Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Petrofac's administration, Swinney's Reform frustration, and Adura valuation
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to energy voice out loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. Petrofac, Petrofac, Petrofac.
- 0:16Things went from bad to worse this week for the beleaguered
- 0:19services giant. But that's not the only thing
- 0:22that was happening this week. John Swinney was threatening
- 0:26reform and also Shell and Ecuador announced their Q threes
- 0:32ahead of their UK combination. That's a lot to talk about.
- 0:36I'm Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, so I can't do it alone.
- 0:40I'm joined this week by renewables reporter Michael
- 0:44Baer. How you doing this week Michael?
- 0:46Yeah, not bad Things I think have been a good week for for us
- 0:49at Energy Voice at the very least.
- 0:51I don't know if we can see that. That's been all round everyone's
- 0:55experience this week, I'm afraid.
- 0:57Yeah, it's kind of, it's always the sad state of affairs and it
- 1:00being in news where bad news gets the most eyes.
- 1:04But then you also kind of feel bad about what's happening.
- 1:10It's been, it's been a been a rough week for a lot of people
- 1:13with the petrol pack news. Matt, you've been following this
- 1:17as well as Matthew Perry, our news reporter.
- 1:20How are you doing this week? Well, I think I had a decidedly
- 1:24better weekend than I imagined most of the executive team at
- 1:26Petrofac had because I imagine there was a a lot going on after
- 1:30the news dropped last week about the Tenet offshore wind contract
- 1:35and obviously the start of the week with the collapse into
- 1:39administration and the delisting again from the the share market.
- 1:43So lot to lot to jump into. Let's let's dive into all the
- 1:47Petro facts. Yeah, it's, it's been, it's been
- 1:50an interesting time. I I feel like I should, you
- 1:54know, give you more kudos for that pun, but but I couldn't
- 1:58think of a nice. Let's just move right past it.
- 2:02But yeah, essentially this week it was confirmed.
- 2:05That the, the the. Firm was applying to appoint
- 2:08administrators the day after, as Matt said, they delisted from
- 2:12the London Stock Exchange. But this this is sort of a long
- 2:16running saga for the the beleaguered services giant,
- 2:20isn't it? I mean, last week we, we got
- 2:23sort of an ominous stock market update saying our restructuring
- 2:28plan might not be going quite, quite the way we thought it was
- 2:31essentially. And then by the end of the week
- 2:3510 at the the Danish energy firm dropped its its contract
- 2:40contract with Petrofac for a European offshore wind
- 2:44substation deal that essentially their entire restructuring plan
- 2:50hinged on. You know, that was according to
- 2:52the judge on the the restructuring court case earlier
- 2:56this year. It left some questions going
- 3:00into the weekend. There was rumours of emergency
- 3:04meetings with the board and ultimately we, we ended up where
- 3:08we're at today. But this isn't, this isn't
- 3:11something that's just happened in the past couple of weeks.
- 3:13You know, we, we wrote a timeline of events on Energy
- 3:16Voice this week showing, you know, showing exactly what had
- 3:20taken place and problems stretched right back to the
- 3:23early 20 tens, you know, with the bribery scandals.
- 3:28And then they all, they got fined for that and sort of found
- 3:31out by the, the SFO in the UK by the end of the decade.
- 3:36And then COVID wasn't kind to them either with some contracts
- 3:40in the engineering and construction division that ended
- 3:43up not paying dividends. And I mean, it wasn't just, it
- 3:49wasn't just Petra fact that that was hit by the COVID season,
- 3:53obviously the COVID pandemic, obviously, but Petra fact did
- 3:58seem to, to take one hell of a beating.
- 4:01And then a middle of this, they've changed, they changed
- 4:03their CEO and there's an awful lot to 1 pack, But there's been
- 4:10an awful lot of response as well from, from industry
- 4:14commentators, from politicians. Matt, you were looking at how
- 4:17people were interacting with this news this week.
- 4:21And I we, we were speaking about it previously.
- 4:25You've got some interesting takes.
- 4:28Yeah, well, I think it's unsurprising perhaps that a lot
- 4:30of the politicians outside of the Labour government were quick
- 4:35to jump on this administration and portray it as being, you
- 4:38know, a direct result of Labour's North Sea energy
- 4:41policies, which we know are very unpopular with the oil and gas
- 4:44sector, You know, things like the windfall tax and the
- 4:46restrictions on on future licensing grounds.
- 4:49But you know, as as you've sort of touched on there, Ryan, I
- 4:52think with Petrofac specifically, that's only a very
- 4:54minor part of the story. It really goes back to the the
- 4:58struggles from a series of sort of bribery, corruption cases,
- 5:02which led to a a large fine for Petrofac.
- 5:05And they've essentially never recovered from there.
- 5:08You know, that that led to them. It was over a sort of cases in
- 5:12Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Iraq, I believe it was.
- 5:15And as a result, they were, you know, prevented from bidding
- 5:18from further contracts for, for a period sort of frozen out by
- 5:21the likes of of ADNOC. And that kind of impacted their
- 5:24operations. And I guess importantly, their
- 5:26reputation, which we know is really important for these these
- 5:29projects to, you know, be able to trust the, the supply chain
- 5:32companies and the tier one contractors that you're working
- 5:34with for these these operators. So that had a huge impact that
- 5:37rolled into COVID and they've just really been trying to
- 5:40balance a House of Cards ever since then.
- 5:42And it all kind of came tumbling down when the tenant contract to
- 5:47the offshore wind from the, the Dutch grid operator pulled out.
- 5:51But, you know, I guess it's not surprising that politician are
- 5:54trying to, to jump on this. You know, they're, they're, I
- 5:57guess, playing to a, a lower, lower information voter that
- 6:01maybe we'll just see a headline saying, you know, another North
- 6:03Sea oil and gas firm is, is struggling.
- 6:05And they'll, you know, politicians are quite keen that
- 6:08those voters will connect that to, to, to Labour.
- 6:11It's, it's, you know, politics rather than then maybe the most
- 6:14the accurate picture of, of what's happened with, with
- 6:16Petrofac. And I guess, you know, I think
- 6:21the, the UK government to Desnaz was, was quite conscious of
- 6:24this. They were, you know, relatively
- 6:27unusually very, very quick to put out a press release as soon
- 6:30as the news came out about Petrofac, they were very keen to
- 6:32point out that, you know, the UK jobs are not at risk.
- 6:36The Petrofac UK arm is doing really well.
- 6:38They've got lots of contracts. They've got a highly skilled
- 6:40workforce. We're going to work with them.
- 6:41So you know that I think that Labour knew what was, was coming
- 6:45over the weekend and then had sort of a, a media line well
- 6:48prepared. And but you know, I think now we
- 6:52focus should shift I guess to the supply chain and the the
- 6:54potential impacts that this is going to have on on those firms.
- 6:58I know that, you know, when we spoke to a lot of the the petrol
- 7:00pack people, they were often very quick to point out that,
- 7:04you know, they had this sort of large order book that sort of it
- 7:08made it feel like the narrow tool was very much right once
- 7:10you get your house in order that there's still a sort of sold
- 7:14foundation for this. So it does raise the question
- 7:16that presumably once the company emerges from administration,
- 7:20what it might look like. The fundamentals seem to be
- 7:24relatively solid. Yeah, I think it was $8 billion
- 7:29that kept pointing to a backlog of work of $8 billion.
- 7:32But we saw this with the Beam administration earlier in the
- 7:36year. And Michael and Matt, you both
- 7:38did some great coverage on that about sort of the knock on
- 7:42effect and petrified being a Tier 1 supplier with £8 billion
- 7:47of work in the back pocket. There will have been companies
- 7:50that have been sort of banking on working with them or have
- 7:54already secured contracts to, you know, subcontracts to work
- 7:58with them on major projects, as is the nature of the beast when
- 8:02it comes to these large energy initiatives.
- 8:06So there there will certainly be a knock on impact.
- 8:09So lower down the supply chain as well.
- 8:11And this is something that, you know, we've heard reports of,
- 8:15you know, petrified, maybe struggling to pay its bills with
- 8:17some of these firms in recent recent weeks.
- 8:20So remind me, Michael, what was, you know, what's kind of the,
- 8:25the, the fallout, What was it? What was the step of the beam,
- 8:28which is obviously a much smaller company, but we saw a
- 8:31lot of sort of bruja around that, right?
- 8:33We saw a big sort of big sort of fuss around that.
- 8:37And fuss maybe isn't the right word because you know jobs are
- 8:40at risk, but you get the meaning of what I'm saying.
- 8:43Yeah. I mean, Matt, I'd have to defer
- 8:44to him on the numbers because he really got into the the
- 8:47documents. But we were, we were seeing
- 8:48quite a few sort of 6 figure, but a lot of the companies owed
- 8:52were old 6 figures, you know, but even for like some of the
- 8:55smaller tier companies, you know, sort of four or five
- 8:57figures is quite a significant hit.
- 9:00Now I spoke to a few of them and I think the consensus was, look,
- 9:03this isn't going to sink our business.
- 9:05You know, we've got enough customers that one of these kind
- 9:09of companies going down with this level of money owed.
- 9:13It's not curtains, but the consensus was, look, if we see
- 9:17more of these happening then yet, that's when we might have
- 9:21to start worrying across, not just for these companies, but
- 9:24across the whole Northeast, the whole UK services sector and
- 9:27definitely a company like Petrofac, you know, having to,
- 9:31you know, I think we all know with administration that you're,
- 9:35you're never going to get all the money you're owed.
- 9:37This is a whale going down and unfortunately, this whale isn't
- 9:39going to support an entire ecosystem on the seabed.
- 9:43Whoops. That was not the best method of
- 9:45work to go for. But look, you get my point that
- 9:48Petrofac is not a small services company.
- 9:51It's it's going to make a big difference to a lot of
- 9:55suppliers, a lot of the the sort of downstream companies, it's
- 9:58going to make a difference in their their own books.
- 10:02Certainly, I mean, I think you know, obviously Petrofac have
- 10:05said the usual thing with the administration that they're
- 10:07looking at merger and acquisition deals and various
- 10:10various other aspects. And Matt touched on the UK
- 10:14government and Petrofac signalling around this being
- 10:16well, the North Sea business which employs about 2000 people
- 10:19across Scotland is, is doing really well.
- 10:22I've heard the word crown jewel and you know, jewel and the
- 10:26crown of this this company. So you know, there is potential
- 10:30for for someone to swoop in, whether that's private equity or
- 10:34Sedara has clearly got some cash to spend.
- 10:37They're paying a lot less for their wood takeover that's
- 10:40expected to be delivered in the coming weeks.
- 10:43Maybe they'll they'll look to expand a little bit with with
- 10:46Petrofac being one of woods previous or big rivals.
- 10:50But that's all speculation. We also.
- 10:52Know that Apollo has been very active in the North Sea.
- 10:55You know, they also tried to take over wood recently snapped
- 10:58up OEG. So I imagine the, the, there
- 11:01will be firms, you know, if, if, if everything is as rosy as, as
- 11:05they're trying to make out in the UK business.
- 11:07And you know, the Gulf based business seems to be doing well.
- 11:10I imagine there will be plenty of people taking a look and
- 11:14seeing what they might be able to to reach into their
- 11:16pocketbooks for. Yeah, certainly, although this
- 11:20is all hearsay, we've not even seen the 2024 full year results,
- 11:23let alone quarterly updates this year.
- 11:26So we don't really know. That could just be signaling
- 11:30from the business. But stay tuned to Energy Voice.
- 11:32We'll, we'll try to keep you updated on this process as it
- 11:36develops, but that does it for this segment will join us after
- 11:40the break as we speak with John Swinney and his threats around
- 11:44reform. So we've had a lot of political
- 12:35tip for tat in the energy space over the past few years.
- 12:38The term political football is often banded around.
- 12:42This week John Twinney continued that with an event in Edinburgh
- 12:46where Anas Sarwar, the Scottish Labour leader, was also in
- 12:49attendance. He was threatening that
- 12:52Scotland's renewable opportunities wouldn't be
- 12:55delivered if that reform or to form the next government which
- 12:59they are pulled to do. Which is, you know, a totally
- 13:03other kind of worms. But Michael, you were there.
- 13:05You were. You were seeing the big man.
- 13:07What was happening? It was.
- 13:09A IIPPRS 10th anniversary conference.
- 13:12So I was in attendance. John Swinney was speaking and I
- 13:16definitely say that he was, he came in swinging.
- 13:19It was probably my my opinion there that he was very much like
- 13:25pushing the, the clean energy, the Scottish independence,
- 13:29rejoining the EU and also going after reform that he really was
- 13:35doing his best to paint this sort of vision for Scotland as
- 13:39an independent Scotland leveraging clean energy.
- 13:42I think is, is very much pushing this idea that I think we've
- 13:45heard before of, you know, that we bring in all of these
- 13:48renewable energy developments, you know, offshore wind farms,
- 13:52especially to create cheap energy that can bring in a lot
- 13:56of new high tech industries like hydrogen.
- 13:59I think that's one that's generally points out that we can
- 14:02produce hydrogen. You know, that's just just one
- 14:05on the list. But you know, it was also that
- 14:08rejoin the EU. He was pointing, I think, as
- 14:11always has been a big part of the the sort of the independence
- 14:15debate, the example of Ireland pointing out how the look they
- 14:20had independence so they can control their own sort of
- 14:24political levers. They've used that to reduce
- 14:26corporation tax, bring in a lot of, for U.S. companies.
- 14:31You know, it's like, why can't we be doing that?
- 14:33Why can't we take advantage of our energy?
- 14:36Rejoin the EU was obviously part of what he was saying, which I
- 14:39think, correct me if I'm wrong, I can't think of any other major
- 14:43political party that's really talking seriously about that.
- 14:47Yeah, I mean, certainly not reform.
- 14:49I mean, Nigel Farage was definitely the poster boy for
- 14:52Brexit. I mean, he was fronting UKIP,
- 14:55the UK Independence Party at the time of the the referendum.
- 14:59So definitely not him. Yeah, I mean, the SNP have been
- 15:03banging that drum for some time and you can understand why.
- 15:05I mean, this is the usual argument they give that Scotland
- 15:08didn't vote to leave the EU. It was the wider UK that did
- 15:11Scotland, you know, if you, if you isolate their voting
- 15:14numbers, it's, you know, they wanted to stay.
- 15:18So I mean, you can completely understand why they think that
- 15:21would strike a chord with Scottish force.
- 15:23It's, it's an interesting 1, isn't it?
- 15:27It feels like it's a similar argument to what we've heard
- 15:30before around yeah, we could be like Norway, we could be like
- 15:35Ireland. It seems to all that seems to be
- 15:37the sort of talking point, which I guess doesn't make sense.
- 15:40But we've also heard around the time of the the independence
- 15:43referendum, you know, that Scotland we maybe struggled to
- 15:47get back into the EU on they're on its own post Brexit.
- 15:50So it's a lot to unpack there. And then you also get into the
- 15:55the political tip for tat that I'm sure sure we'll touch on
- 15:57too. Yeah.
- 15:58I mean I think we could probably say that during Scottish
- 16:02independence the UK would probably have pushed the EU to
- 16:06not not let Scotland just stay in, but I imagine their their
- 16:11opinion doesn't quite count for as much as it it does these days
- 16:15it seems. As though, I guess we're
- 16:17interested in your take on this, Michael, but it seems as though
- 16:19Sweeney was really, I guess setting out the SNPs kind of,
- 16:22you know, campaign cause we've got the holy rood election.
- 16:24It's just around the, the corner in, in May.
- 16:26And it seems that, you know, if, if kind of energy net 0 reforms
- 16:31a threat to your renewable jobs in the future in our offshore
- 16:34wind sector. That really seems to be kind of,
- 16:35I guess shaping up what could be, I guess the SN PS, you know,
- 16:40main lines during that campaign. And then kind of what they kind
- 16:43of, I guess basing it on. And, and, you know, we, I, I
- 16:46guess, do we expect to see, you know, reform playing a, a big
- 16:49role in, in this sort of holy Rood debates?
- 16:52Do we expect them to be touching on, on energy?
- 16:55I guess what, what was, what was your take away?
- 16:58Because because Anasara was also there and, and I think maybe
- 17:02didn't touch on it in energy as much.
- 17:04Maybe that's an indication of Scottish Labour's, I guess,
- 17:07potential thinking of strategy for the Holy Rood election.
- 17:10No, you're absolutely right. Because what is it 7th of May
- 17:12next year that the election takes place?
- 17:15And you know, I know that reform and its extent to which it's
- 17:20going to perform is, you know, I think there's sort of it's up
- 17:25for debate. You know, definitely they've
- 17:27been polling well, we'll need to to see if the polls translate
- 17:31into performance. But even if it doesn't, you're
- 17:34absolutely right. The speeches we got out of
- 17:37Swinny and Sara were were definitely campaign speeches and
- 17:41whether Reform perform it's definitely going to be that they
- 17:45are going to be the heart of it. Because in amongst Sweeney's
- 17:49sort of portrayal of, you know, the sort of future of Scotland,
- 17:53you know, this independent EU country running on clean energy.
- 17:58Basically, we can add to into that the the boogeyman of Nigel
- 18:03Farage and Reform. I think one of the, you know,
- 18:07Sweeney was really pushing this idea that Yep, they are, they're
- 18:11kind of coming, that they're that a Westminster government
- 18:16run by reform is a major threat to Scotland.
- 18:20The I think he definitely used the line that this current
- 18:23Scottish Parliament just isn't strong enough to stand up to a
- 18:27reform LED Westminster government, hence the need for
- 18:30independence. In his opinion that this it
- 18:34would represent an existential threat not only to clean energy
- 18:39in Scotland and the whole UK, to a devolved government in
- 18:43Scotland and very much his entire vision for clean energy
- 18:48and an independent Scotland might be.
- 18:50A bit of a sort of a left, left field take, but I, I almost
- 18:53think that potentially the, the Welsh Senate elections might
- 18:56even be, I guess more interesting to watch because
- 19:00they're taking place on the if not the same day, but right
- 19:03around the same time as the holy rood elections.
- 19:04And you know, we've seen recently Plaid Cameroon has has
- 19:08kind of snapped up a seat in a by election from, from Labour
- 19:12and reform is also rising in the polls in Wales.
- 19:14And there's been a lot of speculation out there that if
- 19:16Labour kind of performs really poorly in, in Wales, where
- 19:20they've obviously had a really long standing support for a long
- 19:24time, that that could potentially be the, the last,
- 19:27last draw for Sakira Summers as Prime Minister.
- 19:30So, you know, if things don't go Labour's way in in Wales, and I
- 19:34guess obviously there will be an eye on on Scotland, but I think,
- 19:36you know, with the SNP is kind of an added long standing factor
- 19:39in there in in Scotland. It's maybe harder to attribute,
- 19:43you know, Labour and things as directly.
- 19:45But yeah, it's certainly shaping up to be a very, I guess key
- 19:52time, I guess for, for those local elections, because if that
- 19:55up ends Labour's leadership in, in, in Stalmer, we could see
- 20:00wholesale changes to their their energy policy.
- 20:02But. Of course, we're just wildly
- 20:04speculating now, as we we sometimes love to do, as is our
- 20:08prerogative and. ASAR where he he was very much
- 20:11of the opinion that he could win.
- 20:12I think the first thing he did was kind of take a bit of a
- 20:15swing at swinny pointing out Yep, Nope, I'm not I'm not going
- 20:19to trash talk reform as like the the basis of my of my talk.
- 20:24He didn't talk too much about clean energy.
- 20:26So hence why, you know, I kind of didn't, didn't include him
- 20:30some of his comments in, in our kind of round up on, on energy
- 20:34policy. But he was very much saying,
- 20:36look, I think we can outperform the polls.
- 20:38I think we, we've got a chance of, you know, having a major
- 20:42success in the, in the Scottish elections at least.
- 20:45It's it's an interesting 1, isn't it?
- 20:47Because, yeah, but like we're saying earlier, we're seeing
- 20:49these political themes for next year's Holy Rood election
- 20:54emerge. And in your copy, you mentioned
- 20:57a piece from a couple of months ago where we we spoke to, spoke
- 21:01to Stephen Flynn, the current MP for Aberdeen S, who's looking to
- 21:07to move to, to Holy Rood in a, in a chef that would see him
- 21:11give up his Westminster seat if he was to be voted in.
- 21:16And he was saying the same thing, you know, under under
- 21:19reform, renewables are dead in the water, you know, and these
- 21:23this is a big economic opportunity for the UK.
- 21:26I think also quite interestingly, is.
- 21:29I feel. Like, you know, I wrote about
- 21:31this last week in my my interview was Russell Finley and
- 21:36the the full interview was on last week's episode, depending
- 21:38on Mr. But this political tit for tat thing, you know, the
- 21:47for, for the SNP that often sort of bash it, you know, their
- 21:50opponents bash their presumption against line, which you could
- 21:53argue was not a good way to to set up their stall for oil and
- 21:58gas. But you know, Gillian Martin,
- 22:01the current energy sack up here in Scotland was sort of saying
- 22:06that their stances, you know, the energy markets changed an
- 22:09awful lot since since Sturgeon was in charge, which I guess you
- 22:13could argue is true. And you know, they're they're,
- 22:17they're advocating for an evidence based approach for oil
- 22:21and oil and gas. You know, so, and for me that
- 22:24all that felt like that was what they were always trying to say
- 22:26with presumption against, you know, that's not saying no, but
- 22:29I think presumption was maybe too strong a word.
- 22:32And instead they're they're sort of advocating for a case by case
- 22:35basis, evidence based. If they if an oil and gas
- 22:38project can you know, explain why, you know, it's
- 22:43environmentally, you know, if it's not too environmentally
- 22:46damaging. And as Rosebank is arguing at
- 22:50the moment, maybe things will be OK.
- 22:53But this sort of politicking around energy is is super
- 22:57interesting right now. And I remember hearing, I can't
- 23:00remember who it was offshore Europe say I'm fed up of having
- 23:05energy conferences where the politicians stand up and speak
- 23:08and then get off stage and leave.
- 23:11We should have a conference with the energy bosses, speak to the,
- 23:14oh, you know, speak at the politicians.
- 23:16And I thought that was quite an interesting one because as we
- 23:19mentioned earlier, if that's they're playing to the lowest,
- 23:23you know, the people that maybe don't pay attention to the
- 23:25industry in the same way that people work in it are like us,
- 23:29report on it, do it. So you end up kind of getting
- 23:33fed up a little bit. I find myself getting fed up of
- 23:35these big statements that mean absolutely nothing.
- 23:40So who knows? We'll wait and see.
- 23:42We'll wait and see. But that's maybe just me moaning
- 23:45a little bit on a on a Thursday morning.
- 23:50Anyway, that that'll wrap up this segment.
- 23:52Let's let's move on to Shell and Ecuador's Q threes as a juror
- 23:58looks to open its doors by the end of the year.
- 24:57Ajura is indeed on the horizon for Aberdeen and the wider North
- 25:03Sea as Shell and Equinor 2 Titans of industry are looking
- 25:08to merge their UK assets. And this week we got a little
- 25:12bit more detail on the formation of that through Shell and
- 25:16Equinor as Q3 results. Matt, you've been Johnny on the
- 25:21spot this week. You've been on the early shift.
- 25:23Tell us a little bit about Shell's results, which just came
- 25:26out a couple of hours ago at time of recording.
- 25:29Yeah. So Shell I guess slightly
- 25:31outperformed analyst expectations in their their Q3
- 25:34results. The adjusted earnings came in at
- 25:37$5.4 billion for the third quarter.
- 25:40That was, you know, slightly up from I guess the consensus
- 25:43analyst forecast was around 5 billion.
- 25:45So they've going to come in above that it's, you know, up
- 25:48from their Q2 results, which were around $4.3 billion.
- 25:52But you know, it's still down about 13% from the Q3 result in
- 25:582024 where they pulled in $6.2 billion in in that quarter.
- 26:04So, yeah, Shell said that the sort of the change in result
- 26:07reflects, you know, softer oil and gas prices, despite the fact
- 26:11that they also had a stronger trading performance.
- 26:15So Shell's chief executive Whalesawan said the results, you
- 26:19know, reflected clear progress across the portfolio.
- 26:23And there's announced another tranche of share buyback
- 26:26programs with $3.5 billion. That's the 16th consecutive
- 26:31quarter that Shells had at least a $3 billion share buyback.
- 26:35So yeah, potentially happy from from investors, you know, it
- 26:39came in a little bit above analyst expectations.
- 26:41We're obviously down from the the highs of previous years
- 26:46where we saw those big results. Not a lot in there to be honest
- 26:49about the UK North Sea there was, you know, I guess mainly
- 26:54then the upstream segment for Shell, their their earnings rose
- 26:58to 1.8 billion and that came largely from record production
- 27:02in Brazil and you know, I think 20 year highs in the in the Gulf
- 27:07of Mexico. So overall a fairly strong,
- 27:10strong quarter from from Shell. But it's interesting, I guess as
- 27:14well to see, you know, even a slight improvement in their
- 27:18renewables and energy solutions, which I think used to be kind of
- 27:22encompasses their kind of low carbon results, say pulled in
- 27:25about 100 million U.S. dollars. So that's a positive result from
- 27:29kind of a break even in previous.
- 27:32So even in their, you know, renewables business, they're,
- 27:36they're making some, some money there.
- 27:37So you know, fairly, fairly decent performance from, from
- 27:41Shell. But as you mentioned, you know,
- 27:43it's interesting to compare that to Equinor cause yeah, they
- 27:47still expect by the end of this year that the NRC operation will
- 27:50be being combined to a juror. This might be the last time we
- 27:54can use the phrase Shakwinor on the on the podcast, Ryan.
- 27:57But you were taking a look at Equinor's books from their Q3
- 28:01results and there was some interesting tidbits in there
- 28:04about a juror? Yeah, I I still prefer the name
- 28:08Shat Oil, but that's maybe just me.
- 28:10A juror did take its toll on Equinor this quarter essentially
- 28:16it reported maybe less than favourable results, maybe not
- 28:20quite as strong as Shell is. It said that, you know, the
- 28:24assets held for sale for the the Ajura independent joint venture
- 28:29has cost about $650 million or in in British money that would
- 28:35be about 492.2 ish $1,000,000. What you know, what's a couple
- 28:41of decimal points and a million between friends.
- 28:44So it's, it's definitely, you know, sort of taken a hit as
- 28:49it's, you know, year on year earnings also, you know, also
- 28:53took a 10% dip. Arguably sort of reading between
- 28:58the lines a little bit in Ecuador's books.
- 29:01It felt a little bit more like they were being all more open
- 29:04about why they're doing this than Shell are at least in their
- 29:09sort of public facing comments. You know, the Ecuador definitely
- 29:14took a good few pars out of its reports to, to moan about UK
- 29:19tax, which I mean, as anyone who keeps tabs on the UK oil and gas
- 29:25market, well, no, that's not a uncommon thing to, to see.
- 29:29But you know, essentially it paid an effective rate of tax in
- 29:33the, in the third quarter of 104.4%.
- 29:38And it's that, that means that it's the first nine months of
- 29:44the year, the, the effective rate of tax was about 880.6%.
- 29:50Obviously, you know, said the EPL was, was part of the reason
- 29:55for that, the energy profits levy.
- 29:57However, Despite that, I mean, we won't shed too many tears,
- 30:00you know, the firm firm still managed to take home £5.27
- 30:03billion in the third quarter and revenues still saw a 7% uptick
- 30:09from the year previous. But I think maybe most
- 30:13interestingly for anyone who keeps tabs on the UK energy
- 30:17market is that sort of looming Ajura presence that we feel.
- 30:22And, you know, both firms, you know, I can't really speak too
- 30:27much on Shell, but I definitely spent my time reading through
- 30:30Equinor's results that Eggnor was very sort of strong.
- 30:35And it's yes, it will come this year.
- 30:37We've got, you know, we're making our way through the
- 30:39regulatory approval process. And you know, they'd said that
- 30:43they were the majority of the required approvals have been
- 30:47obtained for a Jura to open its doors on time, which is
- 30:50interesting because, you know, I think that was just this our
- 30:53peek behind the curtain of all of the, you know, Competition
- 30:57Markets Authority and NSDA approvals.
- 31:01Obviously, we'll need to go to the regulator to transfer
- 31:04ownership of licenses over to a new company.
- 31:08And we've seen in recent months with Deltek and Vrro that that
- 31:12can delay M and a deals. So interesting, interesting time
- 31:18certainly for for keeping tabs on a juror who still are claimed
- 31:24to be the can claim to be the biggest operator in in the UK
- 31:30basin. But with with this sort of
- 31:33rapidly evolving M and a market in the UK, who knows?
- 31:36I mean, you know, Ithaca could put them to that, as could neo
- 31:41and whoever else with all the speculation around buying up new
- 31:44assets. So with this, I guess are we
- 31:50willing to put our necks on the line and say a juror is
- 31:53definitely coming this year or do we see some regulatory
- 31:56hiccups? I can go first because I've
- 31:59never been afraid to make a Dodge prediction.
- 32:02So I'm going to say yes, it's coming this year, of which
- 32:06you're two months, no hiccups, I predict nothing going wrong.
- 32:11Yeah, I can't really see any reason why it it shouldn't go
- 32:15ahead. We've seen other kind of merges,
- 32:17you know any and Ithaca go ahead reps or NEO looking to to go
- 32:22ahead. I don't think there's any kind
- 32:24of thing out of the ordinary that would prevent this from
- 32:27from getting getting finalized. I guess it's just a matter of of
- 32:31of timing of these things, but it'll imagine we'll get over the
- 32:35line. Yeah, no, it's interesting, I
- 32:37guess looking through some of the the numbers as we're
- 32:39chatting, you know, Equinoid sort of separated out there,
- 32:42they're North Sea assets, but Shells got a line in their
- 32:45results about their assets held for sale.
- 32:48But unfortunately, we can't pass out exactly how much they're
- 32:50valuing the UK offshore oil and gas assets because they've also
- 32:54got some mining interest in Canada in their chemicals and
- 32:56products division that is muddying those numbers.
- 32:59But what I've been able to pull out is that the first nine
- 33:03months of 2025, Shell paid a charge of about 509 million U.S.
- 33:09dollars right to the UK energy policy energy profits levy to
- 33:12the windfall tax, which I said was partly offset by selling
- 33:17some disposing some assets for $524 million.
- 33:21Whether those two are directly connected, who knows.
- 33:24But yes, Shell still paying paying some some big bucks
- 33:27relating to the the EPLI mean. We haven't even touched on on
- 33:31sort of future headaches of operatorship of, you know,
- 33:35assets with Shell signed that extension for a few of its
- 33:38Southern Gas, Southern North Sea gas assets with Petrofac just a
- 33:43month or two ago. But I guess that again, we're,
- 33:46we're getting into real wild speculation there.
- 33:49So I think before we get ourselves into some trouble, we
- 33:53should probably wrap up for the week.
- 33:55So thank you, Michael, and that for joining me and thank you
- 33:59very much for listening. If you'd like to stay up to date
- 34:01with all things energy in the UK and further afield, make sure to
- 34:05stay tuned to Energy Voice Out Loud, Same Time, Same Place next
- 34:09week.