Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin and the Mongol Threat: The Diplomacy That Never Came
Transcript
- Lucas: So, we've spent a lot of episodes looking at Saladin's life, his wars against the Crusaders, his diplomacy, his generosity. But there's a shadow that looms over his legacy that we haven't touched yet — a threat that would make the Franj look like a minor nuisance. Luna: You mean the Mongols? Lucas: Exactly. Saladin died in 1193. Just a decade later, in 1200, a strange embassy arrived in Cairo. The visitors were not from the Frankish states or even from Byzantium. They were scouts from a rising power in the East that no one in the Ayyubid court had heard of: the Mongols. Luna: Wait, the Mongols sent an embassy to Cairo in 1200? That's before Genghis Khan had even unified the tribes. Lucas: Yes, it's early. But Genghis was already consolidating power, and his scouts were probing westward. The embassy reached al-Adil, Saladin's brother, who was now sultan. They brought gifts and proposed a trade agreement. But al-Adil, like most Muslim rulers, dismissed them as just another steppe tribe. Lucas: It's a fascinating 'what if' moment. Because within two decades, the Mongols would destroy the Khwarezmian Empire, sack Bukhara, and threaten Baghdad. And the Islamic world was still fractured — the very divisions Saladin had tried to heal. Luna: So you're saying if Saladin had lived longer, he might have turned his coalition-building eastward? Lucas: That's the haunting possibility. We have letters from al-Qadi al-Fadil, Saladin's chief chancery secretary, that show he was aware of the Mongol rise. There's a dispatch from 1191, just after the Third Crusade, warning of 'a great people from the East who sweep all before them.' But with the Crusader threat immediate, the focus remained on the Franj. Lucas: Ibn al-Athir, the great historian who lived through the Mongol invasion, wrote that the Mongols were 'a calamity greater than anything history had recorded.' And he noted that the Muslim world's disunity made it easy pickings. Luna: So Saladin's jihad against the Crusaders, as effective as it was, may have inadvertently left the East vulnerable? Lucas: In a sense. But it's not that simple. Saladin's goal was to unite the Muslim world under Sunni orthodoxy and Ayyubid rule. He did manage to bring together Egypt, Syria, and parts of Mesopotamia. But the Khwarezmian Empire in the East remained independent and hostile. The Khwarezm-Shah, Ala ad-Din Muhammad, even refused to ally with Saladin against the Crusaders. Lucas: After Saladin's death, his successors squabbled. Al-Adil eventually stabilized things, but the Ayyubid confederation was fragile. So when Genghis Khan's armies rolled into Transoxiana in 1219, there was no united front. Luna: And Bukhara fell in 1220. That's only 27 years after Saladin died. Lucas: Right. Ibn al-Athir describes it in harrowing detail: 'They came like a swarm of locusts, killing without mercy, burning the great mosque, and enslaving tens of thousands.' He says the Islamic world had never seen such devastation. Lucas: Now, could Saladin have done anything? He was a master of diplomacy and military coalitions. He might have formed an alliance with the Khwarezm-Shah, maybe even the Qara Khitai, to check the Mongols. But he died before the threat fully materialized. Luna: There's also the question of his health. He was worn out by the Crusades. Maybe he wouldn't have had the energy for another massive campaign. Lucas: True. But what's fascinating is that the Mongol threat actually did eventually unite some of the Ayyubid princes. In 1221, al-Adil's son al-Ashraf joined forces with the Khwarezmians against the Mongols. But it was too late — the Mongols were already too powerful. Lucas: Let's go back to that 1200 embassy. It's recorded by the historian al-Maqrizi. The Mongol envoys were received in Cairo, given gifts, and sent back with a letter. Al-Adil wrote to Genghis Khan, addressing him as 'the Great Khan,' offering friendship. But he also made it clear he saw the Mongols as distant and irrelevant. Luna: So al-Adil basically blew them off. Lucas: Pretty much. He probably thought they were just another group of steppe nomads, like the Seljuks before them. But the Seljuks had converted to Islam and assimilated. The Mongols were different — they had no interest in Islam or settled civilization at that point. Lucas: There's a surviving letter from al-Qadi al-Fadil to the caliph in Baghdad, warning of the Mongol danger. But the Abbasid caliph, al-Nasir, was more worried about the Ayyubids than the Mongols. He actually encouraged the Khwarezm-Shah to attack the Ayyubids — a short-sighted move that only weakened the region. Luna: So internal politics blinded everyone to the real threat. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the tragedy. Saladin had spent his life trying to build a united Sunni front against the Crusaders. But after his death, the old rivalries resurfaced. The Zengids, the Ayyubids, the Khwarezmians — they fought each other instead of preparing for the Mongols. Lucas: Ibn al-Athir, who was a contemporary, wrote: 'Had the Muslims been united, they could have stopped the Mongols at the Oxus. But they were divided, and so the catastrophe came.' He said this with the benefit of hindsight, of course. Luna: Do we have any record of what Saladin himself thought about the Mongols? Any direct mention? Lucas: Not much. The only reference I've found is in Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad's biography. He mentions that in 1192, Saladin received reports of 'a great movement of peoples from the East,' but he dismissed it as distant and not relevant to his immediate goals. He was focused on negotiating with Richard the Lionheart. Lucas: But think about this: Saladin's model of jihad was based on defending Islamic territory against the Franj. Had he lived another ten years, he might have redefined jihad to include the Mongol threat. He had the moral authority to call for a united war. Luna: And he had the military experience. He knew how to fight a mobile enemy from the steppes — he'd done it against the Zengids and the Crusaders. Lucas: Right. The Ayyubid army was heavy on cavalry and archers. They could have adapted. But without Saladin's unifying presence, the Ayyubid princes wasted their strength on petty squabbles. Lucas: In the end, the Mongols reached Baghdad in 1258, destroying the Abbasid Caliphate. That was 65 years after Saladin's death. But the groundwork for that disaster was laid in the decades after he died, when no leader of his stature emerged to unite the Muslim world against the coming storm. Luna: It's a sobering 'what if.' But also a testament to how important leadership and unity are in history. Lucas: Absolutely. And it's a reminder that Saladin's legacy isn't just about the Crusades. He was a figure who, for a brief moment, brought together a fractured region. And after he was gone, the fractures reopened — just in time for the Mongols. Luna: So maybe the real lesson is that the work of unity is never done. It has to be constantly rebuilt. Lucas: Exactly. And that's what makes studying this period so relevant. The same dynamics — internal division, short-term thinking, inability to see emerging threats — they play out again and again. Lucas: We'll never know what would have happened if Saladin had lived another decade. But we can imagine him, in his final years, looking east as well as west, and wondering if the storm he saw on the horizon would be the one that finally broke the world he had tried to build.