Latest / The Team House / Humanitarian Aid To Gaza w/ Former CIA Paramilitary Officer Mick Mulroy | EYES ON | Ep. 11
Transcript
- 0:00Hey guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today about
- 0:03a way that you can help support the podcast. If you're not already,
- 0:07we would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us on Apple or
- 0:10Spotify. Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help it get recognized,
- 0:16and you know, if you've been enjoying the show, we really appreciate
- 0:19your support. Another thing that you can do to support the channel is to
- 0:24become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started just five dollars
- 0:29a month, and when you sign up, you get access to all of
- 0:32our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for that. I mean,
- 0:36we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers, but this is the
- 0:42biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse channel and podcast if you'd
- 0:47like to, and we really appreciate that, So go and check us out
- 0:51at patreon dot com slash the Teamhouse. Hello everyone, welcome to another episode
- 0:57of Izon, and I'm going to I'm going to introduce you very quickly,
- 1:02not because you are less important than our guest, but of course we have
- 1:07have d that's a fair assessment yeah, yeah, okay, yeah, But
- 1:10most importantly we have as our guest someone who is being on team House before
- 1:15Mick Molroy. Also importantly, someone like Counters, a friend. That's not
- 1:21why he's here. He's here because he is the former I'm going to mess
- 1:26this up. I always do Dasney Assistant Secretary of Defense for Special Operations and
- 1:33Low Intensity Conflict Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense. But after the Middle East,
- 1:38for the Middle East, I'm for the Midlease. I'm sorry. I and
- 1:42a former CIA paramilitary officer and perhaps most importantly, former marine, which is
- 1:49why, which is why Jason's not here today, because Jack has a very
- 1:53strict policy of no no three marine marines on. He was if I had
- 2:00more than one, if I had more than two, I'd get my ass
- 2:02street from Jacks. No, seriously, we had we did have complaints.
- 2:07We had one Alex Alex Hollings. We had three marines here and yeah,
- 2:12yeah, we were criticized for not being sufficiently joined. Can you believe that?
- 2:15Anyway? Mick also runs the Lobo Institute. I'm gonna let him talk
- 2:23about that, and he's he's involved in something very important right now that he
- 2:29can't talk about it. We can discuss bl likely without jeopardizing the operation itself.
- 2:34But you heard it first here on eyes on, Mick. Welcome and
- 2:38you are absolutely in stremer consciousness mode as far as I am concerned, So
- 2:44please far away. So great to be here with you guys from Montana.
- 2:49And usually if people are watching as I get out of the way, you
- 2:51can see that it is in fact Montana. So super happy to be on
- 2:57with you guys. You mentioned Lobo Institute as the company that myself and Eric
- 3:00Alric, a former squadron commander retired seal from dev Group, founded around five
- 3:07years ago. The principle behind it is it brings uh former military folks,
- 3:14intelligence folks together along with former humanitarians, whether it's U, n U,
- 3:19S A, I, D or private NGOs. So it's a mixture.
- 3:23Of course Andy is part of it, uh, but it's a mixture of
- 3:27groups that that can take the skills that they've learned and experience that they've had
- 3:31in their past life kind of fuse them together to do good in conflict areas
- 3:36today. And that is exactly what we're doing, and we've done it in
- 3:40Afghanistan. Uh. Yeah, it's some some examples of the work that you've
- 3:46done. I'm of course familiar with it, but it's you know, it's
- 3:51a lot of kind of good stuff in my view, under the radar,
- 3:54which yeah, you know, but but but please say and and it goes
- 3:59to redress the balance perhaps the perception of guys like you know, us as
- 4:04been unconcerned with with you know, with the with social issues right international.
- 4:15I'm I'm stumbling head but you know, what I'm trying to say is that
- 4:18we are indeed warm hearted human beings with empathy that extends beyond the borders of
- 4:26the United States. And you and your is approving that. I agree,
- 4:30And I think we're seeing a lot more than just the Global Institute do this.
- 4:33Like if you look at the fall of Afghanistan and just how many FATS
- 4:36stepped up to do what was essentially purely humanitarian effort to get our partners out
- 4:43of harm's way. Uh, some people, I mean literally and you know
- 4:46I was part of you a part of it, you know, basically throw
- 4:49away their whatever job they were doing to make that happen. And I think
- 4:53we're seeing that continue, so that that's that is true. There is a
- 4:57lot of former military folks, former soft folks that are getting into that,
- 5:01and they're quite frankly, really good at it because that is the environment they
- 5:04spent their whole career, a very dynamic environments of which you have to figure
- 5:10things out. There's a lot a lot of answers, there's not a lot
- 5:12of books written about it, and you have to do it with personality,
- 5:15you have to do it with tenacity. And I think we're seeing a lot
- 5:17more of our brethren get into that. It's a good thing. So what
- 5:23we've done specifically, we have worked long term on Afghanistan. So we just
- 5:29finished the program. It went on since the essentially the withdraw that we had
- 5:35until recently working with the State Department on people that did not have the ability
- 5:41to get out because they didn't meet the immigration requirements for special American pieces.
- 5:46But as far as the Taliban was concerned, they were on the chopping block.
- 5:49So the worst case scenario, they can't come out because they don't have
- 5:53the qualifications, the time, etc. But the Taliban still knows they work
- 5:57directly with the US compniment, you know, straight with the military or the
- 6:00agency, some just with the State Department or even the Agriculture Department. So
- 6:04people that were far removed from anything that Taliban should have cared about, they
- 6:09were still on the chopping block literally for that. So we worked with them
- 6:13both from a security side to make sure which wasn't well covered at the time,
- 6:16right, I mean there was a lot of there was a lot of
- 6:19media attention on what was the category that we put, you know, the
- 6:24special sensitive and vigels that we wanted to get out. But the talent,
- 6:30Yeah, the commandos and the ctpts or the zero units got a lot of
- 6:34attention, as they should. They were certainly the highest on the list of
- 6:38the Taliban. But this is more. This is even like doctors or agricultural
- 6:44engineers and people who worked with the US Agricculture Department to make Afghanistan a better
- 6:48place, you know, just but they were still on the list. So
- 6:51we took our security skills and our humanitarians got them food, medicine and everything
- 6:57they needed, but also kept them one step head of the Taliban, and
- 7:00we did that for quite a long time. How do you how do you
- 7:04do fundraising then? Because I you know you you guys do these things,
- 7:11but I but I don't see a lot of kind of visible fundraising and that's
- 7:15right, very role memories of the Mozhont group where that consumed you know,
- 7:20maybe eighty percent of my time. You know, that wasn't in operations,
- 7:26right, So we worked for the State comment on that project, so we
- 7:30didn't have to fundraise. We've worked in Yemen for the United Nations for working
- 7:36for who now is was good friend of mine, Martin Griffith, who is
- 7:39the overall Humanitarian Undersecretary uh General for the United Nations, but at the time
- 7:46he was the U n Special Envoy, and so that's we worked for them.
- 7:54It was a it was a direct uh you know, business not business,
- 7:59but you know, advisory relationship with the UN. And now we're doing
- 8:03stuff specifically with Gaza. But that's that's it's not sensitive in a sense like
- 8:07it's not some covert operation, it's none of that. It's just pure humanitarian
- 8:11But it's in the middle of the setting up. And that's why I really
- 8:13can't get into the details of that. But I can make it two issue.
- 8:18Do you want me to just kind of frame it and then you know
- 8:22you can we can talk away through it without you being on on thin ice.
- 8:28It's like, yeah, well you can just talk about. You know,
- 8:31I'm an analyst for ABC, so I'm happy to talk about all the
- 8:33issues that you guys. Yeah yeah, If I could just say one more
- 8:37thing about Lobo Institute. We also run an NGO called in Child Soldiering,
- 8:41which is a five O one C three and it is exactly what it says,
- 8:46you know. It's it's an NGO dedicated to stop the use of children
- 8:50in armed conflict, which is a horrible problem that's growing every day, quite
- 8:56frankly, because these conflicts continue and the and the people fighting them keep getting
- 9:01younger and younger. And we've gone far away from you know, old men
- 9:05starting wars and old men fighting wars. It's now not just old man starting
- 9:09wars and young men fighting wars. It's it's kids fighting wars who have absolutely
- 9:13no choice and are used essentially as fadder. UH. So we have NGO.
- 9:18We did a documentary on two former l R A soldiers, uh documentaries
- 9:22called My Star in the Sky. It's going to be made into It is
- 9:26made into a book called All the Glimmering Stars, which will come out by
- 9:30Amazon in May. So's the book plug It's Mark Sullivan. Mark Sullivan a
- 9:37great friend who is a Montana author and a New York Times spectselling author,
- 9:41heard about the story, came to us, went to Uganda with us,
- 9:45met everybody, and uh in in uh be happy to send you a book.
- 9:50I've got the advanced copies that'll that'll gay, that'll get you a launch
- 9:56segment on this pod concept and bring more. Yeah, we'll bring I mean,
- 10:01because it's a fascinating story. Yeah. And I'll put all the links
- 10:03and everything into description to the Global Institute and to the I don't know if
- 10:07the docks out yet, but for like the pre order for the book and
- 10:09everything like that, I'll put all the description. Yep, it's in.
- 10:13It's out for pre order, and a portion of the book is going to
- 10:16our five or one C three and our five o' one C three only contributes
- 10:22to groups that are out in the field doing you know, the work with
- 10:26the kids to rehabilitate them. There's no there's no salaried employee in it,
- 10:30just but yeah, it's us straight volunteers and it goes straight to the groups
- 10:37that are actually out there teaching a former shoulder how to fix the truck or
- 10:43how to plant you know, a garden or you know, raise sheep.
- 10:48It's directly to the rehabilitation ultimate means of living. Yeah, exactly. Yet,
- 10:56so the situation now in in Gaza, I, of course some one
- 11:03of your mini fans on ABC. Uh. You know, I'm not just
- 11:07saying that to be sick aphantic. Actually, Mick, Mick Mix one of
- 11:09those welcome fie. No, but I mean, you know, Mix one
- 11:16of those welcome the welcome faces on TV. You know, because there are
- 11:20some guys who get dragged out to talk you know, military expert, former
- 11:24lieutenant colonel blah blah blah. And you know, this guy either talks drass
- 11:30or he's reading from the cover of the New York Times. But but Mick
- 11:33really gives it a I think. I think in the short segment that you're
- 11:37allowed you you really do do have the knack of breaking down complicated things for
- 11:45the American public. So Congress on that. But yeah, having built up
- 11:50the pressure on you, please, yeah, talk about talk about Gaza.
- 11:54Yes, that big topic obviously, and it's been all consuming for much of
- 11:58us through last several months. I think the stage we're at now is we
- 12:03have a dire humanitarian crisis going up. Before the war started, there's around
- 12:11five hundred trucks of food aid coming in, plus about the same amount of
- 12:15commercial you know, for sale material coming in, and about sixty percent of
- 12:20the population relied on it. Now there's about thirty trucks coming in a day
- 12:26of food aid. Sometimes it gets to one hundred and one hundred percent of
- 12:30the two point three million dollar person population relies on it. So we're seeing
- 12:35how many how many should that be mick in order to sustain the local population.
- 12:39Do we know if you can break that into daily trunkloads. Yes,
- 12:43So if if we were now because we have one hundred percent of the population,
- 12:46before we're sixty, you could you could add to about nine hundred truckloads
- 12:50of direct humanitarian aid is needed to come into Gaza, and not just into
- 12:58the southern part because the structure and we can get into the conflict itself,
- 13:03but the infrastructure is so damage that they can't get up into the northern part
- 13:07of the country we're around. It's hard to estimate, but from talking directly
- 13:11to the IDEA, they estimate around four hundred thousand people are still up in
- 13:16the north, essentially living in the rubble, and they have a very difficult
- 13:20time getting aid to them. So that's why I think a lot of these
- 13:24countries started the air drops they are I think everybody would acknowledge a drop in
- 13:33the bucket, even with the US, who is being biased, but the
- 13:37most effective at doing this every drops around two to three truckloads, right.
- 13:43So that's why there is this big push to open a maritime corridor in which
- 13:50you can deliver aid in bulk, basically doubling, if not tripling the aid
- 13:56that's coming in now, and then as it develops, quadrupling and whatever comes
- 14:01after quadruple aid into into parts of Gaza which can't be reached right right now.
- 14:09So yeah, that is something that the President referenced in the State of
- 14:13the Union and something that needs to happen. And and so that's a really
- 14:16that's you know, that's part of one of the hottest parts of distribution,
- 14:20right. One is you know, one one is entry point into Ganza,
- 14:24getting through that bone neck, but the other is distribution within Ganza to these
- 14:28areas. Right. Yeah, I mean that's actually right that that's a that's
- 14:33going to be a tough not that that as yet is unsolved, but you
- 14:37were booking on solving that is that's a good point, Andy, So,
- 14:41and the answer isn't whether it should be air, ground or maritime. The
- 14:45answer is all the above, right, yeah, yeah, So lots of
- 14:48people create these, you know, these kind of false choices here. We
- 14:52need to have entry points ground, we need to have air drops until we
- 14:56have stabilized the situation, and we need to obviously have a mayor time corridor.
- 15:00But to your point on distribution, that has gotten very difficult. We
- 15:03saw the rushing of the trucks in which people were either run over or were
- 15:11shot by a DF troops that thought they had they posed a threat. I
- 15:16don't know the answer to that, but that's generally what happened. So it's
- 15:20going to be difficult. I think the way to deal with this is to
- 15:24try to flood the zone with humanitarian aid, and that means substantial amounts of
- 15:30air drops done by competent people. You know, the US should be leading
- 15:33that effort. We saw, unfortunately that a non US air drop yesterday had
- 15:39multiple failures of parachutes that crushed six kits and I know that happens, but
- 15:46it was also when my look at it dropped right over the city. And
- 15:50as you are well known, you don't want to be under one of these
- 15:52pallets, even if it does have a fully deployed parachute. So the US
- 15:58is going to do it in a manner that drops it close enough to people
- 16:00can get to it, but not directly you know over there current uh,
- 16:04you know where they reside. That needs to happen, but it needs to
- 16:10also be pointed out that it will never meet the demand, so it needs
- 16:14to be supplemental too, and again needs to in order to work or integrate,
- 16:18needs someone on the ground, frankly, to help with distribution. Otherwise
- 16:25you get kind of a survival of the fittest thing, right and with head
- 16:27drumps. That's part of the problem is that you know, the groups hold
- 16:32people who are most able to get hold of those supplies on the ones who
- 16:36get hold of those. That's right. And to the distribution. It should
- 16:41be under the the U N, under the international aid organizations that are there,
- 16:45and it probably should be Palestinians to be to be frank but of course
- 16:49that also needs to be done completely in line with Israeli concerned security concerns.
- 16:56I mean, it isn't you know a secret that helped loss was armed to
- 17:00the teeth and a lot of that came in smuggled, some of them potentially
- 17:06with humanitarian assistance, and we saw what happened on October seventh. So this
- 17:11needs to be a balance with a critical need for innocent Palestinian civilians to be
- 17:15able to you know, get food, medicine, and clean water, and
- 17:21Israeli's security concerns that they don't see another October seventh, So that is the
- 17:26balance. And then of course this is all happening at a time when Hamas
- 17:30finds it completely acceptable to not only hide amongst its civilian population, but to
- 17:36exploit the conditions that they're in for their own political gain. In my opinion,
- 17:41they actually don't mind that there is all these horrible things going on.
- 17:45They use it for their own political benefit. They often steal food from civilians
- 17:52that otherwise can't defend themselves to be able to get it, and then they
- 17:55just hoard it from themselves. So all those things are a balance. Butately
- 18:00a little kids, a little kid, no matter, or an innocent civilian
- 18:04is an innocent civilian and they and they should not have to, you know,
- 18:08be on the brink of starvation because of Hamas's actions against Israel. Because
- 18:15anything being done then too. And I know this is a very tough question
- 18:19to to coordinate or raise a and I use the term with small you know,
- 18:26a Palestinian authority in Gaza. NRA's being discredited in the sense that it's
- 18:36been discredited, I mean trying to work through UNRA with the Israelis is all
- 18:41kinds of reasons. Probably not a good idea at this stage. But is
- 18:45there are there any alternatives as far as local humanitarian association organization said, the
- 18:51idea of will let function. So that is a very complex but good question.
- 18:57So ANRA was created literally in nineteen forty nine. There's about thirteen thousand
- 19:03employees in Yaza, all of them are Palestinians. A handful took part in
- 19:08the October seventh attacks, which is completely unacceptable. But more I think concerning
- 19:17is essentially the Kamas headquarters was right under the headquarters with tied in for electricity
- 19:23and everything, so in my opinion, that was known to those who ran
- 19:29UNDRAM So it is understandably not an organization of which Israel will work with.
- 19:37But unfortunately that was the infrastructure, the complex overtime infrastructure to distribute aid.
- 19:44So I hope there is a compromise that can be where we can utilize individuals
- 19:49that are in that network to distribute aid and then vet them for their connections
- 19:55to terrorist organizations like HAMAS, and if they are, they need to be
- 20:00out of any group that's funded by the United Nation, which of course twenty
- 20:04two percent of the funding comes from the United States. But the United States
- 20:08and the United Nations itself should just find that unacceptable. But the problem is
- 20:12there is innocent civilians that need to have aid distributed, So there's no easy
- 20:18answer. But I think working together with the Israelies and the UN and the
- 20:22international community, there needs to be a way to get this aid distributed time.
- 20:26Now. Hey guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to
- 20:30you today about a way that you can help support the podcast. If you're
- 20:33not already, we would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us
- 20:37on Apple or Spotify. Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help
- 20:42it get recognized, and you know, if you've been enjoying the show,
- 20:45we really appreciate your support. Another thing that you can do to support the
- 20:51channel is to become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started
- 20:56just five dollars a month, and when you sign up, you get access
- 21:00us till all of our episodes add free. Uh that's the big bonus for
- 21:03that. I mean, we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers.
- 21:08But this is the biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse
- 21:12channel and podcast if you'd like to, and we really appreciate that. So
- 21:18go and check us out at Patreon dot com slash the Teamhouse two. So
- 21:23right now, I mean, I know us efforts that are under discussion now
- 21:29about setting up a you know, a port off shore maybe j Loots.
- 21:33So we joined logistics over the show capability. I feel I feel compelled to
- 21:41spell that out, thank you. But but there's things that uh yes,
- 21:45the US military can put in place. We can talk about security later,
- 21:49but it takes time, you know, it takes to get through the you
- 21:55know, get everyone in place for me weeks. And the need now is
- 21:57immediate. Some you know news yesterday in reliable media about kids you know,
- 22:06starving as you point out, and literally I mean they, I think,
- 22:08find kids yesterday start to death in central Gaza, so they the need is
- 22:15immediate. The EU is on it. Is talking about now sending opening a
- 22:22maritime corridor, right is that? I mean, what are the prospects of
- 22:26that working well? And obviously that what are the plans going ahead to integrate
- 22:30that with with your efforts. I mean, do you think that's that's going
- 22:34to be something that helps? Do you think it's just impractical? I think
- 22:41it will absolutely help in a manner that is much more effective than any other
- 22:45current option, whether that option is tied to mechanics like air drops not being
- 22:51sufficient, or tied to politics like opening other entry points from Israel into Gaza.
- 22:56Essentially, the families of the hostages, understandably, you know, you
- 23:02have to put yourself on their shoes, are blocking because they want their loved
- 23:06one out whoever should have been taken hostage. So there's a political aspect to
- 23:10that that it makes it very difficult. And the maritime quarter can bring more
- 23:14aid in than either of the other two. So I do think it's something
- 23:18that is going to happen. The President mentioned it in the State of the
- 23:21Union. I do think it would be a public private partnership, So the
- 23:25US military will do things like create this peer which commercial iitys can use.
- 23:30But there's other options to create temporary birthing sites that can offload aid into Gaza
- 23:37right now. So I think that will be very complimentary in Unison and it
- 23:45can happen in relatively short time if the international aid community does more than just
- 23:51talk that they start contributing to plans that they believe are very effective and can
- 23:57be done. If they do that, this, this can the desperation currently
- 24:02in Gaza, especially in the north, can be alleviated within weeks. I
- 24:06think potentially a month we could have it stabilized. And then of course they
- 24:11will be the other discussions on the how the war is going to end,
- 24:15whether the office should happen the assault down there, and then how we're going
- 24:19to go forward on any kind of diplomatic solution where this doesn't become a continuous
- 24:25cycle. Mack, I have a question you mentioned, like you know,
- 24:29it needs to be a multi pronged attack, right like air lands whatever.
- 24:34I mean, what role does Egypt play? I mean they share border with
- 24:37Gaza, sure, it's southern in the majority of the aid needs to go
- 24:41to the north. What are they like, Where's what's their role? Do
- 24:47they do anything? Yeah? So they're they're they're a significant partner both in
- 24:52aid coming into Egypt and then coming through the Rafa Gate, which is where
- 24:56a majority of the aid's coming from. That it's been shut down several times,
- 25:02and of course we're looking at a potential assault on the Rotha area which
- 25:06could completely shut down the Rapa crossing to no fault of course to the Egyptians,
- 25:11but that is something that could happen. They're also playing a significant part
- 25:15in the Seaspire negotiations. Egypt, the United States and obviously Israel and Hamas
- 25:22and Qatar are playing to try to come up with the currently right now,
- 25:26a temporary six week truce, if you will, so that aid can flow
- 25:33in more readily, the hostages can be released, and that we can start
- 25:38a long term discussion on how this war will end, including potentially for Hamas
- 25:44leaders to depart Gaza. There's a lot of different aspect in the same way,
- 25:48same way I guess our Fat left Beirut for Tunis right eighty two.
- 25:56Similar make us do these plans depend on the season? Fun so the humanitarian
- 26:03plan does not necessarily need to depend on the Seaspire, And I think that's
- 26:07where the US government has been very forceful. We can't use the deprivation of
- 26:14civilians from food as a negotiation point. And I'm not saying Israel is doing
- 26:18that, but that that was a coment by the president. Actually, yes,
- 26:23right, so very pointed, right, you know, right, you
- 26:27know, we have, as you would guess in Mobile, a lot of
- 26:30connections to the idea, a lot of very good friends. So I'm not
- 26:33saying that they're doing that, but if it's perceived to be, we will
- 26:37let aid into people, uh, civilians, women and children who are starving.
- 26:42If you do that, that is not I think an affective way of
- 26:48bargaining from the international communities, including the United States perspective. So I do
- 26:52think this should go ahead regardless of an agreement on the sea spire. Yeah,
- 26:56that's thanks that that That was a key question that has not been covered
- 27:02in the media, I think probably because a lot of people don't know,
- 27:06you know, that's speculating, that's right. Anything more so, the other
- 27:12thing I wanted to talk about was the security und you know, security plan.
- 27:17It hasn't even been worked out, but you know, for the benefit
- 27:21of the audience and the we've all got memories of Afghanistan right fresh in mind.
- 27:26About the fact that if you have Yes, I'm not comparing the IDEF
- 27:30to the Taliban, but if you have someone providing security in an outer zone
- 27:36like that, you're taking a risk if it's not your people, bottom line,
- 27:41right, And so we're kind of potentially as us in that position again
- 27:45whereby we don't put boots on the ground, all right, you know,
- 27:49I know, we're you know, there's going to be some some exceptions to
- 27:55that, particularly capabilities, but nevertheless, for the most part, you know,
- 27:59so so doing this offshore, but it's still very much a target reliant
- 28:03on the Israelis to provide security on shore. Again, not a not a
- 28:08hit on any other part of the nation force, but but just doctrinally that
- 28:15always feels I mean, you know, even in soft you try to avoid
- 28:18that as much as you can, where you're totally dependent on an unknown,
- 28:25unknown quantity, right, So, and that's going to be a hard part,
- 28:30yes, And as you know, the IDEA F is a very capable
- 28:33uh belter force, right they have some really good units and overall their their
- 28:38uh you know, really really an effective military. So I think there is
- 28:45going to have to be a component where the IDEF does secure any of these
- 28:48landing sites and a delivery sites on the beach. But the UN also has
- 28:53certain requirements that they're not essentially in complete UH cooperation, so they're not on
- 29:00top of each other. So that's going to have to be worked out.
- 29:03There'll have to be some effective way. It's President said there's not going to
- 29:06be US military on the ground, and that's not going to happen, and
- 29:07that's you know, I think we don't want to see something like Somalia where
- 29:12you know, we get there and everybody greets the US military, the Marine
- 29:17Corps is you know, saviors, and then you know, three weeks later
- 29:21they decide that we're not right, and then they're shooting at us, and
- 29:22then there's a war, and then there's you know what happened with black Hawk
- 29:27down. So I think that makes sense. But it does and they don't
- 29:30need to be they don't need to be there's effective ways to distribute aid because
- 29:36this is not a military effort, is a humanitarian effort. So in using
- 29:40the Palestinians right, it's as you're well known for all your time, it
- 29:44has in counterinsurgency type of warfare. It's more it's difficult and different when it's
- 29:49your uncle's distributing the aid on behalf right, you tend not to want to
- 29:53shoot at your uncle or your nephew or your brother. So it needs to
- 29:57be Palestinians ultimately that distributing the aids to Palestinians, because that is different,
- 30:02that is viewed differently. So that kind of interface between what entity that's coming
- 30:07to the beach is and then what entity is distributing it to the Palestinian people,
- 30:12that needs to be worked out. But ultimately it needs to be the
- 30:15Palestinian people under the umbrella of the United Nations invalidated international aid organizations, So
- 30:25those that are there for the right reasons distributing, and although the principles of
- 30:30the humanitarian aid not for political reasons not to you know that that needs to
- 30:34happen. And I think that is essentially where this will be going, with
- 30:38the idea of course overwatching just in case it turns into it, you know,
- 30:45a disruption situation that becomes dangerous not only for the people that are distributing
- 30:49it, for the people that are there to get it of course, because
- 30:52ultimately they end up being just as much as the victims as anybody else.
- 30:56Yeah, I mean the you know, the administration has said, look,
- 31:00we're not waiting on the Israelis too to execute this, but of course the
- 31:04reality is that we do need their their own complicity, if not the I
- 31:11mean, we need that collaboration. And what's going to be interesting to see
- 31:15though, is whether the you know, the the operation still goes ahead even
- 31:22if her mass overtly opposes it, which seems unlikely that you know, that
- 31:26would be just a really bad pr care for for her mask, which is
- 31:32which is a card in our favor, right, I say, yeah,
- 31:36I agree. I mean that they have showed a callous disregard to the people
- 31:41of Palestine, right, I mean the atrocities on October seventh, and we
- 31:45don't have to repeat them here, but if you're not, your audience is
- 31:48familiar with them. They're so atrocious. I don't even know that there's a
- 31:53word for it. So I think they did so knowing that that would cause
- 31:57a reaction. Of course, bring this on to God. I mean,
- 32:01you don't, you don't have to be a plug. Deliberty designed the liberty
- 32:06designed to do that absolutely, and ever since then they've hid right under uh,
- 32:12you know, not just their civilian population, but the most significant part,
- 32:15like schools and hospitals. Right, so people that the most vulnerable and
- 32:19who who the military or any security force should be designed to protect the most.
- 32:23I think they used them and the consequences of our actions trying to politically
- 32:30and unfortunately effectively in some cases. But yes, I do think to your
- 32:35point, they would be hard pressed to attack humanitarians distributing aid Palestinians to Palestinian
- 32:42people who are on the burge of starvation. I agree, yeah, which
- 32:45which means we hope that that is not a preconditioned you know, Hamas explicitly
- 32:52approving, is not a precondition of the that's right, that's right, that
- 32:58shouldn't be one go ahead. Do you think there's any chance the idea for
- 33:04the Israeli government in general will drag their feet with this, especially if they're
- 33:08providing the security. So I don't think so. I mean, there's different
- 33:15political wins if you will, in Israel, just like there is in the
- 33:20United States. I'm not a political analyst, but essentially this won't happen unless
- 33:25they agree. So those that are concerned that this would have a negative impact
- 33:30on Israeli security, I would simply say it's not going to happen unless the
- 33:35Israelis agree with it. So if they're okay with it, they're the people
- 33:39that are most I think concerned about their own security. I think that should
- 33:45be an indicator to anybody else that they believe that does not harm their security.
- 33:50So if it goes ahead, that would be my position to people who
- 33:54are concerned about whether this would jeopardize Israeli security, as they don't think I
- 34:00think, you know, yeah, you know, just a quick opinion on
- 34:05this that I think you can overstate the threat when you have an ongoing operation
- 34:10like this. You can overstate the threat of having weapons come in the real
- 34:14thing that you're concerned about our fighters escaping and being able to return or coming
- 34:17into areas where you've already cleared. You know, I'm talking about from experience
- 34:22in Fallujah. You know, it didn't make any difference to us at this
- 34:25stage whether weapons or or munitions are coming in because as a process they have
- 34:30to be integrated. You know, it takes time, and they're very vulnerable
- 34:32why they're doing that. But the other point is that that's been overlooked on
- 34:39this and this isn't a hit on the Israelis, you know, I suppose
- 34:43it is, but it could equally be a hit on us too. That
- 34:46New York Times, did you know one of their investigative reports, which are
- 34:51generally pretty good, and came up with the conclusion that most of the munitions
- 34:54used in the rocket attacks on seven October actually or a lot of it,
- 35:00different proportion came from the idea for themselves, from all the ordinance they dropped
- 35:02on guds. And my point is that if you were fighting, and if
- 35:07you're in Hamas fighting in guns right now, you want food, you want
- 35:09water, you want shelter, you want to meet freedom of movement, you
- 35:14know you're probably not that low on ammunition. I would guess, you know
- 35:16what I mean. So so you can overstate the threat of weapons coming in.
- 35:22That's what I'm saying. And I'm not saying israelis are. I'm saying
- 35:27you can overstate it and that and that almost his problems, as we've seen
- 35:31when I had another shamand turn convoys. There's a broader like talk to us,
- 35:36like you talk about like you know, they're concerned about Israel Israel,
- 35:38Israel is concerned about the security. It kind of seems like October sixth,
- 35:44they really weren't or they were asleep at the job. I mean, I
- 35:46know that's a longer, longer that's I know, I know it's more of
- 35:51a broader topic than that, Like similar to us, you know, pre
- 35:54nine to eleven, I guess, I mean, I mean, I guess
- 35:57we understood what was going to happen. We had a good idea of it,
- 35:59but we drop the ball. There are a lot of parallels here to
- 36:02that, you know, And I'm not saying going into Afghanistan was a mistake.
- 36:07I don't think it was. But what happened over the last twenty years
- 36:10after that, we're probably there were some miscues. I think Israel's running the
- 36:16running the risk of doing the same thing, because what's the endgame in reality?
- 36:21And yeah, it is a longer conversation, but can they really destroy
- 36:25is hamask gonna go and go to Qatar and live in like a luxury condos
- 36:30and not worry about Mussad comeing too, like put two in the back of
- 36:32their heads, Like we gotta be realistic with this, right, Like I
- 36:37don't know what's the actual endgame for Hamas and for Israel. I don't see
- 36:40it. Sure to both your points and you're right, it is a longer
- 36:47discussion. But at first it was clear was an intelligence failure, we thought,
- 36:52right, and that's they have an exceptional intelligence service, but so do
- 36:55we. And to your point, d we had nine to eleven, right,
- 36:59So it's it's more of a critique with an attempt to improve than just
- 37:04you know, criticism. But then we found out that a lot of the
- 37:07intelligence was already known, right, that came out clearly in the media.
- 37:13They almost had their oper order. I mean, they even knew what they
- 37:15were going to do when they were going to do it. If you talked
- 37:17to you know, obviously I spent a lot of time in Israel recently.
- 37:21You talked to them, they consider it, and I'm speaking for all of
- 37:24them, at least the people I talked to, particularly in the idea of
- 37:28a leadership failure and that they had a lot of the information and it wasn't
- 37:32acting on it. So I think because it didn't fit, it didn't fit
- 37:37that preconsumptions, right, they just said that's impossible. They wouldn't do that,
- 37:40they don't have the capabilities. But they essentially had somebody that was very
- 37:44close to the operational planning, because you know, from the press reports.
- 37:49It laid out what was going to happen. So if you talked to and
- 37:52none of them, of course will talk on the record, but idef in
- 37:57intelligence folks, they obviously, uh take a lot of the responsibility himself.
- 38:02But to also say this was fairly well known and it wasn't making serious so
- 38:07that needs to be yeah, sorry, go ahead, and we did with
- 38:10Yeah, I'll be saying it needs to be reviewed just like we did.
- 38:14They need to adjust accordingly. So it isn't just criticism for criticism's sake.
- 38:16It's uh, it's you know, we want our partners to you know,
- 38:21improve their own security. See that's a really you know, great I mean,
- 38:27it's a great question. And I wasn't. Yeah, absolutely, we
- 38:30should put a whole podcast on this. Specifically, when I was in Israel
- 38:34this time, I asked that question of two former national security advisors, former
- 38:39deputy of Shinbet. I mean, you know, I'm not just trolling this
- 38:44on too in an effort to impress, but I you know, I wasn't
- 38:46just getting speculation from dudes on the ground. His here's some very quick points.
- 38:51Okay, the night before the attack, something between forty and eighty new
- 38:58SIM cards. It's really SIM cards popped up on the network within Gaza.
- 39:01Okay, the ability, now the Israeli's ability to pick up signals intelligence within
- 39:10Gaza was awesome. You know, there's only two phone carriers within Gaza,
- 39:15so they could pick up is just a question, as Mike No's of data,
- 39:19like anything in signals intelligence, how many people you assign to it.
- 39:22But this triggered interest more than interest. So the head of Shinbet got up
- 39:30in the middle of the night, drove into the office, called the chief
- 39:34of staff of the Army. To put this in context, I was talking
- 39:37to a former commander of the Gaza division, all right, and he said,
- 39:42hey, look, within the midst of the fighting in twenty fourteen,
- 39:45he called the chief of staff maybe two times. But here, you know,
- 39:50here you have the head of Shinbet wa waking up, the head of
- 39:52the Army, the head of the IDF essentially, and they're talking about what
- 39:57these SIM cards mean. Now, who recommended what will come out in the
- 40:02investigation. But the bottom line was they agreed together that this was probably just
- 40:09a you know, a periodic exercise, because this happens from time to time.
- 40:15But as Mick points out what they didn't do necessarily was synthesize this latest
- 40:22indicator with a whole bunch of things that were being officially reported, most famously
- 40:28perhaps by the spotters or idea. Israelis have a whole battalion of women,
- 40:32just women who are called spotters. Right, that's not like in the old
- 40:37fashioned sense of peering with binos. They are they stare at screens, surveillance
- 40:43camera screens in the in half a dozen IDF posts around Gaza. Now,
- 40:50there's a lot of questions that came about this, one of which was why
- 40:53were they unarmed? But they had been reporting these spots. It's a very
- 41:01interesting Un't mean this is why it could be a separate episode. But you
- 41:05know, the training for these spots, they get, each one of them
- 41:07learns a part of Gaza, all right, and they just they have that
- 41:13part of Gaza under surveillance and they know it so well that they're recognize it
- 41:16faces people and that's what they do nine hours a day in shifts throughout the
- 41:21day. Right. So they were picking up a ton of stuff to include
- 41:24full rehearsals, right with pickup trucks, even the paraglide apart, right,
- 41:32and they were sending in these reports and we're ignored, and there are you
- 41:38know, I think when as we pull this apart, and the same has
- 41:42happened, as how I point out, in every single military in the world,
- 41:45or I mean national security apparatus will find that the problems are not intelligence,
- 41:51they are cultural. And you know, this deeply seated belief that Hamas
- 41:57could not pull it off. But it's a fascinating topic. And there's you
- 42:01know, there's there's many more, sadly, many more stories here of indications
- 42:07being brought to two people in position of authority to make decisions and those decisions
- 42:14were not made. Last piece is a lot of controversy in Israel right now.
- 42:19I mean who perhaps not the most popular point person there, but he
- 42:23is the prime minister, wartime prime minister, and the country has rallied around
- 42:29him. Okay, but contract controversy over whether Netna who's informed? All right,
- 42:37the head of Shinda kind of unusual. You notice, you know,
- 42:40Netna Who's kind of saying, hey man, I didn't know any of this
- 42:45shit. My intel guys didn't tell me. And now the head of Shinbet
- 42:49at least is kicking is pushing back a little bit and saying, nope,
- 42:52we told you about this publicly, So this isn't healthy, but it's you
- 42:58know, we we're learning a lot more about No, it was not in
- 43:00an intelligence Fadia. It was as a failure of people. Yeah, that
- 43:06was so I did parts of that. I was really fascinating. So I'm
- 43:09not shouting to you. I really look forward to read your book because that
- 43:13that whole thing give you a company. I mean, it's not just for
- 43:15I will gladly take it. That whole thing is not just for the Israelis
- 43:20to review. I think that will be a lot of lessons learned for uh,
- 43:24you know, intel services, militaries and police forces around the world right
- 43:30on, even as effective as they are, as as as impressive that they
- 43:35have it in the past, they can make mistakes. We can make mistakes.
- 43:38That that is something I think, uh seriously, putting that out together
- 43:43would be really uh good for a lot of intelligence services, militaries and on
- 43:51that. On that point, there's two other points you know very quickly,
- 43:53right, but the these Radis had a really good, uh central intelligence unit.
- 44:01I forget what it was, but the problem was, and I believe
- 44:07I can't remember if it fell under the IDF, under military intelligence or under
- 44:10Shinberg. But but the point is it was disbanded several months ago. All
- 44:15Right. I checked on this someone, the former you know, former national
- 44:19security advisor told me that I confirmed it was. It was shut down because
- 44:23they felt that, you know, it was better for each unit to have
- 44:27their own open source intelligence blah blah. In other words, not believing that
- 44:31it was a it was useful, and yet tons of open source intelligence was
- 44:36coming in indicating an attack. You know a lot of people are Arab speaking
- 44:40Israelis were blogging about this and the you know, the ah. The other
- 44:50point, which is also concerning, is the Israelis have a unit called eighty
- 44:54two hundred, which is a signals intelligence unit. Is I I, you
- 44:59know, I'm expert, but people will tell you who are that it is
- 45:04every bit as good as far as sophisticated training equipment as NSA, But it's
- 45:08a question of scale. It's much smaller than NSA. But they shut down
- 45:16their sub unit that was focused exclusively on her Mass and Gaza again a few
- 45:22months ago. So you see, it's just a perfect storm. But as
- 45:25MC points out, there's one kind of cause for all of this, and
- 45:30it runs deeper than any any of the individual approximate causes. And that is
- 45:35this underlying belief that they didn't have to worry about her mask. Her mask
- 45:38was caged in Gaza. Her mask was preoccupied now with running Gaza itself and
- 45:45making money and had no interest in attacking Israel, even though her mass was
- 45:49saying the destruction of Israel was still its first task. Yeah, absolutely,
- 45:54Yeah, that's I didn't know the other parts about. So those are those
- 45:59are other things that I think would be really helpful to come out in a
- 46:01manner that sets out the kind of domino effect of how this ended up in
- 46:07such a catastrophic event, so both the Israelis can avoid it and then we
- 46:12and our and our allies and partners can as well. And you know,
- 46:15whether it's the importance of open source, and I remember when all the intelligence
- 46:19services just poop poo to open source because it was you know, it's already
- 46:22out there, it's not secret, so it's not really intelligent. Well,
- 46:25if it's if it's important, it's important, If they choose to do it
- 46:29openly, then we need to, you know, focus on it and not
- 46:31just uh uh, dismiss it. That's another example. In the seat of
- 46:36Sodith, we had an open source intel cell and and that wasn't my initiative.
- 46:42Someone brilliant guy Seal as a matter of fact, So those two tones
- 46:45do go together. Sometimes recommended that we do open business part and and and
- 46:53it was. And honestly, we got most of all bda battle damage assessment
- 46:59through open source intelligence. Every time we did not, you know, we
- 47:02we would get the reports, and they would even with the Islamic State was
- 47:07even posting like a list that they're dead, you know, every time after
- 47:12right, So it was tremendously helpful, more so than I mean not more
- 47:15so in a different way than more exquisite COVID intelligence like signals exactly. Signals
- 47:23intelligence. Yeah, signals intelligence is like you know, it's like the beam
- 47:28of a flashlight, and open source intelligence helps you focus that beam. Yep,
- 47:34I agree it should again, it should be one of those arguments that
- 47:37it's either or it's all the above. Yeah, totally. Do you want
- 47:43to you had it. I know you had another question for me before we
- 47:45let them. I wanted to bash Nan Yahoo, but oh I thought you
- 47:50were gonna ask about Ukraine. But go ahead. Oh yeah, I mean
- 47:52no, not bashed, nanyah. I mean it just talks to like the
- 47:55kind of leadership I mean lack thereof, like where he's blamed and his guys
- 48:01and you know, his the Shimbet guys are kind of coming back and saying
- 48:05no, this was like kind of known, he knew about it, and
- 48:08he makes you know, he ran in the whole thing of his like mister
- 48:12national security for Israel, right, and just to pass the buck. I
- 48:15know, he's a politician at the end of the day. It's kind of
- 48:17gross, especially when it pertains to something this, you know, catastrophic for
- 48:22Israel, which is now leading to something massively catastrophic for Palestine. I don't
- 48:28know. I for one cannot comment on this because I want to go in
- 48:30and out of his front. Sure, yeah, I mean I'm not so
- 48:34I could pop off. I guess it's okay. Yeah, And I know
- 48:37you guys have friends in the IDEF and sod Or Jim Bette and stuff,
- 48:39and I get it. Hey, we don't go down on that. We
- 48:43already thought, I don't remember, we already go to all that hate mail
- 48:45for bing will always get hate me. It doesn't matter what side we pick.
- 48:50I mean, I don't. I don't have a dog in this fight.
- 48:52I want people to not die at a grand scale. That's what I
- 48:54want, right like, That's what I choose, and I want humanitarian aid
- 48:59to go there on a you know, on a bathing basically a bottom line
- 49:05is yeah, no, I mean at thirty thousand plus civilian debts, we
- 49:08can quote those numbers and we're not but it's it's just it's just snappering.
- 49:15Yeah. And I'm saying that not as a handwringing civilian, but as a
- 49:19guy who's conducted of an operations. That's a sharp end, you know.
- 49:22Yeah, So you know what all this will be sorted out in six months?
- 49:28Where are we mix in your opinion? Well, I certainly would hope
- 49:32that the major combat operations would be concluded, that HAMAS would be to a
- 49:37point where they don't oppose a military threat. I think the idea that they'll
- 49:42be destroying HAMAS is just not the case. As Andy will tell you,
- 49:45R you, No, Ded, you can't destroy a philosophy, but you
- 49:49can bring them down to a point where they can't use that philosophy to wage
- 49:53war against their neighbor in this case Israel, and that I do think and
- 49:58I understand it's it's easier to say this than to get into the weeds.
- 50:01But the only real solution is a two state solution on which the Palestinians have
- 50:07autonomy, they have a future, they have an identity, a national identity,
- 50:13and they're focused on building the capacity of their country economically, politically,
- 50:17educational, all the things that a society focuses on, and they're essentially not
- 50:23a threat to Israel, and that they have agreed to live in peace and
- 50:30coexist. Again, way easier to said than done. People have been saying
- 50:34that for decades, but that I still think is the answer, and then
- 50:36obviously is still the policy of the United States. Things that need to happen
- 50:40to make that happen, One, there needs to be a willingness on the
- 50:44side of Israel, so that's something for them to decide who should lead their
- 50:47country. But that has to be a willingness, and there has to be
- 50:51security guarantees on the side of Israel, like, for example, can they
- 50:54develop a military, can that military be supported by let's say, a rad
- 51:00Can they join a security pack Iran? Things like that, Those are real
- 51:05questions that from the Israeli perspective, somebody has to answer. From the Palestinian
- 51:09perspective, the Palestinian authority has almost zero credibility with the Palestinian people. They're
- 51:19considered widely as corrupt and ineffective. So there has to be what the US
- 51:22keeps call on a revitalized Palestinian authority, which most people say would be composed
- 51:28of technocrats, people are good at their sector of the government, education,
- 51:34agriculture, urban development, whatever it is, and not just people who are
- 51:37tied to somebody politically. So there's got to be a lot and they have
- 51:40to be responsive to the people and not just some political ideology which is largely
- 51:45just reinforced from Oran right. So there's all sorts of things that go into
- 51:51the concept of a Tuesday solution. But I do think that is where we
- 51:55ultimately need to head to, and that's where the international community should go together
- 52:00and enhance that happening. Not just stay talking points, but are they willing
- 52:06to contribute to an international fund to rehabilitate Gaza. Are they willing to ensure
- 52:12that no proxy of Iran is allowed to govern any part of a future Palestinian
- 52:20state. So there's all sorts of things at the international community. But to
- 52:22your question to the I think that's where we want to head within six months
- 52:25and into the combat operations, stabilization, reconstruction, and then this diplomatic path
- 52:30toward a peaceful two states. Holders does that look like elections in Gaza or
- 52:37the West Bank, because like, I don't think what's going on right now
- 52:40with the war is exactly pacifying a lot of folks. I feel like it's
- 52:45probably breeding some extremism. So what happens if it's just a Hamas that's rebranded
- 52:52that gets elected. That's a great point, and it is possible. That's
- 52:55why I'm saying it's easier instead done Right now, Hamas is more popular in
- 53:01the West Bank than it is in Gaza, and so it is breeding some
- 53:08extremist views. And although I don't understand that because I think the Hamas brought
- 53:15this all on the Palestinea people, but it's not up for me to understand,
- 53:17it's still happening. Yeah, So that is, if there was an
- 53:22election today and they were put into place, then I think Israel would rightfully
- 53:28say, well, we're not going to have a two state solution where hamas
- 53:30the group that attacked us on Octobe sever is in charge, and I think
- 53:35most reasonable person would see like neither would we if we were in that position.
- 53:39So again, easier said than done. But I think ultimately, unless
- 53:44we want to see this cycle of violence with an occupation of Gaza permanent,
- 53:51I think that the path that the United States, which can only be a
- 53:54facilitator, is not a dictator in a sense that we can't tell people what
- 53:59to do. The United States can only be as effective as the two parties
- 54:02that ultimately have the decision, which is Israel and the Palestinian people. But
- 54:07I think the United States should be a part of that, regardless of if
- 54:12you I don't through politics, whatever political parties and power, because that is
- 54:17a role we can play because we have more influence on Ariel than any other
- 54:22country in the world. Yeah, I think they trust us. Yeah,
- 54:24I mean, would the US actually go to the extent of like turning the
- 54:30spigot off, you know, the cash machine off. I don't see a
- 54:35political willingness to do that on either party right now. The longer it goes
- 54:38on, you know, that could change, But I don't think we'll get
- 54:42there. I think we need to be a partner for Israel, but I
- 54:45also think we need to be uh, you know, an honest broker.
- 54:49So we're calling low blows and you know, good hits. If you all
- 54:52want to use the boxing analogy, which I do, to be we got
- 54:57to be square with that. I don't think we to do that. I
- 55:00mean, I don't you know, I think I mean that's already that's in
- 55:05the background behind everyone's mind, is the knowledge that the United States gives Israel
- 55:09three point four billion dollars. It's certainly, it's certainly there in the in
- 55:15the media, in the Middle East every day. Israel's very aware of that.
- 55:19It's not something that diplomatically we would ever have to even hint at because
- 55:23you know, as mckpoints out, it's not something we'd follow through. It'd
- 55:27be an empty bluff. But I think more subtly, there are things that
- 55:32are underway to pair as in divide perhaps the prime minister from his cabinet.
- 55:40That hence the invitation to Benny Gantz to come to the United States. That
- 55:45for many was kind of poetic justice because we've seen Israeli prime ministers before appeal
- 55:52to Congress above the president's head. And so here was kind of a tip
- 55:55for not in that way. But you know, so there are ways of
- 56:00doing this that are that don't come down to straight threats with with you know,
- 56:07with a country that is an ally and whose national interests to some extent
- 56:13overlap our own. And that is why Israel is an ally, right,
- 56:16I mean, it's not. It's not because of the crazy right wing cuckoo
- 56:22you know, evangelists. I'll probably get in trouble for that. It's not
- 56:24because of that. It's because it is in the interests of the United States
- 56:29to have a stable partner, a stable and powerful partner in that part of
- 56:32the Middle East. But that doesn't mean that all our national interests overlap.
- 56:37And in the end, I used to remind my guys that says us above
- 56:40your your pocket. And that's what we all have to remember. And you
- 56:45did see President Biden at the end of the State of the Union when he
- 56:50spoke to that congressman. He was on a hot mic and he said,
- 56:53you know, I spoke to b being going to have a come to Jesus
- 56:57moment. I mean, that's got to be like, I mean, I
- 57:00don't know if it's him being dotty or is that actually, like, you
- 57:04know, I don't know. I think what he I think perhaps what he
- 57:07sees has come to Jesus and what Bbces has been brought to Jesus are two
- 57:13separate things. And I don't want to get into the tangled web of a
- 57:17theological discussions. What I simply mean is that they definitely have a different perception
- 57:22of who's leveraging who right, and the domestic audience is the key in both
- 57:29cases. So it's not right and and it I obviously don't do politics,
- 57:36as I said, but Benny gas is very well known and very well liked
- 57:38in the United States. He was the defense for Israel to the United States,
- 57:44and if you know, that's always a significant position, but it's really
- 57:47a significant position in the idea if it's usually the feeder into the chief of
- 57:52staffs or the most senior uniform military And obviously Benny Gantz was a general on
- 57:58the idea, so very very respecting, it very well known. But it's
- 58:01up to the Israeli people to decide who they want to be, uh,
- 58:05you know, their leadership and their prime minister. Yeah, I'm happy you
- 58:15guys. That's that was That was terrific. D you did have before we
- 58:19let Miko, you had one more question right about Ukraine. About Ukraine,
- 58:22I mean, yeah, you saw the New York Times quote unquote report breaking
- 58:27news about uh the special relationship between the Ukrainian intelligence and the CIA and I
- 58:32you know, NATO other NATO intelligence services for sure, uh, which I
- 58:37mean I'm biased obviously because Jack Murphy, our the leader, wrote a pretty
- 58:43in depth article about over like a year and a half ago, and like
- 58:46just magically because the New York Times got the okay sorry Mick from the agency
- 58:52to write this, Uh, it's like news now magically, you know,
- 58:58while at the same time elements from the agency at the time Jack was writing
- 59:04his article were actively trying to kill it and did. But basically, I
- 59:08mean they did their job. They you know, shook a big major publication
- 59:13off the story. I mean, by the way, if they're permitted,
- 59:17not only permitted make friends, I'm wrong, obliged to line when no,
- 59:22that's their job, and they did it well. I respect it, you
- 59:25know what I mean, Like they made it work. But you know this,
- 59:30like this intelligence relationship has probably been building up since twenty fourteen, I'm
- 59:32assuming, right, like since crimea got invade UH annexed. Just speak to
- 59:37it a little bit and confirm jack story. I can't. Okay, obviously
- 59:44obligated UH in perpetuity to protect all covert and UH operations as a as a
- 59:52retire toy person. I obviously know Jackie's a friend him and Dave brother.
- 59:57Dave came to business right here, white Fish. He's a great reporter.
- 1:00:00But you killed them in a hotby that they came between you and now I'm
- 1:00:06not saying that they both. They both have served the national security interest in
- 1:00:10their country with great esteem. I would say, UH, as you know,
- 1:00:15right, But what I would say is the the agency of the paramilitary
- 1:00:20community UH in particular and the soft community inside the US military does have key
- 1:00:27relationships that UH they build over time that you never know when they're going to
- 1:00:31be critically important to our national security. So whether it's in Ukraine, or
- 1:00:37whether it's you know, the Kurds for example before the Iraq War, or
- 1:00:43which then leveraged into our efforts in Syria with the sdf UH, you never
- 1:00:49know where it starts. And when you have that young green beret or raider
- 1:00:53or paramilitary officer that's out there building these relationships that they don't know where the
- 1:00:59lead. Oftentimes it leads to some of the most significant cooperative events we've had.
- 1:01:04Whether it's whether it's building an entity inside Syria that can defeat isis right,
- 1:01:12they can actually win without the loss of many US servicemen and women.
- 1:01:17That's incredibly important. Whether it was in a Rock where we could not hit
- 1:01:22the fourth Infanty division and essentially it turned into a UW effort against eleven Infanty
- 1:01:27divisions that was successful, or Republican Guard divisions in the north. So another
- 1:01:32example, whether it was Ukraine when every analyst I know gave them, you
- 1:01:37know, less than a week once the Russian came across the border, and
- 1:01:43here we are where we are today, wondering why they're not being more effective
- 1:01:46on their counter offensive, ignoring the fact that most analysts didn't think they would
- 1:01:51think Key would last three days. A lot of that. I want to
- 1:01:54give one hundred percent really of the credit to the Ukrainians, but I think
- 1:01:59they were in hand. It's by our partner operations that both the US military
- 1:02:06and the Central Intelligence Agency does that brings that core skill, that brings that
- 1:02:10confidence, that brings that small unit leadership to function in a way that I
- 1:02:15think is exponentially more powerful than their numbers would suggest. And I think we
- 1:02:22do that a lot, and that needs to keep happening, just because the
- 1:02:25global war and terror might be something we put in the rearview era that can
- 1:02:30change overnight, as you will know, but it's also just as effective against
- 1:02:34near peer competitors. In Ukraine is a great example of what they're doing to
- 1:02:38the Russian military, who is by almost every analysis perspective, been degraded substantially,
- 1:02:46like fifty percent or more. Which is why it's so important to keep
- 1:02:51supporting our partners and their most critical time of need, not just for the
- 1:02:58moral right thing to do, but it's on our own interest, right Our
- 1:03:00power is relative to our enemies, are these power is going down substantially because
- 1:03:06of the efforts of Ukraine and our support to them. So I would hope
- 1:03:09that everybody would see that through the lens of US national security interest rather than
- 1:03:15any kind of political filter that might be to the contrary. Put it that
- 1:03:21way, what he said that was, Briant, I was I'm glad we
- 1:03:25got that recorded, So you are, so you are confirming Jack story.
- 1:03:30Just want to get that on record. No, I'll get a call TheMark.
- 1:03:34No, I'm saying that that it's well known that that these partnerships,
- 1:03:40which can start uh, you know, before conflict, can have a profound
- 1:03:46effect reveal untold benefits. Yeah, and and actually uh make you you know,
- 1:03:53I'm we're we're winding up now, but you brought up a great point
- 1:03:57that would be a good another good discussion and being able to reinforce success with
- 1:04:02the light footprint. So Chibani with the SDF right was kind of that.
- 1:04:08It was, Hey, let's drop these guys' supplies and see what happens.
- 1:04:12And then Tibani held on, you know, and and we and we sort
- 1:04:16of realized who all these dudes, these SDF guys and became one of the
- 1:04:23most fruitful partnerships in fact, I you know, maybe the Northern Alliance was
- 1:04:29the other. But of the last three decades of self operations, yep,
- 1:04:33I would I would go with that. I would say the Northern Alliance,
- 1:04:36then the Kurdish element in Iraq, and then SDF in the Pech market in
- 1:04:43the Rock and then the SDF I think is like a culmination of what really
- 1:04:46these type of operations can do with a with a very competent partner, of
- 1:04:50which we make more competent enhanced by intelligence that we can provide, we can
- 1:04:56provide on the ground advisors. The other part to say to that is if
- 1:05:00we want this to be something that can use in the future, we have
- 1:05:03to be good partners. They can't just be disposable. You can't just decide
- 1:05:08one day that you don't meet them anymore and throw them to the walls.
- 1:05:11Not only is that a moral, unethical and not with the United States and
- 1:05:15stand for well remember that in the future and he'll be like, I'm not
- 1:05:19jumping in with you. Guys. You abandoned every partner in the past.
- 1:05:23So if it's again, it's not just the right thing to do, it's
- 1:05:26the right thing to do for us in the future to have partners that consider
- 1:05:30us reliable. That's right. Yeah, Syria and okay, yeah, I
- 1:05:38mean we even carry this on for But what people don't realize is that,
- 1:05:43you know, as we talked about here before, having that that presence in
- 1:05:46Syria is not token. It lies. It lies in an area that is
- 1:05:51that is dearly sought off to buy our enemies. You know, So we
- 1:05:55are again leveraging small amounts of people along within the indigenous troops to to achieve
- 1:06:01strategic effect. Syria is this story in that sense for us and Siriah.
- 1:06:08Absolutely it's a horrible abomination. But what I'm saying is agree. I agree,
- 1:06:14and it's not only a success in the CP front, but because we're
- 1:06:16there, it has an effect on countering or wrong right, I'm gonna dominate.
- 1:06:20If it wasn't for us being there. The only legal reason we can
- 1:06:24be there is to counter isis, which is part of the you know,
- 1:06:30we have to we have to be in Syria because we funked out the wrong
- 1:06:33right. I mean, we can forget this another episode. But I love
- 1:06:40when Andy gets honest. I love it. Yeah, Hey, make you
- 1:06:46You've been an awesome guest, predictably do You've been an awesome producer too,
- 1:06:51And you know, watch watch the space. We've got a couple of things
- 1:06:56and Mick, Mick and his cohorts are gonna appear down the line to talk
- 1:07:00more about this, hopefully an execution, and then de has promised us a
- 1:07:05blowout eyes on weekend, long weekend at at mix. I don't know how
- 1:07:13to put it. Bunker there in white Fish, Montana, we'll get the
- 1:07:18team house private jet fueled double wid out there an episode from that so you
- 1:07:26can all enjoy it vicariously with lots of weapons, pawn and you name it.
- 1:07:31All right, thank you. I want to remind everybody to check out
- 1:07:36all of our mixed stuff. Check out the Lobo Institute. The links will
- 1:07:40be in the description. Andy. Check out Andy's substack and Andy's Twitter.
- 1:07:45Don't forget to like subscribe if you're listening to us on Apple or Spotify,
- 1:07:48rate and review at five stars. And yeah, thank you, and buy
- 1:07:53my book before at least mix comes out. All right, everyone, thanks,
- 1:07:57thanks very much. To see you again in a few days. Nine