Latest / Film And Whiskey / The Passion of the Christ / Maker's Mark 46 Cask Strength Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 2004, director Mel Gibson and star Jim
- 0:03Caviesal gave the world a stirring vision of the last
- 0:06day of a prophet's life. In
- 0:082024, we've returned to a familiar brand of weeded
- 0:12bourbon. The film is The Passion of the
- 0:15Christ. The whiskey is Maker's Mark 46
- 0:18cask strength. More of you than both. This
- 0:21is The Film and Whiskey Podcast.
- 0:42The Film and Whiskey Podcast
- 0:43Welcome to the Film and Whiskey Podcast, where each
- 0:45week we review a classic movie and a glass of
- 0:47whiskey. I'm Bob Book. I'm
- 0:49Brad G. And man, oh man, Brad. Uff
- 0:54da. Did we just watch a heavy
- 0:56movie or what? No man, it's light and airy
- 1:01and just ends on ends on a happy note. Does
- 1:04end on a happy note. What could be wrong with this
- 1:07film, Bob? So today, folks, we are
- 1:09checking out Mel Gibson's 2004 film, The Passion of
- 1:12the Christ. A true box office juggernaut.
- 1:17This thing, like, I don't know
- 1:20if you remember being around this movie when it
- 1:22came out, Brad. This was a weird time to be
- 1:25alive. Like, there were people protesting
- 1:28the movie outside of movie theaters. There
- 1:30were people handing out flyers saying like, you're
- 1:33going to hell if you don't see this movie. It's
- 1:36just a wild time to be a moviegoer in suburban Ohio
- 1:41in 2004. I think it's funny, though,
- 1:45that the two movies that outgrossed it in the
- 1:49domestic box are Shrek 2 and Spider -Man 2. Just
- 1:55for some reason that the fact that those two films
- 1:58are the ones that beat out Jesus dying is pretty
- 2:03impressive. I mean, Jesus beat Harry
- 2:04Potter, Bob. I mean, Jesus always beats
- 2:07Harry Potter. He beat the Incredibles? Yep.
- 2:10This is all in the text somewhere, right? This
- 2:13is in the Bible. Oh, obviously. Jesus
- 2:15beat the Incredibles. Yeah. OK, so, Brad. This
- 2:21season, we are looking at the highest grossing films
- 2:24from 1988 to 2019. We're in 2004, just a little
- 2:30over the halfway point. And like you said, we could
- 2:32have watched Shrek 2. We could have watched Spider
- 2:35-Man 2. Here was my thought process in
- 2:38ultimately suggesting that we do Passion of the
- 2:41Christ. We just did Shrek three weeks
- 2:43ago. I don't like I just don't
- 2:45want to do sequels that soon after doing the
- 2:48original. I don't know that I would
- 2:49have much more to say about Shrek. Oh,
- 2:52so what you're saying is you just want to hold out
- 2:53a little while, give people a little more thirst for
- 2:57Shrek before you review the second one. Yeah.
- 2:59As we know, people have thirst for Shrek. So
- 3:02the second option is Spider -Man 2, which is probably
- 3:06the best superhero movie ever made. And
- 3:09I figure that we're going to do that one at some
- 3:12point. Like, it's, you know, it's on
- 3:14the list. And I figured, like, when are
- 3:16we ever going to be like, hey, you know what we
- 3:18should really do? Passion of the Christ. And
- 3:21I thought that, like, from a cultural standpoint, from
- 3:24the Mel Gibson of it all, this is probably going to
- 3:27be the best conversation that we could have out of
- 3:29any of these three movies this week. And
- 3:31so, you know, I'm sorry that I made us watch a
- 3:34really heavy movie, but I am looking forward to
- 3:36talking about it. Yeah, I have no problem talking
- 3:39about this movie, Bob. It has been a very, very long
- 3:42time since I've seen it. But
- 3:44for me, this movie kind of falls in the vein of a
- 3:48Schindler's List, where I feel like at least once a
- 3:51decade, I should probably sit down and watch it just
- 3:55like for my soul. Yeah, although, you know, I've
- 3:59thought about Schindler's List a lot in the wake of
- 4:01watching this movie. And when we did our Schindler's
- 4:03List review, one thing that I was really surprised by
- 4:07is how much humor that movie actually has. Like,
- 4:10it is a very dark and very depressing movie. But
- 4:14there are moments of levity that Spielberg weaves
- 4:16throughout. And this movie is utterly
- 4:20humorless. And like, I think I'm OK with
- 4:24that because of the subject matter here. But
- 4:26it's also it's really hard to talk about this movie
- 4:29and not either feel bummed out or risk bumming out
- 4:34our listeners or to make it feel like we're mocking
- 4:37the movie by being a little bit lighter with the
- 4:40way we talk about it. And I don't mean to do that
- 4:42either. I know that this is a very
- 4:43important movie to a lot of people and we're dealing
- 4:46with perhaps the most religious of all the
- 4:50religious movies we've ever done. Like,
- 4:51this is a depiction of Jesus himself. This
- 4:54is not like, you know, silence was one thing.
- 4:57We've already had depictions of
- 4:59Jesus. Yeah, we had a depiction of like
- 5:00Jesus's feet in Ben Hur. Ben
- 5:03Hur, come on. They were holy feet. They
- 5:06sure were. So yeah, I don't know, man.
- 5:08I'm like, I don't want to walk
- 5:10on eggshells and I don't want to tiptoe around the
- 5:12topics at hand here today. But
- 5:13like, it is not lost on me that there is there are
- 5:17many minefields adjacent to this movie for a myriad of
- 5:22different reasons. Yeah, I think at the end of the
- 5:25day, Bob, if I'm going to be honest, I think a lot
- 5:29of people might skip out on this episode because
- 5:31they are not as interested in the religious overtones.
- 5:36And I'm okay with that. I'm
- 5:39excited to talk about the movie for what it is. I
- 5:41think it's interesting to watch a movie like this
- 5:43with a critical lens on. Mm
- 5:46hmm. And I think that even if you
- 5:49come to this film as someone who is not
- 5:52religiously inclined, I think that there's a lot
- 5:55that could be taken away from this film. Mm
- 5:58hmm. Oh, I totally agree. And
- 6:01Brad, I have so many thoughts and I'm kind of
- 6:03constructed like an outline of where I think we should
- 6:06go with this episode. But I'm going to set all that
- 6:08to the side for a minute because in order to get to
- 6:11that, we have to get to our first segment of the
- 6:13day, which we call Brad explains. Brad's
- 6:16going to give us the movie plot with only 60 seconds
- 6:19taken on the clock. So let's go ahead and hear
- 6:22you take with this little segment that we call Brad
- 6:24explains. Brad explains is the part of
- 6:27the podcast where Brad breaks down the plot of
- 6:30the movie that he has just seen often for the first
- 6:32time. This is not Brad's first time
- 6:34seeing the Passion of the Christ, nor is it his
- 6:37first time recounting the events therein. I
- 6:40don't know if this is going to be like the
- 6:42shortest Brad explains of all time or if you'll take
- 6:44the opportunity to deliver a five point sermon here.
- 6:47So let me just remind you,
- 6:49you have one minute on the clock to break down the
- 6:52plot of the Passion of the Christ and go. Dude,
- 6:57I could do a five point sermon on the moment when
- 7:00Mary holds him as he's taken the cross and he
- 7:04looks at her and says, Behold, Mother, I'm making
- 7:08all things new. Dude, actually, can we just skip
- 7:13Brad explains and just talk about that moment for a
- 7:16minute? Yeah. Oh, 100 percent, dude. All
- 7:18right. So let's real quick. Bob
- 7:20explains the the Gospels read them. The
- 7:25end. OK. There's a moment in this
- 7:27movie that is far and away for me, the most
- 7:31emotionally impactful moment of the entire film. And
- 7:34like the whole thing is like, Oh, man, this is
- 7:36very powerful and this is very brutal and hard to
- 7:39watch. And then you have the moment
- 7:40where he intersperses it with an, you know, imagined
- 7:45flashback to a younger Mary chasing after toddler Jesus
- 7:50when he falls over and she's there to pick him up
- 7:53and kind of nurse his wounds. And
- 7:56it's cut with her like running down this alleyway
- 8:00with with his blood on her, like chasing after
- 8:04him, hoping to hold him and be able to nurse him
- 8:08back to health again. And it's not going to happen,
- 8:11man. And like his reaction and
- 8:14saying, look like basically look at what I'm doing
- 8:16here. I lost it, dude. I
- 8:20was a sobbing mess for the next five minutes of this
- 8:25film. Yeah. No, that's easily the
- 8:28pinnacle of the movie for me because it's it's the
- 8:31crux of what he is doing. Like
- 8:34at the very center of the life of Christ and why he
- 8:38came is that phrase, behold, I am making all
- 8:43things new. And to see it portrayed so
- 8:46like the oh, man, we can talk about Kavisle's overall
- 8:52performance. But I think in that moment, he
- 8:55somehow manages to sound like he is in incredible
- 8:59pain. And yet there's a little bit
- 9:03of like almost glee in the way he's saying it. Like,
- 9:09yeah, like more like resolve, you know what I
- 9:11mean? Like it's yeah. He
- 9:13has like this sense of like, look what I'm doing,
- 9:16mom. Yeah. Like I'm making all things
- 9:19new and there's this hopefulness in his voice
- 9:22that completely belies what is happening to him
- 9:26physically at that moment. So
- 9:28I think when you watch this movie, there's a
- 9:30couple of things that you can't escape that kind of
- 9:32surround the movie. And one of them I don't think
- 9:35is appropriate for right now. We'll
- 9:36get to that in the analysis portion when we're
- 9:38talking about kind of cultural analysis. And
- 9:40that is the Mel Gibson of it all. But
- 9:43the other thing is you can't really separate this
- 9:45movie out from its use as a tool in Christian
- 9:51culture. And I don't even mean like an
- 9:53evangelism tool. Like, I don't know that you show
- 9:57this movie to people to try to convert them to
- 9:59Christianity. It is perhaps, you know, we
- 10:02just did an episode a few weeks ago where we talked
- 10:04about these faith based films like by Christians
- 10:06for Christians, all the ones that people hate like
- 10:09God's not dead. This is perhaps the most like
- 10:12quote unquote by Christian for Christian movie. I
- 10:16think I've ever seen because it's it's certainly
- 10:19not trying to preach and it's certainly not trying
- 10:24to convert. It is at least on its face
- 10:27just trying to depict what is in the text and a very
- 10:32small portion of it at that. There
- 10:34are like little moments of flashback where you get
- 10:36tiny, tiny pieces of Jesus' teaching. But
- 10:39really, I think you can watch this movie even as a
- 10:43nonbeliever and see in it a very historically accurate
- 10:48depiction of what crucifixion looked like. And
- 10:52also be you do get a sense from the way the
- 10:54film portrays Jesus as like, OK, I may not
- 10:58believe that this guy is God or the Son of God or
- 11:00whatever. But like he is certainly a
- 11:03holy figure with great resolve who sticks to his
- 11:07morals to the end. And I think that in those
- 11:10regards, this movie is a huge success. But
- 11:12you also can't you can't divorce the movie from the
- 11:16way that it's been used, which is very much like to
- 11:20what we just talked about, Brad. The
- 11:22I am making all things new. That
- 11:24means a lot to you and me because we're believers and
- 11:27like we understand like what what does that line
- 11:30actually mean? I think to someone who
- 11:32watches this movie as a nonbeliever, there are
- 11:34moments that really work and there are moments that
- 11:36are probably confounding. And
- 11:38that's one of the confounding moments because
- 11:40it's like I'm hearing Brad G say that this guy has
- 11:43glee in his voice as he's getting flagellated and
- 11:47beaten to death. And that doesn't sit well with
- 11:51me. Do you know what I mean? And
- 11:52I do kind of wonder how effective is this movie to
- 11:57a nonbeliever? And I think parts of it are
- 11:59probably very effective and parts of it are like you.
- 12:03That's gross. Yeah.
- 12:05Yeah. 100 percent. There is a lot of grossness
- 12:08about this movie. And I think that I was struck
- 12:13more than anything else watching it this time with
- 12:16that sense of how much the life and death of Christ
- 12:22probably doesn't make a lot of sense to the world at
- 12:26large. That he he doesn't always make
- 12:30decisions that really make sense that that somebody
- 12:33would make if they were a prophet trying to lead a
- 12:36movement. And you kind of see that on
- 12:39full display here. Like he doesn't answer questions
- 12:42when he probably should. And
- 12:43when he does answer questions, you know, to
- 12:45pilot and to the the Sanhedrin and the other
- 12:50people who are judging him. When
- 12:51he does answer questions, he rarely answers them in
- 12:54a way that is very flattering to him or will
- 12:56get him out of trouble. And
- 12:58I think that it would be very easy to watch this
- 13:01and be like, I don't understand any of his
- 13:05motivations here. Mm hmm. Yeah.
- 13:08And I think like that's a it's true to the text, but
- 13:12the problem is like the text has a whole lot of
- 13:14context to go with it. Like
- 13:15there's a thousand other pages of Bible that help
- 13:17that help you understand why Jesus answers. So
- 13:21much Bible that helps you understand why Jesus does
- 13:24or doesn't answer the way he does in the context of
- 13:27those questions. Whereas in the movie, I found
- 13:30myself Brad for the first 25, 30 ish minutes of the
- 13:33movie really struggling to get into it because I was
- 13:35trying to watch it. Not just through an analytical
- 13:38lens, but through the lens of does this movie work if
- 13:41I'm not a Christian and not like anti Christian,
- 13:45but just. It makes sense to me because
- 13:47I know the text so well, the text that is based on
- 13:50does it make sense as a standalone movie. And
- 13:54I think that I think it struggles in a lot of
- 13:58places. There are moments where it's
- 14:00really viscerally effective. And
- 14:02if I knew nothing about the story of Jesus other
- 14:04than he is a guy who died on the cross, I think the
- 14:08movie can be really effective there. But
- 14:10some of the some of those early going moments where
- 14:12you see like, you know, Jesus before the Sanhedrin
- 14:16and Jesus talking to Herod. And
- 14:18it's like there's just not quite enough understanding
- 14:22of who Jesus is outside of this one night we're
- 14:26watching to understand why he's answering the way he
- 14:29does. What does he think of these
- 14:30people? And I think that like it's not
- 14:33until we get into kind of the meat of the story that
- 14:36the movie really starts working. I
- 14:39don't know if I can view it the same way, Bob. At
- 14:43the end of the day, I think we have to take
- 14:47Gibson's choices as like very intentional in the
- 14:54sense that he is not making this for people who
- 14:58don't know the background. And
- 15:00I think that one of the things I appreciate most
- 15:03about this film is that he skips over so much. Like
- 15:08he gives you the absolute bare minimum necessary for
- 15:13the viewer of this movie to have the maximum impact
- 15:17of what happened on the cross. And
- 15:20it's not, you know, I don't know if this is good
- 15:23or bad, but it's not meant for people who don't
- 15:25believe in Jesus. And so if you are somebody who
- 15:28is not familiar with the source material, I agree.
- 15:30Like it's going to be tough for
- 15:32you to understand all of the different elements that
- 15:36are going on here. And I don't think Gibson, the
- 15:40director really cares. Well, no, and like nor is it a
- 15:44requirement that a movie be all things to all people
- 15:47like that. It's a very common refrain. It's
- 15:50not one that I always agree with, but like, you
- 15:52know, I've had many conversations with my wife
- 15:55about the movie Barbie that came out last year. And
- 15:58at the end of the day, that movie is not for me.
- 16:01It didn't work for me very
- 16:03well, but it's also like I'm not the target audience
- 16:06of the film Barbie. And I have to acknowledge that
- 16:08who cares what I think about it to some extent,
- 16:11you know, I guess what I'm saying, Brad, is the
- 16:13passion of the Christ is Mel Gibson's Barbie. That's
- 16:17that's the quote of today. That's
- 16:19a heck of a statement, Bob. There's
- 16:22a movie that I have talked about many, many times on
- 16:26this show, and it's called The Passion of Joan of
- 16:28Arc. It's a silent movie from the
- 16:30late 1920s. It is one of the 10 best
- 16:33movies I've ever seen in my life. And
- 16:35it's not a coincidence that this movie is titled the
- 16:37same way as The Passion of Joan of Arc. And
- 16:40that movie is literally just a depiction of Joan
- 16:43of Arc's trial and execution. And
- 16:45they got almost all the dialogue in that movie from
- 16:49the actual transcripts that were written down in like
- 16:52the 1200s or whenever it was Joan of Arc was alive.
- 16:56And you don't really know much
- 16:58about Joan outside of this trial. They
- 17:00are accusing her of witchcraft. They're
- 17:01asking her if she thinks that she's the daughter of
- 17:03God and she's saying yes. And
- 17:06then they're like, you're a heretic. And
- 17:07on the page, it's like she kind of does sound like a
- 17:09heretic. And then they kill her and
- 17:11you're like, oh, OK, like even if she is a heretic,
- 17:15I don't know how you feel about this whole burning
- 17:17people at the stake thing. And
- 17:18this movie is very similar to that where like when
- 17:22Jesus is before that tribunal and they're asking
- 17:25him, are you calling yourself a king? And
- 17:27he says, yes. Oh, I understand why they're
- 17:29upset by this. And even though you and I know
- 17:32the context of why they're upset with Jesus goes way
- 17:35beyond that. The depiction of what they do
- 17:39in retaliation against Jesus is the emotional heart of
- 17:43the movie. And this act justified based on
- 17:48what they thought he was guilty of. And
- 17:51I think that it makes such a great. I
- 17:53don't mean to step on my let's make it a double
- 17:54here, but that's that's what it's going to be. It
- 17:57makes such a great pairing with Joan of Arc because
- 17:59even apart from all the context of the Bible, you
- 18:02can watch this movie in a vacuum and still be
- 18:05compelled by the injustice carried out against this
- 18:09man. Yeah, 100 percent. I
- 18:12found myself mostly drawn in by all of the reactions
- 18:18of the secondary characters to what was going on. And
- 18:22I think that's kind of the heart of the movie, right?
- 18:25Is a, we see Jesus going
- 18:27through this brutal torture for most of the movie. But
- 18:33the the reflection points where you get to feel the
- 18:36emotional depth of that come from, you know, the
- 18:40mother of Jesus, Mary, from Mary Magdalene, from John,
- 18:43from Peter, from all of the people who have been
- 18:46with him, who love him so deeply. And
- 18:50I think that as you watch those secondary characters
- 18:54and the performances, I found myself just completely
- 18:59entranced by them, especially throughout the
- 19:01film. Yeah, I think maybe it's time
- 19:03for us to kind of segue out of how the story
- 19:07itself is compelling to you and me as as people who
- 19:09are Christians and talk about the movie making. So
- 19:12like as a movie, again, this is really hard. It's
- 19:15hard to divorce from from our own personal attachment
- 19:18to the story and from the filmmaker himself. But
- 19:21as a movie, let's kind of start talking about what we
- 19:25have here. And I think let's dive into
- 19:26the performances. You're talking about the supporting
- 19:29characters that might be a better place to start than
- 19:31with Jim Caviesal. And if I could talk about one
- 19:34supporting person in this movie, it would be Maya
- 19:36Morgenstern as Mary, because she is like revelatory in
- 19:42this movie. It is unbelievable how good
- 19:45she is in this film, not nominated for anything. She
- 19:48should have been because it is a heartbreaking
- 19:50performance. Yeah, dude, she's she's so good,
- 19:55man. She just has a depth of wisdom
- 20:00and sadness behind her eyes that just never leave. I
- 20:07found myself completely glued to the screen
- 20:10whenever she was on it. Yeah,
- 20:13I'm with you, man. She turns in what might be the
- 20:16best performance of the film. Yeah,
- 20:19I mean, there's a couple other people that I think
- 20:21are really good. The guy who plays John is
- 20:22good. I think that Francesco DeVito
- 20:25as Peter is really good. Monica
- 20:27Bellucci is pretty good as Mary Magdalene. She's
- 20:29probably the most famous person in this movie at
- 20:32the time that it comes out. But
- 20:34it's really Mary. Like she is the one that stands
- 20:37out to me. If there was one other person
- 20:40that I think is worth mentioning in a really
- 20:42small role, it's the guy who plays Simon of Cyrene.
- 20:47His name is Jareth or Yareth
- 20:49Mertz. The guy that helps Jesus carry
- 20:52his cross. He's so good. He's
- 20:55incredible. And it's pretty obvious that
- 20:58the script once like Pontius Pilate and Pontius
- 21:02Pilate's wife to be these sympathetic figures, which
- 21:05they kind of are. But like, you know, if there's
- 21:08one thing that I really didn't like about the
- 21:10script, it's that it sometimes feels like it
- 21:11goes overboard to make some characters sympathetic and
- 21:15then also overboard to make other characters completely
- 21:18unsympathetic. And I wish that it that Clint
- 21:21Eastwood syndrome. Yeah, I wish that it left a
- 21:23little bit more up to the audience as to who they
- 21:26want to place blame on because it's very much like
- 21:28the high priests are wrong and Pontius Pilate is
- 21:31totally in the clear. And I'm like, is he like this
- 21:34doesn't seem. And Harriet is super gay. Yeah,
- 21:38very much according to Mel Gibson. Yeah,
- 21:42I think that I really like the performance by Pontius
- 21:47Pilate. I think that whoever the
- 21:50actor is who portrays him a has to be very Eastern
- 21:54European. Oh, yeah, he's a Bulgarian. I'm
- 21:56looking at him now. His name is Christo Nalmof
- 22:00Shopov. Yeah, I was going to say I grew
- 22:04up in Cleveland. I've been around lots of Eastern
- 22:07Europeans and I was like, that man is not from
- 22:10Italy. But I think he gives a really,
- 22:17really solid performance. And
- 22:19anytime I felt like he was on screen, I feel like he
- 22:25embodies what you read in scriptures. Like
- 22:29if you look at the original text, the way he
- 22:33delivers that line about truth, like what is true?
- 22:36And even the little side
- 22:38conversation he has with his wife about it about
- 22:40like, would you even know truth if you saw it? Like
- 22:43even those tiny extra biblical moments, I think
- 22:49give flesh to the rest of the movie. All
- 22:52right, man, let's talk about Jim Caviesal as
- 22:55Jesus. And this is a performance that
- 22:58has been, you know, praised and criticized and parodied
- 23:03and kind of hasn't been talked about in the 20
- 23:07years since. And especially because Jim
- 23:09Caviesal has now become like he was a TV actor
- 23:12for a while and now he's making only Christian
- 23:15movies. He got a lot of flack for
- 23:17the movie he made last year, Sound of Freedom. And
- 23:20again, like it's it's hard to separate out the content
- 23:22of this movie from things that are adjacent to it.
- 23:25But I really think Jim Caviesal
- 23:27is freaking fantastic in this movie. And
- 23:29for me, the comparison point is Leo in the
- 23:33Revenant. Because that is a role that Leo
- 23:37has been absolutely pilloried for in the years
- 23:41since as like he just rolled on the ground and
- 23:44writhed around and grunted for two hours because he
- 23:46wanted an Oscar so badly. And
- 23:49I've always defended Leo in that movie. But
- 23:51I think in light of seeing Caviesal here, I'm like,
- 23:53oh, no, this is how you do a performance where
- 23:56you're just being tortured for two hours. Like
- 24:00it's a very physically demanding performance. In
- 24:03addition to the fact that he's delivering all of his
- 24:05lines in another language that is a dead language
- 24:08now. I have no complaints. I
- 24:11think Caviesal is really good. I
- 24:12do hate the shampooed feather haired Jesus we get
- 24:17in some scenes, but like that's more of a Mel
- 24:21Gibson decision than it is a Caviesal one. Yeah,
- 24:24100 percent. Like who's the artist that that
- 24:28did the the super famous Jesus painting? Oh,
- 24:31like knocking on the door. I
- 24:33can't remember. Yeah. So that is the Jesus that
- 24:37we get here. Right. Man, let me let me look
- 24:41it up really quick. Yeah, it's the the Warner Salmons
- 24:46head of Christ from 1940. Like
- 24:49that's the Jesus that we have here. And
- 24:53I think there's a lot of people who would probably
- 24:55complain about that. We need a more Jewish Jesus.
- 24:59I think at the end of the
- 25:00day, this is another example of this is a
- 25:04Catholic movie. And we haven't talked about it
- 25:09yet, but this film is like if you're in Christianity
- 25:14enough, you'll recognize this is like a wildly
- 25:17Catholic movie with so many Catholic references. And
- 25:22I think in the midst of all that, I love Jim
- 25:27Caviesal. The only maybe complaint I have
- 25:30about him is that I wish and this is more script
- 25:34than anything else. I wish there were a few more
- 25:37moments of Jesus being lighthearted and like loving
- 25:42in the flashbacks. You know, like the the tone of
- 25:47the movie is somber throughout. And
- 25:51I kind of wish that in a few of the flashbacks, we
- 25:54got a more jovial, like the wild abandon with which
- 26:00Jesus loved his disciples and the people he was
- 26:03ministering to. Because I think that would help
- 26:06illustrate the depth that they have now sunk to the
- 26:10Jewish people in their torture of him. On
- 26:13the opposite side of that from you, but I think for
- 26:16the same reason, I think the amount of flashbacks
- 26:19used in this movie is the wrong number. And
- 26:22either you need to have more flashbacks or no
- 26:25flashbacks. And I kind of feel like the
- 26:27movie would have been my interpretation was the movie
- 26:29would have been better with almost no flashbacks, like
- 26:32no outside context. At all, just the, you know,
- 26:36the Garden of Gethsemane, the trial and the
- 26:39crucifixion. And because I feel like it
- 26:42really undercuts both the rhythm of the movie and
- 26:44like the emotional effectiveness most of the
- 26:46time when they cut away. Mary
- 26:49Magdalene's cut away, unnecessary. I
- 26:52know that it like it is related to what she's
- 26:55seeing happen to Jesus right now, but we don't
- 26:57actually need as the audience to understand how
- 27:01Mary Magdalene was rescued out of adultery and
- 27:03everything like that. Like, like I just wish that we
- 27:06were plunged into this movie and it did not let
- 27:10up for two hours. And I know that that's probably
- 27:12like the idea of that is probably unbearable to a
- 27:15lot of people because it is such an intense movie.
- 27:18But I'm with you, man, either
- 27:20you either have to do more or you have to do less,
- 27:22but there's something off with the calculus of the
- 27:25random cutaways here. Yeah, I see. I
- 27:28don't know if I'm quite there with it. I
- 27:30think that they have about the right amount of
- 27:32cutaways to keep you focused on the action
- 27:34without losing the pacing. I
- 27:38think for me, I think within like, don't add or
- 27:41delete any scenes just within what you had filmed,
- 27:46the timing of it. Give me a little more of a
- 27:49happy jovial loving Jesus that is like the whole
- 27:53reason he came. I mean, you do get the
- 27:56revelation that Jesus invented the table and
- 27:59chairs, apparently. That is the one cutaway that
- 28:02they could have cut. She goes, this will never catch
- 28:05on. That is hands down. The
- 28:09weirdest part of the movie. Like
- 28:11why? I don't know if it's the
- 28:12weirdest, but there's some weird stuff in this movie
- 28:15that we need to get to here. Well,
- 28:17weirdest in sense of tone. Like
- 28:20that doesn't fit with any of the rest of the film
- 28:24and not necessarily the silly Jesus. I'm
- 28:28fine with silly Jesus. It's the whole wink at the
- 28:32camera. Oh, this stupid table never
- 28:35catch on. Yeah, man, I'm with you on that.
- 28:38I do want to talk before we
- 28:39go to break about the other weird stuff, which is
- 28:41the depiction of Satan in this movie. And
- 28:45I don't know if this is a controversial take, Brad,
- 28:48because we are talking about a cosmic battle of
- 28:52good versus evil represented in the crucifixion. There's
- 28:56too much Satan in this movie. Like
- 28:59we needed like one, maybe two brief glimpses of the
- 29:03satanic figure amongst the people for the point to be
- 29:07made. By the time that Satan shows
- 29:09up with the satanic midget baby and then you get the
- 29:14like nine inch nails looking music video Satan
- 29:18at the end screaming at the camera. It's
- 29:21just like it has not aged well. It
- 29:23was not a good directorial decision. I
- 29:26wish there was less Satan in this movie. I
- 29:28don't think it's terrible. I
- 29:29think that if anything for me, as someone who believes
- 29:36deeply in the spiritual realm, I think that it is
- 29:40a really insightful depiction into the wild
- 29:46weirdness with which the spiritual realm operates.
- 29:51And if anything for me, it
- 29:53made it more effective. So I was 100 % on board for
- 29:58all of the Satan scenes in the sense that I think
- 30:02that it added to the film. Oh
- 30:05man. All right, Brad. Well,
- 30:07with that said, I'm going to make an even weirder
- 30:09transition because it feels kind of wrong to pair this
- 30:13movie up with the whiskey. But
- 30:15that's what we do. We watch movies and we drink
- 30:17whiskey. So it's time for us to review
- 30:20some Makers Mark 46. What do you say? I
- 30:22mean, this is like a Catholic film and the
- 30:24Catholics, if nothing else, are all about drinking.
- 30:29Let's get to it, man. All
- 30:36right. So today we are trying Makers
- 30:39Mark 46 cask strength. Now, Brad, I feel like we're
- 30:42finally rounding out the Avengers lineup of Makers
- 30:46Mark products because we've tried Makers Mark. I
- 30:48think, wait, have we tried regular Makers Mark? I
- 30:51was about to say, Bob, I do not think we have. Oh
- 30:54man. Well, then my analogy immediately
- 30:56fell apart. We haven't even reviewed
- 30:58Captain America. Yeah, I know. We're
- 31:01just focusing on Black Widow and Hawkeye here and
- 31:04calling it the Avengers. Okay,
- 31:07so we have tried Makers Cask Strength. We
- 31:11have tried Makers 46. We have not done Makers Mark,
- 31:16but now we're reviewing Makers 46 cask strength. So
- 31:20we've basically tried everything except the
- 31:22flagship product. I think we need to remedy
- 31:24that pretty soon here, Brad. Yeah,
- 31:26I was going to say, I feel like really early in
- 31:29the show's history, we tried a Makers Mark
- 31:31product. It might have been 46. It
- 31:33was, yeah, that was like one of our first episodes.
- 31:36Yeah, and then we took like six
- 31:38seasons off and didn't drink any Makers Mark. And
- 31:43since then, we've tried a few and I've been a fan
- 31:47of just about everything we've had. Yeah,
- 31:50me too. And this is kind of the
- 31:52original, you know, quote unquote original weeded
- 31:55bourbon. This is by far the most popular
- 31:58weeded bourbon product on the market. Definitely
- 32:01does more sales than the wellers that you hear
- 32:03about. It's not as bro -y. It's
- 32:05not as sexy of a name as weller is, but Makers Mark
- 32:09moves a ton of units. And so when they came out with
- 32:12Makers 46, it was a really interesting addition to the
- 32:15Makers Mark lineup. This is a French oak stave
- 32:19finished bourbon. It was one of the first ones
- 32:21to do this sort of stave finish thing. And
- 32:24they called it 46 because I think it was like their
- 32:2546th experiment or the 46th stave. So
- 32:29they just ran with it. And this is the cask strength
- 32:31version of that. The original one comes in at
- 32:34around 90 proof, Brad. It's a pretty low proof whiskey.
- 32:37You and I actually revisited it
- 32:39recently for an episode for our Patreon. And
- 32:43we really liked that Makers 46. So
- 32:45I'm pretty pumped to dive into the cask strength
- 32:47version here. This sample was given to us by
- 32:50friend of show Wes, who has been just bank rolling
- 32:53us through season eight, Brad. Let's
- 32:55go Wes. This one comes in at 109 .6
- 32:58proof. Brad, you and I are drinking
- 33:01this live together, which never happens. You
- 33:05usually come in having already drank it. So
- 33:08you better, you better bring it today, man,
- 33:10because you have no prepared notes. I
- 33:13don't. I have nothing to draw upon,
- 33:15but the faculties that God has given me. And
- 33:19the 600 whiskies we've already tried on this
- 33:22podcast. Yeah, you know, a little bit of
- 33:24experience. All right, man, let's dive in.
- 33:26What are you picking up on the
- 33:27nose of Makers 46 cask strength? The
- 33:30first thing that jumps out at me is the cherry. That
- 33:34just there is no masking that this is a weeded, a
- 33:38well -weeded bourbon. I think that there is a lot
- 33:42of peanuts on this. I think that the oakiness
- 33:46does start to come through. Like
- 33:48you definitely notice those oak staves. But
- 33:52other than that, man, this is just like cherry and
- 33:56caramel and vanilla and peanuts and just all sorts
- 34:01of really pleasant bourbon notes. Yeah,
- 34:04I'm totally with you. It's a really nice kind of
- 34:07black cherry, almost like a black cherry ice cream. And
- 34:10then a little bit of that nuttiness. I'm
- 34:12picking up on that. There's some it's almost like a
- 34:14waxy, the waxy smell of peanuts. So
- 34:17I don't know if I could compare this to anything,
- 34:19Brad. It's like this is the PB and J
- 34:22of whiskey. This is the uncrustables of
- 34:25whiskies. I think the oak is coming
- 34:27through, not in a sort of like overly oaked or sour
- 34:30way the way it's been on some of these well aged
- 34:33products we've had recently. It's
- 34:35more of a sawdusty. And I really, really like that
- 34:37because it gets me back into my great like Noah's
- 34:40Mill wheelhouse. So I'm going to give this an
- 34:44eight and a half on the nose, Brad. I
- 34:45like this a lot. Yeah, I think I'm sitting at an
- 34:48eight on the nose. Man, as I'm getting into the
- 34:52palette here, Bob, this is a delicious whiskey. It
- 34:57has like a little bit of like a cherry capri sun
- 35:05taste to it. Like it's not thick enough to
- 35:09be a cherry syrup, but I don't know. This
- 35:13is the most American sounding review. We've
- 35:16compared it to uncrustables and capri sun so far.
- 35:20That's the truth. We
- 35:20have the palette of five year olds. My
- 35:22daughter has started soccer at the age of three and
- 35:27it is adorable to watch 15 little girls run around and
- 35:32kick a soccer ball. Absolutely
- 35:34love it. But snack time is her favorite
- 35:36part of the experience. And I had forgotten how capri
- 35:40suns are like a staple of soccer snacks. And
- 35:44so at least when I was growing up, the flavors
- 35:48were pretty much ocean breeze and wild cherry. And
- 35:54so I think that might be why it's on my brain.
- 35:56Yeah. But this has that wild
- 35:59cherry capri sun vibe that I really like. I
- 36:04think the nuttiness sticks around. The
- 36:07vanilla is really prominent on the palette more so
- 36:10than on the nose. Bob, this is just a really,
- 36:14really tasty whiskey. I'll come up a little bit from
- 36:17the nose and give it an eight and a half on the
- 36:18palette. Yeah, I think I'm actually going
- 36:20to go down a little bit on my palette score, Brad.
- 36:23This is really good and very
- 36:25solid. But if I could nitpick it a
- 36:28little bit, I think that that oak finish is it
- 36:31tastes more like that toasted oak, really bitter
- 36:34kind of oak that we get sometimes. And
- 36:36it's nice to a point and then you kick it to the
- 36:39back of your palette and it just kind of comes in
- 36:42at first as like a heavy char. But
- 36:44then you realize it's not actually char. It's
- 36:46like a it's like vegetal almost. It's
- 36:50pretty tannic almost, I would call it. And
- 36:54I think that because of that, it almost kind of
- 36:57reminds me of some like dark red wine finished
- 37:00whiskies we've had like a Pinot Noir finish or
- 37:02something. There's there's a little bit of
- 37:04grapiness to this to go along with that cherry. I
- 37:07like it, but it just struck a small bitter note
- 37:11at the end that kind of ruined the rest of it for
- 37:13me. So I'm going to be at a
- 37:14seven and a half on palette and then on finish.
- 37:18I'm kind of in the same spot.
- 37:19I think second and third sip.
- 37:21It definitely improves a little
- 37:22bit, but that note doesn't really go away. And
- 37:25the last note that I'm left with is the nice
- 37:27softness of the wheat on this coupled with a kind
- 37:32of bitter oak. And it's mostly good, but
- 37:35there's just something there that's keeping it from
- 37:37being great. So I'm going to go seven and
- 37:38a half again. Yeah, I think for me, the finish
- 37:41is where I kind of drop off. I
- 37:43think that you start to lose the flavors that made
- 37:49this whiskey really solid on the finish. It's
- 37:53still good. There's still a nice pleasant
- 37:55cherry palette that finishes through, but it definitely
- 38:00disappears into the oak a little bit. I'll
- 38:02give it a seven and a half on the finish. I
- 38:04think I'll give it a seven and a half on the balance
- 38:06as well. The movement from nose to
- 38:09palette to finish is good, but not super complex. And
- 38:15it tails off just enough that I think it's a pretty
- 38:19well balanced whiskey, but nothing outstanding. Yeah,
- 38:23I'm in the same spot, man. I'm
- 38:24going to give it a seven. I'll
- 38:26just give it a seven on the balance because I think
- 38:29that the more interesting conversation here is the
- 38:32price, the value on this. Brad,
- 38:34I'm seeing this online at around $60. I
- 38:37like the website I'm on right now is $62 .99. So
- 38:41let's just call it 60 for the sake of argument. At
- 38:43$60, I can't think of a lot of cask strength
- 38:47bourbons that are also finished bourbons. Like,
- 38:52you know, I was going to compare this to Wild Turkey
- 38:55Rare Breed, which I think is just a vastly superior
- 38:58product to this. But it's not quite fair because
- 39:02this does have an additional step in its
- 39:04production process. So when I take that into
- 39:07consideration, I don't think this is a bad value. It's
- 39:10not my favorite whiskey at this price point. But
- 39:13considering everything that goes into this, I think a
- 39:16seven out of 10 is a pretty fair score on the
- 39:19value here. Yeah, I think that as I consider
- 39:22the value on this whiskey, I'm kind of sitting at the
- 39:26six and a half range. This is a really good whiskey
- 39:29that if it was even just five to $10 cheaper, I
- 39:35would be in a really solid seven and a half, eight
- 39:38out of 10 place. But I think six and a half is
- 39:41a good spot for for Makers 46 cask strength. Yeah.
- 39:45And you know, I think for me, I go back to the
- 39:48Makers cask strength, which I think we just had last
- 39:51season on the show. And that's one of my favorite
- 39:53whiskeys. Like, it's become a pretty big
- 39:56staple on my shelf. It was something that I hadn't
- 39:58tried because it had been six seasons since we tried
- 40:01anything from Makers. And we tried that Makers cask
- 40:04strength and I was blown away. And
- 40:06that's usually between $40 and $50. So
- 40:08this is a significant step up in price point. I
- 40:11think I still prefer the regular Makers cask strength
- 40:14here, Brad, but I'm still coming out to a 37 .5 out
- 40:18of 50. Where are you falling on this
- 40:20one? I'm coming out to a 38 out of
- 40:2450 here. Okay. All right. So
- 40:26we are at a 37 .75 or a 75 .5 out of 100. If
- 40:33I'm being honest with you, Brad, this seems a few
- 40:35points too high. Like, it's very easily in the
- 40:39green. Yes, you should recommend area
- 40:42of our spreadsheet here. Oh,
- 40:44100%. But like, I don't think I'm
- 40:47going to buy a bottle of this anytime soon. Do
- 40:49you? Probably not. I
- 40:53think that there's other cask strength options out
- 40:55there for me. But overall, like, this is a
- 40:59whiskey I would recommend people to buy. I
- 41:03mean, if you go to a bourbon bar and they price
- 41:05things fairly, I would assume this is going to
- 41:07cost you between, I don't know, $13 and $15 for a
- 41:11pour. Yeah. And I think that's a
- 41:13pretty, like, it's a worthwhile pour at that
- 41:16price. And it's 109 proof. At
- 41:19least our barrel is. So it's not like you're
- 41:21getting something that's really diluted and watered
- 41:23down. I would give it a thumbs up.
- 41:25It's just not like my most
- 41:26enthusiastic thumbs up ever. Yeah,
- 41:29I would say so, like three quarters thumbs up. Brad,
- 41:33it is just a very weird day here at Filmen Whiskey.
- 41:36I feel so weird trying to
- 41:38bridge the movie that we're watching with the fact that
- 41:40we are also reviewing whiskey. So
- 41:43I'm just not going to think about it that much,
- 41:44but it's time to get back into talking Catholic.
- 41:48They're all about drinking. That
- 41:50is true. Talking about Jesus drinking and
- 41:53guilt. Those are the two things we do.
- 41:55And they are. This
- 41:56is like the most Catholic movie we'll ever watch.
- 42:00Well, let's talk about it, Brad.
- 42:02What do you say we get back
- 42:02into the passion of the Christ? Let's
- 42:05get to it, man. All right, everybody. That
- 42:12was Makersmark 46 cask strength, a whiskey that I
- 42:16really enjoyed, Bob. Yeah, it was pretty good. I
- 42:19enjoyed it so much. I think I might add it to
- 42:22an infinity bottle that I have going on. Oh,
- 42:24there you go. What are your criteria for your
- 42:26infinity bottle? Because there's a good that are
- 42:29just like, I have an ounce left, it's going in the
- 42:31bottle. And I think that that is a
- 42:33recipe for disaster. Yes, no, that's a recipe for
- 42:36disaster. Unless you're only drinking like
- 42:39premium whiskies, then like, sure, maybe it'll work. For
- 42:43the most part, if I think a whiskey is really, really
- 42:46good. And within, like, if I'm
- 42:53building a specifically more bourbon leaning infinity
- 42:57bottle, I'm not going to put a ton of rise in
- 43:00there, but I might put one or two just to get a
- 43:02little flavor. Yep, yep. So
- 43:05like, I kind of have a vibe I'm going for, and I
- 43:08want it to taste good. You're
- 43:09not just dumping like lagovulin on top of your
- 43:12bourbon infinity bottle. Yeah,
- 43:13although I've been thinking about making some sort of
- 43:17like scotch American blended infinity bottle that could
- 43:21be a lot of fun. Here's the thing. Have
- 43:23we tried making peated bourbon yet? We
- 43:28should. Because like there's peated American
- 43:31single malt. Why have we not applied peat
- 43:33to other things? Is it is it that bad? I
- 43:35have to imagine someone's tried it. Yeah,
- 43:38I would imagine somebody's tried it. Peated
- 43:41rye. They do to that sounds great.
- 43:44Let's do that. Sounds
- 43:44incredible. Let's do it. That'll
- 43:46be our distilleries main focus, Bob. All
- 43:49right, man. Well, while we mull over the
- 43:52business model for our distillery, it is time for
- 43:54us to get into our next segment, which we call two
- 43:57facts and a falsehood. Brad is going to try to stump
- 44:01you, Bob, to our eye. And what is wrong? Two
- 44:07facts and a falsehood. Two facts and a falsehood is
- 44:10the part of the show where Brad presents me with three
- 44:12items as fact about the making of this movie, one
- 44:16of which is a complete lie. And
- 44:17I have to figure out which one that is. Brad,
- 44:20I'm doing, I think, fairly well on the season. Let's
- 44:23see what what old Bob is sitting out here. Eleven
- 44:26and six on the year right now, Brad. Now,
- 44:28Bob, I am going to throw you a curveball today. Are
- 44:31you ready? Mm -hmm. So
- 44:33you you got two losses because of one of our
- 44:37guests steered you the wrong direction at some
- 44:40point. And so I figured that today we
- 44:44could allow for a grace week. Because
- 44:46I felt weird writing falsehoods about a movie
- 44:51about Jesus. You know, maybe we should do
- 44:55that instead of playing our game is just talk about
- 44:57the weird inexplicable guilt related with this film. It
- 45:02is it is indeed the most Catholic of films because
- 45:04yes, I like I feel weird joking about it. I
- 45:08feel weird talking about it even just as a movie like
- 45:11there is there's a lot of Jesus tied up in this
- 45:13movie. And whether or not it actually
- 45:16has anything to do with how Jesus thinks about me.
- 45:20My mind has been telling me,
- 45:22hey, dude, this is a serious business. You
- 45:24can't joke around about the passion of the Christ. So
- 45:28what I hear you saying is I get an automatic win.
- 45:31What I'm actually saying is
- 45:32we're just taking a week off. All
- 45:35right, cool. Well, now that I've included the
- 45:37theme song to two facts and a falsehood and
- 45:39everything else, we're just not going to do it, folks.
- 45:41So there you have it. This
- 45:43week's two facts and a falsehood. Two
- 45:45facts and a falsehood. All right, Brad, let's get back
- 45:48into talking about the passion of the Christ. And
- 45:50I do think that we have to talk about Mel Gibson a
- 45:53little bit because it is, I believe, less than a
- 45:57year after this movie comes out that he has his huge
- 46:01drunken meltdown. One of the most highly
- 46:05publicized celebrity meltdowns of all time. Like
- 46:07this thing dominated headlines for weeks.
- 46:11Everybody was a very big fan of
- 46:13reporting on this. Well, I mean, it had to do with
- 46:15the fact that he was one of the biggest stars in
- 46:17Hollywood and he had just made the passion of the
- 46:20Christ. So he was like he was being
- 46:22lauded very unfairly as like this champion of moral
- 46:28like fortitude and a paragon of what is right
- 46:31in the world. And like that was not accurate
- 46:33at all. And it really came crashing
- 46:36down for him. And I think that whatever your
- 46:38thoughts are on Mel Gibson are very easy to read back
- 46:42onto this movie in retrospect. And
- 46:44I'm especially referring to the fact that even at the
- 46:47time of its release, this movie was condemned by a
- 46:50lot of groups as being really anti -Semitic. But
- 46:54I think that it is worth us mentioning, Brad, that
- 46:56like Mel Gibson has not done this movie any favors
- 47:00with his own behavior. No, it's totally fine, man.
- 47:07Here's the thing about Mel Gibson.
- 47:10Have you ever seen the clip of
- 47:13Robert Downey Jr. talking about his relationship with
- 47:16Mel? Yeah, I have. I
- 47:18think that that kind of... I
- 47:21would hope that anybody who encounters me as a human
- 47:23being will kind of hold the good things and tension
- 47:27with the bad of who I am. And
- 47:30I think that that's kind of the perfect balance you
- 47:33have to hold for Mel Gibson here. Like,
- 47:35is he the person who went on a drunken, outrageous,
- 47:39just rampage and, you know, is bad? Yep.
- 47:45I like, I am sure that he did those things. It
- 47:48does not surprise me at all. Is
- 47:51he also the person who took in Robert Downey Jr.
- 47:54when he was at his lowest and
- 47:55gave him an opportunity to get back on his feet and
- 47:58encouraged him and loved him up to a place where
- 48:01he could become a superstar again? Yep.
- 48:03I believe that that is true. Like,
- 48:05I don't think Robert Downey Jr. was
- 48:07lying about those things. So,
- 48:10if anything, that to me depicts the beauty of this
- 48:14film. That like, when Jesus died on
- 48:17the cross, it was for the Mel Gibson who helped
- 48:21Robert Downey Jr. get back on his feet and it
- 48:24was for the Mel Gibson who was going on a drunken
- 48:26rampage. Like, there's grace for both of
- 48:29those versions of Mel Gibson. Yeah.
- 48:32Man, and I, like, I hate to, I don't mean to soften
- 48:35the impact of what you just said either. And
- 48:37I'm not trying to do that. But
- 48:38I do think that there are a number of people who see
- 48:41this movie and feel very attacked by it. You
- 48:44know, like, we've had, we've had Jewish people as
- 48:47guest hosts on this show before, Brad. Like,
- 48:50it is, I think it is a fair reading of the movie
- 48:52to wonder if Mel Gibson had some sort of animus in
- 48:55his heart against certain people that he is depicting
- 48:57in the movie. I'm not saying he did. I'm
- 49:00not even saying that I agree with that. I'm
- 49:01just saying that's one reading of the film. I
- 49:05also do think, now go ahead. I
- 49:07think for me, though, that's not really, to me,
- 49:11that's too black and white of a reading of this film.
- 49:16Because at the end of the day,
- 49:18like, Jesus is Jewish in this movie. All
- 49:21of the people who care for Jesus are Jewish in this
- 49:24movie. Yeah. Like, sure, the, you know,
- 49:27the Romans are portrayed somewhat graciously, but
- 49:31there's also a lot of the Roman soldiers who are
- 49:33portrayed as absolute pigs. Mm
- 49:35-hmm. And so I think that, I just
- 49:38don't think that you can watch this movie and
- 49:42honestly say that, like, well, Mel Gibson is a
- 49:46racist. He hates all of the Jewish
- 49:49people in the world. Like, there are so many Jewish
- 49:53people in this movie who are portrayed really
- 49:55beautifully and kind and caring. And
- 49:58so I, I don't know, man. To
- 50:00me, I'll just be blunt. I think that's a silly point.
- 50:03Yeah. And I was, I was in the
- 50:05middle of trying to steer away from it, too. So
- 50:07I do think that the other point of conversation around
- 50:10the Mel Gibson thing is like, Mel Gibson is
- 50:13primarily known for directing three movies. And
- 50:15this is the second of the three, the first being
- 50:17Braveheart, second, this, and the third one, a movie
- 50:20he makes, like, two years later called Apocalypto.
- 50:23They are all incredibly violent
- 50:26movies, like, very violent movies. And
- 50:30I think that, like, one of the conversations happening
- 50:32at the time this movie came out, if you read
- 50:34reviews of it, too, Roger Ebert says, this is the
- 50:36most violent movie I have ever seen. And
- 50:38my guy, Raj, was watching some really messed up stuff
- 50:41over the years. So I have to believe him. I
- 50:44have to take him at his word. And
- 50:45I've been doing this thought experiment, Brad, of
- 50:47like, I, I want to give Mel Gibson the benefit of
- 50:51the doubt that, like, he, he found, he, he thought
- 50:55that there was a, a, I want to call it a market
- 50:59opportunity. That's very hollow sounding. But
- 51:01like, in the depiction of Jesus, I think that we
- 51:06have gotten a very sanitized version of the
- 51:09passion and death and resurrection of Jesus in
- 51:12all of the movies that were made prior to this. I
- 51:14do think that it is like, this is certainly the
- 51:17definitive depiction of crucifixion that's ever been
- 51:21put on screen. I do sometimes wonder, like,
- 51:24what prompted Mel Gibson to want to make not just a
- 51:28Jesus movie, but this movie? Do
- 51:31you know what I mean? And I guess I don't want to
- 51:33put ourselves in the shoes of Mel Gibson. But
- 51:35Brad, what would you see as a filmmaker? What
- 51:39is the benefit of making a movie that is solely about
- 51:43the passion of Christ as opposed to any other part
- 51:46of his life? Like, where do you see the
- 51:47appeal of it? And where would your mind go
- 51:50if you were asked that question? I
- 51:54mean, honestly, man, I think it would take me to
- 51:56Dietrich Bonhoeffer, who was a Christian author during
- 52:01the reign of Nazi Germany. And
- 52:04he wrote a book called The Cost of Discipleship that
- 52:06basically argues that grace is costly and that if we,
- 52:12if we don't take grace seriously, it cheapens what
- 52:17we have received. And I think that as a
- 52:20filmmaker, I would want to depict the passion, which
- 52:25we haven't talked about this, but within theology
- 52:29and within specifically, you know, Roman Catholic
- 52:32tradition, probably Orthodox tradition as well. Like,
- 52:36the passion of Christ refers specifically to the
- 52:40events happening between the arrest of Jesus through
- 52:44the... does it go through the
- 52:47resurrection? Or does it just go through
- 52:49the death, Bob? I mean, it has the
- 52:51resurrection happening at the end. Okay.
- 52:54Which is one of the things I feel most guilty about,
- 52:56because I'm like, dude, come on. Like,
- 52:57you didn't have to throw Jesus getting up from the
- 52:59tomb at the end of this movie. Like,
- 53:01it's a movie about how he died. Sure.
- 53:03And I hate when we fast forward to him getting back
- 53:06up. So, you know what I mean?
- 53:07Like, just like, let us sit in
- 53:09the sorrow. Yeah. Well, and that's, I think
- 53:12that's kind of what I was getting at with the cheap
- 53:15grace versus costly grace. Yeah.
- 53:17Is that if I'm going to help people understand how
- 53:21much grace cost, I am going to as viscerally as
- 53:25possible depict what happened to our Lord and
- 53:29Savior. And I think that one of the
- 53:32most deep and enduring powers of movies, of films
- 53:37at large, is their ability to make people feel. And
- 53:43I just, the older I get, Bob, the more I am
- 53:46convinced that people have anesthetized themselves into
- 53:52oblivion in our country. And
- 53:55we desperately need a reawakening of emotions and
- 54:01feelings and an embrace of them. And
- 54:05I think that this movie is an example of that. Like,
- 54:08if you don't embrace the sadness and the brokenness
- 54:13and the despair of the darkest moment in human
- 54:16history, then how are you going to be able to revel
- 54:19in the glory of what Christ offers us? And
- 54:23the heights to which he wants to draw us? I
- 54:26just, I think that sitting in the passion is so
- 54:30important. And so if I was coming at it
- 54:32as a filmmaker, I think I would take the exact same
- 54:35tact as Mel here. Yeah. And I think that to kind
- 54:38of try to draw all this Mel Gibson talk together,
- 54:41like, I think Mel Gibson is a deeply flawed man. I
- 54:43think, you know, there was another incident that
- 54:45happened years after the first one that kind of
- 54:47reconfirmed for a lot of people that they think he's
- 54:50a bad guy. And I'm not arguing that. I,
- 54:53but I do think that you can be a very flawed
- 54:55person and still make earnest attempts at
- 54:59identifying and depicting what you consider to be
- 55:05morally right and true. I understand people who want
- 55:09to read Mel Gibson's flaws onto this film. I
- 55:13personally try to think of it as like he is a deeply
- 55:15flawed man who was earnestly trying to do
- 55:18something that meant a lot to him personally and his
- 55:21faith. Like it's hate to bring this
- 55:24guy up. But like, it reminds me of
- 55:26like the Kanye West thing from a couple years ago. I
- 55:29don't think Kanye West is a Christian. I
- 55:30think at the time he was really interested in being
- 55:33a Christian and his album is this big flawed mess of
- 55:36what he understood or who he understood Jesus to be
- 55:40at that time. And like, there's a lot of it
- 55:43that's theologically incorrect from a Christian
- 55:45perspective. But that's what Kanye thought
- 55:47about Jesus. And I think he was making an
- 55:49earnest attempt to articulate that in the
- 55:52moment. And so I look at this movie
- 55:54and like when I think about the Christian faith,
- 55:57one of the beautiful things about it for me, Brad, is
- 55:59that it is such a, it is such a tapestry. There
- 56:02are so many different strands that you can
- 56:05follow. And different facets of the
- 56:08faith hit different people on different levels. Like
- 56:12there are people who like to sit and think about
- 56:17like the the immensity of God. There
- 56:20are people who like to think about the depiction
- 56:22of God as a brother or as a father, like a familial
- 56:25aspect really appeals to some people. There
- 56:28are some people for whom the violence that Jesus
- 56:32endured is the most impactful thing in terms of
- 56:36them understanding the extent of God's love. And
- 56:40I think Mel Gibson is just one of those people like
- 56:42the dude has a fixation on violence, but that doesn't
- 56:46necessarily mean that the violence doesn't mean
- 56:48something deeper to him in this moment. And
- 56:50I kind of that's what I see here is like, yes, my
- 56:52guy has a propensity for violence. I
- 56:55also think that might just be the way that he
- 56:57understands the story of the gospel the best. Yeah,
- 57:02I don't have any follow up for that Bob. All
- 57:05right, Brad, let's kind of come out of that for a
- 57:08minute. Let's just do a few quick
- 57:09minutes before we get to our final scores and let's
- 57:11make it a double. I do think this is a flawed
- 57:14movie. And I've already talked about I
- 57:16think a lot of the flashbacks are unnecessary.
- 57:18I think the depiction of
- 57:19Satan is unnecessary. When you look at this just as
- 57:23a a filmmakers skills on display, like what are your
- 57:29thoughts on the movie making here? I
- 57:32think the movie making is spectacular. I
- 57:35think that there are instances of 2004 things
- 57:41going on that don't look great. Specifically
- 57:45Jim Caviesles glammed up eyes where they're they're
- 57:52made brown after the fact in post production. But
- 57:55an unnatural brown. Yeah, yes. Yeah,
- 57:58so that that's not great. There's
- 58:01some instances of slow motion that don't look they
- 58:04just look choppy. They're not super well done.
- 58:07There's other places where the slow
- 58:09motion completely fits. Yeah,
- 58:11we were talking last night about the cinematography
- 58:13because you had said to me, I don't know how I
- 58:15feel about the cinematography. And
- 58:17the cinematography is actually one of the few
- 58:19areas that was nominated for an Oscar for this
- 58:22movie. And I think it's really well
- 58:23done like the shot composition, the lighting,
- 58:26the framing, beautiful. But what you have sometimes is
- 58:30like you said this choppy slow mo where a lot of
- 58:33times when a director, especially when they used
- 58:35to shoot on film, if they wanted to do a shot in
- 58:38slow motion, they would shoot it at 48 frames a
- 58:41second. So the film would run through
- 58:43the camera faster because then when you played it
- 58:45back at 24 frames a second, it takes twice as
- 58:48long to play and you have a very smooth slow motion.
- 58:51But what happens is a lot of
- 58:53times you would film a scene in 24 and then go
- 58:56back to the editing room and say, oh, damn it, I
- 58:58really wanted that scene to be in slow mo. And
- 59:00so then you would slow down your 24 frames to 18
- 59:04or 12 or whatever. And there's not frames to go
- 59:07in between anymore. And so it just kind of looks
- 59:09herky, jerky and choppy. And
- 59:11there's quite a few instances of that in this
- 59:13movie. And I think it's it's not
- 59:15necessarily a reflection of the cinematography because
- 59:18the shots were set up really well. I
- 59:21think it's more a question of like, is the editing
- 59:24great? Is the direction great? Because
- 59:25it seems like Mel Gibson had a lot of ideas after
- 59:28the fact and they didn't have the assets to actually
- 59:31make those things happen sometimes. Yeah.
- 59:34Yeah, 100%. There's some weirdness with things
- 59:37like that going on. But it's intermixed with really
- 59:41beautiful shots. I think that he frames a lot
- 59:45of scenes just incredibly. You
- 59:49can tell that he is trying to imitate famous paintings,
- 59:54specifically La Piedta at the end of the film. And
- 59:57and it's it's beautiful. Like
- 1:00:00I can't fault him at all for trying to imitate it.
- 1:00:04A, because the original is
- 1:00:06incredible and B, because he does a great job of
- 1:00:09making it come to life. So I love when he does things
- 1:00:14like that. There was one specific moment
- 1:00:16that I thought was just one of the coolest shots.
- 1:00:21It kind of reminded me of the
- 1:00:24the what's it the the something Lebowski the big.
- 1:00:28Yes. Of all the words you could
- 1:00:32forget from that title. The forgettable movie. The
- 1:00:36big Lebowski. Remember when he puts the camera
- 1:00:39inside the bowling ball? Oh,
- 1:00:40yeah, yeah. There was a moment that somewhat
- 1:00:43reminded me of that where you have this like
- 1:00:46perfectly overhead shot of the three crosses and the
- 1:00:50crowds. And then the the the edges of
- 1:00:54the camera slowly like dip in on themselves and you
- 1:00:58realize that it's like a drop of water falling and
- 1:01:01like you're seeing it through the drop of water.
- 1:01:04And as soon as it hits the
- 1:01:06earthquake happens and the darkness falls over the
- 1:01:09earth and dude, it's just incredible. Probably
- 1:01:13the most terrible thing I'm going to say today. But
- 1:01:15like this is the third movie now where we've had
- 1:01:19like an entire universe contained in a small object
- 1:01:22at the end of the movie. So
- 1:01:23like in Men in Black, they do that zoom out where it
- 1:01:26turns out the earth is just inside of like a
- 1:01:28marble that an alien's playing with. And
- 1:01:30then in the Grinch, it zooms out and everything's
- 1:01:32inside of one snowflake. And
- 1:01:34I just feel like there's this weird cinematic
- 1:01:36universe of like pick a small object and see what
- 1:01:40universe is inside of it. And
- 1:01:41it's like, yeah, OK, if you pick the marble, you
- 1:01:43get Men in Black. If you look in the snowflake,
- 1:01:45you get this warm, happy Grinch movie. Oh,
- 1:01:48if you look in this raindrop, you get to look
- 1:01:50in on the most devastating horrific event in human
- 1:01:54history happening. Yeah, no big deal, man. I
- 1:01:58do think that the score for this movie is probably
- 1:02:01my least favorite part of the film. There
- 1:02:03are a few moments where it's just strings and it
- 1:02:06is like, you know, it's like some Adagio. It's
- 1:02:08it's just heart wrenching. But
- 1:02:11then there's also the like vaguely Middle Eastern
- 1:02:14wailing with drums under it for half the movie. And
- 1:02:19it sounds it just sounds so dated. It
- 1:02:21sounds like every movie that was set in the Middle
- 1:02:23East from 1995 to 2015. And
- 1:02:27like surprisingly, the score for this movie was
- 1:02:29nominated for an Oscar. And I thought it was like
- 1:02:32legit bad. Oh, I think you're crazy. Oh,
- 1:02:35my God. I think it works. I
- 1:02:37wouldn't say it's like a great score, but I think
- 1:02:40it works at what it's called to do, which is to
- 1:02:44underlay what's happening on screen. And
- 1:02:48I think it does a great job of that. All
- 1:02:50right, man. Well, it sounds like we're kind
- 1:02:52of in slightly different places on this film. But
- 1:02:54before we get final scores, it's time for our final
- 1:02:57segment of the day, which we call Let's Make It a
- 1:02:59Double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 1:03:12part of the show where we pick a movie to pair up
- 1:03:14with this one to make the perfect double feature.
- 1:03:17Brad, I've already given mine. It
- 1:03:18is the Carl Theodore Dreyer film, The Passion of Joan
- 1:03:22of Arc. It is one of the 10, maybe
- 1:03:2415 best movies I've ever seen. I
- 1:03:26it's better than this movie. And
- 1:03:28I would highly recommend. I know I've told you before
- 1:03:31and I know it's a hard sell to say like, hey,
- 1:03:34it's basically the passion of the Christ, but it's a
- 1:03:36silent movie. I get it. I
- 1:03:38get it. But like you are doing yourself
- 1:03:41a disservice to not go watch this movie so good.
- 1:03:45I don't know if I'm doing
- 1:03:45myself a disservice. I have a lot of things on
- 1:03:48my on my dock. I'm the general you, you know,
- 1:03:50like, ah, yes, people of earth. It's
- 1:03:53one of the best films ever made. If
- 1:03:55you like movies, you need to watch it. The
- 1:03:57end you you put it on one of our seasons and I will
- 1:03:59watch it. All right, man. What's
- 1:04:01your Let's Make It a Double, Brad? Man,
- 1:04:03honestly, I kind of want to tell people to go read
- 1:04:05the book of John. Like that that would be my
- 1:04:09Let's Make It a Double. As long as it's not the big
- 1:04:11Lebowski, I think you're doing OK. Um,
- 1:04:16man, I really don't know if I have a movie. You
- 1:04:23know, I think I'm actually going to pair it with
- 1:04:24Schindler's List. If I had to pair it with a
- 1:04:28movie that gives an absolutely heart wrenching
- 1:04:31account of a devastating event in human history.
- 1:04:36That's probably the best. Yeah,
- 1:04:38you could do a lot worse. Yeah.
- 1:04:41Yeah, so I'll say Schindler's List. It
- 1:04:43will be the saddest night of film that you could
- 1:04:47ever engage in. I can imagine just like
- 1:04:50walking in on someone who has just finished that
- 1:04:52marathon of movies. Oh, dude, their eyes would be
- 1:04:55just slubbery and yeah, it would be brutal. All
- 1:04:59right. Well, there's our incredibly
- 1:05:01entertaining Let's Make It a Double. I
- 1:05:02picked the passion of Joan of Arc. Brad
- 1:05:04picked Schindler's List. Let's
- 1:05:07give this movie some final scores. Brad,
- 1:05:09I've been waffling between a seven and a half and an
- 1:05:12eight on this movie. I think that it is an
- 1:05:14incredibly effective movie, even if you are not a
- 1:05:18follower of Jesus, even if you're not a believer. In
- 1:05:21terms of depicting a historically accurate
- 1:05:24crucifixion and just the injustices committed against
- 1:05:29a principled person, I think that it is incredibly
- 1:05:34effective. It needs tightening up. It
- 1:05:37could lose 15 minutes. It could do without a bunch
- 1:05:39of the flashbacks and it could do without the Satan
- 1:05:41character altogether. And I think you're looking at
- 1:05:44like a nine and a half. But
- 1:05:45for me, it's going to be seven and a half out of
- 1:05:4810. Man, Jesus is watching you, Bob.
- 1:05:54Judgementally, to be clear. Yeah,
- 1:05:55thank you. Thank you so much. No,
- 1:05:58I think I can understand that take, Bob. I'm
- 1:06:02just on kind of on the opposite end of the
- 1:06:03spectrum. I think that Bell does an
- 1:06:06incredible job with this movie. I
- 1:06:08think the cinematography is beautiful. I
- 1:06:10think the performances are great. I
- 1:06:12think the soundtrack is awesome. There
- 1:06:15is just so much to like about this movie. And
- 1:06:18then you top on I am making all things new and
- 1:06:23the theological implications of what's happening here. I
- 1:06:28think that this is a nine and a half out of 10,
- 1:06:30Bob. I found myself utterly engaged
- 1:06:34and captivated by what Mel was doing. All
- 1:06:38right. Well, we are actually well above
- 1:06:40the IMDB average on this movie of a 7 .2 because we
- 1:06:43are coming out to an 8 .5 out of 10. But
- 1:06:46we'd like to know what you think. How
- 1:06:47long has it been since you've seen The Passion? Is
- 1:06:49it a film that you feel like returning to anytime
- 1:06:52soon? You can let us know on all of
- 1:06:55our social media accounts, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram,
- 1:06:59TikTok, and YouTube at FilmWiskey. Or
- 1:07:02you can jump on Discord. We
- 1:07:03are on there every single day talking with you guys,
- 1:07:06fans of the Film and Whiskey podcast. If
- 1:07:09you'd like to join the conversation, you can find
- 1:07:10a link at the end of every single one of our
- 1:07:12show notes. Next week, we are continuing the
- 1:07:14Jesus metaphors before we dive into the godless and
- 1:07:18soulless world of Marvel. With
- 1:07:20one last hurrah from the Disney Corporation, it is
- 1:07:23The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe, the first
- 1:07:25film in the Chronicles of Narnia series. So
- 1:07:28join us next week for Narnia. But
- 1:07:30until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm
- 1:07:32Brad G. And we'll see you next time.
- 1:07:43Thanks for watching!