Latest / No Way Out / Bad Boyd, Good Receipts: Inside Snowmobiles & Grand Ideals with Ian Brown
Transcript
- 0:20Mark McGrath: So, Ponch, we brought back for another installment on No Way Out.
- 0:25Mark McGrath: The man that we know for sure spent more time in the archives than you and I.
- 0:29Mark McGrath: And you and I have spent a lot of time in the archives.
- 0:32Mark McGrath: And Ian, we're chasing you, but we're not quite at uh the amount of time, the hours that you've logged in in the archives, but we're we're working on it.
- 0:40Mark McGrath: So, Ian Brown, welcome back to uh No Way Out.
- 0:43Ian Brown: Yeah, well thank you, Mark and Punch.
- 0:45Ian Brown: Uh always good to be back and talking with some fellow uh Boyd Aficionados.
- 0:49Ian Brown: Though I'll I'll say if we're talking like raw time in the archives, it could be it could be balanced because most of the stuff in in and say the majority of the work on this book was just me like on my computer or on my iPhone listening to audio recordings and trying to figure out what the hell was getting what what what people were saying with the the god-awful audio equipment of the the late 1980s.
- 1:13Mark McGrath: Well it's a it's a Herculean event effort.
- 1:16Mark McGrath: It's it's it's excellent.
- 1:18Mark McGrath: And as we've had Chet Richards on this on the show several times, and we've talked with Chuck Spinney a lot.
- 1:24Mark McGrath: If you don't understand the briefing, not just the text of the actual documents, but if you don't understand and get some of the back and forth, and we've, you know, Punch and I have listened to those audio recordings, you know, we've seen your transcript.
- 1:36Mark McGrath: Your transcript of Pattern of Conflict, Patterns of Conflict, that's already that's in this again, was already phenomenal.
- 1:42Mark McGrath: If you don't understand that, it's going to be hard to understand Boyd, and you're going to wind up with bad Boyd.
- 1:49Ian Brown: Yeah, and that's really um, that was the ultimate goal of this project was to remove, remove sort of the I you could call it a barrier, you could call it an excuse, call it whatever you want, but remove, you know, the impediment to understanding what John Boyd said about, you know, subject X, Y, or Z by giving you, you know, to the best that we can without resurrecting his body from the grave, his thoughts in his own words to the greatest extent.
- 2:16Ian Brown: And so that's what so you now, you know, you can agree or disagree with him or otherwise, or or come up with different interpretations, but the goal of this was you at least have to acknowledge and and or have the opportunity to grapple with him in his own words rather than having him interpreted through, you know, second or third parties.
- 2:35Mark McGrath: We well, we'll not focus on the the technical aspects, which I imagine if you I don't know, if you want to give a quick a quick summary of the technical side, because I want to focus on the meat that you deliver and show what we talk about all the time.
- 2:49Mark McGrath: Orientation is everything, and a bad interpretation of the Oodaloop sketch will kill you.
- 2:55Mark McGrath: But just speak to the technical uh mountain that you had to climb, um, and then we're gonna get into the the meat of the book and everything.
- 3:03Ian Brown: Yeah, sure.
- 3:03Ian Brown: So I'll I'll uh let me I'll go back to the beginning as best I can, but I'll make I'll try and make this fast.
- 3:09Ian Brown: So I'm holding up this is the cover, I don't know if you can see it, of uh Snowmobiles and Grand Ideals.
- 3:14Ian Brown: Right now it is only in digital format.
- 3:16Ian Brown: Um unfortunately I heard from uh the university press their printing house that they normally use had like a pipe break in it.
- 3:23Ian Brown: And so the physical copies are gonna be delayed a few weeks, but they should still be out in the next month or so, you know.
- 3:29Ian Brown: So certainly in time for uh a hefty Christmas present for those who are, you know, boy lovers of many of the people.
- 3:36Mark McGrath: And tell everybody the price, too.
- 3:38Ian Brown: Oh, it's free.
- 3:39Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 3:40Mark McGrath: Your tax dollars paid for it.
- 3:41Mark McGrath: So make sure you get this book.
- 3:43Ian Brown: Yes, you've already, yeah, you've already paid for it basically, so you might as well go read it.
- 3:46Ian Brown: The the digital version is is available right now off the Marine Corps University Press's website.
- 3:52Ian Brown: But the uh, and before I go any farther, uh let me add just as always, my usual disclaimer that my opinions are my own and don't represent the views of my employer or any other organization with which I may be affiliated.
- 4:02Ian Brown: So the technical so what the book is, right?
- 4:04Ian Brown: It is full of verbatim transcripts of all of Void's presentations, at least the ones that we know were recorded at some point.
- 4:12Ian Brown: The bulk of them are from um archival holdings uh that Marine Corps, the Marine Corps History Division has.
- 4:19Ian Brown: The only one that was from a different source was, I believe, let me double check to make sure I got this right.
- 4:27Mark McGrath: We had a we had a uh a transcript of just that that we made available through HGLX that uh Chet Richards was kind enough to write a foreword to, but that's the one from uh Spacecast.
- 4:36Mark McGrath: Spacecast, yes, yeah.
- 4:38Ian Brown: Yes.
- 4:39Ian Brown: Um the the the all of them are from so Patterns of Conflict, a strategic game, organic design for command and control are all recordings of when Boyd was talking to uh largely a Marine Corps command and staff college audience back in the late 1980s, and these are all held, and um there's they are digital transfers of cassette recordings from those those presentations.
- 5:00Ian Brown: And then uh the conceptual spiral was I think we we all had the same video from uh Spacecast, which was a um the the background of what Spacecast is, I I have a footnote in the book somewhere about it, but it was it was like an Air Force, like kind of um like little mini, mini think tank like uh you know, hacking, um, hacking session, brain hacking session in early 1990s.
- 5:25Ian Brown: Um down in Florida, Boyd was invited to go to give the conceptual spiral talk as part of the agenda for that presentation.
- 5:32Ian Brown: But but as I said, so the technical side is most of these were digital transfers of audio cassettes.
- 5:37Ian Brown: And so um I undertook this effort um uh and with the initial attempts of the patterns of conflict back in like 2015, 2016 when I was working on um my master's, which eventually became the new conception of war.
- 5:51Ian Brown: Um so this is sort of before you had lots of things like generative AI and other like large language model tools that can help you sort of parse this.
- 5:59Ian Brown: So I had to kind of do this the hard way.
- 6:02Ian Brown: But what I uh what I and what I ended up doing was there are transcription companies out there that predated, you know, the surge in LLMs and AI assistants.
- 6:11Ian Brown: So I had uh with the very generous funding of both the Marine Corps Heritage Foundation and then later on the Marine Corps University Foundation, they provided funds for me to send the audio to a transcribing house basically to do a first pass, right?
- 6:26Ian Brown: Like I there are there are dozens of hours of audio.
- 6:29Ian Brown: Me, I don't have the time to sit down and go through that like word by word by word and generate a new transcript.
- 6:35Ian Brown: So um I paid somebody else to do it.
- 6:37Ian Brown: They did a first pass, and the first pass was probably like a it was about 60 to 70 percent of the way there, right?
- 6:43Ian Brown: You know, like most of the words that Boyd is speaking are normal English words, he just talks really fast.
- 6:48Ian Brown: Um, but they're they're they're at least interpretable as English words.
- 6:53Ian Brown: Um, and and there's some parts of the audio where you just can't hear it.
- 6:56Ian Brown: So it was useful to have like the third-party transcribers identify where the where they thought the audio was kind of muffled.
- 7:03Ian Brown: So then I came in after all of this and I did like the refinements.
- 7:08Ian Brown: And some of that was based on all the context uh of you know, of being sort of immersed in in Boyd and people who had written about maneuver warfare.
- 7:17Ian Brown: I could fill in some of the blanks, right?
- 7:18Ian Brown: Like where like if the transcriber just couldn't un understand or end a word at all, I was like, oh no, that's the German word finger spitching of fuel.
- 7:26Ian Brown: There's no reason like a third-party transcriber would know what that word is, right?
- 7:30Ian Brown: But those are the kind of things that I would polish out a lot of very specific, like uh people names or place names or conceptual ideas or doctrinal concepts that the transcriber couldn't figure out.
- 7:40Ian Brown: I was able to fill in those blanks.
- 7:41Ian Brown: So I mean, I ultimately I've listened to all of these recordings like many times to go in and fill in the blanks, but it was just from a workflow standpoint, it was very useful to have that somebody else do that first pass to give me like the the bedrock.
- 7:56Ian Brown: And then I went through and cleaned it up and added the context and also added the uh you know, footnotes and annotations to explain a lot of the, you know, the the words or the oh by the ways that Boyd talked about.
- 8:07Ian Brown: So that was basically the process of how how all these transcripts finally got out there.
- 8:11Ian Brown: And then, you know, I had to do a little bit of interpretation to figure out where to embed all the different slides, you know, because Boyd's going through his slides at the same time that he's talking.
- 8:21Ian Brown: You know, but what like once you know like where slide one starts in in the audio, it's not terribly hard to follow along.
- 8:28Ian Brown: And yeah, he always says next slide.
- 8:30Mark McGrath: Like I know in the conceptual spiral, he always says next slide.
- 8:34Mark McGrath: Like the sound on that one is pretty clear, but the the the video of that is horrible.
- 8:38Ian Brown: You can't it's all murky, but yeah, the the the that that one was probably the the least of a challenge because the audio at least was good.
- 8:46Ian Brown: All the command and staff college stuff was hard rough.
- 8:49Ian Brown: Um but you but like you can hear him.
- 8:51Ian Brown: There are pauses and you can actually hear him like moving the acetate slides on the projector.
- 8:56Ian Brown: Um so so it was it, you know, once you knew where slide one started, it was not it wasn't terribly hard to follow along with it.
- 9:02Ian Brown: Acetate, what the hell is that, man?
- 9:04Mark McGrath: Yeah, let's tell some Gen Z kids about we're gonna have to have to look up acetate.
- 9:09Ian Brown: Yeah, they have to because they're not gonna know what that is.
- 9:11Mark McGrath: They're likely not listening anyway.
- 9:13Mark McGrath: So if they are, we'd love to hear from them.
- 9:16Mark McGrath: But uh so technically this thing was a bear and you and you got through it and it took a while.
- 9:21Mark McGrath: And you go to the bullpen and you bring in the dean of uh Boyd Scholarship that's not a direct acolyte of his, Franzo Singa, of course, the author of Science, Strategy, and War, which I give to clients as a textbook.
- 9:35Mark McGrath: I'm like, read this, we're gonna work, we're gonna work through this, and you've got him engaged.
- 9:39Mark McGrath: What was uh what was that engagement like with Franz?
- 9:42Ian Brown: Uh so I'm incredibly grateful to Franz because he he really I came to him at the 11th hour because part of what I I wanted this book to do was not just like I wanted the the vast majority to just be Boyd in his own words, and then you go and you know interpret and apply as you want to, you know, but I also I did want context as well.
- 10:01Ian Brown: And nobody I know has done sort of more independent research on the conceptual, the intellectual, the scientific underpinnings of Boyd's ideas than Franz O'Senga.
- 10:11Ian Brown: Like the book you just mentioned.
- 10:12Ian Brown: Like to me, science, strategy, and war to me is like the the gold standard of just from a from a completely like um you know intellectual standpoint, reverse engineering, all the underlying concepts, the the scientific uh and and cultural and other themes that you know were very much kind of in the air at the time that Boyd was alive, that he was soaking up.
- 10:36Ian Brown: And and he, you know, Franz goes through all of Boyd's presentations and is like, hey, when he when he does this, you know, throwaway mention of chaos theory, you know, this is what was going on with chaos theory in the 1980s.
- 10:48Ian Brown: And and so Franz has really provided to me like the the intellectual gold standard for um the the the the background, you know, the swimming pool of ideas that Boyd was swimming in at the time that then lets you give greater context.
- 11:04Ian Brown: So um I had I had wanted to have that contextual framework as part of this book.
- 11:11Ian Brown: Frankly, if I had to do it myself, it was gonna take a lot longer.
- 11:14Ian Brown: And uh this book was already late by a few years.
- 11:17Ian Brown: And so it was kind of a Hail Mary pass.
- 11:19Ian Brown: I'm like, I had talked to Sean Callahan actually about doing some of this as well, but his his own workload as you know the new director of the history division, yeah.
- 11:27Ian Brown: Um simply, you know, you know, perfect man for the job, right?
- 11:30Ian Brown: But didn't didn't really allow him enough time to to do that.
- 11:34Ian Brown: Although he was very helpful.
- 11:35Ian Brown: He had his own, he's done his own transcripts that he had done in teaching in elective at Marine Corps University.
- 11:41Ian Brown: So I did not, we we sort of had this like this plan to um compare and contrast like the transcripts and maybe filling in some of each other's blanks.
- 11:50Ian Brown: Um due to due to my the timeline for the book and his uh and you know his bandwidth didn't work out.
- 11:55Ian Brown: Although he did, I think for strategic game, he provided um some really good commentary and helped sort of fill in the blanks on that one.
- 12:02Mark McGrath: But I was saying I was hanging out with him this past weekend at Annapolis for the Navy football game, and he was talking about some of the work that he that he collaborated with you on.
- 12:10Mark McGrath: Of course, he's really busy with the 250th anniversary, so he's got other things on his mind at the moment.
- 12:16Ian Brown: Yeah, so I like you know, I've I've fully appreciated that it would this this might have been this was too just too much of an ask for all the other stuff he had to do.
- 12:24Ian Brown: So I'm like, you know, who else knows Boyd as well?
- 12:26Ian Brown: I'm like, I know I I had I exchanged like brief emails with Franz O Singa a while back.
- 12:32Ian Brown: Um, so I still had his email address, but I just kind of threw a hail on Mary and was like, hey man, like this is the project.
- 12:38Ian Brown: I would you've already written a huge amount of contextual um explanation of of all Boyd's different presentations.
- 12:46Ian Brown: Like, I'm not asking you to do any any you know any new work really, but if you if you would be willing to sort of adapt some of your stuff, um, that would be hugely helpful to just give context to all of these things to the readers.
- 12:58Ian Brown: I think that's the biggest value.
- 13:00Ian Brown: It was fantastic.
- 13:01Mark McGrath: I think that's the biggest value is that is the context that this provides because it adds more if you use the briefings that are all available in multiple spots, if you just use the briefings, you're missing out on a lot.
- 13:14Mark McGrath: And this, you know, he delivered all these briefings a million times.
- 13:18Mark McGrath: You know, there's a million transcripts that we don't ever have, but the ones that you're able to create and the ones that we're able to memorialize, it's important because it does, I think it does add a lot of structure um and and and meat to the uh you know to the to the the format that we are they're all familiar with.
- 13:35Mark McGrath: Because you could take discourse on winning and losing from Grant Hammond, you could get, you know, chet's got all the the briefings up or whatever.
- 13:42Mark McGrath: You can just read them, but it's the engagement that you miss.
- 13:46Mark McGrath: It's the it's the the back and forth.
- 13:48Mark McGrath: And there's some things, especially in the patterns of conflict transcript.
- 13:51Mark McGrath: I mean, that's why I've I've listened and read to that one.
- 13:54Mark McGrath: That that transcript that you had on that was was brilliant.
- 13:57Mark McGrath: I've sent that out to a lot of people, and there's things that he mentions in there, like Wayne Gretzky, and you know, the the the question and answer that he has with somebody on uh on terror, you know, it's almost like he's predicting 9-11, you know, uh years before.
- 14:12Ian Brown: Yeah, well, so so the night like having France give give that overall context was fantastic, and I'm I'm deeply grateful for him like just saying yes to this extra workload and was like, oh, by the way, you've got like a month to do this.
- 14:24Ian Brown: Um how's that sound for you?
- 14:27Ian Brown: You know, this is an offer you can't refuse.
- 14:29Ian Brown: Um, but I think, yeah, having I one I think having all the transcripts together, you finally get um a lot of the stuff that's in between the slides that is simply not apparent.
- 14:40Ian Brown: And if you saw this in Patterns of Conflict, the trend continues across the other presentations where um you you really it really shows you which ideas and themes he he weighted the most in turn in his presentations and and which he he didn't weigh quite so heavily.
- 14:57Ian Brown: And so there are times and as now you see uh in the in the transcripts of him going through his presentations.
- 15:03Ian Brown: Now sometimes he'd like talk about a slide for like two seconds and then he's on to the next one and the next one.
- 15:08Ian Brown: And then sometimes you'd have a slide that would have only like a few sentences on it.
- 15:11Ian Brown: He's on the case.
- 15:12Ian Brown: He'll spend like 15 minutes, he'll spend like you know, half the class just talking about that one slide and you know letting the the natural back and forth the question and answer with the students and the audience go.
- 15:22Ian Brown: So to me, that was one of the most illuminating things about you know finally having his his his ver his words, his verbal, you know, oral presentation along with the text, because they are they're complementary parts of a whole.
- 15:36Ian Brown: And if you're only going by the slides, then you you're you you sort of naturally want to treat each slide as like kind of evenly weighted because you don't have anything to tell you otherwise.
- 15:46Ian Brown: Now you you see what the way he uses the slides.
- 15:49Ian Brown: Um you see what he thought was the most important points to emphasize, which things were um you know, not unimportant, but less important to him.
- 15:59Ian Brown: And then there's actually a couple cases in the in the we have an appendix, just like I had an appendix in New Conception of War.
- 16:06Ian Brown: Um, but in this book, we have an appendix of about uh I'd say a dozen slides from two different presentations that Boyd skipped entirely in in in the instances that he was presenting them.
- 16:15Ian Brown: I think one of them was about six or seven slides from a patterns of conflict, which kind of near the end, he just like like he skips entirely through them.
- 16:23Ian Brown: But I think he said, like, oh, we'll come back to them, and then he he doesn't really come back to them.
- 16:27Ian Brown: And then let me get the other presentation here.
- 16:32Mark McGrath: A new conception of air to air.
- 16:35Ian Brown: Um no.
- 16:36Ian Brown: Oh, conceptual spiral.
- 16:38Ian Brown: There's a couple slides in conceptual spiral that he just glosses over in the in the you know recording that you did for Spacecast.
- 16:44Ian Brown: Um, but we we included them as an appendix because they are part of the slides that everybody has.
- 16:49Ian Brown: Um and and we wanted we wanted this to be you know as complete a book as possible.
- 16:54Ian Brown: So, you know, I I brought I talked to this about you know with with the editor, and like I know I I know this make just makes your job even harder, and this book is already hundreds of pages long.
- 18:03Ian Brown: But like if this is our one shot to do like the definitive void, can we include those slides like somewhere?
- 18:09Ian Brown: So at least like they're they're in as part of the publication.
- 18:12Ian Brown: It's noted in patterns of conflict and conceptual spiral where he skips them, but the slides are still there so that you know in the books that you can go and look at the things that he skipped over.
- 18:22Mark McGrath: I mean, some of the like I was saying, the QA is also important to add context and color.
- 18:28Mark McGrath: So, you know, like in Patterns of Conflict, somebody asks, why do organizations always write memos back and forth and boys answers?
- 18:35Mark McGrath: CYA, cover your ass.
- 18:37Mark McGrath: Like that kind of that that kind of, I don't know, that that that sort of banter, I think, helps add more things to think about when you're looking at the concepts.
- 18:46Mark McGrath: So, you know, when he's talking about organizations being that are founded on mistrust being doomed to fail, that kind of dialogue I think has a lot more weight.
- 18:55Ian Brown: Yeah, that's like yeah, it's the kind of stuff that just doesn't come out in the slides because like he never talks about covering your ass in the in the slides, but it's something that simply unfolded as part of like, you know, organically the discussion with the students.
- 19:06Ian Brown: And it's it's like little little factoids like that, or like, you know, you mentioned, you know, talking about Wayne Gretzky and hockey.
- 19:13Ian Brown: Boyd uses a lot of sports analogies in his discussions with the students to like, you know, explain the concepts.
- 19:19Ian Brown: Like he'll talk about uh how in either like a hockey team or or a basketball team, right?
- 19:24Ian Brown: Like you're always on, you're on offense and defense at the same time.
- 19:28Ian Brown: And so, you know, but sometimes teams will get into a like this this sort of higher mental state where like everything just seems to be going right.
- 19:36Ian Brown: You know, you're just you're clicking, like all your all your passes are clean, all your shots go in the net.
- 19:41Ian Brown: And and you know, he's describing a state of an organization that has implicit communication, implicit trust with each other that isn't isn't expressed via words.
- 19:51Ian Brown: It's just been established in how they've trained and practiced together, and now you're seeing it on the floor of competition.
- 19:57Ian Brown: Um, and and and it's and it's a great fantastic analogy.
- 20:00Ian Brown: He also talks about, you know, when it comes to tempo, right?
- 20:04Ian Brown: Like clock management.
- 20:05Ian Brown: Like sometimes you want to like you want to burn time off the clock by keeping the clock running, you know, especially in football, right?
- 20:11Ian Brown: Like if you're ahead, you just want to burn time off the clock because you don't you want to minimize the amount of time the other team has the ball.
- 20:16Ian Brown: But sometimes you want to slow the clock down, right?
- 20:19Ian Brown: Slow the tempo down and make every second count to your advantage so that you you you can exploit or gain an advantage, even if there's only, you know, like again in in in football or basketball, right?
- 20:31Ian Brown: Like you call key timeouts so that you can you can halt the tempo, reorganize yourself, and uh possibly adjust your strategy so that every one of those final few seconds, you still have an opportunity to gain an advantage.
- 20:44Ian Brown: And and that stuff just isn't, it's just not in the slides, but you hear him talk about it in the in the transcripts, and it like it like, aha, I've got some practical applications of these things that he's you know talking about at very high levels.
- 20:55Ian Brown: What do you got, Brother?
- 20:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh, there's a solid connection to what you just brought up between implicit guidance and control, uh the reallocation of the dynamic reallocation of resources with a high flow sport activity like hockey, and of course uh flow states.
- 21:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the the what you just brought up there is is perfect, and that is implicit guidance and control leads to that heightened sense of peak performance or or those flow states.
- 21:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what John Boyd brought up.
- 21:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He didn't mention Mihai, he chicken me high anywhere uh that I found, but he did understand flow at a different level.
- 21:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's I just want to point that out for our listeners that when you're when Ian's bringing that up, that's the connection.
- 21:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The second tech connection is uh dynamic reallocation of resources.
- 21:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that is a team science thing which says that highly interdependent team activities, uh things like basketball and hockey, which are also flow games, uh moving something from a point or an area to a point, uh that is what we want to emulate and and and copy uh in business uh and in warfare is is how do we do that at a high level.
- 21:57Ian Brown: Yeah, and I think the words you just used are like, you know, he he was sort of talking about these things and but not necessarily using you know terminology that came later.
- 22:05Ian Brown: Um I that that is actually one of the I think the key insights that readers can get from this book is and I I think I mentioned it a little bit in my preface to it, is that Boyd sort of like he had this, you know, instinctual or kind of of gut level understanding of some emerging trends, but you know, the the trends were still very new and nascent and didn't necessarily have the words or terminology attached to it yet.
- 22:31Ian Brown: But it was clear he was like he was he was thinking about it, right?
- 22:34Ian Brown: And so one of the points I made in in the introduction is Boyd regularly talks about the use of like strategic messaging and narrative and having having word have actions match words as ways to either generate trust and cohesion on your side or by showing the divergence between word and action, generating mistrust and lack of cohesion on the other person's side.
- 22:59Ian Brown: And he often talks about, you know, people look at like your subordinates, like they'll look up at you and and you're saying one thing, but you're doing another thing, and they'll they'll be like, you know, those dirty rats, you know, they're they're they're talking out about they're hypocrites, they're talking out of both, you know, sides of their mouth.
- 23:15Ian Brown: Um and I I and I in in this day and age, like it is it is so much easier for disparity between word and action to be observed because every human is now a sensor in the information space, right?
- 23:31Ian Brown: Like boy, like you know, 1997, boy died.
- 23:34Ian Brown: The internet was, you know, taking baby steps toward being something that more and more people had access to.
- 23:41Ian Brown: Uh but I think 1997, I'm still in high school.
- 23:44Ian Brown: I, you know, had a dial-up modem that was competing with the actual phone line in my house, you know, for internet access.
- 23:50Ian Brown: And the the volume of information you could get from this thing called the internet was not huge.
- 23:55Ian Brown: Whereas now, you know, like I'm looking, I've got I'm talking to you through one mobile device and I'm holding two others and or wearing one other here.
- 24:02Ian Brown: I have three different information nodes on my body, right?
- 24:06Ian Brown: And this is now like this sort of the standard for um a lot of people on this planet, even in the poorest of countries.
- 24:14Ian Brown: Like poor countries, everybody's still got a cell phone, right?
- 24:16Ian Brown: Like it's the the technology is so cheap and so proliferated.
- 24:20Ian Brown: And now each one of those is an information node into you know, actions matching words, or having boy talked a lot about having a positive strategic method, right?
- 24:31Ian Brown: Like a you a unifying vision, a vision so noble that could, you know, bring your bring your friends together tightly, but then you know, work as a work to undermine your adversary because your message contrasts with their very negative message, and people are going to want the positive one, right?
- 24:47Ian Brown: So simply having having a positive message that said that says, hey, it's good to be on my team, come to my team, is a is a strategic weapon.
- 24:57Ian Brown: Um and we and again, we have so many more devices now that allow those messages to get out and get proliferated that I think I think if you know, if you did jump drop boy down on the world today, the way messaging, both good messaging and bad messaging is being used, I think he would he would inherently understand because he was already thinking about how you use messaging either as a strength on your side or a weapon against the on the other side.
- 25:23Mark McGrath: We won't go.
- 25:24Ian Brown: He just didn't have words for it.
- 25:25Mark McGrath: We won't go down the rabbit hole, but one of the things I've been taking the charge on is fusing Boyd with Marshall McLuhan.
- 25:32Mark McGrath: And Boyd with the you know, the medium is the message, and again, we won't go into it in depth because we want to stay on the book.
- 25:38Mark McGrath: I'll just say that Boyd inherently understood everything that Marshall McLuhan was saying, even though he never read them.
- 25:45Mark McGrath: Although Andrew McLuhan, who's his grandson, who's a previous guest on our show and um we interact with quite a bit, was surprised that he never read Marshall McLuhan because he read everything else.
- 25:57Mark McGrath: Like he bracked, he basically bracketed around all the things that McLuhan had read.
- 26:01Mark McGrath: So I guess it made a lot of sense to him that that Boyd would understand these things inherently.
- 26:05Mark McGrath: What you're underlying and underscoring right there is the fact that, yeah, Boyd actually did understand the medium and its effect on people and how the form does it is it is important, more important oftentimes than the content.
- 26:17Ian Brown: Yeah, and I I've I've been I've read some of your stuff that you've been putting out with McLuhan and Boyd.
- 26:22Ian Brown: And um, you know, as a as a former Canadian myself, I've I'm I deeply enjoy seeing Marfa McLuhan's name get more recognition.
- 26:29Ian Brown: Although I've I've read his book, I mean, and it um I think he wrote a few books, but sort of like McLuhan's central book.
- 26:37Ian Brown: Man, that was a hard read.
- 26:39Mark McGrath: Understanding media, yeah.
- 26:40Mark McGrath: Yeah, that was a hard read.
- 26:41Mark McGrath: For our founding strategists on the world of reorientation, we're actually having uh for our monthly Zoom in October, we're actually having Andrew come and explain us and kind of give us the the cheat sheet of how to of how to read that effectively.
- 26:53Mark McGrath: Because it's once you it's like Boyd, honestly.
- 26:55Mark McGrath: McLuhan and Boyd are the same in this sense.
- 26:57Mark McGrath: Once you see it, you can't unsee it.
- 26:59Mark McGrath: And once you once you get Boyd, you can't unget it and you can't unsee it.
- 27:02Mark McGrath: McLuhan is the same and they and they go together so well.
- 27:05Mark McGrath: Um, the other one that I talk a lot about is Tayer Des Chardin, which they had both been familiar with, and Boyd had read.
- 27:11Mark McGrath: And the more that you get into Boyd, particularly around orientation, it seems to me, and the more the deeper that you read that book, Phenomenon of Man, by Taylor Des Chardin, which which Boyd read, which by the way, my next trip to the archives, I want to find that and and read the margin notes because I I think that probably had a lot more effect on on Boyd than we than we than we know or understand.
- 27:30Mark McGrath: But we won't, we don't need to go down that rabbit hole.
- 27:32Mark McGrath: So you write this book, this is great because I I think one of the things that you do really well is something that Ponch and I do um a lot, is crash the misconceptions of the simplified ODA loop that was invented over the skies of Korea by a fighter pilot.
- 27:50Mark McGrath: You know, I f I feel like all those things are bullshit.
- 27:53Mark McGrath: And when we talk about authentic UDA emerging from you know the YF-16 and the YF-17 flyoffs and all that stuff, and and his work on destruction and creation, we start talking about that.
- 28:04Mark McGrath: Your your and Franz's book is actually receipts.
- 28:07Mark McGrath: Here are the receipts for that.
- 28:11Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 28:11Ian Brown: Um I and that's why I um the last chapter in the book, we um it focuses explicitly on the ODA loop.
- 28:19Ian Brown: Although I again I think in in having all of this finally together in one place for the reader, you can, you know, you can you can watch Boyd's intellectual progression over time because we've we've tried to order the presentations in the you know the the point in time at which Boyd first started talking about them.
- 28:36Ian Brown: So, you know, Patterson of Conflict was the first big one, and he iterated a ton on that before he ever started spitting off these other presentations that look more deeply.
- 28:44Ian Brown: Um, you know, so but it yeah, the the book is structured in such an order that you are walking through um, you know, Boyd's own sort of intellectual journey as he, you know, taking destruction and and creation as the engine that's driving everything else.
- 28:59Ian Brown: And then each of the presentations is is really him trying to explore more deeply different aspects of destruction and creation.
- 29:06Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 29:07Ian Brown: Um, and and some, you know, patterns of conflict very much grounded in the real world, grounded in military history.
- 29:12Ian Brown: Some of his other presentations get a lot more abstract.
- 29:15Ian Brown: Um, but I'd say like organic design for command and control is fairly abstract.
- 29:20Ian Brown: I'd initially thought the conceptual spiral, like based on the slides, was very abstract, but it's it's actually a very deep walk through like the scientific method and scientific progress and how people, you know, built on the work that previous people had done in different spaces.
- 29:35Ian Brown: And so like the book itself was showing how like Boyd is building on himself over time as he's more deeply exploring his own ideas.
- 29:42Ian Brown: But but two things I think about O loop is uh interesting is that one, yes, we I included a chapter at the end with some analysis of it based on Boyd's notes in the archives where he sort of gets into, you know, well, you know, okay, where did I get what what did the different pieces of the loop mean and where did I get them?
- 29:58Ian Brown: Uh but if you are if if you read the book from start to finish, you you see that uh the the OODA loop wasn't was not like uh first like he didn't come up with it and then try and like spend the rest of his life trying to fill it in.
- 30:14Ian Brown: Right.
- 30:14Ian Brown: The way it flows is that he's uh he's he references it, but he doesn't uh uh it's it's not like uh a key uh foundational underpinning.
- 30:24Ian Brown: Uh it's really something that he he fleshed out and really came to near the end of his life, which is why if you look in, you know, if you listen to patterns of conflict, yeah, he talks about oodaloops.
- 30:35Ian Brown: If you listen, if you I say listen, now you can read it, right?
- 30:38Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 30:38Ian Brown: That's the whole that's the whole point.
- 30:39Ian Brown: But as you re as you read through his presentations, he references oodaloops.
- 30:43Mark McGrath: Well, and if you listen to those and you read those, one would think, without any other previous knowledge or reading destruction and creation, one would think that he's just talking about this.
- 30:53Mark McGrath: But his own at least the illustration of his own thinking evolved because in '95, when he drew the Oodaloop sketch, it's very clear that he's not talking about this.
- 31:03Mark McGrath: He's not talking about uh yeah.
- 31:06Ian Brown: Yeah, he's not.
- 31:06Ian Brown: And it's and in in the notes that are in the archives, and we have in that final chapter, I've I've got some snapshots because I found I didn't find these notes until I think after I'd written A New Conception of War, and I was starting to go into This project.
- 31:19Ian Brown: But you know, he's got um there's a number of different sort of versions of the Oodo loop that he was toying around with, some of which he like he substituted like the steps of the scientific method rather than O O D A.
- 31:31Ian Brown: It was, um, I'm not gonna try and read his handwriting here, but they're like O O A H T, you know, you know, hypo hypothesis and thesis, right?
- 31:40Ian Brown: Like, yeah, so he he was looking at it from a few different ways, but then there's a um a final note where where he talks about like where the different pieces of the loop come from, right?
- 31:50Ian Brown: Like, so in and the analysis and synthesis synthesis, excuse me, inside orientation, his note says equals destruction and creation.
- 31:59Ian Brown: Yeah, right.
- 32:00Ian Brown: Like so that's like that kernel, that engine that underlays everything is the very beginning.
- 32:05Ian Brown: He talks about UDA equals POC.
- 32:08Ian Brown: So he's talking about patterns of conflict.
- 32:09Ian Brown: He talks about um the different components inside orientation.
- 32:13Ian Brown: G-H, C T P E U C equals O D C C.
- 32:17Ian Brown: Uh so that's your genetic heritage, your cultural tradition, previous experiences, unfolding circumstances, those he's linking to organic design for command and control.
- 32:24Ian Brown: I and I'm not sure.
- 32:25Mark McGrath: We should show you Ponch and I have a spreadsheet of all the when we were in there of all the abbreviations that we've looked at, because the ones that you have in the book, we've actually we actually have screen like pictures that we took while we were in there too, and it's still incomplete.
- 32:40Mark McGrath: And we've involved, you know, spinning and richards and G.I.
- 32:43Mark McGrath: Wilson and others to try to crack the code, and there's still there's still abbreviations we're still trying to figure out.
- 32:48Ian Brown: Yeah, so it was it was I appreciated the fact that Boyd left at least like a little bit of a key in some of his notes on this, you know.
- 32:56Ian Brown: But the but the the ultimate point was the final oodle loop that he came up with, he didn't draw it down until near the end of his life.
- 33:02Ian Brown: And it was pretty clear, like it was not the starting point.
- 33:05Ian Brown: It was like the the summation of all the other decades of thought that he had done.
- 33:10Ian Brown: And that was his way of his thinking evolved.
- 33:12Ian Brown: Depicting this.
- 33:13Ian Brown: Yeah, his thinking evolved, and and that was the sort of the final summation, but it it was not the starting point.
- 33:19Ian Brown: It wasn't oodaloop sounds cool.
- 33:21Ian Brown: I'm gonna try and spend the rest of my life smashing stuff in to fit it.
- 33:25Ian Brown: He didn't he didn't build it until he had spent decades exploring lots of other ideas and concepts.
- 33:30Mark McGrath: What that's a key word, exploring.
- 33:32Mark McGrath: And that's another commonality that he and McLuhan had.
- 33:35Mark McGrath: They were exploring and explaining.
- 33:37Mark McGrath: They weren't, or they they weren't, or were they rather they were exploring, not necessarily explaining, because things were always evolving and changing, and they both they both saw that, and they both were able to let go of things once they realized that that thing was no longer wrong.
- 33:52Mark McGrath: They weren't going to ride something down to the bottom.
- 33:54Mark McGrath: They they would let go and they would they would uh you know incorporate or reorient to the new information.
- 33:59Mark McGrath: They both had that in common, which is another really interesting uh um it's it's an expansion of what they do because of the constant process of this exploration and discovery, the constant process of uh destruction and creation.
- 34:12Mark McGrath: And you see McLuhan do the exact same thing within within years of writing a book saying the complete opposite a couple of years later because of new information or new explorations that he realized that that was no longer accurate or relevant.
- 34:26Ian Brown: Yeah, and I think you again in sort of the chronological flow of these of the presentations now, as you see it like if it if if Boyd had like just sort of like locked his thinking into, you know, these examples from military history explain everything, and that's just gonna be my go-to for the rest of my life, you'd like his other presentations would probably just read like you know, different excursions on military history.
- 34:48Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 34:49Ian Brown: But they they don't.
- 34:50Ian Brown: And that's that's what I think is really interesting is chronic as chronologically he's letting his mind go to different places that are um not necessarily directly related to the starting point.
- 35:02Ian Brown: So like you, you know, you start off with military, well, actually, you start off with destruction and creation, right?
- 35:06Ian Brown: Which uh which does have a very heavily sort of science-informed framework to it, you know, but then he spends a lot of you know, the longest presentation being patterns of conflict.
- 35:16Ian Brown: He he spends a lot of time swimming in military history.
- 35:19Ian Brown: But then as you go forward, you can get it.
- 35:23Mark McGrath: And he's riffing off of even though he's talking about military history and conflict and warfare, he's still riffing off of destruction and creation.
- 35:31Ian Brown: Yeah, he is.
- 35:32Ian Brown: And then and then he he can't like each of the following presentations.
- 35:35Ian Brown: It's all a riff off destruction and creation.
- 35:37Ian Brown: Is another riff.
- 35:38Ian Brown: And so like you go like conceptual spiral is heavily like it is, man, it is deeply like scientific method in the history of science and form.
- 35:47Ian Brown: Oh, totally.
- 35:47Ian Brown: If you were to look at it in isolation, you you'd be like, these were not done by the same guy.
- 35:52Mark McGrath: Well, well, so so so that that's the point, though.
- 35:55Mark McGrath: When people say, I'm gonna write a book about Boyd and how to use it in business, or I'm gonna I'm gonna talk about Boyd, or we're gonna teach you the Oodaloop sketch, and they haven't read or dug deep on destruction creation conceptual spiral.
- 36:06Mark McGrath: I'm sorry, you're not gonna be able to grasp anything of John Boyd.
- 36:11Mark McGrath: If you don't understand destruction creation fundamentally, and that everything from that was riffing and developing riffing and then ending his life really with the with the Oodaloop sketch.
- 36:20Mark McGrath: And I don't know how you can teach good Boyd if you're if you misunderstand or don't understand or have never read destruction and creation.
- 36:29Ian Brown: Well, you know, the my hope, my goal with this book is that you you can at least teach better Boyd.
- 36:36Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 36:37Ian Brown: Right?
- 36:37Ian Brown: Because now you've got the The receipts.
- 36:39Ian Brown: You have the receipts.
- 36:40Ian Brown: The primary you have the receipts, you have the primary source material.
- 36:43Ian Brown: I have listened to all the audio so that nobody else ever has to.
- 36:46Ian Brown: And it's now bad though.
- 36:49Speaker 02: Be honest.
- 36:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I have a confession.
- 36:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have a confession.
- 36:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh patterns of conflict, I always push this side.
- 36:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It wasn't the most important thing to me until the book came out.
- 36:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And here's why.
- 36:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When you look at the transcript, you there's 81 times that it's mentioned in there.
- 37:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh John Boyd brings up surprise.
- 37:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's in the brief, it's in his transcript as well.
- 37:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why does this matter?
- 37:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He points out very clearly that um it's about surprise minimization.
- 37:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We create surprise for others, we take actions that create surprise, and we want to minimize that surprise.
- 37:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, where am I going with this?
- 37:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is in patterns of conflict, something that I pushed aside for a long time.
- 37:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And again, going back to what you just published showed me I was wrong.
- 37:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That contains the piece of information that makes a strong connection to what we've been arguing about for the last four or five years.
- 37:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that is a connection between Boyd's journey to sketching Noodaloo and where we are today with the latest and greatest in neuroscience.
- 37:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that is the free energy principle and active inference.
- 37:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The purpose of the free energy energy principle is to minimize surprise.
- 37:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Living system minimize surprise.
- 37:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what it's what it's about.
- 37:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So just this week, after reading it, I'm like, holy shit, there it is, right there.
- 37:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: John Boyd's own words coming right out saying we have to minimize surprise, right?
- 38:01Mark McGrath: So I and he and he also says to tag on the what Ponch just said, he also makes it clear in the audience in the transcript that surprise is not an input.
- 38:09Mark McGrath: You can't input surprise.
- 38:11Mark McGrath: Surprise is an outcome.
- 38:12Mark McGrath: It's not saying we're going to use surprise here.
- 38:15Mark McGrath: You know, you you hope there's surprise, but you don't know that.
- 38:18Ian Brown: Yeah, and that's uh that's one of those areas where I found I I hope that the you know the full transcripts prove helpful because um, for example, he does uh at the end of Patterns of Conflict, he does this excursion on like the principles of war.
- 38:31Ian Brown: And in the slides themselves, it doesn't really capture his sort of very clear disdain for like trying to make lists out of principles and just like throw them all against the wall and you know think that you've discovered something smart.
- 38:44Ian Brown: You know, he made but he makes the point in all of these different lists, and he has like five or six different lists by country, which they're all different, by the way.
- 38:50Ian Brown: So I think he said, like, will the real principles please stand up at some point?
- 38:54Ian Brown: You know, but his point is they're not they're not organized or categorized, like they have inputs and outputs all mixed together, which is not not helpful if you're trying to figure out if if I want, as you said, if I want surprises my output, what is my input?
- 39:07Ian Brown: But I have like surprise and you know, speed and a bunch of other principles just listed without any any methodology of is surprise my input or is speed my input?
- 39:18Ian Brown: Or like, you know, and that's the he doesn't spend he doesn't spend a tremendous amount of time, and it's you know, it's at the end of like six hours of him talking.
- 39:25Ian Brown: So um you can understand his audience might have been a little aghast at that point, but it's the his explaining, you know, why you can't distill things down into principles and why it's important to look in terms of inputs and outputs, because as you said, surprise is an output.
- 39:40Ian Brown: So what do I have to what do I have to put in?
- 39:42Ian Brown: What do I have to do to have a surprise be the thing that is then imposed on my opponent?
- 39:48Ian Brown: Because I don't impose surprise.
- 39:49Ian Brown: Like there's no there's no like artillery shell of surprise or J DM of surprise that I'm dropping, right?
- 39:56Ian Brown: I'm dropping high explosives, which is so my input is violence and physical destruction and shock.
- 40:02Ian Brown: Uh so my my output from that could then be surprise and shock and loss of tempo.
- 40:08Ian Brown: But it's uh and I I think he also talking about surprise, he he sort of doesn't appreciate folks who are like, oh, I'm I'm just never gonna be surprised, right?
- 40:16Ian Brown: It's like I will never be caught by surprise.
- 40:18Ian Brown: He's like bullshit.
- 40:19Ian Brown: No, like you can never, you can never like think of every possible thing the enemy's gonna do to you.
- 40:23Ian Brown: You may get surprised by something you did not expect.
- 40:26Ian Brown: The important point is is your mental framework adaptable enough that you can like absorb the blow, adjust, shift, and then keep going to you know, either continue your operation or adjust it based on the new circumstances, right?
- 40:40Ian Brown: But simply saying you're never gonna be surprised is well, it's gonna hurt.
- 40:44Ian Brown: You say that, it's gonna really hurt when you're surprised because you're not gonna have an answer for it because you didn't think through that eventuality.
- 40:50Ian Brown: Rather than I don't know what my opponent's gonna do, they're gonna do stuff that I don't expect.
- 40:55Ian Brown: So I'm gonna prepare for that by building myself good orientation, good implicit communication, and having my having me and my subordinates able to respond with agility when the surprise comes, because it's gonna come at some point.
- 41:09Mark McGrath: Yeah, that's another thing that you guys do a great job at is really zeroing in on the primacy of orientation and not speed.
- 41:17Mark McGrath: Speed's important, but if you're misoriented or disoriented, your speed doesn't matter anything.
- 41:24Mark McGrath: You're just going really fast in the wrong direction.
- 41:27Ian Brown: Yeah, I think he he says the words, I think it's in Patterson Conflict, where he's like, people talk about like speed, we're gonna go fast.
- 41:35Ian Brown: It's like you're gonna go fast, you're gonna go fast.
- 41:36Ian Brown: If all you're doing is going fast for the sake of going fast, you're just gonna drive yourselves crazy, right?
- 41:41Ian Brown: Like speed, speed on its own is not the point.
- 41:44Ian Brown: It's the tempo and relative speed compared to what your adversary is doing.
- 41:48Ian Brown: And as he does with the sports analogies, which again, they're not in the slides, but they're in the the transcript.
- 41:54Ian Brown: Sometimes you want to slow that speed down.
- 41:56Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 41:56Ian Brown: Right?
- 41:56Ian Brown: Like he makes he makes the point about the V, you know, the North Vietnamese army and the Viet Cong.
- 42:01Ian Brown: They had a very slow tempo, right?
- 42:02Ian Brown: Like they were happy to slow down the clock and use every single second and extend that game as long as they could, because they knew the longer that game extended, eventually we would run out of we'd run out of energy.
- 42:15Mark McGrath: They had a completely different orientation.
- 42:17Mark McGrath: So at that scale, their OODA loop was processing completely differently than than ours.
- 42:23Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 42:25Mark McGrath: And it's um yeah, yeah.
- 42:26Mark McGrath: I think the We went down, I don't say a rabbit hole, I think we went down a a really good route with that because we brought up patterns and how Boyd was talking about Bruce Palmer's book and then the Kripenovich book, uh, I think the Army in Vietnam.
- 42:41Mark McGrath: And then he was also talking a lot about the CAP program.
- 42:43Mark McGrath: So I went back and pulled my old TBS copy of The Village and we read that, and we had Bing West talking about it.
- 42:50Ian Brown: And Bing West came on the show and he was talking about how that orientation and approach was actually highly effective that the Marine CAP program was using and the Marine and the in the uh and the Army Green Berets were using, and Boyd talks about it in the transcript that you have, and that was the one thing that was actually working really well in the in the Vietnam War, but the prevailing orientation didn't yeah, it was the you know, on our side, we wanted we wanted we thought that like fast speed and immediate results was the way to to succeed in that conflict.
- 43:27Ian Brown: Um and it wasn't.
- 43:28Ian Brown: It was the you know, the CAP program understood the the Viet Cong and North Vietnamese, they want to extend the game.
- 43:35Ian Brown: So the CAP program, we're gonna extend right along with them, right?
- 43:38Ian Brown: Um as long as it takes.
- 43:40Ian Brown: Um, until we stop doing that.
- 43:43Mark McGrath: Well, and and the Marine Corps University, which you're affiliated with, has done a great job of uh I I wish that stuff was more widely, widely shared.
- 43:51Mark McGrath: You know, the uh the uh punch, in fact, what was our first trip to the archives together?
- 43:57Mark McGrath: There's that little room where they have all those sort of free books you can take.
- 44:01Mark McGrath: And they had the copies of uh civic action from uh 1966 to 67 or whatever it was, and the publishing approval date from some major general was January, early January of 68.
- 44:12Mark McGrath: I'm thinking, oh my god, he wrote that the morning or the sorry, the month that the TED Offensive was about to start, and he was telling, you know, these these uh I can't think of the guy's name.
- 44:22Mark McGrath: He was a professor at NPS for a long time, but he was basically telling everybody, hey, this is working.
- 44:27Mark McGrath: You know, this is actually working, and nobody, nobody cared.
- 44:31Ian Brown: Yeah, well, you had you had the shock and surprise of the TED Offense to be something that, you know, was not expected.
- 44:37Ian Brown: And we, you know, we the Royal We didn't have the the agility or the mental framework to realize that, hey, they, you know, the Viet Cong actually came out and exposed themselves and uh and we really hurt them.
- 44:49Ian Brown: But the problem was going back to the you know, the words and actions not matching, we we've been saying, and you know, stop me if you've heard this before in recent wars, like we've turned the corner in Vietnam, we've turned the corner in Vietnam, and then you had the Tet Offensive look like, wow, they were full of shit, right?
- 45:04Ian Brown: Like obviously there's still very strong armed resistance.
- 45:07Ian Brown: Why are we here?
- 45:08Ian Brown: What is this all about?
- 45:09Ian Brown: And changed changed the strategic narrative of the war.
- 45:13Ian Brown: And it demonstrated a very big disparity between our words and our actions, because if we had turned the corner, how the hell did they just launch like a full cross-country attack on multiple points simultaneously, right?
- 45:26Ian Brown: Like if we've turned the corner, they shouldn't have been able to do that.
- 45:29Mark McGrath: So why kind of on this topic then, you know, the the other the constant debate of Clausewitz versus Sun Tzu, and and Boyd, I think, understood both better than anybody.
- 45:38Mark McGrath: Um and he used to say the art of war was the one book that he could never find fault with, and he had a lot of contradictions, and we've we've all three of us have all been in the archives to read that copy of On War and read all the marginalia.
- 45:52Mark McGrath: In fact, I took a picture of every page where he wrote a margin note.
- 45:55Mark McGrath: He does a really good job in the text of patterns of conflicts explaining Clausewitz's shortfall.
- 46:00Mark McGrath: How do you think that the transcript helps color that in?
- 46:04Mark McGrath: Because it seems it seems to me that it does make the case that there are good things about Clausewitz, but if you're a Clausewitz absolutist, you're gonna get to that situation we just kind of described, the difference between success with CAP and uh Green Berets and Gorilla Warfare versus the you know the conventional dump everything, bring everything to a bloodbath mindset.
- 46:23Ian Brown: So it's interesting because I've had uh a friend of mine who's also done a fair amount of work, both both both on Boyd, but also Klauswitz, who has a theory that like for all of Boyd's apparent angst against and criticism of Klauswitz, Boyd may have been like kind of a closet admirer in some way, or at least a grudging admirer, because he spends a lot of time grappling with Klauswitz.
- 46:46Ian Brown: Um yeah, as you can see from that that screenshot right there, like um I I think I did a like a word, uh, a word and an idea count at some point.
- 46:57Ian Brown: And like some Sun Tzu and Klauswitz are like the top two theorists that Boyd discusses, certainly in patterns of conflict, right?
- 47:05Ian Brown: Where you know, where we're talking military theory.
- 47:08Ian Brown: Um and I think I think he devotes a lot of time to it because he takes Clauswitz seriously, right?
- 47:15Mark McGrath: Like there are there are some theorists shit on Klauswitz, but he he he points out the contradictions, I guess.
- 47:22Ian Brown: That's he he does.
- 47:24Ian Brown: And I think I think part of it was likely, you know, he he legitimately found found flaws in it.
- 47:30Ian Brown: And and as part of his building, like his building block approach, he's like, all right, there are pieces of Klauswitz that we can take, but there's also pieces that we want to leave behind, and we don't want to like get locked into a Klauswitzian model because it's not it's not complete, right?
- 47:44Mark McGrath: And that's and I mean he would he wouldn't even say like we should only be Sun Tzu and nothing else.
- 47:48Mark McGrath: He would never say anything like that.
- 47:50Ian Brown: No, he uh but he's you know but he he does spend a lot of time critiquing Klauswitz.
- 47:55Ian Brown: But um I like I said I think it's partly because he he he thinks there are there are insights in Klauswitz, but there are also flaws, and he wants to distinguish the one from the other so that you are taking the useful stuff forward, um, but then layering it on top of it all the other things he explores later on in patterns and conflict.
- 48:16Ian Brown: Um and I, you know, I also think like it's it's clear he takes Klauswitz seriously because there are some theorists and writers who he very obviously like boy is like almost dismissive of.
- 48:25Ian Brown: And interestingly, one of one of them is sort of like the key villain in this other book about Boyd, which I had some serious problems with a few years ago.
- 48:34Ian Brown: And we know the book.
- 48:36Ian Brown: Don't even mention it.
- 48:37Ian Brown: And and and actually that book was part of the catalyst for me to finally get off my my ass and finish this one.
- 48:44Mark McGrath: Uh that that book has robbed many a bird of some of the best birdcage liner available.
- 48:50Ian Brown: It's yeah, it's it's rough.
- 48:53Ian Brown: But this is why going back to the going to the primary source material, doing the archival work, you know, that we we have collectively done to find out what did he actually think, what did he actually write in the note in the in the marginalia.
- 49:07Ian Brown: But it was oh lord, VH little heart, right?
- 49:11Ian Brown: So Boyd is is fairly dismissive of Hart.
- 49:13Ian Brown: I think he he mentions him by name one to one or two times in in the version of Patterns of Conf that I use.
- 49:20Ian Brown: Um in the in the video version, he mentions him, I think, but in both cases, it is highly dismissive.
- 49:25Ian Brown: And he says, you know, Hart's book strategy, it's more like I'm paraphrasing, but it's mostly garbage, right?
- 49:31Ian Brown: Like so it's heart, heart has one maybe good point, but the rest of it is mostly garbage.
- 49:35Ian Brown: It's not worth your time.
- 49:36Ian Brown: That is not something that is captured in the slides, but it's it's interesting because that book, that other book, one of the core like pillars of its thesis is that Boyd was deeply enamored of BH Little Hart and was just like sucking down all of Hart's ideas without question.
- 49:53Ian Brown: And like you you listened to his his presentations and now you can read them, right?
- 49:57Ian Brown: Boy, like Hart, he Boyd doesn't give Hart almost a second thought.
- 50:01Ian Brown: He's like, Yeah, that book's strategy, it's not that great.
- 50:04Ian Brown: Moving on, let's talk about Klauswitz, right?
- 50:07Ian Brown: Because Klauswitz, you know, had but he takes Klauswitz seriously as somebody who is a you know like a pure intellect, right?
- 50:15Ian Brown: Like I need I need to take Klauswitz seriously because Klauswitz was serious and thought deeply about war with uh put a lot of rigor and effort into it.
- 50:23Ian Brown: And yes, I have some problems with his framework, and these are what the problems are, but I take him seriously.
- 50:28Speaker 02: Well, it's also unfinished, too, right?
- 50:30Speaker 02: Didn't Klauswitz not.
- 50:32Ian Brown: Yeah, Klauswitz died out before he had a final draft, and so a lot of it is you know his his wife's best efforts to be like a post-to-mis editor, you know.
- 50:39Ian Brown: Um yeah, so you know, in Klauswitz's defense, maybe he would have revised a lot of the stuff to Boyd critiques had he lived longer, right?
- 50:46Mark McGrath: Um I mean that that that take on that bad book, I think it's just it it reduces Boyd to like a warfare strategist only.
- 50:54Mark McGrath: And one of the things that Ponch and I talk about incessantly, without without end almost unceasingly, is the fact that Boyd is looking at complexity.
- 51:02Mark McGrath: Military conflict is a portion of what he's talking about, but at the highest level, this is universal application.
- 51:07Mark McGrath: This is for use in any organization where humans make decisions.
- 51:11Mark McGrath: It doesn't necessarily have to be a uh a rifle battalion.
- 51:14Mark McGrath: It could be it could and that's where that's and it could be in any domain, too, where humans experience conflict, which is not limited to warfare.
- 51:22Ian Brown: No, it's not.
- 51:23Ian Brown: And and that's why I I I hope people find this particular book valuable because yes, you've got patterns of conflict, which is about war, right?
- 51:31Ian Brown: And he's talking to military audiences mostly when he's delivering that.
- 51:35Ian Brown: But all of his other presentations, you know, the organic design for command and control, you know, that's talking about leadership and communication within an organization.
- 51:43Ian Brown: And that's that's as applicable in the business world in an organization as it is in a rifle battalion, right?
- 51:49Ian Brown: And then you if you fast forward to the conceptual spiral, that's all about like the scientific process of build, like looking at what past work has done, but not unquestioningly accepting it, looking at it, questioning it, taking what works, but then continuing to ask what if, right?
- 52:07Ian Brown: Like that, you know, so-and-so came up with like this equation, and in conceptual spiral, he's got like four or five slides, which when I was footnoting these, it was really painful.
- 52:18Ian Brown: And I ultimately had to make some editorial decisions about how much detail like to put into each of those, because I otherwise I'd be writing like biographies of like four dozen different scientists, and then then that chapter would be about those scientists and not about Boyd.
- 52:32Ian Brown: So I hadn't truncated a little bit.
- 52:34Ian Brown: But his point is like he talks about all right, scientist X came up with this equation to explain gravity, right?
- 52:40Ian Brown: And then scientist Y looked at this equation and I was like, hey, this is good, but I still have questions, like there's I feel like there's something missing.
- 52:46Ian Brown: They enhance that equation and they come up with their own, and then a then a third and a fourth and a fifth sign, like so the process never stops, right?
- 52:54Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 52:55Ian Brown: And in that context, he's in and of trying to find, you know, the better a a better, a more, a fuller, more core, more coherent answer to the problem in front of you.
- 53:05Ian Brown: And he's talking about the scientific method in that particular instance, but that always comes back to destruction and creation, which is I am always looking for a better, fuller answer to the problems that are in front of me.
- 53:18Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 53:19Ian Brown: As with like, and that's part of his point about Clauswitz, is like if you take Clauswitz as the final answer, you have stopped trying to grapple with all of the problems that came since.
- 53:29Mark McGrath: You're only looking at a pyramid from one side.
- 53:32unknown: Yeah.
- 53:33Ian Brown: You only see a triangle or or a square or a square or whatever.
- 53:36Ian Brown: Or whatever.
- 53:37Ian Brown: And that's and and you know, I think part of his why he beat up on Klauswitch so much was not to not to disparage all of Klauswitch's ideas, because he he does pull forward some stuff from Klauswitch, you know.
- 53:48Ian Brown: But his larger point is, and and it's the same point in conceptual spiral, and it's the same point in destruction creation.
- 53:54Ian Brown: You can't like you don't you can't stop and say, all right, so and so has figured it all out, and I'm just gonna like, I'm just gonna religiously follow that framework without exploring or inquiring and at any point after that, because that's how you start having that divergence between actual reality and your ability to survive in that reality and reality as you sort of see it.
- 54:14Ian Brown: So, like if we only ever took Newton as the final answer for physics, like we'd all, you know, we probably wouldn't have cars or have an American flag on the moon, right?
- 54:23Ian Brown: Right.
- 54:23Ian Brown: If we'd only taken Klauswitz as our our final framework for conflict, would we still be, you know, fighting in closely packed formations, but just murdering each other under hails of bullets?
- 54:33Mark McGrath: Yeah, our under our understanding of the universe goes a little further than Ptolemy or Copernicus these days, you know.
- 54:39Mark McGrath: But that's the conceptual, that's because of the conceptual spiral and the continuous cycle of destruction and creation.
- 54:45Ian Brown: Yeah, and that's and I think kind of uh again, if you follow the chronology of the book, his his the core engine driving it is how do I survive and thrive in a in an uncertain, ever-changing world.
- 54:55Ian Brown: And each presentation is like a different slice of looking at of of ways to do that and things that you need to do within that.
- 55:02Ian Brown: And yeah, one of them has a highly military context, but other ones have, you know, scientific and engineering context, and others have like, you know, the strategic game of isolation and interaction.
- 55:12Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 55:13Ian Brown: Hey, you could apply that sure to business strategy, but also to political strategy.
- 55:17Ian Brown: Football, hockey, football strategy, yeah, it's teaching.
- 55:20Ian Brown: It's a certain it's like, how do I make my organization better?
- 55:24Ian Brown: And if I'm competing against other organizations, how do I uh how do I exploit their fit their their fissures and or their their their poorer understanding of the reality around them?
- 55:38Mark McGrath: And your understanding of Boyd, Ian, how do you like I I have my ranking and I know Ponch has his, and how would you rank an order of importance?
- 55:47Mark McGrath: Because I've asked I've asked some of the acolytes this that are still with us.
- 55:51Mark McGrath: I've asked them this, and number number one, the answer to number one is always destruction creation, because there's no that's what he riffs off.
- 55:58Mark McGrath: So that's so that has to be number one.
- 55:59Mark McGrath: Then how would you stack the rest of them in order of importance?
- 56:02Mark McGrath: And I I I I I have mine, but I would hear yours first.
- 56:06Mark McGrath: And it doesn't have to be all of them, it could be like the one, two, three, because I I kind of have a one, two, three and then some peripherals, but what do you think?
- 56:14Mark McGrath: I I don't know.
- 56:18Mark McGrath: And by the way, number one has to be destruction creation.
- 56:21Ian Brown: No, no, destruction and creation is is the engine that drives everything else.
- 56:25Ian Brown: Yeah, like that there's no question of that in my mind.
- 56:27Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 56:30Ian Brown: Maybe I'm biased, but uh I I probably I I would submit that patterns of conflict due to its sheer size would probably be number two because due to its size, it allows him to go off and explore uh sort of in more more in different tangential conversations with his students to to get you know more deeply into some of his ideas, even though they are rooted in in military history.
- 56:55Ian Brown: Um it's just I think the the scope and scale of the presentation created more opportunities for him to have those extraneous discussions with his students that go off in interesting directions.
- 57:06Ian Brown: So um I just there's a lot of there's just a lot of stuff, useful, interesting stuff that you can sift through in patterns of conflict.
- 57:15Ian Brown: So that's why I would put it as number two, just for it's got a lot of meat to chew on in there.
- 57:20Ian Brown: The the other three, I I I don't know that I could like say, hey, one of one of these is absolute must-read compared to the rest, because they're all quite they're all different from each other.
- 57:30Ian Brown: And and the point is they're all exploring you know that engine of destruction and creation in different ways.
- 57:37Ian Brown: And I I'm I might say like, you know, it it kind of depends on you know what problem maybe you're looking at.
- 57:43Ian Brown: Like if you're looking at if you're looking at a you know, a question of maybe, you know, in internal leadership and and you know, organizational excellence for yourself, maybe you're looking at organic design because he's talking about you know what how do you effectively you know communicate and work with subordinates or your own leaders, you know, to kind of achieve a goal.
- 58:08Ian Brown: And and he gets away from the idea of like command and control.
- 58:11Ian Brown: Um, and I I forget what he he replaces it with sort of two.
- 58:15Ian Brown: Appreciation and leadership.
- 58:17Ian Brown: Yeah, as as as the structure for doing that, right?
- 58:21Ian Brown: So that's if if if if if leadership and communication is your question or problem set, you should probably look at that one, right?
- 58:27Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 58:28Ian Brown: Whereas um if you're if you're looking more at a a higher strategic level of, you know, not not trying to defeat military militarily an opponent, but understanding how to how to craft like a strategy for yourself and and have better strategies than than competing organizations, maybe the strategic aim of interaction and isolation is something you should look at.
- 58:48Ian Brown: Whereas the the conceptual spiral is almost it's so different.
- 58:52Ian Brown: It's almost like you're it's almost like him looking back through the development of ideas in the way he did with military ideas and patterns of conflict, except now he's looking at it from a scientific perspective.
- 59:04Ian Brown: Yeah.
- 59:05Ian Brown: Um, and it happens to be shorter, you know.
- 59:07Ian Brown: So it has that that going for it.
- 59:10Ian Brown: But it's it's almost like a complete like I'm gonna, I've I've looked at, I've looked at my ideas of competition through warfare.
- 59:16Ian Brown: I'm now I'm gonna look at it from a totally different angle through science, but I'm gonna see some of the same things, right?
- 59:21Ian Brown: Like constantly adapting, building on what has come before, asking questions, you know, finding, finding, challenging those assumptions of, well, you know, maybe, maybe New Newton didn't have it all right, right?
- 59:32Ian Brown: Like just like he says, maybe Klausovich didn't have it all right.
- 59:35Ian Brown: If you never ask that question in the first place, you never get to maneuver warfare and you never get to the moon, you know, to put it to put a lot of people.
- 59:43Mark McGrath: Do you feel like like like I like sort of uh like I think of Boyd's development, and you know, Chet Richards has that epistemology that kind of goes from uh destruction creation all the way to his death, sort of culminating in Oodaloop sketch, and it has all the inputs inside of it.
- 59:57Mark McGrath: So, you know, all the warfighting and all the other history and eastern philosophy and everything that he put into it.
- 1:00:02Mark McGrath: And and I kind of see it as like sort of the say the one, two, three, of course, destruction creation is the number one, the core, because everything is a riff off that.
- 1:00:10Mark McGrath: Then patterns, organic design, command, control, and strategic game are kind of like laboratories for the next big one, which is conceptual spiral, which sort of reaffirms and expands on what he what he sets out with destruction creation.
- 1:00:24Mark McGrath: And then it comes to the essence of winning and losing, which is the distillation of pretty much everything, where Udaloop sketches the only time it's ever depicted, then he dies.
- 1:00:33Mark McGrath: You know, like that's kind of the that's kind of like the big three, if you will.
- 1:00:37Mark McGrath: But I buy into what you're saying and what what Ponchett said about the concept of surprise, patterns, and the other ones really strikes me at these laboratories where he's developing the ideas that you can't have conceptual spiral if you don't have those building and leading up to that, because they sent them on so many different academic rabbit holes that came even got him to the point where he had a conceptual spiral that allowed him to distill it all in essence of winning and losing with the with the Oodaloop sketch.
- 1:01:05Ian Brown: Yeah, and uh, you know, I'm I I hope, you know, I hope people read it and maybe they, you know, they they they weight things their own way um in terms of you know which one is uh is preeminent after just.
- 1:01:18Ian Brown: and creation.
- 1:01:19Ian Brown: Um, but I I you know the I the at a minimum, like you the reader should see development of thought and the way that the material is arranged, which is why, you know, the essence of winning and losing and then the final chapter on the oodaloop is at the end because that is that is the culmination.
- 1:01:36Ian Brown: That you know he didn't he didn't one of it I'm sure drives you crazy as well, but drives me crazy is this idea like the the odo loop like he it sprung fully formed like Athena out of his head and spent the rest of his life trying to fit every peg into that square peg into that round hole right no like that was that was as you said it was the it was the distillation and then the the sketches that he made make it very clear the each presentation is a element that fed into this this final framework that he called the Oodo loop it was never the beginning the oodloop just is it's a quick snapshot of you know dozens and dozens of hours of discussion and other research that he had done over decades.
- 1:02:18Ian Brown: It's the capstone it's not the it's not the engine destruction and creation is the engine.
- 1:02:24Mark McGrath: Well it it became the capstone because he died you know and ironically I mean you know when you look at the you look at the trajectory I mean that was the fitting place where it stops I guess to some extent but what do you think like where do you think he was headed next if he had lived you know he died only at 70 which is not old by today's standards but you know if he had kept going where where do where do you think that he would have gone well like so like I said earlier I think if he had lived deeper into the digital age I think he would have inherently recognized the opportunities and vulnerabilities of of every human being suddenly becoming a potential node for strategic messaging and and narrative.
- 1:03:05Ian Brown: And yeah I think he would have had he would have had tons of stuff to say about that and it would have tied it would have all tied back to you know the my perception of reality versus actual reality.
- 1:03:15Ian Brown: Now that we have you know 500 billion different different input nodes and output nodes of of what reality means to us.
- 1:03:24Ian Brown: Yeah he he probably would have had tons to say about how do you with that that huge volume now of information nodes going in and an ability to access it coming out I'm sure he would have had tons to say about all right, okay, so how does everybody being their own information node now affect your ability to you know to prevent that that disparity between actual reality and and your perceived reality.
- 1:03:50Mark McGrath: I think as you know uh which by the way Ian everything you just said is a perfect seg into how the the fusion of Boyd and McLuhan works so well.
- 1:03:59Ian Brown: Yeah which is and well this is a little bit of a discurse but this brings you back to an interesting point because you'd said that there's no sort of evidence that McLuhan's book was part of Boyd's reading.
- 1:04:09Ian Brown: I think part of what I I I would like people to get out of the book is starting to understand you know where there might have been gaps in Boyd's own ideas and his his look at because it's been a a long critique and I think this is probably a fair critique but Boyd's pretty much silent on like naval warfare except for like an O by the way in patterns of conflict at one point he talks about how I forget the order here but like it was either you got Corbett and Mahan and one of them was beholden to Jomony and one of them was beholden to Klauswitz.
- 1:04:40Ian Brown: So if you study Jomony and Klauswitz you basically like gotten the essence of Mahan and Corbett and that's kind of all he has to say about naval strategy which you could argue is a is a is a fairly large gap because most of the world is ocean and being being silent on strategy on the ocean um is is maybe that's in that's an interesting point and you know he never had to crash a plane into a ship so he has a yeah yeah he has a completely different perspective in that respect.
- 1:05:09Ian Brown: And he's also fairly silent about you know things like logistics which again if you're if you're in that giant ocean domain man logistics you're you're doing nothing without logistics and he again like Boyd he I don't think he ever he ever presented himself or intended to be like a have a theory of everything when it comes to warfare right but you know but he did spend his largest presentation is about warfare and there are aspects of warfare he doesn't talk about so you know now you've got the fullness of his words in front of you you can start I identifying okay the these are places where uh you know Boyd was silent or if we're looking at the other presentations you know he talks about organic design for command and control which has a you know appreciation and leadership element communication is a huge part of that but he doesn't talk about McLuhan at all right and he he talks about strategic messaging and narrative and how you can use messaging and narrative to get allies to your side to peel peel allies away from your adversary and get them to you know but he doesn't talk about McLuhan who is all about how you use like media and messaging to achieve certain goals.
- 1:06:17Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:06:18Ian Brown: But the bracketing on that's frustrating too man I'm telling you it's like it's so you know so part of you know part of what I I hope readers get from the book is you will it'll be clearer where the gaps um in Boyd's coverage are which potentially you know create some interesting opportunities to explore um you know where well you know how how do we improve on boyd right like boyd didn't stop at Klauswitzer Sun Tzu we can't stop at Boyd either so understanding those you know accurately understanding you know gaps or shortfalls in Boyd's own ideas okay how do we take the goodness of Boyd and then build on top of that looking at things that potentially fill in those gaps but you just add Rs to the end man that's all you do risk and then you put pre Uda uh and then you just start adding things to it is really cool.
- 1:07:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm joking.
- 1:07:10Mark McGrath: That's easier than I thought.
- 1:07:11Mark McGrath: Are you familiar with Ouda R I I think I've heard of it.
- 1:07:15Ian Brown: I'm not sure I've yeah you're not missing much.
- 1:07:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It just shows that folks haven't got in and done the work they just don't think they'll read destruction creation.
- 1:07:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't understand that risk is inherent inside of a simulation that you run within your own OODA loop right that is uh expected free energy or risk and uncertainty.
- 1:07:34Speaker 02: And the way they the way they design it it's like an imploding circle it falls on itself.
- 1:07:39Speaker 02: That's what your organization will do if you use it too.
- 1:07:42Speaker 02: But whatever.
- 1:07:43Ian Brown: I mean I I would submit that you know your your analysis and synthesis is including risk as part of that.
- 1:07:49Mark McGrath: Like you don't need a lot of we know that because we actually read the stuff we we we know that yeah but like the people in the you know it's the Peter principle I guess I don't know like this stuff becomes mainstream at NATO or wherever the hell it was because it it like people still I mean maybe we should maybe this is a great place to go people still are afraid of Boyd.
- 1:08:10Mark McGrath: They still don't like to talk about Boyd.
- 1:08:12Mark McGrath: They still don't like to because they because they're afraid of reform they're afraid of innovation.
- 1:08:17Mark McGrath: You know you mentioned naval warfare I mean remember that the Navy wouldn't give him the time you know that he that he demanded to so he never had that back and forth exchange of learning like he did with the Marine Corps and to some extent the army you know because they don't give it a second thought they are are content with what they think and what they believe and they don't want their assumptions challenged.
- 1:08:38Ian Brown: Yeah well hey maybe I again you know part of my goal in writing this book was that now you you don't have an excuse for not at least attempting to grapple with Boyd because you know up until now you know it's it's an excuse that I don't buy but like you can get away with it and saying you know we only have Boyd's flies and they don't you know I I'm gonna critique the slides but not the rest of it.
- 1:09:00Ian Brown: Or Boyd's inaccessible because he never wrote anything down which you know okay granted he didn't he didn't write down all of his speaker notes although all of these recordings had been freely available at the archives or on YouTube for those you know who were willing to put the time into it as as you know the two of you and I have tried to put the time into it.
- 1:09:19Ian Brown: But okay yeah the audio kind of sucks and it's and the video is grainy so okay I in it inaccessible and I'm using air quotes up to a point, right?
- 1:09:28Ian Brown: This I hope removes that excuse because now you have a written document you wanted Boyd in writing damn it I gave you Boyd in writing and you know because it's uh also available in PDF it's searchable right it's searchable you could now you can plug it into all that great generative AI and LLMs that I didn't have when I was writing this and have them start looking at you know themes and keywords and stuff like that because it's now in a format that it can be parsed and studied and searched and uh and more easily processed.
- 1:10:01Ian Brown: So um so now you you don't have an excuse for not grappling with Boyd.
- 1:10:05Ian Brown: You mean you like again you don't have to agree with him and he's got his own gaps and and shore falls or gaps in the reading like he never read which he would admit if he had told you he said if if you think this stuff is doctrine take it out and burn it right now.
- 1:10:19Mark McGrath: I that's that's not what I'm here to do.
- 1:10:21Ian Brown: Yeah but the the point is you no longer have the excuse that he didn't write anything down.
- 1:10:25Ian Brown: Now you've got the written boy deal with him in his own words accurately and then then we can get a better understanding for what he what he thought where he is still useful and where where we need to fill in some blanks.
- 1:10:38Ian Brown: As we wind down one last technical question you know there is that other video of tra of patterns of conflict did you ever attempt to like at a congressional office or something I'm not sure who exactly did you ever try to transcribe that way so um I believe Sean Callahan has a transcript of that um and and that compare and contrast process was was going to be um uh potentially how we were gonna collaborate and again just I I had you know I had a very aggressive timeline for getting the book done and he and he had his own responsibilities and we um we you know we were able to do that with I think strategic game but we had a plan to do it with all the rest of them and you know life just you know for both of us life life gets in the way um the I I think the the one he does at the congressional office it's a little it's a little bit shorter because I I think he'd he may have had some time constraints that you know in the evening with a bunch of Marine Corps students who were just there to like hang out and listen to him, you know, he could spend all night right and the students would still be there.
- 1:11:38Ian Brown: But I also think the the one that I have in my book because he's talking to a military audience he goes more deeply into some military and marine and indeed Marine Corps specific stuff than he does with with the congressional staff office.
- 1:11:51Ian Brown: Because like when he talks about FMFM1 war fighting like his students know exactly what that is because he was caught off the presses at that point.
- 1:11:58Ian Brown: Whereas with the congressional office maybe they I forget exactly when it was recording but you could go to like if you'd say FMFM war fighting to a bunch of congressional staffers unless they're deeply involved in Marine Corps policy they don't know what that is.
- 1:12:11Mark McGrath: If you were to speculate and guess because that's what it would be speculation and guessing I don't know if anybody's disclosed this we know for sure that Mike Wiley was in that room I speculate and guess that General Van Riper the future Lieutenant General Van Riper is in that room because his voice is absolutely unmistakable to me anyway on the on the trend on the tape.
- 1:12:33Mark McGrath: But I've heard that John Schmidt was in that room G.I.
- 1:12:36Mark McGrath: Wilson and possibly Zinnie do you have any confirmation of who was in attendance at all?
- 1:12:42Ian Brown: So I think in in a couple of the transni I mean future general I mean you we all know but General Anthony Zinny I I I'm I'm so like Wiley absolutely was there because he he and Boyd call each other out several times.
- 1:12:59Ian Brown: And he mentions Mike he says Mike you know frequently in the he mentions John and I think I call it out in transcribing that's one of them for those for those other folks if they were in the room I couldn't I I didn't they either were silent or I just didn't recognize the sound of their voices because a a lot of the interaction like the question and answers it's clear it's officers of a lesser rank than Boyd would have held when he retired right like you know it's command of South College right so a bunch of majors and they're they generally start out the questions with you know so sure I'd like to ask about whatever um you know General Van Riper or Zinny probably would not have been talk that way right um and and that's one of the one of the things that I I I note in the transcripts up front is like I there's no class rosters that I could find in the archives.
- 1:13:48Ian Brown: So aside from aside from we do know the dates though right we know the dates yeah we know the dates they're they're all in the spring of 1989 except for um conceptual spiral which was a different different time frame so we we know it was spring of 1989 for the rest of those presentations so like Van Riper and Zinnie they would have been colonels around then or brigadiers maybe they yeah I guess it wouldn't make sense that they were there.
- 1:14:09Ian Brown: They would have been generals.
- 1:14:13Ian Brown: Yeah they would have been generals at that point.
- 1:14:15Ian Brown: Yeah yeah so I short answer is I don't know based based on the discussion going on in the classroom I I kind of don't think that they were there because I feel like if they were there Boyd would have called on them the same way he did with Wiley and uh and John Schmidt a couple times.
- 1:14:34Ian Brown: So I I I don't think we were there but I don't have any any evidence one way or the other unfortunately.
- 1:14:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey guys uh my I'm about to go through a cycle of destruction creation on my front door here but I want to share a few things.
- 1:14:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So future backwards starting with destruction and creation.
- 1:14:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We know that Coram writes in the book that Boyd was on a journey to understand the nature of creativity.
- 1:14:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is after the YF 16, yf 17 fly off which you point out in your in your book on Spiller's critique of the Oodaloop Boyd makes it very clear that the Oodaloop came after that it emerged after that.
- 1:15:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Prior to that, and this is going back to what Moose brought up about the Navy the Navy did engage with John Boyd and they pointed out to him in 1969 and I don't know if you heard this yet from um Captain Dan Peterson the uh Top Gun 1 the guy that created Top Gun our Navy fighter weapon school they engaged with John Boyd and challenged him on his EM theory Naval aviation did not not not the institution it's still navy I mean well no no that yeah but the good part of the Navy.
- 1:15:27Mark McGrath: Yeah the part that actually knows how to knows what they're talking about right yeah um so but the Navy as a whole institutionally rejected Boyd.
- 1:15:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 1:15:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is my story.
- 1:15:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Dan Pederson meets with John Boyd and his guys and they challenge him on his EM theory and they say hey you're forgetting about the most important thing.
- 1:15:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So remember this is before the YF-16, YF-17 flyoff this is 1969, the emergence of the ALT report and then our fighter weapons school um standing up in Miramar, California.
- 1:15:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And they challenge him on this and they're like hey dude your your your theory forgets about the most important thing the human in the cockpit right and John Boyd stays with the Fluid 4 Air Force stays with the fluid for we we see what happens after that after the emergence of our weapons school but the point there is uh John Boyd was fixated on an algorithm his theory a closed loop theory or a closed system theory theory right and then prior to that he had aerial attack study which he basically looked at the geometry spatial orientation of fighter of a dog fight looked at the aim nine B, looked at all all these other things and was able to break down what he knew intuitively down into how you do these things.
- 1:16:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm just going backwards for the future backwards from destruction and creation.
- 1:16:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All of this led up to him trying to understand the nature of creativity.
- 1:16:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why did a man like him come up with the M theory?
- 1:16:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you do this?
- 1:16:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's where destruction and creation came from and that's where we get the oodaloop it's not like you point out in the book it's not from the cockpit of an F-80 that so many guys get wrong.
- 1:16:53Ian Brown: Any thoughts on that yeah so first off yeah I've I've been listening to some of that interview with the the top gun guy and this so that's this is part of like why I I've enjoyed studying boy and and part of what I hope the the book does is get other people to jump like more deeply into some of those areas that I just you know I never I never had the time or ability to follow the thread on.
- 1:17:16Ian Brown: So the so like like that interaction between him and Navy fighter weapon school not something I was aware of, right?
- 1:17:23Ian Brown: So that's that's an area of potentially new and interesting exploration and be like, okay, can I find you know can I now find some threads of Top Gun going through his presentations.
- 1:17:33Ian Brown: Again just not something I'd I'd encountered in my research but it could be there somewhere in the archives um you know waiting to be you know pulled out and then connected back with with his presentations.
- 1:17:45Ian Brown: But yeah I I don't know what it's gonna take to to frickin' kill the vampire of you know where the Uvu came from or the F-86.
- 1:17:56Ian Brown: I I kind of hoped that my first book might help kill that vampire.
- 1:17:59Ian Brown: I know you know you guys have tried to slay that vampire um I'm trying even harder now with this book to slay that vampire the Folk Lord it's so powerful and the myth is so powerful.
- 1:18:11Ian Brown: I mean I've written an article about it the myth of 42nd Boyd it just people just like the story the myth they they do and I um you know part I part of the I I think the how do I put this part of the challenge in in killing that vampire I think is that some of some of Boyd's most sort of ardent proponents and and enthusiastic followers or biographers didn't do him any favors in how they presented some parts of that story.
- 1:18:40Ian Brown: Like you know you mentioned you mentioned Robert Coram's book which for a long time was on the Marine Corps professional reading list um until it got taken off.
- 1:18:48Ian Brown: And I think Grant Hammond's was on there briefly and then my new conception of war got put on there as the boyd book that's on the reading list.
- 1:18:55Ian Brown: But you know I as I was doing my own research for that first book you know I kept finding man there are parts of Corum's narrative like they sound really great.
- 1:19:03Ian Brown: He tells a great story not accurate.
- 1:19:06Ian Brown: But the the problem is the really good sounding story is you said like it's already halfway around the world for stories.
- 1:19:13Mark McGrath: We want to be a lot of people before the truth gets its pants on you know so I mean think about a swashbuckling aviator knocking down enemy fighters with a silk scarf and whatever it's so much more interesting than the reality of a guy locking himself into isolation academically for years of reading books and reading books and writing notes and calling guys at like two in the morning with ideas like that's not romantic at all.
- 1:19:34Ian Brown: Yeah you know like the the the you know the picture of boyd like you know heroically climbing out of his cockpit on a front of I mean that's a great picture absolutely yeah we you we use it we reference it all the time because it is it it it definitely turns heads yeah but but you know but what you know but who who is who is the the real boyd it's the guy who for fun in his off time stole computer processing time to slide punch cards in to go explore uh engineering algorithms right like that that's that that's who he was like he you know maybe 40 seconds of his time is up there dogfighting but what he did for fun was slide punch cards into computers to explore more deeply relationships between different energy states.
- 1:20:18Mark McGrath: Bill Gates of fighter aviation there you go man well I I even try you know on the on the whirl I mean again we we have the because you know Punch and I certainly love the the the fighter pilot Boyd of course it's important to us but at the same time I've tried to integrate more imagery of Boyd as he is most often dressed for this type of work you know wearing a shitty suit with a short sleeve shirt and a tie and he looks out of place.
- 1:20:44Mark McGrath: He looks like he slept in his clothes.
- 1:20:45Mark McGrath: I mean that's the that's the academic boyd that's where all this stuff really uh really originates from.
- 1:20:51Ian Brown: Yeah he looks like one of the Bobs from Office Space you know like that's that much much better in terms of organizational structure than the Bobs from Office Space.
- 1:21:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah there's a video circulating on LinkedIn now uh there's an Australian fighter pilot telling us that the Oodle doop came from the cockpit but it's missing one important thing.
- 1:21:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's missing intent.
- 1:21:13Ian Brown: I'm like oh my gosh dude yeah just shut up yeah people are so easily seduced by just whatever but well I mean I'll all all I can do is just as a you know a an amateur historian like if you go back to the primary sources you will you're always doing the right thing so I've this is I I've I've no schlitz left to give this is my last effort to get the primary sources out there publicly accessible easily searchable readable right in a written form that you all wanted the written form now now it's in the written form and start to deal with it in its actual terms and maybe someday we'll slay the vampires of uh of all of the myths and the legends close with this close with this so I'm listening to no way out and I'm a I'm an athletic director at a high school or a college or I'm a I'm a hedge fund manager I'm a special needs parent I'm I'm somebody not a war fighter why do I need to understand and learn about John Boyd uh well it's as we've been talking about this this whole time like there's Boyd was about more than warfare I think is the ultimate thing and the the core engine driving all of Boyd's ideas was not warfare but it was it's the destruction and creation conceptual model of how of understanding your picture of reality is always incomplete and you have to always try and update yourself, suck in new information, be willing to change your perspective and let go of old conceptions if they don't match the facts of reality anymore.
- 1:22:52Ian Brown: And having your mind open and agile enough to all of those things so that you you may never get close to a perfect you know your perception reality may never be close to what is actually happening out there.
- 1:23:02Ian Brown: But you're always trying to get it to as close as you can because accurately understanding the world around you know give it puts you in a better position to survive on your own terms, which is one of the points he makes in destruction and creation to part of that surviving on your own terms is, you know, bringing others with you, right?
- 1:23:20Ian Brown: Like building up your own whether it's your your family or your team, right?
- 1:23:24Ian Brown: Like building making your organization stronger and more cohesive because you are part, you know, the more people on your team working with you who understand what you're doing, the stronger you are together and you are then better postured to uh to deal with any adversarial or or competitive challenges that come your way.
- 1:23:43Ian Brown: And I think that's part of why like yeah if you listen if you don't have to listen now if you read Patterns of Conflict and the other ones it's it's kind of why he constantly goes to sports analogies because it's like not everything is warfare, right?
- 1:23:55Ian Brown: There's other fields of competition.
- 1:23:57Ian Brown: Sports is one where nobody's dying right but you still want to win.
- 1:24:01Ian Brown: So the the the idea of of that that cohesion that understanding of reality on your side and exploiting failures to understand reality on your opponent's side applies as much to the basketball team or the hockey rink as it does to war.
- 1:24:16Ian Brown: It also applies to uh you know competitive business challenges uh it applies to the scientific method right um because that's the only way you get forward progress is by never never accepting that your mental model is complete or done or freezing it and thinking you never have to do any work again.
- 1:24:33Ian Brown: It's it's I know it sounds exhausting but you don't ever get to stop.
- 1:24:37Ian Brown: You know you don't ever get to stop that process of of of having of building your mental model to be as as accurate as it is to deal with the challenges in front of you because that's the best way to deal with those challenges.
- 1:24:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 1:24:52Ian Brown: There is no way out man there's no way out there's no way out you have to do the reading right there's no way out you have to do the reading and it's not it's not inaccessible.
- 1:25:02Mark McGrath: That's and and and you just made it even more accessible for people.
- 1:25:06Ian Brown: I sure hope I sure hope so because if I see another article or book about the Oodaloop coming from the F-86 or about how Boyd just loved BH Littleheart and was all about BH Littleheart.
- 1:25:16Ian Brown: Bad I might think when that when when this book comes out it's going to be very hard thick and hefty I may start throwing that thick and hefty book at other people hoping that if it hits them on the head maybe the knowledge will penetrate penetrate.
- 1:25:29Mark McGrath: Maybe because I don't I don't know how else to give you that information right yeah I've done everything I can yeah all right Ian Brown the book is Snowmobiles and grand ideals co-authored with the great Franzo Singa we really appreciate you coming on No Way Out and helping us drive the wooden stake through the heart of the vampire of bad boy well done my best.
- 1:25:53Ian Brown: Thank you guys again for the chance to talk with you appreciate the opportunity and I will certainly let you know when the print copies come out.
- 1:26:00Mark McGrath: Excellent we'll should be sure we tell everybody in our network awesome