Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 10/15/26 EPISODE 33: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN: WILD TURKEY 16 YEAR AUSTIN NICHOLS ARCHIVES GOLD FOIL EDITION
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: All right, folks, let's go. We're back for maybe one of the biggest, most anticipated episodes on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. James, I think you were. Were we gonna do the ⁓ we're ⁓ we're not gonna be reviewing Rima Skatsby Reserve. We are gonna be reviewing the Wild Turkey, Austin Nichols archives, 16 year old, cheesy gold foil. ⁓ frankly. Maybe the best packaging to come out this year. Beautiful. It is gorgeous. I would put that as a picture in the house. And as a bonus, we got my lovely wife Molly here. On this episode of the I just got shamed for not knowing what cheesy meant when they call it a cheesy foil. For so those of you who also don't know, it's because of its kitschy gold foil. A throwback. Yeah, yeah. So we're gonna give some information about What cheesy gold foil is, why this bottle, why now? A little bit of history on Wild Turkey. So the story of Wild Turkey is one of the most respected in the bourbon world, deeply tied to family heritage and a refusal to compromise on flavor. The narrative bridges a classic brand name and a mythical vintage bottle. The brand new release that pays homage to both, to both. So the roots of the distillery trace back to 1869 when the Rippe brothers opened a distillery on what is now known as Wild Turkey Hill in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky. However, the name Wild Turkey did not exist until 1940. An executive at the wholesale grocery and distributor, Austin Nicholson Co., named Thomas McCarthy, took some warehouse samples of a dist of the distillery's 101 proof bourbon. On a wild turkey hunting trip with friends. The whiskey was such a hit that his friends kept asking him for that wild turkey whiskey, and a legendary brand was born. That's cute. In 1954, a young ⁓ as a young man named Jimmy Russell, or a young man named Jimmy Russell, joined the distillery. Taught by Master Distiller Bill Hughes and Ernest Rippe, Jimmy eventually took over as Master Distiller. He went on to dedicate over 70 years to the brand, earning the nickname Buddha of Bourbon. Jimmy finally established the house style of whiskey wild turkey, a relatively low entry proof in the barrel, which allowed the natural and bold, natural, bold, and robust flavors of heavy charred oak to shine through. So between 1985 and 1992. Wild Turkey released an iteration of its twelve year old one hundred and one proof that featured a reflective gold foil label accompanied by a shiny gilded tube. Because the flashy nineteen eighties packaging leaned a bit into kitsch, modern whiskey collectors affectionately dubbed it cheesy gold foil. While the package was was a product of its era, the whiskey inside became legendary. During the glut of the The glut era of bourbon, when the supply when supply heavily outpaced demand, distilleries had an excess of mature stock, even though the bottle carried a 12-year-old age statement. It frequently contained whiskey aged up to 18 years or older. The cheesy gold foil is celebrated for a hyper-concentrated, intensely dark flavor profile, dense red fruits, deep leather, tobacco, a heavy dose of what the collectors called old school. Turkey Funk. Today, an original vintage bottle of cheesy goldfoil is considered a holy grail of dusty hunting, regularly commanding $3,000 or more at auction. So fast forward to May of 2026, this year, Wild Turkey officially launched the Austin Nichols Archives Collection, a limited edition annual series designed to honor the distillery's most iconic historic bottles. The inaugural elite release is the cheesy gold foil edition. Spearheaded by Bruce Russell, associate master blender and third generation of the Russell family to run the stills, this express ⁓ expression directly honors the spirit of the old cheesy gold foil era without attempting a perfect identical clone. So this whiskey, age-stated at 16 years old, it is 120-proof. It's non-chill filtered, it's composed of just 50 premium barrels. Pulling heavily, heavily from the fine legendary Camp Nilk Nelson Rick House's suggested retail price on this bottle? $400. Okay. Those secondary prices are are up around $1,000 to $1,200 a bottle. Yikes. Yikes. ⁓ can I ask a uneducated question? Dive in. Okay. Yeah. ⁓ so turkey funk, are they calling it? Just because it has a funk to it and it's wild turkey? Yeah. Or is there a funk wild turkey associated with a little. So that's so I there's no turkey. Like there's some like on the turkey. No, no, no, no. It's just it's the way the whiskey tastes. People have referred to ⁓ wild turkey products as have vena. Kind of a funk said that. A Rick House funk. Yeah. Has nothing to do with the name. That just happens to be Just figure. Beautiful bottle here. the the the box it comes in is crazy. The cork on this thing, it looks like let me get this thing peeled back, but it is ⁓ wooden cork inlaid with what appears to be gold. Well, no wonder it costs a lot of money. ⁓ probably not real gold. ⁓ but ⁓ let's see it says something around the Also growing up in Michigan, this box, anyone from the Midwest probably had a blanket that looked like this So the cork the cork is wood and around the the rim of the cork it says crafted with conviction. And it has a wild and it has a turkey on the top of it. So for those of the can't see it, let's get the pop on it. I do like me some walter. That's a good pop. Good pop. Do you guys know those blankets that look like that? Do you know what I'm talking about? I can't say for the Midwest. You know I know what you're talking about. I'll be honest with you. You don't? Are you talking about like the grandma quilts that like No, no, like a it it would be like ⁓ what's that soft not felt, but fleece. A fleece blanket. I feel like they're I'm gonna find it. I'm gonna find it and order one. Just to match the wild turkey. So on the on this bottle, so last before I like close the computer for the evening. So this cheesy gold. So the flavor profile is what they say. That can we not? You want you don't want to hear it. No. We'll come back to the notes at a later moment. I like that. Good. Yeah. You know what? So it's a $400 bottle. I will say I believe I What did pay on this? 500? 400? No, no, I paid 400. That's right. I did pay 400 on this bottle. Big shout out to El Paisano Liquor in ch downtown Tampa. Our man. ⁓ Amido. I did say when I when I was like, hey, I d let me get that bottle from you. We were gonna pop it on the podcast. So we are popping it the podcast. Cheers. ⁓ Amido. Thank you, guys. Appreciate it. ⁓ let's dive in on the notes, see what we get. Flavor profile on the notes. I mean I know it's one twenty, but has some proof on the nose. ⁓ that I could smell that. But a but a big cherry note on the nose of this bourbon. Yeah. Dark Wild Dark Black Cherry. Like think Luxardo cherry. What ⁓ age is this? Sixteen years. Sixteen years. James has already dived in and tasted. Well, I feel like as soon as I take a sniff of it, it burns a little. So then I stop smelling it. I'm like, I don't know. There was something in there. So I don't get any burn on this at all. Just because I'm a wild turkey I a buff turkey fan. Well, you also you start you in a previous episode, you said your very first bourbon you ever drank was Wild Turkey. Was Wild Turkey one ⁓ one. So I am a big one ⁓ one. Wild turkey fan. All right. but it is a sixteen year old wild turkey. Correct. What's an average age for a a wild like back in the day we were drinking wild turkey? What's the age? Whatever one or one. Seven day. Yeah. Seven to eight years. ⁓ now you said seven day. I was like, can they even do that? Seven day adventist. No, seven to eight years is Jimmy Russell prefers like somewhere between six and eight years. So ⁓ The only reason we're actually getting these high age, sixteen year, high proof bourbons, because Wild Turkey historically has not released anything above like one fourteen, one fifteen on their cast strength single barrel releases. but all their stuff is usually a ninety to one ⁓ one proof. Whew. That is not because Jimmy Russell prefers the younger and lower proofs. ⁓ where Bruce Russell, the grandson Does like higher big higher proofs. He's a ⁓ he's a he's a rye guy. He likes rye. ⁓ and he's also you know, an av avid bourbon guy. So he understands kind of what the you know, the bourbon community's looking for, which is high age, high proof. So where I was going with yeah, he was ⁓ sorry. Yeah, sorry. Is it's sixteen years old. Yeah. Some of my favorite buff turkeys are the same age. Well, it's true. Could this not be that juice same juice and just A wild turkey. It's definitely not the same juice. Okay. Because wild turkey had all the barrels of buff turkey and decided, hey, it doesn't taste like wild turkey, right? ⁓ And I think you wild turkey is distinctly different from a buffalo trace product. Where that buff turkey is kind of like a weird combination of between them. ⁓ so no, I don't I I believe this is high age wild turkey juice that they distilled. But did they did they distill it? Yes. Okay. Yeah. So this this factory or the distillery was still up and running during the time that they did ⁓ go down and do all the renovations, I guess that's where I'm going. Yeah. So those buff turkeys that you're drinking are two years older than this. Okay. So their distillery was back online. They were producing in late two thousand nine or whatever. Do the math. I don't know where we're at. We're twenty seventeen now. ⁓ so yeah, this is this is wild turkey distillate. Yeah. Wait, this is twenty seventeen. No, this is twenty twenty six. What I'm saying is it came back online two thousand eight wild turkey. And there's we're going down a rabbit hole with buff turkey, so we got kind of confused here. Well they took their distillery offline in two thousand eight to do some maintenance. And that's why we ended up. I would like to say sorry, but you're You just said you're going down a rabbit hole, so I'm gonna not take responsibility for that. You two are going down a rabbit hole. Yes, I will say, and I said this before, the longer it sits, the better it smells. Has anybody not taken a sip of it? No, I took a sip. I have not taken a sip. No, I did. And I I love the nose. Still loving the nose. No, the nose is good. But I but I found that if I let it sit out for five minutes even. James, no nose guy. What's that ⁓ comic book character with no nose? The nose no. The no, the guy the the skeleton guy. I don't remember his name. No fuck it. He's on fire. I think Nicholas Cade Nicholas Cade Ghostwriter. Ghostwriter. Yeah, that's James. Our ghostwriter. Okay, I'm going in for the taste. All right, me too. No, the nose it's I always say dusty, it's so good. What do you think? You've tasted it. You were the first person to taste it. It's really good, but it's I mean you could taste the I mean it's old. You can tell. I mean it's sixteen plus years old for sure. Super leathery. Very, very leathery. Well, the nose, I the nose is old. I know you said there's cherry, but it's it's very again, I don't know what else to call it. It's dusty. It's kind of that attic. And that's what grandma's wood boxes. I love that smell. That's what they're looking for. Rickhouse funk. That's that Rick House funk. Yeah. Is that what a Rick House funk is? Yeah. I feel like I should have I need to take my wife to a distillery because you can actually smell what a fucking Rick House smells like walking. I mean, I would I'd burn a candle that smells like that's what they're trying, that's what they were trying to do with this box. Correct. Yeah. They wanted it to taste like an old. Yeah. Dusty bourbon, you might have got back in the 90s or whatever, right? I'm not super good like giving notes on the taste, typically. I I'm not there yet. But the nose, and I feel like it's weird to say, okay, well, I'm not gonna drink it. I'm just gonna sit here and sniff it all. But but like bottle this, put it in a candle. So first sip was amazing. Cherry, sweetness, a little bit of like baked goods. Second sip I l I kinda like wash it around a little bit in my mouth. Get got a little more spicy notes out of it. ⁓ let's read let's let's let's finish reading what they say you taste. What do you get before I read it, James? You're the palate guy. No. The ⁓ It's like don't do that. No, don't do that. But ⁓ I mean your thumbs up, thumbs down. You like it, don't like it? No, I like it, absolutely. I mean, if I don't like it, I mean that's absurd. I mean it's delicious. I mean it does taste. I mean I can taste the old I mean the description to me is spot on. Mm-hmm. Yeah. So what they say here on the at least the the notes that I was able to pull up here. Nose hits With dark cherry, antique leather, and sweet tobacco leaf. On the palate, it delivers a viscous, full-bodied wave of raspberry, plum, dark caramel that leads right into a heavy, complex oak framework. True to its inspiration, the finish is exceptionally long and features that unmistakable peppery old school oak funk on the back end. The bottle itself ditches the cheesy look for a sophisticated vintage-inspired layout. It revives the classic flying turkey emblem from the archival Austin Nichols tubes and features an illustration of the original station master's house on Tyrone distillery grounds. So ⁓ I'm So I was waiting to open my bottle for this podcast and I had a buddy we were visiting recently ⁓ and he wanted to pop the same bottle. And I'm I'll be honest with you, that night I was a little disappointed in it. Tonight, I love this thing. I think it's really good tonight. I love it. Top five for me. Top five of what? You gotta be specif of tonight? No, or of five of this year. Of twenty twenty six. Yes. That I've tasted so far. But I'm biased too, right? Yeah, but I mean that's not really saying much. It's a top two, three bottle out of everyone in the world says the same thing. I don't know. I I actually took what did I tell you before we even started filming? Discouraged. You made me discouraged with the whole thing. Now did I fucking influence you negatively? No, not at all. I mean, but I do get like if you're not a wild turkey fan, yeah, this isn't gonna be your jam. Like if you're I mean if you don't like a bold, punchy fl like dense flavor bourbon, this is this is not ⁓ this is not a casual drinker's pour. It's it's full flavored, yeah. Right in your face type of bourbon. This is the marlboro red wild if Barce was here, the Marlborough red of bourbons. Right. ⁓ and who knows, it you know When you're drinking bourbon, it's all subjective, right? Whatever your what do you ever you ate that night, whatever a lot a lot of things influence what you're tasting, right? And who knows? The other night when I tried this, which was about two weeks ago I was a little bit let down. I I was expecting way more from it. Tonight, I think it lives up to everything that everybody has said online. I'm like, wow, this is this is a great pour. I definitely going on my contender for best of twenty twenty-six list. Where last week I was like, it might not. So I had a discussion with Ronnie earlier, and a lot of people have Have loved this bottle that I've talked to, but a a lot of people are if you're not a huge wild turkey fan, you're gonna go to the Heaven Hill twenty two. And like everyone says those are the two bottles and everyone's like, ⁓ if you don't like this, you're a Heaven Hill twenty two fan. So it'll be interesting at the end of the year to see Well hell, even before the end of the year. I like the Heaven Hill twenty two. Have we had the have I had that? Good. You have not. Really good. I mean, I don't think it's really good. I I haven't had it, but I I think it's in the great category. This or the twenty two? U I mean I I think both of ⁓ are up there. Okay. Right. You know what I mean? So I mean, I think you're gonna it's like I said when you say great category, are you saying that's something less than the best of? No, the best of, sorry. I okay take that back. The best of twenty twenty six or these are these two are gonna be top two or three on everyone's list. Yeah, they're in there, right? And ⁓ maybe even before we'll we'll add it to the our list of contenders for the year that we'll review at the end of the year. but between now and then, hell, well let's let's throw it in a couple maybe we'll throw it in a couple blinds. I that's the true that's the true performance of it, right? Is not knowing what it is, will will we think of it as well as we think, right? I think it's very good. I I as not as much of a bourbon drinker. Sure. Right? Regular human. ⁓ I feel like I emotionally feel stronger towards the the Harris tribute. Just any other random bourbon? Or just well no, like the the the that specific bottle. Okay. I liked so much. And I'm like, well, I mean I I guess that one's kind of expensive too. It's right up there with this. It's the same price. I would love I would love to blind this with something like a duck club. Or ⁓ I honestly I I'm gonna do it. You wait, you guys wait. One of these nights I'm gonna do that and You're gonna you're gonna blind us. You're gonna blind it with water too. I mean that that's that's a hard comparison to make, right? You're gonna know exactly what's what. Well, I'll I'll find another proofier one. Yeah. But I think I think we should throw it in a few blinds with some other big boy. What would you blind it with? ⁓ the Heaven Hill. So I I I there's a couple of ways you you could go. Do you do an all all wild turkey blind? That's what I'm thinking. So I I would maybe throw this if I were to just spitball, I would throw this in maybe a four way blind with Russell's fifteen year old. Because it's the closest in age and it's the one of the huge sought afters. I would put it up against ⁓ one of the rick house single rick houses. And ⁓ and then a lot of people seem to think the wild turkey beacon is up there. The series. The series took the place, and I mean a lot of people are saying that it's not worth chasing because you can just have the beacon. And I was not a fan of the beacon. I've I've put it in multiple blinds and for me it just doesn't sing like other people says it's so good. ⁓ so that that's one way to go. Another way to go is I would throw it up against a Heavenhill 22. I'd throw it up some against some of these eighteen year old Barton big boy bottles, maybe a calumid eighteen or you know shit, some a alt Schuler 18 or 19 year olds or something like that, where where you're you're getting some of those like very thick Oak tobacco, you know, dense dark notes out of it. Yeah. I would not put it up against a duck club or a ninety two proof bourbon. Okay. You know what I meant. I know. I know what you mean. You love that bourbon. I do, but I But I I think those are two different two different drinking experiences, right? I think I think you know, a duck club like, hey, I'm gonna have a coffee cup full of it and you'll be fine. Like it's it's really good, it's smooth. This one is like very thick and chewy and flavorful and you it's you feel like you need to slow down with this one in my opinion. Yeah, just enjoy the pour. This is a this is a my wife likes to use this campfire pour where your life has slowed down. You're having a conversational I have also used the analogy of like this is a a bottle you pull down for a special occasion. I think, you know It's good. We know that's it worth so th now the question on it though, it's four hundred dollars MSRP. Good luck finding it for that. Is it worth eight hundred, a thousand, twelve hundred dollars? No. It's dealer's choice. I mean, I personally wouldn't pay probably even the four hundred for it, right? Yeah. Yeah. But that's just me. Sure. Four hundred's a lot to pay for a bottle. It is a lot. I'm not a guy over MSRP myself. So you would not go over I don't pay over MSRP. Fair enough. That's just that's my that's your rule. That's my rule. Hey. Well, kind of at the end of the day, don't you wonder, like, okay, so four hundred, why are you I I guess supply and demand, but like how dare you, sir, charge me a thousand dollars for a four hundred dollar bottle when he probably bought it for three hundred. Yeah. I know because they can't. Yeah, unfortunately that's the world that we live in with it's unfortunate. I mean a lot of things. It's not just whiskey, it's sneakers, it's everything. Guilty of it. Cars, whatever, right? Someone's gonna put a markup on it if they can, if they can get more money out of you and you're willing to pay it, then they'll get it. ⁓ I do I do think, you know, s other people say like, you know, Wild Turkey for a long time did not sell products that were at that price range. Price point, I I would say. but their products got marked up so much. And so s some people are like, hey, I'd rather see the distillery make the money versus some flipper on the secondary. so, but does that limit, you know, how many people are gonna get a bottle of this, right? 'Cause there's not there's not a lot of people that are like, Hey, I'm not gonna spend over a hundred bucks or one fifty is my max for a special bottle. ⁓ but anyway, I would say if you if If you got a bottle great, let us know in the comments what you think about it. Is it on your, you know, potential bourbon of 2026 list? ⁓ I I don't know if I've ever seen it in a bar, but I would say if you do see it in a bar and you want to try it and you don't have a bottle, and you like wild turkey. Get a pour of it. I mean, it's probably gonna run you fifty to a hundred dollars for a pour. I think it's like eighty bucks pours. Yeah. I was gonna say fifty to a hundred somewhere in that range. It's you know, it's probably tracking along the lines of a A papy or something like that that you get at a bar. ⁓ shame on the bar. I was at a bar recently. Pappy fifteen was one thirty. A pour? Yeah, that's that's up there. I mean, my lord, do you know how many margaritas I can have for that? At six dollars apiece. ⁓ Right. How many course lights could you get? I mean, like that's ridiculous. But I mean, that's you know. That's that's their their prerogative, right? And so yeah. Anyway, ⁓ hey, l love to hear you guys' comments about is wild turkey a bottle you're chasing after this shit show of a conversation? Does it make you want to chase it even more or even less? let us know. ⁓ happy to hear your comments, love to respond to them all. ⁓ if you got a review for us, please leave it on Spotify, Apple Music, wherever you're listening to this, YouTube. ⁓ we'd love to hear your feedback and and love your sport. We'll see you next time for another episode on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. And Ronnie, thank you for letting us enjoy this great port. Okay, hell yeah. Thank you guys for being here. And ⁓ that's what Bourbon's about, is sharing it. So we'll see you guys next time. Cheers.