Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Apple Q4 Deep Value and Technical Analysis: Valuation, Growth, and Risks
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we are, well, we're not
- 0:03just talking about a company, we are talking about a
- 0:05gravitational force. That's a good way to put it, a
- 0:07center of gravity for the entire market.
- 0:09Exactly. We are talking about an entity
- 0:12that, if it were a country, its GDP would rival major G7
- 0:16nations. We are, of course, tackling the
- 0:19absolute Titan of the market, Apple.
- 0:21Inc and not just Apple in general.
- 0:23We're looking at it right now as of today, Thursday, January
- 0:2729th, 2026. It is the day the earnings have
- 0:31dropped. And you know, usually when we
- 0:32talk about earnings for a company this massive, it's it
- 0:35can be a lot of very large, very abstract numbers.
- 0:38Numbers that can kind of put you to sleep, honestly.
- 0:39A billion here, a billion there. But today, today feels
- 0:43different. Oh, it's absolutely.
- 0:44Different is an understatement. I've been staring at these press
- 0:46releases for the last hour and my jaw is, I think, still on the
- 0:49floor. We just got the fiscal Q12026
- 0:52numbers and we are looking at records just being shattered.
- 0:55Shattered is the right word. Revenue records, profit records,
- 0:58services records. It looks like the perfect
- 1:00quarter. On paper, it is the perfect
- 1:02quarter. I mean, this is the kind of
- 1:04quarter that CEO's literally dream about when they go to
- 1:07sleep at night and. There is a very big, very heavy
- 1:10butt looming over this entire conversation.
- 1:13We have a job to do. Our mission today isn't just to,
- 1:16you know, fanboy over the iPhone sales figures.
- 1:19We have to decide if this financial fortress is actually a
- 1:23smart place to put your hard earned money right now.
- 1:25Exactly. And this is the classic conflict
- 1:28in investing, isn't it? It's the one that separates the
- 1:30casual observers from the serious allocators of capital.
- 1:33What's that? It's the conflict between a
- 1:35truly wonderful company and a, well, a questionable price tag.
- 1:40Just because a business is fantastic doesn't automatically
- 1:42mean the stock is a buy. That is such a hard concept to
- 1:46grasp sometimes it feels counterintuitive.
- 1:48So we're going to look at the AI super cycle everyone is
- 1:50screaming about. We're going to unpack something
- 1:52called the yield gap, which frankly I needed you to explain
- 1:55to me about three times before it really clicked.
- 1:57But it is absolutely critical for everyone listening.
- 1:59What's the whole ball game right now?
- 2:01And we are going to try to figure out why the smartest
- 2:04value investor in history, the Oracle of Omaha himself, Warren
- 2:07Buffett, seems to be heading for the exit while everyone else is
- 2:10rushing in. It's the ultimate showdown,
- 2:12right? It's the narrative versus the
- 2:13math. The story says bye, But the
- 2:16calculator, well, the calculator might be saying something very,
- 2:20very different. Before we get into the weeds of
- 2:22the iPhone 17 and all these massive billions, we have a
- 2:26little tool that might help you visualize the market temperature
- 2:30we're talking about. Because context is everything
- 2:32here. Right.
- 2:32If you want to see exactly how, let's say heated the market is,
- 2:36you need data. You have to strip away the
- 2:38emotion and just look at the cold hard ratios.
- 2:40To track total market temperature.
- 2:42Welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett indicator from
- 2:45Apple App Store. It's a really great way to keep
- 2:47an eye on valuations in real time.
- 2:49It essentially measures the market cap of the stock market
- 2:51against the GDP of the economy. A.
- 2:53Classic metric for a reason. And of course, before we dissect
- 2:57the world's largest company, we have to handle the the
- 2:59housekeeping. The lawyers get nervous if we
- 3:01don't. Let's get the legalities out of
- 3:03the way. Full Deep value Research reports
- 3:06can be found in the description links.
- 3:07All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 3:10may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 3:14The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 3:17constitute investment advice. And this is the big one.
- 3:19Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 3:22decisions. If you want to listen to our
- 3:24full deep dive about this topic or access more advanced
- 3:27contents, welcome to join Deep Value Club membership or
- 3:31subscribe to us on Deep Values dot AI all.
- 3:33Right. Formalities aside, let's look at
- 3:35this beast. Let's do it.
- 3:37Let's start with the headline numbers.
- 3:38Apple just reported its first quarter for fiscal 2026.
- 3:42Now, for those who don't follow the calendar, Apple's fiscal
- 3:44year is a little weird. So Q1 actually covers the
- 3:46holiday season, October through December.
- 3:49The big one, the iPhone launch window.
- 3:51Exactly. So the revenue came in at $143.8
- 3:54billion. OK, I want to pause there
- 3:56immediately. We hear billions thrown around
- 3:59all the time in finance. The word billion has almost lost
- 4:01its meaning because we hear it so much.
- 4:03It just becomes noise after a while.
- 4:05It does, but I need you, the listener, to really visualize
- 4:09what $143.8 billion in three months actually looks like.
- 4:15OK, help us scale that because to me it's just a number with a
- 4:18lot of commas. All right, think of it this way.
- 4:20That is roughly $1.5 billion per day A.
- 4:24Day. Every single day for 90 days
- 4:27straight. Christmas, New Year's, doesn't
- 4:29matter. Or if you want to get even more
- 4:31granular, that's about $18,000 in revenue pouring into
- 4:34Cupertino every single second. Every second.
- 4:38Just tick $18,000, tick another 18,000 tick it's it's just a
- 4:44firehose of cash. That is actually hard to
- 4:46comprehend. That's a mind bending amount of
- 4:47money. And here is the real kicker.
- 4:50It's not just the size of the number, it's the speed.
- 4:54That revenue number is up 16% compared to the same time last
- 4:57year. And this is where the context is
- 4:59so important, right? Because if I tell you a tech
- 5:00startup grew 16%, you'd say. That's OK, but not great.
- 5:03Yeah, right. A startup is supposed to double
- 5:06or triple. You expect explosive growth.
- 5:08Exactly. If a small software company
- 5:10grows 16%, their venture capital investors are probably
- 5:12panicking. But Apple isn't a speedboat,
- 5:16it's an aircraft carrier. It's the biggest aircraft
- 5:18carrier in the whole fleet. And usually when companies get
- 5:21to this mega cap level, we're talking trillion dollar
- 5:24valuations, the law of large numbers kicks in, gravity takes
- 5:28hold. You expect them to grow at the
- 5:29speed of the economy? Maybe 3 percent, 4%, basically
- 5:33tracking GDP. Like a utility company, safe,
- 5:35boring, slow. You buy it for the dividend and
- 5:38the safety, not because you think it's going to the moon.
- 5:40Precisely. You buy it and go to sleep.
- 5:42But 16%, that is a growth stock number.
- 5:45That is what we call a reacceleration.
- 5:47It tells us that this aircraft carrier, this behemoth, somehow
- 5:50just started drifting like a speedboat.
- 5:52So the market is reacting not just to the money, but to the
- 5:55change in trajectory. That's it.
- 5:57It's signals that Apple isn't behaving like a mature, boring
- 6:00stalwart right now. It's behaving like a hungry
- 6:03teenager again. And the profit is just as
- 6:05absurd. Net quarterly profit hit $42.1
- 6:10billion. That's up 19% compared to last
- 6:13year. And again, look at the divergent
- 6:15there. That's a really important
- 6:17detail. Revenue up 16, Profit up 19.
- 6:20Right, So what does that gap tell you?
- 6:22It means they're getting more profitable.
- 6:24Exactly. It tells you about operating
- 6:26leverage and efficiency. It means that for every extra
- 6:29dollar of sales they brought in, they kept more of it as profit
- 6:32than they did last year. They're squeezing more pennies
- 6:35out of every dollar. They're becoming more efficient
- 6:37even as they get bigger, which is frankly terrifying for their
- 6:40competitors. So what is driving this?
- 6:42I mean, what is the engine here? Because for a while the
- 6:45narrative, and I remember us talking about this back in 2024,
- 6:48was that the iPhone had peaked. Oh yeah, that was a big story.
- 6:51Everyone has a smartphone. They're all glass rectangles.
- 6:53Nobody needs a new one every year.
- 6:55But clearly something big changed.
- 6:57The iPhone 17 happened. Or maybe more accurately, the AI
- 7:01super cycle finally arrived. The Super cycle.
- 7:04Tim Cook, the CEO, used the word unprecedented to describe demand
- 7:08for the iPhone 17 lineup. And you know, corporate CEO's,
- 7:12especially conservative ones like Cook, he's an operations
- 7:14guy, not a hype man. They do not throw words like
- 7:17unprecedented around lightly. No, that's not his style at all.
- 7:21We've been hearing about this AI super cycle for two years now.
- 7:25Since 2024 people have been saying just wait until Apple
- 7:28does AI. It seems like 2026 is the year
- 7:31it actually landed. But explain why.
- 7:33Is it just a better camera again?
- 7:34No, no, it's not the camera this time.
- 7:36This is a fundamental shift. The thesis was that eventually
- 7:39the AI features what they're calling Apple Intelligence would
- 7:42be so compelling and require so much local on device processing
- 7:46power that you couldn't just keep using your iPhone 13 or 14
- 7:49anymore. Right, because the old ships
- 7:50literally can't run the new brain.
- 7:51You've got it. If you want the on device
- 7:53generative AI, the Siri that actually understands context,
- 7:55the real time rewriting tools, the image generation that
- 7:58happens privately and securely on your phone, not in the cloud,
- 8:01you had to upgrade. So the hardware became the
- 8:03gatekeeper again, Yes. The hardware became the
- 8:06gatekeeper to the new software paradigm.
- 8:09And these Q1 numbers, they validate that thesis completely.
- 8:12This isn't just people breaking their phones and needing a
- 8:14replacement. This is a massive voluntary
- 8:17upgrade cycle. People are choosing to upgrade
- 8:19because they want the new features.
- 8:21So the iPhone isn't becoming a commodity like a toaster or a
- 8:24fridge. It's cementing itself as a
- 8:27premium necessity. It's like you can't participate
- 8:30in the modern digital world fully without the latest key.
- 8:32It's the gateway drug for personalized private AI, and
- 8:36once you buy that hardware, you enter the real profit.
- 8:39Interest which is services. Services.
- 8:41Yes, we have to talk about services.
- 8:42This is the hidden giant inside the giant.
- 8:44The numbers here are also huge. Services revenue grew 14% to a
- 8:48new all time record and this is the App Store, iCloud, Apple
- 8:52Music, Apple Pay, Apple TV Plus, Cup, all that stuff.
- 8:55And this is where the magic of the business model really,
- 8:57really lies. Think about the margins when
- 8:59Apple sells you an iPhone 17 Pro Max.
- 9:02They make a healthy profit for sure.
- 9:04It's a physical object they have to pay for glass, silicon,
- 9:07metal, shipping, assembly, labor.
- 9:10The gross margin on hardware is somewhere around 36 to 40%.
- 9:13Which is great for hardware. Oh, it's incredible for
- 9:15hardware. Most car companies would kill
- 9:18for a 15% margin, but it's costly to make.
- 9:20OK, so they keep about $0.40 on the dollar for a phone?
- 9:23Roughly, yeah, But services. Services is software.
- 9:27Once you build the App Store, once you've set up the iCloud
- 9:29data centers, the cost of selling one more subscription or
- 9:32one more app down load is practically 0.
- 9:34It's almost pure profit. Close to IT services have gross
- 9:37margins typically around 72%. Wow, so nearly double the
- 9:41profitability of the phone. Almost double, which means for
- 9:44every dollar of services revenue, they keep $0.72 as
- 9:47gross profit. And as that slice of the pie
- 9:49gets bigger and it is growing fast, the entire company becomes
- 9:53more profitable per dollar earned.
- 9:55It structurally lifts the profitability profile of the
- 9:58whole organization. They're transforming from a
- 10:00hardware company into a a high margin digital landlord.
- 10:04That's a perfect analogy, and I saw a number in the report that
- 10:07just blew my mind related to the scale of this whole thing.
- 10:10The installed base. Oh yeah, 2 1/2 billion active
- 10:14devices. 2.5 billion, that is. It's hard to even wrap your head
- 10:18around that. That's almost a third of the
- 10:20planet's population holding an Apple device.
- 10:22And think of it this way. That is 2 1/2 billion points of
- 10:25sale. Every single one of those
- 10:27devices is a storefront. It's a credit card terminal in
- 10:30your pocket every time you open the A Tore, every time you renew
- 10:33your cloud storage because your photos are full, every time you
- 10:36tap Ale Pay. Catching That's the famous
- 10:39flywheel. That is the flywheel.
- 10:40You buy the hardware, which is the entry ticket, and then you
- 10:42spend the rest of your life paying small tolls inside their
- 10:45ecosystem. Which brings us perfectly to the
- 10:47business model itself. We often hear the term walled
- 10:51garden. It sounds nice, you know, like a
- 10:53secret garden with flowers and fountains.
- 10:56But in economic terms, it's really a fortress, isn't it?
- 10:59It is a fortress with very high walls and very very expensive
- 11:03exits. If you look at the revenue pie
- 11:05right now, iPhone is still king at about 52%.
- 11:07Services is now roughly 24%, wearables, your watch, your
- 11:11Airpods are about 10%. But the walled garden
- 11:14architecture is what binds all of them together.
- 11:17It's the golden handcuffs. I feel this.
- 11:19Personally, I've thought about switching to Android just to see
- 11:22what the foldable phones are like, but then I panic.
- 11:25What stops you? What's the panic about?
- 11:26The blue bubbles. The blue bubbles, Yeah, I
- 11:28message, of course. If I leave, I'm the green
- 11:32bubble. I ruin the family group chat.
- 11:34My photos are all in I cloud, terabytes of them.
- 11:37My Apple Watch won't talk to a Google Pixel.
- 11:39It just, it feels like too much work, like a massive, painful
- 11:42project. And that is exactly what they
- 11:44want, that feeling of inertia. Let's say you decide to leave
- 11:46Apple. You lose your iMessage history
- 11:48in the blue bubbles. You lose the seamless
- 11:50integration where you copy something on your phone and
- 11:52paste it on your. Mac sand off, yeah.
- 11:54You lose all the paid apps you've bought over the last 10
- 11:56years. You have to buy them all again
- 11:58on the Google Play Store. It becomes a logistical
- 12:00nightmare to leave. It's like moving house, but the
- 12:03moving truck cost $5000 and you lose half your furniture on the
- 12:06way. A perfect analogy.
- 12:08And that's why their customer retention rates consistently
- 12:10hover over 90%. It's not just loyalty, it's
- 12:13friction. High switching costs are a
- 12:15massive, massive component of their economic Moat.
- 12:19Let's unpack that Moat concept a bit more.
- 12:21We hear Buffett talk about moats all the time.
- 12:24Apple seems to have a few layers of defense here.
- 12:26They have what you'd call a very wide economic Moat, protected by
- 12:31I'd say 3 main fortifications. 1st as we just discussed the
- 12:35high switching costs that keeps people inside the walls.
- 12:37OK, so that's defense. Right second is intangible
- 12:40assets, specifically the brand Apple consistently ranks as the
- 12:44world's most valuable brand, and this gives them something
- 12:47incredible pricing power. Explain pricing power in this
- 12:51context. What does that mean practically?
- 12:53It means they can raise the price of the iPhone Pro by $100
- 12:58and people still buy it. In effect, sometimes demand goes
- 13:01up because it's seen as a more exclusive status symbol.
- 13:03So it defies the normal laws of economics.
- 13:05It defies standard price elasticity.
- 13:08Usually in Econ One O 1, when prices go up, demand goes down.
- 13:11With Apple, prices go up and status goes up.
- 13:14It behaves almost like what's called a Veblen good, like a a
- 13:17Birkin bag or a Ferrari. The high price is part of the
- 13:20appeal. And the third fortification.
- 13:21Network effects. This is the magic of the App
- 13:24Store, because iOS users are the ones who spend the most money.
- 13:27Statistically, iPhone users spend way more on apps than
- 13:29Android users. The best developers build their
- 13:32best apps for iOS first. I've noticed that the cool new
- 13:35app always comes out on iPhone first.
- 13:37Always. And because the best apps are on
- 13:39iOS, more of the high value users join iOS.
- 13:43It's a self reinforcing loop. More users means better
- 13:47developers, which means better apps which attracts more users.
- 13:50It's like a toll bridge for the digital economy.
- 13:53If you want to reach the most valuable customers in the world,
- 13:55you have to cross Apple's bridge and you have to pay the 30%
- 13:57toll. It sounds, it sounds perfect.
- 14:00It sounds like the perfect business.
- 14:01It is a wonderful business. There's absolutely no debating
- 14:04that. It is arguably the best business
- 14:05ever built by human beings. But I sense the butt coming
- 14:08again. You can hear it in your.
- 14:09Voice. But investing isn't just about
- 14:11buying good companies. If it were that easy, we'd all
- 14:14just buy the top ten companies on the Fortune 500 list and go
- 14:17to the beach. Sure.
- 14:18Investing is about buying good companies at the right price.
- 14:21And this is where we run into the massive conflict in this
- 14:24deep dive, the bull versus the bear debate.
- 14:26OK, let's play this out. I'll take the bull case for a
- 14:28minute. The narrative seems incredibly
- 14:30strong. The AI super cycle is real.
- 14:32We just saw the numbers to prove it.
- 14:34The ecosystem is inescapable. 2 1/2 billion devices and the
- 14:39quality of the business is just undeniable.
- 14:41I'm looking at the ROIC, the return on invested capital.
- 14:44It's over 50%, even 60% in some estimate.
- 14:48That is elite. Just to clarify that for the
- 14:50listener, that means for every single dollar Apple invests into
- 14:53its own business, into new factories, data centers, R&D,
- 14:57they get 50 to $0.60 back in profit.
- 14:59Yeah, every single year. That's insane.
- 15:01It is. Most companies kill to get 15%.
- 15:03So yes, the bowl case on the quality of the business is
- 15:05ironclad. You are owning A literal money
- 15:08printing machine. So if the quality is elite and
- 15:11the growth is re accelerating from this massive base, why are
- 15:14we even having a debate? Why isn't this a buy everything
- 15:16you can mortgage the house kind of situation?
- 15:18Because of the math, this is where we have to take off the
- 15:21consumer hat, the person who loves the iPhone, and put on the
- 15:24cold hard investor hat. We have to look at the
- 15:26valuation. The price tag, what you pay for
- 15:28that quality. The price tag relative to what
- 15:31you get right now, as we speak, Apple is trading at a price to
- 15:34earnings ratio, or PE, of somewhere between 33 and 35
- 15:39times its earnings. OK, is that high?
- 15:41I mean Amazon used to trade at 100, NVIDIA trades at 50 or
- 15:456035. Doesn't sound crazy in the tech
- 15:47world. For a high flying tech growth
- 15:49stock, maybe not. But for Apple, historically, yes
- 15:53it is very high. Apple's 10 year average PE is
- 15:56closer to 20 or 25 times. So right off the bat you are
- 16:00paying a huge premium compared to its own history.
- 16:02You're essentially paying for 35 years of its current earnings to
- 16:05own one share of the stock. OK.
- 16:07So it's expensive relative to itself.
- 16:09But the real problem isn't just its own history, it's the yield
- 16:12gap. All right, let's unpack this
- 16:13slowly. Yield gap.
- 16:15I hear this term thrown around by bond traders and financial
- 16:18news talking heads. Break it down for me like I'm 5
- 16:21or maybe like I'm a smart 12 year old.
- 16:24Deal. Let's imagine you have $100 in
- 16:26your pocket right now. You have two choices for what to
- 16:29do with it. Choice A You lend that $100 to
- 16:34the US government for 10 years by buying a Treasury bond.
- 16:37OK, Uncle Sam. Pretty reliable borrower.
- 16:39They are printing press, so they're good for it.
- 16:41The most reliable borrower in the world.
- 16:43And right now the government says thank you for the $100.
- 16:47In return, we will pay you 4% interest every year, guaranteed.
- 16:51So you get $4.00 a year. Zero stress, zero risk.
- 16:54Got it. That's my baseline, the risk
- 16:56free rate, 4% of my pocket guaranteed.
- 16:58Now Choice B, you take that same $100 and you buy a share of
- 17:02Apple. Which is way more exciting than
- 17:04a government bond. I can talk about it at parties.
- 17:06Much more exciting, but let's just look at the math for a
- 17:08second. Apple is trading at a PE of
- 17:10about 35, right? Right.
- 17:12If you flip that number over, so you divide 1 by 35, you get
- 17:15what's called the earnings yield.
- 17:17This is effectively the profit that your $100 share generates
- 17:20for the company in a year. And what's that number?
- 17:23It's roughly 2.9%. Wait.
- 17:25Pause. Hold on, I'm pausing.
- 17:27You are telling me that if I take the safe option with the
- 17:30government I get paid 4%, but if I take the risky option owning A
- 17:35volatile stock that could crash tomorrow, I'm effectively only
- 17:40earning 2.9%? That is exactly what the math is
- 17:43telling you today. That sounds completely backwards
- 17:46in finance. In life, shouldn't I get paid
- 17:49more for taking on more risk? That's the whole concept of a
- 17:52risk premium, right? I should get the 4% + a little
- 17:54extra for the stress and uncertainty.
- 17:57Bingo. That is the fundamental rule of
- 17:59investing. You demand a premium for taking
- 18:01on risk. But right now with Apple stock,
- 18:03the premium is negative. You are effectively paying for
- 18:06the privilege of taking on risk. Why on earth would anyone do
- 18:09that? That sounds like charity, not
- 18:10investing. Because the narrative, because
- 18:12of the story we just discussed, the market is betting that the
- 18:152.9% won't stay 2.9%. They believe the AI super cycle
- 18:20is going to blow the earnings up so fast that in three years your
- 18:23yield will be 10%. So they're paying today for
- 18:25growth that hasn't happened. Yet they're paying today for a
- 18:27decade of spectacular growth. The market is pricing Apple as
- 18:32if it's going to grow its earnings at 15 to 18% annually
- 18:35for the next 10 years. It's priced for perfection.
- 18:37Exactly. At $258 a share, the price
- 18:40assumes that absolutely nothing goes wrong.
- 18:43It assumes the AI super cycle accelerates, services keep
- 18:45booming, China behaves, and no regulators get in the way.
- 18:49But the reality check is that even in this record-breaking
- 18:52quarter, revenue grew 16%. That's amazing.
- 18:57But sustaining 15 to 18% for a decade?
- 18:59For a company with a $400 billion revenue base?
- 19:03That is statistically, historically incredibly
- 19:06difficult. And if they slip?
- 19:07If they slip, if they grow at only 10% instead of 15%, which
- 19:11is still great gross for a company that size, the stock
- 19:13could plummet because that premium you paid evaporates
- 19:16instantly. It feels like standing on a very
- 19:19high ledge. The view is fantastic, but a
- 19:22gust of wind could be a real problem.
- 19:24If you're walking on the sidewalk and you trip, you
- 19:26scrape your knee. If you're walking a tightrope 35
- 19:29floors up and you trip. The outcome is very, very
- 19:32different. That is the risk today, and the
- 19:34leads us to another paradox, the capital allocation paradox.
- 19:38Yes, we have to talk about the buybacks because I want to push
- 19:41back on the negativity for a second.
- 19:43We're ignoring the elephant in the room.
- 19:45Which is. Apple is practically a machine
- 19:47that eats its own shares. They have a $110 billion buyback
- 19:51authorization. In Q12026 alone, they returned
- 19:55$32 billion to shareholders through buybacks and dividends.
- 19:59It is a staggering amount of capital being returned.
- 20:01And as a shareholder, I love this rate.
- 20:03They're constantly buying their own stock in the open market,
- 20:05which reduces the total number of shares.
- 20:07That means my slice of the pizza gets bigger without me spending
- 20:10a dime. How can you possibly spin that
- 20:12as a negative? I'm not spinning it, I'm just
- 20:14doing the math. You're right, your slice of the
- 20:17pizza does get bigger, but the crucial question is how much did
- 20:20the company pay for that extra slice for you?
- 20:22They paid the market price. Exactly.
- 20:24They paid $258 a share. Let me give you that pizza shop
- 20:27analogy. Imagine you and I own a pizza
- 20:29shop together 5050. The shop is worth $1 million
- 20:33objectively based on its cash flow.
- 20:35OK, we're pizza moguls. I like it.
- 20:37Now I want to retire and leave the business.
- 20:40You decide to use the company's cash from the register to buy
- 20:43out my half of the business. But instead of paying me my fair
- 20:46share $500,000, you get caught up in the hype about our new
- 20:50pepperoni and you pay me double what my share is worth.
- 20:53You pay me $1,000,000 for my half.
- 20:55Well, that's great for you. You walk away rich.
- 20:57I'm thrilled, but what about you?
- 20:59You still own the shop now 100% of it, but you just drain the
- 21:03cash register to massively overpay for my exit.
- 21:06The business itself is now poorer because you spend a
- 21:09dollar to buy $0.50 worth of value.
- 21:11I see exactly where you're going.
- 21:12You're saying Apple is the one draining the cash register to
- 21:16buy shares at an inflated price at 2:00?
- 21:18$158 a share. Yes, this is the capital
- 21:21allocation paradox. When a stock is cheap, buybacks
- 21:24are magic. They are incredibly accretive
- 21:27and create wealth for the remaining shareholders.
- 21:29But when a stock is expensive, buybacks are a firm of value
- 21:33destruction. They are incinerating cash that
- 21:35could have been used for a special dividend or a big
- 21:38acquisition or more R&D just to prop up a stock price that is
- 21:42already historically high. So you're saying Tim Cook is
- 21:44buying high? I'm saying the math suggests he
- 21:47is buying high. It creates a floor for the stock
- 21:50price in the short term, sure, because there's this massive
- 21:52constant buyer in the market every single day.
- 21:55But in the long term, it is not compounding wealth as
- 21:58efficiently as it could be. It's a defensive move, not an
- 22:01offensive one. And this might explain the next
- 22:03big signal we have to discuss the Buffett signal.
- 22:05This is the real elephant in the room.
- 22:07Warren Buffett, through Berkshire Hathaway, has been the
- 22:10biggest cheerleader for Apple for years.
- 22:12It was his biggest holding by a country mile.
- 22:15He called it the best business he knows in the world.
- 22:17He did. He loved it.
- 22:18But throughout 2024 and 2025, he has been selling and not just
- 22:23nibbling at the edges, aggressively selling.
- 22:26He has sold hundreds of millions of shares, trillions of dollars
- 22:30worth. He hasn't exited the position
- 22:32completely, but he has trimmed it significantly.
- 22:34He basically cut it in half and then cut it again.
- 22:37And you have to ask yourself why.
- 22:39Is he losing faith in the business?
- 22:41Does he think the iPhone is done or the AI thing is a bust?
- 22:43I don't think so for a second. I think Buffett still loves the
- 22:45business. He loves the Moat, the
- 22:47ecosystem, the brand. But Buffett is disciplined on
- 22:50price. He's a value guy at his core.
- 22:52Remember his cost basis? The average price he bought in
- 22:55at was around 35 to $40 a share. And he's been selling
- 22:58AT18020230. He is locking in a gargantuan
- 23:02win, a life changing amount of money even for him, but more
- 23:06importantly, it signals to us that for him, the margin of
- 23:09safety is gone. Margin of safety, the
- 23:11cornerstone of value investing. Right, Buffett has a famous
- 23:14quote. It's far better to buy a
- 23:16wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a
- 23:19wonderful price. For a long time, Apple was that
- 23:23a wonderful company at a fair price.
- 23:24Now it's a wonderful company at a wonderful meeting.
- 23:28Very, very expensive price. The odds are no longer heavily
- 23:31in his favor. Let's run Apple through the Deep
- 23:33Value Investing Standards checklist.
- 23:35You know, the stuff Ben Graham, Buffett's mentor, would look at.
- 23:38Let's be ruthless here. OK, let's do it.
- 23:40First evaluation is the PE under 15.
- 23:43No, it's 33. Big fail.
- 23:46Is the price to book ratio under 1.5?
- 23:49It's 58. A massive, massive fail.
- 23:52That means the stock price is 58 times the value of their actual
- 23:55tangible assets like buildings and inventory.
- 23:58Chance generation. Pass exemplary A+ plus they
- 24:01print money. Balance sheet.
- 24:02Strength. Fake.
- 24:02They have net cash or they're very close to it.
- 24:04They are financially bulletproof.
- 24:06They could survive a decade long depression.
- 24:08So the verdict from a strict old school value perspective?
- 24:11It's a high quality growth compounder, one of the best
- 24:14ever, but it is absolutely 100% not a value stock right now.
- 24:19Correct. It fails the value test.
- 24:21And when you own a growth stock that is priced for perfection,
- 24:24you have to worry about risks. You have to constantly ask what
- 24:27could derail this 15% growth assumption the market is making?
- 24:30So let's look at the headwinds, the things that could pop this
- 24:33beautifully inflated balloon. The first one is always
- 24:36geopolitics, and specifically China.
- 24:39We can't ignore this. It's the sort of Damocles that
- 24:42just hangs over this stock perpetually.
- 24:44Greater China accounts for about 19% of Apple's total revenue.
- 24:49That is a huge customer base. 19 percent is a big chunk.
- 24:52It is, but even more critical than the customer is the supply
- 24:55chain, where the 90% of their manufacturing and assembly still
- 24:59ties back to that region. We've seen them trying to move
- 25:01more production to India and Vietnam though.
- 25:03I see made in India on some iPhones now.
- 25:06Yes, but it's slow going. It takes decades to build the
- 25:09kind of ecosystem and infrastructure they built in.
- 25:11China is a massive ship to turn. The big risk here is what people
- 25:16call decoupling. We get into a serious trade war.
- 25:20Or if tariffs ramp up again, or, God forbid, there's a
- 25:22geopolitical crisis in the Taiwan Strait, those supply
- 25:25lines could be severely disrupted or even severed.
- 25:28And it's not just about making the phones, it's also about
- 25:30selling them there. Exactly.
- 25:32A rise in Chinese nationalism could lead consumers there to
- 25:35switch to domestic brands like Huawei.
- 25:37We've already seen hints of that.
- 25:38The Chinese government banning iPhones for state workers, for
- 25:41example. If Apple loses China both as its
- 25:44factory and as a major customer, the growth story breaks
- 25:47instantly. OK, that's a big one.
- 25:49Then there is the regulatory siege.
- 25:51We mentioned the golden handcuffs earlier.
- 25:53Well, the governments of the world are coming with bolt
- 25:56cutters to pick those locks. They are.
- 25:57The EU is leading the charge with its Digital Markets Act,
- 26:01the DMA and the US Department of Justice is right behind them.
- 26:04They are directly attacking the walled garden.
- 26:07They want to force Apple to allow side loading, which is
- 26:10just a fancy word for letting you install apps without going
- 26:13through Apple's App Store. And if that happens, Apple loses
- 26:15that 30% cut they take on every transaction the Apple tax.
- 26:19Exactly, that is a direct threat to the high margin services
- 26:22revenue. We were just praising if Netflix
- 26:25or Spotify or Epic Games can tell their customers to download
- 26:29their app directly from their website and bypass Apple's
- 26:32payment system. That 72% gross margin and
- 26:35services comes under immense pressure.
- 26:37The tollbooth operator suddenly has a giant hole in the fence
- 26:40where people can just walk through for free.
- 26:42It's a direct threat to the most profitable part of the business.
- 26:45The single biggest threat, I'd argue, and the third risk, is
- 26:48something more existential. It's the innovation dilemma, or
- 26:51what some people call the law of large numbers.
- 26:54It's just simple math. To grow a company that already
- 26:57have a $400 billion revenue base by just 10%, you need to find
- 27:01$40 billion in new revenue. 40 billion.
- 27:03That is the entire size of a Fortune 100 company.
- 27:06Precisely. You have to basically invent a
- 27:08company the size of Coca-Cola out of thin air every single
- 27:12year just to keep growing at a decent clip.
- 27:14Is the Vision Pro going to be that the headset?
- 27:16It seems like their next big bet.
- 27:18It's incredibly impressive technology, but is it a mass
- 27:21market product like the iPhone was?
- 27:23Not yet. It's still very niche, very
- 27:25expensive. Are autonomous systems the Apple
- 27:28car going to be the answer? Maybe.
- 27:30But the bar is set so incredibly high that even a great success
- 27:34might not move the needle enough to justify the current
- 27:36valuation. When you were this big, gravity
- 27:39just pulls so much. Harder.
- 27:40OK, we've looked at the record-breaking numbers.
- 27:42We've admired the incredible Moat and the sticky, sticky
- 27:45ecosystem. We have stared into the abyss of
- 27:47the valuation and the yield gap. We have listed the very real
- 27:50risks. It is time for the verdict.
- 27:52This is the hard part. This is where feelings can get
- 27:55hurt. The research team has crunched
- 27:57the data, run the models and debated this for hours.
- 28:00The question is, do we buy, sell or hold Apple at today's price
- 28:04of roughly $258 per share? The deep value intelligent
- 28:07conclusion is sell, avoid, sell. Wow, that is a bold call for the
- 28:12biggest, most beloved company in the world.
- 28:15People love this stock. It feels safe.
- 28:17It's a discipline call. And look, let's be very clear
- 28:19about what we're not saying. We aren't saying Apple is going
- 28:22to zero. We aren't saying the business is
- 28:24crumbling. We are not saying Tim Cook is
- 28:26doing a bad job. You're just saying the stock is
- 28:28too expensive. We are saying that as an
- 28:30investment right now at this specific price point, it offers
- 28:33a poor risk to reward ratio. You are taking on a lot of risk
- 28:37for potential, essentially very little reward.
- 28:39Walk us through the rationale one more time.
- 28:41Summarize the case for the prosecution.
- 28:43OK. 10 Margin of safety. The PEG ratio, which is price to
- 28:47earnings growth, is over 3. You typically want that to be
- 28:50near 1. You're paying a triple premium
- 28:52for future growth. So you're paying too much for
- 28:54the story. Way too much 2 the yield gap.
- 28:57It's just bad math. You're taking on equity risk for
- 29:00a 2.9% earnings yield when you can sit in risk free treasuries
- 29:03for 4%. That is just bad asset
- 29:05allocation. It's inefficient.
- 29:07You're not being compensated for the risk.
- 29:09Not at all. And three, the risks we just
- 29:12talked about China regulation are non zero, but the price
- 29:15assumes they are 0. It assumes a perfectly smooth
- 29:18ride ahead. So we believe it's better to buy
- 29:21a wonderful company at a fair price and right now the price is
- 29:24not fair, it's full bordering on euphoric.
- 29:26So if we sell now or avoid buying, we are sitting on cash.
- 29:30When do we get back in? Because I know people want to
- 29:32own this company. I want to own this company.
- 29:34It feels good to own it. Of course, it's a company you
- 29:36absolutely want to own eventually.
- 29:38It belongs in a long term portfolio.
- 29:40But patience is the most expensive and rare currency on
- 29:43Wall Street. The research team has set a
- 29:45specific re entry target. We are watching for a pullback
- 29:48to the 175 to $185 range. That's a significant drop from
- 29:53here. That's like a 30% correction.
- 29:55It is. It sounds drastic, and maybe it
- 29:58won't happen, but that price range would bring the PE ratio
- 30:02back to roughly 25 times, which is its historical average.
- 30:06That is what Buffett would call the fat pitch.
- 30:09Investing is a game of patience. You don't have to swing at every
- 30:12pitch. You can wait for the one that is
- 30:14right in your sweet spot. So the strategy is take the
- 30:17profit now if you have it, selling into the strength, put
- 30:20that cash into short term treasuries earning a safe 4% and
- 30:24just wait. Exactly.
- 30:26Let the market cool down. Let gravity do its work.
- 30:29Valuation acts as gravity on a stock price.
- 30:31No matter how good the business is, if you overpay, your returns
- 30:34will suffer. We are choosing to wait for
- 30:36gravity to bring the price back to reality.
- 30:39It's a tough pill to swallow when you see all the hype in the
- 30:41green arrows, but discipline is what separates the pros from the
- 30:44gamblers. It's about ignoring the FOMO,
- 30:46the fear of missing. Out precisely.
- 30:48FOMO is the enemy of ROI. Before we wrap up, let's do a
- 30:51quick summary of what we've covered today, just to lock it
- 30:53in. Sounds good, One Apple posted
- 30:57incredible Q 12026 numbers. Revenue of 16%, profit of 19.
- 31:02The business is firing on all cylinders. 2, The iPhone 17 and
- 31:05Apple Intelligence have triggered a real bonafide
- 31:08upgrade super cycle. The hardware is the gatekeeper
- 31:11to AI again. 3 The mote is wider than ever with 2 1/2 billion
- 31:16devices. The ecosystem is incredibly
- 31:19sticky. It's a fortress.
- 31:20BU T4 the valuation is stretched to what looks like a breaking
- 31:24point. A 33 times PE implies a future
- 31:27of pure perfection 5. The yield gap is negative.
- 31:30From a pure risk reward standpoint.
- 31:32You are better off in bonds than holding Apple at this price for
- 31:34the short term. 6 The smart money, like Warren Buffett, is
- 31:37taking chips off the table. They're selling into the
- 31:39strength, not buying into the hype.
- 31:41And therefore 7 our verdict is sell or avoid and wait for a
- 31:44better entry point around that 175 to $185 mark.
- 31:48And as we leave you today, here's a provocative thought to
- 31:50chew on. We often think of Apple as the
- 31:53safe haven of the stock market. When things get scary in the
- 31:56world, people pile into Apple stock because it feels like the
- 31:59safest house on the block. Right, it's the digital version
- 32:01of gold, but. What if the safe haven itself is
- 32:04priced for perfection? What happens if it misses a
- 32:07step? If it stumbles on the next AI
- 32:09feature or it gets hit hard by an EU regulation?
- 32:12What happens to the rest of the market if the anchor starts to
- 32:15drift? Does the whole boat drift with
- 32:17it? That is the scary question,
- 32:19isn't it? If the General of the Army
- 32:20falls, the troops usually scatter.
- 32:22If Apple catches a cold, the S&P 500 might just get pneumonia.
- 32:26A sobering thought to end on. Remember to keep track of these
- 32:29valuations yourself to track total market temperature.
- 32:32Welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett Indicator from
- 32:35Apple App Store. It's a great tool to see if we
- 32:38are in buy territory or sell territory based on historical
- 32:41data. And one last time on the
- 32:42disclaimer. Full Deep Value Research reports
- 32:45can be found in the description links.
- 32:47All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 32:50may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 32:53The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 32:56constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 32:59before making investment decisions.
- 33:01And if you want to listen to our full deep dive about this topic
- 33:04or access more advanced contents, welcome to join Deep
- 33:07Value Club members.