Latest / Bill & Ashley's Terror Theater / The VVitch
Transcript
- 0:28Welcome to another terrifying episode of Bill and Ashley's Terror Theater on the Marquee.
- 0:36This week is twenty fifteen's The Witch. Join us right after we get back
- 0:41from greasing up our broomsticks and taking a whirl around the woods. All that
- 0:45after these ads we have no control over. Welcome back. I'm Ashley Coffin.
- 0:50Joined us always by my co host and Terror Bill Bria Bill Darling.
- 0:54How are we today? Hello? Ashley? Does that see you book?
- 1:00Before you? Did you ask me about Butter? Because yeah, I like
- 1:04Butter? Yeah it was Butter. Oh. I can't wait to get into
- 1:08it. Later in the show, we will be sharing our genre accompanying recommendations,
- 1:15but first we will have you read from the Necronomicon of Horror. What
- 1:18do you got for us this week in news? Well, in news,
- 1:23I have a couple items from the Necronomicon as well as one of my own.
- 1:27As you may recall, our prior episode was about my sojourn to sun
- 1:33Dance twenty twenty four, and there's one big title that I did not get
- 1:37to talk about because at the time of our recording it, I had not
- 1:40seen it yet. But now I have and I've written a review about it.
- 1:42I'm very excited to talk about it briefly, but before that, I
- 1:46wanted to mention a couple of these news items. One is that are one
- 1:52of our weirdest actors working in Hollywood today, Caleb Landry Jones, who you
- 1:57may remember from Brandon Berg's Anti Viral or of course Get Out or so many
- 2:04other crazy I love him. Yeah, he's a weirdo. The Last Exorcism,
- 2:08right Exorcism. He's apparently going to be taking on the role of Dracula
- 2:15for director Luke Bassan, who made The Fifth Element and m Nikita and a
- 2:20lot of other French genre movies. Very ginger apparent Dracula. Yeah, apparently
- 2:25this will be a quote retelling of Bram Stoker's classic Gothic tale, with Landry
- 2:30Jones set to play the Transylvania count turn vampire. No other details beyond that
- 2:36right now. I mean, with nos Faratu coming out, are you serious?
- 2:38You're oh, yeah. I don't think they're going to have this ready
- 2:42for release yet this year, but I assume next year as like a sort
- 2:46of follow up to nos Faratu, trying to maybe ride whatever wave happens there.
- 2:50So we'll see, but he is an interesting actor to play the role.
- 2:53So I wanted to mention that, do you think the story of Dracula
- 2:57is the most retold story of any story? It's like Hamlets, we have
- 3:02like everything always being done over and over again. What is the one character
- 3:07who's just been done? Well, here's my take. I think if you
- 3:10consider Dracula's story or the let's say, like the trappings of Dracula, you
- 3:15know, in terms of the quote unquote rules of vamporism or the way that
- 3:21the character typically acts or operates, even if they're not named Dracula, but
- 3:24you know, another vampire fiction, then I think you could definitely make a
- 3:29case that it would be that huge, you know, in terms of just
- 3:31Dracula, like literally his name is Dracula. It's also based off Bram Stoker,
- 3:36all that stuff. There's probably fewer adaptations you know, in that case,
- 3:38but like it's still a lot. It's still probably in least of the
- 3:44definitely the double digits, maybe close to triple digits, I'm not sure.
- 3:47But Dracula two thousand, that's West Craven, right, Yeah, well no,
- 3:51if he produced by Wes Craven, Yeah, I think his editor made
- 3:53that movie. I'm pretty sure Patrick Lucier or something movie. The other thing
- 4:00I wanted to mention is that, of course our friends at Blumhouse are still
- 4:03churning them out, but there's someone at the helm of one of their new
- 4:09thrillers which is being made right now, called The Woman in the Yard,
- 4:13who I'm excited about because of his horror pedigree. He is the director of
- 4:16the House of Wax remake Orphan and the Shallows. How may colet Sarah?
- 4:21Okay, I like two out of three of those? Yeah, huh,
- 4:25And plot details are under reps. But we're we're we're now. We now
- 4:32know that it has found its star in Danielle dead Weiler, which is a
- 4:36great name, and Colet Sarah and did whether I have actually collaborated before on
- 4:43an upcoming action thriller known as carry On and dead Weiler was in twenty two's
- 4:48Till as well as The Western and The Harder They Fall, and she's gonna
- 4:53appear in I saw The TV Glow, which is the new Jane Schoenbrun movie
- 4:57that premiered at Sundance, which I did not get to see, which I'm
- 4:59so upset about because everybody looked raved about it, So I'm gonna have to
- 5:02wait and see that one with the rest of y'all. But A twenty four
- 5:05is putting that out, so we'll get a chance to see peasants, the
- 5:08rest of us peasants. But yeah, hallmi call it Sara returning to the
- 5:12horror genre. So we're we're already excited. I'm already excited. No idea
- 5:15what the plot's going to be. It's just a woman in the yard.
- 5:19What is It makes me think of that Amy Adams when woman in the window
- 5:24who's wine glass just keeps getting bigger as the movie progresses. Yep, yep.
- 5:30So you know, there's all these women, there are different places.
- 5:31Who knows where they are next. Another thing I wanted to mention this isn't,
- 5:38you know, groundbreaking news. This is really just a poll quote,
- 5:42but it's something that's fun to speculate on, which is that you know,
- 5:46of course, the Oscars are coming up as we record this still uh you
- 5:49know, so the Oscar campaign interviews are still happening. One of the people
- 5:54up for contention, of course, for best director and best you know film
- 5:57and stuff is Christopher Nolan. You know who made up a timer. But
- 6:00somebody did ask him recently if he'd ever like to make a horror movie,
- 6:03and his quote is, I'll quote right now saying I think horror films are
- 6:09very interesting because they depend on very cinematic devices. It really is about a
- 6:13visceral response to things, and so at some point I'd love to make a
- 6:15horror film. But I think a really good horror film requires a really exceptional
- 6:19idea, and those are a few and far between, so I haven't found
- 6:21a story that lends itself to that. So interesting. He's being very diplomatic
- 6:26and just sort of giving, you know, a kind of generic answer,
- 6:29but I do think it's interesting because obviously, at to this point in his
- 6:32career, he's made several sci fi films, he's made a couple noirs,
- 6:38he's made obviously superhero films, action films, and you know, historical dramas.
- 6:44So he's you know, made his way through the gamut of a lot
- 6:46of different genres, and so horror is kind of I would say, maybe
- 6:49next on the horizon in terms of like, yeah, I'd really like to
- 6:54see, especially given his penchant for messing around with time and messing around with
- 6:58structure, So if you apply that to a horror genre in terms of not
- 7:02just ambiguity, but also confusion and the fear of the unknown, and you
- 7:06know what's going to happen next, I think there's a lot of potential there
- 7:09for his kind of his kind of vibe to work with the genre. So
- 7:13hopefully fingers crossed and in terms of different takes on the horror genre, that
- 7:17this is the movie that I saw at sun Dance, which is going to
- 7:20be coming to Shutter, So we are all going to get a chance to
- 7:24say. I believe they have it as an exclusive, but it is its
- 7:30own unique take on a very tried and true subgenre of horror. It's called
- 7:34In a Violent Nature, and it's written and directed by a man named Chris
- 7:41Nash, and this is his first feature length. He's did a lot of
- 7:45short films before this, but he also was a creature effects supervisor on twenty
- 7:50twenties Psycho Gorman. If you saw that movie. So this movie has delivers
- 7:57the goods in a gore for sure, because what it is is you're gonna
- 8:03so let me start over. You're gonna see this movie described by a lot
- 8:07of critics, people have already published their reviews as being told from the perspective
- 8:13of a slasher killer. That's not entirely true, because remember, if you
- 8:20recall, if you listen to our last episode on Sundance, I talked about
- 8:22Steven Soderbergh's Presence, in which that movie is literally told from the point of
- 8:28view of the ghost in that movie in a violent nature does not give you
- 8:33any It doesn't even do the Halloween thing of like the for opening sequence,
- 8:35you know, as a POV of Michael Myers sort of stuff, never does
- 8:39that. You're always seeing the character in the frame somewhere, you know.
- 8:43But what it does do is it is following that character for the bulk of
- 8:46the movie. So whereas in a regular slasher you would be following the final
- 8:50girl or the group of friends going out to the cabin in the woods,
- 8:56you're only seeing them in the periphery. You're only catching snippets of things dialogue
- 9:01if and when the slasher happens to be near them, you know, which
- 9:05is a really cool kind of retelling of the typical slasher story of like you
- 9:09don't even need all of the backstory of like who these kids are, why
- 9:13they're at the cabin, nobody cares. Yeah, who's who's doing what to
- 9:16who, and who's dating who and all that stuff. But it's really neat
- 9:18that you can get a little snippets of that and and be totally fueled for
- 9:22what happens next. And there's no score to this movie, so there's no
- 9:26music that it's just the sounds of the forest, which is really very Blair,
- 9:33very blair witch and very surprisingly sort of melancholy. So while this is
- 9:37again not told from the perspective of the slasher, it sort of gives you
- 9:41a feeling of like what it might be like to be someone like that,
- 9:46like a Jason Vorhees, where it's like, somebody stole my mom's necklace again,
- 9:50I gotta get mcgrave and go do some killing to get it back,
- 9:54you know, all all the day's work. So yeah, it's a really
- 10:01special and both kind of emotionally investing but also eerie, genuinely eerie movie.
- 10:09So definitely check it out when it comes to Shutter. I don't think there's
- 10:11a date yet that they're premiering it. I'll look it up really quick.
- 10:15But I do know what you're talking about, because I did see that written
- 10:18about as horror movie from the perspective of the Killer. Yep. So,
- 10:22And I think that's because it makes a very attractive log line. You know,
- 10:26it gets people interested, and you know, it gives them. But
- 10:30I do think it's actually something I want to push back against because it gives
- 10:33you a false sense of expectation, you know, because then you're expecting an
- 10:39entire movie the Killer, like you know, like you would be doing the
- 10:43opening sequence for Halloween, but the whole movie, and that's not what this
- 10:46is. And in fact, not only is it not what it is,
- 10:48but it never does that at any point, you know. So do the
- 10:50cuts change from like Killer's perspective to all around perspective or it's yeah, I
- 10:56mean the cameras are like a normal movie. It's just no, it's just
- 11:01like you know, sometimes you might the camera might be just on his back.
- 11:05Sometimes you might see him in the distance. Sometimes that's what I want.
- 11:09So yeah, so it's it's it's very much you know, it's shot
- 11:13in a way that I think is actually very similar to the way Eggers,
- 11:16Robert Eggers shows this stuff, especially in The Witch. But uh, you
- 11:22know, it's it's something where like he is kind of hiding, uh,
- 11:26you don't see the killer full on all the time. You know, there's
- 11:28there's a lot of focus here and there in terms of what his face looks
- 11:31like and all that. So yeah, there's there's a lot of intriguing elements
- 11:37to this, but it's something I don't want to give too much away.
- 11:41So you know, it's something I think you want to experience for yourself.
- 11:43But just go into it not expecting, you know, a POV movie.
- 11:48It's not a POV movie. Okay, that's good. That's good because that's
- 11:52so different. Yeah, it's really different, but in a way that's it's
- 11:56not it's experimental in a way that's really I think the best version of experimental,
- 12:03in the sense that it doesn't throw the baby out with a bathwater where
- 12:07it's like we're doing a slasher differently and like none of it's fun, you
- 12:11know sort of thing like like it's super fun as a slasher by itself,
- 12:13you know, so it's still it still remains part of that subgenre. It's
- 12:18not like, you know, oh, what if we did a slasher but
- 12:22it was you know, in black and white and everyone spoke Swedish and people,
- 12:31you know, it was animated, like you know, it doesn't take
- 12:33things so far away from the genre that like it doesn't look recognizable anymore.
- 12:35Like it definitely is recognizable. It's a classic black backwoods slasher, you know.
- 12:41Nice. Yeah, I'm excited. I'm excited. Yeah. So it
- 12:43should be coming the later this year. Keep cranking the mouse shutter and now
- 12:48it is time for our feature film. All right. Well, you know
- 12:56I've been chomping at the bit literally to talk about this movie for the past
- 13:01couple of months. It is a just tour de force first movie for Robert
- 13:07Eggers. It's still my favorite of his, which we could probably get into
- 13:13a little later, but I do like I just this so which horror films
- 13:18are some of my favorites. I mean all the way from wanting to be
- 13:22the Wicked Witch more than Drothy because I liked her outfit better, uh,
- 13:26to Teen Witch? Do you remember Teenwitch? Oh? Yeah, that was
- 13:28like when it's showing us a different take on like the good Witch to the
- 13:31witches and disliking children, and there was you know, there's just a lot
- 13:35about witch films that really spoke to me. You know, they're black,
- 13:41flowing chiffon outfits, their fierce hats, flying cats. I mean, what's
- 13:46really not to like, you know, representation of the oldest villains of folklore
- 13:50are witches. It goes all the way back, you know, you have
- 13:52your evil Crone. I don't know, it's just there's just something that has
- 13:56always fascinated and terror every kind of civilization, you know, and it's the
- 14:03witch. M h. And I think what's really cool about this movie.
- 14:07There's so much, I mean, there's so much to talk about, there's
- 14:09so much to shout out, there's so much to theorize over. But I
- 14:15think at its core, what this movie gets at is something that is quintessentially
- 14:20American in a way that if you remember when Hatchet was released, the first
- 14:24Hatchet, I think it had a tagline or it's like old school American horror,
- 14:28you know. And I get that tagline because it was it was at
- 14:33a time when you know, the so called torture porn movement was big,
- 14:35and a lot of other sort of indie films were coming up, and you
- 14:41know, the classic quote unquote slasher movie had been out of style for a
- 14:43few years, so it was hearkening back to that. But I always thought
- 14:46of that tagline whenever I thought of the horror film, especially the American horror
- 14:52film, because you know, American culture, as we know, you know,
- 14:56from being Americans and living in this country and growing up in this country,
- 15:00it is a melting pot. It's a hodgepodge. You know. We
- 15:03have all these different sources that are just kind of thrown into this big cauldron
- 15:07to use the witch metaphor and sort of keep bubbled around. Right. And
- 15:11oh and I think that you know, so much of of folklore, of
- 15:18myth of urban legend even you know, comes from different sources. I would
- 15:22say it's either you know, a witchcraft and you know, the fear of
- 15:28a witch as a sort of mythological figure and the urban legend that are the
- 15:31most quintessential American forms of folklore of horror stories, because you know, when
- 15:37you're talking about vamporism, you know that has deep roots in Europe. Even
- 15:41werewolves deep roots in Europe. You know, so many different other mythological creatures
- 15:46have these very European roots. And while the witch certainly does have European roots,
- 15:52the form of it that it's become popularized, you know, over the
- 15:54last century, if not longer, definitely stems from the of this country.
- 16:00And I think what Eggers is the Witch does so well is it points out
- 16:04how that functions as a quintessential American fear in the sense of if we are
- 16:15a pioneer country, you know, if we are a country that still is
- 16:18quote unquote new, and we're trying to carve our own path and you know,
- 16:22tame the wilds to our own you know, interests. You know,
- 16:26the Witch represents all that is scary about that endeavor, where it's like,
- 16:30you know what if we're wrong, What if we're making all of the bad
- 16:34choices and not you know, good ones that we are so prideful and pious
- 16:38about. You know what if you know what if the better way to go
- 16:42about forging a new path is to embrace the darkness as opposed to fight it.
- 16:48You know. So it's like there's all these interesting elements where even though
- 16:52The Witch obviously was a twenty fifteen movie and it comes on the heels of
- 16:56so much you know, in horror cinema, in a strange way, it
- 17:00feels almost like an origin point, if that makes sense, you know,
- 17:04where you could make an argument that, like if The Witch was based on
- 17:10a real story, which it's not, but then again, there's definitely like
- 17:14real elements in there that Eggers was working with, that he was pulling from
- 17:17sources of of of old. You know, you could make a case that
- 17:22this is an origin point. And what's cool is that The Witch, the
- 17:25actual movie, The Witch, is an origin point for the wave of horror
- 17:30that we're still undergoing right now in terms of quote unquote elevated horror. So
- 17:33yeah, I think it's a It's a core movie in a lot of ways,
- 17:36if that makes sense. Yeah, I mean, I think this took
- 17:38everything that I love about folklore, stories, witches, and history and rolled
- 17:44it up into one really atmospheric experience. Because I have seen people complain about
- 17:49saying, you know, oh, this movie's boring and nothing happens, and
- 17:52it's like, well, sure, maybe kind of, But if you're not
- 17:56paying attention to everything else that's happening around the main story, then you're missing
- 18:00out on what is actually happening. And it's really cool seeing some veteran like
- 18:06horror lovers saying it's one of the greatest movies they have ever seen, and
- 18:10it being somebody's first format at the gate, like Scott Derrickson said, he
- 18:12felt contaminated by the by evil after the movie, and it does it like
- 18:18I remember the first time I saw this, I was just blown away and
- 18:21I couldn't stop talking about it. It's the score, it's the the way
- 18:25they filmed at the atmosphere, everything, the performances above everything. Because I
- 18:30don't know, you didn't watch Game of Thrones. No, the main the
- 18:34father and mother of this story are both two different characters in Game of Thrones,
- 18:41and neither of them are particularly important. You're talking to k Yeah,
- 18:48neither of them are particularly important to the story, like memorable characters, but
- 18:52their acting and performances make you remember them, and they stood out like the
- 18:57Ralph I think was only in a couple episodes in one season, and maybe
- 19:02the same with Kate and you just their acting was so strong that you remember
- 19:06it because I remember when this movie came like, oh, it's that guy.
- 19:08I love his voice. His voice is so awesome and I'm so glad
- 19:12he's in this thing, and then just being completely blown away by everything I
- 19:18was seeing on screen, and when you got you know, Witchcraft, I've
- 19:22always really been into that. I remember learning about it in school and I
- 19:26obsessed over everything about the Salem witch trials. I've been to Salem several times.
- 19:32I wouldn't say I'm an expert, but I would go pretty close.
- 19:36But which is our product of cultural anxiety when it comes to women's aging is
- 19:41terrifying. You know, our bodies, you know, for the most part,
- 19:44depending on what you do, can be your primary form of currency.
- 19:47Like if everything goes out, you know, to the wayside, you're like,
- 19:49well, at least I could you know, dance or do something else.
- 19:52But as you start to get older, you lose value. And that's
- 19:55what we've been taught throughout our whole lives is as you age, you lose
- 19:59value. The one way that women are contained in society is because we are
- 20:03expected to focus on being appealing. And that is why the idea of the
- 20:07crone is so terrifying, because she has no interest in that, and you
- 20:11can't you know, trap or trick her because everything that you were, you
- 20:17know, pushing on her is not a problem to her. And then men
- 20:19in society wouldn't really know how to deal with that. And in colonial America,
- 20:25which would look exactly like Thomlinson, just that innocent, beautiful, the
- 20:29more beautiful you were, or the more ugly you were. It didn't work
- 20:33in your favor because of where all the witchcraft hysteria came from. Is jealousy
- 20:37or whatever. We'll get into it a little later, but yeah, it
- 20:41is. It's just a crazy time in history, and it sucks to being
- 20:44a woman when it was coming for this stuff, especially, you know.
- 20:48Yeah, and even just because I know this has been a topic recently that
- 20:52I've seen discussed on social media, the idea of old flesh of the old
- 20:57age as horror creature, horror visual which, as you say, ashes mostly
- 21:07for the most part gendered. It's usually you know, old women over older
- 21:11men. But nevertheless, there's definitely been old men, you know, in
- 21:15horror stories and horror films a lot too. And I think that if you
- 21:18remove the gender from it, which you shouldn't for the witch character, but
- 21:22just you know, speaking about old age as a horror trope in general,
- 21:26and of course is a metaphysical or metaphor for death, you know, which
- 21:32is this visual representation of the end of all of our lives that we know
- 21:36is coming intellectually but not emotionally. You know, none of us believe emotionally
- 21:40that we're going to reach that point, you know, because it's like,
- 21:42oh, that's tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow and far beyond those tomorrows, you
- 21:47know, and certain enough tomorrow is here, and then you look like that,
- 21:49and that means death is right around the corner. You know, you're
- 21:52you're about to die. So that's I think where you know, the primal
- 21:56aspect of old age as horror comes from. And then when you add the
- 22:02gender element to it, that's when you get, you know, more of
- 22:03the witch character of the fact that it's you know, if it's if it's
- 22:08bad enough to be dying as a human being person, you know, full
- 22:11stop, it's much worse to be a woman that that's that old because oh,
- 22:15you're not even hot anymore. You're not even useful as a bearer of
- 22:19children, you're not useful as a protector, you're not using all that stuff,
- 22:22you know, right, So I think that obviously that's where a lot
- 22:27of that comes from. And to your earlier point about how many people revere
- 22:33this movie, which obviously includes us, it should be noted that Eggers himself
- 22:37is not a fan. Where on one of the recent interviews that he gave
- 22:42on the four K release, that second site put out, he calls it,
- 22:45in his view, overrated because he sees a lot of the flaws,
- 22:49you know, as as the creator typically does. Yeah, I was upset
- 22:55by how much he was, like, I don't ever watch this movie.
- 22:56Yeah, but I did like him criticize some of his own shots, and
- 23:00when he criticized them, I go, oh, well, now I'm never
- 23:03going to look at that shot again because you know, it wasn't sweeping enough
- 23:07or whatever so interesting. I get it. It's the same way I don't
- 23:12like to listen when I have to go through with editing with the the podcast
- 23:15and I have to put in the ads, I have to listen to it
- 23:18back, and I'm like, God, what does anybody listen to this shit?
- 23:22Yeah? Yeah, Well, and also I think it's worth putting out
- 23:25because, as I think we've already kind of said, and we're going to
- 23:27say as we continue this, this movie is is so meticulously crafted. It's
- 23:33it's so to the right down to the smallest detail, so well thought out,
- 23:38well planned. And you know, even Eggers's earlier work, which I've
- 23:44only seen a snippet of as one of his short films, Brothers, you
- 23:47know, even right out the Gate, like he had a remarkable degree of
- 23:51control over camera movement, over the placement, over you know, choreography and
- 23:56composition, and you know, some of those things I have to believe were
- 24:02inherent. You know, he wasn't necessarily taught those things. He wasn't necessarily
- 24:06you know, given that from somewhere else. It's like it just comes from
- 24:08him as an artist. And so I think, you know, it's important
- 24:12to point that out just because you know, it's just really telling when you
- 24:18have, you know, even a masterpiece like this, like there's somebody out
- 24:21there and it's usually the person who made it who's like, that's not very
- 24:23good, you know, it's a bunch of crap, you know whatever.
- 24:26Well, it's funny with Brothers because when you watch that, you see the
- 24:30potential and you can see, like the movies, they don't have anything to
- 24:33do with each other. It's just the forest, I would say, is
- 24:38the main character of both of them, and the way he shoots it and
- 24:42makes it feel like it's this living part of the story where when I was
- 24:47watching Brothers, I kept waiting for something else to happen and then was like,
- 24:49oh no, this is just this other side story. But it's filmed
- 24:52so similarly to The Witch that it's easy to think, oh, there's something
- 24:57nefarius in the woods right beyond my site I'm not seeing yet, and that's
- 25:00where the potential comes. And even just in that short film, because just
- 25:04to give you a brief synopsis, because it's really short, it's about these
- 25:07brothers who are, you know, at odds with each other, you know,
- 25:11as brothers sometimes can be. And it's kind of a cane and able
- 25:14story where like, you know, one goes the other into being violent and
- 25:18then violence happens and you know, death ensues. So it is a tragedy
- 25:22and it is brief, and you know, you don't have the full picture
- 25:26of what this family is, why they are the way they are, what
- 25:29even time period it might be. But I think what you were saying Ashes
- 25:34is so key in that short, which is it really proves that Eggers is
- 25:37able to bring a tone to his stuff where there is this mysterious ominousness to
- 25:45the environment, to the characters themselves. Because what's so compelling to me about
- 25:52The Witch is, you know, is I think one of the again I'm
- 25:56going to go back to the word core, but like this is a core
- 25:59movie in the sense that ambiguity is so key to I think the horror genre
- 26:03as a whole, where like because ultimately at the base level of every human
- 26:07being, because different fears for everyone. You know, some people might be
- 26:10afraid of fire, some people might be afraid of bugs, some people might
- 26:12be afraid of snakes, but others might not be at all or much,
- 26:15you know, whereas every single living being is afraid of the unknown because it's
- 26:21the unknown. Like you literally don't know what is this, what it's out
- 26:25there, and what's going to happen. So there's no parameters, and therefore
- 26:29it's confusing or upsetting or you know, compelling, whatever the case may be,
- 26:33you're still affected by it. And I think The Witch taps into that
- 26:37so well, and it taps into ambiguity so well because there are so many
- 26:41readings that people do and can have of what's going on in this movie.
- 26:45Yeah, let me run through a plot, do it? Okay? So
- 26:49in sixteen thirties New England, panic and despair envelops an exiled farmer, his
- 26:56wife, and their children. When the youngest son, Samuel suntenly vanishes,
- 27:00the family blames Thomason, the oldest daughter who was watching the boy at the
- 27:03time of his disappearance. With suspicion and paranoia mounting, twin siblings Mercy and
- 27:08Jonah, suspect Thomason of witchcraft. After the family goat Black, Philip gossips
- 27:12about her to them, testing the family's faith, loyalty, and love to
- 27:18one another. It's hard to get like, it is such a simple plot,
- 27:22but it's hard to kind of put it into like words because it's like,
- 27:26he's not just exiled far, you know, he gets exiled because he
- 27:30is too religious for the extremely religious people, and that is just like,
- 27:37you know, it's even hard, like how do you even go through your
- 27:41life just being like that? And Edgar's talks a little bit about in various
- 27:47interviews in the commentary about how, you know, there was the Massachusetts Bay
- 27:51Colony, which was was it Puritan and separatist? Right, So it's Puritan.
- 27:57So what's the father's name in this? Forgot? Oh William? My
- 28:02name William? So there, yeah, Billy over here is a separatist,
- 28:07right. The rest of them were Puritans, and he was just he was
- 28:10probably torturing everybody in there, like, oh, you're not religious enough,
- 28:14yep, And what's funny is that we we colloquially in twenty twenty four still
- 28:18think of Puritan or the term Puritan as you know, the ultimate version of
- 28:22unfun obnoxious religious person of like, you know, so pious that they don't
- 28:27you know, allow for this or that. And it's funny that like,
- 28:30you know, the Witch presents us with the reality that, oh no,
- 28:33there was someone even more ridiculous than the Puritans, you know, in Yeah.
- 28:37But the way that Edgars puts it in terms of like I think it
- 28:41was Massachusetts Bay that where supposedly they might be at the beginning of this where
- 28:45they were Puritans, and william as you said, as a separatist, and
- 28:49the idea was either you're purifying the Church of England, you know, you're
- 28:53taking the same basic tenets that they created for however many thousands of years,
- 28:57but you know, getting of supposedly the bad stuff and putting in the good
- 29:02stuff, versus separatism, which was okay, throw it all out and start
- 29:07from scratch, you know, and yeah, and Williams's version is unfortunately,
- 29:11you know, starting from scratch for him is like you know, doubling down
- 29:17on the most obnoxious versions of piousness that you can imagine. You know.
- 29:21One of the big elements of this movie is him beating it, not beating
- 29:26literally, but maybe that's happening off screen, beating it to his children.
- 29:30The idea of original sin and you know, this idea that baby Samuel,
- 29:34despite being a literal baby, was born with sin and might be in hell
- 29:38just because that's the way it goes. You know, well that is I
- 29:42So I'm not, as far as I know, I'm not bastized, and
- 29:47I either from that. I'm also from an unwed you know, I'm a
- 29:53bastard, which is pretty funny because you get labeled for that shit. And
- 29:56then people when I was younger would bring it up. I was like,
- 30:00hey, you're mammy Dan, I'm marry if I can masterd you know like
- 30:02that. And it's just crazy because that was when my mom used to make
- 30:04me go to church daycare because it was free. Wow. So I was
- 30:10really exposed to a lot of Catholicism stuff like that. It was weird.
- 30:15It was so weird. It's like, what do you mean, Yeah,
- 30:18so what, Oh, you're going to help because your parents weren't married.
- 30:21What, Yeah, I'm going to send you to hell, Stephanie, you
- 30:25know, and you know, fortunately I don't have religious persecution in in my
- 30:30childhood. I have all sorts of different persecutions to don't worry, but but
- 30:34that one, fortunately I was able to mostly sidestep. However, I was
- 30:38told that my grandfather on my dad's side, because my dad's side of the
- 30:45family has a history of being left handed. I'm left handed as well.
- 30:48Oh you're a which And apparently my grandfather was left handed, but was beaten
- 30:52out of him at school, not at home. At school, they beat
- 30:56his left hand with a ruler so that he couldn't use it anymore and had
- 30:59to force them to use his right hand. Oh go, So well,
- 31:03that's why there's something scarier in the story here than just the religious dogma,
- 31:07because it's the fact that religion can be so intense and it was like almost
- 31:12force of them to see the devil in everyday life. That it's the puritanism
- 31:17that leads to the cause of witchcraft. And you know, again, there
- 31:21were so conservative. They saw witches everywhere back then, like anything that people
- 31:25did, especially with women. And let me say, I have a quote
- 31:30from the uh the malayis Meleficarium ooh, which is the witch's hammer? Is
- 31:37what that is? Also it was written in fourteen eighty six by Heimrich Kramer,
- 31:41and this was like the handbook for finding witches. And let me use
- 31:45this objective and not at all biased quote from him that is in this book,
- 31:52and it says, all wickness is but little to the wickness of women.
- 31:56What else is a woman but a foe to friendship, an unescapable punishment,
- 32:01a necessary evil, a natural temptation, a desirable calamity, domestic danger,
- 32:08and a delectable determent, an evil nature painted with fair colors. Women
- 32:15are by nature instruments of satan. They are by nature carnal and structural,
- 32:22a structural defect rooted in the original creation, like damn Kramer, like who
- 32:27broke your heart? Like really? And in Europe over fifty thousand people were
- 32:31killed, like we did it a little bit differently over here. But that
- 32:35is from the book that was written about finding like which is like what is
- 32:40going on here? And I love that this movie has little parts of that,
- 32:45Like when Caleb is in his fit, his hysterical fit, and they
- 32:50pry his mouth open, what comes out of his mouth is an apple original
- 32:53sin blame it back on the women. You know, it's just us.
- 32:57We're just over here being desireable calamities. Yeah, the more you obviously look
- 33:04at history, the more you realize that patriarchy was an intention. You know,
- 33:09it was not something that the patriarchy tries to sell you on, which
- 33:15is that it was some sort of you know, based in I don't know,
- 33:19natural selection, biology, whatever nonsense they'll try and feed you. You
- 33:22know. No, patriarchy was definitely a movement, you know, whether it
- 33:27was whether it was you know, I'm not saying it was necessarily like a
- 33:30shadow government type of idea where like a bunch of influential dudes got together and
- 33:34decided, you know, amongst themselves. But you found out it wasn't about
- 33:37horses. You really weren't interested anymore, right, right, right, right,
- 33:39No. But also it was because I'm just kidding, but yeah,
- 33:44that it was just the fact that like, clearly from the earliest days of
- 33:51I was about to say mankind, right, uh oh, from the earliest
- 33:53days of humanity, men were threatened by the way that women made them feel.
- 34:01You know. That's why the story is the like it's a great example
- 34:06of it, because the family starts to suspect thomasin because she's becoming hot.
- 34:08I mean that's the best way, Like she's starting to become a womanhood and
- 34:14especially the mom, right and of all people. Yeah, and she's on
- 34:19her face the way you made your brother look at your tits, you little
- 34:22horror. I was like, I don't care how in old English you said
- 34:24that. I know exactly what you said. Yeah, but even just starting
- 34:30with the little freakin' you know, where's my cup thomasin Where's my cup?
- 34:32You know, which I never noticed until I saw the four K version that
- 34:36you can see the silver cups that scene this movie shop perfectly. Oh my
- 34:40god. But still talking about the like, you know, the theological stuff
- 34:46before we get into the movie stuff, because it is like, he really
- 34:49does make such a good story because you can't exactly pinpoint the bad guy from
- 34:54my perspective, right, And I think it again, what I was saying
- 34:59about ambiguity. Know what I'm saying about there's so many reads on this is
- 35:01because this movie does change how you feel about it depending on how which way
- 35:07you want to read it, whether the witch the titular which not just who
- 35:12that might be, because there are multiple options, But what that might represent,
- 35:15which is is? Is the Witch? You know, this thing to
- 35:20be genuinely feared in terms of like this is an abomination against you know,
- 35:24God and nature and life. You know, like it's it's the ultimate evil.
- 35:28Therefore, you know, any surrender to it would be a you know,
- 35:31a failure or a loss. Or is it because you're living in a
- 35:36society that's so oppressive, that's so patriarchal, that's so condemning, that it
- 35:43is a symbol of true freedom, you know, whether that freedom is quote
- 35:47unquote moral or pious or not. You know, is the witch something aspirational
- 35:52even? You know, oh yeah, like right, well that's like earlier
- 35:57when I was saying, like, which is are one of the few ancient
- 35:59monsters that are here in every human culture on the globe as a bride product
- 36:01of our own ability to recognize like evil in everything but ourselves. And so
- 36:08by doing so, you create an evil because it's not you, it's everything
- 36:12else around you. And the real witch is you know, in the movie
- 36:15is Being? Is it being less more than an idea? I guess,
- 36:20like it can spread like a virus, and the idea of the witch can
- 36:23destroy everything because she just has to plan her little seeds. Yeah, and
- 36:28it's not them looking in to be like, oh, I'm I'm being horrible.
- 36:31My little kids are terrible, and everybody's just being horrible and nobody's you
- 36:36know, doing anything about it. We're just blaming this outside force, which
- 36:39is easier to do that, this unseen demon is causing all the problems.
- 36:43It's not because I'm a bad mom, right, No, right, And
- 36:45that's what destroys people. What's funny is that, you know, we've obviously
- 36:51become more enlightened since those times, and yes, and yet not because obviously
- 36:57there's still people in this world living today, working today, warshiping today,
- 37:00who still believe in a lot of what's being believed in in this movie.
- 37:04Not all, but a lot of it. And what you just said ash
- 37:07in terms of the idea of a scapegoat hah goat, and I think that's
- 37:14intentional is so prevalent in humanity, It's so prevalent in human culture, and
- 37:20it still exists to this day. And the real bake your noodle thing for
- 37:23me is, you know, the idea of the witch as this catch all
- 37:29scapegoat, as this person you just throw all your problems onto It's like,
- 37:31where'd the baby go? The witch? Why is the cornon you know,
- 37:35growing? The witch? Why Why does my brother want to fuck me?
- 37:38The witch? You know? Right, So it's it's all that's like that
- 37:43stuff out there, that's the witch, and that's the evil, and you
- 37:45know, it has a source and it has a thing you can throw at
- 37:50where it's like, Okay, I can point to that and that's the problem.
- 37:52Nowadays, we can point to more actual problems that we know do exist
- 37:58in terms of patriarchy, in terms of capitalism, in terms of you know,
- 38:01the one percenters, all that, and yet they still function as the
- 38:07witch for us today. Yeah, it's like, even if you're correct in
- 38:10saying that's so much of bad in the world today is because of patriarchy,
- 38:15are so much as bad because of capitalism. You can't defeat it as much
- 38:20as you can't defeat the witch, you know. Yeah. So well,
- 38:22it's like it's like innocence being pushed so far they commit evil acts to survive,
- 38:27and then they're being branded and labeled like we have this good like Thompson
- 38:30is a good person. Throughout the movie, she has one scene where she's
- 38:34like Abby the witch of the woods. But that was only after her sister
- 38:37said it, yep. And you know she only wants to do good,
- 38:40and she only wants to do it's right. And that, you know,
- 38:44idea of being so innocent and being taken over by evil like that I am
- 38:47no witch is one of the scariest things at that time you could say,
- 38:52as a woman being accused of witchcraft in the sixteen hundreds was no joke,
- 38:57like and you know nothing than that. And you know this is what religion
- 39:01and religious hysteria and religious persecution and repression inevitably does is you know, it
- 39:09could tear you apart, and it tears societies apart, and it's finger pointing
- 39:14and people die. It's it was crazy, Yeah. And the idea of
- 39:19you know, rampant labeling, yeah, without cause, just as a catch
- 39:24all of we in the culture know what is the abhorrent element, and we
- 39:30need to label you that imhorrant element as a way to not just harm you
- 39:34for personal reasons, but to try and exclude you or try and banish you.
- 39:38That still happens today in so many ways. You know, it's not
- 39:42called which anymore, but it's called several different things, cancel culture, what
- 39:46else is that's right? You know? Well, that's why I don't think
- 39:51the joining you know, the Satan worshiping group of whiches is necessarily a good
- 39:54thing. But the fact is that it is preferable to the situation that she
- 40:00is living in in the patriarchal society that was, you know, a much
- 40:04more powerful damnation, you know, going on, like, what's better living
- 40:08in this thing where people are always going to tell me what to do and
- 40:10treat me terribly and you know, always make me shut my mouth? Or
- 40:15do I want to sign this book? Have powers and eat butter? Are
- 40:21you kidding me? Yeah? What are you gonna pick? Like that is
- 40:24in this situation, joining the Satan worshiping group, of which is is the
- 40:28better you know ending to the story, Which is why I don't think that
- 40:30this movie has It's not a bad like a sad or a bad ending.
- 40:36I don't know. I'm kind of on the side with it. It's ambiguity.
- 40:38She found her people, Yeah, it's it's ambiguity. It's most beautiful,
- 40:42which is the fact that it is a cycle of tones of uh,
- 40:47of reads of uh. You know, it's not a binary you know,
- 40:51it's not as bad. It's neither, and it's all at the same time.
- 40:54You know, it's it's you know, it's it's this thing of God.
- 40:59You just said something that made me key in on. Shoot, I'm
- 41:01sorry, I lost it all right, go ahead. It's like, ultimately
- 41:05she gets to have her power and that ending is just a great revelatory ending.
- 41:09And I could see how some people wouldn't see it that way, but
- 41:12me personally, when I see it that way, it's like she didn't put
- 41:15herself in this situation to get there. She tried everything she could do to
- 41:19fight against it and then ended up getting pushed to it. What else is
- 41:22she supposed to do? Yeah, And what I was going to say a
- 41:23second ago is the idea that, you know, if you're stuck between a
- 41:27rock and a hard place of you know, do you want to live your
- 41:30life in the supposedly, you know, nicest way and yet it's going to
- 41:36be just pure suffering from beginning to end or do you want to you know,
- 41:40enjoy pleasure and follow pleasure. And it's something that I think we all
- 41:45struggle with to this day. And I think there is a core idea.
- 41:51Again, I keep coming back to that word. But there's a reason and
- 41:53hey, Caleb spits up an apple core. Oh no, it's the whole
- 41:58damn apples whatever. Okay, but anyway, but anyway, you see what
- 42:02I'm putting down. But uh so, I think that one of the biggest
- 42:07issues with just life in general, especially human life, is that everything that's
- 42:12supposedly good for you is so damn hard. You know, whether it's hard,
- 42:15whether it's like being you know, a help to your community or an
- 42:20activist, or just freaking eating a vegetable. You know, it's like vegetables
- 42:23themselves, they don't taste good, like the butter tastes good, the fat
- 42:28tastes good. So it's that thing of like no wonder humanity built an entire
- 42:34belief system around these truths within life because you know they're there. Unfortunately,
- 42:40is some bearing to them, you know, where it's like, yeah,
- 42:44that's an ultimate good over there, and yet this feels better and this makes
- 42:49me happier and isn't the point of life to be happy? But if it's
- 42:52not, then what is the point of life? So it's this idea,
- 42:55I think what you're getting at with the sort of overbeuros of the of the
- 42:59ending and how is meant to make you feel. That's what's so beautiful about
- 43:01it is that you really can't come down on one side or the other.
- 43:05I think you you know, well you can, but like you know in
- 43:07the sense that like there's always going to be that question in your mind of
- 43:09like, well, maybe that's not quote unquote correct, you know, because
- 43:14it's like, yes, I've freed myself from this awful family. I feel
- 43:16good for the first time in my life. But it's with the devil and
- 43:21the goat and the naked women. It's like, well, that just goes
- 43:24back to women, because like horror loves to to like exaggerate the idea of
- 43:29a girl going through puberty as a source of horror, and it's you know,
- 43:32also a source of female power, and I mean that shows up throughout
- 43:37horror films, even you know, all the way back. Menstruation is a
- 43:39great biological metaphor for this idea that I was trying to get at, which
- 43:45is like this beautiful, you know, natural biological process of being able to
- 43:50create new life. What a grand thing that is. And yet yeah,
- 43:53it's it feels, of course, not speaking of experience, but it feels
- 43:57terrible. Every month, I'm literally bleeding from the end inside. You know,
- 44:00this horrible And that's why you know so much mythology and whatnot for surrounding
- 44:07menstruation and stuff, whether it was being treated as something shameful or something you
- 44:10know, like a curse, like they called it the curse for however long,
- 44:15right, I know? You know so well, that's why this movie.
- 44:17It's like her emergent womanhood is as unsettling to them as the actual witch,
- 44:22and they're just not dealing with it very well. Yeah, it would
- 44:25have been better for her if she did get sent off to another family to
- 44:29live. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I don't know, there's just I
- 44:37think the final card of the film, I'll read the quote because then we
- 44:40can get into the filming and stuff. Was after I saw it was really
- 44:45powerful to me because the final card of the film says, this film was
- 44:47inspired by many folk tales, fairy tales, and written accounts of historical witchcraft,
- 44:52including journals, diaries, and court records. Much of the dialogue comes
- 44:57directly from these period sources, and I was like, wow, what does
- 45:00he mean by that? And being someone who's gone to Salem and really likes
- 45:06learning about all that stuff to find out, like the dialogue, the clothing,
- 45:10everything that they did was taken word for word, picture pery picture out
- 45:16of the history books. Is so cool to do for your first film.
- 45:22Yeah, and it makes a lot of sense once you know Eggers's background.
- 45:24As you know, he did a lot of theater. He also went you
- 45:28know through I think in acting training, and I believe he also designed.
- 45:34He wasn't a production designer per se, but I think he was a costume
- 45:37designer for stage for quite a while. I would love that job. Yeah,
- 45:42yeah, So certainly, you know, The Witch did not completely form
- 45:45out of nothing. It wasn't like he was some twenty something dude at school
- 45:51being like, I'd love to move a movie and then the next day makes
- 45:52the Witch like that, that's not true. So like he did put in
- 45:55a lot of like a decade of work before ever making this movie. So
- 45:59it wasn't like he was he's so preternaturally gifted that you know. But he
- 46:02is certainly gifted. And you know, one of the things that really speaks
- 46:07to that is the fact that he did go to so much trouble to really
- 46:12recapture and to meticulously create the look of this movie, whether it was from
- 46:17the set design to the sound, the dialogue sound to the dialogue, to
- 46:21the systematography. I guess should we talk about the building of the set a
- 46:28little bit, Yeah, sure, I mean I would piggyback off that.
- 46:31Like there were things that he looked into, like the apple popping out of
- 46:35the mouth, which we talked about, is you know, the original sin.
- 46:37But Agar said that he found an Elizabethan witch pamphlet that told the story
- 46:43of a witch who gave their children, you know, poison apples, or
- 46:46gave children poison apples, and that's most likely the origin of the poison apple
- 46:51trope, as the pamphlet predates Snow White by a couple hundred years. So
- 46:54it's like little things like that he was finding. And even the title the
- 47:00vvich is because of the pamphlets that they would send out in Europe that were
- 47:08burned and pressed onto wood. They didn't have w so they would just do
- 47:13two v's, yeah, and that is where he got the He was like,
- 47:15I really liked how that looked, and that's how they would spell which
- 47:19in those were in wooden pamphlets. So that's what I'm going to use as
- 47:22my title. Card and like stuff like that's just so cool. The attention
- 47:25to detail. I'm like, yes, yes, more people need to do
- 47:29what you do. And even the fact that I mean, there's a lot
- 47:31of great in the Again the second sight for k edition I have, there's
- 47:35a great booklet that comes with it, with a lot of essays from journalists
- 47:39and critics, one of whom points out that that title card, which says
- 47:43the Vivich also has the subtitle a New England folk Tale and the W in
- 47:49New is spelled with the w oh. So there is this inherent tension right
- 47:55from the start between the period and the modern day and where this movie kind
- 48:04of fits in between all of that, you know, where Again, like
- 48:07I was saying earlier, we're watching a movie that is set in a period
- 48:09that is predates so much horror fiction, so much horror cinema of course,
- 48:15and yet is a movie that was made in the midst of all of it,
- 48:17after all of those have come before. So this is a movie that
- 48:22is both the beginning and the end in a way. You know, it's
- 48:24it's yeah, it's kind of hey, where all of this came from?
- 48:28Kind of, but also how everything that's already come before this literal movie has
- 48:34led up to this, you know. Yeah, yeah, so get into
- 48:38the they so I think it is funny that this most of the movie is
- 48:42filmed in Ontario. And after they said it, I started to notice because
- 48:45there's a difference between the Canadian woods and the New England's and there there are
- 48:51like a couple shots that are were in Massachusetts. I think there's a couple.
- 48:52Yeah, establishing you can see the uh the there's a certain kind of
- 48:58fungus on the trees that I was you could say that don't grow up in
- 49:01England and I was like, oh, okay, you can see that they're
- 49:05in mass or New England when they were filming it. But yeah, just
- 49:09building everything from scratch. And what the budget was, what three million?
- 49:14Four million? Yeah, something about three million or so, and I believe
- 49:16the movie made forty million, which is crazy. Love that they love it.
- 49:22But yeah, he flew in a thatcher from Virginia and a carpenter from
- 49:25Massachusetts to yeah, currently make the design of the of the I guess you'd
- 49:31call a farm that they built there. And you know, there was a
- 49:37story. I don't remember the exact details because they don't have it in front
- 49:39of me. But there's a story where he found out that a certain way
- 49:45that some of the wood had been sawed, it wouldn't have been used.
- 49:49They wouldn't have used a certain type of saw that they could use nowadays back
- 49:52then, so we had to set it back and have it resawed, you
- 49:55know, with the crete, and which is something that of course nobody beyond
- 50:00the most pedantic you know viewer who right would be another expert on you know,
- 50:07seventeenth century architecture would notice or care about. And there's there's stuff that
- 50:12during his commentary he even mentions, like, I guess the pile of logs
- 50:15that William falls into at the end too modern, was too modern for him.
- 50:19You know. The candles, they're like that lantern had three candles in
- 50:22it when it would only have one usually because the family would definitely not use
- 50:27that many candles. And yet that's a really good point because so much of
- 50:29this movie is candlelight and candle it in the quote unquote candlelate way, which
- 50:35is the fact that like they do add separate or you know, instead of
- 50:37one wick per candle, it's like three wicks per candle. Because it is
- 50:40shot entirely in natural light, you know, which is crazy, but the
- 50:45actors wearing the costumes made from period appropriate fabrics and everything feels real. All
- 50:50the way down to the dialogue is authentic, and most of it was taken
- 50:52from actual transcerpts from the Salem witch trials, Like how crazy is that?
- 50:57Yeah, witch trials. I think there's other things like pam flits that were
- 51:00being passed around at that time, so those wood in pamphlets, wood in
- 51:04pamphlets as well as I think, I guess interviews from people who had lived
- 51:07in that contemporary period. But like maybe he gave statements later on. Did
- 51:13you just imagine how living in religious dread must have been? Like the absolute
- 51:16worst, Like like the devil's real and he's everywhere you are. Oh,
- 51:20your brother's having sexual feelings towards you, so that's your fault. Oh yeah.
- 51:23But just to close that point, all of if all of this sounds
- 51:28daunting to our listeners, because it certainly sounds daunting to me. If you
- 51:30said, if you gave me the concept and said, okay, go make
- 51:34this movie, I wouldn't have the foggiest idea where to start. I'd be
- 51:37like, this is going to take the next ten years of my life.
- 51:38I'm going to have to research, you know. But what Egers was really
- 51:42smart in what he did and how he wrote the script, which was he
- 51:45researched these materials, you know, for a period, but not like his
- 51:50whole life, of course, found some good stuff, and smartly what he
- 51:54did was Okay, he found Let's say he knew that the next scene he
- 51:58wanted to write was this scene where you know, William Caleb, we're talking
- 52:02about hunting, right, So it's like he found some archival materials of Okay,
- 52:07here's a few terms that they were being used in that period about hunting
- 52:12and what sort of things you might talk about. So he would just copy
- 52:15and paste those statements into the script, look at them and go, okay,
- 52:19I can use this word in this word and this word and sort of
- 52:21build a scene around that and then rewrite it in his own words. So
- 52:25in a way you can sort of understand the methodology there, where it's like,
- 52:29Okay, you take the research, you take the materials, put it
- 52:31in the order that you want it, give it the tone you want you
- 52:36know, where it's like, okay, this might be what you might say
- 52:37over the dinner table in this period and stuff like that, and then go
- 52:42from there so that you're not totally working from scratch, where it's like you
- 52:45just have to figure out for yourself, Oh, how would this language work?
- 52:49How would kind of terms? You know, because that's the way that
- 52:52you would never get it done, Like, you would never get it done
- 52:53that way, you know. Now. What I think is super interesting about
- 52:57the storytelling of this too, is they show up very early that the Witch
- 53:00is in fact real, and you kind of forget it as the movie goes
- 53:05on. You know, it's not that you forget, but there is this
- 53:08is it the Witch? Is it not the Witch kind of thing going on
- 53:12that you kind of like let go. And I think it was really important
- 53:15for them to have that scene with the corn and the egots. Egots.
- 53:17Ergots. What I always say it that we know make you crazy, because
- 53:21you see in the Salem Witch Trials it's either those girls were just a horde
- 53:25of horrible bitches or the whole town was poisoned by you know, egots,
- 53:30which makes you you know, it's kind of like a psychosomatic I said it,
- 53:35right, a psychosomatic at a insane kind of thing that you know,
- 53:38gets in your head, and they did use that as an excuse for why
- 53:43the Salem you know, witch trials happen in that hysteria, which I don't
- 53:46fully back or believe. I think that was just trying to sugarcoat a really
- 53:52dark part of our history, as we try to do with every dark part
- 53:55of our history. And this was just another example, like it's just the
- 53:59little word the corn. No, it wasn't. That bitch was a bitch
- 54:02and then she got all her friends to get on that and she thought that
- 54:06she was too pretty and she wanted that person's land, and that's really what
- 54:08it was. You know. Well, it's just like that famous Arthur Miller
- 54:12play, the Worm in the Corn. Yes, well, I'm going to
- 54:15talk about that later. Don't you worry? Oh, I didn't worry.
- 54:19But I do want to introduce the idea now, which is, because you
- 54:22already brought it up, there is a delicious again, there's so much delicious
- 54:25butta, there's delicious Bata, so much beautiful ambiguity in this movie. One
- 54:31of those elements is, yes, we're shown the witch early on, and
- 54:36yet how much can we trust that visual you know, in the sense that
- 54:39like, yeah, we have to take it to face value. It's certainly
- 54:44on a first watch, we have to take it to face value. That's
- 54:45what we're seeing. And I think that's the way that the movie works the
- 54:49best as a horror movie, for sure, because twenty minutes in the tone
- 54:52that they see because because oh yeah, and like there's there's no holds barred
- 54:58where it's like you're gonna see baby skilled in this movie. Where can we
- 55:00go from here? I was like, that makes me fly. Yeah,
- 55:05yeah, well you never know it till you try it. But but I
- 55:09think what's cool in revisiting it and watching it over and over as you can,
- 55:14because this movie is so watchable is the fact that, like, if
- 55:17you take into account the idea that, okay, maybe Thomasin's the witch from
- 55:22the beginning, and even she may not realize it, maybe there are multiple
- 55:28witches here, maybe the kids really are doing black fittis building bidding, you
- 55:31know, and so on and so forth, or and this is the way
- 55:37that I think the actors like to think of it, because to the tea
- 55:39Anya Taylor, Joy and Raphinessen and Kate Dickie all mentioned when they were shooting
- 55:44the movie, none of them ever thought of it as a horror movie,
- 55:46which you hear a lot from horror actors, you know, to be honest,
- 55:50because I feel like there's still such a stigmatization against horror and ghettoization of
- 55:53horror, and you know, it's like, oh, I'm not making a
- 55:55horror movie, making a psychological whatever. But I do think they have a
- 56:00point in the sense that yes, this works completely as its own. The
- 56:04disintegration of the family, you know, through a multiple bad belief systems of
- 56:12just you know, so much inbred resentment and anger and jealousy, and then
- 56:17the fact that they're poor, and the fact this move didn't work out,
- 56:20and the fact that so and so is looking at so and so with lust
- 56:23in their eyes, and the fact that the Korn is not good, and
- 56:27the fact that all this stuff so and in a way this ties into the
- 56:32same kind of metaphor that would be explored well, I was going to say
- 56:37later, but actually it's earlier in cinema history, with stuff like the Amityville
- 56:42Horror and Poltergeist. You know, this fear of you know, the patriarch
- 56:47letting us down as an archetype in American culture and society, where it's like,
- 56:52you know, the so called head of the family can't figure it out,
- 56:55so therefore all of us are doomed. And the fact there is no
- 57:00support system in place to help when things go awry that badly. And the
- 57:05fact that, oh, we got this great new house, but it turns
- 57:07out it's a muddy pit and it's terrible. Uh. And oh man,
- 57:10there might be a supernatural element here that's actually screwing us up to and and
- 57:15even I loved this too, and I want to mention this, you know,
- 57:19before I forget Ash, which is one of the essays in that book
- 57:21on the movie, mentions that in their in their eyes, you know,
- 57:25this is a sort of a art house horror answer to the Evil Dead,
- 57:31you know, which is oh yeah, yeah, it's a collection of people
- 57:36cabin in the woods, so to speak. And it is the disintegration of
- 57:40this once you know, together unit, uh, to the point where they're
- 57:44all ripping each other's eyes out, you know, so to speak. Uh.
- 57:47Yeah. So, since we were talking about the broom before I Forget
- 57:52It, he mentioned it in the commentary and I really appreciated it, the
- 57:58fact that the witch was just flying a stick. Yeah, And because the
- 58:02idea of brooms didn't come into play for witches until the eighteen hundreds. So
- 58:07even when you go to Salem, like there's the witches and the pictures,
- 58:10you see them on brooms, but none of the actual words. They fly
- 58:15around on poles or ungeons is what they call them, right, And the
- 58:20only way, you know, one of the ways to get your ungent to
- 58:22fly is to use the entrails of an unbaptized baby. So the fact that
- 58:27that was where the kind of movie started. And I loved the conversation with
- 58:30Samuel and William, like, you're not talking about the baby. You know
- 58:34what if I just got taken the other day when if I wasn't baptized,
- 58:37And like the question, oh did I say, William? Yeah, sorry
- 58:40talking about Salem Salem Samuel, but uh yeah, I mean it is just
- 58:47it's it is interesting conversations that it just feels so natural, And I think
- 58:52that is what really goes for the movie is it does have these like people
- 58:55just trying to get through and then all of a sudden, you know that
- 58:59you crack an egg and there's a little bit there's a chicken baby in the
- 59:02egg. I don't know what you call it. Or you go to milk
- 59:05the goat and it's blood. Yeah, and there's no you're just she's not
- 59:08telling anybody about it. Yeah, yeah, right, there's this. I
- 59:15think one thing we haven't brought up yet, which I should bring up now
- 59:19because I just made me think of it, is there is a strong element
- 59:22of in the same way that I was just talking about this movie's relationship to
- 59:27you know, societal horror, I guess i'll call it, you know,
- 59:30in terms of Amityville, Poltergeist and all kinds of haunted house movies that you
- 59:34know, go off the paranormal activity, you know, this idea of like,
- 59:37oh, our dream place is actually our nightmare. Right. There's also
- 59:40a strong element of full corror in this movie. And full corror is still
- 59:47a new enough term that it doesn't quite as I think it talked about on
- 59:51this very podcast before with Midsummer It doesn't quite have a definitive definition yet.
- 59:57But generally it concerns horror that is is based in or around or of nature.
- 1:00:02You know, I think is the strongest element in folk hore that connects
- 1:00:07so much you know, that is concerned or considered to be folk hore,
- 1:00:13and certainly the Witch is a movie in which, if you read it as
- 1:00:16such, nature is this force that is this oppressive thing that's out there,
- 1:00:22whether it's represented by the Witch, whether it literally is the Witch or not.
- 1:00:28Again, if you wanted to read this as there actually isn't a Witch,
- 1:00:30but it's just what all these family members are blaming for, the fact
- 1:00:35that the crops are failing, the fact that the animals are sick, the
- 1:00:37fact that you know, all this other stuff is happening, which is what
- 1:00:40I was saying earlier, like that's where the Witch was created from, just
- 1:00:44so you could blame everything that was going bad on something, right, So
- 1:00:47in essence, what I'm saying is the Witch, if we're going off another
- 1:00:52reading, isn't necessarily a being into and of itself. It is a representation
- 1:00:57of the earth, you know, where it's like, this is how we
- 1:01:00can even process the fact that the Earth might not want us around or trying
- 1:01:05to do to it. You know. Well, that's say I like every
- 1:01:07time the screen tends to go black for about ten seconds every time the Witch
- 1:01:12kind of strikes, which is really cool because the Witch isn't on screen that
- 1:01:15much, and when she is, it's often kind of like obscured, the
- 1:01:19same way that like the devil is at the end, there's out of focus
- 1:01:22and focus and in some other form like the hair, we would all assume
- 1:01:27she's the hair. I don't know if she's the goat. I think you
- 1:01:30we're supposed to think that black film is the devil through most of it,
- 1:01:35but I mean she she definitely is. You have the crone, you have
- 1:01:38the the hot one, give the hair, which if you don't know about
- 1:01:44hairs and witches, just google it. I'm not going to do the work
- 1:01:46for you. Just go ahead and google how far back that goes. And
- 1:01:50I just think it was it's just creating chaos, which is good enough for
- 1:01:54me in a movie. And because you're not supposed to fully understand what she
- 1:01:58is doing or if she is doing it, or how many witches there even
- 1:02:01are, because at the end we see how many witches are there? Is
- 1:02:05it this one? Was it a whole group of witches doing this to them?
- 1:02:07We really don't know. And guess what. It doesn't take away from
- 1:02:12the story, No, not at all. It only adds, as we
- 1:02:15discussed right now, like it just it gets you thinking, It gets you
- 1:02:19talking, It gets you excited even to think about all the possibilities that that
- 1:02:23could imply. Dizzy. The hair was extremely cooperative, unlike that goddamn goat
- 1:02:29Charlie, who apparently was a complete nightmare on set. And I love it
- 1:02:32because that goat is intense looking. He is intense looking. I mean even
- 1:02:37just that close above his one eye, you know in that one shot is
- 1:02:39just like this dude, is something's going on with this dude? They found
- 1:02:43the perfect goat, they did, and pour the devil. They found out
- 1:02:47that not only because the goat didn't have I guess a trainer per se,
- 1:02:51like I guess they had a like a wrangler or a minder, but they
- 1:02:53had a couple of wranglers there or is it the because I guess I don't
- 1:02:58know if it eggers wonders like you could even train the goat at all,
- 1:03:01or if it was just not this goat. But you know what they found
- 1:03:06while shooting the film is that Inison had a special relationship with the goat,
- 1:03:08meaning the goat did not like him at all. Just from site on site,
- 1:03:13it was on, it was it was on, and so Inison took
- 1:03:16one for the team many times, where like he realized in order to get
- 1:03:20a performance out of the goat, he would have to be nearby and get
- 1:03:23the goat like riled up, just like you know, teasing it or messing
- 1:03:27with it in some way, which of course resulted in Inison getting attacked by
- 1:03:31the goat three separate times and getting sent to the er three separate times.
- 1:03:35Yeah, when he has to film the scene where he picks up Jonah with
- 1:03:38the one hand, apparently he had been hit right before then and that was
- 1:03:42really hard for him to do and he was in a lot of pain.
- 1:03:45But like on the other side of that, the little girl who played Mercy
- 1:03:49apparently had a fantastic relationship in the coat because you see her like whisperin in
- 1:03:53his air bah bah. Yeah. No, she got really close and the
- 1:03:57goat seemed fine. So yeah, it was just I guess whatever pheromones Innison's
- 1:04:01putting out, those kids were super creepy. And I'm glad he said it
- 1:04:05in his in the commentary because when I watched that, they if you would
- 1:04:11have told me, like legend they had some of the you know, there
- 1:04:15was like little people playing the roles. If you would have told me that
- 1:04:16the actress playing Mercy was like a little person. I would have believed you
- 1:04:19because of how like zoned in that actress was with her dialogue, with her
- 1:04:27acting skills, she knew what she was doing with being attacked with like just
- 1:04:30everything that was going on, I'm like, what are you seven? Yeah?
- 1:04:33Well though, seriously too is the fact that the actress at the time
- 1:04:36of filming was like eleven or twelve, but like she's playing six, right,
- 1:04:40whereas the other the guy playing was it Jonah the Yeah, the other
- 1:04:45twin was actually six, So there's the disparity there where like, wait,
- 1:04:49they weren't really twins, No bullshit, No, they look exactly the same.
- 1:04:55Yeah, isn't that nuts? So it's that thing of like your brain
- 1:04:59is kind of process seeing the disparity even though you can't tell, you know,
- 1:05:01but like you can sense it. I think that's what you're describing,
- 1:05:04where it's like you would have you would have bought if she was a little
- 1:05:08person or not. Yeah, the casting in this is is fantastic. Uh.
- 1:05:13We already talked about Aison, but like I forget, I forgot really
- 1:05:15that Inison was a huge character on the original UK Office. He was like
- 1:05:21the the sort of I guess I'll have to refer to him as like the
- 1:05:25quagmire of that show. But like he was, he was always saying something
- 1:05:28super like off color stuff like very like you know, borderline massagist but sexist
- 1:05:32stuff, you know, and stuff like that. Yeah, he doesn't he
- 1:05:34didn't have facial hair or maybe just a mustache, I forget, but he
- 1:05:39looked super different in the UK office, but you can still tell because of
- 1:05:42his voice. And so it's funny how this in a big way, I
- 1:05:45think, restarted almost Inison's career playing you know, far more regal, historical,
- 1:05:50you know, thrones, because then it was after that and I started
- 1:05:57seeing him pop up and just about everything. Yeah, yeah, but certainly
- 1:06:00it was a big step. And then and then Kate dicky just being the
- 1:06:05intense actress that she is. Everybody who's interviewed about making the movie all praise
- 1:06:11Kate Dickie for Yeah, well she's intense, she's intense, crazy sounds like.
- 1:06:15Then there's Anya. I think this is the first movie I've seen her
- 1:06:17in and look at where she was her first movie, it was, it
- 1:06:21was the first movie she made. He said that the audition was pretty much
- 1:06:27her doing that i'd be the witch in the woods scene where she's talking to
- 1:06:30Mercy and that she just came in with this energy that was exactly what he
- 1:06:33was looking for. And he was like her done, yeah by it,
- 1:06:36And I love what he says where originally and she talks about this too.
- 1:06:40Thomasin was written in the original draft of the script as someone who was playing
- 1:06:45looking and you know, someone who potentially could fit into that family, but
- 1:06:50there's just something within her that's not letting her do it. Whereas as soon
- 1:06:54as he casts Anya, he he literally went back and rewrote the script,
- 1:06:58not much, but like just a few discs options here and there to cater
- 1:07:01Caleb looks at her boobs extra law in the sense that because he wanted to
- 1:07:09give her the space to own the character, in the sense that because Anya,
- 1:07:14you know, was freaking out about it herself, being like, I
- 1:07:15don't I'm not plain looking even if you dirty me up, Like I'm still
- 1:07:18weird. She's weird. We say beautiful, but you know it's that thing
- 1:07:25of like what's what Eggers was smart about was saying, Okay, well,
- 1:07:28this isn't exactly how I envisioned the character when I wrote it, but this
- 1:07:31is someone who works totally you know, in a different way, but the
- 1:07:34same function, which is this woman could never be a puritan like she was
- 1:07:39just right, you know, already set aside as someone who is like special
- 1:07:44enough to like not she wouldn't have a great life just living on the farm
- 1:07:46and living off the land and all that, you know. Originally, one
- 1:07:51of Eggers's early drafts of this was not an anthology per se, but it
- 1:07:59was struck it in a unique way, which was that it had it was
- 1:08:01segmented, and each segment was going to follow a different member of the family
- 1:08:06as the protagonist. And so, you know, this would be so and
- 1:08:11so, you know, Caleb story, this would be Thomasin's story, this
- 1:08:13would be Williams like sort of thing, and it was the producers are one
- 1:08:17set of the producers. There's many producers on it, but one of the
- 1:08:20earlier producers telling him, you know, this would be a lot more sellable
- 1:08:25if we could just rewrite it with like a single protagonist, you know figure
- 1:08:29as opposed to like this choppy, you know thing. But they did say
- 1:08:32that that early version may have been the best version of the movie in terms
- 1:08:36of getting getting all of you know the perspectives in there, and I understand
- 1:08:42what they're trying to maybe get at, which is the fact that what we're
- 1:08:45talking about as this idea of there's so many layers, there's so many interpretations,
- 1:08:47there's whatever. I think that element was probably stronger in that earlier draft,
- 1:08:53if he was able to give it that you know, that that much
- 1:08:56space. But yeah, I just thought of that because of the way that
- 1:09:00he was talking about reworking the script, you know, both before auditioning Anya
- 1:09:03and then later after casting her. And then we haven't talked about Harvey Scrimshaw
- 1:09:08yet. Caleb who Yeah, great voice, ruscious Jesus that kid. His
- 1:09:16whole monologue scene. I just remember watching it for the first time, and
- 1:09:21it's just as silent as the scene. There's no music I don't remember,
- 1:09:25and it's just very visceral watching him. I'm like, what is he saying?
- 1:09:30What's happening? And then he just dies and You're like what the fuck?
- 1:09:33It was crazy And then for someone so young to be like getting it,
- 1:09:36yeah, well well, and again apparently how they manage that is because
- 1:09:42Edgars was going into that scene going, oh, no, how do I
- 1:09:45talk to this? You know, I think he was twelve at the time
- 1:09:46or something. Yeah, how do I talk to this young kid about these
- 1:09:49concepts because he's not a billy freakin He's not just don't tell him that is
- 1:09:55the billy freaking rup yeah yeah, yeah. So so he di go to
- 1:10:00Ralph, and I guess Ralph had become friends with Harvey's father, who was
- 1:10:04around on set, you know, while they were making it, And so
- 1:10:08Ralph and and and Harvey had become tight and he was like, Ralph,
- 1:10:12could you and Kate work something out with Harvey about like how to get him
- 1:10:15to give this performance without literally letting him on the secret of like what he's
- 1:10:19doing. And they worked with Harvey to literally like choreograph like his performance and
- 1:10:26sense like because you can see it when you watch it again, knowing that
- 1:10:28where it's like the way his arm moves over himself yea, his muscle spasm,
- 1:10:33yeah, face, And the core idea they gave to Harvey in order
- 1:10:39like for what emotions to play is just imagine that like you're super thirsty and
- 1:10:44you really need a drink, you know, ah wow sort of thing.
- 1:10:46So it's not too shabby to be that twelve year old kid and your first
- 1:10:50kiss is with an ex Australian ex Factory Secrets model, Lucky Lucky Best.
- 1:10:56And it's great because again it yeah, that scene, it's so much is
- 1:11:04happening in it. A lot of what we already said about you know.
- 1:11:06Yeah, well she looks she's so beautiful, but there's also something very off
- 1:11:12putting about her. But you are also being kind of drawn in. Yeah.
- 1:11:16And if the if the later scene of Harvey's you know, possession if
- 1:11:21you Will, is a reference to the Exorcist, then that scene is certainly
- 1:11:25a reference to the shining you know. Oh yeah, good point of yeah,
- 1:11:29bathtub yep. All right, we're gonna take a quick break and we'll
- 1:11:33be right back, all right, And we are back, all right.
- 1:11:43So I want to get into some of my favorite shots from this movie,
- 1:11:45because I have about four, okay, and there's so some of them are
- 1:11:49subtle, but it's just it's just gorgeous. So my favorite shot is or
- 1:11:55I don't have a favorite. I have four favorites, let's be serious.
- 1:11:59The shot after the baby disappears, it's just a few small branches shaking that
- 1:12:03they did with fishing wire from the branches and the trees but other than that,
- 1:12:08there's no indication that anything was there. And I would say that's what
- 1:12:12I would call a perfect scene and a perfect shot that you know, she's
- 1:12:15doing pikaboo pikaboo with the baby and on the third or fourth pekaboo, the
- 1:12:19baby's gone and then you look up and there's just tree shaking, and I
- 1:12:24don't there's just something about that shot. It is so good. It's great,
- 1:12:30it's wonderful. And it's also even though we keep saying about all the
- 1:12:35different reads of this film of like what really happened here and what really happened
- 1:12:39there? Was it the way it happens that we're seeing it or is it
- 1:12:43happening a different way from I see? And that I think is one of
- 1:12:46the biggest mysteries of the movie. It's like, if you want to take
- 1:12:49the implication that, Okay, maybe maybe there is no witch at all,
- 1:12:54Maybe it's just them going crazy and or you know, hallucinating because of their
- 1:13:00disintegration, what happened to Samuel, Like where did he go? Where did
- 1:13:04he go? Where did Mercy and Jonas go? At the end? Exactly?
- 1:13:08Yeah, I don't know. Yeah, Number two is definitely I think
- 1:13:13The creepiest shot is the raven ripping the breast apart, because she's just laughing
- 1:13:18so maniacally, and Kate is just owning that scene, and it comes off
- 1:13:23something so profound that I didn't notice when I watched it the first time,
- 1:13:28even the first couple times. This might have been the first time I noticed
- 1:13:30it is the cup being back before Caleb and that Samuel are back, obviously,
- 1:13:35as you know, enchantments from the Witch as we're supposed to think,
- 1:13:40or maybe she's just in hysteria, but the first thing that you see after
- 1:13:44she thinks that the baby and caleber back is the cup that we know that
- 1:13:46Williams sold. That he let Thompson take the blame for for a while,
- 1:13:50which was pretty shitty on his part, but him just that that crow coming
- 1:13:55out of nowhere, which is another iteration of the Witch, which is now
- 1:13:58what the third we've seen or fourth, just ripping that nip apart, and
- 1:14:03then you think did that or did it not happen? And you see William
- 1:14:06wake up in the morning and pulls the sheets back a little bit when he's
- 1:14:10getting out of bed, and then it is revealed that is her name Kate
- 1:14:13in the movie too. Yeah Catherine, Yeah, yeah, Catherine, that
- 1:14:15her nipple had been believed on, so something happened. So and a great
- 1:14:21story about shooting that, which is her rich because she the way that she
- 1:14:25is as an actor, she likes to maybe you know, pre plan and
- 1:14:28performance if she can. And she was thinking, you know that a raven
- 1:14:30might be as big as say, like a blackbird or something, so she
- 1:14:33was going to like coddle it as if you were breastfeeding a baby, and
- 1:14:38the image was meant to be a little more less hysterical if it's like,
- 1:14:43you know, just the eerie image of like the bird as baby. But
- 1:14:46once she got on set and they showed her the actual raven they were going
- 1:14:48to use. This thing is huge, and she was like, there's no
- 1:14:51way I can even hold that. But let alone, would be super dangerous
- 1:14:54to hold that because the thing is Vira, go pack your face off.
- 1:14:57Also yeah, peck your face off. And also like they're super strong apparently,
- 1:15:00so like they have this enormous strength with their beaks that like you know,
- 1:15:02you don't want them to let you don't want to let them get a
- 1:15:04hold of like your your wrist or something. Right, So when they were
- 1:15:09shooting that scene, she had like a prosthetic chest on that they made up
- 1:15:12for her right and right away as soon as they let the raven loose.
- 1:15:15The raven was like tied to a string that this handler was holding off screen,
- 1:15:19so like it couldn't actually get to her completely, so like it wasn't
- 1:15:24going to bite her face off, but it was close enough to get the
- 1:15:27nipple right, and they put like you know, food on the fake nipple
- 1:15:30to like you know, attract it and all that, which which worked too
- 1:15:32well. And like the raven like just went to town on this thing and
- 1:15:34like tore off the prosthetic, and like Kate was like she was talking about
- 1:15:40how like she was instantly like just terrified, but she knew she was having
- 1:15:44to give a performance still, so she just started laughing hysterically, and Eggers
- 1:15:47was like, screw it, go with it, go with that impulse.
- 1:15:50And so that's why in that shot she's reacting the way she is, and
- 1:15:55it's oh yeah, as opposed to like maybe something more subtle, right,
- 1:15:58you know, visceral like, and it is, so it's a juxtapitation for
- 1:16:00what you just saw her doing, which is just coddling and being happy,
- 1:16:04and then the next shot is just like nipples being ripped off. It's crazy,
- 1:16:11it's crazy, and it's such a good button to that because remember it's
- 1:16:14intercut with the witch turning up in the barn where Mercy well. And so
- 1:16:18I think it's it's super interesting that all the supernatural moments of the film are
- 1:16:24filmed neither twenty seven or twenty nine frames per frame rate to make it look
- 1:16:29a little crazier or a little bit more magical. And there are several shots
- 1:16:35right out of Eggers's dreams, like the shot of Caleb walking up to the
- 1:16:41witch house. He said, I had that exact dream, yeh, or
- 1:16:44the one that you're talking about now where the you know, the witch was
- 1:16:46sucking off that goat. He said that those were just like straight out of
- 1:16:50his dreams. And another thing that I really loved is at the end the
- 1:16:55sound of chimes that show up when the devil has actually shown up, like
- 1:16:59everybody dead, Thomason's napped, put her head down, got rid of the
- 1:17:03the constraints of her colonial outfit, you know, got all that off,
- 1:17:08which I also see, you know, as symbolism, and you know,
- 1:17:12puts her head down and falls asleep when then you wake up to this sound
- 1:17:15of chimes, this magical sound of chimes, And it really reminded me of
- 1:17:18the scene in Legend, which you haven't seen, right, you said you
- 1:17:21never saw Legend. Really, Scott's Legend, you saw Legend. I've seen
- 1:17:25it a million times. Yeah right, I can't remember how I was talking
- 1:17:27to whatever. Okay, so you know the sound of chimes. I just
- 1:17:30excuse me, listeners, I would like you to know I'm taking that back.
- 1:17:32I'm taking it back. I'm taking it back. Yeah. I love
- 1:17:35the sound of chimes when the devil shows up, and it reminds me of
- 1:17:39that scene in Legend when the Darkness is seducing Lily because all you hear are
- 1:17:43the chimes and he's doing the same thing. He's like, you know,
- 1:17:45seduce ha. But and it's very similar to like do you like the taste
- 1:17:51of battles? Oh? Yeah? And the chimes and it's so cool.
- 1:17:55And I thought that was really cool because the Mark Corvin's score is so good,
- 1:17:59like that score and the choir that he has with like it scared people
- 1:18:01when they were king a thing, and I think it's so visceral. And
- 1:18:05then to all of a sudden have this just like chimes thing that you haven't
- 1:18:10heard throughout the whole movie. I thought it was really cool. It brings
- 1:18:13the realism of the supernatural into it. And that brings me to my favorite
- 1:18:18shot in the whole movie, which I didn't even see until my recent watch
- 1:18:23on four K, and that is at the barn at the end when Thominson's
- 1:18:27about to sign the book, and the books in the forefront of the shot,
- 1:18:30and then you see a single hoof step into the screen in the back,
- 1:18:33and then the next step is, all of a sudden, a boot,
- 1:18:35and then the hoof has now morphed into a boot and it is the
- 1:18:39Devil. And that scene is just so freaking cool, and I never noticed
- 1:18:45it before. It's done seamlessly, perfectly magically, if you will. It
- 1:18:49is one of my favorite shots in cinema. I would even throw out there,
- 1:18:54and I just really really loved how he did it. And you don't
- 1:18:57even see the devil. The guy who's playing the devil is obviously hot,
- 1:19:00but you don't you can tell he is full costume to the works, and
- 1:19:03you never really even with the four K or whatever and not streaming, get
- 1:19:09to see it because it's on purpose. He's shrouded in this darkness and he's
- 1:19:13just so I'd be like, yeah, where do you want me to sign?
- 1:19:16Yeah, get me out of here. And I think it's so beautiful
- 1:19:18that, like, in a movie so saturated with ambiguity, that he adds
- 1:19:23so much visual ambiguity. And I think visual ambiguity only works if you have
- 1:19:28all of those elements in place. It'd be a different story if like he
- 1:19:31went into it knowing. I think he did go into it knowing what he
- 1:19:34was going to show what he wasn't. But if he said, you know
- 1:19:38what, don't even get in full costume, dude, Like just put on
- 1:19:40the hat, you know, and the tunic and that's it, you know,
- 1:19:44because we're only going to shoot you from the waist up and you're going
- 1:19:45to be out of focus. Like he didn't go that, you know,
- 1:19:47that route. He went full on, and that I think is so important
- 1:19:53to give you that feeling of like, I know there's more out of frame,
- 1:19:56but we just can't see it, you know. Yes, Yeah,
- 1:19:59And I think that's that's so key in terms of giving you a a fully
- 1:20:02realized world which just fully sells the supernatural out of it, you know,
- 1:20:08mm hmm, I love it. I love it. Oh yeah, I
- 1:20:11love this movie. Yeah I do too. Man again, so do you
- 1:20:15of his of the Lighthouse of the Northmen. He has three right now,
- 1:20:19just three before. But it's crazy to think of how incredibly influential he's become
- 1:20:29despite just having only three movies under his belt. And what's also nuts is
- 1:20:33that, you know, you have somebody like say ari Astor, who we've
- 1:20:36you know, gushed about in this podcast too. Ari Asta is definitely the
- 1:20:40type of dude who is like, he seems like kind of a fun talk
- 1:20:44to, but like, at the same time, you get that there's definitely
- 1:20:45something odd in that dude. You know, something happened to him, something
- 1:20:48something happened to him. Whereas Eckers seems like the most chill, like just
- 1:20:53average kind eyes and he's I'm trying to say he is. He's not necessarily
- 1:20:58a Stanley Kubrick or even a Christopher and type of like giving you so there's
- 1:21:01a feeling of like the austere genius you know, who's like because if you
- 1:21:04didn't know who Eberteggers was before just you know, before seeing an interview and
- 1:21:09just watch those movies, you'd be like, Oh, that dude's probably like
- 1:21:12really you know, fascinating to talk to, but probably like, you know,
- 1:21:15super intelligent, super you know, studied, and like you know,
- 1:21:18he's like kind of stuffy guy at the dinner party, And that's not even
- 1:21:23him at all. Right, So I think he's an interesting cat in the
- 1:21:26sense that, like he does, he doesn't come off the way you might
- 1:21:30think he might come off from the work that he does. So you're about
- 1:21:33to ask me which of the three I like the most. Yeah, it's
- 1:21:38a hard call because they're all spectacular. I I'd have to see I'm going
- 1:21:45to see later this year. I'm going to rewatch The Lighthouse and Northman.
- 1:21:49Once I do that, I might change my mind. But right now,
- 1:21:54I potentially might say The Northman, okay, just because I am still enamored
- 1:22:00with the way that it takes so much of that mythology and brings it to
- 1:22:04the screen in a way that I don't think any other brand of you know,
- 1:22:09barbarian fiction, you know, even Conyan. I love the Conebo brand
- 1:22:13movie. It's a great movie, but like it just feels in the same
- 1:22:16way that Lighthouse feels in the same way that this feels very uncannily all of
- 1:22:20its own, you know, where it's it's it's it feels, it's so
- 1:22:26obvious that it exists in a spectrum. How many times have you watched The
- 1:22:29Northmen? You said one? Only just the ones? So you know how
- 1:22:30many times have you watched The Witch? Oh? This is probably my you
- 1:22:34know, fifth or sixth time somewhere around there. Okay, and then okay,
- 1:22:40but I only have owned the Ort Northman for a year, so right,
- 1:22:43so we'll see, So we'll see. But and I think, you
- 1:22:45know, we haven't given the Lighthouse it's props, but Lighthouse. I love
- 1:22:48it. I love the Lighthouse. I really is its own you know,
- 1:22:51special uh bizarre, you know, just you know that movie tricked me into
- 1:22:58the like not tricked me, but made me go Okay, maybe Robert Pattinson
- 1:23:01can act like it was very good. I like a lot. There's you
- 1:23:05know, him and I him, meaning can argue about the queer undertones of
- 1:23:10the Lighthouse, but I like it, and I like that there are queer
- 1:23:13undertones and that, I mean, what happens when you end up being isolated
- 1:23:16with people for so long, and that there's a lot of interesting is it
- 1:23:21symbolism or symbology? God, Wiliam de Foe, you've messed me up with
- 1:23:25that symbolism, you know, from Come in Your Face to who Knows What
- 1:23:31like? And there's a lot going on in that movie. But it's not
- 1:23:34just normal come in your Face, because it's it's Robert, it angers,
- 1:23:38it's you know, Octopusthulu. I don't know what do you call it.
- 1:23:44I don't know. It's weird. It's weird is what I'll call it.
- 1:23:46And this movie is more grounded, I guess than the other two. Well,
- 1:23:50the Northman I expected. I expected something different from that, and I
- 1:23:55blame their marketing team because the way that that movie was marketed is I thought
- 1:24:00that Alexander Scarsguard was going to be putting heads to bed. The entire time.
- 1:24:02It looked like an actiony, you know, Viking crazy movie, and
- 1:24:08then you realize, oh, it isn't It is this in depth story,
- 1:24:11plot, character driven. Wow, that was not what I was expecting.
- 1:24:15And I wasn't upset about it, but you know, I don't know the
- 1:24:21ending of that. I was sad, but I think it's supposed to feel
- 1:24:25that way, you know. But this one. I guess, I don't
- 1:24:28know. He tapped into my personal liking like witches and doing things that someone
- 1:24:33like me would be like, oh my god, that wasn't a broom,
- 1:24:36it was a stick or a poll because there wouldn't have been brooms in the
- 1:24:41sixteen hundreds. Yeah, it would have only been sticks. So stuff like
- 1:24:44that was more for me. Yeah, so I guess that's why. Yeah,
- 1:24:48I guess that's why got anything else where we kind of uh, yeah,
- 1:24:53I guess less thoughts really, right, So killing babies is super messed
- 1:24:57up, but like sure, if you're going to be like an ugly old
- 1:25:00and the only thing to change it around is like if you kill a baby,
- 1:25:03you get to be young again. Doesn't that make it really hard?
- 1:25:06Like I'm like, I don't know that baby. You can't talk yet.
- 1:25:10You know, it's not a real person yet. So it's like squish,
- 1:25:14squish, squish, squish, and then you get tough, fly and be
- 1:25:16hot. What's that like to live deliciously? You're goddamn right, I would
- 1:25:20exactly, And I love that The Witch. The actress who played the Witch,
- 1:25:26her name is Bethsheba. What the fuck that's crazy? You gotta wonder
- 1:25:30if that's a stage name or not. Right, It's like, what's going
- 1:25:32on there? What's going on? Yeah? I think that, uh,
- 1:25:39this movie is something that is so special will continue to be so special,
- 1:25:44and both of its time and out of its time, in the sense that
- 1:25:47of its time, it's it kickstarted, you know it. A twenty four
- 1:25:51would not exist without this movie. Let's just be blunt. Yes, A
- 1:25:55twenty four as a brand, and I hate that it's become a brand,
- 1:25:58but it has would not exist about this movie, nor would the movement of
- 1:26:01you know what we're now into this elevated horror so to speak. You know,
- 1:26:06That's why I hold this movie a little higher than Ari Astor's movies.
- 1:26:10And I know, I love Midsummer, I love Hereditary, and I do,
- 1:26:12but the Witch is still preferable for me over all of those other pels.
- 1:26:15And honestly, I would not be surprised if Astor saw this movie and
- 1:26:18went, Okay, now I know how to make Hereditary. You know this
- 1:26:21idea that I'm right. So it's like, you know, I think that
- 1:26:25it's had a huge influence on so many people, whether they admit to it
- 1:26:28or not. And really it's because and of course it's reaching back to I
- 1:26:32don't know, it feels like I'm about to get into recommendations here, so
- 1:26:34I don't want to. Well, I'm ready, I'm ready. Okay,
- 1:26:36are you ready? Yeah, So I'll just continue on that train of thought.
- 1:26:40It feels like it's reaching back to a tradition of very historically grounded,
- 1:26:46religiously grounded, almost you know, dramas slash. I would call them horror
- 1:26:53films, or at least genre films where it's like you're dealing with genre elements.
- 1:26:58So one of my recommendations, because I have two, is there's there's
- 1:27:01old and then there's more recent. So the old is Ingmar Bergmann's The Seventh
- 1:27:05Seal Yes, Yeah, which stars Max von sidao Uh as this Knight who
- 1:27:14uh is you know, literally playing chess with literal death, you know.
- 1:27:17But again again it's a similar question in Bergen's movie as it is Eggers's movie,
- 1:27:23which is is this meant to? Is this actually death or is it
- 1:27:27not? Is it just what this person is, you know, hallucinating or
- 1:27:30are they not? And it you know, it goes through a similar vibe
- 1:27:35of uh dealing with so many different themes of you know, religion, uh
- 1:27:44and the supernatural and you know what all that might mean as a through a
- 1:27:48filter of In this case, it's the Middle Ages, medieval Sweden, uh
- 1:27:53is when it's set and uh so you know it's it's it's concerning as the
- 1:27:58as the title refers to the Book of Revelation and you know, the end
- 1:28:00of the world and you know all of that stuff. So definitely check that
- 1:28:03out. If you dig The Witch, and if you dig The Witch and
- 1:28:05you want to see something that I think was very heavily inspired by it,
- 1:28:10then I would absolutely recommend the work of Oz Perkins, who were going to
- 1:28:14see a new movie from him this year called Long Legs Nicholas Cage, which
- 1:28:17we talked. Yes, and you can basically choose any of his movies because
- 1:28:21he's only got three so far, which are Black Coat's Daughter, I'm the
- 1:28:26Pretty Thing that Lives in the House, and Gretel and Hansel. Gretel and
- 1:28:29Hansel's probably the closest. That's my favorite of that. I didn't like I'm
- 1:28:31the Pretty Thing that Lives and I was so boring, boring, But yeah,
- 1:28:35so definitely if you dig the sort of folk horror e somn ambulance,
- 1:28:44painterly aspects of the witch that you're going to find a lot to like in
- 1:28:46Gretel and Hansel, but I think any of them will work too. Yeah,
- 1:28:50I really I loved the way Gretel and Hansel was shot. Yeah,
- 1:28:54it's beautiful, so cool, and I'm like, you, goddamn right,
- 1:28:57I want to a frame house. I'm going to just kill the witch and
- 1:29:00live here. So what you got for me? So mine's not exactly horror,
- 1:29:05I wouldn't say. It just depends on how you look at it.
- 1:29:08And I'm going with nineteen ninety six The Crucible, So it's Daniel d Lewis,
- 1:29:12it's the Wenona writer and an incredibly stack cast. And then the movie
- 1:29:15is about Arthur Miller's original book about the dramatized and personally fictionalized story of the
- 1:29:20Salem witch Trials that took place between ninety or nineteen, between sixteen ninety two
- 1:29:27and three. So yeah, not horror, but it is kind of horrifying
- 1:29:30what happened. And it is interesting to see Arthur Miller's perspective because it is
- 1:29:36such a very famous book and it does have name John Proctor. You know,
- 1:29:42all the people, Sarah, Sarah whatever, Sarah Miller. There's so
- 1:29:46many of them, Abigail, it's a lot of the people who were involved
- 1:29:50with it, but it took it to this whole like stage performance, but
- 1:29:53you are not not getting history in it. And I think it is a
- 1:29:57really good representation of how scary it it was to be a woman living in
- 1:30:01those times where if your husband made out with the hot young girl next door
- 1:30:10and then was like, I want to break this off, she could go
- 1:30:13to the people and be like, that chick is a witch. She came
- 1:30:15into my room last night and she grabbed my you know, she scratched my
- 1:30:18face, and you could potentially be taken. It was very real and it's
- 1:30:23very scary, and a lot of people died, and you know there,
- 1:30:28you know, it's DDL. Anything. DDL is top of the game.
- 1:30:31And this is no exception because he has that scene at the end where he's
- 1:30:35like, but it is my name, you know, and it's people really
- 1:30:39fighting to be like I can lie to you and say, yes, I
- 1:30:43was at the hand of the devil and live, but that's my name.
- 1:30:46You know. It's just a really you know, even if if it is
- 1:30:50a dramatization. It is a really good look of what was going on during
- 1:30:54those couple of years in Salem, and that is history. We did it.
- 1:30:57We did that shit just so everybody remembers. And you can blame it
- 1:31:00on the air got corn all you want, but it wasn't. It was
- 1:31:02because people were bitches. We didn't have the reality shows to get it out
- 1:31:08with. By the way, Sarah Miller was not in the Crucible. I
- 1:31:12just thought of that name because of Adam's family values and Thanksgiving. It sounds
- 1:31:15familiar. Who knows, Sarah, because I just told you I took it
- 1:31:18from the Thanksgiving play scene from Adam's family villa. Sarah Miller, you have
- 1:31:24Miller, Yeah, you have been. I guess that's where my brain was
- 1:31:27at. Arthur Miller. Arthur Miller is the same kind of thing. But
- 1:31:30that was also a really great stage play, which I would have loved to
- 1:31:32go see. And if you go to Salem, I mean they have the
- 1:31:36Witch Museum, which is like it's like an audio dramatization of what's going on,
- 1:31:43and there's you know, it's a small world in Disney popp like not
- 1:31:46puppets, but like dummies around which I was like sitting there, like if
- 1:31:50I work there, that is the last place I would want to be the
- 1:31:54last person in at the end of the night. It is so creepy and
- 1:31:58scary. But you know, you get to learn about this part of history.
- 1:32:02And I will tell everybody go to Salem, even if you just do
- 1:32:05the which part of it, in the history part for a little part of
- 1:32:09the day. It is a beautiful city, just one of our earliest cities.
- 1:32:13They filmed a little part of this movie there and it was when they're
- 1:32:16living there's a when they're leaving the colony. There is a place in Salem
- 1:32:20and it's like old pioneer town or old colonial village, and it is it's
- 1:32:26seen in hocus Pocus and many other movies where they kept the houses looking exactly
- 1:32:30how they look back then. And it is just fascinating because if you watch
- 1:32:35The Witch and you go, that's crazy. I don't know how anyone lived
- 1:32:39like that. That's how everybody lived. Yeah, And also I'm sure when
- 1:32:43you're visiting Salem you can do a great Aban Costello routine with a museum where
- 1:32:45you can be like, how do you get team museum? They say which
- 1:32:48museum? Yes, ah ah. And on that note, thank you all
- 1:33:02for joining us for this episode of Bill and Ashley's Tater, part of the
- 1:33:08Stranded Panda network. You can find my work in the show notes links below.
- 1:33:13Check us out on social media. You can find this show at Strandedpanda
- 1:33:15dot com and everywhere else you get your podcasts. If you have questions or
- 1:33:19comments, please feel free to write to us at Bill and ash Terror Theater
- 1:33:24at gmail dot com. We're dying to hear from you, see you and
- 1:33:28your nightmares. Would thou like to live deliciously