Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Dealership Service for Electric Vehicles
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we are strapping in for a
- 0:15really high voltage analysis of the automotive service industry.
- 0:18We really are. We're looking at this massive, I
- 0:21mean, seismic shift from the world.
- 0:23We all know internal combustion engines, ICE vehicles to the
- 0:28much quieter, cleaner world of electric vehicles, Ev's, and
- 0:31this isn't just about what you're driving.
- 0:34It's a fundamental change for every single mechanic, every
- 0:37service Bay, and really the entire business model of
- 0:41automotive repair. That's the critical insight, and
- 0:44it hits the service department right where it hurts, you know,
- 0:46in the revenue projections. Oh, yeah.
- 0:48Our sources all point to this, well, devastating challenge for
- 0:51traditional auto shops. EVs just require significantly
- 0:54less routine service. How much less are we talking?
- 0:57We're talking a drop in that guaranteed maintenance revenue,
- 0:59which is like the lifeblood of these businesses, somewhere
- 1:03between 40 and 60%. 40 to 60%, wow, that's a staggering number.
- 1:07And it's because all those routine services that, you know,
- 1:10paid the bills, they're just gone.
- 1:12We're talking about stripping out oil changes, spark plug
- 1:15replacements, timing belts, transmission fluid.
- 1:18Exhaust system repairs, all of it.
- 1:21Those were the reliable high frequency money makers.
- 1:24Precisely. They provided steady cash flow
- 1:27and guaranteed that you'd see your customer a few times a
- 1:29year. The question now is, well, how
- 1:33do mechanics survive, let alone thrive, when their whole
- 1:36business model just vanishes? That is the mission for this
- 1:39deep dive. We're going to unpack the
- 1:41sources and figure out exactly what investments in time, money
- 1:45and expertise are required for mechanics and shops to
- 1:48successfully transition. And become those sought after EV
- 1:52technicians of the future. OK, let's unpack this new
- 1:54reality. What maintenance actually
- 1:56remains? Well, the maintenance landscape,
- 1:58it doesn't disappear. It just shifts dramatically.
- 2:00You know, it moves away from the powertrain to, well, everything
- 2:03else. The electric motor itself is
- 2:05comparatively simple, very robust, but the vehicle still
- 2:08has tires, brakes, suspension, and crucially, this highly
- 2:12complex electrical and computer architecture.
- 2:15So if the engine is essentially bulletproof, where does the bulk
- 2:20of the remaining mechanical work actually lie?
- 2:22I mean, tires, brakes, electrical systems, they've
- 2:26always been important. But the focus shifts to
- 2:29completely different types of failure and stress.
- 2:32It becomes about specialized services like what like deep
- 2:35battery health diagnostics. That requires specialized
- 2:39software, real expertise to monitor degradation and thermal
- 2:43management, and then you have software updates.
- 2:45Which are increasingly just happening over the air right OTA
- 2:48updates. Exactly over the air systems,
- 2:50which means the customer doesn't even need to come into the shop.
- 2:53But the mechanical parts that do remain, they take a real
- 2:56beating. The sources kept highlighting
- 2:58something they called the tire shock factor.
- 3:00What is that exactly? It's a very real phenomenon.
- 3:03It's caused by two things unique to EVs.
- 3:06First, their weight. They're just so much heavier
- 3:08because of those massive battery packs, right?
- 3:10And 2nd, you have the immense immediate torque delivery of
- 3:13electric motors. Those two factors combined put
- 3:16substantially more strain on the tires.
- 3:18Which just accelerates wear and tear.
- 3:20Dramatically. And that completely changes the
- 3:23service schedule. We saw data from 1 high mileage
- 3:26Tesla test vehicle. It ran for 400,000 miles.
- 3:30It recorded 59 total service visits, which is surprisingly
- 3:34similar to a heavily used gas car.
- 3:37But here's the kicker, 47% of those visits were specifically
- 3:42for tires or tire related issues.
- 3:45Almost half of all service visits just for rubber.
- 3:49That really changes the service calculation, doesn't it?
- 3:51Tires become the new oil change, the new high frequency revenue
- 3:55stream. So what about brakes?
- 3:57Well, regenerative braking, the system that uses the motor to
- 4:00slow the car down and recapture energy that significantly
- 4:03reduces wear on traditional brake pads and rotors.
- 4:07But those heavy battery packs, they have to be stressing other
- 4:09parts. They do the suspension system.
- 4:11Ah, OK, exactly. The increased weight puts
- 4:14substantial continuous stress on suspension components.
- 4:17We're talking struts, dampers, bushings, ball joints.
- 4:20So those parts still wear out. They do, and often they fail
- 4:23sooner than in a lighter ICE vehicle.
- 4:25So shops need to get ready for high frequency suspension
- 4:28service, not just tires. OK, this is where it gets really
- 4:31interesting, because the biggest barrier isn't the mechanical
- 4:35parts, it's the specialized knowledge needed to safely
- 4:38repair the high voltage architecture.
- 4:41This is the high stakes part of the equation.
- 4:43Dealerships always dealt with, you know, 12 Volt electrical
- 4:46systems, but the sheer complexity and power of an Ev's
- 4:49architecture that forces the biggest change.
- 4:52It absolutely does. We're talking high voltage
- 4:55systems and these massive battery packs.
- 4:58They necessitate a serious investment in training and
- 5:01special equipment just for proper safe handling and.
- 5:04Mechanics are dealing with systems carrying hundreds of
- 5:07volts. Hundreds of volts potential
- 5:09lethal shock hazards. So I have to ask, how does a
- 5:12standard mechanics training even prepare you for a risk like
- 5:15that? What does that training look
- 5:16like on? The training is intense and it
- 5:19focuses relentlessly on safety protocols.
- 5:22We're talking extensive certification and things like
- 5:25lockout tag out procedures to make sure the power is
- 5:27completely deactivated before anyone touches A component.
- 5:30It requires specialized insulated tools, category three
- 5:34safety gloves that have to be regularly tested, specific fire
- 5:37suppression systems just for lithium ion fires.
- 5:41The liability and safety standards are just exponentially
- 5:45higher. Which adds to the cost and time
- 5:47of getting certified I imagine. A lot.
- 5:49That makes perfect sense, and OK, while the high voltage
- 5:53systems are central, we can't overlook the other systems that
- 5:56come standard on pretty much every.
- 5:59New EV Advanced Driver Assistance Systems, or ADS.
- 6:01Yes. ADS, Absolutely.
- 6:03ADS relies on this complex network of sensors, cameras,
- 6:06radar units. They manage everything from
- 6:08adaptive cruise control to automatic emergency braking.
- 6:12And when those systems malfunction, or even after
- 6:14something as simple as a Fender Bender or a windshield
- 6:17replacement, they need what is it, a calibration?
- 6:20A complex and lengthy calibration process, yes.
- 6:23And this requires highly specialized labor and, well,
- 6:26incredible precision. How precise?
- 6:28We're talking millimeter level tolerances.
- 6:31If you replace a headlight assembly or a windshield, you
- 6:34can trigger a three hour calibration sequence.
- 6:38It needs proprietary jigs, targets, special diagnostic
- 6:42software just to align the system perfectly.
- 6:44So fewer service visits overall, but each one requires much more
- 6:49time and highly specialized high value expertise.
- 6:52That's the trade off. So if a mechanic wants to future
- 6:55proof their career, they have to master both high voltage safety
- 6:59and this incredibly intricate sensor calibration for a DS.
- 7:03But the financial burden on the shop to achieve all of that,
- 7:06it's staggering, it really is. And the manufacturers, they're
- 7:09strict and rightly so. They often require all these
- 7:11training and equipment upgrades before they'll even let a dealer
- 7:14touch an EV. Which puts it out of reach for a
- 7:16lot of smaller independent shops.
- 7:17Exactly. They can't leverage that bulk
- 7:19purchasing power. And the sources we looked at
- 7:22gave specific numbers that really drive home the scale of
- 7:25this to set up a shop that is fully EV ready.
- 7:28We're talking specialized equipment, parts inventory,
- 7:31insulated tools, high speed chargers, OK.
- 7:34What's the number? It can cost anywhere from
- 7:35140,000 to $280,000. Wow, that's a massive capital
- 7:41outlay. Now contrast that with just
- 7:44becoming ADS equipped. Getting a shop ready for camera
- 7:47and sensor calibration is estimated to cost much less.
- 7:51Right. Generally between 40 thousand
- 7:53$70,000. So when you look at those
- 7:55totals, it's pretty clear why experts are saying it will be
- 7:58exceptionally difficult for the average shop to afford to offer
- 8:02both. They have to choose a
- 8:03specialization. You have to and that estimate,
- 8:06that big number, it only covers tools and training.
- 8:09It doesn't even fully account for the infrastructure changes.
- 8:11I mean, we're talking about upgrading the electrical service
- 8:15to the building, installing industrial grade fast chargers,
- 8:19maybe new Transformers to handle the higher electrical loads.
- 8:23Plus you need specialized heavy duty lifts.
- 8:26Why are standard lifts not good enough?
- 8:28It's the weight. The battery packs alone can
- 8:31weigh over 1000 lbs, so you need lifts rated for that increased
- 8:35load, but also designed to safely support the EV chassis
- 8:38while this massive battery pack is being dropped at the bottom.
- 8:42And here's a major physical reality check for shop owners.
- 8:45One source noted that removing an EV battery for repair can
- 8:48take up the physical space of an entire extra service Bay.
- 8:52Safe handling and storage during the process.
- 8:54Exactly. Suddenly, your physical space
- 8:57becomes a critical financial factor.
- 8:59That really raises an important question about the competitive
- 9:01landscape. I mean, given the proprietary
- 9:04equipment, the training, the huge upfront investment,
- 9:07independent shops are facing some really steep hurdles
- 9:10compared to the authorized dealerships.
- 9:12What are those specific barriers?
- 9:14Well, first just sourcing genuine parts.
- 9:17Lithium ion batteries, complex electronic control units, the
- 9:20ECU. They often have very limited, if
- 9:23any, aftermarket availability. So they're forced to buy
- 9:26expensive OEM parts. Right second is the high cost of
- 9:30sophisticated diagnostic tools like thermal imaging cameras you
- 9:34need to spot electrical faults or specialized battery testers.
- 9:38So if they can't get the parts or the special tools, they're
- 9:41locked out of major repairs. Essentially, yes.
- 9:44They struggle to keep pace with all the frequent software
- 9:47updates and they need access to manufacturer specific diagnostic
- 9:51portals which are often heavily guarded or just priced out of
- 9:54reach for smaller operations. And that naturally pulls
- 9:58customer loyalty toward the dealerships.
- 10:00Especially during the warranty period, owners are heavily
- 10:03incentivized to go to the dealer to keep that warranty coverage
- 10:06and protect the car's long term value.
- 10:09But there's a flip side for dealers.
- 10:11They might see more business from older post warranty EVs,
- 10:15but they have fewer chances to actually impress the customer
- 10:18because of the reduced service frequency.
- 10:20The whole customer journey just changes.
- 10:22What's so fascinating here is that the future business model,
- 10:25it just can't rely on the old way of doing things on service
- 10:29volume. Service providers have to
- 10:31incorporate, innovate and invest aggressively to offset that 40
- 10:35to 60% revenue loss. Let's talk about the innovation
- 10:38needed to make up that lost income.
- 10:40Technological incorporation is key.
- 10:43Companies are pushing heavily into predictive maintenance.
- 10:46Moving away from just scheduled check UPS.
- 10:49How does predictive maintenance translate to revenue though?
- 10:52It works by using IoT sensors and data analytics telematics to
- 10:57forecast when a component might fail before it actually happens.
- 11:01So the car tells the shop it needs a repair.
- 11:03Basically, yeah. Ford is using telematics to
- 11:05monitor vehicle health in real time.
- 11:08So instead of waiting for the customer to call when something
- 11:10breaks, the shop proactively schedules the repair.
- 11:13And that allows the shop to guarantee service revenue and
- 11:16schedule its labor more efficiently.
- 11:17Makes every service event more profitable and the software side
- 11:21is also becoming the main route for convenience too.
- 11:23Right. The digital convenience over the
- 11:25air updates are a huge part of that.
- 11:27We're seeing it from Tesla, BMWGM.
- 11:30They can fix bugs, enhance performance without you ever
- 11:33having to visit the shop. It's great for the customer
- 11:36experience and we're also seeing the rise of mobile service
- 11:39units. Like the ones from Nissan and
- 11:41Toyota? Yeah, or virtual maintenance
- 11:43consultations bringing that high value service directly to the
- 11:47customer's driveway. That's the convenience side, but
- 11:49let's circle back to the revenue streams.
- 11:52If the income from oil changes is gone, what replaces it to
- 11:56create steady revenue? New models are emerging around
- 11:59long term ownership and the big one is subscription services.
- 12:03Subscriptions for your car service.
- 12:04Exactly. Companies are exploring plans
- 12:07for things like battery replacements, software upgrades
- 12:10that unlock performance features, or extended
- 12:12warranties. It creates A predictable cost
- 12:15structure for the customer and a steady subscription based
- 12:18revenue stream for the provider. So the repair industry is
- 12:22basically turning into a software and services provider.
- 12:24In many ways, yes. So to sort of summarize the core
- 12:28mandate for the mechanic of the future, they have to be
- 12:31investing heavily in training in infrastructure and proprietary
- 12:36tools, not just to keep up, but to be able to command high
- 12:39prices for this very specialized safety critical labor.
- 12:43This transition isn't optional, it's a strategic imperative.
- 12:47The final analysis is that the service environment is going to
- 12:50be a dual service environment for the foreseeable future.
- 12:53Meaning what? Meaning service networks have to
- 12:55be able to support both IC and EV vehicles effectively.
- 13:00It requires a really carefully balanced strategic approach.
- 13:03Until this transition fully materializes, you have to
- 13:06account for both the old cash cow and the new high tech
- 13:09challenges. Which brings us back to those
- 13:11crucial high price tags we mentioned earlier.
- 13:13Considering that huge investment for being EV ready that 1:40 to
- 13:172:00 to $80,000, should an independent mechanic who's
- 13:21struggling with that capital prioritize high voltage systems?
- 13:24Or the other. PATH or focus on the less costly
- 13:28but increasingly high demand ADS calibration services which run
- 13:3340 to 70,000? Which PATH offers the better
- 13:37competitive edge in the near term?
- 13:39Is it volume or is it specialization?
- 13:42That's a big question and. That is something for you to
- 13:44Mull over as the automotive service landscape just
- 13:46fundamentally changes over the next decade.
- 13:49Always keep learning. Thank you for joining us on this
- 13:51deep dive into the service Bay of the future.
- 13:53If you found this useful, make sure you're subscribed and
- 13:56follow us for more deep dives into the sources you share with
- 13:58us.