Latest / Fintech Conversations with Fexingo: Banking, Payments, and Financial Software Companies / How Buy Now Pay Later Is Reshaping BNPL in 2026
Transcript
- Lucas: So buy now, pay later — it's been one of the fastest-growing corners of consumer finance for the past five years. But 2026 is shaping up to be the year the industry grows up, and that means regulators, credit bureaus, and a real reckoning with how these loans actually perform. Luna: I feel like every time I check out online, BNPL is right there — Klarna, Affirm, Afterpay. But I also hear horror stories of people stacking five loans. So what's actually changing this year? Lucas: Right — the big shift is that BNPL is being pulled into the same regulatory framework as credit cards and personal loans. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — the CFPB — issued an interpretive rule back in 2024 that classified BNPL lenders as credit card providers under Regulation Z. But it's taken until this year for the real enforcement and industry response to crystallize. Luna: And that means what exactly for companies like Affirm or Klarna — do they have to change their entire business model? Lucas: In some ways, yes. The most concrete change is around dispute resolution and refunds — BNPL lenders now have to follow the same error-resolution rules as credit card issuers. But the bigger, slower-moving change is about credit reporting. The CFPB signaled it wants BNPL loans reported to credit bureaus, just like any other installment debt. Luna: Which is a double-edged sword, right — it could help people build credit, but it also means missed payments show up on your credit report now. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where the data gets interesting. Affirm, for example, has been reporting some of its loans to Experian since 2020. But they only report loans with an annual percentage rate — APR — above zero. Many of their zero-interest pay-in-four loans were never reported. That's changing. And Klarna — Klarna announced in early 2025 that it would start reporting its UK and US loans to credit bureaus, including the pay-in-three products. Luna: So the 'free' four-installment loan might start to have a credit score consequence. That's a big shift in consumer perception. Lucas: It is. And it forces the industry to clean up underwriting. Because if a missed payment is going to ding your credit score, the lenders have a stronger incentive to make sure borrowers can actually pay. That's where Affirm's model is instructive. Affirm has always charged interest — their pay-in-four is interest-free, but their longer-term loans have APRs ranging from zero to 36 percent. CEO Max Levchin has been very public that they cap APR at 36 percent, which is the same threshold the military lending act uses for predatory lending. Luna: And that's actually lower than what some credit cards charge, isn't it? Lucas: It is. The average credit card APR in 2026 is around 22 percent, but many cards go into the high twenties or even thirties. So Affirm's 36 percent cap is a ceiling they don't cross. But Klarna has gone a different route — they've moved toward higher apr installment loans in the UK, with APRs sometimes exceeding 25 percent. And they've faced criticism for that from consumer groups. Luna: So we're seeing a divergence — one company doubling down on 'responsible' lending with a hard cap, another chasing higher revenue per loan. Who's winning? Lucas: The market is still voting. But Affirm's approach has earned them a higher valuation multiple relative to peers — investors seem to value the lower regulatory risk. And there's another data point: Apple Pay Later. Apple launched its BNPL product in 2023, and then in early 2026, they quietly shut it down. They're partnering with Affirm instead. Luna: I remember that — Apple Pay Later was integrated into Apple Wallet, but I guess they couldn't make the economics work? Lucas: That's the consensus. Apple's version was interest-free, two-payment loans — very simple, but also very low margin. And Apple didn't have the same risk infrastructure as Affirm. So now, if you use Apple Pay later, you're actually using Affirm's underwriting. It's a tacit admission that BNPL is hard to do profitably at scale without sophisticated credit models. Luna: And that profitability question — is BNPL actually making money for these companies? I know Klarna has been loss-making for years. Lucas: Klarna turned profitable in 2024 for the first time since 2018. They did it partly by cutting costs, but also by shifting their loan mix toward longer-term, higher apr products. In their 2025 annual report, they said their average loan duration in the UK rose from 4 months to 7 months, and their average APR rose from 12 percent to 18 percent. That's a direct response to the profitability challenge. Luna: So the 'pay in four' — which is what most people think of as BNPL — that might actually be a loss leader? They use it to acquire customers and then upsell them into longer loans? Lucas: That's exactly the playbook. Affirm does the same thing. Their pay-in-four is usually zero interest — they make money from the merchant fee, which is around 2 to 3 percent. But longer-term loans generate interest income. The merchant fee plus interest is what makes the unit economics work. And delinquencies? They're actually lower than credit cards for many lenders. Affirm reported a net charge-off rate of about 2.5 percent in 2025, compared to the industry average for credit cards of around 3.5 percent. Luna: That's surprisingly good. But I wonder if that's because their underwriting is stricter, or because the loan sizes are smaller and shorter-term. Lucas: Probably both. The average Affirm loan is around $250, and the average term is 4 months. Compare that to a credit card balance that can stretch for years. So the risk window is much shorter. But there's also a selection effect — the kind of person who uses BNPL tends to be younger, more digitally native, and maybe more financially cautious than the average credit card user who carries a balance. Luna: Still, there's a real worry about debt stacking — people using multiple BNPL services at once. I've seen surveys that something like 20 percent of BNPL users have more than five active loans. Lucas: That's the biggest consumer risk, and the one regulators are most focused on. Because if you have five different $200 loans from five different lenders, none of them sees the full picture. That's why the push for credit reporting is so important — it creates a consolidated view. The CFPB has been piloting a data-sharing framework where BNPL lenders report to a central registry, and several states — California, New York, Illinois — have their own disclosure rules now too. Luna: Let me ask you about the international angle. Europe seems ahead on regulation — the EU's Consumer Credit Directive was updated in 2024 to include BNPL. How does that compare to the US? Lucas: Europe is definitely stricter. The updated directive requires affordability checks for all BNPL products, including pay-in-three. And it caps late fees — in the UK, lenders can't charge more than 15 pounds in late fees. In the US, there's no federal cap on late fees for BNPL, though some states have usury limits. So European regulators have been more proactive. But the US is catching up — the CFPB's interpretive rule was a first step, and there's bipartisan interest in legislation that would codify those protections. Luna: And what about the long-term — do you think BNPL replaces credit cards for a generation of consumers? Lucas: Maybe not replace, but definitely erode credit card usage for certain transactions. The data shows that BNPL penetration in e-commerce is now over 10 percent in the US, and over 15 percent in the UK and Australia. For large ticket items — electronics, furniture, travel — BNPL has become a default payment option. But credit cards still dominate for everyday spending and for revolving credit. The two are coexisting, but the line is blurring. Luna: So BNPL is essentially becoming more like a credit card with fixed installments, and credit cards are adding more installment features. I've noticed Chase and Amex now offer 'pay over time' options. Lucas: Exactly. Amex launched 'Plan It' years ago, and now almost every major issuer has some form of installment feature. So the competition is intensifying. But the pure-play BNPL firms have an advantage in user experience — they're integrated at checkout, they have better approval algorithms, and they don't require you to carry a physical card. Luna: I guess that's the piece that keeps me interested — the technology underneath. The underwriting models that approve a $300 loan in under a second using maybe 20 data points. That's genuinely impressive. Lucas: It is. And it's worth remembering that this technology is also being used for other types of lending — small business loans, rental deposits, even medical payments. The BNPL infrastructure is becoming a broader credit platform. Luna: You know, speaking of how this technology shapes the broader ecosystem — if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, we keep the show ad-free and listener-supported. There's a buy me a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, but it does help us keep drilling into these topics. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small way to keep the show independent. And we appreciate everyone who's chipped in. Luna: Alright, back to the data. Lucas, one thing I want to pin down — will BNPL credit reporting actually help consumers build credit, or could it backfire? Lucas: It's a really good question, and the early data is mixed. A 2025 study from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau found that among consumers who had a BNPL loan reported, about 60 percent saw their credit score increase within six months — because they were making on-time payments and building a payment history. But 40 percent either saw no change or a slight decrease — often because the new credit line reduced their average account age. And for the subset who missed a payment, the score drop was significant — an average of 30 to 40 points. Luna: So it's a tool that rewards responsible use but punishes mistakes. That's basically how credit cards work too. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the direction the industry is heading — treating BNPL as a real credit product. The days of 'no interest, no fees, no credit check' are waning. Now it's 'interest-free if you pay on time, but the credit bureau knows.' And I think that's ultimately healthier for consumers, even if it reduces the novelty appeal. Luna: So what's your call for the next year? More regulation, more consolidation? Lucas: I expect more M&A — smaller BNPL lenders will struggle with the compliance costs of the new rules, and the big players like Affirm and Klarna will acquire them or their technology. I also expect credit card issuers to acquire BNPL firms to bolster their installment offerings. And I think we'll see a continued push toward longer-term, higher apr loans, because that's where the profit is. But the consumer protection guardrails will also tighten — especially around late fees and data sharing. In five years, BNPL might just be called 'installment lending' and be indistinguishable from any other form of consumer credit. Luna: Funny how an industry that started as an alternative to credit cards ends up looking a lot like them.