Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Drops Office-by-Office Detail From Its 2027 Budget
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Hey, everyone. This is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors. Today, I'm gonna be chatting about NCUA's twenty twenty seven, twenty twenty eight draft budget. You're gonna hear me call it 2027. It's a two year budget so that in the event that NCUA doesn't have a full board or can't get a vote that they can still operate while they're trying to figure it out.
- 0:19So I'm gonna ignore the 2028 references to the best of... Best ability just to keep it keep it simple. So 2027 budget. What is it? What's changed?
- 0:31And what's missing? So the headline numbers, NCUA's budget is just over 325,000,000, an increase of 2.9% from last year. 972 FTEs. What's an FTE? A full time equivalent.
- 0:45That's up five from last year, but they are down 23% due to their buyouts from the peak of 1255 in the 2025 budget. The overhead transfer rate. What is it? 62%. Who does it apply to?
- 1:02State charters and NASCUS. That's something that NASCUS will comment on. They keep NCUA's feet to the fire relative to that, and it essentially is how much money gets assigned to the budgets of NCUA is related to insurance work and therefore state charters as part of that. The operating fee, it's down 49 basis points. That looks to me like a number where they said, hey.
- 1:23We want it to go down a little bit. How can we get there? And 49 basis points is better than 50, because it doesn't seem like it was made up. I'd... I'm joking a little bit there, but they had a huge operating fee decrease last year because of the reorg and the buyouts, etcetera, etcetera.
- 1:41So to have a a slight drop there, that's a good thing. So the budget is up 9,200,000 from the 2026 approved amount, and essentially, that's pay. NCUA is paying its staff. It's required to have comparability with other banking agencies and regulators, and they have a contract with the union, and they have to live up to that. And then when they pay the union x based on that, they typically pay nonunion similarly.
- 2:07As I mentioned, 49 basis points, reduction in the operating fee. It's a staff draft only, which it used to be a... It's driven by the board. Maybe not this year because because Cruz is so new, and I'll get into that a little bit. But calling it a staff draft is funny because the the board chair at least approves what goes out and what will be in it, and staff does have a a lot tied to it.
- 2:32A lot of effort tied to it. Used to be my Super Bowl. Took up a big chunk of my time from August through the end of the year when I was the executive director. They'll probably make a few tweaks. They tend to now build a little bit more in saying, hey.
- 2:45We listen so we can cut this and this for a better narrative. So we'll watch for that and see what falls out based on the comments that come in. So why the budget jumped... Why the operating budget jumps 8.2%? We've got contracted services up.
- 3:00And by the way, the operating budget increases more than the other budgets, which was why this was different than the other number. Right? So pay and benefits is up, contracted services are up, travels down a little bit, rent and communication utilities up a little bit, and admin up a little bit. Who pays for it? 70% goes to federal credit unions via the operating fee and their share of the overhead transfer rate, 29.6%.
- 3:2330% for rounding is paid for state charters, which would be insurance related costs tied to the insurance function of doing exams at state chartered credit unions. The reorg, what's going on relative to the reorg? The target date is now December 2027. The goal is to prioritize statutory authorities and most... And the most critical work to reduce and consolidate business units with like functions, possibly ones going away or ones going back to the regions in some instances.
- 3:56And ones if you're... What what that acronym is, it's the Office of National Exam and Supervision. Essentially, every credit union over 15,000,000,000, and all corporate credit unions report to the Office of National Exam and in supervision. Goal is to achieve a higher supervisor to employee ratio. What does that mean?
- 4:14For every supervisory examiner in the field who supervises the examiners as a credit union, there will be more staff that report to them, and they'll be leaner at the supervisory level. And they're gonna use technology to increase staff efficiency. The office budget reflects the current structure while NCUA transitions to a new one. The office of the chief economist, it points out, has already been rolled into the office of examination of insurance. There's...
- 4:38Was $16,000,000 in a fund for reorganizing. They only spent about a million dollars of that. 4.3 of that is going to be earmarked for AI or what they're now calling SI, and I'll get into that. There's no re... New reorganization money in the 2027 budget, and no office is specifically named as consolidation, although they refer to the fact that they may be doing.
- 4:59The ONE's office, the draft doesn't say what's happening. So ONE's budget has gone down 1.2%, while the large Credit Union analytic tool, which is paid for out of the insurance fund, is going up 7.2%, and that relates mostly to the stress testing that they are committed to doing under their regulations. They lost a lot of the staff that handles that, so there is probably inflation in the tools that they're using and maybe getting a few more tools so they can do it without raising their FTEs and still meet their requirements per their regulation. FTEs... Last year's draft showed FTEs going from 57 to 34.
- 5:36Of course, I'm gonna get into the fact that this year's doesn't talk about how many FTEs they have, and there may be a couple of reasons for that. So AI arrives as in the budget, and AI is superintelligence. And $4,300,000 is earmarked from the 2020 reorganization, as I mentioned, earmarked for superintelligence or artificial intelligence. The president's new term for AI in executive order one four four three four is SI, but InsooA is, I think, appropriately calling it SI slash AI. What's it for?
- 6:10Supervision analytics. And again, this is according to the document. Fraud detection, operational efficiency. Some of the new five positions will go into AI. Some meaning more than more than zero and less than five, and is paired with a zero trust cybersecurity push that the agency is going to be having, and you can expect cybersecurity just as it costs more of your budget every year to cost more of NCUA's budget.
- 6:33Questions the draft doesn't answer. Will examiners use Aon credit union data in exams? What governance and model risk controls apply to NCUA's use of it? How will results be explained to credit unions and which vendors and where does will NCUA contract with and where does the data go? YSI, a September executive order.
- 6:55Executive order one four four three four, inaugurating the era of superintelligence. It renames it renames it. Agencies shall use superintelligence and SI in place of artificial intelligence and AI in correspondence, websites, reports, policy documents. Limits to the maximum extent permitted by law. Non statutory documents only.
- 7:17No need to change past regulations, contracts, or grants. Regarding the definition of superintelligent means exactly what the law already calls AI. Next steps: the science advisor will propose a statutory definition within sixty days. Those sixty days would be the end of November, roughly. It's a name.
- 7:37It's not a mandate. The order changes the label. It doesn't require agencies to buy or use anything. What it means for NCUA's draft, SI slash AI is a new federal vocabulary for NCUA even though they're only supposed to say SI. This is the artist formerly known as Prince.
- 7:53Remember when Prince, the the Purple Rain guy from Minnesota, big fan, saw him once back in the day, changed his name to a signal, and that's a symbol. That symbol was known as TAF Cap, if you read it, the artist formerly known as Prince. Similarly to when the executive director, two before me, wanted to reduce NCUA's pay or growth of the salaries and came up with the lump sum where they got... If you hit a cap, you got half your money in lump sum, and you got the other portion in a merit increase. Lump sum became a four letter word, so he wanted to call it pay policy.
- 8:30And then he started briefing the ends to a board, and they looked at him like he had three heads. What's the pay policy? And I had to say it's like the artist formerly known as Prince. He used to be a lump. Now it's pay policy because we don't wanna say lump.
- 8:41So Trump doesn't wanna say AI, probably because artificial sounds bad and super sounds good. What's in a name? Right? That... Shakespeare who said that?
- 8:50Anyway, I digress. So new initiatives and new money, new laws, the genius act, stablecoin issuers, and the twenty first century road to housing act drives some potential rulemaking and potentially a new position. And when I say new position, that would probably be in the stablecoin side. My words, not NCUA's. Deregulation project year two turns to more complex regulations with broader policy and operational implications.
- 9:15What does that mean? I've said a lot of their deregulations was happy to glad. There were some good things out there, and they've made some changes recently on incidental powers, on how the... How your bond works, your Fidelity bond, etcetera. They're saying they're gonna go into the more complex regs.
- 9:32So what would that be? The commercial loan role, risk based capital? Time will tell. But that's a positive if they go there because that could actually lead to a lesser regulatory footprint for you and your credit union. Chartering, a new charter system, 300 to fully digitize chartering workflows.
- 9:49Cybersecurity, I mentioned the 4,700,000. That includes a $3,000,000 firewall refresh, the largest single capital item. Systems changes, the CDRLF grant system six zero five ks set aside for e discovery 300 ks, conferencing six seven hundred and fifty k, and board priorities 500 k. That one I'd be curious about. Liquidations, AMAC liquidation tracking tool, a $106,000, and anything done in AMAC is a share insurance fund cost, and it'll get charged directly to the fund, not tied to the budget.
- 10:24Material loss reviews, I've talked a lot about Jackson, the Area Federal Credit Union. That's gonna be a large material loss review if they have any other things that come out of the woodwork. The draft says that material loss reviews, it appears only once in a bullet in the contracted services category, audit and financial management support. That category is 4.4% of contracts, about 3,200,000 gross, and it includes shares with audits, investigations, and financial management for the inspector general. The inspector general budget does go up from 4.1 to 4.8.
- 10:57My guess is that is going to be contracting potentially tied to these material cost reviews that they may not have the staff for. So what's missing? The draft went from a p... A high of a 109 pages to 26. And what went and when did it go?
- 11:13So the draft budget keeps getting shorter. In 2017, this is when we knew the law was going to be put in place. The budget draft was 53 pages, then the law went in place. '8... 2018, it was 98 pages.
- 11:27In 2019, it increased another four pages to one zero two. In 2020, increased another six pages to one zero eight. That's when I left. That was the last budget I was involved with at NCUA. I retired and became a...
- 11:40Doing what I'm doing now in June 2020. The 2021 draft, the first one after me, had one more page at a 109 and then the slide of pages, and theoretically, the slide of transparency went in the opposite direction. 2022, it went down 11 pages to 98. 2023, it went down 14 pages to 84. In 2024, it went down another 20 pages to 64.
- 12:032025, it actually went the other direction, went up eight pages to 72. Last year, it fell in half from 72 to 35. So what's that? A reduction of 37 pages. And this year, it went down another nine pages to 26 pages.
- 12:19So since its peak in 2021 at a 109 pages, it's down to 26 pages, and that's a drop in pages of 76%. So 76% less transparent, at least 76% less words and verbiage, right, and numbers. Right? So if you use a proxy... If you use volume as a word for transparency, they are less less transparent.
- 12:44And what was the reason for the regulation being put or the act being changed by congress? It was so that NCUA was more transparent. So you could argue that that is not being done. I would argue that some of the changes make sense, and there was a lot of superfluous stuff here that got added over time. But they did take away one thing that I think they'll be putting back soon, and they may have had good reasons for it, but it's glaring that it's gone.
- 13:07So, specifically, what disappeared and when in 2019? Fact sheets, including the budget and financial transparency. Fact sheet left the budget 2023. Individual board member office budgets disappeared and economic outlook and other risk factors that was probably driven by one board member who had something in their budget who didn't want it to be shown, so they put them all into one. 2024, the organizational charts, the enterprise risk management and financial stewardship, budget trends, and staffing section went away.
- 13:38They may have gone elsewhere and may have not been needed here, or it may have been an attempt to have less transparency. You decide. 2025, the agency history and federal compliance costs went away. The agency history can be found elsewhere. This was probably a good change.
- 13:53Why Why did it need to be here? It was redundant. The federal compliance costs, my recollection is that tied to the Mark McWaters area, the era where we wanted to show that these things we had to do and these costs we couldn't control and were mandated by other federal agencies, and they've done away with that. 2026, missions and goals, budget by strategic goal, project by project capital profiles all went away, probably went somewhere else, but also probably not in totality, so a little bit less transparency. And then here in red, if you're watching on YouTube, 2027.
- 14:26What's gone away? Positions by office, per office line items for pay, travel, rent, admin, and contracts. I believe this will be the focal point of what the trade associations, America's Credit Units, DC, UC, and NASCUS. And, usually, the go west loves to come and show that they're relevant here at these things, and they'll probably comment about it too. And what's missing?
- 14:48So last year, for example, the office detail. Last year for the Office of Examination, for example, it would show there were 50 positions, salaries of 11,000,000, benefits of between 4 and 5,000,000, travel of 400 k, rent of 24 k, admin of 46 k, contracted services of just about 1,000,000 for a total of 17,400,000. This year, all it says is the budget is 20,200,000. There's no positions, no pay, no travel, or contract split. E and I, how was it...
- 15:17How did they absorb the office of the chief economist? How many people? You can't really tell. So that's substantial. Why did they do it?
- 15:25Couple ideas. Cruz is new. He stepped in when all of this would be putting in play. He probably doesn't know enough to what he might wanna put into what office. He knows they're gonna do a reorg in 2027, and he probably wants to hear what you say, and he probably wants to hear what staff says at the budget.
- 15:42So glass half full, he didn't wanna commit to something here that he wasn't comfortable committing to, and that's a positive. So maybe this detail will come out. It probably will, but that might be the reason. And they might state it at the hearing that it's a reason. That's a good reason.
- 15:54Another reason they might not have it. NCUA in 2025 announced to their staff that ones was going away, that that cure was... Things were moving in and out of cure and things were going to the regions, and then they didn't do it. They did some of it, but they didn't do a lot of it. Why didn't they do it?
- 16:10Perhaps Haltman got cold feet and didn't wanna do it. Perhaps it was the union exercising their rights. Perhaps it was both of those things, but a one member board making all of these final changes. Probably, it's not something if I was a one board member that I would wanna do. I would wanna have an accomplice in that vote because there's still...
- 16:28Jury is still out on whether a quorum is won and whether or not they need to to act. Whether that'll ever be resolved, I don't know. But the best way to resolve it would be to get another board member in. And, of course, there's the whole Otzka Harper lawsuit situation. And how will that play out?
- 16:46I have heard there's no the administration's got a lot more priorities than who's gonna sit on the NCUA board, but that that also plays into it. And, of course, if you tell the staff that the offices are going away and then you put FTEs in and then you don't do it, that's one thing. And I I believe it's possible that they know what they think they might be doing, but why say it's gonna be 45 FTEs this year instead of 50 and then have it change because that staff looks that as telegraphing where it's going, and it does telegraph it. So don't put the detail in. That would be another good reason for dropping this out.
- 17:23And, again, this is... I've not talked to anybody at NCHW about this. This is me having the... Done the budget for eight years as the executive director, three years as the deputy executive director of why I think this might be happening, the good reasons for why it might be happening. The bad reason is they decided to not be as transparent, and I don't think that's it.
- 17:42So why congress required it in the first place? In 2008, public budget hearings stopped. They were put in place by then chairman Dennis Dollar. Deputy Manette stopped it in 2015. Mulvaney...
- 17:54The Mulvaney and Senate bill at a July hearing. Mulvaney presses for line item data and protests the OTR redactions. Don't get me into redactions. NCUA redacts far more than they legally should. They've got a lot of dead links in a lot of their web pages.
- 18:11I make vague references to that here. Frequently, it's something I've got on my agenda to talk to NCUA about down the road, but that's what put it in play. In 2016, a house report said that the bill will increase transparency and accountability, yet the pages are declining. 2018, it becomes law that they have to publish the draft, hold hearings, and answer comments. And NCUA once said, Office by office detail is a transparency win.
- 18:38So if I was a trade association, I would say just this, that in its Budget and Financial Transparency Fact Sheet 2017 and 2018, NCUA said at stakeholders' request, NCUA began publishing a separate budget for every office broken out by category instead of one agency wide total. The 2027 draft goes back to totals only. So I believe that'll be a big focus of what is said by the associations. What does the law actually say on this? The board shall, on an annual basis and prior to the submission of the detailed business type budget required in paragraph two, make publicly available and publish in the Federal Register a draft of the detailed business type budget and hold a public hearing with public notice, providing of the hearing during which the public may submit comments on the draft of the detailed business type, and prepare annually and submit a detailed business type budget as provided for wholly owned government corporations, which shall address any comments submitted by the public under paragraph one.
- 19:40They will publish a draft, they will hold a hearing, and they will answer comments. So make your comments or ask to speak. Credit unions have occasionally spoke, and that would be a good thing. What are the fair counterpoints? Some of the changes are legitimate.
- 19:54The stabilization fund closed in 2017. Of course, you don't need that anymore. History and org charts are just background. And there was one year that it went up. 2025, it went up eight pages.
- 20:05And this information may live elsewhere, and it may live not. But, anyway, it's gone down quite a bit, 76%, which is less transparent. I think in the future, it'll go back up. And, again, pages aren't proof, but that's a pretty substantial drop. So what to watch for, what to ask for, file a comment.
- 20:22The law requires that they address it at the hearing. What's going on with the reorganization? Ones, what's happening there? A lot of interest there in my clients and in conversations that I have. At AI, SI, how will NCUA use those tools, and what will the governance be so that it's done in a safe and sound manner that will not expose your data?
- 20:42And in December, what's gonna happen? Where does this budget land? What happens in November when they do the hearing? I don't have the date in front of me. I didn't write that down, but that's always interesting.
- 20:51I always enjoy what is said there by the trades, what is said by NCUA and NCUA staff, and there might be a little bit more revealed there. I will do a follow-up podcast possibly with some guests at that juncture, but this is my first take. As always, I wanna thank you for listening. I've got a little bit of a cold. Hopefully, that didn't come through to who here too much on what's going on here, but it is definitely cold season recording this here at the end of October.
- 21:16This will go live on Monday just before the election. Make sure you get out and vote. As always, I wanna thank you for listening. Thank you for watching. I hope you'll do that again soon.
- 21:25If you don't subscribe, please do. If you like this, please share it with somebody else. Please comment on our LinkedIn posts. That helps the algorithms, and please give us some feedback. If you like this podcast, rate us on iTunes, Apple Podcasts, etcetera, etcetera.
- 21:41Thank you so much. We've got some exciting podcasts coming up, and this is Mark Trichol signing off with Flying Colors.