Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #210 - Michelle Cyca
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. This is Van Color. Welcome back to This is Van Color.
- 0:24Housing is expensive, and maybe I'm a cynical curmudgeon, but I'm not
- 0:29convinced that any elected official is even interested in reducing the market price of homes
- 0:35or even the cost of rent. Here to restore my faith in our leaders,
- 0:39or maybe fuel my cynicism is a returning friend of the show, a
- 0:42contributing editor to McLean's magazine. You can also find her in The Walrus,
- 0:46The Tayee, and Canadian Business. She is Michelle Sisa and this conversation is
- 0:51supported by Shelter Point Single Malt Whiskey, distinctly Vancouver Island, uniquely shelter Point.
- 0:58Hi Michelle, I'm so nice to see you again. Thanks for being
- 1:02here. Yeah, thanks for having me back. I got this big problem
- 1:04with the whole housing discourse, particularly on the political level. I feel like
- 1:07every politician is talking about how they want to make housing more affordable, but
- 1:12they forget the part where they have to reduce everyone else's home value and equity
- 1:18in their own home in order to bring down prices. So I want to
- 1:23ask you. You've covered this quite extensively. Do politicians actually have an interest
- 1:27in making the market price of home ownership more affordable. I mean, I
- 1:36think they would like to imagine they could do that without sort of flattening prices,
- 1:41but that's impossible because I'm not an economist. But I think anyone can
- 1:46understand that part of the problem with the housing market is that housing is scarce.
- 1:49There's not enough of it, people compete for it, and we need
- 1:52to build a lot more. But if we build enough for everybody, that's
- 1:55going to cool the market. It's going to bring prices down a little bit,
- 1:57or at least flatten them out. And so people who've been betting on
- 2:01the value of their home continuing to go up the way it's gone up rapidly
- 2:05in the last fifteen years are going to be disappointed by that. They're not
- 2:07going to like it. And we're still in a state in Canada where there's
- 2:12more homeowners than renters. It's about sixty something percent now. And also homeowners
- 2:19tend to be older, older people tend to vote more. Politicians really don't
- 2:23want to alienate wealthy older Canadians, right, so they don't want to do
- 2:28anything to affect their wealth their retirement. So they keep saying that they're going
- 2:30to just build more housing, but it's sort of abstract, like where they're
- 2:34going to build it and how it's not going to affect other people's values.
- 2:38We see this in Vancouver. Every time there's like a proposed apartment building in
- 2:40a residential area, people start complaining that it's going to bring their value of
- 2:46their home doown? Yeah, right, And that's considered a legitimate reason to
- 2:49opposet housing for other people. So it's just, you know, it's this
- 2:52like constant question where you supposed to build it, Like Doug Ford is arguing
- 2:55he should be building it in the green Belt which was formerly like Technic and
- 3:00build some single family homes out there, as if that's going to fix the
- 3:04crisis. You know. So, but in fairness, isn't our you know,
- 3:07certainly Vancouver's economy, but I think even our national economy is so tied
- 3:12to housing, particularly in the financialization and the commodification of housing, where if
- 3:16suddenly you start to have mortgages under water, or just a big reduction in
- 3:23home prices or home values, it could tank the entire economy. Right,
- 3:25Like we're kind of stuck. Yes, we're super overreliant on housing. To
- 3:30prop up our economy and in many ways, like the GDP, and the
- 3:35sort of growth and financial health of the country is artificially dependent on real estate.
- 3:39Right. We kept inflation rates really low and interest rates really low so
- 3:45that people could borrow these giant mortgages to buy more housing, and now everything
- 3:50is really dependent on that. I think one fifth of our national wealth is
- 3:53in housing, and real estate is the biggest sector of our economy, so
- 3:57nobody really wants to disrupt that. So ultimately the dream of owning a home
- 4:02is going to be increasingly more and more inaccessible. Yeah, Like, it's
- 4:08not going to be more accessible. It's not going to be you're not going
- 4:10to get prices to a level where like if you save up, you know,
- 4:14a reasonable amount, you can buy a home exactly because you know,
- 4:16for much of the twentieth century, Canada started building a lot of housing after
- 4:21World War Two, and there was a lot of federal investment in housing until
- 4:25the early eighties. And at that time you sort of had the price of
- 4:29housing track more or less with income. So as people's income's rows, the
- 4:31price of housing rows, but they were tracking each other and that's really stopped.
- 4:35So incomes have grown much more slowly than real estate. And what that
- 4:40means is, if you got into the real estate game a long time ago,
- 4:42your wealth has gone up, you can continue buying housing and stowing housing.
- 4:46But if you're left behind on that curve, if you're just trying to
- 4:47save enough money to buy a place in Toronto or Vancouver without pre existing housing
- 4:51wealth or generational wealth, you're pretty screwed. Like there's just no real way
- 4:57in. And so that's bad enough, But I all so feel like politicians
- 5:01don't have an inherent interest to even make rent more affordable, if only for
- 5:06the reason that so many of them own rental properties and are earning side income
- 5:12from this mental properties. So why would they want to you know, why
- 5:15wouldn't they want to cut their income in half? Exactly for Canadians, I
- 5:18guess the MP for Vancouver Grandville flipped something like thirty three properties in the last
- 5:25ten years. I mean, it's and I think if you go to the
- 5:27Maple they have a great database on this where they've tracked all the MPs who
- 5:32have an investment in housing. It's thirty eight percent of our members of Parliament
- 5:36are landlords or they own investment properties. So that's a pretty large segment,
- 5:42and it's across political parties, right, across political parties. Yeah, every
- 5:45political party has members who are involved in the financialization of housing, who have
- 5:49a stake in that. And you know, I think since the federal government
- 5:54withdrew from investing in purpose built rental and social housing, which was in the
- 5:59early eighties, and they've never really reinvested, it became a provincial responsibility.
- 6:03As Justin Trudeau reminded everybody recently, there just hasn't been a lot of rental
- 6:08stock. So the assumption is, you know, people can buy condos and
- 6:12rent them out. They become small mom and pop landlords. And we're now
- 6:15at a point where more investors are buying real estate than first time buyers because
- 6:19again you have that compounding effect. If you already own real estate, it's
- 6:23easy to buy more. And that doesn't work because people want to maximize the
- 6:28profit of their investment, so they have an incentive to evict renters if their
- 6:30rent is below market, right, you know, they do rent evictions,
- 6:33or they say they're going to move into the suite, or they just sell
- 6:35the unit and then the new owners want to move in. Right, So
- 6:39there's very little stability for people renting in that system, and there's a lot
- 6:42of incentives for people to prioritize greed over creating livable conditions. And so basically,
- 6:46what I'm hearing is that the people who are in charge keep telling us
- 6:50that they have all the solutions to fix these issues, especially if they're an
- 6:54opposition party, right, like, oh, the current government is bad or
- 6:57the past government was terrible, but ultimately they don't have an interest in reducing
- 7:02the cost of homeownership or the cost of renting. Is that a fair assessment.
- 7:06I think that is a fair assessment. I think they would like,
- 7:09so we're screwed. There's no help here, I think. I think we're
- 7:14produce screwed. I think the best hope is, honestly for renters to mobilize
- 7:19and recognize their kind of collective interests. And we're seeing in Toronto there have
- 7:24been rent strikes. In Montreal, there was like an amazing story about one
- 7:27woman who refused to move out of her apartment after a developer bought the building.
- 7:30Like, I think we're starting to see a real sort of class war
- 7:34emerging between renters and landlords. Does that does that lend itself to a political
- 7:39space where party can come in and almost be like the party for renters,
- 7:44whether it's provincially or federally. I think so yeah, And I think to
- 7:47some extent the Conservative government is or the Conservative Party is appealing to that.
- 7:53There's a disenfranchisement, especially among younger generations who just see that the economy has
- 7:57gotten worse, that their prospects have gotten worse, that they probably are never
- 8:01going to own a home in their lifetime, and you can really mobilize that
- 8:03anger. I think, like you have a lot of resentment against people who
- 8:07came into their adulthood at a totally different time in the country's social history,
- 8:11and we're able to get secure jobs and pensions and homes and none of that
- 8:16is left for They're mobilizing that anger, but their solutions again don't speak to
- 8:20what has to be done, which is reducing the value of right. So
- 8:22yeah, I think, I mean, I think all politicians play from the
- 8:24same playbook. We see this meansipally, provincially federally, where they make a
- 8:28lot of promises to change things to get elected yea. Then once they're in
- 8:31office, they're like more reluctant to actually put those into progress. Right,
- 8:35they start saying like, we're going to do some studies, we're going to
- 8:37do some public polling. Eventually we'll get around to it, and then by
- 8:39the next election cycle they could promise they're going to fix the problem again.
- 8:43Right, And in the meantime they can just blame the last party who's empowered.
- 8:48So the Conservatives blame the Liberal Party, the Liberals blame the Conservatives,
- 8:50the NDP can blame everybody. Yeah, it's you know, they're just passing
- 8:54it around. We are now in the podcast exclusive part of my chats with
- 9:00legitimately one of my favorites, Michelle Sisa. Congratulations on the baby. Thank
- 9:05you, and this economy I know, crazy a second kid, that's just
- 9:09greedy throwing money away. No, congratulations, Thanks so much for being here.
- 9:15I know it's a it is a lot to get away from your two
- 9:18kids, so but also a rare pleasure. So thank you for the excuse
- 9:22before we shift gears. Was there anything else that you want to discuss on
- 9:26the housing front. I don't have any more questions for you, but was
- 9:30there anything that that you wanted to miss in that very depressing conversation. I
- 9:33mean, I guess the only thing I wish i'd mentioned was, you know,
- 9:37I think one thing that can kind of straddle the middle ground in housing
- 9:41affordability where it's not just like owners versus renters, is this like investor class
- 9:46of people who are accumulating multiple properties, which is growing all the time.
- 9:50I think it would be very easy for the government to make investing or investor
- 9:54ownership less appealing, like yeah, I know, I agree, and that
- 10:00you know, that's not punishing like current homeowners who just want to be able
- 10:03to rely on their home as their retirement fund, which is the situation for
- 10:07a lot of seniors. And it would you know, level the playing field
- 10:09for those people who are trying to get into the housing market. But that's
- 10:11where I feel like there's all this opportunity to close those loops, and I
- 10:16don't see any politicians moving on that. That's it is wild, because like
- 10:20that form of passive income is not particularly economically productive, and I feel like
- 10:26anytime I've pointed this out on Twitter or on the radio, I will get
- 10:30hordes of landlords being so mad at me, where I'm just like, no,
- 10:33we should tax it, Moore, we should disincentivize this system. And
- 10:37they say, oh, well, you know, housing wouldn't get built if
- 10:39it wasn't for us, and if it wasn't for us, and it's like,
- 10:43but I don't know, maybe maybe if it was already decentivized, more
- 10:48people would own homes or you know, could see that dream of saving up
- 10:50and purchasing their first home. And so I do think it's a broken system,
- 10:56and I it sounds weird, but I almost feel like the only hope
- 11:00at this point, the reasonable hope at this point, is like a two
- 11:03tier system of yes, we still have homeownership and home values at a relatively
- 11:07good rate, but we've a relatively good growth rate, but we've disincentivized owning
- 11:15rental properties to the point where maybe we can stabilize rents. Yeah, exactly,
- 11:20I think. You know, Paul Kershaw of Jen Squeeze has said this
- 11:22a lot, that the best option for everybody would be if prices just sort
- 11:26of flattenote for a long time, so the incomes can catch up and first
- 11:30time homebuyers can kind of catch up. You don't want to crash, but
- 11:33the growth we've had in the last fifteen years since like two thousand and eight
- 11:37is not sustainable. Or realistic, like it's crazy that some people's homes have
- 11:41doubled in value in the last couple of years, and and so you know,
- 11:46there needs to be this reversal I think to thinking of a home is
- 11:48like a lifetime investment where maybe year over year goes up a little bit,
- 11:52but the idea is like it's your home for life. It's not an investment.
- 11:56It's not something you can flip in a couple of years to make money.
- 12:00Or you know us as as a passive income stream by exploiting renters continuously.
- 12:07That's that's something I think that really has to change. And I mean,
- 12:09like Airbnb is something that I think you are seeing some some changes around
- 12:16in municipalities that are really squeezed by it, where people realize they can make
- 12:20way more money on Airbnb than of course having a renter. Why not just
- 12:24you know, have as many Airbnb's as possible. And that's not good for
- 12:28a city, it's not good for neighborhoods. It's like a terrible way to
- 12:31think about housing as this economic asset. And I think that's one where you
- 12:35know, a politician that bans Airbnb can say they're doing something kind of substantially.
- 12:41I also feel like it would be quite popular. Yeah if people hate
- 12:43airbnb. Yeah, and I know, I know, BC Housing Minister Revue
- 12:48Kalon has you know, continued to signal that something is coming. I feel
- 12:50like it should have. You know, happened a long time ago. You
- 12:54see these things on Twitter about you know, the city Vancouver not even properly
- 12:58enforcing short term rentals. It's just such a frustrating space where it's like,
- 13:03I feel like it could be easy to one ban but okay, if for
- 13:07not even going there, just enforce the rules that are on the books,
- 13:09which don't even seem enforced. Yeah, and you know, there's a degree
- 13:13to which, if you're making enough money, getting hit with a fine every
- 13:16once in a while is probably like just the cost of doing business. I
- 13:20think there's probably should send them to prison, send a labor cans to break.
- 13:28Yeah, you know, they could be doing a lot. But if
- 13:31there's one thing you can say about the City of Vancouver, and we can
- 13:33say it soon, it's that there's no process that they can't make more complicated
- 13:37than it needs to be through like endless consultations. Yeah, let's okay,
- 13:41let's let's shift gears. Let's talk about it. People who watch the show
- 13:43or listen to my recent rant just heard me basically theorize that the City of
- 13:50Vancouver's attitude has become one of I got mine, fuck you, And I
- 13:54feel like it's happened on several different files and areas. And you know,
- 13:58I can understan and that people in a city particularly and just people in general,
- 14:03can be apathetic indifferent to the needs of others. What I've what I'm
- 14:09trying to point out in that rant is that I think that with this ABC
- 14:13supermajority, we're not seeing just apathy, but we're seeing city council in city
- 14:18Hall catering towards anger, towards social policy, social programs that are just relief
- 14:26to crises, right, They're not expected to solve the crises that they're in.
- 14:31And so we have now a city council that is voting down expansion of
- 14:35childcare, which is getting rid of overdose prevention sites in a public health emergency.
- 14:41You're much smarter than I am. Am I wrong here? Or has
- 14:43there been a shift in the City of Vancouver and maybe catering towards dismantling some
- 14:48of these social programs yeah, I mean I think I think the election was
- 14:52kind of an inflection point because ABC really campaign on this sort of public safety
- 14:58fearmongering campaign and and I think they had this cozy relationship with the VPD where
- 15:03they had promised to hire a bunch of new cops and increase the vpd's budget
- 15:07kind of to whatever degree they wanted to. And so leading up to the
- 15:11election, you saw this kind of like propaganda of like, you know,
- 15:16violent crime is going up, random crime is going up. Every day,
- 15:18there's all this random crime happening. It could happen to you. It was
- 15:22like really creating this atmosphere of fear where people became really paranoid. They said,
- 15:26you know, like violent crime is everywhere and everyone is a threat to
- 15:31me. And you see that now when people oppose things like social housing or
- 15:35safe injection sites in their neighborhood, they're still drawing on this well of like
- 15:39all of these people are a threat to me and my safety, and they
- 15:41deserve to be here. They're too close to a school, they're too close
- 15:43to a playground. Like you know, this idea that you should be able
- 15:48to make this whole segment of society just disappear, and a lot of that
- 15:50just wasn't really true. Like I think there are obviously some random violent crime
- 15:56in Vancouver and in every city, but the idea that that should be the
- 16:00thing guiding all of our social policy and relations with our neighbors is crazy.
- 16:04Yeah, but that that worked for ABC, that got them elected. I
- 16:07think they really played up this idea that like Vancouver's unsafe, there's a lot
- 16:12of scary people. They're coming to your neighborhood, They're going to threaten you
- 16:15in your way of life, and we need to deal with it by hiring
- 16:18a bunch of cops. Yeah. Yeah, it's It's interesting because you know,
- 16:23the overdose prevention site that they are going to shut down, it's not
- 16:27shut down just yet, but that's you know, they said that they're going
- 16:30to do that. I just found it fascinating. They did it in a
- 16:34way because they've always tried, at least in their communications, to you know,
- 16:38ride the center a little bit, and so they did it in a
- 16:41way where they didn't have like a backup plan like, hey, we're going
- 16:45to open up this better, bigger facility, you know, as we you
- 16:48know, wind this other one down. They're just like, oh no,
- 16:51no, we're gonna we're gonna wind this facility down and no other solution after
- 16:56that. And there their logic was, oh, well it's too small.
- 17:00Oh so this action isn't enough. We're just not going to do it at
- 17:03all, Like it makes no sense. Yeah, it's terrible, I mean,
- 17:07and I think that's the problem with like shelter spaces and temporary modular housing
- 17:10too, where they're they're not supporting it. They're like, yeah, we
- 17:12need more of it, but we're going to get rid of what we have
- 17:15as we figure out how to fix it later. They're just yeating people with
- 17:18nothing. And that was what was so cruel and April about, you know,
- 17:22the dismantling of the sort of tent encampments is they were throwing people's belongings
- 17:27away and there were no shelter spaces for anyone to go to, like they
- 17:33you know, and their calms changed. I noticed that there was there was
- 17:37a some people might say it's nuanced or just a fundamental different thing. There
- 17:41was being communicated, communicated because at the start they were saying everyone will be
- 17:47offered shelter space. Yeah, but then it shifted just slightly to saying anyone
- 17:51who put up their hand got shelter space. And it's like, well and
- 17:55something like that, wouldn't you want to be proactive and wonder where these folks
- 17:59are going to go? I think it has a real feeling of like the
- 18:02Titanic not having enough lifeboats for everybody where they're like, well, but maybe
- 18:06not everybody wants a life boat. I thought of that. I mean,
- 18:11it's terrible, but that's that's the logic that they're Yeah, they're working on
- 18:15and there really is I think, like at every level still this mythology in
- 18:18Vancouver that people who are unhoused are not from here, They're not really part
- 18:22of the city. There's like this myth that's been in place since I was
- 18:26a kid and probably longer that people get busted in from other provinces. They're
- 18:29like, they're just coming here for the weather or whatever, and it's you
- 18:33know, it's not seeing them as part of the neighborhood or part of the
- 18:36community, which is really I think increases that that hostility and like that sense
- 18:41of alienation. And in April, like right before the encampment was torn down
- 18:45by the VPD, there was this article in the Globe and mail from a
- 18:48condo owner talking about how distressing it was that people are camping like outside of
- 18:52his condo and like how upsetting it is to see homeless people all the time,
- 18:56and in there talked about how his property values we're not going out up
- 19:00the way like property values across the city. We're growing up because there's too
- 19:03much visible poverty. And it's just like, there's something so awful to me.
- 19:07It's so terrible about the idea that like the reason this is a concern
- 19:11is because somebody's condo is not inflating in value as much as like a homeowner
- 19:15on the West Side, and not that it's a shame, like a national
- 19:19shame that there are so many people who have nowhere to live. Yeah,
- 19:22exactly. I mean you would think that the concern would be and listen,
- 19:27if you live in a neighborhood where you have those incaments, I get it,
- 19:30Like it is you can feel uncomfortable. You're allowed to do so,
- 19:33that's fine. But at the same time, shouldn't your concern be like,
- 19:37hey, we need to get these people proper housing, as opposed to like
- 19:41just get it out of my sight. Yeah, And that's the attitude that
- 19:42I find very concerning of when you're just like, just get it out of
- 19:47my sight, especially in a city where, like to a certain agree,
- 19:52like I'm sorry, cities are dense, they're going to have, you know,
- 19:56transient or homeless populations. That's just kind of a reality of it.
- 20:00And then going back to your point about well where they're not even from here,
- 20:03people are allowed to freely move within this country. Yes, if anything
- 20:06that pointing that out, let's say, if it was true, pointing that
- 20:10out just means that homelessness and social housing has to be a federal issue,
- 20:15yeah, with a you know, with a good national plan as opposed to
- 20:18just jurisdiction by jurisdiction. Exactly. Yes, people do have the freedom of
- 20:22movement under our charter rights. Like you can't. You can't strip away charter
- 20:26rights from people just because they're poor. And I don't know, it's just
- 20:30it's there's like this total lack of humanity and it is people really just saying
- 20:33I don't want to have to look at this, like can't we move those
- 20:37people out to a less desirable area or like an area where we want to
- 20:41have to see them, And it's not really thinking about how to fix the
- 20:44problem. And I think that's why it's such a shame when there is a
- 20:47proposed like social housing development in a neighborhood like you know, near our Beautis
- 20:52and Broadway, where in theory, like our neighborhood should have people of all
- 20:56social classes. You shouldn't have to just live in one area of the city
- 20:59because you're poorer than somebody on the west Side. And you see real resistance
- 21:03to that of like, these people don't belong here, right, and it's
- 21:07the threat just implied by seeing them. It's not that and a lot of
- 21:10those I mean anything. So many of those temporary modular housing projects have been
- 21:15different, right, Like some had great success and sustained success. Others had
- 21:19a lot of challenges for various different reasons. But it's it is interesting that
- 21:25that basically the city without a plan B or an alternative has basically just said,
- 21:30yeah, we're not going to renew the leases here. The conspiracy theorist
- 21:34in me is thinking that they're just going to sell it to developers like rand
- 21:40to developers. That's my fear. And you know, these are these would
- 21:44be the first steps in executing a plan like that. Yeah, and I
- 21:48think they'll say, don't worry, these developers are going to have to put
- 21:51twenty percent of these units below market rents. But the other thing, instead
- 21:55of paying three grand for a studio per you know, per month, three
- 21:59grand and rent, you'll pay like twenty nine hundreds exactly. Yeah. And
- 22:03another thing is, you know, in June, there was a study out
- 22:06of UBC. I can't remember the authors at the moment, but it looked
- 22:08at what happens to people after they get evicted. It was like a study
- 22:11of renters, and it found that quite a high percentage of them just become
- 22:17homeless if they get evicted because they can't afford, you know, to compete
- 22:21in the rental market for whatever reason. Like if you've rented a unit for
- 22:25a long time and you can evicted, rents have gone up probably way more
- 22:26than you can afford to pay. For people who are on a fixed income
- 22:30because they're disabled, you know, the amount that they're granted through disability assistance
- 22:34is way below what anyone needs to live on in this province. So a
- 22:37lot of people are just like kind of one one eviction away from becoming homeless.
- 22:42And the idea that it's kind of moral failing to be homeless or like
- 22:45that these people have the option of shelters and they just don't want them.
- 22:48I think that's a myth that we should try harder to burst for people.
- 22:52No, for sure, it's actually and I've rented about this before, but
- 22:56it's it's wild to me that in the conversation about homelessness, we don't talk
- 23:03about the cost of rent, like it seems to be missing in every conversation.
- 23:07We talk about mental health, you talk about you know, substance use,
- 23:10whatever. We even talk about social housing to a certain degree, but
- 23:15we don't talk about the cost of rent and how that does impact a lot
- 23:18of folks. And you know, we all have varying degrees of privilege.
- 23:22And there's some of us that obviously own homes. There's some of us that,
- 23:26let's say, if you were evicted, maybe you would have parents or
- 23:29someone else that you could you know, move to for at least temporarily.
- 23:34But there's some people who don't have that. Yeah, And you know,
- 23:37I feel for people that get that eviction notice and they're just like, my
- 23:41rent is going to be double. I don't think I can live in Vancouver
- 23:45anymore. Yeah, right, And oftentimes a lot of professionals I know will
- 23:49just move somewhere else. Yeah, which is really bad. You know,
- 23:52if you have an entire professional class that can't afford to live in the city,
- 23:56Like we don't have enough doctors, we don't have enough paramedics, we
- 23:57don't have enough teachers. You can't actually build a city on real estate speculation
- 24:03a lot, you can't. Yeah, even though like rich bo, Vancouver
- 24:07is trying its hardest to prove you wrong, which show you need somebody to
- 24:11check your high blood pressure and make your Starbucks. Yeah, those people got
- 24:14it. They got to be able to afford a place to live. So
- 24:17so going back to Vancouver, I do want to center this chat around the
- 24:22city of Vancouver specifically. It doesn't feel like there's a lot of vocal opposition
- 24:29to this government, or at least even folks. I would say, like,
- 24:33I'm not talking about you know, people in media, but there's no
- 24:36reply guy for Ken sim On a political level, I think Christine Boyle has
- 24:40kind of been, you know, the go to voice. But I do
- 24:41feel like the Vancouver Greens are really quiet for the most part. They'll do
- 24:45the odd media around, but with all of these issues and things that I've
- 24:49highlighted in terms of, you know, the city making certain decisions that don't
- 24:55make sense in times of crises. Is part of the problem that there is
- 24:59no reply guy, no go to guy. You need a reply guy to
- 25:03save the city. I think that's how it starts. I think, like
- 25:07for all his faults, John Cooper, the one thing he did very correctly
- 25:12was he had clearly had relationships in media and so anytime Kennedy Stewart, you
- 25:18know, and that council made a decision, he was always in the news
- 25:22giving the opposite response. And I don't know if we have that person yet
- 25:26that's true. I mean, I still I still see people saying that ABC
- 25:32is new, that that you know, gets less true every day, and
- 25:37that they need time to figure things out, and so we shouldn't rush to
- 25:41to write them off when they could be starting to make things better. But
- 25:44I do think there's some disillusionment happening, you know. I think the shine
- 25:48is coming off well, and it's it's happening on a lot of fronts,
- 25:52right, It's not just renters, yeah, I think there it's people who
- 25:59may property taxes are not particularly thrilled with the prospect of double digit property tax
- 26:04increases every year for the next four years, right, Like, and maybe
- 26:08property taxes should go up, and they probably should, but they absolutely should.
- 26:14But it's amazing how many people Alex Hemingway, He's coming on the show
- 26:17soon, so that's a conversation I'll have with their property taxes should go up.
- 26:19But also people on the West Side still love complaining, Like every time
- 26:23their composts doesn't get picked up on schedule, they're like where the core services
- 26:27in this city? You know, like they are pissed about their recycling not
- 26:30getting picked up right, and they're gonna let KINSIM know about it eventually.
- 26:34But you know, again, this is kind of the like supermajority thing.
- 26:38ABC has all the power. It's harder for them to say they're not getting
- 26:41things done because they don't have enough, yeah, political power. And I
- 26:45think there's something really funny happening every time there is an unpopular decision, you
- 26:49know, like when Storm Brewing was told that they were going to have to
- 26:52paint over their mural and there for like twenty five years, or this daycare
- 26:56by Ducklas Park that got rejected by the variant right where you see ABC counselors
- 27:02being like, wow, this is terrible. We're going to look into this,
- 27:06We're going to figure out why this happened. And it's like, well,
- 27:07it happened under the by law structure of the city that you could change
- 27:11through your political power, Like you don't need to do another year long consultation.
- 27:15That's what they're saying about daycares. They're like, well, we're doing
- 27:18a consultation or like a review to look at how we can bring our standards
- 27:22in line with provincial standards for daycare. Right, it's like, why do
- 27:26we even have municipal standards. If the provincial standards are good enough, why
- 27:29don't we just use those, scrap the municipal ones, and you know,
- 27:33let people open more daycares. Yeah. I just at a certain point they
- 27:37can't keep pretending that this is all news to that. No, Like I
- 27:40mean when it no, you're absolutely right, like when it comes and I
- 27:42don't know the details here or how it works. But it's like, I
- 27:48fail to believe that the first time they learned about that daycare was from the
- 27:53Dan Fumano article. Someone must have known something about that or at least impassive,
- 28:00Like it must have gone across someone's desk at some point, right,
- 28:03you have incumbent city councilors who are sitting in city in city council. You
- 28:07have a mayor who ran for office for like six years until he won.
- 28:11Like they must know these issues, yeah, and you know they say they
- 28:18want to fix them. That's what I find interesting. Like Peter Meisner is
- 28:21always posting pictures of Montreal being like, wow, look at these beautiful car
- 28:25free plazas. Why can't we have that here? We can't have that here.
- 28:29One might argue it's their job to get him. I was going to
- 28:33let you state the office. Yeah, I don't know. I mean,
- 28:37I just I think he brought back water fountains during a drought that was that's
- 28:40pretty good, all right, and just decorative fountains, which we all appreciate
- 28:45they So I did bring that up in the rant as well. And what's
- 28:48interesting is I'm sure that their response will be, like, listen, when
- 28:52drought conditions were announced for Metro Vancouver, then we shut it down. But
- 28:56the reality, of course, was that everyone knew that that was going to
- 29:00be announced, and everyone knew that the entire province is in a drought,
- 29:03some areas more severe than others. I want to know why we don't have
- 29:07like fountains recirculating water. Surely someone in there. Yeah, I think it's
- 29:11I think there there's a cost to doing that, and so it's possible.
- 29:15It's not it's not impossible. I think it's don't I don't even want to
- 29:19say it. I think it's around like one hundred thousand dollars per fountain,
- 29:23but it's But that's what it comes down to. If it's so important to
- 29:26you, yeah, then hold a bake sale. Cool. There's going to
- 29:30be cost to making carfee plazas, yeah, right, exactly. At a
- 29:37certain point, it's like what do we want to pay for? What are
- 29:38we what kind of city do we want to live in? Right? I
- 29:41thought the daycare debate really got to the heart of that, where some people
- 29:45were like, I just want to be, you know, enjoy the tranquility
- 29:48of my four million dollar home without hearing the sounds of children playing, yeah
- 29:52and wild, and that's you know, that's the vibe sometimes in Vancouver as
- 29:56everybody's like, yeah, we should fix these problems, we should fix the
- 30:00somewhere else, yeah, far from where I live. Yeah, yeah,
- 30:03and in a city that's not really sustainable. People in Vancouver have this very
- 30:06strange, provincial kind of attitude where they seem to think that they live in
- 30:10a suburb when they're like five minutes from the downtown core right and so that
- 30:15they should have like peace and quiet and space and like abundant free street parking.
- 30:18Michelle, who's ruining the city? Is it the neighborhood associations, you
- 30:22know, the small minority of vocal people that that don't want any densification or
- 30:29don't want childcare, Or is it you know, developers who is ruining this
- 30:34city? What is the core problem here? Or is it just like a
- 30:37weird alignment of nimbies and cops and real estate developers, Like, what's what's
- 30:44the issue here? I mean I do. I think to a certain extent
- 30:48it's a shared problem, and a big part of it is the people who
- 30:51complain the loudest, Those squeaky wheels who like manage to get before city council
- 30:55and torpedo things like daycares or new apartment buildings because they happen to be there,
- 31:00complained the loudest. But it's also the fact that we have a city
- 31:03council that listens to that you know, we have like abundant information in this
- 31:07day and age about what needs to happen. Right, we know that we
- 31:10need more housing. We have a pretty good idea of how much new housing,
- 31:14and we know that we need to reseund larger as the city to make
- 31:18building that housing possible. Like we have all this information and the idea that
- 31:21every decision should be litigated by like a handful of cranks is not a good
- 31:26way to run a city. But that's democracy in action. I would argue
- 31:33that, like I retire, you know, homeowner who's not about the threat
- 31:37of a shadow that might be near their house or maybe just like you know,
- 31:41shadowing their Tesla as it's parked on their shady side street. Yeah,
- 31:47that's not That's not how we need to be making decisions. That's like a
- 31:49terrible way to plan and run a city. And we see you know,
- 31:53these kind of half as civic initiatives like the car free plaza on U Street
- 31:59by by Kids Beach, which you know we can all hesitate to call car
- 32:02free because they set up these like temporary modular barriers that just confuse drivers who
- 32:07kept driving through it. And then they were like, well people aren't really
- 32:09using it right. He wants to play in the middle of a road where
- 32:13a car keeps accidentally driving. Good fair questions. So I just I don't
- 32:19know. I feel like, you know, there's a lot of people complaining,
- 32:21and we listen to those people more than we should. And the people
- 32:23who should stop listening to them are elected leaders who have enough information to know
- 32:28what decisions need to be made for the city, and they should just be
- 32:31doing it more. I would like less consultation, you know, I would
- 32:35just like to see some action. Yeah, and you would think that in
- 32:40a supermajority, you know, they could, really they can. Yes,
- 32:46when you think about ABC at least, I mean there hasn't been even a
- 32:50full year yet, but we're close to that. What do they stand for?
- 32:54Because I do feel like there is a more call it right wing to
- 33:00be simpler, like a right wing faction within the within the counselors, and
- 33:05then there's a little more centrism as well. But assessing their almost first year,
- 33:10where like, how would you describe this political party to someone who doesn't
- 33:16he is not familiar with them? Well, I think I might start by
- 33:20saying that they're the political party that chip Wilson chose for the city Vancouver.
- 33:25You know, he didn't elect them all by himself, but he certainly had
- 33:30something to do with it, and I do. You know, it's kind
- 33:35of hard to know what they stand for because they made a lot of promises
- 33:37that I think kind of cut across political lines. They did say, you
- 33:40know, we're going to get more daycarees built, We're gonna get more housing
- 33:44built. They made a lot of big promises. They said they're going to
- 33:46like reduce the budget, and then they got in there and they're like,
- 33:50turns out we can. But that's what I mean, based on their first
- 33:52year performance and what they've actually done, not their promises, how would you
- 33:55describe them surprisingly in effect? I guess, wow, Yeah, they couldn't
- 34:01even hire all those cops. How hard can it be? I mean,
- 34:08clearly harder than what they made it out to be. Yeah, I mean,
- 34:13I guess you know, it's politics. The beautiful thing about democracies anyone
- 34:17can run in, anyone can be elected, and that's great. We should
- 34:20preserve that, but that doesn't mean you get people in political office who like
- 34:22don't really know how For instance, a city works. Ken sim was in
- 34:28business as he reminded us many times during the campaign, and then he got
- 34:31into office, and it turns out it sounds like he doesn't really you know,
- 34:35he's still trying to figure out how to run a city, like how
- 34:37a city budget works, what you can do, what you can't do,
- 34:39how long things take. And I think we are seeing kind of what happens
- 34:45when you have people elected to run a city who are like really learning on
- 34:47the job. I want to believe that Ken has good intent. I'm make
- 34:59sure that I know I'm trying to formulate this thought here. I do think
- 35:04that Ken has good intent. I think he's a good sort of ambassador in
- 35:07terms of like when we're talking about the vibes or just someone who you know,
- 35:12tries to get the city excited about things. I think he is good
- 35:14at that. I am having a difficult time trying to understand what his vision
- 35:17for the city is. And it's interesting because he alluded to this idea of
- 35:22he wanted to accomplish five things and then he wouldn't say what they are.
- 35:24But he wouldn't say what they are. It's very landmark. I'm just going
- 35:29to say it. But it also lends itself to again conspiracy or cynicism of
- 35:34what like I'd be like, oh, so is one of those things selling
- 35:37all the public land to private developments? Right, Like what are those things?
- 35:43And so it's just weird to me that he hasn't, for a guy
- 35:46that's very ambitious, very smart, strange that he hasn't really put forth that
- 35:52vision to Vancouver, right. Yeah. Well, and I think you can
- 35:55campaign on a vision to a certain extent. And I think a lot of
- 35:58people in Vancouver across political lines, agree on some of the problems in the
- 36:01city, right Like, as we've said many times so far, housing affordabilities
- 36:05speak problem, but people disagree on what the solutions are, right, And
- 36:07once you get elected, it's your job to figure out the solutions and start
- 36:10implementing them. And I think it is hard for politicians to shift gears between
- 36:14campaigning where you just have to say things that you know people want to hear,
- 36:17and then actually figure out, like how do you do those things?
- 36:20What is the right path? Like what is you know, when you're talking
- 36:23about people who are on house, is it just clearing their tents so you
- 36:25don't have to see them or is it finding places for them to live?
- 36:29Those are different kinds of solutions. Yeah, and I think, you know,
- 36:34it is hard to know kind of what ABC intends to do based on
- 36:38They're very secretive about it. They're still talking about what the problems are,
- 36:42but it's their job now to think as a solution, right. I pose
- 36:46that question to Ken about the encampments being cleared because there was kind of a
- 36:51coincidental action at city Hall where they brought in that respectful dialogue or whatever,
- 36:59And I was like, are those two things linked because the dates kind of
- 37:00work out in a way that you would have organizations criticizing the decampment, but
- 37:06then city council passing the respectful dialogue whatever that if you get city money,
- 37:12you have to be you can't criticize. Yeah, need no problems with that.
- 37:17Yeah, I mean that seemed coordinated. It was hard. I know,
- 37:21Ken was like, oh, no, they're not related, but it
- 37:22just felt like how could they not be Ye? Well, and I mean
- 37:29that's more worrisome, right, Like they have a lot of power for the
- 37:32rest of their term. They have a supermajority. They can do whatever they
- 37:36want with it. They don't need people, you know, they don't need
- 37:39to bully people in that way. They don't need that kind of political power,
- 37:44and so it's disturbing that they are angling for it. You know,
- 37:46that they're saying, you have to play by our rules, and that means
- 37:50like not even criticizing them, not even lightly criticizing them. The criticism in
- 37:53question was really mild, right, It was just like one person an organization
- 38:00that's received funding raising I think, a really mild concern about Ken Sim's planned
- 38:06governance. Yeah, right. And I don't think anyone wants to live in
- 38:09a city where people can't say things like that. We should be able to
- 38:13criticize our elected leaders. I mean, I think people should get into politics
- 38:16ideally expecting that everyone's going to criticize them. The goal is not to have
- 38:20people praise you all the time. I will say Ken has made himself quite
- 38:28available to media, certainly in my experience, but even talking to others like
- 38:31he does seem quite open to discussing things. But I do think that what
- 38:37would be healthy for city politics is having a few more quote unquote reply guys
- 38:43who were yeah, you know, to really kind of frame critiques in a
- 38:49way that is digestible, accessible, and understanding that there are policy alternatives.
- 38:53Yeah, And I don't Again, I think Christine Boyle has done a good
- 38:58job as you know, a soul one said heat counselor. But beyond that,
- 39:01like it's really hard to see where that other political opposition is going to
- 39:07come from. Yeah, I do think we had a really kind of hollowing
- 39:10out of the political part, Like you know, Gregor Robertson's Vision Vancouver kind
- 39:15of fell apart, and Kennedy Stewart didn't really have a party when he got
- 39:20elected. We didn't have like a clear opposition set up for ABC besides One
- 39:24City which only has Christine representing them on counsel So there isn't you know,
- 39:30you mentioned John Cooper, We don't have kind of a John Cooper oh Man
- 39:35four years ago. If you had asked me, if you have told me
- 39:39then one day, I'd be like, we need more John cooperers. I
- 39:43hope he's not listening. And that's you know, all respect to John Cooper,
- 39:47just saying like it's it's interesting, but yeah, we definitely need I
- 39:53feel like we just need those political voices to emerge. And I think one
- 39:59thing that ABC did very well was in the collapse of Vision and the NPA.
- 40:02It kind of took support from both both of those parties. It's not
- 40:07like it just replaced the NPA or replaced Vision. It like really encompassed an
- 40:13intersection between those two and so it did. Yeah. Yeah, but there's
- 40:19still plenty of political space to criticize. I feel like there is, and
- 40:23I think we'll see more of that, especially as the next election approaches.
- 40:27I mean, every like political system, every tier of government is just you
- 40:34know this like ping ponging back and forth. So ABC, I think really
- 40:37benefited from the fact that people were not thrilled by Kennedy Stewarts stewarts governance or
- 40:45you know, lack of getting things done because he had a very fragmented cancel
- 40:49and you know that's not his fault, but people were frustrated. They wanted
- 40:52like a new party and a new order, and ABC got to bring in
- 40:55that freshness. But they're not going to have that in the next municipal election.
- 40:58They're going to be them and people are going to be filled with criticisms
- 41:01and you know, they're going to have a four year track record that people
- 41:05can drawn. And so I think there's an opportunity for you know, that
- 41:10ping pong ball to get knocked back to the other side of the table to
- 41:14just like really over extend that metaphor. I'll let us to say, you
- 41:20know, people are going to be sick of ABC. We're always sick of
- 41:22whoever's in charge. That's true. Everybody wants a fresh slate. You know,
- 41:27what they should do right before the next election, or maybe a year
- 41:30before that, maybe right before it. They should be the party to ban
- 41:35Airbnb. Oh my gosh, if they did that, they would just get
- 41:38people who go, yeah, well you know they did that, that was
- 41:42pretty big. Yeah, they should just do one good thing. You should
- 41:45be you should be a political advisor. Have you thought about doing one good
- 41:52thing? Try it on for size, see how it feels. Kenson especially,
- 41:57One of those things that I think does get popular are populist support,
- 42:00right, like you would. I think you would have people from all walks
- 42:04of life support banning Airbnb, like I aside for people running Airbnb. Yeah,
- 42:10I think that would be supported. But they are kind of doing that
- 42:15with like because ken wants to bring back you know, fun in Vancouver.
- 42:17So they're they're while also working with a expanding budget. They're they're trying to
- 42:22figure out ways to make things more fun there they are hitting those populist vibes.
- 42:28Yeah, and I mean I think there's you know, at a certain
- 42:30point, you can't be for everybody, and maybe they just need to figure
- 42:34out who their audience is. Like Gregor Robertson was like the bike lane mayre.
- 42:37Yeah, and some people really still hate them for that. But if
- 42:40you like bike lanes, which I do, that's a great legacy to leave
- 42:44that. We have like a really excellent network of separated bike lanes in some
- 42:49parts of the city. We should have more, Ken Sim if you want
- 42:51my vote, you probably wouldn't get it, but that would be that Gregor
- 42:55gets categorized like that because that you often hear that, right, And but
- 43:00it's also recognizing that a lot of development happened under Gregor, and a lot
- 43:06of it was just like private market condos, and Kennedy, to his credit,
- 43:12I think, shifted that portfolio of approvals towards a lot more rentals.
- 43:15And now, obviously time will tell where where development goes under ken Sim.
- 43:21Yeah, but they do have They've got three years left to make very optimistic.
- 43:27I don't think I can be off. I'm so jaded. I'm sorry,
- 43:31but I would love to be wrong. No, I would love to
- 43:36for them to be to be successful and make rents more affordable and you know,
- 43:42start working on solutions for housing the unhoused like that would be amazing.
- 43:47I want them to do that. I would be great. Maybe put a
- 43:52bike lane back in Stanley Park that they took out right cool, it's I'm
- 43:59going to leave it on. Is part of the issue with whether it's that
- 44:01bike lane in Stanley Park, whether it is the decampment that a lot of
- 44:07this stuff and I guess to a certain degree that childcare specce certainly the neighbors
- 44:10that were there a lot of the stuff does have vocal support. So people
- 44:15look at the decampments. They might even look at the empty homes tax exemption.
- 44:22I mean like, yeah, you know what, this does make sense,
- 44:23we support this. Do I think that helps them? Or I guess?
- 44:30I mean, I guess it goes back to the earlier. The earlier
- 44:34thing I are saying is they're not being checked by by a really vocal opposition.
- 44:39There's just you know, they have they have people that general that actually
- 44:44genuinely support shutting down the overdose profession site without the plan B. Yeah,
- 44:49I mean and I think that's you know, there is a degree to which
- 44:52I think people in Vancouver can be vocal and speak out about the things that
- 44:55they would like to see you from this council. I do think, you
- 44:59know, I live on the West Side and I saw a ton of ABC
- 45:01signs during the election, and that's the neighborhood that's quite like really, I
- 45:07mean, most of the West Side of Vancouver is quite insulated from the problems
- 45:09of the downtown east Side, and like the you know, they're still pretty
- 45:15insulated from density. I think that there is a degree to which Ken sim
- 45:20can sort of cater to that base and let let people, you know,
- 45:23be unpopular with the people who are vocal supporters of the kinds of things that
- 45:30he's kind of shown he doesn't really care about. Yeah, so far any
- 45:35cynical takes. Yeah, that's how we're gonna end the chat. Everybody loves
- 45:40ending on a downer. I mean, you can salvage it, but you
- 45:45got like a couple of seconds to figure it out. No, I got
- 45:49nothing, you got nothing. We're fucked, basically, in conclusion, we're
- 45:52fucked. Hopefully the time it wars get us before the housing crisis, Yeah,
- 45:58Michelle was awesome. I'm so glad we could do this in long form.
- 46:02I know when we first had you on the show was a very short
- 46:05segment, but I was very much looking forward to this and you did not
- 46:07disappoint. So thank you so much for your time. Thank you. This
- 46:10is so fun. Absolutely, folks, one of my favorites. She's been
- 46:14dropping banger after banger across several outlets. Make sure you find her and find
- 46:19her amazing work. She is Michelle Sisa and of course I'm moamir telling you
- 46:23that in a city where you can be anything, be colorful, peace,