Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Forgotten Siege of Acre 1189–91
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about Saladin's victories — Hattin, Jerusalem — and we've talked about the set-piece battle at Arsuf. But there's one episode of the Third Crusade that tends to get glossed over in the popular narrative, even though it was the longest, most miserable, and arguably most decisive engagement of the entire war: the siege of Acre. Luna: The siege that lasted almost two years, right? I've heard it called the 'crucible of the Third Crusade'. Lucas: Exactly. It ran from August 1189 to July 1191 — nearly two full years. And what's fascinating is that when the siege began, Acre wasn't even the primary objective for either side. It just became the place where both armies got stuck, like mud around a wheel. Lucas: To understand how it started, you have to go back to the aftermath of Hattin. After Saladin's victory in 1187, most of the major crusader cities fell quickly — Jerusalem, Jaffa, Ascalon. But two key ports held out: Tyre, under Conrad of Montferrat, and Tripoli. Acre had actually fallen to Saladin in July 1187, just a few weeks after Hattin, with barely a fight. The garrison surrendered in exchange for safe passage. Luna: So Acre was in Saladin's hands from the start. The crusaders had to take it back. Lucas: Right. But the man who started the siege wasn't Richard the Lionheart or Philip Augustus — it was Guy of Lusignan. Remember, Guy was the king of Jerusalem who had botched the campaign at Hattin and lost the entire army. After Hattin, he was released by Saladin on condition that he leave the country and never take up arms again. But Guy considered that oath coerced and therefore invalid. He went to Tyre, but Conrad of Montferrat refused to let him in — Conrad had effectively taken over as the leader of the resistance. Luna: So Guy was a king without a kingdom, locked out of the only major city still in crusader hands. Lucas: Exactly. And he was desperate. So in August 1189, Guy gathered whatever troops he could scrape together — maybe a few hundred knights and a few thousand infantry — and marched south from Tyre, not to attack Tyre, but to lay siege to Acre. It was an insane gamble. He had no navy, no siege engines, and Saladin's main army was only a few days away. But he set up camp outside the walls and essentially dared Saladin to come and stop him. Lucas: Saladin did come — in September 1189. He arrived with a large army and attacked Guy's siege lines from the rear. So suddenly, the crusaders were caught between the city garrison and Saladin's field army. They dug in, built a ditch and a rampart, and essentially created a fortified camp. And that's how the siege turned into a two-year stalemate: the crusaders besieging the city, and Saladin besieging the besiegers. Luna: So it was a double siege — like a layered cake of misery. Lucas: That's exactly the image. The crusaders called their position 'the ditch' — a muddy, disease-ridden encampment between the city walls and Saladin's army. Conditions were horrific. Dysentery, typhus, starvation. The chronicler Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, who was with Saladin, describes how the stench of death from the battlefield made it hard to even breathe. Both sides suffered terribly. Lucas: And the naval dimension was critical. Acre is a port city, and control of the sea meant supplies could reach either the city or the crusader camp. In the first year, the crusaders had almost no navy — they relied on occasional ships from the Italian city-states. But Saladin's navy was also weak; he had never built a strong fleet. So the siege became a race: could the crusaders hold out until reinforcements arrived from Europe? Luna: And those reinforcements did come — first in bits and pieces, then in waves. Lucas: Yes. Throughout 1190, more crusaders arrived by sea — Germans, French, English, Italians. The siege became a magnet for the entire crusading movement. By the spring of 1191, the crusader camp had swelled to perhaps 25,000 men, though many were starving and sick. Meanwhile, Saladin's army was also large — maybe 30,000 — but he had trouble keeping them supplied and paid. His war treasury was running dry. Lucas: The turning point came in April 1191, when Philip Augustus of France arrived with his fleet. He brought siege engines — trebuchets, mangonels — and the crusaders finally had the firepower to breach the walls. Then in June, Richard the Lionheart arrived with the English fleet, and the balance shifted decisively. Richard took command of the siege operations, and he was ruthless and efficient. Luna: What was Richard's strategy that made the difference? Lucas: Richard focused on two things: first, he coordinated naval blockade so tightly that no supply ships could get into the city. Second, he kept constant pressure on the walls with his siege engines, day and night. He also used psychological warfare — he had his men build a massive movable tower called a 'belfry' that threatened the walls directly. The garrison inside Acre — a mix of Muslim soldiers and local levies — was exhausted, starving, and losing hope. Lucas: By early July 1191, the defenders knew they couldn't hold out any longer. They sent out a delegation to negotiate surrender. Richard and Philip demanded the return of the True Cross — which Saladin had captured at Hattin — plus the release of all Christian prisoners, and a huge ransom of 200,000 gold dinars. Saladin, who was camped just outside, hesitated. He tried to negotiate better terms, but the garrison inside the city, fearing they would be massacred, decided to surrender on their own. Luna: So the city fell on July 12, 1191, after nearly two years. Lucas: Yes. And the aftermath was ugly. The crusaders took possession of the city, and Richard and Philip agreed to divide the spoils. But the most controversial part came later: when Saladin failed to meet the first installment of the ransom on time, Richard — in a fit of rage and pragmatism — ordered the execution of over 2,700 Muslim prisoners, in full view of Saladin's army. The massacre at Acre, as it's known, has stained Richard's reputation ever since. Luna: And it set the tone for the rest of the campaign. No more chivalry. Lucas: Exactly. From that point on, it was a war of attrition. But Acre itself was the real prize — it gave the crusaders a secure port and a base of operations. Without Acre, Richard could never have marched south to Jaffa. The siege of Acre was the hinge of the Third Crusade. Luna: It's incredible how much the fate of the entire crusade turned on a single city that hadn't even been the original target. Lucas: Speaking of keeping this kind of detailed history going — if you've been following the series, you know we try to dig deep into these overlooked corners. And honestly, the only reason we can keep doing that without ads or sponsors is because of listeners like you who decide to throw in a couple of dollars a month. It genuinely makes a difference — it covers hosting, research, transcription, all of it. If you've gotten something out of these episodes, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo is all it takes. Luna: Yeah, it's how we keep the show independent and ad-free. Every bit helps. Lucas: So back to Acre — one detail I love is that after the surrender, Saladin's brother al-Adil was the one who had to negotiate the release of the prisoners. He worked tirelessly, but Richard's impatience undid all that. And al-Adil would later become sultan himself, but that's a story for another episode. Luna: I'd like to hear more about al-Adil. He seems like such a steady presence throughout all of this. Lucas: He really was. And that's a good thread to pick up next time: the brother who held it all together.