Latest / Keen On America / Rage in the American Republic
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, my name is Andrew Keen.
- 0:03Welcome to Keen on America, the Daily Interview Show about the United States.
- 0:30Hello everybody.
- 0:31It's Monday.
- 0:32February the eighth, 2026.
- 0:35GW Law School seems to be monopolizing the Keenon America Show these days.
- 0:41Few days ago we had Andrew Guthrie Ferguson, a professor at
- 0:47GW talking about his new book.
- 0:50Your Data will be used against you, a kind of libertarian defense against
- 0:54the leviathans of Silicon Valley, and now we have another GW professor,
- 1:00Jonathan Turley, who like Ferguson, has a new book ad, it's called Rage
- 1:06in the Republic, the Unfinished Story of the American Revolution.
- 1:10It's just out his, uh, last book.
- 1:12Many of you'll be familiar with.
- 1:14The Indispensable Ride was a best seller.
- 1:17Uh, expect this one will be two.
- 1:19Jonathan is joining us from his home.
- 1:22Uh, in the Washington DC area.
- 1:25Uh, Jonathan, would it be fair to say that your new book, uh, Rage
- 1:30in the Republic, uh, focuses on the uniqueness of the American Revolution,
- 1:37which of course we are celebrating the 250th year anniversary this year?
- 1:43Well, first of all, Andrew, thank you for having me on your program,
- 1:46and it does indeed look at what are the factors and the personalities and
- 1:52events that came together to create this unique republic 250 years ago.
- 2:00And that first half of the book looks at two revolutions, the American and
- 2:06French revolutions, and actually follows much of the journey of Thomas Payne,
- 2:12uh, who is one of two central figures who played a role in both revolutions.
- 2:16The other being Lafayette.
- 2:18And the, the first half of the book sort of tries to figure out why the
- 2:24American Revolution went on to become the longest, uh, and most successful
- 2:30democracy, and the French Relu revolution went on to become the reign of terror.
- 2:35And what, what the book suggests is that the difference were these
- 2:41precautions that James Madison put together, uh, in the constitution.
- 2:46You know, Thomas Payne was the righteous rage of, uh, the American Revolution.
- 2:51It may have been the truest revolutionary of the American
- 2:54Revolution, and it was James Madison who was sort of the pious logic.
- 3:00You know, Payne knew what it would take.
- 3:03To move a people to revolution.
- 3:05And then Madison knew what it would take to move a revolution to a republic.
- 3:10And it was the combination of those two sort of mindsets and two, frankly, two
- 3:16geniuses that produced this republic.
- 3:20And then the second half of the book looks forward as to whether that
- 3:24republic can survive in the 21st century.
- 3:27And it looks at everything from the combination of robotics and ai.
- 3:32Which I go into some depth on, uh, and the potential of a massive loss of jobs
- 3:38as well as global governance and the rise of what I call the class of new Jacobins.
- 3:46Well, we'll get to that class of new Jacobins in in a few minutes.
- 3:50Um, Jonathan, is your analysis there, and it sounds to me as if your
- 3:54analysis of the American Revolution is.
- 3:57Somewhat burkey in this one, two punch of pain.
- 4:01And then Madison, Madison forcing pain's, anger, and righteousness to into law.
- 4:08You are a professor of law.
- 4:10I I, I Is that fair?
- 4:11Is, is your analysis of the uniqueness of the American Revolution, Bian
- 4:15Burke, of course, being the greatest of all critics of the French
- 4:19Revolution and particularly of Jacobin?
- 4:22Well, I go to some depth about the.
- 4:24Uh, the debate between Payne and Burke, I'm known as a more of a Madisonian
- 4:30scholar, and the book certainly embraces what Madison was arguing.
- 4:35What I find fascinating about Thomas Payne, and he is the most interesting
- 4:39historical figure I've ever researched or written about is that pain.
- 4:44Was a remarkable individual, a true genius, but he did not agree with
- 4:50Madison's auxiliary precautions as he called them, uh, because he
- 4:54believed more in direct democracy.
- 4:57And when he went to the French Revolution, he pursued that with Jacobins.
- 5:01He wanted a unicameral legislature.
- 5:05Uh, he wanted to sort of strip away a lot of those barriers for the public to
- 5:10express themselves through legislation.
- 5:12And it came damn near to killing him that his pain came within
- 5:1624 hours of being guillotine.
- 5:18Uh, and it was just an accident that he wasn't beheaded, but he came
- 5:24to realize that Madison was right.
- 5:26And what he was, what the, the rightness of Madison was in the view
- 5:30that democracies devour themselves.
- 5:33Uh, that at the beginning of the book starts by quoting a Frenchman from the
- 5:37Revolution, uh, who said that revolutions like Saturn develop, devour their own.
- 5:44Yeah.
- 5:44And of course there's that famous novel, the Gods must Have Their Blood.
- 5:48That's right.
- 5:49And pain Watch that happen.
- 5:53In France, uh, the Jacobins, all the leadership of the Jacobins, except
- 5:57for a couple of notable exceptions, all fell under what was called,
- 6:02uh, the Razor of the Republic.
- 6:04They all were devoured by the revolution.
- 6:07And of course, the razor was not just metaphorical, it was the guillotine.
- 6:10I, I'm guessing.
- 6:11Um.
- 6:12Jonathan, the, the, uh, the bad guy in, in your narrative, at least when
- 6:17it comes to France, is, is Robe spear?
- 6:19Does he speak for everything that went wrong with the French Revolution?
- 6:23Well, I go into depth with robes.
- 6:25Pierre and I talk about him in the second half as well.
- 6:28Who would tell you about the new Jack of them?
- 6:30What has to be remembered is that Rob Spear was a lawyer, and when
- 6:34he began, uh, he spoke about the rights of man, about due process.
- 6:38Uh, if you had heard him and read him in the early days, you would've
- 6:41thought he was an A CLU lawyer.
- 6:43And this,
- 6:44yeah.
- 6:44I'm guessing, uh, do you, do you get the Rob Spear types in your classes at gw?
- 6:48I'm sure you shut them up, Jonathan, don't you?
- 6:51Well, you know, the, the thing about it is I, I not only talk about roast
- 6:54beer, but also figures like morat.
- 6:57Uh, journalists, uh, lawyers, professors, aristocrats, uh, who began in the
- 7:02same way but were corrupted over time to the point that Robe Pierre
- 7:06eventually said that terror is virtue.
- 7:09Uh, he came to totally embrace.
- 7:12The execution of those that disagree with you.
- 7:15And the book talks about how this was sort of a rousso revolution in that sense.
- 7:20The, the Jacob Ins loved Rousseau and his idea of the general will, and this was
- 7:25another way of saying direct democracy, that if you unleash the general will
- 7:30of the populace, that it can only come to good because people are good.
- 7:34It was a very naive,
- 7:35yeah.
- 7:35And of course, Rousseau invented the modern concept of.
- 7:39Authenticity and the self and all, all the rest of, uh, that, um,
- 7:45were there any good guys in your.
- 7:47Analysis of the French Revolution.
- 7:49Dante, of course, comes to mind.
- 7:51Uh, who got the French Revolution in France?
- 7:54Tocqueville, I'm guessing from your point of
- 7:55view.
- 7:56Well, the top villain will definitely have to go to Rose Pierre and
- 8:00Marat and Abe and a few others.
- 8:02But I, you know, downtown was no angel.
- 8:06Of course, he, he signed off on the executions.
- 8:10Eventually he joined, um, the.
- 8:14Uh, which was the sort of moderate Jacobin wing, but they had
- 8:18blood on their hands as well.
- 8:20And then ultimately, of course, he was executed.
- 8:22It was an interesting, you know, many of the good ones were of course,
- 8:25executed, uh, because they were good.
- 8:28Uh,
- 8:29the gods must have their blood, Jonathan,
- 8:31that's right.
- 8:32In your historical narrative.
- 8:33The way, uh, we, when, when I was a. A student in England, the way
- 8:40we were brought up in terms of our analysis of these comparative
- 8:44revolutions is we didn't begin with the French or the American revolutions.
- 8:49We began with the glorious English revolution.
- 8:52What's your analysis when it comes to rage and the republic of.
- 8:57The Republican Revolution, or what in part was a Republican revolution
- 9:01in England, the Cromwellian Revolution, which of course was
- 9:03also manifested by a degree of rage.
- 9:06What was different from the American Revolution?
- 9:09Well, this is a book about revolutions.
- 9:12I do talk about the English revolution.
- 9:14I. All revolutions require rage.
- 9:16All these nations are not just the progeny of Revolution, uh, but the result of rage.
- 9:22That's what the Boston Tea Party was after all, it was rage, and
- 9:26you have to move a country to rage.
- 9:28That's why Thomas Payne was so important.
- 9:30That's why he's called the penant of the revolution.
- 9:33It's why he's so extraordinary.
- 9:34I mean, he arrived in this country, barely alive after a voyage, had to
- 9:38be carried off a ship in Philadelphia.
- 9:40That was two years.
- 9:42Just two years before the Declaration of Independence, in two years, he went
- 9:47from being a, an entire and complete failure in everything he had ever done.
- 9:52Every job, every marriage he had to being the penman of the American Revolution.
- 9:57But the American Revolution was the first true enlightenment revolution.
- 10:02Um, not to downplay the English, uh, rebellion.
- 10:06You don't consider it a revolution.
- 10:08You just, you call it a rebellion, Jonathan.
- 10:10Well, I
- 10:11don't mean that king.
- 10:12No, I did, I didn't actually mean much by the, the, the, uh,
- 10:16um, change in, in, in nouns.
- 10:18But the, uh, the American Revolution was, was a direct outgrowth.
- 10:24Of enlightenment ideas.
- 10:26And the Declaration of Independence is largely an enlightenment document.
- 10:30It actually doesn't talk about democracy.
- 10:32It talks about liberty.
- 10:33It never mentions democracy.
- 10:35And in that sense it was a fascination for, for people around the world.
- 10:40Uh, you know, they talked about.
- 10:42These Americans, like they were a brand new species.
- 10:45And it sort of goes when lock said in the beginning, all was America.
- 10:48It was not just that this was an untamed land, uh, it was this notion
- 10:55that this was a country that was starting anew without the sort of
- 10:59calcified structures classes of Europe.
- 11:03And I talk in the book about a Frenchman who wrote under the name, uh, farmer John.
- 11:09Who had a great line and a very popular book in Europe, and he
- 11:13asked, what then is this America?
- 11:17And it was a very profound question.
- 11:19But then is this American?
- 11:20They, the, the, the, the Europeans wanted to know, uh, how this
- 11:25could happen, why it happened.
- 11:28And actually the French modeled originally the revolution on, on the
- 11:33United States, but then refused to create those protections and precautions.
- 11:39Uh, they wanted the revolution, but not what came with it.
- 11:45Jonathan.
- 11:45Um, what about the alternative narrative of the American Revolution?
- 11:52I'm sure you are not particularly keen on it.
- 11:54The idea of the appropriation of indigenous land, the history of slavery
- 11:59in terms of the American Revolution.
- 12:01Are there contradictions, especially when it comes to pain?
- 12:05Pain of course, was not an admirer of slavery, perhaps even of capitalism.
- 12:11Um, what about.
- 12:13The alternative narratives, do you just dismiss them?
- 12:17No, I don't.
- 12:17In fact, I talk about those, the inherent contradictions are glaring.
- 12:22I actually talk about it also in terms of why Thomas Payne was so unpopular.
- 12:27You know, he had the distinction of being.
- 12:30Pursuit for prosecutions in all three nations where he claimed
- 12:33citizenship, uh, forced sedition.
- 12:36Uh, he was the ultimate contrarian.
- 12:39But there was more to that, as I say in the book, that there's a reason why.
- 12:43People preferred figures like Thomas Jefferson, the Thomas Payne
- 12:47Jefferson was tall and erudite.
- 12:50Uh, classically trained, well educated, and a slave owner, Thomas Payne,
- 12:55was vehemently against slavery.
- 12:58And that, I think, contributed to his being an out outlier.
- 13:03I mean, it was, so, there were others that were against slavery, but it was
- 13:06this glaring contradiction that pain himself did not have, which is why I
- 13:11think he's such a, a redeeming character.
- 13:15Um, even if he had very few friends, you know, uh, I, I quote, uh,
- 13:20Benjamin Franklin's daughter is saying it would've been better if he
- 13:23had died right after common Sense.
- 13:25And I note in the book, she was one of his friends.
- 13:28So, you know, it, it, it's an amazing thing about pain.
- 13:32He, he died, uh, virtually friendless, of course penniless, which was the
- 13:35problem he had his entire life.
- 13:39But slavery is one of those big issues that is looming here in terms
- 13:43of the contradictions, particularly if you are an enlightenment.
- 13:46Revolution to deny those freedoms to so many who were enslaved by you.
- 13:52And, and that book does talk about that.
- 13:54It's interesting you bring up Franklin.
- 13:56We've done a number of shows on him, uh, over the years.
- 13:59Um, Franklin, of course, was the reverse.
- 14:03Of pain in the sense that he had many friends both in the
- 14:06United States and Europe.
- 14:08Is he your fourth man, Jonathan?
- 14:10We've got, uh, Madison, we've got Jefferson, we've got pain.
- 14:14Who's the kind of, I don't know what you'd call him, it sounds to me like
- 14:17a kind of anti-hero, simultaneously hero and anti-hero in your narrative.
- 14:22What about Franklin?
- 14:24Well, pain is remarkably and delightfully.
- 14:28Complex.
- 14:29Uh, you know, I quote in the book, I'm a film noir nut and I drive my children
- 14:32crazy 'cause I, I have to have something playing in the background when I work.
- 14:37And it's always a black and white film noir film, which, which probably scarred
- 14:40my children, uh, to, to a terrible, I just
- 14:43hope so.
- 14:43Yeah.
- 14:44And, uh, but the greatest line ever uttered in any film noir.
- 14:49Was delivered by Fred Murray who turned after finding out that the femme fatal
- 14:53had finally lied to him again, as well as to her husband, uh, and she
- 14:58was incapable of telling the truth.
- 15:00He goes to the door, she begs him to stay, and he turns and says, I love you so much.
- 15:05I only wish I liked you.
- 15:07And I think with Thomas Payne, for those of us who have spent a lot
- 15:11of time with him, uh, in, in these histories, um, we all love him.
- 15:16We just wish we liked him.
- 15:17He, he, he had this person was hard to like, because in many ways
- 15:21he was brilliant about humanity, but he was clueless about human.
- 15:26Uh, and
- 15:26the, the, the, the classic conservative critique of leftist
- 15:30for people who are just listening.
- 15:32Jonathan is very formal fellow.
- 15:35He is dressed in a suit and ties a wannabe Thomas Payne in you, uh, Jonathan, do you
- 15:41sometimes wake up in the middle of the night and fantasize of being Thomas Payne?
- 15:47I can't say I fantasize being Thomas Payne.
- 15:49But
- 15:49What about your wife would you like, would she like you to be Thomas Payne?
- 15:52Oh, I don't think anyone would wanna live with Thomas Payne.
- 15:55You know, the interesting you mentioned about George
- 15:57be exciting though for a few minutes, wouldn't it?
- 15:59Yeah.
- 16:00But you know, it's, um, it only took a few minutes before people generally
- 16:04got into a fight with Thomas Payne 'cause he was the ultimate contrarian.
- 16:07And you mentioned Benjamin Franklin, who is, is, is, is
- 16:10prominently featured in the book
- 16:12and the ladies loved, uh.
- 16:14Franklin and Franklin, of course, loved the ladies, especially
- 16:16the French ladies, I think.
- 16:18Yes.
- 16:18And, and the interesting thing is that Thomas Payne had finally hit rock bottom.
- 16:24Uh, he had no money.
- 16:26He, he appeared before Benjamin Franklin in London without a penny unkempt, uh,
- 16:32known as a drunkard and, uh, a contrarian.
- 16:36Benjamin Franklin saw something in that heap of human wreckage, which is
- 16:41a skill that Benjamin Franklin had.
- 16:43He had an eye for talent, but his greatest achievement without
- 16:47question was Thomas Payne.
- 16:49He was the one who paid for Thomas Payne to go to America.
- 16:53He was the one who wrote his son the governor, to ask that
- 16:58he find a position for him.
- 16:59He was the one that told Thomas Payne, you should write.
- 17:03And it, and in many ways the book looks at Thomas Payne because he
- 17:07may be the quintessential American.
- 17:09He came to this shore to reinvent himself to become something new.
- 17:16And what he found was in this place that he said that there was a special
- 17:21something in the United States.
- 17:24And I think that's special something.
- 17:26Is a place without limits.
- 17:28And he came to reinvent himself and he did, he discovered that the most
- 17:31valuable thing he had was, in his head, it was being Thomas Payne.
- 17:37Yeah.
- 17:37And of course, uh, Fitzgerald famously said he was completely wrong on this, that
- 17:42there are no second chances in America.
- 17:44And Thomas Payne had a second chance.
- 17:47And then perhaps that's what America's all about.
- 17:49Let's get to the R word.
- 17:51Um.
- 17:53Uh, Jonathan Rage are, are you arguing in the book that there's
- 17:58something uniquely American, or at least, uh, uniquely American about
- 18:06rage in the American Revolution?
- 18:08I mean, all our revolutions you've noted are, are driven by rage.
- 18:11That was a rageful, as you note about Thomas pain and anger.
- 18:16Thirst for justice.
- 18:18What is so unique about the rage driving the American Revolution?
- 18:24That thirst for justice.
- 18:25Of course, you can find not just with robes beer, with Lenin, with
- 18:29Mao, with many other revolutions.
- 18:32There's nothing unique about the rage in, in, uh, the American Revolution.
- 18:36That's the point of the book that, that rage is, is a very human feeling.
- 18:41It's my second book that deals with my f the, the earlier book that
- 18:45you mentioned dealt with the, what I call the Age of Rage and Yeah.
- 18:48And the subtitle of the book is Free Speech In An Age of Rage.
- 18:52Yeah.
- 18:53But it's not our first age of rage and.
- 18:55It's not unique.
- 18:57But what was unique was the recognition of the founders.
- 19:01They did not want an Athenian democracy, which was utter failure.
- 19:05It, it lasted not that very long and, and ended up in tyranny.
- 19:10They did not want what one framer called a mo that the tendency of
- 19:14democracies to devour themselves.
- 19:16So what was unique was the.
- 19:18Effort put in to create a system that could vent the pressures,
- 19:23that would blow democracies apart, that could handle the rage.
- 19:27That's what was unique, not the rage itself.
- 19:31And,
- 19:31and that's of course Madison and, uh, the other authors of the Federalist Papers.
- 19:37Then are you arguing that the key event perhaps in the revolution was the debate?
- 19:43Articulated in the Federalist papers about a centralized
- 19:46government versus something else.
- 19:49Well, what I talk about, particularly the second half of the book and
- 19:52trying to identify the elements that led us to create this republic
- 19:56is that we're gonna need them more than ever in the 21st century.
- 20:00And many of those are Madisonian.
- 20:02Precautions.
- 20:03You know, I do a sort of, the first half is sort of a tale of two cities.
- 20:07I look at Philadelphia and Paris.
- 20:09Both had violence in the street.
- 20:11This was after the American Revolution.
- 20:14Paris was about to get blown apart again.
- 20:16Uh, there was an attack called the Battle of Fort Wilson.
- 20:19It was actually just James Wilson's home.
- 20:21He came damn near close, one of the founders to being killed by a mob.
- 20:27And many people died, but then it stomped in Philadelphia.
- 20:31That's a true miracle about it.
- 20:33And even though the Constitution was unpopular, it barely passed in
- 20:37Pennsylvania, people discovered that they had an alternative to going
- 20:42into the streets and it's stabilized.
- 20:45That's what was missing.
- 20:47The French Revolution and it take, it takes a lot.
- 20:52When you unleash that rage, it takes a lot.
- 20:54You know, starting revolutions is not as as difficult as ending one.
- 20:58You know, Napoleon Bonaparte, of course, was the result of the French
- 21:01Revolution, but it's Bonaparte.
- 21:03That said, a revolution is an idea that has found its bayonets.
- 21:07The problem is defined a way to put the bayonets away when you have accomplished
- 21:13or articulated that idea, and that's what the French were unable to do.
- 21:18It required a shock.
- 21:20To them to end the bloodletting.
- 21:23You know, you talk about the figures from the French Revolution.
- 21:25One that I spend a lot of time on is, is Corde, who is this
- 21:29beautiful woman who killed Marat in his bathtub and it was famously
- 21:35famous painting.
- 21:36Yeah.
- 21:36Yes.
- 21:37With David, the death of, of Marat.
- 21:40Um, David was himself a radical jack of the.
- 21:42Him and, and this was sort of a propaganda piece he had do, he
- 21:46had Marat laid out like a Piet in the tub with alabaster skin.
- 21:50You know, Marat was in the tub 'cause his, he was covered in sores
- 21:53'cause he had a rare skin disease.
- 21:56And, uh, he, he most likely did not look quite as contented as,
- 21:59uh, have a knife plunged into his chest, but corde in many ways.
- 22:06Was a shock to the system.
- 22:08Uh, her execution was different from the rest.
- 22:12Uh, people found her courage and not just her beauty to be, uh, really
- 22:19sort of, um, all encompassing and watching her execution was robes.
- 22:26Pierre next to him was Dante, both of which would soon
- 22:29fall under the same blade.
- 22:31And I, but Corde was, I think one of those turning points.
- 22:36She was a Republican.
- 22:37She was not, uh, a royalist in that sense.
- 22:41She had seen the bloodletting and wanted to end it, and, but she ended
- 22:44it with an act of assassination.
- 22:47You mentioned earlier that you're a, a Madison scholar.
- 22:51Madison, of course, is famously associated with words.
- 22:54If, if men were angels, no government would be necessary.
- 22:58And of course, we are not in, in terms of defining not being angels was.
- 23:06Madison's analysis that we were rageful or economically self-interested in
- 23:12tend tending towards faction, or are those in his mind the same thing?
- 23:17Well, it may be in some ways the same thing.
- 23:19You know, I, people often will ask me, you know, it seems like
- 23:23Madison was a cynic, uh, that, you know, he talked about factions
- 23:27and how, uh, people form factions.
- 23:29I always push back on that.
- 23:31In some ways, I consider Madison the greatest of optimists because he.
- 23:34Took us for who we are.
- 23:36He didn't, you know, I always tell my students, when my students
- 23:39come up and say, oh, I read, I I've read the US Constitution.
- 23:42I just love it.
- 23:43It's so beautiful.
- 23:44I, I know they've never read the US Constitution 'cause they,
- 23:47well they probably used AI to read it.
- 23:48They've probably got a summary.
- 23:50Yeah.
- 23:50US Constitution reads like the tax code.
- 23:52I mean it, there's nothing but I tell 'em, if you wanna read
- 23:54a beautiful constitution, read any of the French constitutions.
- 23:57I mean, 'cause they had a lot of practice 'cause they failed so often and.
- 24:01You know, but they knew how to write a constitution.
- 24:03They would talk about the rights of man, this horizonal view of who we
- 24:08are, and they would have a revolution, and the next morning they'd wake up
- 24:11and have that morning after feeling that you're not quite the, yeah.
- 24:15Jonathan, what's, you know, I've heard the, it's an interesting argument.
- 24:18I've heard it many times before.
- 24:20What's original about your argument about this distinction between the
- 24:23American and the French Revolution?
- 24:25Well, that's really not the thrust of the book.
- 24:27The thrust of the book.
- 24:28Uh, is
- 24:29so you would acknowledge it's not particularly original.
- 24:32That, uh,
- 24:33about how often the French, about the,
- 24:35well, the, the American was Madisonian and the French was rooted in violence and
- 24:40rage and Rob Spear and the guillotine.
- 24:42No, the book, the book actually, uh, does, it does not just
- 24:46say that the book looks at.
- 24:48The French Revolution and the difference between Voltaire and, and and Rousseau.
- 24:53You know, it was famously said by one French, French historian that
- 24:57the first French revolution was Volta, and the second, which became
- 25:01the reign of terror, was Rousseau.
- 25:03And I look at, at what were the contributors there, because the thrust of
- 25:08my book is really to sort of have some.
- 25:11Guide a survival guide, uh, for, uh, this republic in the 21st century.
- 25:18And we're going to have to rely on those elements more
- 25:21than we have ever done before.
- 25:23And the concern I raise is that many of my colleagues, a lot
- 25:26of law professors, law deans.
- 25:28Uh, our calling for removing some of the very elements, identifying the book
- 25:32is key to why we stabilized and became.
- 25:36So
- 25:37are you suggesting that there are robe spears hidden in lots of law
- 25:41departments around the country?
- 25:43Um, I'm not saying that, in fact, in the book I say I don't believe
- 25:46that any of these new jacobins want to see, uh, um, you know, the, uh,
- 25:52the carts rolled down Pennsylvania Avenue, but neither did robes Pierre.
- 25:57Uh, when he began.
- 25:58The key is that you can lose control, uh, to a mob if you, if you have
- 26:06more direct democratic impulse, if you remove these precautions.
- 26:10And what concerns me is, you know, one of the priorities is the change
- 26:13the Supreme Court to pack the supreme.
- 26:16Uh, also to change the US Senate, uh, with the Dean of Berkeley Law School has
- 26:21a book out saying, no constitution lasts forever, and says that the US Constitution
- 26:25is now the threat that has to be overcome.
- 26:27Who's the dean of the Berkeley Law School?
- 26:29Uh, Irwin Chasky.
- 26:31Yeah.
- 26:31He is been on the show.
- 26:32Let's, so let's fast forward, let's get to the core of the book.
- 26:35Yesterday was the Super Bowl, uh, supposedly bringing Americans.
- 26:40Together of course.
- 26:41Although if anything, it divided them even more attitudes to culture and politics.
- 26:46Some people might be listening to this, um, Jonathan, and thinking, well, this
- 26:51guy's talking about the dangers of mob ocracy, but he's on Fox News all the time.
- 26:56Isn't the danger of mob, ocracy and rage isn't that more manifest on
- 27:02the right with the followers of MAGA and Trump than it is on the left?
- 27:07In America in 2026.
- 27:09I don't see how you could argue that in the sense that there's rage on both sides.
- 27:13You see it all around you.
- 27:15Rage is a strange thing.
- 27:17It gives you license to say and do things you would not ordinarily say or do, but
- 27:23what people won't admit on either side.
- 27:26Is that they like it, it's addictive and it's contagious.
- 27:29I, I don't see any difference in that sense.
- 27:33I, and
- 27:34although, uh, coming back to the politicians, I know, you know,
- 27:38you're not a big admirer of.
- 27:40Some of the, the politicians on the left, you wrote something critical of, of
- 27:44Newsom, but Trump seems to capture the, the sort of the rageful zeitgeist of the
- 27:51age more than anyone else, doesn't he?
- 27:53I certainly don't see a, a rageful trump on the left in America, or at
- 27:57least one who has any political skills.
- 28:01I'm not too sure how you could have missed that.
- 28:03Well, who would be an example?
- 28:05Well, you have everyone from Governor Waltz to the members of Congress
- 28:10calling ice Nazis, Gestapo, uh, saying there's gonna be Nuremberg trials.
- 28:17What do you call that?
- 28:18If
- 28:18it's not, they say that, well, but what is not a,
- 28:23I wanna correct something out.
- 28:25And that is, I've been critical of both sides.
- 28:28My students will tell you I haven't liked the president since James
- 28:30Madison, and so I have criticized President Trump and when I thought he
- 28:35was right, I have said that as well.
- 28:37But there is no lock on rage today.
- 28:40That is a. Conceit that people love to say that it's the other side, right.
- 28:45My rage is righteous.
- 28:46Their rage is dangerous.
- 28:48That's very much the voice of rage.
- 28:51And are
- 28:51you raging against rage, though?
- 28:53It sounds, if you might be a bit,
- 28:55no, 'cause I actually, I don't think that it's, the rage itself
- 28:58is, is the threatening element.
- 29:01We have a system that can handle rage.
- 29:03It, it was, I, I testified once in Congress when one of the members
- 29:08asked me, you know, you always talk to us about, uh, the framers, but
- 29:12you know, people today talk like they're trying to kill each other.
- 29:15And I pointed out, you know, congressman, they were actually
- 29:18trying to kill each other back then.
- 29:20The, the US Constitution wasn't just written for times like this.
- 29:24It was written during a time like this.
- 29:26It was designed to handle rage.
- 29:29I'm not afraid of the rage.
- 29:31What I'm afraid of is removing the elements that we need to
- 29:34regulate, uh, and moderate the rage.
- 29:37That's what can become a hypocrisy.
- 29:40Are we a hypocrisy now?
- 29:42No, because we have a system designed not to let that happen.
- 29:46Go.
- 29:46Going back to pain, say comparing the comparison of pain, who was.
- 29:51An itinerant Englishman who suffered a lot in his life in Jefferson,
- 29:55who was an aristocrat and had a wonderful estate on Monticello,
- 29:58lots of slaves, even a slave wife.
- 30:02He had reason to be cheerful with his wine and his fancy new estate.
- 30:06Uh, some people might argue in America in 2026, Jonathan, that there's all
- 30:11reason to be raged too much more and more inequalities, more and more of a struggle
- 30:17to survive, to pay one's rent, anger on the street, anger against the police,
- 30:22anger within the police, blah, blah, blah.
- 30:25Can one argue in 2026 that the.
- 30:30Rage that you fear and are critical of is almost logical, inevitable,
- 30:36given the economic and cultural organization of the current republic.
- 30:42I, the, that's actually what I say in the book, that the, I don't
- 30:46actually, I, I don't actually.
- 30:48Uh, condemn rage as an emotion or a passion.
- 30:51I, I believe rage is something inherent during times of great
- 30:55economic, uh, and political change.
- 30:58That's not the problem.
- 31:00Uh, but what I am warning about in the book is our, how we're
- 31:05going to face what's coming.
- 31:07Which I believe with AI and robotics will I take the most conservative
- 31:11estimates on the loss of jobs from uh, from that technology.
- 31:16And we are looking at the possibility of a very large static unemployed.
- 31:22Class of individuals who would be supported by the state and the
- 31:26book asks, how does that change a citizen's relationship to the state?
- 31:30I disagree with you by the way, when you said that pain was
- 31:33not a big fan of capitalism.
- 31:34I think you're wrong.
- 31:36And uh, you know, I note in the book that, you know, the Wealth of
- 31:40Nations came out the year of our.
- 31:43Of the Declaration of Independence, it was embraced here.
- 31:47It was not a huge success in Europe.
- 31:48It was a big success here.
- 31:50'cause the founders viewed his economic theory as being the perfect
- 31:55companion to their political theory, and it was the combination of that.
- 31:59That helped stabilize the system.
- 32:02Payne actually said many things in agreement with, with Smith.
- 32:07He was also, however, very forward looking.
- 32:09He would talk about things that we would consider today to be public welfare
- 32:13systems, but he was actually a fairly, um, outspoken supporter of free markets.
- 32:21Yeah, and of course Smith himself was not really smithian in the sense that some.
- 32:28Libertarians have interpreted it.
- 32:30So Jonathan, let's get to the heart of the book then.
- 32:33If indeed, America is on the brink of a new chapter of massive rage, if
- 32:38everyone's about to lose their jobs to ai.
- 32:42What would you advise is the solution?
- 32:44Political, economic, cultural.
- 32:47I actually think the, the book talks about a number of elements
- 32:49that we have to focus on.
- 32:51One is we can't have a kept population, so you can't, uh, this
- 32:57republic won't work if people are simply subsidized by the government.
- 33:01It won't work because it denies something very human about us, not just
- 33:05our relationship to the government, but people need to be productive.
- 33:08They need to have a way.
- 33:10One of the things the framers liked about Smith was they believed
- 33:14that if you weren't economically independent, you'd never truly be free.
- 33:19So the book talks about mistakes that we have to avoid, subsidizing
- 33:23industries that are going to be devastated by AI and robotics.
- 33:27Uh, that's usually the first tendency of politicians is just
- 33:30prop up industries like that,
- 33:32or, or the coal industry in West Virginia that, yeah.
- 33:35Well the key is to find homo centric.
- 33:38Uh, um, occupations and I talk about those, uh, a shift, but we cannot have
- 33:46what I call an arts and crafts population.
- 33:49You can't just entertain the population, uh, that will have no productive use.
- 33:55'cause human beings have to be productive in my field.
- 33:57So you are not a big fan of the abundance argument either.
- 34:01Um, Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson, or the more radical abundance
- 34:05argument out in Silicon Valley that technology will liberate us from labor.
- 34:10It's really Marx.
- 34:11His, uh, German.
- 34:13A German ideology argument that, uh, we'll all be free to be writers or
- 34:18philosophers or poets in the afternoon.
- 34:21You don't believe in any of that?
- 34:22I
- 34:22don't.
- 34:23And I go into in depth on that as to why it's important
- 34:26for people to be productive.
- 34:29You know, I talk about the fact that, look, one of my grandfathers
- 34:32was a coal miner who got black lung in the minds of Ohio.
- 34:35The other one was a, was a Cooper.
- 34:37He made barrels.
- 34:39Neither of them liked their job.
- 34:40I mean, one almost killed my, my Italian grandfather, but
- 34:45if you asked him who he was.
- 34:47Even long after he had left the mines, he said he was a coal miner.
- 34:51And the reason is that we are often identified with what makes us productive.
- 34:55That's why people come to this country, to reinvent themselves,
- 34:59to find their own manifest destiny.
- 35:00The second chances.
- 35:02Yeah.
- 35:03And I think that this idea that we're just going to be a kept population,
- 35:08uh, ignores that very human need.
- 35:11So I, I take your point, Jonathan.
- 35:12I'm not sure anyone would necessarily argue, but in, in our age where we
- 35:17have a, a winner take all capitalism where we have fewer and fewer
- 35:21companies controlling more and more of the economy, uh, open AI anthropic
- 35:26will likely do their IPOs this year.
- 35:29These new AI companies are controlling everything they'll eliminate
- 35:33for better or worse, willingly or, or consciously or otherwise.
- 35:37Jobs to, to borrow, uh, another phrase from a, another revolutionary, I'm
- 35:43sure one that you're not keen on Lenin.
- 35:45What is to be done, what, what should happen?
- 35:47What are you arguing in favor of?
- 35:49Well, I'm arguing in favor of preserving, trying to reduce the dependency and ation
- 35:55of the population by making wise choices as to how we support certain industries,
- 36:02but also to reaffirm those elements.
- 36:05That protect liberty.
- 36:07And many of those elements are the ones being under attack by many
- 36:11folks, including many law professors.
- 36:13And so I, I try to argue as best I can, uh, that we need to
- 36:18preserve that more than ever.
- 36:20Uh, and that could be the key here because.
- 36:24I talk about what I call corporate feudalism, uh, which is the rise of these
- 36:28major corporations and the dangers they, they present Also, global governance
- 36:33systems like the eu, uh, which I believe is probably the worst positioned in
- 36:38dealing with the problems that are coming.
- 36:40I believe the eu.
- 36:42Could ultimately collapse in spectacular fashion because it does not have the
- 36:47elements that I discussed in this book that are going to be necessary
- 36:51to protect individual liberty.
- 36:53And what happens is that when you have a system like that collapse,
- 36:56it's very dangerous because it often ends up in tyranny.
- 37:01Yeah, I take your point, although it's not, it's, it's not a book about the
- 37:04eu, but then if everything you're saying is true, and I don't think many people
- 37:09would disagree that people are gonna lose their jobs, their ways of life.
- 37:14You're arguing against state intervention.
- 37:17You're arguing that a kept population is a, is an unfree population,
- 37:22an un-American population.
- 37:24What becomes of the, the people who lose their jobs, if you're not
- 37:28gonna give them guaranteed minimum income, which I'm sure you're against,
- 37:32then what are they supposed to do?
- 37:33Are you falling back on a kind of hard victorianism?
- 37:36These people should just die on the street.
- 37:39I'm not too sure why you think I'm against supporting people who don't have jobs.
- 37:44Of course, I'm in favor of that.
- 37:46But you're against the cap population.
- 37:49That's right.
- 37:49But there's, there's a little room between that and leaving a population to starve.
- 37:54I mean the, I think that we are going to have to subsidize a
- 37:57large population of unemployed.
- 37:59The question is, what will we do beyond the subsidization?
- 38:03And I argue against certain moves like the subsidy of failing industries and
- 38:08instead shifting over to industries that will remain homo centric.
- 38:12There are certain types of jobs that people are still gonna want a human.
- 38:17Element in the book.
- 38:18I actually call them GYN jobs.
- 38:20Um, and only nerds will understand that term.
- 38:24Uh, 'cause GYN was the bartender on, uh, the um.
- 38:29Next generation on, on, uh, on the enterprise and 10 forward.
- 38:34And I always,
- 38:35so you're a Star Trek person too.
- 38:36You've got a little bit
- 38:37of Well, but it, I always admit was I, I always thought it was curious
- 38:40growing up that you had a replicator right behind Gyan that could make
- 38:45the perfect Rolin sunrise cocktail, and yet people would have her make
- 38:50it, even though that replicator could make literally the perfect cocktail.
- 38:54But this is all fantasy, Jonathan.
- 38:56It's all very well for professors like yourself too.
- 38:59No, hold on.
- 39:01People are gonna lose their jobs.
- 39:02Right.
- 39:03Over, over all this, you, you're not in favor of subsidizing coal miners
- 39:08or maybe lawyers because they're gonna be out of work through ai.
- 39:12What are you suggesting?
- 39:13Everyone should become masses.
- 39:15I mean, gimme some examples of work that you think will flourish in this.
- 39:20Age of ai?
- 39:21Of robotics.
- 39:21Well, I was getting to that.
- 39:23The question is what are GY jobs?
- 39:25What are jobs that people still want a human being to do?
- 39:28And there's a great variety of them from education to certain areas of medicine.
- 39:32I talk about how certain areas of medicine are going to be
- 39:36largely wiped out by ai, robotics.
- 39:38Things like you're not gonna have as many radiologists, uh,
- 39:41just because it's sort of silly.
- 39:42If you can have AI do that function better, but you are gonna have
- 39:47psychiatrists, psychologists.
- 39:49Analyst.
- 39:49You're also gonna have a lot of, of industries, particularly like
- 39:53education, that people are going to still, which is one of the largest
- 39:56employers already in the United States.
- 39:58There are more teachers, although AI can replace teachers, why, why shouldn't
- 40:02a, a smart machine replace a teacher and more than a, a smart machine?
- 40:07Replace a lawyer.
- 40:08Because I, I think it's possible they could, but I do think that that may be
- 40:12a GYN area that, uh, people are still going to want to have human beings
- 40:16involved, including with the law.
- 40:18For example, we've seen ai, uh, involved in the law in a very
- 40:22significant way, but I still think that there's going to be a desire
- 40:25to have human lawyers, human judges.
- 40:27So there's industries like that that we have to.
- 40:30To, to see.
- 40:32So the argument here is not, don't subsidize starving people.
- 40:37Obviously we are gonna be giving some type of living wage to a large population.
- 40:42But what we have to look at is how that affects politically, the relationship
- 40:47of citizens to the government, and how we can preserve the sense of
- 40:51productivity, individuality, uh, that citizens need, uh, to feel fully human.
- 40:59What about the top villian analysis of revolution, Jonathan?
- 41:03That people get angriest, not when they're at their poorest or when they're suffering
- 41:08the most, but actually when they're a little better off is rage rational.
- 41:17Well, rage can't be rational.
- 41:18You know, it's also very subjective, right?
- 41:21That it's, uh, your rage is righteous.
- 41:23Their rage is dangerous.
- 41:25Uh, you know, I've been a legal analyst for Ford Networks for 30 years.
- 41:30C-B-S-N-B.
- 41:31CBBC, uh, and Fox recently, and I've always seen rage on both sides.
- 41:39Uh, and there's always a reason for it.
- 41:43Uh, that's the thing about rage.
- 41:46It's what rage unleashes that can become dangerous if it's not controlled.
- 41:51And that's what Madison and others tried to do, um, did very well.
- 41:56I think.
- 41:58Um, it's what the French failed to do with their early constitutions.
- 42:03Uh, so we have to look at that.
- 42:06And we also have to preserve what I call a liberty enhancing economy.
- 42:11That, you know, yes, we're gonna have to subsidize a large population
- 42:14of unemployed people and many of those individuals, because of their
- 42:18age, we have to accept, are probably not going to be employed again.
- 42:22But we have to be able to use these years to try to prepare for that.
- 42:27Uh, we just can't just cut them checks.
- 42:30Uh, we have to look at the implications politically and socially for people who.
- 42:35Are kept in that sense.
- 42:37So your solution isn't not so much legal, even if you're a legal
- 42:40analyst, it's economic and political.
- 42:43Are there models of this?
- 42:45I mean, are you really calling for a, a digital new deal?
- 42:48Is FDR the model here?
- 42:51No, I wouldn't necessarily say that.
- 42:53I think that.
- 42:54Uh, what we do have to do is to try to preserve capitalistic
- 42:58elements to allow people to,
- 43:01so where's the model then?
- 43:02I I take your point.
- 43:03If you're not falling back on FDR, I'm not sure pain would be particularly helpful
- 43:08here, or even Madison or Jefferson.
- 43:09Where's the model in American history who?
- 43:12Who addressed this issue in a way that you think we can learn from?
- 43:16Or is it so new that we're gonna need to invent new
- 43:19political ideas and politicians?
- 43:22I'm not sure we'll need new political ideas as much as, uh, retooling the ideas
- 43:27we had at the beginning of the revolution.
- 43:29We have a system that is designed to deal with these types of pressures, but
- 43:34we are going to have a mix of social programs, things like a living wage.
- 43:39Uh, we're gonna have to be nimble.
- 43:40Uh, it means that we're gonna have to accept that many industries are going
- 43:44to be robotic, uh, or changed by ai.
- 43:48Uh, we are going to have to try to encourage people to go into
- 43:52those more homo centric industries.
- 43:54I think education will be, I
- 43:55say encourage, I mean.
- 43:57What, what exactly does that mean?
- 43:58Are they being paid to do it?
- 44:00Are they being forced to do it?
- 44:01No, it's to the degree that the government favors new industries.
- 44:05It should be, in fact, new industries, not subsidizing, failing industries.
- 44:10Uh, but also there's a lot of education that the government can
- 44:13help here and directing people who are, who want to be employed.
- 44:18Into areas where there is greater potential for that employment.
- 44:22What you don't want is to have this sort of past dependence
- 44:25where you have people training for jobs that simply won't be there.
- 44:28Right.
- 44:29They, excuse me.
- 44:30I mean, if you are, you know, training to be a radiologist today, I'm
- 44:35afraid that's a bit of a mistake.
- 44:37Uh, and you have to,
- 44:38well, their government never really knows.
- 44:40I mean, who knows whether.
- 44:42Radiologists or lawyers or engineers or politicians or law professors, uh, it
- 44:47sounds to me, Jonathan f finally, that your ideal state, I know you're not a
- 44:54big fan of the eu, but there is a kind of technocratic, enlightenment, fantasy
- 45:01that you have of government may not be quite the eu, but it's Danish or German
- 45:05smart state trying to push people into.
- 45:08Industries that are relevant for the future rather than the past, certainly.
- 45:14Not a MAGA person.
- 45:15You're not a, a Nostalgist, but is there a, a kind of government, maybe
- 45:19the, the Chinese or the Korean or the Danish that, that, that suits
- 45:24your, your vision of the future?
- 45:27Who gets who's getting it right?
- 45:29I actually think the American Republic actually offers the best structure here.
- 45:33And, um, I don't think it's just the government's job.
- 45:36When I talk about educating people, it's going to be a job of society.
- 45:40It's gonna be our trying to direct these discussions, uh, into areas where people
- 45:46can be productive, can be self-expressive.
- 45:49The EU is not the model.
- 45:51In fact, the book goes into how all rights like politics are local.
- 45:56And we have to support, uh, the sort of decentralization of politics.
- 46:01It's the centralization of power that I'm worried about in, in groups
- 46:05like the eu because I think that the EU is inherently unstable.
- 46:09Well, there you have it.
- 46:10Excellent.
- 46:11Uh, conversation by, uh, gw, professor of Law in new book, rage
- 46:16in the Republic, the unfinished story of the American Revolution.
- 46:19One thing for sure.
- 46:20It is indeed an unfinished story.
- 46:23Uh, Jonathan, uh, Turley, congratulations on the new book, and thank you
- 46:27for a fascinating conversation.
- 46:29Well, thank you.
- 46:29I enjoyed it a great deal.
- 46:30Thanks for having me on.