines and
- 3:52they got rid of them and they bought something else.
- 3:54But other people were threatened.
- 3:56Wine comes with ego. What can you do?
- 3:58I know it's yeah. And it's expensive, for better
- 4:01or worse. You know it's the most expensive
- 4:03beverage most people consume other than like, Scotch.
- 4:07Or sake, yeah. Or, oh sake, could get up there
- 4:10too. You're right.
- 4:12I think that's a good entry point to your first book, The
- 4:15Battle for Wine and Love, or How I Saved the World From
- 4:18Parkerization. Did I get that one right?
- 4:20It absolutely did. Yeah.
- 4:22So Parker comes on the scene and I, I know it's not only Robert
- 4:27Parker, but he is kind of the genesis of the wine score, the
- 4:33bigger, bolder. Yeah.
- 4:35So could you dig into what exactly you're fighting the idea
- 4:39of Robert Parker over? Well, the, the basis for that
- 4:44book was, you know, like the elevator pitches.
- 4:48One day I, you know, looked around and I realized the whines
- 4:51that I used to love were disappearing from the earth.
- 4:54And so I went on a journey to find out how this could be and
- 4:59who is responsible. And we were in the era of one
- 5:03very, very, very important one critic who popularized.
- 5:07He didn't create the 100 point score, but popularized it.
- 5:12And people sold out their wines that were rated 95 points and
- 5:17up. And hence came a whole lot of
- 5:20technology to help people get those scores to make wines to
- 5:25cater to this one person's taste.
- 5:29So that influenced the world of wine dramatically.
- 5:36Is it's like an arms race who could make the biggest, boldest
- 5:40wines in the shortest amount of time?
- 5:42Exactly. Yeah.
- 5:46Great. I, I remember I think it was
- 5:48Matt Kramer who said liking a wine for how bold it is is like
- 5:52saying your favorite music is loud.
- 5:55And it's something that always struck stuck with me, to be
- 5:58honest. That might have been you.
- 5:59You know, I've read enough about wine I.
- 6:01Don't think I said that. That sounds cool like that.
- 6:04OK. Cool.
- 6:05But actually, you know it because I don't think that I've
- 6:09used the word loud, but they were very loud.
- 6:12They shouted the most. And you know, when you're doing
- 6:16like wine competitions and you're doing a lot of tasting
- 6:20during the day, those are the ones that you remember.
- 6:23These people tell me. I mean, I'd remember the quiet
- 6:26ones, but hence different tastes.
- 6:30Yeah, well, to remember the quiet ones, to remember the ones
- 6:35that had subtlety that move you in a different way, you kind of
- 6:39have to have conviction. You have to trust yourself.
- 6:43And I think wine is a very unique experience where a lot of
- 6:47people have a lot of fundamental apprehension about am IA, good
- 6:51taster. Like, should I trust myself?
- 6:53Is there someone else I can listen to?
- 6:55And big bold is easy to understand, to grasp, you know?
- 7:00Especially if you're a cigar smoker.
- 7:03Or like a Scotch soaker or like martini drinker like.
- 7:06I drink Scotch. And martinis.
- 7:08Yeah. And pink martinis.
- 7:10I'm just looking for excuses to get me off the hook.
- 7:13Yeah. OK.
- 7:16Yeah, it's, I don't know, it's, it's an interesting thing to,
- 7:21you know. Are you familiar with Rory
- 7:25Sutherland? No.
- 7:30No, so he's a marketer, he's written a couple books, but he
- 7:34what if his like big talking points is he has a lot of
- 7:37contention with people that like the tech Bros in Silicon Valley.
- 7:42And his example is revolving doors replacing doorman in
- 7:46hotels. And he says, you know, you get a
- 7:49typical like optimizer in and they they look at this position.
- 7:53They're like, why do we have a doorman?
- 7:55We could just have a rotating door, solve the problem of
- 7:57opening the door. And he says that what always
- 8:01inevitably happens is they put this quote UN quote improvement
- 8:04in and they realize all the other things that the doorman
- 8:08did, like hailing cabs and making sure that the area was
- 8:11clean and like all the periphery of stuff that wasn't neatly
- 8:15summed up in the like function of a doorman.
- 8:18I feel like this parkerization and this industrialization of
- 8:22wine did a similar thing where like if wine, juice, wine is
- 8:26just like alcoholic liquid that kind of tastes like fruit, like,
- 8:30why wouldn't we do it in the fastest, cheapest way to make
- 8:33like a decent product and send it out mass market?
- 8:36But I feel like it's a misunderstanding of all the
- 8:39things wine can be, if that makes sense.
- 8:41Right. But you actually don't need all,
- 8:44well, all that technology to make a very big, big one, but to
- 8:53standardize it, you have to. And this was not a market that
- 8:57really could take market. I mean fluctuations or even
- 9:01vintage variation. Vintage variation would get you
- 9:04punished. So you wanted to avoid that as
- 9:07all costs and it's not necessarily cheaper technology
- 9:11can be more expensive. Yeah.
- 9:14Yeah. So those are important just but
- 9:16but that was really at that time it was so easy to mimic a wine
- 9:23that was not doing that with technology.
- 9:25So I really don't think there was very much difference even
- 9:28though neither of them were to my taste, but very little
- 9:31difference between what was on the supermarket as a brand and
- 9:35some called Cabernet from, you know, Napa.
- 9:39They're all, they're all all the way down.
- 9:42Yeah, yeah, no. And I'm glad that you, you made
- 9:45that distinction because I think I did misspeak there.
- 9:48We're like, yeah, some of the technology employed that kind of
- 9:51makes wine all taste the same. Like oak barrels, brand new oak
- 9:54barrels definitely are not cheap, but they add.
- 9:58Yeah, yeah. Like oak chips are.
- 10:00Oak chips are, Yeah, that's true, Yeah.
- 10:06And I don't know, it's, it's interesting because you know,
- 10:14you, you have this thing because people do want to, they want to
- 10:19know what they're getting when they buy a bottle.
- 10:21And so I, I think vintage variation is a good example of
- 10:24that. And you know, I talked to, I
- 10:28talked to someone about rums and rums have a similar problem
- 10:33where if you do a small batch, you can have this variability.
- 10:36You see it a lot in like mezcal too, just anything that's really
- 10:40small batch artisanal where the recommendation isn't that you,
- 10:44you don't look for consistency, but you start looking for
- 10:48consistency of quality. Knowing that there's going to be
- 10:50variation, but knowing that they're going to always, you
- 10:54know, do it to a certain high quality, even if year after year
- 10:57is a little bit different. Does that make sense?
- 11:01Yeah, actually this reminded me just two weeks ago had dinner
- 11:07with very just with friends. And as it turns out these people
- 11:11are from Istanbul and make Rocky and brought one of their bottles
- 11:17and they have been doing it since the pandemic.
- 11:20And what they're known for is that it's never the same.
- 11:25They are known for every year it being a different thing, whether
- 11:30it's different herbs that they use or different grapes that
- 11:33they're using, but it always tastes remarkably different.
- 11:37And I found that really fascinating that it was they
- 11:40didn't they they're still actually, they say they're
- 11:43small, they're not that small, but to they make AI think 5000
- 11:49bottles, which is not that tiny, especially for something like
- 11:52raki, which has a very, you know, doesn't.
- 11:55But I love that that it was part of their marketing marketing
- 11:58plan. It's always going to be
- 12:00different. Well, I mean, that is a great
- 12:03way to build in. It's like a subscription model.
- 12:05If you you got to find out what the next taste is, you just got
- 12:08to keep audit buying it. I was I was going to ask you to
- 12:13because I was very curious. I feel like part of the reason
- 12:18that wine, until there are people like you pointing out
- 12:22that there are these variations and that maybe there are these
- 12:26additives that we don't think about, wine is an easy place for
- 12:30alteration to hide because it's not like not like a lot of
- 12:34physical products. And I was for my example, I was
- 12:37kind of thinking of hamburgers. And so like we all know what
- 12:40like a local high quality restaurant with a good
- 12:44hamburger, what that looks like compared to McDonald's.
- 12:47And like there's a virtue in being able to see it.
- 12:50It's but like if you look at a high quality bottle of wine made
- 12:53naturally without additives, you look at one that is, you know,
- 12:57manipulated out the wazoo and you pour both, they look the
- 13:00same. And so like, it's almost like
- 13:03you can hide A lot in that because it's just like.
- 13:06Yeah, it's like. Wine, yeah.
- 13:08They're not necessarily going to look the same.
- 13:10OK. Yeah.
- 13:10Well, so you know more about. This than me.
- 13:12So I it is you let let's take a you know, it's easier to it's
- 13:21easier to see in white wines. You know, that crystalline
- 13:25super, super polished of a white wine, whether it's a supermarket
- 13:31wine or a supposed fine wine that has been filtered and
- 13:35fined, that is going to have a super clarity that that in my
- 13:43view is a real, oh, I don't know, this is a little bit too
- 13:46sanitized. I don't want to go.
- 13:49Near it so. You know, the filtration thing,
- 13:53it's just not going to get as some natural wines can be
- 13:57filtered, but they're just not going to get that high Polish.
- 14:01So in that in one way. You could tell whether or not
- 14:05they had kid gloves or like rough handling on that.
- 14:08Kind of, yeah. OK.
- 14:11OK. That makes sense.
- 14:13And it's, it's really funny is that one reason that I'd
- 14:15probably be very bad in wine competitions when tasting is
- 14:19because, you know, be presented with the glass.
- 14:23I'd be looking and what I'd be looking for is what technology
- 14:26has done to it. So the colour is immaterial to
- 14:29me. I don't see why people will talk
- 14:32about straw, daffodil or whatever colours.
- 14:35It's like, I'm curious about the clarity and how severely
- 14:40somebody is actually cleaning up their wine.
- 14:43That, that makes a lot of sense, man.
- 14:46I've never understood that obsession with colour either.
- 14:48It's like it's, it's a clue to varietal, it's a clue to age,
- 14:55like period, you know, like why, why do you want to have your
- 14:59nebula look like a Sarah? Like, yeah.
- 15:03But it can. Be but it can be, especially if
- 15:06someone's sneaking at cab or you.
- 15:08Know other? Things, yes, yeah, no.
- 15:12And I'm thinking back, I forget what book it was, but you were
- 15:15doing a blind tasting. I think it was the guy with
- 15:19innovation or around that time where it was like 3 different
- 15:23chardonnays 2 that have been altered, one that was the
- 15:26original and if I remember correctly the original was high
- 15:28alcohol and you preferred the original.
- 15:31It's like. Even it was a naked.
- 15:34One, yeah, it was unadulterd was the word that I was thinking.
- 15:37It was like you, you always have a preference for this like how
- 15:41it is, even if technically it might be unbalanced.
- 15:45Great. He got really angry with me.
- 15:48His wife got even angrier. And it was, yeah, it, it hadn't
- 15:56been put through a verse osmosis.
- 15:58So it was the alcohol was imbalanced.
- 16:01And the one that I preferred at least said I'd like none of
- 16:04them. But it did have more character.
- 16:07It had more of a sense of place, yeah.
- 16:12Sorry to interrupt, I promise this will be fast.
- 16:14If you are listening and you like this even a little bit,
- 16:18please go onto whatever platform you are on Spotify, Apple, just
- 16:22give me a quick rating. It is the smallest thing in the
- 16:25world. One tap of the finger and it
- 16:27does mean the world to me and helps us reach more people.
- 16:31All right back at it. I I wanted to read this quote to
- 16:36you because I wanted to get your take on it.
- 16:37And it occurred in a couple of your books and it moved me the
- 16:42first time I saw it. And every time I saw it, I'm
- 16:44like, oh, it's Baldo Capilano. Oh yeah, that it went a lot.
- 16:51Oh yeah, the more there's fake, the more there needs to be real.
- 16:56I love that he was such a great guy.
- 16:58Yeah, yeah. Very quotable.
- 17:01One of those greats that just things would tumble out of his
- 17:03mouth and that is that really to me summed up the force of the
- 17:13natural wine movement and how it happened.
- 17:17Yeah, 'cause we all see, we all see this happening not just to
- 17:20wine but our food, you know, things that something's changed.
- 17:25And it's about, you know, there's this progression where
- 17:30we're getting more and more strange flavors and more Doritos
- 17:34and more fast food and like fiery Nacho flavors.
- 17:37It's like what is happening with our food?
- 17:41And you look around and so many people are suffering and not in
- 17:44good health. It's like, are what are we doing
- 17:47here? You know, like that?
- 17:49I don't know how to say it better than that.
- 17:50Just what are we doing here? It's a it's not just one thing.
- 17:56I do know that my body feels a lot better when I'm in Europe
- 18:00and food has more flavor there, too.
- 18:02It's So what are we doing here? You know, it goes beyond
- 18:07microplastics. It goes, but it's all part of
- 18:13large farms. What happens with large farming,
- 18:17the decline of small farms, the fact that this country doesn't
- 18:20support small farmers. So when you support small
- 18:24farmers, you really, I mean, you might as well be going Tiffany's
- 18:27to buy jewelry. I mean, it's so expensive.
- 18:31But yeah, we are people. But don't read ingredient lists
- 18:39as much as they should, and really don't understand the food
- 18:42process as much as they should. And you know, it's it's weird.
- 18:48Part of me wonders is like, do we just happen to be the nation
- 18:52that was growing while this weird technological like
- 18:57advancement was happening? So we didn't have our traditions
- 19:00to protect us, which might be part of it.
- 19:05I'm thinking like if I'm imagining just Italy and like
- 19:09any average Italian, I'm sure they have junk food over there
- 19:11too. But like it seems to be more
- 19:13about not like it seems to be more about the tradition and
- 19:20withholding, like holding on to these little bitty regional,
- 19:24like sub regional pastas and foods and wines and varietal
- 19:29grapes. Like there seems to be something
- 19:32to hold on to and it's like we had nothing here, you know?
- 19:35Yes, that could be a whole other podcast.
- 19:38Oh yeah, no. No, no, but we but we don't.
- 19:41And I think part of that, it's a very, very big country which
- 19:45didn't have, you know, then I, we moved in with, well, we moved
- 19:56in whoever moved in, in seven, you know, in the, in the late 6
- 20:00hundreds, you know, like kick the people off the land who
- 20:03actually had traditions. Yeah, I guess, you know, just
- 20:08just so we don't go down to like, oh, man, what was what was
- 20:12us for the modern era? Let's let's talk about a place
- 20:15that's close to your heart, which I knew very little about.
- 20:18And I was happy to learn about Georgia and your Georgia
- 20:24adventures. A place that's made wine for
- 20:27time. Well, you know, let's say 1000
- 20:31years. 1000 years confirmed. Kind.
- 20:34Of thing, yeah, which is wild. So I'm going to, I'm going to
- 20:39put your qwervy. Is that how you say it?
- 20:41It's actually easier than it is, but it always starts out as a
- 20:44tongue twister. Quevly.
- 20:45Yeah, Quevry. OK, cool.
- 20:48And so I'd seen pictures of them and I'd mostly in my head
- 20:51referred to them as clay pots because I could never remember
- 20:54how to pronounce a word. So what?
- 20:57What is so special about Georgia?
- 20:59What made you fall fall in love with that country?
- 21:02That they were back in my first visit in 2011, there were so
- 21:11many people that I met. Well, actually weren't so many.
- 21:14There were maybe 6:00 or 7:00, but that there was in that there
- 21:18was an unbroken wine tradition and people were making wine with
- 21:24medieval level technology that were beautiful, absolutely
- 21:30beautiful with the most you know, he just like handmade
- 21:38tools from gourds. You know, that I from from
- 21:44nature with no running water and somehow managed to make wine
- 21:51that was clean and beautiful with, you know, a clay pot that
- 21:55maybe had been in the ground for 2 or 300 years.
- 21:58Not saying that some people didn't have difficulty with, you
- 22:04know, they're hard to clean those quipperies, they're really
- 22:06hard, but goddamn it, some people with complete masters.
- 22:10It sounds like a nightmare you're talking about.
- 22:12People like, climbing in and like, oh, God, I'm like, I can
- 22:16only imagine. Yeah.
- 22:18Exactly and really with you nothing but lime water to to
- 22:23clean. Certainly running water is makes
- 22:28life a lot easier, but a lot of people still don't even have
- 22:32pumps. No temperature control.
- 22:35Sometimes that's, you know, as you know, the new age of
- 22:40Georgian wine making is coming to be.
- 22:42Some people do have electricity. Some people, if they make a
- 22:46large quantity, have pumps. But a lot of people don't.
- 22:50And I just was very moved by the quality of wine and that their
- 22:56survival through the Soviet era, their survival through, you
- 23:01know, religious invaders that tried to chop off their vines
- 23:05and that they clung to it. I have never been in a country
- 23:09that was more that wine was more of a religion.
- 23:13Yeah, yeah. And yeah, that was that was
- 23:19where was that where the priest said.
- 23:22Do you not think that God provided everything that the
- 23:25grape needs to ferment? OK.
- 23:27Perfect, that was. I like that.
- 23:30It was like, this is a religion I can get by.
- 23:31Yeah. Exactly, exactly.
- 23:35And you know, there were during, during the Soviet era, Stalin
- 23:45and the Five year plans came very close to destroying their
- 23:49link with their culture. But people still made wine at
- 23:55home. They still have their.
- 23:57And so really the tradition was kept alive by the villagers.
- 24:02And at one point, I think this is really very interesting
- 24:05because of natural wine and what happened in the 70s and the
- 24:0980's, the commercial, the factory wine became so bad that
- 24:15you really didn't, you only wanted to drink the village
- 24:18wine. And the factory wine was viewed
- 24:20as poisonous. Yes.
- 24:25Oh, quite literally, yeah. Quite literally.
- 24:29Yeah, now my, my wife's family, they're all ex Patriots from
- 24:33Russia. They her parents fled when it
- 24:35was USSR. So it's like, I've heard some
- 24:38stories about like, oh, man, some crazy things that they saw
- 24:43and they, they were even, you know, towards the end.
- 24:45So life, yeah. But life goes on.
- 24:51It is incredible that Georgia was able to hold on to that
- 24:53spark and keep that going through all that.
- 24:57And even in Georgia, there was the fight between the people
- 24:59working naturally and the conventional people.
- 25:03So in 2011 there were maybe 6 people who were commercializing
- 25:08their natural wine, and now it's there about 180 in 15 years.
- 25:17It's pretty remarkable. There's AI mean it is a hard
- 25:23siren song to avoid because you look around and you do see that
- 25:31the the bottles that get the highest prices are those highly
- 25:34manipulated cabs. And like, you know, money
- 25:37speaks. It's a perverse incentive that
- 25:41kind of pushes you in that direction.
- 25:44Right. Yeah, actually, the past two
- 25:47weeks I've been slaving a little bit too hard.
- 25:50Found an article that is is discussing the difference
- 25:55between fine and luxury. Because more and more I'm
- 25:59hearing the two of them being blurred to where fine wine and
- 26:03luxury wine and luxury wine pisses me off.
- 26:07I mean, what? You know, it's like the label
- 26:08wears and you know it. Price has absolutely nothing to
- 26:16do with quality. Yeah, no, that's a good point
- 26:20too, because you save luxury wine and I could already point
- 26:23like picture in my head a couple of brands, like you need the
- 26:26heavy wooden box, you need the heavy wooden bottle.
- 26:29You almost don't even need the juice inside, you know, like,
- 26:36interesting. Yeah.
- 26:38And I, I mean, the question remains, like, does the world
- 26:42need another Okie, Georgian Chardonnay?
- 26:46Probably not. Not unless they were growing it
- 26:49already. You know, like, I did wonder so
- 26:54transparently. I did not even think I was going
- 26:59to try and pronounce any of these Georgian grape names.
- 27:03Are there any that someone listening should go and try?
- 27:06So like are are a specific region they should look up.
- 27:11Well, that's already getting very elevated, but let's talk
- 27:14regions because and I'll, I'll make this easy, but it actually
- 27:21is meaningless unless somebody's tasted the ones.
- 27:24Georgia is a very small country, super small and within maybe the
- 27:27size of Rhode Island or West Virginia.
- 27:33I there are about 550 indigenous grapes and very, very disparate
- 27:41climates. So on the east side you have
- 27:44more desert, more California, more Southern Marone like.
- 27:50And on the West, you're talking more Loire or not really very
- 27:54high elevation, but let's say there's maybe the Gerard, but
- 27:59it'll lower elevation or savoir. There's something can be very
- 28:03Alpine and like in the wines. So very, very different.
- 28:07On the East Coast, you're going to have the most popular grapes,
- 28:11which is hard to pronounce, but actually not once you learn
- 28:16ricazzatelli. Ricazzatelli, see, it's not that
- 28:19bad. Ricazzatelli, it just looks bad.
- 28:21And the other one's Safarovi, that's very easy.
- 28:23So that's basically they're big white and they're big red, OK,
- 28:28but many other things. So ricotta telly is going to be
- 28:32a wine that you will see with the you definitely want it with
- 28:35skin contact. So you want it amber colored.
- 28:39There are some people who make it without, but there's a reason
- 28:43that it's traditional to have the skin contact.
- 28:48If you're making wine naturally without the use of sulfur, the
- 28:51skin really is like sunblock for the grape.
- 28:56Yeah, the natural tannins. Actually work as an anti.
- 28:59Ox that, yeah, OK, great. You know, and so if you're going
- 29:02to Saparabbi's can be very, very big and tannic for me, a little
- 29:07bit much to deal with. Some people are learning to
- 29:10lighten it up. But you know, then another
- 29:15beautiful grape Chinuri, which actually means beautiful to look
- 29:19at and it's beautiful. So Chinuri is lovely.
- 29:26So Liquori a little bit harder to pronounce.
- 29:28That's from the West. And think more muscude or
- 29:32savignon kind of thing. OK, yeah, but.
- 29:35There's tremendous diversity. If you're listening to this too,
- 29:37and you're like, oh man, how would I get a handle on this?
- 29:40There's a great book on this. Just go.
- 29:44Oh, yeah. It's the for the love of wine.
- 29:46You'll you'll get to read all about it.
- 29:49And I do think Riccatatelli, I do believe I've seen or like
- 29:54I've heard that grape because I think they grow it in Romania
- 29:57too, right? Exactly.
- 29:58Okay. Okay, cool.
- 29:59And even Romania, Macedonia, okay, even northern Greece.
- 30:05That's. Oh yeah, that is right.
- 30:07Okay, yeah, it's funny, you know, I knew very little about,
- 30:11you know, Georgia probably two or three paragraphs from my
- 30:13Psalm studies and that's it. So I think it is coming online
- 30:17more. Most of what I did in the Psalm
- 30:20world was in like 2012, 2013 ish.
- 30:23So it's probably more of a it's rising *.
- 30:27There, Right. Exactly.
- 30:29Early days, yeah. You know, I'd be remiss if I did
- 30:34not ask you about this serial killer.
- 30:37And I know that that is the biggest like 316 to.
- 30:41Schedule Topics. Ever.
- 30:42But I'm like, this is a story I did not expect.
- 30:47Do you mind telling us that story?
- 30:50So there were two stories of it in For the Love Wine, my last
- 30:54book. It is the first one.
- 30:56Was horrifying and then it just kept going.
- 30:59OK, so when I was when I was 14, through a series of missteps, I
- 31:10ended up being photographed on a rooftop by a strange man.
- 31:18It started to rain, it started to pour and I had to help him
- 31:25bring his photography equipment into his very, very scary apt.
- 31:31I immediately knew I had to get out of there, but he delayed me.
- 31:39But a well, he delayed me from whatever I said here, here's my
- 31:46work. Take a look at my work.
- 31:47You see, I'm a real photographer and I was OK.
- 31:50You know, like, I'm still wanting to think that he's, you
- 31:53know, not a dangerous guy. And I look at the photographs
- 31:58and like, OK, out of here. At that point, he went to the
- 32:01bathroom. I'm at the door trying to get
- 32:04out and he is naked from the naked, you know, and I, I like,
- 32:14I really do not know how I got out of the apartment, but I got
- 32:18out of the apartment. I left something behind.
- 32:21And I mean, I was a very sheltered 14 year old and I, I
- 32:28only knew about perverts. Actually, I did not know about
- 32:32somebody who'd rape and kill me. So I went back.
- 32:37I was furious. How dare he?
- 32:39I pounded, I said my book, please.
- 32:41And I grabbed my book from him. And I, as he brought it, as he
- 32:44pleaded with me that he wasn't going to hurt me, I should just
- 32:47come back. Obviously I'm, you know, I don't
- 32:51know where the children are listening.
- 32:52So I'm I'm just not disclosing I.
- 32:54Don't. I don't think the children are
- 32:56listening to this. One, But anyway, so so 40 years
- 33:01later, I'm in a hotel room having done a champagne seminar
- 33:05and I turn on the TV as I'm doing packing and I see Ronnie
- 33:12Alcala sentenced to death, serial killer Ronnie Alcala
- 33:16sentenced to death. And I'm like, but that's not
- 33:19Rodney Alcala, that's John Berger.
- 33:21So I was Googling through the night until I realized that he
- 33:25was actually, that was one of his aliases.
- 33:27And I said, my goodness, I escaped a serial killer.
- 33:30And I could have been, you know, one of his early victims, so.
- 33:38Yeah, what a wild story. You know what are the things?
- 33:44It was wild story. One of the things that I really
- 33:49appreciate about your writing, and I've been struggling to put
- 33:52it into words, but I think it just occurred to me, you kind of
- 33:56write in the way that the wines that you like exists.
- 33:59You know, there's, it's not edited out, there's the rough
- 34:04patches, the good and the bad, but you just kind of you, I
- 34:08mean, you must clearly curate the stories.
- 34:10You must clearly intervene and tell the stories and make them
- 34:14make sense in a logical manner. But it seems like it's a lot of
- 34:18naked stories, You know, it's the naked wine of the literature
- 34:23for the wine. World I think I, I'm basically a
- 34:26memoirist that found herself as a wine writer.
- 34:31So and think very early on because when I started writing
- 34:38about wine, especially books, because I feel most of my
- 34:45knowledge is empirical. Yes, a lot of research, but I,
- 34:50you know, didn't study. I feel like I have to use myself
- 34:57to deliver the message, to deliver the information.
- 35:00I also, since I am dealing with often a lot of very technical
- 35:05information, I want it to be in. I want the technical information
- 35:11to be embedded in a story. That makes sense.
- 35:15And so I sacrificed myself. Yeah, because no, no one's
- 35:19clicking on, you know, the firing line just for the like,
- 35:22the pH is 3.9. And it was like, but, you know,
- 35:27you know, a couple, a couple people smuggling in a bottle to
- 35:30a restaurant without corkage. Yeah, I'll follow that.
- 35:34That sounds good. Yeah, I do want to make sure,
- 35:41too. Before we get too far along, I
- 35:44wanted to ask you because a lot of people that listen to the
- 35:47show are servers, bartenders, people that work in restaurants.
- 35:50If if you were talking to someone in that audience, maybe
- 35:53a little bit on the younger side and they weren't sure how to get
- 35:56into wine, and maybe, like, they know that if they learn about
- 35:59wine, maybe they can increase their cells and, you know, they
- 36:03see other people enjoying it. What?
- 36:05Where would you tell them even to begin?
- 36:10Well, that's actually a. That's a case by case, because
- 36:15how? OK, let's.
- 36:16Be asking how do you find restaurants?
- 36:18Yeah. Working in a restaurant, well,
- 36:20basically what they do there are in every state, there are
- 36:27industry wine tastings. So even if you're in a
- 36:32restaurant that doesn't have a sommelier, that doesn't have a
- 36:35wine director, but somebody else is doing the wine buying, just
- 36:39noodle around. Ask your local wine shop how you
- 36:43can get in touch with getting on the calendar for industry wine
- 36:48tastings. That's how I learned.
- 36:50And you just taste and taste and taste and they're they're that's
- 36:57the beginning point. Or gather your own little group
- 37:01and do tasting groups. That's also how I learn tasting
- 37:05groups with friends. Whether you start at, you know,
- 37:10you do you organize it by grape variety or region or technique,
- 37:18you know, like we're going to do and you know, like in depth on D
- 37:24stemmed or whole cluster. Let's get let's figure out what
- 37:27this tastes like, you know, but there are gazillion ways to
- 37:33decide how you're going to organize that blind tasting.
- 37:37But yeah, like get on the industry route.
- 37:40A lot of just stores have in in store tastings to start there.
- 37:47I think that's and you've got you've got a taste.
- 37:49There's no way around it. You have to have as as much
- 37:54diversity as you possibly can. The other thing I have to say
- 37:57that I was writing about wine far too long before I set foot
- 38:04in a vineyard, and it's embarrassing to say that.
- 38:07That's a, that's a good one, yeah.
- 38:09But until you actually go and visit I I cannot believe that I
- 38:15call myself a wine writer with like maybe having gotten to 2.
- 38:20So it was really only at that point that I started really
- 38:23understanding. It does help to actually start
- 38:27tasting first, then go so you can ask more interesting
- 38:30questions. But you have to go and visit.
- 38:33You have to go and meet the people.
- 38:35There's no shortcut to one. But there are a lot of people
- 38:38doing Instagram somalier thing, picking up tips, but that's just
- 38:42what other people liking and you can't talk about them
- 38:44convincingly. Yeah, yeah.
- 38:47There's a world of difference between I find this bottled to
- 38:50be XYZ versus, you know, John Psalm 21 said.
- 38:55Hey, this is the hottest thing. I'm like, that is so meaningless
- 38:59to me. Yeah, no, you know, just to echo
- 39:03your point on the go to some like finding some vineyard, you
- 39:08can go some wine region. I would say find a region too
- 39:13that's not super industrialized, you know, like, or maybe not
- 39:17even that, just like somewhere that's not the Super popular
- 39:20ones. Like enough people are going to
- 39:23Napa like it's all going to be just show and glam.
- 39:27Oh. Yeah, Napa's the last place you
- 39:28should go. Sorry, no, yeah, find, find
- 39:30somewhere like off the beaten path.
- 39:32Like I honestly, I one of the first ones I went to and I loved
- 39:36it. And I know that it's probably a
- 39:38lot of manipulated wines out there, but there's also a lot of
- 39:42really little gems. But Lodi, it was the first place
- 39:45I went and it was great. You know, Backcountry actually
- 39:48got to meet the growers. It's beautiful up there.
- 39:50Yeah, the pizza's great. Yeah, the pizza's.
- 39:52Great. I do want to ask you, you know,
- 39:58I thought it'd be cool you had eight tenants of a great wine in
- 40:03natural wine for the People. And I'm happy to read them off
- 40:06if it helps. But yeah, because.
- 40:09You think it's good to remember them all, but yeah.
- 40:11Exactly. That's why I wrote them down.
- 40:12I have them right here. So I love it because you're
- 40:16like, this is how to evaluate wine.
- 40:17This is how I do it but I also will never give a score.
- 40:21It was like touché good good on ya.
- 40:25First, you had emotional impact. Yeah, like the reason that I,
- 40:31there are two reasons that I, that I organized those tenants
- 40:38is that there was one time I, somebody asked whether they
- 40:42could, you know, like mirror me while I was tasting.
- 40:46I said sure. And then she said, after about
- 40:4910 minutes, can I ask you something?
- 40:50Do you first taste for flaws? And I'm like, I started laughing
- 40:54because I thought that was ludicrous.
- 40:56I said, no, I, I first taste for enjoyment and then I dial it
- 41:01back. And so it seems to me that one
- 41:04of the most important things about a wine is an emotional
- 41:07impact. Is it, does it have anything to
- 41:10say to you? Are you noticing it?
- 41:13No, even. If it's hate, even if it's hate.
- 41:17It's like this one's. Yeah.
- 41:18It makes me angry. Yeah.
- 41:20Yeah. Right.
- 41:21Yeah, Yeah. If you look for flaws first,
- 41:24it's Brené Brown always says if you once you go out looking for
- 41:28the world, you'll find. And like, I'm thinking there are
- 41:30wines that have a touch of VA. There are wines that have some
- 41:33Brett on them that are beautiful.
- 41:35And if you just go looking for flaws first, you might stop
- 41:38there. Exactly.
- 41:41Your second one was life. Yeah.
- 41:46Life. Yeah, it's, yeah, I used to do,
- 41:50I used to do tastings, dead or alive tastings, the blind just
- 41:56like identify the dead wines in the middle of the year.
- 42:01Yeah, that's I, I think that is it self-explanatory whether the
- 42:07life is that. Did I have life as well as
- 42:11evolution in the glass? Because they do.
- 42:12Evolution in the Glass is the next one, actually, yeah.
- 42:16Yeah, they do overlap. So one thing that evolution of
- 42:20glass, though it is tied to life, though it is a little bit
- 42:23different, something life would be just as it overly sulfur
- 42:28snuffed out evolution of glass is every every sip is going to
- 42:33tell me something different about this the wine or after two
- 42:37days, if it's open, is it still alive and is it still speaking?
- 42:41Yeah. Versus versus that white one we
- 42:43were talking about at the beginning, overly sterile
- 42:47clinicalized, Yeah, 4 was balance, which makes sense, yes.
- 42:53Like. Even Chardonnay earlier maybe
- 42:56out of balance, yeah. Great.
- 42:58And it doesn't mean it's a doesn't mean it's a deal
- 43:00breaker. The thing about these things is
- 43:02not one thing is necessarily a deal breaker, but I think that
- 43:05if you have five of these, you have a superlative 1.
- 43:10But anyway, keep on going. What else?
- 43:11Yeah, sure, sure. Yeah.
- 43:12Drinkability and digestibility. Yeah, this is something that
- 43:18really I think would be a foreign notion to somebody who
- 43:23doesn't have experience with natural wine about the idea that
- 43:28you actually there's. And it was a revelation to me
- 43:32that there's some wines that you feel bite you on the inside.
- 43:36Like, great. Like, oof, that was tough.
- 43:40Were ones that you just feel actually can be pretty healthy.
- 43:45Your body takes them in. I don't have a good way.
- 43:50It's one of those things that I can show you, but I don't know
- 43:53where I can tell you, but it's basically going to feel like
- 43:56oxygen. Well, I mean, it's it is that
- 43:59example from before the hamburger.
- 44:00If you have like a local guy that does local meat and all
- 44:04great produce, baking a hamburger versus how you feel
- 44:07after you eat McDonald's. You know, we may not be able to
- 44:10sum it up in so many words, but we all know it.
- 44:12We like we've all experienced it.
- 44:15Savory was the next one. Savory is extremely important to
- 44:21me, and it really is something that separates the greats from
- 44:30the commercial. There's so much emphasis on the
- 44:34quality of the fruit and the prettiness of the fruit and the
- 44:38fruit descriptions. But for me, it's the bitter,
- 44:45it's the savory, it's the earth, it's the leaf that adds to
- 44:50complexity and that actually it where there's something other
- 45:01than the fruit in that grape that was allowed to come
- 45:06through. Yeah, and I'm, I'm thinking
- 45:10about right now Beaujolais as an example.
- 45:14You know, the the like iconic Beaujolais that gets released,
- 45:19the nouveau like, do you want to drink that all the time?
- 45:24No, especially like the really bottom rungs of it versus like a
- 45:29really well done crew. Beaucholais still very pretty
- 45:34wine, but there is something else there besides just fruit
- 45:39and fruitiness. You know, like.
- 45:41If it's always can get really boring, you know, it's like, you
- 45:46know, it is. You know, it's the salt.
- 45:50You know, it's a salinity. Salinity gets used a lot in wine
- 45:55these days. But, you know, it's a lift.
- 45:58Tomato leaves, Yeah. Last to you, transparency and
- 46:03then sense of place. OK, so transparency is is, is,
- 46:12is this wine hiding something? Is technology hiding something
- 46:16in the wine? So that would be too much oak,
- 46:20something that is getting between you and too much oak.
- 46:25Is it acidified? Has it been manipulated in a
- 46:28certain way or is it really just a a naked wine just standing in
- 46:33front of you? You know so I think that's is
- 46:36some yeah and and since a place. So I think that especially for
- 46:48somebody fairly new and by fairly new, it could be a decade
- 46:52into their one journey being able to sense terroir is
- 46:59actually anyway is kind of a it's, it's very abstract.
- 47:06It's like there are a lot of things like farming can trump
- 47:10terroir. It's like, what does it actually
- 47:12mean? And I realized that for me, it
- 47:14means I don't know where this is from, but it takes me somewhere
- 47:17and I want to see where this place is.
- 47:20So if something has a sense of place, more usual than not, I
- 47:25will be. If it's really compelling to me,
- 47:27I will be on a plane or in a car very soon to go and find out why
- 47:33this this this specific place called out to me.
- 47:37And I think you don't need to have a sense of, you know, like,
- 47:41you know, in, in The Dirty guide to wine when I, you know,
- 47:46divided wine into, you know, rock type.
- 47:51I don't think you need to have a sense of whether it's from
- 47:54granite or limestone or schist. You can drill that in later, but
- 47:59just does it take me somewhere I think is super important.
- 48:04Yeah. And I mean, if you are just
- 48:06starting out on this journey, there are some places that I
- 48:10mean, I'm thinking about the wine that you fell in love with,
- 48:13even if it wasn't the most elevated bottle.
- 48:14But you know, the Piedmont Nebula and Barolo and
- 48:18Barbaresco. Like that is a wine that is from
- 48:21a place. And like, yeah, you try to grow
- 48:24nebula elsewhere. And there are some examples that
- 48:26are OK. But like you go there and
- 48:29something about that area and that grape just fit, you know.
- 48:33And I mean, if you you kind of go through the other wines that
- 48:36you were fighting Parker with your first book, you know, the
- 48:40Riojas, like you have tamper neo and ganache and all, you know,
- 48:44grown elsewhere. But they're the way that culture
- 48:48grew up. Like it's a place to you.
- 48:50Like there, there are these places.
- 48:52So if you find these iconic old world, you know all those catch
- 48:57phrases that you recommend that we use to find bottles that have
- 49:01some of these characteristics, you will start piercing together
- 49:04some of these here and there I think.
- 49:09So. Hopefully that's, that's the
- 49:11journey. Yeah.
- 49:14Alice, you're awesome. It was, it was awesome getting a
- 49:17chance to speak with you and getting to look through your
- 49:20work for the listener at home who wants to learn more about
- 49:24you, follow you and read some more of your stuff.
- 49:27Where could they go online to find you?
- 49:29Well I do have a sub stack and it is really just Alice firing
- 49:34FEIRFEIRING. It's pretty easy to find
- 49:40Instagram it's Alice dot firing. If you forget who I am you can
- 49:44Google red haired wine writer natural wine.
- 49:47It'll come up. There are 6 books you should go
- 49:51out and read them all. And sounds like you have and I
- 49:54really appreciate this very thoughtful interview.
- 49:58No, no, yeah, no, it's, you know, I, I only knew of you from
- 50:02my wine studies from The Dirty Guide to Wine, just when I was
- 50:05trying to get a handle on different soil types as I was
- 50:08going through the song world. So it was really great rounding
- 50:10out the whole the whole experience again to learn more
- 50:13about you. And then anyone who's listening
- 50:17in the all the links to everything she said will be in
- 50:20the show notes just in case you couldn't write that down just so
- 50:22you can click on over and check out everything else has.
- 50:26Before I conclude, I always like to ask my guests, is there
- 50:29anything that I missed that you'd be remiss if we didn't add
- 50:33into today's conversation? And I thought I had thought
- 50:38about that. Let's see.
- 50:45I know it's, it's trying to like advice to a server who might be
- 50:55getting involved in the wine world.
- 51:00Let's see. God, why am I really coming up
- 51:07with nothing? Yeah, actually going back to as
- 51:11far as describing a wine to a potential customer, the kind of
- 51:16fruit, the kind of fruit, the Raspberry, the strawberry, the
- 51:19Rose is completely immaterial. And if you can find something
- 51:24else to say about it and some enthusiasm, Oh yeah, you know
- 51:29what I did for those people who are aspiring Psalms?
- 51:34This is one that I wanted to talk about, something that I
- 51:39hadn't really thought about till I did a very long deep dive
- 51:42into, into people who are doing competitions and what some world
- 51:48really is like is that one of the most important qualities
- 51:52that a sommelier can have is emotional intelligence.
- 51:58That ability to to suss out what your customer wants and meets
- 52:06them there. Some people are born with it.
- 52:10Other people who are not can learn some tips and it really is
- 52:16nothing more than asking questions.
- 52:19If you can't just someone up, which sometimes can, but asking
- 52:23questions, be there. Listen, if you give somebody a
- 52:28wine within their price point and meet them where they are, I
- 52:33think that customer's going to stay with you forever and always
- 52:36remember that experience. I agree, Yeah, I think that's
- 52:40well said. You know, I I have all my flaws
- 52:44and I'm I'm not a full time, so I'm more manager, but you know,
- 52:48I forget names of bottles, I mispronounce things.
- 52:51But every guest that I approach when they're asking for
- 52:54recommendation, I always start with what do you normally drink?
- 52:57And like, just start somewhere. It's like, OK, you've had this
- 53:01bottle you like, Merlot's great, you know, because I see too many
- 53:06people that just go for like, oh, you're drinking XYZ, look at
- 53:10this most expensive bottle and then the one $100 less.
- 53:13And then this one you like. Yeah.
- 53:15So I'm sure with all the travelling you do, you get to
- 53:18see a lot of different styles of songs.
- 53:20And yes, the good, the bag, the ugly.
- 53:23Yeah, yeah, yeah. Some of them actually pissed me
- 53:28off so much that I write about them, but not you really have to
- 53:31really go out of your way for me to do that.
- 53:33Yes, yes. But if you'd like to know more
- 53:36about that, check out the sub stack.
- 53:37And awesome Alice, thank you for.
- 53:41Thanks so much, Andrew. Thank you for listening.
- 53:46That is today's episode. Now if you have not taken a
- 53:50moment to check out our website, please do.
- 53:52It's serves you right pod.com. We have past episodes and all
- 53:58sorts of other things there. If you want to get in touch with
- 54:00me, that's the place to do it. I do appreciate that you've
- 54:03given me your most valuable asset, your time and attention.
- 54:07So thank you for listening and stay tuned.
- 54:11We have some really cool guests coming up.
- 54:13I would hate it if you missed it.
- 54:15Cheers.